We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Use of Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act—Motion.

Contributions 192–393 of 587. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Or his famous housing scheme.

Comment on this

One begins to wonder why Deputy Cosgrave did not move this motion himself. After all he is the leader of the so-called United Ireland Party in the House. Outside, there is another self-elected gentleman who does talk from the high stool, but in this House, at all events, Deputy Cosgrave is the leader of the new party. Deputy MacDermot has been given the job of moving this motion to-day. One begins to wonder why he was selected for that particular job. It may of course have been that Deputy Cosgrave wanted to ensure that when he brought Deputy MacDermot into the Cumann na nGaedheal web he would at least give him the satisfaction of having a day out afterwards. That may be the reason, or it may have been that Deputy Cosgrave may have regarded the moving of this motion as a high honour for Deputy MacDermot. That honour may have been given to Deputy MacDermot as a quid pro quo because Deputy Dillon stood up while the National Anthem was being played in Thurles recently. Even though Deputy Cosgrave may have felt that he was honouring Deputy MacDermot by getting him to move this motion in return for Deputy Dillon standing up while the National Anthem was being played, still I think the Deputy himself might have moved this motion because he came into this House two years ago and made a long speech as to the necessity of the Government being armed with these powers. He believed it was necessary that the Government should be armed with these powers and he thought the Government should have these powers at its disposal. Supporting the case that the Government should have such powers, Deputy Cosgrave said: “The powers and machinery provided by this Bill are necessary not merely for this Government, but for any Government that may come into power if the will of the majority of the people is to prevail.” Did Deputy Cosgrave read that portion of his speech as well as the other portion of his speech? At the present time he is able to digest the Centre Party, but I am afraid he could not to-day digest that portion of his speech made in 1931. Is that the reason why Deputy MacDermot was chosen to move this motion? Deputy MacDermot takes up the role of acting as adviser to the Labour Party. The Labour Party do not require him as adviser; he has no qualifications for advising them. Let him dispense with that grandfatherly role because his knowledge of the Labour Party, and the period of his residence in Ireland, do not qualify him to advise anyone in this country. The role of pretending to be an adviser to the Labour Party has given him his present position in the council of Deputy Cosgrave's wigwam.

Deputy MacDermot went on to talk in terms of lofty idealism. He said he did not expect too much idealism from politicians. That was a very unhappy phrase coming from the Deputy. He appealed to people whose minds were free to think. After talking about idealism, and minds free to think, he expressed his amazement that the Labour Party would not vote for this tricky motion submitted in his name. The Deputy need not talk too much about idealism or of people with minds to think. He need not talk too much about the Labour Party or the ideas he ascribes to them. It is no fault of his that he is not a member of the Labour Party. Will Deputy MacDermot tell us what he said to a member of the Labour Party in Belfast some years ago when he told him he was prepared to fly under any flag, whatever the party. The House would be interested to have that.

Comment on this

Let us have it from you.

Comment on this

Let Deputy MacDermot repeat here what he said in Belfast to a Labour candidate, and let him put that side by side with what he thinks of the Labour Party here now.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy say what it was I did say? I have not the slightest idea.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy himself state it.

Comment on this

Let you state it. Do not you run away from it.

Comment on this

You ran away yesterday with "your legs between your tail." In the course of his speech here Deputy MacDermot talked about——

Comment on this

Tell us what he said in Belfast.

Comment on this

We know what he said in Leinster House.

Comment on this

If Deputy MacDermot agrees. Let me ask him this: Does he wish me to give a personal conversation that he had? If so, I will do it, but let us be fair. I am not wanting to do it.

Comment on this

One thing at a time. Deputy Norton asks me to repeat some statement he said I made in Belfast. I cannot repeat a statement, of which I have no recollection, and of which Deputy Norton has given no hint as to the sense of it. If he will say what he says I said I will tell him whether it is true or not.

Comment on this

The Deputy says he has no knowledge of his statement. I can bring him to the person to whom he made the statement.

Comment on this

Slander by innuendo.

Comment on this

Ask Deputy MacDermot to give the statement. I am referring to a remark he made to a Labour candidate in Belfast.

Comment on this

How can Deputy MacDermot give it when he does not know what it is?

Comment on this

If you want it out then out it will come.

Comment on this

I beg Deputy Norton to stick to one thing. We were talking about Belfast. Let him stick to that. If he wishes to bring out anything I said in Belfast he is welcome to bring it out.

Comment on this

I ask the Deputy now does he recollect a conversation he had with a Labour candidate in Belfast, when he was fighting an election there?

Comment on this

What conversation?

Comment on this

In reference to the question of the Deputy's politics and his facility to go into any Party.

Comment on this

I certainly do not.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not remember his conversation. Will he deny his remark about joining any Party?

Comment on this

I deny here or anywhere else that I ever stated that I did not care what flag I fought under or what Party I belonged to.

Comment on this

I did not say that. What I said was that the Deputy stated that he had such a knowledge of public life that he could go into any Party, Liberal, Labour, or Nationalist——

Comment on this
A Deputy

What is wrong with that?

Comment on this

I am sorry to be taking up the time of the House with this matter, but as Deputy Norton brought it in, and laid so much stress on it, let me say this: I went to Belfast on the invitation of Mr. Devlin. I was introduced by him to some Labour men. Mr. Devlin was doubtful if the chances would not be better if I called myself a Liberal rather than a Nationalist. There was never any question of calling myself a Labour man. I said I preferred to stand as a Nationalist and although I was offered by the Liberal organisation £1,000 towards my election expenses if I stood as a Liberal, I stood at my own expense, and at a cost of £1,500, as a Nationalist.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton had not the courage to go to Belfast and fight there.

Comment on this

The Deputy never had the courage to go anywhere.

Comment on this

I will tell you what Labour was in Belfast and what it was here too.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Order! I think we have had enough about Labour in Belfast and about Labour here. Let us get on with the motion.

Comment on this

I was through the mill.

Comment on this

It must have been a very inefficient mill. The statement I made in respect of Deputy MacDermot's views on Labour and his previous views on the Labour Party, as expressed in Belfast and elsewhere, entitles me to say that Deputy MacDermot is very ill equipped to advise the Labour Party about what they should do in this or any other matter. The Deputy should drop that line. If the Labour Party want advice it will go to one who knows them much longer than the Deputy.

Comment on this

To Deputy Davin or Senator O'Farrell perhaps.

Comment on this

The Deputy could talk about the appalling severity of the Constitution (Amendment) Act but he forgot to tell the House that it was introduced by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. Deputy Cosgrave then said that the Bill was necessary, not only for his Government, but for any other Government if the will of the majority of the people was to prevail.

Comment on this

And the Labour Party thought it was not.

Comment on this

That Bill was introduced in 1931 and was passed by this House and the Seanad with a speed that disgraced both institutions. I believe that the Act was actually in operation when Deputy Cosgrave left office. Deputy Cosgrave, apparently, visualised a situation where the Constitution (Amendment) Act which took junks out of the Constitution, and made inroads on the democratic rights which were in the Constitution, should be a permanent feature of municipal law in this country. When that Bill was before the House the Labour Party voted against it. When the Bill was discussed in the Seanad, Labour Senators voted against it and fought it in every possible way in the limited time put at their disposal by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party which used this House just as a registering machine for the views of its Executive Council which it decided must be steam-rolled in any manner on to the whole people of the country. At that time the big battalions which supported the Cumann na nGaedheal Party succeeded in having the Bill passed, but our position then was quite clear. We were opposed to the Bill; we disliked the Bill.

