Use of Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act—Motion.
Contributions 1–191 of 587. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I beg to move:
That in the opinion of the Dáil the Government's use of the Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act, 1931, has been unjust and oppressive and is deserving of censure.
The motion covers both the bringing of the Act into operation and the administration of the Act after being brought into operation, and, if the Government fail to justify what they have done under either heading, there is no doubt that their conduct can be justly described as "unjust and oppressive." The subject matter of this motion is one that necessarily excites strong feeling in all those who believe that the Government has acted unfairly and tyrannically, but I shall try to say what I have to say in a good-tempered manner, and to refrain from leading the debate into the bitterness and personalities that were aroused by the same subject in 1931. I have, however, one strong thing, and even an offensive thing, to say, and I propose to say it at once, and to get it over. That is in reference to the Labour Party. It is stated in the Press, with apparent authority, that the Labour Party intend to support the Government on this motion. Well, I have studied politics long enough in various countries to know that one must not expect too much idealism among politicians.
Comment on this
I must say that I have never heard of, or read of, any action so unprincipled, so contemptible, and so definitely degrading to political life, as would be a vote by the Labour Party in favour of the Government on this motion. They would not merely be voting in flagrant contradiction of all their declarations on this subject in the past, but they would be voting, and I do not hesitate to say it, against the opinions to-day of those among them who have any longer got minds that are free to think, or hearts that are free to feel.
The Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act, 1931, which I propose to call henceforth by its popular name, the Public Safety Act, is an Act of appalling severity. It is not my business to inquire whether that Act was justified in 1931, but I will say quite candidly that there are things in it I personally would feel a difficulty in supporting, under any circumstances. At any rate, this can scarcely be denied —that these powers of life and death, these powers of defining crime and punishing crime, should not be given to a few military officers, or to the Executive Council, unless upon the ground of overwhelming necessity. The Government cannot escape the imputation of having been unjust and oppressive unless it can show, first, that there has been a widespread prevalence of serious crime, and, secondly, that the machinery of the ordinary law for dealing with such crime has broken down.
In 1931, the then Opposition went much farther than that in the position they took up. They admitted, through Deputy de Valera, as he then was, that "terrible things had recently been done." They did not deny that there had been intimidation of witnesses, and intimidation of juries, which had prevented the punishment of the offenders. They did not deny that there had been violence used against the Civic Guards, but they claimed that there had been, in some cases, provocation by the Civic Guards. They took the view that for a Government to bring in such a Bill as the Public Safety Bill was in itself a confession of that Government's unfitness to govern, and that in the words of a certain Deputy Fahy, "A Government should take office that believed that they could govern without such a measure as this." Deputy de Valera, as he then was, stated that a Government bringing in such a measure was acting on the motto "If anyone gets in your path, squelch him, by God squelch him." Deputy Seán T. O'Kelly said that the measure could only sow the seeds of strife and dissension. Deputy Ruttledge said that the constitution of the tribunal was enough in itself to damn the whole Bill, as members of the Defence Forces would necessarily regard themselves as servants of the Executive Council. Senator Colonel Moore declared that the whole law was in such conflict with the first principles of justice that any sentence of the tribunal would be devoid of moral validity, and any death sentence would be nothing short of murder. All these things, and more, with illustrations from the lives of the principal members of the then Government, were said by Deputy MacEntee, whose sober and kindly eloquence so endears him to this House.
Whether or not all these fundamental objections to the Public Safety Act can be sustained, I am on safe ground, at all events, in saying that a prevalence of crime and a breakdown of the ordinary law are necessary to justify it.
Let us consider the circumstances under which the Act has been brought into operation by the present Government. Where was the serious crime? I know of no crime or, at any rate, of no crime amongst the organisation against which the Act is being directed. The Government brought this Act into operation to deal with the National Guard. What crimes have the National Guard committed? I know of only one attempt at a full statement of the case against the National Guard. That is the statement that was made by the Minister for Justice in the Seanad. I can only describe that case as unbelievably frivolous. Objection was taken to the internal constitution of the organisation and also to their political objects. As regards their internal constitution, the duties of obedience and discipline, the system by which officials were appointed by selection from the top rather than by election from the bottom, were things that existed equally in bodies that no Government outside perhaps Germany, Spain or Mexico, would think of banning. They exist in religious Orders, in the Boy Scouts, in the Salvation Army and even in the I.R.A. Te duty of obedience does not imply that orders are to be obeyed if those orders are contrary to law. In any case, the National Guard has substantially the same constitution as when it was known as the A.C.A., and the Government did not find it necessary to take these extraordinary measures until it became the National Guard and until General O'Duffy took command of it. So far as I can learn, the influence of General O'Duffy on the National Guard was entirely beneficial. He purged it, let me say quite candidly, of some doubtful characters. I do not know of any large political party or political organisation which has not got some doubtful characters. General O'Duffy purged the organisation of some doubtful characters. He announced that it was to be definitely a non-military body, that it was not to have military drill and that it was not to carry arms. What has there been in the career of General O'Duffy that would make us believe these pledges were not to be relied upon? I certainly wished—I said so at the time— that he had chosen for the organisation some less military-sounding name than the National Guard. As it happened, the conversations which brought about the formation of the United Ireland Party had begun a few weeks before General O'Duffy took over the A.C.A. and called it the National Guard. One of the things I had brought forward at the very first of these conversations was that the A.C.A. should be reorganised and that it should be given a civilian name such as the "Young Ireland League." Nevertheless, when General O'Duffy, with his distinguished record of service to the State, took over control of the National Guard, I could not but feel that, from every point of view, it was a satisfactory thing—that his experience of discipline and his wide knowledge of how to deal with men would be of the greatest value in securing that the organisation would be conducted upon right lines.
There is no disguising the fact that just as the Irish Volunteers were brought into existence by the licence that was accorded to the Ulster Volunteers, so the A.C.A., in the form it took in 1932, was brought into existence by the licence that was given to the I.R.A. It was also obvious that some of those who were prominent in the A.C.A. were influenced and had their views and their speeches coloured by observation of Fascist developments in certain foreign countries. It did seem possible, in view of the feeling aroused by the parades and the intimidation indulged in by some members of the I.R.A., and in view of the articles that appeared week by week in the "Phoblacht," that we were moving towards a civil conflict between what the President described as "private armies." When General O'Duffy took over, I felt reassured and I believe I was justified in feeling reassured. I thought that a youth movement, laying stress on athletics and laying stress on voluntary, public service and on devotion to law and order and to the rights of the individual was the best possible antidote to the corruption of our young people by subversive influences.
It is true that, in some of his speeches, General O'Duffy expressed himself as wishing to make rather radical reforms in parliamentary government. Candidly, I do not agree with everything he said on that head, but there was not a word of illegality in it and no suggestion that the reforms he advocated were to be introduced by force. What, then, explains the violent excitement registered by the Government, their stocktaking of arms, their absurd Guy Fawkes fire in the cellar of Leinster House, their enrolling of new Civic Guards, experienced in the use of the gun, and the sensationalism that caused such an inrush of foreign newspaper correspondents to report upon the lurid happenings in this country—all these events that, according to the statement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce in this House last night, caused so much damage to Irish trade? What was the real cause of all that? I am quite sure that the cause of it was the sudden conviction of the Government that General O'Duffy was a political danger to them.
Comment on this
I shall not accuse them of having acted fraudulently. I shall assume that they believed, or half believed, what they said about the danger of the State. But men must be judged by their actions, and the action of the Government in calling in the Public Safety Act and proclaiming the National Guard is none the less unjust and oppressive even if they worked themselves up to the belief that they had grounds for doing so. Whether they intended it or not, they acted to the full on the motto referred to by the then Deputy de Valera, "If anyone gets in your path, squelch him, by God squelch him."
Having obtained their dictatorial powers, the Government did not stop at using them against the National Guard or even impeding the Young Ireland Association, which has taken the place of the National Guard. The powers which they had not thought necessary for dealing with the terrible acts of sabotage that took place during the railway strike and which they did not think necessary for dealing with the attacks on private property and individual liberty by members of the I.R.A. they are now using against farmers who have been driven to desperation by the ruin brought upon them by the policy of the Government. As the case of some of these men is sub judice, I am not in a position to speak freely on that head.
Comment on this
I will say this: assuming there was a deliberate refusal to pay rates by people able to pay them, or assuming even that there was a movement to persuade or to intimidate people not to pay rates who could pay rates, there is nothing at all to show that the ordinary law was not sufficient to deal with the situation, and, as Deputy Davin said in 1931, that there is not still ample machinery for dealing with any refusal to pay rent or to pay rates. The Government were not confronted with any sudden or unexpected emergency. Anybody with sense knew beforehand that there was going to be difficulty this year about collecting rates and indeed about collecting annuities when it comes to collecting annuities. They had had sufficient illustration of that from what occurred last year when for so long they insisted and pretended that annuities must be paid and when in the end they took action to save themselves from having to incur the odium of collecting them. I may say that I personally was put in this awkward position, that having been consulted by supporters last year as to whether to pay or not to pay, I advised them that it was their duty to pay, and they did pay, and that I afterwards had letters of reproach from them and inquiry as to whether I could not get their money back.
