We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Central Fund Bill, 1934—Second Stage.

Contributions 1–210 of 432. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Central Fund Bill, 1934
Enacted

No. 16 of 1934 ›

I move: That the Bill be read a Second Time.

Comment on this

After the eloquent speech of the Minister for Finance, I propose to be almost equally brief. Having said what I thought most important to say on this subject yesterday, I am intervening to-day only for a moment, on account of the fact that an incorrect report of something I said appeared in certain newspapers to-day—Irish and English. I said yesterday that I had no difficulty in thinking of a number of individuals —and I mentioned, as an instance, Lord Russell of Killowen—who would make admirable chairmen of an arbitration tribunal, and whose impartiality and ability could not be doubted. What I said was correctly taken down by the official reporter; I consulted the typescript of the official report. I am also correctly reported in the Irish Times, but in some newspapers I am incorrectly reported as having said that I was able to state that Lord Russell of Killowen would be willing to act in that capacity. I wish to make it plain that I neither stated that nor meant that. I have a great dislike for rash statements or sloppiness about matters of fact, so I thought it desirable to make this correction.

Comment on this

The Minister, or the Ministers, I presume, made their statement on this particular Bill yesterday. The public, of course, realise that there is a certain amount of danger that they may be misled by the way in which the Estimates appear. It may be following the custom, but even the Minister for Finance in his speech made it clear yesterday—and I think it should get full prominence—that the increase in the expenses to be met this year is not something under £2,000,000 but practically £6,000,000, and so far as I can see that £29,000 odd which we are voting is not the final Vote for this year. Apart altogether from the money that is necessary to carry on the Central Fund services, there may be many Supplementary Estimates that the Dáil will be compelled to meet this year, and, therefore, many further burdens that they may have to put on the country. I remember when the Fianna Fáil Party were in Opposition how eloquent they were on the possibility of running the country on much less than were the Budget requirements of that particular date. Some of them were so eloquent and so rash as to promise to do it, if they got a chance, on, I think, £11,000,000 or £12,000,000. Remember that that was altogether independent of the question of sums that were paid in the way of meeting the land annuities charge, or paid to Great Britain in connection with certain other claims. This was to be a saving made in what I might call the spending Estimates.

At the time, many of the opponents of the present Government found it necessary to warn the people that, if the present Government got the chance which they were asking the people to give them, in ten years the Budget would not be £21,000,000 or £26,000,000, but nearer to £40,000,000. To many people at the time that looked an absurd over-statement. Nobody could imagine that the expenses of running this country would amount to anything like that, and yet after two years of office they are approaching that figure. They are certainly much nearer to that figure than they are to the figure that was handed over to them by their predecessors. Not only from the progress that we have seen in the past under the Government policy, but from the speeches of the Ministers and from the lightheartedness with which they approach the imposing of taxation burdens and expenses on the country, it is quite obvious that we need not wait for ten years, if the present Government is allowed to continue in office, before the £40,000,000 mark is reached and passed. Anybody who has the future welfare of this country at heart need only cast his eye over the figures for the last couple of years, and it does not require very great imagination or any gift of prophecy to be able to suspect very strongly whither the Government is driving the country. Not merely was the promise made in speeches, but the promise was made, officially almost, by the Fianna Fáil Party in their published programmes, that they could run the country on something over £12,000,000, and yet the Vote on Account now is approaching that £12,000,000, and if we take the two sums mentioned in this Budget —the amount added on by way of Supplementary Estimates—we have surpassed for a mere one-third of the year what the Government undertook to run the country for for a whole year. As I say, the fears that many of us expressed in the last years of the office of the late Government have proved well-founded, that if these Fianna Fáil Deputies got into power, they would show themselves to be exactly as spendthrift in the management of the nation's finances as their supporters in local administration had proved themselves to be, and that they would be as prodigal and as wasteful of the nation's resources as they have been prodigal and wasteful of the moral foundations of the country.

The promise at that time—and we all remember how it was placarded all over the country—was economy. State services were too costly, and administration expenses must be cut down. What are the facts? Everybody, unfortunately can see them too clearly. Is the boast now of economy? Does the Government even pretend it is? What was the lesson to be learned from the speech of the Minister for Finance last evening—that the motto of a wise Government ought not to be "Save and save"—that was good enough while they were in Opposition —but "Spend and spend, and the more you spend the better for the country?" Waste and waste; money will circulate all the better; people will have time to buy more watches and clocks"—a great proof of prosperity, certainly! If the policy of the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Agriculture is allowed to continue much longer, I admit that the people will have nothing else but time on their hands and will have very little else to measure except the passage of time. The only real success that the Government has registered is in this direction of keeping up and increasing expenses. Not a week passes that the Government, that was so eloquent in reference to the cost of administration when they were in Opposition, do not create some new job, some new position. It is not merely that they are spending in various services but they are spending more in the administration itself, and the cost of administration has gone up. Remember that their promise was not to save by keeping the annuities and the other sums that Great Britain claimed were due; the promise was to effect savings and the savings were to be in addition to these withheld sums. It is quite true that they have kept the annuities, but, as has been pointed out again and again, they have kept the promise in the letter, but not in the spirit.

The annuities money goes from the farmer and more than the annuities money—at least more than is necessary to pay the interest on the annuities, which is all the English Government, I understand, is meeting at the moment. Therefore, there is no redemption of the land taking place, even, so far as these sums collected are concerned. The annuities money even goes, and obviously, we are not to be free from that particular phase of the matter until the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Agriculture have succeeded, by their conjoint policy, in destroying the whole export trade, or 95 per cent of the export trade, of this country. Then, we may be in a position to boast that not merely have we kept the annuities, but that we have kept the annuities moneys, or the moneys to pay the annuities. When the members of that Party deal with the very serious situation that is confronting the country, I suggest that, besides repeating libels on Deputy McGilligan, as was done last night, that have been contradicted and controverted in this House again and again, they address themselves to the actual facts. Falsehoods against a Deputy, even if he is an ex-Minister, should not be current coin in this House.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce boasted last evening: "We are an expanding business." His Department certainly is and so is the Government. They are an expanding business and the rate at which they are expanding is enough to give even the most enthusiastic supporters of the Government pause. I suggest that it is one of the few big businesses in the country that can boast to be expanding. It is expanding in its collecting powers, expanding in its expending powers, expanding in the staff it employs. So far as real industry in the country is concerned, the industries that are being made a real success of by the Government are the levying of taxation, the expenditure of money, and the meeting of the needs of the people by doles and various other expedients of that kind instead of allowing these things to be met by a proper economy.

However, everybody realises now what the Minister for Education was so naive as to plump out, namely, that people should not take Fianna Fáil promises seriously. The promises did the job; they got the present Government in, but to utilise them here in a debate was not, he thought, quite the thing. I suggest that all Government promises, whether on the hustings before an election or from the Front Government Benches, are pretty much of the same value. The last place you can look for truth at the present moment is in Ministerial statements, and the people know that. We listened here last week to two speeches from the same man, the President of the Executive Council. We had a Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde performance, so far as the general effect was concerned, but his followers down the country know perfectly well how to interpret those speeches. His followers at Ballybunion on Sunday, firing on people going to a meeting and arming themselves with hammers and iron bars to utilise against the official forces of the State, knew precisely what was meant. "Up de Valera and down O'Duffy"— that was the burden of his speech, too. These were the cries. It is one thing to make an appeal for the giving up of farms illegally held, but the representative of the State, in a case that was before the court yesterday, apparently, sees no harm in the arms being held. I am not now going into the question of the arms being used to fire a salvo over a grave—that is a mere nothing, judging by Government action—but the question of the arms being illegally held. In fact, an ex-Minister for Justice, a member of the President's own Party, instructed by the State, does not attach much importance to the statement of the President on that particular matter.

We can expect very little in the way of candour from any Ministerial statements at the present moment. It is useless for anybody who knows the condition of the country to suggest that the purchasing power of the community has increased. I admit that the paralysis of business has not yet crept up to the cities; but it has certainly crept in from the country to the country towns, and I have heard it said by business people and by others —and this is a little more important, possibly, as an index, than watches and clocks—that this is about the worst Shrovetide that this country has experienced for quite a long while. What is the Ministry's remedy? Their remedy is taxation—increased taxation—increased taxation must follow increased expenses. According to them, increased taxation is a stimulus to industry—the higher the tax the better for the industrial and economic life of this country. That is the new doctrine. The Minister had to wait till he left the Opposition and got into the Government Benches to realise that saving truth! Could anybody imagine such a topsy-turvy type of thinking in economics, politics, and in everything else they do? What the ordinary man in the street regards as sane, they regard as insane, and what the ordinary man regards as insane, they regard as sane. They have turned everything else upside down—nationalism, liberty, and everything else. Why should they not turn the finances of the country upside down? If the taxpayer pays, the Minister for Finance says that he can put on more—that it is proof that the taxpayer is prosperous. If the taxpayer says that he cannot pay—if he finds a difficulty in paying—I presume that the new Vote for the secret service will be used to nose out non-existent conspiracies.

The President knows that, when he made a statement in Dundalk about a suggested widespread conspiracy, everybody who read his words must have been aware that they could only have referred to a case actually before the courts. We gathered from the President's speech on the last night the respect he has for the courts. Apparently, one of the few industries the Minister has increased is secret service, and he increased it from £10,000 to £25,000. I suppose he and the President between them will be able to get such reliable information as they got in the case of that "widespread conspiracy," or as they got in the case of Deputy Mulcahy. That is the purpose of the secret service. The people's money is going to be used to ferret out lies against the opponents of the Government—to invent lies against the opponents of the Government. Naturally, if you pay out a sufficient sum of money you will get lies, all right, and the topsy-turvy President, when he gets that lie, will argue in his topsy-turvy fashion that he is conferring a benefit on Deputy Mulcahy. The ordinary man, however, will believe that he is slandering the Deputy and putting his life in danger, but, like the Minister for Finance, the President has no difficulty in saying that such a suggestion is absurd. The Ministry at present can stand on their heads. As I say, where the ordinary man sees a gross libel, they see a benefit conferred.

Right through the life of this Government so far, you have, in the case of their promises before they came into power and in the case of their performances since they came in, the proof that words mean one thing and that performance is an entirely different thing. Despite all the statements of the Ministry and Deputy Corry it is evident to everybody that at the present moment the country is not in a prosperous condition, that farmers are not in a prosperous condition, and that the 40-acre farmer is not £40 a year better off than he was before the Government took office. This should be the very last time, when the resources of the people are least capable of meeting the strain, to push this country economically into a mire from which it cannot get out. Not merely are they heaping expense on expense, but, notwithstanding all their promises, and gross and cynical violations of these promises, they are mortgaging the whole future of the country in everything they do. What is their policy? Not merely are they making the country poorer and trying to bankrupt it, but they are pauperising the population of the country as far as they can. Their policy is seen in this present Bill which is to give effect to the Vote that was agreed to here last evening, and that policy is that they are determined to try to smash any independent-minded person in this country. That is the aim of their economic policy; that is the aim of their political policy; and that is the sole outlook they have so far as this country is concerned.

In great matters and in small matters the whole future of this country is being put in jeopardy and is almost being put beyond the possibility of recovery. They are continuing the policy that should have been plain to any level-headed person from the first Budget statement of the Minister for Finance. They are continuing that policy and they are continuing in the same callous, light-hearted fashion in which the Minister for Finance introduced his first Budget. Let any member, even of their own Party, ask himself has he the same enthusiasm for that policy now as he had two years ago. Have they, or their supporters in the country, the same belief in the policy for which this money is being asked? Everybody knows that there is no such thing now as that enthusiasm. They are frittering away not merely the resources of the country but the belief and enthusiasm of their own followers, as everybody who goes through the country knows. They had a plan. They had a plan for everything. They had a plan for employment. Where are the factories, and what is the type of employment? It has been impossible to "draw" the Minister for Industry and Commerce on that particular matter. No information has been given to the public, except the merest statements from a Minister who is completely irresponsible when it comes to statements. The country is asked to rely on such statements, but no method is given to the public whereby they can check whether there is a word of foundation for the statements.

The same Minister spoke last evening of the Fianna Fáil plan in relation to agriculture. The farmers of the country would like to know what the plan is. The Ministers have had six and a half years in this House and two years of office as a Government. Have not those years and the experience which they should have got but have not got, weaned them from the weakness of regarding as a policy a few vague, general statements?

As to the Fianna Fáil plan for agriculture, we heard it very definitely acknowledged in this House by the Minister for Agriculture himself—I remember I made the point against him and he admitted it was perfectly sound—that if his wheat policy succeeded it meant more root crops and more root crops would mean more cattle. Therefore, the Minister for Agriculture's policy must mean more cattle. What for? Useless slaughter, according to the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I admit that is a policy, but the ordinary man in the country may be forgiven if he thinks it is a policy of sheer madness. And that is the Fianna Fáil plan to save agriculture—more wheat, more root crops, more cattle! What for? Slaughter. They are thinking it over —the measure is not yet ready—but that is the famous Fianna Fáil plan to save agriculture.

Everything else is in precisely the same position. If a policy of this kind were conceived outside a lunatic asylum then undoubtedly the people would take steps to see that those conceiving it were put inside the walls of the said lunatic asylum. But, apparently, it is good enough to deceive the country. The country need not be surprised at what it is getting at present. That was clear from the moment the Minister for Finance addressed himself in this House to the financial condition in this country. Gone now all talk about taxable capacity! Gone all the arguments and suggestions that taxation will hamper business! All that has disappeared. The great, supreme and sovereign remedy now to promote industries and business in this country is to increase expenses and increase taxation!

Comment on this

We were told by President de Valera that "the British market is gone for ever, thank God." What is the position of the agriculturist and the farmer to-day? We are told to till more land and fatten more cattle. Where is the market for the surplus cattle? The Minister for Industry and Commerce last night told us that cattle were making a better price than two years ago. I wonder where the Minister got his information. Any cattle that are not carrying with them an export licence are making 10/- per cwt. live-weight less than cattle with an export licence. When the requirements of the home trade are filled there remains 58 per cent. of the fat cattle in the Free State for which there is no market. I am anxious to get the Minister for Agriculture or some of the other Ministers to tell me where is the alternative market that is needed now. Those of us who live in tillage and stall-feeding districts are running short of roots and hay. What is to become of the stall-fed cattle when they are turned out? Where is the alternative market? It is not a laughing matter—it is a very serious thing. It means bankruptcy for the country. If the farming industry is not prosperous, no industry can be prosperous. It is time for the Government to waken up and get us back our markets or the alternative markets that we were promised.

