Workmen's Compensation Bill, 1933—Committee. - Debate Resumed on Amendment 2.
Contributions 1–199 of 402. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 44 of 1933 ›
When progress was reported yesterday we were discussing this proposal, in the name of Deputy Costello, that the definition of dependency contained in sub-section (2) of Section 7 should be deleted, and that the law in that respect should remain as it is at present. In the course of that discussion a certain amount of unnecessary heat was introduced, and I think members of the Dáil, in their anxiety to score points in debate, began to lose sight of the question involved. I should like to ask that this question be reconsidered without that heat and with a view to arriving at a conclusion which will secure the enactment of the measure in the best form possible having regard to the circumstances. I am sure there are no members of the Dáil who feel it possible to make substantial polical capital out of a Bill of this nature and I should dislike very much that the Bill should be made the means of achieving political kudos or in any other way be used for the purpose of accentuating or emphasising Party differences. I think it was Deputy Dillon said yesterday that we are passing a Bill here which is likely to fix the law in relation to workmen's compensation for a number of years and that an opportunity of reconsidering whatever decision we make now may not arise for some time. Consequently it is undesirable that this decision should be taken on Party grounds, or for the purpose of securing any temporary Party advantage.
I have very carefully gone into the whole matter at issue since the Dáil adjourned last evening, and tried, as calmly as I could, to place before myself all the arguments on both sides. Having done so, I have come to the conclusion that no case for amending the Bill has been made. The suggestion was made that this sub-section embodied a reactionary proposal, that, in some way, it was an attempt to infringe the rights of the workers, and that the existing law was more beneficial to them than this Bill would be, when it became an Act. The most effective answer to the claim that the sub-section of the Bill embodies a reactionary proposal is that this was the first time that claim was made. Until yesterday, so far as I have been able to discover, nobody had asserted that this particular phrase was contrary to the interests of labour, and particularly, that claim has not been made by any Labour leader. The phrase was recommended in Great Britain by the Inter-Departmental Committee which the British Government established in 1923, on which there were prominent Labour leaders. These Labour leaders subscribed to the report. It is notable that they attached to the report an addendum of their own in which they dissociated themselves from certain recommendations, but they did not dissociate themselves from the recommendation in this particular matter.
The British Act of 1923 was passed and, so far as I have been able to discover, was passed in this respect, at any rate, with the approval of the Labour representatives in the British Parliament. In 1925 another British Act was passed embodying the same phrase, and again that phrase appears to have had the support of the Labour Party in Great Britain. The Inter-Departmental Committee on Workmen's Compensation which was established here in 1925 also included in its membership a number of prominent Irish Labour leaders. The report they submitted was an unanimous report and, in the absence of proof to the contrary, I must accept it that the Labour members of that Committee agreed to the recommendation made in this connection. I refer also to the fact that following the publication of this Bill I had an opportunity of discussing it in detail with representatives of Irish organised labour, in the form of a deputation from the Irish Trades Union Congress. Deputy Norton told us that if he had been present on the second occasion I met the deputation he would have raised this point. The fact is that it was not raised, although the deputation came very well briefed indeed. Consequently, it was not until yesterday I had any indication, from any source whatever, that the phrase it is proposed to insert in the Bill was considered objectionable to Labour interests. If that contention was made it was made yesterday for the first time.
What is the origin of this phrase? The first appearance of it occurred in a judicial decision in Great Britain, a long number of years ago, a decision subsequently reversed by the decision which was quoted here yesterday, which was given by Lord Halsbury in 1900. That decision of 1900 operated until the Act of 1923 was passed. It still operates here. The Committee which was established in Great Britain considered this matter, and in their report they did something which the Committee here did not do; that is, they set out the considerations which weighed with them when making their recommendation. I presume most members of the Dáil who have interested themselves in this matter have read the report, from which they will have seen that the phrase was adopted by the Committee from the Statute of the State of Massachusetts, where it was interpreted in the leading case in that connection in the following words:—
"The test of dependency is not whether the petitioner, by reducing his expenses below a standard suitable to his condition of life, could secure a subsistence for his family without the contributions of the deceased son, but whether such contributions were needed to provide the family with the ordinary necessaries of life suitable for persons in their class and position."
I quote that because the suggestion was made here yesterday that the phrase "suitable for persons in their class and position" was inserted for the purpose of limiting the amount of compensation which the relatives of a deceased worker might obtain. The fact is they are inserted there to ensure that the provision to be provided will not be the barest minimum which will sustain life, but an amount which will provide the necessaries of life, having regard to the class and the position of the person concerned. The interpretation which has been put upon that phrase in the courts in America and in the courts in Great Britain has operated to that end. It has astonished me that members of the House who have been suggesting that this phrase, which appears in the British Act, should not be inserted in our Act, have not attempted to support their contention by any proof that the operation of the sub-section in Great Britain has resulted in hardship. The proof is all to the contrary. Deputies who take the opportunities available to ascertain what are the facts in that regard will find that what I am saying is true.
I do not want to stress the argument that it is desirable that legislation here should conform to legislation in Great Britain. So far as I have been able to discover from Departmental records, the policy of my predecessor was to enact legislation in a form which would keep it as close as possible to the form in the British Act. Not merely was that decision made by my predecessor, but it was made by the Executive Council of which he was a member. That argument could, undoubtedly, be stressed too far. We have to bear in mind that, apart from one or two mutual companies, there are no Irish mutual insurance companies doing workmen's compensation at present. We trust that that position will be remedied at some stage. In so far as any litigation may arise out of this sub-section, it will probably be litigation initiated by English companies, that have had ten years' experience of the operation of the sub-section and are familiar with the interpretations placed upon it by the British courts.
The two main arguments against the insertion of the sub-section were (1) it was reactionary in so far as it was detrimental to the interest of the workers—and that argument I am quite satisfied holds no weight whatever; and (2) it would lead to a considerable amount of litigation. The second argument, of course, could be used against the whole Bill. If the sole purpose is to avoid litigation there would be no purpose in changing the existing law at all, which has been in operation for almost 30 years. The intention, however, is, and I gather that it is the agreed purpose of all Parties, to endeavour to improve the law and I suggest that this is an improvement of the law and that it secures that the compensation paid to the partial dependants of a deceased worker will not be paid as at present where no question of actual dependency arises at all and the only question at issue is the financial injury resulting from the workman's death. The view I hold is that it is difficult to justify payment for compensation to persons who are not, in fact, dependent for support on the earnings of the deceased workman. The purpose of the Bill is to ensure that those who were dependent for support on the earnings of a workman killed or injured in an accident should be provided for. The present practice resulting from the interpretation put on the law by judicial decisions is that compensation is paid in respect of financial injury, in respect of the pecuniary loss sustained by the relatives of the workman. In my opinion it should be paid on the basis of compensating them for the loss of support and should be qualified so as to ensure that support in that connection will not merely mean the amount of assistance which will support life but the amount of assistance which will support the life heretofore enjoyed by the persons concerned and by persons in the same class and position.
The issue is, I think, quite clear. The argument in favour of the existing law is that any change in it will give rise to litigation. That is the first argument. It is undoubtedly true that the exact interpretation of this section will only be fixed by judicial decisions and we have to bear in mind the fact that it is in operation for 10 years in Great Britain and that although decisions of British courts do not bind the courts here, nevertheless the knowledge of what these decisions are will deter people from seeking to get interpretations placed on the section in the courts here where similar attempts in Great Britain have failed. Consequently, I do not feel that the argument about litigation need worry us, particularly having regard to the fact that we are making in this Bill a number of changes in the existing law and the argument could be used equally effectively against any one of them.
The other argument is that the change proposed is reactionary. I deny that. I deny that it is in any sense a worsening of the position of the relatives of a workman who is killed at his work. The section has not operated in that direction in Great Britain and the usual legal records which I have examined show that quite clearly and put it beyond dispute. Deputies who advert to them will, I think, see that for themselves. On the other hand, we have the fact that the change does bring the law into conformity with the main ideal behind it—the idea of compensating people for loss of support through the death of a relative. The fact that it has been recommended not merely by an Inter-Departmental Committee here representative of organised labour and organised employers, that it has been recommended by an Inter-Departmental Committee in Great Britain similarly composed and that it has been the law in Great Britain for 10 years, shows there is some case for keeping the law in conformity or, at any rate, for not needlessly bringing it out of conformity, and I think the balance of argument is in favour of leaving the Bill unchanged and resisting the amendment that has been suggested.
Comment on this
When the Minister for Industry and Commerce rose to-day he began by making a very commendable appeal for the absence of Party spirit. Having made his appeal, he went on to suggest that Party feeling had manifested itself last night and that it was sought to make Party capital out of this amendment. I want to remind the Minister that before the Committee Stage was taken at all, I asked him to send this Bill to a Select Committee, the proceedings of which would be private so that we could discuss it as much as we wanted to quite freely and come back here with an agreed measure and that no one could be tempted to try to make Party capital out of it. In fact, he declined to do that, Heaven knows why. I want further to adduce as evidence of our entire disinclination to introduce the Party spirit into this, the fact that when we came to discuss this, Deputy Morrissey and I differed as to the desirability of this amendment, and made no secret of it. So far as this Party is considering this Bill in Committee, we do not regard the Party Whips as being on at all. We do not consider that there is any obligation on any member of this Party to vote one way or another except as his conscience dictates on a measure of this kind.
We are perfectly clear, those of us who have so far contributed to this debate, that this proviso is a bad proviso. It applies almost exclusively to all these family pool arrangements. Contrary to what the Minister thinks, the effect of this new sub-section, in my opinion, will be to reduce the claim of a bereaved person to anything in excess of bare necessities. Under the law as it stood, and as it stands, the measure of a person's damage from the death of a relative was the difference between what the maintenance of that relative cost and what that relative contributed to the family pool. Under the proposed new law, the measure of the loss will be so much of that difference as is necessary for the provision of the ordinary necessaries of life suitable for persons in his class and position.
Comment on this
Why does the Deputy say that? Has that been the interpretation put on the section in Great Britain or America?
