We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Vote No. 3—Department of President of Executive Council (Resumed).

Contributions 1–130 of 252. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I understand that the Attorney-General is in possession.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I have nothing to add.

Comment on this

Do I understand from the Attorney-General that he has nothing to add in reply to the matter introduced into the debate on Friday by Deputy Cosgrave?

Comment on this

I have already said all I intended to say.

Comment on this

On the matter introduced into the debate by Deputy Fitzgerald?

Comment on this
Hugh Victor Flinn Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Flinn) Fianna Fáil

Can we take the Vote now, sir?

Comment on this

No, but the House understands that the Executive Council propose to have no reply to the matter introduced into this debate by Deputy Cosgrave on Friday. Again, sir, I oppose this Estimate and the proposal that it covers. The proposal definitely is to use public funds for the purpose of party propaganda. The Executive Council propose to have a political shop-front of their own in Dublin, for which they have been seeking a man, and a political shop-front of their own in London, for which they have a man, but the work for these political propaganda shops and the material that is to be retailed through them is to be provided by this Information Bureau by persons paid at the public expense. It is to be given out through a party propaganda shop in the City of Dublin —obviously such—and through the new Secretary of our Legation in Washington, and thus the people at home and the people abroad are going to be doped with the necessary propaganda to cover the terrible state of affairs brought about here as a result of their policy, which will be issued through these agencies, prepared at the direction of these agencies, but paid for at the public expense.

The Minister for Finance has been terribly interested in avoiding delay in the putting forward of what is to be done here with regard to the production of industrial alcohol. He was urgently anxious on a similar occasion to tell what was going to be done with regard to beet. We will hear on Friday something of what is going to be done or what are the promises with regard to industrial alcohol, but I submit that after that, after these promises have been made, we are going to be in a position in which we now are with regard to general information on industrial development here which we have tried to get from the Minister for Industry and Commerce. We are going to be left without; we are going to be told that the statistics are not comparable. A new Department is being set up here to take out of the hands of ordinary civil servants the compiling and issuing of details of facts with regard to their Ministries. The position in the different Departments has come to this, that the facts set out by the experts who handle these inside the Civil Service are so clear and so unpalatable that they have to be issued with a coating of propaganda over them or they have to be obscured entirely by a coating of propaganda, so that the ordinary channel for getting facts from Government Departments is apparently going to be shut up and the public abroad and at home are going to be supplied with what is prepared in a propaganda Department instead.

Exception has been taken to statements made by Deputy Fitzgerald that certain passages were cut out of the paper, United Ireland, last week, and the Attorney-General has attempted to show that the Editor of United Ireland could print anything he liked and that the printer could print anything he liked. The statement of the Attorney-General, however, was explicit on this point, that he told the police the passages which he indicated should be taken out were definitely seditious and that he, as Attorney-General, might proceed against the printer if he printed them. Now, either the printer was being given, through the police officer, the opinion of a good Attorney-General or the opinion of a bad Attorney-General. If I, as a printer, got the opinion of a good Attorney-General that a certain passage was seditious, and if I considered the Attorney-General a good person, whose opinion was worth having, and a man who stood over his job, I certainly would not print that passage. On the other hand, if I saw the opinion of a bad Attorney-General and that his opinion was not worth much, I might, nevertheless, hesitate very much, because, just as it might be a lot more troublesome to be handled in a dentist's chair by a bad dentist rather than by a good dentist, it might be even more inconvenient in the courts to be handled by a bad Attorney-General than by a good one. What happened definitely with regard to United Ireland is that pressure was brought to bear upon the printer, and the printer was bludgeoned into leaving out a paragraph which, as has been stated, was a normal comment on the Government's attitude.

The President has informed us that the object of this Bureau is to keep the public at home and abroad right on certain matters—on the fact that there is no imminence of a civil war; on certain matters with regard to our finances; on certain matters with regard to our industrial development, and the position of employment here and what is being done for the people. The President said that the prestige and credit of the Saorstát have been injured by reports representing the country as being on the verge of revolution. The President suggests that part of the duty of the Bureau of Information would be to dispel those ideas. I want to suggest that the duty that is going to be thrust on this Bureau of Information is an entirely different one. It is to prepare this country and countries outside for actions that the Ministry propose to take, because, while the President implies by his statement that he is thoroughly anxious that nobody would think for a moment that this country was near revolution, his Ministers are going around the country every Sunday telling the people that it is. Take one particular Minister, the Minister for Education, who is reported in the Press on 5th February as having been in Kilkenny on the previous day, Sunday. The Minister is reported as saying:—

"The real purpose of those behind General O'Duffy, and who are using him as a catspaw in the game, is to seize power by unconstitutional means. There is no use in saying or pretending that this will not happen or that it cannot happen. We have seen and we know what is taking place on the Continent; and, if the object of that movement is not to seize power in the same way as has been done on the Continent, why is this movement modelled so closely and with such servility on the Continental organisations?"

Then he goes on to say:—

"I say that the promoters of this movement have one object only—to build up and develop a military or semi-military organisation in this country on a Fascist basis until such time as they are in a position to take over power by a coup d'étát, and if they get the opportunity they will take advantage of it. This is the purpose of these men who have been discarded by the electorate and turned down at two general elections.”