We are told that the Government have done a lot for the dairy farmers. There is one thing they have done for them, anyway, in my constituency. Two years ago a dropped calf was worth £4; to-day it is worth 15/-; so that they have taken £3 5s. off the value of calves. We hear a lot about the price of pigs at present. What is the cause of the rise in the price of pigs to-day? In November, 1932, pigs went as low as 17/- per cwt. live-weight. There was a loss of £2 per head on every pig produced in the country. That is the reason why pigs are a good price to-day. When we have a surplus of pigs it will be the same as when we have a surplus of cattle—there will be no market for them.

Then we are told to grow wheat— that that is the saving of the country. Any practical farmer knows that to grow wheat you have to have rotation; that you must stall-feed cattle and fatten pigs. You will have to have farmyard manure to put into the land or you will not grow wheat very long. The growing of wheat is very heavy on the land. If a farmer is not in a position to put farmyard manure back into the land he will not be able to grow roots or to grow wheat a second year. I ask the Government, as business people, to start and get us back our market or the alternative markets that we were promised. We do not want the British market if we can get a better one, but we want that market found for us. In conclusion I can tell the Dáil that the farmers of the Free State, and especially the farmers in the County Wexford, are in a very bad way. We were promised that we would be able to get away 40 per cent. of our cattle under licence. My experience is that up to now a farmer with 20 cattle only got four away. Therefore, it is time for the Government to do something for the people.

Comment on this

Before I came into this House I was told that politics were a dirty game. During the two years I have been here I have learned that it is a very dirty game. I have listened to the speeches of Opposition Deputies and the remarks they addressed across the House to Ministers were simply scandalous. They come in here and pretend that Ministers are so inexperienced that they have no knowledge of the people and of the needs of the country and that all the genius is represented on the benches opposite. I am not inclined to place a tremendous value on words. Deputies on the other side seem to imagine that words mean a lot. I have heard misrepresentations here time and time again with regard to the position of the country and to the impossibility of doing this and that in relation to tillage and building up industries. I have no doubt whatever that all these things are going to take a considerable amount of effort on the part, not alone of the Government, but of the Opposition and the people of the country. We, in this Party, want the assistance of everybody who can help in the slightest degree to try and uplift the country to a condition of things that will give us an opportunity of having the people live here in a state of ordinary frugal comfort. To hear Deputies speak here in this House one would imagine that we were to get the millennium in this world. This world is a vale of tears and we will never get the millennium here. Let us make the best use of the opportunities presented to us and of the circumstances which exist. The Deputy who has just sat down accused the Government of making promises that they would reduce taxation. I am not contradicting him when he states that they did make promises, but I am inclined to think that they did not make the promises, they simply made statements.

Comment on this

A distinction without a difference.

Comment on this

It would be just as well if Deputy Anthony would listen to what I have got to say and he may alter his mind if he does. I am not contradicting Deputy Professor O'Sullivan in what he stated, but I am putting it that in my opinion the Ministers did not make promises. They simply made statements, and I can quite understand their making statements that they would reduce taxation if they got the power. I am speaking altogether personally in this matter and I am not voicing the opinions of the Fianna Fáil Benches nor of the Ministers. I am not in their confidence to that extent.

Comment on this

You will after this speech anyway.

Comment on this

When I have made my speech the gentlemen on the opposite side of the House will have an opportunity——

Comment on this

One honest Corkman anyway.

Comment on this

Ministers made certain statements. I am not asking the House to accept it as a fact, but the way I put it is this, that they made statements, not promises. What is the result? They came into the Dáil and they took up the functions of Government. They found, as a matter of fact, that the position was much worse than any of their worst expectations. It was much worse, and they found that instead of being able to reduce taxation they were faced with the necessity, in order to keep the people alive, of increasing taxation. What is taxation for? It is used for the benefit of the Irish people, to keep them going, to keep them alive, and I think that is a very useful purpose in which to employ the revenues of the nation. They made some sort of an attempt in the interests of the people to make the Government in some way Christianlike.

Deputy Dillon last night called attention to the fact that we shipped a certain number of cattle during a certain period. I think during this year we shipped more than last year over a certain period and got no increase in money for them. It was clearly agreed that we shipped 5,000 or 6,000 head more cattle and got some thousands of pounds less for them. What is Deputy Dillon's point? By chance, I have got the gross figures dealing with these exports. I have got certain figures here with reference to the reduced price. What do we find from these figures? In 1931 the Danes shipped 367,000 tons of bacon to England; in 1932 they shipped 383,000 tons. That is an increase of 16,000 tons. They got £1,400,000 less for the increased quantity owing to the difference in price between 1931 and 1932. Now, we will take butter——

Comment on this

The Deputy is comparing different years.

Comment on this

I am comparing two years and I will tell the Deputy why I am mentioning that. The figures are not comparable in bacon for the simple reason that the supply of Danish bacon came down by 141,000 tons in 1933. The Danes made up their minds that bacon was not paying them and that they would not go further in that trade. I want to tell the Deputies that those conditions that they object to and complain of here exist in other countries. One would imagine from the talk used by the Deputies here that those conditions do not exist in any other country but this and that it was the fault of the Government. In the case of butter, the Danes shipped in 1932 6,000 tons more butter to England than they did in 1931. But they got £2,200,000 less for it.

To come back to the bacon trade developed by the Danes, I remember when the Danish bacon trade started the Danes did not know how to cure it and in the month of June it used to be returned to the wholesalers in Manchester and the Danes had to stand the loss of that. That was some 40 years ago. In 1931, the Danes shipped 367,000 tons of bacon to England. We shipped in that year 14,800 tons or the equivalent of about two weeks' supply of the Danes. The Danes had no political dispute with England about the Oath. They had no economic dispute with England about the annuities. The English Government calmly turned about and told the Danes: "Keep down your supply of bacon by 20 per cent." What does 20 per cent. represent? About 70,000 tons. That represents, according to the size of pigs cured for bacon in Denmark, about 1¼ million pigs. The Danes were told to find a market for their pigs elsewhere, that the English could not take them. The poor simple Danes!

I read to-day in a paper connected with the trade that a few years previous to that the Danes were congratulating themselves on the enormous quantity of bacon they shipped to England. They stated that if they shipped less they might have got more money for it, but that the policy they were adopting was not without its compensation because of the fact that their bacon on account of the lower prices penetrated into the lower strata of society and that when the price rose these people would still get Danish bacon. The Danes did not expect that they were going to be cut off in the way they were, that they would be asked to reduce their export of pigs by 1¼ millions and that they would have to get rid of that number elsewhere. The Danes got rid of not alone 1¼ million pigs but of 2½ million pigs. In 1931, they shipped 367,000 tons and this was cut down in 1933 to 226,000 tons, that is a reduction of 141,000 tons of bacon.

I do not want to take up the time of the House at too great a length but I want to get Deputies to see these things from a different point of view. Those figures are from the trade returns for the year 1933 given here for the advantage of their readers by the Grocer newspapers. We hear a tremendous lot about the British Commonwealth of Nations. I believe that Deputy MacDermot is very anxious that we should remain in the British Commonwealth of Nations. He does not say so, but one can read between the lines. Here is a gem, and they are official British figures. In 1933 the Danes shipped to England 125,000 tons of butter, New Zealand shipped to England in the same year 125,000 tons of butter. I know something about the butter trade and, honestly, if I were asked which butter I would prefer I would certainly say Danish. The 125,000 tons of butter were worth, I should say, about £250,000 more than the New Zealand butter. The Danes got £15,000,000 for butter in 1933 and the New Zealanders, for butter practically as good, only got £10,000,000, so that £5,000,000 less was given to the daughter of the Empire than was given to the Danes. The fact is that the Danes have an alternative market. That is the reason they were able to command their price. We cannot get these markets because others are in possession of them—90 per cent. of them.

Comment on this

What are you going to do?

Comment on this

What alternative markets have the Danes?

Comment on this

We hear Deputies talking continually about what Ministers intend, and what they do not intend. The Deputies draw on their imagination. It is what they think Ministers think they tell the people and this House. They reiterate the same thing ad nauseam. There is direct misrepresentation of the Government's intentions. Deputies and ex-Ministers should be very careful, because they have got a duty to the people. They are part of the Government here, being the official Opposition, and their responsibility is as great as that of Ministers.

Comment on this

Tell us what they intend?

Comment on this

Yes, the responsibility of the Opposition is as great. I say that the Government found things in a rotten condition when they came into office. If any Deputy intended to build a house, if he did not make a start, the work would never be finished and his family could not occupy it. If a Government neglects the duty it owes to its people, it is a negligent Government. Every measure that the Opposition, when in office, should have taken they neglected to take, and it was left to the present Government to come in to clean up the mess. I heard a gentleman of wide experience, a man who is fast approaching 70 years—I may say that I am in the same position myself —say that if that bunch—he was referring to the previous Government —was in for another couple of years it would not be worth anybody's while taking their place. The present Government took office, notwithstanding the condition in which they found things, and they are doing their best for the country, despite an Opposition that has no consideration whatever for the people, judging by the way in which they are opposing this Government. The man I am referring to went further and said:

"If I were one of the Fianna Fáil Party I would not take over the Government until the mess was disclosed and the blame given to the proper people."

Comment on this

He did not know the Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this

I spoke of a man who was going to build a house for his family, and I said that if he did not start to build there would be no house for the family to go into. We have an increasing population because the countries of the world have closed their doors to emigration, and it is no longer possible for our people to get work in these countries. What is going to be the condition here if the Government did not make an attempt to increase tillage and to start industries? All the people will be idle. It is well known that the devil finds some mischief still for idle hands. That is what is going to happen. The sooner people with money, people who have property, and an interest in this country realise that, the sooner will they give this Government a helping hand. The misrepresentation that has taken place has been continuous on the part of the Opposition since the Government went out of office. The Opposition see that they have no chance whatever of getting back on the Government Benches, by reason of their neglect of the people's interests. I do not think it is relevant to this debate, but the reason they are giving their help to the Blue Shirt Party, by allying themselves with it, is in order that they can bludgeon their way back to office when they are strong enough. It is because they realise that their bluff has been called, and that the Blue Shirts are not going to be permitted to get sufficiently strong——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not relevant.

Comment on this

Would it be relevant to ask the Deputy why Deputy Cosgrave could not address a meeting in Cork without having it smashed up?

Comment on this

We will discuss that if I am here when we are talking on some other subject.

Comment on this

Stick to butter and tillage.

Comment on this

I have already told one story of the old gentleman who was full of wisdom. He told me another story which I would like Deputies to remember, to see if it would not in some way help to alter the behaviour of the Opposition in this House, not in the interest of the Government, but in the interests of the people. The country between Mallow and Cork is very hilly. There is a place there known as the Ballinahoura hills. I have been up there several times and I advise Deputies to go there, because the view is a glorious one. The story told me by this old man was that on one occasion when two brothers were going up the hills with a heavy load of sand the horse was not able to do the work. These brothers were giants of men. They took the horse from under the cart and one of them started to haul the load. When they got to the top the man who was hauling said: "I never in all my life had to work so hard. I did not think I could do it." The other brother replied: "No wonder you found it so hard, because I was pulling you back." The other brother said: "By that means you lose a brother." In this country the Government is pulling one way and the Opposition is pulling the other way, but between the two, if all of us do not pull together the nation is not going to succeed, and the only policy which is likely to bring success to this country cannot be carried through. I earnestly exhort Deputies to give some more thought to the general world position to-day. This is not confined to Ireland. We have a very difficult problem here—a vastly different problem from the problems of the other nations because we had our industry and our agriculture out of order and we have a new situation by reason of the increasing number of people in the country. If preparation is not made for that increasing population, there is going to be a calamity of some description. That will not happen if the Opposition unite with the Government—I do not want them to agree upon everything, but not to try to push the cart backwards.

Comment on this

At the outset, I want to deny an allegation made a few days ago by the Attorney-General. He said that I charged him with interrupting at a public meeting. I am sorry he was misinformed. I made no such charge against the Attorney-General and never thought of doing anything of the sort. From what I know of the Attorney-General, he is the last man who would be guilty of conduct of that sort. I wish all his followers were as well-behaved as he; if they were there would be no trouble. I stand, however, by what I did say and the Attorney-General can deny that if he likes.

The last speaker touched upon some points upon which we can all agree. He thinks that there should be co-operation amongst the different parties. I agree. Where he makes the mistake is in throwing all the responsibility for co-operation on the Opposition rather than upon the Government. If the Government Party wish to have co-operation, they should set the good example. I am sure that they will find the Opposition quite glad to co-operate on certain broad principles, which have been stated time and again. The Deputy stated—and rightly stated—that there is too great weight attached to words here rather than to deeds. He dissociates himself from the Fianna Fáil Party and their pledges. He says they were not pledges, that they were only statements. That is a very fine distinction. It is the first time that we have heard in this country that promises made at election meetings for the purpose of securing votes are simply statements and not pledges. I suppose that is the Fianna Fáil doctrine, but it is a new doctrine so far as this country is concerned. Whether intended as promises, or statements designed to deceive the people, the people accepted them as promises. When members of the Fianna Fáil Party were making those statements they knew that they would be accepted as promises. And they were. Therefore, they must be regarded as promises. The Party that secured a mandate upon those statements, or promises, claim now that they are putting some of them into operation, but they are doing the very opposite.

Deputy Dowdall referred to the Danes and to the business they are doing in the British market. According to our Minister for Agriculture, the Danes have been trying for 100 years to get a footing in the British market. For 100 years they did not succeed in doing that—until the Fianna Fáil Party came into power. Our Minister for Agriculture gave them an opportunity to add greater strength to their position in the British market than they were able to do for the last 100 years. This is the first time the Danes have succeeded in winning a war against this country. Instead of this being an economic war between this country and Great Britain, it is an economic war between this country and the Danes. The Danes have won, I am sorry to say. I hope, however, that we will oust them again. I hope that a Brian Boru will arise who will succeed in winning the economic war and clearing the Danes out of the position which we hitherto occupied in the British market.

Comment on this

It is an information "Boru" we are to get.

