Use of Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act—Motion.
Contributions 394–587 of 587. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
Because you were asked time and again to name a single instance in which he let you down and you were unable to do so. The President on one occasion quoted a report, a confidential report, which he had received from him, although I have heard the President denouncing such a practice when it suits the President not to do it himself. He said that General O'Duffy had sent him in the name of every individual who was in the A.C.A. and reports naming every circumstance which was brought under his notice, whether he believed it or not. That is the man whom the people of this country are asked to believe was going to lead a bloody revolution, to carry out a coup d'état, to overthrow the Government and plunge the country into chaos. The Government expects the people to believe it. Well may Deputy Norton say, as he said on the last night the Dáil met in the last session, that the Executive ought to realise that they cannot gull and fool the people all the time.
I remember very well after Fianna Fáil came into office, I think it was Deputy Smith made a maudlin speech somewhere down in County Longford in which he said that it warmed his heart to look down into the eyes of the plain people and to see the light of liberty shining there since the Public Safety Act had been suspended. Upon my word, there is no use concealing it, when the President used to get up here saying that he genuinely felt that that kind of legislation was bad for the country I had a soft corner for him in my heart. I used really think that "Be he right or wrong in his general policy, that man is doing his best. He is really making a sincere endeavour to get away from that kind of thing and he is doing his best." I used to think that a lot of what he said was deserving of high praise. Then I made a strange discovery quite recently. I found that the President was a student of a certain political philosopher called Niccolo Machiavelli. I turned up that distinguished philosopher to find out what his advice was and strangely enough I found that Niccolo Machiavelli, in a book which he had written entitled The President, supplied instructions for Presidents who wanted to keep their jobs. These are the instructions:—
"Therefore, it is unnecessary for a President to have all the good qualities that I have enumerated but it is very necessary to appear to have them. And I shall dare to say this also, that to have them and always to observe them is injurious and that to appear to have them is useful—to appear merciful, faithful, humane, religious, upright and to be so, but with a mind so framed that should you require not to be so, you may be able and know how to change to the opposite. For this reason the President ought to take care that he never lets anything slip from his lips that is not replete with the above-named five qualities that he may appear to him who sees and hears him altogether merciful, faithful, humane, upright and religious. There is nothing more necessary to appear to have than this last quality, inasmuch as men judge generally more by the eye than by the hand because it belongs to everyone to see you but to few to come in touch with you."
Everyone sees what you appear to be; few really know what you really are.
"For that reason let the President have the credit to conquer and hold his position. The means will always be considered honest and he will be praised by everybody because the vulgar are always taken by what a thing seems to be and by what comes of it, and in the world there are only the vulgar for the few find a place only when the many have no ground to rest on."
I must say when I read that combined with the knowledge that it was not unfamiliar to the President I began to wonder if I had been a great deal simpler than I thought I was. Let us remember what President de Valera promised us. Broadly, we were to have benignity, prosperity and peace. Well we got a taste of the benignity the night he took down a lock of his hair and said it was the happiest day of his life when he made his political opponents drink gall and wormwood.
Comment on this
If I have misquoted the President I withdraw unreservedly, but that is the impression that he left on me, that he felt on that occasion that the Opposition were drinking gall and wormwood, and that it gave him infinite satisfaction. We shall get the quotation — that is the fairest thing — and if I have misquoted the President I shall withdraw and apologise. Then we got the prosperity. There is no need to talk about the prosperity because it is all round us for everybody to see. The President has a monument more enduring than marble in the Fianna Fáil prosperity. Then we came to the peace. You see, the President was everything he should appear to be, but he was always ready, when the occasion called for it, to be something else just as well, and when the Fianna Fáil Party made up their minds that there were rocks ahead, and blue rocks, the President bethought himself of his old acquaintance, David Lloyd George, and discovered a German plot, and just as quickly as President de Valera was whisked away from the Mansion House 16 years ago, he planned to whisk away the leaders of the movement here. He ought to have remembered that there was nothing redounded more to his advantage in the election of 1918 than that he be whisked away under a Public Safety Act. He ought to have remembered that nobody on either side of the political fence in Ireland in those days believed the raméis about a German plot, and he ought to have remembered that if he took up those methods they would fail just as certainly. I want now to refer for a moment to column 1861 of Volume 48, No. 5 of the Official Debates. The President there said:—
"That would be corruption, to my mind, and studying the attitude of the Opposition to-day and carefully studying some of the statements that they made at the time, there was just that danger, that there would be in office men who would abuse their office by making that discrimination. I know it is gall and wormwood to them that they are not here to do it and that is the whole trouble. They are not here to do it, and it is the great and supreme pleasure of my life to know they will have to digest that gall and wormwood."
Comment on this
Here is the sentence:—
"They are not here to do it, and it is the great and supreme pleasure of my life to know that they will have to digest that gall and wormwood."
Comment on this
I can well understand that a word might be spoken in heat which the President would be glad to withdraw and I do not want to saddle on the President any particular venom connected with that statement. If he feels that he wants to say now that he was carried away in a moment of heat and that that did not truly represent his point of view, I will be profoundly influenced but I will not be as deeply influenced as I was before I read The President, by Niccolo Machiavelli.
Comment on this
Having made their absolutely futile attack on the National Guard and having failed to bring home one single charge that could provide a shadow of justification, they moved on to the allegation that there was a conspiracy to withhold the rates and the land annuities. That statement is false. There is not, and I do not believe that there ever has been, a conspiracy amongst the farmers of this country to withhold rates or annuities and at no time was it necessary in this country to bring in a Public Safety Act to make the farmers pay what was due. The farmers of this country paid land annuities and rates for the last 60 years and they never defaulted a penny until President de Valera became President of this State. That is a long and honourable record and they will not default, those of them who have the means to pay. I invite the President to remember that when Lord Clanricarde was evicting tenants in Galway he adopted exactly the same attitude as the Fianna Fáil Government adopts to-day. He said: "Are they not legally bound to pay these rents? Is that not the law? Does any one challenge my right to collect rents? I will collect them no matter what happens and I do not care whether there are 1,000 police or a 1,000 military, I will get my rents or the people will go out on the road." He got them and the answer of the Irish people to that was the "no rent" manifesto and the Plan of Campaign. That was in 1881 and bear this in mind — and I have said it on public platform after public platform — what was justifiable in 1881 is not justifiable now. In those days, we had the British Government in this country and we could not put the British Government out no matter how unanimous we were and, therefore, when they determined to oppress our people we were entitled to avail of the best means at our hands to resist them. That is no longer the case and—I have said it repeatedly— if the Government adopts landlord tactics the only legitimate thing to do in this country is to put out the Government and put in a new one and, with the help of God, that is what the people are going to do. Remember this, however, that where there is a man who has not got the means to pay and who has seven or eight young children in his house and a wife and the bailiff goes in to seize a couple of cattle that are providing milk for those children, I would spit on the man, who would go to the sheriff's auction and buy those two cattle and I would despise the Government and I would despise the Minister for Justice who would send down officers to take milk out of the mouths of children. It is not a crime in this country yet to be poor and if the Fianna Fáil Ministry imagine that they can persuade the people of this country to stand by while women and children are stripped of the absolute necessities of life they are wrong and the people would not be worth their salt if they did.
I say that if there is a man who has the wherewithal to pay his legal dues who attempts a conspiracy to withhold rates or taxes, the Government has every right to insist on getting them and to take any steps that may be necessary to get them. They have got to realise, however, that they have reduced a large number of the farmers in this country to a condition in which they are physically unable to pay and in the name of peace and in the name of good government, I appeal to the Government not to drive these people to madness because there are no leaders on God's earth who will be able to control them. If you drag eight men up to Mountjoy, one of whom is the father of 10 children, another of whom is the father of seven children, and another of whom is the sole support of a widowed sister who has a large family, throw them into jail and keep them there for three weeks without any charge, it is more than flesh and blood can stand to watch them, and if it happened to the neighbours of the President when he lived in Co. Limerick, his own people would be out on the roadside demonstrating against the man who did it. If you have a charge to bring against them, there was a court in Waterford beside their houses in which you could have brought it. You have a man in jail now who had to go home to his wife, in childbirth, from the Civic Guards' hands. You had him arrested and had to let him go home while his child was being born and like the spirit that was in him, when his child was born, he took pen and paper and asked you to come for him again.
Comment on this
The last Government in my belief would not have hounded down people who are not able to pay, but there is no use in talking in hypothesis. We are now discussing what the present Government has done and is doing and there is no use in wrapping the cloak of Cumann na nGaedheal around you and saying "If they would have done it, why cannot we"? I am discussing what you are doing and not what Deputy Cosgrave would have done 10 years ago. I do not care what he would have done. I am discussing now what you are doing and all I say is that if there are men in a conspiracy to withhold rates who have the means to pay them I have no sympathy with them.