Comment on this
What I said last year with regard to rent I also said with regard to rates. What I said was in strict accordance with the official policy of the Centre Party and the National Farmers and Ratepayers' League. At the very first meeting on 15th September last year of the National Farmers and Ratepayers' League I ran the risk of incurring unpopularity, and I did incur the severe displeasure of my friend Deputy Belton, because I opposed and defeated a motion which seemed to imply that it was not the duty of the people in this country to pay their rent and their rates if they could pay them.
Comment on this
In frequent speeches in the country, in letters to the newspapers, and in speeches here in this Dáil, both my colleagues and myself have stated over and over again that we would not stand for any person refusing to pay who had the means wherewith to pay.
Comment on this
At the same time, we have always said, and we still say, that it is grossly unjust of the Government to seek to collect these moneys in view of what they have done to the farmers of this country, and that so far as we can legally save from victimisation the unfortunate people who cannot pay we certainly will do everything to save them. All this talk about conspiracy in relation to non-payment is pure and absolute humbug. Take the case of County Kerry, which I suppose is the most Fianna Fáil county in Ireland. We had the figures published only the other day showing that in the collection of the current rates out of £76,000 only £4,000 have been got in. Is there a Fianna Fáil conspiracy down in County Kerry? If so, why have not the local Fianna Fáil Cumann been proclaimed under the Public Safety Act? The Government's policy was bound to lead to all this. I suggest that these oppressive and sensational measures against the unfortunate farmers are just what Americans call a "frame-up" by which they hope to persuade the country, and, indeed, even to persuade themselves, that what has come to pass is not a proof of their rashness and of their folly but of the wickedness of the Opposition.
I do not propose to detain the House at this stage because I feel that I shall be obliged to say something more in reply to this debate. My difficulty at the present moment is that the Government have not put up any case for us to deal with. They simply have not begun to make a defence of the harsh and arbitrary action that they have taken. Still less have they attempted to explain the lack of impartiality with which the Public Safety Act is being administered by them. They have given us no clue to the mental process by which they reconcile what they are doing now with what they did in 1931. I can find more excuse for them than I can for the Labour Party. It is the besetting sin of Governments to believe that the Opposition is composed of enemies of the country who ought to be squelched, or sent to bed, as the Minister for Industry and Commerce puts it. But a Labour Party that supports tyranny has been false to everything for which a Labour Party stands.
Comment on this
I should be glad if the Deputy would explain anything he has to explain in this House. This conduct of the Government, although it can be advantageously differentiated from that of the Labour Party, has certainly antagonised me more than anything that has occurred since they came into office. In 1931 Deputy de Valera referred to the terrible things that had been done. He said that the true remedies were infinite patience and brotherly love. I do not sneer at that sort of talk, mind you. I do not sneer at it; I believe there is a lot in it. "Let us appeal to them," he said, "and asked them in God's name not to do those things." What has happened to make those methods inappropriate in 1933? Are infinite patience and brotherly love to be reserved for people who have actually committed crimes? If people are suspected—and suspected only on slender grounds—of being about to commit crime, is there any reason why the Government should not appeal to them in the name of God not to do those terrible things they are suspected of being about to do, instead of hauling them before a military tribunal, or even of using the ordinary law against them?
I suggest that there is nothing in the career of the President of the Executive Council which becomes him so little as two things he has done during the last few months. The first is his declaration that it was the supreme pleasure of his life to make his opponents digest gall and wormwood; the second is his assumption and his abuse of the powers contained in the Public Safety Act. He affects to sneer at my professions of devotion to the rule of law, and to individual liberty within the rule of law. I am not afraid to repeat those professions. I feel so deeply on the subject that not only would I immediately abandon any political party, or politics itself, if I were to be called upon to do anything which infringed those principles, but— what is perhaps more of a test—I am prepared to stay in politics and fight for those principles when they are shamefully deserted by the people whose job it is to support them.
Comment on this
Deputy MacDermot, in the exceedingly moderate and able speech to which the House has listened, challenged the Government to make a case. The Government at no time in this House, and in none of the many speeches which the President and the Ministers have made throughout the country, put up a semblance of a case for their conduct either in calling this Act into operation again, or for the method in which they are enforcing it. It is not merely an insult to this House that the Government does not reply, and does not put up a case for abrogating the ordinary constitutional rights of the people of this country, but it is an insult to the country. It is not only an insult to anything in the nature of democratic rights and democratic principles, but it is an insult to such principles and to such rights as we have good reason to expect from a Government. In their action in bringing this Act into operation without a tittle of justification, in their refusal to utter a word of excuse or to put up even a semblance of a case, they showed their real attitude towards democratic institutions, and the real value of the respect which they sometimes mouth for the rights of the ordinary people of this country. We expected nothing better from the Government. In office and out of office they have trampled on the rights of the people of this country. They have trampled on everything which this country holds dear. It is nothing surprising, therefore, that they pursue their usual tactics of sitting tight and saying nothing.
Mr. Flinn made a remark which was inaudible.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy was going to make an unfortunate intervention. He had better not. There was a big onus on the Government to justify their action. Have they done so? In any speech through the country have they done so? Here in the Oireachtas Deputy MacDermot referred to the speech of the Minister for Justice in the Seanad. Is it on that they are standing? Is that their case? Does not that amount to the argument that because they do not like the political tactics, the political doctrines and the political aims of their opponents they are going to utilise the enormous powers conferred by the Public Safety Act on the Government against them? I am speaking only of the Government Party. I am not going to waste any time on the other Party, until I am aware that they have any principle to which they can stick. I have no doubt they will give utterances to any number of principles, but I should prefer to see them sticking to one or two.
What is the real reason for the action of the Government in this particular matter? The real reason is perfectly clear. The real reason is that the Government or the Executive Council saw growing up in this country a healthy, God-fearing, law-abiding movement which made an appeal to the young people of this country, and they determined to squelch it. It is because they saw that movement growing up that they determined, most tyrannically and without the most flimsy excuse, to utilise the enormous powers which the Oireachtas has entrusted to a Government of this country to deal with very exceptional situations. What has been their hope always? To whom has their appeal always been made? To the youth of the country. To whom has the President made his appeal on platform after platform? To the youth; to the young priests—apparently the old ones have no sense as far as he is concerned— and to the young people. He saw a movement growing up that is appealing to those young people, a law-abiding movement a movement whose very essence was respect for the law, respect for the rights of the people as a whole and of the individual people of this country. Because that movement was making a successful appeal he determined that he would use the methods of the Public Safety Act against that particular movement or that organised movement. He determined he would break it if he could. He determined between the illegal actions of those underneath and the tyrannical power of the Government that he would squelch this new movement. Both combined, and we have the Government hand in hand with anarchy, the Government hand in hand with those who have no respect for government, not even for his Government. Between these two millstones he hoped to grind this new movement out of existence. He had built his hope on the expectation that the sane, moderate, constructive policy for which Cumann na nGaedheal had stood so long would not appeal to the imaginations of the younger people. He felt he was safe. But recently he saw, and the members of his Party saw, a movement growing up that was appealing to the imaginations of the young people and without a single evidence of illegality, without a single charge being made against them or being proved in any court, he determined he would squelch that movement. That movement, and the people behind it, stood in his path. Away with them.
I have always been convinced—and I wonder if I have before now expressed it in this House—that with the President's enormous faculty for proving things the day would come when he would undertake to prove two things; first one thing and then another. I have always felt that the day would come when he would undertake to prove that the people of this country have morally no right to get rid of him and his Government, and, secondly, he would undertake to prove, and would prove it to his own satisfaction, that the people of this country had constitutionally no right to get rid of his Government. What is he now attempting to do? To deprive the people of constitutional methods of getting rid of his Government. It is because there was that kind of successful movement and successful appeal being made to the country that his Government has determined to act tyrannically. The country knows very well what is the explanation not merely of his conduct and the conduct of his Executive on the present occasion, but what is the explanation of the hysterical speeches he has been making in the last couple of weeks through the country. Everybody knows it and it must even dawn on some of his own followers. This man who appeals as head of the Government, the man who above all others ought to have respect for governmental institutions and for the courts that he has called into existence, goes down to the country and makes speeches that made by an ordinary man would have brought him before the courts for contempt. That is his respect for the institutions of the country and that is his respect for the instruments he is trying to utilise to further his own ambitions.
The new movement is banned not because illegality has been alleged or can be alleged against it, either in its methods or aims. It is banned because it is a successful movement threatening the existence, in a constitutional way, of the present Government. Reference has been made to the circumstances that made the passing of the Public Safety Act necessary. I will ask the Deputies, those who still profess, even though they have their tongues in their cheeks, a certain respect for Parliaments and a certain respect for democratic institutions, to contrast the conduct of the Government of the day when this Act was passed, with the conduct of the Government of to-day. Whether or not you agree with them the Government of that day made a case for the action they were taking. I hold they made an unanswerable case and a case that was satisfactorily proved.
There was, as the great bulk of the people of this country knew, evidence of a conspiracy to upset the established Government of this country. That is certainly no exaggeration. There was a conspiracy to upset the Government of the country by force and that conspiracy was quickly threatening to become a successful conspiracy. That was the situation in 1931. The ordinary administration of the law had completely broken down. Every method had been tried by the then Government to cope with a very serious situation, to cope with a situation that was trampling under foot the rights of the ordinary individual in this country and the rights of the whole people of this country. It was only when all its efforts failed that the Public Safety Bill was brought before this House and the Act put into operation. You have nothing of the kind to-day.
