We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Vote No. 3—Department of President of Executive Council (Resumed).

Contributions 131–252 of 252. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Of course these protests are all very well when they come from honest motives. The Ministry is at present engaged on an investigation by itself on a matter on which it is itself in the dock.

Comment on this

It is not in the dock. There was some talk of censorship, but we have in the Party organ allowed to be published—and if I had anything to do with it it would not be published——

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

If there was a censorship it would not be published.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Is this relevant?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

As relevant as the speeches which preceded it.

Comment on this

This is the United Ireland paper, and when we read this we can understand what is the object of the Opposition in raising this matter in the way it did. This organ says in a certain statement: "This is the story of Mr. de Valera's Dundalk bombers of women and children." I say that is a damnable suggestion and that there is no truth whatever in that. I say that if I were censoring, and if there were a censorship, a paper using such statements would not be allowed to be published.

Comment on this

It has nothing whatever to do with it. The President is not above the law. If he has legal rights, he has legal remedies, and there are places for them, but he is not going to pull any red herring across the track in respect of my statements.

Comment on this

The President has spoken in reference to the attitude taken up by Deputy Cosgrave and asked why the matter should not be raised by a private notice question. Might I ask if the matter assumes in his mind the importance which he seems to attach to it now, why he could not have made a statement here to-day after questions on the matter?

Comment on this

Because this thing is quite irrelevant to the debate and no statement could be made. The charge was altogether irregular, and so far as our information goes, there seems to be no foundation for it. Investigations are proceeding and at this stage a statement could not be made.

Comment on this

The President made a statement that Deputy Cosgrave's speech was prejudically affecting police work. Why when the matter is so important could he not make a statement with regard to it to-day?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That query is out of order.

Comment on this

These are peculiar points of order. I thought a speaker was only supposed to be interrupted on a point of order, yet the President got up and read out a paper. What I have been trying to point out is that this Bureau, as it has been already in operation for a few days, shows its lamentable uselessness. People are led to believe that this institution would be a means of getting authoritative information from Government sources, and the only authoritative information it could get since it was set up, as far as I can gather, seems to be a reference to a private letter sent from Danzig to the President. Whether it was published with the permission of the writer or not I do now know. I suggest that this Department, useless as it clearly is, for giving information in which the public are keenly and rightly interested, will be used for the purpose of adding to the already existing injustices which are operating under this Government. There has been an argument just now about a matter that took place in Parnell Square. The Minister for Justice——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is not prepared to hear anything further on that subject.

Comment on this

It did not seen to be irrelevant just now. On the one hand, the President said that if there is any reference which is not flattering——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is irrelevant. Its introduction originally was irrelevant. The subsequent discussion was irrelevant and must be taken as concluded.

Comment on this

It seems to be wholly contradictory to me. It seems rather hard on me but I am respecting the ruling of the Chair. The Bureau of Information on its negative side is associated with that censorship. If it were anything, which would be worked impartially, something might be said for it but there is every indication, unfortunately, that we are going to have a tyrannical censorship, a censorship which, as between one Party and another, outrages justice. The President, in regard to a paper which represents one section, said that he would override the law, that whether the law allowed him or not, rather than allow himself to be spoken of in a derogatory way——

Comment on this

I did not make any such statement.

Comment on this

Is this a point of order?

Comment on this

It is a point of explanation.

Comment on this

I can only be interrupted on a point of order. I have been interrupted long enough in this insolent way.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am prepared to hear the President on a point of personal explanation.

Comment on this

On two occasions already the Deputy has suggested that I was putting myself above the law. I said that if there was a censorship and I were censor, I would not allow that statement to be published because I believe it is calculated to bring the Government into contempt, and worse, that it is sedition of the worst type.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Would the President allow a Communist paper to be published?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The President's word must be taken as to what he did say.

Comment on this

Is it your ruling, sir, on a point of order in regard to a matter which has been discussed here in the House, that the word of the President in regard to a certain statement of his own must be accepted by three-fourths of the Deputies of the House who were witnesses of the statement and who have different impression of what he did say?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The practice of the House has been that until the Official Report is available a Deputy's assurance as to what he said must be accepted.

Comment on this

I suppose the Official Reporters can be reprimanded if necessary.

Comment on this

Again I say that is a damnable suggestion.

Comment on this

However, we shall see the Official Report. I understood that a speaker could only be interrupted on a point of order. The President has got up time and again and interrupted me on matters which were not points of order.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not, directly or indirectly, question the ruling of the Chair.

Comment on this

I was not questioning the ruling of the Chair. I was only talking about the general lack of ordinary good manners on the part of the President. There is just one other matter to which I wish to refer. On Thursday last a most immoral and diabolical doctrine was preached by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. He said:

"The policy of this Party has been approved of by the people and if the purpose of this Party is to give effect to its policy, then any Party purpose that this institution may be used to effect, in so far as it conforms with the policy the people have approved of, is a good purpose."

That, to my mind, is a most diabolical doctrine. The argument is that the Fianna Fáil Party went out with a policy, and that they got a majority of votes. Now, of course we need not go into the fact that the declared reason for the last election was that it was necessary before a settlement of the economic war could be arrived at, that the Government was prevented from enforcing a settlement in the way of a surrender by the British——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

How does the Deputy relate the settlement of the economic war to this Vote?

Comment on this

Yes, sir, I am relating it to the argument that because the people gave a majority of votes to a certain Party, because the people approved of the policy of a certain Party, there has to be a suppression of justice, there has to be a Party tyranny based on the supposition that that Party is supported by the people. The argument is that any money that the Government expends in promulgating and propaganding what they themselves want to be propaganded, is clearly justified, on the grounds that they got a majority vote at the last election. I say that is a proposal of Party dictatorship in defiance of all justice.

The President, the Minister for Industry and Commerce and other Ministers have consistently assumed that nobody in this country has any right whatsoever except the majority. They are assuming now that they have a perfect right to go out and pick the pockets of the unfortunate minority. The minority is waved aside. The only moral law is that the majority will must prevail. The majority may want to rob the minority. "These," says President de Valera, "are entirely my ethics.""That," says the Minister for Industry and Commerce, "is the policy of the Government." It seems to me that those statements and the whole argument of the Minister for Industry and Commerce must not be allowed to pass unchallenged. Governments exist to promote the well-being of all the people.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I should like to hear what bearing a speech on political morality or on the ethics of good government has to this Vote.

Comment on this

This Vote is a direct challenge to political morality. The Fianna Fáil Party, not satisfied with getting, by a side-wind, a subsidy out of the unfortunate people of America, are now going to impose taxation on the people here for the purpose of misleading those people to their own detriment. That is clear to every intelligent person here from the statements made by Government Ministers. At the last election the Government wanted to be given a majority so that they could put an end to the economic war. Since then the President has declared that he thanks God for the economic war.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The economic war may not be discussed now.

