Wearing of Uniform (Restriction) Bill, 1934—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 164–319 of 469. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 13 of 1934 ›
If every other Party in this State were to organise their supporters on the basis on which the Fine Gael Party are organising their supporters to-day, it would not be very many months until this country would be an armed camp, with the supporters of the different political Parties equipped with firearms and with other weapons for the destruction of human life. It does not require much imagination to see how long or how short a period it would take until that armed military camp would lead to a conflagration in this country which would inevitably mean strife, civil war and faction fighting. In the general melée I believe that democratic government in this country would be pulled down, and pulled down, perhaps, forever. It is because I do not want to see Party politics develop along military lines that I support this Bill, and I hope that it will be passed and that it will be used to put down any attempt to create here political movements of the military character which have stifled freedom of speech and liberty in other countries in Europe to-day.
To get back to Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney's moral force: I wonder what kind of moral force was exhibited by the Deputy's supporters in Kildare on Sunday last. It was perfectly clear to all the people who attended the meeting that it was moral force accompanied by knuckle dusters, metal bars and rubber truncheons. That was the display of moral force in Kildare on Sunday last, and any Government that does not attempt to put down that kind of thing, whether practised by Blueshirts or any other kind of shirts, is unfit to be a Government. I hope this Government will put down any further attempts by the Blueshirts to organise in that way, and also to put down the attempts of any other Parties either to organise hooliganism at political meetings or to organise their followers on the same basis as the Fine Gael Party is doing to-day.
Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, after bringing us back to the days of Henry VIII and so on, might explain what kind of moral force is being practised to-day by many of the employers who are supporting his Party. In many places in Kildare, workmen are being urged by their employers to join the Blueshirt movement and to wear blue shirts at political meetings. The only purpose of that kind of persuasion by employers is to use the weapon or economic necessity against their workmen in order to get them to embrace the economic and the political policies of their masters. A definite attempt is being made to-day in the County Kildare by employers to compel their workmen to wear blue shirts; and the price of refusing to do so is the loss of their employment. There is even more than that. Have we not had an example recently where a resolution was passed by supporters of the Party opposite—I think, indeed, by the Party opposite—urging Blueshirt employers only to employ those who support the Blueshirt movement?
Comment on this
Is Deputy Fitzgerald suffering from mental aberration? If he reads his own Party organ he will see it.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan will get it up in the next bundle of statistics for him. It can take the place of some of the other quotations that he quotes here from time to time. Everybody knows that there is a definite movement on foot to compel workmen to wear the blue shirts of a Party they hate and that they have no use for. Everybody knows that every effort is being made by those Blueshirt employers to dismiss people who will not embrace their politics and to employ people who do. If that position is permitted to continue, it means that there is no such thing as freedom of speech or freedom of the ballot. If the employer is to be allowed to use his position as an employer to coerce his workmen in that way, there is no such thing as freedom of speech or freedom of the ballot. It simply means that the employees must, as a condition of working for their employer, not merely render service to him but, willy-nilly, swallow his politics as well. Does Deputy Belton suggest that that is a desirable situation to create in this country? If this Bill did nothing else than to save workmen from the indignity of being compelled to wear a particular type of shirt simply because it is prescribed for them by their employers, then this Bill would be justified by that alone.
Comment on this
Deputy Esmonde makes an annual speech about a lady friend of his out in the front lawn.
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir, I have two men in my employment who canvassed against me at the last two elections. They are still in their employment, but if the Deputy persists in this they will leave it.
Comment on this
Nobody suggested that Deputy Belton would stoop to these disgraceful methods to which I have referred.
Comment on this
Well, if so, I am afraid the Deputy will have to write out his resignation from his present Party soon. There is only one other Party left now that the Deputy can join, and that is closed to him.
Comment on this
It is the only Party in which the Deputy has not been, and he will not get into it even if he resigns from his present Party.
Comment on this
I started by saying that I was in favour of this Bill because I hoped it would put an end to the growth of political Parties on a military basis. I hope it will be used to put an end to military-political movements, to ensure that we shall have civilian politics and that every Party in the State will be assured of freedom from molestation from any other group, whether at election or any other times. It is very bad manners and very bad taste that any section of the people should attempt to dictate to another section to what extent they should address the public or what kind of statements they should make to the public. We are supporting this Bill in the belief that it will end the militarisation of our political life. I hope it will be used with that object in mind. I hope it will be used impartially and without hesitation so as to ensure for all political Parties in the State freedom of speech not merely at election times but at all other times.
I am supporting this Bill for something more than that. The growth of the Blueshirt movement and movements of that kind, no matter what their political objective may be, means inevitably the coercion of the people into the acceptance of the viewpoint of the strongest military Party in the State. The result of that conception of Parliamentary life is to get rid of democratic government and democratic institutions, to establish a political dictatorship, and to maintain that dictatorship by murders, jailings, concentration camps and the bludgeoning of political adversaries. The right to elect and reject a Government is the most precious right the plain people of the country possess. It must be preserved for them at any cost. All the power the State has at its disposal should be and must be used—it will have the warmhearted support of this Party—to secure that the right of the people to elect and reject Governments, without fear of economic or physical violence, will be preserved for the plain people. In that spirit, I am supporting this Bill. I hope that, once the Government are armed with the powers contained in this Bill, not only will they be enabled to stamp out the growth of political movements on a military basis but that, in addition, they will use the full force of the State to ensure fair play and a fair crack of the whip, equal opportunities and equal responsibilities for all political Parties. I have said that I did not regard this Bill as the triumph of one political party over another. I would not vote for this Bill if it were merely an attempt to squelch political opponents. I am voting for it as an effort to put down the organisation of political parties on a military basis. I hope it will be used with that object, and, at the same time, to ensure that the right of the people to elect and reject Governments, without molestation and without reprisal by political Parties or employers, will be preserved.
Comment on this
Were it not for the remarks of Deputy Norton regarding the number of surplus blue shirts in Kildare I should not intervene at all. I should like to know from Deputy Norton whether I could be supplied at a cheap rate with some of these surplus blue shirts. The colour is a matter of indifference to me. With them I should be able to clothe—and comfortably clothe—the shirtless people and the unfortunate unemployed in East Cork. It seems an extraordinary thing to me that at this stage of our political career it should be necessary to bring in a Bill of this character. There must be something extraordinarily wrong in the country when the Government introduce a measure such as this which, if enacted, will be a complete failure, just as all the other Coercion Bills introduced by the old ascendancy gang during the Balfour régime were a failure. I always opposed coercion Bills, and I shall do so as long as I am a member of this House.
I think that there should be some other means of bringing together the two Parties which have torn this country into shreds by abusive criticism both inside this House and outside it. To my mind, the country to-day is in a sad and deplorable state. What is at the bottom of all this trouble? One Party trying to supersede the other. We must remember—every member of this House should remember—that the present Government got a mandate from the Irish people by a large majority. We must recognise them as the Government of the country. It is the duty of every citizen to support constitutionally that Government and to obey the laws which they administer. The abuse and the mud-slinging indulged in in this House, from time to time, is most painful and regrettable. Are we to go back to the deplorable incidents of the Civil War? Is any organisation to fan the embers of the deplorable and horrible incidents which occurred during that time? We owe a greater duty than that to our people and to our country. The people are crying out for unity and for peace. We owe a duty to our illustrious dead—men who unselfishly gave their lives for Irish freedom. Their names are spoken of in this House as lightly as if they were mere passing shadows. These men who died for their country have gone before the Judgment Seat and their names should not be lightly spoken. They were the noblest and bravest sons of our land. If they could speak from out their graves to-day, what advice would they give to all parties? Would they advise hatred and bitterness? Not at all. They would advise that all parties should unite to one end—to bring about the upliftment of our country and the peace and prosperity of our people. If that is the condition that exists at the present time and if it is likely to continue for any time, I see no future for this country. It would be impossible for any country to carry on an industrial policy when we find people carrying arms outside the authority of the State, and when we find them assembled at cross-roads at night when they ought to be in bed. There should be only one army in the country, under the control of the Minister for Defence. Those new politicians and warriors, that have sprung up like mushrooms in the night, now come forward. For what purpose? Is it that they love President de Valera or General O'Duffy? Or is it that they love any political party? These people come forward, not for the love of any party but for the love of sheer devilment and for the purpose of causing trouble in the country.
There is only one way, as far as I can see, of bringing about a settlement of this deplorable controversy. I make this suggestion as one who has spent the greater part of his life in campaigning for the prosperity, freedom and welfare of this country. I make this suggestion to the leaders of the two great political parties in this House. There is one way out of the difficulty, at present, and that is to go into the peace conference which Cardinal MacRory consented to preside over. That would be a means of bringing about better understanding, and showing a united front in our demand to the English Government for the settlement of this deplorable economic war which is at the bottom of the whole trouble. I, for one, never asked the Government to go on bended knee, or hat in hand, to ask for a settlement of the dispute with Mr. Thomas. If we want to bring the economic war to a satisfactory conclusion we must get the united support of every political party in this country and show a common front in our demands to which we are justly entitled.
