Central Fund Bill, 1934—Second Stage.
Contributions 211–432 of 432. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 16 of 1934 ›
No, it is probably wrong. Before I leave this general question of the economic position of the country I should like to say a few words about the fantastic theories expressed a few minutes ago by Deputy Fitzgerald. Mind you it is only when we hear Deputy Fitzgerald and Deputy Mulcahy and others like them speaking in these debates that we realise how they succeeded in bringing this country into the hopeless plight in which they left it in 1932. The appalling ignorance of the elements of political economy which they have displayed in the course of these speeches is the only explanation of their extraordinary incompetence as a Government.
The arguments put forward by Deputy Fitzgerald would not be advanced by a first year student of political economy in any university in the world. Yet that Deputy and Deputy Mulcahy were for ten years here responsible for directing the economic affairs of this country and its political destiny. Is it any wonder they failed? The Deputy makes the extraordinary contention that the imposition of tariffs is in some way a farming out of taxation. He has not even attempted to get the theory of protection right, much less to examine the actual results of the various tariffs that have been imposed. Is it a farming out of taxation to impose a tariff on imports of woollen cloth? This country is able to export woollen cloth into protected markets and sell because of its quality? The latest figures of exports show a substantial increase in the exports of woollen cloth since we imposed a duty on that item and gave the industry the security of the home market on which to build up an export trade. We put a duty on linen cloth, and in the matter of linen cloth exports we have to-day the same result—an increase of exports. Right through every other branch of industry the same thing has been shown.
Comment on this
There are four wireless stations in the country—Athlone, Dublin, Cork and Deputy Dillon. If Deputy Morrissey wants to be recognised as the fifth he will have to send in his application on the usual form.
Comment on this
The point of wireless! The duty imposed on wireless sets imported into this country was imposed by Mr. Reginald McKenna in 1915, and was inherited by the Free State when it was established.
Comment on this
If the Deputies who want to make speeches on matters of this kind will even hold a Party meeting before determining what they are going to say, and ask the members of their own Party who know what is happening in relation to the various industries it would be better for themselves and for the House. In that way, they might be able to start with a knowledge and experience of some members of their own Party, and not make statements such as Deputy Fitzgerald made here to-day. Were they to do that, I would be prepared to take them seriously. But I do not believe that there is inside the ranks of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party or, as they call themselves now, the Fine Gael organisation——
Comment on this
——or amongst those in external association with it a Deputy who knows anything about industry who is not standing 100 per cent. behind the policy of the Government in relation to industry, so much so that the Leader of the Party has had to swallow his words, so much so that his latest outburst shows that he has been forced to admit, as Deputy MacDermot yesterday admitted, that the Government's policy in relation to industry was sound in every respect. It would, I think, add to the dignity of this House if members of the same Party, speaking upon the same subject, would try to use the same information and hold the same opinions. It is rather peculiar that we had Deputy Fitzgerald a few minutes ago indicating that the Government policy was wrong in everything, and that their whole programme was rotten, when a few minutes earlier we had Deputy McGovern congratulating them on their milk policy, and previous to that, we had Deputy MacDermot congratulating as, as he did yesterday, on our industrial policy. The fact is that each Deputy supports the Government on matters that affect himself and condemns them on other matters, but between them there are some of the Opposition Deputies prepared to support the Government in every part of their policy.
I listened with considerable astonishment to Deputy Fitzgerald speaking of the land annuities and appearing to take it as fundamental that might was right; that any country which was strong enough to break treaties; or any other country that was strong enough to seize the property of others, was entitled to do it; that countries too weak to enforce their will upon others were to put up with what they were able to get. That is the sound national policy that Deputy Fitzgerald and his Party are prepared to advocate for this country—"take what you can if you are strong enough and if you are not strong enough put up with what you get." It is a good job that in all Irish history there were considerable numbers of people who had a very different outlook to that and it is a good job too that at the right time in the history of this country there were men found with a very different outlook from that, men some of whom I am sorry to say are now amongst the Cumann na nGaedheal Party and who have lost the dignity of their nobler boyhood.
But to come back to economics, it is indicated here that this Government had done something extraordinary in subsidising wheat. The Government embarked upon a wheat scheme and they have subsidised wheat. One fact I will bring to the notice of Deputies here and that is that the Canadian Government are subsidising wheat production. Deputy Hogan used to talk about the impossibility of growing wheat here in competition with Canada. The Canadian Government has subsidised wheat production.
Comment on this
Not production; Canada is over-producing wheat. It has subsidised the marketing of wheat. The Minister is on dangerous ground there when he talks about Canada subsidising production.
Comment on this
The only other matter that was raised was the Department of the Minister for Justice. The Minister for Justice is unwell and unable to be here and apparently Deputies felt they could criticise that Department and the Government because certain political crimes have gone unpunished. I do not want to treat this matter in a Party spirit. It is a matter which is of rather grave concern to all Parties here. If Deputies will cast their minds back over the years which preceded the change of Government they will remember a number of outstanding political crimes which went unpunished. That state of affairs arises out of our history.
For many generations it was regarded as a patriotic attitude to refuse to give information to the police. That attitude towards the police and towards the cause of justice and law has persisted despite the new conditions prevailing here. It is because of the prevalence of that attitude which is in its conditions a slave attitude that both our predecessors and ourselves have been unable to get in relation to a number of political crimes the necessary information which would enable the culprits to be brought to trial. I would ask Deputies opposite not to endeavour to make Party capital out of that. Any Party capital that they can make out of that attitude will be at the expense of the whole country. They should endeavour to co-operate with us so as to get a new spirit into the people, a new sense of duty into the mind of the ordinary citizen in relation to the State, so that we will at some stage come to the point at which every citizen will consider it his duty to report to the responsible authorities all the information he may have of any offences against the law. I have now finished talking in a non-Party spirit, and I will say this that General O'Duffy might give a lead. I notice that he said in a recent speech that he had information about a number of bank robberies that were about to take place. The police are still waiting for the tip as to where they are to take place, so that the robbers can be apprehended.
Comment on this
I was taking General O'Duffy seriously. He said that he knew of a number of bank robberies that were to take place. It is his duty to pass on the information to the responsible authorities, so that the necessary protection can be afforded to the banks.
Comment on this
With regard to that, I ask General O'Duffy to give the source of his information, and I suggest that Deputies opposite should help the Government to carry out its duties or should refuse to take from public servants information that should not be given to them.
Comment on this
On a point of order, does the Minister allege that public servants have improperly communicated information to members of this Party? If so, I feel that he should allege it bluntly and not by implication, because what he alleges is false. What he said was implied, without alleging it. I challenge him, as a Minister of the Executive Council, to say that any public servant has communicated information to us improperly. If the Minister says so I will deal with it.
Comment on this
I did not think it was denied. I assumed after Deputy Cosgrave made his statement about Parnell Square, and after Deputy Mulcahy made his statement to-day about the same thing, and about what took place in Tipperary, that they had some foundation for their statements. There was only one possible source of information.
Comment on this
I am very interested in Deputy Dillon's statement, because we must now assume that anything said by his colleagues on matters of this kind are the products of their imagination.
Comment on this
It is not necessary that any additional measures to those we have already should be taken to find it out.
Comment on this
May I remind the Minister that a situation which was already difficult and critical has been, worsened by the Ministerial pronouncement that information did come from members of the State Services. In view of that statement there is a further argument why the tribunal should be established.
Comment on this
There may be another explanation. I had better qualify my statement. I noticed that General O'Duffy stated that a number of the I.R.A. were joining the Blue Shirts. Perhaps that may be the cause.
Comment on this
Put it to the test and set up a commission to get all the information that is demanded.
Comment on this
I do not know that we are demanding any information that we have not got. I ask Deputies, if, the debate is to go on any longer, to try to meet my initial plea, that they should give some clear idea of what they want. They have been in a fog up to the present. Deputy McGovern is no more clear than Deputy Fitzgerald, and Deputy Fitzgerald is no more clear than Deputy Mulcahy. They used many words but did not convey to me any clear idea of what they wanted done, or any clear idea of what they would do if the responsibility was theirs. I want some responsible member of that Party to answer my question. That rules out Deputy Dillon. If there is any such member in that Party, with authority to speak, it will be of considerable benefit to the people and to this House if that information in some clear form is made available.
Comment on this
Some gentleman associated with the French Revolution spoke of audacity. The motto of the Minister for Industry and Commerce all his life is: "Brass, brass, and still more brass." So far as brass goes to dazzle the eyes of the public and to prevent them from seeing what is scabrous in the public life of this country since he became Minister for Industry and Commerce, I do not complain. But when he continues, and attempts to slander public servants of the State, I resent it. The Minister, in the meanest possible way, sought to imply, without having the courage to make the charge, that there were certain servants in the public service of the Saorstát who were betraying their trust. From the back-benchers that kind of filth is insignificant, but from a Minister of the State it is scandalous.
Comment on this
If it implies, as is alleged, that they betrayed their trust there ought to be the judicial inquiry for which we have asked to put that matter to the test before an impartial court, and to let public opinion in this country pass judgement on the verdict. The Minister to-night began with the same preposterous misrepresentation that he began with last night. He said that the total Estimates this year amount to £29,709,000 and that last year they amounted to £27,000,000. They were nothing of the kind. The Estimates last year were £22,000,900; this year they are £29,709,000, and no amount of wriggling on the part of the Minister will get away from that fact.
Comment on this
I understand the Estimates too well. On top of the Estimates must be put the Central Fund, and on top of that such Supplementary Estimates as the Government must bring in in the course of the year. Last year these amounted to about £5,000,000. They will not amount to so much this year. But we do not know. That will represent a total expenditure in this year of between £35,000,000 and £39,000,000. That communication is made to this House while I have in my hand one of the documents that produced the miracle of Fianna Fáil being returned to office in two succeeding general elections. You can fool them once, and I am sorry for them; you can fool them twice, and I am sorry for them again, but if you can do it the third time, then God help the dupes. Here is what they are fooled with, a delightful piece of Fianna Fáil literature. It is written more in sorrow than in anger, and is headed "They call it folly." What do they call folly? When the Fianna Fáil Party expressed horror at the huge sum that Cunmann na nGaedheal promised to spend in the government of this country—£27,000,000—they called it folly.
"When the Fianna Fáil Party proposed a reduction of £3,000,000, Cosgrave denounced the proposals as childish folly, and used the automatic majority to vote down every argument used by Republicans in favour of this reduction. The Irish people are far poorer than they were during the Great War. Yet during the Great War the British governed the whole of Ireland at a cost of £12,761,666."
The base, brutal and bloody British Saxon, according to the Ministry, governed this country for £12,761,666. Let us take the Minister's statement as representing the fact, as it was on that he based his argument. Great Britain governed this country for £12,761,000. It continues: "Everybody knows that Great Britain was not niggardly in spending Irish money."
