We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Land Bill, 1933—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 198–423 of 423. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Land Bill, 1933
Enacted

No. 33 of 1933 ›

May I ask leave to withdraw the amendment on the understanding that the Minister will accept the principle of making it mandatory on the Land Commission to reinstate all those evicted from their holdings?

Comment on this

We will see what we can do.

Comment on this

Before this amendment is allowed to be withdrawn, I want to know whether or not the Minister is prepared to accept the principle that it should be made mandatory on the Land Commission to offer reinstatement on the original holdings, or on equally suitable holdings, to tenants evicted, whether subsequent to May, 1878, or to the passing of the Land Act of 1881. I prefer the former and Deputy Davin prefers the other. Does the Minister accept that principle, and is he prepared to introduce, on the Report Stage, an amendment, the object of which will be to offer reinstatement on the original holding or an equally suitable holding to every tenant evicted under the land war?

Comment on this

I can accept that unreservedly, but the Deputy said "evicted tenants."

Comment on this

Or their representatives.

Comment on this

I am asking Deputy Davin not to withdraw the amendment altogether, but to withdraw it temporarily and bring it up again on the Report Stage so that the matter can be discussed then.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister what is the object of that?

Comment on this

Because I want to examine the amendment and its effect more closely than I have been able to. It must be remembered that there are 167 amendments and I have not had time to examine their full effect. I suggest that Deputy Davin can put down the amendment on the Report Stage and move it then if I have not tabled an amendment that will meet the case.

Comment on this

Surely, if the Minister is prepared to accept the principle, that will meet the matter. With all due respect, I submit that the Minister has had as much time, and much greater assistance to enable him to do so, to examine these amendments than private Deputies have had. I submit that a very important principle is raised by this amendment. If the Minister is prepared to accept the principle I have no desire to intervene between himself and Deputy Davin. If he is not prepared to accept the principle that evicted tenants or their personal representatives must be offered reinstatement on their own holdings or on suitable alternative holdings, then I ask the House to divide on this amendment.

Comment on this

What is meant by the term "evicted tenant"? Deputy Dillon dropped the phrase "evicted during the land war." I think the amendment would include those evicted by the Land Commission.

Comment on this

I hope that it will include those who are going to be evicted by the Land Commission.

Comment on this

That is merely frivolous.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy read the amendment? It says: "in consequence of proceedings taken by or on behalf of his landlord."

Comment on this

I only want to be put right on the matter.

Comment on this

I think it is plain for anybody who can understand English and the Deputy should not misrepresent it.

Comment on this

I was not attempting to misrepresent it. It is quite easy to make mistakes. The Deputy himself can make mistakes and if he would bear that in mind he might not be so intolerant of the mistakes of others. However, I should like to know, in connection with this amendment, what the Minister proposes to do with regard to the number of farms in the hands of the Land Commission at present. There is quite a big number of farms all over the country in the hands of the Land Commission where the tenants have been evicted on account of nonpayment of their annuities.

Comment on this

On a point of order, the amendment refers to the landlord and I think that the Deputy is dealing with quite another matter entirely. He is dealing with the period subsequent to the disappearance of landlordism from the tenure of this country.

Comment on this

I suggest that it is very much the same question. Now that the arrears are to be forgiven and that these tenants can be restored to their holdings without having to pay the debt that was formerly required to be paid before they got repossession of their holdings, it is natural that they will be wanting to know whether they will be entitled to resume possession now. The Minister has not said anything about that so far and I should like to know what his intention is in that regard.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Deputy Moore is, possibly, the only Deputy in the House who wants a definition of what is meant by an evicted tenant. All of us, who have lived here during our lives, know what is meant by an evicted tenant, and we include in that term the people who represent them now. I think that, if there is any section in this Bill, and if there is any principle put forward in any amendment for which the Minister should not require any time for consideration, it is this principle here. The principle put forward in Deputy Davin's amendment is one that every person in this House understands. I would press the House to ask for a decision now on the question of the principle raised by Deputy Davin. Is the Minister prepared to accept the principle raised in Deputy Davin's amendment, apart from the question of details which can be considered later on?

Comment on this

May I submit that what an evicted tenant is is not at all so clear as Deputy Rice and Deputy Davin have tried to make out. "In consequence of proceedings taken by or on behalf of his landlord." Now, up to 1931 the State was acting for the landlord in regard to rent so that it would include people evicted as late as 1927 and 1928. Deputy Rice, with all his legal knowledge, could not see that. He thinks I am very stupid indeed not to be able to understand what an evicted tenant is. Evidently it is the other way about. Deputy Rice does not understand what is meant by this amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Deputy Moore has made a graceful attempt to try and cut across this discussion so that a decision on this might be postponed. I assume that is the reason for Deputy Moore's assumed ignorance of what is meant by an evicted tenant.

Comment on this

Deputy Rice is suddenly coming to the rescue of the evicted tenants.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Not suddenly at all. Why does the Minister say "suddenly." In my occupation I had more to do with evicted tenants than ever the Minister had, and not against them either.

Comment on this

I am not denying all that.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Why does the Minister say "suddenly" then?

Comment on this

In this way: Deputy Rice was a member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. It was in office for ten years and introduced three Land Bills, and no amendment of this description was inserted in any one of them.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I would remind the Minister that no Land Bill introduced by Cumann na nGaedheal could ever have the effect of evicting as many tenants as the Bill we are discussing now will.

Comment on this

The Deputy cannot ride away on that horse. The Deputy is suddenly getting very excited about this.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I am not a bit excited. The Minister is rather excited about the idea of having a division on this amendment now.

Comment on this

Why does Deputy Rice want this amendment at this particular time? For ten years Cumann na nGaedheal were in office, and they did not do it. We are in this Bill continuing the power to give land to evicted tenants.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister is not forgetting about Section 31 of the Act of 1923 in which an evicted tenant is defined and provision is expressly made for him.

Comment on this

Is the provision outlined in this amendment made for him in that Act?

Comment on this

I am simply giving the Minister that information and trying to keep him right.

Comment on this

Is the right in the terms of the amendment we are discussing?

Comment on this

I am not discussing the amendment at the moment. I am simply dealing with the statement of the Minister.

Comment on this

The Deputy is a member of the House, and it is no harm to ask him a question. We are all in favour of the evicted tenants, but we want to see where we are going. Deputy Davin himself admits that in some cases a regulation will be required to exclude certain people who think they have some legal title to be called the representatives of evicted tenants.