Do we understand from the President that the Bureau of Information is going to issue, either to outside countries or to the people here, information that will deny the suggestions made in Kilkenny on 4th February by the Minister for Education? I think it is important that we should hear the President on that point, because on the following Sunday, the 11th February, as reported in the daily Press of 12th February, the Minister for Education was again at it. Referring to General O'Duffy's movement, the Minister said that these people seemed to have it at the back of their minds that they could get into power in some other way than by the votes of the people, and he proposed a policy of education as the only policy that would put an end to a scheme of things in which a minority were trying to seize power.

The Minister for Education was again at it on the 18th February. As reported in the Press of 19th February he stated:—

"The position is a serious one so far as peace and good order are concerned. The fact that members of this private army do not carry arms, as we are told, cannot hide the fact that they are a private army with the object of overawing the people and setting themselves against the Government."

The President's own organ on 5th February published a statement in reply to a statement issued by the I.R.A. which stated:—

"As to the charge that we ‘take no note of the widespread anger and resentment against the Fascists,' and that we fail to urge the ‘appropriate action' against them, we take such note of these things that we see the almost certainty of civil war unless the action to be taken in the present situation is not left to those who alone have been given by the people the authority to decide upon that action and to direct it."

As to the attitude of the President's propaganda organ and the President's Minister on this subject, we have also had the ex-Minister for Justice, Deputy Geoghegan, explaining that one of the Estimates before the House at the present time, the new Supplementary Estimate for the Army, is to deal with a huge increase of expenditure incurred in order to throttle an attempt to rob the people of Parliamentary Government.

We might take the President at his word in this statement of his. The position taken up eternally by the President was that those who are politically opposed to him were unconstitutional. All his propaganda in the past had not only been to that effect, but definitely had as its kernel the charge that, whether they were in power or whether they were out of power, his political opponents were always preparing to prevent the majority of the people here from setting up whatever Government they wanted. His whole propaganda on that matter, both at home and abroad, particularly abroad, before he took over office, was to the effect that the Cosgrave administration were making every possible preparation to prevent the Fianna Fáil Government taking over office if they got a majority here. The greatest sample that we get of the President's capacity as a propagandist, or of the President's spirit as expressed in propaganda, is in the weekly issue of the Fianna Fáil dope through the columns of The Irish World in the United States.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I fail to see what relation weekly propaganda in The Irish World bears to this Estimate. On an Estimate the House usually discusses the administration of the Department concerned. It would require much ingenuity to relate propaganda in The Irish World or the President's capacity for propaganda in 1930, to the institution of this Bureau.

Comment on this

I say that this institution is being set up by the President for the purpose of issuing propaganda and that one of the matters upon which he is going to issue propaganda is the extent to which there is, or there is not, a revolution pending in this country. That is to say, for the overthrow of the present Government by force of arms. I am suggesting that what the President is proposing to deal with through this bureau of information is the steps which he proposes taking, alleging that he has to put down revolution in this country, for preventing its uprising and I am saying that the propaganda that will be carried out by the President on that subject through this Information Bureau will be in acordance with and in keeping with the propaganda carried out in the past. That is, it will be machinery for charging his political opponents with attempting to overthrow the majority Party in power here by force of arms. I want to speak briefly of the President's roots in that matter. We had a case here in this House where the President got up and told the House that I had been in Glasgow, meeting the British Minister for War for the purpose of getting armed assistance from the British Government to assist me and my colleagues in putting the Fianna Fáil Government out of power by force of arms.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The President's Department is not under review in this a Supplementary Estimate. Debate on a Supplementary Estimate is confined to the purpose of the Vote and its administration by the Department concerned. As I have already said, Deputies may not discuss every possible contingency that might arise, and if they were allowed to voice their conjectures and surmises as to the activities of a Department not yet functioning the debate might be interminable. The "roots of the President's information" on certain matters are not in order.

Comment on this

I am discussing the statement of the President in which he said that the prestige and credit of the Saorstát have been injured by reports representing this country as being on the verge of revolution, and the proposal put to this House that this Bureau of Information will have as part of its work the combating of suggestions made here and elsewhere that this country is on the verge of revolution. I am arguing that the President's statements cannot be taken at their face value. I am arguing that the purpose of the President in setting up this Bureau, in so far as it will deal with any aspect of what he refers to, will be to continue the line of propaganda that has been carried on all along— that his political opponents are acting in an unconstitutional way and that in particular they are seeking to overthrow his Government by force of arms. The person who was responsible for the President making these statements here has been the spearhead of the President's propaganda drive in that direction for years past. Before the President sat down in his presidential seat, and when it was absolutely certain what the result of the election in 1932 would be, the particular person who induced him to make that statement with regard to me here in this House, induced the Minister, who is now the Vice-President, to go late at night to the Archbishop's house, in the City of Dublin, and to make the charge to the Archbishop there that particular members of Deputy Cosgrave's late Administration were preparing that night to seize arms in certain barracks in the City of Dublin and to prevent Mr. de Valera's Administration taking over office.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The political history of 1932 is not relevant, neither is the present condition of any political party.

