We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Wearing of Uniform (Restriction) Bill, 1934—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–163 of 469. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Wearing of Uniform (Restriction) Bill, 1934
Defeated

No. 13 of 1934 ›

Thomas Derrig Minister for Education (Mr. Derrig) Fianna Fáil

We read in the newspapers this morning that an important concession had been made by the Director-General of the League of Youth towards the betterment of conditions, and particularly the preservation of order in this country. An order has been issued countermanding a previous order that supporters of the Blueshirt organisation should get their children to wear blue shirts or blue blouses or other blue insignia in schools. I wonder why the Party opposite did not consider, before the original order was issued, what the effects of it were likely to be. I wonder also why it is, if the Party opposite are so greatly interested in democratic rule as they pretend to be, that it has to be left to the Director-General of the League of Youth organisation outside this House to determine when, where, and how steps are to be taken to ease whatever difficult situations we have.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say when the original order was issued or if he has any information?

Comment on this

The Deputy will get an opportunity of making his speech. If he will consult the statements made by a very prominent member of that organisation in West Cork he will be able to judge for himself whether orders were issued or not.

Comment on this

Deputy Hogan approved of it yesterday.

Comment on this

Then the Minister has no information.

Comment on this

I can only hope that this concession will extend to other matters and in other directions: that it will be recognised that, while Party advantage may accrue from certain manifestations that have taken place in the country recently, certain expressions of feeling and certain operations, that ultimately there is a loss to somebody. I question very much whether the Opposition Party are not going to lose quite as much as the Government on this matter. In any case one thing is certain: it is that the country as a whole is going to lose.

I have stated outside this House that, in addition to the campaign in respect of which orders were issued for the wearing of uniforms and badges in the schools, other very serious manifestations of this Blueshirt spirit are making themselves felt in certain areas of the country. There is, we know definitely, a campaign not to pay rates or annuities. In certain parts of this country labourers have been compelled by their employers to wear blue shirts, and if they refused to do so they lost their employment. In certain parts of this country business people in the towns and Fianna Fáil farmers at the fairs have been boycotted. When they stood with their cattle on the fair greens they were passed by because they were supporters of the present Government.

Comment on this

Who passed them by?

Comment on this

The buyers who supported the Deputy in South Tipperary. All these manifestations, which have accompanied the spread of this movement, undoubtedly tend to disturb public feeling and to create breaches of the peace, and if there was no reason whatever, except that these things have happened, I think the Government would have been sufficiently justified in introducing this Bill and trying to get it passed into law.

We are told in the newspapers this morning, in connection with this concession that has been granted, that the League of Youth propose to stand for their essential rights. Now are the essential rights of the League of Youth the same as the essential rights of the Parliamentary Opposition in this House, and what are these essential rights that the Opposition are striving for and that they say are being jeopardised by this Bill? That is the whole problem. That is what Government spokesmen have sought to find out in this debate. They have asked a number of questions to endeavour to elucidate that position and they have got no answers. In the first place, it is suggested that all the members of this organisation, with its Director-General issuing orders and countermanding them outside this House, with or without reference to his Parliamentary colleagues inside this House, are a perfectly harmless body of men—as harmless as Deputy Dillon. I should like to believe that, but I am afraid that Deputy Dillon finds himself in the position, although he will not admit it, that he has been rather misled in this matter. His statement yesterday, that he is very well pleased with his new colleagues and with his new situation, will not, I think, deceive anybody. We have seen cases recently at the Military Tribunal; they may have been exceptional cases; they may have been unusual cases; they may have been cases out of which it would not be proper for me to build a case against the Blueshirt organisation; but in any case, I submit to the House that these cases which have recently been heard in respect of members of the Blueshirt organisation in Limerick and in Leix, showed clearly that some members, at any rate, of that organisation are either in possession of arms or are carrying on a traffic in arms.

The Opposition must find themselves in a difficult position on this Bill. Which attitude are they going to take up? Are they going to take up the attitude that they are going to persist with this organisation even if this Bill finds its way to the Statute Book; or are they going to take up the position, which one would imagine they would have been driven to by a realisation of the facts that are staring them in the face, that the leadership of that organisation and the whole organisation itself should be on a proper democratic basis, and that there should not be the slightest tittle of doubt as to where they stand with regard to the democratic institutions they claim to have set up in this country—not alone to have set up, but for ten years to have carried on very effectively, as they say, and to have handed over to their successors in complete order?

Now this official Opposition in this House cannot claim that the events which have taken place recently in Europe, or the events which have taken place in this country, the incidents and occurrences that have accompanied the spread of the Blueshirt organisation, came to them unforeseen; that they did not anticipate this development, because I find that when the Constitution (Amendment) Act was introduced into this House, it was quite clearly foreseen, and it was explained to the House by both President Cosgrave and the then Minister for Finance, Mr. Blythe, that such an organisation as was growing up on the Continent of Europe might ultimately grow up here and that if steps were not taken to prevent that— some such steps as they were taking under that Act—such steps would have to be taken later on when conditions, probably, would have become very much worse. In fact, Deputy Blythe said at that time that even if the national unity which the present Minister for Defence spoke of, and which he suggested might be brought about, could be achieved, it was no safeguard whatsoever that in a few years time we would not have to deal with precisely the same conditions as those which were developing on the Continent and elsewhere. Deputy Blythe, the then Minister for Finance, column 352, volume 40, of the Official Debates, said:

"There is no use in failing to recognise the facts in the world to-day. There is no use in blinking the fact that there is a new sort of anti-democratic theory, a new teaching of a policy of a minority seizing power.

Mr. Derrig: Your policy.

Mr. Blythe: That policy is all through the world. I believe that as things are going in Europe and throughout the world even Governments and States that have had no cause, for a long time, to fear armed movements or violent attacks on the majority are liable now, and will be liable in the future, to fear them."

Speaking on the same occasion, Deputy Cosgrave said:

"A State based on parliamentary institutions requires, for its proper functioning, not merely the goodwill but the positive allegiance of all its citizens."

I should like to ask whether the Parliamentary Opposition, in their conduct in this country during the past few years, have based their policy and have worked towards an objective that had these considerations in mind; in the first place, that democratic government in many parts of Europe was threatened and might very easily be threatened here; and, in the second place, that if democratic government is to continue, it is not alone necessary that the citizens should be peaceful and law-abiding, but that they should be active in their co-operation with, and support of, that government. The example, I suggest, Sir, should come from the Party opposite, who have talked a good deal in past years about the will of the people and the supremacy of the people's Parliament.

The Minister for Justice pointed out yesterday that the Director-General of the League of Youth had quite different ideas with regard to this matter of semi-military organisations when he was Commissioner of the Gárda Síochána. The Minister pointed out that, not alone had General O'Duffy seen fit to call special attention to the British Fascist Party— a small Party of a dozen or a few dozen individuals in black shirts—but that he actually called special attention to the demonstration of the British Legion on the occasion of Armistice Day, and pointed out that if that parade were allowed to take place—marching in fours, words of command, and so on— and having regard to the general circumstances of the parade, it might give rise to serious disorder. If that was the contention of General O'Duffy on that occasion with regard to the parade of that body for that particular purpose that we know they have in mind, how can the Opposition get up here to-day and suggest that this Government, or the present Commissioner of the Gárda Síochána, should permit to continue marchings, mobilisations, assemblies, and travellings all over the country in lorries, of blue-shirted men, to the tune of several hundreds, to each one of their several demonstrations? How can they suggest that that state of affairs should be allowed to continue and to go on, not for one day in the year, but for every day? It was with a view to stopping the demonstration planned for the City of Dublin last August that we took action, because we believed that that demonstration would certainly lead to most serious disorder, if not to bloodshed; and we stopped it, on advice given to us, by the most effective means at our disposal.