As regards freedom of speech it is the God-given right of every individual in this country, or any other country. Every man has a right to his own political views and to express them whether in private or in public, but no man has a right to stand on a public platform to incite people to violence or to bloodshed. A great deal has been said as regards disturbances at elections, and especially during the last election. It was said there was no freedom of speech for any candidate who held different political views from those of the Fianna Fáil Party. I have not that to say for East Cork. During the whole campaign, at that election, there was not one interruption at any meeting that I addressed. I consider it was one of the most orderly elections ever held in my memory; and when that election was over there was no animosity whatsoever shown by any political party. We forgot everything about that election when it was over. We had other and nobler ideas and views before us, and that was to do our best for the people who elected us. In God's name I make this appeal here to-night. Look not too much into the past; it comes not back again; wisely improve the present. The opportunity is there if you wish to avail of it. Let us, therefore, go forward to face the future without fear and without favour, and with manly energy let us work for the welfare and prosperity and contentment of our people.
Comment on this
I listened to the speeches of three Ministers and later to the speech we have just heard from the Leader of the Labour Party. I suppose one ought to be thankful to the Leader of the Labour Party when he expressed himself in such a completely hypocritical way that it gave us at least some sort of estimate of the righteousness of the position he had taken up. He explained he was going to vote for this Bill because he said that he stood for freedom of speech, for the right of political parties and all the rest of it. Deputy Norton has been living in this country for the last few years; and he knows perfectly well that that period has been a period which has seen the prostitution of Government. The Government completely rendered itself deaf to every thought of justice by using its power and authority, not in the interests of the State generally, or for the well-being of the people, but in the interests of their own political followers. Deputy Norton knows perfectly well that before the Blueshirts were ever heard of constant items of news in the newspapers were accounts of assaults upon people attending public meetings. Now he will support this Bill because he stands so strongly against coercion, and in favour of justice and democracy and the rest of it. Like the Minister, he found it hard to point to anything in the Blueshirt movement in this country which rendered it in any way undesirable, or at all calculated to produce an evil effect in this country. Like the Minister, he wandered round the issue. I was rather surprised to hear him lay particular stress upon Austria. What was done in Austria was this. Austria's equivalent to Deputy Norton's Labour Party, was called upon to surrender its arms. It refused and when the Government proceeded to collect those arms that party proceeded to use them much in the same way as the I.R.A. and such criminal organisations had been doing in this country. I was rather surprised to hear Deputy Norton laying special stress upon Austria, as if what occurred there was a kind of counterpart to creating blue shirts and was properly dealt with by the Austrian Government. Deputy Norton made a gratuitous and wanton attack upon Italy, Germany and Austria. Such attacks are a disgrace to this House. It is not our business how other people manage their affairs. The Minister for Justice told us of Belgium and Switzerland and Norway and Sweden and so on. The Minister for Justice, like Deputy Norton and the Minister for Education, misunderstands words. For instance, the Minister for Justice used the word "adequate" when he did not mean "adequate" but "considerable." He said that since the Fianna Fáil Government came into power they gave more adequate protection to meetings than we did when we were in power. I am quite ready to admit that perhaps hundreds of times the protection we gave was not altogether adequate but the Minister misunderstands the word. Deputy Norton misuses the word "democracy." I could describe myself as a democrat.
Comment on this
The type of democracy propounded by Deputy Norton is absolutely criminal from my point of view.
Comment on this
It would have been a good job if you did not describe yourself as a democrat 18 years ago. You are late in doing so now.
Comment on this
He is proposing a thing that has been condemned by every serious teacher of morals throughout the whole history of the world. He is proposing that somehow or other authority and power are going to be divorced. We had the analogy of other countries. I want to get the analogy with this country. The Minister for Justice misunderstands the analogy. He said that because of an external attribute—in Italy a black shirt, in Germany a brown shirt, in Ireland a blue shirt—because of that mere attribute, the situation, the conditions and the whole nature of the various organisations are identical. They may be or they may not be. You might just as well say that a certain murderer has brown eyes and that, therefore, everybody who has brown eyes is a murderer. Because, possibly, people in Germany, whose uniform is a shirt, do certain things, therefore, according to the Minister for Justice, anybody who wears a uniform in the nature of a shirt is necessarily and by nature going to do these things. It is on that kind of wrong-headed—I can hardly call it thinking, that the whole defence of the Bill is based.
What is the situation? The Minister for Industry and Commerce gave it to us, up-to-date, in tabular information. The only thing that was wrong was that it was completely contrary to the truth. The Minister for Justice had said before that that the Government might have been rightfully suspicious about the time of its formation of the circumstances of the movement that afterwards became the Blueshirt movement. He said that the members were originally ex-officers, that the Government might have suspected the peculiar time of its formation, and might have been suspicious because the movement was composed of these ex-officers. What is the history of it? I think it was the Minister for Industry and Commerce said that as soon as the civil war was over, the contending parties were ready to be friends, but the loud mouthed politicians willed it otherwise. What happened was that when certain people found it was dangerous to stand up against an organised army, they sought safety by downing arms. Then when the large army, which it was necessary to create, was no longer required, and, when in the interests of economy the Government proceeded to demobilise it, the officers, instead of living in barracks, had to go back to different parts of the country where these men who had been afraid to stand up against the army were now living. These ex-officers were often assaulted, and their lives were in considerable danger. These men, who had given such gallant service in putting down organised crime in this country, then found it necessary to organise in their own protection.
The suspicious time about which the Minister for Justice spoke was the time when the people who downed arms had again embarked on their campaign of murder. They had attempted the murder of a juryman. They had murdered a witness, murdered a police officer, murdered a labouring boy, and there were places in this country where to have served this State wrote you down as a traitor to what the other people stood for and as destined for a traitor's fate to be administered by any person who liked to think that he had such authority. Then it was quite rightly necessary that some of these ex-officers should think about organising in their own protection. They were living in isolated places all round the country. When the Public Safety Act, the Seventeenth Amendment to the Constitution, was brought in, these people who liked to go round when they were guaranteed safety, went effectively out of operation. When the present Government came in it released the criminals from the prisons. It allowed the criminal organisations to organise. It ordered the police to hold up traffic to permit demonstrations by organisations that existed to overthrow the State which the Government existed to defend. Then they proceeded to deny us, and the then Centre Party, the right of freedom of speech. It did happen that this organisation of ex-officers felt they had a duty as citizens and that was the duty to come along and protect those meetings. That organisation proceeded to extend itself, so that as far as the exofficer element was concerned it had ceased to be the outstanding feature of it. It became a general organisation of young men who stood against the tyranny that this Government was engaged in promoting. It stood for the rights of citizens, the natural rights they possessed. This organisation then developed in a much larger form for the purpose of protecting public meetings.
My own experience was this: that before the Blueshirts started and well before they wore blue shirts, at every meeting one attended one was constantly interrupted and stood in danger of being physically assaulted, and one was even physically assaulted. When the Blueshirts came along, these meetings could be held in peace. To speak of my own experience, there was, for instance, a meeting held in a place called Paulstown where blackguards came in and assaulted the people and injured some of them. There were no Blueshirts at that meeting. A couple of weeks afterwards I held a meeting at the same place which Blueshirts attended. They had no uniform at that time. There was not a murmur at that meeting. That peaceful state of affairs remained and I had no further interruptions at meetings until this Government decided to ban the National Guard. The very first time afterwards that I addressed a meeting there was an attempt made to get at me where I was speaking, and the police had to struggle with the men to get them away. They were not arrested. There had been no trouble as long as the National Guard or the Army Comrades' Association was in existence, no trouble until this Government stepped in to make it safe for the blackguards in this country to smash up meetings. In spite of the fact that Deputy Norton thinks it is an outrage to our country to say that it contains blackguards, we say that there are many blackguards in the country. Not alone that, but there are many murderers in the country.
Comment on this
At any rate, that is the position. The Government is going to obey again the orders of its criminal masters. It is going again to make any effort for the people of this country——
Comment on this
The Deputy has made a statement that the Government is obeying the orders of its criminal masters. I suggest that he should be called upon to withdraw that statement.
Comment on this
The Deputy's supporters were responsible for any unpleasantness that occurred on that day. They provoked it.
Comment on this
On the point of order, I think the statement that the Government is obeying its criminal masters is a political statement.
Comment on this
Surely the implication is quite clear. Deputy Fitzgerald has made the statement that the Government must obey its criminal masters. The implication is that the Government has no moral authority and that those who disobey its enactments are quite justified in doing so.
Comment on this
It is purely a matter of construction. It is purely a matter of how a person construes the statement. The statement made by Deputy Fitzgerald was that the Government are under the control or are influenced by criminal people, outside or inside. That is a purely political statement.
