Private Deputies' Business. - Relief of Rates on Agricultural Land.
Contributions 132–268 of 268. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Is it the policy of the Opposition to pay them? I am trying to find out something of value in the present debate.
Comment on this
Is it your policy to pay the land annuities or not? I appeal to them not to answer. They will only be getting a further rebuff from the acting leader. There will be another split in the Party if you do not stop talking.
Comment on this
I asked how are the prices going to be increased and I was told they would be increased by getting a removal of the 40 per cent. duty. I asked how was the removal of the 40 per cent. duty going to be secured and I was told it would be on the basis of paying the land annuities. Then there were shouts of "No" from several other Deputies. If their policy is to pay the land annuities, then they have to contemplate this campaign in connection with the collection of land annuities. They cannot pay the land annuities unless they first collect them. Is it their solution to go around this country with the battering ram, the bailiff and the sheriff to squeeze out of the farmers the £5,000,000 they have got to collect in order to secure the market?
Comment on this
If it is not their policy to pay the land annuities, what policy are they going to adopt in order to get rid of the 40 per cent. duty? Let them give us some information on that point. Let any one of them who chooses to speak tell us what did happen in 1931, when their deputy leader, their second in command or third in command, Deputy Cosgrave, asked for a moratorium on £250,000, payable under the 1925 agreement. If it is their policy not to pay the land annuities and if they think they can secure the removal of the 40 per cent. duty, we want some evidence of their ability to do that. All we have is their miserable failure to get a year's moratorium on the payment of £250,000.
When they got that rebuff in Downing Street they came back here and faced the Dáil and never said a word about it. They kept their lips shut about it; they kept that fact from the Irish people, although they knew perfectly well that if they mentioned that fact here they would have had the unanimous support of the Dáil, a support which would have secured the very minor concession that they were seeking to obtain.
Comment on this
The Minister having made his point, I submit that it is not the policy of this Party that is under discussion at the moment, but rather the policy of the Government. The Minister's remarks are absolutely irrelevant. He is not dealing with the motion before the House.
Comment on this
The question of the land annuities, the ability of the people to pay rates and the question of the economic condition of the agricultural community were spoken of for at least an hour and the Minister is entitled to reply.
Comment on this
The policy of Deputy Morrissey's Party may not be under discussion, but the policy of the Party to which Deputy Belton, Deputy O'Higgins and Deputy Minch belong, is. They have tabled this motion. They invited this discussion and they are asking the Dáil to condemn the action of the Government in reducing the total of the grants payable for the relief of rates on agricultural land. I asked them if they were governing the country to-morrow would they increase the grant and I could not get an answer from them. I asked them what they would do, if they were in office, in order to relieve farmers. They have been talking about low prices. What would they do to increase them? What would they do to increase the grant? They have talked about the burdens on the farmers. What would they do to reduce those burdens?
Comment on this
We are anxious to learn. I have explained why the grant was reduced. I pointed out that although the agricultural grant was reduced by £450,000 there was left in the pockets of the farmers this year over £3,000,000 which the Party opposite, were they in office, would have taken out.
Comment on this
One quarter of the land annuity charges which they paid in 1931 is all they are being asked to pay this year.
Comment on this
Deputies will have an opportunity of giving their views when the Minister has finished.
Comment on this
I would be glad to hear, particularly from Deputy Rice, how we are to get rid of the 40 per cent. duty. I advise him to get down to the Front Bench and have a little consultation with the occupants there before he talks, or he may find himself taking the long, long road he once took before.
Comment on this
I want to know if Deputy O'Higgins's objection to the payment of bounties on exports is held by the majority of that Party and I would like to know what is their general policy in respect of agriculture. We have given the farmers three-quarters of the land annuities this year. We have given them assistance in the matter of milk production. We have given them assistance which has secured for them a price higher than that secured by any other creamery suppliers in the world. We have given them a bounty in respect of wheat production and they are receiving a price for wheat higher than is paid in any country in the world.
Comment on this
As a result of our efforts the farmers have had the advantage of an improvement in barley prices and they have secured in respect of oats, although the price is low, a price higher than is obtained in Great Britain or Northern Ireland. We have taken certain measures in respect of bacon production, which have secured an additional market valued at £400,000 a year and which have brought the price of bacon pigs to a stage higher than in 1931. We have helped them to meet the fall in prices in respect of other commodities.
Although times are bad, and depression has had its effect, and although nobody in this country is as prosperous as he will be before Fianna Fáil has quit office, nevertheless the people are able to meet what is coming; they are better off than are the farmers in most countries; they appreciate what the Government is doing for them and, if Deputies opposite doubt that, we will be glad to give them another opportunity of facing the people and hearing from their own lips what they heard last January. Deputy O'Higgins talked about the manly course and the straightforward policy that should be taken. Let some Deputy opposite respond to Deputy O'Higgins's appeal, stand up manfully and straightforwardly, and tell us what that Party would advocate and what it would do if it got the chance. Perhaps the Deputy will tell us also if the rest of the Party agree with him in what he says.
Comment on this
I had not intended to intervene in this discussion until I heard some of the simple-sounding questions addressed to us by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I do not know whether it is correct to describe the Minister as having brains or as having character, or as having both brains and character; but one thing he certainly has got, and that is histrionic ability. I feel that he would have made his fortune on any stage. Now, who is this who is asking for elucidation and enlightenment about the policy of this Party? What could not be said about the vagueness, the ambiguity and the inconsistency of the policy of the Party opposite? Who can tell us whether their policy is to get back firmly into the British market, or get out of it and throw it aside for ever? Who can tell us whether they are in agreement with the speeches that they allow some of their supporters to make around about the country in favour of debasing the currency of this country, or in favour of expropriating the banks of this country? Who can tell us just what amount of sympathy they have with the existence of the I.R.A.?
I am perfectly well aware I am travelling outside the terms of this motion, but I submit I am not doing so to any greater extent than did the Minister. If we are to be cross-examined about every alleged ambiguity lurking in our policy, surely it is legitimate to cross-examine them too? I could mention a great many things that the policy of the Party opposite is very far from being clear on, and it is very far from being clear on these points, because they are aware of the fact that to become clear would be their own destruction. It is just the fact that there is ambiguity that gets them along at all.
There is no such obscurity about the policy of this Party and there is no difficulty about answering questions put to us so rhetorically by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Are we actually in favour, he asks, of giving back this money to the agricultural grant? The answer is very simple; it is "yes." He next asks us if we were to be put into office in this country would we start collecting the full amount of the land annuities. Well, now there can hardly be an educated person in this country that does not know full well that after what has been done to agriculture in Ireland the old scale of land annuities will never be collected again.