Deputies opposite, I think, will have some trouble in showing their consistency in demanding to-day that they should be entitled—because, remember this: the demand, although nobody has voiced it, is there implicit, if not in this House, at least outside in the country wherever the Director-General makes a statement—that one political Party in this country should be allowed to set up a private force of a semi-military character, drilled, disciplined, marching under orders, wearing uniform or semi-uniform, and carrying weapons. That is the claim that is made. That is the implicit demand, but nobody on the opposite side of the House has the courage to say that that is the policy. The House would like to be quite clear, and the Government would like to be quite clear, in view of the responsibility that they feel upon them in this situation, as to what is the attitude of the Opposition and what is their real attitude in regard to that demand, which, I think, I have stated in very plain and very clear terms.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce, speaking yesterday, put some very pertinent questions. No reply has been given to them and I should like to repeat the questions. If we are to permit an organisation of that character—a private army, as it has been called, attached to a particular Party—to parade in uniform or semi-uniform, to carry weapons and to purport to take upon themselves the duties of the police, where is it going to stop? On what ground can the right to do the same be denied to other political Parties or other groups? On what ground is the old I.R.A. to be denied the right to come along with green shirts or the Communists to be denied the right to come along with red shirts or some other group or political Party to appear in similar guise and to do the same kind of thing that is being done in the streets of our towns at present?

Comment on this

Has your Government attempted to stop them?

Comment on this

Deputy Anthony has already spoken and I hope he will allow me to continue. Even if that question be disposed of, the question arises, why other movements and other organisations should not be allowed the same facilities. To what extent is the present organisation going to be permitted to continue to usurp the functions of the forces of the State? The Opposition talk very loudly of their allegiance to democratic government and their submissiveness to the institutions of the State, but do they seriously contend that this organisation ought to be allowed to go on and extend its powers until, in due course, it would take the protection of this House and the protection of the Government into its private keeping? According to Deputy Costello, this is the first occasion on which a political Party has been definitely mentioned in connection with a ban on uniforms in any country. I question whether in every case in which a ban on uniforms has taken place that ban has not been made against particular political groups or political parties.

Another argument we have heard is: "We are either illegal or we are legal. If we are illegal, why do you not proceed against us? If we are legal, why do you not allow us to continue?" Deputies know very well that Parliaments and Governments have had to deal with matters—I am not referring to political matters solely—which nobody foresaw ten or 15 years ago. New movements have sprung up and new circumstances have arisen. There has been a great change. These circumstances could not have been foreseen when Saorstát Eireann was set up. For instance, the ban on emblems worn by school children was taken out of the rules. Up to that time, the display of religious emblems was forbidden by the old National Board. It was thought —and rightly thought—that it was a proof of our new-found liberty and independence that the religious emblems of the majority of the Irish people could be freely and openly shown in the schools. The rule regarding emblems was, therefore, removed. Can anybody have the slightest doubt that if President de Valera or Mr. Peadar O'Donnell or anybody else who did not happen to have the same political creed as the gentlemen opposite set out to organise a movement having a distinctive type of shirt, going round protecting, mar eadh, their meetings, marching and parading under commands, mobilising and going to different parts of the country in motor lorries, and having the full paraphernalia of a private army—does anybody suggest that the late Government would have allowed that situation to exist for 24 hours? Were the late Government terribly worried about these constitutional points and points of law or the desire that everything should be legal? The Attorney-General gave some striking examples yesterday and I should like to refer to some of the statements made with regard to this question of the Government and the Constitution when the Constitution (Amendment) Bill—we all know its drastic character and its far-reaching powers—was going through this House.

Mr. Blythe then said:

"There is no use in talking about the Constitution in the way in which it has been spoken about in connection with this matter. The thing that is necessary when you are dealing with a conspiracy of this sort is to give the Executive the powers to deal with it. There is absolutely no other way of protecting the ordinary citizen. It is only by the weapons that the Executive Council has in its hands that the ordinary citizen can be protected."

Deputy Fitzgerald said:

"Deputy O'Connell talked about this Constitution of which we were so proud, this democratic institution, and so on. I think, so far as I can judge from the feeling of the House to-day, there does not really seem to be any divergence of principle between any of us who have spoken, but I think there is a tendency to stress what I might call non-essentials and to overlook essentials. Why have we a Constitution at all? Why have we a Government? Why have we a State? If the Constitution is going to interfere with the State performing the functions it exists to perform, obviously there is nothing in the Constitution to be proud about. If the State fails to perform the functions it was intended to perform, then we had better have something instead."

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

We are now, perhaps, getting the "something instead." Another aspect of this matter I should like to refer to is the unfortunate attitude the Opposition have taken up. They cannot rid themselves of the idea that in some way they are still responsible for the Government of this country, that we are here by their toleration, that we are only, as one might say, the Fianna Fáil Party in office, that we are not the Government, that they were the Government, of divine right, and that the present Government is to be the object of insult by every corner-boy in the country. Yesterday evening, we had Deputy Hogan making a most disgraceful speech. He talked about cheapjacks, but I should like to know what cheap-jack selling clothes at a country fair could have sunk to the level Deputy Hogan sank to and has tried to bring this House down to. I read an article this morning in the Irish Times telling us the depths of moral degradation we have suffered. A few months ago the Irish Times told us, because of a report that was not published—for very good reasons—either by this Government or by its predecessors——

Comment on this

They were right in what they said.

Comment on this

Because of that, the Irish Times thought fit to say that some abominable position had arisen in regard to public morality in this country. I should like to tell the Irish Times that the time has not yet come when the Irish people will take their standards of morality—public or private—from the old ascendancy gang. The Irish Times, like the Daily Express——

Comment on this

You are ashamed of it.

Comment on this

——and every other English newspaper will take their cue from what the Opposition are saying inside and outside this House. Yesterday Deputy Hogan asked a question: "Are the Irish fir for self-Government?" He put it in this way: "We are fit for self-Government, but you are not." But the Irish Times says, can anybody say that the Irish are fit for self-Government——

Comment on this

On a point of order. Did not a Deputy opposite compare this place to a circus? Deputy Corry called it a circus.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not a point of order. The Deputy must resume his seat.

Comment on this

One of the Minister's own followers——(Deputies: Order! Order! Sit down.)——compared this House to a circus.

Comment on this
A Deputy

And now we have the clown.

Comment on this

Yes, and the baboon on the other side, the lowest type of mammal.

Comment on this

When the Constitution Bill was under discussion, in the House, Deputy Cosgrave referred, and I have no doubt he had a good deal of sympathy from those who differed with him, to the efforts that had been made to poison the minds of the people against their representatives. Is there anybody in this House, or outside it, who has suffered more from attempts to poison the minds of the people against him in public and in private than President de Valera? Even to-day they are not content. What are those people who talked some years ago, so glibly, about democratic rule and the necessity of maintaining the supremacy of the people doing to-day? They are bullying and threatening the Guards, telling them that if they are not very careful they will not remain long in the force. They refer to the men taken into the Guards as the "Broy Harriers." Of course there is nothing about the Blueshirts: they are such quiet boys, and respectable young men. These recruits are men of character who did much for this country. But the men are abused and ridiculed by people who were not to be found when work had to be done. We have examples like the statements about "de Valera's bombers" statement at meetings in Cork, and elsewhere, that the Government of this country is deliberately bringing about a situation, reducing the people to utter economic helplessness, and trying to bring about such an economic collapse was never was known before, and so on. Is that reasonable or fair? Is that the type of fair play Deputy Hogan and others have in mind when they ask for fair play all around? Let us, by all means, have fair play all around. Let those who have experience, and who know the difficulties of the situation, give a good example to their followers and I assure them that matters will very quickly right themselves.