Comment on this

I hope we shall get a Brian Boru later on. Deputy Dowdall referred to our increasing population and what is to be done regarding that problem. The Opposition is quite aware of the increasing population. We are well aware of the difficulties and are prepared to make provision for the increasing population by finding employment for them. The increasing population cannot be maintained upon doles and unemployment assistance. Productive work must be found for them. Otherwise, the country will go into bankruptcy. You cannot live by spending capital on keeping a population idle. The doles and unemployment assistance will run out in a few years and the country will be bankrupt. What will happen then? We must keep to facts.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce takes credit for establishing industries. I do not want to detract from that credit. I wish him success in establishing industries. I should be glad to see 1,000 industries instead of 300 prospering in the country. The great mistake the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Agriculture made was that they virtually killed the industry that was three times as good as all the others put together. Not only that, but the baby industries the Minister is starting here are dependent on the main industry, which has been practically killed. These new industries are unable to stand upon their own legs. They are walking upon crutches. They have to be supported by tariff crutches and these tariff crutches have to be supplied by agriculture. The agricultural community are the consumers of the manufactured products of these industries. How will the agricultural population be able to purchase the products of these new industries if they themselves are getting less than the cost of production for their produce? That is really what is happening at present. I challenge anybody to deny that nine-tenths of what agriculturists are producing is being produced at less than the cost of production. In a specially favoured area where the land and climate are suitable, they may be able to grow a few acres of wheat and a half acre of tobacco and these crops may prove economic. They may even provide a profit, but you must have regard to agriculture as a whole. You must consider the whole agricultural population and take the rough and the smooth into your consideration. You must take county with county. Unless practically the whole of the agricultural population get an opportunity to produce at an economic price and are provided with a market for their produce, there is no use in talking about the produce of 100 or 100,000 acres out of the 12,000,000 acres in the country.

There is no use in talking in thousands where millions are concerned. There is something like 12,000,000 acres of land in this country, and unless that can be turned to profitable production there is no use talking about our being in a safe position. Unless agriculture is prosperous all those other industries depending upon agriculture will fall like a house of cards. It is absolutely foolish to talk about building up industry, and providing employment for the population, while the one industry that can stand upon its own legs is crushed as agriculture is being crushed in this country. We ought to get down to facts, and to recognise that the principal industry in our country is the one that must get a chance. It cannot be protected merely by tariffs. It is all very well to talk about protecting the home market, but the agricultural produce of this country would support a population of about 10,000,000. We have only 3,000,000. What is to be done with the surplus? We are told that there is going to be a Bill brought in to destroy the surplus. I hope no member of the Government has gone so far from commonsense as to introduce legislation of that character in this country. We have to give our agriculture a chance. People working all their lives, and their fathers before them, in a particular industry and district, know what they can produce properly and economically. Unless something is produced economically it is no use; we cannot afford to produce it at a loss. If everything is produced uneconomically how can you pay your way? The fact is the people are living on the nation's capital at the present time, and, such prosperity as the Minister boasts of, is a false prosperity. It is a prosperity brought about by the expenditure of capital on public and private buildings, in grants for home assistance, and one thing or another. But there is nothing being built up for the future, no return for the money expended. We have to get to the foundation some time or other. Therefore, I think we should begin with the basic industry, and give the people engaged in it a chance of making good. Then the other industries will come along, and make good, because they are dependent upon agriculture.

I heard the Minister for Industry and Commerce, when Deputy Dillon showed how the adverse trade balance has increased although our total trade had been reduced to about half, state that that was a good sign of the times. He said it was a good sign of the times to see the adverse trade balance going against us. I cannot understand that. It is the first time I ever heard it said by any responsible person. I wish the Minister would make his position clear, so that we can understand what he means when he says that the increase in the adverse trade balance, while our total trade was being reduced, was a good sign of the times.

Comment on this

That was just a statement of his.

Comment on this

Is it that he did not mean it?

Comment on this

Ask Deputy Dowdall!

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

We hear a good deal about Denmark and the position that that country holds. We are told that while there is depression here, there is also depression generally all over the world. We might agree there is depression and that it is not confined to this country. But there has been, and is, improvement in many countries at the present time. Instead of going to European countries, and comparing our position with them, I think, as a member of the British Commonwealth, we should compare our position with the other Commonwealth countries. I shall give some figures to show the position that other Commonwealth countries are in in the British market, compared with this country. Let us take for comparison the years 1931 and 1933. The Irish Free State, in 1931, exported to the British market 4 per cent. odd of the whole British imports. Although we are told now that the British people are not able to buy our goods, the most they imported from us in 1931 was 4 per cent., so that we were only able to supply a little over 4 per cent. of their requirements. But what was the position last year, 1933? Our exports to that country were reduced to 2.63 per cent. of Great Britain's requirements. That is a reduction of 38 per cent. in the value of our exports to Britain since 1931. What was the position of other Commonwealth countries? The average increase in the value of the exports from the other Commonwealth countries within the same period, that is, 1931-33, was 31 per cent. I shall give the figures for each country. Canada increased the value of her exports from 3.81 per cent. in 1931 to 6.84 per cent. of British requirements in 1933.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy know what the Canadian exports to the British market were?

Comment on this

I am taking the figures from the Independent and I am prepared to stand on them.

Comment on this

That is about the best thing to do with them.

Comment on this

Newfoundland increased her exports to Britain from 0.24 of Britain's requirements in 1931 to 0.32 in 1933; Australia increased from 5.31 of Britain's requirements in 1931 to 7.19 in 1933; New Zealand increased from 4.39 in 1931 to 5.50 in 1933 and South Africa increased from 1.52 in 1931 to 2.14 in 1933. In every case there was an increase and the average increase for all those countries was 31 per cent., whereas the Free State, instead of increasing, has decreased its exports to the British market by 38 per cent. That is the position. We are told that all countries are suffering alike, but the depression has passed in some countries. The worst time for them was the year 1931, and there has been a steady decrease in depression in these countries since then. But there is no indication of a decrease in the depression here, and it certainly is time that there should be.

Last night we were told about the price of pigs increasing since this time 12 months. Why compare the prices now with this time 12 months? Why not compare them with prices across the Border just now as the prices across the Border represent the prices to which we are entitled were it not for Fianna Fáil policy? That would be a fair comparison. The price for pork and pigs has increased all over the world, at least on the British market and in Northern Ireland. It has increased much more than it has here. In yesterday's paper I noticed that the price for pigs and pork in Northern Ireland was 82/6 per cwt. and in the Free State 58/6, showing a difference of over £1 per cwt. Taking the whole year round, generally speaking, there is a discrepancy of £1 per cwt. on the average between the prices paid in Northern Ireland and the Free State. The reports in the newspapers prove that. The same thing applies to cattle. The cattle trade has been so often discussed here that there is no need for me to deal with it now. But the difference in prices that applies in the case of pork and pigs applies also to calves, turkeys, eggs and to everything else that the farmer has to sell. I give the Government a little credit for what they did to help the dairy farmers, but what is it worth? I happen to live near the Border. I am well acquainted with the conditions that obtain on both sides of it. Last summer we on the County Cavan side of the Border got 3¼d. a gallon for our milk. Of course, that was not a great deal, but it was better than what they got on the other side. The price in Fermanagh was 2¾d. a gallon, the difference in favour of the Free State being a halfpenny per gallon. But when I say that we have to remember that half of that halfpenny came out of the farmer's own pocket, so that the net gain to him was only ¼d. a gallon more than his neighbour on the other side of the Border got. Therefore, it comes to this: that we can give the Government credit for increasing the value of his milk supply to the farmer by ¼d. a gallon. What does that mean to the farmer? Take the average 400-gallon cow in the County Cavan. It means 400 farthings to the owner, or 8/4. That is the whole gain. Against that we have to set down a loss of £5 on calves, £1 per cwt. on pork, 6d. a dozen on eggs, £6 a head on cattle and so on.

It is impossible for the country to carry on while the principal industry has been struck at in this way. The fact is that taxation has been increased by £8,000,000 since the present Government came into power. They got into power on the strength of the statements they made that they were going to reduce taxation by £2,000,000 a year.

Comment on this

Promises.

Comment on this

They were only statements. We cannot call them promises any more. We cannot take them seriously any more, no matter what they say. At any rate, they got in on the strength of the statement that they were going to reduce taxation by £2,000,000. That means, now that the Estimates have gone up by £8,000,000, that taxation has been increased by £10,000,000 a year over what it should be. With taxation going ahead at that pace how can progress be expected in any direction? Certainly the industries upon which the Minister for Industry and Commerce appears to be relying so much will not thrive. They will fail unless he tackles the root of the problem and puts our basic industry on its feet and gives the farmers a chance to make ends meet. If the farmer does not get that chance how can he afford to give employment on the land? He cannot continue to produce at less than the cost of production and not even the Minister for Industry and Commerce can compel him to do that. He cannot compel the farmer to continue losing money. If the Government want the farmers to produce, then they must make it remunerative for them to do so. Make it worth their while to do so. They are all anxious to make money and a living out of their land. In fact they have to do it as they have no other means of earning a living. When the people about whom the Minister for Industry and Commerce is so much concerned find that they cannot produce the goods in which they are interested at a profit because of the competition they have to meet from other countries they at once form themselves into a sort of a ring and say: "If we can put up a good case to the Minister for Industry and Commerce he will put on another 100 per cent. tariff on the goods that we want tariffed and then we can charge another 100 per cent. higher for our products." There is not much trouble in getting an increase in a tariff. Of course some of these people may want a certain amount of protection to enable them to meet outside competition, but as regards the agricultural community how are you going to protect them? You cannot do so because they have an exportable surplus, and in any way there is no question of protecting them. The little bounties that they are getting on the sale of cattle, pork and other things do not represent one-fourth of the tariffs that they are obliged to pay, so that instead of protecting the agricultural community and of giving them 50 per cent. over and above world prices what is really happening is that they are producing at 40 per cent. less than world prices and in many cases their losses are much greater than that.

Let me give a few instances. I am aware that bulls bought in the Free State for £3 were sold for £9 in Enniskillen. Instead of a tariff of 40 per cent. that was 200 per cent. The same thing happened in the case of sows. The trouble in connection with these tariffs is that animals of small value have to carry the same tariff as animals of greater value. There is a flat rate. For instance, you may find poor people with old cows and aged cattle. Ordinarily they would be worth about £5. Across the Border in Enniskillen they realise about that, but they are sold for about 10/- on our side. There is a difference of 500 per cent. there as between the prices prevailing on each side of the Border. In view of those conditions I do not see how the farmers can continue. The sooner this thing comes to an end the the better. I do not want to delay the House much longer, but as a practical man coming up from amongst the farmers and knowing their position, I want to warn the Minister that unless there is a change in Government policy soon the country will go down in bankruptcy. The Government should do something in time and not wait until it is too late.

I do not know how this taxation is going to be raised. The people that I know in the country are not able to pay any taxation. I would like to know what the annuities are being collected for. They are not being paid over to Great Britain. It is plain to everybody that the farmers have paid these annuities three times over in tariffs. At least they have paid them twice over in the various losses that they have sustained since this economic war started. Would the Minister tell me what these annuities are being collected for?

Comment on this

To pay for their land, what else?

Comment on this

Not according to some members of his Party. Are they being collected to buy land for distribution: to purchase untenanted land to make tenant farmers?

Comment on this

I told the Deputy.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance ought to know, and I would like to have an answer from him. What is the Land Bond Bill for if the annuities are being collected for the purchase of untenanted land? Can the Minister for Finance tell us that? If he is not able to answer it, then I will give him the opinion of some of his colleagues on the subject. Here is what one of the Fianna Fáil Party, Mr. Smith, said at a meeting in Tullyvin, in the County Cavan:

"Look at the plan the Opposition adopted in order to attack them most effectively. They said: ‘When these annuities are not being paid to Britain, why pay any of them at all?' adding: ‘If Britain is not entitled to these moneys, surely no one else is entitled to them.' They forgot that while the Government had given 50 per cent. reduction in the annuities, there was such a thing as untenanted land——"

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy please give the reference?

Comment on this

This is the Anglo-Celt of March 3rd, 1934. The quotation goes on:—

"and they knew it was their policy to take that land and make it tenanted. For that they must have money and, therefore, they must get the other 50 per cent. from the tenant farmers in order to make more tenant farmers."

I should like to ask is that what all this money is being collected for—yes or no?

Comment on this
A Deputy

Both.

Comment on this

I should like to know what is the Minister's answer?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy want a statement or a promise?

Comment on this

A statement will do.

Comment on this

You will get neither one nor the other.

Comment on this

I do not care whether it is a statement or a promise so long as it is an answer. Are we going to get that information or are we going to be left in the dark? I ask the Minister again to answer this question, because the farmers are very anxious to know the answer. Some of them are doubtful, but the Minister for Finance should be able to give us some little instruction as to what this money is being collected for, or at least say if it is being collected for that purpose. If so, what is the Land Bond Bill intended for? This House should not be humbugged by bringing in a Land Bond Bill to provide for the purchase of land——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The purchase of land cannot be discussed on this Bill. The House may discuss expenditure, and some aspect or aspects of Government policy relevant to expenditure.

Comment on this

We are dealing with Estimates, and one of the Estimates is for the Land Commission. These remarks apply to the Land Commission.

Comment on this

We are not dealing with the Estimates.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The House is discussing, not the Estimates, but the Central Fund Bill.

Comment on this

You are talking about half an hour, and the Minister does not know what you are talking about.

Comment on this

I shall not stress the matter, as the Minister does not seem to know.

Comment on this

You have said enough to make the Minister think.

Comment on this

We were promised alternative markets, but I think that the alternative markets have all gone west. I think it is generally recognised, on both sides of the House, that there are no alternative markets. I join with other Deputies on this side of the House in asking the Government, when they cannot provide the alternative markets that they promised, to get us some market and so give the agricultural community an opportunity to make good and enable them to produce economically instead of producing at a loss. If they are producing at a loss they are unable to pay taxation or support the other industries that are being started. Unless this demand is met, unemployment will increase from time to time. Instead of there being a reduction in unemployment, unemployment has been steadily increasing. It will continue to increase because no man will employ labour if production is unprofitable. The small farmers and the small farmers' sons are unemployed but they are not registered as unemployed. The small farmers with four or five acres and their sons are almost starving. They are not registered as unemployed but they are unemployed nevertheless. This is a serious matter and I appeal to the Minister to bring this economic war to an end and to give the agricultural community a chance to work their bit of land and make some sort of living. It may not be a very good living but they will be able to exist on it at any rate. I know that in County Cavan there are thousands of young men who would be away, if they could get away, out of the country. They have been told, and promised, that if they stood by Fianna Fáil work would be provided for them. There is no work for them now except a few relief schemes, but any of the industries that are started up here are of very little use to them. Not one of them is getting a job in them. I think it would be only fair, if I might suggest it within the rules of order, that in these industries that are being started up here there should be a certain quota of workers taken from counties like Cavan and Leitrim where there are large numbers of people who cannot find employment in the country. They have nothing to look forward to and they are entitled to some consideration. I think that the Minister for Industry and Commerce should take a quota of the workers from such counties and give them employment in the new factories.

Comment on this

Might I suggest that we take a vote, if there is to be a vote, on this stage of the Bill now and resume the debate on the Fifth Stage?

Comment on this

The Minister may be assured that he will get all stages of the Bill to-night and that there will be no discussion except on this stage. I submit, a Chinn Comhairle, that the most appropriate stage to enable this discussion to continue, following the discussion yesterday, is the Second Stage.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Quite so.

