Wearing of Uniform (Restriction) Bill, 1934—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 320–469 of 469. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 13 of 1934 ›
I wish we would all develop Deputy Davin's degree of optimism. He is about the most optimistic man that ever walked into any assembly if he hopes that there is to be an impartial administration of this Bill when it becomes an Act, especially after what we have seen of the administration of its predecessor on the statute book. The Deputy asks why do we want uniform.
Comment on this
I shall tell the Deputy all about the uniforms. He does not seem to like them at all. We heard a lot about the uniforms of the Blueshirts provoking attacks upon meetings. The Front Bench opposite for once whistles the same tune, and it was to the effect that attacks on meetings were really provoked because of the attendance of men in blue shirts.
Comment on this
The contention was that it was the attendance of men in blue shirts and girls in blue blouses that led to attacks on meetings. I am not going to act the ghoul like the Minister for Finance and go back to 1922 and 1923. I could ask about things recent in memory, about the seven bloodhounds of Castlereagh. That was all years ago in the spring and summer of 1922. Fair-minded Deputies will agree with this. There was a Government in power and a political Opposition here in 1932. We were the political Opposition. Like a political Opposition we had a perfect right to hold meetings throughout the country, to rally our defeated supporters. It is particularly necessary after a defeat to be politically active, and during that spring and summer we attempted to hold meetings. Every single meeting we held up and down this country was either attacked and partially broken up or completely broken up. Take any of the posters of the organ of the Government, if you like, any Monday morning during the spring and summer of 1932. There were big screaming headlines on the posters every Monday morning—"Cumann na nGaedheal meeting broken up. Mr. Blythe shouted down. Mr. Cosgrave not heard in Cork." Every Monday morning you had the same dismal, disgraceful reports in the Irish papers.
Comment on this
Deputies must not interrupt. If they continue to do so, they must take the consequences.
Comment on this
The point I am making is that right during that period there was not a blue shirt or a blue blouse in the whole of the Irish Free State, at least that we were aware of. That state of affairs continued right up to August. Then six or seven individuals—and I am giving a little bit of true history now—met together and their tone was that the game was up and that with the mob unloosed and with no protection from the State authorities, normal political opposition and normal political constitutional activity in this country were finished. They saw the growth and the alarmingly increased strength of other organisations standing against the State, standing as much against a Fianna Fáil Government as against a Cumann na nGaedheal Government. One man said: "Surely something can be done." Another said: "If young men can be recruited into organisations to defy their own Parliament and tear down their own State, then, by heavens, young men can be got into an organisation to defend their own Parliament and stand by it."
Comment on this
The man who said that was Ned Cronin. Out of that, with that inspiration, with that motive, with that intention, never since departed from, the A.C.A. came into being, out of that the National Guard, out of that Young Ireland, and out of that the League of Youth. The aim, object, motive and inspiration of all were that common constitutional democratic inspiration——
Comment on this
He sounded the note and 100,000 have taken it up since. I am asked about the uniform. Right through the early days of the A.C.A. men went round to meetings. There was rowdyism at the meetings and rowdyism in the towns in which the meetings had been held and reports came to me, for one, that certain members of the A.C.A. were behaving in a riotous, disorderly manner in towns after meetings. The reports I got were that the rioters or the rowdies were not all members of the A.C.A. Reports of that nature came in and we had a discussion about them. I was not prepared to say that everyone who criticised the A.C.A. was necessarily untruthful and that everyone inside the A.C.A. was necessarily truthful. We had a discussion about it and we said: "We will put down all that. We will see that there is cleanliness, decency and discipline inside this organisation. We will see that the man who misbehaves himself is made so very conspicuous that he can be taken by the back of the neck when he misconducts himself"——
Comment on this
Wait now. One thing at a time. With that aim in view, and only with that aim, we adopted the blue shirt.
Comment on this
If the Deputy will sit quietly I will answer him, but if the Deputy wants to make me rough I can be every bit as rough as the Deputy. With that object in view we adopted the blue shirt. Certainly, all complaints as to indiscipline, as to riotous behaviour and rowdyism then disappeared. It might have been the fact that a man felt that all eyes were on him. It might be the fact that people stuck better together when they were dressed in a common shirt. Not only that, but from that week the strength of the organisation kept doubling itself. Then it was that the political mind saw the importance politically of a shirt and blouse. We adopted the shirt when the merger came along and when Fine Gael was established. We adopted the shirt as the shirt of the organisation, if you like, because it was such a potent recruiting factor for the organisation. In order to further our political strength and our political success, we got blue blouses also and got ladies to wear them. That is the case, and the people over there know that. They know it has been the most successful political card that was ever thrown on the table of this country, and because they know that we have the present Bill. They talk about continental dictatorship — Latvia, Sweden, Belgium, Switzerland—but the only thing that is worrying the people opposite is the Irish Free State, and the increasing and rapidly growing strength of the Opposition in the Irish Free State. They know that the great rapidity of the increase in strength is attributable to the influence of the blue shirt and the blue blouse, and this Bill is brought in, not to promote peace, but, as far as possible, to paralyse the political Opposition in the country. But the effects of this Bill may go a lot further than the people opposite think. We have this wobbly defence on European grounds, no attempt at defence on Irish grounds. We have the optimistic Deputy opposite hoping that it will be impartially administered. You have me here telling you this, that it is with difficulty, with extreme difficulty, we got the members of previous organisations to accept your laws, to bow their necks, to bend their knees——
Comment on this
The Deputy who has just interrupted has been previously cautioned in regard to his interruptions. He has persisted in interrupting and he will now retire for the remainder of the sitting.
Mr. Donnelly then retired.
Comment on this
I have merely one more word to say, and I address this directly to the Government. Before you proceed any further along this line of testing and provoking beyond endurance practically all the young men who are opposed to you in this country—I am not going to say a majority, and I am not going to say a minority—but practically all the young men who are politically opposed to you, I would ask you to weigh the matter carefully in your minds. As regards this Bill, coming as it does like a sledge hammer stroke after your calling off of parades, after your bans, after your suppressions, and with the knowledge you have of the difficulties experienced in getting acceptance of the calling off of those parades and the acceptance of those bans, if you do not want to make a dangerous situation a lot more dangerous and a lot more difficult than it is at the moment, either for you people over there or for the people who sit here, I would ask you even at the eleventh hour to withdraw it, because it is purely a vindictive political measure, and because the only effect of it will be to provoke a difficult state of tension and danger in this country.
Comment on this
If some of us had not heard Deputy O'Higgins before, had not heard him with the same pretended sincerity making somewhat similar appeals here and adopting afterwards a very embittered and nasty attitude outside, we would have taken more interest in his statements and tried to convince ourselves that he was honest. He preaches here in the interests of peace and unity, but elsewhere he adopts a different attitude. If he spoke to the men for whom he talks here with the same pretended sincerity all along the line, there never would have been a need for the introduction of this measure. Deputy O'Higgins appears to think that we are convinced that when his Government was in office they took every possible opportunity of seeing that fair play all round was administered, and he appears to think that our supporters should have no grouse whatever against the ruling power of that time. He talks about the difficulty of getting his supporters to accept this Government's rule. It is truly remarkable when one realises that he and the men associated with him were saying for ten years that we were the people who would not recognise anyone's rule, while he and his supporters were always prepared to accept the rule of the majority. Now he tells us that he went to the utmost limits of his power to get his associates to accept the authority of this Government, which was returned to power by the majority vote of the people.
Why has he kept that up his sleeve? Why did he not acquaint us that the people who were behind him would not, unless under extreme pressure, accept the rule of any Government other than a Cumann na nGaedheal Government? He talks about bitterness and about this Government driving men too far. Deputy O'Higgins and his associates should be the very last to talk of driving men too far. They, in their time, drove men to their graves, drove men out of the country. The man who is over there and who was head of their Government batoned men out of public positions, men who were prepared to accept their authority peacefully but who were not prepared to be worried, who were anxious to be allowed, if you like, to hold mental reservations. But the Government of the time would not tolerate that; they drove them out. Now, because that very Party are in Opposition we are told that no Government should drive young men too far. This Government, we are told, should not drive ex-officers of the Free State Army, men who were disciplined for ten years, four years, or three years, men who learned what it was to serve under their Government and to accept majority rule—we should not, we are told, drive them too far, although we have a mandate from the people to rule and to carry out a certain programme. Surely Deputy O'Higgins knows very well that he is not sincere when he makes those statements and that nobody can accept as being sincere a single word he said in that strain.
Following the last two elections, when we won with sweeping majorities, I remember that at the victory meetings we attended the strongest appeal that went out from our platforms was for toleration and friendship amongst the people, the burying of the old enmities that divided us. I remember also that at practically every meeting addressed by our opponents they reminded the people that we were a Party in whom nobody could have confidence, that we were unfit to rule, that we were blackguards, and they did all in their power to raise again the old bitternesses, the old enmities and the bad feelings that were just on the point of dying out. In spite of the fact that we did win a sweeping victory at the last two elections, there were no outrages committed against our opponents at the time. Our people stood the test very well and I will remind Deputy O'Higgins that it was just as difficult for our people to accept him and his Party as ordinary politicians who were entitled to be heard as it was for his supporters to accept our people as a Government. Surely Deputies opposite will concede that our people had just as much reason to be angry and embittered against them. Surely there will be a little give and take. He will, I am sure, admit that his difficulty was no greater than ours in getting our people to accept them as politicians with an absolute right to make their views clear before an audience in any part of the country.
With all the statements over the past two or three days one would think there was no disturbance at all during the ten years of Cumann na nGaedheal rule and that every crime that was committed was detected and the perpetrators were sentenced. I know that crimes were committed during the rule of our predecessors for which nobody was apprehended and I venture to say that more interest was paid by the leaders of Cumann na nGaedheal at the time to making political capital out of those crimes than towards apprehending the people who committed them. I think it will be accepted as true that a larger percentage of criminals went unapprehended under the rule of our predecessors than has been the case under this Government over the same period of years. There must be a little give and take and they must realise that when we were in opposition here there were certain parts of the country where we could not address a public meeting. We were driven out of certain parts of our own constituencies by supporters of the Party opposite. The Guards who were there could not raise a voice and did not raise a voice. We were driven out, bottles were thrown at us at meetings which we tried to address. All that happened under the Cumann na nGaedheal regime.
