We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Vote No. 3—Department of the President of the Executive Council.

Contributions 141–286 of 286. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

On a point of order, this matter was raised by interruption when I was speaking and you will recollect, sir, that I decided not to pursue it on the grounds that it would be out of order. I should like to submit that if Deputy Flinn is to be permitted to proceed with this, I should have the opportunity of replying. We are in Committee, I believe.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Parliamentary Secretary is replying to points in the speech of Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this

He is nominally doing so but I submit that nothing that Deputy McGilligan said justifies the line he is now taking as to the unanimity of the House in regard to never paying the annuities.

Comment on this

Do you repudiate General O'Duffy?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has raised the point that the, parliamentary Secretary has gone more deeply into the matter than any Deputy on the opposite benches who preceded him. That is quite true.

Comment on this

I accept that, sir. The suggestion is that I have gone deeper into the perpetuality of the annuities —

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Into the question of the land annuities, which is not relevant to this debate.

Comment on this

I agree that it is not relevant and I apologise to myself for being dragged off the regular and straight path to follow the variegations and wanderings of those bright boys opposite. It is puzzling when you think that the mind of every Deputy who spoke on the other side was imbued with revolution. They could not get off the word "revolution."

Comment on this

I never mentioned it.

Comment on this

I never mentioned it; therefore nothing was said.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary said "every Deputy."

Comment on this

What the Deputy has not said has not been said; what the Deputy does not know is not known; no one who is not the Deputy does not exist. That is a syllogism for the Deputy.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary has said that every Deputy on this side who had spoken had talked about revolution. That statement of his is utterly incorrect.

Comment on this

If, by any chance, the Deputy did violate the rule and custom of his Party by not doing so, I apologise. But how on earth he managed to keep off it I do not know, considering that it seems to he the only thing——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Parliamentary Secretary might manage to get on to the matter before the House.

Comment on this

I was getting on to it. The next question was the registered unemployed. What that has to do with the Press bureau I frankly do not know, but a late member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, a respectable member of society, a man who has "walked with kings and yet not lost the very common touch," thought it was in order. I will tell you what the Press bureau will say on the unemployment question. He wanted to know what it might possibly tell him about the unemployed. It will tell him that in every day of every week and of every month since last June up to the end of this year the figures were better, progressively better, than they were in the previous year. It will also tell him that all the slanderous misrepresentations made are due to the difference between the figures of last year and the one before it. It will tell him that that misrepresentation was due to the deliberate and maliciously untruthful suppression of the fact that those figures were taken upon an entirely different basis. I think that would be a very useful thing for the Press bureau to do. Say that you take the case of people on the other side who are asking to enter into certain contractual relations and, after they have discounted the fact that we are all liars, thieves and murderers here, after they have discounted the fact that no Party in this country will keep its agreement and the fact that both Parties in this country have decided that under no condition whatever, whatever Government is here, will they ever pay to England, to Mother England, their just debts——

Comment on this

I submit again that this is out of order.

Comment on this

After they have discounted all those things they will still be faced by the fact that it is suggested this country is unstable in the sense that our unemployment figures are right; that the people are becoming less able to meet their obligations even if they could. Is not that a matter for the Press bureau: to say what I have said in this House and what the Deputies can quite easily check: that no Deputy in this House has contradicted and that no Deputy on the other side of the House has had the manliness to repeat—that in every day of every week and every month from last June until the end of this year the figures have been improved. It might go on to tell them something more about the unemployment figures: that there has in the interval been a new Act passed for the purpose of dealing with unemployment in a different manner: in a more Christian manner: that a new inducement has been held out to the people artificially to register. It might go on to explain that the unemployment registration figures are rising and must rise until we reach a new balance represented by the bringing in of the people who think that they are entitled to get maintenance out of the new Act. Would not that be very desirable, a proper thing for the Press bureau to speak of? There are various other things that it might speak of. I have no doubt that there are Deputies on this side and on the other side of the House who, before the debate concludes, will think of a lot of other valuable and useful information that this new officer of the State will be able to give.

Then again, I know that your imagination will also be a little bit shocked —I mean there are certain things that expand your imagination. We discussed then peat and the price of beet. God only knows what we did not discuss.

Comment on this
A Deputy

And butter.

Comment on this

Yes. There was greasy butter. There is a very beautiful little town — I give this as an illustration of how far one might travel if one were prepared to link arms with the staggering Deputies opposite.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not know if the Parliamentary Secretary was in the House at the time, but if he were, he certainly is aware that a member of the Opposition was prevented by the Chair from discussing the activities of the Minister for Agriculture and ceased to do so as soon as his attention was called to it by the Chair. Opposition members were told they could not discuss every possible aspect of Government policy which might be dealt with by this Information Bureau, and the Parliamentary Secretary is proceeding to do exactly that thing: to initiate a debate that might not end for weeks if that line were allowed to be pursued.

Comment on this

With every possible respect, I submit that I have not raised one single new point, and that I have not dealt with a quarter of the old points that are available. When I think of all the things that I might discuss: the heat value of peat and how much of it you get for a penny, and how it compares with coal; the production of industrial alcohol and why the Minister for Agriculture went on to milk, my moderation amazes me.

Comment on this

After the exhibition of peace-time deck tricks which we have been treated to for the last halfhour, it is difficult for anybody who witnessed that exhibition to realise that this is the same House which last night forged through a Bill to victimise every vocational officer up and down this country in order to get the sum of £1,000 per annum, and that now in this light-hearted frivolous mood we are to put through, in a frivolous spirit, an Estimate for £10,000 to spread the political propaganda of Deputy Hugo Flinn's Party. I wonder if in doing this there is any recollection of the fact that it is not 12 months ago since a Bill or a motion to provide something like £100,000 was put through this House to subsidise the political organ of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

That is an untruth.

Comment on this

Do you mean that it is the organ? If so, I agree.

Comment on this

The whole thing is untrue.

Comment on this

Coming back to where I left when I was interrupted, I ask the House to remember that last night we were asked to victimise every teacher under every vocational educational committee in the country and every dispensary doctor in the country, and that these teachers got their salaries chopped to provide £1,000 per annum for a State in distress. We are asked now to provide a sum of £10,000 to disseminate Fianna Fáil propaganda. That £1,000, collected off every teacher of a vocational education committee, is to go to employ one man to spit out Fianna Fáil propaganda. I ask the House to recollect that, within the last 12 months, we had to provide a sum of approximately £100,000 to subsidise the Irish Press— the newspaper of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this
A Deputy

That is not so.