Comment on this
I am not prepared to give way. "To-day," says the leaflet, overflowing with solicitude for the agricultural community,
"the agricultural prices show that, for every £100 they made in 1911, the Irish farmers now make £131, but for every £100 of taxation in 1911 under the British, the Cosgrave Government now demands £376. When Fianna Fáil pointed out these facts in the Free State Parliament and declared that they showed the absolute necessity for a reduction in the appalling cost of government, Deputy Cosgrave and his automatic majority called it childish and voted down the proposal even for a reduction of £3,000,000."
A paltry £3,000,000.
"The Cumann na nGaedheal candidate stands for this impudent refusal to reduce taxation nearer the pockets of the people. He asks the people to vote for more impoverishment still.
Vote for the Fianna Fáil candidate and taxes the people can bear."
£27,000,000 and now a minimum of £35,000,000, with a possible £39,000,000. The trade then was represented as being only £30 per cent. higher than in 1911. It is now substantially lower than it was in 1911. Yet, the Minister for Industry and Commerce has the incomparable audacity to get up in this House and defend those extraordinary proposals. In the usual childish Fianna Fáil way, he does not attempt to defend the items responsible for this inflated taxation. What he says is: "If you have anything to suggest, suggest it. We are waiting for you to say something."
Comment on this
The Minister, in his endeavour to be facetious, desires to escape the unpleasant facts. But it will not work. I shall tell him what he could reduce and reduce very conveniently in these Estimates. He could reduce the Secret Service Vote. He could reduce the £25,000 to a figure no greater than his predecessors ever asked. In their last year in office, his predecessors spent £2,700 on the Secret Service. This year, Fianna Fáil—the Government of peace, prosperity, love and Christian charity—requires £25,000 to pay their spies. The Minister could reduce the Estimate of his own Department. The cost of his own Department is up by £100,000.
Comment on this
That is the Department which has the handling of the licensing provisions of the statutes passed through the Oireachtas. That is the Department that distributes flour licences in County Donegal.
Comment on this
Twelve months ago, the Minister for Industry and Commerce stood up here to sponsor a tariff on egg boxes. I warned the Minister then that if he did that he would do an additional grievous injury to an important branch of the agricultural industry. He did it in his usual ignorant way and, as a result of that tariff, thousands of Irish eggs were a few weeks ago taken out of the cold stores in Glasgow and destroyed by the public health authority, as unfit for human consumption. Bear in mind that these eggs——
Comment on this
On this Bill, specific tariffs may not be discussed nor can the administration of particular tariffs be discussed.
Comment on this
He should consider whether statements of that kind are going to help the country's trade in eggs. Wild statements of that kind should not be made.
Comment on this
The Minister had plenty of time to make his speech. This very question, I should like to point out respectfully, was raised on this Vote before, and representations were made in respect of it. I merely desire to raise the same matter that was raised on the Vote before in order to draw the attention of the House to the Minister's reaction to the representation.
Comment on this
The House is considering not a Vote, but a Bill. The Vote on Account was debated yesterday. When the Estimates for the Departments come up for consideration, details may be discussed. That will be a more appropriate time.
Comment on this
I think I should be allowed to conclude, briefly, in view of the attempt of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to misrepresent me.
Comment on this
The Minister said that with the deliberate intention of ensuring that you would take a particular view. He knows it is not true, and I hope you will permit me to refute it. The quality of the eggs, as shipped, was the finest quality going into the Glasgow market——
Comment on this
The Deputy is not in order in suggesting that the Minister acted on the presumption of the Chair ruling in a certain way.
Comment on this
I should be long sorry to reflect on the Chair in any way, but I would have no hesitation whatever in reflecting on the Minister. I know very well what the Minister's intention was.
Comment on this
It is a reflection on the competence of the Ministers on the Front Bench. A substantial economy could be made in that Department. As regards the Army, we all remember that, year after year, Fianna Fáil challenged the then Government to reduce the Army Estimate. This year, we have the Army Estimate raised by £250,000 and that for the purpose of putting arms into the hands of every young man in the country. That is a reduction that might well be made. There could be a reduction of £2,250,000 in the bounties if the Government had the courage to go and settle the economic war that they were responsible for precipitating. Their own President has said in public that he fired the first shot in that war. He has stated in public that he thanks God the British market has gone. And he has an estimate for £2,250,000 to-day in order to buy his way back into the market that, he thanks God, he threw away. That is an economy that might be made. If that economy were made and if you afforded an opportunity to our people to earn their living without subsidies, grants, doles or anything else, there would be a lot more to be said in defence of the swollen Estimates now before us.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce wants to know whether we would be prepared to advocate the repeal of that part of the Cereals Act which provides for the Indian meal admixture scheme. I should be prepared to vote for the repeal of the whole Cereals Produce Act because they have gone about the promotion of cereal production in the most inefficient, extravagant, and ineffective way they possibly could have gone about it. So far as flour production under the Cereals Act is concerned, it is costing the country little short of £750,000 per annum. The employment afforded by it cannot exceed 300 men in the mills of this country. I say that the Indian meal admixture scheme is costing the farmers of this country £2 a ton on their feeding stuffs. I have not computed the average annual cost of that to the whole country, but it must be a break and a burden for pig producers, fowl producers, egg producers and cattle raisers in this country of an appalling nature. Neither the Minister for Industry and Commerce, nor the Minister for Finance, knows the first thing about the interests which, in their ignorance, they are injuring and destroying in this country. We are told we are to have a grand experiment now for the improvement of Irish manufacture in the promotion of the manufacture in this country of industrial alcohol. That is held out to the unfortunate people driven to despair by the misery inflicted upon them by this Government. Anxious to cling to any straw, they turn to the vague promises of the Ministry to set up an alcoholic industry in this country. They know, and we know, that the price of that is about 3/- per gallon and that the product for which it is substituted can be bought on the Dublin quays at 4d. per gallon. And we are told this is a necessary means of relieving the industrial problem in this country.
Nothing, to my mind, is more revolting than the dragging of the unemployed into discussions, and using them in a kind of game of battledore and shuttlecock in this House. I have not the slightest doubt that the Minister for Industry and Commerce is just as anxious as I am to get the unemployed men of this country back to work. We never impugned his honesty on that score. I am sure there is not a Deputy in this House who does not share that anxiety. But it is more than patience can bear when we see men losing their jobs—many of them losing permanent jobs that they held for years—and then to be told by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that the unemployment problem was never better than it is to-day. I am not going to dwell upon that. All I say is ask the Leader of the Labour Party, and ask the members of the Labour Party, to get up in public and state their views as to the conditions of unemployment in this country. In every speech they make they declare that the present situation is bad, and they point out to the Government the enormous and the growing problem confronting us. Let us make no capital out of that. For goodness' sake, let Ministers join with us in the face of this great and growing problem, in agreeing that what we have done so far does not seem to have struck at the root of the problem and that we must try to do something more. We have our view, and that is that unless you can restore the general prosperity of the country unemployment is bound to rise, and that, struggle as you may, if you destroy the sources of your main industry, factories must close and the rate of unemployment must rise. You must restore prosperity to the consuming public and unless you secure that everything else you do is going to go by the board.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce talked about making economies and said that when the Government tried to make them we obstructed them. All last week, he said, the Local Services (Temporary Economies) Bill was held up by the Party opposite. Has he forgotten what the Fianna Fáil promises were? Has he forgotten that what induced the Labour Party to call upon the people to return the Fianna Fáil Party to power was the promise that they would reduce taxation by two millions per year, without interfering with anybody's salary and without reducing the public and social services? The only contribution the Government has made to that promise is to reduce salaries. In present circumstances, I am one of those who think that something could be said for reducing salaries if you have no other means of effecting economies, but what taxes one's patience is to see men's salaries cut while dozens of other officials are appointed to swallow up the economies you are making at the expense of your own workers. It is the same principle that the labour sweater has advocated ever since the wheels of machinery turned in Manchester. If you want more work cut down the employees' wages and hire a few more men. That is the rottenest form of economy that could be embarked upon. Unless you start out with the principle that you are giving every man a fair day's wage, and insisting upon every man giving you a fair day's work, and even expecting him to lend a hand, and to give a little extra effort to help you out in time of stress you are on wrong lines. If you reduce staffs to the lowest possible level consistent with efficiency and that you are satisfied every man is giving you the best and that you are still in difficulty, then I say that it is just to go to the employee and say, "you must share these difficult times with me. I, as employer, will make my contribution to the deficiency and I ask you to make yours." But before doing that you should make sure you have made every form of economy that efficiency and good directorship can secure. Unless you have done that you are making for inefficiency in the public services and endangering the Departments of State. The Minister gets up and says, "do you want us to build houses?" Of course, everyone wants the Government to build houses. No one is a more strenuous advocate of housing than I am. I was a strenuous advocate of the building of houses before the Minister for Industry and Commerce began to talk about it. We could spend all this money on social services if the financial stability of the country was not being destroyed. If there was any light on the horizon, or any prospect of revival, a burden of that kind could be borne comparatively easily. It is a legitimate thing to pledge the future prosperity of the country in order to redress the present crying evil. But the whole problem is that, so far as any rational man can see, there is no future except disaster. We are squandering our capital on this infernal economic war. We are also pouring it out all over the country when we should be applying it to social services, to solving the housing problem and things of that kind. But we are trying to burn the candle at both ends. At the same time that we are spending huge sums on social services of this kind we are wiping out the sources of our income in the agricultural industry. That is why this note of warning is struck. That is the whole case put from these benches. Our trade is dwindling, our prosperity is vanishing and at the same time the Estimates for the Government services are going up. Improvement, says the Minister for Industry and Commerce, can be made and will be made in the old age pension system. That is a very interesting declaration. What is the nature of this improvement to be? I think every Deputy in the Fianna Fáil Party ought to pay a call to the Minister for Industry and Commerce and ask him what the improvements in the old age pensions legislation are going to be. Is it going to be tightened up, or what is it? I do not know of any Act for which the Fianna Fáil Government is responsible that is more deserving of commendation than the Act by which they restored the pensions to the old age pensioners, and I freely give them credit for that.
Will Deputies, asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce, repeal the Unemployment Assistance Act when they come into office? They will not, and if the Minister would throw back his mind a few months he would remember that the first time the principle of that Act was accepted in this House it was on a motion put down by Deputy Morrissey for discussion, calling on the Government to provide work or maintenance for the unemployed. I well remember President de Valera getting up and saying at the conclusion of a long debate "Very well, we are accepting the principle of that motion and when we call on you to implement it we hope you will stand by us in doing so." We did stand by the Government in doing so. The motion was put down and spoken to, and we meant what we said, so that the Unemployment Assistance Act was the consequence of the introduction of that motion from this side of the House.