Comment on this

The argument put up by a so-called responsible Minister in this House was that the ethics of this proposal were all right because Fianna Fáil got a majority in the last election and therefore it has the right to seize public funds to be used in the interests of the Party. That is the argument put up in relation to the Bureau. I say that that is an immoral argument and should at once be refuted. This is merely an attempt to rob the Irish people in the interests of a certain organisation. Does it mean that whatever other Government comes into power it can say: "We have a majority. Our policy is to put money in our own pockets. The people voted for us and therefore we have a perfect right to do it." That is the argument submitted by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and I say that that implies a Party dictatorship. The Government adopting that attitude has not in mind the well-being of the people generally, but rather the people in their own political organisation.

Every action of this Government has given an indication of that corrupt theory, and that corrupt theory has manifested itself in corrupt practice. Last Thursday a responsible Minister here preached a fundamental doctrine of corruption in justification of this corrupt thing that the President now proposes to do. I know that Deputy Norton and his henchmen have got up in their usual slavish fashion and they have signified support of this proposal. Presumably they accept the theory of the Minister for Industry and Commerce that Fianna Fáil, having got a majority, have a right to seize public funds in the pursuit of their policy. Deputy Corish, in the interests of his constituents in Wexford, voted to give this Government powers to continue an economic war which is doing so much for the well-being of the people of Wexford. Deputy Corish and the members of his Party are pre-eminently responsible for the existing condition of things. The present situation could not exist without their support. Apparently that Party now accepts the doctrine that Fianna Fáil, having got their majority, are not only right in pursuing their policy in complete defiance of and in utter disregard for any concern of public good, but they are also right in seizing public funds in order to blind the people as to what is the truth and as to what the real well-being of the country demands.

Anybody who votes in favour of this proposal is voting in favour of a Party dictatorship. Time and again we have had the President misrepresenting the situation. Without even purporting to quote, he has declared that our Party stands for dictatorship. Every act in his own career has clearly indicated that he is incapable of thinking in any other terms than in terms of dictatorship, and the policy of Party dictatorship was clearly proposed by the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

What about your Army dictatorship in 1924?

Comment on this

I had no Army dictatorship in 1924.

Comment on this

—You know you had.

Comment on this

There was no Army dictatorship in 1924.

Comment on this

Read the late Kevin O'Higgins's speeches.

Comment on this

The Deputy would be well advised to read Senator Johnson's speeches at that period.

Comment on this

The late Kevin O'Higgins took very good care that there would be no Army dictatorship. The late Kevin O'Higgins was murdered and the Deputy now comes in and in order to cover up his dirty act in supporting this proposal he refers to what the late Kevin O'Higgins took very good care should not operate in this country. Kevin O'Higgins stood always between this country and any attempt at tyranny. The Labour Party are now trying to use that as a justification for their slavish, crawling support of a corrupt proposal on the part of the present Government. I do not think there was ever such an immoral proposal made or such an immoral doctrine preached as that put forward by the Minister for Industry and Commerce the other day. I would not mind it so much except that he submitted it in all naïveté and simplicity. He seemed to presume that everybody in this country accepted that doctrine, because he is incapable of thinking in any other terms than in terms of Party graft and Party dictatorship. We are asked to vote here in order to give an additional machine to people who cannot think in any terms other than terms of corruption, Party graft and terms incompatible with any decent conception of public morality.

Comment on this

I rise on a point of personal explanation, arising out of a remark made by Deputy Norton. Deputy Norton implies that in 1924 I stood to arrange an Army dictatorship. I utterly repudiate that and I will recall to Deputy Norton and to members of the House certain facts. I would like, first of all, to refer Deputy Norton to the statement of the then leader of the Labour Party in this House on that particular subject. I will ask Deputy Norton to refer to that and then review his outlook on the whole matter. The second point I want to emphasise is that I handled the Army, so far as the State here is concerned, in 1922, 1923 and 1924. I left the Army in certain circumstances in 1924.

Comment on this

Left it? That is good white-washing.

Comment on this

I left the Army in 1924.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy asked permission to make a personal explanation and was allowed to do so. Personal explanations should be brief, particularly when, as in this instance, the explanation arose out of interruptions from two Deputies not participating in the debate.

Comment on this

What I am about to say is very material to this debate. As I have said, I left the Army in certain circumstances in 1924, when the Army had done its work. I and the officers who left with me left this House and the country with an Army that served the people when the people wanted its service, served the people under us, and that Army served this House and the people when we left.

Comment on this

Thanks to the Army.

Comment on this

Before the debate comes to an end I would like to point out that notwithstanding all we have been told there is one thing we have not yet been told. It is a matter on which we are entitled to a plain statement; that is, whether the opposition to the Vote is opposition to the principle of a Bureau or not. It would be a fair inference from Deputy Mulcahy's speech to-day, for instance, that the Opposition would approve of a Bureau of Information if there were any other Government in power. The Deputy, however, obviously contemplates this Bureau in present circumstances exuding dope, wrong information, and misrepresentation on every subject that it may touch. It would be possible I think to have a Bureau that would not act in that way. It would be possible to have a Government that would not mind telling the truth with regard to the big national questions that affect this country. What we are concerned to know is—would the Opposition oppose the idea of a Bureau in such circumstances as that?

Usually with regard to Estimates, we treat them as if they related to permanent things, as if the subject of the Estimate were part of the machinery of the State, irrespective of the Party in power. Not so, however, in the present discussion. I have heard a great deal of the discussion here and certainly a great deal of it has been based on the assumption that the Bureau will be used by the present Government to misrepresent the position in this country and particularly to misrepresent the opponents of the Government. I suggest that is a new way of discussing Estimates. If there is a lack of confidence in the Government with regard to this matter, it would seem that that lack of confidence would apply to every Department of the State and would be a good reason for refusing money to any Department. If the Ministers are prepared to mislead their own people, if they are prepared to mislead foreigners and to tell deliberate lies about the circumstances of this country, surely none of these Ministers is fit to be trusted with the guardianship of any Department. Would the same criticism not apply to every Estimate brought before this House?

I think if there is still anybody to speak from the Opposition, we are entitled to know whether they would approve of a Bureau of Information in ordinary circumstances or, if there were not such an immoral Government in power as there is at present, would they agree that such a Bureau could be very useful both to this country, to our friends abroad, and to those interested in the country abroad? Would they agree about the setting up of a Bureau which would tell the truth about the aim of the Government in power and what the policy of that Government was with regard to constitutional questions, with regard to cultural questions, with regard to their line of policy on industrial development and the treatment of leading social questions such as unemployment? Would a Bureau which would tell the truth about these questions serve a useful purpose? I think the House is entitled to know—and it is obvious that we ought to know in voting on this Estimate—whether the Opposition are prepared to agree to that, or whether their opposition is because the Government in power at present is a Government which not only may but must abuse the power that would be given to it by the approval of this proposal.