What is our plan for getting back the English market, for bringing the so-called economic war to an end? Have we not stated our plan hundreds of times? Our plan for getting back the British market is the very simple one of acting like business men and taking the necessary steps for getting it back. What are those steps, and what does this economic war—we have got to call it that for want of a better name—spring from? It springs from two things: one, the resolution of the present Government to treat obligations entered into by the previous Government as of absolutely no account; and, secondly, the attitude of the present Government with regard to the question of our relationship with the British Commonwealth. The two questions cannot be dissociated: one cannot be settled without the other being settled. Now these are questions that can be settled perfectly well and perfectly honourably, and to the great advantage of the people of this country, by making up our own minds as to what we want and by going and entering into negotiations in a businesslike manner.
The first obstacle that confronts the Fianna Fáil Party as regards making any sort of agreement with England is that they have not made up their minds, so far as I can gather, as to whether they want most: the unity of Ireland or a republic. If they made up their minds as we have made up our minds, that what we want is the unity of Ireland and the effective freedom of Ireland as a whole: that we are quite prepared to stay as equal partners in the British Commonwealth on that basis, well then it would be easy for them, as it would be easy for us if we were in power, to go to the British and say just that—to make perfectly plain what our ideal was, and to say at the same time that in view of constitutional developments in the last few years, in view of the Statute of Westminster and in view of the general feeling throughout the Commonwealth, that the time had come to remove, by mutual consent, any contractual obligations that may be thought to exist on this country to stay within the Commonwealth. In other words, to make it perfectly plain that we are absolutely free to go out of the partnership that constitutes the Commonwealth at any time the Irish people wish to do so.
Comment on this
I say that to make that position clear is the first step. As long as you have got a republic hanging about in the background you cannot get any further with the financial question. Of course, if you want a Twenty-six County republic, and if the people cannot be taught the folly of a Twenty-six County republic without first having one, then go ahead and declare your republic, and I must say that I do not know why you are not declaring it. Go ahead and declare it, and after a few years' experience we may have the commonsense to turn our thoughts once more to the unity of Ireland, to try and accomplish it, and come back into the partnership of the Commonwealth in order to do it. But you cannot make an end of the economic war until you put your cards on the table as regards your attitude to the whole question of constitutional relationship with Great Britain.
The British have already indicated on frequent occasions in the speeches of their Ministers that, in the whole of this dispute, they are not nearly so much interested in the financial aspect as they are in the constitutional aspect, and further in the general principle of the sanctity of agreements. It is perfectly well known to every thinking man, even in that Party, that if we acted in such a manner as to give evidence of our bona fide acceptance of the principle of the sanctity of agreements, and also if we made it plain that we were prepared to continue as free partners in the Commonwealth, agreement on the purely financial side could be got, and got without much difficulty; but the unfortunate thing has been that that Government and that Party have not been nearly as much interested in obtaining good terms for the Irish people as they have been in repudiating and dishonouring everything that was done by their predecessors in office. By doing so they have not only brought great dishonour on this country, but they have involved it in this economic war as well. There have been governments found in other countries who have thought nothing of sacrificing the honour of their country to material interests, and other governments that have thought nothing of sacrificing material interests to honour, but this Government has achieved the feat of sacrificing both simultaneously.
According to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, if we did succeed in getting back the British market by methods of frankness, of negotiation and goodwill it would be of remarkably little value to us when we had got it back. The Minister pointed to the bad condition of the farmers in England and Northern Ireland, as he is entitled to do, and indeed of farmers all over the world; but when he suggests that our highest ambition would be to make the Irish farmer no worse off than the English farmers or the Northern Ireland farmers are at present he is saying something that is not so, because much more than that could be accomplished. As I pointed out to him on a previous occasion, there ought to be joint action by the farmers in the Free State, the farmers in Northern Ireland and the farmers in Great Britain by which the farmers of these islands would get protection as against the foreigner, and that is what could have been accomplished at Ottawa if our case had been properly fought there, and that is what will be accomplished at some time in the future when there is a Government in office here with courage and intelligence enough to make a decent trade agreement.
The Minister has suggested that Deputy O'Higgins—I did not hear part of the Deputy's speech—has expressed himself as opposed to bounties. I very much doubt if that is a correct report of what Deputy O'Higgins said, but Deputy O'Higgins is certainly entitled to point out this: that it is perfectly ludicrous for a Government which is saying all the things that that Government is saying to be giving bounties, to be at one moment decrying the British market and the next moment to be spending all that money to get into it. When the Minister has the audacity to talk about prices, low as they are, and to say, "Well, it might be worse, or it really is not so terribly calamitous," let us ask him this question: what would the prices be if there were no bounties? The prices, bad as they are, are artificial and the collapse would be simply appalling if artificial measures were not taken to keep things going to some extent. The Minister for Industry and Commerce also accused this Party of having engaged in a campaign to prevent rates being struck by county councils. That is not true.
Comment on this
In certain counties there was opposition to a rate being struck for reasons that I need not go into, but it is quite untrue that there was a general campaign by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, so far as I am aware, against the striking of rates. If there were a general campaign, it would have been spread through all counties instead of being confined to a few. As far as I am aware, no such campaign took place or had official endorsement.
Comment on this
I have no recollection of any statement by Deputy Cosgrave on the subject. I believe there was a resolution passed congratulating some county councils——
Comment on this
For having taught the Government something. There was one resolution of one convention expressing sympathy for men who were honestly fighting, to the best of their belief, in the interests of the unfortunates who were not able to pay. If I had been a member of a county council myself my feeling is that I would absent myself rather than join in striking a rate——
Comment on this
It may have been improper to oppose striking a rate, but I do not know how anyone with any sort of feeling for the farmer could have actually taken an active hand in striking a rate in the circumstances existing and in the peculiar situation created by the Government's complete forgetfulness of its own pledges and by its reduction of the Agricultural Grant. We come back now to the fundamental fact, that the Minister for Industry and Commerce never so much as alluded to during his whole speech, that the present Government promised specifically full derating. In the election manifesto of the Fianna Fáil Party in January, 1932, full derating was specifically promised and was dropped.
