Private Deputies' Business. - Relief of Rates on Agricultural Land.
Contributions 1–131 of 268. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move the motion which stands in my name and the names of Deputies O'Higgins and Minch:—
That the Dáil condemns the action of the Government in reducing the total of the grants payable for the relief of rates on agricultural land.
I want to remind the few Deputies on the opposite benches that they cannot always promise and never fulfil. You can fool all the people some of the time but you cannot fool all the people all of the time. The President has got a long innings in fooling a lot of the people, but he is now nearly caged. On the eve of his getting power in a free election by the manhood and womanhood suffrage of the State that he had endeavoured to destroy by force of arms, he made a promise to the people that, if returned to office, he would derate the agricultural land. That was a political contract which was dishonoured the moment the President got power, and still stands dishonoured, to his everlasting discredit and the discredit of the Ministery he presides over. Together with that propaganda, he got into office on the cry "No coercion and release the prisoners." I stand here as a Deputy elected by the independent courageous voters of North City, who were not afraid to vote for me and my colleagues even though they were terrorised by gangs coming out of the election offices of Fianna Fáil in North City. The very act condemned by the President, his colleagues and his whole Party——
Comment on this
We are now travelling a bit from the motion. This is a motion condemning the action of the Government in reducing the total of the grants payable for the relief of rates on agricultural land. We are not discussing any other act of the Government, and we are certainly not discussing the particular act to which the Deputy is referring.
Comment on this
I want to outline the setting in which the Government found themselves and what I might call the gentleman's undertaking they had given the country, the political contract that was sanctioned by the country, on the one part, and President de Valera and the Fianna Fáil Party on the other part, not to increase the burden on agricultural land, but to wipe out that burden altogether. On that political contract the President got elected to power and that political contract he broke. If that were a legal contract the electors of this country would have a cause of action against the President and his Ministry. But there is no legal contract. The people, when they gave their votes, gave all they possessed to designate their citizenship in their native land; handed it over to President de Valera and his Party and handed it over to see it dishonoured since. When the present Government came into power over one and a half years ago they found the grants to agriculture for relief of rates made up of an original grant of about £600,000, which was able to be doubled in 1924 by the previous administration, and in 1931 the previous administration increased that grant by £750,000. At that time, President de Valera and his colleagues were very eloquent in this House and throughout the country in declaring that that was inadequate, that agriculture wanted more help than that. President de Valera at that time moved in this House a resolution that the increase in the agricultural grant should be £1,000,000 at least. The Cosgrave administration gave further relief to the extent of £750,000. That was not acceptable to the farming community. What was the reply of the Cosgrave administration to the dissatisfaction of the farming community and to the query that was raised as to what was going to be done with the produce of the taxation imposed to finance that further agricultural grant? The taxes imposed, speaking from memory —I have not my papers with me, as I had to come here direct from one of the President's coercion courts and I have not all the detailed references that I should like to have in reference to this, but I hope to be able to give them before the close of this debate—included 6d. in the £ on income tax, 4d. on petrol, and a halfpenny, I think, on sugar. I do not know if there was anything else. Anyway, at the time I remember calculating what the produce of this taxation would be for 12 months and it amounted to somewhere between £1,100,000 and £1,200,000 annually. A query was put to the previous administration as to what they were going to do with the profit they were going to make out of this new taxation, out of which they were only earmarking £750,000 for the relief of rates on agricultural land. The reply given was a reasonable one. The agricultural community, who put up the query, were informed by the Executive Council of the day that for the financial year 1931-2 these taxes would not be producing for 12 months, but that they would be producing for a period that would give approximately only £750,000. That was a fairly sound answer. In the following year these taxes were producing for 12 months. President de Valera and his Government inherited the produce of this taxation for 12 months, which amounted to between £1,100,000 and £1,200,000 paid into the Central Fund. But President de Valera did not see fit to have the same mentality as he had the year previously and give to suffering agriculture the relief that he said in 1931 was necessary to keep the life in agriculture. It shows that the President in this matter, as in every other matter that he ever took up, had no regard for the interests of this country but was only playing politics.
Anybody who follows the trend of prices knows that agriculture in this country, and probably all over the world, was more depressed in the beginning of 1932 by many points than it was in the beginning of 1931. Perhaps I would not be overstating the case if I took the President's basis as the proper basis to work upon. From the further depression that came over agriculture in 12 months, assuming that it was absolutely essential to keep agriculture on a certain standard in 1931, assuming that it required relief from the Central Fund to the extent of £1,000,000 to keep up the same standard in 1932, it would require relief to the extent of £1,500,000. The predecessors of the present Government relieved agriculture to the tune of £750,000 out of special taxation from which they had practically no more produce than that. But the President inherited a produce of about £1,200,000 out of that taxation and he gave only £750,000—the previous grant. Then he introduced a sum of £250,000 to be given for the derating of agriculture on farms up to £10 valuation— another vote-catching device of the President. Political propaganda was made out of this—political propaganda that the President had redeemed his promise or his outlook on the agricultural situation of the year before, but he did not make clear to the country and to this House that he had more than that, that he had about £200,000 more than that profit out of the very taxation that the previous Administration had imposed on this country. His colleagues went around the country shedding crocodile tears over the condition of agriculture for the last couple of years. Three years ago the Minister for Education, in long and wordy letters to the Carlow Nationalist, gave the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party on this matter of derating. Because I had another engagement to-day, and had to come direct here from that engagement I have not those letters, but I will be able to quote them before the close of the debate on this motion. If the Minister for Education has to eat his words I hope he will eat them to the accompaniment of more courteous language than he used in writing those letters.
Now we come on a little further in last year, and the President, in effect, said to the country: "Those people who took up the Treaty and worked it let down the farmers of this country by agreeing to pay a tribute of £5,000,000 to England, but we will not pay that tribute any longer." The President is a mathematician. I have been only a student of mathematics; I have never been a professor of mathematics. If the President's knowledge of mathematics is to be measured by the deductions which can be made from his public utterances when he tries to fool the people of this country into believing that under his Administration this tribute, as he calls it, of £5,000,000 to England is not being paid, then the President should go back and start studying rather than professing mathematics. We have all been in the firing-line of agriculture. To use a picturesque phrase of the President himself, we farmers who have been in the front trenches in this economic war are getting nearly tired of it. We have come out of the trenches; we have come over the top; and we are going to advance, not to recede, in spite of the President's Coercion Acts. Let him remember that the day of back-room politics in this country has gone. We are going to defend our rights, our homes, the homes of our children and the homes of our ancestors in this country against any scheming politicians, whether those politicians invoke Coercion Acts or whether they do not. The people of this country are not going to be fooled by professional politicians for ever. The Front Bench is beginning to recognise that the man behind the plough, the man in the factory, the man behind the counter, the man who is working, is the man who is running this country, and that on him the future of this country must depend. If he stops working, the jobs of the professional politicians will become very precarious; but he has not made up his mind to stop working, neither has he nor any self-respecting citizen of this country, in working out their salvation, made any decision or organised any association to disobey the law of this country. We will leave that to those professional politicians who challenged the will of the people in this country and are sufficiently hypocritical now to come out as the champions of the will of the majority— people who never respected the majority in this country, and would not respect it now only that they think they have it for the time being. The majority in this country wanted derating. They were told: "Give us your votes and we will give it to you. We will give you derating"; but they did not get derating when they gave their votes. They got the gall and wormwood so dear to the heart of the President. He may smile, but the honest farmer who wants to pay his way and cannot pay it, and who gets nothing from President de Valera but coercion, cannot smile to-day. He has never drawn a salary out of politics. He has had to work for his living. Those people can smile who have done better in politics than they ever did or were able to do in their professions.
We saw the 1st July coming last year, and we saw a tariff of 20 per cent. put on agricultural produce going into England. The people were told: "Do not sell your stock. This is only a passing thing. We will win." About the month of August our enterprising Minister for Agriculture stated at a public meeting "Not only will we win but we have won." He said that England was crawling to us. Have we won? No, but another 20 per cent. was put on. The people who were told to hold out in the month of July held out to have another 20 per cent. clapped on. Of course we have flippant loud speakers coming in here saying that all the evil forebodings of the Opposition Party have not fructified. A gentleman of leisure who hailed over here from Liverpool can come in and dance around on those benches opposite, and talk lightly of the sufferings of the people of this country, but he will not trust even his little bank account in this country.