Comment on this

It was stated by the President here that one of the reasons that induced him to introduce this Estimate was the statements that are being made abroad that this country is on the verge of revolution. I am charging the President with proposing to carry on this Bureau in the same spirit and under the same influence as induced him to come into this House and make the statement that he did, and that induced the person who is now Vice-President to go to the Archbishop of Dublin late at night——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That incident is not relevant. Whoever called on the Archbishop of Dublin in 1932, it was not, I presume, the officer to be appointed under this Vote. The Deputy will please resume his seat. Debate on a Supplementary Estimate is normally confined to the administration and policy of the Department. This Bureau will be open to annual discussion in this House when the Estimates are being considered. That will be the time to review the activities of the Bureau. To forecast now what the Bureau might do in every eventuality would lead us from China to Peru and from Canberra to Kinvara.

Comment on this

As you have said, sir, the ordinary practice is to discuss the administration of the Department, but here is a proposal for some unnamed sum of money to be expended on a Department which does not yet exist. You referred, sir, to the person who is to be appointed, but as far as this House is concerned, the person responsible is the President. He is the person who is going to be responsible for the person who will operate this Department. If we could only discuss its administration, as it has only commenced its administration since the day before yesterday, it would seem futile to bring the Vote before the House at all. I submit that we should be allowed to discuss all its possible activities. The President himself indicated certain matters with which the Bureau will deal. This is a Department acting under the aegis of the President for the purpose of giving information to the world in relation to the operations of Government Departments and Government policy——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Does the Deputy rise to make a set speech or to put a point of order?

Comment on this

The point I make is that as we have been told already what we may not discuss, as it has been suggested that the proper thing to discuss is administration, and, as we cannot discuss administration, it does seem to us that some possible indication might be given to us of what we may discuss. Failing that, I would suggest, with all respect, that the President took certain specific items that might be dealt with. Are we to be confined to the items which the President suggested might be matters that might be dealt with by the Department, or are we to anticipate, arguing from the known to the unknown, certain matters which this Department may have to deal with, in giving service to the State which may be diametrically opposed to the interests of the State?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy suggested that the Chair referred to the official, who may be appointed to this Department, as a proper subject for debate. That is not so. He also suggested that I proposed that the debate be confined to administration. During the two days on which this Vote has been under discussion, the Chair, owing to the exceptional character of this Supplementary Estimate, has given considerable latitude. I say that the whole political situation here and the actions of any men three or four years ago are not in order in this debate. And every sphere of Government activity may not be debated. It is not for me to guide the members of the House as to what they may say; it is my duty to pull Deputies up when they say what they should not say.

Comment on this

I want to be clear with regard to your ruling. I do not understand you to restrict me to administration. I can have nothing to say with regard to administration. A Vote for the expenditure of a sum of money has been put to us for a particular purpose, action to be taken in the issuing of information by the Executive Council as a whole, with the President as the principal responsible person. I am discussing the policy. I am taking some of the President's remarks as to what he will deal with in the matter of propaganda through this Bureau, and I am indicating, not so much specific actions on the part of the President or any of his Ministers or any of his propagandists, but rather am I indicating the general line upon which propaganda from the Party opposite has proceeded in the past.

I have mentioned a single instance with regard to the President and a single instance with regard to the Vice-President, indicating the lengths to which they are prepared to go to make the charge against their political opponents that they are acting in an unconstitutional way; not only that, but they are endeavouring by every possible means to get arms, now from a military barracks in the city, owned by the Irish people and controlled by Irish troops, and now from what is supposed to be an alien enemy across the water, all for the purpose of using them against the elected Government of the day here. All these things have their roots in the past. In 1930 they were issuing broadcast to the world that we were on the eve of a dictatorship here if the old Cumann na nGaedheal Party could possibly help it. Anyone anxious to believe that could have the word of the chief propagandist of the Fianna Fáil Party, the man who induced the President to make a certain statement here, and the man who induced the Vice-President to go to the Archbishop's Palace. So far as propaganda along that line is concerned, the propaganda that is going to be issued here will not be propaganda in the nature of information that will clear the fair name of this country from charges such as the Ministers opposite have made against it. Only their own actions could ever bring a stain on this country.

For one reason I oppose this Estimate. I do not take the President's word at its face value when he indicates what he is proposing to do with regard to making it clear that this country is not on the verge of revolution. If the President wants to give the House some sign of his sincerity in that matter, he will take one of his Ministers and talk to him and shut his mouth. The others are just as bad, but for three weeks running now the Minister for Education has been at it, and his own organ has definitely stated that if they cannot do something that they have in their minds at the present moment, they see nothing before this country but civil war. If the President takes exception to the case I make against him, in fairness to this House and to our people outside he should deal with the matter and give the House greater earnest than he has given up to the present, if we take his statements in conjunction with all the other statements, statements even by himself and other Ministers and all his followers throughout the country on the same subject.