Comment on this
There is the Peart v. Bolckow, Vaughan & Co., Ltd. case taken from the 1924 reports. I have not got the big book of case law in reference to this. I have only a couple of cases before me, and the principle was further decided and has been most authoritatively decided in the Young and Londonderry Collieries Company, 1924, taken from the 17th Butterworth Workmen's Compensation Cases, page 215.
Comment on this
It is perfectly manifest from the decision that the principle accepted is that where it was held that the surplus of the person's contribution, after his maintenance had been deducted, was the sum which would provide the family with a measure of luxury over and above the bare necessities, they were not entitled to claim in respect of that surplus. You had, therefore, a situation where a family living in very humble circumstances— and mind you, the arbitrator was entitled to take into consideration his personal knowledge of the general conditions under which the class of person he had to deal with was living— and the arbitrator knew that he was entitled to take those circumstances into consideration, and to say that the difference between the maintenance of the deceased person and his contribution to the pool is £1 per week, but that any part of that over 10/- is not essential to the provision of the ordinary necessaries of life suitable for persons in the claimant's class or position, and he must therefore assess the damage done to the claimant on the basis of his having lost 10/- per week.
All we want is that the law should be left as it was and that the court should decide the measure of damage by the amount of the actual loss. Otherwise it seems to me we shall have a situation arising in which a poor family will not be entitled to as generous measure of damages under the Act as a family living in comparatively comfortable surroundings. As far as I can see that is the situation which the new proposal will create and has created in Great Britain. I think that in so far as it has been created, that part of the workmen's compensation code in Great Britain is wrong and we would make a great mistake in following it. The difficulty in this situation and the difficulty that is going to come up against us is, that in dealing with a question of this kind in Committee of the House, you will have lawyers—and I do not wish the Minister for Industry and Commerce to leap to his feet in a moment and say that I am placing myself in this category; specifically I am not—but you will have lawyers of distinction getting up and taking different views of what the effect of a section of this character is likely to be in the Irish courts. You will have them even taking different views as to what the consensus of opinion expressed from the judicial bench in England is. One will take the view that one case is peculiarly authoritative. Another will take the view that another case is peculiarly authoritative, and that if he had to go into court to put up one case, he could pull the court with that case, whereas an equally distinguished lawyer may take the view that by putting up the other case he could pull the judicature of this country to that view. All I wanted was that we should have a committee where counsel and practising barristers in this country could come before us and express their opinion on such questions as this—say what in their opinion would be the judicial interpretation of a section of this kind in the light of the general trend of Irish law. Even at this eleventh hour I think that suggestion might very profitably be carried out. I want to assure the Minister that there is not the slightest inclination on this side of the House to dragoon him or to pillory him as being on the side of the poor or against them. I am convinced that this is a bad provision although the Minister may be convinced that it is going to be a good provision. I am merely trying to express my point of view as the Minister is quite entitled to express his.
Comment on this
Notwithstanding the statement that I made last night to the effect that the signatures of the Labour members who sat on the 1925 Departmental Inquiry must not be taken as indicating that they endorsed everything in that report, the Minister comes along as fresh as ever to make the same allegation to-day.
Comment on this
Why must they not be taken as endorsing the report? Surely the assumption is that they agreed with the report they signed.
Comment on this
The Minister is not a child in politics by any means. I was a member of the Committee which appointed these three persons to the Inter-Departmental Committee. I know the problem that faced them when they came to the report and I know they disagreed with many of the recommendations contained in the report, but in order to get an agreed report they were willing to tolerate certain disadvantages in order to get certain advantages. Although they are not asked now to stand over that position, I am perfectly prepared in their name to take that report as it was signed by them with its advantages and to put up with its disadvantages. But as I said last night, we are not being asked to implement the report. The report has been cut down in certain important respects.
Comment on this
The Minister knows perfectly well that the Bill is not making the provisions which were made in the report. If the Minister compares the recommendations in the report with the provisions of the Bill he will be more convinced than ever of that fact. We were perfectly prepared to take a Bill based on the report, but this Bill has deviated from the report in many respects. While we are prepared to take the advantages with the disadvantages of the report, it is quite another matter when you come to ask us to take the disadvantages of the report without giving us in the Bill the advantages which the report gave us. The Minister again said that this was the first he heard of this opposition. From the first we were opposed to this particular section of the Bill, so when the matter was mentioned last night——
Comment on this
It is the first time I have seen it suggested that Labour representatives were opposed to it, having regard to the fact that Labour representatives in Great Britain and in this country signed a recommendation making this change.
Comment on this
I have explained already that they signed the report taking its advantages and its disadvantages.
Comment on this
I am not responsible for what they did there any more than the Minister is. The Minister has said that he did not hear of the opposition to this section until now. Again I say that I was chairman of the joint committee of the Trade Union Congress which examined this section and which prepared the brief which the Minister said the deputation had. I have already told the Minister of the circumstances which prevented my being there on the second occasion. I think that Deputy Dillon has shown that there is a very strong case for leaving the law in this respect as it stands, as it has stood for the past 30 years or for over 30 years. It seems to me to be almost impossible for anybody reasonably to argue that this section is put into the Bill for the purpose of assisting the workman or assisting the dependants of the workman because the whole phraseology approaches the matter from the point of view of limiting the compensation and the actual extent of the dependency by referring to "the necessaries of life suitable for persons in the class and position of the claimant." As Deputy Dillon pointed out in the case of the person who is contributing, over and above what he got back from the family, a sum of £1 per week, if it can be shown in court that only 10/- of that £1 is necessary to provide the necessaries of life suitable to the dependant's class and position, then it seems to me that the courts under this particular section will have to say: "You will only get compensation based on the 10/- per week, because in the view of the court when it came to construe this section, that was all that was necessary in your domestic circumstances to provide the necessaries of life." I should like the Minister to address himself to that particular point. If he examines the subject and adverts to that point he will have no hesitation in recognising that this section is put in definitely to restrict the facilities which were open to claimants in the past. Its only effect can be to make it more and more difficult for the dependants of a workman to receive compensation. It would seem that in future a person will have to go into court and not merely prove that he was partially dependent on a person who has lost his life, but bring in the family budget and show that what he was consuming were necessaries of life and that there were no luxuries in it. If there were luxuries in it, it seems to me that the courts, inevitably, will have to say in respect to the luxuries no compensation, and in respect to the ordinary necessaries of life some compensation, but there may be wide discrepancy between the view of one person as to what are ordinary necessaries of life and the view of another person. The family motor car might have to be scrapped by a decision of the judge.
Comment on this
That is why these words are put in there—to decide what are the necessaries of life having regard to the station of life occupied by the person concerned.
Comment on this
Surely, everybody who likes a motor car is entitled to have one—the farm labourer just as much as the professional man living on Merrion Square, the farmer who is able to buy an old family Ford just as much as the man who can afford to purchase a costly motor car. Everybody knows that, as a result of this, the family Ford is going to go, because the judge is going to say: "This is not a necessary of life, and it is a most intolerable thing for a man like you to be driving around the country in a motor car." All that restriction will be imposed under this particular section. I think that the Minister might well leave this 30-year-old judgment alone, and he would be dealing much more fairly with the people concerned.
Comment on this
There is one matter to which Deputy Norton has not referred, and that is that this particular amendment of the law in Great Britain took place in 1923 for the first time and, after that, a Labour Government was in office and no attempt was made to alter the law so as to restore what he describes as a 30-year-old judgment. If Deputy Norton looks at this 30-year-old judgment, the Main Colliery case, he will see, I think, that one of the matters which troubled the court was, that they found a difficulty in exactly understanding what was the meaning intended to be given to the word "dependant." One of the reasons they arrived at that particular decision was the difficulty which they saw in getting hold of some other standard with sufficient precision to enable it to be clearly understood and clearly followed, and to become a sort of working rule for courts subsequently in the interpretation of the section of the 1897 Act which was then under discussion. I would submit to the House, however, that we are now in this position, that while prima facie one would be inclined to agree—particularly lawyers—with the view of the court in that regard, circumstances are altered for us now in considering this suggested amendment here. First of all, you have the fact that in Great Britain 23 years after that decision was given, the legislature there—and apparently, from what the Minister has said, and his statement has not been contradicted, with the concurrence of Labour representatives in Great Britain—made this amendment in the law which really brings the law into conformity with what was the intention of the framers of this particular type of legislation. You have the fact, therefore, that that was done in England and was done, as the Minister has said, apparently with the concurrence of the Labour representatives.
While I do not want to suggest that we should be copying English legislation in matters of this kind, there is this very strong consideration which, I think, is very appropriate to this particular type of legislation and particularly appropriate in this very Bill: that the legislature in England, in considering legislation of this kind, has a much greater amount of material at its disposal to enable it to decide what is the proper type of legislation, what is fair legislation, and how the scales are to be balanced between the claims of the workmen and the obligations of the employers. In England they are, in some proportion, almost as industrialised as we are an agricultural community in this country; and while, as I said a moment ago, it may not be justifiable, possibly, to suggest that we should always look at their Acts in dealing with matters that we are considering here, I do suggest strongly to the House that, having regard to their peculiar position and the circumstances which obtain there, more than ordinary attention should be paid to an enactment such as this Act of 1923, followed by an Act of 1925 in England, which is now under discussion. Moreover, when, as appears to be clear, Labour in England which, again, has a much wider range of material at its command, I am sure, through its various organisations, unions and so on— when, as I say, Labour in England, which has ample material ready to be called on at a moment's notice on the most minute point of industrial legislation, has allowed and did allow that amendment to creep into the law in 1923 and 1925, I think we should give some weight to that consideration. Perhaps I should not use the word "creep." The amendment came in quite openly and, in the discussion in the Houses of Parliament, was not attacked or condemned as far as we know. Possibly, there may be some reports which show that it was attacked by British Labour representatives, but, so far as we can trace, British Labour representatives inside and outside the House of Commons in England allowed this 23-year-old decision to come into the law in England. That consideration alone, I would suggest to the Labour representatives here and to other members of the House, is something which ought to have some weight in discussing this section.