Comment on this
I have given the Deputy a great deal of latitude, but I am certainly not going to allow him to indulge in personalities regarding any member of this House, no matter on which side that member sits. Further, I am not going to allow him to traverse the whole ground of the economic war all over again.
Comment on this
Has not the member to whom the Deputy refers frequently indulged in personalities in this House, and not been called upon——
Comment on this
I am sure the Deputy will agree that, even if that member has indulged in personalities, two wrongs do not constitute a right. I am sure he will agree that that Deputy should not have indulged in personalities.
Comment on this
I beg to remind the Leas-Cheann Comhairle that on a certain occasion he referred to——
Comment on this
Is the Deputy alleging that the Chair is not dealing fair play, as it understands it, to every Deputy?
Comment on this
I am suggesting that Deputy Belton was quite in order in referring to a speech made here some days ago, when the Deputy to whom he refers became most personal, abusive and vulgar.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows there is a perfectly well-established way of discussing the ruling of the Chair, if that is desired, but it is not in this ad hoc fashion that I can allow it.
Comment on this
I suggest, sir, that Deputy Anthony might withdraw the statement he made when he said there was one law for one and another law for another with reference to the occupant of the Chair.
Comment on this
I did not hear Deputy Anthony make any such statement. I heard him say that there ought not to be one law for one and another for another.
Comment on this
I was referring to no matter that had not a direct bearing on the economic situation of this country, which situation is predominantly an agricultural situation. In fact, I was not venturing in on the industrial field at all. As you will remember, my starting point was the condition of agriculture in 1931, the measures that the previous administration considered should be taken, having regard to the resources of the country, to help that situation, the measures that the then Opposition, and now the Government of this country for the last year and a half, considered should have been taken in that year, having regard to the resources of the country. I mentioned what the previous administration did and the taxes it imposed. These taxes were not producing for the whole of the year. The next year they would be producing and did produce for the whole of the last financial year. The Central Fund had the benefit of those taxes and, I submit, made a profit out of that taxation of about £200,000 over and above what it agreed to give to agriculture last year, notwithstanding the propaganda that they had increased the grant for relief of rates on agricultural land by £250,000. My line of argument is that you must correlate the amount of grant to the general economic situation. For instance, we could have an economic situation here and get no grant and be better off than if we got complete derating. But I want to move on parallel lines that the economic situation generally was worse last year than the previous year, is still worse this year than last year, and that further depression is further accentuated by the artificial depression produced by the present Government, namely, the economic war. As to the results of that economic war, if we are to accept as approximately accurate 50 per cent. of the case made by the Fianna Fáil Party in 1931, then, agriculture should be eliminated altogether in the present circumstances and conditions from our entire economy. We know that we lost £15,000,000 or £16,000,000 in our export trade—agricultural produce— all that stuff thrown back into this market here and the price in the home market aggregating that amount. In other words, agriculture lost an income of £15,000,000 or £16,000,000. In addition to that, England confiscated out of the agricultural produce that was exported sufficient to pay the annuities and other pensions and local loans that the President and his Ministers are stumping the country and fooling the people about, giving out false propaganda that we will pay these sums no longer.
I will give one instance, and one instance only. There was a very famous sale carried out a few days ago in which six cattle were bought for export for £14, and the purchaser who was provided by the Attorney-General swore in the witness box that he paid England £15 duty to get these six cattle shipped over to England, and he sold them at a good price. It is a good price to get £14 for six cattle here. We ship them over to England and before England will take them at any price she must collect a duty of £15. The President —noted mathematician—has left the House. I should like to know in respect of what England has collected that £15? In respect of what? Is it an ordinary tariff England has put up? No. It is a tariff to get her annuities, her local loans and her pensions amounting to, approximately, £5,000,000. Who is paying them? An unfortunate farmer down the country has to pay for those. The man who bought them on the instructions of the Attorney-General knew what he would have to pay to get them into England before he put a price on them. It is immaterial to him whether he had to pay £15 or whether he had not, but it is not immaterial to the farmer who owned them. Let us look at it in another way. This man swore that 50/- apiece was a great price for year-and-a-half cattle. A year and a-half ago will any man deny that when these were only dropped calves they were worth £3 10s.? That was before the blighting influence of the present Administration was beginning to take effect in this country.
Who rears the calves in this country? The poor unfortunate small farmer who has been fooled by Fianna Fáil propaganda and bribed by grants. Where were these grants found? In the course of this debate we shall find where they were got. During that period under review the farmer was told he should pay his annuities along with his rates. He has paid them or he has accepted responsibility for them. To be more correct, by an Act of this House passed by the Government in order to deceive the farmers, the farmer is made liable for the annuities over that period when the price of farmers' produce was reduced from about £10 to £2 10s., and in that relation proportionately. A number of the farmers who stood on the Fianna Fáil platforms throughout the country and who would not pay their land annuities and rates got the benefit of the funding. A challenge was thrown out to the Government, and nobody dared take up that challenge because nobody would be so foolhardy as to attempt to do so. A challenge was thrown out by a Deputy who is now present, and no attempt was made to deal with that, because the Ministers knew that a counter contradiction would come from every parish in Ireland. They thought it was better to let the hare sit. They have started a hare now that will not sit.
We are proceeding along the line. The punitive tariff is increased, the resources of the country are drying up and we are well into the financial year. That economic war that was won a year ago, according to Deputy Dr. Ryan, Minister for Agriculture, must now be fought out. Anybody who wants to recover the markets is told that he is only like a baby crying out for the moon. Yet we are taxed to provide subsidies to provide that moon or to secure that moon for which we are told we are crying out like babies. Is it not a pity that some Minister opposite would not resign and let the Government co-opt somebody from amongst the agricultural labourers who might know something about the job?
We start off this year and the Land Bill is introduced. Speaking from memory, a sum of something like £2,000,000, that is as legally owed as any private debt, is confiscated. That was money owed to the county councils of this country by the defaulting annuitants. A sum of £250,000 was wiped out by the generosity, prompted by political propaganda, of the Government. We know it is very easy to be generous with other people's money. But it is a very bad principle to adopt, because a contract was signed by the farmers who got their lands purchased.
Never before was the law of contracts broken by any responsible men in this country. The Government broke the law of contracts this year. They saw no difference in the remission of arrears due to the Government under those contracts and the remission of arrears due to rack-renting landlords during the landlord régime. So much for their knowledge. These sums then were lost to the ratepayers. In addition there was another item, the outstanding annuities for last year, which amount to about £2,000,000. That was to be funded over a period of years according to the present Land Bill. The Government claimed that when that money would be paid it would belong to the Central Fund and not to the local authorities to whom it legally belonged. In addition to that, the local authorities were this year informed that the Agricultural Relief of Rates Grant would be cut down by £448,000. Notwithstanding all these increased burdens, general depression, and the deprivation of our markets, our grants were cut down. Moneys due to us by law were taken away from us, and are being taken away from us. The promise of derating has been dishonoured. Then we come along a little further. We find that the other string to the Fianna Fáil Party, when seeking office, was their abhorrence of coercion. That was used, together with the German No. 2 plot, to further impoverish agriculture and to destroy the agricultural industry in this country.
Comment on this
Well, if you, sir, will allow me to develop it, I think I will be able to correlate the two.
Comment on this
I have allowed the Deputy to go very far, but surely he cannot see any relevancy between a Coercion Act and this matter of £448,000 that he is bringing in.
Comment on this
There was a vacuum created in local finance because of this reduction in the grant. That £448,000 must be felt by the people from whom that grant has been withdrawn. It must be felt by the people who have been deprived of the ownership of the moneys due to them. That deprivation has been brought about by the provisions of the Land Bill. And that sum is to be made good by the people deprived of their markets. It is to be made good by the people whose produce has been reduced by more than 50 per cent. in value. If that vacuum is to be made good it must be made good by the people. The Government, instead of dealing equitably and according to their promises with such ratepayers, now see fit to invent a German plot and use a Coercion Act so as to make the people fill that vacuum. Does not that correlate this matter with the Coercion Act?