Deputy Dillon referred to the question of public meetings. Everybody knows that even when there were 15,000 persons connected in one way or another with this particular Party in jail, men like Deputy Hogan were not allowed a peaceful hearing in the country. But the reason was obvious. Any decent respectable citizen objects at times to things stated on platforms and when these things are flagrantly untrue disturbances occur, created by those on the platforms who are in my opinion often primarily responsible——

Comment on this

How says the Minister for Justice now?

Comment on this

Let me remind Deputies opposite that on a famous occasion, when Deputy Hogan was speaking in Ballaghaderreen, when Deputy Dillon, who talked here about public meetings, was put up in court and was cross-examined he had the same views about both wings of the Sinn Fein Party at that time—he was asked was the meeting an orderly meeting, and he said it was an orderly meeting so far as Sinn Fein meetings go. Everybody knows that it was anything but an orderly meeting; that there was a baton charge even into Deputy Dillon's own yard, much to the pleasure of Deputy Dillon. On the 27th April, 1932, I think it was, Deputy Dillon announced in this House his great and profound pleasure at the fact that the President and the ex-President, who in former times were united together against England, were now divided and were attacking each other. This is something like what he said on that occasion: "I am glad they have changed a little and attacked one another, and I must say, God forgive me for it, it sometimes gives me great satisfaction to see them at it." I am sorry to say the Deputy has disimproved in his new situation. Perhaps it is from the fact that he is growing militarist in his old age. He is getting obstreperous. Most of us have passed that stage, but apparently the Deputy is only now entering upon it, and due allowance has to be made for him. When the Deputy tells us that his Party "wiped the square of Macroom with their opponents," I would inform him that in that particular area there were several hundred men in arms at the worst period of the Black and Tan struggle, and that those men who have handled arms—no matter what Party their opponents belonged to—would not be put upon unduly and would retaliate, and we have had reprisals in this area, and when the Deputy says that his Party "wiped the square of Macroom with their opponents," he must remember the Government may have had a little "cleaning-up" to do afterwards. And this is the unfortunate position that has arisen in many cases where Deputies have instructed or allowed their followers to wipe the public squares with their political opponents. "We don't want to fight, but by jingo if we do." What a sad change for Deputy Dillon!

Now, in conclusion, I would like to ask whether the position really intended is, as we seem to gather from the statements of Deputy Costello and Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, to pursue this policy of organising and extending this force and allowing it to presume to take over the functions that belonged to the services of the State? If that position be allowed to continue, there can be no doubt whatever, as the Minister for Industry and Commerce pointed out yesterday—I need not go over the ground covered by him—that it can only have one result, that it will add fresh fuel to whatever feuds and political passions there are already. One body is not going to remain inactive while their opponents, with all their organisation, appear in public marching up and down the main streets of Irish towns under the protection of the forces of the State. People would be more than human if they allowed that.

Comment on this

Another incitement!

Comment on this

If there is any improvement in the situation in the past six months, let us be clear it is not because of this manifestation of strength, but because the Government took measures, and strong measures, under the machinery they brought into operation, to deal with the situation. A very large number of men have been sentenced to imprisonment. We do not want to go further than is absolutely necessary, but our opponents could make the situation very much easier for themselves in this country if they would do the right thing now. I appeal to them to consider the matter carefully, whether it is advisable for the sake of transient political advantages, even if such there be, to continue this policy. I doubt very much if the Irish people will ever be got to rally to a movement that has nothing Irish about it, that is taken holus-bolus from Continental movements that have had their origin in entirely different circumstances.

Comment on this

What about Sinn Féin? Where did Sinn Féin come from?

Comment on this

We have a small country; we have adequate representation for the people, an excellent system of representation. We have a system which gives every Party due and adequate representation in this House.

Comment on this

Sinn Féin came from Hungary. What about Kossuth?

Comment on this

If the Opposition are not content with that, and they really see something in the corporative system——

Comment on this

Sinn Féin was imported——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Anthony having persisted in interruption will withdraw from the House for the remainder of the day.

Comment on this

I merely said Sinn Féin had its birth in Hungary. All right, Sir. I am not sorry to be away from some of the hooligans here.

Deputy Anthony then withdrew.

Comment on this

If the Opposition really think there is anything in an Irish corporative State, let them bear in mind that the natural Party to advance towards that State is the Labour Party, and that Irish democracy is not going to stand by while a State is set up in this country on the abolition of trade unionism and on the destruction of the political rights of the plain people. They are certainly not going to allow that state of affairs to arise here. They are certainly not going to allow it when it is plain to the people that the way in which it is sought to bring about the change is by the development of this private army which, in due course and in due time, when it gets the opportunity, will not alone overawe the citizens, but will certainly overawe the Parliament of this country and the Government of this country, if it is able to do so.

Comment on this

The Minister for Education is greatly daring when he reminds us that the Government have imprisoned a number of people during the last few months, and gives this as an explanation of the fact that there are not more complaints to be made against the behaviour of the Blueshirts. He has evidently overlooked the circumstance that at least 80 per cent. of the people whom the Government has found it necessary to imprison, have been friends and followers of their own, and that of those Blueshirts who have been in prison, I think practically all have been imprisoned for no worse offence than for the mere fact of being Blueshirts, or wearing blue shirts.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

That is not so.

Comment on this

The vast majority.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

If the Deputy wants the figures I can give them to him. I should like to know where anybody has been charged with wearing a blue shirt?

Comment on this

You tried to make it an offence and made a fool of yourself in the High Court.

Comment on this

I am well aware that no legal charge of wearing a blue shirt has been preferred as it would not have been possible to charge them merely with wearing a blue shirt. All I say is that these men were, in fact, imprisoned when their only offence was that of wearing blue shirts.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Practically every one of them was charged with the possession of guns.

Comment on this

What about O'Duffy and J. L. O'Sullivan?

Comment on this

Will the Attorney-General say how many of them are in jail at the present moment for the possession of guns?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

How many Blueshirts?

Comment on this

Yes. I am putting the question and he can answer it later. Before I pass on to the main body of my remarks I want to refer to one or two remarks—

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

There were 14 imprisoned.

Comment on this

Out of 12? The Attorney-General said yesterday that there were only 12 Blueshirts in prison.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

There were one or two more yesterday.

Comment on this

Is that the full number?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I shall give the Deputy the names if he challenges my statement. I merely gave the numbers roughly yesterday.

Comment on this

At any rate whatever charges these men are imprisoned upon, it is a known fact that the vast majority of the persons imprisoned by the Government under the Public Safety Act have been, not Blueshirts, but the friends of the Government, however much the Government may have disliked to have to imprison them. The Minister for Education made allusion to the matter of children wearing blue shirts in school and he alleged that there had been an order that that was to be done. I should just like to mention in passing that I am authoritatively informed that no such order was issued.

Comment on this

It was advocated at public meetings.

Comment on this

I am not talking of what was advocated. I am talking of the Minister's statement that there was an order to that effect when, in fact, the wearing of blue shirts by children at school has been out of the abundance of their enthusiasm for a good cause and has not been due to any order. The Minister made allusion to the disgraceful behaviour of the Opposition in suggesting that there were any flaws in the character of the "Broy Harriers". He used the expression himself. I have no wish to make any reflection on that body——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The officers whom the Deputy styles "Broy Harriers" are officers of the Gárda Síochána and should be referred to as such. Deputies of all Parties must realise the result, the repercussions, of bestowing on servants of the State, or sections of such, nicknames calculated to bring them into ridicule or contempt.

Comment on this

I was merely repeating a phrase the Minister had used.

Comment on this

I did not use it. I was quoting the phrase as an example of what is being said by the Opposition. I do not agree with it, and I was not using it.