Comment on this
Derating was dropped, but the Fianna Fáil Party reduced the land annuities instead. Why? Was it because after mature consideration they came to the conclusion that that was the best way to benefit the poor people? That was not the reason. They had all the materials before them when they promised derating for coming to that conclusion. The reason they changed their minds as to the proper form to give relief is this: they realised that they could not collect the land annuities which their own supporters opposed and would not pay. They thought the rates a less urgent problem and they thought it an easier matter to collect the rates than the land annuities. Now they find the collection of the rates difficult and they do not find themselves able to repeat their evasion of last year. They are now alleging there is a nation-wide conspiracy against the collection of rates.
Comment on this
I am sorry to find a split in the Fianna Fáil Party. The President used the expression nation-wide conspiracy, and so I leave it to the Minister for Industry and Commerce to rebuke him for saying anything so silly. A conspiracy was alleged and I take this opportunity with regard to that to repeat that the allegation is pure and absolute humbug and the march of events will show that it is humbug.
Comment on this
I have been listening to members on the opposite benches talking about the farmers and the hardships of the farmers. I am not a farmer but I know a good deal more about the farming conditions in the country than those who profess to speak for the farmers on the opposite benches.
Comment on this
I said on the opposite benches. I claim to know as much about the conditions of the farmers as those Deputies who a short time ago belonged to the Centre Party. On the average the small farmer in my constituency is a hardworking, patriotic Irishman. An attempt has been made in Cork County, for the past year and a half, to persuade these farmers that they were unable to pay their rates. It was attempted at meeting after meeting of the Cork County Council. The people who told them this, and how badly off they were, always made sure to have their own rates paid, but the other fellow was always very badly off. One of them of the landlord tribe boasted that while the de Valera Government were in power he would not pay any rates. Still, when the rate collector called upon him he wrote out his cheque. A good many more of them, in order to make it impossible for the Government to continue to collect the rates, left their land go to waste. They said it was no use to work the land. Still, when there was an acre wanted for a cottage for a labourer that land was not available; it got a tremendous value all of a sudden.
Deputy Dillon, who was one time a kind of leader in the Centre Party and who is now a petty leader of some kind in the new Party, said here last week that there were 1,500 people in the Square of Macroom assembled to hear him, and that about 80 or 90 supporters of de Valera came into the square and deliberately attempted to break up that meeting——
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon talked a good deal about farming and about the number of farmers that came to Macroom to listen to him. I am not a farmer, as I say, but I was there too and I say that a man like Deputy Dillon, who is in a responsible position, should not come to this House and make a deliberately false statement of that kind.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not entitled to say that any Deputy made a deliberately false statement in this House. He may have made an incorrect statement, but to say that a Deputy made a deliberately false statement is not in order.
Comment on this
I withdraw the charge, but he made a statement that was not true or that was inaccurate. I think it is a wrong thing for a man—I am sorry he is not here—who is in a responsible position to come in here and tell the Dáil and through the Dáil tell the country that such a thing happened. It did not happen. I am not going to go into the details of what happened because I do not believe this is the place to go into the details. There was no attempt made to break up the meeting.
Comment on this
I am sorry but I must intervene to say that Deputy Dillon's version of what took place was correct, because I was there.
Comment on this
I say I was there too and it was not correct. There were interruptions, undoubtedly, but I have been interrupted several times at meetings myself. I like interruptions now and again.
Comment on this
I am quite aware of that, but it was just as relevant on the day Deputy Dillon introduced it here. Deputy Dillon also spoke at a monster Hibernian demonstration in Ballyshannon some time ago, and he said there that "he wanted to tell the people of Donegal that he promised to remain independent and to concern himself with the rights and interests of his own people. He had done that and would continue to do that, and if they wanted a representative who would sell himself to Cumann na nGaedheal or to Fianna Fáil, they must look for someone else." These are the people who now come in here and tell us about derating, about land annuities and about how hard hit the farmer is.
Comment on this
Yes, they talk about everything, like Deputy Anthony sometimes. It is about time that these people examined their consciences.
Comment on this
I do not think some of you have, but there are some honest men on the opposite side and it is about time they would stop trying to fool the country.
Comment on this
Deputy MacDermot and Deputy Dillon took a trip down to Cork last Sunday and they became poetic, or at least they took poetic licence. Deputy MacDermot gave us a new version of "The Wearing of the Green" in which he substituted fs"blue" for "green" and if I am not mistaken, it would be very easy to introduce the red and white. I suppose that is one way of setting the economic war with England. Deputy Dillon also took poetic licence and tried to start a new national anthem. I forget what the opening bars were. Those are the leaders or the sub-leaders who are going to help the country. They are going to lead the farmers. They know nothing whatever about tillage; they are afraid of their lives to till. Some of them told us here last year that barley was all right if it was cheap enough. More of them told us that barley was too cheap. They have been asked by the Minister for Industry and Commerce to try to agree on a policy. Why do they not try to agree amongst themselves and try to give a lead to the country that in some way would benefit the country instead of wasting the time of the Dáil and their own time in fooling the people of the country, telling them lies and making false statements time after time? They ought to try to get down to facts sometimes. They talk about the English market. Why do they not tell us what way they have of getting it back?
Comment on this
Yes, we had a lot of them in the past while they were in office. I often saw myself where you tried to sell people's cattle to get the land annuities off them in order to hand them over to England. That was your policy and it would be your policy again if you got into power, but there is no hope for you ever. You are finished.
Comment on this
The last speaker has referred to the differences of opinion between Parties on this side of the House. If there are differences of opinion with regard to the price of barley, that is quite a natural thing. The farmers as a whole do not gain by having cheap barley or dear barley. I shall try to answer that part of the question. In a county into which feeding stuffs have to be imported it is an advantage to have cheap feeding stuffs, whereas in a grain-growing county it is an advantage to have them dear. There is one thing, however, on which farmers in all parts of the country will agree, and that is, that there should be a good price for the finished product—cattle, pork, pigs, eggs and butter—and this can only be obtained by the restoration of our chief market. These other contentious points that have been introduced do not affect the main question. The real necessity is to have a good price for the finished product and that will suit the interests of every class of farmer in the country. The Minister for Industry and Commerce referred to the fall in the price of primary products all over the world and he said that the price of agricultural produce has been hit more than any other. What has the Minister done to help the farmers, who are producing these agricultural products at an enormous loss? His contribution to relieve the situation has been to make the prices 40 per cent. worse than they would be in normal circumstances. Not only has he made them 40 per cent. worse in regard to what they had to sell in the midst of these admitted difficulties—and he did admit them—but he has made everything they have to buy dearer in order to help other industries at their expense.