Comment on this
It certainly does not, and the Deputy knows that. A certain Act was passed by this House, and it has been used by the Government. That Act is beyond the discussion of the House while we are dealing with this motion.
Comment on this
I am not discussing the Act. I am discussing the application of the Act to a matter that is, I submit, very closely related to, and is part of, the motion I am now discussing. The Act is beyond discussion. It was an Act before I came into this House, and I have no intention of discussing it. I am discussing the misapplication of this Act.
Comment on this
Of course the Minister for Finance always sees that a matter that hits him and his administration directly between the eyes has nothing to do with whatever is under discussion. People, through all the agencies I have outlined, have been reduced to the poverty line. Taxation to pay the British, that was there before those payments were withheld, is still functioning. The land annuities have to be paid. Last year they went into a special fund that normally would have gone to liquidate that debt to England by the direct method—words that are very familiar to my ears after the last few days. By the direct method they would be paid to England, but under the present administration for the last year-and-a-half the Central Fund responsibility has been cut out and the general taxpayer has been cut out and, by the indirect method, the farmer is forced to pay to England. For every pound he had to pay by the indirect method the Government secured a pound in the Suspense Account, and when the debt for the year was liquidated to England by the agricultural producers here, morally and equitably that Suspense Account belonged to the farmers, because they had paid the debt.
Did the Government listen to equity and morality? No. It confiscated the money, and stated that the people would not pay, but that they would make them pay. We had that statement after the people had already paid twice. The members of the Government are trying to convince the public that people who have been robbed on all sides in the manner I have outlined do not want to pay and will not pay. I will not mention the methods they are using. There are a lot of appeals thrown out for unity and co-operation in this country. There never was a time when there was as much need for the unity and co-operation of all political parties and all sections of the Irish people as at the present time. No man can travel this country and say honestly that it is not on the edge of a precipice. There is not a producing industry carrying on on its own resources in this country economically sound. The greatest industry of all has to pay three times as much now as when the present Administration came in. Its income is hardly one-third of what it was when this Administration took over.
This motion is far from being comprehensive enough to meet the existing situation, but it meets a portion of that situation which cannot be explained away by any camouflage. This motion condemns the Government for not giving to agriculture in the current year the same treatment that it gave it last year. It is not giving it the same treatment when agricultural wholesale prices the world over are much below what they were in 1931. On top of all that, agricultural prices in this country are further depressed to the extent of 40 per cent. by reason of the actions of this Government.
Let us turn to the employees in agriculture. We find that the agricultural employer, by reason of legislation such as is going through the House now, will have to pay twice the amount he used to pay for national health insurance. The employees also have to pay roughly twice the amount for national health insurance. All the overhead charges in the case of agriculture are going up and the income is dwindling to vanishing point.
I do not know if newspaper reports are reliable regarding political alliances, but I do appeal to the Labour Party, in connection with this motion to remember that in this House they must be free, if they are to be honest to their constituents, to vote as they think best, regardless of any commitments they may have with the Government Party. I am not saying that they have any commitments, but the Labour Party represent, above all others, the agricultural workers and the small farmers, and this is a motion which vitally interests them. The big centres in the Free State, what you might call the industrial centres, have sent no Labour Deputy here. If Labour Deputies in the House are going to forget their constituents, then the sooner they take off the Party label and put up whatever label is more appropriate, the better. I am sorry the leader of the Labour Party is not here. I am sure that there is no industry in Kildare, excepting the agricultural industry, that could elect a Labour Deputy. There have been some mushroom industries started there, but I do not think that the extent to which they have developed would be a sufficient prop for Deputy Norton to lean on and disregard the agricultural workers in Kildare.
The promises that the Government Party made the country were many times better than this. The economic war was to be settled if they were returned, while the derating of agriculture was one of the principal planks in their platform. Neither has taken place. What did exist a year ago does not exist now, and the substance of this motion is a return to the status quo of last year. It would be an impertinence on my part—I am supposed to be impertinent— to direct the attention of Labour Deputies to the elements of economics, but they know that charges on, and relief of industry travel up and down the line. They know that the results of increasing the burden on agriculture and diminishing the return from it will fall first, and most heavily, on the people they represent, the people without whom there would not be a Labour Deputy in this House. Now, if by political alliances the Labour Party is going to neglect the interests of their constituents, then it will take a lot more than the new unit of specials to prevent the people from hearing the truth about the Government Party and their allies in the coming months. To the Government Party and to the employing farmers in that party who know the conditions of agriculture, I would say this: remember that in voting against this motion you are voting against the undertaking that was signed, sealed and delivered in an honourable way at the last election between you and your farming constituents. You promised them full derating and a settlement of the economic war. Candidates of the Government Party, when appealing for the agricultural vote at the last general election, never hinted or suggested that the status quo would not remain. Now not only have you repudiated the promises you made at the last general election, but the status quo has been repudiated in this one respect. I appeal to Deputies opposite who represent agricultural constituencies, to Deputies who would not be sitting here if they were not able to pitch a plausible tale to the farmers of the country, to see that the status quo is restored. The status quo in this one respect is all that this motion asks.
Deputies opposite who are working farmers know that there is no man as hard hit at present as the working farmer. They supported a Bill that was passed here recently. I may say, in passing, in connection with that Bill that the Government had not the full support of their own Party for it. Under it, it was proposed to reduce salaries by something like 5 per cent. or 10 per cent., but all the members of the Government Party did not support it. Some sat on the fence and would not support it. Propaganda, or tomfoolery, was made with the phrase that the farmer could not remain in the front line trenches if the other fellow did not pay up something. If that is the principle that we are going to work on, then the Government is only playing with the situation. If everybody is to fall into step with the farmer and his workers, then it is not a 5 per cent. cut but a 40 per cent. cut that should be looked for.
Comment on this
So far as I was concerned, the amendment meant no cut, and I stand by that, because I take a longer view of economics than the halfpenny view. If we are going to be a self-contained economic unit in this country, then we can only be that by keeping up the purchasing power of the masses of the people. If we are going to cut down wages and salaries we are going to lose in the prices we get for our produce, and our last stage will be much worse than our first, because any obligations that we have now when the standard is high will become unbearable if the standard is lowered. If farmers on the opposite benches think they are going to improve the farming situation by lowering the standard of other people, then they are simply going to cut the farmer's throat and going to drive this country headlong into bankruptcy. Instead of farmers opposite proposing to reduce others to the poverty line in which we ourselves are, let them take a step forward now, not to reduce the standard of the non-agricultural population, but to raise the standard of the agricultural population. That, in essence, is this motion. Its purpose is to leave the agricultural community in as good a position as the present Dáil found it in last February. That is the essence of this motion, though it falls very far short of even 1 per cent. of the promises held out by the present Government Party at the last election.
The motion is not comprehensive enough to deal with the whole economic situation. It is not even comprehensive enough to deal with a tithe of the promises held out by the politicians opposite when they last consulted the electorate and on foot of which they got elected. When they reduced this sum last March they had no answer to give for their action but one: "We went before the country, they elected us, and we are speaking for a majority of the people." I venture to say there is not a Deputy opposite who, if he were to go before any agricultural constituency at the present time, would succeed in getting his money back on the policy that the Government have pursued since the last general election. Not one, and if there is a single Deputy who thinks that he would succeed on that policy I challenge him to a contest in any agricultural constituency in the Free State. Even the Deputy who has spoken—let him give in his resignation to the Ceann Comhairle and I shall give in mine and fight him in any agricultural constituency upon that issue. Deputies opposite know in their hearts that they have fooled the agricultural people of this country. It is a pity the Deputies opposite would not take a course of reading John Mitchel's small History of Ireland since the Siege of Limerick. There they would read from the stinging pen of Mitchel the efforts that were made to reduce the agricultural population of this country to professional pauperism. That is what this Government is doing—reducing this once flourishing industry to one of professional pauperism. If there is any Deputy opposite who is prepared to stand before his constituency as a candidate in support of the administration of the Party opposite, I am ready to stand against him. Let him hand in his resignation now, and I will give in my resignation, and face him in the by-election in any constituency in this State on the question of the Government's agricultural policy. We want no sham threats about organisations disobeying the law, or wanting to break the law, or about mysterious organisations that will not meet their responsibilities.
