We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Vote No. 3—Department of the President of the Executive Council.

Contributions 1–140 of 286. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I move:—

Go ndeontar suim Bhreise ná raghaidh thar £10 chun íoctha an Mhuirir a thiocfaidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar críoch an 31adh Márta, 1934, chun Tuarastail agus Costaisí Roinn Uachtarán na hArd-Chomhairle.

That a Supplementary sum not exceeding £10 be granted to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending 31st March, 1934, for the Salaries and Expenses of the Department of the President of the Executive Council.

As is clear from the White Paper on the Estimate, this is to defray the expenses for a Bureau of Information. The function of the Bureau will be to collect and make available to the public information concerning the activities of Government Departments, and the national policy underlying those activities. The electors of the Saorstát have adopted a policy which involves important changes in our economic structure and external relations. The active and intelligent support of the people is necessary to the success of that policy. To give that support the people must have full and accurate information of the aims of the Government, and the methods by which those aims are being realised. It is important also that opinion abroad should be well informed regarding events here. It is not, for example, sufficiently understood in other countries that the economic war which is being waged against us has been undertaken in an effort to compel us to pay money which we are convinced is not due; nor is it widely known that we have from the beginning been ready to submit the dispute to the arbitration of an impartial tribunal. It is important for the national credit that these facts should be fully understood. In the absence of any central office from which information could be readily obtained, many false and harmful reports have been published in the Press at home and abroad. Quite recently an Irish paper published a report that the Government proposed to introduce war bread of a "dark brown" colour. Other papers, in England and elsewhere have been ringing the changes on that report. Some have described the bread as "black"; others, more moderately disposed, have called it "mottled." The basis for the report was that the Government was considering a proposal for the inclusion of a small percentage of oaten flour with wheat for bread-making; but, however absurd it may be, many people believed the statement that the result would be a black or dark brown bread, and they felt that the Saorstát was reaching the end of its resources.

The prestige and credit of the Saorstát have been injured by reports representing the country as being on the verge of a revolution. On the other hand, while the hardships caused by the economic war are frequently stressed, comparatively little attention is given to the Government's efforts to relieve the sufferers, or to the work that is being done to provide employment for an increasing population, and to improve the social conditions of the people. The root cause of these damaging reports is not, for the greater part, malice, but the fact that it is easy to develop the news value of a calamity or an incident of disorder, and that the investigation of constructive work and its results is a comparatively difficult task for which few journalists have time. Constructive work, however, has its own interest and news value, and if the facts concerning it are made easily accessible I am confident that journalists generally will be glad to make use of them. At all events, I think it is the duty of the Government in present circumstances to provide the facilities. Until the Bureau has been some time in existence it will not be possible to say with certainty what staff will be required, or what its cost will be. It is, however, intended to keep the expenditure to the minimum consistent with effective work.

Comment on this

I rise to urge that this Vote be not given. Nominally we are asked to vote £10. Actually we are asked to incur immediately an additional expenditure of £900 to £1,000 a year, and as the President has just said he cannot even tell us what additional staff and expenditure will be involved. It seems to me that this proposal is either silly or corrupt —probably both. It is a very good example of what the French call Vidée fixé, because this is merely to fulfil a desire which is dear to the President's heart, and which apparently has been a fixture for the last twelve years. On 7th September, 1922, the President wrote: “I would like to see S. O'Keeffe for a Press interview. If you get in touch with him I will see how it can be arranged. Ask him to send me along leading questions.” It looks as if the unfortunate people of this country are being asked now to give some unnamed amount—but more than £1,000 a year— to provide the President with somebody near by whom he can have to ask him leading questions all the time. A Department such as is proposed is not required in a country under normal conditions. It is true that when a war is taking place, and censorship is operating, propaganda becomes one of the weapons in the armoury of warfare. It is usually of course the most disgraceful weapon used in war. The President read out a statement purporting to justify the establishment of this Department. He says it is necessary that the activities of Government Departments be known. There is no need for the creation of this Department for that purpose. The activities of Government Departments become apparent to the people in the legislation produced in this House. That legislation is often advocated on one side and deprecated on the other, and the ordinary administration of the country is made known to the people without any special machinery for it. Apart from that, each Department has its activities, and journalists of this country who know their job will—if they think there is any portion of any Bill that they require elucidated—get on to the appropriate person in the Department concerned, who is clearly much better able to explain any intricacy or any dubious point than would be a man in a Department by himself.

The President went further and said it was also necessary to make known the national policy underlying the activities of Government Departments, and he says that the active support of the people is necessary. The people of this country have a perfect right to form any opinion that their judgment indicates to them of the action of the Government. An attempt by a Government to use public moneys to bludgeon the minds of the people, and try to relieve the people of the duty and the opportunity to judge things for themselves by pouring out a mass of propaganda to mislead them, is both corrupt and silly.

I know the President has always had in his mind the idea that somehow or another, by propaganda, you could melt December's snow by thinking of fantastic summer's heat. I know he has always thought it possible by propaganda to make black look white; I know he has always thought it possible by propaganda to make crime look like heroism and national service; and thus to-day he seems incapable of adjusting himself and learning with the passage of time, because if anybody had an opportunity of learning that the people are not going to be misled by such talk he should have had such an opportunity. He worries about opinion abroad. Clearly when things are going on in an ordinary way under a good Government in this country, and there are ordered conditions, opinion abroad is not concerned about what happens here, but he indicated that he wants the public in this country to pay for the purpose of misrepresenting to the public the policy of the Government. The people of this country have heard enough argument about the land annuities to form some idea as to what are the rights or wrongs of the situation. The President wants a public department established for the purpose of putting the party policy of Fianna Fáil before the people. He already owns a newspaper for doing that, a newspaper which, by the way, when it was looking for people to subscribe for its shares, assured everybody that it was not going to be a party organ—far from it. People in America were assured that Mr. Cosgrave was most anxious that it should be started and everybody was assured——

Comment on this

Is this germane to the debate?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

A discussion of the shareholding of the Irish Press is not in order.

Comment on this

I was not even proposing to discuss such a thing. What I am saying is that on a previous occasion, under the President's aegis, people were assured that an organ would be started that would not be for the purpose of party propaganda, and still less for the purpose of dirty propaganda, but anybody with any intelligence, who sees a couple of copies of that paper——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The policy of the Irish Press may not be debated on this Estimate.

Comment on this

I am drawing it in only as an analogy. We are now asked to vote money, as previously people were asked to give money for a purpose, the only justification of which would be, that it was for clearly public services, without relation to party, as the Government is supposed to have nothing whatever to do with party politics, and the departments of State are supposed to have nothing whatever to do with party politics. Here we are asked to establish a department for the purpose of saving the pockets of the Fianna Fáil people and to impose on the public in this country a tax in order to propagand the tactics of this Party. The President gives an instance of what this is to correct. There was a terrible national situation created by the fact that the bread proposed to be made not purely of wheaten flour was described as dark brown, as black and as mottled. We talk of black grapes and white grapes, and I do not know whether, if the President were to send to a fruiterer's shop for white grapes, he would be indignant and say that he had been deceived when he found that the grapes, whatever colour they were, were not white, and that black grapes, instead of being black, were purple. When we speak of white grapes, we do not mean grapes that are white, but we mean the type known as white grapes. In most northern countries people eat rye bread or barley bread. Neither rye bread nor barley bread is black, but they are both called black bread. Black bread is the name given to any type of bread to distinguish it from bread made of wheaten flour.

The President proposes that the Irish people, apparently, should not be allowed to have bread made of wheaten flour but a mixture, and then suggests that the world got the idea that we were on the verge of a breakdown because we were getting bread described as dark brown or black. In most northern countries in Europe a certain section, at any rate, of the population eat bread which is not made of wheaten flour exclusively. It is not black, but it is called black, just the same as we speak of white grapes. The President and the rest of us are called white men, but if any of us came in here with our faces the colour of this paper, which is white, people would think there was something wrong, but the President with his exact mind wants the newspapers to give the exact shade that describes the bread which it is proposed to foist on the Irish people, and in order that that may be done, we are asked to embark on an expenditure the extent of which we cannot be given.