Comment on this
I did. I said it in Mullingar and in Monaghan, but I say that if the Government are going to continue driving people to desperation who cannot pay, who have not got the means to pay, they themselves are deliberately trying to break the peace. I say this system of harrying farmers with Civic Guards is, I will not say deliberate but is certainly calculated to provoke a breach of the peace, and is wrong. These farmers look upon the Gárda Síochána as their friends. Most of the men in the Gárda Síochána are farmers' sons. These farmers have no desire to be brought into conflict with the law, or with representatives of the law. If you are going to so handle the situation that on every possible occasion you will create a position in which there might be a conflict, be it upon your shoulders if there is a breach of the peace. I know most of these men, and I know that nothing is further from their minds than to have any conflict with the police. They do not want it, they are law-abiding family men. It will take more than President de Valera to persuade the people that men with seven, eight or 10 children are engaged in any conspiracy to defy the law. Men so circumstanced do not go into conspiracies of that kind. No one knows that better than the Attorney-General. So far as we are concerned the Government need never be afraid that we will try to sabotage them, or hold them up for seeking to uphold the law. Never. Can he say the same of the five Deputies in Limerick who chose to go down to the public streets and to denounce the Gárda Síochána in all moods and tenses, when they knew that the Minister for Justice had the intention of instituting an enquiry into certain occurrences there on Saturday night.
Comment on this
Ní fior an rud adubhairt an Teachta. Ní dubhairt mé aon nidh i gcoinne na Gárda Síochána.
Comment on this
——chose to go there. The Gárda intervened, but not more than was necessary, to prevent blackguards firing broken bottles at unarmed and defenceless men. I believe the broken bottles were deliberately prepared for the occasion. Where you had a gathering of from 10,000 to 12,000 men coming in peacefully to listen to their leaders speaking, you had about 150 supporters of Deputy O Briain and other Deputies from Limerick coming out to peg stones on the public streets at peaceful men. Astonishingly enough we discover that in the midst of the howling mob is one of the Fianna Fáil Deputies for the City of Limerick, who has come forward and said: "Throughout the whole night I was with them. I saw what they were doing, and I got a whack of a baton myself." Upon my word, if that warrior had not more control over his own followers than he seems to have had he deserved a whack of a baton. No man ever deserved it more.
I say that there was no single case of illegality brought home against the National Guard when in existence. There was no single statement in this House which would give a shadow of justification for the introduction of this Act. The worst thing that the Minister for Justice had to say was that the fact was that General O'Duffy had advocated strong arms and stout sticks to defend themselves. Thanks be to God, we had strong arms and stout sticks to defend us, both in Limerick and Macroom. There has not been a single suggestion that the National Guard ever sanctioned any illegal activity of any kind. There was a kind of suggestion from the Minister for Justice that the house of some widow had been broken into. I do not know who was responsible for that but the Minister for Justice was responsible for breaking into a widow's house in Waterford. I did not hear him talking about that to-night. He did not confine himself to breaking in and smashing her property. The Minister has no conclusive proof of who perpetrated the outrage on the widow to whom he referred. Let me say that if anyone commits an outrage on a widow or on a spinster the Minister may rest assured that the members of this Party will give him every support in enforcing the law, and in protecting every widow and any other citizen of the State from outrage at anyone's hands.
Attacks have been made on General O'Duffy. There is not a single instance in the career of General O'Duffy that he need be ashamed of, or that any man in this country need be ashamed of. I was on opposite sides to General O'Duffy for a good while. We differed, and differed strongly. He never did anything to which I could point the finger of shame. I believe in anything he ever did he acted in the best interests of this country, according to his own convictions, and I have yet to find men on the benches of Fianna Fáil who can honestly get up and say otherwise. You have tried to justify the introduction of this Act on the allegation that there was a conspiracy to withhold rates and land annuities. There is not. There never was. You have eight men in Mountjoy Jail. It took you three weeks to formulate a charge against them. The President chose to go to Dundalk and to prejudge the issue.
Comment on this
I am quite prepared to bow to any ruling of the Ceann Comhairle. The Ceann Comhairle heard the speech the President made read out by Deputy Costello to-day. I hold that I am entitled to interpret that speech as a clear prejudgment of the issue. The President may not so interpret it, but I certainly do, and 90 per cent. of the common people in this country so interpret it.
Comment on this
I heard the speech read out to-day. As far as I can gather it did not refer to any particular case.
Comment on this
The Deputy interprets it differently and I am not preventing him. On my reading it did not refer to any particular case. However, it is not for the Chair to interpret it.
Comment on this
I will briefly recapitulate in order that the House may judge again as to whether it was as I stated. The President chose to refer to what he alleged was a conspiracy to withhold rates, and chose to refer to the serving of boycotting notices on the owners of threshing machines, because of which eight men are lying in jail. Having announced that they were there because of a desperate conspiracy the Attorney-General charged them with boycotting and, I think, with serving boycotting notices on the owners of threshing machines. Is not that so? Then the President gets up and says that he did not prejudge the issue. You have five intelligent men sitting on the Military Tribunal. I pay this tribute to the Minister for Defence, that I do not care how often the President prejudges the issue, I believe you have independent officers sitting there, and that these five officers of the Irish Army will give a fair verdict according to their judgment no matter what the President says. If and when they come up, which ever way it goes, it will be no thanks to the President that the eight men will get a fair trial. The President ought to realise that, because it was a desperate thing to do. Therefore I submit that the plea and justification for invoking the Public Safety Act has fallen to the ground. It has been introduced to smash a great political movement. Some "goms" were persuaded to subscribe to its introduction, because they were fooled into the belief that there was to be a coup d'état. They are now kicking themselves for having been led into such a ridiculous and preposterous situation. Some members of the Labour Party have cleared out. They could not bring themselves to vote for it. I do not blame them. I suppose they will be expelled from that Party. We will wait and see.
Comment on this
I do not want to prejudge them. But I would not feel myself quite so safe if I were to be handed over for judgment to the five front-bench members of the Labour Party as I would in going before the Military Tribunal. Bad and all as the Public Safety Act is, I should prefer that form of trial. I do not envy Deputy Davin or Deputy Murphy.
The Government case has completely collapsed. There was no justification for the introduction of this Act. There was no threat to the State. There was no threat to anything, but there was a continuance of Fianna Fáil insanity in public affairs. Public Safety Act or no Public Safety Act, the movement General O'Duffy is leading will go on. Public Safety Act or no Public Safety Act, Fianna Fáil is breaking down.
Comment on this
I am stating what is happening. Fianna Fáil is melting and Fianna Fáil does not like to think that it is melting. Despite the fact that it has taken a hearty meal to keep up its courage and its strength, that will not suffice. It will only serve to bring down the Labour Party with it. And it is a pity. However, you paid your price for the penny roll and the hairy bacon and the devil will exact his due in due time. The fact of the matter is that, from a political point of view, Fianna Fáil never more effectively exposed themselves to the public than they did on the day they invoked the Public Safety Act. We know now what their protestations of virtue were worth. We know now what Fianna Fáil justice means. Fianna Fáil mercy, faith, humanity, religion and uprightness— we know now what they are worth. The Irish people are beginning to learn that everything is not exactly what it looks. Give them another six months and there will be a story told which began with Fianna Fáil and which will end without even the mention of their name.
Comment on this
Now, let us weep on each other's shoulders. Deputy Dillon says poor Fianna Fáil is gone. He is sorry, desperately sorry. That poor heart of his is riven with the thought. Let us see what has happened — 47, 54, 62, 77. Two general elections inside a year and the biggest majority that ever a Party had here given to this Government. What has happened to make us all weep on each other's shoulders because Fianna Fáil is gone? Nothing has happened except that Deputy Dillon has found a new seat on a new front bench. What other basis is there for the belief that Fianna Fáil is gone? How many general elections do they want before they learn their lesson, that this country is sick and tired of Cumann na nGaedheal and of all the permutations and combinations of names under which that discredited organisation still occupies a front bench? Deputy Dillon said we were gone. Then, he said it again. Lest we might not be completely convinced by the argument, he said it a third time. That is the only evidence. He is not a prophet. He is only speaking with absolute certitude in relation to the future. He is inspired. He is not a prophet. All he can do is read the future absolutely. I am rather inclined to think that we have had some prophets on that front bench before this year. Last year, Ireland was to be bankrupt after two months, three months, four months, ten months, a year, two years and now it is put off for another six months.