Comment on this
I do not mind. I am ready to withdraw it. It is not whether I say it or withdraw it that matters. It is the thing that is true that matters. That is the tragedy in this country at the moment——
Comment on this
I suggest that the Deputy might deal very carefully with his suggestion that there are organisations for the express purpose of murder, as he very nearly indicated a few moments ago. He indicated the names of such organisations, the members of which are known.
Comment on this
I suggest that there is a law in operation in this country which says that any organisation which does any of a certain number of things is unlawful, and then it proceeds to set out as unlawful the very things that are set out by that organisation amongst its chief aims and objects. That organisation is, therefore, unlawful, and the Government is clearly failing in its duty, indeed I might say it is prostituting its authority in failing to take proper action against that organisation.
Comment on this
I cannot allow the Deputy to say that anybody is guilty of murder until such time as the authority set up by this State to decide on that has so decided.
Comment on this
The only people I recognise as having the right to take life are the legitimate Government, and if other people claim that right, then I must say that their doctrine is the doctrine of murder. However, I am prepared to go off that. What I wanted to come to was the representations, I might say the history given here by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. He knows perfectly well that there is this organised opposition to freedom of speech. My own experience is that there was no adequate police protection given until it was clear that the members of the organisation which we will call the Blueshirts were going to give that protection. As a result, the people who came to deny the ordinary rights of citizens were, instead of injuring the people who wanted to exercise those rights, more likely themselves to be injured, and then there was more police protection given.
The Minister set out several items. The first stage, he said, was the uniform. There was no uniform at all as a first stage. The procession here in Dublin was banned before there was any uniform used. The Government indicated its clear disapproval and threatened action long before the uniform came in. Time and again, these organisations were denounced, irrespective of uniform. Now we find the outstanding feature of this Bill relates to the uniform, and why? Does the wearing of a uniform automatically make a man lawless? Is there something inherent in the uniform, something in its very nature which makes it dangerous to the State? Is there something about it morally or legally wrong? Nothing of the kind. But this Government proceeds to pick particularly upon the uniform.
The next item selected by the Minister for Industry and Commerce had relation to incitements to disorder. Wearing uniforms, he said, promotes a desire to support others, whether violently or peacefully. The wearing of a uniform certainly does promote a desire to support others, and it is a very worthy desire, a very right and proper thing. I can even quote Scripture in that respect: "It is better that two should be together than one, for this is the advantage of their society. If one falls he shall be supported by the other. Woe to him that is alone for when he falleth none shall lift him up." And again: "The brother that is helped by his brother is like a strong city." And the Blueshirts are like a strong city because they support one another. That is why they have to be suppressed now. When we went about unprotected and isolated the blackguards could attack us and make free speech impossible. Then we were not dangerous. But when brother supports brother and becomes like a strong city, then the whole anger of the Government rises up, the situation is no longer tolerable, and they determine to put a stop to it.
There is something innately wrong in organisation, we are told. The fact is that the Government have put forward no reasonable case in relation to uniforms. They have not been able to point out that we do incite to disorder. The Minister's third point was that opponents decide to uniform themselves. What is the position here? The question is who is A. and who is B.? The Blueshirts began to protect the citizens against an organisation that already existed, although that organisation was not uniformed. The Ministers seem to be talking the wrong way round and one might say that the Blueshirts are the reaction against the others. As the Minister stated, if constitutional rights justify uniforms why not other parties too, and so on to civil war.
What did this Government consider justifiable before the Blueshirts came along? They considered it justifiable for an organisation existing for the purpose of overthrowing this State by force of arms to have perfect freedom to organise, to have the police hold up traffic while they went about with their processions and to use their privileged position to try to seduce the whole youth of this country into paths of crime. That was what they considered justifiable, and then the Blueshirts came along to alter that situation and, thank God, they have altered it very considerably in spite of the Government. The fourth point of the Minister for Industry and Commerce was this: He talked of Austria's critical days and said that the Nazi ultimatum has expired. His fifth point was that one private army overthrows a Government and dictates. What private army proposes to overthrow the Government of this country and dictate? It is for the private army that this Government prostitutes its authority in order to relieve it from being made amenable to the law. That is the only private army that proposes that.
We are told the Blueshirts must be prohibited and that is the order the Minister for Industry and Commerce gives. The position is really peculiar. He might have stressed all sorts of other things about the Blueshirts, but what is stressed is the uniform, and why? Because the Blueshirts are the one body who have adopted the uniform and who make it abundantly clear who and what they are. The body that the Government want to protect does not wear a uniform. The only type of uniform, if one might call it that, that the members of that body indulge in is the mask in order to conceal the images of the men, because they do not want to be known when they are out doing certain work. They do not want uniforms. All their actions have been furtive and they have always wanted to avoid the light of day. They have threatened men with death unless those men committed perjury to save them from being brought to justice. The members of that particular organisation object very strongly to the Blueshirts having uniforms. It will be no hardship to the criminal organisations if this Bill prohibits uniforms, because they do not want them. It is significant that the Minister does not ban masks. The men with the masks are the men who go out to do certain work at night time. The Blueshirts go out in broad daylight and they are not afraid to show who and what they are. Yet they are singled out to be banned by this Government.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce talks about loud mouthed politicians whose greatest crime is that they are endeavouring, according to him, to revive old bitternesses and bring about disorder. What are the catch-cries on our side that are likely to revive old bitternesses? The other day I was coming out of a cathedral with Deputy Cosgrave, and supporters of the present Government shouted: "Murderers," and "Seventy-seven murders." Of course the seventy-seven was a wrong number, but the implication there was that when the last Government, protecting the people's rights and exercising its legitimate authority, brought crime to justice, the members of that Government were, therefore, murderers. That propaganda was spread about by the members of the Front Bench opposite, and was kept alive by them, and they now come in full of pious, hypocritical unction, and say: "We are trying to ameliorate the old bitternesses that those people over there are trying to fan up."
We did not want to start any particular organisation if the people's rights could be protected without it. The position was forced upon us, absolutely forced upon us, and forced upon us by the action and inaction of the Government opposite. Now when they see—having failed to do their duty, and having prostituted their authority —that the country is reacting against them, that the Blueshirt movement is growing from day to day, and that the youth of this country is no longer led into the ranks of the Communistic I.R.A., they ban the Blueshirt movement.
Comment on this
Certainly. Every man's duty is there, and here we have a Government that is not doing its duty. There is an innate right to organise. Every man has a right to protect himself.
Comment on this
I will tell you this, that when the Government's law is contrary to right reason, then it is not binding.
Comment on this
There are certain laws that are quite above the Government's laws, and any law produced by the Government that runs contrary to them is clearly contrary to right reason.
Comment on this
It is clearly contrary to right reason that the Government should not make a criminal organisation in this country amenable to the law, and should make law-abiding men, merely by a declaration of the Government, amenable to the law as though they belonged to an unlawful association. That is clearly an outrage on justice and an outrageous use of Government authority; it is clearly and demonstrably—although it does not need demonstration—contrary to right reason. If I go to address my constituents, and the supporters of the people opposite come along to assault me and those people who are assembled there, then I have an absolute right, according to right reason and irrespective of what the Minister for Industry and Commerce thinks about it, to see that I exercise my right without interference, and, if necessary, to protect myself by force.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton over there talked about Kildare last Sunday; it seemed to have made him very uncomfortable. He talked about truncheons and knuckle-dusters.
Comment on this
He said a most remarkable thing—that he could produce doctors who would say that the wounds they had treated had treated had been actually inflicted by a truncheon or by a knuckle-duster wielded by a man wearing a blue shirt. It is the most marvellous type of diagnosis anyone ever heard of, but Deputy Norton has promised that he will get those doctors to come and swear that they examined those wounds, and that they know perfectly well it was a Blueshirt inflicted them.
Comment on this
He was very indignant. He did not say—and I watched what he did say—that those men in blue shirts, armed with truncheons and knuckle-dusters, went out to interfere with the citizens and assault them with those weapons. He said that citizens were assaulted, and, of course, he proposed that proof which I have mentioned. If I have reason to believe that a man is going to attack me, surely I have the right to at least have a defensive weapon which is of such a nature that I can only really use it when I am being attacked. If I go out with a gun I might, perhaps, shoot a man who is 300 yards away from me, but if I have a truncheon I can only hit a man when he is practically within arms length of me. The proposal is that we are to be unprotected. The Minister for Justice said to-day that members of the I.R.A. who fired rifle shots over the grave of some man were quite law-abiding because they had permission to have the rifles and to fire them, but other men whose lives are in danger from those very people are disarmed by this Government; they are not even to have a knuckle-duster or a stick, so that things will be perfectly safe for those people who put the Government in power just to carry out this policy, and so that they will not even get a cut or a bruise when they come to deprive citizens of their rights, and possibly even to murder them. Deputy Norton in the interests of all that is holy and beautiful is supporting this very Bill.