The President complains that people abroad thought that we were on the verge of a revolution. What brought that about? What was the party that insisted on saying that we were on the verge of a revolution? Organisations were started here, declaring and living up to their declarations, that they stood entirely in favour of the maintenance of ordered conditions in this country, and that they did not propose to resort to methods of force in an attempt to change the Constitution or overthrow the Government by armed force, but Minister after Minister went around and talked about the approaching coup d'état the attempt to overthrow this State and all the rest of it, and then, having done that, come along here and ask that the Irish people shall be taxed in order to undo the antinational and dishonest propaganda which they carried on during that period and, even at this moment, are carrying on. He complains that while attention has been called to the sufferings imposed by what is called the economic war, little attention had been given to the efforts of the Government to provide employment for the increasing population, and for the relief of the farmers. Just a week or two ago, the Government, without this department at all, gathered together manufacturers and industrialists, as they were called, many of whom did not employ as many people as a single farmer's wife employs, and that meeting was paraded as though there were 9,000, 900 or 90 new industries in this country—and there was only one industry lost, agriculture. If there is anything that requires establishment in this country it is the proper ratio between the piffling industries the Government is trying, by dint of imposing heavy taxes on the consumers of this country, to establish, and the one great industry in this country.

We have to view this proposal in the light of our experience of the Government. The Government has taken on itself exceptional powers, the justification of which would be that there was actually a dangerous situation in this country. I am prepared to agree that there is a dangerous situation in this country. There are illegal, unlawful associations in this country which do represent a very serious threat to the moral and material welfare of the people in this country but the special powers taken by the Government were not designed to deal with them. Those powers were taken merely to deal with a perfectly lawful association and those powers were used merely to make membership of a lawful association carry with it all the penalties that should attach to membership of an unlawful association, and at the same time, the members of the unlawful associations are allowed to go perfectly free. In order to support that situation the Government now indulges in a form of censorship. I can quite understand that, irrespective of other matters, censorship might be exercised merely in the interests of truth, but in this case, we have censorship exercised for the suppression of truth. I will give an instance. United Ireland this week has a number of passages excised from it under the orders of the Government. One passage went this way:—

"The malice of this crime——

that is, the crime committed in Dundalk

—could not be excelled by people who were utterly blind to all moral law. First of all, armed bullies not only denied the right of Irish citizens to differ from them in political opinions, but they implemented this denial by seizing citizens at the point of the gun, maltreating and robbing them."

That was permitted but then, the Government steps in to say that this must not be said:—

"Thereafter, not satisfied with the privileged position our Government has given to their criminal organisation..."

That is excised. Is what is contained there untrue—that the Government has given a privileged position to a criminal organisation? Does anybody doubt that the I.R.A. and Cumann na mBan are criminal organisations? If we examine the Act that the Government has in force, we find that Section 19 says:—

Every association which does any of the following things shall be an unlawful association, that is to say, has amongst its professed objects or advocates or encourages or professes to encourage the overthrow by force of the Government of Saorstát Eireann or the alteration by force of this Constitution or the law.

Is the President going to suggest that this organisation, the I.R.A., which he refuses to take action against, while he takes action against a perfectly lawful organisation, does not fulfil that first condition given there that makes an association unlawful?

The law says that membership of an unlawful association shall be met with certain penalties. The President refuses to apply that law to membership of that organisation, and he denies the right of any person to affirm what he himself knows is perfectly true with regard to his own acts and lack of acts. Paragraph (b) provides that every organisation "without lawful authority organises or maintains or endeavours or purports to organise or maintain an armed force" shall be an unlawful association. Would members of the I.R.A. assert that I was libelling them in saying that they fulfilled that condition: making them an unlawful association to the very uttermost part. Their whole purpose and method is to organise and maintain an armed force. Paragraph (c) says: "promotes or encourages the unlawful possession of firearms by its members."

Does anyone deny that these organisations, protected by this Government that will not apply the existing law against them, "promote and encourage the unlawful possession of firearms." Moreover, paragraph (d) provides: "engages in, promotes, encourages, or advocates any act, enterprise, or course of action of a treasonable or seditious character, or promotes, encourages, or advocates the attainment of any objects of a treasonable or seditious character." The whole purpose of these organisations is to promote and encourage the commission of offences, of obstruction and interference with the administration of justice and the enforcement of the law.

The President knows—he referred to it in Tralee a month or so ago—that an organisation sent out, from its address in Dawson Street, to two jurors, a communication which was an implicit threat to those jurors that if they failed to commit perjury in the service of that organisation they would meet with a traitor's fate. The President referred to that document in Tralee: that there was an organisation, to his knowledge, that aimed at the frustration of justice at the very fountain head in his country.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I would like to hear how the Deputy can relate a discussion of the detailed activities of certain organisations to the Vote before the House.

Comment on this

I will do so. It is proposed to set up a bureau to deal with the Press. At the present moment the Irish people are asked to be taxed in order that the Government may have this weapon for what the President would call, I presume, the dissemination of the truth. We know that the policy of the Government at this moment is to suppress the truth in this country. I am pointing out how they are acting in a tyrannical way in suppressing a mere statement of fact which is irrefutable. I suggest that the possible purpose for which we are now asked to vote money is that the Government may have an efficient machine for the suppression of truth in this country; to prevent people knowing exactly the truth with regard to the Government and its policy. I am pointing out how, even in anticipation of the establishment of this bureau, the Government is acting. I am pointing out that here they have suppressed the words: "Thereafter not satisfied with the privileged position our Government has given to their criminal organisation." An organisation which tries to promote perjury in this country and to defeat justice at the point of the gun is pre-eminently criminal. The law is there for the purpose of dealing with the members of this organisation, but the Government refuse to deal with this organisation. It puts the members of it in a privileged position where the penalties of the law will not be applied to them while, at the same time, the Government with its full knowledge, by making a false declaration, that, in their opinion, a certain organisation is unlawful, knows full well that it does not fulfil any of the conditions laid down for making an organisation unlawful by definition.

The Government distorts, frustrates and abuses the power of Government to get after certain people who are law-abiding while, in a most disgraceful way, it prostitutes government power by withholding the penal operation of the law against certain people who fulfil every condition that makes an organisation unlawful—whose activities include the blowing up of houses, the murdering of men by brutal beatings and an attempt to frustrate justice by promoting perjury amongst jurymen at the point of the gun. Those who do these things are exempt. The law provides that we are not allowed to have guns without permission and licence from the Civic Guard, while the President in this House got up and said that he had no intention of going out to get the guns possessed by the members of this organisation, whose methods are murder and the promotion of perjury in this country. We are not allowed to say—it is sedition to tell the truth in this country—"We are therefore not satisfied with the privileged position our Government has given to their criminal organisation." Is there any member of the I.R.A. or of Cumann na mBan who is not well aware that under this Government they have a privileged position: that they have rights that do not apply to the ordinary citizens of this country. But the ordinary citizens of this country are now being called upon to pay taxes to enable the Government to suppress the truth. The article reads on:—

"They demand that ordinary citizens should shelter their crimes by calling upon Eternal Truth to bear witness to a lie by committing perjury in the courts. The punishment for refusing to commit perjury is, apparently, to be blown up in one's house. And if an elderly woman and tender children should also be blown up it, apparently, means nothing to the degraded consciences of these criminals. It is heartbreaking to think that such things can happen in our country— and how shameful it is that they are done in the name of Irish patriotism.

The words which follow were suppressed. They are not allowed to go before the Irish public. They read:

"And that the organisation that promotes such deeds is in the privileged position of having the law of the land made non-operative against them, while it is strained to breaking point against those who give heroic service to save the youth of Ireland from being led into similar paths of crime."