The President is going to tell the world and the people here the position with regard to our national finances and our alleged commitments to other countries. But no people in this country have so misrepresented the country as regards the burden of taxation under which the people are labouring as the members of the Party opposite, through their propaganda machine. As far as the world centre for the dissemination of their propaganda on the subject of taxation is concerned, the Irish World was their centre in 1930 and has been all along until the present; it was their chief propaganda agent for the world at large. We were told in 1930 that the overtaxation of Ireland was most appalling. The overtaxation of the Irish people a couple of years ago was, we were told, most appalling. This Information Bureau is now going to soft pedal to our people at home and the people abroad as regards what the taxation really means. The farmers are going to be told that their burdens are very much lighter than they used to be, that they have the MacEntee Millions coming to them every year to the tune of £6,000,000 or so. The propagandists on the far side specifically took certain statements with regard to the last Minister for Finance, Mr. Blythe, and they made very illuminating comments on them for the information of the world.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I understood the Chair ruled these references out of order. Is the Deputy entitled to attempt to bring those matters in again?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Articles in the Irish World in 1930 are out of order.

Comment on this

At any rate, Deputies over there pointed out that the last Minister for Finance had made certain statements with regard to expenditure and they pointed out that the Minister for Finance in his Budget speech had taken certain items, such as the Post Office, the service of debts, superannuation, police pensions, the Army, the collection of revenue and judicial salaries, and these added up made a total of £16,180,000.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

May I point out that the Deputy is deliberately defying the ruling of the Chair?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy purporting to discuss the details of the financial position in 1930?

Comment on this

I am going to refer to the details of the financial position to-day.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has ruled that references to what took place in 1930 are not in order.

Comment on this

Am I out of order in pointing out that whereas the propagandists of yesterday——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The propagandists of yesterday were not the Government. This Government has been responsible for policy only since it assumed office.

Comment on this

This Government is going to tell the world that taxation in Ireland is really very light, although the people are asked to bear £4,000,000 more annually since this Government came into office. This Bureau is going to be used to show that an addition of £4,000,000 in taxation is the greatest benefit that could be conferred on the people, whereas, when they were promising before they came into office a reduction of £4,000,000 in taxation, they were pointing out that the taxation under which this country laboured at the time was appalling.

That is the mentality of the Deputies opposite. They saw the possibility of saving £3,000,000 out of £16,000,000 over a particular set of items in 1930, and they are asking us now to vote money to tell the world that because, instead of reducing the taxation of the country by £3,000,000, they have increased it by £4,000,000 or more, that this country is well delivered from the hands of the people who are now trying to get back into power by unconstitutional means and by an odd collection of arms from barracks here in Dublin or from the English War Minister in Scotland. The President says they are going to tell the country about the great industrial development that has taken place here. The mentality of the President, so far as can be known up to the present, has been that Irish progress has been sacrificed by the Free State Imperial clique, and when the Attorney-General made a short intervention in this debate he was shy of intervening on a second point. I would like to hear the Attorney-General on another point. The President is going to tell the world at large what he and his Government are going to do to revive Irish industry. But in September, 1930, they were charging Cosgrave's Government with wiping out the Clondalkin paper factory. I do not see Deputy Brady here——

Comment on this
Mr. Brady

I am here.

Comment on this

It would be interesting to hear Deputy Brady on the development of Irish industries——

Comment on this
Mr. Brady

You will hear me shortly about industry.

Comment on this

——because while the Free State Imperial clique was wiping out industries, according to the propaganda issued by the Fianna Fáil Party, two years before they came into office, they did not say anything about Deputy Brady's part in the matter or that the Attorney-General was representing an English company imposing a tariff on paper in this country.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy certainly could not contend that his present line of argument is in order.

Comment on this

Well, briefly, the mentality of the Party opposite in the matter of propaganda and the issue of information is what it has been in the past, and I oppose this Estimate, because, to repeat again, the people who oppose this Government, and every Party that opposes them are unconstitutional, and this Bureau Department is going to be used to show they are. Every Party who went before them in the past has been piling taxation on the unfortunate Irish people and has been sacrificing Irish progress to Imperial interests. They sought to carry out the work of exposing the prosperity fake of the Cosgrave Government, and they are going to continue by means of the public purse to misrepresent their opponents and to draw a smoke screen over the appalling damage that they are doing here to the country at large by over-taxation, by industries that are developed in the most haphazard way with no roots to many of them, and very little prospect in front of them except further unemployment and the loss of a certain amount of capital. We all know the position that has been taken up by the Minister for Industry and Commerce with regard to unemployment. Unemployment figures in the country rose enormously in 1932. They were so queer that he could not answer a question about them. Then he told the House in October, 1932, that he was making an examination into what exactly they represented.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The unemployment figures are not relevant.

Comment on this

The country is going to be told through the medium of this Bureau the position with regard to employment and unemployment in the country. The country could be told that by the Department of Industry and Commerce, but the Department of Industry and Commerce has refused, up to the present, to disclose it. Certain figures have been issued, and they were so queer that a year ago special examination was made into them, I admit, three or four months after the Minister promised to make it. In October, 1932, he promised an examination of these figures, and on the 4th January, 1933, his Deputy (for at that time he was away), the Minister for Education, told the House——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It should not be necessary to remind the Deputy that those figures are quite irrelevant.