Now the Minister for Industry and Commerce is a remarkable man in the way in which he tosses things off. Sometimes he would like to forget them. Somebody said to him, when he rejoiced in the fact that he had come back to office the second time, "How did you come back?""What does it matter," said the Minister for Industry and Commerce; "we came back and that is all that matters." That is the doctrine of Fianna Fáil. Out on the hustings, promise the people anything: promise the sun, moon and stars, but get back. Do not fail to promise anything that may be necessary to get us back; promise them a reduction in taxation, an increase in social services, a settlement of the economic war, the de-rating of agricultural land, an increase in the Gaeltacht services: promise them, in fact, anything you like, it does not matter, we will endorse any promises you make until the election is over, and then we will all try to forget. If the people will not forget, we will put up the Minister for Education to explain to them that when you are fighting an election you have to make promises that you do not mean, or we will put up Deputy Dowdall who will explain to them that promises made off election platforms are not promises but just statements.
Comment on this
I hesitate to be quite so trenchant as my colleague, Deputy Burke, who says "A respectable name for a lie." I cannot imagine Deputy Dowdall ever telling a lie, but it is an interesting outlook on life: on the hustings, promise them anything, bearing in mind that promises made on the hustings are not promises, they are only statements. If the people do not know what Fianna Fáil statements are by this time, well then more foolish are the people.
Comment on this
It is difficult to have patience really with the extraordinary indifference of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to the implications of what he himself has said. He proceeded to compare the prices that were current in this country in 1931 with the prices that have been current throughout 1933 and 1934. Now, in order to do that he had to look at the trade returns for those years, and how he could do so, without visibly blushing, I do not know. I am going to read for Fianna Fáil Deputies the trade returns, month by month, since they came into office, and the trade returns relating to the year before they came into office. In the January before they came into office our exports were £2,991,000; the figure for January of this year is £1,255,000. The adverse trade balance in January, 1931, was £563 on exports of practically £3,000,000. This year there was an adverse trade balance of £1,076,000 on exports of £1,255,000. Next month the figure is £2,915,000 as against £1,356,000; next month £2,951,000 as against £1,774,000; next month £2,636,000 as against £1,447,000; next month £2,630,000 as against £1,582,000; I should say that in October 1933 the trade was £3,848,000, and last October £1,942,000. The trade of this country is progressively vanishing. The adverse trade balance is within measurable distance of being as great as our total exports now. In this year of grace, with these figures before our eyes, the highest Estimates that have ever been introduced in this House, except in one financial year at the very beginning of this State, are being presented by a Fianna Fáil Government. Is it any wonder that people are astonished at the effrontery of the present Administration? The Minister for Industry and Commerce quoted, as evidence of our increasing prosperity, our rising imports of tea, tobacco, etc. I dealt with that contention last night at some length, and I do not propose to cover that ground again. By some extraordinary whimsey the Minister seemed to hear from Deputy MacDermot an unqualified endorsement of the industrial policy of Fianna Fáil. I do not know how he heard it, nobody else heard it. Deputy MacDermot has been criticising and condemning the general policy of Fianna Fáil up and down the country during the last few years, and he has been amply confirmed in his prognostications and in his views.
When Senator Connolly arrived in the Lower Rosses with tar barrels, with sods of turf blazing on hay forks, and with Deputy Brian Brady in the midst of the throng, we were told that the Senator had come to the Rosses with salvation in one hand and a bag of gold in the other: that the bogs were going to be converted into gold mines, that the Rosses were going to flow with milk and honey, and that all that the people had to wait for was to give the Senator time to get back to Dublin until he proclaimed the millennium and sent back Deputy Brady and Deputy Hugh Doherty with their hands dripping with benevolence. They are still waiting. I wrote a letter on behalf of a poor fellow who lives in the Lower Rosses to say that several months ago he wrote to the Gaeltacht Housing Department to know would they lend him a few pounds to build a pig sty. Now that was not much. That was not an awful lot, but I got a letter to-day from the Department of Gaeltacht Housing to say that they had received my letter and that they were sorry to tell me that the Minister had a great many applications to look into and that he could not look into the question of this poor fellow's pig-sty for several months to come. Now we are told that the Government is ready to pour out money for housing to improve social conditions, but here is an unfortunate fellow in the Lower Rosses who wants to build a pig-sty and the Minister has not time to look into the question, he has so many applications to consider and he will not be able to look into it for some considerable time. In fact, he regrets to inform me that he does not know when he will have time.
Comment on this
The Deputy has been told that to debate an individual tariff would be out of order. How much more, therefore, would a debate on the question of one pig-sty in the Rosses be out of order?
Comment on this
Surely it is relevant to suggest that the Minister, having gone up there with these sods of turf, his tar barrels and Deputy Brian Brady, and having come back to Dublin and having got with his tar barrels and his sods of turf and Deputy Brian Brady what he wanted from the people of the Rosses, that he has very rapidly forgotten the people from whom he got what he has got on false pretences?
Comment on this
The question is whether we are providing enough money for proper purposes or too much money for wrong purposes. The Minister is well aware, having listened to his colleague, that the fullest indulgence was asked of the Chair and was graciously granted. I do not propose to go one inch further than the Minister's colleague went, and certainly I think, when I bring Senator Connolly or his successor face to face with the pig-sty from the Rosses, the people of the Rosses will fully understand what the promises that were made to them by Senator Connolly, Deputy Brady and Deputy Hugh Doherty in the light of the tar barrels and the sods of turf were worth. They were aptly described by Deputy Dowdall—just mere statements. That is what the statements were worth.
In conclusion, Sir, reference was made to the Vote for the Department of Justice. I am sorry the Attorney-General is not here. It is none of my concern to comment, nor do I intend to do, so, on any verdict of the Military Tribunal, but I do want to comment on the instruction received by counsel appearing before the Tribunal. Some men were brought before the Military Tribunal on the charge of carrying firearms and using them without a permit. I have no complaint whatever to make of men, who were associated in arms with another man who is now dead, paying any tribute they deem proper over the grave of their deceased comrade; but I have every complaint to make that men should use an occasion of that kind, which should be sacred to every man, for a flagrant breach of the law and a defiance of the duly elected Government of this country. I have every complaint to make that State counsel, when they come to prosecute these men, go into court on instructions which amount to this: that the court is invited to say, by counsel representing the Attorney-General, that a man who illegally uses a firearm, and who retains possession after he is prosecuted, is to be let go, even though he openly defies the jurisdiction of the court and defies the right of the court to try him by refusing to plead, while other men who are not charged with using a firearm, who were admittedly men of high character and law-abiding men, are prosecuted to conviction for having in their possession a firearm and are sentenced to six months in jail.
Comment on this
The Deputy said he had no intention of doing certain things. He is now contrasting two sentences.
Comment on this
I have no comment to make on the decision of the court. What I desire to comment on, without any reference to the decision arrived at yesterday by the Military Tribunal, is the speech made by counsel for the State before the Military Tribunal. I have no comment to make on the sentence of six months' imprisonment on a man for having arms illegally in his possession.
Comment on this
One moment. I am addressing the Chair. I am suggesting it is a matter that would be more properly discussed on the Vote for the Department of Justice or the Vote for Law Charges.
Comment on this
The matter could be more properly raised on another occasion, but the Deputy is not out of order in raising it now.
Comment on this
The point I make is this. I do not desire to comment in any way on the verdict which condemned a certain man to prison for six months for the possession of arms, but I do desire to complain that State counsel should go into court with an instruction, when making exactly similar allegations on behalf of the State, deliberately to ask the court to take an entirely different course. It does not matter what the court subsequently did; it does not arise. The fact is that the Attorney-General instructs counsel to go in to make identical allegations against two different men and he instructs counsel to say—"Press for a conviction against A. and ask the court to acquit B." That is not justice, and the Attorney-General who gives such instructions should be ashamed of himself. I would not complain if the Attorney-General's instructions to counsel were to state the facts and make no comment, to leave the matter to the court, but I do complain that one attitude is adopted towards one body of men and another attitude is adopted towards another body. That has been done. Life is not worth living in a country where common justice is going to be withheld from the people in that way.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Minister should keep order until I have finished. He can then speak as long as he likes.
Comment on this
Well, as long as he is allowed. There is no use arguing, if it is the intention of the Minister to argue, that because somebody did me an injustice in the past I am entitled to do the other fellow an injustice now. I do not for a moment accept, as I have already indicated to the Minister, his version of a lot of things that happened in the past, and he will not accept mine. There is no use in going into those things——
Comment on this
——because we both know, when we are starting off, that neither can hope to convert the other. He has one view; with me another view obtains. Here is a question that we can discuss as two individuals in the public life of the country, and here is the Attorney-General who is responsible for it. I am particularly glad to see him here on this occasion. I say it is not dealing out even-handed justice to instruct State counsel going into court—I am repeating this, A Chinn Comhairle, because the Attorney-General has just come in—to conduct the prosecution of two different groups of men charged with an identical crime, to prosecute one to conviction and to prosecute the other with a clear request to the court to acquit, or at least to forbear from sentencing. That is not justice. That is not holding the scales of justice impartially, as the Attorney-General claimed to hold them a couple of nights ago. I do not underestimate the difficulties attendant on the duties of the Attorney-General in this State, no matter what Government he belongs to. The courts are there, and there is necessity for judicial consideration of the facts laid before them. You have two groups of men, both charged with illegal possession of arms, and you have one body of men going into court and saying: "I desire to make my respectful submission to the court, to receive its verdict, and to abide by its sentence, whatever it may be," and you instruct State counsel: "Those men should be prosecuted to conviction—not vindictively, but prosecuted to conviction." You have brought before the court another group of men, charged with having and using firearms, and they get up and say: "We will not plead," which is as much as to say: "We do not recognise the court; we do not recognise its right to try us; we do not recognise the right of the Attorney-General to arraign us." After adopting that attitude before the whole country, State counsel comes forward and as much as says: "We had to prosecute them, but we do not want to have them convicted." That is not justice. It is the worst form of injustice; it is administrative injustice; it is interference by the Executive with the courts. There is no remedy in the hands of the civilians of the State against that kind of thing. If it develops in this country then God help everyone who had the misfortune to be born an Irishman.