Deputies have spoken about this Government being responsible for disorders at meetings. They themselves were responsible during their term of office for disorders at public meetings and in certain parts of the country we could not address the people. The people over there should be aware of their own record. Possibly their memories are very short. They may have forgotten those incidents but I think it is more likely that they have not. I will not say they tried to encourage disorder—they declare that we have encouraged disorder, but that is false—but they certainly never tried to curb their followers or to prevent, when in office, obstructions at meetings in certain parts of the country which we tried to address. After the by-elections, while they were in office —there are Deputies sitting opposite who know this—the houses of supporters of our people were attacked in different towns. Their walls were tarred; their doors were smashed in. In one town in my constituency a particular supporter of theirs handed out shotguns to their own supporters to go and attack the people whom they had defeated in the election, and there never was a word about it. They pretend now that while they were in power nothing that was wrong ever happened; we were given absolute protection. Even though those things did happen, if we—because we wanted protection, because we were being attacked with shotguns and attacked in every way, our houses, our people, and our friends—wanted during that time to organise the young people of our organisation into uniforms, to put weapons into their hands, to go around and bully and bludgeon the people, I may tell you that Deputy O'Higgins would make a very different speech to the one he has just made. Deputy Cosgrave would take a very different view on a measure of that kind if it was a matter of our putting our people into uniforms and putting weapons in their hands when we were in Opposition.
It has been stated here that there is no reason to doubt the intentions of this organisation, but why blame members of the Government for doubting the intention of General O'Duffy as far as attacking the institutions of the State is concerned when Deputy MacDermot, the Vice-President of the organisation, has doubted them? He himself has stated that they caused him great "perturbation"—I think that was the word he used—that he was seriously troubled because of statements of certain lines mentioned in General O'Duffy's policy. Deputy MacDermot, who is Vice-President of the organisation, was seriously troubled because of those things. He told us, I think it was on last Sunday week in Castlerea, that before he ever agreed to a merger of his Party with that of General O'Duffy he got an undertaking from General O'Duffy about several things. Is this private undertaking given to Deputy MacDermot to be accepted by everybody? What was the undertaking? What did it recant? What was he not going to do that he had previously stated he would do, and that was troubling Deputy MacDermot? When Deputy MacDermot is troubled about the matter, can you blame members of the Government for being troubled? Deputy MacDermot has told us that he has an international reputation as a politician. He told us he studied politics in more countries than one. We know he did. He studied form in France; he studied in England, and in the North of Ireland; now he has come here; he studied in the United States and in Canada. If a man with an international reputation in politics feels there is something dangerous in the policy as outlined by General O'Duffy, until he gets a private undertaking, surely the Government are absolutely entitled, in the interests of peace in this country, to take the view that he has given of General O'Duffy at its face value. He has not given any private undertaking to the Government yet. When he does, the Government might be disposed to take a different view as to his statements on certain matters.
It has been stated that the Blueshirts brought absolute peace to this country, but the Deputies who spoke opposite, and who knew the reverse was the case, did not mention certain facts of which they were aware. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney spoke very early in the debate, and he made it his business to be absent from the House as much as possible from that out. That is unusual for Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. At a meeting in Castlebar a few weeks ago, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney told a delegate meeting of Blueshirts there of a meeting he had held on the same Sunday morning in a place called Killawalla. He told them that there was opposition present at the meeting, and he told them of the great job which the Blueshirts did in hammering the opposition that was there. He told them that after the hammering there was a perfectly peaceful meeting. What I should like to question Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney on is this point: He said that after that it was quiet; he said that after that it was quite possible to hold an orderly meeting, more orderly than if the Guards had been there. That is from the ex-Minister for Justice. What respect are the people to have for the Guards when Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney creates the impression at a delegate meeting of Blueshirts that wherever the Guards are there is bound to be trouble; that they could have a more peaceful meeting at a place where the Guards are not present. Is not that nice respect for the law by the ex-Minister for Justice?
On the night after the release of General O'Duffy the Blueshirts throughout the country were evidently instructed to demonstrate their joy, as they were entitled to do. They met in Swinford, having been brought in from places surrounding the town of Swinford. A young man walking along the footpath shouted "Up Fianna Fáil." The Blueshirts attacked him, knocked him out with a blow of an iron bar, and he had to be carried away by a detective member of the Gárda Síochána and two or three civilians. That is the type of peace that the Blueshirts have brought wherever they have gone. On the day of the meeting addressed by Deputy Cosgrave in Swinford town, and by General O'Duffy and others, the Blueshirts were advised by the speakers, I must admit, to go home early; that is, as far as the public statements were concerned, they were advised to go home early. Blueshirts from the surrounding districts were driving through the town of Kilkelly on their way home in two lorries belonging to Deputy Dillon. There were four people standing outside a shop in Kilkelly. Not one of the four was over 21 years of age. They shouted "Up de Valera," or "Up Fianna Fáil," I do not know which, three or four times. They kept shouting, possibly, the whole time as the Blueshirts were coming down the street. The Blueshirts got off the lorries and beat two of those fellows with iron bars that they had in their possession. A man who takes absolutely no part in politics, and who happened to be standing at his shop door, rushed out, and tried to pull one of the young lads away. He was hit on the head with an iron bar by one of the Blueshirts, and the window of his shop was broken. They smashed the window of his shop, and four of them attempted to pull down a petrol tank which was at the door. There was absolute riot in the place for at least half an hour, created by the Blueshirts. There was no disturbance until they came there; there would have been no disturbance if they had continued on their way. Deputies opposite may smile at that, and think that after all that is only my side of it, but I have here a statement written by a member of the organisation and published in the Western People. This incident was reported in the Mayo News, and I have a letter here from a Blueshirt in Kilkelly, who writes to explain it away. He says this: “An article appeared in last week's Mayo News headed ‘Blueshirts' blackguardism in Kilkelly,’ and went on to say that Blueshirts returning from Swinford meeting attacked people and broke their windows. It is true a window was broken, but not a plateglass window, as stated. What really caused the trouble was this: as those young men were proceeding home, quietly and orderly, a gang of hooligans, aided and abetted by some people here who should have known better, commenced to jeer and shout at them, and even before they reached the square they were shouted at by some very nice young ladies, and a few more ancient ones who should be shouting at their own sons. In the rush which the Blueshirts made on the mob a window got broken, which a sum of about 5/- would repair. That was the only harm done, as the heroic mob ran too fast for the Blueshirts.” What harm would be done if the heroic mob did not run too fast? Are the Blueshirts entitled, as they appear to feel they are, to jump off lorries on every occasion on which people shout “Up Fianna Fáil,” or anything else, and smash those people's heads with iron bars? Is that the type of thing to which any Government could close its eyes? We have also a statement signed by a Blueshirt in the Western People of the week before last, which criticised a statement published in the local paper about certain blackguardly acts by Blueshirts. It sets out:—
"On behalf of the young men whom I had the pleasure to travel with, I wish to return thanks for the protection given us, even though we were quite capable of protecting ourselves and would have proved it if the occasion had arisen for doing so."
Comment on this
That is the attitude, and we get "hear, hear," from Deputy McGuire, who, by the way, has not worn a blue shirt yet.
Comment on this
You may have tried it on before the mirror and looked at it, but not in public. To that attitude, there comes "hear, hear," from Deputy McGuire. Are organisations throughout the country to dress up in military kit of that kind and to go trailing their coats all over the country before everybody who opposes them politically or otherwise? Are they to be allowed to say: "If you hit me, I will hit you"? Is that the method the people over there would adopt to give us peace?
Comment on this
Very well, we will take you at your own word. We had General O'Duffy stating at a meeting of Blueshirts in the South of Ireland, a few weeks ago, that for every blow they got they would give back nine.
Comment on this
That is the type of thing the Government is up against. That is the type of thing that hot-headed young men about whom Deputy Dr. O'Higgins appears to be greatly concerned are to hear every day in the year, but, mind you, Deputy McGuire would never say that in public.
Comment on this
Because there was a time when more than broken bottles were being thrown and when the Party opposite were in much greater danger than they are in now and Deputy McGuire did not even throw a bottle.
Comment on this
I would advise the Deputy to get on to the motion before the House and to get away from personalities.
Comment on this
Might I refer to the fact that Deputy Cleary used the phrase "dirty rat" to a Deputy last night and he was not called to order for it?
Comment on this
I do not know whether the Deputy intends to criticise the rulings of the Chair or the conduct of any other occupant of it, both of which would be disorderly.
Comment on this
What I want to know from the Opposition is if their methods in Opposition are to be taken as those in statements issued by members of their organisation? Are their methods to be those of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney who impresses on the Blueshirts wherever they come together that they can have more peaceful meetings anywhere they go without the help of the Guards? Are they to go trailing their coats and declaring from the house tops that for every blow they get, they are going to give back nine? Is there simply to be mob law in that way and that the strongest party is to win—that the party that gives the most blows back is the party that must rule? What about the Government forces? Have the Government no responsibility? Are they to be left out of it? I would ask the Opposition whether, when they were a Government, if any responsible Deputy or man in public life made a statement urging on his supporters to go in for mob law and nothing else, they would quietly sit down and give their benediction to such pronouncements? That is the serious point about it. I do assert that long before there was anything in the nature of serious disturbance in this country, Senator Blythe used these words, without any provocation whatever, in Clifden: "The A.C.A."—as it was then—"would knock smithereens out of the I.R.A." I assert that when a man like Senator Blythe was put in a very inferior position, was cast out of public life by the people as the people were entitled to do, he became so embittered, as did the men over there, that their only care was to smash the Government in office and prevent any rule by Government here. He started out in Clifden and members of his organisation have carried the ramp on ever since, that the A.C.A. or whatever they might call it, were there to smash to smithereens anybody who opposed them, in the hope that ordered conditions would be made absolutely impossible here.
So well was the ramp carried on and with such enthusiasm—and I must admit that it must have taken a lot of enthusiasm—that pacifist Deputy Dillon down in Cork said, with his chest out: "We do not want to fight but, by Jingo, if we do——." Every place they went they trailed their coats, and in every village into which they went they irritated the minds of the people so much that a nasty, bitter atmosphere was left behind, an atmosphere even more bitter than the dying atmosphere of the civil war. Those of the Deputies in Opposition who, not like Deputy Dillon or Deputy McGuire, are long enough in public life to appreciate these things, should realise that that is one of the things that should not be encouraged in public life, and I venture to say that even Deputy Doctor O'Higgins, in his best moments, does not agree with his Party going around trailing their coats in that way and irritating the minds of the people.
We have talk about the I.R.A. having arms and I should like to speak pretty frankly about this matter. This Government has been in office for about two years. Are they to be blamed because they have not done in two years what Deputy Cosgrave did not do in ten? Is that the case made by the Opposition? Are we supposed to be so superior to them that we should have done in two years what they should have done in ten? Is that the charge they are going to make? Deputy Dillon will probably say—it is like what he would say— that the I.R.A. have arms. Why not have the question of those arms directed towards Deputy Cosgrave, and why not ask him what efforts he made during his ten years to collect arms from unauthorised people in this State or what efforts he made to detect crime during his ten years of office? The whole thing amounts to this, that this Government is being blamed for not doing, in less than two years, what the previous Government did not do in ten and what I am convinced, from their attitude in opposition, they deliberately refused to do, because they knew that the only hope they have in this country is to have a bitter atmosphere, a nasty public feeling. It is in those circumstances that they and the element behind them, who always thrive in that atmosphere, will probably get to the top. They talk about the blue shirts being worn in schools. The one charge they have not made against us is that the Government are not responsible for that. But they have denied absolutely that General O'Duffy is responsible. Who is responsible for the wearing of the blue shirts? Who has asked the people to go out and wear nothing else but blue shirts?