Comment on this
Why did Cumann na nGaedheal go to the country last time? Because it was a prophet, because it was perfectly sure that, under the cover of the Public Danger Act — this damnable instrument which they made, this lash which they are now feeling — they would come back. They went to the country because they were prophets. They were perfectly sure that they were coming back with a majority. They were perfectly sure that they were coming back with a majority this time. Did they? If we have another general election now and they are beaten, inside two months of Fianna Fáil coming back with a majority bigger than it has now, that exponent of sober justice on the other benches, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, will get up and call us "limpets." After we had been two months in office, with two general elections in a year and with the biggest majority that ever a Government had received in this country, the sense of proportion and the sense of responsibility of the Party opposite is represented by letting Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney get up and call that two-months-old Government a Government of limpets. What sort of reliance can you place upon any statement of fact, let alone statement of prophecy, coming from that bench? Deputy Dillon accused the President of most horrible things — of saying that it was the joy of his life, to see men suffer the gall and wormwood of not being allowed dishonestly to discriminate against their political opponents. Is there any man in this House who would not be glad and proud to find that a condition had been produced in this country in which no man would be in a position, unfairly and dishonestly to discriminate against his opponents? Is there anything wrong with that statement? It is an elementary statement of simple justice which most of us would regard as a platitude that nobody could possibly get up in this House and take the responsibility of repudiating or dissociating himself from.
I am told that they are going to win the general election in Trinity College. That will decide the issue. The Irish Times will come out with two Latin quotations and it will say "The great heart of the people is sound; the judgement of the Irish people has been given and Fianna Fáil is condemned by the intelligence of the people. We were told about a little chap called Machiavelli. I wonder if Deputy Dillon, who has departed—again simply a premonition ; I do not want to prejudge the issue but I would not mind making a bet on it——
Comment on this
I will put it in the same bank as Deputy Cosgrave had an account in the name of Doyle.
Comment on this
I would not have to. I would have to transfer my Irish money from Ireland to an English bank.
Comment on this
I am prepared to give a cheque on the same English bank that Deputy Cosgrave issues cheques on signed in the name of Doyle.
Comment on this
All right, I have made that offer. There was the raméis of the German plot. I want you to go back and see what the raméis was under which this damnable Public Safety Act was introduced. Ireland had gone Communist. Do you remember that, or have you tried to forget it? Do you forget that the whole of Ireland had suddenly gone Communist? Do you not know that they were going around whispering to Bishops and whispering to all sorts of people all sorts of terrible tales about this Communism? Do you not remember the terribly strained circumstances under which that Bill was introduced, when every member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party had to come up guarded by three separate C.I.D. men? Stunts! Do you remember the circumstances?
Comment on this
Deputy Geoghegan at Ballinamuck advised the young men of Longford to call on their representatives and warn them.
Comment on this
Was it for that reason or because there was Communism alleged in this country that that damnable Bill was introduced?
Comment on this
The allegation was that this country had gone Communist. That was the stunt under which every member of this House had to come up guarded, and some of them had to change their guards because they could not keep up the pace of the Deputies.
Comment on this
That is exactly the fool question I wanted to get. I was waiting for some lunatic to ask it.
Comment on this
Deputy Flinn has stated that that was the question he wanted some lunatic to ask. All right, when Deputies have done laughing I will proceed.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I want to know if that statement is in order in this House as addressed apparently to some Deputy in the House—personally, to me, as I was the Deputy who made the remark. I am not going to be deterred from putting my question by any nationality on the opposite side.
Comment on this
I was waiting for somebody of the kind and nature of intelligence who would give me that opening.
Comment on this
Is it right for another Deputy to say that Deputy Flinn thought he was looking in a mirror?
Comment on this
Would you not like that we should have done so? There is one gospel I have in life—to find out what my enemy wants me to do and not to do it. That is why we did not withdraw the Public Safety Act. Under what circumstances was this bright young bantling of an Act introduced? It was introduced by a Government which had control of the Seanad. It was introduced by a Government which previously had introduced a Public Safety Act when it had control of the Seanad. It was introduced by a Government which after a year withdrew the previous Public Safety Act because they knew they still had the control of the Seanad. If Cumann na nGaedheal think so badly of their love-child why did they not destroy it before they went out? They had time to destroy 5,000 files. They had plenty of time to destroy a great deal of the evidence of the kind of thing which was behind the mentality which created the Public Safety Act. They had not the intelligence to destroy that before they went out.
Comment on this
Why did they not? Because they were prophets again, like Deputy Dillon. They were as sure then, as Deputy Dillon is now, that Fianna Fáil was gone. Give them another general election and they disappear. Is anybody going to suggest they would have left in our hands the possession of that instrument, that they would have left in the control of the Government that was coming in that instrument if they had not thought that they themselves would be that Government? Let us assume for a moment that we had withdrawn that damnable creation of the mentality of Cumann na nGaedheal and that an emergency had arisen in which a Fianna Fáil Government desired extra powers. Is there any man in this House who is going so completely to wreck his reputation as a man of veracity as to say that we could have gone to the Seanad and asked them for any powers which would conflict with the continued domination in the Seanad and in the Dáil of the state of mind and the interests which were represented both by the Seanad and by the Dáil? Now perhaps Deputy— what is his name?—Belton—
Comment on this
When he telephoned me from Cork to write a speech for the debate at Commercial Buildings—
Comment on this
I sincerely hope the Deputy will produce that speech, and I promise to read it to the House.
Comment on this
I will produce the acknowledgement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to the speech I sent him.
Comment on this
For 15 minutes at the Commercial Buildings you were wirelessed all over the country with my speech. The speech that I had written you gave to the public.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy trying to give me the Fascist salute? We were called here, a Chinn Comhairle, to discuss a matter which we were told was of the greatest and most serious importance. The levity with which it is being treated is a fairly good indication of the value they set on it. Oh, but there were serious things happened to-night, things so serious that if I were Deputy Dillon I should find somebody's bosom to weep upon. A very serious thing has happened to-night. A threat has been made on the integrity and future of this country, a threat of a character that I never thought would be used in this House. A scandalous effort has been made to stampede this House into an action which its better judgment would prevent its taking. Deputy MacDermot has threatened to withdraw from public life!
Comment on this
Another very serious thing has happened to-night—another of those things which make this very serious debate upon a vote of censure an historic occasion; we have discovered that President de Valera once did possess, but has lost, the good opinion of Deputy Dillon. Deputy Dillon read to me something from an old friend of mine called Niccolo Machiavelli. The idea is that the President should speak deliberately, and all that sort of thing. Had he looked up anything about centre parties, united parties, conglomerate parties or anything of that kind, he would have found that they were told that while they must not do anything in the direction of liberty they must speak of liberty. They must speak of "law-abidingness"; they must speak of justice; they must speak of democracy. The Centre Party has done nothing else but talk about those things, while as a matter of fact they have as much belief in them—well, my imagination baulks at finding a parallel. Deputy Dillon asked the President to prove that any information that got into the possession of General O'Duffy —I understand it is rather doubtful as to whether he is a General or not— did not get into his hands. That is one of those things which it would be utterly impossible to prove, and Deputy Dillon knows it. I wish those amazing people who are full of all the wisdom and knowledge of the world would turn those great brains of theirs to the solution of some of the practical economic problems of the country instead of wasting their great talent upon things so unimportant.
Deputy Dillon said that the Public Safety Act, when it was introduced, shocked him. It shocked him into silence. We did not hear anything against it ; we did not hear a word against it ; he was shocked, but he let it go on. He said that there were the germs of a great political movement in —I am not quite sure whether it was the A.C.A., the U.I.P., the N.G. or the F.G., but there were germs of great advantage in one of those alphabetical monstrosities. It had youth behind it. Everybody pays a tribute to youth at the present moment. It is lip service that is being paid to youth on the other side. You remember during the last general election the slogan of Deputy Cosgrave was, "Youth is with me." Youth was with Deputy Cosgrave, apparently, at the last election, until the votes were counted ; then everybody else was in favour of youth being with him. You remember that cartoon in which a whole lot of people "Sez he," and there was only one person left to "Sez me." Then you will remember that a body called Fianna Fáil, a Communist revolutionary tribunal called the Fianna Fáil Government, suggested that the franchise for local elections might be extended to youth. Perhaps the House has forgotten it, but that absolutely amazing and revolutionary proposal was made, and what was the Centre Party—I understand there is only one representative of it now——
Comment on this
I doubt the relevancy of extending the franchise to youth, but the Deputy is certainly extending the scope of the motion before the House.
Comment on this
This is a youth movement—a germ that is going to grow. As soon as it was proposed to recognise youth and its responsibility in the matter of local government they were immediately described as a lot of hobbledehoys and flappers. That is what youth is when they do not think it is going to vote with them. That is what youth is when you take it in the mass ; when it is allowed to use its own judgement, and when you do not just get the handpicked, selected, sons-of-your-fathers youth, for the purpose of calling it the youthful branch of the United Ireland Party. This body is supposed to be non-political. I read with great care the 972 speeches of that strong silent man, General O'Duffy. He certainly said that the parliamentary system was wrong, and he was in favour of another and entirely different system. After it had ten years of trial then he would permit the people to choose. What was happening in the ten years? It was after this new system of his, which was non-political, which was not connected with any other Party, which was too intelligent to be connected with any other Party, had had ten years of administration that he was prepared to give the country an opportunity. Deputy O'Duffy—I wish he were! I do wish he were Deputy O'Duffy. I think we ought to give a walk-over to Cumann na nGaedheal in any one of its own constituencies in Ireland in order to bring him in here.