Comment on this

I was quoting it and replying to the Minister. I only want to say on that head that, while in no way casting any general reflection on the character of that force, it is, at the same time, legitimate to point out that men have been recruited to it who have failed to get characters from their parish priests. A statement was made here the other day that recruits had to get characters from the parish priests. The next day I received a letter from a parish priest in which he stated that he had refused a character to a man who had been recruited to the force.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Did you get one?

Comment on this

I beg your pardon? I merely make that statement in passing because the Minister for Education has been unfair in suggesting that the Opposition have unjustly criticised the manner in which that force was recruited.

I am prepared to admit to those who are not familiar with the condition of affairs in this country that there is a prima facie case for this Bill. I share the dislike which has been expressed by many people for manifestations and movements on the Continent. I have no desire, far from it, to see this country go the way of Germany, or of Austria, or even the way of Italy. I think that the world during many years past has seen too much soldiering and too much playing at soldiers. I do not think that, in itself, prohibition of political uniforms is an act of coercion or an unjustifiable invasion of the liberty of the individual. I admit all that. But we have got to deal with the situation as it is in Ireland, and we have got to consider this Bill, not in isolation, but in reference to all that has gone before it, and in reference to the condition of things which, it is alleged, it is designed to cure.

The Government contend that in bringing in this Bill they are championing democracy and parliamentarianism against militarism and Fascism. If I could accept that contention I would support the Bill. I was called upon to decide the attitude to be taken on this matter much sooner than this. This question with regard to Blueshirts has not arisen for us now. It arose for us some months ago when the new Party was formed and when we had to decide very carefully to consider what was our duty and what attitude we should take towards what is known as the Blueshirt organisation.

The reason why we cannot support this Bill, and why my colleagues and myself took the position that we did some months ago, is because we do not accept either branch of the Government's contention. We do not agree that the League of Youth is a militarist organisation and we do not agree that the Government are the champions of parliamentarianism and democracy.

What is a military organisation? In what important sense can it be said that the League of Youth is military? It is not armed; its members are not trained in the use of arms; its members are not trained to believe in the use of force to overthrow the rule of law. Unlike various bodies on the continent with which they have been compared, they do not attack or try to discredit the institutions of the State. They have not, in fact, interfered with anybody's liberty; they have not sought to impose their will on anybody by force; they have not been rowdy or aggressive. Last Sunday I attended a meeting in Kildare where there was a very big gathering of Blueshirts. There was a procession of them which extended outside the town for a long distance; perhaps for three-quarters of a mile or a mile they were strung out along the road. The Minister for Local Government and Public Health arrived in his car and drove along the full length of the procession. There was not so much as a hoot or a jeer or a hostile demonstration of any kind.

Comment on this

He got the salute.

Comment on this

Later on it so happened that I had to leave the meeting earlier than most of the speakers and when I made my way out of the meeting I found, as I got to the outskirts, that there was a cordon of Blueshirts holding hands and separating those who wished to listen to the speakers from interrupters who were outside the cordon. Surely that is an example of a very excellent civic spirit on the part of the Blueshirts and is in definite contradiction of what the Minister for Justice suggested yesterday about their habit of unnecessarily creating rows with members of the audience at public meetings. In practically every speech that is made to the Blueshirts or by any of the Blueshirts emphasis is laid on the preservation of the rights of citizenship, on the liberty and dignity of the individual citizen and the duty of preserving the fundamental institutions of this State. Deputies opposite may feel like distrusting the sincerity of such speeches, but, even if they do, they must surely realise that such speeches cannot but be good propaganda for ideas that we ought to wish to see reverenced in this State and that are becoming more and more reverenced in this State in consequence of that propaganda. I think even persons like myself who dislike, by instinct, anything in the nature of regimentation or marching and counter-marching, may set against that superficial imitation of militarism, those signs and tokens of discipline that sppeal to the mind of youth, as a compensation, the good which is being done by turning all that youthful energy along praiseworthy channels, by turning the minds of the young people not to turbulence, not to revolt against the State, but to maintaining order and to building up the State.

Another thing we might bear in mind is that in the past the sort of organisations that we have seen evil resulting from have not been organisations like the Blueshirts, who have come into the open and proclaimed themselves for what they are. We have had much more to fear and suffer from organisations that preferred to work in the dark, to work under cover. We have had more to fear from the sort of mentality that enjoys writing anonymous letters or raiding people's houses wearing masks or threatening or even murdering people so bold as to identify them in the witness box. I think that is another very considerable compensation that we ought to bear in mind, those of us who dislike even the appearance of regimentation and militarism in a political organisation. It is a considerable compensation that young men are coming out into the open, into the light of day, and are proclaiming themselves for what they are. I scarcely share the fear or the hope of the Minister for Education that other bodies, such as the I.R.A., will imitate the Blueshirts in that respect and start wearing green or other coloured shirts, because unfortunately bodies which have as their aim the overthrow of the institutions of the State and which have as their methods the invasion of property and attacks on the person of private citizens, are very unlikely to advertise themselves to the public by putting on anything that could be called a uniform.

I think then I am justified in saying that in no important sense are the Blueshirts a military organisation and that in so far as there are superficial suggestions of discipline or drill or militarism about them, there are very considerable compensations to set against those. What now about the Government who wish to destroy the Blueshirts? Can we accept them as the champions of individual liberty, of parliamentarianism and of democracy? I think we must test their claim in that respect by considering their attitude on the one hand to the constitutional Opposition, and on the other hand to associations outside the law, such as that to which I have been referring. What has been their attitude to the constitutional Opposition? Even the soberest and most responsible minds among the Ministers opposite seem to have accepted it as an axiom that it is the duty of the Opposition to stop expressing their opinions as soon as those opinions have been rejected by the electorate of the country. They seem to think that it is the duty of the Opposition simply to sit still and admire, and occasionally to exclaim how astonishing it was that while they were in office they had not thought of all the brilliant things the Government have thought of. Consequently they go around complaining in the bitterest terms because the Opposition carries out the duties that every Opposition must carry out in any country where parliamentarianism is understood. Parliamentarianism and democracy would become an absolute sham if freedom of opinion and freedom of speech were wiped out in the way in which the Government would seem at times to wish them to be wiped out.

Moreover, the Government have this responsibility, that not confining themselves to reproaches of the sort they have made in this House, they have gone around the country attacking us in such intemperate language that the result is sure to be a perversion of the people's minds as to what liberty in a Parliamentary country consists in. I do not want to go through a long string of quotations. It would be perfectly easy to do so, but it would take up a very considerable time. The Minister for Finance is sitting there, and let me mention, as one instance, that in a speech made in Mallow in the summer of 1932 he used remarks about Deputy Cosgrave, and, indeed, about myself, of such a character that if either Deputy Cosgrave or I had been murdered the following day there is nobody but would have seen a connection between the speech of the Minister for Finance and our murder. If it is not egotistical—and after all it is more convincing to talk about one's own personal experience—I might also mention that Deputy Ben Maguire, who, I believe, is Chairman of the Fianna Fáil Parliamentary Party, made a speech down in the West in which he alluded to me several times as comparable with Judas Iscariot, and in which he went the length of using these words—in answer to an interrupter who had been audacious enough to call "Up MacDermot"—"MacDermot is betraying this country in exactly the same way as Judas Iscariot betrayed Our Lord." That is not just from a back bench Deputy. It is from apparently one of the most highly considered Deputies in the Fianna Fáil Party, or he would not be its Chairman. Similar speeches have been made in great numbers, and the danger of violence in this country against members of the Parliamentary Opposition, exercising their legitimate functions, arises, in my opinion, in the main from the fact that Deputies over there, who ought to know better, have used language of that type in regard to them.