Following that, a period of two years elapsed, after which this particular section again came under review in the British House of Commons and was embodied in the Act of 1925. It was not embodied merely by reference, but specifically and verbatim re-enacted in the 1925 Act. Again, as far as we can trace, Labour representatives either inside or outside the House of Commons in England do not appear to have criticised it or to have condemned as reactionary those who were introducing it into legislation there.
Comment on this
That suggests to my mind this: As I said during my opening remarks, British Labour representatives are in a much better position, as are the British employer representatives and as are the members of the British House of Commons, to estimate the effects of a section such as this and in a much better position to consider the way in which it would operate and to examine the arguments for and against it when under discussion. Such an Act as this would have been intensely wider in its effects in England than it would be here. The effects must have been brought home to thousands more people there than they would be here. If Labour in Great Britain allowed this provision to pass without opposition and allowed it to be re-enacted after two years without opposition, I suggest to Deputy Norton that that is a consideration of some importance in deciding whether or not we should follow on the lines of the British legislature. He may not think so, but I commend that aspect of the question to the Deputy's consideration and to the consideration of the other Deputies who are taking this issue seriously. It is very easy to say that this is a reactionary provision and that it is unnecessary. Prima facie, the considerations I have mentioned would dispose one to the view that the amendment of the law made in Great Britain was not an unreasonable one. Experience of the working of the older judgment had shown the amendment to be not unreasonable. Ten years have elapsed since the new section was brought into operation in England and, in those ten years it was possible to test whether the fears expressed by one of the judges were realised. Lord Davy said:
"I agree with my noble and learned friend of the Woolsack that that is a much more satisfactory way of construing this Act—to look at the actual income and expenditure rather than introduce some vague and uncertain standard which it is impossible to lay down with precision."
That would appeal to a lawyer and it appealed to the court there. Approaching this question as a lawyer, one would say that that is a very sound reason for not departing from the law as it exists at the moment. But, with these views before them, the British Parliament did make this change in the law. Now, they have had ten years' experience of its operation in England. If the critics are relying on that argument—it is one they ought to be able to rely upon if they want to induce people of commonsense to take their view—they should be able to bring forward some statement as to the operations of this section in England. They should be able to show how far the courts have found difficulty in construing this provision, how far the law has been thrown into confusion and what anomalies have arisen by reason of the change condemned so vigorously by Deputy Dillon.
I have here, as I assume Deputy Dillon has, a recent Willis, in which the effect of this amendment of the law is summarised. Like the Deputy, I have not got the complete reports but I looked at the reports of some of the cases. So far as I can see, there was a certain volume of litigation in England about this provision. Although I shall hardly be taken as seriously wishing that litigation should be diminished, I do agree that it would be unfortunate if the introduction of this amendment were to produce a crop of litigation and throw the insurance companies, the employers and the workmen into a state of confusion as to the effect of the new section. Within the period of ten years which has elapsed since the introduction of this section, the courts have laid down certain principles. If Deputy Dillon examines the samples of the cases given in Willis, he will find that the new section in England does, in fact, carry out what was the intention of the original Act and that this decision of the House of Lords really widened the scope of the section beyond what its original framers intended. There do not appear to be many cases on the question in England but there are a certain number. The judges there have been able to lay down certain principles to guide the county court judges in construing this section. One thing that still remains as a first principle is that dependency is still a question of fact. I imagine that in ninety-nine cases out of a hundred—I was going to say in nine cases out of ten—this particular amendment will not produce a different result from what would have been produced under the other section. The Deputy may ask "If that be so, why change the law?" After all, this was progressive legislation and it did improve the position of the workers. Unless we adopt the principle that any person who suffers pecuniary loss by the death of another is entitled to compensation, unless we go the whole way on the lines of Lord Campbell's Act, it seems to be quite reasonable that some evidence should be required that the claimant was deriving benefit from the earnings of the deceased in the sense of relying upon that person for support. That is all the word "dependent" originally seemed to mean. That was what the first decision in England held it to mean. That was what the text writers held it to mean and it was only after this decision that the word got a wider meaning. They have in England gone away from that. They have enacted this provision without serious opposition from those who ought to be, who are regarded as being, and who, Mr. Norton must admit, would be the severest critics of any type of reactionary legislation affecting the working classes. That legislation has been ten years in operation in England. During that time, there was a Labour Government in office in England. So far as I am aware, no serious suggestion was made that that section should be repealed and a return made to the earlier provision.
The decisions of the courts here need not follow the decisions in England. When I say that certain principles have been laid down by the courts in England, I do not argue that the same principles would necessarily be laid down here. It is quite possible that different principles would be laid down by the courts here. But if anomalies arose or if hardships were brought about it would be quite possible to have the law again amended. I suggest that there is no really serious argument against following the example of a country which has more experience of industrial conditions than we have, and I think that the section should be enacted in the form in which it appears.
Comment on this
I want to say very briefly, in reply to the observations made by the Minister in his opening remarks to-day, that in putting down this amendment I had no intention of making any Party capital out of the matters that are involved in the amendment or in the sub-section, nor did I expect that any such considerations could possibly arise on such an amendment. They were very far from my mind and from my expectations and it came as a surprise to me that such considerations were allowed to arise yesterday. I may say that we have no intention of making this Bill a Party measure. I have only one intention and that is to do what I conceive to be in the best interests of the working people who are to be affected by this Bill. Might I say, without offence to the Minister, and I am sure he will take it in the proper spirit, that he is rather too much of the advocate for this Bill? Without entering into any consideration as to whether my observations yesterday to the effect that this is a reactionary measure were responsible for the subsequent heat or whether the Minister's observations about our hypocrisy were responsible, may I suggest that he should not be so much of the advocate for the Bill? He may possibly take up the attitude that this Bill is as much his predecessor's as his Bill.
The point is that every Party in the House wants to improve the Bill. We have discussed this matter at considerable length and, of course, we could, if we so desired, have a grand cabman's holiday here, those of us who are interested in the legal profession, reading cases from Butterworth and Willis and quoting other cases from the Irish and British Courts on the various sections. We could, if we wished, keep the Dáil going for a very considerable period in that way, but the fact of the matter is that we merely want to improve this Bill from the point of view of the working classes. It is a remarkable fact that the British House of Lords, in their decisions over the last 30 years, have in practically every instance given the most liberal interpretation to these Employers' Liability and Workmen's Compensation Acts and they have always given decisions in favour of the workmen. That is a remarkable fact, but it happens to be perfectly true, and every court leans towards giving a liberal interpretation in favour of the workman to any of the provisions of legislation of the character we are not enacting.
But if our courts, coming to construe this measure, find themselves in the position that the legislature here has had an opportunity of stating definitely what is to be the law, having regard to British decisions on similar legislation in England, then it may be that the courts here will find themselves fettered in their desire to give a liberal interpretation to this legislation in favour of the workman. This sub-section, so far from being what the Minister appears to think it is—and I think the Attorney-General supports him in so thinking—a matter of clarity and freedom from doubt, is quite uncertain, and the latest British decision on the sub-section has left the matter in complete uncertainty. The British House of Lords has refused to determine what exactly is the meaning of these words to which we take exception in this sub-section. We are now proposing to enact a sub-section which is left by a recent decision of the British House of Lords in a state of complete uncertainty as to its interpretation.
This amendment was put down by me for this reason, that some months ago it fell to my lot, in the course of my practice, to consider this question of partial dependency in connection with an actual case, and I had to determine the state of the law here and in England. I came to the conclusion that if ever a Workmen's Compensation Bill came into this House, and I had any control over it, I would see that this sub-section (2) would not get into the Bill. It was for that reason I put down the amendment. I convinced myself as an ordinary practitioner on the hazard that this was a bad sub-section from the point of view of the worker. It was not through any, motives of political expediency or Party capital that the amendment appeared on the paper.
I did not adduce the argument yesterday that this was a copy of the British section or that this measure is largely a copy of the British Act. I do not think that is an argument against the measure. I think in legislation of this character it is eminently desirable that, so far as possible, and so far as the differing conditions in the two countries allow, the legislation should be parallel here with what obtains in England. As the Attorney-General pointed out, they have great experience I of this class of thing in England and we may well benefit by that experience. My object is to enable the working people to benefit by the experience which the British people have had for years.
The Minister told us that he had convinced himself that no case had been made against the section. In putting forward that observation he showed himself to be what I have already said—I hope without offence to him—an advocate for this Bill. He is not in the position of being bound to stand over every line and section in the Bill. If it is pointed out to him now, as I believe we have conclusively pointed out to him, that this sub-section is against the interests of the working people and is taking away the rights of the partial dependants of working people which they have enjoyed for a period of 33 years, it is not an answer to say that, because the Labour Party here or in England have never objected to a similar provision, it should stay in. I think that is no argument. The fact that the consequences of this sub-section have not been brought to the consideration of the Labour Party may possibly account for the fact that they have not raised this matter. Now that it is raised I suggest it is a matter worthy of attention and should not be brushed aside lightly by merely saying that the British and Irish Labour Party have never raised the matter.
We feel we have made a conclusive case against the proposal in the Bill. When you are changing a state of affairs that has existed for the benefit of the working people for 33 years, it is the duty of the people making the change to bring forward a conclusive case in favour of it and it is not for those who object to it to be called upon to prove that the section is not going to work properly and in the interests of the working people. The Attorney-General advances the argument, as I understood him, that this amendment really gives effect to what was the intention of the legislature as far back as 1899.
I think I dealt with that argument yesterday when I said that this sub-section does not give effect to the intention originally of the legislature because the House of Lords in 1900 authoritatively declared what was the intention of the legislature, different to what is contained in this sub-section and as admitted by the Minister. This sub-section proposes to change the decision given by the House of Lords 33 years ago. But assuming that the House of Lords, in the year 1900, had stated "although we believe it to have been the intention of the legislature to have enacted something other than we are going to decide, yet they have enacted what we are deciding. In other words, we are deciding contrary to the intention of the legislature and to the strict letter of the law." Assume that they did that in 1900. In the year 1906 that same legislature, with the decision of the House of Lords before them and after-six years had passed, gave legislative sanction to that decision of the House of Lords. So that I am entitled to say this, that when the British legislature, in 1906, allowed the House of Lords decision to stand and to continue to be the law of the land, the intention of the legislature from 1906 onwards was perfectly clear. Now you are deliberately to set aside what was the intention of the legislature in 1900 and what was the practice in this country for the last 33 years.