If conditions are going to arise in this country in which the Attorney-General will adopt different attitudes towards different men, simply because some of them belong to one political organisation and others belong to another, justice and decency in the administration of the law will have ceased in this country. He has an enormous responsibility on his shoulders. On him rests the responsibility for preserving a tradition that has been well maintained in this country for the last ten years—even justice for every citizen. No one will be more culpable than he if that tradition is destroyed. He is the head of the Irish Bar. The traditions of the Bar and the traditions of the profession are in his hands. He got them clean and decent, and he is well able to maintain them if he wants to. In so far as he gave his instructions to counsel in the case before the Military Tribunal yesterday I cannot see how he can reconcile it with his sense of duty. That reference was made—and it was properly made—on the Vote in respect of the Department of Justice. There remains the last matter which I referred to as a possible source of economy, and that is the Secret Service Vote. I should like to hear the Minister for Finance——
Comment on this
Well, I am very anxious to hear the Minister for Finance explain how it is that when £10,000 was sufficient for his predecessors, the greater part of which they did not spend in any year, it has become necessary for him to spend £25,000. I ask him to remember, when he is paying spies to spy on his political opponents, that they will concoct stories so long as there is money forthcoming to pay for the stories. I ask him to bear in mind that if panic and hysteria are being created in Government circles by the information which is reaching them it is largely their own fault. If they put out notices offering to buy that information they will get plenty to avail of the offer. I want to remind them that they would be much better employed in spending that money on something else. So far as we are concerned, the spies are welcome. As I said last night, if they can turn an honest penny mooching around our premises, or prying into our letters, or conducting the other laudable occupations of a paid spy, they are welcome to it, but public money could be better spent. I suggest to the Minister for Finance that before the Budget is introduced he should consider the economies under the heads I have mentioned, and I suggest to the Attorney-General that after yesterday he should steel his resolution to stand a more stern custodian over the honour of the profession of which he is the head in Ireland.
Comment on this
A Chinn Comhairle, while the Attorney-General is here. I should like to follow immediately in Deputy Dillon's footsteps in speaking with regard to the contrast in the type of prosecutions of those who are before the Military Tribunal belonging to two different political parties. Like him, I should like to make clear at the outset that I have no fault to find, good, bad or indifferent, with people who may differ from me politically to-day when they assemble either by way of firing a volley of shots, or by way of paying any other tribute to the memory of a man who was unquestionably a gallant soldier of this country. When I refer by way of contrast to the type of prosecution that was aimed at men from Cork, and to the type of prosecution that was aimed at men from Leix, I am dealing purely with the instructions delivered to the prosecuting counsel in each of the two types of case in which the offences were exactly the same.
We had a group of men from the South of Ireland before the Military Tribunal and the offence was, that they had arms in defiance of the existing laws of this State, and the fact, undisputed and uncontested, was not only that they had those arms but used those arms, and, in addition, that those arms are not now in the custody of the State. We had two men from Leix, neighbours and friends of my own, before the same Tribunal in the same week—men whose records as soldiers of Ireland would only be second to that of the man who died in Cork—and their offence was that they had arms. There was no suggestion, no evidence, that they had used those arms, and those arms are now in the custody of the State. A learned gentleman, instructed, I must presume, by the Attorney-General, pointed out the gravity of the offence committed by these Leix men—the gravity of holding arms, the gravity of being within reach of arms —and those men were sentenced to a heavy term of imprisonment. They knew they broke the law. They did not whine at the imprisonment. They did recognised the court and I am not complaining of the sentence. What I am pointing out is that it was quite evident that the instructions of the prosecuting counsel were to press that case and to press for a heavy penalty. I was there when the case was on. Then, we had another group, charged with the same offence of possessing rifles in defiance of the laws of this State—belonging to a different political party, it is true—and except counsel flew in the face of the instructions he got, clearly his instructions were not to press the case, not to ask for any penalty, not to demand any punishment—and no punishment was inflicted.
We heard a lot in the last week about impartiality, about holding the scales of justice equally and about there being no discrimination against political opponents and here, hot foot on all these protestations, we have in the same week, pressure for a heavy penalty for a certain offence and a demand that no punishment be inflicted for a similar offence. The Executive Council has power to remit sentences and while I am not complaining of the sentences imposed on those two Leix men, I would urge that if the Executive Council is not to be discredited for all time as the most partial administrators that ever occupied a Government front bench, and if the Attorney-General is to keep the honour and respect which has always been accorded to his office, this is a case where the Executive Council should step in and equate the penalties where the offences are equal. In those two cases, there is no punishment for one group and a long term of imprisonment for the other. I am not urging punishment for the southerners. I am urging that the same treatment should be given to the Leix men; and it is within the power of the Executive Council to step in now and equate things by remitting the sentence imposed on those Leix men.
It is a test of impartiality; it is a test of the equal pressure of the law and of a fair crack of the whip of the law, when you get two cases, the offences being exactly equal but the political labels in their coats different and different instructions issued to the prosecuting counsel. I do not think that I am exceeding what is common knowledge when I say that different instructions were given in each case to the prosecuting counsel, because, in one case, the counsel said that it was the type of case in which he had to look for a heavy punishment and in the other case, if it is properly recorded in the newspapers, the prosecuting counsel said "I am not here to press for punishment." In other words, he said clearly to the court that in spite of the breach of the law and in spite of the offence committed, he was not there, as representing the Attorney-General, to look for any punishment. Be that as it may, the one thing that I am urging in this case and the one thing that is necessary if the Government and the office of Attorney-General are to keep the respect they should get from the country, is the remission of the sentence in one case, so that when men commit the same offence, they will have equal liberty and will both be allowed to go home to look after their families and their farms. I raised that point because I thought that if I was going to deal with such a point, in fair play to the Attorney-General it should be dealt with when he was present, and I hope that when he speaks in this debate, he will give an assurance that any influence he has will be used with the Executive Council to remit the sentence on those two Leix men and to see that, for the same offence, they will enjoy the same amount of liberty or the same punishment as men who hail from County Cork.
I have often heard that figures can prove anything but all my life, I have been rather bad at figures and I am not easily convinced by figures. We have heard figures used in this debate from one side and the other to prove directly opposite points of view, but while I am not easily impressed by figures, like most other people, I am impressed by facts and whereas we may either agree or agree to differ as to the rightness of the present economic policy of this country or as to the national necessity for some particular course, I think that any Deputy on the opposite benches, who keeps his feet down on the ground, will admit the facts of the situation and that all the Couéism which the Minister for Industry and Commerce can bring into play will not "kid" the people of this country into believing that, in fact, they are prosperous now. Any honest Deputy on the other benches who goes down the country and moves amongst the people knows that, whether it is necessary or not, there was never in our recollection as desperate a state of affairs existing in this country as exists at the present moment, and any Deputy who has the courage to stand up and say it, knows that whether you take the farmer, the working labourer, the labourer who is out of work, the shopkeeper in the town or the professional man, everyone in his own walk of life is unable to look round the corner of one month, that county finances are running out and that the prospect ahead is as black a prospect as ever was witnessed in this country.
It is not honest and it is not fair to the people for any Minister with a glib tongue to get up from the front bench here and to announce that we are living through the boom of prosperity, that work was never so plentiful, and money so loose and free in the country. That is a bad joke at the expense of the people who are going through it. It is doing no good, because when people, knowing the facts, listen to that kind of tommy-rot, the result is that they lose faith in any form of democratic institution in this country. They will say: "These men up in Government Buildings know nothing about the country. They are up there saying we are prosperous, and where am I to turn for work?" It would be better in the long run—even better politics—to face up to the facts as they are and to grapple with them. You cannot, by a glib tongue or a noisy speech, convince a hungry man that he has had his dinner. You cannot, by a glib tongue or a noisy speech, convince a fellow who is out of work that he has work. Neither can you convince the man who is getting rotten prices that he is getting good prices. The proof of the pudding is in the eating.
What are the two big sums that we have? There is one huge sum, something nearly £1,500,000, for maintenance of the unemployed. I do not begrudge one penny of that, but why is it necessary? It is necessary because unemployment is prevalent and because destitution is rife. What is the other big sum? We have £2,500,000 to get stock out of this country and into England—£2,500,000 to help stock out, and £5,000,000 on the other side to help it in. We have £7,500,000 for the sake of sticking on to £5,000,000, and losing our good name. We are asked how this Vote could be reduced. A little sprinkling of common honesty would reduce it by £2,500,000 on the figures before us. It is not denied that you are paying your annuities to John Bull. You are paying them on the head of every beast going into the market, on the beak of every chicken and on every hamper of eggs that go into the market; and according to the figures published, and not disputed, the equivalent of what is being retained is being collected. Now, that might be contradicted because the figures are not actually equal. Neither is the length for which one is being collected and the other retained. Tariffs were imposed on, I think, the 11th July, and the annuities were retained from the 1st January. Making allowance for that particular six months, the exact equivalent of what you are retaining is being collected on the other side.
Comment on this
They are being collected from the unfortunate farmer by a tax on his produce. Who else do you think is paying? That is the kind of silliness that this country is suffering from. It is that kind of shallowness that has brought about this situation where we have a grant of £1,500,000 to bring about employment in this country. That kind of silliness is at the bottom of the curse that is over the country at the moment, and as long as we have that kind of irresponsible, frivolous mentality in charge of one of the most important Departments of the State, we will find these sums going up year after year as they have gone up since that particular mentality took charge of that Department. It is irresponsibility flavoured with dishonesty, because I do not care whether a promise is called a promise or a statement, the promises of public men are the only thing to which the electorate of this country can pin their faith. If the people are constantly disillusioned, if they lose faith in the integrity and honesty of the public men of the country, and if they cannot put trust in the words these men say publicly, then they will lose faith in Parliament and the end of this country will be worse than the beginning.
We hear a lot of talk deploring unconstitutional action. We hear of throwing our arms in a heap in order to build a cross out of them. If there is one thing calculated to drive the people of this country back into unconstitutional action, it is for responsible people to be reckless about the words passed by them to the public. Here we have year after year a mounting bill; and it must be recollected that it is only just three years ago since we had the Minister for Industry and Commerce, then Deputy Lemass, and the Minister for Finance, then. Deputy MacEntee, speaking from these benches here and weeping crocodile tears at the extravagance and the undue height of taxation in this country. We were told that we were a little island people, that we were aping the expenditure and machinery of a great empire; that we had our Civil Service moulded on the Civil Service of a great empire; and that the people of this country or the industry of this country could not afford to keep a Civil Service of the size we had, or an Army of the size we had, or a police force of the size we had. With all the accompaniments of play-acting, we had from these benches year after year an attack on the people who sat over there for the size of their Army, the size of their police force and the size of their Civil Service. We had, by one speaker after another, pledges given that they would reduce the strength of all those services and bring the size of those services into line with the strength of the country. That was just three years ago, and since that time, since Fianna Fáil got into office, you have every one of these services growing visibly month after month and year after year; more tens of thousands of pounds required—hundreds of thousands of pounds required—and hundreds and thousands more people taken in, so that the Civil Service is inflated beyond recognition. If there was any honesty when these people were over here, then there must be absolute dishonesty when they got over there; and if they are honest over there now, then they were completely dishonest in their statements over here. We have a Civil Service grown beyond recognition. We have a new Army super-imposed on the old Army. We have a new police force added to the old police force. Then, to keep the face of economy on the most extravagant Government that ever cursed this country, we have an axe applied to the salaries and wages of the servants of the State. Even then, no lesson is learned by the fact that if you interfere with salaries you will have so many going out on pension that the economy will end in increased expenditure. So we have, in this year's Estimate as against last year's Estimate, an extra £25,000 for pensions. In the light of that, this economy, which means increased expenditure, must be carried down to local services. We have been asked to make suggestions with regard to reductions.