Our position to-day is equally clear. We are still opposed to the Act. We still dislike the Act. There are features in the Act which, in the circumstances of either 1931 or 1933, do not seem to justify it as part of the municipal law of a democratic country. That is our position. That was our position then. That is our position now. But if the Act exists at all, if there are these ugly, objectionable features in it, if this appalling severity is associated with it, then the responsibility for all that rests on the shoulders of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, which was responsible for introducing the Bill into this House.

Comment on this

It rests on those who are using it.

Comment on this

We still dislike that Bill. We hope that many of the powers which are in the Act will be shed even though Deputy Cosgrave said when introducing it that these powers were necessary not merely for his Government, but for any other Government which might follow it. We were told during the course of this debate by Deputy MacDermot that the National Guard was a peaceful and law-abiding body. If that is so it should have another kind of leader because the speeches made by the leader of the National Guard did not indicate that if he were to have his way it was going to remain a peaceful and law-abiding body. We are told by the leader of the National Guard that the parliamentary system in this country is un-Irish and must be replaced. That was a reflection on the parliamentary system in this country, a definite overt attack on the parliamentary system and a definite indication of that gentleman's contempt, not merely for our parliamentary system, but for the institutions which are set up under it. If our parliamentary system were so un-Irish, if our parliamentary system were so objectionable to that gentleman, why was it necessary to introduce a Constitution (Amendment) Act to maintain this un-Irish parliamentary system? If that statement, delivered definitely, delivered, perhaps, with the same deliberation as Deputy Costello states the President delivered his speech at Dundalk, represents the mind of the National Guard, or the mind of the United Ireland Party, then there is only one logical end to that Party and that is to scrap our parliamentary system, despise and trample on our political institutions and have, in this country, the system of political dictatorship that has disgraced the pages of recent political history in other countries.

The leader of the National Guard wants a new scheme, a scheme which is not only primitive but extremely medieval. He wants a new system created, and if one is to examine the new system which that gentleman wants created, one will have no hesitation in saying that as compared with his system, the old scheme of an Ard-Righ in this country would be the last thing in modern parliamentary democracy, going back to a scheme of parish councils when a whole ring of people were to be consulted before something was finally decided. The boss of that system will make sure whatever is going to be decided will get lost on its way around the ring, while the leader of the party which expresses his viewpoint will make sure that he is safely ensconced in office, doing all through this dictator in the country, what dictators have done elsewhere, to the cost of democracy in other lands. One cannot merely judge that gentleman's declarations about an un-Irish parliamentary system without taking some cognisance of the military form which his organisation has taken, nor can one overlook that so far as the methods of salutation amongst the Party are concerned, they have gone to Germany to get the Fascist salute. He dislikes our Irish parliamentary system. He thinks it is un-Irish, that it has too much of the Irish character and Irish democracy about it and that it must be got rid of. He sets up a Party, presumably, to do away with our Irish parliamentary system and he wants to give this Party the emblem which has distinguished Hitler's storm troops in Germany. That is the attitude, if the leader of the National Guard really represents the National Guard.

I wonder during the negotiations whether Deputy MacDermot secured any promise from that gentleman that he now regards our parliamentary system as sufficiently Irish not to make an attack upon it? Is the position to-day that the leader of the United Ireland Party still thinks the parliamentary system un-Irish? If so, does Deputy MacDermot agree with that viewpoint? Does Deputy Cosgrave agree with that viewpoint? If it is un-Irish, if Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy MacDermot agree that it is, in what way is that un-Irish parliamentary system to be replaced and by what other system is it going to be replaced? If one is to gather anything from the speeches of the leader of the United Ireland Party—and Deputy MacDermot knows it as well as Deputies sitting on these benches— it is that the speeches made by the leader of the United Ireland Party are speeches made by a person who is ambitioned with a desire to be a personal dictator in this country. The United Ireland Party may try to establish a political dictatorship in this country but speaking for the Labour movement and the Trades Union movement, I say that any attempt to set up a dictatorship will be opposed in the bitterest possible manner, with all the resources at the command of the Trades Union movement and at the command of the Labour movement. A dictatorship here would mean what a dictatorship means elsewhere—suppression, tyranny——

Comment on this
A Deputy

A Public Safety Act.

Comment on this

——internment, theft, robbery, persecution. These are the distinguishing marks of dictatorships elsewhere, and these will be the distinguishing marks of any dictatorship that is set up here. At this very early stage in its career, this Party has found it necessary to copy the Fascist-Hitlerite salutation. Probably it would like also to copy their tyrannous methods. Let me pass on to refer to a remark which Deputy MacDermot made in the course of his speech. He said that he personally was opposed to lending his aid to any campaign to avoid the payment of rates. When I interrupted him in the course of that speech, I asked him if that statement also applied to a repudiation of any advice not to pay land annuities. Before Deputy Minch leaves the House, I should like to quote a speech which he delivered in Monasterevan and which is reported in the Leinster Leader of 26the August, 1933. Speaking in Monasterevan, in a speech reported in that paper, Deputy Minch used these words:—

"He had advised the farmers last year not to pay annuities, and his advice to them now was the same."

There is definite advice by a member of the new United Ireland Party.

Comment on this

That is not rates. You are talking about rates.

Comment on this

When the Deputy was out of this House I was listening to the speech of his deputy leader, and I asked his deputy leader whether he would also oppose and not lend any countenance to an attempt to prevent the payment of rates. He said that he was opposed to any campaign to avoid the payment of rates. I also asked him if he was also opposed to any advice to persons not to pay land annuities and he said he was, and Deputy MacDermot will not deny that statement made in this House. In any case, the Official Report will show what I am saying to be true. We get Deputy MacDermot saying that he is opposed to anybody advising people not to pay annuities, and we get Deputy Minch, in Monasterevan, at the end of last month, saying that not merely did he advise the farmers this year not to pay their annuities, but he advised them on the same lines last year and with Solomon-like wisdom, came back to tell them to stick to the same course.

Comment on this

They have paid them ten times over already.

Comment on this

Does Deputy MacDermot agree that that is an excuse for not paying annuities?

Comment on this

It is a pretty obvious excuse.

Comment on this

Does Deputy MacDermot agree? Does Deputy Cosgrave agree?

Comment on this

Reconcile yourself with your own leader; do not mind me. Deputy MacDermot told us that he was responsible for the name of the new United Ireland Party——

Comment on this

Are you finished with me?

Comment on this

Yes, thanks. If the Deputy gets off as well with Deputy MacDermot at the next Party meeting it will be all right. Deputy MacDermot told us in the course of one of his speeches that he was responsible for christening the new Party and that he had called it the United Ireland Party. In his first speech as deputy-leader of the Party, he tells us that he does not agree at all with many of the things said by the leader of the Party. He repudiates now any advice calculated to impede the payment of land annuities, which is another way of saying to impede the payment of rates. He disagrees on the one hand with the leader of the Party, and Deputy Minch has just recently come in to show that no matter what Deputy MacDermot's views are about annuities he has a policy of his own— and no new policy at all but started last year and continued this year. I would ask Deputy MacDermot now whether he will stand up and repudiate that advice given over the County Kildare by Deputy Minch. Is Deputy Minch right or is Deputy MacDermot right? It does not matter, of course, if Deputy Minch is wrong, but Deputy McDermot has a responsibility in the matter and the country is entitled to know whether Deputy Minch's policy with regard to the annuities is right or whether Deputy MacDermot's policy with regard to them is the right one. Which is the policy actuating the new Party? Which is the right kind of advice? I hope that Deputy MacDermot will deal with that matter when he is replying.