I suggest that if there is any speaker on the Opposition who will attempt to answer that question he will find himself in a peculiar position with regard to his colleagues who have preceded him in the debate. You could not possibly see any Government acting in so immoral a way as to misrepresent a situation with regard to every Department of life in this country at the present time. I believe it would have to be admitted by everybody who views it at all in an impartial light that such a Bureau would be of immense advantage to those who were interested in the country, particularly those living abroad. Even more, I consider that in the case of those living abroad, such, for instance, as the half a million Irish people living in Glasgow, that they are entitled, in view of their attachment to this country and in view of the very great services they have given to this country from time to time, to have information as to the Government's activities and to get it from sources to which they can attach confidence. It seems entirely right that they should not be left to rely on English and Scotch newspapers to tell them what is happening in this country. Anybody who has contact with the Irish abroad, in Great Britain or America, must know that one of the first questions you will be asked is what is your Government doing on a particular matter? You will be asked such questions as, what is the position with regard to unemployment in your country, and have they got rid of the landlords yet, and so on. It is not right, I suggest, in view particularly of the great services they have rendered to the home country from time to time that they should be encouraged to believe by prejudiced newspapers abroad that this country is in an anarchic state, or that this country is seething with discontent about unemployment, when that is not the case.

This debate throughout has, to my mind, been a very sad reflection on the ability of the Dáil to discuss questions of principle apart from personalities. As a matter of fact, there has not been five minutes of the whole debate devoted to the question of the principle of the Bureau. You have instead a whole list of accusations against different Ministers of the Government and against the Government collectively. So far as the Estimate is concerned that has left the debate a useless one, giving no help to any Deputy to make up his mind. So far as I can see for myself, the proposal to establish a Bureau is well justified in any circumstances; it must mean very great benefit to the prestige of this country and react to our advantage as a nation.

Comment on this

Deputy Moore has put a couple of questions. Really, though I wish to say that I generally appreciate what Deputy Moore contributes to this House and the spirit also in which he makes his contribution, yet surely he is asking us to do a thing that is completely unreal. We are not discussing the question of this principle of the Bureau in the abstract. We are discussing it in a concrete situation. We are not discussing it in reference to the individual who may be appointed as a civil servant as director of this Bureau, about whom I have absolutely nothing to say. We are discussing it in reference to the political head of the Department, the man who, I presume, so far as this House and this country is concerned, will guide the policy of this particular Bureau. I suggest in that connection that the most relevant thing we can discuss—and anything that ignores that and does not take it into account would be almost irrelevant and would certainly ignore the prime factor—is the President's control of this Bureau; not the use to which it will be put under some person in the abstract of whom we know nothing, but the use to which the President from what we know of him and his Government would put the Bureau. That use of this particular Bureau was plainly indicated by Deputy Fitzgerald as described by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. He laid down the general principle that their Party having been chosen by the people of this country, and having got the confidence of the people of this country, were entitled then to help on their Party by any means that would help them on so long as the people put them in power.

That passage was clearly read out by Deputy Fitzgerald. It is as follows:

"The policy of this Party"

—that is the Fianna Fáil Party—

"has been approved of by the people, and if the purpose of this Party is to give effect to its policy, then any Party purpose that this institution"

—namely, the Bureau—

"may be used to effect, in so far as it conforms with the policy the people have approved of, is a good purpose."

I suggest that we must take into account—anything else would be completely unreal in this debate—the attitude of the President, and, to use a phrase used elsewhere by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, his conception of the truth. After all he is the political head of this Bureau. It is a portion of his Department. Does anybody in this House who is not committed wholeheartedly to the President believe, not that the President wants to tell the truth, but that the President can tell the truth or can see the truth. That has always been my tremendous difficulty with the President. I am not interested now in the question of whether he wishes to put the truth as he may see it before the people. That is not what I am debating. That question of honesty does not arise. What does arise is the proved incompetency of the President again and again to grasp the truth. It is not a moral delinquency that I mean; I am not suggesting that. It is an intellectual failure on his part to grasp the truth. Mind you, the man who is going to be at the head of this Information Bureau is the man who got up in this House and said that the Irish Press was not a Party newspaper. That is his conception of the truth. I am taking it that that must be the line of policy—as he is the head of this Department and responsible for the policy of the Department—which this particular Bureau must follow. Surely the President has made it quite clear again and again that he is incapable of seeing facts as they are—that he cannot see what is. He can prove, we know, anything. The Bureau I presume will have to do the same. If the man who is appointed is sufficiently subservient he will have to take his conception of truth—to use that peculiar phrase from this debate—from the President. I have no doubt that at the beginning you will find a man optimistic enough to think that he will be able to give his own conception of truth to the public. Does anybody, even in that Party, think that he will be able to convince the President if the President happens to disagree with him? I have asked in this House did anybody ever convince the President of anything.

Comment on this

Certainly not you.

Comment on this

And I do not think members of the Party have done so either.

Comment on this

There is no need.

Comment on this

I do not think members of the Party have done so either. The President is capable of seeing any truth he wants to see. He is capable of proving to his own satisfaction, and I presume the Bureau must do the same, that the people of this country have morally no right to get rid of his Heaven-sent guidance; that even constitutionally they would have no right to get rid of it; and that any steps he will take to prove to them that even constitutionally they have no right to get rid of his guidance will be correct. I suggest to Deputy Moore that the whole question hinges about the extraordinary conception of propaganda which the President has, about his conception of any other point of view, about his conception of indentification of the country, not of himself with the country, but of the country with himself, because after all remember you are dealing with a man——

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

——who, as head of this Bureau does not need to go to the country for the facts. He can find them like other people in other countries have found them, by looking into his own heart. That is sufficient. The Bureau will have to follow his conception of the truth, and that is the kind of dope which the country is bound to get; not merely may get, but, to use Deputy Moore's change from the word "may," must get, and cannot avoid getting with the present Government in power, and with the President at the head of this propaganda Bureau. It is precisely on our full knowledge of the propagandist powers and the propagandist mind of the Government and of the President that our main objection to this particular Vote lies. I do not think that the House can afford for a moment to let that out of sight. I can assure Deputy Moore that when discussing estimates it is not at all a question of discussing the Civil Service. It is a question of discussing the policy of the political head. That is generally what is debated when the general debate on the Estimate is on. I suggest to him that we are following that precedent here in discussing the attitude of the President to propaganda, the confessed attitude that that is a Party Government that is sitting there; that it can utilise this particular office, and apparently the funds that will subsidise this particular office, for Party purposes, and that it feels perfectly entitled to do so. We have had instances; I am not going into any detail in those things, but we have had instances as to their line towards those who critise them.