Deputy Dillon has made many suggestions. He has pointed out your increase in Secret Service expenditure. Will we get any explanation of that increase? We know there have been tales carried to the Government, tales which have even put the President in a most humiliating position. We have action taken based on these silly stories that were carried to the Executive Council, and that action has plunged this country into an expenditure of hundreds of thousands of pounds. We had silly stories about Deputy Mulcahy's movements, we had silly stories about General O'Duffy's movements, and following each silly story we had more and more expenditure. Is that what the country got from increased Secret Service expenditure?
A Vote increased by 150 per cent. wants some explanation, not the details of the expenditure, but the conditions that necessitated the increase of 150 per cent. We have this new Vote for a new Army, for a new police force, and we have this launched as a non-political Army. But we have every possible precaution taken that it must be a political Army. We have only one group in key positions, and we have it laid down that these men give the certificate without which nobody can go before the tribunal or committee. We have every precaution taken that it must be a political Army.
In view of the economic circumstances existing in this country, in view of the slump in trade, in view of the loss of markets, in view of the widespread destitution and the amount of unemployment, I think the first gesture of real economy and the first gesture of impartial administration would be the abolition of forces that are going to cost much money and which are definitely political in their nature and foundation.
Comment on this
I did not intend to speak on this Estimate, but when I heard the speech made by Deputy Dr. O'Higgins I considered that something might be said on that subject. The Deputy speaks of economy and how the Government should economise in much the same way as he would have spoken when the late Government was in power. I take it that he would admit that economy, as far as government is concerned, in a country that is highly protected, is totally different from the economy that is practised in a country that has free trade. We here have decided to protect this country, industrially as well as agriculturally. I do not think that that is exactly our decision. Many people and parties previous to us had come to the conclusion that protection was one of the things this country demanded and needed. In fact, for generations it was preached and accepted by the people, but their misfortune was that they did not just have an opportunity of putting it into practice.
I take it, Deputy O'Higgins will agree with me on this point, that the economy as practised now is somewhat different from the economy practised before the advent to power of the Fianna Fáil Government. You had then in power a Government which was semi-protective. They had gone as far as to satisfy more or less what they would call, perhaps, the extreme men in their own Party. But we had decided that we would practise to the full the policy of protection. We found that certain occurrences here gave us an opportunity and, perhaps, forced us to take the opportunity of protecting this country. In the few months after we had adopted that we found that other countries were inclined to do the same thing. A great country like England, which based its prosperity largely on free trade teachings, was ultimately compelled to adopt the same attitude as we did. In fact, the world position to-day is that all countries have erected around them tariff barriers, and all countries are giving bounties and subsidies on the exports of their produce.
What I want to refer to particularly is world conditions. Deputy O'Higgins spoke exactly as if things were the same as they were two years ago, or 20 years ago. But we must remember that world conditions are not now the same. A week ago we had the Minister of Agriculture for England speaking, I think, in Scotland, lamenting the position and sympathising with the farmers of England and saying that this year was the worst year that they had experienced in farming in 130 years. It is quite obvious that it is not sunshine with them there. One of the main arguments used here is that we deliberately gave away the market, referring always, of course, to the British market. Now, the British market was a valuable market. It was a valuable market.
Comment on this
What about the English farmer? Has he any claim or any standing there? I think he could do with a little assistance in getting that market. He might give us the benefit of it. But as he is to-day he does not own his own market. His Ministers admit that; they are not denying it. They are making every effort possible, and one direction is in the direction that we talk most about, and that is the market for beef. The English farmer will have considerable difficulty ever to get that market. None of their responsible Ministers there deny that difficulty. Deputies here spoke of the English farmers. What do they say about it? They say, if they could keep out the Argentine and South American meat they would have a chance for their own industry. But what do the Ministers say? The Ministers and the Government say: "This is a very delicate question: we will proceed slowly." What do the working population of England say? They say: "No, no, we are not going to pay 1/- or 1/6 for meat when we can get Argentime meat for a few pence." We have got to face up to that position. Whatever we do to carry on, to some extent, on the stores side. I believe we would have to do what the British did, to think seriously about the beef question and about where markets are to be got. The value of poultry produced in Great Britain and Ireland last year was as great as that secured from beef. About 80 or 90 per cent. of the meat used in Great Britain is foreign. Are we entitled to continue to hope that within the next 20 years that market will ever be recovered by the British farmers, not alone by us? Deputies on the opposite benches should consider all these facts. Instead of lamenting what is gone, they should co-operate with us to see if something more substantial could not be done for the future. Deputies on these benches will not turn down any workable suggestions from the other side.
Comment on this
Suggestions have been made. One thing is that it would be unfair to the farmers of this country to tell them to depend on a particular market. It is only fair that farmers should be told to do what we have told them to do, and what the Minister of Agriculture in England has told the farmers there to do—to change their system. No one will deny that. The same day that the British Minister told the farmers to grow more wheat, as the only thing to do, the Minister for Agriculture here was saying the same thing to Irish farmers. It is not fair or right to encourage a body of men to pursue a course that is doomed.
Comment on this
Speaking seriously, I do not think the people have much to regret. I know as much about the meat and the cattle trades as any Deputy. I know that as a result of following a certain policy the people were forced out of this country as rapidly as they could get away. An industry that does that, and that reduces our population below 3,000,000, is not one that any democratic Government should wish to maintain. As an alternative industry I admit that it is good enough if it can be kept going and is profitable. What is the position here? Since 1929, which was the year of the great collapse, the cattle industry has been going down year by year. This question has been made a political one by the other side. The Party opposite believe that if they could start this stunt they could torpedo the people into supporting them. They failed, because the people are sensible and understand the ins and outs of the question. They know what the position is in England, and what it is in every country that depends upon agriculture. Our export surplus was all agriculture. Was it not time, and only fair to the country to try to make some change? Like sensible men those on the opposite side are beginning to recognise what their leader definitely admitted when he said: "We will do all we can to pursue the policy of the other Party. We will support the industrial side and the wheat policy." Those on the opposite benches profess to have great hopes of a settlement with England. How are they going to bring about a settlement? They could turn their minds to something constructive, and tell us how they are going to bring about the settlement. They could tell us, if tariffs are imposed, what will be the position of English farmers who purchased cattle that cost them £9 here in addition to £6 duty and £2 for other expenses, or a total cost of £17. Where is the English farmer going to come in there? Is there not a problem there? The British farmer wants his own market, but he is willing to give us a slice, if he gets hold of that market. As a matter of fact, the English farmers have less hold on the English market than we have. People on the opposite benches should think the matter over. There is no use going along other lines. The Leader of the Opposition Party is taking up that attitude each Sunday. He adopts a big slice of our policy every week as being the correct one. Next Sunday there will be less to say against it. There is nothing else for that Party to do.
Comment on this
When Deputy O'Reilly intervened at this particular juncture I wondered what was behind his remarks. I wondered all the more when he was speaking for a few moments because, on the rare occasions that he speaks he is very lucid. He was more involved this evening than the average Fianna Fáil back bencher. I thought the Deputy was going to tell the Minister for Finance something about the tobacco industry, in which he is very interested. I thought he was going to give the House his views on the policy of the present Government regarding this year's tobacco crop.
Comment on this
The Deputy went on to deal with agriculture, and naturally we imagined that he would be very interested in the Irish farmer, and would devote his time trying to explain the policy, or lack of policy of his own Ministers. He spent most of the time in making a plea for English farmers, telling us the policy of the British Minister of Agriculture. With all possible respect, I suggest to the Deputy that the British Government and the British Minister of Agriculture are well able to look after their own people. The British farmer is making a better effort to look after his own interest than perhaps the average Irish farmer. I suggest that the Deputy might, with profit to himself, and to his Party, and certainly with profit to the Irish farmers, give that deep study and consideration to the position of Irish farmers which apparently he has given to British agriculture. I want to be brief, because I realise that this Bill, in accordance with the practice of the House has got to go through to-night. Before concluding I want to say that the conclusion I came to at the end of Deputy O'Reilly's speech was that he was put up to kill time. He almost invited interruption. Let it be said to the credit of the Party on these benches, that there was no interruption, because we were not going to play into his hands.
I want to say a few words on what, to my mind, is the most important side of this question. That is with regard to unemployment. I want to deal with the amazing speech delivered last night by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and the even more amazing speech which he delivered this afternoon. Those of us who have had to listen to the Minister for the last seven or eight years, and to a lesser extent, perhaps—because we do not even take him so seriously—to the Minister for Finance, I must say never heard a more barefaced untruth.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce told us last night that the unemployment situation was much better than it was two years ago. I had expected—even yet I am an optimist —that the whole Front Bench of the Labour Party would have jumped to its feet on hearing that. The Minister talked about 45,000 being put into employment in two years. There is not a member sitting on the Labour Benches or on the Fianna Fáil Benches who does not know that that statement is absolutely untrue. What is the basis for that statement? I am prepared to accept the Minister's statement that there were 45,000 extra employment books issued. Has any man on the Fianna Fáil Benches any knowledge of how the unemployment exchanges are worked? You can get 100,000 extra books to-morrow by giving 100,000 men one day's employment. There was not a single member of the Labour Party to remind the Minister of the fact—although they have a motion down on the paper for the last 12 months—that there are to-day more registered unemployed, according to the figures issued by the Minister's own Department, than there ever were in the history of the State. There are 100,000 unemployed. The Minister talked about emigration being stopped. Of course, it is. But he implied that it was the Fianna Fáil Government that stopped emigrations. We all know that if the American Government had not shut down immigration completely, instead of 30,000 going out, as went out three years ago, there would be 70,000 clearing out, or probably more. The Minister for Industry and Commerce should have some appreciation of his responsibilities so far as the unemployed are concerned. I know that the members of the Labour Party are in close touch with the actual conditions, notwithstanding the amazing speech made by my friend, Deputy Keyes, last night. He said that conditions in Limerick were never so prosperous, that shopkeepers were never so well-off. I challenge Deputy Keyes to say in Limerick City that there is not more unemployment to-day than there was 12 months ago. I challenge him, or the Minister for Finance, or the Minister for Industry and Commerce, to go into any part of Limerick City and ask any shopkeeper or professional man if he is as well off as he was 12 months ago or two or three years ago. I shall, however, only go back for 12 months— the first 12 months of Fianna Fáil government. Let them deal with that. I challenge any member of the Government to go to any fair in Tipperary and to say that things are improving. The Minister for Industry and Commerce says that things are getting better every day. The Minister for Finance told us a fortnight ago that the farmers were never better off, that they were never in a better position to pay their debts and that the shopkeepers never found it easier to collect their debts. I challenge the Minister for Finance to ask any shopkeeper who is a supporter of his own in the town of Tipperary if that statement is true. Of course, it is not true. I wish the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who was talking about the country improving and the farmers being prosperous, had been at the fair in Nenagh last Monday or at the fair in Thurles on Tuesday, when men were glad to make a sale for as low as £5 per head for a two-and-a-half year old beast and £3 5s. 0d. per head for a two-year-old beast. Then they would know something about the country. I realise that the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance, above all Ministers, speak with absolute recklessness and without any great regard for truth, hoping that they will stagger a bit near it. In attempting to stagger towards truth, they stagger away from it. The facts I have stated are well known and, so far as we are concerned, there is no necessity to refer to them. The statements made by the Ministers are so palpably absurd that the most foolish supporter of the Government in the country knows that they are untrue.