Every honest man in this country wants to meet his responsibilities. If there are dishonest men who do not want to meet their responsibilities they should be made to meet them. The first responsibility for the economic life in the country depends upon the Government, and no agent in this country has done more to kill economic life in the country than the present Administration. They try to cajole the people by telling them that England is responsible. England is not responsible. The Government opposite are responsible. They preach the lying doctrine that the man who tells the truth in this country is playing the English game. When the people want to come into the open and tell the truth, what are they met with? They are met by an army of thugs who try to break up their meetings because they are afraid of the truth. There is something wrong with any Government that will tolerate gangs going round to political meetings to break them up. There is something that Government wants to hide. They should have nothing to hide. As the custodians of law and order, they should use their power in the interests of all. They do not want law and order because they do not want the people told about the cajolery and lying preached by the present Government. Now we have the truth out. If there is any man opposite who has pluck enough to face an agricultural constituency upon the issue of the agricultural policy of the present Government, or want of agricultural policy, or destruction of agricultural policy by the present Government, I shall face him in that constituency.
This motion that I am moving to-night has been on the Paper for the last four months, but the trickery of the Government deprived us of private members' time in which to move this motion until it is almost out of date. We cannot recover this money now. This money is now being earmarked for another purpose. It may bring pauper relief to the unfortunate workers of this country who should be working in productive employment. But there is no productive employment because, as I mentioned before, there is no productive industry that is economically sound. There is no purchasing power in agriculture. This would not appreciably improve the position of agriculture but it is one of the steps forward, retracing steps backward that the present Government has taken. That is the way the Government has dishonoured their contract with the people. This motion asks this House now to endorse what in effect is a censure of the Government, not so much for any particular line of policy as for having broken their promises to the electorate and the people who sent them in here. It is timely when the muddy waters are being stirred up and the lying propaganda is used that the farmers of this country want to evade their responsibilities—it is time to let it go forth that this House will no longer give confidence to a Government that has forgotten its promises to the people, and a contract entered into six or seven months ago, and takes away the advantages that the people had before that promise was given them, and before the world depression and the artificial depression produced by the present Administration. I am not in a position to go into the details of the situation, but I appeal to Deputies on all sides to remember that we are up against a terribly dangerous situation at the present time. Even if we forget what it is that caused that situation, even if we never uttered a word of blame to anybody responsible for the situation, we cannot close our eyes to the fact that this country is up against a situation never experienced before, and that to save the country from bankruptcy it will take every man and every woman to come in and work together and push in one direction. If they do not push in one direction, but keep pushing in an opposite direction, nothing short of a miracle can save this country from bankruptcy and ruin. Let us forget the cause that produced that terrible situation and give a vote expressive of our conception of that situation when the time comes to remedy it.
Agriculture is the parent of industry. It was described by a great European statesman as the mother of the nation's wealth that industry employs. The talk about the twopenny-halfpenny industries in little backyards, that you would require a microscope to see, which are subsidised by agriculture, is absurd. Why not turn to agriculture? Take a step in that direction and there you will have a new orientation of policy as a gesture in the right direction, as a corrective which by co-operation and goodwill, not by false accusations from a Government Department and not by the application of coercion, will save this country from bankruptcy and ruin. The way that the Government is travelling is the way to create disunity. That is the way to lead to bankruptcy. This motion which I ask the House to adopt is a gesture in the direction of unity and the co-operation of all classes and creeds to save this country from ruin before it is too late.
Comment on this
If one did not know Deputy Belton and had not previous experience of him, his earnest manner would deceive one that he was really earnest. Deputy Belton has brought any amount of simulated heat into this proposal, just the very same as Deputy Belton's Party and his allies have gone round the country during the last 12 months endeavouring by every possible means in their power to give all the support they could to those who are fighting this war against the Irish nation. We have been accused here that we were in favour of derating. We were absolutely, but we profited by experience. When the £750,000 in the relief of rates was corkscrewed out of the last Executive Council here by me, I watched the result very closely. I found that one old rack-renting landlord in my parish got just three times as much relief as the balance of the farmers of that parish put together. That old rack-renting landlord got more of that £750,000 than the two parishes combined in which he lived. That is the system that Deputy Belton and those associated with him want to continue. That is whom they represent, the gentleman with the 1,200 acres who will not pay his rates. Despite all the assertions made by Deputies opposite, no less than seven separate resolutions were passed by meetings of the Centre Party in my constituency in the last six months refusing to pay rates and calling on the people to refuse to pay rates. What are the facts? I discussed this matter in another place. I discussed it within our Party ranks as to which would be better for the farmers of this country—complete derating or the 50 per cent. reduction in annuities and I plumped for the 50 per cent. reduction in the annuities. I knew the farmers and I counted up the loss to the farmers by the reduction in the agricultural grant and that paltry reduction was completely wiped out. In Cork County in 1931-32 we got something less than £241,908 in relief of rates. In 1932-33 we got £265,769. In 1933-34, that is this year, we will get £209,306. In other words, we lose in Cork County by the reduction of the agricultural grant £56,203, whereas the 50 per cent. reduction in the annuities in Cork County will mean £223,613.
Comment on this
What have the farmers lost as a result of your policy? What are they getting for their dropped calves and cattle?
Comment on this
That is the position. Cork lost £56,000 by the reduction in the Agricultural Grant and by the reduction of 50 per cent. in the annuities they gained £223,000. These are the facts, facts which Deputies opposite do not like very well. Then in addition to that we are spending £250,000 on labourers' cottages, of which the Government is guaranteeing 60 per cent. That is £150,000 provided for houses for labourers about whom Deputy Belton was talking, labourers whom members of the Centre Party cut 4/- or 5/- per week in their wages, when they found the result of the last election. These are the stubborn facts. These unfortunate labourers had to wait for ten years without these houses. They were charged 6/- a week by farmers for houses with two rooms, houses in which the rain poured down on top of them morning, noon and night.
The last Executive Council were there for ten years. They had not Deputy Belton's support for the ten years, I admit, but Deputy Belton supported them at the last election. These labourers would still be without their labourers' cottages were it not that this year this Government is providing 60 per cent. of the loan charges, a sum of £150,000 set aside for the building of these cottages in Cork County. Let us see what this howling is about. We lose £56,203 and we gain £223,613 by the reduction of 50 per cent. in the annuities. We gain £150,000 in the 60 per cent. cost of the labourers' cottage scheme for the county. These are facts. Was there ever anything so ridiculous as hearing these people coming in here and howling, or howling at the cross-roads, howling about things that they know are false and misleading? Honesty! Honesty from that gang! Deputy O'Leary was anxious to know what the loss on cattle was. I will give it to him. I gave it to him here the other night. I should like Deputies to consider facts and look them in the face. I am speaking here as a working farmer, as a farmer who had to earn his living all his lifetime. I had to work from 12 years of age and I had no other living. I had to pay rates and annuities during the period when these gentlemen under their Coercion Acts kept me in jail and I paid them. Take the case of the ordinary farmer in the country. I am not concerned with the 1,200-acre gentleman who will not pay his rates and who comes howling up around this part of the world, nor am I concerned with any one of these other ranchers who are endeavouring to use the ordinary small farmer as a smokescreen to defeat the Government that has been elected by the majority of the Irish people. For six months of last year we had them howling at every crossroads. We took them to the country and the country gave the people opposite their answer and if we turned them out again in the morning there would be very little howling left in them and well they know it. I went down to my people in 1931 and I got something like 5,000 votes. With this economic war in full belt, and with this 40 per cent. on, I got 11,000 votes. That is the people's answer to your howling—a groaning, moaning, miserable gang and there is not a farmer amongst them.