Leaving aside now the question as to whether the Attorney-General had any right to do, or whether he was doing out of the goodness of his heart—we will suppose that he was doing it out of goodness of heart—what he did in connection with that newspaper, I should like to ask him and ask the House to look at the passages that he excised, and to judge from them what is the Government's attitude towards criticism. I am not now dealing with whether or not he had a right to do what he did. I am dealing with the attitude of mind even towards criticism. The suppressing of your opponents views ought to require more justification than the particular Government dope that is likely to be put out in the interests of the President. We know they cannot stand any criticism of any kind. Does anybody, or does the Party that is supporting this particular Vote, really believe that the truth is going to the people from this? Is there the slightest chance that anything except the ordinary Party dope will go to them? Will it be anything except an officially acknowledged type of propaganda such as we get from the paper that the President has described as a non-Party organ? We have again and again here in this House tried to get various information from the President. He has made statements here and through the country. Most of the people have been surprised to learn, sometimes months, sometimes years afterwards, that his statements meant the opposite to what they thought they meant. Is that the truth we are going to get from this particular Bureau of which the President is the political head? It might, I admit to Deputy Moore—unfortunately not "must" on this occasion—give useful information to the country. It might, for instance, tell the country where all the industries are. That would be most useful. Again and again in this House—and Deputy Moore referred to industries— every effort has been made to get information on that point. Is there any reason why the information should not have been given and given effectively by the Minister for Industry and Commerce? Surely not. Will this Bureau give the information which the Minister for Industry and Commerce refuses to give? Can it give the information the Minister refuses to give? Here is a matter on which not merely the people in this Party but, I can assure the Deputy, the people in his own, Party, his own supporters, really do want information. I know, as I have said before, a Fianna Fáil Club in Kerry which cannot see the industries in its own native county and which suggests that there is a boycott there. Numbers of industries may be there, but they cannot be seen by that particular Fianna Fáil Club in Tralee. Will the Bureau give the information which the Minister for Industry and Commerce so determinedly refuses to give to this House?

I suggest that the most relevant thing in this debate is the proved inability of the President to put a plain, objective statement on anything in which he is interested before the people, and that, for that reason, this House ought not to consent to vote the money for the setting up of this particular Bureau. As I say, we know too well the propagandist activities, the propagandist spirit, the propagandist ability, if you like, of the Fianna Fáil Party and of the Fianna Fáil leaders. You need only read the speeches of the Ministers, any time you like, from that bench opposite. They are not dealing with the subject under discussion but are very often merely statements of propaganda and misrepresentation of their opponents. They have shown themselves always, in office and out of office, past masters so far as that is concerned. I suggest that that is the most relevant fact this House should bear in mind in the setting up of this particular Bureau, and it is because we know the spirit that is bound to, that must, if we use Deputy Moore's phrase, animate and inspire this Bureau that we oppose it. On the question of the individual, as I said at the beginning, I have no doubt that an individual might be optimistic enough to think that he will be able to give out the truth as he conceives it to the public, but how any self-respecting man will be able to stay in the position after the experience of, say, six months, I should be interested to see. Any such man who is not prepared to accept for the President, so far as this country is concerned what is called in reference to the Russian people the Messianic complex must certainly be an extraordinary optimist or extremely subservient, so far as the President is concerned.

I can understand any man being sufficiently optimistic at the outset to take up this particular work, but I am not interested in that particular side of the matter. I am not interested in the individual who is taking over this Bureau; I am interested in the Minister responsible for this particular Department, and I object to the Vote because we have to do with this Government, with its known characteristics, a Government that boasts that it is a Party Government —as is acknowledged by the man who, I may say even to the President is his best propagandist, the Minister for Industry and Commerce—which is not fit to be trusted with this power any more than it is fit to be trusted with many of the powers to which Deputy Moore referred. That really is the gist of my opposition to this. It is because I do not think that this sub-Department is capable of being used for anything but—that is putting it a little too strongly because it may be used occasionally for disseminating truth; if we could be sure that all it said was false, we might be able to arrive at the truth, but very often, I have no doubt, it will tell the truth but I am equally convinced that very often it will dole out and will be bound so long as the President is in control of it to dole out propaganda which is Party propaganda or will appear so to the great bulk of the people—Party propaganda in the narrow sense of the word. Many people on this side who oppose it know perfectly well what the Government propaganda is worth so far as truth is concerned. I suggest that it is because the people of this country—and very quickly, mind you, because it is not so long since the President got into power—are finding out what both the negative and the positive propaganda of the Government is worth, that this Bureau is called into existence. It is because the people are finding out that both the attacks of the Government, in the way of propaganda, on their opponents and also, the promises they made, are so much worthless propaganda that this particular sub-Department is called into existence.

Comment on this

When we listen for a little while to Deputy O'Sullivan, one can clearly understand what is the whole trouble with the Opposition. The whole trouble is that a Government other than themselves happens to be in power and that nothing can be trusted to us to be done properly and that the only people who can do anything properly, justly and fairly are themselves. There is a difference of opinion about that and that difference of opinion was pretty well settled by the country in two different elections and so far as the Deputies on the opposite side are concerned, they will have to put up for another three, four or five years, anyhow, with having a Government such as we have to-day. This Government came into office with a certain programme. That programme was endorsed by the electorate and we have no apology whatever to make to anybody for pursuing that particular policy. This debate, however, ranged over Government policy and the speakers on the opposite side were very hard put to it indeed to find an excuse for dealing with the debate in the manner in which they dealt with it. All sorts of excuses that anybody could see through were put forward for introducing all sorts of irrelevant matters. It was impossible for the Chair to prevent that from happening, because no sooner was a Deputy held up on one particular point than he immediately got some other excuse for proceeding on another point and he had got half way through it before the Chair or anybody else could see whether there was any relevancy in it or not.

Deputy O'Sullivan's effort, however, was a masterpiece. It is because of the personality of the person who is to be in charge of this Bureau that there is objection. It is not a question of a Department of State being put up or the merits of a certain policy in general but it is the merits of that particular Department because it happens to be directed by somebody to whom Deputies on the opposite side object. Deputy Moore asked that somebody on the opposite benches would speak to this as a matter of principle. One Deputy did and only one—Deputy MacDermot. He said that, quite irrespective of the Government in power or of any views he might hold or that any other members with whom he was associated might hold with regard to the Government, he would oppose it in any case. That is a point of view that one can understand—I can, at least. I am quite willing to admit straight off that it is a department that can very well be abused. But so could practically every other Department of State be abused if you have people in office who are corrupt enough to abuse it. There is scarcely a single department from which information is not being given out in one way or another to the public which, if inaccurate, could mislead the public. There is hardly a Department of State which, in one way or another, if abused, could not be used for what might be called narrow Party propaganda.