Comment on this

Well, figures were published this week by the Department of Industry and Commerce showing the number of people registered as unemployed throughout the country. The Minister for Industry and Commerce examined the different classes of people registered in different areas for the purpose of ascertaining whether they were really unemployed or not, or what exactly was meant by the abnormalities shown in these figures. That was 12 months ago. He has got that information and he has refused it to the House. When we come here to the House we are told that the total number of unemployed in the country to-day is more than last year; that the tendency to-day throughout practically the whole country is a tendency towards an increase in the number of unemployed persons registered, whereas for two months last year they were decreasing. The Minister for Industry and Commerce will tell the House the figures are different, that you do not understand them. He will tell you it is all right and that there was never less unemployment in this country than there is to-day.

To side step away from the Civil Service whatever limitations there may be in the figures that are represented to the country and the House in regard to unemployment figures which you may have to-day, will mean that these figures will be worth nothing. They will be but the most useless kind of propaganda dope. When taken out of the hands of civil servants they are handed into the hands of a person whom it is proposed to employ for propaganda purposes in this new Bureau. The Department of Industry and Commerce in issuing figures either from the point of view of industry, employment or unemployment, would be much more satisfactory to the country. The people at home and abroad would be much more satisfied if they could get these figures from the Civil Service than from propagandists if they are to make head or tail of what is happening. We are to have this new Bureau set up and then there are to be three centres of Fianna Fáil distribution of propaganda. The main purpose of the setting up of this Bureau is to serve them with information and obey their beck as to lines upon which information is wanted by the Government. It is simply making use of the public purse to do the fag work in the gathering together of information to put them in the most suitable light, and to cover them with the most suitable skin for the purposes of the President's policy. The President's policy and the President's line of propaganda is a line that, while you may endeavour to cut off its tap root here in the discussions in the House, is going to have its tap root as long as the President is a propagandist.

Comment on this

I just want to refer to some matters spoken about by the Attorney-General on Friday morning. The Attorney-General's information was not quite correct. I am not at all saying that the Attorney-General wanted to mislead the House. I am quite satisfied that he stated the case as he understood it. In a nutshell——

Comment on this

Might I ask is this in order? Is there to be any end to the debate? Is every single thing which members on the Opposition side wish to raise going to be relevant?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The House being in Committee, Deputies may speak more than once. I do not yet know what line the Deputy intends to pursue.

Comment on this

Apparently they do not want a discussion on it. Quite right, too!

Comment on this

The Attorney-General said: "In any case, the result of the consideration of the matter by the printer and his publishers and editor was that these passages were excised voluntarily by the people themselves." I just want to tell the Attorney-General that he was misinformed in thinking that whatever understanding there was went beyond the printer. I want to say that I think the printer was quite right in coming to such an understanding—if he could do it—with the police. I wish to say also that under the circumstances which prevail in this country at the moment I think that one might almost express the word "appreciation" of the Attorney-General. We have got to a stage in this country at the moment when there is a most arbitrary interpretation by a tyrannical Government as to the meaning of the word "sedition." A printer, or publisher, or editor may ordinarily be expected to have some fair idea as to what he would be allowed to publish and what he would not, but we are actually in a position in this country now when nobody knows what might be declared to be sedition. Under such a declaration they may be put to enormous loss. Consequently any printer who could get any sort of guidance beforehand from an authoritative source is well advised to get that guidance. That arrangement did not go beyond the printers. The Attorney-General says he informed the police that he thought certain passages were seditious, and that if they were printed he might take the matter before the Military Tribunal. What I am informed—on this I have only second-hand information, so I am not purporting specifically to refute what the Attorney-General said—is that the police told the printers that the copy as it was would not be allowed to be issued, but that it could be issued if these three passages were excised. As I said, I have that information only second-hand. Even supposing what the Attorney-General said to be true——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of the excision of some paragraphs from a certain journal should not strictly have been raised on this debate at all. However, as the Deputy rose to make a statement of facts in reply to the Attorney-General, I shall hear him on those facts.

Comment on this

The Attorney-General suggests that those things were removed voluntarily, and that therefore there was no censorship. I want to say, first of all, that my information, which is only secondhand, implied no voluntariness but a direct instruction given to the printer that the thing would not be allowed to be issued.

Comment on this

Might I suggest that there is a more appropriate way to raise this matter if the Deputy wants to have it debated?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy purported to state some facts on which he alleged that the Attorney-General was misinformed. I allowed the Deputy to make his statement while pointing out that the whole discussion might be ruled to be irrelevant.

Comment on this

I do not wish it to be thought that, in saying the Attorney-General did not put the facts, I am suggesting that he sought to mislead the House; I am not questioning the bona fides of anything he said. The Attorney-General's argument was that there was no censorship. The information I have is that the printers were informed that the paper would not be allowed to be issued. 11,500 copies were already printed, and they were at a loss to that extent. I also want to point out that in the existing circumstances in this country, if a printer is told that the Attorney-General considers certain passages to be seditious, and that if they are printed he will probably take the matter before the Military Tribunal, that is absolute censorship, for this reason: sedition is a word——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I allowed the Deputy to get up at this point to make definite statements on questions of fact, on which he did not accept what the Attorney-General had said. But I cannot allow him to discuss the meaning of sedition. If the Deputy has facts to put I should like to hear them.