Comment on this
That strong silent man! He ought to be here. When Deputy MacDermot is telling one story about the policy and Deputy Minch is telling another story and when everyone else is correcting everybody else the man who is boss ought to be here. What is the use of sending an office boy and they are all office boys? Why not send over the boss? Let us hear what he has told them to-day.
Comment on this
Ah yes, put him up for Trinity or put him up for Puck Fair. We had a public recantation of policy. I have seen three members of the Farmers' Party speak in this House and I have recollections they made precisely the same kind of speeches when they were in definite and inexorable opposition. The vanished Centre Party made the same sort of speeches upon these benches and of which Deputy Kent now alone remains. They were then all for economy and for every economy. Now they are out for cutting down expenses? Are they for that now? They were immensely efficient and they did transfer themselves into the possession of Cumann na nGaedheal. How did they do it and why? And what was the kind of person to whom they did transfer in the opinion of the tiger who absorbed them? There was a leader of the Farmers' Party here——
Comment on this
I agree it is past. We will leave it at that. We are told this is an Act of appalling severity. When this Act was being introduced the Cumann na nGaedheal Government was warned that they could not possibly anticipate that there would be permanently upon the Government Benches men of the intelligence, probity and patriotism of Cumann na nGaedheal. They were warned that there might even be a Labour Party there. Now let us assume that what is happening under this Public Danger Act is ten thousand times worse than you say it is. Who is responsible for it? Who is responsible for leaving the instrument there? Remember what you said about it. Lunatics! We are not all lunatics. That was the mildest word. We were thieves, liars and murderers. We were thieves and anarchists and yet you, very intelligent people, went out and left that dynamite in the hands of those whom you had called liars, murderers and anarchists. What can you expect?
Comment on this
You are responsible. I tell you now that if you multiplied every evil thing which you say about our administration by ten thousand you will still have to say to yourselves: "It was we who put this into these wild men's hands, this horrible instrument of oppression!" And when it all boils down and the talk is over and the inspired angel of peace, Deputy Dillon, gets up, what does he say? He says: "I am perfectly satisfied that under the Public Safety Act as at present administered by the five officers in Portobello Barracks that justice will be done"! What is all the complaint about? What is all the growling about? The one testimony we have got as to the unimpeachable justice and the safeguarding of everybody in this country under the Public Safety Act has come from Deputy Dillon who tells us that the verdict which is going to come from those officers will be a just one.
I have no use for the Public Safety Act. It was a damnable creation of low and mean intelligence. It was created for the purpose, if possible, of steam-rolling out of existence the political opponents of Cumann na nGaedheal. I do not know anything low enough or mean enough on whom to use it except on those who created it. They made the lash. I hope the lash will not have to be used. I hope we will see a condition in which it will not be necessary to use it. But if there is anybody in the whole world who has no cause whatever to complain of what has been done under it, it is the Deputies opposite who were the Cumann na nGaedheal Party and who are now a sort of mixem gatherem of God only knows what. I do not know if you would call them remnants of every sort of political intrigue that was ever created. If anything is done under it, so long as it is down there, there is no case for complaint by you and everybody knows it. But you the members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party who ought to have consciences should feel that if the lash falls on any but yourselves the responsibility is yours. If it falls upon yourselves you are getting what you damn well deserve.
Comment on this
After listening to the cloquent speeches that have been made in this debate from lawyers and Ministers and from last but not least the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Flinn, I feel rather timid as a farmer and the representative of farmers in butting in on this debate. Nevertheless, I wish to put before this House a few important points as regards the attitude which I intend to take up on this Motion. As one who has had personal experience of coercion laws and coercion courts under the Balfour regime during the land war in this country I want to say that I do not like coercion. When I was a mere young fellow I was tried in one of these courts by two notorious Removable Magistrates known as Colonel Caddell and Colonel MacArdle now long deceased. I do not wish to be uncharitable to their memory, but I only wish to say that I hope they are not gone to the land of Terra del Fuego but to a far happier and nobler land. I have had personal experience of military tribunals too. I have been tried before them.
I strongly object to any coercion Act of Public Safety brought in by any Government or by any Party in this country. This Public Safety Act was brought in by the last Government. It has now been revived by the present Government. Does any Deputy here for a moment imagine that this Public Safety Act will bring about peace and unity amongst the Irish people, that peace and unity about which we hear so much, which is so often talked about but which is never seriously considered? There is only one way as far as I can see in which this country will become prosperous and united and that is when we have the unity of all the big parties in this House. There is nothing impossible in the way of bringing that about.
What has been engendered for the past couple of years, particularly in the last two years? Nothing but bitterness and hatred amongst the members of different Parties and amongst the people in the country. The time has come when this pot of poison must be upset. The cup is overflowing with anger, hatred and revenge. It is time that that should be upset and that there should be brought about what we all desire, a united people, just the same as we were from 1916 to 1922 when we were the admiration of the whole world. There are two roads upon which we can travel. One is the thorny road that will bring nothing but misery and ruin to the country. The other is the road we will travel if we become, as good Catholic, Christian people should become, united. It is only then that we will make any progress and that we will have any peace and prosperity in this country.
I have a personal objection to this Public Safety Act. I have already given my reasons in that regard. I have also an objection to any conspiracy. It has been alleged by the Government that a conspiracy has been started with the knowledge of the Centre Party. Organisations and leaders may come and go, but the Farmers' Party will remain for all time. You must realise that under the present circumstances the farming community are being driven swiftly into the shifting quagmire of economic ruin. If the conditions that now exist continue, in the very near future this country will be in bankruptcy. The majority of the farmers are not in a position to pay rates or annuities; they are not in a position to buy the necessaries of life for themselves or their families. As regards the payment of rates, I will vouch for the accuracy of Deputy MacDermot's statement. He never advocated the policy of the non-payment of rates. I agree with him that any man who is in a position to pay rates is not worthy of being called an Irishman if he does not do so voluntarily. If the rates are not paid who will be the sufferers? The sufferers will be the aged and infirm and the mentally afflicted.
The farmers have been in the front line trenches for the last 18 months. They have borne the burden of this economic war with very little assistance from other sections of the community. I think it is time the farmers were taken from the first line trenches and given a chance to maintain their families and an opportunity to pay their rates, which they are morally bound to do. Give them a chance to live in peace and comfort. This Government will never succeed, any more than any other Government, by putting into force drastic coercion laws or Public Safety Acts. So far as I can see, there is only one hope for the country and that is to have a united party, working for the welfare and prosperity of the people. I have been elected by the farmers and I shall do my utmost to carry out the trust they have reposed in me. I sincerely hope I will be in some way instrumental in putting all thoughts of civil strife and all the existing hatred to one side for all time and that I will be the means of bringing about a united Irish people.
Comment on this
If there is anything that would go to show the difference between now and two years ago, anything that would go to show whether there was any reason for this Act, it has been amply demonstrated by the debate this afternoon in the House. Those of us who were here two years ago, when the Act was introduced, can contrast the atmosphere and the tenor of the speeches and the way in which the measure was dealt with generally, with the proceedings here to-day. I have listened to the speeches delivered from the opposite side, and I may say that I felt myself going from one degree of disgust to another. Deputy Hugo Flinn, the last speaker from the Government side, filled one absolutely with disgust. Does the President, or the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who gave us a wild outburst and, if I may say with all respect to him, the weakest speech he has ever made in the House, because he had a very weak case, stand over the speech of Deputy Hugo Flinn? Every time I listen to Deputy Flinn, and never more so than to-night, the more I am proud of the fact that he is not an Irishman. No man, I do not care whether he is Fianna Fáil or Cumann na nGaedheal, whether he is Labour or Centre Party, as it was, with Irish blood in his veins, could talk in the strain in which Deputy Hugo Flinn talked to-night. Deputy Norton talked about burlesque and Deputy Flinn, next to Deputy Norton himself, should take the chief part in that respect.
Deputy Hugo Flinn is a professional politician in the real sense of the word. Deputy Flinn has no more affinity with Fianna Fáil than I have— and that is very little. Deputy Flinn would feel really happy if he would be allowed into the Tory Club in London. Deputy Hugo Flinn has prostituted everything that is decent in upbringing, in education and in training. I am one who did not get a university education, but when I realise that Deputy Hugo Flinn is one of those who had the privilege, because of his father's wealth, not because of anything he earned himself, of going through some of the best schools in this country—and perhaps it is only fair to say of the schools in this country that the effect was spoiled by his long sojourn on the docks in Liverpool—I can recognise quite clearly that education does not mean anything.