The Attorney-General and the Minister for Justice think that they have satisfied all reasonable demands with regard to the preservation of law and order if they can prove that they have given proper instructions to the police; if they can prove that they have told the police to be impartial in the performance of their duties, and to be firm in the performance of their duties. I say that the responsibility of the Government does not end there, and that anything they can do in the way of instructions to the police is trifling and nugatory in comparison with what they could do by creating a proper public spirit in this country, and not the public spirit that in point of fact they have tried to create with regard to the exercise of the rights of the Opposition.

Take, on the other hand, the attitude of the Government to the I.R.A. I have not yet heard a single member of the Fianna Fáil Party, on the Front Bench or behind it, go the length of saying that he disapproves of the I.R.A.—not one; I heard some say they approve of it. I have read in the paper the utterances of, I think, their leader in the Seanad, to the effect that he hopes that organisation will continue to flourish until the day of the declaration of a Republic. I have myself repeatedly tried to extract from the President a definite statement as to his attitude to that body, and I have never succeeded in extracting it. It was not until after the National Guard came into being, with General O'Duffy at its head, that the President even went the length of saying that he advises young men not to join any military or quasi-military bodies. The fact remains, however, that with all his enormous prestige, and his responsibility, and his influence over the youth of the country, he has never, so far as I am aware—nor has any one of his followers—definitely said: "The I.R.A. is an institution that ought not to exist." As I have said, on the contrary there have been many utterances of quite a different tendency. It was only the other day that we had a Fianna Fáil Deputy saying, in connection with the Minister for Defence's new force, that he considered it should be recruited with the idea that the people who composed it should have a governing influence on the political opinions of the masses; in other words, that they should intimidate the masses. We had another speech some time ago, made in the presence of the President by a Deputy from Kerry, in which he referred to the members of the I.R.A. as "the real people who ought to be in control of this House and of this country."

If that is the atmosphere, it is perfectly idle for the Minister for Justice or any of his colleagues to get up and speak on an academic basis about the desirability of banning the Blueshirts, or interfering with such an organisation as the Blueshirt organisation. We have got a special situation here in Ireland—a special situation created by the fault of the Government if not by the intention of the Government, by faults of omission and by faults of commission. There is not a single member of the Opposition who is not conscious of a tremendous difference and a tremendous improvement throughout the country in the morale of the people as a result of the development of the Blueshirt organisation that has taken place within the last six months.

Comment on this

We were told by the Attorney-General yesterday that the last general election proceeded under ideal conditions—under as good conditions as any general election in the world. I utterly deny that. From my own personal experience I say that people were kept by threats from attending meetings all over the country. I know it is true that in my own constituency they were kept away by threats from attending meetings. That the number of meetings at which one was shouted down was relatively few, is perhaps true. I was prevented from speaking only once.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

And I prosecuted the people who interfered.

Comment on this

Quite true, and I think the highest penalty imposed was a fine of ten shillings.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I was not the judge. That was a matter for the District Justice and not for me.

Comment on this

There is not the slightest doubt that a general spirit of intimidation prevailed, and there is not the slightest doubt that supporters of that Party which objects so much to badges and emblems congregated in scores with badges and emblems outside the polling booths on the polling day, and stood there and interfered with the people who came up to vote; that they made demonstrations—people wearing the official badges of the Fianna Fáil Party made and encouraged demonstrations against those who, they believed, were going to vote against them, and that they established, so far as in them lay to establish, an atmosphere of intimidation at every polling booth in the country. That will not happen at the next general election, and the reason it will not happen is because of the existence of the Blueshirts, and for no other reason. I could hold meetings in places to-morrow without people being afraid of attending them where I could not have held meetings under these conditions before, and it is not true that interruptions and interference have been the result of intemperate language by speakers on our side. I defy anybody to point to a speech of mine in the country which contained such intemperate language as is suggested by the Minister for Education. I was stoned in the City of Limerick on one occasion when there was not a single Blueshirt to be seen and where I had held a meeting indoors and in private. I have been interfered with over and over again before I had opened my mouth, and not in consequence of anything I said on that or any former occasion, but because it is the set policy of the great majority of the supporters of that Party all through the country to interfere with us and to frighten people from supporting us, and to suggest that we are bad Irishmen and that they are entitled to deal with us in that way because we are bad Irishmen.

For every act of blackguardism of that sort which they commit, they are able to point to the utterance not merely of a back bencher but of a front bencher, of a Minister, or, perhaps, even of the Chief of the Government, in justification for what they are doing. It is not the slightest use for Ministers to say in one breath: "We stand for free speech, and we do not want people interrupted," and the next moment to denounce these people and call them traitors and bad Irishmen, and say that they are committing an offence against all the laws of morality, and all the laws of constitutional government in venturing to express opinions at all that are disagreeable to the powers that be. That is the real condition of affairs in this country, and the Government ought to face it.

As I have said, if this Bill were regarded in an academic fashion, I can see much to be said in favour of its principle. It goes so far in certain details that I think it will be found impossible to administer if it passes into law, but, as regards its general principle, I quite agree that in a country where the proper conditions of parliamentary government prevail and where the foundations of democracy are in fact preserved, uniformed political parties or parts of political parties are something that one would rather be without.

The Government in this Bill are not taking the first step towards the achievement of their object. They are taking one of many steps. What exactly has decided the order in which they have taken those steps, I do not know. I wonder whether this Bill is being brought in now because they have become displeased with the operation of the Public Safety Act? I wonder whether it is because of the embarrassing necessity which that Act has placed them under of shutting up supporters of their own in prison, that they are now trying an alternative method which will enable them to confine their attentions to supporters of the Opposition. In any case, I find nothing at all unfortunately in the record of the Government to lead me to hope that this Bill represents a real effort to bring about in this country conditions of genuine democracy and genuine parliamentary government.

There have been a good many references in this debate on their side to a desire for more peace and harmony and co-operation. I wish I could take those expressions seriously. I wish I could hope that the Government would retrace their steps and try to bring about the harmony in this country which I think myself ought to be quite possible to bring about. I have suggested before now that it would be quite possible for members of this House to come together on the whole question of preserving ordered conditions in this country and I think it would be possible for them to come together on much more than that. I think it would be possible for them to come together on lines that would permit the settlement of our financial dispute with England and of our constitutional relations with England. I think that to a large extent we are fighting about shadows. I think that the fundamental differences between the various Parties in this country are not nearly as deep as they appear to be. I think that the Government is being dragged along a path which, in its heart of hearts, it must at times realise is not a wise or sane path to pursue and that it is being dragged along that path because of its own past and its own pronouncements that would be far better forgotten.

I wish to say again, in conclusion to my remarks on this Bill, that at any time the Government shows the slightest disposition to call the Opposition into consultation, to call the Opposition to their aid in arriving at a settlement of our difficulties with England, in arriving at a settlement of our economic difficulties and in arriving at a policy that will lead towards a reunion of the Irish nation as a whole, they will find the Opposition only too ready to co-operate, but as regards this Bill and as regards the spirit behind this Bill, it is impossible for anybody on this side of the House to respect either the objects or the methods of the Government.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

Might I ask Deputy MacDermot how does he explain or defend the mobs organised by his Party to prevent an auction of seized cattle on three successive days in Waterford?

Comment on this

How does the Attorney-General explain the arrest of nine farmers from County Waterford and their being brought before the Military Tribunal on no charge at all?

Comment on this

I was unable to catch the Attorney-General's question.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

In this morning's paper, there is the report of a third attempt to sell cattle in Waterford at an auction at which a large organised mob attended. This is the third attempt the auctioneer has made to dispose of the cattle and on each occasion an organised mob has prevented it. On the first day, there were Blueshirts present.

Comment on this

Who organised them?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I suggest that they were organised by the Deputy's Party.