The Minister for Agriculture has officers in different parts of the country representing the Department. They have to do their best to have the policy of the Department put into operation. They have to appeal to the farmers and others to grow wheat and do a number of other things. There is no doubt that all those, if they were to be improperly used, could be used for very narrow Party purposes. All I can say to Deputy MacDermot is that when he objects to this particular Department on principle, because it can be abused by people who are corrupt enough and who are dishonset enough to abuse it, he has no remedy as long as there are dishonest or lying people in existence and as long as such people can by any possible means come to be a Government.

Listening to Deputies on the opposite benches one would imagine that this was something unique; something that did not exist in any other country; something that was the conception of Fianna Fáil; that it could not possible exist in any other part of the world except such parts as might happen, like here, to have, as they suggest, a corrupt Government. The fact is that there is scarcely a country in the world that has not such a Department. I have a long list here. It does not purport to be in any way completely exhaustive. In that list I find the United States of America to start with. The United States has a section in the Department of State for the supply of current information. The Department of Agriculture has also a special section for publicity. Then we have Great Britain. In Great Britain it is not definitely a Department of Publicity but there are Press officers attached to the Foreign Office and the Treasury and to the India Office. In Germany there is a specific Department of State under a Minister known as the Department of Educational Propaganda and that is probably one of the most active Departments of its kind in the world. In France there is an Information and Press Section attached to the Department of External Affairs. Japan has an Information Bureau in its Department of External Affairs. That exhausts the larger countries.

Now let us come to the relatively smaller ones. In the Argentine there is a Section in the Department of External Affairs called the Information Bureau. In Austria there is a special Commission known as the Federal Propaganda Commission. In Bulgaria there is a Press director in the Department of External Affairs. In Denmark there is a Press Bureau in the Department of External Affairs. In Finland there is a Press Section in the Department of External Affairs. In Greece there is a Press director in the Department of External Affairs. In Latvia there is a Press Section in the Department of External Affairs. In Persia there is a Press Information Section in its Department of External Affairs. In Czecho-Slovakia there is a Section in its Department of External Affairs for the distribution of political and economic information. In Turkey there is a Press Information Bureau attached to the Department of External Affairs. As I have indicated, this list is not exhaustive, but shows that this idea of a Bureau of Information if established here will not be unique and that it supplies a want which has been felt in practically every country in the world.

There might be some excuse for Deputies opposite talking as they did if they were ignorant of that, but they are not. I listened to the long speech of Deputy Fitzgerald which suggested indignation. It would be interesting to hear what that Deputy said when Minister for External Affairs when he introduced a Vote for a much larger amount for the same purpose that we are introducing it here. It was not in a period of war. It was in 1924 when there was peace. Let us see what that Deputy said who simulated all this indignation and who tried to attribute to me things that he knew could be done with it, because he had done them. I have a file here which shows how he misused it. If I were to read through the file, or extracts from it, Deputies would understand that what the Deputy was doing was suggesting to me things which he was capable of and did himself.

Comment on this

Would it not be more decent for the President to read them than to make the suggestion he is making?

Comment on this

I am certain, having looked through them, that what I state is true.

Comment on this

Would it not be more decent to read them than to make the suggestion you are making?

Comment on this

When I come to some of the remarks of the Deputy I will show you how decent he was. It would be more decent for the Deputy to suggest the name of the person who was supposed to inspire me, but he did not do it.

Comment on this

I gave the President every opportunity of finding out.

Comment on this

The Deputy suggests that there is something mean about my referring to the files. I am referring to them because the Deputy who was responsible at the time knows that what I say is true. As far as meanness is concerned, I say that the Deputy should not talk about it. He suggested a short time ago without giving the name that there was somebody who was prompting us in our propaganda.

Comment on this

Will the President take steps to give everybody that information? The President ran away from his promise in connection with it.

Comment on this

Why did not the Deputy give it if he knew it?

Comment on this

I asked the President to allow full information to go out with regard to it and the President took every step he could to prevent it.

Comment on this

In relation to the interview, the moment I found that the information I got was false—first of all I said what I did before the Deputy, not by innuendo. I said it because I thought it was true. I gave an opportunity to the Deputy to contradict it.

Comment on this

Did the President take any trouble to investigate it before he made the statement?

Comment on this

I have given a full explanation and I do not intend to go any further.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This matter does not arise out of this Vote.

Comment on this

Will it be the custom for the Press Bureau to publish a charge first and investigate it afterwards?

Comment on this

In order to give people a chance of denying it.

Comment on this

I propose to read what Deputy Fitzgerald, when Minister for External Affairs, said about this particular Department which was in existence at the time. I shall have to weary the House with it because, in order to contrast the speech which we have listened to this afternoon and the speech on Friday last with this, Deputies should hear the whole of it.

He said:

"The Publicity Department has decreased its expenditure by, roughly, one-half. This work falls into two classes. One activity of it might be described as a Public Record Office. It is necessary for this Government, as for every other Government, to be informed as to what is happening in the world, what is being stated in the Press of the world, and in other periodical publications; and for that reason, instead of each Department in the Government having such a Record Office it is found more efficient and more economical to concentrate that matter in one office. The work there, then, is to note the Press and other publications of various countries in the world, and to call the attention of each Ministry to such information as may be likely to interest them, and to keep a record and to keep files of any cases of important publications, and to keep a general record of all such matters as may either now or at any time in the future be required to be referred to. Apart from that we require to have some machinery for conveying information or for rectifying misinformation. It must be remembered that practically every country does this; and most countries are much better situated for doing it than we are. To begin with, we are a new country and an unknown quantity in the world. Ireland is not only an unknown quantity in a neutral form, but in a negative form. We have a definitely anti-Irish Press, particularly in the greatest news distribution centre in the world, namely, London; and we have recognised the fact that for the sake of our commercial relations, and for the sake of our general good name in the world, we do require not to be misled. Every country has such a Department, but other countries have an advantage that we have not got, and it is this; that the Press of other countries is usually supplied with a certain number of representatives in foreign countries; and the usual system is that the foreign representatives of newspapers who are away from their own country usually get in touch with the political representation in that country, and those journalists act as a channel for information and for correct information concerning their own country in the foreign countries in which they are living. Our Irish Press does not indulge in such a foreign news service. I think it has to be generally recognised that our Irish Press depends almost to an exclusive degree upon the London News Agencies. Therefore it is necessary to maintain this Department, for some time to come at any rate.

"In the early days of our existence this Department had another activity, namely, what you may call pro-State propaganda in this country. That was a very difficult situation to be faced with, because there was always the question as to whether the information which we put out could be considered as pro-State, or whether it might not be regarded as pro any one shade of opinion in the country. As far as I was concerned, I endeavoured, when we were doing such work, to confine the activities of that Department to the narrowest limits of pro-State propaganda; but I admit that there was very often considerable doubt as to where the pro-State began or ended and where the pro-Party began. Apart from that there are certain forms of advertisement which every Government has to indulge in. For instance, during the last year we had to advertise the National Loan. The publicity work of that was done by this Department. We had also to conduct a certain amount of publicity work for recruitment for the Army."