The Deputy, I think, was asked to-day in the course of his speech by the Minister for Justice whether he knew there was any campaign on foot against rates. If the Deputy likes to go down to my constituency he will find that there is an organised campaign being carried on by well-to-do farmers against the payment of rates in that country. Deputy Minch ought to know it.

Comment on this

There is no such thing in the country as a well-to-do farmer.

Comment on this

We saw the one the other day with the motor-car who could not pay income-tax.

Comment on this

He has as good a right to a motor car as anybody else.

Comment on this

Quite; but he ought to pay his way. Everybody who is not blinded by sheer political malice knows that any policy calculated to impede the payment of rates is a policy designed to end the whole system of local government as we know it in this country. A campaign against rates means the absolute demolition of the system of local government which we have in this country. It means, if it is successful, that there will be no work for the road workers; it means that there will be no houses built for local authorities; it means that there will be no public health work; that there will be no vocational education, no scholarships for the children of the workers and, in the end, it means that even the poor and the destitute will get no assistance whatever because, if rates cannot be collected, it will be impossible to provide them with any sustenance in their difficulties.

Comment on this

And what if they cannot be paid?

Comment on this

That is the end to which the campaign against rates is leading. That is the policy which is being connived at to-day by the United Ireland Party.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy repudiate Deputy Minch? Is Deputy Minch repudiated? Is that admitted?

Comment on this

No, it is not.

Comment on this

If Deputy Minch advised anybody who could pay his annuities not to pay, I entirely disagree with him.

Comment on this

I hope that Deputy Minch will take that rebuke and get the next train back to Monasterevan.

Comment on this

He knows the conditions in his own constituency; we do not.

Comment on this

From all accounts, the Deputy knew it in the 1932 election.

Comment on this

Might I suggest that it is time that Deputy Norton told us whether he holds that the ordinary law cannot deal with the non-payment of rates and annuities?

Comment on this

If it is shown to me that it is necessary to adopt any more effective policy than the ordinary law; if it is shown to me to be necessary——

Comment on this

I believe it is.

Comment on this

What about the murders? Do you agree with them?

Comment on this

Another ride on the tiger.

Comment on this

Talk to the lady, and do not mind the tiger. If it is necessary for this Government to have any extra powers to deal with a campaign calculated to impede the payment of rates and to bring to an end the system of local government we have in this country, so far as this Party is concerned, this Government or any Government in this country will get powers to deal with that situation sooner than see the system of local government collapse, because if it collapses it is not Deputy MacDermot who is going to suffer. It is the poor and needy people in this country who will suffer. As Deputy McGilligan told Deputy MacDermot recently, if this country went down the Deputy had no heavy moorings around him to prevent him getting the next train out. That is Deputy McGilligan on Deputy MacDermot. So far as we are concerned, if it is necessary to give this or any other Government powers to deal effectively with a campaign engineered for political reasons to bring to an end our whole system of local government, that Government, whatever its political complexion may be, will get those powers from this Party. I regard this whole motion, both in its phraseology and in the speeches that have been delivered in support of it, as nothing more or less than a vote-catching device. It is nothing more or less than a trick designed to save Deputy MacDermot's political face. This motion will cut no ice when the people know that it was the very Party, of which Deputy MacDermot is now a member, was responsible for introducing this Act, which they now trickily and dishonestly pretend to dissociate themselves from. Notwithstanding all the wisdom of the political correspondents of the Irish Times and the Irish Independent there was not the slightest hesitation, as far as the Labour Party is concerned, in opposing this motion.

Comment on this

Where are the others?

Comment on this

Where are the other two Deputies?

Comment on this

I will make my statement. The Deputy can go back on it to-morrow, but he will find it rather awkward. There was not the slightest hesitation in deciding on our attitude in this matter. As a matter of fact, and in order to give the political correspondents of the Irish Times and the Irish Independent some wise advice for the future, let me tell them that the person they stated presided at the Labour Party meeting yesterday is, I believe, not in the country at all. If that is any indication of their political wisdom, well they are entitled to the credit of it. The Labour Party have not the slightest qualms of conscience, and are not going to be tricked and trapped into voting for this dishonest motion, submitted by the Party that is responsible for the situation that they now pretend to deplore. Unanimously the Labour Party decided to oppose this motion, because they realised from the outset that it is designed, firstly, to catch votes; secondly, to attempt to put the Labour Party into a difficulty, and, thirdly, to provide theatricals for Deputy MacDermot.

Comment on this

After that rather lengthy speech by the Leader of a section of the Labour Party, I think it necessary to read out the motion before the House:

That in the opinion of the Dáil the Government's use of the Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act, 1931, has been unjust and oppressive and is deserving of censure.

I listened patiently to Deputy Norton. He spoke at length, but I listened with sympathy, because we can all sympathise with any man who finds himself in the humiliating position of having to make a public recantation of policy. That is exactly what we witnessed here this evening, and that is why we got such a deluge of long words. The Deputy was quite obviously muddle-headed and mixed up. He has shown so many political changes for the last eighteen months that we can sympathise with his state of mind. He started by walking in rather unfortunately and putting his two feet into an attempted joke. He followed it up by referring to persons "retreating with their legs between their tails." The two things together are evidence of the state of mind that he unfortunately finds himself in.

Comment on this

The Party opposite has more tails than legs.

Comment on this

The tiger had swallowed the lady. The joke gave evidence of muddle-headedness in order to get over the undignified position he was in, in having to retreat from a policy held so steadfastly up to a couple of years ago. The men of moral courage and brains in his Party were expelled from it because they would not support him. I can sympathise with the Deputy, but I cannot sympathise with his effort to hide his disgraceful retreat, in the way he launched out into a violent attack on a distinguished servant of the State, a person who is not a member of this House. I think it was rather unworthy, and I think in that particular line of action Deputy Norton has not even the support of a section of Irish labour. I have too much respect for all sections of Irish labour, representative as they are of Irish athletics, and clean-minded Irish opinion, not to feel that they deplore the fact that Deputy Norton took that line as his mouthpiece this evening.

This country for the past eighteen months has been subjected to a great number of knocks, and to a great number of shocks, in order that Ministers may pose before the country and the world as strong men, strong men anxious to assert the right of government. When the strong men are up against it we have a number of little rabbits sitting silent in their seats, or running here and there, in and out of the Chamber. For three long hours no one was put up to give a Government defence or to attempt to give a Government defence to this House for invoking the powers of an Act which was carried in a very different state of affairs some years ago. From the hysterical shrieks of passion of Fianna Fáil, and those who to-day ornament its front benches, not one word was heard in defence. After three long hours the Minister for Justice was put up. I have too much respect for the Minister for Justice, both as a parliamentarian and as a lawyer, to suggest that he should be judged by his form this evening. He stood up and made statements about an organisation which had ceased to be, in order to justify the application of this particular Act to other organisations, and to other individuals. Speaking as Minister for Justice, in his first breath, he announced to this House and to the world, his absolute ignorance of the subject he was pretending to deal with. He has all the facts relating to the A.C.A. and the National Guard in his custody—every file, every document—but his very first statement showed that he had not looked at the first files relating to that particular organisation. He started his case by making a declaration which is substantially different from facts. He referred to the date on which the A.C.A. was founded as February of last year, being just a couple of years out in his reckoning. He is the one man who has relevant documents that his agents have not seen. I merely point out that particular exhibition of ignorance in order to show the reckless spirit in which this Act was brought into being, and in order to point out the lack of knowledge, or lack of correct knowledge, which that particular Minister was suffering from when the country was asked to suffer under this Act.