There has been talk about a dictatorship. I think it was the Minister for Justice who said Gen. O'Duffy talked about a dictatorship and a new system. When he talked about this dictatorship and a new system the only instance that he gave in our programme was the corporative State which, he said, is something new. That astounded me, because before a great many of the Deputies in this House were born the implications of the corporative State were clearly adumbrated by Pope Leo XIII. Those people go around the country in a most scandalous way, out raging all the instructions they have from the Church, and pretending they are governing according to the Encyclicals. According to the Minister for Justice, nobody in this country ever read an Encyclical, because the corporative State is most clearly set out by the Pope. The Minister for Education goes further, and says that if you are going to form a corporative State the proper Party to do that is the Labour Party. He even tried to incite the Labour Party to resist it, and said that the Labour Party would not stand idly by and see the trade unions and the trades union officials' jobs jeopardised. We are told authoritatively about the opposition between the Labour Party and the employers: "There cannot be a question of any perfect cure except this opposition be done away with," that is the opposition between the Labour Party and the employers, "and well-ordered members of the social body come into being anew, vocational groups, namely, binding men together not according to the position they occupy in the labour market but according to the diverse functions which they exercise in society." The Pope goes much further. He definitely refers, as follows, to a specific proposal with regard to the corporative State:—
"Within recent times, as all are aware, a special syndical and corporative organisation has been inaugurated which, in view of the subject of the present Encyclical, demands of us some mention and opportune comment. The State here grants legal recognition to the syndicate or union, and thereby confers on it some of the features of a monopoly, for, in virtue of this recognition, it alone can represent respectively working men and employers, and it alone can conclude labour contracts and labour agreements. Affiliation to the syndicate is optional for everyone; but in this sense only can the syndical organisation be said to be free, since the contribution to the union and other special taxes are obligatory for all who belong to a given branch, whether working men or employers, and the labour-contracts drawn up by the legal syndicate are likewise obligatory. It is true that it has been authoritatively declared that the legal syndicate does not exclude the existence of unrecognised trade associations. The corporations are composed of representatives of the unions of working men and employers of the same trade or profession, and, as true and genuine organs and institutions of the State, they direct and co-ordinate the activities of the unions in all matters of common interest. Strikes and lockouts are forbidden. If the contending parties cannot come to an agreement, public authority intervenes. Little reflection is required to perceive the advantage of the institution thus summarily described: peaceful collaboration of the classes, repression of Socialist organisations and efforts, the moderating influence of a special ministry."
Now we are denounced as attempting to set up a dictatorship in this country on no other grounds than that we have incorporated something on those lines as part of our policy. The Minister for Justice complains that we are proposing something which was never heard of in this country before. I misunderstood one point. He talked about rapid trips on the Mediterranean giving people certain ideas as to what could be done here. It was the Minister for Industry and Commerce showed me a possible meaning. I had thought, when he was talking about those rapid trips on the Continent and about their giving people certain ideas, that he was referring to the light beer business.
Comment on this
It was not a joke— this business of dictating to us exactly how we are going to run things. The Government objects to what we wear as a political organisation, and Deputy Norton objects to the way in which we give out our orders to our own organisation. He objects to the fact that the Director-General of the Blueshirts, not being a member of this House, dared to give an instruction, and he considered it something undemocratic. He says that everything should be on a democratic basis. What does he mean by that? We know that what President de Valera means, when he speaks of democracy, is autocracy and merely mob rule, but what Deputy Norton means is something that has been ratified by the last congress of the Trade Union Congress or something that was codified by the Fabian Society in England and is never more to be questioned. This constant misunderstanding of words——
Comment on this
I do; I am bound to. I recognise that the Fianna Fáil Government in this country is the authoritative Government and that I am bound to be submissive to law, not only by virtue of the civil law but by virtue of the binding nature of my own conscience. What I object so very strongly to as regards the Government is that the Government is constantly propounding sedition. I give allegiance to the State. The Minister for Education read out a passage from a speech by me, in 1931, and I agree with everything I said, and not only do I agree with it, but every right-minded man in this country would necessarily agree with it. The thing was not to be answered, but, because of some peculiar mental limitation of that unfortunate man, he thought it was something that was going immediately to condemn the man who propounded it. He quoted Deputy Cosgrave as saying that there was a duty of allegiance to the State, and then he had to twist round the words and say afterwards that by virtue of President Cosgrave, as he was at the time, talking about the duty of allegiance to the State, this Government, therefore, has the right to claim the active support and co-operation of all people. This Government has a right certainly to the active support and co-operation of all the people in producing the general well-being, but for this Government to claim that, when it is doing all that is humanly possible to injure the people of this country and to corrupt the people of this country, we are bound by some new moral law invented by themselves to support and assist them and to connive with them in doing that, is a claim which, personally, I have no intention under any circumstances of ever allowing.
The whole point of view put forward by the Government is that as they have been elected as the Government, we are bound to support them, and the people of this country are bound to support them, and not to utter a word of criticism on all the appalling acts they are doing to the detriment of this country. The Minister for Education almost whined about the fact that we are sometimes critical of the Government, and the Minister for Industry and Commerce turned round on me yesterday when he said that he was speaking as a Minister and not as a member of a political Party. Everybody in this House knew perfectly well that he was speaking as a particularly —if I might use the word without offence; I cannot think of a better— unscrupulous Party politician, and I went so far as to say "Question," suggesting that I did not necessarily accept fully his statement in assuring the House, against all apparent truth, that he was speaking as a Minister and not as a Party politician. He turned round and said that that was the sort of sedition that had to be put down in this country. Note that this Bill gives the decision on all these points into the hands of an Executive Council who think that it is compatible with freedom that we are to be forced to think or to pretend to think that every futile thing they are doing is the acme of human wisdom.
Just a week or so ago there came up in this House the question of the censorship of United Ireland. The Attorney-General, having seen it, proposed that certain things be excised. Otherwise, it was all right, and everything else that he saw in it was not seditious, according to him, but the President got up and denounced the Attorney-General in this House and said that, by Jove, if he had been doing the job—knowing much more about law than the Attorney-General—he would have excised this other bit and would not have stood for it. The Minister for Industry and Commerce yesterday said that merely to question his statement, when he chose to say that he was speaking as a great national statesman and not as a party politician, is sedition—and into those people's hands the Labour Party proposes to place all this enormous power, and just note how enormous the power is. The Minister for Justice said yesterday in, as one might say, mitigation of what he was doing in this Bill, that it is not as severe as the Seventeenth Amendment to the Constitution. This is in addition to the Seventeenth Amendment to the Constitution. It is being brought in because they found that there were not sufficient coercive powers given to the Government under the Seventeenth Amendment to the Constitution, and yet they are the Party which got up and got blue in the face—and Deputy Hogan yesterday said that he believed they were sincere; I do not know how anybody like Deputy Hogan could be taken in by such humbug—and fulminated against that Bill as an outrage against freedom. They now agree that it does not give sufficient coercive power, and they must take further powers to be used by them, in a prostituted way, for the crushing and elimination of their political opponents in this country.
I must say that when people get up here and state, without, as one might say, putting a tooth in it, that they stand for a certain thing and are not ashamed of it, I have some respect for them, but the utter contemptousness of the Deputy Norton business here to-day is something which is really degrading to human nature.
Comment on this
I stand certainly for a form of democracy, but I do not stand for what Deputy Davin stands for, and I think that there is, therefore, a prima facie case for saying that I stand for something fairly good. Then we have this business of talking about private armies with regard to the Blueshirts. An army, I presume, is called an army because it has arms. The Blueshirt organisation does not propose to arm its members. I am not going to say that you might not find an odd Blueshirt who possessed an arm, but I will say that I am quite satisfied that there are not as many illegal arms held by members of the Blueshirt organisation as there are by members of President de Valera's organisation. I am quite satisfied that they have many more but, as he said himself, he does not propose to go out after the arms so far as these people who put him into power are concerned, but he is determined to take any coercive power that is required to put down an unarmed organisation like the Blueshirts.
Deputy Norton thought that he had a great thing when it was stated that the Parliamentary system is not Irish. Just on a matter of fact, is the Parliamentary system Irish? I think it is a very creditable thing for the English that they are really the arch propounders and inventors and promulgators of the Parliamentary system, but it does not follow that because a thing was made in England it is necessarily bad and should be replaced. I, personally, think that it is abundantly clear that it should be changed and reformed. It has been pointed out often, by more authoritative people than I am, that it is clear that Governments have taken on more business than they can attend to, and have taken on so much business, which is not properly theirs, that they do not look after their proper business properly, and it is certainly desirable that there should be an intermediate state between the naked individual and the Government in the form of corporations. It does seem to me that, until it is proved to the contrary, it is desirable that those corporations should be given certain statutory powers which they will use much more effectively and with greater justice than can possibly be done by such an assembly as a Parliament. I, for one, speaking for myself, certainly entirely agree that the present Parliamentary form has proved itself inadequate and is calculated to prove itself harmful and that there should be a change.