The Minister said that these words, "suitable for persons in his class and position" were put in for the benefit of the worker. If, and in so far as they are for the benefit of the workman, I have no objection to them, but they were the same words that were used in the judgment that was set aside by the House of Lords in 1900. The House of Lords decided in 1900 to set aside these words in favour of the partial dependence of the working people. But assuming that they are in favour of the working man, and assuming that the intention of putting them in is in favour of the working people, the phrase that we object to is the phrase "provision for the ordinary necessaries of life." That is what we object to. That is the vicious portion of this sub-section, because it will impose upon the people who claim to be partial dependants of the workman, the necessity for coming into court and discharging the onus cast upon them by this sub-section, and proving that the money they got from the deceased workman was spent by them on the ordinary necessaries of life. It will be then for the court to determine whether the things in respect to which the money was spent were, in fact and in law, ordinary necessaries of life.
I do not know what any ordinary judge may decide to be the necessaries of life. The British House of Lords have left the matter in the air after ten years' experience of a similar sub-section. As the Minister has asked me to quote cases, I will do so. I would refrain from quoting cases in this Assembly, were it not that the Minister asked me. May I refer him to the most recent case on this or on a similar sub-section, the McArthur and Fife Coal Company decision in the House of Lords in 1926? That was after the 1925 Act had been some time in force, and after the 1923 Act had been in operation for some years. What is the result of this decision? Here is what the judgment says: "It would seem that the question of the effect of the statutory definition (that is, as to partial dependency) upon the method of calculating the compensation to partial dependants has yet to be discussed and has not been finally quoted by the foregoing dicta." So that the reason which is put forward by the Minister as one of the arguments which in this matter stand for themselves is that it is one of the sub-sections which bring the beneficial state of the law into force. It is bringing into force a state of law on which the British House of Lords has not yet finally decided.
I do not know yet where we stand on this matter. May I read an extract from this authority, an extract which will bring it home to the Deputies that this phrase is one of complete ambiguity and is one which will give rise to litigation which will require an authoritative decision of the Supreme Court of this country for its interpretation or definition? Here we have an opportunity of deciding definitely and authoritatively what ought to be the proper definition of this phrase and as to whether we should put this sub-section in. Yet, we are completely passing a sub-section the proper interpretation of which has not yet been decided by the British House of Lords. Here is the extract:—
"Assuming that a claimant brings himself within the statutory definition of a partial dependant, there arises the question whether the statutory definition has affected the assessment of compensation without determining the amount reasonably and proportionately to such dependants of the injured, for the person who has been a dependent of the deceased to any extent for the necessaries of life is entitled to be compensated not only for such loss but also for such luxuries on which he may have been dependent on the deceased."
Then they set out various aspects on which one says he is and another says he is not. If you put it into this sub-section you leave it still in the air.
I would ask the House to consider the position of anyone going into court on behalf of a working man and trying to prove his case and trying to bring himself within the sub-section. Bringing himself within the sub-section would be a considerable task. The position would be that it would be found that no one would be able to advise the dependants of a working man as to whether they have a good case. We are now going to put in this sub-section which so far from being properly and definitely construed with a definite and beneficial construction to the working people given to it, is a sub-section the construction of which is completely indefinite and indecisive at the present moment.
We have had a state of affairs here in this country for 33 years which has worked well. Practitioners know what they have got to prove. The judges are experienced in administering that law and the insurance companies know what they have to face. What is the case now for putting in a sub-section into this new Bill? It puts the whole matter into the melting-pot; it will leave people in a state of indecision and it will leave the working people in a state where they will not know whether they have come within the provisions for compensation or not. I fail to see how the Minister in view of the arguments brought forward here has convinced himself that this is a beneficial and clear provision. The Minister says he is convinced himself and his opinion is that this sub-section is something that would be beneficial to the working people and not to their prejudice. He may have convinced himself of that but the judges have not yet convinced themselves of it so far as a decision on a similar sub-section in England is concerned. This sub-section is going to take away the right which the partial dependants of the working people had for 33 years. In place of that you are going to put in a sub-section of which at the moment nobody is able to get a proper interpretation.
Comment on this
Question—"That the sub-section proposed to be deleted stand"—put.
Do you agree with this result?
I do not know whether anything that really arises upon the Schedule referred to in this section would not be more properly raised on the Schedule than on the section.
Comment on this
I want to raise the question of the Workmen's Compensation (Anglo-French Convention) Act of 1909. That is repealed by this section, but it may be dealt with on Section 69. I want to raise the question now with a view to seeing whether Section 69 adequately covers all the Acts referred to in this section.
Comment on this
The enactments repealed by Section 13 appear in the First Schedule. The first mentioned is the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1906; the second is the Workmen's Compensation (Anglo-French Convention) Act, 1909, which was an Act passed to implement the Convention arrived at between the British Government and the French Government to provide for certain reciprocal facilities, I think, for British workmen who suffered injury under French jurisdiction, and for French workmen who suffered injury under British or Irish jurisdiction. What I want to ask the Minister, on this section, is whether provision is made in this Bill, or whether it will be necessary to make provision in this Bill to fill the gap that will be created by the repeal of the Act of Edw. VII, c. 16, and whether, when dealing with that question, he will consider reciprocal arrangements with other States along similar lines? At the present moment I do not quite know what the arrangements are as between this country and Great Britain in respect to workmen's compensation. I think this might be a convenient opportunity for the Minister to open that question and state what the exact position is.
Comment on this
I think that question would be more properly raised on Section 69, which permits the Executive Council to enter into reciprocal arrangements with other countries and on sub-section (2) of that section which particularly relates to the Anglo-French Convention, and in connection with which power is taken to enter into agreements.
Comment on this
The House will remember that in the Expiring Laws Bill, dealt with yesterday, several Acts were left standing although we knew they were being repealed by new Bills actually passing through the House. With that analogy it seems to me that it would be more expedient to allow this French Convention Act to stand pending the arrangement of a new convention. If we pass this Bill in its present form the benefits of the 9th Edw. VII, c. 16, will cease and there will be a hiatus between the passing of this Bill and the establishment of the new convention.
Comment on this
The manner in which a convention is implemented raises a question of national status. The proposed convention between the French Government and the Saorstát will replace the existing agreement between the British Government and the Government of the Saorstát.
Comment on this
But all that cannot be done by a turn of the hand. No doubt, owing to the friendly relationship between our Government and the French, everything will be done, but meantime these formalities have to take place. I would have thought the easier way would have been to make a new convention and then to repeal this Act. But to repeal the Act first and then to embark on a new convention seems to me a dangerous procedure if we are, in fact, deriving any benefit from that Act. I do not know—the Minister has no doubt examined the question—but there may be cases arising from month to month the remedy for which is found in that Act. If we adopt the procedure proposed in the Bill a situation may arise in which one or two individuals will be deprived of their rights simply as a result of the procedure which we saw fit to follow. I take it the Adaptation of Enactments Act carried over that.
Comment on this
My learned friend thinks it is very debatable. I do not know whether it is or not. I suggest that it carried over the conventions as well as the Acts of Parliament arising out of the conventions. Certainly, whether it did or not, it is a question to be considered. We ought to know what we are doing. Unless the Minister is quite clear that no anomaly will arise from the procedure which this Bill proposes to follow, I think he ought to drop this Act from the Schedule and allow it to be dealt with by a later amending Bill. However, there is no hurry about it. Between this and the conclusion of the Committee Stage the Minister can turn that over in his mind and when we arrive at the Schedule he can decide whether it is prudent to drop this particular Act out of the Schedule or not. The other one I wanted to mention was 8 and 9 Geo. V., c. 14. That is the Silicosis Act. Is that fully provided for in the new section contained in this Bill relating to industrial diseases?
Comment on this
I move amendment 4:
In sub-section (1), line 17, after the word "accident" to insert the words "whether within or without Saorstát Eireann."
This amendment, I hope, will not give rise to any Party differences, although in the course of the discussion, perhaps, references will be made to Northern Ireland. It is to be hoped, however, that references to Northern Ireland will not arouse any heat or Party differences. The object of the amendment is to draw attention to the fact that if the section is allowed to stand without some such words as I have indicated in my amendment a state of affairs may arise whereby grave injustice may be done to workmen. The kind of situation to which I wish to draw attention would arise where a workman was employed by an Irish employer in the Irish Free State, doing his ordinary work in the Irish Free State, but in the course of his work it may become necessary for that workman to go either to England or to Northern Ireland. If, in the course of carrying out his work, he is sent by his employer either to Northern Ireland or to England and meets with an accident, admittedly arising out of and in the course of his employment, he will be debarred under this section as it stands at present from compensation. Take the case of a man living in some of the Border counties. He is employed by an Irish Free State employer under an Irish Free State contract. In the course of his employment he is sent with a consignment of cattle, say, over the Border—legitimately, let us observe in parenthesis. For the sake of this argument I assume that he would go there legitimately. In the course of his employment it becomes necessary for him to cross the Border, say, for one hundred yards and he meets with an accident arising out of or in the course of his employment one hundred yards over the Border. Under the section as it stands he gets no compensation. I do not think the Minister would like to see that state of affairs occurring under the Bill. It occurs to me as not being a proper state of affairs to allow to happen.
It arises in this way: In the year 1909, under a similar section in the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1906, a British workman employed by British employers was sent on their work to Malta and arising out of and in the course of his employment, as was admitted, he met with an accident. I forget whether he was killed or not, but, at all events, he was injured and he was entitled to no compensation because the Act had no extra-territorial operation. Without wishing to cast any doubt on that decision, it appears to me to be quite unreasonable. It is still more unreasonable when you have regard to the relations that exist between this country and England commercially and the daily intercourse that must take place between people here and people in England, or people here and people in Northern Ireland. If a man, in the course of his employment, is sent, say, from Lifford to Strabane across the bridge just across the Border and meets with an accident, he will get no compensation, although if he met with the accident one inch on this side of the Border he would get compensation. There is an actual case at present pending before the Supreme Court. It has been decided by the High Court, following this decision in England, that the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1906, has no application outside the territorial borders of the Irish Free State. That decision is the subject of an appeal to the Supreme Court.