The Minister went on to make the case as the Government spokesman, and as Minister for Justice, why the operation of an Act that everyone on the opposite benches had cried out against with all their energy three years ago, should be brought into operation at present. Did he produce one scrap of evidence, or one quotation from the beginning to the end of his speech? I leave that to any impartial people inside or outside this House. He brought a report before this House from General O'Duffy as Commissioner of the police. He misread and misquoted that particular report. He took a section of the report and even misquoted that. He alleged that that report contained a certain statement. After saying that, when challenged to read the report, which never contained any such statement, he sprang from that into an airy ventilation of his own views, observations and opinions. But no case was made, nor did he attempt to make a case, for the application of the Public Safety Act to present circumstances. I feel I am at one with the Government in my opinion that in advocating acceptance of this motion before any impartial tribunal, I should be in the position of a man pushing an open door. I maintain that I am at one with the Government in that opinion and that that is evidenced by the fact that, with great theatrical management, with alleged conspiracies, with fires in Government Buildings, with the withdrawal of arms permits from everybody who obeyed the law and applied for a permit to keep a gun and with wild, hysterical speeches by the President of the Executive Council, the stage was set for the bringing into operation of this particular Act. Yet, they have not attempted to bring one member of the organisation the Act was supposed to deal with before any impartial tribunal since.

There was supposed to be a conspiracy and a plot to upset the Constitution of this State or to challenge in arms the armed forces of this State. We had a plot manufactured in this country many years ago to be used against the Irish people—a thin, hollow plot. It was naturally distasteful to the Irish people and the people reacted and recoiled with such sheer disgust that the Administration responsible for the hatching of the plot lasted a very short time in this country. But that Administration was foreign, and the minds that hatched that plot to libel decent Irish people were foreign. Here, we have them imitated by Irish people sitting on the Government Benches of an Irish Parliament. If you wanted to get after particular men, to hound your enemies or political opponents out of public life after hounding them out of their means of existence in this country, you could have done it according to some Irish precedent or you could have done it according to some decent precedent. The way you went about it and the manner in which you did it was typical of your whole administration so far. The ordinary people—even those unaffected by your plots, your alleged conspiracies, your little fires at Fianna Fáil banquets—are beginning to see through the humbug and vindictiveness of the whole thing. Having brought that Act into being, having prepared the public mind by framing a whole series of plots, threats and menaces to the State, having hung round the shoulders of men, whose only crime was fearless defence of the State, portions of your own discarded mantle in order to try to put your political opponents in the same position as that occupied by your Party some years ago, you have libelled some of the finest and greatest Irishmen that ever lived. The ordinary man and woman up and down the country are aware of that and nobody is better aware of it than the electorate on which the Labour Party will rely one of these days for votes.

This Act, brought into being to meet an alleged conspiracy against the State—a formidable organisation of armed men plotting to overthrow the Government—was, in its application, used against seven or eight brokendown little farmers, who were lodged in jail for three weeks without a charge. This Act was introduced in a way which showed the characteristic cowardice that has been the outstanding feature of all the acts of this Government. A date was chosen on which the Dáil would not be sitting. A time was chosen when the Deputies of the Irish Parliament could have no voice or say as to the circumstances existing or the justice or injustice of applying such an Act in present circumstances. Now, weeks after this particular device for bludgeoning political opponents was selected by the Government, we have a front bench populated by mutes, robot-men waiting for the button to be pressed by the great magician. There is not one of them to stand up and attempt to justify the operation of such an Act. But, relying on a clear mind and a glib tongue, a trained lawyer is put up to make the best possible case without any material. Even that trained man, that expert in such a type of debate, made no case that would impress any impartial person inside or outside this House. We have the statement made that a man was caught with a gun here and that a man was found armed there—two, three or four men out of an organisation of some 30,000, and that in a country which lately had a civil war, with practically every man in the population armed. I venture to say that if you take 1,000 clergymen or 1,000 St. Vincent de Paul workers or any ordinary class of the population, you will find, up and down the country, a higher percentage armed than you did inside what was known as the A.C.A. Would that be an argument for applying the Public Safety Act to the St. Vincent de Paul Society or to the clergymen of this country—because one of them here and one of them there had been found to have a gun? It is to be remembered that, from the top, there were the strictest orders that could be written to members of this organisation against the carrying of arms without a Government permit. I venture to say that if you look up your records and disclose the contents of the files with the same amount of elation and irresponsibility that you do when these can be used against a political opponent, you will find that a bigger percentage of the permit-holders for arms were members of the A.C.A. than of the rest of the population. These orders are in your custody now, because every document has been taken over. I can quote from the documents in your custody the very strictest orders, issued right from the beginning, to those who had arms without permits, that they should either apply for permits for these arms or surrender the arms. Deputies on the Government Benches know that those orders were obeyed, that they applied for permits. I know that the holding of arms without permits by members of that organisation was true of a lesser percentage than would be the case if you applied the same standard test to the general public. Two years ago, we had the then Deputy de Valera and all the Deputies who now ornament the Government Front Bench in full cry against the viciousness of a Government that attempted to apply such an Act against organisations throughout this country that had openly gloried and boasted of their murders, referring to them as executions; against organisations that had for years attempted by murder and intimidation to tamper with the courts of this country; and an organisation whose sinful and criminal activities were so broadly and generally known that they were brought under a ban in a joint pastoral of the Catholic Bishops of this country. Hot upon the murder of a plain servant boy in Tipperary, who was hauled out of his bed and his mutilated remains found at a cross-roads next morning, identified only by the trousers he wore; hot upon the murder of a police officer returning to his young wife, whose orphan children were born three weeks after his brutal murder; in an atmosphere such as that, and following a ban which was the result of consideration by the Irish Bishops, when the Government of this State attempted to apply an Act of this kind to these organisations, every man who sits on that Front Bench nowadays was in full cry against the undemocratic, brutal methods of Government as applied to the people.

The Labour Party were so horrified and appalled at the application of an Act such as this to a country such as ours, even in conditions such as those, that they expelled two members of their Party, one a Deputy who represented the constituency in which these two murders had taken place. They expelled them from membership of the Labour Party. Yet here to-day we have that Labour Party, and we have that Fianna Fáil Party applying that same Act to an organisation, whose only offence in the eyes of the Government is that the men at the top were big and brave enough for the first time in this country to go out and recruit young men, to go through the highways and byeways preaching respect for the law, and preaching to all they met that, irrespective of who was head of the Government, or of the Party that was the Government of this country, the State was bigger than Governments, that the State was greater than parties, and that it was the duty of the decent youth of Ireland to stand for support of the State, no matter what set of politicians was governing. Their aims and their objects were published throughout the land. There was nothing secret about that organisation. The Press and the police were invited to every meeting held. When hordes of journalists and trained detectives walked into the headquarters to put their questions—ten questions at a time—was there ever any of the ambiguity that characterises that Front Bench over there latterly? Was there any question ever asked that was not answered by a plain, blunt yes or no? All these statements, interviews, speeches, correspondence, all orders issued down to the country, and all correspondence and queries up from the country are in the custody of the Government at the present moment and in the custody of the Minister who spoke here an hour ago. Was there anything in all these documents, in those 18 months, of which any Irishman should be ashamed, or for which he should hang his head? If the same searching examination, if the same magnifying glass were applied to the utterances of the men who sit over there now, if the same thorough investigation of their records, their letters, and their speeches, were made it might not be in the interests of this House, or the position of respect which this House should hold in the eyes of the Irish people, to have one-tenth of them produced or read.