Comment on this
It is very seldom that in this House, or outside it, I indulge in personalities, but it is very hard to sit here and listen to a person like Deputy Flinn—his name is spelled in his own peculiar way—talking about men like General O'Duffy, or talking about any other decent Irishman, or talking about the lash being laid on, or talking about the fact that the last Government should not have left it in the hands of the present Government. There is one thing, anyway, about those who may be brought under the lash of the Public Safety Act. They will not make so contemptible and so ignoble a plea as Deputy Flinn made when he was going to be conscripted by the British Government, as he should have been.
Comment on this
So much for Deputy Flinn. I have said so much about him because there are some Deputies in this House who perhaps do not know him and who perhaps might be influenced, although I think that would be impossible, by his theatricals up and down the floor with his hands on his hips.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is this an exposition of Deputy Flinn's personal character by Deputy Morrissey or a contribution to the debate on this motion?
Comment on this
I have given Deputy Morrissey a good deal of latitude. I was just thinking that Deputy Morrissey was coming to the end of Deputy Flinn and was going to deal with the motion.
Comment on this
I do want to say this, that I feel in a rather strange position in this House to-night. The Minister for Industry and Commerce shakes his head, but I do not feel at all as strange as the Minister feels, and I am sure I am feeling much more comfortable than the President does on this matter. Let me say this, that I am absolutely in favour of the Public Safety Act, although I do not consider for one moment that in the way in which it has been used by the present Government it is at all as necessary as it was in October, 1931. Let us review the position, and let me say, in passing, that I am sorry that all the eight members of the Labour Party who are privileged to sit in this House, and the other eight or nine who are not privileged to sit in this House— who failed to secure election in the country, but who could have a voice in expelling Deputy Anthony and myself from the Labour Party for voting for the Public Safety Bill—are not here to-night, because I want to ask them this: how can they say that what was black yesterday is white to-day?
Comment on this
I am not saying it. I voted for the Public Safety Act, and if the present Government will use it impartially, I will stand by it to-day and will vote for it.
Comment on this
But remember this, the Labour Party and the Fianna Fáil Party voted against a Bill that was brought in for what purpose? To deal with those who murdered MacCurtin and Ryan in Tipperary, to deal with Saor Eire and to deal with Communism. It was admitted that there was a conspiracy to uproot, by force, this State. The Labour Party could vote against the Bill and then could expel two members from the Party because these two members thought it was necessary in the interests of the country and in the interests of peace: that it was necessary to secure that every man would have the right of freedom of opinion and the right to earn his living in his own way. They thought it necessary that such a Bill should be put in the hands of the Government that was responsible and answerable to the people. To-day that same Bill is being used not to deal with Communism, not to deal with Saor Eire, not to deal with the I.R.A., and not even to deal with the National Guard. It was ostensibly reintroduced by the President to deal with the National Guard, but it has not been used for that purpose. It is being used to deal with the eight or nine farmers in the County Waterford who are accused of being members of a conspiracy. They are brought and lodged in Mountjoy Jail for three or four weeks without any charge being preferred against them, and are then informed that they will be brought before the Military Tribunal, which can impose all the terrible penalties we have been told of. The President himself told us that it was the greatest piece of coercion since Cromwell's time. That is to be used against those farmers, but the men who are smashing private property, the men who spurned the President's advice when he told them that they were bringing shame on their country, the men who are going about the country smashing property inside and outside, and who are putting their fingers to the nose of the President and his authority are brought before a district justice. The eight or the nine men from Waterford, who cannot, because of the policy carried out by the present Government, pay their rates are to be hauled before the majesty and terror that the people opposite told us surround the Military Tribunal.
Comment on this
The President has made many twists during his political life. God knows he has made many, including the famous one when he and other members of his Party said they would be in their graves before they would take the Oath and come into this House, but I suggest that this is the biggest twist he has ever made in his life, but big and all as it is, it is nothing compared to the twist made by the members of the Labour Party. I want to ask Deputy Keyes who is now a Deputy in this House but who was not a member at the time that the Public Safety Act was introduced— he was a member of the body that voted for our expulsion—this question: How can what was right then be wrong now? I want to ask Deputy Everett, the Leas-Cheann Comhairle and Deputy Norton this question: Are the six members of the Labour Party who are in the Dáil to-day going to vote for the expulsion of the two who are not here, or are the two who are not here going to vote for the expulsion of the six? I will put it this way: that the man who rather than come in here and vote against this motion went home to his constituents this morning has a better right to vote for the expulsion of the six than the six have to vote for his expulsion or that of the Deputy who, according to this morning's newspapers is suffering from a nervous breakdown but who looked in the pink of health in the House yesterday. I hope that his nervous breakdown will only last as long as this Bill lasts. I do not want to go further than that. As one who has given a pretty long service, both in the country and in this House in the Labour movement, as one who has been consistently a Labour man from the time he left school and a practical Labour man at that, I am very sorry indeed to see the workers of this country let down in the way they have been let down.
Comment on this
I am not going to say that. I do not agree with that. I know some of the men who represent the Labour Party in this House and I know them to be decent, honest, straightforward men, but I also know others who are advising them outside, those who did most to put Deputy Anthony and myself out of the Labour Party, I know that they have forced them because of the grip that Fianna Fáil has got on them in the last two years. Deputies on the Labour Benches know that as well as I do.
Comment on this
Deputy Kelly knows nothing about it. I know a lot about it and I know a lot about what happened in 1927 but I am not going into that now. Deputy Norton, to-day, was obviously unhappy. He is usually very fluent if not very impressive. He usually tries a joke but it is not always a success. To-day he was so bewildered that he talked about a Deputy leaving the House with "his legs between his tail." That is what the Labour Party have done. They have their legs between their tail and not their tail between their legs.
Comment on this
I have sat throughout this debate and tried to learn what was the charge definitely made against the Government. I listened to the Deputy who moved the motion, and the only thing I could find in the charge is that we called in the Public Safety Act and have not used it. The suggestion is that we have not used it except to the extent of proceeding under it against persons who are charged with conspiracy. Now, I certainly feel much happier here, facing charges of that sort, than I would feel if Deputies on the other side were charging us with sitting idly by while civil war was being created, and while people were being killed, If we had sat idly by, that might very well have happened in Dublin, and if we had not taken the action we did, then, I think we would be seriously open to censure. It was because we felt it would not be right for us to take no action, and that we had a definite duty to preserve order, that we took the action we did. I might say, before I leave that, that I do not believe there is a single person in the country who does not believe but that we acted rightly upon that occasion. I do not care about the compliment paid to General O'Duffy by one of the Deputies on the other benches. I say that General O'Duffy did the right thing in calling off that parade. He certainly did the right thing, just as the Government did the right thing, in saying that the parade should not be held. Until we said that that parade should not be held he was making preparations for uniforms and sticks to carry it out. The preservation of order is not too easy a task. It is not an easy task, particularly in times of crisis, and what we would expect from Deputies who talked so much in the past about the preservation of order, is that they would assist us and not choose to be the people to incite to disorder.
Now the history of the A.C.A., or the National Guard, or whatever name you care to call it is rather interesting. It began with the organisation of trained soldiers, ex-Army officers and men. It was formed during the election of 1932.
Comment on this
Perhaps the author will tell us the exact date it was formed, but that is my recollection. It was formed for what? The ostensible purpose was to preserve free speech. It was suggested, at that time, the police were unable to maintain order, and yet the person in charge of the police at that period was General O'Duffy. There are people who have been anxious to misrepresent this country on every occasion, to represent us as a lawless people and as a people who, at elections, are out to break each other's heads. The universal testimony of all observers of these recent elections is that they were particularly quiet elections, especially so if we remember the issues at stake and the tension that was obvious in these elections. We say there is no need and that there should be no need to organise a body to usurp—for that is what it was intended to do—the functions of the State forces. If the police are not sufficient then it is the duty of the Government to make provision, and to mobilise, if necessary, all right-minded people in the country to see that order is kept. It is not the function of those who want to make a private army to do that. We cannot make people popular. We were doing our best to prevent people interfering with those who are unpopular and we did give— and General O'Duffy knows well we did give—our political opponents that full protection—such protection that they objected to it as being more than sufficient. What, then, was the need for a private army? We did not bother much about it. We knew very well it had not anything in it that would make for its continuance. We knew it had no cohesiveness and we knew that inevitably it would fall asunder, and our general policy for keeping the peace was proving effective. But General O'Duffy comes along and says: "We have got to make this something very different from what it was. We have got to use the symbols of Fascism—the symbols used on the Continent—to attract our young people. We have to bring parliamentary institutions into disrepute. We have to state that the only way for the country is to have a one-party movement." In other words, get power by force and when we have got it by force, then, if there is a minority, break every head that opposes us. That is the policy General O'Duffy was holding up before the Party opposite.