Comment on this
I did not mean that exactly. I apologise. Who encouraged the people not to associate with anybody except those who had the blue shirts on? Deputies opposite all know, because they are now reaping the first part of the whirlwind. They ran away from their campaign. They are apologising now because the school children have been made by their parents to wear the blue shirts. They took Deputy Dillon at his word. The parents thought it was the right thing to do and they got the blue shirts. Now they are apologising. They got the blue shirts because Deputy Dillon and the like of him went on with that kind of campaign without considering what its effect would be. The campaign was "Speak only with Blueshirts; deal only with Blueshirts; dance only with Blueshirts," and so on. If this campaign were applied more fully, as Deputy Dillon would like it to be, he would have to reckon in other respects. I have here a verbatim report of a speech made by Deputy Dillon in Swinford a few weeks ago. It is very illuminating to quote passages from Deputy Dillon: "Blueshirt girls when at a dance will not dance with anyone who is not a member of a Blueshirt organisation; Blueshirts will dance with Blueshirts and not with Fianna Fáil. If there is any lady with a blue blouse and she is not called out, do not forget to call her out."
Comment on this
There is statesmanship by Deputy Dillon. That, of course, is very interesting, and it is all right to laugh at. In the future, anybody who heretofore has been a wallflower at a dance can buy a blue blouse and everything will go on swimmingly. She will be called out immediately on the instructions of Deputy Dillon. It is quite a nice thing to see, a week after that statement was made in Swinford, a certain Senator, a member of the Oireachtas, stating in the South of Ireland that she was convinced that the Blueshirt was the armour of honesty. If statements by men who pose as being responsible men in public have that effect upon the public mind, what are you to expect from members of the Blueshirt organisation? It is all right to laugh at it. But what if it is carried out to its full extent? What if Blueshirts only dance with members of their organisation, what if Blueshirt children only go to schools where there is a Blueshirt teacher, what if Blueshirt Catholics only go to chapels where there are Blueshirt clergymen? Deputy Dillon should not like to have that carried out to its full extent in Swinford. Deputy Dillon is laughing, but it is not a laughing matter. We cannot bring it out. He knows what I mean and he will not question me on it.
Comment on this
What if Blueshirts refuse to deal only with Blueshirt houses? What if every member of the public who deals in Deputy Dillon's shop and who is not a Blueshirt refused to go in? What if the division is going to be so clear? What would be the effect of that division in the schools, the dance halls, the business houses, the churches and other places? What will Deputy Dillon do when that comes about? What if other organisations go out and put on their uniforms too, as they would be entitled to, and which they absolutely would if it were not for this measure? If that other organisation said "Do not dance but with Greenshirts; do not associate with members of any other organisation divided from them," you would have a very nice state of affairs here. You would then have no association with anybody except those with whom you are in political agreement.
These people carried weapons like iron bars that are now being carried by members of the organisation. Unfortunately when they met there was a knocking on the heads, there was a row, there was a brawl, but when the brawl would be taking place I am sure Deputy Dillon would be as far away as he has ever remained from what he calls a brawl. It is all right for Deputy Dillon to encourage that sort of thing. We do not want to fight, but if a fight takes place, I believe Deputy Dillon will go back behind his counter and leave his mugs to thrash it out, and if they win he will then go out and do the peacock's walk, and he will tell the people they are great people because they won. That is the type of people the Government are up against, unthinking individuals who do not think of one thing except to prevent Fianna Fáil from carrying out its policy and their endeavour to destroy the Government and destroy respect for the State. That is their only idea and their only intention. They are succeeding well as far as many of their own followers are concerned. But there are other forces behind them in their organisation who see otherwise. I think that if ever they got back into power they would have to face a situation of this kind. They would reap the whirlwind that they have sown themselves.
We had Senator Blythe stating a short time ago that if they did get back into power, these Blueshirts would not be done with, that they would be part of the State forces. This will make them become more enthusiastic, and they will do things which they would not do if left to themselves and their ordinary judgment. This sort of talk will make them do certain things that are not good. I suggest that the best thing for the Opposition Party is to have a measure of this kind passed into law, and see that it is administered with absolute impartiality in the State, and see that no petty politicians are allowed to militarise or to arm their members and dress them with uniforms. Parties apart from that can go out and address public meetings. They can insist on getting ample protection, the protection which they are absolutely entitled to get, and to develop this State just as they wish on political lines. The Government would be failing in its duty if it did anything else but bring in a measure of this kind. The Government would be failing in its duty if, when this Bill is passed into law, it does not put it ruthlessly into force against anybody and any organisation that tries to break that law.
Comment on this
Some of you will never break it. The Government must insist on absolutely peaceful conditions here, and insist on the law being obeyed. It is only under those circumstances that the Government policy can be put into operation, and it is only under those circumstances that the Government and the country can continue to prosper and to go ahead.
Comment on this
So much has been said on this Bill as to the danger of civil war and so forth, that I think it would be as well if, perhaps, a few questions were asked so far as the provisions of this Bill are concerned. In the first place, I should like to ask the Minister if, in the event of the members of the Blueshirt organisation being ordered to wear, say, blue dungarees, the Civic Guards if they met a number of men wearing blue dungarees would compel them to take them off? It might so happen that many of these men might have nothing under the blue dungarees and, accordingly, they would appear naked. In that case, would they be liable to be arrested for indecent exposure? While speaking about dungarees, I should like to know from the Leader of the Labour Party, in view of the fact that, perhaps, 99 per cent. of the dockers, who work along the docks in Dublin, Cork, Waterford, Dundalk and Drogheda, as well as the workers in the building trade and, in fact, workers in general, wear dungarees, whether he would agree that it would be unlawful and illegal for these men to wear blue dungarees. That is an aspect of the situation that I should also like to have explained by the Minister for Justice. It might so happen, if the Government Party went out of office, in the event of the Opposition wearing blue dungarees, that President de Valera, who would then be ex-President, might be compelled to take off the blue dungarees. I am sure he would look a fine spectacle without any trousers, and the people passing might call him such nicknames as Daddy Long Legs, etc. All these things can be done under this Bill, and it is, therefore, only right that we should have some explanation from the Minister for Justice.
Dealing with the provisions of this Bill, the Leader of the Labour Party asserted that were it not for the wearing of blue shirts there would be no interruptions at public meetings. The Leader of the Labour Party speaks in this House as if he represented the honest workers of this State. He does not, because with the possible exception of Deputy Corish, not a member of the Labour Party owes his election to this House to the votes of the honest members of trades unions. That is evidenced by the fact that the Labour Party has not got a single representative in the capital city of the Free State. So much for Deputy Norton's contention that he speaks on behalf of official labour. What I should like to ask Deputy Norton and the members of the Labour Party is this: is it not a strange thing that it was only when the Blueshirts came into being they thought fit to object to the wearing of any uniform that would give people the impression it was a military organisation? It is extraordinary, yet it is a fact, that whilst the members of that Party have not the least hesitation in mentioning by name the Blueshirt organisation, Deputy Norton or any member of the Labour Party, and for that matter any member of the Government Party, never mention the I.R.A. as an illegal organisation. The only explanation I can find for their silence in that respect is that, in the main, a very large percentage of the members, especially on the back benches of Fianna Fáil, owe their election to this House to the votes of members of that organisation. That is the reason why that organisation has never been specifically mentioned as being an illegal organisation. It is only when they come to deal with the Blueshirt organisation that they are clear and emphatic as regards their opinion of that organisation.
I want to state here and now that I have never been identified with anything savouring of militarism. That is not to say that if the occasion arose I would not have the courage to enter a fight and defend myself. I am not, however, one of those who look for trouble, but I can meet trouble when it comes. As far as the personnel of the Blueshirt organisation in the county I represent is concerned, I can say that it is composed of decent, honourable and law-abiding citizens. The manner in which the Blueshirts conducted themselves on their first appearance in public at a meeting recently held in Dundalk, excited the admiration of the people of Dundalk in general, and no more peaceful and more law-abiding men ever attended a meeting in Dundalk for the past 50 years. Now we are coolly told that the members of that organisation are out to undermine the institutions of this State. In support of that contention Deputy Norton referred to what had taken place and is taking place in other European countries, especially Germany, Italy and Austria. But, as was rightly pointed out by Deputy Fitzgerald, the strong measures taken by Dr. Dollfuss in Austria were taken to save that country from the attacks of the Socialist Party. As a worker, and as a member of a trade union, I say: "Heaven save Ireland from ever being under the domination of a Socialist Government." That is the explanation of the strong measures that were taken by Dr. Dollfuss in Austria, and by Mussolini in Italy.
There are different forms of what is called democracy. The democracy I have been accustomed to is that kind of democracy that instils into the minds of the people respect for law, and, in so far as workers and employers are concerned, respect for the individual rights of employers as well as employees. When Deputy Norton speaks of dictatorships in European countries, he forgets that, on at least half a dozen occasions in this House, he openly declared that capitalism must go; that there must be a state of affairs, as I pointed out previously, symbolic of the state of affairs which exists in Soviet Russia.
As far as the Blueshirt organisation is concerned, I believe it was started mainly for the purpose of having free speech at public meetings. Nobody can deny that over the Twenty-Six Counties there had been a deliberate attempt to prevent people who disagreed with the policy of the present Government from freely expressing their opinion. That is a well-known fact and cannot be contradicted. There was the insidious propaganda—I would almost go the length of calling it a diabolical propaganda—by which our young men in the Twenty-Six Counties were urged—by people who had not the courage to come out in the open and do it themselves—deliberately to upset public meetings held under the auspices of the United Ireland Party. There is no use in attempting to draw a red-herring across the trail by stating that were it not that the supporters of the United Ireland Party wore blue shirts, there would not be any opposition at their meetings. If the Blueshirt organisation never existed, or if it were confined exclusively to what is known as the United Ireland Party, these organised attacks on the liberties and on the members of that organisation would continue. I am sorry to say, from inquiries I made, that, as far as County Louth is concerned, the chief offenders in that respect are prominent supporters of Fianna Fáil.