Comment on this
I withdraw. Take the ordinary small farmer in this country at present, examine his position, and see how he would stand if Deputy Hogan, the greatest Minister for Agriculture who ever lived, were still here dealing with him. Would he be as well off, or would he be still in the land of milk and honey, of which they were talking for ten years? I will take the 40-acre farmer and examine his position. He would have, in livestock, 6 cows, 6 calves, 6 sheep, and a pair of horses. His tillage on his farm would be an acre and a half of potatoes, an acre of turnips, and an acre of mangolds. He would have 4½ acres lea ground which he would set in oats, and 2½ acres, in addition to his potatoes and mangolds, which he would set in wheat, and 2 acres of barley. He was told that wheat would not grow in this country and that he would rob himself by trying to grow it. Let us examine his position and compare it with what his position would be under the benevolent administration of the greatest Minister for Agriculture who ever lived and his position under Fianna Fáil to-day. I am not going to say that he is a millionaire, nor am I going to say that he is even well off, but I am going to say this, that he is a hanged sight better off than he would be if he were still under the lash of the gentleman who lashed him without mercy for ten years. Take, first of all, the amount that man would lose. On his six calves, he would pay 50/- apiece if he sent them to the English market.
Comment on this
We say that the farmer is getting a bounty, and the farmer says he is not getting it. The Deputy represents the man who must be getting it.
Comment on this
That farmer would pay 50/- apiece on his six calves. That is, he would lose £15 by the economic war, so far as these calves are concerned. His ten sheep would have, say, 16 lambs, and sending these to the English market he would pay 12/- apiece and would lose £9 12s. I have not got the amount made up here that he would lose by this reduction in the rates, but I will not be a minute making it up. It represents just 1/2 in the £ in Cork County, and even if we said that he lost 2/6 on his £20 valuation, he would lose 50/-. He would thus lose altogether £27 2s.
Comment on this
He would lose altogether £27 2s. granting that the Deputy, who interrupted a moment ago, puts the cattle bounty into his pocket.
Comment on this
Now we will take the other side of the picture. What would be the average milk yield of this farmer's six cows? Some of them might give 800 and some might give 400—we will take 500 as the average. That would be 3,000 gallons of milk, and if the greatest Minister for Agriculture who ever lived were sitting on these benches that farmer would be getting less than 2d. per gallon for that milk, and I defy Deputies opposite to deny that. I challenge them to deny it and to prove their denial here. Twopence a gallon would be the price of that milk if that greatest Minister for Agriculture were sitting on these benches.
Comment on this
The present price is 4d. I do not say that he is going to be a millionaire as a result of it, but it represents 2d. a gallon more than he would get if Deputies opposite were in office.
Comment on this
The average price of creamery butter in the English market during the last 12 months would not amount to 70/- a cwt.
Comment on this
70/- a cwt. was the price of best Irish creamery butter in the English market during the last 12 months. That would work out at 2d. per gallon, and when the Butter Prices (Stabilisation) Bill was brought in here, Deputy Hogan got up and said: "I had that 12 months ago and I threw it out," and he went into the lobby and voted against it, followed by as many Deputies as he could delude into following him. That Bill raised the price of that butter for that farmer from 70/- to 133/- to 136/-, and that farmer to-day is getting 4d. per gallon for his milk. That represents a 2d. per gallon gain on every gallon of milk he produces at present. That is £25 a year on the milk of his six cows, giving 3,000 gallons of milk, and a farmer with cows that do not give 500 gallons of milk does not deserve to have them. He gains £25 by having a Minister for Agriculture here who knows what the farmer wants and gives it to him.
Now we will go a step further. That farmer, if he took our advice, grew two and a half acres of wheat. On the last occasion on which I grew wheat under Deputy Hogan's benevolent administration, I got £6 a ton from Messrs. Furlong in Cork for it—the world market price. The world price of wheat, delivered at Cork Quay to-day, is £5 12s. 6d. Take it at even £6 and with a guaranteed price of £9 10s. to that farmer, on his two and a half acres of wheat he would have two and a half tons and that means that that farmer gains £8 15s. on his wheat alone. We will next take barley. On his two acres of barley he would get the British market price, and best malting barley in the English market to-day is hanging around 10/6 a barrel while the price here is 15/6. That is, he gains 5/- a barrel on 20 barrels of barley, out of two acres. That makes £5 more. On his annuity of £20 he gets a reduction of £10 By having a Fianna Fáil Administration in office that farmer gained £48 15s. against the £27 2s. he lost. Economic war and all, that is the position after giving the benefit of every doubt and of every howl. I am not saying that the farmer is well off; I am not saying that he is a millionaire; I am not even saying that he is able to pay his way.
Comment on this
I will say this much, that he is far better off under Fianna Fáil than he was under Cumann na nGaedheal. These are the facts, and facts are stubborn things. I challenge any Deputy on the opposite benches to deny these figures. That farmer is £21 13s. 4d. better off now, tariff war and all, than he would be if Cumann na nGaedheal were in office. That is the case of a small farmer with 40 acres of land. We had moaning and wailing from the benches opposite and in the country. You would think the poor fellows were going to die. They did not die. As a matter of fact, I remember at the election that the leader of the Farmers' Party in this House—and I am proud to see that he remains the leader of the Farmers' Party—was crippled with rheumatics. The other day I saw where that Deputy challenged the Minister for Defence to a competition over hurdles. If that was the effect on farming and on their health I think the Opposition should be delighted. There should be no more moaning. At the last election that Deputy was crippled with rheumatics, but now he is able to challenge the Minister over the hurdles, and even to swim the Liffey.
Comment on this
The way he has worked has made them supple. I heard these moans all over my constituency at the election. One of the principal agents of the Centre Party kicked up the dickens of a row and stated that if this Government were returned again he would sell out. He was a big pig feeder, having 800 or 900 pigs and employing four or five fellows. "If that Government is returned I will clear out," he declared. "I will take my business across to England and avoid the 40 per cent. that I have to pay now for conveying them over, after rearing and feeding." He tried the experiment. He sacked the five men he employed at Glanmire, and went over. He remained three months and then came back to rear pigs under Fianna Fáil. He wrote to the Press complaining because he was made feed the pigs with Irish grain. When he was across the Channel he could feed them on grain that came from China or from Timbuctoo, and he had the 40 per cent. that he has to pay now for sending them over. He is back now and is rearing pigs and paying the 40 per cent. That is an honest example of a man who tried the experiment. What happened?
Comment on this
God knows there are not many who would say so. If the Deputy heard the story they told me about him down there——
Comment on this
I know that some Deputies will get up to complain. I am giving an example of a pig feeder who tried to experiment. I will tell a joke about another one.
Comment on this
Another pig feeder. He goes by the name of Buckworth down in Cork. He wrote to the newspapers complaining about the admixture scheme. Within the past two months, when a deputation of the Tobacco Growers' Association waited on that gentleman, to get a portion of an old store he was using in connection with the pig feeding industry, what did he say? His answer was: "I cannot spare it. I am feeding 800 pigs. During the last 12 months I made £2,000 profit on pigs." That is another of the bucks who signed with the ex-soldiers and the secretary of the Farmers' Union in Cork, complaining about being compelled to feed Irish grain to pigs. The House can just imagine the campaign of humbug that is being carried on throughout the country by these gentlemen. On this motion I want to impress upon the House that while Cork County lost £56,000 this year, owing to a reduction in the agricultural grant, against that it got a 50 per cent. reduction in annuities amounting to £223,000 or four times the first figures in addition to getting another £150,000 for assistance. Deputy Belton and the other propagandists can count that up when preaching their doctrine, or otherwise let them stay at home and let the Dáil do some work.
Comment on this
I was delighted to hear from Deputy Corry that the farmers in Cork are really wallowing in prosperity. It was the first cheerful note struck here for a long time. I am delighted to know that a representative Deputy, who claims to have such immense support in Cork, could come up to the capital and tell us that in fact the farmers of Cork were never so prosperous.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I have been misrepresented by Deputy O'Higgins. I did not say that the farmers in Cork were wallowing in prosperity. I said they were not millionaires. I said that I would not say they were well off; that I would not say they are able to pay their way. I said they are better off anyway than when their gang was here.