We have, however, at the present moment an opportunity of putting the matter right and I suggest that we should take the opportunity of making clear whether it is or is not the intention of the Oireachtas that a workman employed in Irish employment, under an Irish contract, going to Northern Ireland in the course of his employment and meeting with an accident there arising out of and in the course of his employment should, or should not, be entitled to compensation. The actual case I am referring to was a case where a stable boy was sent by his employer, who is a trainer at the Curragh, over to Liverpool to the Grand National with a horse and, admittedly arising out of and in the course of his employment, he was injured over in England. The High Court here have held, following this decision, that he was not entitled to compensation. I suggest that it is unreasonable that that state of affairs should be allowed to continue.
The definition of workman is pretty largely widened by this Bill so to cover people with £350 a year and people of various kinds will be brought under it. I do not know whether there is any such thing as a commercial traveller going to England from an Irish firm, but I assume there would be such a person. If he meets with an accident in England arising out of or in the course of his employment he gets no compensation. If a man is sent with cattle to Birkenhead and meets with an accident on the Birkenhead Pier, he gets no compensation. If a man is sent from one end of a street to another in a town bordering on the Irish Free State and Northern Ireland, if he meets with an accident at one end of the street he gets compensation; but if he meets with an accident at the other end of the street he gets no compensation. It is for the House to decide whether that state of affairs should continue or not. I suggest it should not continue and I bring the matter before the House in order that a decision may be taken upon it. The amendment, in my opinion, is in favour of the workman. It is an amendment which ought to be accepted. Possibly in the form in which I have put it down it may be too wide. I think it is not too wide but other people may think it is too wide. I suggest, however, that some definite provision should be made in this Bill, now that we have an opportunity of making the wishes of the Legislature clear, and not leave it to the chance of a decision one way or the other in the courts. We have an opportunity now of making our opinion clear. I suggest that the House ought to make up their minds one way or the other and I urge that they ought to make up their minds along the lines I suggest in my amendment. That is a matter for the House, but I do suggest that they ought not to leave the section in the state of uncertainty in which it exists at the present moment.
Comment on this
I rise to support the amendment in the name of Deputy Costello. The test as to whether or not a person ought to be compensated is not the locus in quo of the accident which occurs to him. The test should be solely a question of whether it arose out of his employment and occurred to him in the course of his employment. I think it is unreasonable to say that a servant who is sent on his master's business outside the borders of the State, and met with an accident in the course of that employment, should not be compensated for it. You can conceive such a situation arising on the Border as a man working on one field of his employer's land, and meeting with an accident, being entitled to compensation because it is within the borders of the State, and a man meeting with an accident in another field being outside the protection given by the Workmen's Compensation Act. The same thing might arise in a house on the Border. A servant meeting with an accident in one room might be entitled to compensation, while a servant meeting with an accident in another room might not. The proper test is whether the accident arose out of his employment and in the course of it. I, therefore, support the amendment moved by Deputy Costello.
Comment on this
The purpose of this Bill, and the purpose of the Workmen's Compensation Act in Great Britain, and as far as I know in every country, is to provide compensation for workmen injured by accidents within the jurisdiction. I do not know why it is assumed that a workman who met with an accident in Northern Ireland or Great Britain would not be compensated. He is entitled to compensation under the British Act. The effect of this amendment, if accepted, would be to entitle him to get compensation twice.
Comment on this
Allow me to suggest to the Deputy that he might be wrong. I just want to break the suggestion gently to him if I can—he might be wrong. The fact is that I am advised that a workman employed by an Irish contractor, say on a contract being carried out in Northern Ireland, and injured in the course of that work, is entitled to get compensation from that employer through the Northern Ireland court.
Comment on this
It is true that compensation awarded by a Northern Ireland court might not be remitted to the Saorstát, or vice versa, but that is a question of reciprocal arrangement. Power is taken under the Bill to enter into a reciprocal arrangement, and until such an arrangement is made there may be difficulty. I cannot see, however, that the difficulty would arise out of the type of case which the Deputy suggests.
Comment on this
I am loath to believe that the Minister is still so far adopting the role of advocate that he will not see the reasonableness of the amendment put forward here. The very answer he gave clearly shows that he is adopting that role. It is no answer. The Minister talks about reciprocal arrangements. Reciprocal arrangements will not cover the case I have mentioned. You find an accident, say in Northern Ireland, happening to an Irish Free State workman employed by an Irish Free State employer who lives in the Irish Free State. It seems to me a very peculiar thing to say that you have got to have a reciprocal arrangement with Northern Ireland to enable him to sue his own employer; that you have got to get him to sue in Northern Ireland an employer with whom he is living in the Free State; and that you have to have a reciprocal arrangement with Northern Ireland to enforce that judgment given in Northern Ireland against the employer living in the Free State.
Comment on this
I will give the Deputy an instance of a German workman enforcing a claim for compensation against a German employer in the Irish Free State—Messrs. Siemens Schuckert.
Comment on this
Can you give me an instance of an Irish employer living in the Irish Free State, employing an Irish workman living in the Irish Free State, and that workman being forced to take an action in Northern Ireland against that employer living in the Irish Free State, going through all the machinery of service outside the jurisdiction in order to get a man with whom he is probably living brought into a foreign court, further machinery being necessary to enable that judgment to be enforced through the courts of Northern Ireland and through the Irish Free State courts against an employer with whom he is living? The thing is ludicrous.
I want to make a further point which I omitted to make originally. The 1906 Act applied as between the three countries—the whole of Ireland, England and Scotland—so that wherever an accident occurred to an Irish workman, whether in England, Ireland or Scotland, that workman was entitled to get compensation. If the accident occurred in England he was entitled to sue his employer in Ireland. This Bill takes away that right from him, a right which he had by reason of the three countries being politically one. In consequence of the political severance it has been decided that that right under the 1906 Act is gone, largely by reason of the fact that there is no machinery. That was the decision in the Armstrong and Alexander cases, but the decision in a recent case is that by reason of the operation of the 1906 Act, as kept in force by Article 73 of the Constitution, it operates only within the area of the Irish Free State. It seems to me to be utterly unreasonable to say that a workman employed by a farmer on the Border can get compensation if an accident arises in one field but cannot get it if an accident arises in another field.
Comment on this
With great respect he cannot, at the present time. He has to sue his employer. Where can he sue him? He cannot sue him in the Northern Ireland court because the contract is not made in Northern Ireland. Number two, he cannot serve his employer because there is no machinery for serving him; and, number three, how can he enforce his judgment in the Northern Ireland courts?
Comment on this
I am surprised at the statement of the Minister that he is prepared to leave a workman who meets with an accident outside the jurisdiction to obtain compensation in the British courts, considering that quite recently I had occasion to lay before the Minister for Justice the case of an Irish Free State employee working for a cross-Channel firm on a contract in the Saorstát, meeting with an accident and receiving compensation in the Free State court. The compensation was duly paid by the British firm as long as the contract was being carried on, but immediately they finished the contract and returned to Bristol they repudiated the compensation awarded by the Free State courts and refused to make any further payment. The local agents on behalf of that workman had to take any settlement they could get—a good deal less than the man was entitled to—because of the lack of machinery to enable them to compel respect for the court decision. If that is going to continue it will be very difficult to get any justice. I certainly think we ought to take the necessary precautions under this Bill to enforce the decisions of our own courts and protect a Free State workman who meets with an accident across the Border, without depending on the reciprocal conditions of the Northern courts.
Comment on this
Surely we are asking no more in this amendment than to extend to the ordinary workman what the Bill itself extends to seamen. Is not that so? Am I not right in believing that this Bill provides that if a seaman working in an Irish ship for an Irish master sustains an injury in Chinese waters he can notify the Consul— incidentally the British Consul—and that will be notice for the purpose of this Act, upon which an action can be based in the Irish courts to recover damages from an Irish master? Surely this amendment is on all fours with that? What we are asking for the ordinary workman is that without the intervention of the British Consul, he can start proceedings in the Irish courts to recover compensation from an employer for injuries sustained in the course of his employment. If the Bill purports to do that for a seaman what argument can the Minister adduce to refuse to do it for the ordinary workman, to whom an accident is more likely to happen than to a man in the mercantile marine? I suggest that with the analogy of Section 65 with the sub-section applying to seamen very little remains to be said.
Comment on this
From the Minister's remarks it would seem to me that his difficulty is the possibility that the workman might receive compensation under two Acts. If that is the only difficulty I suggest that it is not beyond human ingenuity to meet the situation, and to enable the Bill to be so drawn as to preclude the possibility of that happening. It is all right to tell a workman that the courts in Northern Ireland are open to him if he meets with an accident. You might as well tell a tramp that the Gresham Hotel is open to him. These people have not the ghost of a chance of getting in there. A workman meeting with an accident in Northern Ireland may have such impediments put in his way, when suing an employer for compensation, and then in enforcing judgment, that, in fact, he will get no compensation at all. It may be exceedingly difficult to get over these impediments. They may constitute such a formidable barrier that the employer may be able to defeat the purpose of the Bill, or the litigation which it would be necessary to institute might be of such a costly character as to deprive the man of portion of the compensation he would get if there were greater facilities at his disposal for prosecuting his claim.
Deputy Costello, with his legal experience, told us of these difficulties. A writ has to be issued against the employer who lives outside the jurisdiction of the courts and permission obtained to serve it. Then the employer has to be directed to attend within the administration, and when judgment is got it has to be "marked" in order to be enforced. An astute or an unscrupulous employer has many ways in which to seek refuge, while the workman is trying to get this huge machine to work on his behalf. It must be remembered that we are dealing with workmen, people whose energy and weekly wage are their only guarantee that they will not be in the workhouse. That is the kind of man who is being asked to go to a court outside the place where he resides to sue his employer. Very often the workman has not merely to fight the employer, but a wealthy foreign insurance company. I suggest that the Minister should look into the matter again and not make it possible for an unscrupulous employer, aided and abetted by a wealthy foreign insurance company, to deprive a workman of compensation that he would have got if he had sustained injury within the jurisdiction of courts operating in this area. If it is only a matter of preventing a person getting compensation twice, I am sure the Minister will be able to find words to get over the difficulty. To tell a person that he has a right of action in Northern Ireland or Great Britain, if he meets with an accident there while working for a Saorstát employer, is not giving him a fair chance of having at his disposal machinery which is at the disposal of fellow-workmen who happen to be employed in the area of jurisdiction of the Free State. The Minister should look into this matter again, to try to remove what will be an admitted handicap if the Bill is allowed to pass in its present form.