I have gone the length of saying that, as far as my personal opinion goes, President de Valera, who is in the House at present, has absolutely no sympathy with the policy pursued by many of his supporters in the constituency I represent. I will give a case in point. I have here a pamphlet which was issued, to my own knowledge, by men who, at the last election, stood on platforms in support of Fianna Fáil. This pamphlet is headed "O'Duffy Murder Gang." The names of respectable citizens of Dundalk are given in the pamphlet, because they subscribed to the funds of the United Ireland Party. That is evidenced by the fact—and it must be within the knowledge of the President, and members of the Executive Council —that the collector was recently arrested at the point of the revolver. I am here to state that 99 per cent. of the moneys collected on that occasion came mainly from people who were supporters of mine at five previous general elections. It is a lie and a slander of the worst description to so dub decent men, who subscribed to that fund in exercise of the liberty that should be enjoyed by every citizen, irrespective of what particular Party he belongs to. As a result we know what followed. I am not going to go into these horrible details. I stated before in public that I would rather draw a veil over them. I do not and never did blame the President. I have always held that he was out for fair play for everyone in this State. If he suffers from the criticism levelled at him in this House, and outside it, I can tell him honestly, and without fear of contradiction, that the men chiefly responsible for such criticism are his own followers. Therefore, I say, let Deputy Cleary not get up in this House and impute dishonest motives to people who are members of the United Ireland Party. As far as County Louth is concerned, he will find that we have done our best to put the policy of the Government into operation, in so far as that policy tends to improve the position of the people of that county. I want to assure the President, as far as I am concerned, that he will have no better supporter in having that policy put into operation. At the same time I am entitled to disagree politically in certain respects with the policy pursued by the present Government. I have the right to differ. But that is no reason why supporters of Fianna Fáil in County Louth should endeavour to prevent the supporters of the United Ireland Party from freely giving vent to their feelings when, how and where they please.
I should much prefer that this Bill was never introduced. As far as County Louth is concerned, conditions there are all that could be desired. There is peace, and there is goodwill, more or less, amongst the different sections of the people. But, I am afraid that happy state of affairs will not continue if this Bill is passed and put into operation. I heartily join with many Deputies on this side of the House and with many Deputies who spoke from the Labour Benches in asking the Government to hasten slowly in so far as the operation of this Act is concerned, because there are many men who, at the present time, are members of the Blueshirt organisation who are of a very quiet disposition. But it so happens that quiet men can be very determined if and when the occasion arises, and I am one of them. I am one of those who never look for trouble but I never shirk it. It might be well to remind some Deputies in the Fianna Fáil Party that so far as I am personally concerned the history of Ireland—in so far as patriotism is concerned—did not start in 1916 or in 1922: that there were Irishmen before 1916 and after it, patriotic Irishmen who worked for the good of the country according to their lights. They will continue to do so. It is because we are imbued with that spirit that we want peace and prosperity in the country. I am convinced that the differences that exist at the moment between the two Parties can be adjusted; that when they are adjusted it will only be a matter of time until the major differences that exist between this country and Great Britain will be adjusted to the mutual advantage of the peoples of both countries.
Comment on this
It is an experience to listen to a lecture on the introduction of militarisation into politics and the disadvantages attaching to blue shirts from members of a political party which was founded on a dumping arms order, and forced into existence by the futility of a military mission sent by them into Russia, and by the incredulity with which their supporters in America received their grand ideas as to what could be done with an army here and the job that was waiting for it. But the propaganda must go on. The Party that has propagandised itself into power, that has kept itself in power by nothing but propaganda, that is unable to deal with the social and the economic difficulties and troubles that the country lies under, must continue its propaganda. The House passed a vote the other day for the setting up of a Bureau of Information, but that is not sufficient. We have this Bill brought in here for the purpose of blinding people's minds by propaganda, on the one hand, and giving the Government, on the other, a chance of running away from the responsibilities that attach to their office.
The various Deputies who have spoken have all taken up some particular bogey to hang in front of the people. The Minister for Justice, who, in the beginning of his speech, let, as Deputy O'Higgins said, the cat out of the bag, stated that this Bill "is frankly directed against the Blueshirts, and that is the problem at the moment." But another cat came out of the bag when he was finishing, when he charged this Party here with stirring up disorder in the country in order that, being unable to get back into power by any other way, they might get back into power on disorder. The Minister for Industry and Commerce held up before the people of the country the civil war that was facing them, and the challenge by some armed group in the country to take over by force the government of this country. He explained the simple process by which all that comes about. First, the party adopts a uniform; secondly, that uniform irritates others in the country. The third stage is reached when other parties in the country adopt another uniform and they prepare for civil war, and for the fourth stage the Minister turned to yesterday evening's newspaper and said: "See the Nazi threat to a government in power." The Minister for Finance has discovered a murder in the ranks of the organisation that they want to proscribe, and the Leader of the Labour Party finds a military dictator. He helps the President out of the position that he was not able to get into, and he brands myself, for one, as being a person who, long, long ago, wanted to be a military dictator, and clearly finds that there are ex-soldiers in the organisation. All these are terrors that are going to frighten the people of this country, they think, from looking around them and seeing what are the facts of the situation, and of organising to deal with the problems that require to be dealt with here. The problem of the Fianna Fáil Party may be the problem of the Blueshirts, but the problem for the people of this country is to get ordered conditions here, ordered Government, an impartial Administration, a chance to use their own intelligence in an ordered way, to get rid of the economic difficulties that they labour under and to go about doing their own Irish business.
People are asked to look at conditions in Europe and to look at conditions here and to give the Government permission to go ahead in this particular way. The Minister for Justice told us that because of the terrible conditions that exist throughout Europe all the Governments have acted in this way by bringing in a Bill to ban shirts. He told us about Belgium, Holland and other places. They do not tell us anything about the Bills that were brought in to banish military uniforms and badges. They do not tell us that when the Minister for Justice introduces his Bill he treats us to a translation of a speech made on a similar occasion by a Minister in Belgium. He did not recall that about September of last year English school boys, travelling into Belgium from Germany, because they wore the Swastika were arrested, deprived of their passports and imprisoned under a law that exists there, a law that prevents people wearing Nazi badges or uniforms entering Belgium. He tried to hide for us that what the Belgian Government is protecting itself for is a development in Belgium of an organisation associated with the people who trampled their country under foot in 1914.
When he tells us that the Dutch Government have introduced a law against the wearing of political uniforms, he does not tell us that the Government that introduced that law in Holland was a Government drawn from all parties, with the exception of one, a Government that had decided that it would put aside all party questions and all questions dealing with religion; that it would concentrate on matters that concerned agriculture and industry, the economic conditions of the country, and the balancing of their Budget; that it would take every step possible to resist terrorism and disorder in the country; and that the uniform law was introduced against a political party in the country that was collaborating with Communism that was disloyal to the throne, and that was out against the Constitution of the State. That is the picture that is with-held from us here when the Minister comes in here and, unable to make a case for his Bill himself, gives us the speech of a European Minister. The beginning—the first step—says the Minister for Industry and Commerce, is that a Party adopts a uniform. A lot went before the adoption of the uniform, and before the law dealing with the adoption of the uniform, that the Ministers on the far side did not tell us about. We are not particularly interested with what went before either the adoption of the uniform or the passing of the law in any European country. We are concerned with conditions here, and part of the problem that is associated with the Blueshirt problem in the Government's mind is that the eyes of the people in this country are being a little bit opened and that they are able to look at such problems without these problems being obscured in any way by the European situation. The first step is the adoption of a uniform by a political Party. Let us look at the situation here with that axiom of the Minister's in our minds. Deputy Cleary has just been telling us that from the time they got into power the first word that was on their lips from every platform in this country was "toleration." A Deputy from Mayo tells us that; a Deputy from the constituency that the Minister for Justice represents, who, the very first month he was in office, went to Deputy Cleary's constituency and his own, and said: "Get the accursed crowd out of our way." That was his litany. Ministers on the far side—the Minister for Finance—went through the country asking the people to spit on the name of Cosgrave as they would on that of Leonard McNally, Castlereagh, or any traitor the Irish people ever had to them. Ministers held up Deputy Cosgrave, his associates and his Party, as people who were not only applauding England in a certain attitude towards this country, but dictating to England what kind of action she should take. That was the toleration, and that was the type of things that Ministers in this country were saying in the spring and summer of 1932. It was no wonder that meetings were broken up and free speech interfered with in the way Deputy O'Higgins described it then. Then, he said, the Army Comrades' Association came, and it has been suggested by Ministers in this debate that the Army Comrades' Association was formed first when it was seen that the Cosgrave administration was going to go out of office, and that the purpose of the Association was to use force to throw the Fianna Fáil Government out of office.
It would prolong this debate to go into many matters in connection with it. The Minister for Justice, on one particular occasion here, has informed the House that the police authorities did me the honour of mentioning me as a person who was most active of the ex-Ministers in working up the Army Comrades' Association in 1932. The date of that police report was September, 1932. I had one connection with that organisation, if it could have been called a connection, before the date of these reports, and it was that I addressed a meeting at Beal-na-Bláth in the end of August. The line I took at that meeting was that circumstances had prevented Michael Collins being seen in his true light; that the fact that he appeared on the horizon of Irish politics in the bedraggled ranks of Pearse's army in 1916, and that he died in the uniform of a Commander-in-Chief of an Irish army, had tended to make people, particularly the young men in the country, look on him particularly as a soldier, and had tended to obscure all the magnificent work he did as an administrator, all the work he did as Minister for Finance and as the most prominent member, perhaps, of the Dáil Eireann Cabinet in the old days—all the work he did as Chairman of the Provisional Government and all the work he did in England when he went to argue the Irish cause—work not as spectacular as that of a soldier, but work that was far more important. I asked them not to be led away by the picture of Collins merely as a soldier, but to take these other pictures into their minds so that in the responsibilities of the work that would fall on them in these days they should model themselves on the worker who said: "Make anything you like of me— your Commander-in-Chief, your Minister for Finance or your Minister to London—make anything you want to make of me, and I will work in one just as I will work in the other." I pointed out that the work that had been done in the past had brought newer and different and more important responsibilities on the youth of this country than the responsibilities of a soldier. That was my association with the organisation up to the time the police reported about the magnificent work I was doing for it. If I was able to address men in that particular way, it was a compliment to the men themselves, because I was simply expressing their spirit.
A month after that, I went down to County Limerick with two other members of this House to speak on the political affairs of the time to the electorate of County Limerick. It is true that I went to tell them that the whole economic situation of Limerick county as well as that of other counties was being destroyed by the actions of a number of people, among whom were three or four they had elected in County Limerick; and that the destruction of the country could not go on without the direct vote and assistance of these men. Were we allowed to hold our meeting there? We held it; but not because the spirit of toleration that Deputy Cleary speaks about had been disseminated through the land, not because the Government was standing for the impartial administration of the law but because there were stout hearts in this country representative of the true instincts and true spirit of the people. They decided that what was fought for and won in the past was not going to be lost or sacrificed for want of a few courageous hearts to stand up for it on a day of difficulty. The Minister for Justice suggested, in response to an intervention by Deputy Fitzgerald, that he had not particulars of Kilmallock. I am going to weary the House slightly by reading some extracts from the Cork Examiner of 10th October about Kilmallock, because we had better see things in their true light.