Comment on this

It was, I think, £100,000 plus £10,000. I disremember the exact figure, but it is on the records of the House.

Comment on this

I should like to say that that statement, in whole and in part, is untrue.

Comment on this

You are very fond of contradicting yourself, but you should get out of the habit of contradicting others when they are right. We have had this particular proposal referred to by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance as an Estimate to provide a Press agency — a Press agency for the Party in power, a Press agency at the expense of the taxpayer to bolster up a tottering political Party. We had no justification given us by the individual who introduced the Estimate beyond the statement that it had to do with black bread and revolution. If this were to put an instrument into the hands of the Government, costing either £10,000 or 100 times that amount, an instrument that would be genuinely used by the Government to deal with revolution or threatened revolution, I should have no hesitation in voting for the provision of the money. But that organ, which has been already so heavily subsidised has, so far, only added to the forces of revolution in this country, and has never come out to condemn any of the agents or forces driving this country towards revolution.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have pointed out to other Deputies that the policy of the daily papers, or of any particular daily paper, is not in order on this Estimate.

Comment on this

I was discussing more the revolution to which the President alluded.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy referred to a particular paper.

Comment on this

I am really at a loss, following the Parliamentary Secretary, to know exactly what can be dealt with and what cannot be dealt with. We had from the speaker who spoke last an exhibition of clowning, but very few facts. I presume that a subsequent speaker is entitled to follow him in the particular matters he dealt with or attempted to deal with.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Parliamentary Secretary replied to arguments which were irrelevant on this Vote. The Deputies concerned and the Parliamentary Secretary were pulled up by the Chair.

Comment on this

I am always very obedient when it comes to the ruling of the Chair. I propose merely to reply to some of the arguments put forward by the Parliamentary Secretary. In his remarks with regard to the likelihood of revolution and his justification for the exercise of the powers of the Public Safety Act, he pointed to the fact that it was the creation of the Party that now sits here. He rather laboured the point which has been laboured with very little success by lawyers sitting opposite, that any organisation declared under that Act to be illegal is thereby illegal. If he had ever read the Act, or even glanced at it, he would know that the declaration in itself does not make any organisation illegal, but that that declaration is supposed to depend on contributory factors named and on evidence forthcoming that, in some one of these particulars, the organisation has offended the law. The change of name, which he is so skittish about, is not any more remarkable than, nor is it so precipitate as the change of the man who wanted to lead a No Income-Tax Party in this country when he was blowing the bugle of Cumann na nGaedheal down in Cork, and changed not only his outlook, his political label, his financial tune, but his whole public creed merely because he was not selected by that Party and put up as a candidate. People in glass houses should not throw stones.

Changes of name on this side were merely in compliance with the laws made by the opposite side. The change probably upset people opposite. They would like us to follow in their footsteps, defying the law because those laws were made by political opponents. They would like to provoke us into the same type of lawlessness that they created, fostered and encouraged up to the date that they became the Government of this country. If there is one thing that this country should be proud of, it is that there are in it organisations of youth that are not too hot-blooded or blinded by passion to comply with the law, no matter how unjustly it is administered. I myself felt, when I spoke here on a previous occasion, that successive bans would have the effect of stirring up organised trouble throughout the country. At that time, I ventured to express the hope that such would not occur. I am proud to-night to be able to boast that such did not occur. The provocation of successive bans having failed to drive these people into revolt against the laws of the State, are being supplemented by every provocative statement that can be made by certain Ministers. They have been supplemented by provocative pronouncements in that heavily subsidised journal——

Comment on this

I should like to ask if we will be allowed, in reply, to travel over all this ground, or if the Deputy is to get away with these statements without reply.

Comment on this

The Deputy will get away with whatever the Chair allows him.

Comment on this

I ask for a ruling from the Chair as to whether this is relevant to the Supplementary Estimate.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I have not had the advantage of hearing much of what the Deputy has been saying. When I hear how Deputy O'Higgins develops his argument, I shall be able to answer the question of the President.

Comment on this

For your information, sir, and in order to demonstrate the fact that I am driving rigidly between shafts, before I referred to this particular line I drew attention to the fact that the previous speaker on the opposite side had discussed this ban, the reason why it was banned, and made mirth of the subsequent changes of name as a result of that ban. The President, when introducing the Estimate, referred to the fact that among the subjects which should be dealt with by this Department were questions such as black bread and revolution. I am following by that, and I am daring to express the hope that this subsidised Department will not have to deal with revolution. I am replying to the Parliamentary Secretary that those changes of name were indicative of the desire of the political Opposition to respect the State, no matter who the rulers of that State were, and that these particular changes of name, which he makes a joke about here, were produced by the corrupt manipulation of the laws of this State — of the Executive Council of this State — and that if there is to be revolution in this or in any other country, it will be produced primarily by corrupt manipulation of the laws by those charged with the responsibility, mainly, of upholding the law.

We are being asked to subsidise another political propagandist Department functioning under the Fianna Fáil Government, and the one we have already subsidised heavily has done more to incite revolution in this country than any foreign agents or activists in this country. In the light of the provocative propaganda that is being disseminated by that subsidised organ day after day, I ask, are we wise to provide more money in order to carry that work further? If the Fianna Fáil policy has so landed this boat on to the rock of shipwreck that every little worker and employee up and down the country has got to draw a little bit less for his labour at the end of the week, that even a sum of £1,000, collected from 50 or 60 individuals is vital to the further financial stability of this State—if there is any honesty or any sincerity in the case that was advanced from those benches last night, then, certainly, this £10,000 for political propaganda should not be voted.

Comment on this

Notwithstanding the temptation to which one is subject by reason of the examples set by previous speakers, I do not propose to make any excursion into the domain of general State politics such as we have listened to in this House to-night. Deputy Fitzgerald opened the debate from the Opposition Benches and his speech was nothing more than a raking of the ashes of the civil war just an attempt to see whether he could discover in the ashes any spark which might be fanned into flame again so that he might re-enact here in words the physical struggle of 1922 and 1923. Listening to the speech, it was perfectly clear that Deputy Fitzgerald was more concerned with using this House as a platform from which to attack a particular organ of the Press than he was to discuss the merits of the proposition that is before the House this evening. His speech was one, long, blinding wail of insane political passion against a Press organ, just because it does not happen to take the viewpoint of the Party opposite. One would imagine, listening to Deputy Fitzgerald's speech, that the Party opposite, when in office, had no Press organ whatever, but everybody knows that during the period they were a Government they had practically every Press organ in the country, not merely at their beck and call, but even in their pockets, and when one particular Press organ in this country at that time dared to criticise the policy of the last Government they were refused advertisements which were in the power of that Government to give.