Everyone could have foreseen, the more stupid even could have felt what was coming on hearing the speech of the President in the middle of July last. The President then in defending his own Vote made it plain that he was going to use these powers. The President made it quite clear to us on these benches, though no illegality was then suggested, as to the organisation, that he was going to use the force that was put into his hands by the Oireachtas. When we determined to bring in the Public Safety Bill, and when we asked the Dáil and Seanad to pass it, and when the members of the Dáil and Seanad stood up to their responsibilities despite the threats that were made against them, it was because the ordinary law had not merely broken down but had demonstrably broken down. The Dáil and Seanad performed their duty to the people. Terror was gripping one part of the country after another. Not merely were crimes being committed, but crimes were being committed with impunity. Those who committed them knew they were committing them with impunity.
Is anything of that kind suggested now? Nothing of the kind. The whole sum of their contention is that it is a successful political campaign against the political existence of the Government. We have had attempts since this Government came into office to stir up panic now and then. Nobody can yield to me in the respect I have for the propagandist ability of the Party opposite. But great as is their propagandist ability they have only made themselves completely ludicrous by the plots and mare's nests that they have discovered. We had the Attorney-General going down to the police courts and invoking the celebrated Secrets Act in order to create an atmosphere. But he was laughed out of court. No wonder the Government would not now go into the ordinary courts. Any time they went in they were laughed out of court. In that celebrated case in which the Attorney-General displayed himself so remarkably, the jury did not think it worth while to listen to the case for the prisoners so lacking of any evidence and of any foundation was this case and so entirely devoid of foundation was the whole scare.
The Government put this Act into operation to deal with an organisation that, before everything else, is a law-abiding organisation and that has determined that respect for the law, respect for the rights of the individual and the individual's property, would be the sheet-anchor of its programme. It was against that organisation that the Government called the immense powers they have at their disposal into operation. We have heard hysterical speeches from the Leader of the Government. We have heard him in this House and we have read the speeches he made in the country. I have yet to hear him give a real, straight, vigorous condemnation of real disrespect for the law, of real breach of the law, of real extreme views either on economics, politics or methods. He may advise people "Now, be quite; you will only damage your cause and play into the hands of your enemies." Mild censures and pats on the back of that kind are not what the country is entitled to expect from the head of a responsible Government. However, that is all we ever get from the Front Bench opposite. All their condemnation, all their hysteria, all their philippics are reserved for those who respect the law, for those who have moderate opinions. We have now a most scandalous abuse of power.
This Act has been in operation for something over a month. What is the bag that the Government has got? A couple of farmers. There has been a tremendous undermining of the whole foundations of the country! We are told about an alleged conspiracy. Of course the President, even though the matter is sub judice, has no difficulty in dealing with it in public.
Comment on this
Not at all! The President never says anything any person understands him to say. That is the bag they have got after a month, and it is connected with the refusal, perhaps owing to inability or otherwise —I cannot deal with the case now—to pay rates. The Government has made it impossible for a large number of the people to pay rates or anything else. That is the result of their policy. Why are they so ready to come to the conclusion that there is a conspiracy? Anyhow these trumpery cases that the Military Tribunal is now called upon to deal with cannot surely have been the excuse for calling this Act into operation? The cases had not occurred at that time. Of course that has nothing to do with the real reason. The Government has the power and we are all familiar with the Government's old argument: "What we are doing is legal, therefore we are justified in doing it." Again and again we have heard that particular excuse given by the Government. It is no excuse in this instance.
Nobody denies that the Government has these tremendous powers. The greater the powers they have the more exceptional the powers, the stronger the case that must be made for their utilisation. They must show their moral justification for utilising these powers. They have done nothing of the kind. The very magnitude of the powers given, the tremendous power of life and death even over individual citizens that this Act puts into the hands of the Government, makes it all the more incumbent on the Government and those who support the Government to see that such powers are not used except in the last extremity. Now they are being used, not merely not in the last extremity, but actually before there is a tittle of justification for utilising even one-hundredth part of the powers contained in the Act. You have as usual a complete lack of moral responsibility on the part of the Government. They think because they are the Government and possess the power that there is no moral restraint on them. Again and again we have listened to that particular type of argument and sophistry in this House. It is quite in keeping with everything else they have done.
We have not here a Government that is looking after the welfare of the people, that is determined to protect the rights of the people. We have a Government determined to utilise to the fullest the immense powers that were obtained when the whole nation was threatened, when its existence was threatened, in order to squelch their political opponents. There is talk of panic. We were often accused when we introduced measures here that we were acting in panic. There is a panic now, but it is not a panic that has any reference to the welfare or safety of the State. The only panic that exists is as to the length of tenure of office of the present Government. Their hope is that between unrepressed illegality from below and Governmental tyranny from above they will be able to deal with a strictly constitutional menace and hold their position.
Comment on this
Deputy MacDermot, when proposing the resolution which is now before the House, said he had no intention of indulging in personal abuse or anything in the nature of bitterness. I propose to follow his example and his lead. I do so for the reason that I am opposed in principle to personal abuse and bitterness, because there is no necessity for such methods to recommend the adoption of this resolution, not merely to the House, but to the country as a whole. The actions of the Government in connection with their employment of the Public Safety Act, as it is popularly called, have engendered in the people of this country a feeling of tremendous indignation. It would be gratifying to us, merely from a political point of view, if we looked at the matter from such a narrow point of view, to realise the full extent of the indignation which is aroused against the Government's actions in this respect. Something more has been aroused against the Government, something which is of deeper significance to them from the point of view of their political longevity. The people of this country are laughing at them and when the people begin to laugh at a Government, that Government's days are numbered. The actions of this Government, which they intended to be representative of the big stick policy, have merely resulted in a wave of derision against them passing over the country.
Now, I do not intend to go into any point as to how the Government ought to have used the Public Safety Act, as it is called. As to how they failed to use it in certain directions, I propose to pass over with just one or two casual comments. This Act, the Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act, is popularly called the Public Safety Act. It is more than a Public Safety Act. It is part of the Constitution of this State. While I agree with what Deputy MacDermot has said, that it is an Act of appalling severity, and that in order to justify its being brought into operation, a widespread prevalence of serious crime and a breakdown of the ordinary courts are necessary, I think the Act is something more and requires something for its justification if it is to be brought into operation by any Government. When this Act was being introduced into this House as a Bill by Deputy Cosgrave, the then President of the Executive Council, he said that it was an Act that not merely his Government required but that any Government of this country required. It was introduced as part of the Constitution of this State. It was deliberately introduced into Article II of the Constitution of this State, the Article which states explicitly that all powers of government are derived from the people of this country, as an instrument to safeguard the rights and liberties of the people of this country. Its only justification, the only justification that any Government can have for the use of the extraordinary powers that are contained in that Act, is the fact that the very foundations of the State are being menaced in such a way that the ordinary institutions of the State are not able to cope with the menace. That is the only justification for the use of the extraordinary powers that are contained in this Act.
When it was introduced into this House by the late Government they were told that its powers might be abused. They said that it was necessary for any Government to have the powers contained in that Act at their disposal for use if the foundations of the State were being menaced, and that they would leave it to public opinion and to the verdict of the people to pronounce upon any Government that would misuse the powers then inserted in the Constitution. This Government has abused those powers and it remains for a verdict to be given upon their action. They have misused its powers not because there is any threat or any menace to the foundations of this State or to any of the institutions of the State. There has been no evidence given to the country that there was any menace to the foundations of this State: that there was any state of disorder that the ordinary forces of the State could not cope with, or that there was any necessity to abandon the ordinary law which the present Government have rather belatedly professed themselves to be so fond of. They have used, as a previous speaker said justly, the powers of this extraordinary Constitution Act which were intended for the protection of the rights and liberties of the people when they are menaced, merely for the protection of their own party politics and their own party life. They have passed in the last 12 or 15 months from a state of fright to a state of panic and from a state of panic to a state of stampede and terror at their political prospects.