They were hit not only in the price that they got for what they produced, but they were hit also in the price of what they had to buy. They had not only to bear up against the depression which he admitted existed, but they had to carry 40 per cent. over and above that. They had to prop up other industries at the same time. In order to make the position worse, he comes along and withdraws half a million in grants from these unfortunate farmers. It seems like a deliberate conspiracy amongst the Government to render the farmers bankrupt and to kill the one industry we have in the country.
The agricultural industry represents 75 per cent. of the production in the State or of the wealth-producing industries of the State. With the exception of one or two other industries such as Guinness or Ford's, it is the only industry in the State that is self-supporting. That industry has been killed. The Government has killed the only industry in the country that counts. The policy of the present Government so far as agriculture is concerned stands condemned, and it deserves to be condemned. I hope that the Government will even now take stock of the position and that they will do something even at the eleventh hour to save the country from complete ruin. They profess to believe that the farmers of the country are not so very badly off. According to Deputy Corry, before he withdrew his statement, the farms of the country were flowing with milk and honey. I think that if the Deputy went through the country he would find that there was very little milk and honey flowing so far as most of the farmers were concerned. The Minister for Industry and Commerce told us about the farmers in Northern Ireland and in England. I happen to live very near the Border and I know that at the last market in Cavan, when pork was sold for 40/- a cwt., it was sold for 58/- across the Border. That is one example. The same applies to fowl and to eggs and, of course, to cattle. I need not refer to cattle because that aspect has been adequately dealt with by other speakers. I think it was the Minister for Industry and Commerce who told us about the price of bacon here at present as compared with 1931. He did not tell us the price of pork or bacon pigs as compared with the same price on the same day in Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
They cannot send them into Northern Ireland. There is nobody buying pork in Northern Ireland at present and the Deputy knows it.
Comment on this
It would be a more appropriate comparison than comparing prices now with prices in 1931 and while there was such a discrepancy, 18/- a cwt., the retail price of bacon in the Free State was dearer on the same day than it was in Northern Ireland. I can produce figures to prove this. These are points which are very serious for farmers. We were told about the price the farmers are getting for milk. I admit that they are gaining in milk and butter but they are losing on so many other articles that they are producing —cattle, pork, eggs and fowl and any other articles which they produce. If they are gaining a little on the price of their milk, they are paying it out of the other pocket and they are entitled, even in normal times, because of the tariffs which they have to pay to prop up manufacturing industries in this State, to bounties on exports, so as to increase the price of their commodities. Even if there was never an economic war, they would be entitled to bounties on such commodities as butter, eggs and pork in order to compensate them for the losses they sustained through the tariffs imposed on them for the protection of manufacturing industries. They are paying almost double in the Free State what they are paying on the other side of the Border for wearing apparel and other necessaries. I admit that that is necessary and that we want to build up industries here. I quite agree that that is a good policy but the money raised in that way should go back to the agricultural community in bounties and these bounties should be confined to such commodities as would increase the price of the produce giving the most labour. That would suit the small farmer and the labourer as well.
The position of the farmer in the country and of the agricultural labourer as well, is terrible at the present time. I know that they are working on much less than the cost of production and that instead of having an ordinary living wage, they would not have five bob a week to live on and work as hard as they have to from year to year. I know, from experience, that no farmer is able to pay a labourer and say that he can make ends meet. I know of no small farmer whose family is working on the land, who is able to keep clothes on his family and feed them. That is the position in which they find themselves and I am surprised to see the Labour Benches empty with this motion before the Dáil. The leader of kid-glove Labour is not here but he would be very eloquent if a proposal were put forward to reduce a person's salary of £700 or £800 by a small percentage. He is not here, however, to defend the agricultural worker and the small farmer who are working as sweated labourers——
Comment on this
——at much less than cost of production. I do not believe that any average small farmer, or labourer, is getting 10/- a week out of that labour. I do not care what they convert their labour into, or what class of commodities they raise for sale. In face of that we find that these gentlemen are absent. It will be interesting to see what attitude they will take on this motion. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has asked Deputies on this side how they could settle the economic war. Deputy MacDermot has answered the question, so I need not go into it, but, speaking as an ordinary Deputy—and this is my own personal opinion—I have not consulted anybody—I would say that whatever the Government might do, they are not in a position to settle it for the reason that they repudiated agreements made by their predecessors and they have no moral right now to make an agreement, because some other party at present in the wilderness might be led into this House by Deputy Belton, or by some other modern Moses, and might repudiate that agreement when they came in here.
Comment on this
I say that the present Government are not in a position to make an agreement, but I might make the suggestion that if they do want to settle this question, they would need to make some gesture and get all the Parties in this House to form a National Government and to recognise that there was such a thing as an agreement. It does not matter whether the agreement is good or bad. I am not going to stand up to defend it, but the fact is that there was an agreement and it should be recognised. What should be considered now is not the going back to the past, but dealing with the present and the future and to consider where the country is getting to and if an agreement is made to be in a moral position to say that that agreement is going to be kept. I do not think that the present Government can say that so long as they repudiate agreements of their predecesors because some other Party might come in, as I have said, and repudiate that agreement. This reduction of £440,000 is only a fraction of what the farmers have been deprived of. The Minister for Industry and Commerce told us that the proposal to reduce this was very unpopular. I say it was much worse because it is an unjust thing. It is an unjust charge on farmers to have to pay rates on land in any case, or in any circumstances. It is a sort of income tax on the income arising out of one particular class of business that does not apply to any other class and I have always strongly held the conviction that this is an unjust charge which should be abolished altogether. That means complete derating and not merely is £448,000 involved, but more nearly £3,000,000.
Comment on this
Government speakers tell us that when they relieve the farmers of the responsibility of paying the able-bodied unemployed, it is a grant to the farmers. I wonder how they could bring themselves to think that that responsibility should be on the farming community. I would like to ask Deputy Corry, who should have responsibility for the able-bodied unemployed. If they are unemployed, I will not say that it is through the fault of the Government entirely, but the responsibility is on the Government to provide for them.
Comment on this
Considering that you advised people to sack them and got them to sack them, you ought to blooming well pay for them.
Comment on this
Men will not work if they are not paid and the farmers are not able to pay them. If farmers cannot afford to give more than they get from their own labour and the labour of their families—because farmers and their sons and daughters are sweated workers—they will not get employees to work. Farmers are not able to pay rates or annuities, let alone to pay labourers. I think it is admitted that the more they produce the more they lose, and the sooner they will be bankrupt. I knew farmers who employed labourers before the economic war started at all. These progressive farmers could not make ends meet. They kept six or seven labourers. They were progressive men, so progressive that they are gone out of the country. I do not know how many labourers Deputy Corry keeps, or what system of farming he follows. I know many farmers who have not the same market as Deputy Corry. He should be thankful that things are going so well and that his land is flowing with milk and honey. When Deputy Corry and those who hold the same views make statements, I hope they will be able to stand over them. I am not going to withdraw anything I said.