Deputy Fitzgerald told us about all the vices of the Irish Press and all the dangerous and insidious things that paper does from the point of view of the Irish people. The fact that it is progressing, from the point of view of circulation, looks as if the people of this country, who are not the money-bags of this country, are perfectly satisfied, or, at all events, reasonably satisfied with the news service given by that paper. According to Deputy Fitzgerald, however that paper has every possible vice. I will say this, however, that no matter what that paper does during its life-time, I am satisfied that it will never call an Irish soldier an assassin as some of the papers backing the Deputy's Party did, and that it could never sink to the disgraceful level of calling on an alien power to murder Pearse and Connolly as another Press organ in this country did. We have been told to-day that the Irish Press has all the vices which it is possible for a journal to have. No matter what mistakes it commits from the point of view of journalism, it will never disgrace the name of Irish journalism and Irish nationality in the manner in which other papers in this country have disgraced it.

Deputy MacDermot talked on this publicity department as if he had never heard of a State publicity department before. According to him, it is a dangerous and undesirable thing for any Government to have a publicity department at its disposal, because it could be used for all kinds of strange things by the Government in office. If he had been familiar with the happenings in this country in 1923, 1924, and 1925, he would not be so shocked at the notion of a publicity department at all, because if he looks up the Estimates for 1923-24 he will find that the Government of the day, the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, of which he is now a member——

Comment on this

No, I am not.

Comment on this

Well, the Deputy can pretend it as much as he likes. I do not mind him pulling his own leg, but it is unfair that he should pull other people's legs. In that year they spent £3,600 on a publicity department, when, according to the Deputy's Party — his Party now — these were years when there was so much milk and honey flowing about that there was no need to tell anybody they were there — it was so obvious to everybody. In 1924-25, they spent £3,043 on a publicity department and paid the director of the department, whom they described as the head of the publicity department, £1,000 per annum — even though they only paid the temporary shorthand-typist 27/7d. per week and the unestablished messenger 25/- per week, and, in case he might indulge in any riotous conduct, they gave him an annual increment of 1/- a year. In the same Estimate further on we find that a sum of £5,250 was provided for publication and distribution in the Publicity Department for the purposes of purchasing, printing and distributing books, newspapers, pamphlets and photographs. If the Deputy had been in the Party then his photograph might be well-known in the country now. At all events we have it that in the year 1923-24 the Deputy's Party spent £3,600, and in 1924-25, £3,000, apart from the sum spent on the distribution of pamphlets, photographs and newspapers.

Comment on this

How much since? Can the Deputy give the figures for dates subsequent to that? If he cannot what is the relevancy of something done so long ago?

Comment on this

If the research department of the Deputy's Party has collapsed I do not mind introducing him to the research department of the Labour Party, where he will get that information to-morrow. The Deputy got up in blissful ignorance of the fact that there was a Publicity Department here before. He has only now discovered that there was a Publicity Department, otherwise he would not have made such a foolish speech. In his speech he committed himself to the principle that it was highly dangerous to have a Government Publicity Department. If the Deputy had lived in this country in 1923-24 and 1924-25 he would have known perfectly well the purposes for which the Publicity Department in these years was used. Let the Deputy look at some of the Press statements issued in that period and he will have no hesitation in making up his mind that it was used for party political propaganda much more than in the interests of the nation as a whole. I look upon this Estimate purely as a business one. I see national advantage to the people of the country in being made aware, in every possible way, of the activities of any Government in power, so that they may know what Acts are passed by this legislature, the benefit of these Acts, so far as they affect the people, and in giving information with some kind of enlightened thought on the Acts of this legislature, rather than having them construed from documents by the vapourings at cross roads of people who have not prepared them but put into their hands by others as incapable of writing them as the persons who made the speeches.

The President made the case for this Estimate, that it was necessary for internal purposes and also necessary for external purposes. I quite agree that it is eminently desirable, as a matter of external policy, that there should be some kind of Publicity Department which would give the people regular news items, showing the work of this legislature and the actions of any Government in power, no matter what the political complexion of that Government may be. In existing circumstances, however, there is a particularly strong case for a Publicity Department, from the point of view of our relations with other nations. Everyone knows perfectly well that there is a financial dispute on to-day with a nation which is capable of controlling, to a very large extent, the news agencies of the world, and which has shown in the past, perhaps never more effectively than during the great war, that it could use the Press agencies for every purpose for which it wanted to use them. Deputy MacDermot travels frequently and does not confine his survey of life to this small island. I wonder when travelling to Paris if he looks at the continental edition of the Daily Mail that circulates on the train. Taking any news item in that paper that has any particular reference to this Government, I am perfectly prepared to allow the Deputy to arbitrate as to whether it is fair criticism or unfair criticism.

Comment on this

I would like to inform the Deputy that from my experience the French people do not read the continental edition of the Daily Mail. They read the French newspapers. Further, from my experience the official Fianna Fáil point of view is more than well represented in the French Press, and in the American papers, the two foreign countries with which I am most familiar.

Comment on this

That is not the point I was making.

Comment on this

It was, and it is the sensible point.

Comment on this

As the Deputy's speeches are not distinguished for sense, I think it is impudence to suggest that he is a judge of sensibility.

Comment on this

Do you mean sense or sensibility?

Comment on this

Both. The Deputy can have his choice. Everyone knows that when Britain wants to blacken a people in the eyes of the world the Press agencies are used for the purpose. Whenever it is a case of showing that the movement for Indian independence is a rabble movement, initiated by a low class in the community, the floodlights of publicity are turned on India, and the world is told of these awful people that Britain is spending so many millions of money trying to civilise, even though the people do not want civilisation by Britain. Whenever it is a case of misrepresenting Egypt, or any other country where Britain wants to get a footing, the Press agencies throughout the world are controlled and manipulated. With that knowledge of the manner in which the Press agencies are utilised for political propaganda by that country, it seems to me highly desirable that some effort should be made here to create an Information Bureau and a news publicity service to enable us to try to tell the world the truth about what is really happening here. Some of us remember Britain's newspapers and Britain's Press Bureaux here. We were told that the I.R.A. was a murder gang. That was the information that was disseminated by Britain's news agencies and by Britain's Bureaux in this country. It seems to me to be highly desirable, especially in existing circumstances, that some effort should he made to secure that the Irish point of view should be put before the world, as well as the condition of affairs here, rather than looking to any other nation, for its own ends, to point out the real position. In that sense I look upon this Estimate as a good investment for the nation. The amount involved is small.