Comment on this

I do not accept the statement that the crowd was organised and, without further information, I do not accept the statement that the crowd behaved improperly.

Comment on this

Why are 27 cattle seized for a debt of £35?

Comment on this

The Attorney-General is aware that they were blue cattle?

Comment on this

Yesterday evening Deputy Hogan in the course of his contribution to the debate on this Bill indulged at times in possibly a farrago of politics and at other times in a lecture to the Labour Party. I cannot help the Deputy's political manner in this House or outside this House, but I question the right of the Deputy to set himself up as one entitled to lecture the Labour Party on what it should do and does or on any other matter which comes before this House. The Deputy is not qualified either by his knowledge of working class conditions or by the personnel of the group which supports his Party in this House or outside it to advise the Labour Party on any matter in which the Labour Party is vitally concerned.

Again on yesterday evening Deputy Hogan emulated some other members of the Opposition and proceeded to treat the Dáil to the history of the Civil War. His speech yesterday was reminiscent of the bitterness associated with the Civil War period. It was an effort to rekindle the ashes of the Civil War which up to some time ago were happily dying. The Deputy indulged in an attack on the Government and not merely on the Government, but on the whole nation, and that attack was a disgrace, not only to this House, but to any responsible Front Bench. Yesterday evening Deputy Hogan described Irishmen as "brats, blackguards and hooligans." His admiration, if not his actual adoration, was retained for the British people and the British Government. One is tempted to believe on this question as to whether we were fit for self-Government, whether the Deputy would not, in fact, wish that we were still a province of Britain. Because it seems clear to me that, though the Deputy may live in Ireland and may represent a Galway constituency in this House, his spiritual home is across the Channel. I do not propose to follow the Deputy into the vituperation in which he indulged yesterday. I do not propose to follow him in that disgusting display of bad manners to which he treated the Dáil yesterday or to follow or imitate the Deputy when he described our people as "brats blackguards and hooligans," in order that the Irish Times may write leading articles upon the Deputy's measurement of the standard which he is so anxious to follow——

Comment on this

Talk about the Bill.

Comment on this

The Deputy is as disorderly this evening as he was yesterday.

Comment on this

I advised the Deputy to talk about the Bill. That is not disorderly.

Comment on this

I regret the necessity for the introduction of this Bill. I regret that it should be necessary in the year 1934, in a democratic State, to introduce a Bill of this kind. But with the experience of the last 12 months before our minds, it is necessary that we should take stock of the position. It is necessary that we should observe the tendency of certain political developments in this country It is necessary that we should preserve the rights of democratic Government in this country and that we should check any tendency to indulge in the militarisation of political parties here.

During the past twelve months there has been an evident growth of a military spirit in political matters. There have been attempts to organise large-scale demonstrations on military lines and with uniformed participants. Many who attended those demonstrations were armed with weapons which could be quite destructive in faction fights and which it is admitted led to faction fights. Once that sort of thing is pursued by one political party it will be followed by another political party. The country will just be treated to the position of one political party arranging demonstrations of a very peaceable character and other parties will inevitably be driven to the same action of organising other demonstrations in order to show to the people that they are just as strong and just as fearless, militarily, as their opponents.

The growth of that spirit has been particularly noticeable during the past 12 months. It is a growth that must inevitably lead to strife; it must inevitably lead to bitterness, and it must inevitably help to sow here the seeds of bitter faction, fighting and dissension amongst our people. I will concede at once that the position in this country is very much more peaceful than it is in other countries. In the matter of serious political crime we have a good deal to congratulate ourselves upon. The country has been relatively free from that. The reason the country has been relatively free from political crime is all the more reason why steps should be taken to retain that desirable position here.

Comment on this

By retaining the Blueshirts.

Comment on this

To-day there is an increasing element of political hatred and bitterness in our national politics. If that condition of affairs continues it can only help to embitter relations between all political parties in this country. It only requires a very little march from that state until we begin to sow the seeds of civil war in this country. If we are again to sow the seeds of civil war in this country, and if we are to have civil war again, this nation will be treated to another holocaust such as it experienced in 1922 and 1923. That is the position to which no sensible public representative in this country should in any way lend his countenance.

No sensible public man should lend his countenance to a scheme of political development which is calculated to sow in this country the seeds of another civil war, which will mean the same shedding of blood, the same shedding of tears, and which will mean the same national loss as our people endured in 1922 and 1923. Should the catastrophe of civil war ever visit this country again, then, in my opinion, it will mark the end of democratic Government in this country. It will mean a bitter struggle on both sides with murders following. The inevitable end of that civil war will mean the establishment of a dictatorship by the strongest Party, the survivor of the war.

Deputy MacDermot struck a note in his speech which was helpful, and, possibly, the most helpful speech made by a member of any Party. He wished that agreement could be got in order to secure here normal political methods in dealing with our different political quarrels. I would heartily re-echo these sentiments which were uttered by the Deputy. I would wish it were possible by agreement between the Parties to get back to the normal methods of Parliamentary Government in this country, and to get back to the position when political Parties in this country would be organised on normal political lines instead of being organised by Parties on military lines, the leaders issuing them with uniform and equipping them with weapons of offence, and generally inculcating in our people a spirit of military aggression which in the long run can only be used to the destruction of our own people and possibly to the injury of the social fabric of the State.

If that position cannot be brought about by agreement between the different political parties, those of us who believe in Irish democratic methods instead of the disgraceful tyranny that has characterised the the Parliamentary Government in Germany, Italy, and lately in Austria, must ask ourselves where we stand in the position which confronts us to-day. So far as this Party is concerned, it has always been the Party of peace. It has always stood for the settlement of our difficulties in a peaceful way. So far as the politics of this State are concerned, our attitude is an endeavour to create here a period of peaceful Government by peaceful Parliamentary Opposition and peaceful Parliamentary discussion, believing that along such lines of peaceful Parliamentary methods and peaceful Parliamentary discussion reside the best hopes of this nation in bringing about social and economic regeneration. We have to ask ourselves, in the situation with which we are confronted to-day, whether we stand for permitting political developments to continue on the lines on which we have seen them proceed in this country during the past 12 months. We have to ask ourselves whether we stand for a kind of political life, which enables political Parties in the State to organise their members in a quasi-military body, dressed in uniform, armed with missiles, responding to military commands, and bearing military titles; or whether we want to see our political life ordered on the basis of civilian political Parties, pursuing civilian methods of discussion, free altogether from those detestable forms of militarism which, in the past 12 months especially, have taken deep root in our country.

We have only to look around us in Europe to see what has happened where political parties took on a military orientation. We have only to examine what the position was in Germany during the growth of the Brownshirt Nazi Storm Troop movement there.

At that time, of course, there was a democratic Republican Government in existence in Germany. I talked to many members of that Government, and at that period they never dreamt that the Nazi Storm Troop movement could possibly assume the dimensions it has assumed to-day. They did not see any need then to proscribe the wearing of uniform or to curb the military tactics of the Nazi Storm Troopers. They are wiser now. Many, from internment camps to-day, can regret the day they failed to check the growth of that military movement. Everybody knows that the Brownshirt movement in Germany started in just the same way as the Blueshirt movement is starting in the Free State, ostensibly peaceful at first, but showing every week in a more naked fashion the mailed fist beneath the velvet glove. Everyone who knows anything of the growth of the Brownshirt movement in Germany knows perfectly well that it started in precisely the same way as the Blueshirt movement here.

Comment on this

I wish to question that, and to give the Deputy a chance of answering. I question very much the statement that he has just made, because when the Brownshirt movement started in Germany there was a Government in office which preserved order, and which had no semi-military organisation connected with it; nor was it ever suggested, as far as I recall, by anybody connected with the Brownshirt movement that the movement was started because they were not able to get free speech and individual freedom throughout the country.