We remember that before the last general election, shortly after the present Government came into power, the constitutional rights which the last Government had put into the Constitution: the right of free speech, the right of freedom to hold public meetings, the right of freedom to express your political opinions, were menaced and that the Government of the day— the present Government—then stood by. Deputy Cosgrave, the leader of the Opposition, the ex-President of the Executive Council of this State, was unable to address his own constituents in his own City of Cork, a constituency that had returned him at the head of the poll on several occasions by a very substantial number of votes. He was unable, by reason of the hooliganism which was organised and obviously organised, to address his own constituents. That example was followed in every part of the Irish Free State and, as against that menace to the liberties of the people under the Constitution which were not being maintained by the Government, there arose in this country a spontaneous movement to protect those rights and liberties of the people. That particular movement, spontaneous as it was as I insist, was not in any way organised, engineered or fostered by any particular party or by any politicians. The Army Comrades' Association came spontaneously into being because the Government whose duty it was to safe guard the rights of its citizens were neglectful of their duty, because they thought it was in their own interests that they should overlook the hooliganism that was going on in every part of the country. When the Army Comrades' Association effectively fought for the rights and liberties of this people we were able, because of their efforts, and not thanks to any action of the Government, to make our voices heard throughout the country, and then it was, when the Government saw that the Army Comrades' Association was making progress in the country, that they took fright. But if they took fright they did nothing about it. They relied upon personal abuse and hooliganism to deal with the menace to their political future that was threatened by the existence of the Army Comrades' Association. The blue shirt, which is so dangerous for them now and such a terrible menace to them, was the emblem of the comradeship which bound together the Army Comrades' Association, was no menace to them at that time, and as to the Army Comrades' Association which is now apparently deemed to be such a menace to the State, no action was taken against it. The Public Safety Act was not put into force and the Blueshirts were not banned. But the Army Comrades' Association engendered a more dangerous movement against the political existence of the present Government because it came into being, as I have said, for the purpose of doing the job that the Government have failed to do: to maintain the constitutional rights and liberties of the citizens of this country whatever their political opinions may be. It was attracting to it the youth of this country, that new generation which is growing up now and which is seeing through the spurious patriotism of the present Government—with its catch-cries and political baits. This new generation is getting down to the essentials, because it sees that it does not matter what form of Government this country has provided it is free and prosperous, and, provided that it is respected, as it is not respected at the present moment owing to the policy of the present Government, by the nations of the earth.
They see that that is the essential thing and not catch-cries about political forms. When the National Guard came into being the Government took panic. They took greater panic because, as has been pointed out by Deputy MacDermot, General O'Duffy took charge of that new movement. It certainly was a guarantee to the people of this country that the new movement would be subjected to proper discipline and proper organisation when General O'Duffy was at its head. He had come out from the high office which he had occupied for nearly 11 years in this State as the head of the Gárda Síochána and not a single back-bencher, no matter how much he might have wished to be able to do so, was able to level one charge against General O'Duffy that he had been neglectful or failed in his duty to the Government which dismissed him during the period from February, 1932. There was not a single charge that they were able to level against him. The meanest back-bencher of the Fianna Fáil Party, or the back-bencher with the meanest mind, and there are a few of them in the Fianna Fáil Party, was not able to do that. The meanest of the meanest minds of the Fianna Fáil Party was not able to suggest anything against General O'Duffy, his conduct or personal probity or his loyalty to the Government which he served after the change. He was away on a tour and came back; and in a few weeks after his return he was made head of the National Guard. It was suggested by Ministerial spokesmen that in these few weeks he had so got command of the forces in this country that he was able to make himself dictator of this State, and that not only were the political prospects of the Government menaced, but that actually the State was in danger of being subverted by this man who had just returned from his holidays. Stunts were then got up. First we had an extraordinary and an outrageous plan for the collection of arms—a collection of arms not illegally held, but a collection of arms legally and properly held. Then we had the formation of this new force of so-called police with their revolvers in their waistbelts, hanging around Government Buildings, as if everyone who passed in and out and every member of this House were a menace to the State and the Government. No wonder the people are laughing at such a farce as has been set up by the present Government.
The National Guard was proclaimed under the Public Safety Act first. What is the peculiar comment? Not a single member of the National Guard was prosecuted for membership of that so-called illegal assembly. Not a single effort in reference to that body supposed to be such a tremendous menace to the State. But an attack was made upon a few unfortunate farmers, who were supposed to be members of a conspiracy, not an unlawful association, but on the supposition that it was a body brought into existence for the non-payment of rates and taxes. And it is singular that while the Public Safety Act gives the present Executive power to declare unlawful any association which is supposed to exist for the non-payment of rates, no order is made by the Executive declaring any association in the country to be an unlawful association. The country can infer from that that the Government with that power in their hands to ban a specific association as unlawful were not able to point to any single association in the country as an unlawful association. But they collected a group of five or six farmers in Waterford and put them into Mountjoy Jail. I am not going to comment on this pending case; but I am entitled to say this: they left these farmers in Mountjoy Jail without the State being able to put forward any charge against them whatever. They only knew a day or two ago that they were to be brought before the Military Tribunal: "Justice shall not be sold or delayed." These men were left in jail without any charge being made against them. We were told that the Minister for Justice and the Attorney-General were considering further charges against them. Is it the policy of the Government to arrest people first and then see what charge they can afterwards bring against them? That is the policy that has been adopted in relation to the five or six farmers in Mountjoy Jail who are to be tried by the Military Tribunal. After they had been 15 or 16 days in jail they are then told what the charge was against them, and now we are told that further charges may be sprung upon them irrespective of whether they shall have time to meet them or not.
That is one side of one case—people without any charge being made against them kept in jail. The other case I wish to mention is one that has also come before the Military Tribunal. What are the circumstances in that case? One man got one day's notice of the charge against him. One of the defendants who appeared this morning before the Military Tribunal and took his trial without fear was told yesterday that he had committed an offence. For the first time he was served with a document yesterday morning and he was compelled to answer this morning four charges under the Public Safety Act made against him. Can it be said by any fair-minded person that that is a fair from of trial? Must it not be admitted, on the contrary, that it is a complete denial of justice? They make their charge this morning—and I shall comment no further upon that case or upon the case against the Waterford farmers. But I am entitled to say this: that the action the President of the Executive Council took in Dundalk on September 10th this year, when he commented upon the pending case of the Waterford farmers, was one that was a gross abuse of his position as President of this State. I have his speech in my hand and I propose to read the portion of it of which I complain. If the President makes any quibble as to whether or not it is a comment specifically as such on a pending case, people can judge as to whether even though it is not technically a comment such as would lead him to be brought up for contempt of the Military Tribunal before that Tribunal, it was still such a comment, and such action should not have been taken by any member of any Government if he had any sense of decency for his position or if he had any respect for the law. The President later levelled charges against Deputy MacDermot that were clearly libellous, because I see from the newspapers that President de Valera read that speech in Dundalk and read it very carefully and his speech was therefore a libel. He made this libellous charge that Deputy MacDermot was encouraging a conspiracy which he alleged to be in existence for the non-payment of rates in this country. The only action Deputy MacDermot could take, with any dignity to himself, was to ignore these foul charges which everyone knows to be unjust and the making of which was a grave abuse of the position which the President enjoys. The President said—and I am reading from the Irish Independent of 11th September this year—speaking about Deputy MacDermot:
"He is anxious to preserve the public services, but he has allowed members of his Party and branches of his organisation to conspire to bankrupt the local authorities by organising a campaign against the payment of rates. He values personal liberty—no one talks more frequently about it—but he has apparently no objection to the boycott of men whose only offence is that they meet their lawful obligations and perform their duties as honest men and good citizens."
It is no part of my function to make any defence of Deputy MacDermot. No defence is required or necessary against that foul attack. But I want to direct the attention of the House to words used there by the President—"the boycott of men." Take that in connection with the further paragraph in which he referred to the campaign of Deputy MacDermot against the payment of rates. He said:—
"This illegal conspiracy had assumed a very serious aspect in some parts of the country where representatives of the Farmers and Ratepayers' Association had been endeavouring to intimidate farmers into signing a pledge to pay no rent or rates. The names of the farmers who refused to enter into this dishonest undertaking were placed on a list of boycotted persons which was circulated to owners of threshing machines and other persons who would be likely to have dealings with them."
At the date on which that speech was made the Waterford farmers who are to be tried next Monday were awaiting their trial on charges which were subsequently revealed to them but which at the date at which the President spoke had not been revealed to them —charges of boycotting people with threshing machines. They are standing their trial on Monday next on a charge of taking part in an illegal conspiracy to boycott people with threshing machines. Could anybody reading that passage not know that in that passage is a reference—it could have no other reference—to the people who were languishing in Mountjoy, no charge having been made against them at that time, but people who were subsequently charged with being engaged in an illegal conspiracy to boycott persons who owned threshing machines? Could anybody doubt that the previous passage, where he speaks of an illegal conspiracy, was a comment upon a pending case? The question that the Military Tribunal has to deal with next Monday is the question as to whether there exists or does not exist in this country an illegal conspiracy. That is the fundamental issue which the Military Tribunal has to decide at the outset of the case on Monday. The question which will determine the whole case is whether there is or is not an illegal conspiracy. The Attorney-General knows that the evidence he must produce must be evidence to show the existence of this illegal conspiracy and the burden lies on him, even before the Military Tribunal, to prove that the accused men are guilty.
Comment on this
But the President comes forward on 10th September and says there is an illegal conspiracy. He pre-judged the very point, the fundamental issue, which the Military Tribunal has to decide next Monday. Is that an abuse or is it a proper use of governmental powers, or is it not a thing that should bring down scorn upon the person who so abused his high authority and his high position as to make use of these expressions at a public meeting? We would make an excuse for a political leader being carried away in the heat of a moment in a crowd. We would make excuses for a public man on a public platform making mistakes, but the President read the statement, according to the newspapers. He read it slowly and deliberately. Slowly and deliberately, he made a statement prejudging the issue which the Military Tribunal has to decide next Monday against the Waterford farmers.