I believe, from the point of view of the citizens resident here, from the point of view of our people who live in other lands, from the point of view of putting ourselves right with every other country, that this Estimate will yield a very substantial return, and will help to curb some of the misrepresentations of rather unfriendly neighbours. I hope it will do much to curb many misleading statements issued by newspapers in this country, with the benediction of the Party opposite, in order to misrepresent everything done by the Government, just because they happen to dislike its political complexion.

Comment on this

Hear, hear. That is well spoken.

Comment on this

I understand we are in Committee, and consequently I can speak twice. I believed some other Deputies were going to speak.

Comment on this

The Deputy wants to give them time to think. Carry on.

Comment on this

I think it worth while to assure Deputy Norton that, what he conceived to be his revelation with regard to the fact that an Information Bureau existed some years ago, has no effect at all in shaping my opinion, that in principle, in normal times, or anywhere near normal times an Information Bureau of this sort is a mistake and a danger. After all we are human beings and it is a particularly characteristic failing of every Government to think that its particular point of view is the one that is right and the proper national point of view. Consequently, if a Government has an Information Bureau at its beck and call, it is absolutely bound to use it for Party purposes. I defy Deputy Norton to deny — in fact he has admitted by his own speech that he could not deny or would not deny — that it will be used for Party purposes, not for disseminating something that the Irish nation as a whole wishes to have disseminated but for disseminating the point of view of the particular Party that happens to be the Party in power at the time. I say it is bad in principle. Deputy Norton implies that we are doing the same thing as Great Britain is doing. I would not care if Great Britain were doing it but it is not a fact that Great Britain is doing it.

Comment on this

I did not say so.

Comment on this

The Deputy implied it. The notion that Great Britain has a stranglehold on the Press of the world, is altogether mistaken. Great Britain is unpopular. As a matter of fact, a powerful country is generally unpopular. America is also unpopular in all European countries, and you will find that in nine countries out of ten, the general trend of the local Press will be against any Great Power where there is any matter in dispute between that Great Power and a Small Power. I believe the Deputy is entirely astray in thinking that there is a special need for a small nation to set up a Press Bureau. As a matter of fact I doubt if this Bureau will be very much assistance to them, because I think that Fianna Fáil propaganda is being very efficiently conducted already. I wish to compliment the Party opposite on the energy and efficiency of its propaganda. It is put in such a form as to have an effect on uninstructed minds. It would have little or no effect on instructed minds, but the Fianna Fáil Party does not consider instructed minds, knowing that they do not count very much from a voting point of view. On uninstructed minds it has its effect. It is well conceived and it is pushed with the greatest assiduity. I daresay this Bureau will not add much to the efficacy of its propaganda. The object possibly is to provide more jobs. It is from that point of view that Deputy O'Higgins took particular exception to it, that it should be created at a moment when we are enforcing economies as per the Local Government (Temporary Economies) Bill, not to speak of the earlier Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, particularly at the moment when we are doing that, it is indecent to let the public in for the sort of expense that is proposed in this Estimate.

It is really time that Deputy Norton and other Deputies should desist from the practice of expecting rather new members of the House, and members quite new to this Front Bench, to debate and stand over the doings of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party in the past.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Be careful.

Comment on this

Everything they may have done may have been desirable, but I decline to spend my time reading up old files for the purpose of defending every past action of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. It may be that they were justified in 1924 in opening a Press Bureau. I do not know the circumstances, or whether there were such revolutionary conditions obtaining then as to make such a thing necessary. It is, however, irrelevant. In point of fact, what stands out is that when they were last in office they did not have such a Bureau. Presumably they gave it up because revolutionary conditions were past. That, again, I do not know, but they gave it up. If they were justified in having it they were justified, and if they were not justified in having it, they saw the error of their ways and they gave it up. Why should we be going back to a bad system on the plea that it was followed by somebody else? At the time perhaps, for all I know, it was justified. I have tried to be moderate on this question, as indeed on all occasions in this House. I have not personally rested my opposition to this Estimate on the sins of the Government. I rest my opposition to the Estimate on the fact that it is unhealthy and unsound for a Government to set up with public money a Party Publicity Bureau. It is a thing that is disgusting and cannot he defended.

Comment on this

Deputy MacDermot is apparently troubled because this Press Bureau which it is proposed to establish may be used for Party purposes, something which, he implies, he and those associated with him, never consider, something which he assumes must be necessarily bad. What does the Deputy mean by Party purposes?

Comment on this

I mean something on which you should not spend public money.

Comment on this

That is about as clear as all the other utterances of the Deputy and means as much. We have Party Government in this State. This Party was elected by the people on a policy approved by the people, and the purpose of the Party is to give effect to that policy. I know that Deputies opposite have not yet grasped the fact that the people prefer this Party to theirs. For ten years they regarded themselves as appointed to office in this State, not by the will of the people, but by some Divine ordinance. They regarded themselves as demi-gods, ruling by some authority which came from within themselves and not under any obligation to seek any renewal of that authority from the people. They look upon us as intruders, somebody who got into power by some freak of chance, or as a result of some vile, low-down trick. Deputy MacDermot is beginning to get the same ideas as those with whom he is now associated, just as one child can get measles from another. He is also beginning to regard himself as one of the little group of individuals, the little group of demi-gods, who are the rightful rulers of this country, and who have been wrongfully displaced by demons from the nether world who can do nothing right and whose sole purpose is to pile corruption upon corruption, to use Deputy O'Higgins' phrase. The policy of this Party has been approved of by the people and if the purpose of this Party is to give effect to its policy, then any Party purpose that this institution may be used to effect, in so far as it conforms with the policy the people have approved of, is a good purpose.

Comment on this

Why not bring in a public estimate to pay Party organisers in that case?

Comment on this

There used to be estimates for that too. We know how the unemployment grants were spent.