Mr. McGilligan rose.
Comment on this
Before Deputy McGilligan begins, I should like to call the attention of the House to the fact that there was an understanding that the Vote on this stage would take place at 10 o'clock and that all the other stages would be taken before 10.30. I suggest that some time ought to be allowed to the Attorney-General or to myself to conclude.
Comment on this
I understand that the arrangement was that all stages would be given to the Minister before the House rose at 10.30.
Comment on this
I have yet to learn that Deputy Morrissey is Whip. The arrangement has been made between the Whips, and I am putting it to you, Sir, whether or not we are going to be allowed to reply.
Comment on this
There is no use in putting that question to me if an arrangement has been made between the Parties. My duty is to call the members of the different Parties according to the usual convention.
Comment on this
I understand that Deputy McGilligan has not yet been called. I think that we ought to have some statement from him as to whether or not he will conclude his speech in time to permit the Attorney-General to conclude. If not, in accordance with the usual convention, the Attorney-General will present himself as a speaker from the opposite benches.
Comment on this
I merely want to deal with a matter which was referred to by Deputy O'Higgins and some other speakers. That is the contrast drawn between the manner in which a case was presented to the Military Tribunal yesterday and a case which was tried last week. I presume that most of the Deputies have read in the newspapers of both these cases. It should hardly be necessary for me to go into the facts in order to show that these cases were as far apart as the poles in respect of the circumstances out of which they arose. Deputy O'Higgins referred to a charge of possession of arms by a firing party in County Cork. It is hardly necessary to remind Deputies of what happened in that case. One of the accused men named Hennessy pleaded guilty and his counsel, Mr. Moloney, on his behalf stated
"that Hennessy was in the old days of the Anglo-Irish war a companion-in-arms and otherwise of John Nyhan, whose funeral he attended. Hennessy, who was wounded during that war, suffered throughout it with Nyhan. When Nyhan died he was invited by other companions to go and pay the last respects to his soldier-comrade. At the burial ground he was given a rifle from a car. He used it in firing over Nyhan's grave. When the proceedings were over he returned to the car and replaced the rifle. As far as the rifle was concerned, he absolutely knew no more about it.
"The prisoner was not now, and had not been for a long time, engaged in war-like activities. He and Nyhan, and their companions," said counsel, "have done their work for the country, and he has laid down his gun. He is not an active member of any organisation, and as far as the incident at the funeral was concerned, he only went to pay the last respects to the memory of a soldier. The prisoner had no intention of causing injury to any person, or of any deliberate rebuff to the Free State. His action was purely sentimental, and there was nothing in it which could be interpreted as criminal."
Then the statement of Mr. Geoghegan representing me was in these terms:
"The terms of the Firearms Act were so clear that any citizen who was not a member of the State forces, or otherwise excepted from the provisions, and possessed a rifle, was guilty of an offence, no matter how laudable might have been the object which prompted him to have the firearms.
"Circumstances of an explanatory and perhaps extenuating nature have been put before the court," continued counsel. "I am not suggesting that it is anything other than praiseworthy to pay respects to a dead soldier.
"Nyhan was a very gallant man and a very brave soldier. There is no conflict regarding the attitude that any patriotic citizen should adopt to his memory. There is many a right and admirable thing, however, which can be done in a very wrong way.
"What was done in this instance was in itself splendid, but unnecessarily wrong. It may be, perhaps, that there was a want of knowledge. Where it is thought right and fitting that a volley should be fired over the grave of the dead soldier, the Government are prepared not merely to permit, but to facilitate this payment of a last tribute.
"If permission is asked by anyone in charge of such a ceremony it will be given in any proper case. Nyhan's was, undoubtedly, a proper case. Not merely that, but rifles and ammunition will be loaned for the occasion, and for the purpose, to responsible citizens.
"This is undoubtedly the first case of this nature in this court. The court will, no doubt, take the fact into account. I am not here to press for punishment, but rather in the interests of public order. If there is, however, any repetition of this kind of occurrence it will be a far graver and more serious matter."
The other prisoners declined to plead; they declined to recognise the court. First of all, the court had dealt with Hennessy who had pleaded guilty and had that submission made on his behalf which was considered by the court and it decided to postpone sentence for 12 months. I do not suppose the Opposition, however they may criticise me, would wish to criticise what was done by the Tribunal, in the exercise of its diseretion, in view of all the circumstances before them. The other case related to exactly the same occurrence, and although the prisoners met the charge in a different way, or made a statement which is reported in the papers, the court, again in its discretion, saw fit to deal with that case in precisely the same way. I am not going to say that my action, or the action of counsel representing me, may not possibly be criticised. Some Deputies on the opposite side of the House saw fit to criticise it very severely; but I think it will be admitted by most Deputies that in that particular case there were certain circumstances arising out of a long history of that kind of incident which did distinguish it from cases in which people were found in possession of arms without permits and were brought before the court and charged either with the possession of arms or for an offence involving the use of arms. A warning was given there by counsel, and I repeat it here, that such an attitude will not be adopted as far as I am concerned in any future case of the kind. I certainly intend in future, if cases of a similar kind arise, not to allow any sort of excuse to be made on the ground that the persons who engaged in the use of firearms, did so for even such a laudable enterprise as this, without having obtained a permit for the rifles or to use them for that particular purpose.
Deputy O'Higgins seeks to parallel that case with the case before the Tribunal last week. I think Deputy McGilligan appeared for the defendants in the case to which he referred. The suggestion was made that counsel on my behalf pressed that particular case. I have here the report of the case and I think if I read the opening remarks of Mr. Haugh who represented me it will be clear even to the most biassed mind that there was no parallel between the two cases.
"Peter Mahon, Main Street, Stradbally, and Edward Dowling, Courthouse Square, Stradbally, were jointly charged before the Tribunal with intimidating John Reilly from lawfully driving a motor car along the public highway, and with unlawful assembly; and with conspiracy with other persons unknown to intimidate John Reilly from driving a dance band to the dance hall at Wolfhill. Mahon was further charged with unlawful possession of a Lee-Enfield rifle and with membership of an unlawful organisation, the Army Comrades' Association.
"Mr. Haugh said the cases arose over a hold-up of a dance band on its way to the dance hall at Wolfhill on Sunday, January 28th. Evidence will be given that the dance was being held under Fianna Fáil auspices and that the prisoners belonged to the political parties opposed to Fianna Fáil. On the night in question the dance band was proceeding by motor, and they came to an obstruction on the road. They stopped the car and observed four masked men, at least one of whom carried a rifle, and another a revolver. The masked men told them that they would not be allowed to proceed to the dance, and ordered them to turn back. Three rifle shots and one revolver shot were fired over their heads. The band turned back and proceeded to the dance by a circuitous route.
"Counsel then proceeded to detail the evidence that would be advanced to connect the accused with the hold-up of the band."
I presume that is what Deputy O'Higgins referred to when he suggested that that charge was pressed. Well, undoubtedly, the charge in that particular case was one that nobody would deny was a charge that should be pressed. The hold up of a dance band by masked men with rifles is surely a charge any prosecuting counsel would be justified in pressing. I gave no particular instructions in regard to the case. I relied on the good sense of Mr. Haugh, who is an experienced counsel, to deal with the case as, in his discretion, he thought fit. If, as Deputy O'Higgins says—he was present in court—the case was pressed, I accept his point, but I ask any reasonable person was it not perfectly right that it should be pressed?
Comment on this
I am going to state the result. I am not accustomed to concealing anything or playing any tricks with the House.
Comment on this
That is just the sort of charge the Deputy would make.
Comment on this
I was about to say, and it is only fair to say it, that in regard to that particular case, on the charge of holding up, the accused were acquitted. But it is also fair to say, and Deputy McGilligan himself will have to admit it, that the presentation of the charge against his clients in the closing address of counsel for the prosecution was eminently fair.
Comment on this
That is admitted. How Deputy O'Higgins comes into this House to suggest that the case was pressed in view of what I, personally, happen to know from counsel himself who opened it, is more than I can understand. I do not know that it is necessary to do more than detail the facts of the case to show the difference between them. Deputy O'Higgins has thrown out a suggestion that in view of the fact that these men were acquitted on that charge—I am not saying in any way that they were not innocent of the charge—I will consider that. I think only one of them was acquitted.
Comment on this
One in that case and one previously. I will certainly consider the suggestion that he has made, although I think he might have hesitated to present his charge against me in the way he did: that they were two precisely similar cases and that a completely different attitude was taken up in regard to them. Notwithstanding that, I will look into the facts in connection with these cases and see whether the suggestion that he has made may be acted upon.
Comment on this
I will content myself by saying something about these cases. I do not think I would omit one word of what Deputy Dr. O'Higgins has said about them. When the Attorney-General stands up in his mild manner and tells us that he has been criticised, I wonder has he any appreciation of the value of the word criticism. There must be scorn and contempt, and a hissing about the Attorney-General's ears because of the manner of his presenting these two sets of cases here to-night. It just showed the partisan biassed mood in which these cases are dealt with. So far as this House is concerned, his presentation of these cases stands, in this way: Guns were taken and shots were fired over the grave of a particular soldier— a dead man. That is one case. That is the fair presentation of it, and then, with regard to the other, what has the Attorney-General to say? That two men were charged with a hold-up of a dance band. That is what he stressed, the hold-up; but there was not a particle of evidence about a hold-up. The court found that there was no hold-up so far as these men were concerned. That is the equal presentation of the two cases that we have got. Let me add a little to it.
Comment on this
You did not read the newspaper account. You had counsel prosecuting for you. You did not state here the full details that I am sure have been given to you.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy like me to state them? It might not suit him if I did.