Comment on this
Read his original statements. We read them. They were quoted here to-day. It was quite obvious to everybody who read the original interviews when he took over the National Guard what his purpose was. I say it was quite obvious what his purpose was. What was the meaning of the uniform? What was the meaning of the salute? and what was the meaning of the drilling? Of course we are told there is the St. Vincent de Paul Society. They had arms and so had the members of the St. Vincent de Paul Society. The people in this country are not fools and they know that a military organisation is proposed when they have arms at their disposal.
You might talk for a long time about its not being an armed body, but it will not carry any conviction whatever with it. Here you have a nucleus of trained soldiers. They were going to train the youth of the country. They were going to band them together in a military organisation. They got them to disapprove of ordinary representative institutions. They were to be in power, but they never suggested how they were to get into it. Having got into it, they were going to hold it for ten years, and at the end of ten years they would be good enough to allow the people to pass judgment on the system whether it was good or bad. They had arms at their disposal. They were trained. They had a nucleus of already trained soldiers, and young people were to be trained with them. I think it was stated that they denied that they had these arms available to seize power. If we were dealing with a number of people like the Deputy who moved this motion, or the innocent Deputy Dillon, we might have allowed these things to pass and not worry about them, but we were dealing with men who had on a previous occasion brought off a coup, men who had on a previous occasion suppressed representative institutions, who on a previous occasion suppressed the Republican courts, when they were being brought before these courts for assuming power and preventing the Dáil from meeting. We were dealing with people who were involved in a civil war before and who were going about trying to incite another civil war. We would not be fit to be a Government here if we allowed these risks to continue. I will say further, and I will give the Deputy an opportunity of saying that it is true or untrue, that at the time all this was being done information came to us that a Deputy on the opposite benches, a former leader of the Army, a former Minister for Defence and Chief-of-Staff, went over to Glasgow and had in Glasgow a conversation with the British War Minister.
Comment on this
I will ask that any group of Deputies or any group of Irishmen anywhere be brought together by this House to take evidence on what the President now says. I offer that absolutely solemnly and seriously here, and I expect the President who made that charge to see that a tribunal is set up to deal with the matter.
Comment on this
I shall speak in my own way and I will not be dictated to by Deputy Hogan or anybody else. I am delighted more than I can say——
Comment on this
There is no use in engendering heat in the discussion. The President is proceeding to make his speech and Deputies should wait to allow the President to develop his speech in his own way.
Comment on this
I would ask Deputies to leave this matter at this stage between the President and myself. I would ask the President to give me now that assurance that he will set up a tribunal that will examine into this matter.
Comment on this
As I say, I am delighted, because the last thing I wanted to believe was that in circumstances such as ours, such a thing could be done. I say such a report came to me on the occasion, and I mention it to give an opportunity to the Deputy publicly to deny it. I shall give him an opportunity to meet such a tribunal.
Comment on this
I shall set up a body in so far as I am legally able to do it. I do not know at the moment. I told the Deputy that nobody is more anxious to see the particular charge disproved.
Comment on this
There are a certain number of Parties in this House and if the President finds he has any legal difficulty in dealing with this matter, will he set up a committee of one, two or three members of each Party and put the information before them and enable such moneys as will be necessary to be provided to bring any witnesses who may be required?
Comment on this
I certainly say I will do that. I would not make that charge but felt that, in fact, it was my duty to make it having heard these reports.
Comment on this
The one thing we did not want in this country was to have any such position, but knowing the situation that we were dealing with, and having such a report, I was convinced that we should take the most extreme steps, if necessary, to see that no damage could happen to this community. We took these steps reluctantly. We brought that Act reluctantly into operation. It was part of the regular law of the country when we came into office. We suspended portion of it. If it were possible to save the State and provide against possible disorders by any other method, we would have adopted that. It was our duty to use every legal means that were at our disposal to deal with the situation as we saw it. We did that. We have possibly saved bloodshed. We are going to use it to deal with the type of campaign which was foreseen by our predecessors when they put a certain provision into the Act. Why is it, if you were only dealing with Communism or dealing with murder, that you put into this Act as one of the things that constituted an organisation illegal—why did you put into it this question of rates, the refusal to pay rates or other moneys due to the Central Fund? You have it as part of the Act. Why? Because you realised that it was the most dangerous type of attack that could be made on the body politic.
Comment on this
It was preached by no responsible person. Wherever any responsible person spoke, he made it quite clear to everybody that these moneys must be paid.
Comment on this
——that I spoke in public, I urged that, because that was the charge that our opponents were anxious to level against us. Listen to the speeches made during this debate. What were they? They were incitement all the time to these people not to pay. Who is going to tell whether a person is able to pay or not? Is not that what the courts are for? What is the meaning of a conspiracy which intimidates other people who can pay from paying and getting them not to pay? Everybody knows that that campaign would not only bring the whole of the local government system into abeyance but would practically end our society as we understand it.
Comment on this
I have said it at every time. I have listened to Deputies' speeches and some of them have been trying to discourage the Civic Guards at a time when they want all their courage to deal with the situation they have in hand. They are told that the Government will not be behind them. I say this to the Civic Guards, that every man of the Guards who does his duty impartially will be backed by us so long as we are the Government.
Comment on this
General O'Duffy was removed because we could not have the confidence in him that we felt we should have in a man in that position. That is true. We did not wish to do him any injustice, but we were faced with the position that we had either to depend on a man who, we felt, had certain sympathies——
Comment on this
Which were proved afterwards by events. One of the things that a man in that office had to do was to deal on the one hand with illegal activities by the I.R.A., if they were responsible for illegal activities, and, on the other hand, to deal with a similar sort of activity by the A.C.A. and we felt that there would not be impartiality. There would be, at least, a natural bias and because of that we felt it was not right to leave him in that office. Did we propose to victimise him? We did not. Against the strong public opinion of those who voted us in here we brought in a Pension Bill. General O'Duffy was not strictly by law entitled to get a pension—he was removable without any charge stated —but because we wanted to be fair and because we had only a feeling, a natural feeling and a right feeling in the circumstances—and, as I say, a feeling that was proved correct by events afterwards—we thought that it would not be fair to dismiss him and to dismiss him without making some provision for him. Notwithstanding the popularity which the gentlemen opposite want to pretend that General O'Duffy has, we had to face a great deal of odium from our own people for the bringing in of that Bill. We brought it in and the first thing that this guardian of the law does is to try to make the carrying out of the law much more difficult than it had ever been before because it is quite obvious that if you have two bodies and both of them have arms and both are antagonistic and if you let one carry on it will be an incentive to the other to become strong and to build up and if we allowed that to take place we would eventually find ourselves in the same position in which we were before.
Comment on this
We have not encouraged the other. We have tried by a policy of patience to allow a movement built in the past and having its roots in the past to die out. That is a very different thing from dealing with a new organisation that was got up for very new purposes and with new objectives. We tried by patience to bring about a situation in which the young people of the country would see that now they can put forward any policy they wish and can come in here and need accept nothing except the ordinary rule that the majority of the people's elected representatives should decide policy. The result was that the great majority of the young people of the country were supporting that policy and accepting it but our progress in that respect did not please Deputies on the opposite benches. We had here the constant complaint over the last year that we were not doing this, that and the other thing; we were not following the road they wanted us to travel but I say that we had more success in our policy for keeping peace than they had. We have not encouraged anybody. Our whole policy was a policy of peace, a policy of trying to get the differences which had arisen in the civil war period bridged over, if possible, and if it was not possible to bridge them over, as seemed very likely, that the bitternesses would be assuaged. But this new movement, this National Guard, this new Fascist movement, as it was here, was reviving all the old bitternesses and it was our duty to see that progress along those lines did not take place.
We have no apology whatever to offer here. If we were defeated on this motion here, I should certainly go out of office gladly, believing that we had done exactly the thing that a Government should do but I do say that it would be a very grave mistake for the Dáil to defeat the Government on a motion of this sort under such circumstances, and I do not see how any responsible Deputy could vote for it. As I say, the circumstances in the country are difficult. The task of keeping order is going to be increasingly difficult and everyone who opposes us in using the means that were put up at our disposal by our predecessors will make that task still more difficult. When we set up a court we set up the same court as that set up by our predecessors and any member on the opposite side who believes that it was necessary then to endow the Executive with these powers and who now votes against the Executive for putting them into operaiton is clearly convicting himself. He is convicting himself of trying to promote disorder.
The Guards were attacked and we had incitements to those who wanted to believe themselves, or who wanted to adjudge themselves unable to pay rates that they should not pay their rates and meet their obligations. The court has been attacked here. I remember that on a former occasion we would not be permitted to make reference to the court such as were made here.
Consequently, as I say, we face this charge without fears of any kind. As I say, if I were standing here as the head of the Executive and facing the charge that with these instruments at our hands, these methods of maintaining order, we had stoodidly by and allowed a situation to develop which had in it what we believed to be dangers—and not merely did we believe it, but the vast mass of the people believed that these dangers were there—if that parade had been held in Dublin on that day, and if there had been, as a result of that meeting, loss of life or serious injury either to persons or to property, then really we would be open to censure and feel that we had deserved any condemnatory vote that we got from the other side.