Comment on this

There is another consideration. One of the first functions of this Bureau is to provide a system of public education and Deputies opposite should be grateful for that, because they need that type of public education more than anybody. As a sort of preliminary, however, we will give them a little private education. Fact No. 1—there is Party Government in this State. Secondly, the Fianna Fáil Government was chosen by the people and put into power by them to carry out a Party policy. In case Deputies may have thought that the people made a mistake, we gave the people an opportunity of confirming their decision and they did it with emphasis. They dotted the "i's" and crossed the "t's" of their decision. If there had been any lingering illusion in the minds of Deputies opposite as to what the people really meant when they put Cumann na nGaedheal out of office and put Fianna Fáil into office, that illusion must have been shattered 12 months ago when the people reaffirmed their decision. Their decision was that this Party, with its policy, should be given control of the Government of this country and empowered to carry out its policy.

Comment on this

But it did not do it.

Comment on this

It is proceeding to do it. In order to secure effective implementation of this policy it is necessary to secure in many matters of social and economic concern the co-operation of the public. Not merely was this Government elected by the people, but it is a people's Government, recognising that its authority comes from the people and that its power to do anything effective depends on the extent to which it can get public co-operation in its task. The main function of this institution is to assist us in getting that public co-operation. It is not necessary to enumerate here for the purpose of making Party propaganda various matters of Government policy in respect of which public co-operation is necessary. They are well known to Deputies. In so far as they take any interest in matters coming before the House, they must know that a large part of the Government's programme depends for its fulfilment on the extent to which the people are prepared to assist it and bring it into effect. If we are going to get that public co-operation in the degree in which it is required we must have the public informed as to the manner in which their co-operation can most effectively be given. That is the purpose of the Bureau. We have had a difficult task in giving effect to our policy, and the main difficulty was the deliberate campaign of misrepresentation which Deputies opposite embarked upon. Not merely did they try to wreck the Government policy on every item, but they tried to secure that those who wished to co-operate in giving effect to that policy would be misinformed about it. On every occasion that the opportunity offered to them to prevent good being done as a result of Government policy they tried to prevent it being done for Party purposes.

The Party opposite, so far as I can see, does not disagree with this Government in anything except one thing. The one thing with which they disagree is that they think they are better men than we are; but they are not. They are wrong in that as in everything else. That affects themselves. But, on the main lines of policy, whatever they may have said last month or last year or two years ago or last night, they appear now to be standing with us. It is a good thing that this evolution of ideas should have taken place amongst the members of the Party opposite. If this Press bureau does nothing else except make it generally known, not merely in this country but outside it, that Deputies opposite have hauled down all their flags and decided to endorse the policy of Fianna Fáil, the national policy on all matters, then it will be well worth whatever expense is involved in its establishment. Is it not a good thing that the British should know that the Leader of the Party opposite stated only two nights ago that no matter what Government is in power the land annuities will never again be paid to England? Does not that serve a useful national purpose so that the people in Great Britain who are hoping to manoeuvre the people opposite back into power in order to get that cash from the Irish people will realise that their last hope has been destroyed, that the last line of defence on which they were relying has been turned?

I remember hearing a few years ago the Minister for Agriculture in the Cumann na nGaedheal Government discussing the possibility of growing wheat in Ireland and saying that you might as well talk about growing bananas. Is it not a good thing that the Party Convention which Deputies attended last week decided that the wheat policy must be given its chance? Deputy MacDermot, of course, can excuse himself by saying that he does not stand over everything the Cumann na nGaedheal Government did. He does not know what they did. He will not find out from those with whom he is associating now, apparently, because they are very anxious to forget what the Cumann na nGaedheal Government did. They certainly will not talk about it. They have even been criticising this Government because its industrial policy is not vigorous enough.

A short while ago the Control of Manufactures Act was not merely opposed but obstructed by them. A few weeks ago they were criticising the Act because it did not go far enough. Is it not a good thing that we should have information as to the matters upon which we are all agreed given to the public? Surely that is not serving a Party purpose. The issue of the land annuities, the necessity for the development of a home supply of wheat, the necessity for industrial development, and other matters which were a short while ago matters of controversy, are now matters of agreed policy. In so far as this Bureau sets out to secure public co-operation in effecting that policy and putting it into operation, then there is no Party purpose being served but the common purpose of all of us.

I agree that Deputies opposite do not like being tied down to a policy. Perhaps they fear publicity as to their attitude at the moment on any given issue might tie them to that attitude and they do not like being tied. We heard Deputy O'Higgins talking about men who change their Party. If he had put back his right hand he would have hit Deputy Belton and if he had put back his left hand he would have hit Deputy MacDermot. If he looked behind him he would see men who have in their time been associated with every political Party in this State and with attempts to form others that never came into existence.

Comment on this

And the Minister changed his policy a dozen times. He was Minister for Defence in a revolutionary Government outside against this State. Who is the twister?

Comment on this

Need Deputy Belton ask?

Comment on this

The day that Deputy Belton came into this House the Minister said he would never come in.

Comment on this

Let us consider the question of the inadvisability of having a Press bureau because it might be used for Party purposes. The suggestion has been made here that any attempt on the part of the Government to influence the Press must necessarily be bad. Deputy Norton referred to the fact that there was a Press bureau here before—an expensive one. It disappeared it is true as such seven or eight years ago, but another institution was substituted for it. Deputy Fitzgerald can tell Deputy MacDermot, if he does not know it already about the conferences that took place every Monday morning in Government Buildings when Mr. Ernest Blythe, the then Minister for Finance, met representatives of all newspapers except one and gave them their orders for the week. Every Monday morning that conference took place and the representatives of the Press sitting around Mr. Blythe got from him their instructions as to the line they were to take on every issue of public importance likely to attract attention during the week.

Comment on this

Instructions !

Comment on this

One newspaper was not allowed to be represented—the Irish Press.

Comment on this

It was not a newspaper.

Comment on this

It was excluded from the conferences to emphasise the fact that the statements made were not mere impartial surveys of Government policy to be made public, but conferences of men associated for one Party purpose. Deputy MacDermot is very innocent I know, but he is not so innocent as to believe that the others who sit with him on the benches opposite are as innocent as he is. That arrangement worked very well. All the newspapers of this country, with the one exception, were able to talk with one voice every Tuesday morning stating, not the truth but the representation of the truth which the Government at the time wanted to have believed. That was very often misrepresentation. It was as a result of that arrangement, that very close co-operation between the Government and the newspapers, that many ideas became accepted in this country which would never have been listened to by any intelligent person if all the facts could have been made available. Not merely were those conferences held, but the Government's power to provide revenue for newspapers in the form of public advertisements was used entirely to subsidise those newspapers that supported the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. Can Deputy MacDermot explain to me why it was decided by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government that no public advertisements of any kind were to be inserted in any newspaper, whether a daily or weekly newspaper, critical of Government policy?