Comment on this
I believe the Military Tribunal will decide it truthfully. I have every confidence in the Military Tribunal and I am not going to cast any reflections on it, but I did reflect and very seriously reflect, and I think the people of the country will bear this in their hearts, on the contemptible and cowardly treatment to which these nine farmers have been subjected, even if they were guilty of the offences with which they were charged. The law protects people even if they are guilty against any prejudging by any person, however exalted the position he may occupy, of an issue which has to be tried by a court, however it is constituted.
Then we have the case which is at hearing to-day about which I will say nothing, but I am entitled to comment on the events leading up to it. Everybody remembers the incidents at the cattle market a couple of days ago. The incidents there produced, as I have said, derisive laughter throughout the country. It was not merely indignation. It was regarded as a matter for universal amusement and laughter that the Minister for Justice should be obliged to send down a member of the police force of this country to bid at an auction. The incidents that took place there took place good-humouredly. They were accepted by the people in this country in good humour and they laughed. But, no! The Government did not want it as a piece of good humour. They were wounded because people had laughed at them and they wanted again to have the catch-cry of the old American song:
"John Brown's body lies amoulderin' in the ground."
What they got however was "John Brown's breeches are amoulderin' in the pound," and the people are laughing at them. But the whole force of this Constitution Amendment Act, the Public Safety Act, is invoked against a crowd of farmers who met in the ordinary place where farmers meet, the cattle market, to look on and laugh. The Act which was to make better provision for safeguarding the rights of the people is invoked to safeguard the rights of John Brown and to get portion of his breeches and his revolver.
We hear talk from Ministerial spokesmen about the necessity for maintenance of the law. We will pass over in silence their death-bed repentance in this behalf, but I will point out this, that they will bring into greater disrespect the law by some of the methods they are employing at the present time, than any breaches of the law by any of the unfortunate farmers who have been driven to desperation, as has been said here to-day. One of the ways into which they must bring the law into disrepute is the misuse of the law, and the endeavours they have been making to deceive the people of the country into the belief that it is illegal to wear a blue shirt. That, too, may be a matter for laughter, but it is no matter for laughter if the police have instructions to baton those who wear blue shirts at meetings of a political party, the members of which are working lawfully and by constitutional means for the achievement of their aims. It is no laughing matter if the police have instructions from the Minister for Justice or even if they have his authority, to baton people who wear blue shirts. I assert here authoritatively, and we are prepared to prove it, that there is no law in this country to prevent me or anybody else, a member of the Young Ireland Association of Fine Gael, or an ordinary member of Fine Gael, from wearing a blue shirt on a public platform or wearing it anywhere we like. We propose to do that, and if our right to do so is challenged, that challenge will be taken up and I shall prove what I say here, prove it with conviction, that there is no law to prevent anybody wearing a blue shirt, that it is perfectly lawful for every member of the Young Ireland Association, which is attached to Fine Gael, to wear a blue shirt, which is the emblem of this Association to which we have the privilege and the pride to belong.
Comment on this
I should like to ask if the members of the Government Front Bench realise that they are sitting in an Irish Parliament built up by Irish democratic labours and safeguarded by that, or do they think that they are lying in the dark behind the hedge down in Kerry?
Comment on this
I should like to ask if the Government Front Bench realise that they are in an Irish Parliament, built up by Irish democratic effort and safeguarded by that?
Comment on this
That does not arise out of the Motion before the House. If the Deputy desires to speak he will have an opportunity to do so.
Comment on this
I think the House should realise what was the atmosphere when the late Government introduced what has been called to-day the Public Safety Act. At that time, there was very serious and grave danger that the law in certain cases might break down altogether. At that time, jurors were shot and witnesses were shot. They were murdered, deliberately murdered, and it was for that very reason and to prevent as far as possible anyone being murdered who was a juror or a witness, that the Public Safety Act was brought in. That was the reason. What was the reason for bringing it in now? Was there any grave and serious crime of that nature committed? Who were to be the first people to be tried? Who are going to be tried next Monday? What I am going to say now I say very seriously to everyone in this House. If there is any conspiracy for non-payment of rates—and so far as I am concerned I say that I know of absolutely none— the whole blame for that conspiracy, if it does exist, lies on the Government. The reason it lies on the Government is that they cannot make one law for themselves and another law for the rest of the people. They deliberately withheld the land annuities which constituted a solemn undertaking given. The President of the Irish Free State said on several occasions that the people were not able to pay and that he was not going to send their money over to England. He withheld that money and he cannot deny it. The right and decent thing to have done would have been to go over to England and make the case that the people could not pay and see what arrangement he could have made. I am absolutely certain that he would have made a very good one indeed. But he did not do that. He said, "I will not pay——"
Comment on this
The Deputy will please be seated. The retention of the land annuities does not arise on this debate. The decision to retain the land annuities was come to by this House by a majority vote, and may not be criticised in this debate.
Comment on this
What I wanted to get at is that a grave decision was taken, and that these unfortunate people—there is no question about it— have paid their rents in the tariffs, and have paid them time and time again. Some of them now say that they cannot pay, and to my mind, the situation is perfectly plain. I admit that people who have paid through the tariffs have already paid their rates, but I do say that no matter what happened in the past, the law is there and the law must be obeyed, and it is the duty of every person who can to pay his rates. If a bad example has been set by the Government, it is no reason why the people of this country should follow that bad example. Let them face up to their responsibilities. If they can pay it is their duty to pay. The person about whom I am concerned is the poor unfortunate person who cannot pay. A bad example has been set, and the responsibility for what happens is on the Government.
To refer to another matter, which, to my mind is very serious indeed—the whole question of law and order in this country. We all know perfectly well, or should know, that we have the finest force in the world, a force that any nation should be proud of, and a force that this country has every right to be proud of. I refer to the Civic Guards. What has been done to uphold the prestige of that force? I am very sorry indeed that the ex-Minister for Justice is not in the House. A short time before he relinquished the post of Minister for Justice I was perturbed by what I saw going on in the country. I saw the Civic Guards being made an absolute mockery of. I went and saw the Minister for Justice—and if he were here to-day he would bear me out— and I said to him: "I have come to speak to you as man to man," and I told him what I saw going on, and the danger the country was running into. What has happened since then? Things have got worse and worse. We have had the appalling scene in the market in Dublin—and to think that a Minister for Justice of this State should allow an unfortunate Civic Guard to be put into that position. It was degrading to the force, the finest force that any country ever had, and all my sympathy is with the unfortunate Civic Guards. Last night I read the following in the "Evening Herald." It is headed "Limerick Scenes." I am not going to read out the whole matter, but there is one particular item of which I wish to inform the House, and if the Deputy is present he will have an opportunity of contradicting the statement which I am about to read. It is:—
"Mr. Robert Ryan, T.D., said that it would be a poor day for Ireland if they were to have an expeeler for a national leader."
Comment on this
There is nothing in the conduct or in the record of General O'Duffy that can bring a blush of shame to any citizen of this country. He has got a great record, and a clean record. What is the insinuation in that statement, but that the Civic Guard, the finest force in this country, are so low and so degraded that no leader should be taken from that force. That is the insinuation in the statement. It was the insinuation of a member of this House, whose first duty it should be to uphold that force in every way. I make no further comment, except to say that if that Deputy has any decency he will get up in this House and withdraw what he said. General O'Duffy's record stands. No one can touch it. But no one has a right to touch the record and the reputation of the Civic Guards. If members of the Guards commit an offence they will be brought to trial in due course. No one has a right to foul the name of the force in any way. Certainly, no member of this House has a right to do so. If he thinks he has the right to do so he ought to be ashamed of himself. I think it is a terrible thing indeed that it should have been necessary to bring forward this vote of censure on the Government, at a time when the country is striving as hard as it can to keep the wolf from the door. Yet, when times are difficult, and hard, with no justification whatsoever the President sets up a tribunal. That is an admission that he has failed, and that the ordinary law is not sufficient to deal with any man who is accused of non-payment of rates, or anything of that kind. The whole thing is a mockery, an absolute mockery. That is the last word I have to say about it.
Comment on this
Is it fair to inquire if the President is going to intervene in this debate? So far as this Party is concerned, we all know perfectly well that the rest of his Party do not count for a row of pins. The President will get up and say what he has to say and that is all that really matters. If he is going to say anything it would be of great interest to the House to hear it now.
Comment on this
It has been made manifest by all the speakers in this debate, even to the meanest intelligence, or the meanest back-benchers in Fianna Fáil, and also to the tin-whistle players in the Fianna Fáil band, the official Labour Party, that the Government's use of the Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act, 1931, "has been unjust and oppressive and is deserving of censure." That it is unjust and oppressive has been very clearly demonstrated. The suppression of the National Guard has been mentioned as one of the acts of oppression of the present Government. An examination of that position has been made by one or two speakers. I propose to say now what I said elsewhere in relation to the A.C.A., which has now become known as the National Guard. The A.C.A. was established at a time when it was almost impossible, and certainly dangerous, to advocate any policy that contravened in any way, the policy of the present Executive. We have freedom of speech enshrined in our Constitution. We have people mouthing about freedom of speech in the Fianna Fáil Party, but, in practice, it has been found that when a member of a constitutional party in this House, a man, who was head of the Government at one time, ex-President Cosgrave, attempted to address a meeting in Cork, where he headed the poll with at least three or four quotas, and where he still enjoys the confidence of the people, a number of hooligans and wastrels were organised by Fianna Fáil to prevent him addressing his constituents. That was the position as we found it in Cork.