The paper says:—
"A pitched battle was waged in the streets of Kilmallock yesterday, when an organised opposition sought to break up a Cumann na nGaedheal meeting at which General Mulcahy and Professor Hayes were the principal speakers."
Deputy George Bennett and ex-Deputy Dick O'Connell were also speakers.
"It was the first time since their formation that members of the Army Comrades Association were called into active service. Fifty of them augmented a small force of Civic Guards to the extent of rendering futile the efforts of the would-be meeting wreckers. Yet, it was no bloodless conflict in which the Association registered its initial success in assuring freedom of speech. Far from it. The results of the clash of yesterday were seen in quite a number of casualties on either side. ... That trouble was brewing was apparent some time early in the day, when large numbers of known Fianna Fáil adherents assembled in the town. General Mulcahy's meeting was timed for 2.30 in the afternoon, and just before that hour a number of young men collected at the Castle Arch, in Emmet Street, bearing two streamers, each supported on two long poles. These had the respective inscriptions: ‘Kilmallock stands for de Valera,' and ‘Remember the 77 executed; their executioner is here to-day.' Marching four deep and with these streamers held aloft in front, these processionists proceeded down Lord Edward Street, past the hotel in which the speakers were awaiting their meeting. At the end of Lord Edward Street, the opposition element sang the ‘Soldier's Song,' and here, apparently, their numbers were substantially augmented, for they retraced their steps through Lord Edward Street, again in processional order, some 200 strong. Into Sarsfield Street they marched, and gibed at Limerick Army Comrades' Pipers' Band, which waited on the street to play the speakers to the platform. The march was continued to the end of Sarsfield Street, where a halt was called. Meantime, the Pipers' Band was about forming another procession to march up Sarsfield Street, when Superintendent Holland, in command of the Civic Guards, suggested that they do not do so. The band immediately acquiesced, as did also those who had fallen in behind it. The speakers and their supporters moved to the platform ... Mr. Bennett was speaking some few minutes when the opposition crowd, now estimated at some 300, came in view, shouting as they marched towards the meeting. A dozen Civic Guards—Superintendent Holland, two sergeants and ten Guards, to be exact—moved in a line across the roadway to meet them. There was a short parley, and it was then seen that the crowd was getting out of hand and that the police cordon would be broken by sheer weight of numbers. It was at this point that 50 members of the A.C.A. under Commandant Cronin, of Charleville, intervened. The banner-bearers, egged on by the crowd behind them, persisted in breaking through. The police drew their batons and, in a moment, there was turmoil. Superintendent Holland, wielding his walking-stick, led the baton charge, while others took hold of the poles to which the streamers were attached, wrested them from the hands that held them, tore the streamers to shreds and used the broken poles as weapons of defence. Sticks, hurleys and batons clashed. Guards and civilians went down in the muddy roadway and a regular pitched battle that had alarming possibilities ensued. Then two shots rang out in quick succession, and these had the immediate effect of causing many of those on the street to run for shelter. Apparently, too, they had their effect on the opponents of the meeting, for their ranks broke and they fled back along the street. Mr. Bennett, during all this disturbance never once faltered in his speech."
Comment on this
I shall tell the Deputy anything he likes at the end of my speech. The report goes on:—
"The opposition element returned. There was another scuffle, in which many were badly handled, and there were crashes of glass as shop windows went in. Stones began to fly in all directions, and there were many narrow escapes from these. They struck against the shuttered windows of other shops and, were it not that Kilmallock business people still favour to a large degree the old-time timber shutters, the results in glass breakages would have been numerous. Comparative quiet was again restored, with the opposition group at one end of the street, the cordon of Guards—their mud spattered uniforms testifying to their zeal in the prevention of disorder— situated a few yards away, the body of Army Comrades stationed about half way between the latter and the meeting."
After attempting to attack the meeting in that way, after keeping up sustained attacks from the outside and after going to the back of the houses and throwing stones at the speakers, they realised that they could not prevent the people of Limerick being spoken to by the representatives of this Party. They went, then, a few yards away and started to hold a meeting. The paper reports:—
"The rival meeting was presided over by Mr. Michael Hayes, Chairman of the East Limerick Executive of Fianna Fáil, and the speakers thereat included Messrs. Patrick Carroll, Kilfinane; Michael Walsh, local Joint Treasurer of the Fianna Fáil Club; Seán Hayes and Seán Hogan. The latter, in the course of his address, intimated that he would send a telegram to the Minister for Justice, Mr. J. Geoghegan, informing him of the occurrence there that day and asking for an inquiry into the alleged shooting. As the result of yesterday's hostilities, seven persons were admitted to hospital in Limerick."
There were cases before the courts as a result of that. Who were the people sentenced by the courts and punished by the courts? A man who assisted the Civic Guard to stop that mob of 300 from assaulting members of the crowd and breaking up that political meeting was fined £10 because he had a revolver for which he had not a licence, the licence having expired a short time before.
Comment on this
Is this an attack on the District Justice?
Comment on this
It is an attack on anyone who is responsible. Two persons were punished by the court. One was fined £10, which was reduced to 5/-, on appeal to the Circuit Court. Those who were part of the mob were up before the District Justice. He held up dealing with them or punishing them——
Comment on this
The Deputy is contrasting, so far as I can see, the District Justice's way of dealing with one set of circumstances as against another. That is, surely, imputing prejudice to the District Justice.
Comment on this
I do not intend to impute prejudice to the District Justice but, so far as the impartial administration of the law goes, as well as the interest of free public speech, I want to point out that of the people who were charged——
Comment on this
The Deputy is suggesting, by the way in which he is dealing with the matter, that the District Justice dealt in a particular fashion with certain people and that he did not apply the law impartially.
Comment on this
I am not suggesting anything, good, bad or indifferent, as regards the District Justice. I am telling what happened.
Comment on this
It is this—that, because there was peace in the district, a case that had been held up for eight months was dropped. I only want to lead up to the type of people in the crowd—people who were not punished. Prominent in the crowd were men of the name of Fraher. They got no punishment for what they did in Kilmallock that day.
Comment on this
Surely, the Deputy is criticising the decision of the justice. If the justice did not punish these people, clearly there was no evidence on which he could give a decision against them. We cannot discuss here the decision of a court.
Comment on this
By contrast, the Deputy is implying that the District Justice did not deal out justice impartially.
Comment on this
I want to say distinctly that I wish to make no contrast, good, bad or indifferent. I want to talk of what happens in carrying on ordinary political business here. Deputies will go down the country and attempt to address a meeting. A mob of 300 will attempt to stop them. A group of young men will assist the Guards in protecting the meeting. Two of the persons who assist the Guards will be punished by the court and, so far as the others are concerned, no punishment at all will be dealt out.
Comment on this
I cannot allow the Deputy to proceed on those lines. If two sets of persons are brought before a judge, and one set, with certain political convictions, are dealt with in what the Deputy considers a harsh fashion, and the other set is not dealt with in the same fashion, the Deputy, when he comments on that, is criticising the application of justice by the judge.
Comment on this
Very good. We will leave it at that. In the mob that attempted to stop that meeting there were people of the name of Fraher, and I want to show the kind of people that that mob was made up of. The Irish Press on the 18th February published a statement about sentences inflicted upon certain people in Limerick. It stated that:
"Judge McElligott sentenced Thomas Fraher and Patrick Fraher (junior) to 18 months each with hard labour, and John Carroll to 12 months with hard labour for breaking into the house of John Ryan, Kilmallock, on the night of December 15 last, and taking £6 10s. and goods. Carroll and Fraher (junior) pleaded guilty, and Thomas Fraher was found guilty by a jury. Evidence was that the house of Ryan, who lived with his two sisters, was entered by masked men, and that while the raiders were in the house the mask fell off Fraher (junior). Fraher (junior) gave evidence implicating Thos. Fraher."
So that the only people that were punished in that disgraceful scene at Kilmallock were two men who stood out for the rights, and stood out successfully for the rights of the Constitution that our people here possess. Nothing happened to the rest, and when they had got free of their misdeeds because of the position in the district then——
Comment on this
I do not know the case the Deputy is referring to, but he appears to be referring to a judgment and a decision of a court. Of course, the decisions of courts are not subject to revision here, this House having no judicial functions.
Comment on this
I am recalling the fact that a number of persons attempted to break up a Kilmallock meeting in 1932, and that they have since been declared by a court to be of a type that put on black masks on their faces and went into a person's house at night and robbed him, and we have the satisfaction of knowing that they are putting in a period of imprisonment. That was at the end of 1932. Deputy Cosgrave went to Limerick in September, 1933. What was the situation there then? Again the Cork Examiner of 25th September records:—
"Limerick experienced one of the wildest occasions in its political history on Saturday night, when the first meeting of the United Ireland Party was held at the Crescent. Numerous baton charges by the Gárda Síochána took place previous to, during, and following the meeting. Wild scuffles for the possession of flags occurred in the streets. Bleeding bandsmen played the National Anthem as a beginning to the meeting, and were so badly injured as to be unable to play it at the end."
They were attacked, broken bottles being thrown at them as they emerged with Deputy Cosgrave from the hotel to go to the place of meeting. They were wounded in a horrible fashion and they simply staggered on, doing their duty until they reached the platform. A party escorted Deputy Cosgrave and the other speakers from the hotel to the platform. Some of that party wore blue shirts; the band was in blue shirts, and thus, owing to the assistance given to the police in Limerick 12 months after Kilmallock, it was possible to hold the meeting which it would not be possible to hold otherwise, although 27 people had to be taken to hospital as a result of the blackguardly attacks. The following day the Cork Examiner says in its leading article:—
"The country will be interested to hear President de Valera's explanation of the conduct of the unruly elements professing to support him who banded themselves to prevent the leaders of the United Ireland Party holding a public meeting at Limerick on Saturday night."
That was 12 months after the meeting at Kilmallock. The country was able to see what President de Valera had to say upon that matter. In his organ the next day he said:—
"The one thing that could defeat the people now is disorder, and we ourselves are convinced that the gentlemen who have made a profession of parading in blue shirts are determined to create that disorder."
The men who prevented the meeting being broken up in Kilmallock, and who had become more disciplined and organised as Deputy O'Higgins said, and who put on uniforms to discipline themselves and to distinguish themselves from the mob—these were the people that the President contends were responsible for the attempt to break up the meeting in Kilmallock 12 months before. Is it any wonder that the Ministry in this country, in these circumstances, find themselves up against the realities in a matter of law and order? How did they attempt to get out of the difficulty? You have the extremes to which the President was driven in August last to make a case for an attack on that organisation. He had to get up here in this House and tell the people that there was a case for getting these extraordinary powers because an ex-Minister had gone over to Glasgow, and in collusion with the British Minister had got British armed assistance to help the organisation here and to put himself and his Ministers out of office. He was driven to that extremity in August last.