Comment on this
I do not want to import any bitterness into this debate, and I do not want to keep the Dáil long. I think I am expressing the point of view of nationalism in this country when I say that the people are getting absolutely disheartened and disillusioned with the present position. I agree with Deputy Morrissey when he says that he is in favour of the Public Safety Act. So am I. I think it is one of the best features in the Constitution. I believe in democracy; I have always believed in democracy. Of course, I know that a country must be up to a certain standard and a certain level before it can run democracy successfully and the real issue here to-day is whether we are fitted for democracy.
Comment on this
I hope that you will. I hope the present Government will. We proved that we were fit for democracy because we established it here. Do not laugh. We established majority rule in this country. There is no doubt about that and no quibbling will get away from it. It is up to you to prove that you are fit for it and that you are good enough for the inheritance which we handed over to you. Remember—and I mean this— that you have the whole nationalist tradition of this country in your keeping. Do not abuse it. I believe in the Public Safety Act. We have universal suffrage in this country and every man and every woman who has reached the age of 21 has the vote. We have Proportional Representation. We have the widest possible franchise and I believe in that. I am not one of those who share the belief that old people only should have the vote. I hear, and we all hear, no matter what Party we are in, statements by people that "it was a pity to give the vote to the flappers and to the young people" and so on. So far as I am concerned, if the young people of this country are not able to run it decently I do not care who runs it. You cannot have any of these expedients. I did believe—I was brought up to believe, and I was born in the tradition of those who believed—that the people were able to run the country decently, young and old, and that they were entitled to the chance of running it. If they are not able to run it, President de Valera can run it, the English can run it, or any other foreigners can run it. I do not care.
If you have that wide franchise, then you must have strong administration. You must have strong administration especially in a country like this which has no tradition in self Government, which has for years been in opposition and which has developed all the weaknesses of a country which has been for years in opposition and for that reason, I am all in favour of the Public Safety Act. I am in favour of the Public Safety Act because I believe in democracy. I was in favour of the Public Safety Act when the Government of which I was a member introduced it, and when the present Labour Party opposed it. I remember well that they opposed it at the time in the name of democracy. They said that they stood for the poor man, for the man without influence, the man without wealth, the man without any of the indirect means that we are all aware of, of influencing a Government. In the interests of free speech, of free thought, if you like free expression of opinion, they were opposed to any such draconian legislation. I thought they were wrong. Deputy Morrissey thought they were wrong, but we both thought that they were sincere. I do not think that any longer. If there is a grain of character in any of you, you know perfectly well that I am telling the truth, that they are not sincere now, if they were sincere then. I do not believe any longer they were sincere. Remember the circumstances under which we brought in the Public Safety Act. I do not want to import any bitterness, but really in this country people ought to tell the truth and should call a spade a spade. Am I not right in saying that the Public Safety Act was introduced to deal with an organisation that was using murder as one of its methods, and which openly gloried in the use of murder? I am not in court now, so that I can talk out my mind straight. Remember that the I.R.A. had an organ, An Phoblacht, which referred to the murders.
Comment on this
I do not mind the Deputy's interruptions. They were straighter than him in the matter. They admitted all the murders and ugly things they carried out, and what is more, Mr. de Valera, as he then was, justified them. Remember the country will never get over that. You justified them. I remember when foul murders were committed in this country you stated that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenny, who was Minister for Justice, was in the same position as Sir Hamar Greenwood. You stated that when you were where I am standing now. These were the words. What did they mean? You justified them, and because you justified them remember this, you have the major responsibility for everything they did.
Comment on this
I will address the Chair. To-day President de Valera has the major responsibility, and he can never shed it, for everything that was done. Years ago in this Dáil I foresaw, as every man with the instincts of government by democracy foresaw, that we would reach the present situation. I said that it did not matter to me whether he was a coming President in this country or not. It did not matter to me whether he got a majority or not, but he would never speak for the Irish people, as he was at the mercy of a group of ruffians, who shouted publicly the word murder louder than any other group. That is the position you are in to-day. It was not you introduced the Public Safety Act. It was your masters. It was not at the behest of the Irish people, but at the behest of the I.R.A. Everyone knows it. Remember this, you will never have a conclusion until everybody in this country says what he thinks. I am sorry to have to talk so bitterly, because I think the situation is getting past us. I think the present position of affairs cannot last, and that this country cannot last, unless we all pull up and take stock of the situation. I do not care who rules in this country. I would like to think that there were men of character on the benches opposite who would get up and speak out, but they are only creatures. I am talking sincerely. Deputy Lemass has brains but no character. I listened to Deputy Flinn. Were you ashamed of him—a parvenu? Were you ashamed of him before the whole world in the present position of this country? Are you ashamed of the position to which you have brought this country, and every honest workingman in it? If not, I am, and so are the people behind us, because we have good Irish blood in our veins. Our fathers before us were Nationalists, and we do not like the English and the foreigners to be proved right when they said that we were not fit for self-government.
What is the position in the country? I agree with President de Valera that it is bad that any section should advocate the non-payment of rates. I do not care who takes charge, but the next Government is going to have a terrible task, an impossible task, and everything that happened not only in our time, when we were the Government, but at present, is going to make it more difficult because of the waste of money. Money is important and is wanted for the poor, for the labourers, for the farmers and for social services. It has been wasted. I would not mind that. We would get over the loss. There are immense resources of wealth in this country. What we will never get over, if the rot is to continue much longer, is the demoralisation that has taken place. That is what we will not get over—the demoralisation. A businessman, a farmer or a shopkeeper may meet with losses or with difficulties, but he will get over them, on one condition, that he retains his courage and self-respect. That is what this country is losing. I know decent men, who now say that they do not intend to pay rates, who never dreamt of saying so before. I know decent men trifling about paying debts. Who started that damnable doctrine but the President of the Executive Council.
Comment on this
I remember when you six lawyers—and God knows you should be proud of them——
Comment on this
I remember when farming was prosperous, when we were endeavouring to make it pay, and as efficient as it should be. When people were well able to pay the annuities, when they were willing to work and to employ labour, when there was an honest, decent tradition in this country you butted in.
Comment on this
The President butted in. With what? "Don't work and don't pay" was the slogan preached for five years, and it was you demoralised the country.
Comment on this
The Deputy has been told that he must not address himself to the President in person. The history of the last ten years has nothing to do with this debate.
Comment on this
I think with great respect that I am dealing with a point that is very relevant. The justification for the introduction of the Public Safety Act now is that there has been a no rates campaign. That is what I am dealing with. That no rates campaign had its roots deep in the past, and if this country is demoralised at the present moment, and if there is a spirit against work and the honest payment of debts, I say the President of the Executive Council alone has the highest responsibility in that respect. It was he made it. This was a rich country in 1924, 1925 and 1926. It was a rich country when Deputies who are now Ministers went around the country in a flippant way, in a garrulous way like Deputy Lemass and Deputy MacEntee—I will not say in a garrulous way of Deputy Aiken, because he is almost incoherent and inarticulate— and they told the people that they were poor, down-trodden, and should not pay, as they were suffering under the grossest tyranny. They discredited democratic rule in order to find excuses for destroying majority rule. When they had done that they had sowed the seeds and we are now reaping the whirlwind. Honestly, if we do not all face up to it, I think this country is in danger. I ask all to try to save it, because it is a situation that will not last much longer.
Putting the Public Safety Act into operation against the National Guard will not solve the problem. Everyone in the country knows that that act was a lie. The typical excuse of the Minister for Industry and Commerce really amounted to this, that General O'Duffy practically established village councils. That is not sufficient justification for the Public Safety Act, even if he did do so. After all, a threat to establish parish councils it not a terrible threat. There is a more serious situation in the country, and I ask the Deputy to pluck up his courage and to remember that loquaciousness and a certain amount of smartness are not going to get the country anywhere. If this country is to get anywhere, the people who run it must have a little bit of character, courage and common honesty. I ask the Minister to remember that when he thinks he is making a great speech and making clever points. That is what he lacks and that is what you all lack on the Front Bench. I know that there are honest men on the back benches of Fianna Fáil. They come from the people. They know, as I know, that the country is in danger at the present moment. They know that this thing cannot last. They know that we are facing bankruptcy. They know that this gross partiality in the administration of the law is only further demoralising the country. There is not, I suppose, any man in the country, no matter how illiterate, who does not feel the contrast. What has happened recently? A member of the United Ireland Party was fired at down in Kerry and there was a man arrested for it. I do not say he was guilty. The man arrested should be charged with attempted murder. Where was he brought? Before a district justice Every day there are, as we read in the paper, men committing the gravest possible offences. They have been brought before district justices while a few unfortunate farmers who, if you like to put it that way, have been demoralised or have been unable to pay their rates are hauled before the Military Tribunal.