That is the position which gave birth to the Army Comrades' Association, which later developed into the National Guard. I feel, sir, that on the occasion of a general election there would have been no possibility of any person in opposition to the present Government addressing a meeting, without running the risk, either of being violently attacked, or perhaps maimed for life. That that spirit is not dead in the country has been made manifest within the last couple of weeks. We had a number of persons going about the City of Dublin smashing and breaking the property of the citizens. We had no sustained effort made to put down that practice. Yet we are told that we have a constitutional Government in office. It is quite a usual thing to read in the Press that persons have been violently assaulted, that houses have been attacked, that the homes of humble labourers and workers have been attacked, and at the end of the paragraph we find these words: "The Gárda have been active in the district, but so far no arrests have been made."
Comment on this
We read the caption: "Attacks on persons coming from Cumann na nGaedheal meetings," and the concluding sentence runs, "The Guards have been active, but so far no arrests have been made." I want to pay this tribute to the Guards. I believe, with Deputy The O'Mahony, that no finer or better force exists. But they would not be human if they did not react to the present state of affairs. When the Guards brought prisoners before justices, I have my doubts whether they would be regarded at headquarters as efficient policemen, particularly if they indicted persons found disturbing Cumann na nGaedheal or other meetings, whose spokesmen or whose candidates were in opposition to those of Fianna Fáil. That is the natural reaction in a police force, and I want to say deliberately that I feel, with many other responsible citizens in this State, that the morale of the Gárda has been attacked, and that dry rot has also set in in the courts of justice. When I take up the daily press, what do I find? People charged with crimes of violence give the excuse that they were members of, or were in some way connected with Fianna Fáil, and they get off, either with a paltry fine or are let out. That is what has occurred in the country. As Irishmen, we must face up to the facts and not be ashamed to proclaim that there is that inherent weakness in our people at the present moment. That is the reaction of the forces of law and order to what is taking place here— to the sentiments given utterance to by responsible members of the Fianna Fáil Party.
It would be interesting, at this stage, to recall what some members of the Government Party and their hangers-on of the Labour Party said on the occasion of the introduction of this Act in October, 1931. On that occasion, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, then Deputy Lemass, said:
"The National Executive of Fianna Fáil has thrown out a challenge to the Government which it cannot ignore. We say we are satisfied that there is neither need nor demand for this Bill on the part of the public, and we ask them to test public feeling by going to the country on the matter."
I wonder if the Minister for Industry and Commerce is of the same opinion now that he was on the day he made that statement. I wonder if he is prepared to go to the country, not alone on this question of the Constitution (Amendment) Act, but on the whole policy of the Fianna Fáil Executive.
The Minister for Finance, then Deputy MacEntee, said on the same occasion—I do not propose to give lengthy quotations from these speeches —excerpts will suffice:—
"Would any member in this House who was formerly a member of the national organisation—I can see some of them here whose record is a brave and heroic one—in 1921 or 1922, when they were discussing the Treaty in the Dáil, tell us what was their attitude to that matter then?"
At this juncture, I might say that I felt then as many other public citizens felt at that period—when murders were being committed in the country, when Superintendent Curtin was shot and in his shooting were involved the deaths of two babies; when young Ryan was shot on the Tipperary hills by men wearing masks—that there was urgent necessity for a measure of this kind. The same reasons cannot be advanced to-day. So far as I know, up to the rather tragic occurrence in Kerry a few days ago, nothing has occurred that would justify the continuance of this measure. I pass from Deputy MacEntee, and I give a quotation from a more important person, the present head of this State—President de Valera. President de Valera then made what I considered a half apology for some of these murders and assassinations. I do not want to misquote him. I want to be quite fair to the President. He said:—
"These men are misguided if you will, but they were brave men, anyhow; let us at least have for them the decent respect that we have for the brave. They have done terrible things recently, I admit, if they are responsible, and I suppose they are. Let us appeal to them and ask them in God's name not to do them."
Apparently somebody sneered at that because the President continued:—
"You sneer at that. It would be more effective, probably, than all your coercion and all your threats, all the shame and slime that you tried to pour upon them to-day."
I could, of course, quote some of the lesser lights of the Fianna Fáil Party who spoke on that occasion but, as I have already indicated, I do not want to weary the House by quoting too extensively from these speeches. It will be no harm, however, to quote what a former leader of the Irish Labour Party, Senator Johnson, said in that connection:—
"I, for one, have been pilloried for quite a few years, attacked and threatened, for having said what I repeat to-day, that when a body of people ostensibly aiming at the overthrow of a Government, make an attack upon the social fabric, it is certain that the community which is attacked, if it has any self-respect, will retort in kind and will throw in its last ounce of strength, its last penny of resource to save the fabric of society."
That is exactly what the A.C.A. and the National Guard did. The urge, as I have already indicated, came from the fact that any person who exercised the right of free speech, and who was in any way opposed to the present Government was belaboured with sticks or stones or bottles, if he did not get what the unfortunate man down in Kerry got—a bullet from a rifle which, apparently, is not under the control of the Government, as it should be. Senator Johnson continued:—
"I say that again and I say that the people who have threatened me, time after time, for asserting that sound doctrine, are quite free to take whatever revenge they wish or make such exposures as they will of my what they call traitorous activities towards the working classes. They are welcome to their denunciation. While I hold that view, I say this Bill, and all that is embodied in this Bill, is a greater danger to social stability because it establishes in the minds of the ruling classes a sense of absolute power, a feeling that no matter what may be the reason for agitation they, at least, are authorised by the publicly-elected legislature, to act as autocrats, to act ruthlessly, with the full sense that they are protected by the law."
Senator Johnson is a member of the other House, and I do not propose to make any comment whatever, on that speech, delivered in 1931. But I shall certainly watch, as the people to-day are watching, with interest the action of the Labour Party in the Dáil and in the Seanad on this question. I have already pointed out that there was very grave and urgent necessity, and that there were solid, valid reasons for the passing into law of a measure of this character, when it was first introduced into this House. We had one of the greatest men that this country ever produced assassinated, and still no trace of his assassins. We had a Minister assassinated—the late Kevin O'Higgins—and still no trace of his assassins. It is suggested, at any rate, that these assassins are known, but because of their association with a certain very powerful body the present Government is unable to lay hands on them.
Now we come to another reason why the use of the Constitution (Amendment) Act, 1931, has been unjust and oppressive. The position of the police force in this country is being rendered very difficult. I do not want to touch on any case that is at the moment sub judice, but I can quite understand a highly efficient police officer, who feels that it would be necessary for him to have a large force of police in evidence at some political meeting. I can also anticipate what could easily happen in present circumstances to that police officer. He might easily be reprimanded at headquarters for waste of energy and for having too many policemen present at that particular meeting. Let us consider the other side of the picture. If, in his wisdom, this police officer thought that a dozen or half a dozen policemen were only necessary, and that subsequently some disturbance took place, he might easily be reprimanded by his superior officer and told that he should have a larger or stronger force of police present on this particular occasion. It appears to me that the Government's want of action in certain matters where decent government is called for is having a very demoralising effect on those who are administering law and order in this country. In order to clear the air, if certain members of this House are not the dumb driven cattle—to use a peroration made famous in this House by Deputy Flinn—of Fianna Fáil or their slavish followers of the present Labour Party, I want to ask them some questions which will be illuminating and certainly very instructive to the electors of the different constituencies which they represent. I can quite understand the attitude of Deputy Norton and Deputy Hogan (Clare). Deputy Hogan was a member of the Labour Party while I was a member of it, but Deputy Norton was not; he was not a member of the Parliamentary Labour Party at any rate. I can quite understand the attitude of Deputy Hogan and Deputy Norton, because they have all along been almost proclaiming themselves as followers of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
I could name occasions when the Deputy voted against party decisions when it suited him. I want to get a clear straight-forward statement. What does Deputy Corish, for instance, tell his constituents in Wexford? I believe the Labour Party intend to vote against this motion, but will they tell the people when they go back to the country that they did so, especially in the remote country areas where the daily newspapers are not bought, and let us have an end to this making Labour speeches at the cross-roads and Fianna Fáil speeches when they come to the Dáil?
Deputies Keyes (Limerick), I am quite certain, must have arrived at the decision that the Government's use of the Constitution (Amendment) Act has been unjust and oppressive, because he, as a member of the Labour Party, was one of those who were very emphatic that Deputy Morrissey and Deputy Anthony should be expelled from the Labour Party. Deputy Davin is ill and I am not going to say anything about him. Then there are Deputy Murphy and Deputy Everett. I am quite sure that Deputy Everett does not altogether subscribe to everything Fianna Fáil says. I hope Deputy Everett, who voted against this measure on a former occasion, will have the pluck and honesty—I know he is an honest man—to vote in favour of this motion now. Now we come to a newer member, Deputy Pattison of Kilkenny. He may have been silenced, but he has not been expelled for a speech in which he said that he had no more confidence in the Fianna Fáil Party. We have had Deputy Corish stating that we had baby factories in this country. Let us boil all this down to common decency and honesty. What are they going to do to-day? If any member of that Party abstains from voting is he going to be expelled from the Party, or are they going to expel themselves automatically and do the decent thing and dissolve?