Now when a ban has been put on that organisation of the youth of the country, put on by a Government misusing their powers and applying an Act, the qualifying conditions of which applied in no way to that organisation, and when by their propaganda and by their provocative acts up and down the country they have failed in one attempt after the other to provoke the men of that organisation into a breach of the law, they finally attempted one desperate expedient. Those men were organising to honour the memory of dead patriots who had been leaders of theirs. The organisation for that ceremony was going on for six months, published in the public Press, posters up at every railway station, advertisements on dead walls up and down the country. For six months the detailed organisation for that particular ceremony was going on and for six long months no action was taken by the Government, no hint that it should be called off. But, in order to demoralise those men, or, alternatively, seeing that young blood is hot blood, to provoke them into an open and violent breach of the peace, nine or 11 hours before that solemn ceremony was to take place, when men would have already left their homes, when all arrangements had been made, on the very eve of the ceremony, we got a Government proclamation, a Government ban.

I should like the Government to take notice of how that was accepted. Leadership of young men is difficult. Young men are hot, young men are fiery, young men do not understand bending even before pressure, young men do not like to be asked to turn from their path even because of authority. But what was the reaction of the man who is head of that organisation, a man who was hounded out of the highest position in the police force of this country, a man who has been hounded ever since by Ministers, particularly by the President in his new role? He put his whole future, his name, his prestige, into the melting pot in order to stay within the law. He called off that parade. We are living in a country that often had big men, but the biggest act, the bravest act of one of the biggest men was that O'Duffy called off that parade. He played the game that Ministers thought he was not big enough to play, and the men behind supported him because the men behind him knew that there was no necessity for them to give any public demonstration of physical courage, because they felt that the men who had fought and bled for democracy in Kilmallock and other places up and down the country had given sufficient evidence of their physical courage. Through that movement and through that ban the organisation grew in strength. That organisation had been definitely non-party. In facts real or distorted quoted by the Minister for Justice in referring to the A.C.A., we heard to-day of information that he was getting with regard to the A.C.A., but there was no ban; there was no invocation of the Public Safety Act. The A.C.A. was a non-party body; it was not a political menace; but the A.C.A. changed its constitution to the extent that it would become a political party. Then a political menace grew up, and then we had the Public Safety Act invoked.

Comment on this

Now the truth is out.

Comment on this

We had the Public Safety Act because it became politically awkward, and in order to bludgeon political opponents. There had to be the same test as we had on that August Sunday; the same test as to whether we would further bend the knee; whether we would further bow to authority, administered by no matter what type of hands or what type of minds; a further test had got to be put on the members of the National Guard; a further attempt to provoke defiance of authority and defiance of the law. That test again was faced up to by men whose only allegiance is to the State, and whose only attitude is respect for the law and hope for a clean administration. That organisation ceased to be; that organisation went out; but the vast majority of the members of that organisation—and I hope, in time, all the members of that organisation—joined the Young Ireland Association, the Young Ireland Branch of the United Ireland Party. But the vendetta had got to be kept up. The vindictiveness had got to be continuous. Those men who had dared to become a political menace had still to be bludgeoned up and down this country. The medium selected to identify those men, so that the full weight of Government passion might be vented on them, was the colour of their shirts. Men were beaten and victimised up and down the country because they wore a shirt of a particular colour, because they wore the emblem of the New Party, which happened to have been previously worn by the two other organisations.

We have an attempt by the President in his public speeches, and apparently by the Government as evidenced by police activity, to dictate to the Irish people not only as to what they will drink or what they will grow on their land but we have an attempt at dictation as to the colour of the shirt they will wear. Probably it would be all right if we aped degenerate dictators; if we went around in large sombreros and Wellington cloaks. Would that be admissible, or would that be accepted as a real Irish dress? We have this attempt at mimicking the actions of men who never were democrats abroad We have had every attempt to make illegal or drive out of public life a political opposition. It is time that the members of all Parties in this Dáil realised exactly what is going on. If they have any doubt they should at least investigate the circumstances, any type of investigation, but the fuller the better. We have no hesitation in saying that they would come away satisfied that the set of circumstances which the Government pretended was in existence never existed except in their own minds and in their past records. I will wear my own shirt, be it blue, white or yellow. I will carry my own cloak, but I will never shoulder or carry even one corner of the discarded mantle of the President of the Executive Council. While all this is going on we have a lot of cheap talk about a Christian State. A Christian State has got to be founded on Christian principles. It has got to be founded on Christian justice and Christian charity. With cheap lip-service to a Christian State we have this kind of activity carried on, and this kind of biased and partial administration of the country and the law. When all this is going on we have people standing on political platforms and presuming to quote the Pope's Encyclical; distorting and misinterpreting that Encyclical with the abnormal and distorted vision of men who see red when they are faced with blue.

There is one thing I should like to say, and it is a tribute anyway to a portion of the Fianna Fáil Party. In regard to all the unjust, personal and malicious attacks that have been made on General O'Duffy since he came into public life—every phrase, examined under a microscope, twisted, distorted and hurled back in an attempt to injure that man—I should like to say that during all that jumbled and unjust attack on a great leader and a greater soldier the men in the ranks of Fianna Fáil who can lay some claim to a soldier's record have been silent. I think it is to their credit to say that. The attacks have come not from the Party as a whole. Those discreditable attacks have not come from those who can lay claim to a soldier's record. They have come rather from politicians who have grabbed the material gains of the sacrifices of soldiers.

Comment on this

It is to be gathered from the speeches we heard from the benches opposite that the Deputies there resent the Government using the Act passed by them in order to suppress the activities of an illegal association of which some of them were members. As usual, however, the Party opposite is divided in its line of defence. The line of defence taken by Deputy MacDermot was that the Act should not have been used, because there was no danger that the men who were behind the National Guard organisation were a menace and it should not have been assumed that they meant what they said. The second line of defence was taken by Deputy O'Higgins, who, having made it, cleared out of the House. His speech was so incoherent that it can only be explained by the deep resentment that he feels that the Government's action called the bluff of those associated with him and in doing so exposed their weakness and futility. A few months ago Deputy O'Higgins was going around the country telling public meetings that all the toughs in Ireland were under his command. We have got, he said, the toughest crowd and to-night he assures us that if we got 1,000 clergymen or 1,000 Vincent de Paul workers, they would be a tougher crowd——

Comment on this

Withdraw.

Comment on this

I withdraw nothing. What was the purpose of this speech made by the Deputy? Was it not to assure the Dáil and the country that the members of his association were so docile and meek that they could not be a menace——

Comment on this

Rubbish. He said nothing of the kind.

Comment on this

Then if that is so why are you putting the Safety Act into operation?

Comment on this

Well, the tough crowd that he was boasting about did not prove to be so very tough when the opportunity was afforded them. We called their bluff. It is the disappointment, anger and resentment occasioned by the fact that we called their bluff that led to this outpouring of abuse that we have been listening to.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Let us get the history of this stated. First we have Deputy MacDermot, and next we have Deputy Costello, and thirdly we have Deputy O'Higgins. We are told that twelve months ago free speech was threatened and that because free speech was threatened the A.C.A. came spontaneously into existence in order to defend the democratic right of public meetings and freedom of speech. If free speech was threatened here whose fault was it?