These words have not been allowed to go before the Irish public, but the Irish public knows perfectly well that every word there is true. They know that the Government's dishonest suppression of that is guided not by zeal for the service of the State but by a foolish attempt to conceal from the Irish people the true acts or lack of acts of this Government. We are not permitted to say that an organisation that promotes such deeds is in "the privileged position of having the law of the land made non-operative against them." The President himself got up and said that the law of the land did not permit of unlicensed and unpermitted arms to be held in this country, although responsible people in this country would not assert Government authority to get and seize arms that he himself at one time had arranged to put in dumps. The article goes on:

"We pointed out only a week ago that unless the Government faces its responsibility and decides on the suppression of the I.R.A. the tide of outrage which has been flowing in the country for some time is bound to rise. Last Sunday's events showed that we are not far from the point when the taking of human life will become almost as much a commonplace as the interruption of public meetings or the blocking of roads. The culpable responsibility of the Government for the evil developments that have been taking place is very great indeed. The statements of many Ministers have been such as inevitably to incite to violence. When Mr. de Valera said that he could not make individuals popular he ought to have known that he was telling the stone-throwers and other attackers of free speech to go on with their job. Even as recently as last Friday Mr. de Valera's organ, the Irish Press, wrote a villainous leading article in which it stated that the ‘proceedings of the Ard-Fheis of Fine Gael were such as to give satisfaction in London.’”

That, of course, was a clear incitement to the blackguards to carry on their blackguarding. The article in United Ireland continued; but this portion of it was suppressed:

"It proceeded by inference further to attack the organisation and its leaders as pro-British and anti-Irish. Such articles lead as surely to violent attacks on the Constitutional Opposition as if that were their sole and deliberate purpose. Fianna Fáil however, has sinned not merely by loose and mischievous talk but by cowardly inaction. While perfectly law-abiding organisations have been banned, and while bank managers and other responsible citizens have been disarmed, the I.R.A., so often condemned by the Hierarchy, and admittedly engaged in subversive activity and Communist propaganda, has been left untouched, and its members have been assured that no search for their arms will be made by the authorities. Until the Government withdraws the promise of immunity from the I.R.A., until it instructs the Civic Guard to get after them, matters are bound to continue to get worse. The Dundalk outrage, one of the vilest since Seán McGarry's house was burned, ought to make even this Government think seriously of the position and prospects and of the duty it owes to the people."

Is there anything untruthful in that? Everybody knows that the Government is refusing to take even the same action against the I.R.A. that it has taken against the National Guard and the Army Comrades' Association, both of which were lawful associations and would, if they still existed, be lawful associations.

Comment on this

On a point of order, what is this debate on?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The debate is on the Vote before the House. The Deputy in possession said he was illustrating his argument by comparisons. For ten minutes, he has been speaking on the desirability of suppressing some organisation and on the legality of another organisation. The line of argument which he has been pursuing is not relevant to the Estimate.

Comment on this

May I point out that, in introducing the Vote, the President stated that one of the objects of the publicity bureau was to prove to the world that we were not on the verge of revolution? Does not that introduce the question of revolution and how near we are to it? Surely, that matter enters into the debate by reason of the President's own statement and, surely, illegal organisations come under the head of revolutionary forces.

Comment on this

The Government is exercising at this moment powers of censorship. If these powers were justly and appropriately used, one might say that there was a case for establishing a special department and that the matter might properly be left in the hands of the Government.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is point in what both Deputies say but it is not in order to debate the desirability of suppressing one organisation, giving details of the activities of that organisation, and the undesirability of suppressing another organisation, with details of the activities of that organisation. It is not in order to go into these matters. The Deputy has been allowed to speak at considerable length on that line and has said sufficient, I think, for the purpose of illustration.

Comment on this

My only point, in dealing with the matter was that the Government might argue that they suppressed the matters in this paper to which I have referred on the ground that they were misrepresenting the truth. In order to bring out the fact, which hardly needs bringing out—it is patent to everybody—that every word contained in those articles was true. I had to refer to the two organisations and to the Government action in connection with them. My sole purpose was to show that the Government is now using its arbitrary powers of censorship to conceal its own criminal acts, I might say, from the people and that it now wants us to vote money to give it an efficient machine that it may pursue this utterly unlawful and immoral campaign and finance it out of the public purse. We are asked to vote the money to do that. The President, I know, can always convince himself that anything he stands for, by virtue of the fact that he stands for it, is right and that anybody who is against it is wrong. His own conscience, I am certain, is clear that everything that will tend to keep him at the head of affairs here is in the national interest and, therefore, that the unfortunate Irish people should be taxed that they may themselves be blinded as to the real facts. I know the President is satisfied that the only destiny God ordained for this country is that it should be ruled by a man named Mr. de Valera. Others may have other views. We may think that to ask us to hand over to a Government that prostitutes its authority and uses its power to defend the evildoer and to punish the law-abiding a machine for misrepresenting the whole position of the people is to ask us to do something which can only be described as criminal. It just happened that I was able to give an illustration in that respect.

There has been a permanent scandal since this Government came into power. We know that the President has an interest—I shall not say a financial interest—in a certain private organ. A regular feature of that organ is to come out with a heading about something or other and, next day, to say "As was exclusively announced in yesterday's Irish Press.” These “exclusives” are always in the nature of departmental information.

Comment on this

Have we or the Government any control over that organ? Is it paid for out of the funds of this House?

Comment on this

That point does not arise. The Government is using its position at the present moment to favour a certain organ.

Comment on this

That is untrue.

Comment on this

Not only is that being done, but when an unfortunate journalist was brought before the Military Tribunal he stated that the information he published, which was not in other papers——

Comment on this

If this is a matter that can be raised at all, surely it is on the Vote for the Department of Justice it should be raised.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No moneys are voted by the Dáil for the paper referred to.

Comment on this

I am not referring to it in that relation.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That journal is not subsidised by the Oireachtas and a discussion of its policy is not in order.

Comment on this

It gets information.

Comment on this

All I am saying is that, at present, the Government——

Comment on this

The Deputy was speaking about journalists and the trial of a journalist.

Comment on this

That surely is most appropriate. The journalist said he had information from official sources. He swore that. We must, therefore, take it as true—that it came from official sources. It may have been from a Minister or somebody acting in the name of a Minister. That journalist had, in order to shelter that person, to break the law and suffer punishment. The law was broken and he suffered punishment in order that an official person should be sheltered. Why was it necessary to shelter that official person? Because that official person, whether he was a Minister or a civil servant, had used his position as public trustee to give a special favour to an organ in which the President is very interested. In order that revelation should not be made as to where that information came from, that unfortunate man had to go to prison. Now we are asked to vote a sum of money for the establishment of a bureau to be in the hands of a Government that, even without that bureau, has used its machine to favour one newspaper in which is has an interest.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

It is quite true.

Comment on this

What is the use of the President's talking in that way. The journalist announced that he had information from an official quarter. That information was not available to other people. What was the official quarter?

The President rose.

Comment on this

Is this a point of order?

Comment on this

Are we to be allowed to reply to all these statements regarding every Department of State, or is this debate concerned with the Estimate before the House?

Comment on this

Is that a point of order or is it not? I ask to be protected from these insolent interruptions by the President.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question asked is whether this debate is to range over the whole field of Government policy.

Comment on this

I suggest that the matter I have been dealing with is most appropriate.

Comment on this

On a point of order, this is a Supplementary Estimate dealing with a specific item in the President's Department. It is not usual on a Supplementary Estimate to discuss the administration of the Department as a whole.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Vote before the House deals with the establishment of a Government information bureau. The Deputy is advancing arguments against the Vote.

Comment on this

I am dealing specifically with information, if not with the bureau. Information was given from official sources, as was sworn by that journalist, who is, incidentally, an employee of an institution in which the President is interested.

Comment on this

Again, I ask——

Comment on this

Is this a point of order.