Comment on this

As I say, the Minister has the assurance that he will get the Bill to-day.

Comment on this

It seems to me that, whether they were promises or statements, the election advertisements of Fianna Fáil have been a God-send to the Opposition. Without them, I wonder what on earth they would speak of? This is the third Budget or the third occasion on which financial questions came up for consideration since the new Government arrived, and it looks as if this third period is to be as full of quotations as either of the other two periods. It looks as if the mental laziness that has characterised the Opposition, since they became an Opposition at all events, is going to express itself in simply repeating useless quotations from Fianna Fáil speakers once again. It is very disappointing, very disappointing at all events for those who do not feel that the time has yet arrived for a Fascist Government in this country, and who believe that this Dáil is the best way to settle the problems of the country and to keep the country in existence as a going concern. It is very disappointing to find that the Opposition which had ten long years of government, and the Ministers of which must have again and again discussed these financial problems—must have repeatedly looked around for experiments and new methods in the matter of financial expenditure—are now satisfied on all big occasions to take refuge behind quotations. It is a disquieting circumstance for the future of the Dáil that all they have got to offer the House is the constant reiteration of Fianna Fáil promises. It so happens that I am not concerned with Fianna Fáil promises, because I do not remember that I personally ever made any promises to the electorate, but whether such promises or statements were made or not, I think it is time that the Opposition really abandoned that line, and that they addressed themselves to a criticism of the financial position and financial policy of the present Government.

In all this pretty vast sum that is proposed for expenditure during the coming year, is there nothing to induce Deputies—especially those who have had experience of government—to offer some little criticism other than criticism that comes from comparing performances with promises or criticism that comes from prognosticating the most terrible disaster? Deputy Professor O'Sullivan's speech to-day was simply a repetition of the speeches he made on last year's Budget and the Budget preceding that; that the country was on the verge of ruin, that the paralysis was creeping along; it has not yet reached the big cities, he said, but is in the small towns. If anybody in this House goes to the trouble of looking up Deputy O'Sullivan's speech last year when the financial position was being discussed he will find those identical phrases and that identical prophecy—that paralysis (I think that that was the word he used) had not only set in but was gradually making headway. We know that Deputy Hogan of Galway, the ex-Minister for Agriculture, speaking on the first Budget of the present Government, prophesied that within six months the country would be in a dangerous position. On at least two or three occasions since he has prophesied that we were on the verge of bankruptcy. Now is that helpful, I wonder? Is that real criticism? In the whole of Deputy O'Sullivan's speech to-day there is nothing but a number of general statements like this: "Meeting the needs of the people by doles and so on instead of letting those things be met by a proper economy." Why cannot Deputy O'Sullivan tell us what he means by a proper economy?

Comment on this

Ask Senator Connolly, the Minister for Forestry.

Comment on this

I am speaking of Deputy Professor O'Sullivan. I am just asking why an able man like him, who has had a lot of experience of government, cannot enlighten us a little bit further than that.

Comment on this

It is your job. You undertook it.

Comment on this

Why cannot he enlighten us a little bit further than by criticising doles—we all know they are not a desirable thing—and saying that the needs of the people should be met by a proper economy? Any child in the country could make a remark like that provided he is not challenged to explain what it is. Surely a proper economy is the biggest thing in the world to describe.

Deputy O'Sullivan went on to state that the paralysis of business had not yet crept up to the cities, but it has certainly crept up to the small towns. "This was about the worst Shrovetide for years and years." What in the name of goodness is the use of making statements of that kind? As a matter of fact, I think I would be correct in saying that so far as the Christmas trade is concerned it was extraordinarily good last year and the year before. I have not much knowledge of the Shrovetide trade, but I hardly think that reference can be regarded as a serious argument. He talked of the Government pushing this country economically into a mire from which it cannot get out, and mortgaging the whole future of the country in everything they are doing. "Not merely are they making the country poorer and trying to bankrupt it, but they are pauperising the population. Their policy is a determination to smash any independent-minded person in this country." It is not at all helpful to find the leading spokesman for the Opposition relying on generalities of that kind. If the country is in a serious condition, if farming is in the very dangerous plight that it is represented to be, surely there is something more to be expected from those who take that view. Is there not something of a more detailed kind to be expected than mere statements of abuse? We all know that farmers are in difficult circumstances at the present time. There is nobody on this side of the House who would say for a moment that farming is a prosperous business——

Comment on this
A Deputy

Except Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

There is, I suggest, plenty of scope for suggestion and genuine criticism as to the system of helping farmers by means of bounties. In my opinion bounties are justified. I think they are doing a great deal of good, but I know that there are a great many people throughout the country who are sceptical that the full amount of the bounties is reaching the farmers. There you have, at all events, seeing the very large sum provided this year for bounties, reason for constructive suggestion and for genuine criticism. Yet, instead of that, we are told that the country is going straight to destruction, and that all that is required is a change of Government. I have not found the farmers taking that view. The remarkable thing is that while farmers admit they are in difficult circumstances, the very best farmers in the country are adapting themselves to the new circumstances, and believe that those new circumstances had to arrive in any case. They are glad that they did arrive, and they feel that their prospects will be very much greater under the new system than if they had been under the system where their whole reliance was based on supplying a market which varied in value from day to day, irrespective of any influence they might exercise, and irrespective of any wish on their part; which varied in its demand and varied in the prices it offered, and over which they had absolutely no control. It will be found that the very best farmers in the country take the view that that was not a secure position for farmers to rely on, and particularly that it was not a secure position on which a country should base its economy.

Considering the very short time that we have now had the new policy in existence it is a remarkable thing to me how many farmers have now come to accept that condition, and to say that they are working in much more hopeful circumstances and not at all dissatisfied that the change has taken place. Similarly, the country generally is satisfied that the industrial effort which is in progress at the present time had to be begun; that it was too long delayed; and that it is essential it should go on to its proper completion. There is nothing but enthusiasm for the efforts that are being made to balance the country's economy so that it will be no longer dependent for its requirements on other countries. There is general approval of the Government's policy. Though this bill is undoubtedly a big one—and we will not be able to judge how far it corresponds to the country's ability to pay until the Minister has presented his Budget—it is a fact, I think, that the great bulk of the expenditure here meets with the determined approval of the people. Not only that, but it has caused the people to believe that now, at all events, they have a Government in power which is genuinely desirous of helping every legitimate effort in the country, and of assisting those without property to a better and more wholesome life. I challenge the Opposition to say what particular item in the whole list of proposed expenditure they are prepared to say is uncalled for and is objectionable. They are not prepared to say that of the bounties, I think, and they cannot be prepared to say it of the big sum of £1,250,000 provided for unemployment assistance, since they themselves agreed to the Bill that went through, but, in that connection, there is surely plenty of room for suggesting as to how that sum can be reduced by the provision of public work or as to what would be the most desirable policy for the Government to adopt in regard to it. Frankly, I do not like to see that sum provided at the same time as there is a reduction in the amount allotted for relief works. On a superficial glance, it seems as if the Government might run the risk of depending on that assistance and give up the effort to employ people by means of public works. I hope that is not the case. I have only my own impression to go upon but I should be glad if the Minister would deal with that matter in his reply.

There are two or three other matters on which I should like some information; for instance, with regard to the grants for fisheries purposes. The grant under that heading is reduced substantially. Does that mean that the Government despair of making the fishery industry a prosperous industry? Does it mean that they are prepared now to let it go its own way and that the Sea Fisheries Association has not so justified itself as to enable them to continue supplying the Association with funds as they have done heretofore? That, in my opinion, would be a very regrettable decision and I should like some explanation of the reduction. There is another matter I wish to refer to before I sit down. Yesterday, the Acting-Leader of the Opposition, in his speech on the Vote on Account, referred to the Government repudiating its debt to England. It seems to me that that is a very regrettable word to use, and, particularly from one in his position, it is a most undesirable word. The word "repudiation" has a very ugly meaning, as Deputy MacDermot himself showed in the course of his remarks. The Government of the Free State, so far as I am aware, have never repudiated their debt in the ordinary sense; they have never repudiated a debt that was plainly due. They have simply challenged the claim that this debt was due and that is very different from repudiation. It is a strange thing indeed to see one who is usually so careful of his language as Deputy MacDermot using that word, obviously in an opprobrious sense——

Comment on this

It appears to me that if a nation says that a debt is neither legally nor morally due and proceeds to stop making payments of the interest on that debt, repudiation is the only appropriate word in the English language for the conduct pursued.

Comment on this

I, for one, do not at all agree with that interpretation. Repudiation would arise where payment was refused of a debt that was admittedly due, but to refuse to pay sums which you consider you do not owe and in respect of which you say: "I have no evidence that these are either legally or morally due," would not be repudiation, and I suggest that if that were repudiation we would all be guilty of repudiation in our personal affairs from time to time. Nobody is going to pay a debt unless he is satisfied that it is legally and morally due, and to be accused of repudiating a debt because one denies liability would be an extraordinary use of the word.

As I remarked in the beginning, it is a great pity, from the point of view of the prestige of the Dáil, that we have not a little more genuine criticism of Government policy on an occasion like this. I think there is plenty of room for such criticism. I think, as Deputy Dowdall said, that the Opposition have a very serious and responsible duty in the House, and I frankly think that they have not been discharging it. Their constant references and misstatements with regard to the economic war and their tendency to take refuge behind such things as pre-election promises on the part of individual members of the Fianna Fáil Party indicate that they are either bankrupt of ideas or too mentally lazy to exert themselves. I rather think it is due to laziness on their part because assuredly, when such big accounts are presented, when there is such a variety of items to be considered, it should be possible for them to offer something more useful than the rather barren contributions we have heard during the past two days. Certainly, there is no speaker from the Opposition who has made one remark that would induce a member on this side of the House to consider that the Government was not entitled to his vote on this occasion.

Comment on this

I am gratified to hear Deputy Moore awakening to the idea of mental laziness, where he thinks he sees it, and I hope that the Deputy will continue his appreciation of that particular specimen or thing, will get after it, hunt it down and begin to talk to it. If he looked around or if he could look in a glass, I think he would see a very fine specimen of it, and if he starts in a courageous kind of way to tackle the monster, would he ask himself why he does not go up to Cavan, or even down to Wicklow, and correct some of the things he said long ago, which, undoubtedly, misled people as to the condition of things then, and the prospects that were before them, and try to correct some of the false ideas they now have as regards his many statements? If he will do that, I will undertake to give him a couple of months to turn, but I cannot help giving him a kind of push along that road by asking him to remember one of the statements that he made, and to find which we have to turn, like our friend from Cavan, to the Anglo-Celt. I am not going to call it a promise, but Deputy Moore told the people of Mullinalachta in 1929—I admit that it was a number of years ago——

Comment on this

Where is Mullinalachta?

Comment on this

It is not in Cavan.

Comment on this
Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

What did Gladstone say in '66?

Comment on this

Deputy Moore said:—

"Did they not read time after time that the load of taxation on the people was greater than the country could afford?"

The date is of a certain modern significance because the taxation of this country was very considerably lower than the Minister for Finance has it to-day when Deputy Moore went out as an evangelist to evangelise the people to the cause of lower taxation. The Deputy was there anyway, and he can look up his diary if he doubts it.

Comment on this

I never heard of it before.

Comment on this

Good enough. The Deputy now appreciates how important it is, for the general education of the Fianna Fáil Party, including their knowledge of the geography of their own country, to recall some of the statements they made before, so that the Deputy will have a lesson in geography as well as in economics. But he continued to say that it was greater than the country could afford. He said:—

"...The lavish expenditure on pensions and salaries to unnecessary officials and all sorts of useless services should be drastically curtailed. It was no fault of the Fianna Fáil Party that their appeals had not been so successful as they should have been. If the people seriously desired that the money should be spent economically, they could not expect to achieve that end by electing a Government which had shown a gift for the most reckless extravagance and irresponsibility in regard to the people's money. If the men and women who went there that day looked the facts in the face they could not feel satisfied that a bill for taxes amounting to £21,000,000 a year plus £10,000,000 for local government——"

which was an exaggeration of the Deputy's,

"——all of which had to be paid before they thought of bread for themselves or clothes for their children, was fair or just in the present circumstances of agriculture...."

Comment on this

It must have been a great reporter who reported that. I never spoke so fluently in my life.

Comment on this

No wonder the Deputy would come here and cry to Deputy McGovern and other Deputies from this side of the House: "Kamerad! Do not hit us with what we said previously." There are people in this country who want to hear Deputy Moore and other Deputies on the present position, and if they hear them on the present position well and clearly enough, they will not ask the Deputies to bother about 1929. The only way in which we can bring moral force to bear on the Deputies on the far side in order to make them face their own people and answer for the responsibility which is theirs, in spite of what Deputy Dowdall may persuade them, is to remind them of what taxation was in those days and what they had to say about it then. When Deputy Dowdall speaks of statements and promises, there is a lot of subtlety in what he says; but there was a lot of subtlety used by Deputies on the far side in the brave days of old.

A Deputy of the Fianna Fáil Party then said:—

"Mr. Cosgrave costs us over £12,000 a year. We would cut down the salaries of the President and of the Ministers of the Executive Council to one-half of the large sum connected with the office of every one of these gentlemen."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will please give the reference.

Comment on this

It is from the Kerry Champion of 6th December, 1930. How much of that £12,000 has been cut down? This Deputy said: “Mr. Cosgrave costs this country £12,000.” According to that Deputy, they would cut the salaries of the President and the Ministers down to half. They would cut down considerably the expenses of these gentlemen. The expenses of the gentleman who has replaced Mr. Cosgrave have been reduced as against Deputy Cosgrave by £677. Deputies will see that it stands at £11,568, as against £12,245 for 1932-33.

Comment on this
Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

I think the Deputy is mixed up in his dates. Does the Deputy want us to follow on that line?

Comment on this

I want the Minister to understand that some of the stuff that was passed over on the country by way of statements, with implied promises and other things implied, were statements of that particular kind—that Deputy Cosgrave, when President, cost the country, personally and in his office, £12,000 a year, and that they would halve that. I want to ask the Minister how it is that he has reduced that great cost, in spite of all these statements, by simply the sum of £677. Deputy Moore, reasonably enough, asked why Deputy O'Sullivan did not give criticism—and by criticism I understand that the constructive mind of Deputy Moore means constructive suggestions—as to what ought to be done. There is just one constructive suggestion as to what ought to be done, and that is—get out! When an electrician goes into a power-room where there is something dangerous and urgent to be done, he does not usually want a bunch—to use the elegant word of the gentleman friend of Deputy Dowdall—of fellows running around him asking what does he think they ought to do. He wants to go in and deal with it himself, and there is only one useful and reasonable suggestion we can give to Deputy Moore's friends, and that is—get out; because to the people who can stand up here and ask you what they ought to do with regard to agricultural industry there is no use in giving any suggestions, if they cannot see what is plain under their noses, and that is that they cannot build up this country industrially while they are smashing up the products of agriculture. There is no use in making any suggestion to such people other than the suggestion I have referred to.