Comment on this

Your toughs.

Comment on this

Who was responsible for the maintenance of order at public meetings? The Civic Guards. At that time who was Chief Commissioner of the Guards? It was Mr. O'Duffy. He was responsible for seeing that the Guards kept order at public meetings. It was he, through the orders he got from the Government, who was responsible for that. Ask him to tell his associates in the Party opposite if he failed to carry out these orders either through unwillingness to do so or inability and incompetence to do so. The responsibility was on him and not on the Government.

Comment on this

Run away. Come on to the knaves and traitors.

Comment on this

In so far as the Army Comrades' Association was an organisation brought into existence to protect the rights of its members we had nothing to say against it. In so far as it tried to arrogate to itself the functions of the police force it was merely a public nuisance. It was only when it set out as its chief objective to overthrow democratic institutions in this State that we suppressed it. The A.C.A. was organised on military lines. It prescribed a uniform for its members. It was officered by people who gave themselves military titles. It had arms at its disposal. If the object of that association was, as Deputy O'Higgins said, to go round the country preaching respect for the law, why did they require these titles, these uniforms and these arms?

Comment on this

They had no arms.

Comment on this

Did Deputy Dillon get an assurance that they had not arms?

Comment on this

They never had them.

Comment on this

The Deputy is more gullible than even I thought. Subsequent to the development of the A.C.A. on the lines I have indicated it was transformed into the National Guard. It was given a new title, a more military title, and it was placed under the command of Mr. O'Duffy——

Comment on this

General O'Duffy.

Comment on this

A man called O'Duffy.

Comment on this

Is it asserted that that organisation was a political organisation? Is it pretended that it at any time even described itself as a political organisation?

Comment on this

Of course it is not. What does Deputy Costello and what does Deputy O'Higgins mean when they say that we used the power under the Public Safety Act to suppress political opponents? The National Guard was not a political organisation. It did not even pretend to be a political organisation.

Comment on this

It said it might.

Comment on this

I will tell you what it said. Mr. O'Duffy, Director-General of the National Guard, in a statement——

Comment on this

General O'Duffy is down there.

Comment on this

——What is he General of apart from being a general bore? He is reported on the 11th of August as having given the following statement to the Press. It was the 47th statement that week. "Politics," he said, "are barred in the National Guard. Any overtures made to them by the Cumann na nGaedheal or Centre Party had been rejected. The Fianna Fáil Party had tried to make it appear that they were associated with politics, but that was false. He believed that if a vote were taken to-day 99 per cent. of the National Guard would vote in favour of their remaining anti-party." On the following day he made another statement.

Comment on this

Like the Minister.

Comment on this

Here is his further statement: "It should be now clear to all who wish to see, that we are determined to keep the middle of the road, independent of all Parties. It was under these conditions that I accepted leadership. Those who allege that we are linked up with any political party or group of parties give us credit for very little intelligence." Deputy O'Higgins said here a few minutes ago that he always sympathised with those who had to make public recantations. He has got to exercise his sympathy now with his own Party. That non-political organisation had an objective which it did not pretend to conceal. I quote this statement to refute those who said that the Public Safety Act was used by the Government against their political opponents. The people against whom it was used claimed that they were not politicians at all. They said that if they had association with the Party opposite they would have very little intelligence. What were its objects? "It plans to remodel the Irish Free State Parliamentary system upon rather revolutionary lines." That was a statement by General O'Duffy, the Director-General of the National Guard.

Comment on this

Read it.

Comment on this

I will.

Comment on this

What paper is that?

Comment on this

It is from the Irish Times of the 11th August.

Comment on this

The new Bible of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Sgéal féin, sgéal gach éinne.

Comment on this

Aithnigheann ciaróg ciaróg eile.

Comment on this

General O'Duffy stated——

Comment on this

He is General O'Duffy now.

Comment on this

I am quoting from the Irish Times of the 11th August, the main page, double column, about half way down: “The present Parliamentary system was English. The system he championed was closer to the old Irish method of government. After it had been tried for, say, ten years,” said the General, graciously— the word “graciously” is mine—“he would give the people an opportunity of voting for or against its continuance.”

Comment on this

Yes, after they had ten years' experience. They were not to be given an opportunity of voting to bring it into existence. He made that quite clear. He was going to give an opportunity of changing the system after ten years.

Comment on this

Read what he says.

Comment on this

"The present Parliamentary system was English. The system he championed was closer to the old Irish method of government. After it had been tried for, say, ten years, the people would have an opportunity of voting for or against its continuance." Here we had a military organisation, with a military title, organised on military lines, with a uniform, with companies and company commanders, with arms at its hand or in a position to procure arms, declaring its objective to be the destruction of the Parliamentary system in this country and its replacement by some fantastic system of dictatorship which General O'Duffy had evolved. Deputy MacDermot agreed to-night that Mr. O'Duffy was talking nonsense when he was talking in that strain. He realises himself he was talking nonsense. Is there any Deputy opposite who agrees with him that the Parliamentary institutions of this State should be replaced by a system of local Soviets such as Mr. O'Duffy recommends? He called them village councils, but so far as I know Soviet is Russian for a council.

Comment on this

Where is the reference to village councils?

Comment on this

The only difference between Mr. O'Duffy's method and the Russian method is that in Russia Soviets are selected on a representative basis, but under Mr. O'Duffy's system the members would be selected by Mr. O'Duffy. Is there any Deputy opposite who approves of that system of government?

Comment on this

The Minister has misquoted. The word "village" is not there.

Comment on this

Does Deputy O'Sullivan approve of that system?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have listened to six Deputies on this side, and they spoke without interruption. The Minister will now be heard without further interruption.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation. I do not want, in any way, to interfere with the proceedings of the House, but I have raised the point that a word has been misread— it is a serious charge—into a statement.

Comment on this

I could not bring in all Mr. O'Duffy's statements here to-day.

Comment on this

The Chair properly objected to too many interruptions, but I think that mine is a proper one. A statement has been repeatedly misquoted. I have asked if one particular word can be found in the statement in any report, even the report in the Irish Press. Can any report of the statement be found using the words “village councils”?

Comment on this

In this particular report that I have the word "village" does not appear, but I will read what does appear; it is just as foolish.

Comment on this

I am sure the Chair will understand that my interruption was justified.

Comment on this

I can produce the reference to village councils if the Deputy wants it. There was a period of two hours between the statements, and there was a change of policy. Mr. O'Duffy said it was his ambition to introduce a system in which Parliament would consist of representatives of professional and vocational groups such as farmers, engineers, teachers and those engaged in labour. Women, he explained, would be attached to the groups of their husbands or fathers. There might be something to be said for village councils but, for that——! I think on that alone any man could be certified.

Comment on this

Tell that to the Cumann na mBan, but first of all produce the reference to village councils.

Comment on this

We have these professional councils, women being attached to the groups to which their husbands or fathers belong.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister will now withdraw?

Comment on this

What I want to know from the Party opposite is whether they agree with all that?

Comment on this

On a point of order. I rose to explain my interruption. The Minister actually misquoted a statement.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this

It was misquoted, anyhow. I do not suggest the Minister meant to do it. Perhaps he will now say that he did misquote it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister stated that the word "village" is not in the quotation, and therefore the matter is ended.

Comment on this

Does Deputy O'Sullivan stand for village councils? Does Deputy Morrissey agree with that?