He brought in his Constitution (Amendment) Act, and put it in force with that excuse. He told us the Military Courts have been operating since. With what result? Eighty plus 12 cases had come up before the Military Court under that Act and 12 of these cases dealt with the Party here for which it was specially instituted. By introducing that measure the President by the general circumstances that led up to its introduction, and the condition to which the country was reduced then, and which has continued since, was forced because he had the weapon in his hand and because he brought it in for that purpose, to use it. But the difficulty he is up against is the material that he has to work on because it is material he does not want to work on. Now the Executive sets out to create a new series of crimes and a new series of criminals. And the new series of criminals are those people who had put on blue shirts in order that they might more effectively and more orderly carry out the special duties which attach to citizenship here in our present circumstances.
The Minister for Justice is interested in files. I shall ask the Minister for Justice to look back over some past files — particular files — immediately before the passing into law of the Constitution (Amendment) Act, and to look at the position in Tipperary then. Superintendent Curtain had been killed; Ryan was assassinated. If he looks at these files he will find that there was in Tipperary a meeting attended by Seán Russell, a short time before the members of the present Ministry sent to Russia that military mission that proved to be such a futility. Russell attended a meeting of certain people in South Tipperary, and he told them to keep quiet for a while; that if they did not, the Constitution Bill would be passed, and President Cosgrave as he then was, would get powers to deal with them; he told them to wait until after Christmas. He reviewed the Army position and found that they were in possession of one Lewis gun, one Thompson gun, 67 rifles; 20 revolvers; 5,000 rounds of rifle ammunition and 100 rounds of revolver ammunition. Yet all the Minister does is to go to South Tipperary, to Ballyneale, to find a member of the Fine Gael organisation with an old revolver that has no trigger, that cannot be fired unless you push an improvised trigger with your thumb. He has to find him and send him before the Military Tribunal. That is the kind of administration that we are getting under the Constitution Amendment Bill.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy say when the revolvers, the Lewis guns and the Thompson guns were in South West Tipperary?
Comment on this
Because they had not the close knowledge or association with the people who had them as the Minister.
Comment on this
Remember what the position was. They were inspected and reviewed by, as I say, Seán Russell, who, the Minister for Industry and Commerce two years before had said, was the best man that could go to Russia on the military mission that was going. I have not the close association, or the members of the Executive at that time had not the same close association, with the people who knew of these arms and who were capable of dealing with them and disposing of them.
Comment on this
So that the Minister has to go to Ballyneale. We have heard of impartiality of administration here. We have heard talk of the tolerance that is spoken of by Ministers from one end of the country to the other. Ministers, by the talk in which they have indulged, by the charges they have made and by the propaganda in which they have engaged, have created a problem for themselves. They are running away from that problem. They are running away from the problem that they have been forced up against, of dealing, under their own machinery, with 80 cases of their own friends, as against 12 of our followers, in spite of the partial administration. Therefore this Bill has to be introduced. It will also help them to hide and obscure from the minds of the people generally the condition to which they have brought them. The Minister for Education tells his constituents of events in Germany and in Austria to prevent their hearing what he says to them in other sentences—that the Executive Council cannot provide all the money for public works, that the ratepayers will have to provide some of it or they will not have any works, to blind them to what the Minister for Defence has said in regard to taking land from people who will not use it, and to make them deaf to what the Minister for Industry and Commerce has said about the slaughter of cattle. All these problems are pressing on the people and so the Government invent the problem of the blue shirt. Propaganda is not going to solve these problems. It is evident on one side that the Blueshirt Bill is propaganda. On the other hand, there is an attempt at dictatorship if Ministers on the far side had guts enough to be dictators, but in the hands of people, in whose hands the Constitution Amendment Act is crumbling because they have not the moral courage to use it, the Blueshirt Bill, when they get it through as an Act, must and will crumble also. Meanwhile just as the material emancipation of the people has gone on, their political emancipation, the emancipation of the mind, is going on even faster, and that is the problem that is really before the Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
It is extraordinary how Deputies on the opposite benches have not got sense enough to see that they cannot have it both ways. We cannot be in a perfectly peaceful position with ex-Ministers in this State creating a scare and Deputies such as Deputy Mulcahy getting up to tell us how serious the position is. Now, we are in a serious position. There are Deputies on that Front Bench, as there are Ministers on this, who have seen civil war generated in this country and who know that the bitterness which is being created to-day is going, if it is not stopped, to bring about exactly the same situation. I lived through 1922 and I know how, step by step, the very same thing that made civil war inevitable in that period is going on to-day, and Deputies on the opposite benches ought to co-operate with us here, who have lived through the miserable period since, in seeing that it does not eventuate from it. This country is either blessed or cursed with the fact that there are such people on these two benches. It will be blessed with it if their knowledge and experience will save the country from such another civil war.
Comment on this
It will be cursed with it if the bitterness which was engendered at that time is going to continue now to create another civil war. Yes, we are up against it. This Government was elected into power on a programme which should have appealed to every Irishman, no matter what side he took in the civil war. We tried to get our people to work on the motto of Tone, to put aside the memory of the dissensions of the past and to try to come together, if we were all Irishmen, in a country that was worth saving, a nation that was a grand nation, that we should, as we were, ready to die for it, be all ready to live for it and forget the past bitternesses which, God knows, were imposed from outside. Now, what is the position we are in? When we came into office we knew that there were problems against which coercive methods had been used and which they did not solve. We came in here and we said: "We believe that our people are a noble people, that they are a sensible people, that they will recognise fair play, one to another, and that if the Executive takes time, has patience, the good sense of our people, old and young, will finally triumph."
For a year we were in office. In that year we were getting more and more peace until there was not, as can be seen if you look up the records, a period since 1922 in which there was greater peace in the land. We were attacked here in the House and blamed because we were not taking certain measures which those on the opposite benches would have taken if they were in office. They might have been necessary if they were in office. That is a fact; they might have been necessary. We were getting reports, and we knew what the situation in the country was. We knew that with the removal of the Oath and the passage of time, the peace for which we were looking, and wanted to see, would be established. The Oath was removed. There was available then to every section of the Irish people an opportunity of going before the electorate and putting their programme, Republican or anything else. They could have their representatives freely elected, owing no allegiance to anybody, to no Power under Heaven except the Irish people. And with that there before them it was quite clear that it was only a matter of time until the motives which banded the I.R.A. together would cease to operate and when, instead of having a military organisation with arms at its disposal, arms which were intended originally to fight for the freedom of this country against foreign countries and which never should be used against the people here, these guns would either get rusty or would finally, when the Republican Government was elected and a Republic declared, be surrendered to the representatives of the people.
Patience was all that was required, but human beings approach problems in different ways. Our attitude of patience was nothing but cowardice in the eyes of those who were using force. I believe in patience. I do not believe in combat, which was put as the motto of the National Guard. I believe in persuading the people to do what is right, if you can. I always knew that, if we were forced to it, the Executive had behind it all the resources of the country and, if it had to do it and was forced to do it, it could mobilise all the sensible people in the country to see that order would be kept. But that policy did not recommend itself to the people on the opposite side and we were attacked here for cowardice and weakness and every possible effort was made to force us to adopt a policy which had proved unsuccessful in the hands of our predecessors.
I have no doubt they are very happy to see us in this position, but I can tell them that I foresaw this position when Fianna Fáil was founded, and I did not shirk the responsibility of coming into this position and I am not going to shirk it now. I am not a fool in politics. I have as good experience as anybody on the opposite benches, and I believe I know the Irish people as thoroughly as anybody on the opposite benches. I knew what I was doing. I knew the difficulties that were in front of our Party unless commonsense were rapidly going to be supreme, and the gentlemen on the opposite benches, if it is any satisfaction to them to know that we are in this position, they can have that satisfaction. But I do want them to know that we have not simply stumbled into it. Let them have their satisfaction, and it is a poor satisfaction for any Irishman.
Deputy Mulcahy has told you how at Kilmallock and at Limerick freedom of speech was denied to him. I have, through my whole life, at every meeting that there was occasion to do it, asked the people of Ireland not to be tyrannical one towards the other, to give fair-play one to another. When meetings at which I was were occasionally disturbed by interrupters, and when some of the people in the crowd wanted to pitch them out, I have frequently said: "No; let us hear that man's question; let us answer his question," and in 99 cases out of 100 the answering of that question was helpful and not harmful. I do not stand for disorder. I do not stand for interfering with the rights of others, and I make an offer to those on the opposite benches now. If they quit this tomfoolery of blue-shirting, which is provocative here as it was in Belgium and in Holland, and all those other countries on the Continent, and if we cannot get by the ordinary forces of the law, the existing forces of the law, fair-play at political meetings, freedom of speech at political meetings, we will get a joint composite force, a national force, and we will preserve order.
The greatest enemies of this country, whether in 1922 or now, are the people who create disorder, because disorder, where there are guns available, is going to stop, not at fisticuffs, not at blows of knuckle-dusters, or cudgels, but ultimately it is going to lead to more serious bloodshed. Not very long ago I read a dispatch which Mr. Lloyd George sent over here in the summer of 1922, and I read the reply which the Executive of that day made, having Irish interests at heart as I will admit on seeing it. Trying to put off a conflict, they were temporising, when a spark out there in the streets set fire to the powder magazine and we had a civil war in which we were on both sides involved. Do we want that again? Are we going with our eyes open back into a situation like that? I appeal to every decent Irishman, to every Deputy here, to everyone through the country not to play the game of the enemies of our country by allowing that to happen.
We have come in here with responsibilities. We hate, I hate, everything that tastes of coercion; I hate it from the bottom of my heart. We brought into operation the Seventeenth Amendmend. We did it because I did not want to see bloodshed in the streets of Dublin, and I gave that as the principal reason, as it was. That was the immediate reason for bringing down that Act and, having it down and seeing the situation as it was, and sincerely wishing to put it aside, we have been unable to do so because of the fact that we are only seven or eight years removed from that civil war and the bitterness of that period is still in the hearts of many, and it does not require much to set fire to the powder magazine again.
We are bringing in this Bill with reluctance. We want, as a first step in securing order, to prevent the provocation of disorder. We were accused here the other day of establishing a Party propaganda bureau. We were accused of doing that by the very Deputy who himself made an excellent speech at the time he, on a previous occasion, brought a similar proposal forward. We were accused by him although he knew what we were doing has been done in practically every country in the world. We are accused of bringing in this Bill as an attack on political opponents; we are accused by people who know full well that the problem we have to deal with here is not confined to our country. The difference is that here it would be much more dangerous and terrible and menacing if it got under way than it would be in any of these countries to which reference was made by the Minister for Justice. Deputy Mulcahy would have you believe that in Belgium the reason for the introduction of the law was to prevent a foreign organisation coming into Belgium. Nothing of the kind. It was brought into Belgium to prevent a conflict between the Greenshirts and the Blueshirts. The Blueshirts were a Socialist organisation. They had been peacefully in existence for a long time but the advent of the Greenshirts and the danger of clashes between the two made it necessary for the Government of Belgium to bring in a Bill to ban all uniforms. This Bill is not merely to ban the uniform of the Blueshirts, as those on the opposite benches would have you believe. It is to ban the wearing of uniforms as a political distinctive mark by any political party.