Some of the statements made from the opposite benches are in keeping with the promises that were made during the election. Statements are made in speeches but are withdrawn after five minutes. That is one of the things we have to complain about in the present Government. If they put a policy before the people, they should stand by that policy. But if they tell the people one thing, and then do another thing, I think the people have reason to complain. They did not tell the people at the last election that they were going to cut down the agricultural grant for the relief of rates. On the contrary, they let the people understand that the land annuities would be kept at home, and that the money would go towards complete derating for farmers. Speakers on the Government benches stated that the farmers had been given a present of three-quarters of the annuities. These speakers did not tell what British Ministers told, how much had been collected in taxes on farmers' produce. It is considerably over £3,000,000. A great deal more than the amount of the annuities has been collected. While it is admitted that farmers have paid a great deal more than the amount of the annuities in tariffs they are asked to pay half again, and are cut £448,000 that was to relieve the rates.
Comment on this
After Deputy McGovern's tears for the unfortunate farmers of Cavan, I cannot understand how there were from 20,000 to 30,000 people at the football match between Cavan and Galway last Sunday week, if they are so poor down there.
Comment on this
I want to contradict the hypocritical statement of Deputy MacDermot, that there was not a no-rates campaign in the country, organised by what was his Party, but which has been lost in the merge. That campaign was conducted in my constituency by every branch of what was the Deputy's organisation. Farmers were got to sign undertakings that they would not pay rates. They wanted to get out President de Valera by the non-payment of rates and to put in who?—the warriors who are making war on the very poor; people who were going to rob of every benefit in the way of social services the neediest in the community. To whom did they go? Did they discriminate between farmers who are unable to pay and farmers who are able to pay? No. They went to the rich men in each parish, the men with the biggest holdings, who had gilt-edged security, and got their names as a headline for the rest. There was no discrimination between those unable to pay and those able to pay. The ringleaders of the campaign, the men who will be in arrears when this question is all threshed out, are the men who are best able to pay, the men who want to wreck this Government by inflicting injustice on the poor so that the curse of ranching might remain in the midlands. If they succeeded in that campaign it would mean goodbye to all sympathy for the poor and for those who are down. Deputy O'Higgins talks about being straight and manly. Let him advise his comrades, who are well aware of what I am saying, to be straight and manly; not to be saying one thing to-day and another thing to-morrow; that they do not stand for the non-payment of rates. Then the secrecy and the collusion of their lieutenants throughout most of the counties in that base campaign will cease.
Deputy McGovern referred to the markets in Northern Ireland. The Party to which he now belongs got out a leaflet. It was like the 24 bob leaflet with no printer's name on it that was put on the lamp posts, and for which apparently no Party took responsibility. This leaflet was distributed at the football match. It stated that butter was 8d. per lb. in Northern Ireland. Let them distribute that leaflet in the dairying districts. Deputy MacDermot talked about a combination of British, Northern Ireland, and the Free State farmers in order to secure a monopoly in the markets. The very Party that I now accuse of getting out that leaflet pressed for a free market for Australian butter which, if we had it, would smash the dairying industry in the south. There has been talk about the standard of living of the farmers. Every liner that calls at Galway, as Deputy Brennan knows, brings returning emigrants from the greatest country in the world, where they cannot get a living. Let Deputy Brennan ask some of those who have come back about farming conditions, and about other conditions, in the United States, and let him make a comparison between the standard of living there and the standard of living here. It will be a revelation. The great point in this whole debate concerns the price of cattle. That is the big argument. I contend that whether a beast cost £8 or £18, what the farmer is concerned with, after a period of four months' or six months' feeding, is to turn over 30/- or £2 on that beast. The man who bought in January in the Six Counties, even though he paid £3 per head more for his stores and sold them for £3 more than in the Free State, dropped an equal amount with the Free State farmer.
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture has done his best and has come to his relief by defending and protecting the dairying industry.
Comment on this
I want to point out to Deputy Belton that in Mullingar, at the last fair in January, when certain people read the paper and saw that the Government had dissolved the Dáil, they lost their heads, said "De Valera is beaten" and paid £2 or £3 over the market price. They have suffered the consequence since. But the men who bought cattle in April and May have turned a profit of 30/- or £2 or £2 10s. per head.
Comment on this
You talk about getting back the British market or a monopoly of the British market. Do you think that Britain, which has broken every agreement made with this country, is going to sacrifice the Australian, Canadian and Rhodesian farmer to satisfy us, if we adopt the policy of conciliation and humility advocated by the Opposition? No rational person believes that. The Government are this year giving back to the farmers, in the form of annuities, the sum of £3,225,000 and, because of a decrease in the Agricultural Grant of £200,000 as compared with 1931-32, this debate has been initiated. If this were a genuine debate, concerned with the effect of the decrease in the Agricultural Grant, it could be understood, but the subtlety in the debate is this— the Party which sponsors this motion, while denying any responsibility for the no-rate campaign, secretly engineered it and are carrying it on outside. If Deputy O'Higgins, Deputy Belton and the rest want to be straightforward, let us have a straightforward repudiation, an unqualified repudiation before this debate ends and then we will get back to the point——
Comment on this
I should like to know if the Deputy, in his closing remarks, suggested that I was furthering directly or indirectly, or in any way, a no-rate campaign. Did he convey that impression to the House?
Comment on this
The motion before the House is "That the Dáil condemns the action of the Government in reducing the total of the grants payable for the relief of rates on agricultural land." My intelligence may be at fault, but I found it very hard to relate Deputy Kennedy's remarks to the motion before the House. So far as Deputy Kennedy, Deputy Corkery and the Minister for Industry and Commerce were concerned, there was hardly any need to tell the House that they did not follow farming. That was fairly evident. One of the most amusing arguments I ever heard was that put forward by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Corry and other Deputies on that side—that the Government are entitled to withhold a sum of £448,000 in grants because they are making a reduction of half the annuities this year. That is one of the most amusing things I ever heard.