Comment on this

On a point of order, it is usual on an Estimate to discuss the administration of the Department concerned. If there is any relevancy in the point Deputy Fitzgerald is making, what proof has he that what he alleges arose out of the administration of the President's Department. How has he made it relevant to that Vote, or to this particular Vote?

Comment on this

What we are proposing is to create a new bureau to give information.

Comment on this

To give information, and to vote public money for that purpose.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is a Supplementary Estimate for the Department of the President of the Executive Council, and the Executive has collective responsibility. The Deputy is entitled to give his reasons why money should not be voted for a Government information bureau.

Comment on this

Yes, why it should not be voted, but if there is anything in the Deputy's point it is why money should be voted.

Comment on this

On the contrary, we are asked to vote money for a certain purpose, to be put into the hands of people who, in relation to that purpose, have already shown they cannot be trusted to use it properly. It was sworn in the courts that that information came from an official source, and, when information as to what was the official source was asked for, that information was not forthcoming. The reason that information was not forthcoming was that these official sources have been available to that paper for the last two years and were not available to others. It was in order to shelter that relationship between official sources and that paper, and to continue the feeding of that newspaper with Departmental information that the unfortunate journalist was put in the position of having to break the law which the Government exists to see is not broken. He suffered a penalty for his act, while the really responsible person stayed behind, and, mark this, that man was merely acting as an employee of an editor belonging to an organisation which has, if I remember aright, in its articles of agreement, that the whole policy of the paper was to be such as would be decided by Eamon de Valera. President de Valera has two capacities, as head of the Government and as a private individual. The head of the Government was also responsible for the policy of the paper.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has been told already that the policy of any journal is not in order in this debate.

Comment on this

I was only speaking of the policy of President de Valera.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has referred to the policy of the paper, and that is irrelevant.

Comment on this

I would respectfully suggest that reference to the administration or control of that paper is not relevant either.

Comment on this

As I said, Mr. de Valera has two capacities. He is, no doubt, the official person with authority in this State, and he is the private person. Whatever be the cause, it does happen that the administration of the Government has been able to be worked in order to put a certain newspaper in a privileged position, through which it had certain channels of information, which then led to a situation in which a journalist was put in the position of having to break the law and suffer a penalty for doing so, in order to shelter a person, whether a Minister or otherwise, so that it would not be made public what his channel of information was, and in order to put that newspaper in a better position than its competitors. Now we are asked to vote money to give the Government a machine to carry on a policy of misrepresentation of facts in this country, and a policy of arbitrary power to suppress the truth. It is irrefutable that this Government, while invoking the law to operate against a perfectly lawful association, has ignored unlawful associations whose method is murder.

Comment on this

I should like to ask, sir, how does this arise in a Supplementary Estimate?

Comment on this

I suggest, sir, that I should not be constantly interrupted by the Minister. We are asked to vote this money. As I have already said, I have noted that the President has always had it in his mind that a journalist can somehow or other make black appear white. I know that for years he has had a constant feeling of that want, and that he wanted, as he wrote on the 7th September, 1922: "Mr. S. O'Keeffe to be asking him leading questions."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The President was not a member of the Executive Council in 1922.

Comment on this

No, sir, but it is very unfortunate that in 1934 he should become responsible and use his responsibility and authority in order to gratify that wish that has been operating in his mind fixedly and unchangingly since September, 1922. The Government has used its power already tyrannically. The President has a private organ of his own, which paper——

Comment on this

The Deputy is again referring to the paper. Is that in order?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has been warned that neither the policy of the Irish Press nor of any other journal is in order.

Comment on this

I will try to keep off it, sir. We are asked to embark on a new bureau. What is in the future is unknown. We can only argue from the known to the unknown. This Department is going to be under the supreme control of President de Valera. When you are going to ask the unfortunate people of this country to be taxed for such a purpose as this, ordinary wisdom and human prudence suggest that you can judge what you can anticipate from what you know has already been done. We know that the Government has prostituted its authority in order to suppress the truth. Just like the Minister for Finance last night, when he said that only for the Opposition the British would somehow or other have collapsed on the economic war long ago, but the President will get up probably and say that the loss of the British markets is a Godsend and they will say that if Fine Gael came into power we would not be able to get anywhere. Yet, the Minister for Finance last night assured us that the Opposition was injuring this country by encouraging the British, and that the British can only keep going by virtue of the encouragement they get from us. We are now asked to provide out of public funds a special organ for putting across that kind of dope on the people of this country. The people have been free only for about ten years. We have not the long tradition of freedom behind us that other countries have. It is important that our people should be encouraged to face up to political realities and that they should not be doped in this way. We are asked now —the President not being satisfied with his other resources—to vote out of public funds special moneys to keep the people of this country in ignorance and to mislead them so that they may serve the interests of the Fianna Fáil Party to the detriment of their own interests and of the interests of their country.

Comment on this

I only intend to speak a very few words on this Estimate, but I may say at once that I am entirely opposed to it. My opposition to it is not based, in the main, on the very unfavourable view that we take on this side of the House with regard to the special qualities of the present Government. This is an Estimate which I should oppose no matter how high my opinion were of the Government, because I think it is intolerable in principle that the Government of the day should be given public money to set up a party publicity agent, and I do not really see how anyone sitting on the benches opposite can honestly deny that that is what this gentleman is to be—a party publicity agent. He is to receive a salary which, taking the President's ratio, is the equivalent of paying £59,400 a year in England, or, in a few years' time £66,000 a year. He is to receive as much as one of His Majesty's Ministers sitting on the bench opposite, and the Irish people are to be asked to find that money for the purpose of adding to the resources of Fianna Fáil publicity. I am at a loss to imagine on what reputable ground that action can be defended. I may say, by the way, that this Estimate appears to be somewhat of an insult to Mrs. Sheehy-Skeffington, who informed the world a few days ago that she held the position of Irish national propagandist. As that duty is already being performed free of charge, it seems rather unnecessary to pay a gentleman £1,000 a year to do the same thing, especially as there is to be a staff added later, which will greatly increase the expense.

Deputy Fitzgerald stated that in a time of war a propaganda bureau could be defended. The President might argue that the situation between ourselves and Great Britain was analogous to war, but that is a plea that cannot be admitted, inasmuch as disputes of a financial character between nations occur quite frequently, and the whole world would be driven to an orgy of propaganda if it was to be understood that each time such a dispute arose the Government of the day was justified in creating a bureau to disseminate information.

The President gave as an example of the special need for creating this bureau, that the world in general did not understand that he was willing to submit his case in the financial dispute with England to an impartial tribunal. I do not feel able to let that statement go without challenge, because I do not believe he is willing to submit his case to an impartial tribunal, and I do not believe he has ever been willing to submit his case to an impartial tribunal. If he was, I am quite convinced it could have been accomplished. He would never even go so far as to say that the Irish representatives on the arbitration tribunal would be Irish citizens, because if he had gone so far, the question would then be narrowed down to the selection of a chairman, and there is not a single person in this House so childish that he does not realise that an impartial chairman could be secured; that if one were simply to select a number of reputable and capable people, without considering whether they were inside or outside the Commonwealth, it would be perfectly easy to pick out an impartial chairman. If necessary, we could draw a name out of a hat, without deciding beforehand whether he was a Commonwealth person or a non-Commonwealth person. Moreover, some of the more recent utterances of the President, in which he stated firmly that under no circumstances were any payments ever going to be made to the British again, certainly seem to imply——

Comment on this

General O'Duffy said the same thing.

Comment on this

General O'Duffy did not say the same thing.

Comment on this

Do not let us have repudiations so soon.

Comment on this

General O'Duffy made a statement from which one sentence was extracted carefully by the Irish Press, and that sentence was not what is suggested by Deputies opposite.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Who is responsible?

Comment on this

If the Chair would allow me, I would be perfectly willing to go into the views of the United Ireland Party on the settlement of the economic war. I am afraid the Chair would not allow me, so I will have to ignore the interruptions, much as I would like to deal with them.