We have not adopted that policy. The Deputy can read Government advertisements in his Irish Times just as we can read them in the Irish Press. We have deliberately decided not to use that power, because we think it wrong that that power should be used in that manner. But our predecessors had no scruples about it, and when the power of subsidising by advertisement did not prove sufficiently effective they devised the system of subsidising one particular newspaper on the ground that it used to print in an obscure column a paragraph printed in the Irish language. Year after year they brought in an estimate for that particular subsidy on the ground that it was intended to encourage Irish when it was really designed to buy the political support of a particular newspaper that circulated in a constituency where an unpopular Minister was trying to hold his seat.

It is true that we are spending a lot upon education. This State provides a very large part of its revenue every year for educational purposes. This addition to the Educational Vote is a small one. Nevertheless, it is an important, item, and if it succeeds in getting into the minds of Deputies opposite and those other people who are influenced by Deputies opposite that there is another side to the story than that which they are continually presenting, a side which is not associated with any particular Party, but a side none the less worth knowing, then it will be well worth while. The particular side that we want Deputies to understand is that the various matters of Government policy that are likely to be the subject of publicity are designed to improve conditions in this country, to improve the status of the State, and the material well being of its people.

It is, I think, rather pitiable to see Deputies opposite rising from their benches here day after day to gloat over every little item that they can extract from some public document which seems to show that conditions in this country are not all that they, might be. If some factory closes down to-morrow, if any number of people are unemployed, if a particular section of our community are hit in some economic manner, Deputies opposite stand in their benches to cheer. They are cheering every week-end at public meetings knowing that that tends to show that the fight for the improvement of the economic organisation of this State is not yet over. It is pitiable. Some of them at one time used to think themselves good Irishmen, used to talk about the effort that could be made to promote industrial development, to secure a recasting of our economic organisation so that we would become a more self-contained, a more self-sufficient nation. Now that the effort is being made they, for merely Party reasons, find themselves opposed to it, and not merely that, but gloating over every little defeat that may be suffered in the campaign and pretending to ignore the much greater victories.

The main purpose of this bureau is to secure that information will be given to the public and to Deputies opposite that will make them realise that the campaign that is being conducted in this country is not being conducted for the benefit of one Party or one section of the people, but for all the people, and that it is good national work, work in which they should be co-operating. In this matter we are hoping to get co-operation of the masses of the people, and I think we can be certain of that. We can get that co-operation if information is available as to the manner in which it is required. If the educational campaign is pushed sufficiently far, I believe we may eventually get the co-operation of some of the Deputies opposite. In many respects they have publicly adopted our policy and subscribed to our programme. They have subscribed to it in broad outline if not in detail.

Comment on this

Rubbish!

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy will give us one broad detail on which they disagree?

Comment on this

Yes, governing the country by corrupt methods.

Comment on this

I gather that Deputy Fitzgerald is against governing the country by corrupt methods?

Comment on this

Yes, by the whole programme you have indicated.

Comment on this

That is another indication of agreement of which I was not aware before. I did not know that the Party opposite had changed their policy in that regard. We quite agree with Deputy Fitzgerald, and that is another point of agreement. I think there is nothing left now upon which we could disagree.

Comment on this

The Minister has laid out a programme of corrupt Government.

Comment on this

We have laid out a corrupt Government—that is true. I do not want to delay the House much longer. I am surprised and pained at the manner in which the debate on this Vote has developed. I think Deputies opposite should appreciate the necessity of having an organisation that would link up the people with the Government so that those in power would be given public assistance in the fulfilment of their policy that they might not otherwise be able to secure. The last Government tried to govern when it was completely out of touch with the people, and I think they have admitted it publicly that they were out of touch with the people. This Government is determined, so long as it remains in office, to keep in touch with those who have put them into a position of authority so that it may have the co-operation and help of the people in carrying out the policy that the people endorsed twice within a period of twelve months.

Comment on this

As I listened to the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce there came into my mind an epigram of a very well-known Frenchman. "Hypocrisy," he said, "is the tribute which vice pays to virtue." I wish I could call the Minister for Industry and Commerce and his followers in the Fianna Fáil Benches hypocrites, because that would be a kindly word to apply to them in comparison to any word which can be applied to them after the extraordinary speech which we have just heard from the Minister. There is no shame about it now, there is no secrecy about it now, there is no hiding of it now. We have got definitely from the Minister the putting forward of this doctrine which we guessed was being practised before, but, no matter how much it was practised, we never thought it would be preached in this House, that the Fianna Fáil Government and Party consider they are entitled to use public money solely for Party purposes.

Comment on this

There is nothing in that.

Comment on this

That is what the Minister has just put before the House—that we are entitled to use public money for purely Party purposes. What is the reason he gave? The reason he gave for this open avowal of corruption on the part of his Government, this undisguised avowal of corruption, is this, that they got a majority at the last election and, therefore, they are entitled to spend such public money as they wish in promulgating their ideas.

According to the Minister for Industry and Commerce they are entitled to subsidise out of public funds any single purpose which they think is helpful to them. Not merely that but we have this astonishing doctrine preached in this House that any Government that at any time ever has a majority in this House is entitled to use public money for the entrenching of its own position. I have heard of graft in various countries in the world. I have heard of political corruption in various countries in the world. There are scandals in certain countries at the present moment arising out of political corruption. But I wonder if the doctrine of political corruption has ever been preached so openly in any assembly in the world as it has been preached by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in that extraordinary speech which he delivered to the House to-night. Now we know where we are. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said they got a mandate from the people to carry out their policy. Did they say to the people of the country, "Yes, put us in office and we will use as much of your money as we wish to use for our purely Party purposes?" Was that part of the policy they put to the electorate when they got a mandate? As a matter of fact, I deny and I deny strenuously that the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the rest of the Front Bench of Fianna Fáil ever got a mandate for the policy they are carrying out. He said they got a majority from the people twice. What is the use of making statements in this House, statements which everybody knows to be untrue in fact? Take the election of February, 1932. What majority did they get then? They were in a minority if the Party that was not elected as tied to them did not form a coalition with them; they had no majority. And the policy which the Labour Party put before the electorate at that election was not identical by any means with the policy which President de Valera and his Party put before the electorate.