Deputy Norton talked on this Bill and told us he was voting for it because he hopes one thing and he believes the other. Everybody knows there have been illegal organisations here before this Government came into power, but up to the time this Government came into power they were not functioning. When this Government came into power these illegal organisations were given a new lease of life. They were given freedom and encouragement to go round and recruit into their ranks young men who were asked to accept doctrines contrary to the morality preached by the Hierarchy in this country. These organisations have consistently, during the last two years, endeavoured to deny the Opposition their constitutional rights. The Government has Amendment 17 to the Constitution in operation and this enables them to deal adequately with these illegal organisations.
We had Deputy Lemass saying: "If you have one organisation wearing uniforms the one danger in that is that it may produce others." I will admit that it was the situation created by the unlawful action of the Fianna Fáil supporters and the I.R.A. in this country which made it necessary to start the Blueshirts. If the Government were honestly concerned about that situation in the country what would have been a clear demonstration of their honesty of purpose? It would have been this: that having seen that the Blueshirt organisation was made necessary by the action of certain unlawful organisation to which I have referred, they would proceed to put those unlawful and illegal organisations out of operation. Then they could turn round to the Blueshirts and say to them: "You see that these illegal organisations who are interfering with you are now done away with, and that those evils which made it necessary for the Blueshirts to be created have ceased. Therefore, you have no longer any reason for continuing the Blueshirt organisation." That would be a fair argument to use towards a simple minded person like Deputy Norton.
Has the Government done anything in that direction? Nothing at all. When there was a riot and an attempted murder in Tralee the President of the Executive Council went down there to apologise to the people of Tralee for having to put some of the rioters into prison. It was reported, and not contradicted, that Mrs. MacBride, speaking at a meeting protesting against certain conditions in Arbour Hill Military Barracks made the statement that when in Arbour Hill she met the Minister for Defence and that he had turned to her and said, when she was complaining about the cells in Arbour Hill, "Would it not be a terrible thing if the place were made more comfortable for the Blueshirts?" I do not know whether that is true or not, but it was not contradicted. If it is true what does it mean? That this Government which has outraged justice is not motived by a desire to promote justice but by a desire of vindictiveness—to make certain people suffer so that they may be empowered to inflict greater injustice and punishment upon others who have broken no law.
Within the last fortnight there was a riot in Dundalk and some days afterwards there was apparently a meeting called to protest against the presence of Blueshirts. Only one man turned up at that meeting to protest against the Blueshirts. That man was the sole solitary survivor of what must have been a big thing. The others must have been called off by Mr. Aiken, Minister for Defence. If the Minister were to tell the truth it means this: that a member of the Government was associated with men who did what he wanted them to do, to make a protest against the existence of Blueshirts in Drogheda so as to give this Government an opportunity of saying: "there is strong indignation everywhere around the country against the existence of the Blueshirts.""Strong indignation" is a humbug and it is a humbug that is being worked by members of the Front Bench opposite.
Suppose what the Government says was true that these riots at our meetings only come about by reason of the fact of men being there in blue shirts— which is clearly untrue because my own experience is that it was impossible to have a meeting anywhere in the country before we had the Blueshirts and we have got good meetings now. But supposing it were true, what does it amount to, what does it mean in effect? It means that if you want to deprive citizens of their rights, you have only to create disorderly conditions in the country. The Government will not punish you for having created these disorderly conditions but it will punish the people whom you have attacked. That is a doctrine which will lead to an outrageous state of things in the country. If I am exercising my rights and somebody comes along and attacks me in the exercise of my rights am I the person who is to be punished or blamed by the Government or is it the actual law-breaker who has attacked me? The argument put forward by the Government is an argument calculated to create conditions in this country which will make law impossible.
Because the I.R.A and the Fianna Fáil people go around and attack meetings held by the Opposition it is held by the Government that it is wrong on the part of the Opposition to hold those meetings. If it were unlawful for us to hold those meetings there would be something in that argument but the law gives us the right to hold meetings, and we are to be banned because the followers of Fianna Fáil are acting unlawfully and criminally. Another suggestion put forward by the Minister for Industry and Commerce or possibly it was by the Minister for Education, was this: The United Ireland Party hold a meeting and people come along from Fianna Fáil and I.R.A. to beat the people who were at that meeting; but in their attempt to break up that meeting and inflict suffering on the people attending it, these attackers find that instead of succeeding they themselves actually get beaten away and they suffer. Then we are told that that is a situation that must be stopped because it will promote reprisals.
The Minister justifies reprisals against people who dare to defend themselves against the bullies who dare to deprive them of their rights. That is the point of view put forward here by the Government—that uniform at meetings creates disorder in this country. But these disorders were here and were permitted by the Government before these uniforms were worn. The Blueshirts is an entirely different type of organisation from that type of organisation which goes around at night armed with guns breaking into houses. The Minister complains that the organisation puts a strain on the authorities. Is it the fact of our holding meetings that puts a strain on the authorities, or is the strain put on the authorities by the action of their supporters who go to break up our meetings? And if our meetings are broken up, are not these attackers the people against whom the law should be put in force, and not the people exercising their rights?
We are supposed to be rational human beings. But according to the Ministers on the Front Benches their followers seem to be like bulls who become excited when they see red. The supporters of the Government become excited when they see blue, and the Ministers tell us that it creates bitterness and the Blueshirt organisation is to be banned because the supporters of the Minister cannot control themselves when they see blue! Yesterday the Minister for Finance came along and began accusing people outside of murder and shouting "murder" here. He is the type of man who is capable of creating bitterness, because he is incapable of thinking along any other lines or in any other terms than in terms of bitterness. I am prepared personally to forget everything about the President's past, but certainly when he gets up here and misrepresents things I feel it my duty to get up here and correct him, but that does not matter a great deal. Even with his past it is possible for him to be quite a decent man in the future. I would like to see some signs of that. We have been told that the uniform is copied from other countries. All sorts of things have been copied from other countries.
Comment on this
I would like to point out that the Minister for Justice yesterday was telling us about all these things done in other countries. I just noted that he said the thing was put in operation by the king in a certain country. Now the king is above all Parties and above all politicians, and I presume he is not moved by Party spirit or Party vindictiveness. To show that there is not a complete analogy between the situation in this country and others, it is those Ministers over there, who during the last two years were in office, are to be given these abnormal powers under which they have broken the law themselves. They also told the police to break the law under the Seventeenth Amendment. They are now going to take these additional powers and say, in taking them, that it is all right as in other countries the king operates them. The Minister implied all the time that there was a direct identity, more than an analogy, between us and other countries. He spoke about Switzerland. The situation there was something that I knew about. In Switzerland about one-quarter of the population are Italian in race and language, and were the last people to be incorporated into the Federation. You can step across the street and walk from Switzerland into Italy. In Italy there was a Fascist organisation, the Blackshirts. In Switzerland there was also a Black-shirt organisation which the Government felt was really controlled from Italy and was being operated in Italian interests. They were, therefore, very nervous of the Fascisti. There was no relationship to that position here.
The Minister said that because they were wearing certain types of shirts in other countries, and doing certain types of things, therefore we were doing them. I want to debate the matter on the exact position. I believe it was a good thing in the interests of law that our organisation here should be put into uniform in the form of blue shirts. When you go to a meeting, it is certainly well to be able to see who are your supporters and who are not. I often go to meetings and the people come into the front, and you do not know whether they are supporters or not. You have a position of disorder such as Deputy Norton and I had in 1927 when, at a meeting in Rathmines Town Hall, there was an absolute riot. As was typical of him, he allowed himself to be cowed and would not stand up to them, but I certainly made my speech. There was a riot there. It was impossible for any stewarding to prevent a riot there. The people all came in and took up their position there, and certain strong supporters of the Government opposite—I happen to recognise some of them—were right in the front. If our supporters at meetings are in uniform, they can take up their position, and we know where they are, and it makes stewarding very much easier. This law is to prevent that.
This law, it must be remembered, is in addition to the Seventeenth Amendment of the Constitution. The Government, even though they have broken the law and outraged the law of the Seventeenth Amendment, still found that it has not completely fulfilled their purpose, because their purpose is clearly a dictatorship. They object to the fact that the people of the country should belong to any other organisation than the organisation which they control. Deputy Norton talked about freedom. If I remember rightly, it was only a couple of days ago that there was a query from the Labour Party indicating that unless a man belonged to a trades union, to be completely bossed by the members of the Labour Party, he was to be deprived of the ordinary right to have something to eat and to live. That is the type of freedom apparently that Deputy Norton wants. The Government object to anybody who is not shouting "Up de Valera," and "What a splendid economic policy." We are not to be allowed to think in this country. Their only way of preventing us thinking is to take enormous coercive powers, and to use them as dictators, to see that they are going to be not merely kept in power, but not made uncomfortable by having the truth occasionally stated about them and their policy.
That is the purpose of the Bill. That is what the Labour Party is voting for. They are voting to indicate that they consider the coercive measures which they denounced in 1931 were not sufficiently coercive, and that this Government, which has proved itself the enemy of justice, that has been deaf and blind to justice, that has no regard whatever for impartiality, that has used its power to corrupt the people, should have full dictatorial powers and be completely masters of the unfortunate people.