Comment on this

We do not take the whole thing seriously, anyway.

Comment on this

I say that the President has made a statement which would seem to imply that, even if he had ever been willing to accept an impartial tribunal, he is no longer willing to accept it, or any tribunal whatsoever. I am personally quite convinced that he never for a moment contemplated accepting any tribunal, and if negotiations about arbitration had gone any further, they would have resulted in his proposing a class of person as Irish representative, and as chairman, who would have turned the arbitration more into a knock-about show than a serious arbitration. I am opposing this Vote. I do not propose to say anything more, except to repeat that this Vote ought to be rejected in any right-thinking Parliament, on principle, quite apart from whether the Government of the day are an especially deserving Government or an especially undeserving Government.

Comment on this

I want to make a few remarks with regard to this Vote. I am opposing it for one or two reasons. Whilst it may be necessary that in this country we should have a Government information bureau I object to the method of the appointment. Since this Government came into power there have been a series of what I can only term political appointments, given to persons of their own particular views in politics, without any examination, or other method of arriving at their fitness for such positions. I object to the method of selection, because we find that in other Departments of State appointments akin to this were made by the Appointments Commissioners. Why was not that practice carried out in the case of this appointment? Certainly there are very many capable journalists in this country, a very large number of whom are capable of undertaking the duties which appertain to this appointment. I would like to know from the President if any of these journalists were interviewed, or if their credentials were examined, and by what method he arrived at the selection of one person amongst the whole journalistic profession. Was the appointment advertised in the ordinary way that Civil Service appointments are advertised? If not, why was not the usual practice adhered to? That practice was consistently followed by the Government that preceded the present Government, and, to a certain extent, it has been followed by the present Government within the past few years. I want to know why that practice has been departed from now.

Comment on this

Last night we spent our time, by contrast with this Vote, in debating the necessity for getting £1,000 from vocational education committees in this country, and we were discussing how we might get an odd £10 or £15 from medical officers of health, and from poor law dispensary officers. The only argument put up in relation to their "cuts" was that it would be unfair to leave these people untouched when everyone else was getting a whack. Here is one man who is not getting a whack. Here is one man who can stand up with a clear conscience and say: "I have gained." Someone is going to get £900 yearly, rising by £25 to £1,000, for giving out Government dope. What is the dope to be about? Look at the enticing list the President gave. The populace and the world must be told the truth about black bread; the populace and the world must be told the truth about the annuities, and the National policy in the matter of arbitration in regard to them.

The world outside, and I suppose the people at home, must be told about revolution and whether we are on the verge of it, a job that would require a man at even more than £900. He has got to show again what is being done in the way of providing employment for our young people. I should like to say a word on some of these items. Black bread! The adjective annoys the President. Supposing he calls it black and tan bread—would it be anything better? Supposing he puts it this way: white bread gone dirty through the Fianna Fáil administration—is it any better? Supposing he calls it white flour blackened by Fianna Fáil handling, will it please any more, or yellow bread for conscripts?

Comment on this
A Deputy

Or "cods."

Comment on this

Or "cods." Or he may say: "Let us call it mourning bread"—we are in the season of Lent —ashen grey for penance, the penance brought on us by the policy of the Party opposite, for their sins. We have had one good year already. Whether it be black bread or whatever colour be decided upon, I suppose it will be an offence to allude to it by any, other name. Perhaps we shall be told that this bread will be the most nutritious and the most wholesome for our people. It will be what the people were sighing for, nourishment from God. It will be something at least as desirable as the loss of the British markets, something possibly for which the President in his exalted moments when he has nothing else to do, after a few prefactory "damns," will thank God. That is a good preamble for the institution of the new Department. We have got to get this bread over. The idea that it is lowering the standard of living for the people has got to be abolished and something put in its place. We will get the same change, perhaps as the President made in the famous interview published in the Manchester Guardian. Possibly there will not be a lower standard but a “changed standard.”

I am glad to see that the new Department is going to deal with the question of the annuities and the payments to Britain. I tried to get the Minister for Finance this morning to deal with this matter and he refused. Will the new Department be called upon to deal with that matter or with the statement made in the British House of Commons recently, that in fact, in so far as certain duties were concerned, which were imposed 21 months ago, and as far as other duties were concerned which were imposed 18 months ago, they have been enabled to extract from the produce of this country and the people of this country, two years defaulting moneys? The man who explains that is worth £900. The Minister who is getting more than £900 could not explain it to-day. He has got to go on to explain further how are we retaining in this country the land annuity moneys if in fact, the British can either in 21 months or 17 months extract the full total from us by duties imposed upon our produce. Will the Information Bureau explain this: what is the justice of asking farmers who used only to pay that portion of the withheld moneys which is represented by annuities, to pay now not merely the annuities, but the R.I.C. pensions?

When the Bureau has answered all these questions will it give us any reason for this further matter? If the loss of the British market is inconsiderable why is it that we send, or what madness is it to send, so much stuff from the Free State into that undesirable market when we are paying more than the land annuities to send that stuff in? Will anybody have the temerity to suggest in view of all that has been collected in duties that we have retained the land annuities in this country? What happens if the British do go back on their own promise and extract more from us than the moneys held by us? Supposing they do collect more than this £800,000, which is to be extracted in a short period, seeing that they have in a shorter period almost by 50 per cent., extracted £660,000, we are in a bad way. Supposing they stop short at the amount we have withheld, what happens the amount which should be devoted to sinking fund purposes? The British say that they are not bound to pay into the sinking fund and they are not paying into it. It was provided under the sinking fund arrangement that the annuities would be terminable at some future date, but no provision is now being made for the sinking fund, so that the annuities will be paid in perpetuity and that is what is called saving the country money. I asked the Minister for Finance a question in regard to these two items to-day. I asked him, if the position which I think might occur, should arise, and if as a result of that position the British really extracted from us more than we withheld, what provision he had made to meet the situation. The Minister said he was not prepared to admit that such a situation could arise and added: "If it should, no doubt the Government will be fully able to deal with it." May I put this gloss on it: that they will be able to fool the people on this problem as they did on the land annuities problem? The result of that will be, that in that roundabout way with a great dislocation of trade, we in fact pay more than what it is said we are keeping from them. That is the second item the President has outlined for his Information Bureau. We are going to have the whole matter of these annuities discussed. They involve the finances of this country. We had a Loan here recently and this morning also I tried to get from the Minister for Finance some particulars in regard to that Loan. It is a thing the Government should be anxious to explain.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Committee is debating a Vote for a Government Information Bureau. I was not in the House when the President spoke. The Deputy has asserted that the President mentioned certain matters——

Comment on this

I am taking that on hearsay too, sir. I was not here either.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The President apparently referred to certain matters with which the Bureau might deal. Obviously it would not be in order to take all possible items, pursue them in detail or anticipate the work of the Bureau or draw up a questionnaire for the guidance of the Bureau. It is not in order to bring in by a side wind the question of the Loan in regard to which the Deputy has a question on the Order Paper to-day.

Comment on this

Might I get that ruling explained? Am I precluded from raising anything, simply because I raised a question in regard to it on the Order Paper to-day?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No.

Comment on this

I take it further that in seeking information on matters affecting the new Department, we are not to be restricted to the matters which the President mentioned.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Does the Deputy suggest that he is entitled to deal with all aspects of Government policy on this Vote? Surely the Deputy does not contend that any activity of any Government Department which a Deputy may wish to discuss can be debated on this Vote? It certainly can not. A question was asked to-day by the Deputy in regard to the last National Loan. The question was answered and if the Deputy thinks that by a side wind on this Vote he can debate that matter now, particularly as he was precluded from debating it on the adjournment he is mistaken.

Comment on this

I did not attempt to raise it on the adjournment.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I beg the Deputy's pardon. I have made a mistake as to the matter which the Deputy wishes to raise on the adjournment.