Therefore, I deny and everybody in this country who has studied Irish affairs to even the most slender extent must be aware of the fact that in that first election in February, 1932, President de Valera got no majority at all from the Irish people. It was only because he managed after the election to induce the Labour Party to do what they had never said during the election they would do—to join up with them—it was because of that and because of that only that they got into power. Take again the last election. Even at the present moment they have not a majority of the elected members of the House as their professed followers. There is actual equality at the present moment of those who are his professed followers and those who are not. The Labour Party have not stated up to the present day that they completely endorse this policy. The Labour Party have voted against him and they have criticised his policy, indeed very heartily criticised his industrial policy and his policy of whole-hog protection.

It was only because of other reasons they proceeded to keep him in power. That is the reason why he is there now. But never at any time has President de Valera received a mandate from the elected majority promising to support him in this House. At one time, if the Labour Party had not twisted from the policy upon which they were elected he would not have been in power at all. At the next election it was only by the sufferance of the Labour Party that he had anything more than a bare equality as far as the elected members of the House were concerned. I know his Party propaganda and I know what it is. I see the Irish Press which makes the statement that he was elected by the overwhelming majority of the Irish people. I do not mind that. I do not take seriously anything of the political propaganda which is put forward in the official organ of the Party opposite. But it has surprised me that the Minister for Industry and Commerce has got the affrontery to come into this House and to make a statement which every single person knows to be at variance with the facts.

But the Minister did not by any means stop there. He said that we had changed our policy. We have not changed our policy. Our policy stands where it was. He instanced that we have said that the wheat policy should be given its chance. We have, but that is not a change of policy on our part— absolutely no. We say now as we have always said that the wheat policy is a thoroughly unsound policy but we are thoroughly consistent in this one overriding, over-ruling principle which every Government ought to honour and which we certainly will honour. That is that if persons have expended sums of money on the assurance given by one Government than its successors in office should not vary that promise to the detriment of persons who have invested money on the faith of that promise. Persons have invested money on the faith of the promises made to them on this wheat policy and we say that since a Government gave that promise we as successors of that Government—and I trust I may safely promise very shortly that we will be— are bound to see that these persons who invested money on the promise of our predecessors are not deceived. That is an attitude from which we have never departed. It is a perfectly fair attitude and it is an attitude from which I do not think any Government should depart. If citizens invest money on a definite promise from one Government it would be very unfair, I think, to them that that promise should be departed from.

As a matter of fact I think the wheat policy is radically unsound and that it is bound to kill itself and kill itself very shortly. The Minister said that he and his Party on coming in were pledged to a policy. To what were they pledged? I know that there is one thing to which they were pledged. That was that if they got into power the economic war would be ended in a fortnight. That was the one promise that was given in every constituency in the State. We know that there were pledges that there would be complete derating. We know that there were definite clear pledges that there would be factories in every town and village specifically named by the Fianna Fáil orators at the cross-roads. Those are the type of pledges and that is the type of policy which were put forward by the Fianna Fáil Party at the last election. That was the type of policy and that was the nature of the promises which induced a large section of the electorate to vote for the Fianna Fáil Party. I say it is not our Party that has changed, but very much their Party that has changed. They have changed since they came into office; they have changed very, very much indeed from what they used to be. The Minister for Industry and Commerce talks about a change of policy on our part. I wonder if in the history of the world you could get a more vital change of policy, a more complete volte face, than has been made by President de Valera and the whole of his Executive Council; I am not talking of his Parliamentary Secretaries. Indeed, President de Valera is not satisfied with one volte face. It is rather a little bit like a teetotum; he goes spinning round and round. There was a time when President de Valera and his friends were actively up in arms against this particular State, the State of which he is now the head.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

What the events of six years ago or eight years ago have got to do with the motion before the House is not apparent to the Chair.

Comment on this

I was leading up, A Chinn Comhairle, to a speech made within the last fortnight, or less, in this House by President de Valera.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not on this motion.

Comment on this

That is the common policy; that is part of the policy which this Press Bureau is going to spread to the world——

Comment on this

How do you know?

Comment on this

——the speech in which he said that he and his followers were not Irregulars but were regular troops, from which it follows that the present National Army and the Guards are Irregulars. You cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

A debate on one motion may not be carried over to quite a different motion. It is not in order to resume now a debate which concluded a week ago.

Comment on this

I think I may venture to say that I am always scrupulous in my obedience to what the Chair rules.

Comment on this

Give us an example.

Comment on this

My submission is that we are going to have a Bureau of publicity; that that is to spread purely Fianna Fáil doctrine; that one of the principal items of Fianna Fáil doctrine is the item which was enunciated by President de Valera the other night, which is to the effect that the National Army is a body of Irregulars. I submit that on this motion I am entitled to criticise current Fianna Fáil propaganda. If you rule to the contrary of course I will accept your ruling.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have ruled during this debate that a discussion on the policy of an organisation or the policy of the Government is not in order. Deputies are confined to arguing for or against the setting up of this Bureau.

Comment on this

Might I respectfully point out that the Minister for Industry and Commerce based his argument in favour of that on those lines: that the policy of the Government has been approved of by the people, and that being so, the Government was eminently justified in spending public money in propaganding their policy, or whatever version of it may be on at the moment. That was argument put forward by the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

Not quite.

Comment on this

The argument put forward was that their policy had been approved of by the people, and that therefore they had the right, as in this instance, to spend public money on the promotion of that policy, and in deceiving the people regarding it. I suggest that, if that is the basis of it, then it does seem to me one has the right to consider the policy that was put forward by the Government and the policy which the Government is actually pursuing; to consider whether the theory of the Minister for Industry and Commerce should work out; and whether we as a Dáil would be justified in voting public money to promulgate some of the items of policy which the present Government is responsible for.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I did not hear the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce——

Comment on this

That is unfortunate.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I was not in the Chair when the Minister spoke. I have not heard the Deputy who is in possession refer even once to the motion before the House—that this Vote be passed.

Comment on this

It does seem to me to be a very unfortunate thing that the Minister for Industry and Commerce can indulge for half an hour in a diatribe against the United Ireland Party, and that when we stand up to reply to that——

Comment on this

I did not. I congratulated them upon their new policy.

Comment on this

When we stand up to reply to that it is unfortunate that we are not allowed by the Chair to make our reply. The attack was allowed by the Leas-Cheann Comhairle in the Chair.

Comment on this

Is this a reflection on the Leas-Cheann Comhairle?