The Deputy asks, nevertheless, for some criticisms—some items that ought to be changed here. There are some items to which I should like to refer. There was a time, when the Fianna Fáil Ministry of Finance started, when it stood like a three-legged stool. We had the Minister for Finance himself and his Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Flinn, and we had the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, Senator Connolly. Then, Senator Connolly went across to London while the great scheme of the Land Act for land settlement was being dealt with here in this country—the only scheme that many people in the country looked to in order to do anything to improve production in the country. One leg of the Ministry of Finance went to the World Economic Conference in London to settle world affairs, and after he had settled everything over there he came home and he was presented with a sum of £121,804—double the amount that the Cosgrave Administration allocated to forestry in their last year of office—and he was told to take himself away to the side of a mountain with that sum of money, and we were told that we need not expect any results from him for the next thirty years. Although he came home in time to tell the Seanad what he thought about his great schemes under the Land Bill, we have not heard a word from him yet. He has gone off, as I say, with just twice the amount of money for forestry that the previous Administration allocated in their last year of office, and he has gone off to hide himself on the side of a mountain. One leg of the financial stool was gone. The second leg has been doing rather badly. It was a bit shaky when it was found that income tax was not going to be wiped out. Recently, the Minister for Finance saw a fellow in a hotel giving a tip of a shilling to a waiter or a porter in the hotel and he got the bright idea as a result of which waiters in hotels are now being assessed for income tax on their tips.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I would remind the Deputy that the Second Stage of this Bill affords a recognised opportunity for discussing certain general aspects of Government policy in relation to expenditure. The incidence of any particular tax or the method of collecting it is not relevant and should be raised at the appropriate time.

Comment on this

I only mention that to show that the second leg of the stool is completely gone and we are left with the financial stool standing on one leg. It is probably leaning up a bit against one of the Minister for Industry and Commerce's new factories. There is really nothing keeping the stool up at present but that particular kind of uplift which the Minister for Finance himself showed us that he had here the other night. It is somewhat balloon-like and gaseous on the top. It is keeping itself apparently upright, but I suggest that it is in a very unsteady position at present. It is full of uplift, full of gas, and a lot of other things that, if they could be transferred to the people of the country generally or to the Opposition, might keep us standing upright. We are presented in this spirit of uplift by the third leg of the stool with a bill for £29,709,000, where two years ago we were dealing with a bill for £21,969,000, presented by an Administration that was crushing this country under a tyranny of taxation, that was making it impossible for agriculturists or, indeed anyone else, to live in the country, except a few fat Ministers and a few fat civil servants.

When we turn, on the invitation of Deputy Moore, to consider some of the items, we are struck by certain pronounced increases. The Army has gone up by about £158,000. The Civic Guard has gone up by £991,000 and the Secret Service, on the face of it, has gone up by £15,000. Reviewing what this means we are reminded of the statement of a gentleman that the Fianna Fáil people very often quote, particularly in view of the leadership they would like to follow, a gentleman who, when he was leaving politics, said that his people should avoid the necessity of overgrown military establishments which, under any form of government, are inauspicious of liberty, but which are to be regarded as particularly hostile to republican liberty. That was Mr. Washington, on the position of republican liberty and military expenditure. The people who are increasing the Army by this substantial sum to-day are people who had a definite mentality about Army expenditure, about expenditure on the Civic Guard and expenditure on the Secret Service long ago. The second leg of the Ministry of Finance that has recently tottered had an outlook on the Army the same as his outlook on income tax. Speaking on the 11/5/29, as reported in The Kerryman, he said:—

"The cost of maintaining order in the Free State, whoever was responsible, was higher than they could afford to pay. Ireland was not a criminal country. A British Prime Minister had said that there was less crime in Ireland than in any country in the world. Why, therefore, should they maintain in this country two bodies in addition to the courts, one costing £1,800,000, and the other £1,400,000 per year just to keep them in order? Whoever is responsible for them is engaged in very unpractical politics. The cost of the irritation of a section of their population at the present time was millions of money, and it had got to be stopped. He advised any member of Cumann na nGaedheal who may be listening to him to use his influence to have that state of things ended and he would be doing more useful service to his country than anything he (speaker) could think of at the present time."

He was speaking in 1929 when he said the expenditure on the Army was £1,800,000. I should like to call the attention of the Minister for Finance and Deputy Moore to the position with regard to the proposed expenditure on the Army, the Guards and the Secret Service in the light of what happened in the past. In the year 1924-25 the total sum spent on the Army was £2,994,000. Three years afterwards, in the year 1927-28, it was £2,017,000. Three years after that again, in the year 1930-31, it was £1,133,000. In the year 1931-32, the last year of the Cosgrave Administration, the total sum spent on the Army was, £1,160,000.

One of the present Ministers, Deputy Derrig as he was then, had an attitude towards the Army when in March, 1931, just three years ago, as reported in the Dublin Chronicle, he said:—

"Huge sums of money were being annually expended on the maintenance of the Free State Army. Fianna Fáil advocated the disestablishment of the Army, and it was stated in reply to this contention that by its abolition a large number of men would be placed on the dole. That might be the case, but if they were to disband it and put the men on a heavy dole the expenditure would not be as heavy as that at present, something like £220 in the year per man."

That was the Fianna Fáil attitude to the Army. I should like to ask the Minister for Finance, the Minister for Education and Deputy Moore why they are raising the cost of the Army to £1,442,000 this year as against £1,160,000 in the last year of the Cosgrave Administration. The increase in the case of the Army as against the last year of the Cosgrave Administration is £298,000; in the case of the Civic Guard, it is £119,000.

When we come to the Secret Service we have an interesting story. In the year 1925-26 the actual amount paid out for Secret Service was £8,000. In the next two years no money was paid out for Secret Service. In the following year, 1928-29, the amount was £3,498; in the following year £1,504; in the following year £1,409, and in the last year of the Cosgrave Administration, £2,200. The present Ministry started off with an expenditure of £891 in 1932-33. The estimate which has been made yearly of that expenditure was as low as £10,000 but under the present Administration we are going to have £25,000 voted for Secret Service, as against approximately £1,500 spent annually for the last three or four years. What are we going to get in return for that? What is the necessity for the increase?

Comment on this

Can we discuss that? Can we discuss details?

Comment on this

Is it a detail to ask the House what we are going to get for an increased expenditure of over £250,000 on the Army; an increased expenditure of £120,000 on the Gárda and an additional sum of £20,000 for Secret Service?

Comment on this

The Estimates come up separately.

Comment on this

This is not a question of Estimates. It is a question of broad, general policy and a question of peace. We were told by the Ministers three years ago, that it was the irritation caused to a section of the population that was responsible for the high cost of the army and police, and that less irritation on this section of the population would mean a reduction of millions in the amount of money spent on the army and police here. It is perfectly obvious to us here that this increased expenditure this year is due to the increased irritation in the country—increased irritation of every class of person in the country who is trying to earn his living in an orderly honest way—it is due to the increased irritation amongst the farming population which sees three-fourths of their cash market wiped out, and it is due to the additional irritation that is brought about in the country because of the fact that the Ministers have succumbed to the temptation of harassing and harrowing their political opponents. We see a sample of what we are going to get for this money which is to be used for the purpose of crushing out political criticism, crushing it outside the precincts of this House. Here now we see Deputy Moore getting up in a sanctimonious way asking us a number of questions. If we take what is happening at the hands of the Attorney-General and at the hands of the Minister for Justice at the present time, if we look at the simple type of case that came before the Military Tribunal yesterday, and the various samples of shooting over graves with rifles by unauthorised people, we will understand what is taking place.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I understand that case was tried before the Military Tribunal and that sentence has not been pronounced. The merits of the case cannot be gone into. It has never been the custom of this House to review the actions of any judicial or quasi-judicial body and, though a nice distinction might be drawn in the case of the Military Tribunal, the Chair, following analogy, precedent and reason, and realising as Deputies must realise, that it would be most inadvisable to debate such matters in the Dáil, rules that review of the actions and decisions of the Military Tribunal cannot be allowed.

Comment on this

I hope, Sir, that you will not find fault with me for discussing details that you consider out of order, but I think that this is a matter of grave moment for the Parliament of this country. What I am dealing with is a matter that cannot, I submit, be ruled out of discussion here—I refer to the grave miscarriages of justice that are going on in the country. I am not going to discuss these——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy suggests that there was a miscarriage of justice in that instance, it is a matter that cannot be raised here. The Deputy is proposing to review the jurisdiction of a duly constituted court. That is a function which this House is not qualified to perform.

Comment on this

I submit that I am in a position within limits to discuss the different lines of action taken in Cork, Kerry and Mayo in these cases. I submit I am in a position to discuss the facts that different action was taken in relation to these instances by the Minister for Justice in Cork, Kerry and Mayo——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The actions of the Minister for Justice are relevant.

Comment on this

On the Minister's Vote.

Comment on this

I am talking of the action of the Minister for Justice as it affects the peace of this country and I am saying that it is possible in the case of one type of action for the parties to be brought and charged before a court other than the Military Tribunal, as in Cork, and it is possible that in the case of an action of the same kind in Kerry to have the parties brought before the Military Tribunal; again, it is possible to have another action of the same kind take place in Mayo under a permit of the Minister for Justice, given, I suggest, after the occurrence had taken place. That is the position as far as the Minister for Justice is concerned.

Comment on this

I might raise the point here that the Minister for Justice, in connection with the case in Mayo, made a statement of the facts to the House—that the permit was given on application before the event, and I submit that Deputies are expected to take the Minister's word.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Such has been the custom.

Comment on this

At any rate, I am pointing out the actual happening. I am perhaps going a little close to the wind because it is a matter of vital importance to this country. That is the case that was dealt with yesterday where sentence was given. There was a verdict of guilty and a suspended sentence was imposed. The facts in that case were that certain people were in possession of unlawfully held arms. Other cases have been brought before the Military Tribunal for being in possession of arms and ammunition held in other ways and the parties have been sentenced to an imprisonment.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not in order in attempting to discuss a sentence of that court.

Comment on this

Well, part of the reason why there is going to be an additional expenditure of £298,000 over the enormous expenditure that Ministers considered there was on the Army before their time; and part of the reason why £119,000 additional is being spent on the Gárda Síochána, and part of the reason why nearly £25,000 additional is being spent in respect of the Secret Service is because the people of this country are being unfairly and unjustly dealt with, as between the different classes, by the Minister for Justice and the Attorney-General, but the courts directly appointed by the Minister for Defence or by the Executive Council are discriminating between the different classes of people in the country. I would ask, in passing this additional money for the Army, the Gárda Síochána and the Secret Service, is that policy that we see up to now going to continue? I would further ask is the policy of neglect on the part of the Minister for Justice or on the part of the Gárda by direction of the Minister for Justice, to follow up serious crime, going to continue in the way it has continued? Will the Minister tell us is this policy of neglect of their duties by the Gárda acting under the Government going to continue? Does the Minister promise a change in the attitude of the Department of Justice? If his Department gets this additional £25,000 for the Secret Service is he going to direct them to find the murderers of O'Reilly and Daly in Cork and is he going to discover who carried out the appalling outrage in Dundalk?

The Executive Council has been asked by Deputy Cosgrave to set up an inquiry into the deliberate neglect of the Guards, on the direction of the Minister for Justice, to deal with an assembly of persons, who acted unlawfully in Dublin on the 10th February. There was a deliberate neglect by non-interference, where they knew that persons calling themselves engineers, and as being engineers of the I.R.A. were meeting for the purpose of making a mine which was to be exploded on the following day. The Minister for Justice and the police are charged by us with having knowledge that on that Saturday persons were assembling in Dublin for the purpose of making a land mine, which was to be exploded on the following day near Dublin. These persons came from different parts of the country. They were traced by the police from different parts to Dublin, where they assembled under observation. Nothing was done to interfere with them and there was the appalling outrage in Dundalk on the following day. The Ministry have denied that there is any connection between one and the other. We asked for a judicial inquiry into the whole matter. The Ministry that denies that there was any connection between the Dublin meeting and the Dundalk occurrence, know that on the following week houses were searched in Tipperary and arms got. A considerable quantity of explosives was got, also exploding apparatus and coils of wire, and it is known that people were traced by the police to Dublin. They know that one of those persons has Dundalk connections. Yet we are told, with as much brazenness by the Minister for Justice as if he was the Minister for Industry and Commerce, that there was no connection between the meeting in Dublin and the affair in Dundalk. We demand that the public shall know the full details, in the interests of the Government itself, and in the interests of a proper response on the part of the people to the administration of law. What is the use of taking £25,000 for Secret Service, if we are to get no open explanation from the Ministry as to what their difficulties are, in the first place, in arresting murderers like the murderers of O'Reilly and Daly in Cork——

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I do not think that Deputies should refer to these cases at the moment. They are under investigation.

Comment on this

It is not sufficient to tell months after the occurrence that cases are under investigation.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I ask the Deputy not to refer to the Cork cases. These are the cases I referred to.

Comment on this

The Attorney-General's face contains a certain amount of what he would like to call assurance, or that he would like to be felt as assurance. What assurance can the Attorney-General give us with regard to Dundalk?

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I would ask the Deputy not to refer to the Cork cases.

Comment on this

I am asking the Attorney-General if he can tell us about Dundalk, or if he has anything to say about the Ministry of Justice and police non-interference with those people who, to their knowledge, came on that Saturday prepared for such a deed. See the position that this House has got into, when it is asked to vote substantially increased sums for the Army, for the Guards and for Secret Service.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I will let the Deputy into what is in my knowledge about Dundalk. He asked for an assurance about Dundalk. I do not think it is proper for him to refer to the Dundalk incidents now. If the Deputy asks me to let him know, as far as I know, what is within my knowledge about Dundalk, I am prepared to let him know.

Comment on this

Surely some kind of public statement is wanted from the Ministry on the matter. No statement at all will satisfy the people except a full judicial inquiry into the circumstances of that Saturday, what led up to it, and some of the events that followed.

Comment on this
The Attorney-General

I do not think it would be proper for me to make any statement about Dundalk.

Comment on this

The position I suggest up to the present is that we have an incorrect and an untrue statement from the Ministry with regard to it. The sooner the Ministry make up their mind that they are going to meet the suggestion contained in Deputy Cosgrave's motion, the better for order generally, the better for the taxpayer, and the better for the morale of the different forces looking after the administration of order in this country.