Comment on this

It was the question which I have now debated that I was precluded from raising on the adjournment. I take it that the question of black bread is a major item of Government policy on which the Bureau will supply information so that it is relevant for discussion on this Vote? Is there anything more important to the country than the finances of the country, with which the question of the National Loan is linked up, and the failure of the National Loan? If there is anything which the Government Bureau will find it necessary to deal with it is this question——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Let us get clear on this matter. The Deputy has reverted to the contention that this officer when appointed will have to deal with all aspects of Government policy and that therefore all aspects of the National Loan, for instance, are open for discussion. That is not the case. Deputies are limited to advancing reasons why such a Bureau should or should not be established.

Comment on this

The President's only speech on this matter was to show by a series of examples what the Bureau would deal with. That was the only excuse given—that there was a necessity for dealing with items, and the President outlined some. If we are not to go beyond what the President mentioned, then where is the limit to be put? I suggest that it is certainly not to be limited just because the President chose certain things, otherwise we will be forced to the conclusion that if the President made no speech in moving we could not discuss the Vote, which is absurd.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has not given any such ruling.

Comment on this

I am not saying so.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair said that Deputies might give reasons for and against the appointment of such an officer, but that the debate should not range over all the matters with which that Bureau might possibly deal. It should be obvious to the House that every activity of the Government might on that contention be raised—which would result in an interminable debate. Reasons may be advanced for or against the institution of the Bureau, but Government policy may not be debated.

Comment on this

Let me confine myself to the points which the President gave as the foundation for the introduction of this Vote to pay this £900 per annum for the purpose of establishing a Bureau. Revolution was the next item. I do not know if there was a colour attached to it. Journalists are fond of the word ruddy in front of that. Are we on the verge of revolution? The President has led quite a number of people to believe that we are. The President was forced to employ an instrument which he detested— the Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act. And why? Mainly because of the famous Hailsham lie. That was his own statement. Having this information on our hands, we could not do otherwise than introduce this. At the moment there are men being brought up on charges which the Ministry themselves, when examples are given to them amongst their own servants, describe as ridiculous.

Deputy Fitzgerald dealt at length with the revolution aspect, and I am not going into it in detail. The basis of the President's contention for the use of the so-called abominable instrument of the Military Tribunal, described by his Minister for Finance as the seven bloodhounds long ago, is the fact that somebody lied to him and he was foolish and weak enough to believe a monstrous statement, flung out here as truth, about Deputy Mulcahy. He has run away every time that has been put to him since, and refused to give information about it. Will the Bureau give the information, or hereafter is this £900 a year man to stand for the odium and contempt which the President's weakness in believing stories that he is too anxious to believe may bring upon him?

The matter of the imprisoned journalist was raised already. I want only to say this about it: somebody in Government circles, according to the oath of the journalist, not denied by his editor, gave information exclusively to that paper. The person who gave the information was not man enough to come forward and say where it came from, and the Ministry who were brought into that case through that particular piece of evidence were not plucky enough to admit who had the responsibility on him for making the statement, and one man suffered. Is the new appointee here going to be put in this ugly position, that any time there is a mishandling of Government information he is the man to be hauled before the Military Tribunal and do his month or six weeks for refusing to answer a question? Is that what the £900 a year, rising by £25 per year, is to be given for? I think in China they used to have a system whereby a man could buy himself off punishment by putting forward a substitute. Is that the game here? The President can laugh. The President used not to laugh when Hailsham was mentioned before. He used the phrase once about words twisted by knaves to make a trap for fools. He was either a knave or a fool, or possibly himself never understood it, and he certainly twisted the phrase. He now gets another conscience to put between himself and the public — a salaried conscience. If there is another journalist to be imprisoned, this, presumably, will be the man; at any rate, this is the man on whom the odium will lie, and the President can indulge in his favourite game of repudiation.

The biggest job of all in connection with the Bureau is to tell of the means employed to give employment to the people of the country. Might I suggest a few figures that he might explain? Speaking in this House before Christmas, the Minister for Industry and Commerce asserted that the really true test as to the growth of employment was the test of the Unemployment Insurance Fund and the stamps that were bought for it. It is a good test. He stated in this House that in 1928 those figures were so much, in 1929 so much — an increase; and in 1930 still an increase. He then took a deep breath and took the plunge and said that in 1933 they were up by £60,000. Then he made a rapid calculation, and it was an accurate one this time, that £4 in the fund represents a man given employment for 50 weeks in the year. He then divided the figure by four and immediately there were 15,000 people in employment to his credit. That bubble did not last long. Another question put down revealed that the money had to be divided between the years 1931, 1932 and 1933, and it then appeared — this is possibly subject to explanation by the Bureau — that in 1931, the last year of the regime that was destroying Irish industry, 11,000 people had gone into new occupations. Then the Minister for Industry and Commerce came with his high tariffs, quotas, impositions, and helping the Minister for Finance to save money, and we find that in that year, with all these advantages and all the enthusiasm of a new Government and a new policy that is going to turn the country into a paradise, he put less than 6,000 people into employment. Last year, with the continuance of the high tariffs and extra impositions and bounties and quotas, he had 1,500 people put into employment.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy might show the relevancy of the number put into employment to this Estimate.

Comment on this

If the President is going to ask the Bureau to tell how the Government is providing employment for young people, I am asking him to explain certain figures. I submit it is quite relevant. In two years the new policy which was to provide employment for the people has not succeeded in putting anything like as many into employment as the last Government did in the last years of its period. There is another side to that. To-day I asked a question as to the drawing out of the fund. That is the opposite side to it. New men may come into the fund, but the people who are still there may get out of employment and may draw from it.

In 1931, there was a sum of £546,000 paid out in benefit, and in 1932, the great year of tariffs, the great year of employment, the year when 84,000 people were to be given new employment, the payment of benefit increased to £638,000, nearly £100,000 more by way of unemployment insurance benefit. That certainly will be something for the Information Bureau to think about, and that represents only industry. I suppose when the President speaks of employment he will include agriculture. What about the number registered as unemployed? What about the increased numbers going on home assistance? What about the Unemployment Assistance Bill which, according to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, is to provide relief for 60,000 people for whom no work can be got? According to the Minister for Education, it is not right to talk of 60,000 people; the figure should be 90,000.

Comment on this

What about your own statement that they may die of starvation?

Comment on this

I never said it. I have refuted it a dozen times. I will take you to Grangegorman on it.

Comment on this

That might be risky for Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this

A few of you should be put in there.

Comment on this

Will the new Bureau talk about peat? Will it tell us the price at which peat is being retailed in the City of Dublin? Will it give us the equivalent figures in calorific value as between peat and coal? Will it tell us that the result of the peat scheme is that the people in the tenements of Dublin are paying very nearly as much for the peat brought from the country districts as they are paying for coal with the tariffs imposed on it, and that the best that can be said for peat is that it has about half the heating value of coal?

Comment on this
A Deputy

It is Irish, anyway.

Comment on this

There are lots of other things Irish that could be burned too, but we refrain from doing it. Will it be the task of the Bureau to make ready the way for all new schemes? Will they have to do propaganda? Will they indicate the economic value of the articles that are going to be produced? Will they tell us whether these things are being dealt with on the basis of giving good value for good money, or will it simply mean sloshing more money around?

Comment on this

What about wheat?

Comment on this

That is beyond even the propaganda department.

Comment on this

What about chaff?

Comment on this

They may deal with agriculture generally. They may tell us in a sort of jocose way why the Minister for Agriculture has gone on to milk. The story used to be told of Lincoln that when he proposed to move a General whom he admired, General Grant, to pursue one of the defeated Generals on the other side, the objection was raised that he drank, and his answer was: "I would like to know the brand; I will send some barrels of it to other people; he wins battles." I can see the President looking at the Minister for Agriculture and his drink and work, and saying: "If I catch any of the rest of you drinking milk, you will be sacked." Think of that unfortunate man. He has all the oats of the country to carry. Previously I represented him as staggering about like a new Atlas with a greasy load of butter on his shoulders. He probably will have to bear part of the repercussions of the peat scheme. He certainly will fall foul eventually of those who have been deluded about wheat. He is getting into trouble already about tobacco. I wonder is there anything upon which he can pride himself? Is there anything that the new Bureau will be able to say on his behalf?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy knows that much of what he said was quite irrelevant.