Comment on this

Everybody in the House heard it. I stand up to reply to that attack and, since we got hit, to hit back. I submit——

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this

I am in possession.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I wish to point out that during the course of my remarks no Deputy raised any point of order.

Comment on this

Is that a point of order? Where is the point?

Comment on this

I submit that the Deputy is taking advantage of the fact that you were not personally in the Chair during the course of my remarks, and that he is trying to mislead you.

Comment on this

Might I point out in reply to those remarks that no Deputy in this House took objection either to what I said on a point of order.

Mr. MacEntee rose.

Comment on this

No. I want the ruling of the Chair.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The ruling of the Chair is very clear. The Ceann Comhairle should not on resuming the Chair be asked to go back upon the rulings of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle or other occupant of the Chair.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce made allusion to the way in which this institution, as I call it, was treated by the previous Executive. Might I follow him through that charge, a Chinn Comhairle?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may when speaking to the motion reply to charges made.

Comment on this

That is all I have been doing for a long time, a Chinn Comhairle. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said that information was given to newspapers tied to the Cumann na nGaedheal Party when in office and refused to the Fianna Fáil Party organ, the Irish Press. That statement is completely inaccurate. There was no Party paper belonging at any time to the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, and there was not a single Dublin morning paper which did not, again and again, criticise the Cumann na nGaedheal Party when in office. We had no tied paper; never had a tied paper, nor have not a tied paper at the present moment except our own weekly paper.

Comment on this

So they have a weekly paper.

Comment on this

I say, and say deliberately, that there was all the difference in the world between a paper which was nothing else but a mere medium for Party propaganda, and a newspaper which was giving news to the people. There was all the difference in the world between the two. Their Party newspaper did not get advertisements? Well, we had a weekly paper at the time ourselves— the only paper we had—and that paper did not get advertisements.

Comment on this

It did.

Comment on this

It did not.

Comment on this

It did.

Comment on this

Government advertisements?

Comment on this

I invite the Deputy to look at his files?

Comment on this

I should like to see any one of them. I deny it absolutely.

Comment on this
Hugh Victor Flinn Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Flinn) Fianna Fáil

Will you bet on it?

Comment on this

It did not get such advertisements.

Comment on this

Have a bet.

Comment on this

I certainly will not.

Comment on this

An even £50?

Comment on this

I certainly will not.

Comment on this

Three to one in fifties?

Comment on this

I certainly will not have a bet, or any avoidable dealings with the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance. I have rather too much respect for myself.

Comment on this

The Deputy gives his word, but he will not risk his money.

Comment on this

I say that no such advertisements were given by the Government to our weekly Party paper. I say that and I say that deliberately. We had the regular Party organ, not an industry at all but a mere Party propaganda sheet, run by the then Opposition and run by the present Government, for the purpose of not giving the truth but to give its own version of the truth to use the Minister's strange phrase—to give its own version of the truth, whatever that may mean, to the Irish people. There was all the difference between subsidising a paper which, goodness knows, has been subsidised by strange and devious enough methods, and giving advertisements to a paper which is an ordinary industry run on the ordinary commercial lines upon which newspapers ought to be run. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, however, goes a little bit further and talks about the victories that he has achieved although he admits that, in some respects, conditions are not all that they might be. There is not a person living in this country but knows that conditions are not all that they might be if there was anything like a competent Government in office. Conditions are so bad in this country that it is extraordinary how any Government, in the short space of two years, have managed to bring about a condition of affairs so deplorable and that is known by every person in this State. It is known by everybody who is interested in agriculture, the main source of this country's wealth, and it is known by the increased numbers of unemployed who are walking the streets of our towns.

Comment on this

That is a blue lookout.

Comment on this

And where are the factories? We want to know where the factories are—these subjective factories, the factories that exist in the imagination of the Minister for Industry and Commerce which we, the ordinary men in the street, cannot find. Now we know the Party purposes for which this large sum of public money is going to be spent. It is to be spent on promulgating purely Party doctrines. It is to be spent on making statements like the extraordinary statements of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, arising from his defects of memory, made in this House to-night. Never before in the history of any country as I have said, has corruption stood up so openly, so brazenly and pronounced itself so openly, as has been done by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in his speech to-night. Never before, I believe, in any assembly has the doctrine been openly, boldly and unashamedly preached that the Government in power is entitled to use public moneys for purely Party purposes. It is not this measure really that is so much at issue; it is not the importance of the money that is really so much at issue but every single person in this House who gives a vote in favour of this Estimate will be voting in favour of the principle put forward by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. He will be voting for the principle that the Government is entitled to buy support for itself out of public moneys and that is certainly a degradation to which, I think, few members of the Fianna Fáil Party will gladly lend themselves. They will go and vote—of that I have not the slightest doubt. They will vote for corruption preached so openly as it has been preached but I think few of them will vote for that corruption willingly.

Comment on this

In different circumstances, a publicity bureau for national purposes would do a good national service but we have in this country one publicity bureau known as 2RN, a wireless publicity bureau. We want a counterpart to that in this Press bureau, which, I suppose, will be 2DV. When the secretary of a national organisation in this country dared to offend the jazzing principles of a Minister, a talk he was to give from 2RN was promptly cancelled. Now, this Press Bureau is to be set up to do a national service and is it not very reasonable to expect that the authority that stopped Mr. O'Kelly from delivering his address from 2RN will stop and muzzle any public man in this country from having the services of that bureau? Is it not a proof that if a bureau like this is set up, it will be used for purely Party purposes? It might be no harm if they would when they use it for Party purposes, make it clearly understood, not only in this country but outside it, that it is being used for purely Party purposes so as not to disgrace the whole Irish race as being represented by what the Fianna Fáil Party are pleased to call a national policy. The Minister for Industry and Commerce thinks that by thumping the table and saying, "We did this and we did that," he must carry conviction. How long are we doing anything that would entitle the Party opposite to dare to stand up in this national assembly and say that any member of this assembly, not on their benches, deviated from any political principles he held in years gone by. The Minister for Industry and Commerce taunted us here with supporting, to quote him, "our wheat policy, our beet policy and our industrial policy." Deputy Norton went down and dug up a musty record to prove that Cumann na nGaedheal spent public money on some publicity bureau from 1923 to 1925.

Comment on this

Did Cumann na nGaedheal publish musty records?

Comment on this

It was a musty record in which you dug up this information.

Comment on this

Pretty fresh.

Comment on this

From 1923 to 1925 the Party opposite were piling expenses on this country instead of doing anything constructive. I move to report progress.

Comment on this