Comment on this

The Brownshirt movement in Germany, as the Deputy well knows, was started, not so much to get free speech, but in order to exterminate free speech.

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

The Blueshirt movement here, to-day, led by a man who says that the Parliamentary system here is un-Irish and must be replaced, inevitably means the end of freedom of speech in this country.

Comment on this

He does not say it.

Comment on this

The Deputy was talking of the beginning of the movement.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will be patient, I shall develop the point. It is not denied, however, that the leader of the Blueshirt movement in this country to-day is a gentleman who said the Parliamentary system here is un-Irish. It is not denied that he said that the Parliamentary system must be replaced. That is not denied.

Comment on this

It is not accepted.

Comment on this

That was a very useful admission from Deputy MacDermot.

Comment on this

What admission?

Comment on this

I have no doubt that it will appear on the next agenda at the Party meeting.

Comment on this

He will be fired out.

Comment on this

What I meant is that I do not accept the accuracy of Deputy Norton's quotation.

Comment on this

I agree that since that gentleman's speeches have been sub-edited lately there is evidence of greater sanity, a little more sanity in the political utterances coming from him, and for that, of course, the nation and the Party opposite will have every reason to thank themselves. But the plain fact remains that the Blueshirt movement in this country to-day is being led by a man who says that the Parliamentary system is un-Irish and must be replaced. I defy anybody on the Opposition Benches to say that that speech has in any way been withdrawn by the gentleman who made it.

Comment on this

Explained.

Comment on this

He is the Director-General of the movement from whom the lesser fry in the Party must take their instructions.

Comment on this

I say this, that in the heads of the U.I.P. policy, which was adopted at the recent convention of the Party, it is plainly set forth that we stand, all of us, for Parliamentary Government and democracy.

Comment on this

Is not the General supreme?

Comment on this

Deputy MacDermot's interruption reminds me of the story of the small man who married a very big woman.

Comment on this

You told us that before.

Comment on this

Realising that he was no match for this lady of considerable physical proportions, and wanting to keep on good terms with the lady, when he came out of the church he said to her: "Now, Mary, you and I are one.""Yes," said Mary, "but I am the one." Deputy MacDermot is just in the same position. They are all one, but the Director-General, the man who discovered that the Parliamentary system in this country is un-Irish and must be replaced, is the one. If anybody has any doubts about it, even the Deputy's own Party organ makes it perfectly clear. That gentleman goes out to the country leaving behind him manuscripts of speeches. He gets the streamer headings in the newspapers and the leaded type. Deputy Cosgrave, who led the Cumann na nGaedheal Party for the last ten years, gets two or three lines, and Deputy MacDermot is sometimes lucky if he even gets that.

Comment on this

He was not allowed to make a speech in Swinford.

Comment on this

Is it not perfectly clear then who is the one? There is not the slightest doubt in anybody's mind, and I wonder Deputy MacDermot questions it. The real leader of the Party is the gentleman who has stated that the Parliamentary system in this country is un-Irish and must be replaced. I defy any of the Deputies opposite to get the gentleman to repudiate that statement which he then made.

Comment on this

Are you going to prove that the system is a Gaelic one?

Comment on this

Judging by the Orange, Freemason, and pro-British people that it commends itself to, it apparently is not.

Comment on this

That is not an answer.

Comment on this

What about the British trade unions?

Comment on this

Deputy MacDermot agreed with the statement that the object of the Brownshirt movement in Germany was to exterminate free speech. I was making the point then that the same object is at the roots and the foundations of the Blueshirt movement in this country and must inevitably be at the bottom of any other movement started in this country by any other Party where the object is to militarise our political life, because the inevitable end of that, no matter what the object is, is to set up here a military group, a military junta, to dictate to the people, not in the way the people desire dictation, but to ensure that the people by the support of a military force will be compelled to accept the viewpoint of the dominant military Party in the State. It is the Blueshirt movement to-day; it may be the Brownshirt, or any other kind of movement, another day. The inevitable result is to attempt to militarise our political life; to secure domination over the people in one form or another, with the same particular object.

We have had the growth of the Fascist movement in Italy attired in black shirts. Everyone knows perfectly well what that movement has meant in Italy. It has meant the stifling of individual liberty, and the stifling of democratic liberty. It has meant the trampling under foot of the democratic institutions of that country. Of course, some of our people go to Rome and they imagine that Rome is Italy. I wonder, if they took a look at some of the provincial towns and cities in Italy, whether there is anything in the Italian system of Government, or in Italian economic and social life, that our people have any reason to envy. When visiting provincial towns in Italy one sees clearly the difference between the standard of life of our people and the standard of life enjoyed by the ordinary Italian worker. The Italian worker pays unemployment insurance contributions and, when unemployed, receives 3/- or 6/- or 9/- per week. Does anybody want to establish here a system of unemployment insurance benefit which will give these rates to our people, even though the Italians pay higher premiums than our people are paying? We have seen recently the growth of another uniformed force in Austria, and we see the kind of tyranny that has been the outcome of the establishment of that uniformed force. I put this question to Deputy MacDermot and to Opposition Deputies: Do they want to see established here the system of Parliamentary parties that has been established in Germany, in Italy and in Austria; and whether they want to see these Parliamentary parties end, as they must inevitably end, with the same tyranny that has disgraced Germany, disgraced Italy and disgraced Austria in later years? We had lately, especially from the speeches of the Opposition Party, admiration expressed for Fascism. We were told that the real remedy for this country is to copy the Parliamentary methods of Italy, to copy the economic and other methods of Italy. Although they are afraid to say it, what is really meant is that they are very anxious that we should copy the political methods of Italy, which means a uniformed political party, armed with missiles and more dangerous weapons, organised on military lines, subject to military control and to military organisation, leading inevitably to the suppression of free speech and to the destruction of democratic government. Do the Blueshirt people of to-day want that to be the end of their endeavours?

Does the Blueshirt movement to-day, or any other movement of that sort, no matter what label is around its neck, want to establish here a system of government similar to that of Italy, of Germany and of Austria? If they do, I suppose they will endeavour to secure the establishment of that system. At all events, I am going, so far as my power in this legislature is concerned, to frustrate the growth of a military political party, having for its object—as such parties have in every country where they are established— the destruction of free speech, the destruction of democratic institutions and the establishment of a dictatorship. Once the position is achieved, in which it is the privilege of the plain people to render homage to the dictatorship, they have to endure that tyranny.

Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney worked himself up into quite a fury last night about the moral force of the Blueshirt movement. The Deputy told us that the movement rested purely on moral force. I wonder if Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was supplied with a return of the implements that were taken to the Blueshirt demonstration in Kildare on Sunday last. I wonder if the Deputy knows that some of the people who were attired in blue shirts in Kildare on Sunday last were equipped with metal bars, knuckle-dusters and rubber truncheons, and that they used them. The local doctors will testify to the fact that people were assaulted with these instruments.

Comment on this

Can the police testify to it?

Comment on this

If the Deputy will put down a question the Minister for Justice may get that information.

Comment on this

If the Deputy has any doubt about it I will give the names of the doctors who treated the people.

Comment on this

You want the police on the job.

Comment on this

What are the names of the doctors?

Comment on this

The dispensary medical officer in Kildare and the doctor who attends Kildare Infirmary. These are easily identified. Is it not a rather curious position, that the moral force which Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney says is the main foundation of the Blueshirt organisation, is the kind of moral force that equips itself with knuckle-dusters, metal bars and rubber truncheons?

Comment on this

The kicking cow.