Comment on this
Half-hearted retractions are getting fashionable in that corner. I submit to the Dáil that I am giving a fairly accurate and reasonable interpretation of the story that Deputy Corry narrated for us. I submit that what he wanted to portray to the Dáil was the prosperity of the Cork farmer under a Fianna Fáil Administration. What came into my mind when Deputy Corry was speaking was which of them—the Minister for Agriculture of Deputy Corry—is honest or which of them is the rogue; which of them knows the most about the position of the Cork farmers. I have a distinct recollection of reading quite recently the report of a speech by the Minister for Agriculture, delivered in the midst of these prosperous Cork farmers, delivered in the very midst of these farmers who are making easy money, according to Deputy Corry. What was the tune the Minister piped that day? Was it one of elation, was it one of prosperity? Did he point out to them the fortunes they are making under the Fianna Fáil Government? He was up against them. He was not talking to a group of people here in Dublin, 150 miles away. Face to face with these prosperous farmers, these people making easy money, what was the tune the Minister piped? "I sympathise with you. You are going through it, but you are sticking it well. Hold on. Better times are coming. A little pat of butter here and a few eggs there— that is the way we will get on." There was no victory dance on that particular platform. Face to face with the farmers that Deputy Corry tells us are wallowing in prosperity, it was one even note of sympathy——
Comment on this
The Deputy has stated that he is merely interpreting Deputy Corry's speech; he is not quoting it. He is entitled to do that.
Comment on this
Prosperity is making the Deputy unduly susceptible. He used not to be so very thin in the skin. I should advise the Deputy, in spite of the prosperity and in spite of the easy money, to keep on working hard, as he told us he was doing at 12 years of age, so as to keep the skin hard. Then he will not be so thin-skinned. I wonder who is correct—the Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Corry or the farmers themselves. If there is all this prosperity in County Cork under a Fianna Fáil Administration, if they are so vastly better off under a Fianna Fáil Government—in deference to the wishes of Deputy Corry we shall keep away from the word "prosperity"— than ever they were, I wonder why the county council had such reluctance to striking a rate this year to make provision for the public services of County Cork. I wonder why the legal machinery which certain individuals had such a contempt for a few years ago had got to be invoked. Was it all roguery, or was it that the people found difficulty in paying? What we have got to face up against in dealing with this motion is whether or not it was fair or honest or just to reduce the grant in relief of agricultural rates this year. The responsibility of the people opposite is to justify in this year the reduction of the grant towards the relief of agricultural rates, to show that the position is so much changed that the people are better able to pay more rates this year than they did in previous years. Deputy Corry started out to make that case because it is the only reply that can be made to this motion. When the case he endeavoured to make got an ordinary, every-day, honest interpretation, we had a withdrawal, a recantation, a denial of the obvious interpretation, a running-away from the whole case. It is about time something coming from those benches was stood over by somebody. You cannot catch a centipede on the wrong foot. We are dealing with a lot of political centipedes and no sooner do you think that they are on one foot than you find that they are on one of the other 99. A little straightforwardness and less shiftiness is what is wanted in public administration and it is what is wanted in the Parliament of this country. Go your course, wrong or right, but, wrong or right, stand over the course you go. Do not be ashamed of it; do not apologise for it but, above all, do not run away from it. We have this action by the Government, reducing by a sum of half a million pounds the grant in relief of agricultural rates, and the responsibility is on the Government to show why this particular year was selected for reducing that grant, to show that that grant was required to a less degree this year than in previous years or, alternatively, to show that the farmers were better able to pay increased rates this year than in other years. That is the only way the motion can be met. That case has got to be made or that policy embarked upon by the Government is wrong.
I hold that the particular action of the Government in reducing this grant has had many disastrous consequences. I regard the whole thing as a tombstone erected on so many broken promises—promises given in a public way by public men with great responsibilities. I think that this is rather unsafe, that reckless breaking of promises sets a bad headline inside the country. It is a bad headline from people in big positions to others. This disregard of the word given, of the promise made, is one of the serious consequences of this particular action. Another is the acute financial distress which has prevailed throughout every county in this State—banks refusing any further overdrafts, officials and officers working without pay, public services, in some cases, on the verge of financial collapse and secretaries and others responsible telling anybody concerned—and I am certain reporting to the Government Department concerned—that they cannot see their way around the next two months. That is another result of this particular Government action. Then we have another result—a tendency on the part of people not to pay. I am not referring to the people who cannot pay, but we hear from the benches opposite that there is a tendency on the part of some who could pay not to pay. All that is attributable to one thing—the amount of political trickery and shiftiness which is associated with this particular act.
Comment on this
"Hear, hear," says the Minister. If he says that in five minutes time, I shall echo it.
Comment on this
Let us have the particular atmosphere and association of this. When was the grant reduced? Was notice given? The Minister "hear, hears" from the Government Bench but he is quite doleful when down in Skibbereen.
Comment on this
Was notice of this reduction given in January? Was it given at the time that you were seeking votes? Was it given at the time when you were making your promises? Was it given at the time when you told the public you had your plans made? Was there any hint, any suggestion, that you intended to reduce the agricultural grant? Was there any hint of that even last January, or even in February when the county councils were, one by one, preparing their estimates, arriving at their financial commitments for the year, and arriving at these estimates with the knowledge and belief that the fund that had flowed to them the previous year would flow to them again? Even then, was there any hint, was there any open honesty on the part of the Government? Those men, voluntary workers, county councillors in every county up and down the country, made their plans, examined their estimated expenditure for the year, and, as soon as they were shackled by the law to embark on that particular expenditure, then and then only were they notified that half a million pounds was going to be withdrawn. I do not hear any "hear, hear" now. Is there anybody that will applaud that particular course? It is not so much the financial result, it is the unmanliness of the whole thing that is really contemptible and really deplorable. It is that unmanly way of doing the thing, even if it has to be done, doing it in a crooked, secret way, that is deplorable. Mind you, it is becoming a characteristic Government action. One of the direct results of that is the difficulty of getting in rates —the difficulty that we hear so much about. People are brought before the Military Tribunal, allegations and suggestions made from political platforms that there is a conspiracy not to pay rates. The only evidence that is before the country is open evidence of a conspiracy to cod the ratepayers, a conspiracy to cod those responsible for striking the rates. There is no getting away from that. The dates are there. The method in which it was done and the time when it was done are all there. The actions and protests of the various county councils are all on record and the result is all round us to-day.
As I said in the beginning, if a Government reduces the grant in relief of agriculture there is a responsibility on that Government to show, either that the occasion for such a big grant has passed, or that agriculture is more profitable and that a higher rate can be paid. If that case is made, well and good. But, what is the particular year, and what is the particular set of circumstances in which the Government reduce this agricultural grant? We have a situation existing in this country generally referred to by Fianna Fáil politicians as an economic war. The name, of course, is dishonest—absolutely untrue. The picture it is meant to convey of courageous troops marching to battle is humbug and dishonesty to rally the supporters who are falling away in order to be able to shout "traitor" to those who oppose them. Economic war; one country, we suppose, endeavouring to starve the other country into submission; and the unfortunate taxpayers outside all providing bounties in order that more and more cattle can go over to feed John Bull and enable the British Chancellor of the Exchequer to collect the annuities. Tariffs imposed minute by minute, hour by hour, on this side of the water; tariffs on every commodity coming in from Great Britain. The tragedy of the whole thing and the humbug of the whole thing is that the taxes imposed by Great Britain on Irish produce landed in Great Britain are paid by the Irish people and the taxes imposed by this Government on British produce landed at Irish ports is again paid by the Irish people. I put this to the heroes opposite, who must be in some kind of a war atmosphere in order to survive at all politically; I put this to these economic soldiers: supposing things were the other way; supposing the particular phase of this economic war was that John Bull was paying all the taxes on English goods landed at Irish ports and that John Bull was paying all the taxes on Irish goods landed at English ports, then we would have something to cock out our little chests about. Then we would have achieved something; we would have done something for the people of the country, beyond indulging in humbug, codding the county councils, codding the taxpayers, and, in the long run, codding ourselves. Because, mind you, if you live long enough in that kind of false atmosphere, if you continually give out this false stuff, you will begin to believe it yourselves after a while. The results are serious enough at this particular point; continue, and the results may be so serious that the country cannot be retrieved.