Comment on this

It is funny.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy spoke of the price of peat and the comparative calorific values of peat and coal. He spoke of providing something for the Information Bureau to think about. The duty of Deputies is not to provide material for thought for the Information Bureau, but to give reasons for or against the establishment of the Bureau. The Deputy proceeded to deal personally with the Minister for Agriculture. Surely that does not arise on the question of the advisability or otherwise of appointing an Information Bureau.

Comment on this

If the Information Bureau will not deal with the Minister for Agriculture and all his works and pomps about this country, I do not consider it worth voting a shilling to, nor will anybody in this agricultural country, either. However, I will not wander much further. There is one last question I would like to raise. Deputy Anthony raised the matter of the appointment. Who is it going to be, and who is going to make the appointment? The papers have reported a certain name. That may be repudiated. Somebody may have to suffer for having given wrong information. I hope, to a certain extent, that the name is a correct one, not that I am to be taken as approving of the appointment, the person appointed, the salary given, or the whole scheme. I am, at any rate, glad of this, that the Ministry have not stooped to take anybody from a newspaper which has been found recently in this country professing it is an upholder of Christian principles, and even the great upholder of law and morals, and then stooping to review a book last Tuesday——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The review of a book in a certain daily paper is certainly not in order.

Comment on this

May I say this to put it in order——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No; the Deputy must not discuss the matter further.

Comment on this

The book itself has been declared out of order by the Minister for Justice as being generally indecent, and yet that paper reviewed it.

Comment on this

What is the name of it?

Comment on this

"Shake Hands with the Devil."

Comment on this

The Deputy who is departing showed such a complete lack of ingenuity and collapsed so suddenly that I take it the intention is to talk this matter out as long as ever the Deputies over there can manage to do so, and that they will endeavour to bring in every possible subject, to drag in everything they can. They began by putting up Deputy Desmond Fitzgerald, who, when he accompanied the ex-President to America, was described as a reformed poet. We all know what poetic licence means. It means that you are never on your oath. Well, Deputy Desmond reformed poet Fitzgerald was certainly not on his oath to-night. He has gone out so that he cannot be cross-examined. He led the House to believe that the Government had actually censored a disreputable little rag issued by the U.I.P., that they had actually cut out passages of it. Now, there are a good many people in the House, and I am putting it to all sides of the House whether that impression was or was not conveyed by Deputy Desmond Fitzgerald. I am asking Deputy Desmond Fitzgerald or any other member of his Party to say whether it is true in fact that the Government, or any part of the Government did cut out, censor, black-out in the United Ireland Party organ the passages which he says were blacked out? It is very easy for him to get out of the House. It is very easy for the Deputy, having made that statement, and having put before this House statement after statement in relation to that, to get out so that he will not have to answer that question, the question of who it was took it out. Who took those pieces out of the paper? It is a disgraceful thing to have done that, it is a disreputable thing to have done it, according to the reformed poet. But who did it? He left you under the impression that it was the Government. I am asking the Cumann na nGaedheal Party or the U.I. Party, or the Farmers' Party or the National League or whatever they are calling themselves at the present moment — you have got to be very up to date to know what their name is——

Comment on this

It is not a "No Income-Tax Party."

Comment on this

Have you changed your name since last night?

Comment on this

The League of Youth.

Comment on this

The League of Youth! They are getting so young that if they get much younger they will have to be carried around in cradles. But I am getting back to the statement actually made that the Government censored and destroyed portions of their wretched little rag. Deputy Desmond Fitzgerald is not the only person who knows all about that rag. I am putting it to the other rag merchants: Is it or is it not true to say that the Government did take out portions of that paper, and if it is not true, who was it, that of their own choice, did that disgraceful thing? Somebody had better send a message to Deputy Desmond Fitzgerald that we would like to get him here in the box. Another thing he told us about was "a single farmer's wife." That is not merely poetic licence. That is the very indecency that the Deputy who has just departed from the House has protested against so violently, "a single farmer's wife!"

He said there was a dangerous situation in the country; that there was an organisation here consisting of most disreputable people, a privileged criminal organisation. Deputy—no, not Deputy, but I think it is a pity he does not come here instead of leaving his office boys to talk for him and contradict him, instead of leaving his office boys to explain him away— General O'Duffy said the other day that every single member of the I.R.A. were Communists, and then he went on to say that he got 500 of these Communists in the U.I.P., and he next went on to say that there were 750 Guards dismissed for conduct of one kind or another that deserved dismissal and then he said that he got the majority of them in the U.I.P. —this privileged Communist organisation consisting of criminals recruited from the I.R.A. He has these and the disreputable members of the Guards, 750 of them.

We generally hear stories of miles of Blueshirts. The highest figure I have yet seen of the Blueshirts in the Press was exactly the number of the 750 disreputable Guards and the 500 recruited Communists of the I.R.A. Naturally, Deputy Desmond Fitzgerald said that there is a privileged criminal organisation. But we are not privileging. Are they only suggesting that the President is privileging it? Then we have this salaried conscience. There is not a single man on the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches who ever drew or would draw a salary. There is such a high moral tone that their whole Party, through which they have carried on the government of this country, is such that not one single one of them took a salary. Some of them would not even take four salaries and a bonus at the same time.

They were so conscientious that they would not even divulge to the House for fear it might discredit the House, for fear it might shake and appal the conscience of the House, that while they were acting as medical officers, while they were acting as Deputies, while they were acting as other things as well, they were also directors. A "salaried" conscience — four times "salaried" conscience! I hope that in future, when some time 3,000 years after Tibb's Eve Deputies with long grey beards, with sticks to help them in, will come in to occupy again the Front Benches of Government and not that of the Rotary Club, it will be clearly understood there will be no salaries for fear it would interfere with their delicate consciences. Again, there is a censorship. They say it is not a censorship in the interests of the truth. They say it is a censorship in the interests of everything that is untrue. I wonder if that particular newspaper man were to publish the actual speech that Mr. O'Duffy delivers instead of the speech that is handed by his secretary to the Press, whether that would be regarded as censorship in the interests of truth? It is time that somebody went round and really did collect these gems of political wisdom which are being suppressed by, I am sorry to say, all the papers.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And which are not pertinent to this debate.

Comment on this

Only to the speech, and I am getting off that. I am only indicating this. The next thing they said was that the activities of this Press Bureau would be directed against perfectly lawful organisations. Now I take it that they mean the hydra-headed, multi-named organisation to which they at the moment belong; or perhaps they are in process of changing from it to another organisation, whatever that is. They mean the Fine Gael, or the fine gale — the big wind. That is a perfectly lawful organisation, and that statement is made by the ex-Minister, who passed the Public Danger Act, which at the present moment they are so very much annoyed about not having destroyed. Under the precise provisions of that Act, by the precise machinery laid down by that Act created by them, that mutable organisation does in fact become an unlawful organisation. A perfectly lawful organisation, therefore, is one which is, under the Act and the direct provisions of the Act passed by the gentlemen who complain of it, an unlawful society. We did not create the machinery. We did not create the machinery which we are told is being strained, and which made of those various organisations and their overnight successors illegal organisations. The Deputies opposite created it; the Deputy who complained of it created it, and it is under precisely that same machinery that whatever was done to the little rag of a U.I.P. organ was done. They are responsible for it, whatever it is. If a perfectly lawful organisation has become an entirely unlawful organisation it has become an entirely unlawful organisation under the provisions of the precise machinery set up for the purpose of making it an unlawful organisation. They went on to say — I myself am frequently puzzled to see how I can be in order in discussing what they did say; I am referring to that delicate conscience which I have in those matters, and it is not a salaried conscience in this matter at all, but when a Deputy has for five or six years trod the path of order, without ever departing even by a hair's breadth from it, it is a rather serious matter that he should feel himself now being led down the primrose path to disorder following a reformed poet. They told us that this Government — and remember we are discussing a motion to set up a Press agency of some kind — has committed a horrible primevality. I should like a glass of water, I cannot go on on milk!