Comment on this
I know that Deputies profess to have nothing but the most peaceful intentions with regard to that uniform, but we cannot afford to take the peaceful expressions or the peaceful intentions as expressed by Deputies as a sufficient safeguard for this country. Deputy Cosgrave appeals to his record, and asks would he be associated with any movement that might tend to overthrow political institutions or to establish a dictatorship here. I might say something which I do not want to say if I suggested that Deputy Cosgrave's assurances would not be enough to save such a situation. I think I saw somewhere that Deputy MacDermot said a dictatorship would be established in this country only over his dead body. Again I say we do not want to see Deputy MacDermot's dead body, nor do we think his dead body would be a sufficient safeguard against the establishment of a dictatorship. I tell both of those gentlemen that if this explosion which is possible should take place, or, if I were to use a similar simile, if that storm should arise, they would be only corks on an angry sea. We are not going, with our responsibility, simply to desist because we get assurances of this kind. The fact is that those assurances are not believed by a large section of the people. The fact is that statements such as those made here by the ex-Attorney-General, Deputy Costello, are not believed by the people. What they believe is that just as the wearing of shirts was but the preliminary in other countries to the establishment of a dictatorship, so here the wearing of shirts helps the banding together of people who could measure their strength, as the Belgian Minister put it, and see what are their chances of success by violence when the time arises. The headline and example of what happened in those countries is before our people's eyes, and it does not matter how you may say that that movement has no sinister purpose, it is not going to be believed by the people. Just as Deputy MacDermot said that a dictatorship would be established here only over his dead body, so there are in this country a large number of people, much larger, perhaps, than Deputy MacDermot imagines, who would say too of themselves that it is only over their dead bodies a dictatorship would be established, and who, therefore, would be tempted to attack by force those whom they suspected, rightly or wrongly, of having the intention of establishing such a dictatorship. Now I believe in liberty. I believe in liberty for the individual. I believe in democratic liberty. I believe that as human beings we are not to be dedicated to some idol of the State, but that the State should be organised for the benefit of the individual.
Comment on this
Those are the principles of liberty which are very dear to the hearts of Irishmen. There are Irishmen in this country—and I am one of them—who will die as readily as Deputy MacDermot would rather than see without resistance something established here which is going to deprive us of every right that we thought valuable. You are complaining on the opposite benches because we are introducing something here that is going to limit your liberty. What liberty would there be if there was established here that type of Fascism which it is suspected you intend to establish here? Do you think you would stop at simply preventing the wearing of badges of political organisations that might give rise to trouble on the streets? You would not. Countries where uniforms are forbidden have been mentioned. I will repeat some of them. You have Switzerland, the country, perhaps, of all others which has the most democratic organisation; you have Holland; you have Sweden; you have Norway; you have new countries like Latvia and you have Roumania; but you have also, I would point out to you, Italy and Germany. Those who are opposing the bringing in of this measure know in their hearts that if that which is feared, and which a large section of the people are opposed to, took place in this country, you would have none of that liberty which you are claiming for yourselves, and which you say we are denying you by measures of this kind. You would not then be allowed to write in your papers and speak of a gangster Government, nor would you be allowed to speak of the head of the Government as being responsible for having bombers in Dundalk. You can now say those things, although there are many of the Irish people outraged that you can say them. You can oppose the efforts of the Government elected by the majority of the Irish people to carry out its programme. You can oppose it now, but I should like to see the person who would try to oppose any programme that was going to be put forward by the substitute that you want, or at least that you are suspected of wanting.
Comment on this
I agree it is very different, but it is not very different when we have nothing to prove that we can accept the assurances of Deputy MacDermot or Deputy Cosgrave. Deputy Cosgrave is moved aside by General O'Duffy. I have listened to expressions from the opposite benches which make it quite clear to me that they would have none of the irresponsibilities which General O'Duffy has been guilty of on platforms, but they are not able to restrain him. You think when he has organised his League of Youth and when he has regimented them that you will be able to restrain him. Well, we have a solemn duty to our people to see that he will not get by force into a position to deny our people the liberties which are their right. He can go before the Irish people. If he has a programme he can get from the Irish people recognition and approval for that programme, and if he becomes a Government he can come over here. I can promise that if he does there will be far less liberty in this country than the liberty which it is enjoying to-day. He has that way of doing it, and because he has that way of doing it— as it was done in the past, as Cumann na nGaedheal were doing it—he has no reason to complain. He should not have to be dependent upon the glamour of blue shirts or the Roman salute in order to get him the support that would be necessary for him. I do not want to be misunderstood. I have no fault to find with the colour blue, none whatever. As a matter of fact, I like the colour blue and the Minister for Defence and myself showed our liking for it by choosing it as the colour for the dress uniform of the cavalry section of the Army at the time of the Eucharistic Congress. We have no objection to blue. It has, as Deputy Cosgrave said, roots in the traditional past and we have no fault whatever to find with it. I should like, however, at this stage, to say just one little word about it. A few days ago, I saw an account of a meeting down in Limerick at which Lord Muskerry was speaking. Speaking, as I remember, to the labourers of Limerick, he appealed to them in these terms:
"We have to choose to-day whether you will join our Party and endeavour to follow in the footsteps of St. Patrick or whether you will go over to Fianna Fáil and become an advocate of their thinly-disguised policy of Communism, class hatred and destruction which they are preaching in a camouflaged form."
Comment on this
He went very near it. Is there anybody here in this country who can accuse me of preaching class hatred? When Deputies on the opposite benches were indulging in it, I was not. I have never preached class hatred in this country. The reason I quote this is with reference to St. Patrick. If there is anything more contemptible than another, more disgusting than another, it is for people in any political Party in this country to try to drag in religion to help them.
Comment on this
The majority of us here in this country are of the same religion, and if any of us love that religion and love that Church, we will not seek to drag it into Party politics here.
Comment on this
I am saying it. I have always held it and have always said it and I have never attempted to do what is being done from the benches opposite. Every Irishman and every Catholic knows full well that it would be a bad day for the Church and a bad day for religion that it identified itself with political Parties. It has a mission, it has a duty, far above politics. Politicians are up to-day and they are down to-morrow. The dictator of to-day is the exile of to-morrow, and those who love religion and love the Church and want it always to be in a position in which it will be able to be above politics and able to deal with and speak to all its children with an authority that will be unsullied because it is known and appreciated to be non-partisan will deprecate the attempt that is being made here by Lord Muskerry, following others, to associate the Blueshirts with St. Patrick.
We are accused of Communism, and Deputy Mulcahy says that it is near the mark. He is far more of a Communist than I am and he knows it. I have never stood for Communism in any form. I loathe and detest it as leading to the same sort of thing that I loathe and detest in the type of State that General O'Duffy would set up, because they are both destructive of human liberty. Communism is antagonistic, as everybody who understands it feels, to that individuality of soul which every one of us was given by the Creator. I am not in favour of Communism. I do not believe in it either as a social policy or an economic policy, or any other, and I defy anybody in this country to show that at any time I have supported, or in any way trafficked in it. The Deputies yonder, in the same type of despicable work they are at to-day, when they try to associate us with it, went out on a campaign through the country and they went to the religious authorities and told them the danger that was threatening of Communism. They did that at a time when their own private reports from their police officers let them know that there was no immediate danger or menace of Communism. I asked for reports about Communism when I came into office and I got them from the former Commissioner of Police, General O'Duffy, who talks so much about it now, and he knows it is false. I have that report here. It was, I think, he said himself, a report of fifty pages. It was a lengthy report, anyhow, and I got it summarised.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I suppose this report will be made available to Members of this House?
Comment on this
I am going to give a summary—a statement with regard to counties—and the report, if necessary, can be put on the Table of the House.
Comment on this
I have got here reports which, as I have said, are a summary of that report which was got at my request from all the superintendents of the Guards throughout the country. Here is what the report reveals. Cork is a city of some industries where you might have expected if there was much Communism about to find some traces of it. And this is an extract from the report put here in the summary prepared for me:—
"There does not appear to be any definite effort to bring Communistic influence to bear on the unemployed as at present organised, for there is no distinct organisation of unemployed under Communistic auspices."
There is no Communism then in Cork and this was the position as at November 10th, 1932—no organised Communism in Cork.
In Carlow-Kildare, similarly, there is no organised Communism. The Carlow report says:—"There are no Communistic organisations in this county." The same statement is made with regard to Kildare.
In Monaghan-Cavan the report is similarly "no."
In Clare the report states:—"About 20 members of the Kilrush branch of the Irish Transport and General Workers' Union belong to the I.R.A.; about 50 more support that organisation, and their outlook could be said to be more Communistic than national." Reference is made to "a Communistic cell recently formed in Kilrush by Mr. T.J. Ryan, local organiser and Commandant of the West Clare Battalion I.R.A." That is Clare. "In Kilrush there are about 20 members of the Kilrush branch of the Irish Transport and General Workers' Union belonging to the I.R.A. and about 50 supporters of that organisation." I do not know what the position in Clare is to-day. I know that there was at that time a labour dispute and that there were difficulties in Kilrush, but I take it for what it is worth.
In Donegal two men are mentioned, one whose activities have been referred to in previous confidential reports. He gave out Russian periodicals weekly, distributing them to the local people. It is believed that he advocated Communism, but so far his activities have been confined to the locality in which he resides. In August this man was visited by a Russian lady and a few days later left. That is the position as given by the report from Donegal.
In Galway, the report does not disclose the existence of any Communistic organisation, and Galway was going to be the centre of a great Communistic Convention and I will tell you how beautifully this educator of youth is able to turn it on at a United Ireland Party Convention. In Galway there is no Communism.
In Kerry it is stated "no Socialistic or Communistic agents have so far existed or become active in the division." In Leix-Offaly there is nothing to show that any Communistic organisation exists though the report refers to attempts from Communists outside the division to bring some of the unemployed into their ranks. "Generally speaking," the report says, "Communism has got little or no hold in this division."
In Limerick, it is stated, that there was a failure to form a branch of the Workers' Union of Ireland and the report states "the president of the City Workers' Union is stated to be of a Communistic mind." But he appears to be the only Communist agent they discovered in Limerick. Now I am reading this for the House because I want the people of this country to realise how they are being humbugged.