Comment on this

I do not think Deputy Davin did admit that.

Comment on this

I think that anybody who wants to face this problem honestly must admit that there are certain people who have a very tenuous claim to be called the representatives of evicted tenants. We want to see them dealt with. There is a necessity for exceptions and, certainly, as it stands, Deputy Dillon would not accept the amendment. Deputy Dillon wants the amendment changed from 1881 to 1878. As the amendment stands I am not prepared to accept it.

Comment on this

For what reason?

Comment on this

Because, first of all, if we are going to deal with it all we want to deal with the evicted tenants from 1878 instead of from 1881.

Comment on this

Is that the principal reason?

Comment on this

That is one reason.

Comment on this

Compulsion?

Comment on this

So far as compulsion is concerned, I am in favour of the Land Commission being compelled to acquire land as speedily as possible for genuine evicted tenants, and also for the genuine representatives of evicted tenants who are competent to work land.

Comment on this

Who is to decide that?

Comment on this

It will be decided here first by the representatives of the people, and then the Land Commission or the appeal tribunal will decide what is a genuine evicted tenant and what is not.

Comment on this

A Land Commission inspector will decide?

Comment on this

There will be more than an inspector.

Comment on this

This will not go to the appeal tribunal, but to an individual to decide.

Comment on this

The Land Commissioners will make the decision.

Comment on this

The Commissioners but not the appeal tribunal.

Comment on this

If a man feels he is aggrieved who is he to appeal to?

Comment on this

It is a pure question of administration for the Land Commission and the Minister, and not for the appeal tribunal. The appeal tribunal has certain functions, and this is not one of them.

Comment on this

The amendment states that "a person who or whose predecessor" and so on "shall be entitled on making application in a form," etc., "to be restored to his original holding."

Comment on this

That is a pure question of administration.

Comment on this

If the Land Commission do not do it, to whom is the aggrieved tenant to go?

Comment on this

The words of the amendment would compel them to do it. That is the difference between the Minister and myself.

Comment on this

I am prepared to put in an amendment on the Report Stage compelling the Land Commission to give land, within a reasonable period, to genuine evicted tenants and to genuine representatives of genuine evicted tenants who are competent to work land.

Comment on this

Would the Minister tell us the difference between the word "genuine" as explained by Mr. Birrell in 1907 and, later, by Deputy Hogan, who preceded the present Minister?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

I would like to know from Deputy Davin if he has any particular period in mind? As the amendment reads it would include evictions carried out right down to 1931, or has the Deputy in mind only those whom we mean when we use the phrase "the victims of the land war?"

Comment on this

Would Deputy Moore tell us what persons who held land in 1881 have been evicted by the Land Commission during the past few years?

Comment on this

Quite a number.

Comment on this

I would like to hear about some of them.

Comment on this

Some hundreds all over the country.

Comment on this

Evicted from the holdings they held in 1881 by the Land Commission in the last few years?

Comment on this

During the last ten or 15 years.

Comment on this

But their holdings must have been bought under the Ashbourne Act?

Comment on this

Am I to understand that the Minister's reply to the case made had any relation to the declared policy of his Party in this matter? Is he prepared to implement the policy of his own Party's declaration of last year?

Comment on this

I told Deputy Davin quite definitely that if he wishes he can withdraw this amendment, and put it in on the Report Stage, if the amendment we put in does not meet with what he considers to be the needs of the situation. I have stated that I am prepared on the Report Stage to introduce an amendment which will make it compulsory on the Land Commission to acquire land within a reasonable period, and to distribute it to the representatives of genuine evicted tenants.

Comment on this

The word "genuine" is the snag.

Comment on this

Have they not to be genuine evicted tenants?

Comment on this

Or their representatives.

Comment on this

Or the representatives of genuine evicted tenants competent to work land.

Comment on this

In the case of the Luggacurren tenants, the people who owned the land, and who were evicted, have in many cases died and their sons must be reinstated.

Comment on this

I am prepared to give land to sons, if the sons are fit to work it. I am quite prepared to compel the Land Commission to do that.

Comment on this

If the word "genuine" is left out I will accept it.

Comment on this

Have they not to be genuine evicted tenants?

Comment on this

What is the use of putting in the word "genuine?" Surely only genuine cases will be admitted whether the word is in or not?

Comment on this

There are some people claiming to be evicted tenants, who are not really evicted tenants at all.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin's amendment does not ask the Minister to include everyone that claims to be an evicted tenant.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Surely the answer is that the Land Commission will investigate every claim to see if it was a proper one?

Comment on this

A person's legal representative could prove that he was entitled.

Comment on this

The issue is clear, whether the Minister is prepared to accept the mandatory element in the amendment or not. He will not give an undertaking that he will introduce an amendment on the Report Stage, to offer every evicted tenant, or his personal representative, the holding of land from which he was evicted, or an equally suitable holding. That is the net point. If the Minister is prepared to accept that he can say so.

Comment on this

He has already said so.

Comment on this

He has not.

Comment on this

If he does not say so the amendment should be voted upon now.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this

As there seems to be a lot of quibbling, I suggest that Deputy Davin should wait until the Report Stage. If he is not then satisfied with the amendment moved by the Minister he can move his own amendment, and nothing will be lost. In the meantime the Minister will have an opportunity of meeting the case. That is only fair.

Comment on this

The Minister, quite unconsciously, has made it appear that I am making a case for people who are not genuine evicted tenants. I am doing no such thing.

Comment on this

The Minister has offered to meet Deputy Davin and, if he is not satisfied, he can move the amendment on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Why the quibbling?

Comment on this

You are quibbling since 1923. I brought home an evicted tenant and he was kicked out. I brought an evicted tenant home from America and the military were sent to evict him.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this

I gave Deputy Davin an assurance regarding any genuine evicted tenant, or a genuine representative of an evicted tenant. I am prepared to bring in an amendment on the Report Stage that will make it mandatory on the Land Commission to divide land within a reasonable period, for genuine evicted tenants, or the representatives of genuine evicted tenants, competent to work land.

Comment on this

Competent to work land.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

That is discretionary power.

Comment on this

If Deputy Davin is not satisfied on the Report Stage, he can move his own amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Apart from the Deputy who moved the amendment the rest of the House are entitled to consider it.