Comment on this

If that is Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney's conception of moral force, one shudders to think what the use of military equipment would be in the Deputy's mind. Everyone knows that the growth on a large scale movement of a military character cannot be confined to methods of peaceful persuasion. The inevitable result of throwing together large sections of uniformed men in a military form, with the officials bearing military titles, is to drive that movement towards the use of arms, whether they take the form of firearms, or the form of almost equally destructive weapons. The inevitable effect is militarism, to import a military complexion into our political development, and to drive parties towards the use of arms either in the form of firearms or other dangerous weapons. It is quite impossible to expect that any party, once they become a militarist organisation, can possibly prevent that movement from having recourse to weapons, or to violence in some shape or form. I look upon this Bill, not as a Bill to enable one party to triumph over another party. I do not look upon this Bill as in any sense conferring a party victory on one party over another party. While I will vote for the Bill, I would not like to see it regarded as a victory for one party over another party, nor would I like to see this Bill, when it becomes an Act, implemented in any party fashion.

Comment on this

You will see no more democracy when this Bill becomes an Act.

Comment on this

We did not see much of it during the time the Deputy's Party was in office.

Comment on this

It is time the Deputy read the Bill to see what it means.

Comment on this

I read it before the Deputy was privileged to be here.

Comment on this

Then you did not understand the English language.

Comment on this

Now that we have got that advice from the fountain head of all knowledge of the English language, I will do my best in future.

Comment on this

Nothing you do will be an improvement on what you have done.

Comment on this

I hope when I have mastered it as fluently as the Deputy that I will be able to explain the farmers' grievances in less than six hours.

Comment on this

The one issue took six and a half hours.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin said nothing, though he got the reports.

Comment on this

I am not voting for the Bill in any sense with a desire to see one party triumph over the other. I am not voting for it so that I may be used by one political party against political opponents. I want to see this Bill used as an effort to put down definitely, deliberately and systematically any attempt to organise political parties here on a military basis. No matter what labels they may have attached to them, no matter what their complexions may be politically, no matter what their objects may be, and no matter what uniforms they wear militarily, I want to see put down any attempt to rear up political parties on a military basis, because the inevitable result of the growth of such political parties would be domination and tyranny over the people.

Comment on this

As this Bill purports to do.

Comment on this

Complaint was made in this House during the discussion on this Bill that it is difficult for one political party in the State to secure freedom of speech at public meetings. I am voting for the Bill definitely in the hope that once it is passed we can resume in this country ordinary civilian political development: in the hope, too, that a vigorous effort will be made by the Government to ensure that every political party in this State will be entitled to all the freedom of speech at public meetings which they desire. The right of freedom of speech at public meetings is an essential condition of freedom and of democratic government. I put this to the Government: that with the passage of this Bill, they must take steps, vigorous steps and ruthless steps, if necessary, to ensure that every political party shall have the right to plead its case before the electorate. If that attitude is adopted by the Government vigorously and, if necessary, ruthlessly, then there can be no possible excuse for organising mobs of people in uniform, equipped with knuckle dusters and metal bars on the plea, the specious plea, in my opinion, of keeping peace at political meetings.

I have never stood for organised rowdyism or organised hooliganism at meetings. So far as this Party is concerned it will back any measure introduced here, or support any measure under Government auspices outside this House, the object of which is to put down the hooligan and the rowdy at political meetings held here. I think it should be made perfectly clear by the Minister for Justice to the Guards that, in their efforts to stop interruptions at public meetings, to curb attacks on people at political meetings, when they are attempting to put their views constitutionally before the electorate, they will have the fullest support of the Government. Certainly, so far as this Party is concerned, any attempt to put down hooliganism at political meetings will have our warmest support.

I hope that the Minister for Justice, when replying, will make it clear that more and still more force, if necessary, will be used to ensure freedom of speech at public meetings. If you once allow the mob to dictate as to who is to be permitted to address public meetings in this country, then you have given over completely the right to function as a Government. If you once allow the mob to dictate as to who is to speak and who is not to speak at a public meeting, or to set itself up as a body to censor the speeches delivered at public meetings, then you have abdicated completely your right to govern in this country. The right of freedom of public speech is such a necessary condition of freedom that it is absolutely imperative that the full resources of the State should be used in the effort to ensure it for every political Party. So far as this Party is concerned we stand for it. The Party that would allow the mob to dictate and to rule in that matter is simply sowing a wind and will inevitably reap the whirlwind.

In the speeches that were made from the Opposition Benches yesterday, it appeared to be claimed by them, although it was not definitely stated, that they had a perfect right to organise a political party equipped with uniforms, with lethal weapons, organised on a military basis with the officers of the party holding military titles. Is that the claim the Party is making?

Comment on this

What is a lethal weapon?

Comment on this

Here we have a Deputy, who occupied the office of Minister for Defence for over five years, asking what is a lethal weapon.

Comment on this

I am asking for the Labour Party definition of it.

Comment on this

Nobody could give a better definition of it than the Deputy himself.

Comment on this

If I wanted a definition of it I think the first I would go to would be the Deputy. I ask: Is that the claim of the Party opposite, that they have the right to organise a political party on a military basis, equipped with lethal weapons, with the officers bearing military titles, and the right to march in military formation in uniform? Is that the claim of the Party opposite?

Comment on this

Why the protest then against the prohibition of the use of weapons and uniforms in this Bill?

Comment on this

We will tell you.

Comment on this

I submit that it is the clear claim of the Party opposite, notwithstanding the half-hearted attempt that is now being made to repudiate it. Is not every other political party equally entitled to do the same kind of thing if it is possible for the Fine Gael party to organise on a military basis? If it is possible for the Fine Gael Party to do that, then of course, the same right must be accorded to the independent group.

Comment on this

Why not, if they keep within the law?

Comment on this

Will it not be possible for the independent group to do the same thing, and for Deputy Kent to make sure that he will be reinforced outside this House by a party similarly equipped?

Comment on this

The people I represent here have nothing that would enable them to buy shirts.

Comment on this

Will it not be possible for the Labour Party to organise a movement in the same way?

Comment on this

If you did, it would show the smallness of your numbers.

Comment on this

People in my part of the country were given five shillings to enable them to buy a blue shirt— wherever the money came from.

Comment on this

If the Fine Gael people claim that they have the right to organise their Party on a military basis, the basis on which they are organising the Party to-day, then every other party within the State, in this House and outside this House, has a perfect right to do the same thing. If they have a perfect right to do the same thing as the Opposition Party in this House are doing, are not we going to be presented here with the position that every party in the State that is represented in the House, or that is represented outside the House, can organise their supporters on a military basis, with uniforms and carrying firearms?

Comment on this

Yes, if the Government will not take up the firearms that are not under Government control.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy read the proceedings of the Military Tribunal yesterday?

Comment on this

I read the Bill, which is more than the Deputy has done.

Comment on this

I am sorry that the Bill had to undergo the tyranny of the Deputy's reading of it, if that is all the Deputy drew from it.

Comment on this

You have not come to the Bill yet.

Comment on this

I will not take six and a half hours to come to it, in any case.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Norton is entitled to make his speech without interruptions. Deputy Belton has been warned, not alone on this occasion, but on many other occasions not connected with this Bill, that he will have to cease interrupting unless on a point of order.

Comment on this

Might I remind the Leas-Cheann Comhairle that Deputy Belton has not been warned to-day?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I said that the Deputy was warned on several occasions not connected with this Bill.

Comment on this

I hope that statement does not damage the Deputy's character in the Press.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must withdraw that now.

Comment on this

I withdraw it, but the Leas-Cheann Comhairle has made use of that language on previous occasions.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Leas-Cheann Comhairle makes use of the expressions he considers necessary to maintain the rules and order of this House, and he will continue to do so. Deputy Belton has been continuously interrupting for the past six or seven minutes.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

On a point of order, Sir, should not the Deputy withdraw the statement that you have said something to blacken his character?

Comment on this