Comment on this

When you say you allowed me to get up to state certain facts, there seems to me to be a suggestion there that I am making a second speech on this matter under your tolerance, by special privilege. Am I not in order, sir——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The House being in Committee, Deputies are entitled to intervene more than once, but speeches must conform to the rules of order. It was straining the rules to allow that discussion to be initiated by the Deputy now in possession, or to be replied to by the Attorney-General. The discussion must end now.

Comment on this

It does seem to me that such a Bureau as this, which is going to issue information, will almost inevitably also have what I might call a negative operation in the form of censorship, especially in the existing conditions in this country, when the Government has a powerful censorship machine which it is using in a most arbitrary and tyrannical manner at this moment. Further, I would suggest that not only is it using it tyrannically, but most unevenly, and that this Bureau is going to be used for the purpose of ensuring that the great injustice which comes through the uneven operation of the present censorship can be more effectively done when this Bureau is established out of public funds. I should like to point out—but I will bow to your ruling—that whereas one item in one paper—an item which is merely a statement of opinion on Government policy; which is only what I might call an elucidation, the drawing of a conclusion to point out the moral of a statement made by the President himself in this House—is banned as seditious, another paper is allowed to print (after it has been submitted to some authority, whether the Attorney-General or the Military Tribunal, I do not know) open appeals to the young people of this country to join an organisation which is unlawful under the definition of the law as it is now applied in this country, the definition under Article 19 of the Constitution (Amendment) (No. 17) Act. A certain paper is allowed to issue appeals to all the young people of this country to break the law of this country by joining an unlawful association, whose purpose is to overthrow this State by force of arms, and to bring the people of this country into that immoral condition where the jurors will corrupt justice at its very source by committing perjury in the interests of that association. They are also allowed to print open Communist propaganda, after that organ has been submitted to some authority. There are things which I myself have written, and I can assure you, sir, and the House, that there is nothing further from my mind than any desire to embark upon a course of sedition. If I thought that anything I was writing was seditious it would not need the Attorney-General or the Military Tribunal to suppress it, because I would suppress it myself. There is this absolute injustice, which is against justice, morality, and the common weal of the people of this country——

Comment on this

May I ask again what is the relevance of this to the debate? Are we to go into every single matter which every Deputy cares to raise?

Comment on this

I protest against being interrupted.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The President, quite rightly, questioned whether the Deputy's speech was relevant. The Deputy's speech is not relevant, and he must bring it into relation to the Vote.

Comment on this

It is repetition also, I suggest.

Comment on this

I will come on to a more recent matter. I understand that this Bureau started operations on Monday. This Bureau, for which the public is to be taxed, is, presumably, to fulfil some useful purpose. On Friday morning last, Deputy Cosgrave referred to the fact that a certain building, used by an unlawful association in this country, was not interfered with, while another building, belonging to a lawful association, was interfered with. He pointed out that one of the things that have shocked this country more than anything might conceivably——

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

On a point of order, am I to understand that the Deputy is suggesting that No. 5 Parnell Square belonged to a lawful association?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I suggest that it is not in order directly to challenge the order of the Military Tribunal which closed that building because it was the property of an unlawful association.

Comment on this

Is this a point of order or an interruption?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair cannot pronounce on the legality of any association.

Comment on this

I asked if this was a point of order.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

My point of order, if the Deputy did not understand it, was to ask if it was in order, or within the Rules of this House, for a Deputy to challenge a ruling of the Military Tribunal.

Comment on this

Did the Military Tribunal lay down who owned No. 5 Parnell Square, or say that the people who owned it were an unlawful association?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

They closed the building as being a building used by an unlawful association.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

In answer to the Attorney-General's question, it is not lawful for this House to challenge the finding of any duly constituted court.

Comment on this

Is that relevant to the statement made by the Deputy?

Comment on this

Is this whole matter relevant to the debate?

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Is it in order for the Attorney-General to misrepresent the statement of a Deputy addressing the House because that is what he did?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

If I misrepresented the Deputy, I withdraw, but I understood the Deputy to say, and he accepted my interpretation, that the Military Tribunal has closed 5 Parnell Square, although it was not the property of an unlawful association.

Comment on this

My contention is that the Act defines what is an unlawful association and it states certain methods and certain aims which make an association unlawful. At the same time, it states that the Executive Council may state that, in its opinion —and we all know that the word "opinion" implies something which is open to doubt—a certain specifically named organisation is unlawful. The Act also says that when the Executive Council has done that—and whether it does it honestly or dishonestly does not matter—the Military Tribunal are bound to accept that affirmation by the Executive Council as full and conclusive proof. The Military Tribunal were bound to accept that false statement by the Executive Council as full and conclusive proof and the Military Tribunal had no option but to find as they found, but inasmuch as the organisation which owned that premises did not possess any of the aims or pursue any of the methods laid down in what is defined as making an unlawful association, I maintain that it was not an unlawful association, whereas, the other organisation is pampered and put in a privileged position by the members of this Government, an organisation whose method is crime and whose purpose is revolution but, which, for that very reason, is put in that pampered position and allowed to go free and to do all it can to seduce the young manhood of this country into their criminal ranks, under the very ægis of this Government. That is why I say that No. 5 Parnell Square belonged to an organisation that was not unlawful.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The ownership of No. 5 Parnell Square or of any other premises does not arise on this Vote.