Comment on this

The defence put up for the enormously increased taxation is the great service that is being given. It may seem rather cantankerous on my part but I object very strongly to this proposal. The President when speaking last week gave lip service to what I might call the rights of persons as against the State, but it is quite clear that in this country we are moving as quickly as we can to the condition in which we shall have a totalitarian State, to be run by the Government of the day. It has increased taxation by about £9,000,000 over what it was a few years ago. It is going to make the people of this country civil servants. The farmers are civil servants already. The Government's social policy is that the labourer shall not be worthy of his hire, because he shall produce something that will not be enough to pay him for the work done. We are told that the Government of the day has done wonderful things and has given the farmers bounties and subsidies. That means that they are getting the farmers into their grip. The only hope held out to farmers by the Government is that they shall be salaried officials, of a sort, because the Government can do what it likes with them. If farmers do not run their business as the Government decides then the bounties or subsidies can be stopped. The Government scheme includes turf, wheat, beet, tobacco and industrial alcohol. It is admitted, when a man has worked and produced tobacco, that what he has produced would not be sufficient to pay him for his work. But the Government will come along and give him a subsidy. It is the same with wheat. If we are to get away from cattle, and if farmers are to produce wheat, the Government will come along and subsidise them. If farmers go in for industrial alcohol an equivalent of what will cost 3/- could be purchased for 4d., but the Government will come along to assist. The Government policy also includes an enormous system of tariffs, which means that manufacturers are practically in the Government's control. It works out in any tariffed industry in the same way.

When we see all the taxation the Government is putting on the people, we overlook the fact that this system of enormous tariffs is either subsidising manufacturers by exemption from tax, in that they do not pay a tax which other people have to pay, or it is a farming-out of taxation. Let us suppose that the Government put a tariff of 70 per cent. on some import. I have no doubt that some people have every reason to be grateful to the Government for providing them with a way of making a quick fortune. These people can be put in the position of being able to impose taxation on the community to the extent of 70 per cent. of the value of their goods. As a result, they are, perhaps, able to employ a certain number of people. These people are being paid, not for what they produce in the way of value, but out of taxation levied upon the people by virtue of the powers farmed out by the Government. Here we have a position in which the Government can get control of the wealth of the people and distribute it around and nobody, we are told, has any right to complain. When the Government Party were in opposition, members got up and cried out about the taxation of the State. They got into power and they are increasing the taxation enormously.

Although the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who does most of the talking on agriculture, does not really want to pretend he knows anything about the condition of the country outside his few little factories, he must know, as everybody knows, that the farmers, when it comes to the end of the year, find that, far from having been paid for their labour, they have to live on their capital. Roughly, their position is: the more work they do, the less they are paid for it. The Government, first of all, by its own wanton act, creates a position in which a large section of the community are not able to make a profit out of their labour. On top of that, the Government piles an enormous load of taxation, so as to reduce whatever little accumulated capital the farmer may have. The Minister for Industry and Commerce always likes to challenge my authority. I say that that is a perfectly immoral position. It has been laid down as a distinctly unlawful act for a Government to dissipate the patrimony of the people by an overwhelming burden of taxation, such as this Government is imposing at the moment. The Government having set out to create a condition in which they will control all the wealth and the people be able to live only in so far as the Government, having collected the wealth from the people, will distribute some of the collected wealth, proceeds to prostitute justice. Justice should be the mainstay of a Government. It is said that justice is the conserving force of States. We have had to refer even to the action of the Government in that regard. Yesterday, we had counsel, feed by the Government, to go into court to see, so far as we can judge from the action of counsel, that the law was not applied against certain people who were law breakers. That is an appalling state of affairs. We had yesterday men charged with having been in unlawful possession of rifles, parading with them and shooting with them. These rifles, they were careful to see, did not come into the control of the State. They were not handed over to the officers of the State. They were handed over, presumably, to an unlawful association whose purpose is to overthrow this State. A week before, men were brought before the court—quite properly—for having been in unlawful possession of rifles. So far as I read the report in the papers, one man concerned had had the rifle since 1923, when it was given to him for the purpose of protecting people whose lives were in danger from certain criminal organisations. In that case, the arms did come into the possession of the Government.

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy is now criticising the decision of a court. He is alleging partiality against the Military Tribunal.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am watching the Deputy very carefully to see if he makes any reference to the decision of the court. So far, he has made no such reference.

Comment on this

I know that this is a painful subject for the Government and that they want to cloak their action. Every time we get up to speak on this matter we are subjected to constant interruption. The Government prosecuted certain men who had rifles in 1923. They were not guilty of parading with them or of using them. These rifles came into the possession of the Government. Yesterday, the other men were brought before the court, charged with illegal possession of and with using rifles. They saw that the rifles did not get into the possession of the Government but that they got into the hands of an unlawful association. At the same time they refused to recognise the court, thus carrying out part of the policy of trying to overthrow this State. Counsel, feed by the Government, went into court practically as a defender of these men and indicated to the court that the Government considered that no punishment should be imposed in these cases.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Has the court decided?

Comment on this

The court has decided. I agree that the court had no option——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The court having decided, the Deputy cannot, on the basis of criticising counsel, criticise the action of the court.

Comment on this

It is very far from my intention to criticise the action of the court. If I were a member of the court, I could not have done otherwise than find as they found.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The position is that counsel made certain statements before the court. On the assumption that we are criticising counsel we are, in fact, criticising the decision of the court.

Comment on this

If I may say so with all respect, we are now voting money for the Department of Justice and the Minister for Justice. The Minister for Justice and the Attorney-General, who is associated more or less with his Department, are responsible for keeping the law and for the prosecution of people who break the law. Acting on the instructions of the Minister for Justice or the Attorney-General, a certain line of prosecution is taken. What I am criticising are the instructions given and the line taken by the Department of Justice which, notwithstanding that it is called by that name, has used its power and authority, not in the interests of justice, but in the interests of injustice. Not only is it a crime against justice, but it is a crime against the people that, by the action of that Department, a situation is created whereby it is indicated clearly to a section of the people that this Government entirely approves of the breaking of the laws, provided they are broken by the right sort of people— the people of whom the Government approve. That is the criticism that I am putting forward, and I have nothing whatever to say to the court.

We have members of the Government Party going around and misrepresenting the position in this country. We have a Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Little, who writes—I admit that there is a great opportunity for dodging the giving of a subscription— and states that a certain organisation, which is pre-eminently constitutional. is unconstitutional. That is all part of the same policy of partial justice— partial justice which can lead to nothing but the promotion of disorder and crime. We are now asked to provide money for the carrying out of the Government policy. What do we find? The very head of the Government announced here some time ago that Deputy Mulcahy had seen Lord Hailsham, clearly indicating that the purpose was to get arms into this country. He said that he had received a report to that effect. In making that scandalous speech in this House, he was speaking under privilege. If he had made that statement outside this House it is quite clear that he would be uttering a criminal libel against Deputy Mulcahy. It is the duty of every ordinary citizen of the State, and still more of members of the Dáil, and, of course, it is pre-eminently the duty of members of the Government and especially of the President, to protect the citizens of this country. Yet the President, in this case, by refusing to take proper action by disclosing the name of his informant is compounding a felony. He is sheltering a man who propounded that criminal libel, not only by not giving his name, but by making the statement under the privileges of this House. The President knows the man who uttered that libel, and it is his duty, as a good citizen, to enable the law to be put in motion by General Mulcahy by bringing proceedings against that man. But the President shelters him and preserves his anonymity.

Last week the President kept us here for several hours, speaking about himself. If anyone says anything about the Minister for Industry and Commerce, for instance, he is really providing matter for that Minister to deal with. But when the whole Government is, as one might say, labouring under a statement which implies disgrace to the Government, it is the duty of the Government, not only to persons who make the charges, but to the country as a whole, to clear themselves. A statement was made some time ago by the Leader of the Opposition about a celebrated meeting in a house in Parnell Square on a certain Saturday. The Leader of the Opposition said this meeting took place, and that those engaged in it were dealing with the land mine, that the police were aware of it, and took opportunities to observe what was going on there. We know that the next day a land mine was exploded in Dundalk. The Minister for Justice got up after the Leader of the Opposition had made that charge, but he refused to say anything except that he was satisfied that there was no particular relationship between the meeting in Parnell Square and the outrage in Dundalk. If it is a fact that the police were aware of this meeting, dealing with land mines to be used against the people of this country or to be used against the State, then the Government is guilty of criminal neglect in not proceeding against those people. If, on the other hand, it is untrue, then the welfare of the country requires that the authorities should be cleared of that imputation. When we wanted an opportunity of discussing the matter, and wanted to have a judicial inquiry into the matter, we were unable to have a discussion on the subject, because Private Members' time was appropriated by the Government. The Dáil sat late the same day, not dealing with matters in which the rights of the people were involved, but discussing whether Private Members' time should be taken for new legislation. This Government, which has taken from the people their patrimony, not a share of their earnings during the year, but whatever little capital they may have, now turns round and says to the people these things do not matter, but what is much more important is that the Government have a right to dictate to the people what they are to wear.

Apart from this taxation, implied in the Central Fund Bill, there is other taxation which the people have to bear. The British are taxing us. Members of the Government maintain that we are living in an era of enormous prosperity in this country, but, surely, they do not expect to be taken seriously. Take the figures given in the British House of Commons a short time ago. The farmers of this country used to pay £4,000,000 in land annuities. Roughly £3,000,000 was paid under Acts prior to the Land Act of 1923, and, roughly, £1,000,000 under the Act of 1923. In paying that £4,000,000 they were paying, first of all, interest on the money they borrowed, and they were, also, liquidating the debt by means of a Sinking Fund. What is their position now? Instead of being in the position of paying £4,000,000 a year, and paying off the money they borrowed, Mr. Thomas's figures go to show that we paid in a year and nine months to the British Government £7,000,000, that is, £3,500,000 a year. Ministers now say to the farmers: "See how generous we are. Instead of paying £4,000,000 you are now only paying half the annuities so that you are only paying £2,000,000 a year now." That is to say, in reality that where the farmers were paying £4,000,000 a year before for the money they borrowed, they are now paying £5,500,000. Judging by the figures we get from the British side, it is apparent that the British Government is paying off the interest on the land bonds, but not the Sinking Fund, so that the farmers, while they are paying £5,500,000 where they previously paid only £4,000,000, are not paying off in Sinking Fund the money they borrowed. If there was a settlement to-morrow the farmers would have to pay two years' further instalments. The Government said this condition is going to go on for ever, so that the farmers are paying annuities that were to be terminable not of £4,000,000 as previously, but £5,500,000.

The main aspect of the policy of any State is, one might say, justice, the maintenance of order, the economic side of the country's affairs and foreign relations. Now, I happened to be speaking with President de Valera a few nights ago, and we talked about big nations and small nations. The one thing that one would judge was clearly approved at that gathering was that the making of treaties between countries was a very big matter. Countries make treaties one with another. It is always possible for the stronger country, by the use of material sanctions, to force its will upon the weaker country. The operation of treaties is a sort of bond of honour and saves the bringing into operation of those material sanctions and permits them to come to a sort of friendly agreement. When we consider which is likely to stand for the breaking of treaties, we see it is the stronger power because it can make its will effective by the use of material sanctions. The people that clearly benefit by observing the rule of honour, in keeping treaties, is the weaker side. This Government is now asking money for the management of external affairs. Yet it has admittedly set out to break the Treaty. If I were English I would not so much mind the breaking of treaties, because I would say: "We have the Army and the Navy and the Air Force, so that if treaties are to be broken we may break them more effectively." Where the stronger country breaks the treaty with the smaller country they can do so because they are backed by the greater strength. But our country comes along and says: "Treaties be damned. In so far as they do not suit us we will not keep them. If there is anything not coming to our side then we do not care and will not keep them."

What is the real position? This country should be the very country to denounce any such policy. We have to make arrangements with other countries. If these countries do not keep their arrangements with us we are not in a position to send our forces to crush them and make them keep to their arrangements. If we make treaties with the big Powers and they like to break them they can do so. We can do nothing against them. The very fundamental ideas of foreign relationship are completely reversed by this Government. They throw their weight about and talk about running an economic war with England, which, I suppose, is another thing that we are paying for out of this Vote. Who is winning the economic war? The Minister for Finance and his colleagues went around and said that they would have won the economic war only for our criticism, and, according to their theory, truth is incompatible with Irish nationalism. We were traitors and should be shut up. We had a general election a year or more ago so as to make it abundantly clear that we did not represent the people and that the Government did for that purpose, and the purpose was to enable them to bring to an end and to a successful conclusion the undesirable conditions at this moment existing between this country and England. The Minister for Finance goes around and says that they are bound to win the economic war, and conveys to the people of the country that they have some means of bringing England to her knees, of forcing upon her a sort of pusillanimous surrender in which she will agree that no matter what we do our goods must always go perfectly freely into her market and that is a possible meaning of their phrase "winning the economic war." But there is another meaning, and it is that this Government had a certain amount of negotiation with the British. As told to us by Government spokesmen, disagreement resulted as to whether or not the claim to the legal retention of the land annuities here should be considered by a Commonwealth court or by an international court. I can quite see that the Government could turn around, if the British agreed to put the matter before an international court, and say: "You see we are the victors; we have won, as we promised, in this quarrel with England: we are going to be the victors." Conceivably, that could happen, but what is the position?

A year ago or more I asked the Attorney-General if, as a lawyer, he would get up and say, first of all, that he thought it practically certain, or probable or at all likely or possible that an international court could be expected to decide as between us and England as to our legal right to retain the land annuities here: that they would give a decision in our favour. The Attorney-General was very careful, as a lawyer, not to give an answer in the affirmative. I am satisfied that he knows perfectly well that it is as certain as any human thing is certain that, if that part of the dispute went before an international court, there could only be one decision, and that is, that legally we are bound to pay these annuities. I am also quite certain of this: we have at election times and other times pointed out to the people that we were satisfied that an agreement could be made with England which, even if it did not completely remit the payment of these sums to England, would at least mean an enormous reduction, say, to something like less than half the full amount. I am perfectly satisfied that the Ministers on the Front Bench have good reason to believe that that is so. So that the victory the Government talk about: that the British would surrender to this Government and agree to let the matter go before an international tribunal, which must, almost of a certainty, decide that we are legally bound to pay the annuities, would mean that we should continue to pay the sum that was previously paid. That is the victory, possibly, that they are asking us to bring about. The alternative to that is that the British would not surrender on that point: that they would refuse to surrender. This Government could negotiate, but instead they are committing themselves beforehand to accept the findings of an international court which will almost certainly be that we will have to pay the full amount.