So far as we are concerned, we shall obey the law. We made the law. We established majority rule. We hope by obeying the law, even when that law is abused, even when the Administration is guilty of gross abuse of power, we will teach something to the country. I do protest, in that connection, against the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to-night. It was a cheap speech. The principal point he made was that when they put the Public Safety Act into operation the National Guard disappeared. Very well. If it did what is the lesson? It is a tribute to the National Guard and their respect for the law. Do not think they were afraid. They are the men who established majority rule in this country. They are the men who carried through the civil war, who established this Parliament and who did that in spite of guns and of propaganda. They did that and they were not afraid. They obeyed the law on this occasion and I hope they will always teach you to obey the law and that the people of the country will learn something from their action. But you must remember this—you cannot go on with this gross partiality, you cannot have this contrast for any length of time without completely demoralising the country. Everyone sees that in this organisation, the I.R.A., they are free to do as they like. The President makes the point that there has been peace for the last two or three years. I do not think there has but, so far as there has been peace, at what price has it been bought? I came to the conclusion that there has been peace because the President is carrying out any command that comes from this body that calls itself the I.R.A. The Governor-General was removed and the Oath was removed. All these things were done. Who dictated them? Was it these men behind the scenes—these young men without wit, words or worth and of all classes? A lot of them have no national tradition. Were they the people who dictated the present policy of the Executive Council? If they were, it is a terrible state of affairs. That was the reason you had comparative peace in this country. You can always have peace on these terms. But I suggest to the President that he is not responsible to these men. He is responsible to the majority of the Irish people and he has prostituted his high office and he is doing a great disservice to a very great and ancient nation in yielding to that body. In my opinion he has been doing that. What is the present position? He has been feeding them for the past three or four years and the more they get the more they want. The result is that they have got out of hand and are carrying out their policy in spite of him. It was obvious that that would come. It is no consolation to me or to any man of goodwill that it has come—none whatever. It was inevitable and I hope worse will not come. The President can go on with the administration of the Public Safety Act, so far as we are concerned. We regard it as a gross abuse of power. We will always obey the law.
Comment on this
I never encouraged gun carrying except under licence.
Comment on this
I do not think you can. The President, I suppose, was referring to me when he spoke of the possibility of members of the St. Vincent de Paul Society having guns. Certainly— under licence. That is what I meant. You will find in any organisation an odd man who has a gun without a licence. That is inevitable. What counts is the official policy of the organisation—the view put before the organisation by its leaders. There is no doubt, as Deputies opposite must know, that the official policy of the National Guard, as it was, or the Young Ireland Party, as it is now, is a policy of peace, of civilian action, of banning the gun. That is the official policy and that is what counts. Deputy Killilea might be able to give me an example of a fellow who came into that organisation with a gun for his own purposes. That is inevitable, but that will not last long when the leaders have set their face against that sort of thing. That has always been the policy of the National Guard.
Can any Deputy opposite deny this? I have addressed many meetings since 1923. In 1923, we got the votes of 70 per cent. of the electors of this country. Yet, I never got up to address an election meeting in 1923 that there was not a determined attempt to shout me down. I suppose that is the experience of practically every Deputy on these benches. At a time when we had at least 70 per cent. of the country with us, there was a determined and organised attempt to prevent free speech. We lost a certain amount of support as the years went on. We had less than 70 per cent. in 1927 and less still in 1929. But the attempt to prevent free speech got greater. I have had considerable experience in addressing meetings throughout the country and my experience has been that since 1923 there has been a determined attempt to prevent free speech. The National Guard were organised for no other purpose than to try to combat that. The police cannot do it, as Deputies know very well. The police rush in through the crowd to arrest a man and that is enough to disturb the whole meeting. The only way to get free speech in this country is to get a number of young men into an unarmed organisation who will not be intimidated by any bully, whether he has a gun or not. That is the whole object of the National Guard. And that is the organisation that is being banned. Go on and ban it. You will not kill it. It will go ahead. You will be found out. We will obey the law. We have always obeyed the law.
Comment on this
Nobody ought to know better than the Attorney-General that we have obeyed the law.
Comment on this
You have said just now that the National Guard would go on although it is banned.
Comment on this
The movement behind the National Guard will go on. The movement to see that there is free speech in this country will go on in spite of anybody and none of these third-rate quibbles will confuse that point. I do not think any of us is very much concerned about putting this Public Safety Act into operation. We have nothing to fear, we have no secrets. That Act is necessary—keep it there and use it against the people against whom it should be used. But it is a gross abuse of power at the present moment. I think I am expressing the point of view of every decent man when I say that that Act was put into operation not against a military organisation but in order to kill the political opponents of the present President. If there was anyone in this country who was aiming at a dictatorship, at one-Party Government, it was the President. But that hope has now died in his heart—he can give it up. This country will go on in spite of him.
Comment on this
In introducing this motion I said that it was up to the Government to prove that there was a prevalence of serious crime in the country and also to prove that it could not be dealt with by the ordinary law and that if they failed in either of those things there was not the slightest doubt but that the use of the Public Safety Act had been unjust and oppressive. I put it to every fair-minded Deputy in this House, have the Government established either one or the other, that there was a prevalence of serious crime or that the ordinary methods for dealing with crime had been tried and found insufficient? We are now where we were when we started. No serious case has been made for the Government's action. Not one of their speakers has even pretended to establish that they have administered this Act with impartiality. The President has put forward the remarkable view that infinite patience and brotherly love were appropriate to an organisation, which he admits to be of an undesirable kind, because it had been a long time in existence, but that no such patience and brotherly love were to be tried on an organisation that happened to be of more recent date; that no infinite patience or brotherly love was to be shown towards the unfortunate farmers who, if they were guilty of the things the President has suggested they are guilty of, might surely in the circumstances of the case have been treated with very considerable restraint and a very considerable degree of mercy.
I listened carefully to the President's speech and I tried to see what points of substance there really were in it. As far as I can make out, the most that anyone can think he made any show of establishing was that it would have been undesirable to allow that parade to take place in Dublin to which he referred. Supposing that is true. Does that justify him in keeping the Public Safety Act in operation now? Does it justify him in using it in the case of the farmers? Another point he made was that what was so very undesirable about the establishment of the National Guard was that it gave further life and encouragement to the I.R.A. Is that true? I absodutely deny it. I say, on the contrary, and I am speaking from knowledge, that there were parts of the country where young men were being practically forced to go into the I.R.A., that these young men are no longer feeling under that obligation to go into the I.R.A. and that that has been entirely due to the National Guard. I say that definitely and with knowledge. I will say more than that. The President says, and I am prepared to accept his sincerity in saying it, that he regarded the I.R.A. movement as unfortunate and undesirable; that he regarded the members of it as being misled, and that he desired time and brotherly love to cure them of their false theories. That was his attitude. Of how many members of his Party was that the attitude? How many of his Party have welcomed the existence of the I.R.A. and welcomed the existence of those false theories? How many of them are anxious that that organisation should continue and, though they desire them to keep quiet while this Government are in, desire very much that they should not keep quiet if any other Government came in? That was stated plainly in the Seanad by one of the Fianna Fáil leaders there, Senator Comyn, who, in the debate there, said that he hoped the I.R.A. would continue to exist until the day that a Republic was proclaimed in this country.
I also listened attentively to the speech of the Minister for Justice, and I found even less to comment on or to answer in his speech than in the speech of the President. He did say one thing, however, that I want to refer to. He said that I found his speech in the Seanad unsatisfactory and unconvincing and that that obviously was not the case with the people who heard it because the speech had been so convincing that the Senator who introduced the motion there had withdrawn his motion. I have taken the trouble since the Minister for Justice spoke of consulting that Senator as to whether that statement represented the facts and he has assured me that it does not represent the facts; that he did not find the speech of the Minister for Justice convincing and that he only withdrew the motion because his purpose in introducing it had been to get the matter ventilated and that he considered that when it came to an actual vote of censure on the Government, which was what it amounted to, the proper place for such a vote to be taken was the Dáil not the Seanad, and that is the only reason the motion was withdrawn.
The Minister for Justice referred in passing to one incident in Dunboyne, with which I happened to be acquainted, in which he suggested that a leader of the A.C.A. had committed an outrage. It so happens that I know the priest whose servant that boy was and know that he was an uneducated young boy who was acting under a violent sense of personal grievance. The incident has absolutely no significance as having any bearing on the general policy or outlook of the National Guard.
The Labour Party have told us that they came to a decision to vote with the Government on this motion and that they came to it without the slightest hesitation.
Comment on this
Never mind about unanimously. If they came to it without the slightest hesitation, I say more shame to them. I cannot imagine how, if they had any sincerity in them, they could have come to that decision without the slightest hesitation in view of the outrage to all their principles that they have so frequently declared the Public Safety Act to be. I appeal confidently to every fair-minded Deputy in the House to support the motion.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?