Comment on this

Why did you not move it since 1923?

Comment on this

I am not asking Deputy Davin to withdraw the amendment. If he likes he can move it on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

In view of the Minister's statement that there will be an opportunity of considering the matter on the Report Stage, I think there is no use in dividing. I suggest to Deputy Davin that he should withdraw the amendment now.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Why withdraw it? This question has been discussed by the House and it is the desire that a vote should be taken on it.

Comment on this
Division

Question put—"That the said new section be there inserted."

Tá 40
·
Níl 43
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I beg to move amendment 128:—

Before Section 29 to insert a new section as follows:—

Any person who is at the passing of this Act in occupation of a cottage and/or an allotment provided under the Labourers (Ireland) Acts, 1883 to 1919, shall be provided, after application in a form to be prescribed under this Act, by the Land Commission with an additional parcel of land of not less than five acres in extent whenever land is being divided in any area or district.

I think it is only right that, where it is possible, additional land should be allotted to the tenants of labourers' cottages. During the last couple of years no class in the community has suffered as much as the workers in the rural areas. Every increase of rates on the bigger farmers and every tariff meant a reduction of wages for the agricultural worker. In many cases, where there are large estates convenient to labourers' cottages, the tenants of the cottages are unable to get even a pint of milk from the owners of the estate. Even the men employed on the estate have to pay 6d. a quart for milk. After the last election the owner of an estate in the constituency which Deputy Moore and I come from reduced the working week of the tenants employed on his estate and he told them that that was the result of voting for the Labour and the Fianna Fáil candidates.

The tenants of labourers' cottages have only half an acre of very bad land. In the old days when cottages were being built the worst portions of land were allotted to the labourers. If their holdings could be extended in the way I suggest then, when there would be very little work available outside, those tenants would have an opportunity of providing food for their families. They would be in a position to feed cattle and carry out a considerable amount of tillage. I am sure this amendment will meet with the approval of all sections in the House. The amendment merely seeks to grant tenants of labourers' cottages additional parcels of land whenever land is being divided in any district. Those men are familiar with agricultural work and this will enable them to pay their rents and educate their children. If there are any further dismissals from employment in agricultural areas, those men can be occupied tilling their own land. I trust the Minister will give this amendment sympathetic consideration.

Comment on this

The Deputy is aware, of course, that at the present time there are 42,000 occupiers of labourers' cottages throughout the country. He cannot be unaware that a large number of the occupants of these cottages are not agricultural labourers. There has been a controversy raging up and down the country at the different county councils as to whether or not a man who was not a genuine agricultural labourer should be left in a cottage. Statements have been made at the different county councils that cottages are occupied by school teachers, hackney car owners, engineers, and different other types of the professional and artisan classes. The practice of the Land Commission has been that wherever and whenever an estate has been divided and where the occupants of labourers' cottages on the estate or tenants on the estate are competent to work the land such people get perhaps a few acres and sometimes an economic holding.

There were three estates divided within the last year or so and in one of them in County Meath the total number of allotments was 20. Of these, seven went to occupants of labourers' cottages. They got between them an area of 98 acres at a price of £1,079. In another case in Tipperary the total number of allotments was 22. Of these, three were occupants of labourers' cottages, and these got between them 43 acres and 3 perches of land, costing £666. In another case in Tipperary there were 24 allotments made on the estate; two of these were occupants of labourers' cottages and they got between them 59 acres at a price of £768.

I have every sympathy with the man who wants to provide economic holdings for the occupants of labourers' cottages, when these are people who can work an economic holding. I am in favour of giving allotments where the occupant of a labourer's cottage is a man who can work the land, and work an additional couple of acres, put a cow on it to get milk for his children, keep some hens and have eggs for his family. I think such a man should get the land. But I do not believe that every occupant of a labourer's cottage should get land. I am thoroughly convinced he should not. I know two labourers, occupants of cottages. One of them is a man who works every inch of his half-acre. The other has not even grazed his plot with a goat for the last 20 years. He has done nothing with the land and now, under this amendment we would be compelled to give a man of that class who has wasted his own half-acre another five acres. I certainly would not stand for it.

If a man has shown that he is capable of working the land, that he desires land, and that he would make good use of it, I would be prepared to give him an extra couple of acres or even to give him, if possible, an economic holding. But I am not prepared to give an extra holding to a man who has not proved that he can work the land he already has. I have given the House the figures in three typical estates, to show that the practice of the Land Commission has been to give land to the people living in labourers' cottages whenever these labourers have shown that they are competent to work the land. But to make that a general rule compelling the Land Commission to give land to every occupant of labourers' cottages, whether that occupant is a school teacher, plumber, or agricultural labourer, is a principle for which I am not going to stand.

Comment on this

I wish to say a few words in support of this amendment. I think the Minister should accept it. Five acres would enable a labourer to keep one cow. There are unfortunate labourers living in labourers' cottages who are paying 3/- or 4/- a week for milk. If these had five additional acres of land they would be able to keep a cow and calf. In my own constituency there are, at present, estates held by the Government which they could break up and in that way give five acres to each labourer living in the district around that estate. In my constituency there are over 5,000 labourers' cottages and each and every one of these labourers are capable of working the land. They are all agricultural labourers. For this reason I ask the Minister to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

It is quite true that the Minister can take up exceptional cases, either in his own county or in any county in the State, where the tenants of labourers' cottages possibly are not all working the small holdings attached to their cottages, but I think it is quite true also to say that the boards of health have power to deal with individuals of that kind. This amendment is put forward because it has been our experience, and it certainly is my experience in my constituency of Leix and Offaly that in no case has any cottage tenant got any addition to his small holding, out of any estates divided in that constituency. I certainly made strong representations and protests to the Land Commission in several cases where they declined to deal with such applications in the past and where cottage tenants were living adjacent to the estates. I presume the estates that the Minister quoted have been divided since the Fianna Fáil Government came into office and to that extent it is certainly an advance on the previous position.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I beg your pardon, that is not so.

Comment on this

The Land Commission officials in making inquiry as to the suitability of applicants for land under the 1923 Act scarcely ever took into consideration the names of the applicants who resided in labourers' cottages. There is one Deputy sitting on the Opposition Benches who is aware that I made protest to him against the action of a Land Commission official on two occasions. That official told the applicants that no applicant residing in a labourers' cottage would be considered for an addition to his holding. I am surprised to hear that there is even one case where a school teacher is residing in a labourer's cottage. That, certainly is not any great credit to the board of health concerned, because certainly there are more suitable and deserving local applicants for that cottage, people who would be more entitled to it than a school teacher. It would be interesting to know in what county that is. I am certain that if it were known, that county board of health would get a very bad reputation for its administration.