Comment on this
I think the case mentioned by Deputy Norton does not arise. It has been clearly laid down that a person cannot get double compensation for an accident.
Comment on this
That was the Minister's case. That case cannot arise. A person cannot get compensation twice for the same accident. I remember a case I had ten or 12 years ago where a man was killed. I served a notice under the Workmen's Compensation Act claiming £300 and, as the man had a large family of minors, in order to protect myself I issued a writ under Lord Campbell's Act. The insurance company lodged £300 under the Workmen's Compensation Act and then tried to stop the action under Lord Campbell's Act. The court refused to stay the case, stating that the company had not been asked to lodge the £300, that they could not bar the proceedings seeing that neither case had been tried. The court decided that double compensation could not be received. If compensation is given in the Free State or in Northern Ireland the decision must be accepted in one or the other place. The Act does not say where compensation is to be given. That is immaterial and, in that way, the Minister's difficulty does not arise.
Comment on this
The argument of the Minister in answer to the amendment was a perfectly fantastic one. He stated that the workman could sue in the court of the territory in which the accident occurred. In the case mentioned by Deputy Costello, that of a stable boy who was sent to Liverpool, and who brought an action in the English court, he had to find an English solicitor to bring the action, and to bring his employer over to have the question of right decided in an English court. The thing is grossly unjustifiable. It is putting a very serious, and often an insurmountable obstacle in the way if a person has to go to an English court, to get money for a solicitor to act there, and to bring witnesses over to have the case tried. It is also unjust to the employer who lives here, like the trainer at the Curragh, who was brought across to England to have it decided whether he was liable for the accident to an employee during the course of his employment. I do not understand the argument that was put forward by the Minister—if it can be called an argument. The obvious and the convenient way is to have the matter decided where the parties live. If a drover who is sent to Birkenhead with cattle meets with an accident, according to the Minister he has to go to England to bring an action and bring his employer over from this country to answer there. I say the argument of the Minister is fantastic. I do not understand why he put it forward.
Comment on this
Nobody wants to deprive the workman who meets with an accident in the course of his employment from getting compensation, but we do not want him to get compensation twice. That is the only question that arises, whether the enactment of this amendment is going to enable him to get compensation twice from the same employer.
Comment on this
Does the Minister suggest that a man injured in the circumstances mentioned, the stable boy from the Curragh, can bring an action in the English courts and get compensation there against an Irish employer, and then come back to the Irish courts and bring a similar action and again get compensation?
Comment on this
That is why I described the argument as fantastic. No court would listen to the second action in either country.
Comment on this
The point I want to make is that that will not happen. I suggest if this amendment is carried it could happen. I do not suppose anyone would suggest that the Bill should be so amended as to permit that. The purpose of this Bill is to provide compensation for accidents occurring in the Irish Free State.
Comment on this
Half a dozen words in the section to prevent any two claims being made.
Comment on this
Then I suggest that as this is a question of fact in one sense, we leave this matter over until the next stage and we will then have the question of the state of the law clearly set out for discussion. If there is a case for amending the Bill, it can be amended but it has got to be amended so as to ensure that the position will not arise which I understand the amendment will give rise to.
Comment on this
Let us get some indication of what the view of the law on the other side is. The case put by Deputy Costello is: A Saorstát employer has a Saorstát employee and he sends that Saorstát employee across the Border and somewhere in the Six County area that employee gets hurt. The Minister contends—does the Attorney-General agree?—that that employee can take that Saorstát employer into the Northern Ireland courts and get compensation? That is the Minister's contention. Does the Attorney-General agree? I do not think that there is any doubt about the law on that. Does the Attorney-General think that the Minister's statement is correct? That is the net point.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not satisfied with what the Minister has said that there is no intention to try to deprive a workman of any benefit it is possible to give him under this legislation. In view of what the Minister decided with reference to the matter I did not intend to join in the discussion at all. Deputy McGilligan has his own motives for wishing to have the matter pursued further. The Minister in making the statement he did make, is relying on the advice given to him by two lawyers who have considered the matter and, whether I agree or not with that, the position is that the Minister's action in postponing it until Report Stage, in view of what has turned up in the discussion, is the most reasonable way to meet it. I would hesitate to say that Deputy Costello would make a statement as to the law without having considered fully his responsibility in subscribing to a statement of the law such as he has made on this section. As to Deputy McGilligan's view of the law I would not attach any weight to it.
Comment on this
And as to what Deputy McMenamin said, it is obvious that he does not understand what is under discussion at all. He is talking about a completely different thing. Deputy Rice is as positive as he usually is, without realising the difficulties of this matter. There is one aspect of this which Deputy McGilligan, if he recollects the Report on which this legislation was originally based——
Comment on this
The Deputy, as usual, is furnished with a mass of detail for such a discussion as this. He is going to read a page of it, but perhaps I am going to anticipate him in the page I propose to refer to. In this matter of the effect which was created by the Treaty in regard to rights such as these, I think it was Alexander's case which first showed the difficulties which were created by the coming into existence of the Saorstát as a separate entity. In that particular case and in the Report on which this section is based, it had always been suggested and apparently, always adopted until Deputy Costello put down an amendment, that the way of dealing with this type of case was by some reciprocal arrangement between the different countries. So far as I read page 52 of this Report, it refers to the Alexander case, and refers also to Judge Hanna's evidence before the Commission. The suggestion was there put forward that the case as outlined by Deputy Costello, as I understand it, should be met by a convention.
"The witness suggested that the obvious remedy for difficulties of this kind was the application of a convention by agreement between the Governments concerned, and he referred to the Anglo-French Convention as a solution of the question of similar concern to English and French nationals.
The concluding portion of the judge's evidence suggesting the points to be covered by an arrangement of this kind and referring to the desirability of having similarity in the compensation laws of the countries concerned, may here be reproduced...."
and then reproduced are a number of cases. I think I am right in saying that one of the cases covered is the one which Deputy Costello has instanced here, so that when the Bill as drafted by Deputy McGilligan's instruction and direction, and with his approval——
Comment on this
I suppose the Deputy wishes to disown it?
Comment on this
I understand the Bill to have been drafted years ago.
Comment on this
I understood that the Deputy was Minister?
Comment on this
In control of the Department of Industry and Commerce?
Comment on this
And I understand that it actually went the length of getting into a White Paper?
Comment on this
And yet the ex-Minister wishes to disown responsibility for a provisional draft which took the shape of a White Paper and which went before the Executive Council as a White Paper.
Comment on this
I do not understand what the Deputy is at.
Comment on this
With my little experience of government and my little knowledge of how Ministers handle matters, it sounds a most extraordinary statement for the Deputy to make when he says that he, as Minister, allowed a White Paper to go before the Executive Council for discussion for which he now denies responsibility.
Comment on this
The distinction between being a Minister in control of a measure which takes the shape of a White Paper and goes before the Executive Council and accepting responsibility for it may be too fine. "Being responsible for it"— perhaps the Deputy will accept that— that he was responsible for putting the measure in the shape which it took of a White Paper?
Comment on this
And it contained this provision in the form in which it now stands and without the suggested amendment now put forward.
Comment on this
I am not aware that it contains any suggestion to meet this particular type of case.
Comment on this
I am not to be impugned because you do not know something. That would be a big list against me.
Comment on this
I will stand criticism from anybody who knows the file but not from a man who is wandering.
Comment on this
My information is that the White Paper or memoranda in the Minister's Department for which he was responsible or any notes he has made on it contain nothing in the shape of Deputy Costello's amendment. Does the Deputy deny that?
Comment on this
He is not prepared to deny that statement.
Comment on this
I am not prepared to answer you in your present wandering state because you are not capable of enunciating correctly what you are pretending to think.
Comment on this
The Attorney-General and Ministers may be replied to, but not answered by way of interruption.
Comment on this
The Deputy is very sensitive. He calls "jibing into answering" the asking of a question in regard to a matter which he himself brought under discussion by challenging my statement.
Comment on this
He is very sensitive. I wish he would have regard to other people's sensitiveness to the extent to which he wishes to have his own sensitiveness regarded. I can see no reason for objecting to having this matter considered on Report and if the view which is put forward on the responsibility of certain officers, legal officers, that this amendment, if it goes in its present shape, may have the effect of enabling a worker to recover twice, if that danger is likely and can be avoided, surely the sensible thing is to let this discussion go over to Report.
Comment on this
I agree that it is proper that the Minister should consider this on appropriate advice before Report. I only wish to make the matter clear so that the consideration of my amendment may not be made on a false basis. The Attorney-General has stated that this White Paper that is supposed to exist contains nothing like my amendment. Of course it does not, because this decision on the meaning of the section has only been given in the last few months. It was certainly not given and never occurred to me when I was in office, and if I were asked for advice on the section, I would have given an advice contrary to the High Court decision. I am still in hopes that that decision may be reversed by the Supreme Court because I am still convinced that it is a wrong decision. I would have thought that the state of affairs that existed pre-Treaty would be carried over by Article 73 post-Treaty. The purpose of the amendment is to cover cases which cannot be and should not be covered by an international convention. The type of case covered by an international convention or by a reciprocal agreement is the case, say, where an Irish citizen is working for an Englishman or a Frenchman or a German and you want to get your rights against him. Say a German is over here and you want to get your judgment against him made effective as against his assets in that country. That is the type of case that should be covered by an international convention, but it seems to me the height of absurdity to suggest that in the case of an Irish employer working in Ireland, employing a workman who is an Irishman, perhaps living in the very same house with him or certainly living in the same town with him, that you should require an international convention in order to enable him to sue his employer in the District Court or the Circuit Court. That is not the case that is covered by the arrangement made in——
Comment on this
I do not like to interrupt the Deputy, but I would draw his attention to page 52 of the report. Unless I misunderstood him, the case mentioned in paragraph (1) is the case which the Deputy was referring to.