I do not know whether the Government would actually deny that they are satisfied themselves that by negotiation an agreement could be come to with the British under which they would only have to pay less than half what they previously paid. Yet we are asked to vote money to this Government for a policy which even if it were successful would mean that our people would have to pay twice as much as they would have to pay if the Government were unsuccessful in their policy. Now every activity of the Government, as I have pointed out, is getting a greater control over the people pre-eminently through this method of taxation. It used to be thought that whatever other disadvantages there were in being a farmer, at least, one was independent. What is the position now? That the farmer who used to own his land, subject to the payment of a terminable annuity, is having new taxes imposed on him. He now has to pay this Government £2,000,000 a year in the way of land annuities. Previously he was paying back money that he owed, money which had only to be paid for a term of years, at the end of which he became absolute owner of his land. This Government, with all its arrogance and extending its functions beyond its proper sphere, is now seizing the farmer's land. The farmer only holds his land through paying what is actually a rent to the Government. We have Fianna Fáil Deputies going around assuring their henchmen, the chief appeal to whom appears to be the promise that they will get something that belongs to somebody else, that if the farmers do not run their farms exactly as this Government dictates, then the land will be taken away from them. I have already pointed out that this Government proposes that the farmer must use his land for producing wheat. The Government's own action is an admission that the production of wheat is not a paying proposition for the farmer: that the labourer is not worthy of his hire because the price to be got for the wheat would not pay him. It recognises that, and says to the farmer "You must be given money out of taxation; otherwise clearly it would not be worth your while to grow wheat." It is the same with regard to tobacco. No man in this country would grow tobacco if the Government did not assist him either by a subsidy or by exempting the tobacco from taxation. If it did not do that he would be simply wasting his time and his labour.

That is the sort of economic policy that is proposed here. Then we had the Minister for Industry and Commerce going to the Belton Street Technical Schools propounding a new theory there: that one of the troubles in this country was that people had interpreted the Bible too literally: that unless a man works neither shall he eat. He said this Government had a great policy: that the first step in their economic policy was an unemployment relief scheme. The great advantage of that scheme he said would be that it would prevent a whole lot of people from working. He indicated that, to an ever increasing degree, people must stop working. Apparently his idea is that the growth of machines not merely increases production but will eliminate man: that man is going to be wiped out by machinery. Then the Minister is going to make the country prosperous by making fewer and fewer people work; by having a constantly growing leisured class doing nothing, but merely living on the production of the few who continue to work.

One knows that the Minister for Industry and Commerce is pre-eminently an astute politician. One had thought that when he got into office he would drop the catch cries with which he set out to fool the people of this country, and that he would do all he could to save his face on that point: that he would not go out of his way to propound an even more futile and lunatic theory than he had propounded before. We are asked to give the money which is got out of the labour of the people producing in this country to run the Minister's Department, the purpose being to make us richer and richer by having fewer and fewer people working so that less will be produced, and that is an economic policy according to Lemass. As I tried to point out, if you take the general State policy, the general State policy is the totalitarian State, and as Deputy Lemass always challenges me, I shall just read this quotation:

"Hence the prudent Pontiff had already declared it unlawful for the State to exhaust the means of individuals by crushing taxes and tributes."

That is exactly what this Government proposes to do under this Bill. Its justification is that it is extending its activity from day to day so that it now says whether we are to wear one colour or another. The farmer is merely a tenant worker for the Government, dependent just the same as a civil servant is dependent, in order to maintain his family, on any little doles or bounties the Government may give. If you consider the number of people in this country who are living by grace of the Government, you have the farming community, you have the Civil Service, the Army and the police; you have the unemployed and the old-age pensioners, and the policy of the Government is that it should take possession of all the wealth of the country and that it should distribute it to support them. That, of course, is the policy of Russia where they have class distinctions. If one looks to the administration of justice in this country and the jobbery of the Government, one always finds these class distinctions. If you are one of an organisation that puts the Government into power you can take out a gun, shoot it off, and the Government will pay a man out of the taxes to see that you are not punished, whereas if you should belong to an organisation which does not, heart and soul, support the Government they will legislate to put you into prison unless you dress exactly as they decide you should dress. So the Government, extending its powers over the person in this country, at the same time prostitutes justice. So in its relations with other countries, its theory is that treaties should be broken, not thinking for a moment that the one country that should stand for the sanctity of treaties, even when in some particulars they might not be in our favour, is this country, which is not in a position to force its will on other countries by material sanctions.

The Government also proposes that our chief industry should be orientated having in mind that the British market is gone. Time and again they have gone around telling the farmers that the British market has definitely and finally gone and that nothing that we could possibly do will bring that back again. They put their argument this way: "Will they not see that the British are going to be self-supporting in future in agriculture?" Now, England is just about twice the size of this country. They have 40,000,000 of a population, which means, presumably, that an area in England equal in size to our country could feed about 25,000,000 people. At the same time we, in this country, if we produce in agriculture in the same manner as they say England is going to do, should be able to produce agricultural produce to support 25,000,000 people. If we are going to do that it means that we would have to export sufficient agricultural produce for 22,000,000 people. We never have done that and I do not think that we are ever likely to. For that reason it is not possible in England to raise agricultural produce sufficient to supply her population.

Our Government, again, turns round and says: "You see, in the old days the British had a free trade policy; now they have a tariff policy. You may rest assured that although your goods went to England in the old days without paying any tariff, although you are told that the payment of tariffs is brought about absolutely by the action of the Government in running the country into the economic war, that is all rot; it is all Opposition talk, because it is part of the British policy to have tariffs in future." I think it was in the year 1926, at the Imperial Conference, when we were negotiating with the British, the British Government said that they intended at that time to go in for a tariff policy, including the imposition of tariffs on agricultural produce. We did not protest. On the contrary, when an election came along in Britain and a new Government came in whose policy did not include tariffs, they did not write over to us to say: "You must be very delighted at the change in policy, because agricultural produce will not be subject to a tariff; the whole tariff policy comes to an end." On the contrary, the British Government voted millions of pounds for the Empire Marketing Board, which they recognised as a very inadequate substitute for what would have been possible if they had gone on with their tariff policy, including the imposition of tariffs on agricultural goods. The position in England now is exactly what they apologised to us for not making it before. They voted millions of pounds to try to make up to us for the loss implied by the change of policy at that time. Our Government now points to the present policy of the British Government, which every one of the Dominions wanted in 1926, and they say: "You must be prepared to suffer; you cannot expect to get into the British market. The fact that the British Government have embarked upon a policy of tariffs, including the imposition of tariffs on agricultural goods, puts them in a position that they were not in previously. They can stop supplies, and can arrest the marketing of our goods in Great Britain."

This Government, having gone on with that completely dishonest propaganda and having promised, if I remember aright—the Minister for Industry and Commerce will correct me—that everybody engaged in agriculture should be richer by £16 per person per annum, having made them much worse and it being no longer possible to pretend that the millenium is coming, they now say that even if things are worse it is going to continue, but that it is not humanly possible to get the British market back. It is perfectly clear to anybody who takes the trouble to think that, first of all, the British cannot support themselves on home-produced agricultural goods. Secondly, it will be observed that the other Dominions have been able to export rather more into the British market during the time that we have been precluded from sending our goods in. It will be observed too, that now, as was not the case before, the British are in a position to give our goods more favoured treatment as against goods coming from non-Commonwealth countries. If one went through all the items it would be perfectly clear to everybody, not blinded by Fianna Fáil prejudice, that in a general way the less money this Government is given the better, because they use money for the detriment of the people and not for their good.

I only propose, in connection with this Bill, to deal with the general State position, the totalitarian State. In spite of the high-sounding speeches of President de Valera—we know that whenever he makes a high-sounding, high-principled speech we can be prepared for something rather drastic in the way of tyranny from him—I think it an appalling situation that you have an economic policy in which the labourer knows after he has done his day's work, his week's work, or his year's work, that his work has not been capable of producing sufficient wealth to support himself and his family, that he is not dependent on his labour or the produce of his labour but that he is dependent on the dole he is going to get from the Government. Whether he be a manufacturer taking advantage of the tariffs; whether he be an employee working inside a factory, which exists and continues to exist only by virtue of having the power to impose taxation on the people; or whether he be a farmer who is not now a peasant proprietor having to pay a debt which would vanish at the end of a period of years, but who is now a tenant of the Government carrying on at the will of the Government—and whenever that Government takes the whim that his work must take this form or that form, the Government have him in their power and will be able to deal with him—he is in an equally bad position.

That unfortunate man who previously paid £4,000,000 annuities is now quite clearly paying no less than £5,500,000 a year. So far as I can judge, and I should be glad to hear that I am wrong, whereas previously in paying £4,000,000 a year he was actually reducing his debt by a sum of practically £700,000 a year, now in paying £5,500,000 instead of paying £4,000,000 he is not paying off that £700,000 a year, as in the present state of this country the farmer must continue indefinitely to pay almost half as much again as he previously paid for his land, being no longer owner of his land, not paying off the debt he previously contracted, and being able to carry on only at the will of the Government. I know the Government's mind is entirely working on the lines of constantly increasing the Government's activity, to the detriment of the freedom of the person and of the natural human initiative operating in this country. If that goes on long enough—unfortunately it cannot go on very long, because the present policy of the Government means a very strict time limit before we have arrived at bankruptcy and the disorder inevitably following on that—but if the Government were actually able to continue indefinitely, it would really mean that we would all suffer from that demoralisation which inevitably comes to the unemployed man who is dependent on doles, because it means that the Government takes possession of whatever people are producing in this country, and then as an act of grace gives to one or another such share of the results of that production as it in its goodwill fancies.

I think the whole line of the Government, apart from the material bankruptcy that it is leading us to, is leading to the moral bankruptcy of our people, and to a disimprovement in the whole character and morale of our people. I think this constant and appalling increase in taxation is not really a lawful act of this Government, but an act quite contrary to natural justice; an act which is merely an act of expropriation of the possessions of anybody who, in previous good times, may through thrift have accumulated money or goods, or cattle or land. This Government now proposes in effect, not honestly and not directly, but clearly in ultimate effect, to expropriate those people of their goods. Consequently, I think that everybody should try to put a stop to this career the Government is embarking on. This constant increasing of taxation is something which cries out loud for remedy. We know perfectly well that with all the fine talk of the Minister for Industry and Commerce about those factories he has started, the unemployment figures are constantly growing, and must inevitably grow until this country goes out of production.

Comment on this
Seán F. Lemass Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

The Lord offered to spare the sinful cities if they produced five just men, and Deputy Moore offered to forgive the Cumann na nGaedheal Party if in the course of this debate they produced one constructive idea. My inclination is to be even more generous with them than Deputy Moore. I will forgive them if they produce one clear idea. I have listened to the whole dreary debate, and in not one single speech was expression given to one clear idea, not even in the totalitarian speech of Deputy Fitzgerald. Deputy Mulcahy, when challenged to give expression to one constructive idea, said the only idea he had was that the Government should go out of office. Deputies opposite have misread those figures so as to bring themselves to believe that they point to an increase in taxation. Assuming for the moment that their reading of the figures is correct, although it is obviously incorrect, I want them to tell us clearly and precisely what they want done about it. They are supposed to be a responsible Opposition Party. They include amongst their number men who were Ministers of this State for ten years. Surely, after some cogitation and labour, they might produce one constructive suggestion as to how the possibility of increased taxation might be avoided. What do they want reduced?

Comment on this

Inefficiency.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton has said that he wants inefficiency reduced. That records another point of agreement between Deputy Belton and members of the Fianna Fáil Party. If he keeps on asking for things of that kind, he will soon be unable to resist the temptation to come back to the fold. There is set out upon that White Paper the estimated expenditure under various headings. Deputies who want to see the total of those Estimates reduced must indicate where savings are to be made. What do they want to save on? The total excess between the figure for the coming year and the figure for last year is, as I pointed out yesterday, roughly £1,800,000; an excess which is more than accounted for by the difference in the figures in respect of the Local Loans Fund. The estimated total of the advances to be made from the Local Loans Fund in this year is £4,200,000, as against £2,150,000 last year, a difference of £2,050,000. That difference accounts for much more than the total excess about which all the Deputies are agitating themselves. As they are well aware—or, at least, as some of them are aware—advances from the Local Loans Fund are made to local authorities upon a repayment basis, interest being chargeable upon the advances until repayment is completed.

On the basis of those figures, if there were no other factor in the situation, no other charges to be met, and no additions to be made to that total, Deputies could be rubbing their hands in anticipation of a reduction of taxation in the coming Budget. They do not understand the figures, and that is why they have been speaking so much about them. If they had made the slightest effort to examine the figures and understand them, if they had done more in relation to the whole publication than look at the totals, they would have come in here and made speeches which would have suited their political policy much better by assuming that reductions in taxation were coming, and arousing public anticipations concerning them. As it is, the public must be pleasantly surprised no matter what happens in the Budget, because Deputies opposite have painted so dire a picture and pointed out such an appalling prospect that even the worst things which the Minister for Finance could conceive will appear to be trivial, in comparison with the fears which the Deputies opposite are arousing in the taxpayers' minds. That is bad politics. It is quite clear from the speeches of the Deputies opposite in the course of this discussion that they have not yet discovered why they lost the election in 1932. They must have in their Party headquarters a staff of clerks engaged on the task of conducting an inquiry into the reason for their defeat. They go back over all the advertisements published by the Fianna Fáil Party, over all the speeches made by members of the Fianna Fáil Party, and examine into every detailed utterance that was made, every idle word that every member of Fianna Fáil ever spoke——

Comment on this

You have said it!

Comment on this

——in order to find the reason for their defeat. They even traced Deputy Moore as far as Mullinalachta in 1929, and we have an ex-Minister, a Front Bench member of the Opposition, coming in here with his Press cuttings bearing on Deputy Moore's speech at Mullinalachta in 1929——

Comment on this

To wallop poor Deputy Moore!

Comment on this

——to explain why his Party lost the election in 1932. The only answer I have to make to all that is, that not merely did they lose the election in 1932, but they lost another in 1933, and they are going to lose another in 1937. They have not yet found out why they lost, and they will not find out so long as they follow their present channels of investigation. They will want to look at themselves and within themselves to find out the real reason for their failure. It is quite true that I and other members of Fianna Fáil said frequently, prior to 1932, in this House and out of it, that on the basis of the Estimates for Supply Services prepared by our predecessors, savings amounting to £2,000,000 were possible. They were possible, and on the basis of those Estimates for the same services very nearly £2,000,000 have been saved. If Deputies opposite will only examine the figures in detail, if they will only try to exert themselves for a few hours and do their duty as an Opposition, they will find out that that is true. I am quite prepared to admit that the full £2,000,000 has not been secured, and it has not been secured because Deputies opposite fought so desperately to prevent economies being effected that the Government plans were in part nullified.