This matter has been carefully considered by the Labour Party before we put down this amendment. I know of very few cases where occupiers of a labourer's cottage would have the courage to apply for an economic holding. The majority of men who live in labourers' cottages, so far as my knowledge of such people goes, are men who are employed by the county council as road workers or employed as agricultural labourers, or in the outskirts of the towns, employed by the shopkeepers. In such cases it is impossible for the occupiers of labourers' cottages to produce enough food to maintain themselves and their families on their three-quarters of an acre and at the same time provide grass for a cow and a calf or two. The intention behind the minds of the people responsible for this amendment is that five acres should be made available where land is being divided, so as to provide the occupiers of labourers' cottages with two or three acres for grass and enough land to produce potatoes and vegetables for the support of the occupier and his family. That is the intention behind the amendment. I am prepared to admit, and the Minister will have to admit it also, that possibly in the case of those two bad tenants he has in mind there will be no land made available for division in that area, and in such a case it would be impossible for the Land Commission to provide this addition to the holding which he has in mind.

Comment on this

I put this to Deputy Davin. If, within the terms of his amendment, land falls into the hands of the Land Commission and if there is a man living in a labourer's cottage on the estate who has failed to work the half-acre or acre that he has, is the Land Commission to be compelled to give that man five acres?

Comment on this

There might be a reason for that. In the old days the worst half-acre on a farm was selected for the labourer's cottage—the portion that was of little use to the farmer, a barren place or a piece of bog or rock.

Comment on this

Supposing he is in possession of an acre of good land and he failed to work that land or stock it for the last five or ten years, is the Land Commission to be compelled to give that man an additional five acres?

Comment on this

Deputy Davin has completely misconceived the position. Under the 1923 Act the Land Commission always gave land to the labourers who were put out of employment, by reason of the division of an estate, whether they lived in labourers cottages or not. I know plenty of cases where labourers to the number of ten or 12 got economic holdings on an estate. Deputy Davin also said that the procedure of the Land Commission, as outlined by the Acting-Minister in that statement he read out, was an advance on the previous position. It is not. It is a retrograde step, because what is happening is that seven labourers are getting 98 acres, that is, 14 acres apiece. The labourers are now getting uneconomic holdings. I know that of my own knowledge. They are getting holdings of £6 or £7 valuation. Deputy Davin considers that that is an advance. It is not an advance. He said that was an improvement on the procedure adopted by the Land Commission under a previous dispensation. It is not an improvement. It is a very decided retrograde step. Personally, I regard it as extremely bad policy to give less than an economic holding to anybody. Deputy Davin spoke about the labourer who has to get work on the roads or to get work near towns from local farmers. What is going to happen to that labourer when all that work stops, as stop it will? The work from the local farmers will stop when this Bill is in operation, because most of the farmers who give employment to labourers will have their land taken from them. The work on the roads will stop when the money runs short, and that is not going to last very long. What will be the position either of the labourer whom the Minister speaks of who has a 14 acre holding or a £6 valuation holding, or the labourer whom Deputy Davin is interested in and who has to live on six acres of land? I will tell you where we are going—we are going back to 1848. Even before this Bill is passed in my own county I saw estates divided and holdings given to landless men of 15 or 16 acres of poor land, the valuation of which would be about £7. There is a new definition now of an economic holding. The economic holdings that were made under previous Acts were between £12 and £20 valuation and sometimes up to £25. It is now cut down always by one-third, and often by one-half. You will have a new class of small tenants whose standard of living will be extraordinarily low. That has happened already and it is certain to happen under the Bill which is to deal with congestion and landless men. There will be a new class of tenant whose condition will be worse than the occupier of a holding of £3 valuation in 1848 or 1860.

Comment on this

I do not want to be unfair to Deputy Hogan or to misrepresent the position during his régime, because I know that when an estate was acquired and divided the men who lost their employment as a result of the acquisition of such an estate were almost in all cases that I know of provided for. The Minister has read out a list which I believe includes the names of occupiers of labourers' cottages who were not employed on the estates concerned and that is what I say is an advance on the previous position in so far as I cannot give the name of one occupier of a labourer's cottage not employed on the estate who got any land under the Act of 1923 in my constituency.

Comment on this

What good is six acres to a man anyway?

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister to accept the amendment. I would ask him to be big enough not to mind the officials in the Land Commission and let them do their work which they failed to do up to this.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the new section be there inserted."

Tá 26
·
Níl 45
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 129:—

In sub-section (1), page 22, line 47, to delete the words "notwithstanding that the price has not been agreed upon or fixed."

I think this amendment is covered by the next amendment in the name of the Minister. The only point I would like to be certain about is that payment will be made to the landlord on a fixed date, and the object of the amendment is to provide that it should be made on the appointed day. A long time may elapse between the appointed day and the time when the price is fixed, and in that time the value of land may appreciate or depreciate. I want to provide that the landlord shall be secured and that the value of the land should be prescribed. I think, as I say, that the object of the amendment is covered by amendment 130.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is amendment 131 also covered by 130?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

It raises the same question. In sub-section (2), after the word "behalf" it proposes to add the words "and at the value of the lands on the appointed day". The section gives power to take untenanted land and to fix the price provisionally. Sub-section (2) provides "In default of agreement the price of lands in respect of which the appointed day has been declared under the foregoing sub-section of this section shall be fixed in accordance with the provision of the Land Purchase Acts in that behalf". My amendment proposes to add to these words in order to make it definite and clear what, I think, the section proposes to do, that is, to declare the value of the land on the appointed day. The value of the land may change in favour or against the Land Commission but I think it is the intention of the Minister to fix the price on the appointed day. It may work in his favour in some cases or against him in others, but it would prevent litigation and disputes as to what the real date is. I suggest that the Minister might accept that amendment.

Comment on this

I think it is covered by amendment 130.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

With great respect I do not think it is covered. This section stands by itself. A good deal of argument could be put in on the construction of the section as it stands, that it does not mean the appointed day and that it may mean another date.