Comment on this
Last year the Government came to the conclusion deliberately that the farmers were not able to pay any annuities at all. They withdrew the proceedings they had instituted against the farmers. Now, they say they must pay half the annuities this year. Because they are going to pay half the annuities this year they are to be docked £448,000. That puts the matter in a nutshell. We were not asked to pay last year and we got the £448,000 that is being withheld this year. The Government come along and say now: "We will remit half the annuities and compel you to pay the other half and because we are making a reduction of half on paper we are going to dock you £448,000." That is the most illogical and dishonest argument I ever heard. Deputy Corry, with all his blustering in this House, is a very simple man and is very useful to the members on this side. He tells us a lot of things that other members on that side would not tell us. To show the simplicity of Deputy Corry, let me refer to a statement made by him recently in this House. He stated that the remission of the unpaid annuities would be a great relief to the ratepayers. What were his grounds for that statement? His contention was that the man who did not pay any annuities for a good many years and who had them remitted now would, because he would be required to pay half the annuities in the future, pay all his rates as well as the apportioned parts of the annuities. He was referring to the man who had never paid annuities. That is the type of thinking done by Deputy Corry.
What the type of thinking of the Minister for Industry and Commerce is, it is hard to imagine. One thing exceeds the Minister's glibness and that is his arrogance and the manner in which he deals with a subject like this. It would be amusing if it were not such a tragedy to watch the manner in which he tried to cover up the situation by reference to the prosperity of the country in 1929 and the drop in prices in 1929, 1930 and 1931 as compared with the present time. He even went so far as to say that there was a bigger disparity in the prices of 1929 as compared with the prices of 1930-31 than there was in the 1931-32-33 prices. He did not expect anybody to believe any such thing. He could not expect them to believe it and he did not. Speaking in the House last week on the Unemployment Assistance Bill he said that the important thing in relation to economic affairs is the value of the production that takes place here. Then he goes on to show, as he tried to show this evening, that the disparity in figures was so great between those two years—1930 and 1931—there was such a drop in the value of production here that a Cumann na nGaedheal peace was worse than an economic war. The insinuation was that production had gone down in those years. Let us see what were the figures in those years. In his own publication we find that in 1927 the number of cattle shipped from this country was 377,965; in 1928, 421,280, in 1929, 416,410 and in 1930, 428,138. Those are the years in which quoting figures of money, due to world depression, due to things over which no Government had any control whatever, the Minister for Industry and Commerce wanted to convince the House that production had gone down in this country because the value of the articles produced in it had gone down. I certainly would not accuse the Minister of not having intelligence and ability. But that makes it all the worse when you get him making a statement like this: "In the two years the value of wheaten flour produced here decreased from £3,000,000 to £1,800,000." What are the facts? That the production of sacks of flour had not gone down in those years, but the price of foreign wheat went down and it cost the community in this country less to buy their flour. The Minister for Industry and Commerce tries to make capital out of that to show that the productivity of the country had gone down. That, to my mind, is perfectly dishonest.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce made one statement this evening that I certainly recommend very strongly to himself and his Party. He said that the proper thing for the people on this side of the House was to sit down and think and say nothing. That is the very thing that I recommend the Minister to do and which he ought to do. If the Minister, or the Front Bench, or the members of the Fianna Fáil Party would sit down and think out what is happening in this country at present they would, in my opinion, take some steps to remedy the state of affairs that is existing and that is coming upon this country. What is the position in the country at present? The position is that the country is living absolutely and entirely on its capital. Just as surely as any man might be living on the few pounds that he has in the bank or in the post office, drawing upon it week in and week out, or month in and month out, so surely is this country living on its capital.
The Minister referred to the price of milk and butter as compared with other countries. What has caused that? The subsidy. From whom? Is it a subsidy paid by England? Is it paid by Rhodesia or Australia or some foreign country? No, we pay it ourselves. We are living on a policy of subsidisation from beginning to end. How long is that going to last? How long can it last? If you were to withdraw the bounties and subsidies and the Government grants by way of road grants or anything else and withdraw pensions, whether old age pensions, military pensions, or British pensions, you would have absolutely nothing in the country. Is there any industry in the country at present living on its profits? That is a question I should like the Minister to think over. I strongly recommend the Minister to take the advice which he tendered us and to sit down and think out where he is going and where the country is going. That being the state of affairs existing, was the Government justified in withholding from the local authorities £448,000? The Minister for Industry and Commerce said it was. The reason this year was selected, he said, was because the farmers would only have to pay half the annuities this year; notwithstanding the fact that last year he told us we were able to pay nothing, and he did not ask us to pay and we got this £448,000. This is the year he selects to dock the grant, the year in which he says we must pay half the annuities.
There are only two things which would justify the withholding of this grant from county councils. One would be the increased prosperity of agriculture and the other a decrease in expenditure or else a recoupment of the revenue to the local authorities from some other quarter. Has any of those conditions been fulfilled? Absolutely none. The Government know as well as I do that the country is living on subsidisation, is living on its capital and that that cannot continue. Yet this is the time they select to dock us £448,000. Then we were asked to increase social services. We were pressed to build labourers' cottages. We are trying to build them. We have borrowed a considerable amount of money to build them. As far as our county council is concerned, and I think practically every county council in the Saorstát is in the same position, although the Government treated us with the utmost discourtesy and never informed us that our grant was to be cut—as a matter of fact they gave us to understand distinctly that it was to be the same as last year —we set out to prepare our estimates and for the sake of the workmen we maintained the roads at the usual rate. Then, when we had our estimate complete, the Government came along and said: "You must find certain other moneys from the people's pockets because we are not going to give the same grant." It was the first time that county councils had been treated in that way.
However, the county councils generally stood up to the situation and faced the position. I certainly say that as far as any general allegation is made that county councils or members of this Party went out on a "no-rates" campaign, I distinctly and definitely deny that. There was no such thing.
The position is now that, with depleted resources, county councils are trying to carry on. We are endeavouring to collect the rates against great odds. I am not referring now to any conspiracy that the Minister may say exists in any part of the country. I am referring to the fact that the prices of live stock and of agricultural produce have reached such a low ebb that the people have not money to pay. I know perfectly well what I am talking about. I was in the south of my county last Sunday week where the people every year pay their rates out of the price of their oats. What is the position there? The oats were threshed. The local dealer always gave them the sacks for the oats and he took their oats and exported them. This year he would not give the sacks; he had no sacks. He did not know what the business was going to be. The farmers had to cover up their oats in the fields after the threshing. Last week he came and gave them sacks and they are disposing of their oats at 6/- per barrel. These are people who took the advice of the Minister for Agriculture and the Fianna Fáil Party to go into tillage. How are we going to get rates from those people? I hope we will get them. We will make an effort to get them as far as we can.