Comment on this

Deal with the motion.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Morrissey agree with that policy?

Comment on this

The Minister will hear me all right.

Comment on this

The Party over there have accepted General O'Duffy as their leader. Do they all agree with their leader's policy? Already he has been repudiated by at least two Deputies on the Front Bench opposite. Will they repudiate him generally in respect to this particular matter? I ask the Party opposite to formulate a policy, if they can, without bursting their Party. They might, at least, let us know where they stand.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Are we discussing the motion on the Order Paper which reads:—

That in the opinion of the Dáil the Government's use of the Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act, 1931, has been unjust and oppressive and is deserving of censure.

or are we discussing the policy of the United Ireland Party? We are quite prepared to discuss either, but under the rules of order I think we are constrained to discuss only the action of the Government in invoking the Public Safety Act.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is so, but as at least five Deputies on the Opposition Benches dealt with the policy of General O'Duffy, the Minister is entitled to reply.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon pays himself a compliment when he speaks about the policy of the United Ireland Party. Apparently he knows it, but he is the only one who does. I am speaking about the policy of Mr. O'Duffy when he was Director-General of the National Guard, when he had at his command a military organisation, in uniform, with arms at its disposal, an organisation that did not associate, and was not going to associate with any political party. That organisation had certain objectives. How did it intend to achieve them? Not politically, because it would not touch any political party, Mr. O'Duffy assured the country. When the Cumann na nGaedheal and the Centre Party approached them they rejected them with scorn. "Do you think," he said, "we have no intelligence?" That military organisation was suppressed, and it was suppressed in the interests of public peace through the instrumentality of the Public Safety Act. Now, there are things in that Public Safety Act that we do not like, but we did not frame it.

Comment on this

Take them out.

Comment on this

If Deputy MacDermot's point is that we are taking a sledge hammer to crack eggs, our answer is that the sledge hammer was the only weapon available. If the Act had been less drastic in its provisions we might not have regretted it, but so long as it is necessary to secure that anybody who wants to change the Constitution of the State, should first of all, seek the mandate of the people for that change, we are going to use whatever powers are available to that end. The use of these powers has had its effect.

Comment on this

Not the use—rather the abuse.

Comment on this

Mr. O'Duffy has now abandoned all these notions which Deputy MacDermot described as nonsensical. The Centre Party has found its natural place in the ranks of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party and the National Guard has become a youth movement. We saw some of the youths on the benches opposite to-night. I want to tell Deputies opposite that any attempt to organise a military movement in uniform, with or without arms, is going to be dealt with by all the powers at the disposal of the Government. We have made this country a freer country than it was when we found it.

Comment on this

And a poorer country.

Comment on this

It is open to everybody, no matter what sort of political constitution he wants here, to advocate his views in public and, if he gets a majority, to come on to these benches. Whether he wants union with Britain or the restoration of the old Constitution, the preservation of the new Constitution or some of those fantastic schemes which this nit-wit talked about in the days of his hilarity, it is open to him, if he gets a majority of the people, to give effect to his views but not otherwise. The public wearing of the blue shirt was symbolical of the National Guard. I would remind Deputies that under the Act which they devised the burden of proof on any person charged with being a member of an illegal organisation rests on that person, and that anybody convicted of that charge is ineligible to be a member of the Dáil.

Comment on this

Is that a threat?

Comment on this

The Deputy can take it as such if he likes.

Comment on this

I suppose that is why the Guards were asked to take the names of Deputies wearing blue shirts this evening.

Comment on this

There is another matter, however, besides the National Guard which has got to be dealt with and that is the campaign for the non-payment of rates. Deputy MacDermot and Deputy Dillon said that as the leaders of the Centre Party they did not advocate the non-payment of rates. Of course, they did not. They took good care to save themselves but they sent the poor mugs, the simple-minded members of their organisation to do it. Their hands are clean but some of their victims——

Comment on this

That statement is false.

Comment on this

Is this a point of order?

Comment on this

It is. Both the President and the Minister have been told that it is false and the Minister is now repeating it. I would like to know from the Chair if I am entitled to describe, in language that I should like to use, the statement of the Minister.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not make any speech advocating the non-payment of rates. He merely talked in general sympathy with those who were advocating that campaign.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Minister referred to members of the Centre Party as poor mugs.

Comment on this

If the cap fits wear it.

Comment on this

I think the Minister should be asked to withdraw that statement.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister did not so describe any member of the Dáil.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has ruled that he did not.

Comment on this

I do not think that any other word would fittingly describe those who allowed men like Deputy MacDermot and Deputy Dillon to lead them into the situation in which they now find themselves.

Comment on this

The Minister made a statement. I have informed him that that statement is untrue. I suggest that under the rules of the House he is now obliged to withdraw the statement.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is usual to accept a Deputy's word.

Comment on this

I am accepting the Deputy's word that he did not advocate the non-payment of rates.

Comment on this

Or that he did not send any member of his Party or any agent to promote the non-payment of rates into any part of this country on any occasion.

Comment on this

I am quite certain the Deputy covered his tracks.

Comment on this

I am determined to bow to the ruling of the Chair in this matter. I have made a categorical statement denying the contemptible allegation of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Am I to take it that he is not going to be compelled to withdraw the false charges he has made?

Comment on this

I suggest to Deputy Dillon that he ought not to press for a withdrawal. Everyone knows that the statements made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce are worthless.

Comment on this

They are worth a good deal more than you think.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister must accept the Deputy's word.

Comment on this

If you say so, I will accept his word. I am quite certain that Deputy MacDermot and Deputy Dillon did not advocate the non-payment of rates. They merely went out and made speeches inciting others to do it.

Comment on this

The Minister said that members connected with the Centre Party made statements advocating the non-payment of rates.

Comment on this

Members of the organisation of which Deputy MacDermot and Deputy Dillon were supposed to be the leaders went around the country organising not merely a campaign for the non-payment of rates but a campaign to boycott those who did pay. I say members of their organisation did that. They are supposed to be the leaders of it, but, of course, they are supposed not to be responsible.

Comment on this

I submit, with all respect, that the Minister is now trying by a side wind to get around the ruling given by the Chair a moment ago.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not so interpret the Minister's speech.

Comment on this

I am saying that members of the organisation initiated the campaign.

Comment on this

I submit, with respect, that the Minister is now trying to get in in another way the statement which the Chair ruled out of order a moment ago.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have said that I did not place that interpretation on the Minister's speech.

Comment on this

They did not advocate the non-payment of rates. They merely subscribed for the defence of those who did.

Comment on this

Members of your own Party advised the people in 1931 not to pay the annuities. The campaign was to pay no rates and no annuities, and it was on that you got into power.

Comment on this

They did not tell the people not to pay the rates, but subscribed to the defence of those who did.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Minister is thinking of the President's tactics——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not a point of order. There must be no further interruptions of the Minister.

Comment on this

My answer to Deputy MacDermot and Deputy Dillon is that those who did go out openly and did advocate the non-payment of rates were better men than Deputy MacDermot or Deputy Dillon, even though those of them who are convicted of that charge will have to suffer punishment for their illegal action, while Deputy Dillon and Deputy MacDermot go free. Deputy Costello delivered an impassioned speech here this evening, in the course of which he asked if there was any member of the Dáil who could justify the action of the Government in removing General O'Duffy from the commissionership of the Civic Guard. Is there any member of the Dáil even on the benches opposite who now doubts the wisdom of the Government in effecting the removal of a man who has proved himself to be a bitter political partisan and, what is more than that, utterly incompetent? His removal was, in fact, too long delayed. Not merely do Deputies know in their hearts that to be true but every citizen of the State knows it to be true. The Government could not expect efficiency and loyalty from a force officered by such a man as General O'Duffy has now publicly proved himself to be.