Comment on this
The full report will be laid on the Table of the House for Deputies to read. We next come to Louth-Meath. There is no evidence of any Communistic organisation in this division or the association of anyone here with such an organisation elsewhere. That is for Deputy Coburn. There is no report of Communism in his constituency.
Comment on this
"In Longford-Westmeath there is nothing to report to indicate the existence of any Communistic organisation. A meeting was held in Longford in October, 1932, at which a certain person was expected to speak. He did not turn up. Scarcely anybody attended the meeting." In Mayo there is no sign of Communist tendencies. Roscommon: "There is no reason to believe that the unemployed of this county are allied to an organisation with a Communistic outlook." Sligo-Leitrim, two persons are referred to.
We have rather a long extract here about these two persons. One of them has been deported since. Tipperary; no evidence is given of the existence of any Communistic organisation. Several individuals are mentioned in the report who are said to have Communistic views. In some instances leaders of the branches of the Able-bodied Unemployed Men's Organisation are described as Communists, but it is not stated that they are engaged in open propaganda. Some of them were involved in the seizure of Cleeves' Creameries in 1922.
In Waterford-Kilkenny the report states that a certain person, one of the leaders of the Able-bodied Unemployed Men's Organisation, is in touch with the leaders of Communism in Dublin but that he has not disclosed his Communistic doctrine to the rank and file of the Able-bodied Unemployed Men's Organisation. That is Waterford-Kilkenny. There is, however, a further portion of the report, and it says that a certain person is stated to have visited Russia two years ago and to have brought back a quantity of Soviet literature. The Irish Mines and Quarries Union at Castlecomer is stated to be controlled by this man. There are no further particulars given of this organisation. It may be presumed that this refers to the branch at Castlecomer. Wexford: "Several persons are named as holding Communistic views, but it is not suggested that there is any Communistic organisation in the county." Dublin-Wicklow, not including Dublin: "Communistic agitators have not made their appearance." In Dunlavin the non-existence of Communistic activities is reported. But a number of men locally unattached to any organisation may, it is stated, have tendencies in a Communistic direction. "The Finglas Branch of the Able-bodied Unemployed Men's Organisation apparently savours of Communistic ideas, but they have given no trouble so far." Dublin City. Now perhaps I had better read just this: "The Workers' Revolutionary Party and the Communistic Organisation has its headquarters in Dublin. It is stated that approximately there are 400 members in the Dublin district, several of the moving spirits of the Association are Englishmen and Scotsmen. Another Communistic organisation is the Union of the Dublin Unemployed Workers Movement which at the date of the report had rooms in North Great George's Street." The Workers' College is then described. I think there was talk some time ago about this Workers' College. It was closed in June last for want of students, and it was the only Communist College that existed in Dublin.
I have gone over the reports made by the officer in charge giving information to the Government of Communist activities throughout the country. We have got those reports and watched them day by day and under our eyes, whatever tendency to Communism was there, was fading away. It was fading away because the one thing that might give it life was anything which could be regarded as an attack upon the freedom of the workers. This country is not a natural breeding ground for Communism and everybody knows it. It is opposed to our religion; it is opposed to our individualistic tendencies; it is opposed to our whole scheme of life. If there is one country in the world more than another which is unsuitable soil for Communism it is this. It was raised as a bogey by the gentlemen on the opposite benches in order to give them an excuse at one time for the Bills which they introduced and they are continuing to use it to-day as an excuse for their Blueshirts. An excuse must be given for them. One excuse is that they have to preserve order. It is extraordinary how this community of ideas travels across the water. In Belgium protection was also given as an excuse. The proper people to protect the rights of the citizens are the organised servants of the State and the State will have to procure sufficient to keep order. As I have said already, if Deputies on the opposite benches want to work for order they will find us more than willing to supply all the means that may be necessary, and if the ordinary forces of the State are not sufficient to secure order, I say our two organisations together can secure it; but they must be controlled and directed by the proper responsible authorities. There must be no usurpation whatever of police functions by unauthorised persons or by people who want to use that as an excuse for building up a political army.
I have dealt with two of the excuses. One of the excuses is the keeping of order. As a matter of fact, they know that it provokes disorder. They have complained that their people suffer. We have got complaints that our people suffer. If somebody loses a coin in the street and starts to look for it a large number of people will immediately collect around him through pure curiosity. When political meetings are held people go to them. Unfortunately opponents go as well as supporters and it is a very difficult task indeed to get opponents of a political policy to keep quiet when they hear things that are distasteful and hurtful to them. We have had scenes provoked here in this House where at least we ought to be able to control ourselves somewhat. We have had scenes provoked in this House by references one to another and to things that we do not agree upon. Something hurtful is said. The person saying it may believe it to be true, but there is an immediate response from those who do not agree. We all have commonsense enough to know that with the limited human intelligence we have, unable to see truth as a whole, each one of us only able to see a narrow facet of it, we are not able to agree about certain things and we will not view these things in the same way. The trouble about it all is that very often the more sincere we are and the more certain we are that we have got the whole truth the more intolerant we become, and the more desperate sometimes we become, if our conception of the truth is assailed. If Deputies in an Assembly like this, used to each other's remarks—our skins by this time ought to have been very well tanned— become excited when there is some perversion of what they regard as the truth, is it not obvious, that when people who have not our experience, who have not got the training we should have got in self-control, go to meetings as opponents and hear things said which they believe are——
Comment on this
The kind of interruption we complain of is not at all what the President is suggesting. The interrupters who come to our meetings start interfering before we begin to speak at all.
Comment on this
I am quite willing to concede to the Deputy that, unfortunately, that sort of thing does happen. Deputies know that on more than one occasion I have had to face people who did not agree with me.
Comment on this
I have had to put up with interruptions. I know that that is exasperating, that it offends every conception of fair play. But we are living in a world of human beings, unfortunately, and not in a world of angels.
Comment on this
Let us take that fact into account and try, so far as we possibly can, to approximate to the ideal which we think is right. We are willing to do that. As I said at the beginning, I detest it from my heart. I think it is tyrannical and unfair. It offends every feeling of mine to see any interruptions of this kind. When I say interruptions, I mean the kind of interruptions that Deputy MacDermot has been speaking about, those deliberate interruptions, as if there is anything good or right in a policy you are going to kill it by shouting it down. If the policy is right, it is going to triumph in spite of you, and if it is wrong, you give it a sort of artificial life which it would not have otherwise. There is nothing more stupid, or more insane, than the attempt to combat political opinions and political policies by interruptions. If I had my way, and if my will could do it, I would urge people going to public meetings, if they thought there were opinions going to be expressed that would be disagreeable, to make up their minds, as I have often to do here, to stay away. Very often I find the task rather a difficult one.
Comment on this
We all do, I admit, but, in the long run is there not some work that will be of some good to us? If people go to political meetings and want to hear what their opponents say, at the start they should make up their minds that they will hear things which will rile them and exasperate them. If they think they have not sufficient control of themselves, so as to keep quiet, then they should keep away.
Comment on this
The Minister for Justice tells them to go there. What does he mean by saying "keep the accursed crowd out of the Government's way"?
Comment on this
I sincerely say now, as I have said before, that I have often wondered whether this country would not be better off if the whole lot of us, on the benches on both sides, were taken out and put into some foreign island, and made to live together. I have often thought that seriously, when I see what is happening. I am quite willing to go with the Deputies opposite.
Comment on this
If I thought for one moment that it was going to mean an advantage to this country, and if I could prove that to myself, I would do it willingly.
Comment on this
If I thought it would save the country, or save it from the kind of craziness which I see he is bringing upon it, I would go.
Comment on this
Even though Deputy MacDermot might have the satisfaction, and I might have the misery, I would be prepared to do it. That is a fact. Remember that the feelings we have here and the passions we exhibit at times, are right through the country. A couple of days ago I met two deputations. One represented the Army Pensioners' Defence Association. There was a man on one deputation who formerly held high rank as a soldier. A few days later I met another deputation, and a brother of this man was on it. They had taken opposite sides. We must remember that the division at the time of the civil war has gone down, and has divided families, putting brothers on opposite sides.
Comment on this
I am not asking the House to judge who was right or who was wrong. I am asking the House to take facts into account and to remember that there is right through this country that desperate division of opinion and fierce passions which are ready to be kindled at any moment. Deputies should bear that in mind when they start a dangerous course, such as I can see to be the course that those on the opposite benches are engaged in at present. When I was in the United States I travelled through the Southern States, some 60 years after a civil war had been fought in that country. The position there was not quite the same as here. There were certain territorial divisions which kept them apart. I was entertained to a banquet at a certain city in one of the Southern States. The chairman of the reception committee was a Federal Judge and although 60 years had passed there was the same bitterness in his heart against the "Yankees" as he called them as was in the heart of his father, and in the hearts of those who were active participants in that war. If that can be so where people are separated territorially, how much more is it so in our country? Do we not know that we cannot take risks here that could be taken in other countries? Do we not know that there is a situation here far more dangerous, if it got ahead, than such a situation would be in Belgium, in Holland or in Switzerland? These countries have had no recent civil war. The leaders on opposite sides in these other countries are not relatively young men which, again, is either to the good fortune or eternal misery of this country. We are relatively young. Every member on the opposite benches and on these benches could, if driven to it, be an active participant in a physical conflict to-day. I ask Deputies on the opposite benches not to persist in trying to do this thing.
It has been said that we are a partisan Government. I say that is not true. We came into office in most extraordinary circumstances. I believe you can search the pages of history in vain to get a parallel. We were the defeated side in the Civil War of a few years ago. Then we went to the Irish people with our programme and we were elected by a majority. We came here to take over the State organisation and the State machinery, every single part of which was built up by and composed of persons very largely who regarded us as deadly enemies until a few years ago. To the eternal credit of our country I say that, and certainly as a justification I am going to admit it, because I think it is right to admit it, as a justification and proof of the professions of those on these benches now, who were formerly on the opposite benches, that these servants of the State took their orders from us. The members of the Army who were opposed to us, and who fought us physically, took their orders from us as the elected Government of the Irish people. The civil servants, many of whom served against us and used their brains and their intelligence to defeat us, being human beings could not help having their bias and their sympathies, but I can say honestly and sincerely, speaking for the Departments with which I am connected, that I have got as good service from these men as I could expect from anybody under any circumstances.
Comment on this
There is a police force which like the Army was largely recruited from former comrades of the I.R.A.—those who took one side when it divided. They had difficult work to do through the country. They were sent out unarmed and often amongst a hostile people. We can only confess, as far as we are able to know, that these officers have loyally served us. We came into office and we got service. We came in and we got that service because these men realised that we are not a partisan Government. It is said that we have been vindictive. It has been said by supporters of Deputies on the opposite side that we have acted vindictively. I ask Deputies to show me a single example of vindictive action on our side. I move the Adjournment.