Comment on this
I will give the Attorney-General time and opportunity to state what has been told to him. With regard to most of these men, was this contrast made: that they refused to recognise the court; that they had rifles in their possession; that they did not say where they were, and did not offer to surrender them? Were these men interrogated? Were the powers of the Public Safety Act used against them? Were they questioned? Failure to answer questions might be made a substantial charge against them. Let us get the other side. One man is charged. The question of an attempt to hold-up should not have been introduced against him, because there was not a scintilla of evidence put before the Military Tribunal with regard to one of these men that he had anything to do with the so-called hold-up. What is he charged with? With having a rifle, and he had a rifle. Was that charge withdrawn? Was there any statement made at the Attorney-General's behest with regard to the time he got the rifle, or the purpose he got it for? The Attorney-General did not state that here. I stated it before the Tribunal, that both these men who were accused of having rifles and who were found guilty on that charge got them on a particularly sad occasion when Deputy O'Higgins's father had been murdered.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins's father was murdered and people were asked to come and guard the house.
Comment on this
I have the statement here if the Deputy wishes to see it.
Comment on this
I asked was that the original statement.
Comment on this
The Attorney-General got his chance. Deputy O'Higgins's father was murdered and the people in the neighbourhood felt, as these two men said, that the assassins would not be content with the old man's blood: that they would return again and attack the family and the house. Men were asked would they come and guard the family and the house against the return of these assassins and they said they would. Lacey and Mahon were picked. They got guns. They got them from the Curragh, in the most open way, and they used them when the assassins did return to that house from which a murdered man's corpse had barely been removed. Was there any failure to press the charge against Mahon and Lacey: the charge that they had rifles? Was there any evidence even put forward that Lacey had used the rifle ever since? Why did not the Attorney-General say that, after the case had concluded, Mahon was recalled by the Tribunal in order to be asked and to make it clear in every way that he had not been in this so-called hold-up. He was asked could it possibly be that the rifle had been extracted from where he hid it without his knowledge and used by somebody else. His answer was such that the Military Tribunal accepted his statement.
Mahon and Lacey recognised the court. They were interrogated at length. They were interrogated beyond the powers the police have under the Act under which they presumed to act. There were five charges preferred against one of these men. Two were dropped through irregularity, and the court dismissed the others except the single thing which had been admitted by men who recognised the court that they had the rifles. One of them gave to the court in great detail the occasion upon which he got it. If further substantiation was needed it was that these very rifles were used a few days after the death of Deputy O'Higgins's father against the attack that was made upon his family and house. The Attorney-General's counsel in that case presented the case fairly. He did it in this respect that he said that undoubtedly the charge about unlawful assembly could not be substantiated. He said that undoubtedly the charge with regard to the membership cards could not be substantiated. He said there was a grave doubt about the whole matter of the hold-up but did he say one single word so as to get the Tribunal to remit any of the penalty with regard to the possession of the rifle? Not a word, and then the Attorney-General presents these cases as if they were equal—the case of men who recognised the court, men who had stood their defence and who were interrogated. Their rifles were taken from them and they are now serving six months. The Attorney-General thinks that is fair and equal as compared with what his counsel said yesterday in relation to those others. That same counsel appeared before the same Tribunal in two other cases. I raised a question with regard to one of those cases on the Adjournment two weeks ago. It was the case of a man charged with having a rifle. An expert was called and said that the rifle was obsolete. The President of the Court asked that it should be handed up, and having examined it, he said that it was obsolete and would not harm anybody. The counsel who appeared in these other cases yesterday and made an appeal for leniency in relation to those charged said in this particular case I am dealing with that it was not for a man of the type of the accused to be left to judge for himself whether a rifle was useful. It might be made usable he said. The man who, in the eyes of the Tribunal, had the obsolete rifle, was found guilty of that charge and bound over in a particular way.
Comment on this
Not even as near as the Minister is to balancing his Budget. Does the Attorney-General remember one other case when a number of farmers were brought up for what he yesterday called "the no-rates campaign" but had to correct subsequently to "the alleged no-rates campaign," and when that same counsel who pleaded yesterday for leniency talked about the savage methods of terrorism and intimidation which had been indulged in in that particular portion of County Waterford, and when the other counsel representing the Attorney-General said that he had to rub his eyes to assure himself that he was living in Catholic Ireland and not in Bolshevik Russia? Yet the Tribunal in the end said "not guilty." That is called justice, and that is the Attorney-General who says that he can hold up his head in pride and that he is not a person who is in the habit of abusing these powers—powers that were always dangerous in anybody's hands but are particularly dangerous in the hands of a weak and incompetent man. So much for that.
We are discussing at the moment a Central Fund Bill which asks us to vote £2,000,000 for certain purposes and £10,000,000 for others; to vote £10,000,000 out of a sum of nearly £30,000,000 which stands in the Estimates for the year. It is an oft told tale, but I want to repeat it again, the tale of what was promised with regard to the public services, with regard to taxation, and with regard to economy. Does the Minister remember: "Here is what a Fianna Fáil Government can and will do for you"?
Comment on this
On the day the cattle are slaughtered I will put it with them. Here is what they said about economy:
"Economy means the elimination of waste, getting 20 shillings value for every pound of the taxpayers' money spent in the public service. Fianna Fáil is satisfied that substantial economies are feasible without reducing social services, inflicting any hardship on any class of Government servants or impairing in the slightest degree the efficiency of the administrative machine. It has examined with minute care—"
I am sure the Minister was one of those who made this minute examination—
"the Estimates for Public Services for the current year, and is convinced that a saving of many hundreds of thousands of pounds without including such items..."
I will not go into these. They refer to pensions and the rest of it. It goes on to say:
"The burden of taxation can be lightened by not less than £2,000,000 per year."
Instead of that we have £29,709,000 Estimates for the year. When that sentence was written, the Estimates were in the neighbourhood of £22,000,000. We have jumped up by £7,000,000 instead of going down by £2,000,000. We have reduced the salaries of Government servants and we have not, to quote the rest of these promises, "86,000 people put into employment," and that in only a few of the industries. I have often turned against the President his famous figures, the ratio of 66 to 1. What does it amount to?
Comment on this
We had better quote it once more. It is a great figure. On that basis it would represent by the English Government an increase in its Budget of about £500,000,000 in the year, and this at a time when it had failed in nearly every other one of its promises. We were to get 86,000 people into employment and the Minister for Industry and Commerce last night in my absence here said that I had agreed with him that 14,000 people had gone into insurable occupations recently. It is a typical performance of the Minister that he should say that. He gave these figures and I challenged them. I rose to refute them and he gave the hint to his colleague to move the closure. Then I am adjudged to have agreed with him. I suppose it is another way of slapping one across the teeth to move the closure. It certainly stops argument, but it does not always give a man the right to say that his statements are not challenged. I now challenge his statements with regard to people put into insurable occupations. Does the Minister remember the way he represented the increases? Speaking one night here, taking just a chance, as he often does, and hoping that no one would notice the funny gap he had left, he challenged us on this matter of the sale of unemployment insurance stamps and the contributions to the fund. He said that was the real test and he gave us the figures in this way: "The income from the sale of unemployment insurance stamps in 1928 was £655,000; in 1929, £679,000, and in 1930, £703,000." That is the real figure on which he based his argument. For 1930, or before the Minister assumed office, the figure which he quoted was £703,000. He then jumped on to 1933 and said that "if the old rates of contribution had continued to be paid the figure would have been £760,000, showing an increase of £60,000, which represents 15,000 men getting employment for 50 weeks." He continued: "It is on facts like these I base my contention that there are more people in insurable employment in this country now than ever there were since the Free State was established... Deputies opposite quote statistics which obviously they do not understand." From 1930 he took a sudden jump to 1933 and said in that period we had £60,000 of an increase and he took the credit for it all. We thought we would prick that bubble and we asked a question and divided up the dates somewhat as between 1930, 1931, 1932, and 1933. This question was asked half way through November and the Minister was asked to give the exact figures for 1931 and 1932, and to compare these with 1933. That was on the 16th November and he must have known what the actual amounts were up to that date, and he must have known also what was the percentage of the entire sum that was received in the last six weeks of any year. He had to attempt an estimate and the £760,000 went up a bit. The £703,000 for 1930 was lowered. The Minister had nothing to do with that year so that it could be depreciated without any harm to the Minister. It became £699,193. That is a thing that does not matter. For 1931 the figure was £744,000, an increase of £45,000 for the year with which the Minister had nothing to do. Taking his own basis of £4 per man it meant 11,000 people put into occupation. In 1932 the figure rose to £767,000, an increase of £23,000 over the previous year. On division by four, that means nearly 6,000 people. In 1933 the figure is £773,000, an increase of £6,000 or 1,500 people.
Comment on this
Although the Minister was within six weeks of the end of the year and had statistical information as to how much of the Fund rolled in during the last six weeks of the year? But that was not good enough, so we got it raised to £700,000. In 1931 the figure is increased by £44,000, the other remains at £767,000, but in 1933, six weeks later, it is found that the figure is not merely the estimate of £773,000 but it rises to £784,000.
Comment on this
I am not sure if this debate had waited until after Easter that it would not be well over the £800,000 mark.
Comment on this
That is the Minister's type of figuring. One night when he thought he could get away with it he claims the whole £60,000 between 1930 and 1933 as his work, and when we check up we find that £45,000 of it does not belong to him at all, and that all he can claim is £23,000 in the first year of his magnificent tariffs and bounties, and £6,000 in the second year, with all the subsidies and bounties and tariffs. Then he comes along with a new idea. Even if you take the new figure of £784,000 it only represents an increase of £40,000 on the year 1931, and 40,000 divided by 4 gives only 10,000 people. The Minister is again at a sorry disadvantage over the whole thing, because in two years on that figuring he has only put 10,000 people into occupation, whereas in the last year of the decaying Cosgrave Administration——
Comment on this
The Minister, the other night, wanted to make the figures bigger, so he says: "No longer will we divide by 4, because that is no longer the value of the stamp; we will divide by 52 weeks multiplied by 1/1." What has he built up his adjusted figures on? Is it on 1/1? The Minister talked of thimble-rigging last night. It is about time that we should get the thimble lifted off himself for the evening. I could say a great deal worse than that.