Comment on this

Was he removed for incompetence?

Comment on this

Go ahead and do not answer him.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have already warned Deputies not to interrupt. They know the consequences if the warning is not obeyed.

Comment on this

His proved incompetence would have justified his removal. The use of this Act in order to ensure that the funds required by local authorities will be available itself justifies it. If there was no National Guard at all, and if there was no attempt to organise ex-soldiers on military lines for the purpose of achieving by military methods a nonpolitical objective, this Act might still have been necessary to deal with the much more insidious and dishonest campaign with which the National Farmers' and Ratepayers' Association is connected. Deputy Dillon and Deputy MacDermot took the right course when they ran for shelter in time into the broad bosom of Cumann na nGaedheal. Their Party was due for an exposure which would have made it impossible for them to stand up again before the Irish people, and so, as Deputy Norton said, they went for a ride on the tiger. The use of the Act has been justified by its results. Not merely has that justification been admitted by all those in the country who are supporters of the Fianna Fáil Party but it is admitted by all those who are its opponents. On the date upon which the proclamation of the National Guard was published the Evening Herald, which is not a Fianna Fáil organ, in its leading article expressed the general feeling of relief which had been created by the action of the Government, followed by the calling off of the parade. Deputies opposite know quite well that if the Government did not act, and if they had got away with their proposals, there would have been, in Dublin and elsewhere disorder with which the ordinary police force would not have been able to deal. By taking action, at the right time, and to the extent necessary, we preserved the public peace and that result justified our action. The fact that those who gave, under cover, encouragement and sustenance to the no rates campaign now publicly repudiate it, is another result to justify the bringing of that Act into operation. This debate has served a useful purpose in so far as it made it quite clear to the men who are members of the National Farmers' and Ratepayers' Association that if they proceed in their campaign their leaders will let them down.

Comment on this

Some considerable observation of the proceedings of this House has taught me one lesson: that President de Valera is about the most astute politician in this country. Whenever there is a debate in this House calling into question his conduct, as head of the State, he puts up the simpletons to get off their chest any kind of tomfoolery they like to pour forth. And when the Opposition have torn to pieces, and scattered these, the President gets up and really shows his hand, generally at an hour in the evening when there is no time for anyone to answer him. We heard the Minister for Industry and Commerce just now. He spoke for some considerable time, and his nominal purpose was to justify the Government in invoking the Public Safety Act when, and in the circumstances, they did. He began by saying they were told that free speech was threatened, and he scouted the idea. Does President de Valera remember a day when he was in Glenties and addressed a meeting there? There were hundreds of supporters of the National Centre Party in the town who went quietly to his meetings and listened respectfully to what he had to say. Does he remember that, half an hour after he finished his speech, and while he was still sitting in his hotel in the town of Glenties, and I and a few of my side addressed my supporters in the town, his friends came along and broke up our meeting?

Comment on this

They were the great warriors.

Comment on this

The President himself was a witness of it. Shortly afterwards I went to Macroom. There were 1,500 people in the square to hear us. About 80 or 90 supporters of President de Valera came into the square and deliberately attempted to break up our meeting. The Civic Guards did all in their power to make an end of that disturbance. They went to these men and tried to get them out of the crowd, but every one who had to be ejected kicked up a row with the object of breaking up the meeting. Subsequently 50 members of the National Guard went over to those people and said to them perfectly peaceably "Will you go away and stop interrupting this meeting?" Then the National Guards withdrew for a while to let them go. And when they did not go away these 50 members of the National Guard simply wiped the square of Macroom with President de Valera's 70 or 80 men. If they had not wiped the square with these 80 men they would have made it impossible for the 1,500 people assembled there to hear us. There is no use in Ministers saying that there is no threat to free speech. Everybody knows that during the last election every meeting that was not in favour of Fianna Fáil was interrupted by followers of the President; and he knows that well himself.

Comment on this

Except in Louth. There were no interruptions there.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce went on to say that this movement of which General O'Duffy was head was not a political movement. He knows perfectly well that that statement is not true. He knows perfectly well that General O'Duffy, on more than one occasion, said he was quite prepared to contest an election in this country, and to go into active political life if circumstances rendered that course desirable. He knows perfectly well, and everyone in the country knows, that as long as the A.C.A. presented no political menace to Fianna Fáil there was no Public Safety Act necessary. It was when the A.C.A. seemed to have got a germ of a great political movement that would show up Fianna Fáil, and eventually defeat Fianna Fáil that the Public Safety Act was invoked. We were told that the President had his heart rent, that his love of Ireland induced him to do things that made him weak to have to do them, and that it was only his high sense of duty that made him invoke legislation to put an end to such a national peril. There was no national peril but there was peril to the Fianna Fáil Party and their policy.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce began by saying that General O'Duffy was a Fascist — a kind of Mussolini and Hitler rolled into one. Then he told us that General O'Duffy was a Communist. It is the same old story. When a man is not here to defend himself peg mud at him, peg every kind of mud at him in the hope that some will stick. Then the Minister went on with a magnificent flourish, taking a lesson from the President in reference to what he said about the men who were to be charged before the military tribunal. He declared that these men were guilty of certain crimes and should, therefore, be punished. A member of the Executive Council, who could replace any member of the military tribunal to-morrow if he wished, gets up and gives judgment on the persons who are charged before the military tribunal — a tribunal which has the lives of these men in its hands. He says, in so many words, to the tribunal "Here are the victims; it is your job to execute them". That is the departure for which the Labour Party stands. We used to talk of the poor soupers when a person harassed by poverty and hunger sold his soul to satisfy his hunger. The people would sing of them "They sold their souls for penny rolls and lumps of hairy bacon". That is what might be truly said of the Labour Party here to-day. They have sold their souls for penny rolls and lumps of hairy bacon. Perhaps they have no souls to sell. One would almost hope so because it is a pity to see damnation take place under your own eyes.

Every man in this House who loves liberty instinctively recoiled from the Public Safety Act when it was first brought before this House. I have no apology to make for saying that. The severity of its terms and its character generally shocked me. But it is well to remember that when that Act was introduced into this House there were men being murdered on the roadside. Members of juries were murdered; witnesses were murdered; members of the Gárda Síochána were being murdered and there was a time of grave difficulty when, as Deputy O'Sullivan said to-day, the ordinary process of law was breaking down and the jury system was being made impossible by the fact that jurors were liable to be assassinated in the public streets if they were faithful to their oaths. I doubt if even these desperate circumstances would have persuaded me to vote for the Public Safety Act. But here you have a movement to-day under the control of a man who was for 11 years Chief of the police force here and prior to that was a high officer serving in the force of which President de Valera was the head, and never on a single occasion was his integrity questioned. He was for 18 months the instrument of the preservation of law and order in this country for a Fianna Fáil Executive and he never let them down. He put into the hands of President de Valera every syllable of information that reached him about the Army Comrades Association, although he would be the last man to deny that he had many personal friends in its ranks. He felt, as a man like General O'Duffy must feel, that he had undertaken to do a job for the State and that no matter how that might hurt him personally, it was his duty to do his work or resign. There never came into his office or possession one single word of information that was not immediately placed in the hands of the Government.

Comment on this

How does the Deputy know all that?

Comment on this