Comment on this

I was referring to what was stated here on Friday last——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Which was of questionable relevancy.

Comment on this

I want to bring it in on the actual administration of the Bureau about which we are now speaking. That Bureau, I understand, was opened on Monday; it was open yesterday and the day before and, presumably, to-day, though I know nothing about to-day, but the whole people of this country, horrified by the appalling crime carried out under the ægis of an organisation put in a specially privileged position and immune from the operation of the law of this country, by the present Executive Council——

Comment on this

Is this relevant?

Comment on this

Is this a point of order?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is quite legitimate to question the relevancy of a speech. What happened in Dundalk or Drogheda is not relevant.

Comment on this

I am speaking now about the very administration of this office since it was set up. The whole Press of this country and the Press beyond this country are interested to know whether there was any foundation in fact for the appalling revelation made by Deputy Cosgrave in this House on Friday. There was no point on which it is more important that information should be given to reassure the people of this country that the Government was not guilty of complicity before and after the fact of the crime in Dundalk. The Pressmen went on Monday, and went on Tuesday——

Comment on this

Again I ask, are we to be kept here all day listening to these irrelevancies?

Comment on this

Before you give a ruling, sir, may I suggest that it is quite relevant, if the facts are as stated by the Deputy who is speaking, namely, that this Press Bureau, which is meant to give information on important matters to the public, has been in operation for two days. If it has failed to give information on this important matter, I suggest that few things could be more relevant to this debate than that particular matter.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair does not know whether the Bureau, for which sanction is sought in this Vote, is in operation, but in any case a detailed discussion of the Dundalk incident is out of order.

Comment on this

I thoroughly agree, and I fully accept the Ceann Comhairle's ruling, but I did not hear the Deputy entering on a full discussion of that incident. I suggest, with all respect, that he referred to the incident, and from the occurrence of that incident he drew certain conclusions as to the attitude of the Government on the question of giving information to the public. That, as I understood him for the two minutes he was on this question, was the gist of his argument.

Comment on this

I have stated here that it was my information that this Bureau, and the director in charge of it, began operations, presumably, at the public expense, and the director, being paid out of public funds, the day before yesterday, Monday, and was, presumably, being paid as an operative functioning in this Bureau by the State to-day, yesterday and the day before. I maintain that if this Bureau was to fulfil any useful purpose, if there was any justification for robbing the unfortunate taxpayers of this country, it had a pre-eminent opportunity of making it abundantly clear on Monday last. Pressman after Pressman was going around seeking information. They were ready to publish that that Bureau had stated that there was no foundation whatsoever for the affirmation made here on Friday by Deputy Cosgrave and, on the other hand, they were ready to publish a statement on behalf of the Government that the Government was determined to bring to justice everybody who was in any way implicated in the appalling crime in Dundalk. What service did the Bureau give? Not one scrap of information could be given. It leaked out that some number of detective officers had been suspended from their duty, but no word as to whether or not the statement made by Deputy Cosgrave here was true or, if it were true, what action the Government was taking to reassure the people.

All we have—and I presume it comes from this Department—is a reference in to-day's papers to what, I presume, was a private letter from the High Commissioner in Danzig to President de Valera. Whether this Bureau had the permission of the writer of that letter to refer to it or whether it was merely given by the recipient of that letter in the hope that it might bring some personal kudos to himself, I do not know, but I do say that we have now two or three days' experience of the operation of this Bureau, and it has failed and failed lamentably and failed criminally in its first function, which would be to give information to the people that would reassure them on one of the most vital points on which they could possibly be informed. As I said, it was stated here that the police were watching a certain place while arrangements were being made in preparation for a diabolical crime in which a woman and two children were mutilated by certain criminals. That statement was made last Friday. There has been a dead silence on the point ever since. It has been stated that a man named Gilmore was arrested and released. It has been stated that a caretaker of 44 Parnell Square——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy might relate those arrests to the Estimate.

Comment on this

I think so. I presume that the Bureau of Information is giving information as to the operations of the various Departments of State, and that it was its clear function to give that information.

Comment on this

Could it be its function if the police were making inquiries? Is not that a matter for the police Department? How could it possibly be a matter for the Bureau?

Comment on this

Is the Department of Justice a Department of this State?

Comment on this

The Department of Justice, as the Deputy should know, in connection with police matters has to let the police do their own investigations in their own way.

Comment on this

Is it not the position that the police were not allowed to do their own investigation?

Comment on this
Patrick Joseph Ruttledge Minister for Justice (Mr. Ruttledge) Fianna Fáil

That is not true. It is like some other statements that were made. The position with regard to this is that a certain statement was made last Friday by Deputy Cosgrave. I understood that statement to be that from No. 5 Parnell Square certain detectives or police officers were keeping in view certain other premises in Parnell Square. Anything that was done in that way was done by the police in the exercise of their duties and in view of any information they might have had. The Deputy went further and stated that he was satisfied that certain mining operations, or something to do with mines were going on there. He went further and stated that the only mine that was exploded was that exploded in Dundalk on the following day. This can be the subject of debate at a later stage in this House. All I am prepared to state to the House or to the people outside at this stage is that the police are satisfied that there is no relation between what happened in Dundalk and anything that took place in Dublin on the previous day.