Then Deputy Norton, when it is in the very act of doing that, turns round and does the patriot, and protests against Deputy Hogan having suggested yesterday that the action of some people in this country justified what was stated in relation to themselves, and what was stated about the whole of us, that they are unfit for self-government. If there was ever any proof of some of the Irish people being clearly not fit for self-government, it was the contemptible line taken to-day by Deputy Norton.
Comment on this
The Deputy who has just spoken is, in my opinion, the last Deputy in this House who, from his own language, is likely to forget the dirty, bloody history of the civil war period. On every conceivable occasion, when given the opportunity, in this House under cover of a political measure, he came here for the last ten or 11 years and made the same speech and the same charges against the present Government when in opposition that he has made here to-day when they are here as a Government. I am one of the people who have a sincere hope that the time is not far away when the political parties in this country will be able to come together in some conference-room and compose their differences on some of the major issues now in dispute, and particularly the dispute with another country. But, when it comes, I hope Deputy Fitzgerald will not be one of the people who will represent the Party opposite at such a conference. If he does, it is almost certain that such a conference will be a failure, because he will go there for the sole purpose of making it a failure.
This Government justly and rightly claims the right to have a mandate to do many things. They were returned at the last election by a majority vote of the people. If they got a mandate for anything they got a mandate to preserve peace and to administer the laws passed in this Parliament in a fair, firm and impartial manner. Can the Government, or anybody who speaks for this Government, say that they have carried out that primary duty? If not why have they failed to do so? The Government, in my opinion, certainly have not preserved peace in this country, because they have failed, within the last three or four months especially, to provide the right of free speech for their political opponents. If they have not done that, the Opposition have some responsibility for the Government's failure in this respect. The Bill now before the House is the very best proof that can be given that the Government have failed to carry out their essential duty in regard to the preservation of peace and order in this State. I believe myself that the supporters, or a section of the supporters, of this Government were originally responsible for the creation of the Blueshirt movement. I may say, at the outset, that I am definitely and conscientiously opposed to any political party in this country having at its disposal, or as part of its organisation, a body of men or women, or boys and girls, who will parade in semi-military uniform, and if this measure was introduced by any other Government, under the circumstances which we know to exist in this country to-day, I would be as much in favour of it, for the very same reasons.
I am not so concerned whether they wear badges or not, because most of the people who meet them in the streets, or on country roads, would not know what these badges represented, except they made a close examination of them. Of course, we are told by the Opposition that it is absolutely essential for their preservation that they should have men and women, and even boys and girls, parading in uniform for the purpose of maintaining that political Party in existence. Does anyone with common sense suggest that it is necessary to have women parading in blue blouses in order to maintain a political party, or, as has happened during the past few days, to encourage boys and young girls to do so? I do not know if they were encouraged to attend convent schools in a blue uniform.
Comment on this
I have not much respect for the intelligence of fathers or mothers who allow young children to attend schools wearing the uniform of Blueshirts or other organisations.
Comment on this
May I say that the Deputy's statement is absolutely untrue, and the Deputy knows it to be?
Comment on this
General O'Duffy, the supreme leader and dictator, of the party with which Deputy Morrissey is associated, has issued an order to-day——
Comment on this
It is not Parliamentary to say: "The Deputy's statement is untrue, and the Deputy knows it." It is a euphemism for lying.
Comment on this
The statement made by the Deputy was made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce last night, and it is absolutely untrue. Deputy Davin knows that it is untrue.
Comment on this
I point to the statement made by General O'Duffy in the Press that speaks his mind in this country, as the best proof that what I have said is true.
Comment on this
Perhaps if Deputy Morrissey had his Chief Whip beside him he would not make the statement he has made.
Comment on this
I would like to know from the Minister for Justice, or from whoever replies on behalf of the Government, what is the exact nature of the latest orders given by the Ministry for the preservation of peace at public meetings. The House is the proper place to give that information. Let us have the information so that we can judge for ourselves if proper and effective steps were really taken, at any time, to preserve the right of free speech for the leaders, or spokesmen, of political parties. I think Deputy Hogan was quite correct in his description of what happened at most of the meetings that were held, in regard to affording protection to the spokesmen of the Blueshirt organisation, or the U.I. Party. The Guards attend in large numbers, and at considerable expense to the State, but they simply divide the mob that comes there for the purpose of interrupting, or breaking up the meetings, from the sympathisers and others who are, perhaps, neutral in their attendance. I suggest to the Minister for Justice that that method has proved to be a failure, and that if the police forces are to get proper instructions to prevent intimidation, and to prevent mobs from breaking up public meetings in future, they should be told to clear the mob element away, and to deal with them in a more effective way, by arresting or charging the leaders of those who go to these meetings for the purpose of preventing politicians and public men from putting their views before those who want to listen to them. I am entitled to ask for definite information as to what specific instructions have been given by the Minister for Justice, or by the Cabinet, to the police, in connection with these very important matters.
I also am entitled to know what instructions will be given to the Guards if and when this measure comes into operation, so far as using their discretion to seize uniforms and badges. The Minister for Justice said that the terms of the Bill give the Guards discretion to seize uniforms and badges, and that the police have ample powers in that respect. Am I to understand that the instructions to the police will be to seize only badges now worn, or that may be worn in the future, by the Blueshirt organisation, and that no other organisations, whether green, black or other colour, are to be interfered with? We know that the I.R.A. at present represents a very large number of individuals in this State. Are we to understand that while the Blueshirts are to be deprived of their uniform, other organisations, such as the I.R.A. are to be allowed to go round wearing some particular form of uniform or some form of badge? Let us be clear about this, because if I am to vote for this measure it is for the purpose of having it fairly and impartially applied towards every section of men, women and children who may infringe its terms.
Comment on this
The Deputy will have an opportunity of making his speech. I am sorry that his inspiration, Deputy Anthony, is not there to help him.
Comment on this
I realise, and otherwise I would not say it, that we are living in a civil war atmosphere. I say that deliberately. Anyone who knows anything about conditions prevailing in certain parts of the country to-day should say it, if he believes it, and should try to help in his own way to avert it, or having to pay for the luxury of a second civil war, inside ten or 11 years. If I thought that by giving the powers contained in this Bill the Government would administer the measure in a partisan spirit, or administer in such a way as to deprive political opponents of their constitutional rights, I would, if I had the power, put the Government to the country, and would even wipe out the Labour Party, before giving any such powers. A civil war can be brought about by people on the opposite side not acknowledging the law, by challenging the law and operating, as they have been operating in semi-military or military uniform, and organising people for the sole purpose of smashing up the power of this Parliament which was established by a free vote of the Irish people. That is undoubtedly the object of the General at the head of the Blueshirts. He said that was the policy.
Comment on this
Having some knowledge of conditions in the country I believe that a section of the supporters of the present Government have a very grave responsibility for the creation of the Blueshirt organisation. We are told, and I believe we are entitled to believe, that the Blueshirt organisation was founded originally to help the leaders of the political Party in opposition to get a fair hearing. Had these people received the hearing which they were entitled to receive from the very large section of the people who believed in real freedom I believe there would be no Blueshirt organisation in existence to-day. I also believe that many of the blunders made by this Government, the blunder of bringing General O'Duffy into court, and giving him a free advertisement at the expense of the taxpayers, has also helped to bring a considerable number of recruits into the Blueshirt organisation. I firmly believe that. There are people on those benches who believe it. General O'Duffy is that type of vain man who likes to see his photograph in the newspapers every other day, or his name mentioned somewhere in them. Nobody has done a greater service to advertise him freely, at the expense of the taxpayers in some instances, than the present Government by bringing him into court on frivolous charges in some cases; at any rate, frivolous in the sense that they have not brought it home to him that he has committed any particular crime against any law.
Comment on this
I do not want to say anything about cases in which judgment has been reserved. If this measure is going to be impartially administered it is absolutely essential that the State forces entrusted with that serious responsibility will not be interfered with by politicians or instructed to carry out any particular political decisions. We have plenty of evidence that even Deputies of this House, and I regret to say Deputies on the Government benches, have publicly interfered with the Guards. They have publicly condemned the Guards for doing what they believed to be their duty. We had a case in Limerick some time ago of a public meeting that was attended by three or four Deputies who sit on the Government benches. They publicly condemned the Guards without, I presume, having heard the Guards' answer; without having investigated the charges made in the proper governmental way. They demanded the removal of certain high officers in the Guards in that particular area. Recently, we had the case of the Chairman of the Government Party organisation, Deputy Maguire, making similar charges, and publicly condemning the Guards—calling for the removal of responsible officers from the area which he represents in this House. I say that is uncalled for.