Comment on this

I move amendment 130:—

In sub-section (2), line 52, after the word "fixed" to insert the words "by reference to the value thereof as on the appointed day".

Comment on this

I am advised that No. 131 is covered by No. 130.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I do not know. It is a different sub-section, dealing with a specific case, and I am not quite satisfied that it is covered.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is the same sub-section.

Comment on this

I move amendment 132:—

In sub-section (4), page 23, line 14, to insert after the word "interest" the words and brackets "(less Income Tax)".

Sub-section (3) provides that the vendor is entitled to receive interest on the amount of the bonds, less income tax. In the following sub-section there is also reference to the interest to be paid on the bonds, and there is no provision for the deduction of income tax. I want to make it perfectly clear, and I am sure the Minister will accept the amendment, that income tax is not going to be deducted twice over. It would appear from sub-section (3) and sub-section (4) that the Minister has a right to deduct it twice over. Line 5, sub-section (3) says:—"...a sum equal to interest (less income tax)." Lines 13 and 14 of sub-section (4) refer to "the amount so paid into the Land Bond Fund, together with the interest paid on the bonds..." There is no mention of income tax there.

Comment on this

Under the Income Tax Acts, income tax must be deducted at the full standard rate from the interest on land bonds. It may be that the recipient of the interest is entitled to repayment from the Revenue Commissioners of the tax so deducted. If he has in fact obtained repayment of such tax obviously he is not entitled to deduct the same tax from the interest which the Land Commission calls upon him to refund under sub-section (4).

Comment on this

I see the point.

Comment on this

If he has not already claimed relief or repayment from the Revenue Commissioners it is open to him to do so immediately the interest has been refunded to the Land Commission.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I move amendment No. 133:—

In sub-section (5), line 25, to delete the figures "25" and substitute the word "ten."

The sub-section provides that in relation to guarantee deposits the provisions of the Act of 1931 shall apply in the case of untenanted land for which a provisional price has been declared under this section, with the modification that the deposit shall be 25 per cent. of the provisional price. That seems to me to be too large a sum to require as deposit. The price will always be fixed within a very narrow margin, and I therefore suggest to the Minister that he should accept the amendment.

Comment on this

If there is not a fairly wide margin naturally the tendency with the Land Commission will be to play safe. The provisional price will not be in operation very long, I hope, and I think it is better that the Land Commission should have a margin of 25 per cent.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I see the force of what the Minister says, but I do suggest that 25 per cent. is too high. Would the Minister consider the figure of 15 per cent? Twenty-five per cent. is an enormous proportion having regard to the competency of the valuers who act for the Land Commission. It seems incredible that there would be such a wide margin.

Comment on this

The provisional price, I presume, will be based on the inspector's valuation of the land. It is scarcely conceivable that there would be such a margin between the inspector's valuation and the price which would ultimately be fixed by the appeal tribunal. Taking the cases which passed through the Land Commission for, let us say, the last six months, it will be found that there is scarcely a difference of 5 per cent.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

It would meet the point if we made it the same as in the case of tenanted land—10 per cent., but in any case not exceeding 25 per cent., as the judicial commissioner shall think fit.

Comment on this

Twenty-five per cent. would be far too high.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I am suggesting "but not exceeding 25 per cent. as the judicial commissioner shall think fit." I suggest "10 per cent., or such greater sum as the judicial commissioner may think fit, but not exceeding 25 per cent."

Comment on this

Not exceeding 20 per cent.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Make it 20 per cent. Twenty-five per cent. is too wide a margin.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

The Land Commission will not apply it unless it is thought reasonable.

Comment on this

It might happen that quite a long period would elapse.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

It will not be put as high as 25 per cent. unless there are strong reasons for doing so.

Comment on this

Twenty-five per cent. is mentioned quite specifically.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I am suggesting the acceptance of an amendment to make it read as I have said.

Comment on this

I move amendment 134:—

At the end of the section to add a new sub-section as follows:—

(6) Notwithstanding anything in Section 36 of the Land Act, 1931, interest on land bonds advanced as the price of untenanted lands for which a provisional price has been declared under this section shall be paid to the person appearing to the Land Commission to be the owner of the lands prior to the purchase, but the judicial commissioner may, on the application of any interested person, direct that such interest or any part thereof shall be paid to such interested person.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

The amendment moved by the Minister meets the principle of my amendment No. 135.

Comment on this

I move amendment 136:—

In sub-section (2), line 36, after the word "the" to insert the word "appeal."

This is purely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I move amendment 137:—

In sub-section (2), to delete in line 36 the words "on a question of law."

That is to say that where a petition is presented and questions arising under it are to be considered by the lay commissioners their determination shall be final, subject only to an appeal to the tribunal. We propose to delete the words "on a question of law." We think every question that arises for consideration might be left to the tribunal to settle, whether it is a question of law or a question of fact.

Comment on this

I cannot accept that amendment.

Comment on this

There is then no appeal of any kind from the Commissioners on the resumption of a holding. A holding may be resumed by the Land Commission, that is to say, by the lay commissioners, without any appeal of any kind. A £4,000 or £5,000 holding may be resumed without any appeal to any tribunal. Remember the discussion which took place on the constitution of the tribunal; the Minister carried his point. Here is a case of the resumption of tenanted land, and there is to be no appeal of any kind. That is a most extraordinary state of affairs.

Comment on this

Might I appeal to the Minister to reconsider his decision, so as to accelerate the progress of the Bill? It is not an unreasonable amendment.

Comment on this

I suggest that the Deputy put it down again on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment 138:—

In sub-section (3), after the word "holding," line 46, to delete the words "notwithstanding that the resumption price may not have been fixed" and substitute the words "on the date on which the resumption price shall have been determined."

I do not think the Minister will have any objection to accepting that amendment. It really does not impose any hardship on the Land Commission, and it does help to facilitate the tenant from whom the land is being resumed.

Comment on this

This section is more or less on the same lines as Section 29.

Comment on this

I admit that.

Comment on this

If the Deputy's amendment were accepted it would take us back to where we are at the moment. What we are trying to do is to acquire lands and to divide lands on a provisional price basis.

Comment on this

My amendment only relates to the question of price.

Comment on this

Yes, but the principle of Section 29 is that the Land Commission will have the right to go in on land even though the price has not been finally determined. The same principle is in Section 30.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

It would alter the whole section if this amendment were put in.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 139:—

At the end of the section to add a new sub-section as follows:—

If any such petition as aforesaid is granted then it shall not be lawful for the Land Commission to exercise their powers of resumption and the holding shall be vested in the tenant.