In this set of circumstances, with the price of every article of the Irish farmers' produce tumbling one after another, such a year is selected to increase his rates, to reduce the grant in aid of his rates. Then, when a Deputy gets up to make the only case which would justify such action, and when the obvious interpretation is put on the case he makes, immediately there is a withdrawal. This is what I would like to know and what the country would like to know: what were the reasons that prompted the reduction of the agricultural grant in the middle of the so-called economic war, at a time when one Minister after another, when addressing an agricultural community, sympathises with them, tells them that it is necessary, but to stick it out; that times are hard. but that they will not always be so hard? Why was such a time selected? Again. I say the reason is obvious. It is just another bit of political trickiness, of political shiftiness; an attempt to buy political support with public money.
What is the position? Some 12 months ago we had a motion put down by Deputy Morrissey asking the Government to accept the principle of providing either work or maintenance for able-bodied men in this country. At that time the Government was living in another atmosphere of make-believe, another atmosphere of false promises. The wheels of industry were going to buzz in this country. 80,001 men were going to be employed in two or three months. In the atmosphere of all that kind of propaganda this particular motion of Deputy Morrissey had got to be accepted. The principle of work or maintenance was accepted. The reason why that responsibility was put on the Government was in order to take it off the ratepayers; that was the only reason. The Government accepted that principle of work or maintenance. The other day there was no reference to the work—not a bit; but there was a Bill brought in to provide what was called maintenance. It was supposed to be coming out of central funds. It was supposed to be a Government grant, a Government effort to provide maintenance. £500,000 was provided as a sum to start the finance of this new scheme. There was something familiar about that particular £500,000. It was the very same sum as had been withheld from local rates. In fact, there was no contribution from central funds. There was no effort by the Government to relieve the ratepayers, to take the responsibility off the ratepayers which should never have been imposed on them. In fact, you might as well have left things where they were. The ratepayers are providing maintenance. It is the ratepayers' money, withdrawn from the agricultural grant. Another —just another—little political trick, just another little example of how important politics appear to that Front Bench opposite, and how unimportant a little straightforward legislative business appears to the same Front Bench.
I say that it does not matter who sits on the Government Front Bench provided facts are faced up to. Whether it is Fianna Fáil or Labour or whatever Party sits there, there is a definite and solemn responsibility on them to do their best for every industry in this country, but to do their very, very best for the biggest industry this country ever had, or ever will have. To play politics at a time when the farming industry is going down and down, to withdraw finance from that industry—finance which could at the moment save it—in order to buy, say, tens of thousands of votes around the country, is not playing the game straight; that is not playing the game you were sent there to play. You were sent there to administer the affairs of the country, to do your best for the country, to do your best particularly for the main industry in the country and not to play politics. You should have quit politics when you got into that bench. You should have begun to think of business. Even at this stage I would ask that this much might result from this particular debate before it is finished—that it might bring the Government back to a realisation of the responsibilities which they accepted when they took their seats on those benches. When they took their seats on the Government Bench they ceased to be the representatives of one set or section of politicians throughout the country. They became the representatives of all the people, irrespective of class and irrespective of politics. It is not facing up to that responsibility, it is not being true to the responsibility which is yours, to continue day after day and year after year playing politics from Government seats.
Comment on this
The motion before the Dáil is:
That the Dáil condemns the action of the Government in reducing the total of the grants payable for the relief of rates on agricultural land.
In some peculiar way, which I cannot follow, Deputy O'Higgins succeeded in linking up with that motion an allegation that the Government is using public funds to buy political support. That allegation, associated with that motion, seems to bespeak a muddled mind. I cannot follow the Deputy. If the Deputy were criticising us for having increased the grant for the relief of rates on agricultural land to an exorbitant degree, then undoubtedly we might be faced with an allegation, such as the Deputy has made, of fleecing the taxpayer for the purpose of getting political kudos, but the motion refers to the action of the Government in reducing the grant. The reduction of a grant is never very popular, and the Government took action in the reduction of this grant knowing it to be unpopular, but knowing it also to be the right thing to do by the country. Of course the conception of a Government doing the right thing by the country is so foreign to the minds of Deputies opposite that they cannot quite grasp it.
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy is referring to, but perhaps he will explain later on. Cheap? It reminds me of a blackbird singing its song, but perhaps it has some significance. When Deputy O'Higgins speaks here he always asks others to adopt the manly course, to do the straightforward thing. It is a sort of complex of his. Just as a person who knows himself to be inferior to his associates is continuously asserting his superiority, or a person who is engaged in some intrigue against his comrades continuously suspects them of intriguing against him, so Deputy O'Higgins always feels it necessary to assert the desirability of a straightforward and manly course, and to urge others to adopt it. What is the straightforward and manly course for Deputies opposite in relation to this motion? I suggest that the first thing is to tell us what exactly they would do if the responsibility were theirs. I am anxious to find out. One of the childish illusions which Deputies opposite cherish is that by some stroke of luck they will at some time again become responsible for the Government of this country. Let them indulge their day dream to the extent of telling us what they would do if they became the Government of the country. Let us assume a myth, and try to imagine the Front Bench opposite transferred to the Front Bench here. I do not know who would compose it, because the Front Bench opposite appears to be filled by a sort of rotating system, but assuming that it would be possible to get agreement amongst the Party opposite as to who should be the members of the Government and that they were transferred over here and asked to explain to the Dáil their policy, what would they say? Would they say they were going to increase the grant for the relief of rates on agricultural land? Do you want to increase the grant for the relief of rates on agricultural land? That silence speaks a lot. What else would they do?
Let me tell you something about the reason why this year was chosen to reduce the grant for the relief of rates on agricultural land. The total reduction is £450,000. In this year farmers are going to be asked to pay only one quarter of their land annuities, one quarter of what they paid in previous years. Not £450,000, but well over £3,000,000 of the amount they had to pay in 1931 is being left with them this year. It is surely obvious to Deputies opposite that the farmers, en masse, are getting a much greater measure of relief from the central authority in this year than ever they got before, or than ever they will get again. That is why this year was chosen to reduce the grant for agricultural land, and also because the Government proposal which was discussed in the Dáil this evening means that farmers are going to get back more than was taken from them in the reduction of this grant for the relief of rates by transferring from the rates to the Unemployment Assistance Fund the responsibility of providing for able-bodied unemployed. The total amount paid in home assistance in county council areas last year was £300,000.
Comment on this
Assuming that all of it was, I say that more than twice that amount is going to be paid in future and that the rate charge for home assistance is going to be very considerably reduced. In return for the £450,000 taken from these areas a much larger sum is going back in addition to the £3,000,000 remission of land annuities. What would Deputies opposite do? They are continuously talking as if the restoration of Cumann na nGaedheal to power was going to mean immediate prosperity for the farmers. How are they going to get it? We want to know. We are willing to learn. Maybe the people would not tolerate Deputies opposite in office, but if Deputies opposite have any ideas as to the return of prosperity let them not keep it secret. Have they got an idea? Do the Deputies opposite know what they would do if the responsibility of Government was theirs? They used to short here about giving the farmers back their markets. What did they mean by that? Would the farmers get back their markets if the Party opposite became the Government to-morrow and, if so, how are they going to do it? We could get back the British market to-morrow, no doubt, by dropping our claim to the land annuities and to the other payments now being withheld. Is that the way that you will get back the markets? We want the Deputies opposite to tell us. If they can get any agreement among themselves as to what the policy of their Party is, let them announce it. I suggest that the only reason that they have not announced their policy is that any attempt to formulate it would burst their Party into five parts. But if they have got any agreement even upon the most meaningless phrase that could be passed off on the country as a policy, let them tell us what it is. Do they propose to get the British market back by paying the land annuities in full to Great Britain, and, if so, are they going out around the country with the bailiffs and the sheriffs for the purpose of collecting these annuities? If they succeeded in restoring to the farmers the £450,000 additional agricultural grant, which was taken from them, at the cost of taking from these farmers the £4,000,000 in land annuities, I am afraid that the farmers would not see the point of it. Do the Deputies opposite see the point of it? They are so very shy of telling us what they stand for that some of us have come to the conclusion that they stand for nothing. If the Party has not a policy, is there any individual in the Party opposite with a policy? Is there one Deputy opposite who knows what he would do if he were made a dictator under Mr. O'Duffy's dictatorship plan? Would he increase the Agricultural Grant? Would they collect and pay to Great Britain the land annuities? If they are not prepared to do that, how do they propose to get back the British market they are talking about?