I have given the whole of the statement with reference to the Publicity Department, and Deputies will find it in columns 799-800, Vol. 8 of the Debates. Anybody who has listened to that statement must find it difficult to understand the statement made just recently and that made on Friday by Deputy Fitzgerald. As I say, he knew that in every country of the world there is such a Department and he knew full well how necessary such a Department was. It was peace time at that time. The need for the early pro-State propaganda that was referred to apparently had disappeared. With that knowledge he comes here and tries, I suggest, to mislead not merely the members of the House, but the public as to the situation. This Department is a necessary Department. Every word that was used by Deputy Fitzgerald when he was Minister with reference to the need of it I subscribe to and say it is a fact from my experience. This nation of ours is being assailed at the present time from outside and we are trying, in the face of outside attack to change our whole economic life. To do that, without the nation suffering more than is absolutely necessary, we require the co-operation of our people. We require that they should understand why certain things are done and that they should get the fullest possible information about the activities of the various Departments in order to save them from being misled by such misrepresentation of these activities as is constantly being put before them.

I am not going to go into the side issues that have been raised in this debate. I feel that if I did I would be as guilty as those who abused the privileges of the House by raising these matters in the manner in which they did. Every one of those points can be met in their appropriate place. There , however, I think in all fairness one thing to which I should refer and that is another statement made by Deputy Fitzgerald. He suggested in that of his of just giving half-truths, that in establishing this Department I was continuing something I had in mind back a long period and that I was about to bring into the office some agent or other who had served my purpose in the past. He read an extract from a letter which appears in this paper presented to Dáil Eireann entitled: "Correspondence from Eamon de Valera and others." He quoted this paragraph of a letter dated 7th September. I admit I wrote it.

The letter says:

"I would like to see Seán O'Keeffe for a Press interview. If you get in touch with him I will see how it can be arranged. Ask him to send me along leading questions."

There was some suggestion in Deputy Fitzgerald's remarks that this journalist who was referred to here was somehow an agent of propaganda for me. The director of that Bureau, Mr. Seán O'Keeffe, is a journalist who is known throughout this country and far beyond it. There is nobody in that profession who will deny for a moment that he is a journalist of ability and repute, and he has never at any time lent himself to anything which would bring discredit either upon himself or upon the country. As a journalist at the time, like many other journalists, he tried, on the inspiration of the newspaper for which he was correspondent, to get an interview from me. The newspaper in question was the Manchester Evening News. I have here the interview and I am willing that both he and I should be judged on that interview and I am prepared to put it in comparison with anything that emanated from the Department when it was controlled by Deputy Fitzgerald. I think that it is only right, when there have been suggestions of misuse of that Department attributed in advance to us, that I should read this interview.

Comment on this

I hesitate very much to interrupt the President, but I do submit that what he proposes to do is going far beyond the proper bounds of this debate.

Comment on this

You do not like to hear it.

Comment on this

The reference of Deputy Fitzgerald which I heard was a very transitory one and I personally did not draw the inference from it that the President says he drew. Whatever inference he drew from that transitory reference, I suggest that to read out the whole newspaper interview would be entirely irrelevant to what we are now discussing.

Comment on this

It was a very malicious reference.

Comment on this

I propose to read the interview because I think it is the best answer that can be given to the suggestion that either the officer who has been appointed—he has been appointed, because I believe that no better person could be appointed and he is now a civil servant and the suggestion that he could be anything else of course is absurd——

Comment on this

I would like to say this, and I believe I can speak for Deputy Fitzgerald as well, that there is no desire on these Benches to cast any reflection on the character of Mr. O'Keeffe.

Comment on this

I think Deputy MacDermot should confine himself to standing over his own views. I will say to him that it is a very dangerous thing to stand over anything Deputy Fitzgerald may suggest. As regards the expression "leading questions," everybody who has been interviewed by Press representatives will understand what it means. I am sure members on the opposite Benches have been interviewed many a time. These newspaper representatives come to them wishing to get information on certain points and views on certain points and there are leading questions. In fact, the words were in quotation marks and leading questions meant questions suggesting particular topics and, if you like, even the answers to these particular topics might come along. This is the interview in question——

Comment on this

I respectfully suggest that this is irrelevant and if you feel there is a difficulty about judging whether it is relevant or not I suggest that the President would read the remark made by Deputy Fitzgerald which he says justifies it. It is in the report, I think, and I believe it will appear that there is nothing in that report to justify the reading out of the interview.

Comment on this

Will we be able to comment upon it as a sample of the propaganda that will be indulged in now at the public expense?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot give a decision in advance and I do not propose to give a decision in advance, but I think that what the President proposes to read is relevant inasmuch as it will indicate what the journalist, who, unfortunately, was referred to, and I think he should not have been referred to, and the President propose to utilise the Bureau for and how it will be utilised.

Comment on this

It is important that Deputies should remember the time. It was the 7th September, just before the Provisional Parliament met in 1922. The following is the text of the interview:—

"I asked if he could see any way out through a revision of the proposed Free State Constitution.

"I still maintain," he replied, "that the straight, bold course is the best. Those who try to be too clever end in over-reaching themselves. If you want to arrive at a constitution satisfactory to Irishmen, you must strain the Treaty out of the plain meaning of the terms. If the Treaty is so unsatisfactory that it must be strained, then go honestly about it and get a revision of the Treaty. It is the best for Ireland, and it is the best for England."

"But if England persists, under threat of war, in holding us to the Treaty, and if the majority of the Irish people choose to accept the Treaty rather than the alternative— war?

"If that should prove true, then I can only say that, in my opinion, both Ireland and England are making a terrible mistake and will suffer for it."

"For Ireland, the Treaty will mean violent political agitation and turmoil in one form or another for many years to come. Agitation that will make progress in a cultural or spiritual direction impossible, and progress in a material way more impossible.

"For England, it will mean a continuance of those impossible relations which resulted in the war of the last few years. An arrangement dictated under threat of war can never be the basis of anything but suspicion and distrust between the two nations, and an everlasting jockeying and intrigue—one against the other.

"Last December was the time to put the relations between the two countries on a stable basis. The opportunity was lost then. It is incomparably more difficult to secure that basis now, but it is not impossible if men of goodwill will set themselves to the task. For England a treaty entered into by Irishmen with goodwill would be of more value and give her more real security than all the guarantees she may be able to extract from an unwilling people by force. For Ireland it would mean internal peace and an opportunity to get on with the work of national regeneration and national reconstruction, for which all the best in Ireland is yearning.

"The trouble has been that in the last Dáil there was little attempt to discuss the Treaty on its merits as an effort of statesmanship, or to calculate its bearings on the future. Side issues of a personal and Party character were introduced to obscure the main consideration. The best case made for the Treaty, from the statesman's standpoint, was that made in the letter which General Smuts wrote to me, as President, about a year ago.