Comment on this

If the Minister is prepared to make that statement now, will he say if he has made that statement after investigation of all the circumstances himself?

Comment on this

After investigation that has been in progress by the police. If I get reports from Dundalk or other places the Deputy does not expect that I should go down personally and investigate them. So far as having competent and reliable officers to carry out the investigation, from information, the source of which I could not disclose in any way, these competent officers are satisfied that there is no relation between Dublin and Dundalk.

Comment on this

A very serious statement was made on Friday, and it has been examined, and apparently judged and decided upon by all the persons that were implicated in it, and I am not satisfied with the statement of the Minister.

Comment on this

Unless I cannot rely on any officers under my Department, I am satisfied that there is no relation whatever between the regrettable and dastardly thing that happened in Dundalk and what occurred in Dublin. I am quite satisfied of that.

Comment on this

The Minister has had investigations made into this matter and he has had all the documents before him, I presume?

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

It has been investigated by himself personally?

Comment on this

So far as documents are concerned. I do not understand what the Deputy wants to get at when he asks if it has been investigated by myself personally. Every document and every report that has come in dealing with these particular matters has been examined by myself personally. Certain conclusions are submitted in those documents from these competent officers, and I have no reason to disagree with those conclusions of those officers who made certain investigations and who are still pursuing their investigations. The Deputy will appreciate that at such a stage as this it is very difficult for me to go into any details, and I do not think that it would be proper that I should.

Comment on this

The Minister has gone a certain distance. He is satisfied now before the case is thoroughly investigated and sifted, and he has pronounced upon it, but I am not satisfied with it.

Comment on this

The Deputy made a statement last Friday. I had certain information at that time. The Deputy's statement seemed to be based on very definite information. I have made inquiries since, and I would be very glad if the Deputy can give to the police authorities the basis of his information on which he made this statement in the House that went through the country.

Comment on this

That is a "get out."

Comment on this

That is not a "get out."

Comment on this

The matter is too serious for that. It is a new order and a new phase of public business if those who are charged are going to be judges, jury, witnesses and all.

Comment on this

That is not correct. I should like to know what the Deputy means.

Comment on this

The Minister is in possession of information.

Comment on this

With regard to the incident, I think the Leader of the Opposition acted in a most outrageous manner in raising that matter. I think it was his duty either to raise it that morning by a private notice question or give information to the Minister for Justice in order that there would be no prejudice to any examination necessary in that case. He had a private notice question down that day on another matter.

Comment on this

I have longer experience of administration than the President or the Minister.

Comment on this

Of course.

Comment on this

Much longer. I have a greater appreciation of the importance of administration than either of them. If I were not satisfied that they had failed in their duty and that they were going to fail in their duty, I would not have raised it.

Comment on this

Give up posing.

Comment on this

There is nothing else but posing on the Benches opposite.

Comment on this

Give us information; do not be making statements which you cannot prove.

Comment on this

I want to be clear on the matter. I was not here on Friday. I understood the Minister to say that the statement was made that certain police officers entered 5 Parnell Square and from there observed certain things happening in another house; that the further statement was made that that meeting had something to do with the preparation or construction of mines; that furthermore an explosion took place next day at Dundalk and that that was the only explosion that took place. I understand that these are the statements that the Minister attributes to Deputy Cosgrave. He denies, I understand, that there is any connection between Dublin and Dundalk. His denial, I understand, is limited to that.

Comment on this

And that is based on the fact that the matter has not been completed while certain inquiries are being followed up.

Comment on this

Certain inquiries were made and the Minister has pronounced on them, although they have not been completed. His denial is limited to that.

Comment on this

Does the Minister deny the purpose of the meeting under observation was as I stated?

Comment on this

I will not say anything further. At a later stage I am prepared to have the whole matter discussed.

Comment on this

A discussion does not satisfy me at all. This is a matter which is too serious for discussion. It is a matter for investigation by persons——

Comment on this

If it is too serious for discussion the Leader of the Opposition should not prejudice the police work.

Comment on this

I have said nothing about police work.

Comment on this

What else is it?

Comment on this

Will the President state what I have said in connection with the police work?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy suggest that we have interfered with the police?

Comment on this

I say it is untrue.

Comment on this

Will the President say in what way I have interfered with the police work?

Comment on this

I suggest that if the Leader of the Opposition were acting properly if he had the information which he gave to the House here he would, in the first instance, have put down a private notice question by which it could be properly raised here and not by a side-wind, in a debate like this, be making political capital out of this serious business. Instead of bringing it in by a side-wind he could have asked a private notice question, just as he asked another private notice question, and given the Minister notice of it or else, if he had information which would lead to the connection of any individuals with this, he could have given that information to the Minister instead of coming along here and trying to prejudice enquiries which are essential in the matter. I protest against the question being raised in this way.

Comment on this