I maintain that, with conditions like that in the country, it was the Government's responsibility to see that the grant was not curtailed and certainly that the position that existed in the country at the time did not justify the curtailment of the grant.
I think one of the most arrogant statements I ever heard in my life was the Minister for Industry and Commerce accusing this Party to-night of lowering public morality. Mind you, coming from the Fianna Fáil Benches it was amusing. There are many things which would not surprise me, but really that did surprise me, because there is one thing that this country will have to look to in the future and that is to try to blot out the demoralisation which Fianna Fáil has brought it. Fianna Fáil know that. They know it perfectly well. It is not a bit of a joke, nor the position of the country is not a bit of a joke. Even though Deputy Flinn and Deputy Corry and other people may make jokes about it, it is not a joke. If it were not for the tragedy it would be a huge joke—all this thing about "the British markets are gone, thank God; they were not worth holding." After all the President's statements about the British market, the only six cattle he ever had in the world he had to send them across.
Comment on this
It has cleared up in any case this question of the tariff. We have it now on oath from the gentleman who bought the cattle that he paid £15 tariff to the British Government on cattle which were only value in this State for £14. I hope that will sink into the mind of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The members of the Fianna Fáil Party have been time and again trying to tell this House and trying to tell the country that as a matter of fact we were getting better prices here than were obtained in Northern Ireland—all this smuggling notwithstanding; we were to close our eyes to that. We are to close our eyes even to the man who according to this day's paper has had to forfeit 20 cattle and £100 by way of fine. Of course he was only doing that as a kind of amusement; it was not for profit. He would not run that risk except for the sake of amusing himself. All this is a huge joke. Then we have the Minister for Industry and Commerce boasting of the price of farm produce here, which the Irish people are paying for themselves. It is a case of the right hand pocket paying the left hand pocket. To any person here who has listened to Fianna Fáil on this side of the House and listened to them on that side of the House it is really amusing. I remember the Minister for Industry and Commerce, the Minister for Finance, and Deputy Corry in particular, rising in these seats and demanding higher and greater grants for the poor ratepayers, the poor ratepayers who at that time were getting 100 per cent. more for their cattle than they are getting to-day. Fianna Fáil from these benches promised that if they ever got into power they would give us full and complete derating, and this is what we get. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Lemass, made another statement here. That was the statement which he made about ending the economic war. It will take a lot of Deputy Lemass's rhetoric to convince the people of the country that that economic war cannot be settled.
Comment on this
It will take a lot of your eloquence to convince the country that it cannot be settled.
Comment on this
Quite, and I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce knows it can be settled, and so does the Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
What we ought to have in this House is a little more common honesty. It would take us a lot further if the Government had a little more common honesty and a little less of this spurious patriotism.
Comment on this
We hear all this talk about the British market which is gone, and which was not worth maintaining, but notwithstanding all that we find from the figures that at the present time we are sending over as much to the British market as ever we sent; but at what price? They are our only buyers. The Minister thinks that is a joke too. The Minister for Finance in this House some time ago said that were it not for the fact that we have an economic war and that the stock is being held on this side the price would be much lower on the other side. Of course he is not a farmer either. We heard a lot from the Government about winning the economic war, and the people are looking out for the victory. What will the victory be when it is won? The Minister for Industry and Commerce wanted to know from us a while ago what was our policy. What he said was in effect, "I am in the dock. If you were in the dock what would you do?"
Comment on this
Exactly, "What would you do?" Make your own defence. Defend yourself in this case. It is not customary, I think, for the accused to ask the accuser, "If you were in the dock what would you do?" It is not a customary way for conducting a defence, even before the Military Tribunal.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce a question, and I should like to receive an answer. I am not inviting interruption as the Minister does, but I should like to know what is this victory we are after. What are we out to win? If we win the economic war what will we have won when we have won it?
Comment on this
Won the war, exactly —but the spoils will go to the British. They will have been gone by that time. We will have lost the market, and there will be no chance of reviving it. The President says we might as well be crying for the moon as looking for this market, notwithstanding that the only six cattle he ever had he sent over. What are we fighting for in the economic war? If there is a war on we must be fighting for something, and I should like to know what that something is if it is not the British market. The President says it is not, and I am still waiting to know what the victory will be when we have won it.
Comment on this
Exactly, why do we want to win it? There is absolutely no industry in this country at the present time living on the profits of its own undertaking. They are all subsidised. How long can that continue I should like to know? Apart from politics altogether, and apart from the fact that I am one of the Opposition, I think that the Government should seriously consider the situation from that angle. This country is absolutely and entirely living on its capital at the present time, and that cannot continue. It is no good saying to the House that the Government was entitled to reduce the Agricultural Grant this year because it had halved the annuities.
Comment on this
Last year you declared that we should not pay any annuities, that we were not able to pay; and we had that £440,000. This year you have deducted that, and still you say that we have to pay quarter of the annuities.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry told us that the withdrawal of the grants meant in Cork the withholding of £56,000. Remember that Cork did not pay any of that last year.
Comment on this
Is that so? In conclusion, I should like to say that neither of the conditions has been fulfilled which would justify the withdrawal of the agricultural grant. The two conditions which, to my mind, were essential would be that agriculture had become so prosperous that it did not need that subsidy or else the expenditure of local councils had increased by an equal amount. I maintain that neither one nor the other was in existence at the time.
Comment on this
This debate has ranged over a good many questions. Of course, there are a great many questions involved, but I think, after listening to the speech from the Minister for Industry and Commerce, the person who would have the hardihood to say that the farmers are in any way embarrassed would have a colossal "neck." The Minister, in his most dogmatic fashion, has assured the people of this country that we never were as prosperous——
Comment on this
Oh yes— and that the farmer has got everything that should make him happy and contented. The Minister went further. He cited the reduction of the land annuities to one-quarter and he told us of the various grants that the farming community will be in receipt of. He failed, however, to tell us or to admit the fact that the farmers of the country are not only paying their land annuities in full but paying the impost as well of the R.I.C. pensions and local loans. He asks the question of us: "Do we intend to pay the land annuities if we are over on the benches opposite?" I should like to ask him a question in return.
Comment on this
Suppose the British agree to your terms of arbitration and that the case goes against you, will you pay?
Comment on this
How are you going to collect these land annuities off the farmer even using the sheriff and every means you can? What will you do if the case goes against you?