Sub-section (1) of Section 30 provides that a tenant of a holding shall have the right to petition the Land Commission against the resumption of that particular holding. Following on that, procedure is laid down by means of which the Land Commission shall determine or shall deal with that petition. I propose to add at the end of the section that if such a petition is granted it shall not be lawful for the Land Commission to exercise their powers of resumption and that the holding shall be vested in the tenant. I do not know whether it is necessary to add a sub-section of that kind at all. The vesting of the holding in the tenant following the grant of the petition should be a purely automatic process. I do not imagine that the Minister will have any objection to accepting this amendment of mine.

Comment on this

The position is that if the Land Commission decide not to resume a holding, they automatically vest it in the tenant.

Comment on this

I want to make that perfectly clear.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 140:—

In sub-section (1), line 56, page 23, after the word "land" to insert the words "other than land purchased under the provisions of the Land Purchase Acts."

Under Section 31 of the Land Act of 1923 it is provided that advances may be made to the following persons or bodies for the purchase by them from the Land Commission of parcels of land:

(a) A person being the tenant or proprietor of a holding which in the opinion of the Land Commission is not an economic holding.

(b) A person who has entered into agreement with the Land Commission for the exchange of his holding.

(c) A person who was evicted within 25 years before the passing of the Land Act of 1923.

(d) A person being a labourer who by reason of the sale of any lands under the provisions of the Land Purchase Acts has been deprived of his employment, and

(f) any other person to whom in the opinion of the Land Commission an advance ought to be made.

The last provision of course covers landless men. The Minister has stated that Section 31 gives him much greater power to deal, not alone with the problem of congestion but with the problem of landless men and other classes, than he had under the previous Land Acts. In this amendment I want to limit the Minister's powers to acquire only untenanted land under this particular section for the purpose of dealing with certain classes of persons mentioned in Section 31 of the Land Act of 1923. I want chiefly to insure that registered land or purchased land shall be utilised only for the purpose of relieving congestion. Section 31 as it is worded undoubtedly gives the Minister most extraordinary powers. When Section 31 is related to Section 28 the Minister has far greater powers than he had under any previous Land Act for the purposes of acquiring and distributing land to classes of persons mentioned in Section 31 of the 1923 Act. I want to distinguish so far as the acquisition of land is concerned between the operation of Section 31 and Section 28, and to ensure that the land acquired under Section 28 shall be utilised for the purpose of relieving congestion and that that acquired under Section 31 shall be divided for the purposes mentioned in Section 31 of the Land Act of 1923.

Comment on this

I might remind the Deputy that a few moments ago he was very gravely concerned about evicted tenants. There are certain cases where there are evicted tenants and representatives of evicted tenants living alongside men who had the land vested in them—in some cases holding up to 1,500 acres. We cannot touch an acre of that even to deal with the case of the genuine evicted tenant as the law stands. We want to take power to deal with the cases of the evicted tenants.

Comment on this

I think the Minister said that there was only about 200 such tenants. He would not require much land to deal with them.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider this? He has protected the £2,000 worth of purchased land in a certain way. He provides in his own Bill that it shall only be taken off a tenant if and when the Land Commission provide a holding of the same market value for the tenant. Would he add this further protection, that that land shall be only taken on the basis set out in the Act for the relief of congestion?

Comment on this

If the Deputy would turn to amendment No. 143 in my name, he would see that I want to take power to provide land so as to include the provision of sportsfields, parks, pleasure grounds, playgrounds and gardens for the inhabitants of villages, towns or cities or for schools. I want to have power under Section 31 to provide even where the land is vested for playgrounds and gardens for villages, towns, cities and schools.

Comment on this

Does the Minister suggest that he is going to take special powers under the Bill for the purpose of providing playgrounds, town parks, etc., by acquiring registered land?

Comment on this

I want to have power to acquire registered land for that purpose.

Comment on this

Purchased land for that purpose?

Comment on this

Yes, where necessary.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That takes my breath away. I thought it was generally understood that it is some hardship, to put it no further, to take £2,000 worth of vested land where a man has a holding working it as an ordinary farmer. I thought it was generally agreed that it was a hardship to take that land. It is agreed by the Government that it is a hardship to take it because they came in with a Bill which gave special rights for the protection of such land. I am suggesting that in addition to the right of protection they provide for such holding, his holding can only be taken if he is paid its market value, and that if he gets a holding of equal market value such holding can only be taken for the relief of congestion. You are dealing only with land worth £2,000 which is worked in accordance with proper methods of husbandry. Would it not be a monstrous thing to take that land?

Comment on this

I would remind Deputy Hogan that that land can be taken compulsorily under other Acts. First of all, it can be taken for the building of labourers' cottages and it can also be taken under different Housing Acts in order to provide building ground. It can be taken under the Shannon scheme, and was taken under the Shannon scheme.

Comment on this

Does the Minister really think that is an analogy? You are taking power here to take it for landless men. That is a different proposition. That is the kind of holding on which there would be only one labourer's cottage at most. I have hardly ever seen a holding of 140 acres with more than one labourer's cottage. Here you are taking power to take the sort of land to which I have referred for landless men, and by that sort of land I mean £2,000 worth of purchased land on which a man and his family live, and which he farms as an ordinary working farmer in accordance with proper methods of husbandry. Is it too much to ask for such protection that it can only be taken for the relief of congestion?

Comment on this

As this amendment stands, it does not apply to £2,000 worth of land only.

Comment on this

I know that, but if the Minister refuses that amendment will he give consideration to the other matter involved on the Report Stage?

Comment on this

I should like to go into that, but as it stands I would not consider it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I understood the Minister to say that he could not accept the amendment as it stands, but, if he does not, I think he should consider giving it sufficient consideration to see that that sort of farm is protected to the extent that it can only be taken for the relief of congestion.

Comment on this

We will consider that.

Comment on this

I move amendment 141, which is a drafting amendment:—

In sub-section (1), page 23, line 58, after the figures "1923" to insert the words "as extended by this Act."