I could quote from the speeches of several of these Labour Deputies, both here and at the cross-roads, to show that they felt during the passage of this Act that, in any case, it would be unjust and oppressive. As I have indicated, at that particular juncture in the history of this country there was a necessity not alone for one Constitution (Amendment) Act but for 45 of them to put down the murders and assassinations. Some of them had not the guts to say so. When they went back to their constituents they said they were shot or put away, but they had not the guts to say that they were murdered. All of these members without exception—I suppose I might except Deputy Hogan—declared their attitude in relation to the Treaty. They knew as well as I do now and as I did then, and as every honest man must admit, that the task of a Government is a very difficult one. A Government, whether it be Fianna Fáil, Cumann na nGaedheal or Labour, will from time to time do unpopular things —unpopular being translated not in the strict dictionary sense. But if a Government intend to govern they become unpopular. We know they become unpopular because policemen have to do their duty. We know of various ways in which a Government may become unpopular. I put it to the Labour Party that if and when the Labour Party, as I envisaged and every other member of that Party envisaged, come to govern this country they will of necessity have to put down crime and disorder wherever it shows its head. Would they flinch from doing that? Would they flinch from doing it because it might mean more kudos for them? That is what they will do to-day if they vote against this motion, because, not in all cases, but in most cases, they owe their election here to the extra preferences which have been scattered about, like pepper from a pepper pot, by the Fianna Fáil Party.
I do sincerely hope—perhaps it is a vain hope—that members, whether they be members of the present Government or their hangers-on of the official Labour Party, will at least do the straight, manly and honourable thing in this matter. I hope they will ask themselves the question: "Is there now the necessity for the invocation of this Act that there was in 1931?" I challenge any member of this House to show that there is any necessity for it. It has been said that a conspiracy not to pay rates was on foot. That has been successfully challenged in this House. So far as it relates to the City and County of Cork I know that there is no conspiracy in regard to the non-payment of rates. The records will go to show that every farmer and every householder there is endeavouring to pay his rates. Even if there were such a conspiracy on foot the ordinary law as it stands is quite capable of dealing with the people concerned without invoking the aid of this so-called Coercion Act.
A very useful argument—useful for at least some people—was made in this House on one occasion. It was to the effect that the operation of this Act would interfere with organisations such as trade unions. It was stated in reply that no decent or honest man in this country need be afraid of the operation of that Act. As far as I am concerned, and as far as any other decent or honest man in this country who respects the law is concerned, I feel that there is no grave reason to fall foul of this Act; but an organisation has been proclaimed, an organisation which has published its aims and its objects, all of them constitutional, an organisation which is all the time proclaiming that they do not want their members to carry arms. What has been the reaction of the Government to that? They proclaimed the organisation, because they knew it was a growing organisation. They proclaimed the organisation because they want the footpad, the waster and the hooligan to prevail in this country. That is the reason that the Fianna Fáil Party are invoking this Act in order to suppress the National Guard. Suppress the National Guard by all means and the hooligans can successfully split up meetings. They did it successfully up to the time the A.C.A. was organised, and then your followers went behind ditches and shot men in the back.
Comment on this
Deputy MacDermot, in introducing this motion, stated that no defence had been made, so far as he was aware, for the introduction of this measure. He was not satisfied that the defence I made in the Seanad carried any weight. It seems rather extraordinary, if it carried no weight, that in the Seanad itself—where the views, I think, of the majority at any rate, would be very similar to Deputy MacDermot's—that particular vote of censure was not proceeded with. It was withdrawn after the matter had been dealt with. Everybody, except those who are wilfully blind, or are anxious to shut out from them everything connected with the movement known as the National Guard, formerly the A.C.A., in this country, knows what the position is. There is no desire, and there has been no attempt in this country, to interfere with any political movement, but the Government has made it perfectly clear that movements which, under any sort of guise, carry on military activities, are not going to be treated by the Government as political movements.
If we go back to the beginning of the A.C.A., about February of last year, we find it started for social and perhaps philanthropic purposes. We find it with its aims and objects to secure the rights of its own members. With the lapse of time we find that movement in the country spreading. We find ex-officers at the head of it, and we have sufficient information to show that those men are being drilled and brought into companies through the country. Even then we should have been justified in interfering, but, in our efforts to try to carry on in this country without resorting to any coercion or other extreme measures, we allowed things to lapse. The next thing is a badge is suggested, and the further step is the adopting of a uniform. I asked in the Seanad, and I ask here again, if people intend their movement to be a political one what advance do they think they will make by putting on blue shirts or putting on a uniform? Deputy MacDermot may have raised his ambition since he found himself on the seat over there, but I do not see him losing his head so much as to put on a blue shirt yet. I do not think it will be of any advantage to him in Roscommon or elsewhere to come out in this blue shirt. That blue shirt is intended, no matter how it may be described by those who imagine the people they are talking to are very innocent, as a military emblem. It is there for no other purpose. You have, as I pointed out in the Seanad, chevrons showing the various classes or ranks; you have your company directors; you have your district directors. Of course you must have at the head something in the way of a general, so you have him called a director-general. I should have thought that Deputy MacDermot at any rate would be more careful in what he would say about democracy, but I find to-day that he apparently does not take any exception to selection instead of election. That is a big change, even greater than I thought would take place through coming from that seat to that. I did not think such a thing was possible. If Deputy MacDermot is going to admit that selection is a good or democratic means of securing representation in this country then what is the necessity for having elections at all?
Comment on this
I never said that. I never for a moment said that selection was the proper method of securing representation.
Comment on this
I said it was perfectly legitimate, for any private society that liked, to have selection as a method instead of election.
Comment on this
If we believe what we see in the papers, there has been some sort of amalgamation between the body which stands for selection as against election——
Comment on this
We were led to believe, from what we read in the newspapers at any rate, that the National Guard and those other bodies, including Deputy MacDermot's Party, had all conglomerated into one body.
Comment on this
I apologise to Deputy Kent. I do not want to mis-quote Deputy MacDermot but he approved of the objects and aims and of their constitution. That is very clearly, at any rate, set out in their constitution. It is to be selective and dictatorial rather than elective. People have joined these units. They are called "units," a term that is not applied to political objects. It is purely a military term. The people who join those units are subject to district commanders or officers. The term is purely a military one and the organisation works all right from the bottom up to the top——
Comment on this
Whenever anything becomes annoying to Deputy Anthony he can only take one side and not see the other side. When one is on the run cannot the Deputy leave him on the run? When General O'Duffy was elected as Director-General of this body—whether it was his inspiration or the inspiration of people associated with him—we had a statement which I referred to here on the last night I spoke, and I have heard none of that statement recanted since Deputy MacDermot became associated with General O'Duffy. We had the statement that the constitution was an un-Irish one; that the people who drafted it should be thrown into boiling oil. We had never been told how he was to bring about a change, but he said a change would come through the National Guard; that the National Guard would bring it about soon. He was careful not to say by what means.
Comment on this
Not at that time. If the Deputy can show that quotation I will withdraw, but General O'Duffy said no such thing at that time. Intensive organisation was undertaken by General O'Duffy after he had taken over the command. He went through the country and indicated that he was going to have this big procession or meeting here in Dublin in August. It was indicated to him that that procession, owing to the strain that it would impose on the police force in this country, would not be permitted. But General O'Duffy, the man who has such great respect for the law and who, with his new body, which also has such great respect for the law, or rather pretends to have great respect for the law, said "ban or no ban, that procession will be held." He made another statement later on when he said "proclaimed or not, the National Guard will go on." I am quite satisfied from the information that I have that every effort is made to have that National Guard go on.
Comment on this
I knew that and I accept that. That National Guard through the different counties is drilling. It is drilling in various parts of the country. Reference was made here to-day to the crime committed in Kerry the other day. The unfortunate victim of the crime confessed, or rather stated to the police when arrested, that he had been out drilling his men at the time he was shot. That is not an excuse for anybody to shoot him, and I am not giving it as an excuse.
Comment on this
We have arrested some men and we are making no further remarks on it. I am only giving this as an example to the House that drilling is going on all through the country and particularly in the Munster counties. It is going on in every county.
Comment on this
I should like to have a definite reply from Deputy MacDermot as to whether he is aware that drilling on a national scale is going on by the people who form the National Guard.
Comment on this
On the last occasion when I was speaking about this matter I mentioned General O'Duffy's report when he said that a considerable quantity of arms was in the body known as the A.C.A. I should like to know whether Deputy MacDermot when he was associating himself with these people got any assurance from them that they were going to hand up the arms under their control? Was there any assurance given about that?
Comment on this
Then General O Duffy reported wrongly to the Government. I do not want to interfere between General O'Duffy and the Deputies opposite. General O'Duffy reported a year ago that they were a heavily armed body.
Comment on this
Is the Minister referring to the report from General O'Duffy previously read in this House? Because, if so, I want to point out that the report does not contain what the Minister is reading into it. He said that he knew that, following the mutiny some arms had passed into the hands of Colonel Jerry Ryan, who subsequently joined the A.C.A., and that presumably those arms have been in the custody of the A.C.A. That is very different from what the Minister has read into the report.