Comment on this
The Minister will have to speak up a bit because that is like the ridiculous statement he made the other day. He said that he was not aware of ridiculous things when I asked him about the poultry in Longford. It is no small matter. He told me the other day that he was not aware of ridiculous things when I asked him the question was he aware that a number of poultry had been sent to the British market and because of the workings of the tariff there the exporter got a bill for 3/6 instead of receiving any return and, further, that seven people who have been in permanent employment for years are now unemployed. That, to him, is a ridiculous thing that he is not aware of. It would be much better if the Minister would go out through the country and consult the farming community who have large families to support and who are faced with the increased rate that the withdrawal of this amount has imposed on them. I agree that there are people in the country able to pay the rates and I hope they will pay them. I agree that, because of the circumstances in which we find ourselves, obedience to the law is the best doctrine anybody can preach in this country and, as one who has preached that doctrine since we got our own Parliament, I am glad the stage has arrived in which everybody in this House, including the Government, is preaching the doctrine of obedience to the law. The charge was made here this evening by Deputy Kennedy—I am sorry that he is not here at the moment—that the Farmers' Party in his county started the "no rates" campaign. I admit that he did not start a "no rates" campaign in his own county, but he certainly came to my county in 1931, to the village of Ballinamuck, and there preached that doctrine to the large farmers and the small farmers of the Ballinamuck district and, consequently, to the people of Longford. He said that the first responsibility of the farmers was to feed and clothe themselves and their families and to let the sheriffs and the Government go to hell, to use his exact words. That was all right for a Fianna Fáil Deputy then in Opposition, but it seems that is very bad tactics for a Fianna Fáil Deputy when he happens to be a member of the Government Party. I should like to remind him and the members of the Government opposite that if there is a "no rates" campaign in any part of the country it is in the part where they themselves have the greatest support, and that that is due in no small measure to the policy they preached for the years in which they were in Opposition.
During the election of 1932 the farmers were told that they were robbed; that Mr. Cosgrave was the greatest robber that ever God put into this country; that he frittered away £5,000,000 of the people's money. They told the people "Return us to office and we will relieve you of that £5,000,000 right away. We will give you complete derating and increase the grants necessary for the social services. We will build houses as fast as mushrooms," and so on. There is no use in going into all they said—employment for everybody, etc. Where are those promises gone? They were then talking to a farming community who were receiving prices for their produce from 20 per cent. to 30 per cent., and in some cases, 60 per cent. more than they are receiving to-day. They promised that if they were returned to office the farming community would be put into the heaven that Mr. Lemass, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, attempts to contend that they are in now.
In every part of the country the farming community are hard hit, and the time when they are hard hit is the time that the Government decides to reduce this Agricultural Grant. When the income of the farming community has been depressed by 30 per cent., 40 per cent. or 50 per cent. that is the time the Government select to put an additional load on their shoulders. They tell us that the farming community are in the front line of trenches and that they are going to receive some benefit later on. What are the benefits that the farmers can secure if this policy of the Government continues? The Minister does not tell them whether or not it is the restoration of the market. He does not tell them whether he is going to increase the price of the oats that are now lying unsaleable in every barn in the country. But he tells them to get on and develop the policy of Fianna Fáil, namely, the policy of self-sufficiency. That is the self-sufficiency which if brought to its logical conclusion will see the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce standing behind the little wheel down the country spinning and doing things like that until the time comes when we will be all wearing the bawneens.
I admit that there is very much to commend the promotion of cottage industries and that these would help the people to exist perhaps in the frugal comfort outlined by the Government. But at the same time we have a market within very easy distance of our country, and it is natural that we should do everything possible to do what all the countries in the world are doing—to retain that market. It has been pointed out here this evening that when the President, or perhaps it should be the Attorney-General, had a a few cattle to sell there was only one place in which to sell them—Great Britain. It is an extraordinary situation too that cattle, valued at £14 in Dublin, a price said to be a good price, had to pay a tariff at the other side of over 100 per cent. That is a most extraordinary situation indeed.
We are told day after day that the Northern Ireland farmer is not a bit better off than the farmer in the Saorstát and that prices for cattle and agricultural produce in Northern Ireland are not better than the prices here. If that is the case—we know, of course, that it is not—why should people in the Free State try to smuggle cattle across the Border? What would be the advantage? The extraordinary statement was made here this evening that there were attempts being made to bring cattle and agricultural produce here and that they were being smuggled across the Border into the Saorstát. That would certainly be like bringing coals to Newcastle.
The County Longford is a county of small farmers, at least the greater part of the county is. In every case the reduction of this grant means a considerable increase in the rates. No matter how small the farm is or how small the rent or how small the valuation, the farmer in any one of his sales in the local fairs pays his rent and rates in full through the operation of the tariffs. As a matter of fact, the housewife by the loss that she has sustained in the sale of her poultry and eggs without including cattle, sheep or pigs at all, pays the rent and rates three or four times over. In any one of these small farms there is reared a flock or two of turkeys, a flock or two of geese, and large numbers of chickens. It was from these sources that the farmer's wife in many cases derived her income, and she did a great number of things with the money so earned. Now, that whole trade has been completely wiped out.
The housewife has been sustaining very heavy losses since the commencement of the economic war in the matter of her poultry and eggs. For the last month in particular that whole trade has been completely wiped out. It was with the money made on these things that the farmer's wife paid for a number of the small things she had to purchase for the house. Very often, too, the workmen's wages were paid out of these moneys. Yet, at the very time when that income had been wiped out, at the time when the majority of these people are brought face to face with poverty, that is the time when the Government says "you must pay more rates than you paid last year; we are going to reduce the Agricultural Grant by £448,000." Therefore, I contend that the members of this House, no matter on which side they sit, whether on these benches or on the opposite side, should have the interests of the farming community at heart and should support this motion. If members on the Government Benches do not want to support this motion publicly, I submit that it is their duty and it is their responsibility to tell the Government the hardships they are imposing on the people and to induce them to take steps at the earliest possible moment to relieve the people from these hardships. It is their duty to use all their influence with the Government to induce them to restore that £448,000 which the Government has taken from the Agricultural Grant. Furthermore, it is the duty of the Fianna Fáil supporters to see that the moneys that have been funded under the Land Bill, which are to be paid to the Central Fund should be paid in full to the local authorities. These moneys, beyond question, are due to the local authorities and they should be paid to them in full, thereby relieving the farming community to some extent, at any rate, of the burdens which they are now compelled to bear.
Mr. Davis rose.