Comment on this

What about light beer?

Comment on this

I do not think the Ceann Comhairle would allow me to discuss light beer except in its relation to milk, which I think I will be able to do later. This criminal organisation called a Government has actually allowed people to have guns without permission, and they want to know whether this new Press agent is going to repeat the declaration of the President that he has no intention of going out to get the guns. Since when has it become a new thing for a President not to go out after and get the guns? Did the President who went to America with the reformed poet go out after the guns where he knew they were? Did General MacDuffy go out and get them where he knew they were, and where he told the late President they were? Did he go out after the guns which he knew were in the hands of his own supporters, and which were taken out of the barracks of this country with the knowledge of the then Government? Is there anything new about a President who does not go out to get the guns? If there is not, why should they be so worried that there is to be set up a Press agent who might possibly talk about things of this kind? Is it that they are afraid? Is it that they are afraid that this disreputable Pressman might say: "The custom of this country, as initiated by President Cosgrave and followed by President de Valera, is that no President will go out after the guns in the possession of anybody whom he thinks ought to have them." There was ten years' precedent for that before we came in. What is wrong with the precedent? There is nothing wrong with the President; I am speaking of the precedent. What is wrong with the precedent? For ten years Cumann na nGaedheal allowed anybody that suited them to have any kind of weapon they liked, to use in any way they liked, on whom they liked, for any purpose that suited their own Party.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle. Fianna Fáil

The Parliamentary Secretary has expressed a conscientious regard for the rules of order and procedure. The Chair suggests that he has gone quite far enough on the lines he has been pursuing.

Comment on this

My difficulty has been that I have been listening, as I thought, to the devil quoting Scripture from the other side. They then go on to what they say is a permanent scandal in this country the relations between the President and a particular Press organ in this country. They go on and talk about that for as long as they like. What would have happened in this country if there had not been that Press organ? What would have happened in this country if there had not been someone else, outside the ring of paid and kept Press, for the purpose of telling the truth?

Comment on this

There might be no income tax.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy will ever pay income tax out of his income as a professional man.

Comment on this

Joke over.

Comment on this

What a nice man.

Comment on this

What would have happened if there had not been that Press? I am only going to give you one illustration. I want you to go back to the day when the kept Press came out, the day before a general election, with the story that a Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy and two Civic Guards had been murdered by Fianna Fáil. You remember that?

Comment on this
A Deputy

No, they forget it.

Comment on this

That story came out. Every time before a general election they had some stunt to work. That was a stunt apparently which they had kept for the general election in 1932. What would have happened if there was not another Press in this country, of the kind which yon are attempting to attack?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies on the opposite benches were forbidden by the Chair to discuss the policy of a certain Dublin daily paper.

Comment on this

I accept that absolutely, and I am not going to discuss the policy. I am simply dealing with the question of the existence of that thing, the President's connection with which was attacked — the bare existence of it. If that thing had not existed that lie would have been got away with, and because that thing which they have stigmatised and attacked did exist that lie was caught and throttled and strangled and broken, and a different Government was sent here, sent on to these Front Benches than would have been sent if that damned lie had been allowed the propaganda and the freedom and the exaggeration that it would have had in the hands of the kept Press. If there were not somebody to publish on that morning the result of the inquest, everybody knows what would have happened. Naturally, they do not like the Press which queered the pitch of the vilest and most contemptible political manoeuvre that has ever disgraced politics in this country. Then, Deputy MacDermot discussed, with considerable liberality the possibility of the existence of an impartial tribunal. He told us and went into detail on the difficulties in regard to it, of the kind of tribunal that might have been set up. This is on the question of whether or not we would have a Press bureau in this country. Am I to follow him into that track? I think I will not, sir. I think I will leave him wandering in the inane by himself.

Deputy Anthony wants to talk about political appointments. Our predecessors never did—these Simon Pures, these unsalaried consciences that set up the Appointments Board after they had stuffed every place in this country that they could with their own pals. Yes, I like the conscience of these people who do not like political appointments after they had filled the plums for themselves. They set up the Appointments Commission to prevent themselves having to decide between all the other people whom they did not reward and now what the poor unfortunate Pressman has to do with political appointments, I am again puzzled to know, but I am perfectly satisfied that Deputies opposite who, for ten long years, occupied the Front Benches of the Government and had all the responsibilities of Government, and all the respect which they naturally had for this great institution they have set up, must have known what that had to do with the Pressman or they would not have talked about it. My small intelligence, however, suggests to me that I might leave that alone also, until we come to discuss it on the Rates Motion of Deputy Belton on which, I understand, everything is in order.

Then, Deputy McGilligan had a meal of black bread, war bread, famine bread, all these terrible things that are going to destroy the teeth and the digestion and tear down the physique of this country — something that you will not be able quite to decide whether it is axle grease or animal food. That is the sort of thing that is held out to us as black bread. It is held out to us as black bread by the very Deputies who ate it in the restaurant day after day and did not know that they were eating it. I wonder if the propagandist, salaried-conscience Pressman will let that out? I wonder if by any chance he would reproduce, for the benefit of the public, cross sections, at different angles, of white and black bread? He might, for instance, start a lottery, a guessing competition, as to which was the white and which was the black bread. He would be amazed at the disreputable things he could do, but whatever he does with black bread, the Deputies opposite ate it and did not know anything about it. Deputy McGilligan then goes on to raise a high question of economic policy upon which I think you will agree, sir, that I would be bound to discuss not merely tariffs, quotas, credit-reform systems, and millennium dawnings but these two years of defaulted money which the British are supposed to have collected in one year. All that propaganda is founded on the idea— and it is one which I commend to the Minister for Finance because it is going to make his Budget very, very convenient — that all taxes that are collected on tariffed imported goods are paid by the person who sends in the goods. The whole calculation of Deputy McGilligan depends on adding together the whole of the taxes collected on Irish goods sent into England and he says that all those are paid by Ireland. If the Minister for Finance wants to balance his budget, all he has got to do is to go on putting tax after tax on the British and say that the British are paying all the taxes as they come in. There is not, even on the opposite side, a fool big enough to believe that. That, however, is the contention which is made.

Comment on this

There is not a fool——

Comment on this

There is a fool big enough to open his mouth.

Comment on this

There is not a fool big enough here to make that statement.

Comment on this

They say that there is a fool born every minute. Deputy Belton must have been born twice and born twins. The next thing that Deputy McGilligan says is that the annuities are made perpetual, but what on earth is to happen in a country in which there are only two points of agreement which unite the whole people, one being that we will both scandalously break faith with England. That is one and there was not anybody in this House, or anybody in the other House who mattered, who was not prepared, in the opinion of the British, deliberately to break faith with the British on three Bills introduced in this country.

Comment on this

In the opinion of whom?

Comment on this

In the opinion of St. Thomas of Westminster.

Comment on this

In the opinion of one man.

Comment on this

In the opinion of St. Thomas of Westminster.

Comment on this

In the opinion of Lord Hailsham only, so far as I know.

Comment on this

In the opinion of St. Thomas of Westminster. In the opinion of the British and in the opinion of the people you have got to negotiate with. There is, however, a second matter on which there is universal agreement. It is really amazing. They change their opinions nearly as quickly as they change their names. We have universal agreement now that, whatever Government is in power, no Government in this country will pay the annuities. According to Deputy McGilligan, we are faced with the horrible prospect of the annuities being made perpetual in a country in which no Government will pay the annuities.

Comment on this