Comment on this
General O'Duffy did not state in that report that the arms were in the hands of the A.C.A. He suggested that the arms might have found their way into the A.C.A. Read the report.
Comment on this
The report says:—
"There is no doubt that a considerable number of individual ex-Army officers are in possession of revolvers, and even rifles, held surreptitiously as souvenirs of the pre-Truce period. Further, many ex-National Army men, when leaving the Army in 1923-25, brought arms with them. I have, however, been informed as already reported to the Minister, that certain members of the organisation hold extreme views, and would be prepared to urge the use of force in pursuit of their policy."
Comment on this
The report goes on further:—
"It is certain, however, that Mr. Jerry Ryan could, should the occasion arise, muster a fair number of the arms taken from Templemore military barracks during the mutiny."
Comment on this
I see that the unfortunate Jerry Ryan will be thrown over now, though he is one of your leaders.
Comment on this
I ask the Minister for Justice to tell the House if it is an offence for a person to be in the position of being able to procure arms? That is all that is stated there in that report. The report does not say that the organisation has the arms, but that Colonel Ryan could secure arms. Is that an offence? I ask the Minister to answer that question either as a lawyer or as the Minister for Justice?
Comment on this
There have been complaints on one side of the House that no members on the Government Benches have spoken. The Minister for Justice is now speaking, and surely he ought to be allowed to make his speech without interruption.
Comment on this
If the Deputy thinks that there are misquotations, he can quote correctly when the Minister is finished.
Comment on this
I have pointed out that the Opposition have been asking for a Government statement. A member of the Government Bench is now making a statement, and surely he ought to be allowed to proceed without interruptions.
Comment on this
I am asking Deputies over there whether they accept what General O'Duffy stated as true or not.
Comment on this
The point made by Deputy O'Higgins as to whether this individual, Mr. Ryan, actually had the arms, had control of them or could get control of them, is certainly a very thin point. I am sure Deputy Cosgrave knows the circumstances that existed around that time.
Comment on this
I was not in the House when the Minister was reading the report. Perhaps he will read it again for me.
Comment on this
At that time Colonel Ryan left Templemore Barracks with a considerable quantity of arms. I agree that the Minister for Justice or any other member of the Executive Council from that time down made no attempt to get the arms back, notwithstanding the numerous reports they had got about them. Perhaps that seemed to them to be an impartial administration of the law. A party of men happened to take part in a mutiny against the State, and that party, with arms, are let go free. I would like to know from Deputy MacDermot, who has now associated himself with those people, whether he has any assurance that these arms are in the hands of those people, or under the control of people in the organisation with which he is associated. I would like to know if he has made any contract with them, as a part of his allegiance to them, now that he has become a member of that body, that they are going to surrender those arms to the proper Government of the State.
Comment on this
I ask the Minister about his Government—whether they have the means at their disposal to recover arms or not?
Comment on this
I have here one quotation from the United Irishman of the 20th May last. It will show what a normal, law-abiding body this body, then known as the A.C.A., was. It says: “... Within the next year or so, democracy will be preserved in the Free State only by the strong hands and stout sticks of the citizens enrolled in the A.C.A.”
Comment on this
Of course, there is nothing whatever wrong with that. There have been incidents: shots have been fired. I agree nobody has been brought to justice, and I do not want to place it on any particular organisation. As a result of activities in Tipperary, special patrols of Guards are patrolling the county for the last three months. People have been held up and have been beaten on the roads. There has been the case of an unfortunate widow whose house was entered forcibly by masked and armed men. I could give further particulars, but it might be suggested that I am trying to attack some organisation. I would be glad to show the particulars at any time to Deputy MacDermot.
I have been told there was no serious crime in this country since the A.C.A. was formed. Up to the crime that was committed in Kerry a week ago the only serious crime committed since the present Government took office was committed by an A.C.A. man, a man convicted as such. It may not be a crime in Deputy MacDermot's eyes, but you had an unfortunate man in Meath who was going into his own home, going in his own door; his gun was stolen by the leader of the A.C.A.; it was levelled at this unfortunate man, and his limb was shot off. That is not much, of course, but that was the only crime, the only serious crime, in which there was an actual shooting from the time the present Government came into office until this crime in County Kerry a week ago.
Comment on this
Do I understand the Minister to say that this man was shot in Meath by the leader of the A.C.A., the priest's boy?
Comment on this
If he swore what was wrong, I cannot help it. There is another aspect with which Deputy MacDermot dealt and that is with regard to the campaign against the payment of rates. When I say a campaign is in existence I am not referring to Waterford County and I do not want to go as near to the wind as Deputy Costello.
Comment on this
I am now referring to a boycott in several counties. Such a campaign is in existence and I am surprised that Deputy MacDermot is so far removed from those who were formerly members of his Party as not to have ascertained that such a campaign is in existence. He is either a very innocent man or he is absolutely out of touch with them if he does not know that. I will ask him if there is not such a campaign in Kildare, if there is not an organiser in Kilkenny and if there is not such a campaign in Tipperary? Does he mean to say he knows nothing about that? With regard to Kildare, one matter is so very recent that I will ask him to consult with Deputy Minch, who may be able to tell him a few things about it. There is no use in making the statement here. "We have always asked the farmers to pay if they are able to pay." Who is to decide whether a farmer is able to pay or not? What were the courts set up for in this country?
Comment on this
It is the same as has been done by my predecessors on many an occasion. A special Act was passed in 1926 called the Enforcement of Court Orders Act which provided that police could seize and sell cattle.
Comment on this
Yes, when you had a market. The law in this matter, so far as we are concerned, will be enforced even if police officers have to be used to go there to see that the sales are carried out in spite of a conspiracy against them. We are going to see that that is done and we are going to secure that the conspiracy will not succeed.
Comment on this
When I am talking about responsibility you need not try to drag that red herring across the path.
Comment on this
Was it not to your advantage that we were so long? I thought it was your complaint that this economic war is going on too long. The position is that an individual is at present evading arrest. Why should any individual be evading arrest?
Comment on this
Why should any individual be evading arrest if you are quite satisfied such a position exists?
Comment on this
No, you may have to search for him. If the citizens of this country obey the law and do not try to break it there is nothing to fear under this Public Safety Act. That was the attitude taken up by the Opposition.
Comment on this
That, as I say, was the attitude taken by the Opposition, but there was this position We stated to the people that we were determined to avoid having recourse to any of those measures. We hoped that we would be able to carry on in this country without recourse to any coercion measures, but there were certain people who, relying upon that, were determined that they would go along to the last extremity and, in that way, would be able to evade their liability to come under the ordinary law. If we have had to bring this measure into operation it is because we were compelled by people who were determined to get around the ordinary law and set up in this country a military force that would be a menace to the Government and the people of this country. That is the sole excuse for bringing this measure into operation.
Comment on this
It was stated, I think, by Deputy O'Sullivan at the time: "Anybody who is familiar with the movement in the last 15 years in this country knows how remarkably quickly the situation may get out of hand whatever the intention of the individuals." That was the Deputy's statement at the time. We were not going to allow the movement here to get out of hand. We had got the information, which I have already stated to the House, that drilling was going on by an armed body whose leaders had declared that they were in a position to oppose the Constitution. They said it was not an Irish Constitution. They are the people who, as I have said, prepared the Constitution. With all that in our mind it is quite clear what the position was tending to. Did Deputy MacDermot want to allow drilling by an armed body to go on? Did he want us to create in this country a situation that must inevitably, and would inevitably, lead to civil war if steps had not been taken to deal with it? In this motion he talks about the misuse and the maluse of this measure. I want to know in what way it is being mal-used. Complaint was made by Deputy Costello about men being arrested and thrown into prison and kept there for a time. When Deputy Costello was Attorney-General numbers of people were arrested at that time and thrown into prison and made wear prison clothes before ever they were tried, and yet the Deputy makes complaint about this. We have used this measure in the most sparing way that we could possibly use it, and I do not think anybody could say anything to the contrary.
Comment on this
We have used it sparingly and we intend to so use it, but we will use it at any rate firmly to prevent people under any guise or under any name bringing up a military body in this country that is going to be a menace to the institutions of this State.
Comment on this
I regard this motion, not only in its terms but in the speeches which have been used in support of it as constituting nothing short of a national burlesque. This motion and the speeches used to support it might well be translated or converted into a play and acted as a comedy in some Dublin theatre, or in some Roscommon theatre, if Deputy MacDermot would prefer to take the show there. When I was listening to Deputy MacDermot's speech I noticed a smile on Deputy Cosgrave's face, and I began to think of a Limerick I read at one time:
"There was young lady from Niger
Who smiled as she rode on a tiger:
They came back from the ride with the lady inside
And the smile on the face of the tiger."
Comment on this
There was no doubt during Deputy MacDermot's speech who was the lady and who was the tiger. Deputy Cosgrave said that he was tiger hunting in Thurles recently.
Comment on this
I only hope the Deputy will not try his last effort on the President if he does not want to give him indigestion.
Comment on this
The Deputy, in his new attire, has been responsible for more interruptions this evening than he has made during his whole career as a member of the House. I would suggest to the Minister for Local Government that he might consider the question of bottling the Deputy's shirt and administering it to people in low spirits if it is responsible for producing the exuberance that Deputy Davitt has displayed this evening.