"If anything could have converted me to acceptance of the Treaty, that letter would. Without hesitation, a united Cabinet, however, rejected his recommendations. The change that took place in the minds of some members of the Cabinet between August and December can be judged from this fact alone. For Mr. Griffith, as for me, the securing of a united Ireland—a single State—was of first importance. To follow the lines suggested by General Smuts meant that we should first abandon our own proved impregnable position and face the certainty of disruption in our hitherto solid ranks, without any reasonable hope that the objective for which the risks were taken would be reached. Unfortunately Mr. Griffith was later led away by the chimera of the Boundary Commission which he had hoped would take Fermanagh, Tyrone and other areas from the Northern territory and so bring partition to end later, automatically.

"What might have been anticipated happened however. (This is the 1st September, 1922). At the first protest from Ulster the English politicians ran away from their pledges given in private and betrayed the Nationalist Irishmen that trusted them. These were too much committed by their previous action and could no longer make an effective resistance to the betrayal.

"The Ulster question is an Irish domestic question and must be settled in Ireland by the representatives of the people concerned. The problem is so to fix the framework of the relations between Ireland as a whole and England as to provide for the desired settlement between the north and the south being effected within it. To satisfy the sentiment of the south the sovereignty of the nation as a whole must be safe-guarded. To satisfy the sentiment of the north, at the moment, some connection with the British Empire has to be provided for. It happens that the condition imposed by the latter largely meets the material demands of the English as well. The proposal for External Association was, therefore, not a personal whim, but is the solution rigidly imposed by the fundamental political facts, at the moment, unless force or coercion is to be used against the north or against the south.

"The Treaty means the coercion of the south and the coercion of a large part of the north—both. The propertied classes, the manufacturers, the traders, if they were wise, would have opposed this peace by coercion for their interests suffer by the instability of any such dictated peace. The war on the south has wasted, in a futile attempt to destroy an aspiration that has outlasted the attempts of seven centuries, money and wealth that would have provided for the social and economic needs of all sections of the community, and made the people prosperous and happy. No one gains by this war—all lose by it. If the millions spent in the European War had been devoted to provide for the social wants—what a different world we would have to-day."

This was the interview that was supposed to paint me as a vile propagandist and was supposed to paint the officer who is appointed as director of that Bureau as capable of this vile propaganda. This was published in England. I have read it at length for the House because it does show that whenever there was a question between this country and Britain and my views at any rate were asked upon it, I did my best to inform the public who were to read it what were the principal facts of the situation.

Comment on this

From behind a wall of glass, a fortnight after Collins's death.

Comment on this

These were the facts of the situation—the facts of the situation as the Deputy knows they are.

Comment on this

From behind a wall of glass.

Comment on this

Talk about a wall of glass! It proved again what my attitude was, namely, that I could not prevent this thing which at this particular time I indicated was the danger. However, I am not going to go into that. I am not going to get back into any further discussion of the past. I simply gave this. I am willing to be judged on it, on this terrible piece of propaganda that was suggested as showing my powers as a propagandist by Deputy Fitzgerald. In principle then I disagree with Deputy MacDermot. I think my experience is that it is an essential part of State machinery, essential at the present time when we want the public to know the truth, to know the facts, and when we want the public to co-operate with us. This so-called immoral doctrine that has been suggested was used by Deputy Lemass is a statement of fact—that an Executive has been chosen by the people to lead them in a certain work and in order that the people may understand that they are being led in that particular work of reconstruction, they want to be able to co-operate by having the facts put to them. Every Department needs it and this Department, therefore, can with more economy as Deputy Fitzgerald says now that it has been centralised, secure this information so that it can be available for those who seek it and for the people as a whole. There is another matter to which I should refer. On every occasion the members on the opposite side tried to damage as much as they can the Irish Press. We know why. There is one suggestion which was made, and which is a false suggestion. I do not want to call it any stronger name. That is that the Irish Press has been subsidised by State moneys. That is a falsehood.

Comment on this

A demonstrable falsehood—not to Deputy McGilligan, of course, because there is none so blind as those who will not see.

Comment on this

That is a glass house story, at any rate.

Comment on this

None so blind as those who do not want to see. The capital of the Irish Press was subscribed by this country—10,000 shareholders in it—and by friends of Ireland in the United States. It is they who subscribed the capital. If the people who subscribed the money in the United States, and got Irish Press bonds for it, care to use those bonds or did care to use those bonds to subsidise the Irish Press, that is their business. That is their subsidising, and not the subsidising of the State, no matter how some people may twist it.

Comment on this

Even if the promise was got beforehand?

Comment on this

It has nothing to do with the State. The State owed that money to those American citizens. They subscribed that money and it was their money that went into the Irish Press and not any State money.

Comment on this

But not via them.

Comment on this

It was their deliberate will to put it into the Irish Press, and I say again that it is a deliberate falsehood, worthy of those who make it, to suggest that the Irish Press is subsidised from State funds. Still more contemptible is the original suggestion that I was subsidising myself, and putting State moneys into my pocket. I want every Deputy here and I want the country to realise what the real situation is. The capital of the Irish Press was subscribed by Irish people in cash and by American people partly in cash and partly in the bonds which they assigned for that purpose. It is their money then that is in the Irish Press and to suggest that this State is subsidising the Irish Press is just as untrue as it would have been to say that the United States Government was subsidising us when those same American citizens, when I was over there in 1919 and 1921, made available for our fight here American liberty bonds. I got American liberty bonds from American citizens. The capital values of them were redeemed by the Treasury of the United States. Could it be said that the Treasury of the United States was subsidising us? It was a friendly Government to England. Could it be said that because I got American liberty bonds from American citizens the American Treasury was subsidising us? Of course the American Treasury did not subsidise us. Individual American citizens put their bonds to the purpose they were entitled to put them to. They gave me those bonds and it would be as wrong for this State—more wrong for this State —to refuse to pay the moneys on those bonds to the Irish Press, when they had been assigned for that purpose, as it would have been for the United States Treasury to refuse to give the money on those bonds to me as trustee at that time, simply because I was doing something which, perhaps, the American Government did not want in any way to be associated with. I say, therefore, that there is no subsidising of the Irish Press.

As regards the Irish Press being a Party organ there is the usual quibble. What I said was that it was not a Party organ in the sense that it was not under a Party or capable of being controlled by a Party. The Irish Press is a newspaper owned by the subscribers—owned by the shareholders. I was, when I was a member of the directorate, Controlling Director of Policy. That was one of the articles of association. But the Party as a Party could not control it, and there is no control of that paper by the Party. It was founded with a definite policy and a definite purpose, and it has been constant to that policy and to that purpose. I know that the Deputies on the opposite benches dislike that very much, but they will have to put up with it. There is nothing else I feel called upon to comment upon. The question of the annuities was brought in, and there was a suggestion that I would put forward our view with regard to the annuities. The members of the opposite benches when they were a Government used State moneys to give their side of the case——

Comment on this
A Deputy

And England's side of it.