Comment on this

The next amendment, No. 142, I think, is covered, to a very large extent, by what the Minister said to Deputy Hogan with regard to considering the matters raised in these amendments between now and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 143:—

Before Section 32 to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) The provisions of Sections 4 and 20 of the Irish Land Act, 1903, and Section 18 of the Irish Land Act, 1909, as extended by Section 69 of the Land Act, 1923, shall be and are hereby further extended so as to include the provision of sports fields, parks, pleasure-grounds, playgrounds, and gardens for the inhabitants of villages, towns or cities, or for schools amongst the purposes for which advances may be made under those sections, and schemes may be framed or amended under the said sections for or so as to include all or any of those purposes.

(2) The trustees mentioned in paragraph (e) of sub-section (1) of Section 31 of the Land Act, 1923, shall include trustees for all or any of the purposes mentioned in the foregoing sub-section of this section.

Comment on this

There would have been a lot of debate on this section were it not for the undertaking given by the Minister that the other matters will be considered on Report Stage. I take it that it will be considered?

Comment on this

Yes, it will be considered.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 144:—

Before Section 32 to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) Where lands have been vested in a purchaser under any Land Purchase Act prior to the Land Act, 1923, and the sporting rights (including fishing rights) on or over such lands or in the waters adjoining or intersecting such lands were not so vested, the Land Commission may, if of the opinion that it would be for the benefit of the country that such rights should be acquired and that such rights (other than fishing rights) should be vested in the proprietors of the lands on or over which such rights (other than as aforesaid) are exercised as an appurtenance to such lands and if such proprietors are willing to purchase such rights (other than as aforesaid), make an order declaring the appointed day in respect of all such rights and vesting the same in the Land Commission at a price, payable in land bonds, to be fixed (in default of agreement by the lay commissioners subject to a right of appeal to the appeal tribunal.

(2) Section 41 of the Land Act, 1927, shall apply to fishing rights acquired under this section.

Comment on this

I have some doubts about this section and I should like to hear what the Minister has to say about it.

Comment on this

The position at the moment is that with regard to any sporting rights that were vested in the landlord under the old Acts no matter how much local agitation is against the landlord going over the tenant's land, nothing can be done to settle the dispute. We want to take power in this Bill, where the Land Commission sees fit, to acquire those sporting rights and vest them in the tenants who are agreeable to purchase them. With regard to the fishing rights, we want to take the same power as was taken under the 1923 Act under which all the fishing rights were bought up. We want to go back over the old Acts and to purchase these rights that were vested in the old landlords and vest them in the tenants as was done under the 1923 Act.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment No. 145:—

Before Section 32 to insert a new section as follows:—

Notwithstanding anything in this or other Land Acts no land shall be compulsorily acquired subsequent to the coming into operation of this Act unless the Land Commission are satisfied that such land is not at present providing an amount of employment proportionate to its acreage and character, and for the purpose of computing such employment children of the tenant or proprietor employed on the land shall be taken into account.

The principle of this amendment, standing in my name, as I understand it, has been accepted by the Minister and by the Fianna Fáil Party as a whole. They have frequently indicated, in the course of the debates on this Bill, that in practice no proprietor, or tenant, will be disturbed on his land if the land in question is giving its due amount of employment. If that is so, I suggest that it would be an enormous improvement to this Bill to embody that principle in the Bill and that it would tremendously increase the feeling of security of tenants, or proprietors, of land throughout the country. It would give the Land Commission a valuable working principle on which to go and I suggest it would be a great help to the whole carrying on of agriculture in this country and would enable everybody to feel that he was safe in improving his land and making the very best of it and sinking money in it. As long as the authorities are satisfied that the land was giving its due amount of employment, I think the proprietor of such land should not be disturbed under any pretext.

Comment on this

I should like to hear what Deputy Hogan has to say on that.

Comment on this

If that is so, the Minister will hear from me. I think it is a perfectly sound amendment in the circumstances of this Bill. Personally, I am against the Land Commission, or any other body, telling any man how to work his land, and I take it that so is Deputy MacDermot. But the position now is that in a great many respects it is left to various departments to say what sort of stock a farmer should have and it is not for me to complain about that. The position is generally now for departments to say on what lines lands should be farmed. As Deputy MacDermot pointed out, the principle in this amendment is a principle which has been absolutely accepted by the Government Party. All their public pronouncements have been on the lines that the Bill is not to affect any land that is giving value to the community either from the point of view of production or from the point of view of the number of labourers employed. I should be particularly in favour of this because whatever little land I have supports a rather big number of workmen, but I assure the Acting-Minister that if he had that in his mind in inviting me to speak I am not thinking of that so much.

Under the circumstances of the present time, however, having regard to the length to which this Bill goes and to the insecurity in which tenants are placed, I am entirely in favour of this amendment. One thing seems to me to be clear, and that is that the Government cannot, consistent with any of the statements that they have been making, refuse this amendment. This Bill, if passed into law, will give the Land Commission power to acquire the land of biggish farmers whether they employ much labour or not. It will tend, undoubtedly, to make them feel a sense of insecurity and in that respect, also, the effect of the Bill in future will be that people will do less work, incur less capital expenditure and, therefore, employ less labour.

I am perfectly satisfied that, except for this section, the whole trend of this Bill will be to employ, if you wish, less paid labour on the land. This is the only section that will do anything to counteract that general tendency in the Bill. I think that must be admitted. Every previous section of the Bill will at least have the tendency of preventing owners of land from incurring expenditure and, therefore, of employing labour on whatever land may be left to them. This attempts to counteract that. It is an attempt which is consistent with the declarations made by the Party opposite. Apart from politics altogether, there is no doubt about it that the particular farm which is employing the most labour, is producing most and is doing most for the country. No Party, no matter what their policy on land may be, has ever denied that, or attempted to deny it in public. In that state of affairs I do not see how the Government can refuse to accept this amendment, and particularly I do not see how the Labour Party can vote against if they have any interest other than a political interest in labour. I honestly believe that this may do something to create employment on the land. There are people yet in this country with a certain amount of land, up to 200 acres or thereabouts—I am not speaking of millionaires—who have a certain amount of capital, whose lands would not be taken in any event, and who will feel a sense of security as a result of the passage of this. If they have that provision there it will undoubtedly have the effect of getting them to go in for a type of farming that, while it may not be any more remunerative, will give more employment. I know a few people who happen to have a bit of money who are anxious to hold their land and are thinking on those lines. Apart altogether from the political aspects of this, I believe that the acceptance of the amendment would be a genuine improvement from that point of view to this Act.