I invite Deputies opposite to enlighten us on these matters. We have pleaded with them before in the House and outside the House to tell us what their policy is. I ask them again, as public men representing constituencies in this country whose duty it is to help to formulate the public opinion of a part of our people, to make a beginning here by telling us what conclusions they themselves have reached, if they have reached any conclusions. They ask the Dáil to condemn the action of the Government in reducing the total of the Agricultural Grant, but they do not propose that it should be increased. Is that their policy? Are they urging that the £450,000 by which the Agricultural Grant was reduced should be given again in this year to the farmers and, if so, where do they propose to get it? The benefits which the Party opposite, apparently, offer to the farmers are a vigorous campaign to collect 100 per cent. of the land annuities, additional taxation to provide £1,250,000 in respect of R.I.C. pensions, and so on, and no economies. In return for all that they hope to get in the British market an opportunity of disposing of our surplus of agricultural produce at a better price, and they have not yet realised the illusion upon which they are basing their whole political conception. It is not there. The farmers could not do it. If you seek to get back the British market at that price, you will break this country. You say that the farmers are not well off. Of course, they are not well off. We know they are not well off. Neither are the farmers in Northern Ireland nor in Great Britain, France, Germany, or the United States of America well off. There is no country in the world in which the farmers are well off at the present time, because of the tremendous fall in the prices of primary products, a fall which has not been reflected in the prices of other commodities to the same degree. It is the duty of the central authority to help the farmers to weather this depression so that they will be able to take advantage of any trade revival that may come about with their productive capacity unimpaired. Go and ask the farmers of Great Britain if they are satisfied with present conditions. You cannot do better for the farmers of this country under any circumstances than make them as well off as the farmers of Great Britain and Northern Ireland are. Are the farmers of Northern Ireland so well off? Do we read in the Press speeches of their representatives boasting of the prosperity they are enjoying there, or do we read the reverse? And it must be remembered that the farmers in the Six Counties do not pay annuities to Great Britain. They pay them into a derating fund. They do not pay rates. Deputies opposite have got to tell us how they are going to put our farmers even into as good a position as the farmers of Northern Ireland. You can only get the same price for their produce but can you, at the same time, give them the measure of relief they are enjoying? You cannot do it. You may be fooling yourselves but you are fooling nobody else. If you want to carry any weight in the political life of this country, my advice is to sit down and think seriously for a week without saying anything and then for all of you to agree amongst yourselves as to what you will say.
I gathered from Deputy O'Higgins that he objects to the payment of export bounties. Is that the policy of the Party opposite? Undoubtedly, we could pay the £450,000 additional grant for the relief of rates on agricultural land if we stopped the export bounties as Deputy O'Higgins suggests. Does any other Deputy opposite suggest that it should be done? I should be glad to hear from them. Deputy O'Higgins apparently was speaking for himself alone, mé féin instead of Sinn Féin. We are told that the reduction of the grant had many disastrous consequences. Deputy O'Higgins talked about its effect on public morals. It was not the reduction of the grant that had any effect on public morals. It was the campaign which the Deputies opposite decided to initiate when the reduction of the grant was announced. As to the effect on public morals, Deputies must quite seriously lay the blame for that and for any deterioration in public morality at their own door. Deputies will remember that early this year we had an effort made by certain county councils to prevent the striking of a rate at all. We had that campaign officially endorsed by the Cumann na nGaedheal Convention held here in May last. Deputies are now telling us that they never advocated the non-payment of rates. Their memories are very short. They cannot remember their own policy for six months. I invite Deputies opposite to go back over their newspapers and read the speeches made in May last, when they gave public support to the members of the different county councils who were trying to prevent a rate being struck.
Comment on this
I am speaking of the action of the Opposition. They have put down a motion on the Order Paper and it is for them to justify that motion and to justify their attitude in relation to the question involved and also to tell us what their policy is in relation to that matter. The public morality of a certain section of our people was seriously undermined by the attitude adopted by Deputies opposite in the beginning of the year. But they failed in their campaign to prevent a rate being struck. They failed in that campaign and because they failed in that they began to go around the country making speeches about the poor farmers who could not pay their rates. They continued in that until they had induced, here and there, a local agitation to prevent the rates being paid. In so far as assistance from the Central Fund was ever given to the agricultural community, more assistance has been given this year than in any other two years added together——
Comment on this
I will answer that interruption in a minute as to whether more is required or not. We are told that prices have fallen. Prices for all agricultural products are low. For a number they are higher here than anywhere else, but taken on the whole they are low. Farmers are getting for their milk sold at the creameries a higher price than any farmers in Europe——
Comment on this
If the Deputy will put down a question I will guarantee him that they are paid 4½d. in 12 places in the country.
Comment on this
The farmers are getting, in respect of other crops, a higher price than in England or in Northern Ireland. In fact, there are attempts being made to smuggle in certain crops from Northern Ireland into the Saorstát so as to get higher prices. Cattle prices are falling, but since July, 1932, to this day the fall in cattle prices was much less than the fall that took place in 1931. Let the Deputies go back and look at the records for those years. Prices of cattle fell in 1931 considerably more than since the economic war began. I said the other day that the Cumann na nGaedheal peace was worse than any economic war and all the statistics for the period bear that out. The price for bacon pigs is higher than in 1931. Prices for sheep have fallen, but the price has not fallen as much since the economic war began as it fell in 1931. Not merely have conditions in some respects been improved for the farmers in so far as their cash obligations to the public funds have been reduced, but, in addition, they have been induced by circumstances to commence the change over to a sounder system of economics. Remember that when I say the prices of cattle have not fallen since the start of the economic war as much as they fell in 1931, I say the same in relation to sheep and other agricultural products. I am not denying that prices have fallen.
Comment on this
And three-year-old cattle are sold for £5. That is the price now. Compare that with the prices in 1931.
Comment on this
In several other countries farmers would be glad to get that price for their cattle.
Comment on this
Will the Minister compare the price now with the price paid in 1931 for cattle?
Comment on this
By taking off the 40 per cent. tariff on our cattle.
Comment on this
One man has spoken. I have been asking the Party opposite to tell us how to increase the price of cattle, and one man has come in now to tell us. How are you going to increase the price?
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is it correct for the Minister to conduct a cross-examination of the entire Party in the course of his speech? Is not that inevitably going to lead to constant interruptions?
Comment on this
I can understand how reluctant the acting leader of the Opposition is to hear Deputy Rice's answer.
Comment on this
I put it to yourself that if they are not answered it is because the Opposition desire to be orderly. The Minister need not comment that if they are not answered they are therefore unanswerable.
Comment on this
I got an answer as to how to increase the prices. I was told that it was the policy of the Opposition Party to secure better prices for our exports on the basis of paying the annuities.
Comment on this
Again, on a point of order—I put this point solely in the interests of good order—if the Minister goes on with his tub thumping we will have a thoroughly disorderly debate.
Comment on this
If the Opposition Deputies want a settlement on the basis suggested by Deputy Rice——
Comment on this
Has not the Minister been asking for interruptions since he started his speech? Is he not asking for them?
Comment on this
All this perturbation arose from the fact that Deputy Rice has let them down. Deputy Rice was not in the Dáil at the beginning. He walked in now and he answered a question and we get not a definition of the Party's policy but a denial of it. Their policy is not to pay annuities.
Comment on this
The Minister is proving now what Deputy Hogan said last week that he has brains but no character.
Comment on this
The Deputy may have character, but apparently he has no brains. His policy is not to pay the land annuities but to settle the economic war. Nevertheless let him tell us the sequel. That is what we want.