I think it is very questionable conduct on the part of Government Party Deputies to be interfering in the political sense with the Guards in the discharge of their duties. The Minister for Justice is responsible to this House so far as the Guards are concerned, and the Commissioner is responsible to the Minister. If officers of the Guards do not perform their duties faithfully, then it is the Minister's duty to remove them or to deal with them in a disciplinary way. I think it is very unfair on the part of Government Deputies to go out publicly and condemn the Guards on charges made before any inquiry or investigation has been held. I think that is a very wrong thing to do. I am aware that in my own area the conduct of officers of the Guards, sergeants and even ordinary guards, has been discussed at local Fianna Fáil club meetings, and that resolutions from those meetings have been sent to the Minister for Justice. The Minister can contradict me if he can, but I take the liberty of saying that during the last couple of months a large number of such resolutions have reached his office. If that kind of thing were to be allowed to go on I would have very grave fears about giving the powers contained in this Bill to the Government. If this measure is to be impartially administered, that must be done under cover of instructions publicly made known through this House to the people of the country and to the Guards. I think Deputies should leave the Guards to do their duty in accordance with the instructions given.
The Minister for Justice rather surprised me when endeavouring to make a case for the Second Reading of this Bill. He actually quoted particulars of legislation passed in other Parliaments to deal with what he said was the same kind of menace which had sprung up in continental countries during the past year. Surely no one in this country will say that either the position here or the outlook of the people here is in any way comparable to the outlook and condition of the people in the continental countries which the Minister mentioned. The principal leaders of the two political parties in this country are exposing themselves daily, weekly and monthly at home and abroad as the leading Catholic political leaders of the whole world. They paraded themselves on certain occasions before the Pope in Rome and got certain decorations. But what do they do when they come back here, great Catholics and great Christians as they are? When they come back from Rome, after making a general confession there, they are so Irish that they will not speak to one another.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton joined up with the President in declaring that I attempted to be a military dictator.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton never suggested what Deputy Morrissey has just suggested: that he joined with the President in charging you with having been to the British Minister for War.
Comment on this
It is the same as if Deputy Norton sat alongside the President and supported him singing "The Bonnie Banks of Loch Lomond," the President taking the high notes and Deputy Norton taking the low notes.
Comment on this
As far as I know Deputy Norton's views—it is his business to speak for himself—if he had his way the man who persuaded the President to make such an unfounded allegation would not be in the service of this State.
Comment on this
It has been contended that the Blueshirts have not been acting in a provocative manner. I believe that they have, and I want to say this to Deputy O'Higgins. There are many men wearing blue shirts in the county that the Deputy comes from and in the constituency that both of us represent that he would not be seen dead with during the pre-Truce period.
Comment on this
There are many men in that county and in other constituencies supplying funds to these people to parade at Blueshirt meetings to-day who certainly would not supply funds to the Sinn Féin movement in pre-Truce times.
Comment on this
We are out for unity, for bringing all together. We want the bitterness of that period forgotten.
Comment on this
I believe that persons in blue shirts at public meetings, especially when they parade before the public meeting takes place, are acting in a provocative way. For the same reason I believe that people wearing other types of uniform, associated with other political Parties, are helping to create further provocation: to build up an organisation on the other side. The Blueshirt organisation in this country, so far as my information goes, has helped in some areas in the country to increase, and increase considerably, the number of men who are now members of the I.R.A. That is the service that it is rendering to the country. It is helping to build up and to make stronger the I.R.A., which would not be anything like what it is were it not for the provocation given in certain parts of the country by the activities of the Blueshirts, their parading and so on.
I disagree with many things which this Government has done since it came into office. I admit that the Government was put into office by the free vote of the Irish people in February, 1932, at an election which was as free as any election held in any country in the world. The minority in this House, and in the country, have no right to build up behind them an organisation of a semi-military character which is set up for the sole purpose of bringing down the Government elected by the free will of the people. I was glad— and I am a member of this House since it was set up —I was delighted on the first day I saw the Fianna Fáil Deputies march into this House, because, when I saw them come in here, I said that constitutional government had been made safe for a considerable period by their coming in here. I was much more delighted when I got the opportunity myself of helping to put that Party into office by my vote, because I did so for the purpose of enabling the people of this country to have an opportunity of an alternative Government and to enable them to see, as they are now seeing, and as they will see more in the future, that the promises the Government made when they were in opposition are in many cases impossible to fulfil. I did that deliberately, and, by so doing, I considered that I was doing a good work for constitutional government in this country.
Comment on this
In reply to Deputy Donnelly, I may tell him that I never promised a beet factory to every town in my constituency, and I never told my constituents that I would buy a private residence and reside on the outskirts of every town in my constituency. Consequently, I will not have to face the people in the future with the crime on my conscience of having broken such foolish promises. I am voting, without any reservation, for the passage of this measure, for the purpose, as I believe, of preventing further civil war in this country. I have every hope that the Minister for Justice and his colleagues in the Cabinet, backed by the Party elected by the people of this country, will administer that measure in such a way as to prevent such an occurrence happening in the lifetime of the youngest member in this House. One civil war in the lifetime of any Deputy in this House is enough. One civil war is enough in a generation. The civil war had to be paid for by the money and by the blood of the innocent majority of this country. It is the innocent majority who always have to pay for the follies of the leaders who help to create the conditions that bring about a civil war. I would say to the Opposition that they have the opportunity now of accepting a majority decision of this House on that matter, and I say to General O'Duffy, who is not a Deputy of this House, that he has a far greater chance of leading a majority back into this House in the future by carrying on a constitutional political organisation, free from militarism, than he has by following his present tactics. The majority of the people of this country do not want any armies, private or otherwise.
Comment on this
If I had my way I would disband the National Army. If I had my way I would take every gun away from the National Army and from the private armies, and would bring them out in the Lord Mayor's yacht and dump them in the sea, if the Lord Mayor is willing to lend his yacht for that very desirable purpose. The majority of the people want to live in peace and harmony with each other and not to be interfered with by Greenshirts or Blueshirts. As far as I can understand their mentality, they do not want to hear anything about the creation of armies or semi-military bodies of that character behind the political Parties in this State. I hope and trust that this measure will be administered in a fair and impartial manner. If it is administered in a fair and impartial manner, as it is the duty of the Government to administer it and not to use it in a vindictive way, the future will tell that the passage of this measure will have done good work for the future peace and progress of this country.
Comment on this
Were it not for the second last sentence of Deputy Davin's speech, I should be completely puzzled as to what his attitude was with regard to this Bill. He performed a rather difficult accomplishment, and he performed it rather with the skill of an experienced expert. He whistled two tunes at the same time; but I will say that, at any rate this time, he decided to give a vote. He is coming on, and I hope he will keep on in that direction, and that, even though it is against my view, he will stand up according to the convictions he has, and follow that statement with a vote.
Comment on this
There were one or two things he mentioned in the course of his statement, and I do not think he would have mentioned them unless he was misinformed. One statement was grossly unfair to General O'Duffy and his whole organisation. That statement was that the General issued instructions to school children going to school to wear the badge of the organisation or the uniform.
Comment on this
I did not make that statement. I think if the Deputy gets the shorthand notes he will find that I did not make that statement.
Comment on this
A Deputy's statement as to what he said or did not say must be accepted in this House.
Comment on this
If the Deputy asserts that he did not say it, I accept his statement, of course; but perhaps I might put it that he conveyed to this House that it was by the direction of General O'Duffy that these political badges or the uniform of the organisation were brought into the school life and that, as a result, bitterness and disagreement had arisen in school life.
Comment on this
Would Deputy O'Higgins accept this—that if General O'Duffy did not say it, some of his supporters in Cork said it and advocated it?
Comment on this
I am dealing now with General O'Duffy and the views of the organisation. No member of the executive of an organisation can be held responsible for every individual utterance by every individual member of that organisation down through the country. I want to point out that even from the early days of the Army Comrades Association some 18 months ago, I myself gave specific instructions to many colleges and schools that, during the school term or while attending school or college, the badge of the organisation should not be worn. That policy has been consistently carried on inside the successive organisations that succeeded that Association; and it is not fair to the executive or to the head of the organisation even to suggest by implication that any disagreement or bitterness that crept into any school was due to any act of, or even due to any connivance from, the head of the organisation. That is clear enough, and if it is not sufficiently clear, I will make it clearer.
That is one statement I was anxious to contradict, and there is another statement on which I should like more information. When the Deputy was speaking, and when Deputy Morrissey interrupted him, he referred to the fact that, at all events, his Party had wiped out Deputy Morrissey. I expect that in his reference to wiping out he really meant that he and his Party had expelled Deputy Morrissey from the Labour Party. I asked why, and I was not answered.
Comment on this
I was not answered, and I did not expect an answer, when the Deputy was speaking on his feet, defending the very measure which Deputy Morrissey was expelled from the Party for supporting under other conditions, and more dangerous and more difficult conditions, than those prevailing at the moment.
Comment on this
There is just one other thing I would like to mention and I will finish with my colleague. He referred to the fact, further, that General O'Duffy had declared his intention to smash the Parliament of this country. Now, that is not correct.