Comment on this
That would probably cover it, but that is not a case that requires an international convention.
Comment on this
With the greatest respect to Judge Hanna if he intended to cover it by sub-section (1) I entirely disagree with him, but I do not think he did. My case is where you get a contract made in the Irish Free State with an Irish workman and an Irish employer living in the Free State, and where an accident happens just outside the borders of the State. It would be the height of absurdity in that state of affairs to have an international convention to do one or two things, namely, to enable the Irish workman to sue his employer in an Irish court or else enable that Irish workman to go solemnly outside the jurisdiction, cart his employer outside the jurisdiction, get a foreign jurisdiction and have an arrangement to make that foreign judgment enforceable against an Irish employer, against his neighbour——
Comment on this
Did Judge Hanna not think it necessary?
Comment on this
Is he not a recognised authority on workmen's compensation?
Comment on this
I am quite satisfied that No. 1 does not answer the case I am putting. I am quite satisfied that Judge Hanna—and I know that he is a recognised authority on those questions—would never suggest that you should have an international convention to decide a purely intraterritorial question, to enable an Irish workman to sue an Irish employer in Irish courts. I do not think he ever made the suggestion——
Comment on this
There are a few people here who might be invited to the next garden party. May I put this question to the Attorney-General? It seems to me clear from the way in which the section is drawn that it is not possible for a Saorstát national employed by a Saorstát employer to sue that Saorstát employer in a Saorstát court if he meets with an accident say in Great Britain. I think that is clear from the Bill. Consequently, the employee, in order to get a remedy against his employer, must sue in a British court in a case of this kind. That procedure would constitute a hardship against the workman.
Comment on this
Too many cooks spoil the broth and I am afraid too many lawyers will spoil this Workman's Compensation Act. Let us suppose that that Irish workman can sue that Irish employer in the English courts. The trouble to which the workmen may be subjected may, in some cases, provide a source of glee for the employer or the insurance company but suppose the Irish employer was quite agreeable to be sued by the employee in an Irish court in respect of an accident which happened in Great Britain, would it be possible for the court to hear that claim or would they have to go over to Britain to have the claim heard there?
Comment on this
It should not be necessary in the case of an agreement to go over to Britain and have the case heard there.
Comment on this
I should like the Minister, at any rate, to understand this point, because the Attorney-General has failed to understand it, before he comes to deal with it on the next stage. We have the extraordinary fact of the Attorney-General being asked his opinion on a matter of law and of his simply refusing to give it. He shelters behind some unknown lawyers who have given a certain advice to the Minister. One is tempted to ask whether they were Glasgow lawyers, but that might be rude in the circumstances. Here is the head of the profession, the titular head of the profession, in this House and he is asked this simple point, which is the basis of the Minister's case, and he cannot give an answer. The basis of the Minister's case is that if the amendment is carried in certain circumstances the employee will be unable to get compensation. What is the other way in which he will get it, as the law stands at present? Take the circumstances put up by Deputy Costello. A Saorstát employer has a Saorstát employee and he sends that employee across the Border and that employee gets injured across the Border. The simple question is put to the Attorney-General: Can that employee, as the law stands at the moment, sue the Saorstát employer in the British court?—and he cannot answer it or, at any rate, he has not answered it. He knows very well he cannot but he does not want to let down the Minister. Deputy Norton's argument proceeds on the basis that that individual has a right to get compensation but that he has a difficulty in going to the English courts. Would the Attorney-General bring himself to the position of venturing an opinion as to whether he has rights in the British courts in these circumstances? Let us imagine such a man getting over all the difficulties. Can a Saorstát employee, injured while in the Six Counties, take action in the British court against a Saorstát employer by whom he has been employed? It is a very simple point. The Minister says that he can, and if this amendment is passed he can then come down and get compensation here, and it is on that basis he is going to reconsider all this. The Attorney-General knows that that is not the state of the law. I suggest that if the Minister had read the report we would have been saved all this discussion. This whole page starts with the "Alexander" case. This thing refers to Deputy Costello's case. Mr. Justice Hanna said this, or is quoted as saying it:
"There were two underlying principles as regards workmen's compensation legislation which, by reason of the legal operation of the Treaty and the Constitution of the Free State, had become very far-reaching, namely, the position of the Free State, in international law, as a separate entity to be treated as in the same category as a foreign country, and the territorial application of the Workmen's Compensation Acts."
Mr. Justice Hanna is quoted here as the greatest authority on workmen's compensation, and I think it will be admitted that he is entitled to be so called. He continues:
"These resulted in two disabilities in the case of an ordinary Saorstát workman: firstly, that he cannot bring a foreign employer before the Saorstát courts...."
That is not the case we are talking about, but I want the Attorney-General to weigh this:
"...and, secondly, if his injury occurred without the Saorstát he cannot make the Saorstát employer liable."
Is that a clear statement of the law? It answers Deputy Norton's point. It is not a question of making him liable in the British courts, he cannot make him liable. Then Mr. Justice Hanna goes on to deal with the case of foreign contractors operating in the Saorstát, with which we are not concerned. The Attorney-General says that Mr. Justice Hanna recommended the application of a convention. Let us pause here. Mr. Justice Hanna is, by common consent, an acknowledged authority on workmen's compensation. Mr. Justice Hanna has given decisions in which it is clear that he has adverted to the new position in the Saorstát since the Treaty and its position in relation to the remnant of the United Kingdom. It is suggested here that this authority on workmen's compensation, this judge of ours with his knowledge of the repercussions of the Treaty upon the position of the two countries, considers that it requires an international arrangement to make or to enable the Saorstát employee to sue a Saorstát employer in the Saorstát courts.
Comment on this
That is what is here, and the suggestion is that Mr. Justice Hanna was in favour of that. The Attorney-General runs away from it now.
Comment on this
Let me read further. It is clear that when you do not pay attention to a document you can take a very absurd meaning from it. The report continues:
"The witness suggested that the obvious remedy for difficulties of this kind...."
The difficulties referred to here are those caused by the "Alexander" case and the case of foreign contractors and Saorstát employees and nonSaorstát employers:
"was the application of a convention, by agreement between the Governments concerned, and he referred to the Anglo-French Convention as a solution of questions of similar concern to English and French nationals."
Now we will take up the next sentence, which is as follows:—
"The concluding portion of the judge's evidence, suggesting the points to be covered by an arrangement of this kind, and referring to the desirability of having similarity in the compensation laws of the countries concerned, may here be reproduced."
Comment on this
That is the Commission's comment. Here is what Mr. Justice Hanna said:—
"I would venture to make the following suggestions:—
(1) Every domiciled Irish workman who is injured while working anywhere either in or out of the jurisdiction for an Irish employer should be entitled to bring proceeding in Irish Free State courts."
There is a recommendation, and the Attorney-General tied that up with his recommendation for an international convention. I think he did.
Comment on this
The Minister is so fogged about the matter that the meaning is not clear to him. The justice goes on to make other suggestions which ought to be covered and to which effect can only be given by agreement.
Comment on this
Why did you not put them in the White Paper?
Comment on this
I will come to the White Paper in good time. Do not draw malodorous red herrings across the trail when you are in a hole. Mr. Justice Hanna goes on as follows:—
"The consideration of the foregoing matters indicates, almost conclusively, that the compensation law in the adjacent States should be the same so far as the substantial benefits are concerned, though some difference as to procedure may be considered necessary."
That is the point as to whether there should be an equality as far as compensation is concerned. Then, the justice finally takes up this point again:—
"But there are other considerations. If we take what is called the ‘Boundary,' we find on either side of it considerable towns from which contractors may have occasion to send workmen over the Border to do work, and even many farmers have carting of produce or driving of stock into market towns over the Border, in doing which work their servants may meet with accidents for which provision must be made. In fact, there is a mobility of labour which in its daily routine cannot recognise the exact territorial limits of a State, and the rights of both workmen and employers should be established irrespective of this."
We are getting away from the convention, and we are getting definitely away from this absurd view sought to be imposed on a justice of the standing of Mr. Justice Hanna, that he thought that there should be an international arrangement to cover the case of a Saorstát workman meeting with an accident in the Six Counties and wanting to get compensation.
Comment on this
The next paragraph speaks of that also. Does the Minister think that that refers to the case we are talking about at the moment? The Minister is in a national fog, and he should not try to drop into an international one.
Comment on this
The amendment is being resisted on the basis, firstly, that at the moment the law is that, in the conditions talked of by Deputy Costello, that employee cannot claim compensation—Mr. Justice Hanna said he could not. The second contention is that Mr. Justice Hanna recommended that that type of case should be covered by an international convention.
Comment on this
And so did they! But when you try to make a fool of them the case is different. In the one case it might not matter so much, but in the other case you are guilty of something like contempt of court. It will not weigh much either way with the world or with the nation. As to the White Paper, I challenge the Attorney-General, with all the information at his disposal, and with his fingers on the files, to produce any evidence to this House that that Paper represented the considered view on workmen's compensation.
Comment on this
The Deputy did not consider what he put up to the Executive Council.
Comment on this
He did, and the Executive Council thought fit to consider them occasionally, not like the Glasgow case, where the President did not think fit to consider the Attorney-General. Let the Attorney-General produce this White Paper, and let him produce with it the old much-thumbed Bill in typescript form and falling in pieces, and he will see the obvious reason why that skeleton measure had to be got into some form for people to consider.
Comment on this
It would have been better to spend another four years at it than to wander into this sort of performance. If the Attorney-General talks about something I did, as if it were a serious recommendation of mine, let him produce the evidence. He has a habit of running away, I know, but since he has inaugurated this thing himself let him produce the evidence. Let him give us his standing on this whole matter. Is he yet able to tell the House what is the law on the simple point: a Saorstát employer, a Saorstát employee, the employee getting injured in the Six-County area? Can that employee claim compensation anywhere as the law is at the moment? If we can get an answer to that, we shall know how to proceed.