Comment on this

As one who comes from another part of the country to that represented by Deputy Hogan, I would urge the Minister to accept the amendment. This would be giving the good farmer the minimum security that he needs. Like most Deputies who have been to their constituencies recently and who have been questioned about this Bill, I personally would be glad to be able to point to such a provision in this Bill: that a farm that is being carried on in a proper way will not be touched. We have had the assurance from the Government Benches and from Government Deputies inside and outside the House that there is no fear whatever that this Bill is going to touch the person who is carrying on in the way that he should carry on. I support Deputy MacDermot's amendment. I would say to the Minister that he would be doing a very good service to this Bill and to the people who want to carry on in the country by accepting the amendment.

Comment on this

Deputy Hogan realises that this is going back on a section that he fought for in 1923: resumption proceedings.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I guessed there would be something like that when I invited the Minister to speak on this.

Comment on this

Under Sections 28 and 29 of the 1923 Act the Land Commission can take land from anybody, from a judicial tenant, and resume his holding no matter how he is working it, even though he is providing employment on it, and need not necessarily give him any land in exchange. That is what all the row was about in the case of the 1923 Act. Also under that Act the Land Commission can take a vested holding for the relief of congestion, but in that case they have to give land equally suitable elsewhere. I must say that I am sympathetic to what Deputy MacDermot is trying to do. The difficulty is to find words that will cover the idea that he has in mind. If we had any standard unit value of land; that one could say that a man who has 20 units of that value was keeping himself and one workman on it, or one son over 18 years of age, it would be easy to legislate, but we have no unit value at the moment. The poor law valuation is not, in fact, in present circumstances any criterion of the value of land.

Comment on this

Would not the Minister agree that the Land Commission would have to take this point into consideration? In any case they would have to try to make some estimate if they were going to do their work well. They have a whole lot of other problems to consider in connection with the acquisition of land that are every bit as difficult as this is: to assess what is the amount of employment the land ought to give. I was speaking quite honestly this afternoon when I said that we wish to be in a position to reassure people's minds throughout the country as to the effect of this Bill. There is nothing that would put us in that position more thoroughly, apart from the withdrawal of the Bill altogether, than the acceptance of this amendment. I have spoken to some members of the Labour Party and find that they are sympathetic to it. I am not surprised, because, as Deputy Hogan has pointed out, there is nothing that could more conduce to using land in the way that would give the greatest amount of employment than a provision of this kind.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have been informed that agreement was reached by all Parties to finish the Committee Stage of this Bill by nine o'clock. If that is so, is it agreed that all Government amendments be taken now and that all other amendments be left over for Report Stage?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What has the Minister to say with regard to this amendment?

Comment on this

I will consider it between now and the Report Stage. I would like to cover the idea that Deputy MacDermot has in mind, if it is possible to find a form of words without restricting us too much. The Deputy can hold over his amendment for Report Stage, and move it again if I am not able to bring in something to meet him.

Comment on this

Then I am to understand that I can move the amendment again on Report Stage?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

We are agreeable to have all Government amendments taken now.

SECTION 33.

(3) Clauses (b), (c) and (g) of sub-section (2) of Section 24 of the Land Act, 1923, shall be and are hereby amended....

The following Government amendments moved by the Acting-Minister for Lands and Fisheries were agreed to:—

147.—To delete sub-section (1).

149.—To delete sub-section (2).

154.—In sub-section (3), page 24, line 39, to delete the brackets and letter "(c)".

154a.—Before sub-section (4), to insert a new sub-section as follows:

(4) Where sub-section (1) of Section 24 of the Land Act, 1923, has become or hereafter becomes applicable to any land by virtue of the amendment of that section made by this section, such application of the said sub-section to such land shall not be prejudiced or prevented merely by reason of a previous determination that the said sub-section did not apply to such land.

154b.—To delete sub-section (4).

Comment on this

On the Report Stage, I propose to move an amendment to this section to make it clear that the term "permanently submerged" includes land which is covered by the regular flow of the tides or is lost to cultivation or use by the action of a river or other cause outside the control of the tenant.

Comment on this

What about an embankment that gives away and damages land?

Comment on this

That is covered already.

Comment on this

I move amendment 158:—

In line 52, after the figures "1923" to insert the words and figures "or Section 33 of that Act."

Comment on this

I move amendment 167a:—

Before Section 48 to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) The Land Commission when distributing the purchase money of an estate shall deduct from the amount of the purchase money payable to any person any debt due or payable by such person to any Minister or Government Department of which the Land Commission has received notice before the making of payment to such person.

(2) When the amount of any such debt has not been ascertained the Land Commission shall retain such sum as the Minister or Government Department requires out of the amount of the purchase money to which the person by whom such debt is due or payable is entitled until he has delivered the necessary accounts or made the necessary returns to enable the Minister or Department to whom or to which such debt is due to determine its exact amount and such exact amount has been determined.

Comment on this

Is that inserted at the instance of the Revenue Commissioners?

Comment on this

At my instance.

Comment on this

It seems extraordinary.

Comment on this

I want to raise a point on this.

Comment on this

It can be dealt with on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I suggest that this amendment should be left over.

Comment on this

On the Report Stage I will bring in an amendment to amend Section 73 of the 1923 Act to give the Land Commission power to admit to the benefits of the Land Acts a tenancy expressed to be for temporary convenience if on consideration of all the circumstances they come to the conclusion that the expression was inserted in the instrument of tenancy in order to exclude a tenancy when in fact there was no real temporary convenience to be served.

Comment on this

From that point of view would the Minister consider amending the definition section to deal with agistment or grazing tenancy in lands under lease?

Comment on this

I will consider it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

So that the whole tenure of the agreement will be taken into the agreement.

Comment on this

And not what is in the lease.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Are there any non-Government amendments which we have not reached, to the principle of which the Minister would agree?

Comment on this

I do not think so. As to amendment 161 in the name of Deputy G. O'Sullivan, I will bring in an amendment to change the wording.

Comment on this

Will the Minister consider Section 38 again on the Report Stage?

Comment on this

Yes. I also want to bring in a drafting amendment to Section 21, so that a funding annuity may be charged on a holding as if it were an ordinary advance, and a drafting amendment to Section 12 (6) (c) page 9, line 24 to insert the words "and additional sums" after the words "annual sums."

Comment on this