Comment on this
Wait now! This particular shoe might be un-Irish and you can call it un-Irish. Would it be fair to say, because you called it un-Irish, that you were out to smash the shoe? Deputies should be careful in talking about public men and about men who figure prominently in the public life of the country. It would be a very serious thing if any man, even an obscure man, but even though obscure, with some influence in the country, got up and declared his intention to smash the Parliament of this country; but it would be a hellish thing if a man in a prominent position in public life and with great influence in the country should do so. It is, therefore, very, very serious for a Front Bench Deputy, for a man who can put the 'phone to his ear at any time and ascertain the accuracy or inaccuracy of his statements—it is a very serious thing for a Deputy in that position to come to this House and play recklessly and freely and falsely with the statements of any public figure in the life of this country. I admit that things are just as dangerous in this country, that there is a little bit of electricity in the atmosphere— more than is healthy and more than is safe. If there is anything calculated to send a spark along that electricity, it is the kind of reckless statements and speeches made by Deputy Davin.
Comment on this
It is a reckless thing to make a statement of which you are not quite sure about a public man when you can ascertain whether it is true or not by going to the next room and taking up the telephone. That is all I have to say on that point. I hope that when Deputy Davin stands up in future he will be more careful in his references both to parties and individuals and that he will be particularly careful when referring to an individual who does not happen to be a member of this House.
Comment on this
The same applies to the Press. The Press has an influence in this country second only to that of the Deputy. The Press has got to be very careful of the statements it makes and it has got to be very careful—I have spoken on this matter before— with regard to the accuracy of its reports. I listened to the discussion on this Bill—a Bill admittedly designed to pull the shirts off the political opponents of the present Government, a Bill which, according to the Minister, is designed for the purpose of de-shirting his political opponents. As I listened to the discussion, I thought that there was surely enough crime in this country and surely enough undetected criminals without the whole lot of us sitting down deliberately to manufacture a new crime, and, if possible, to manufacture a new set of criminals. If we had reached the point in the life of this country at which we could say "crime has practically disappeared or, if crime has not disappeared, at least, we are getting after and grabbing by the neck all the criminals and there is no undetected crime in the country"— if we had reached that point, there might be some excuse for our sitting down to manufacture new crimes and taking the risk, at least, of manufacturing 100,000 new criminals. Remember, when we are dealing with this kind of thing, we are, as I said before, dealing with young blood. Young blood is hot blood and there is a point beyond which you cannot safely provoke young blood. If this Bill ever becomes law, I am very much inclined to think we shall have reached the point beyond which we cannot get those individuals to submit any further. They have submitted to humiliation. They have submitted to what cheap minds would call "degradation." They have bowed their knee before Power, even though they opposed bitterly that Power. They have bent their neck and walked under the yoke in a humble manner time and again in the last six months. Inside that organisation, time after time, it took lengthy argument, courage, determination, supplication to get that organisation to bow to the law of the land and to submit to what they call harsh and unjust laws particularly aimed at themselves. Be it remembered to the credit of those young men, irrespective of political hatreds and political divisions, that, after all, they were Irish and, after all, they were democrats and that hating, as most of them did, the political outlook of the Fianna Fáil Government, in the end, they accepted the fact that the Fianna Fáil Government was put there by the votes of the Irish people and should be obeyed the same as a Cumann na nGaedheal Government. I appealed before not to make that job harder. Have those men not humbled themselves sufficiently? Is there any point in driving the whole organisation under the surface? Has not this country suffered enough from the curse of secret societies, from the curse of organisations going under-ground, from the curse of young men plotting against those in power, from the curse of young men being driven to appeal to the gun in their pocket rather than parade with their grouses or their grievances or with their policy in the broad light of God's own sunshine?
I appeal to you, even at this eleventh hour, not to drive further than natural forbearance the members of that organisation. If your desire is to humiliate them, have you not done that sufficiently? If your desire is to show your power, have you not done that sufficiently? If your desire is the clean desire of demonstrating that you are the Government of the country, have you not done that and have not we accepted that? Did we not call off our parade in honour of heroes that were our leaders and are now dead? Did we not accept your first, second and third ban? Did we not change our name and constitution merely because you declared our name and constitution to be illegal? Have we not done all that should be expected of any group of citizens in a free country? Must we go further? Must we pull the very shirts off our backs? Must we go back and say: "That which was no sin yesterday, that which was all right yesterday and that which was allowed to our people under our free constitution yesterday, will not be allowed tomorrow? You must go back on all that.""Why?" they will ask. "Because the Government wants further to humiliate you, because the Government wants further to provoke you." To take Deputy Davin's line, suppose we argue that this applies to all, and they reply, "Will you show me any other organisation that has its shirt, will you show me whom this is aimed at but ourselves?" I must be silent and everybody here would have to be silent in face of such a question. Nobody over there would defend that measure on any other ground than the honest ground put forward by the Minister for Justice in introducing it, when he stated openly and honestly that it is aimed at one organisation and at the clothes worn by that organisation. In view of that utterance by the Minister in charge of the Bill, is there any point in his allies coming along and saying that it is an all-round Bill, that it applies to all? In a noisy manner, the cat got out of the bag at the beginning of the debate and not all the Deputy Davins and all the Labour Parties can put that cat back into that particular bag.
Comment on this
On what ground was this Bill defended? Time and time again I have appealed to the Government in connection with many measures, whether these measures were good or bad or just or unjust, for goodness sake to stand upon their own legs and defend them by conditions prevailing in this country. I have constantly objected to Bills being introduced and being defended by the Government because the Cumann na nGaedheal Government had done the same thing. I have asked them time and time again, as I said, to stand upon their own legs.
Comment on this
I asked them whether their measures were right or wrong to stand over them when they introduced them. We did not shelter, in our time, behind other countries, or other Governments. In connection with this measure, which is a Bill really to victimise the Government's political opponents, there was scarcely a word said about the conditions in Ireland to justify its being brought forward. We were brought by the Minister for Justice on a tour all round Europe, and we heard the names of countries that I, for one, was unfamiliar with. The Minister for Justice, because he is a weak linguist just as I am, was not able to make a speech out of many of these foreign languages in favour of this measure. His speech was mainly the speech of the Belgian Minister for Justice, when he introduced a somewhat similar measure in Belgium, and it was supported, to my amazement, by an extract from another speech made by Sir John Simon, the British Foreign Secretary.
I point out that this particular Bill is in addition to Amendment 17, Article 2a, of the Constitution. It is in addition to the powers and penalties of the Public Safety Act. Deputies opposite will remember the time when that Act was introduced. I will not weary the House by quoting what was said by Deputies opposite, some of them who are now Ministers, with regard to this Bill when it was introduced, yet now we have them seeking these powers in addition to Article 2a of the Constitution. In addition to the A.C.A., there is also banned in Ireland the association of the League of Youth. Now I want this to sink in. We have organisations in this country proclaiming their policy to the world. One is the League of Youth. Now, for the moment I waive the question whether its aims and objects as published are its real aims and objects, but I say that its published aims and objects vouched for and printed, are as follows:—"(1) To promote the voluntary reunion of the Irish nation; (2) To educate and interest the youth of Ireland in the responsibilities of citizenship; (3) To develop in the minds of young people an understanding and appreciation of democratic rights and responsibilities; (4) To promote social order; (5) To encourage voluntary public service; (6) To oppose Communism by upholding Christian principles." These are its published aims and objects.
There is another organisation, and it has public aims and objects, and these are published. It says it shall endeavour to achieve its objects by:—"(1) Force of arms; (2) Organising, training and equipping the manhood of Ireland as an efficient military force; (3) Assisting as directed by the army authority all organisations working for the same objects." There is the position. You have two organisations at least in this country. One stands for the aims and objects I have read out. The other definitely and noisily proclaims that it stands for the use of force for organising and training the youth of the country in the knowledge of arms, and for achieving their aims by force. And an Irish Government, posing as a constitutional Government, acting under the Constitution of the Free State, bans with all the ruthlessness of the Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Act—which of these organisations? Which of the two? The one that stands for the objects I have read out first. Is there a man or lady on the benches opposite who is not ashamed of that discrimination? What is the case made here for such discrimination? The only case made as justifying the suspension of that organisation was that it might resort to arms. The other organisation declares openly that they have resorted to arms and intend to do so. May I give one illustration further?
We hear a lot about Catholicity in this country. This first organisation pledges itself in bold print as opposed to Communism. The other pledges itself in equally bold print to associate itself with any other organisation that stands for the same purpose and objects as itself—the overthrow of the State as it exists.
This latter organisation has been condemned by the Hierarchy of the Catholic Church in Ireland. The other organisation suffers from no such ban, and all the vindictiveness we complain so much about is applied not to the organisation banned by the Hierarchy of this country but to the other organisation. Is it the organisation that declares itself determined to ally itself with Communism or anything else that is banned? No. The ban applies to the organisation that was not banned by the Hierarchy, and that openly, and even noisily declared its intention to oppose Communism. Yet in the light of that knowledge Deputy Davin tells us he will vote for the Bill in the hope that it will be fairly and equally administered.