Comment on this
Are we to understand that Deputies opposite want this matter decided now or do they wish to have it left over for next stage?
Comment on this
If the Attorney-General finds himself in a position in which he cannot make up his mind——
Comment on this
I fully appreciate that and, if the Minister allows me to finish my sentence, I shall explain. If the Attorney-General cannot make up his mind as to what the law is and wants time to consider the matter——
Comment on this
Does the Deputy want a vote on this amendment now or does he want the matter left over?
Comment on this
If the Minister would address the Chair, he would obtain the information more readily than by making disorderly interruptions.
Comment on this
The Minister has asked whether the Opposition desire a vote now on this amendment or whether they desire to have the amendment left over.
Comment on this
I do not wish to contest your ruling, sir, but, as I see the situation, we are entitled to debate this amendment.
Comment on this
If the Attorney-General is not in a position to say now what the law is, and if he is prepared to defend the proposition that in order to afford the right to a citizen of this State to sue another citizen of this State in the courts of the State, an international convention is required——
Comment on this
If the position is as I have suggested, it would be better to postpone the matter until the Attorney-General has made up his mind. So far, the Attorney-General has declined to answer a direct question put to him— whether or not it is necessary to have an international convention to make it possible for one citizen of this State to sue another citizen of this State in the courts of this State.
Comment on this
It is not, and I never suggested it was. All I suggested was that, when this question was being approached by the Committee, Judge Hanna and those who considered it regarded it as a matter that might properly be made the subject of a convention before legislation was introduced. That was the reason I suggested that the matter might be reconsidered. In the case of extension of judgments—making English judgments enforcible here and our judgments enforcible across the water— legislation is required both here and in Great Britain. Before you proceed to legislate in such matters, it is usual to have a convention securing reciprocity. At the moment, we have not reciprocity with regard to extension of judgments.
Deputy Costello, if he were here, would admit that the question of dealing with the law and amending it has been several times considered, so as not to allow the British to occupy the favourable position they do with regard to the enforcing of ordinary judgments, having regard to the fact that they are not allowing us a similar privilege in their courts. This question is on the same sort of footing. Despite Deputy McGilligan's suggestion, I interpreted what Judge Hanna suggested on page 32, as this—that it was a proper subject for an international convention although, whether there was an international question or not, legislation would be required here. Before we embark on legislation, which will put certain people in a favourable position, we ought to consider whether we will get reciprocal arrangements with the other countries involved. That is all I intended to suggest and that is all I do suggest. That is the only question on which the Minister wants to have a postponement.
Deputy McGilligan, for reasons quite obvious, wishes to bring me into conflict with advice which the Minister has got. I want to protest against the attacks made upon me by Deputy Rice, in his sneering references, and by Deputy McGilligan. My attitude is quite reasonable and fair. I have just read here the opinion of two officers who are not practising lawyers, but who are lawyers. I do think that it is most unreasonable and unfair for these two Deputies to seek to involve me in an altercation with these officers. It would have been more fitting if some show of reason had been made by Deputy McGilligan. I imagine that if Deputy Dillon had sole charge such reason would have been shown, and I think the matter might be allowed to stand over so as to have the question of policy and any question of difference in the law determined at a later stage.
Comment on this
I am sure that there is no desire to introduce acerbity into this matter. But it does seem that we have difficulty in arriving ad idem. The difficulty we envisage does not call for an international arrangement——
Comment on this
The situation, as we see it, is one in which a workman might be injured and would have no remedy at all at law. He could not sue in the British courts, even if he could get his employer to go into the British courts, because there would be no contract within the jurisdiction. He would have no grounds for action even if he could get his employer to go across the Border. He could not sue in the Saorstát courts when he came home, because he is expressly excluded by statute from obtaining any remedy for an injury sustained outside the jurisdiction. All we are trying to secure is that that employee will have some remedy somewhere. There may be other matters arising which would be suitable subjects for an international arrangement, but these can be best dealt with under the section of the Bill which provides facilities for making reciprocal arrangements. But here is a situation in which an injured workman has no right of action in Northern Ireland, and is prohibited from taking action in Southern Ireland. The purpose of Deputy Costello's amendment is to give him in the Saorstát courts the remedy which the absence of contract deprives him of in the British court, even if he could bring his employer into that court.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy read Article 2, on page 82 of the Report? It deals with the point as to the convention.
Comment on this
It refers to your point, and it shows that I am not wrong in saying that this is a proper point for a convention.
Comment on this
As to the point of a person securing compensation twice, we have no control in Great Britain or Northern Ireland or in France. How can we say, if we give the right of action here, that the claimant will not be able to get compensation in Northern Ireland as well? Consequently, there must be an international agreement.
Comment on this
If that difficulty were seriously present to the mind of the Minister, it would be very easy to amend the law further. However, if the Attorney-General and the Minister feel that it is better that the matter should be given further consideration, and if they consider the question with a view to incorporating in the Bill an amendment on the lines of Deputy Costello's——
Comment on this
The Minister's suggestion being that it is an ill-considered amendment? The Attorney-General should take note of where the acerbity is coming from now. I prefer to overlook the Minister's interjection. I am perfectly certain that Deputy Costello and other Deputies here will have no reluctance to postponing the matter to the Report Stage, provided the Minister and the Attorney-General will look into it with a view to drafting an amendment to achieve the purpose we have in mind, over and above what they themselves purport doing by way of reciprocal agreement with Great Britain.
Comment on this
I do not want to prolong this matter. I merely want to give an example. I can assure the Attorney-General that there is plenty of available material in his office with reference to illegal trawling. I know it was the bane of my life for years.
Comment on this
With regard to illegal trawling outside the territorial limits in Saorstát waters, Saorstát fishermen, fishing by certain methods of trawling which are declared illegal, can be prosecuted and fined in Irish Free State courts and it does not require an international convention to do that. Neither would it require an international convention to enable a man to sue his employer, who is living beside him, in reference to a contract.
Comment on this
The object I am aiming at is a state of affairs that does not require an international convention.
Comment on this
With regard to Section 19, a variety of considerations arise. This is one of the sections which, above all, I wanted sent to a select committee. In Section 19 you have the critical words "for the purpose of his trade or business." These words have given rise to boundless litigation and there is every promise that they will give rise to boundless litigation in future. It is a source of very great regret to me that we have not been afforded an opportunity of studying these words with expert advice with the object of discovering some different formulae that would make their meaning clearer. The Attorney-General will remember that three alternative meanings have been adduced by the judicature for those words and eventually a kind of compromise meaning has been adopted which has done very little to clarify the situation.
The second thing I want to draw the Minister's attention to is with reference to the position of agricultural labourers. Normally, if an agricultural labourer is working for somebody who undertakes to do work, say, for a farmer, he has his remedy against his direct employer and the farmer. If, however, the sub-contractor proceeds to do the agricultural work with machinery, for some reason that commended itself to the British legislature it was decided that the employee would only have his remedy against the sub-contractor and that the employer would be discharged from liability. Why exactly that is carried over into legislation in this country, I do not know.
The third point I want to raise is this. Sub-section (5) provides: "This section shall not operate to prevent a workman recovering compensation under this Act from the contractor instead of the principal." In England the purpose of that sub-section was, I think, effected by a rule under the workmen's compensation rules which were provided for in one of the schedules—I have forgotten which of them. In the workmen's compensation rule 2, sub-paragraph (2), it was provided that the workman need not elect between the employer and the sub-contractor until a verdict was given. In Ireland, apparently, he must elect before he starts the proceedings. The rule was laid down in Ireland in the case of Myer versus the Dublin Corporation, in 1912, that as between the sub-contractor and the employer the workman must elect before he starts proceedings. If he starts proceedings against the sub-contractor, and the sub-contractor proves to be a bankrupt person, he cannot abandon the proceedings and go for the employer, because he is estopped the moment he opens proceedings.
In England the rule would appear to be the same as the rule that applies when he is making his election as to whether he will go under Lord Campbell's Act or the Workmen's Compensation Act. He is not debarred from changing until judgment is given. In view of the fact that the ruling in the case of Myer versus the Dublin Corporation has been upset by the workmen's compensation rule 2, sub-paragraph (2), in England, I think it might be as well that the Minister should consider adopting that view by statute in Ireland also. Otherwise the judgement in the case to which I have referred will stand. The particular advantage arising under the English rule is that the workman can actually make the principal and the contractor joint defendants and can, apparently, recover jointly against them. Here, of course, the workman is debarred from that remedy and I suggest to the Attorney-General and the Minister that they might take that matter into consideration, as well as the machinery question, if it has not already come to their minds.
Comment on this
As the Deputy is, no doubt, aware, we are not proposing to change the law in this respect at all. The whole of Section 19 is a reenactment of a section of the 1906 Act. It may be that it is possible to improve upon the verbiage, but those who have considered the matter, including the Inter-Departmental Committee, have not been able to suggest any alteration. I have no reason to believe that if we set up another committee, similar in constitution to the committee of 1925, it would fare any better in this respect. If the Deputy likes to try his hand at producing a form of words that will be more suitable than the words in the section, I shall be glad to consider them on the Report Stage. No suggestion has yet been made from any responsible quarter which could receive support. If it is desired to make the contractor and the principal jointly responsible, we can have that matter discussed upon the Report Stage, if an amendment is tabled. The position is that no recommendation to effect a change in that regard has been made, and, consequently, we are re-enacting the section of the 1906 Act without variation.
Comment on this
I take it the Minister and the Attorney-General will look into the question I have raised. If they do, I think they will find it is deserving of consideration. The Minister has not stated why he deemed it prudent to adopt from the British legislation the provision about exempting an employer where the sub-contractor uses machinery.
Comment on this
I think the purpose behind sub-section (3) is quite clear. If a person is employed by a threshing machine owner, then he is employed by the threshing machine owner and not by the farmer for whom the threshing machine owner at the time is working.
Comment on this
That is not the point. Surely the whole object is to preserve the right of the worker to proceed against the sub-contractor or employer. The exception is made where the sub-contractor works with machinery, ploughing and threshing and other agricultural work.
Comment on this
But the obvious thing is that it is only when it is a question of agricultural work that special exemption is given. It is not given in the case of any other sub-contract.