Comment on this

——and it was an imperfect statement of it. I have not got a copy, so I can only venture to give my recollection of the words. So incomplete was it that the very basis of the British claims was dismissed. First of all the fundamental document was not referred to. It was not published, and when Mr. Thomas referred to it as the fundamental document was the first time we got it as a whole. We had to go and search for it in the Departments. He said—I am not giving the exact words, but only their meaning as well as I can recollect it— that this particular original statement was confirmed by documents some time later. That second document was referred to. It was referred to in this particular pamphlet which was brought out. It was sent out at State expense. Lawyers were fed at State expense to give the case. This confirmatory document was dismissed by saying that it had practically nothing to do with it —that it had reference to another much smaller and simpler matter, namely the question of income tax. It is from people who know that such a department existed, from people who have abused it, as I have said, and from people who have used it to give this particular thing here with regard to the annuities, that we have objections raised to our having this Department. I suggest that their own knowledge of how they abused it in their own time is the prime moving purpose in their objections now. That may be valid. It may be valid in the sense that the fact that they did misuse it proves at any rate that it can be misused. I have admitted that. As I have said, so can practically every other Department of State, if there are people there who have the will and the dishonesty to abuse it. As a necessary department, just as other departments are necessary, I recommend it to you.

Those are the actual words in which the second document was referred to: "Those clauses accordingly" that is the ones having reference to the annuities, "represent nothing more than a statement of the dispute as to the right to make income tax deductions." There is somewhere else this other phrase that I have referred to —that it has nothing whatever to do with it.

Comment on this

The whole thing is very clear!

Comment on this

The whole thing is quite clear.

Comment on this

Your statement is extremely lucid.

Comment on this

If the House bears with me, we will explain. We might try and let this blind person who does not want to see, see a little bit of the light.

Comment on this

Have an adjournment and get it afterwards.

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for Defence (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

Take your time now, sonny.

Comment on this

"The above clauses one and two of the Heads of Ultimate Financial Settlement have no relation to, nor are they any authority, for such payment." That is more explicit than my words, "They had nothing to do with it."

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I will repeat it for the Deputy. "The above clauses one and two"—that is referring to the annuities—"of the Heads of Ultimate Financial Settlement have no relation to, nor are they any authority, for such payment." That is what is stated in this—this case that probably cost a good part of £1,000 to get out, published by the Government of the day and published, what is more, in anticipation of a general election. This was such an accurate case for it, such an accurate statement of the case, and was so thoroughly honest, that when we come to get from Mr. Thomas the basis of his claim, the very opinion which they dismiss in these words which I have read for you was made the basis of his claim.

Comment on this

Rubbish—entire rubbish !

Comment on this

I have nothing more to say.

Comment on this

I am rising only for a moment. A reference was made by Deputy Fitzgerald to the past relations of the President and Mr. O'Keeffe as follows:—

"On 7th September, 1922, the President wrote: ‘I would like to see S. O'Keeffe for a Press interview. If you get in touch with him I will see how it can be arranged. Ask him to send me along leading questions.'"

Then, Deputy Fitzgerald comments:

"It looks as if the unfortunate people of this country are being asked now to give some unnamed amount—but more than £1,000 a year —to provide the President with somebody near-by whom he can have to ask him leading questions all the time."

In view of what Deputy Fitzgerald's remark amounted to, I put it to the House whether the reading aloud of that long interview is not something of a character that debars the President from accusing anybody else of misusing the privileges of this House. He made a statement a moment ago on the subject of the Irish Press. I am a steady reader of the Irish Press.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Do you buy it?

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, I always find that reading a newspaper of opposite political opinions to one's own serves better than anything else to confirm one's own political opinions. I listened, however, with astonishment to the President's statement that that organ is absolutely independent as regards its conduct of policy because if that be so, it appears to me a most extraordinary coincidence that never once have I seen in its columns the slightest reflection on the wisdom of the Fianna Fáil Government in anything, great or small, since it came into office. It appears to me that if a newspaper has swallowed as completely as that newspaper has done, the doctrine of the infallibility of a particular Government on all occasions, it is a misuse of words to call it an independent organ of opinion.

The interview which the President read to us was interesting, and, from a purely selfish and personal point of view, I am not sorry to have heard it. It gives me the opportunity of making this remark to him. Great objections can be urged, both from the Irish point of view and from the English point of view, to the Treaty and could have been urged at the time but I suggest to him that whatever objections there were to the Treaty fade into insignificance beside the objections there were to proceeding with his plan of seeking something called "external association." I suggest to him that the notion adumbrated in that interview, that external association was something which would have satisfied the sentiment of Northern Ireland, is utterly absurd and that there was no hope whatever of settling Irish affairs on the basis of that idea of external association at that time. I dare say many of us had alternatives in our minds as preferable to the Treaty. I myself had. I would have much preferred to see a system inaugurated of Dominion Home Rule here in Ireland for a period of years, with the understanding that after that period had expired, we should have a free vote on whether we should stay in the Commonwealth or go out of it.

What, however, is the good of going into all these old matters now? I suggest to him that a very useful thing which the new Press Bureau might do for him would be to keep him thoroughly informed as to what is taking place in South Africa. He mentioned the name of General Smuts, and it is worth while recording how completely General Smuts's policy in his own country has been justified by events and how General Hertzog, who, a few years ago, corresponded to President de Valera, has now come round to General Smuts's point of view, and how Mr. Malan, who, perhaps, might be said to correspond to Mr. George Gilmore or some other extreme Republican leader, has also come round nine-tenths of the way, and how the affairs of South Africa are now in a happier state on the constitutional side than they have been since the Boer War. For heaven's sake, let the Press Bureau inform the President and the country about things like that, that have a real lesson for ourselves. Instead of running after will o' the wisps, let the Press Bureau induce the President's followers to grasp the fact that it is the reality of independence that matters.

Comment on this

Might I ask Deputy MacDermot one question before he concludes? In the course of his remarks he said that reading newspapers representing political points of view different from those expressed by his own Party only confirmed him in his sense of the righteousness of his own Party——

Comment on this

I said nothing about my Party.

Comment on this

The Deputy said that reading newspapers representing different points of view from his own only confirmed him in his own point of view. Would the Deputy tell the House, if that is so, what is he doing on his present bench?

Mr. Rice and Mr. Anthony rose.

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for Defence (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

This debate has gone on for two days and many Deputies have spoken a couple of times. I think it is time it came to an end and I move that the question be now put.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am accepting the motion that the question be now put.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

I thought the Chair had called on me.

Comment on this

You have taken about three days at it already.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the question be now put."

Tá 71
·
Níl 49
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Division

Main Question put.

Tá 68
·
Níl 49
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?