The Deputies opposite do not want economies. That is their public policy. When the Government introduced here a Public Services (Temporary Economies) Bill, not merely did they oppose it but they obstructed it. They produced, I think, 250 frivolous amendments for the Committee Stage and they continued the debate on these amendments over two weeks, in a vain attempt to prevent the Bill going through. They are adopting precisely the same tactics in relation to another economy measure which is now before the Dáil. They do not want economies and it is sheer humbug on their part to pretend to criticise the Government for not effecting all the economies we believe to be possible, when we cannot get the co-operation of the Opposition in the achievement of even much smaller economies than were originally spoken of. Economies have been achieved despite the Opposition and economies will be achieved wherever the opportunity offers, but in so far as there has been an increase in the Estimate for Supply Services, it is due to the fact that new services have been created. I urge Deputies opposite to tell us if they want those services stopped and tell us clearly if they want those services stopped, and not to give us the type of speech we have just heard from Deputy Fitzgerald which one might understand if one got it in print and read it five times every day for a week. We want to be told, in plain language that the ordinary man can understand, which of the new services set out in this official publication they want to abolish and which of these services they will abolish, if, by any misfortune, they should ever become the Government of this country again.

There is an item of £4,200,000 in the Local Loans Fund for housing. Do they want to stop housing? If we stopped housing, we could effect a saving in the Estimates for this year that would be greater than all the saving that was ever accomplished in any other three years put together. That is the biggest single item upon that list. A sum of £4,200,000 will be advanced from the Local Loans Fund mainly to finance housing activities and to the extent that it does not go into housing activities, it is going to finance public health schemes, sewerage and water works, throughout the country— schemes that are necessary in the public interest in many towns.

Comment on this

And within the country's capacity.

Comment on this

It is quite within the country's capacity to provide the money for that purpose.

Comment on this

That is the trouble.

Comment on this

There is an increase in the Estimate for old age pensions. We know the policy of Deputies opposite on that question; they do not need to tell us. When they were a Government, they sought economy by reducing the amount of the old age pensions. They did not offer to reduce their own salaries; they did not seek for savings in the ranks of the civil servants; they did not seek for savings through the elimination of waste. They sought and found them by reducing the amount paid to the old and destitute poor. We have reversed that. A Bill was introduced here in 1932 to amend and improve the Old Age Pensions Acts, which resulted in that increase. Do Deputies want to stop it? Mind you, I think that we could possibly contemplate some revision of that measure and the opportunity of doing so will arise when the unemployment assistance scheme is in full operation; but its main principles are quite sound, and although improvements upon it could be effected which might result in some saving without occasioning hardship, nevertheless, on the whole, this House was quite justified in passing it. If a Cumann na nGaedheal or Fine Gael or Blue Shirt Government comes into office in this country by any means, fair or foul, are we to understand from them that one of their first acts will be to repeal that Bill and effect savings in consequence?

Comment on this

Is it in order for the Minister to suggest that the official Opposition will come into office by fair means or foul?

Comment on this

Have the official Opposition not been suggesting all day that this Government got into office by foul means?

Comment on this

Is it in order, Sir? The implication is quite clear.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I take it that it is a political reference.

Comment on this

Does the Minister admit that?

Comment on this

Of course, it is.

Comment on this

Carry on, then.

Comment on this

And if they ever do get into office, it will be by such means.

Comment on this

It is the way everybody gets in, apparently.

Comment on this

They never will.

Comment on this

The next substantial item showing an increase is the provision which has to be made this year in consequence of the passage of the Unemployment Assistance Act. Will Deputies opposite repeal that if they get the chance? If they do these three things—repeal the Fianna Fáil Housing Act, repeal the Fianna Fáil Old Age Pension Act and repeal the Fianna Fáil Unemployment Assistance Act— they will save £6,000,000, or at least, they will reduce the total of the Estimates by that amount. No wise person would call it economy but they will reduce the total of the Estimates by that amount. Are they going to do it? Can we get any reply to that question in the course of this debate? The people of this country, to whom the Deputies opposite are making speeches every Sunday at the cross roads, are entitled to be informed of these things and not of the abstract thoughts that wander occasionally into the mind of Deputy Fitzgerald. Let us finish, once and for all, this reference back to the Fianna Fáil election advertisements.

Comment on this

It is very distasteful.

Comment on this

We have not achieved these economies. We told the people before the election in 1932 that on the basis of the services then maintained, these economies were possible. We achieved certain economies but not them all and we found ourselves, at the end of 1932, in a position different from what we had contemplated, in consequence of the development of the dispute with Great Britain and the attitude of the Opposition Party, and we went back to the people and, in January of 1933, with a full knowledge of the fact that it was not possible for us to carry out that part of our policy, with a full knowledge of the fact that in respect of other parts of our policy modifications were being forced upon us, the people sent us back here with an increased majority.

Comment on this

To settle the economic war.

Comment on this

We came back, and that is the main thing. Deputies opposite were repudiated despite the efforts they made to filch the Fianna Fáil policy and masquerade with it as their own. We are now in office following an election in which the people clearly understood that the new situation arising out of the financial dispute with Great Britain was going to necessitate increased expenditure and that, in fact, such increased expenditure was going to be sound national policy under all the circumstances.

Let us consider what Deputies mean when they talk about the burden of taxation. This country could not afford to waste £5,000,000. This country could not afford to pay out £5,000,000 for which it got no return. If the total amount that we raised in taxation next year were only £5,000,000 it would be too great a burden for our people if all that money were wasted. This country could afford to spend a much larger sum than we contemplate taking if it gets full value for it. In 1929 and 1931 there was a burden of taxation that was too heavy for our people, because too much of the total revenue secured was being exported without benefit to the country and too much was going in waste.

Comment on this

Is it not going still?

Comment on this

No. The country is getting value for every penny of it now, and 80 per cent. of the total amount raised in revenue goes back to the people in some form or another— whether in the form of unemployment assistance or housing grants, agricultural subsidies or old age pensions, or in some other way which helps to constitute the incomes of large numbers of our people. In so far as that is happening it is merely a re-distribution of the national income, so that those with too much are being asked to part with some in order to help out those with too little. That is not a burden. Taxation only constitutes a burden when the revenue is wasted, and I submit that any impartial critic, looking through the Estimates, examining them in detail, and comparing them with the Estimates of our predecessors, will be forced to agree that there is very little wastage, if any, as compared with that which was experienced previously. Certain wastage, no doubt, there must be, where large sums are being dealt with; but taking the total amount raised and the total amount that goes back to the people, the wastage is very inconsiderable indeed in relation to the wastage calculated upon the same basis in any year of the previous regime.

There was a suggestion here, however, that the country would be better off if we got back to the conditions prevailing under the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. That is a theory worth examining. If there is any illusion in the minds of anybody concerning a matter of that kind, it is just as well to dispel it. Let us clear away some of the fog that has been created by Deputies during this discussion, and let us get that particular contention out clearly so that we can have a look at it. If the same legal and financial provisions operated now as operated on the day upon which Fianna Fáil came into office, the price of butter would be lower; the price of oats would be lower; the price of bacon would be lower; the price of milk would be lower; the price of sheep would not be changed; the price of cattle might have been a trifle higher, but that is open to question.

Comment on this

Can you give any proof for what you are saying?

Comment on this

Certainly. During the period of office of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government the price of agricultural produce was determined by the price in the British market. Is not that so?

Comment on this

It is determined by it now, less the price of the tariff.

Comment on this

The price of butter would be lower. Does the Deputy dispute that? The price the farmer is getting for it now is higher.

Comment on this

Because of the subsidy.

Comment on this

The price of bacon would be lower. During the last year of the Cosgrave régime £1,200,000 worth of foreign bacon came into this country.

Comment on this

Who put the tariff on it?

Comment on this

There was a tariff, but it was a farcical tariff.

Comment on this

What was the net effect of the tariff on bacon? Was it not prohibitive?

Comment on this

I am told that the tariff on bacon was prohibitive. It is just as well to get that matter cleared up so that Deputies cannot make the same contention again. Bacon imports in 1929 were valued at £1,600,000. Bacon imports in 1931, the last year in which Deputy Cosgrave was President, were valued at £1,229,000.

Comment on this

When was the tariff put on?

Comment on this

That is the value of the bacon imports during the last year that Deputy Cosgrave was President.

Comment on this

When was the tariff put on?

Comment on this

By the Fianna Fáil Government in its first year of office—in July of 1932. The Deputy is wrong, as usual.

Comment on this

A tariff was put on by the previous Administration.

Comment on this

A tariff which was farcical.

Comment on this

When was it put on?

Comment on this

The tariff put on by the previous Administration was ineffective, and it was designed to be ineffective. It was designed merely to yield revenue and not to protect the industry.

Comment on this

What was the net effect on the pig industry?

Comment on this

The effect has been that there is a 50 per cent. increase in pig prices since.

Comment on this

What was the effect on pig production?

Comment on this

At the present time pig production is less than required.

Comment on this

And our export trade was lost.

Comment on this

Nonsense. It is going up. Has the Deputy read the figures which are sent to him by the Department free of charge?

Comment on this

I have read them.

Comment on this

I want to get back to the original point. What would be the position here if in every way conditions were the same as they were at the time when Cumann na nGaedheal went out of office? The price of butter and the price of bacon would be less and there would be still £1,200,000 worth of bacon coming in. The price of wool would be less. The price of sheep would be no higher. The price of barley would be less. The price of wheat would be less. The price of cattle, as I said, might be somewhat higher, but that is very doubtful.

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain, if cattle would be higher in price, how feeding-stuffs would be lower?

Comment on this

The price of cattle might be higher, but the doubt arises from the fact that since 1932 the British have adopted a cattle quota, and they have not adopted that for our benefit alone. They are applying it ruthlessly against other countries, and they are applying it no more ruthlessly against them than they are applying it against ourselves. It is impossible to estimate accurately what the effect of that quota would be upon cattle prices independent of tariffs. Let us assume for a moment that the removal of the special duties upon Irish cattle would have resulted in some increase in price. I again, however, want to express my doubt, because the surplus of fat cattle not exportable would be just the same and would, in consequence, sell at no higher price than it is selling at the present time, so that the increase that might have resulted in cattle prices would be very slight indeed. The farmers would be paying £5,000,000 a year to England.

Comment on this

They would be paying £3,000,000.

Comment on this

The farmers would be paying £3,000,000 and the rest of us over £2,000,000.

Comment on this

The farmers are paying £5,000,000 at present.

Comment on this

They are not paying anything of the sort.

Comment on this

Who is paying the duties?

Comment on this

The British consumer.

Comment on this

Economics up to date.

Comment on this

I want any practical farmer, not a member of Cumann na nGaedheal, but somebody with intelligence, just to examine those facts and ask himself whether he would be prepared in cold blood to substitute existing conditions, bad as they are, for the conditions that might have existed if Cumann na nGaedheal had not been cleared out of office in time. What are Cumann na nGaedheal going to do if they get back into office? Are they going to adopt their declared policy in relation to butter? They voted against the Price Stabilisation Act here. Was that vote a declaration of their policy? Are we to take it from that that if they come back into office that Act is going to be repealed with the Housing Act, with the Unemployment Assistance Act and with the Old Age Pensions Act? We must take it unless we have a clear declaration to the contrary. If they come back into office, are they taking the tariff off bacon and going to provide that market, worth over £1,000,000 per year, again for the American and Canadian exporters to the detriment of our own pig producers?

Comment on this

I am not taking Deputy Belton as speaking for the Party in that matter. I want that statement confirmed by each one of the ten leaders.

Comment on this

I am able to speak on that matter.

Comment on this

Are they going to abolish the scheme for the admixture of native cereals with imported grain for feeding stuffs?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy speaking the Party policy in that matter or only his own? Let him summon a meeting of the grand high council and see if he can get a unanimous declaration in that matter.

Comment on this

There is a unanimous declaration of the feeders on that.

Comment on this

The Cumann na nGaedheal Party may have abandoned all hope of getting support in the counties where the grain is grown, but I should like them to consider the consequences of a declaration to that effect before they make it. We have some idea of what Deputy Mulcahy meant when he said that the only constructive idea he had was that the Government should get out of office, presumably to allow his Party to get in again. It is just as well for Deputies, including the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, and their supporters outside the House, to understand what that change is going to mean—the repeal of the Housing Act and the cessation of housing activities; the repeal of the Unemployment Assistance Act; the repeal of the Old Age Pensions Act; the repeal of the Butter (Price Stabilisation) Act; the repeal of the Cereals Act; the repeal of the protective duties that have benefited the pig producers; the repeal, presumably, of other measures which are equally beneficial to the people, which Cumann na nGaedheal opposed for no other reason except that they did not think of them themselves when in office. That is their policy. That is what they are offering to the country. It is upon a programme of that kind that they have the audacity to think they would even get at another election half the seats they got at the last.

We have had this question of the economic position of the country discussed so often that I am not going to go over it again. I merely repeat what I said before, that there are more people in employment in the Free State to-day than ever there were. The revenue to the Unemployment Insurance Fund from the sale of stamps is higher than at any time since the Free State was established. The number of unemployment insurance books exchanged at the end of the last insurance year was higher than at any time since the Free State was established. The imports into this country of the goods, the consumption of which indicates a rise in the standard of living, were higher last year than the previous year. We brought in more tea, we brought in more sugar, we brought in more tobacco, we brought in more wine, we brought in more motor cars, we brought in more wireless sets, we brought in more clocks, and we brought in more watches.

Comment on this

And we sent out less milk.

Comment on this

The increase in the imports of those goods which we do not make ourselves, and most of which are luxury products, is an indication that conditions here, if not as good as we would like to see them, are improving. As Deputies are aware, the total of the bank clearances is generally accepted by economists as the index of commercial activity and the total was higher than in any year since 1924—£269,173,000 as against £267,348,000 in 1932, and £249,980,000 in 1931.

Comment on this

What years are you quoting?

Comment on this

1933, 1932, 1931. In 1933 they were £269,173,000.

Comment on this

My figures are £267,120,000 from the journal quoted by the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

I am giving official figures: 1932, £267,348,000.

Comment on this

My figures are £273,057,000.

Comment on this

They are wrong. 1931, £249,980,000. The value of the bank notes in circulation in mid-December, 1933, was higher than at any time since Free State bank notes were issued.

Comment on this

What is it to-day?

Comment on this

To-day, it is lower than it was in mid-December.

Comment on this

It is lower than ever it was for the last three years.

Comment on this

Nonsense. The bank note figures fluctuate from week to week. The figure in mid-December, in anticipation of the Christmas trade, is the only figure which can be quoted with any degree of surety as to the relationship with the figure on a similar date in previous years.

Comment on this

I am giving average figures for the years 1931 and 1933, and there has been a drop in 1933 of £200,000. Does the Minister contradict that?

Comment on this

I have not got the figures here.

Comment on this

May I give another figure?

Comment on this