Comment on this
Look at that for a method of calculation. The Minister apparently said to himself: "We will claim the 60,000; nobody will notice it. It is nothing like as brazen as the other things I have done. Think of the factories. We will claim the 60,000, and when it is challenged, and it is discovered that 40,000 does not belong to me at all I will exaggerate the figure." How did he exaggerate it? He took not the real figures but the adjusted figures, the real figures being based on contributions amounting to 1/1. He adjusts that to the old rate of contribution of 1/7. Having got the new figure built up on that rate, he divides not by the 1/7 but by 1/1, and so he gets the 14,000 for himself. That is typical of most of the Minister's calculations. And that is what I was supposed to have admitted! Let us take it that the chancy work had come off. The Minister took his chance. Supposing he had got away with it, what did it amount to at best? It meant that in two years of the new economy, with the tariffs and bounties and everything which one could hope for in industry in this country, he could claim 14,000 people in insurable occupations, and in my last year I could claim 11,000; and I had not a tot of 100,000 registered unemployed, and I had not a tot of 130,000 people getting home assistance. Fianna Fáil prosperity is on the march; the tide is rising, I understand the Minister for Finance said the other night. The tide is rising! We will all be submerged by it soon. Fianna Fáil prosperity is going forward. Let us have a Prosperity Day. The Labour Party have a Labour Day. Why not have a Prosperity Day? I will give you a few appropriate dates when it might be held; say when the figure for unemployment goes over the 100,000 mark.
Comment on this
Why not let us have it in memory of the day on which for the first time the Government of this country sought to get money from the people of this country on their credit as a Government, and failed?
Comment on this
The first time it was a failure. That is one thing which the Minister can claim credit for— accomplishing a failure.
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture is not here. The Minister for Industry and Commerce often represents him, or perhaps it might be more correct to say misrepresents him. What about the day we slaughter the cattle? That would be a good idea for Prosperity Day for the new State. We are getting people out of agriculture; even Deputy O'Reilly admits that. They are going with the cattle. At the moment, they have only reached the half-way house of being unemployed. They are on the dole. This Vote on Account rises by £1,200,000 this year to make some provision for those unfortunate folk whom the fanaticism and stupidity on the other side have driven out of the work for which no substitute has been provided.
Comment on this
There are more people on the dole; more people on home assistance, and more people registered as unemployed. I want to make a suggestion to the Minister about those slaughtered cattle. We are going to offer burnt offerings to economic nationalism. There used to be a common habit of breaking a bottle of something on the bows of a ship when it was being launched. Why cannot we go a bit further on this scheme for destroying good food in this country? In the classical times, when a man died they put what was the equivalent of a farthing in his hands to case his passage across the Styx when he was going below. Why cannot we bury part of the fodder with those cattle? Why not get rid of some of the surplus variety of things we have? As a special offering to stupidity of the fanatical type, as we launch those cattle into eternity—whatever kind of eternity they have—could we not break a bottle of Bass on their foreheads? We could thus play up to what I call the stupid patriotism on the other side, even so stupid that the new people decry them, and to the economic nationalism which they do not yet see fit to decry. We are effecting a change over rapidly, according to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, from the old bad economy of this country to something far better. What is the something that is far better? We are getting the people into productive work? The Estimates, according to the Minister for Finance, represent in the main expenditure of a productive type in this country; £1,200,000 given to people for merely doing nothing is productive expenditure! Let us take one of the good schemes. The Minister for Industry and Commerce last night said: "Before you go to bed every night say "Wheat, beet and peat,' " Provided you repeated that you would go to Grangegorman. I will give them another slogan. As well as saying "Wheat, beet and peat," add butter, and bread and alcohol. Let us take, in a metaphorical sense, alcohol. We are going to have industrial alcohol in this country. We are going to spend £100,000 on this productive work this year.
When the Minister was speaking of it about ten days ago I asked him was it a fact that the lowest price at which he could produce in the factory an imperial gallon of industrial alcohol would be 3/-, and that that had to be compared with 4d., the c.i.f. price of petrol at the Port of Dublin, and he denied it. Since that, we have had the advantage of seeing a particular publication and 3/- is stated as the price by a chemist in this country who controlled the biggest, if not the only, industrial alcohol plant England had during the war, and he advised them that if they could not burn the place down they should blow it up, so uneconomic was it. He states his opinion that if we got a particular type of tuber grown in this country which we cannot grow and got a certain bigger yield to the acre than we get at the moment, and if we got a particular starch yield from that more than what we get at the moment, we might hope to get industrial alcohol produced at the factory at 3/- a gallon. But the Minister has better hopes. That chemist goes on to say that there is no doubt that in the earlier years the price will be much higher, because he does not expect to get this peculiar concatenation of favourable circumstances, if he ever gets them—but he will not get them at once—and he does say that 3/- is the lowest figure, and we are going to spend £100,000 to brew in this country a half million or so gallons of industrial alcohol which will be produced at 3/-, without any selling charges, and that has to be compared with petrol which comes in from outside at 4d.
Has the Minister considered the losses there are in other countries on this matter? Does he know that the French Government loses over 500,000,000 francs in the year taking in subsidies and the loss of revenue that used to come from petrol and does he know that the calculation has been made that in America, where the stuff is brewed from maize, if the American Government paid the farmers of the United States something short of 300,000,000 dollars for the maize and burned it, they could save another 300,000,000 dollars? That is what is called productive work—the spending of £100,000, to get industrial alcohol at 3/- in the factory compared with petrol at 4d. at the Port of Dublin. Would the Minister not stop before he spends a penny on these factories and calculate that if he bought all the potatoes in the Cooley area and dumped them into the sea, he could spread all the benefit which he is going to spread through Cooley by the purchase of potatoes for manufacture into industrial alcohol and save the State considerably if he stopped short of this mad idea of establishing one, two, three or four factories of this type in the country for that particular purpose at those prices?
That is what is happening and it is only a miscroscopic way of showing up the folly that is going on all round. We are to say "wheat, beet and peat" before we go to bed at night, but if you had any thought for the future, you would not go to bed after saying those things. Resources can be wasted and the Government can have the melancholy satisfaction that it will be others who will have to get the people of this country out of the mess they are landing them in. They will have nothing to do with it. It is the other people who will come afterwards who will suffer from the squandering of the limited resources of the country, from their action in putting up all these numerous plants which are of no earthly use to anybody and from the lowered credit of this country brought about by obvious maladministration, financial and economic, of the country in the last two years. I have queried this whole matter of the land annuity payments and the supposed retention of the money in this country on other occasions. We are told we save the money. It is as plain as a pike-staff to anybody who can see that not merely are the farmers of this country paying every shilling of the annuities, save only the Sinking Fund payments, but that they are paying, in addition, something like £2,000,000 for R.I.C. pensions and other matters, and after these have been paid, they are being fleeced to the extent of half the old annuities, and we are told by the Minister for Finance, in a mood of equanimity, that we do not pay, but that the British pay. Has the price of food gone up in Britain by reason of the addition of the tariffs on our goods? That is the test as to who is paying, and we can apply that the other way. Of the British goods coming into this country which we tax, in respect of how many has the price been raised on us?
Folly brings this about, that not merely do the farmers pay every penny of the annuities, but they pay these things, in addition to the land annuities, to this spendthrift Government, and the people of the country are being mulcted in the payment of what are called retaliatory tariffs, the majority of these being imposed on goods which we cannot buy with value anywhere else and for which we must pay plus the tariff while we still continue to import them here. Deputy O'Reilly thinks that the British market is gone. "The British market is gone; the British are looking after that market themselves." The Deputy went back to 1921, progressed from that and then jumped to the year 1929 with regard to the figures. Would the Deputy take home these figures and consider them for himself? About the year 1928, in meat of all types, eggs and butter, the British imported into their 45 million nation about £330,000,000 worth of goods, and produced less than £140,000,000 worth of them. They consumed about £330,000,000 worth and produced at home less than £140,000,000 worth, and we supplied less than £30,000,000 worth of the residue. Have the British stopped consuming now and if so, by how much? Have the British made up the difference between, say, the odd £140,000,000 worth which they produced at home and the £330,000,000 worth which they used to consume to any great extent by home production? They have made it up to this extent that we cannot get food in to the extent of the £30,000,000 worth that we used to sell there when we were wise and until you get to that point, nobody ought to be fool enough to say that the British market is gone.
If we are being crushed out of the British market, we are being crushed out by the Argentinian and the Dane and we are being crushed out by these people because the British have taken us at our own word in one thing and have decided to regard us as strangers to their Commonwealth economically, and Deputy O'Reilly knows as well as any man that, supposing we were back on a business footing with the British and supposing we even adopted the procedure of sending over coupons for these duties to the British and allowed them to collect the annuities on them, we would not be paying the annuities then any more certainly than we are paying them at the moment. If we did that and paid those moneys over decently and straightforwardly, instead of having them collected from us, with the maximum of expense and the maximum of trouble, we would, at the same time, have more favourable regard from the British with regard to entrance into their market and we would proceed to get preferential terms with regard to the amount of meat of all types and butter and eggs which the British are not yet able to produce for their own consumption and which are now being supplied by other members of the Commonwealth or by people who are completely and entirely outside the Commonwealth. I have asked the Minister for Finance several times to keep, at any rate, his best eye on the situation to the extent that he would find out and let us know at what stage, prior to the close of the financial year, the British would, in fact, have collected from us all the annuities so that we would know that we had not to go on paying any more and so that this country might have one test week—and a good test it would be for people like Deputy O'Reilly— during which these tariffs would be taken off and the ordinary flow of trade between the two islands might start again even though it has been interrupted by the unfortunate history of the past two years.
The Minister, however, must turn his blind eye to that situation. The Minister will not admit that the moneys are being collected, and for that reason we have got to go into this absurd business about beet and wheat and industrial alcohol, and for that reason we have got to have expenditure swollen in an attempt by the Minister for Finance to get by taxation out of this people what he otherwise would have got by funding and borrowing, if the credit of the country had only been good in his hands and he had been able to get any decent response to his Fourth National Loan. Shall I move to report progress, Sir?
Comment on this
I have been informed that an arrangement was come to between the Whips whereby I was to have half an hour to speak.
Comment on this
Deputy Mulcahy stated here in the House this evening that he would give an undertaking that all the stages of this Bill would be concluded this evening.
Comment on this
I said that discussion, as far as we were concerned, would be finished by ten minutes past ten, and that all the stages of this Bill would be given to the Minister to-night after a division on the Second Reading.
Comment on this
I am sorry to tell the Deputy, through you, Sir, that I am informed by the Whip that the vote was to be taken at 10 o'clock. Of course, as usual, the agreement is not being kept.
Comment on this
I suggest that if the Minister is desirous of speaking he can speak now, and can speak until 10.25.
Comment on this
There is nothing to prevent all the stages of the Bill being concluded after the division is taken, as there will not be any division but the division on the Second Reading.
Comment on this
As I was listening to Deputy McGilligan speaking, some lines out of a song in "The Tempest," with which many Deputies, I am sure, are familiar, came to my mind. They begin: "Full fathoms five thy father lies," and they end up to the effect that "Nothing of him that doth fade, but doth suffer a sea-change into something new and strange." It will never be said of Deputy McGilligan, however deep he lies, that we shall ever have from him something new and strange. I knew, when the Central Fund Bill was down for discussion this afternoon, that he would appear in his usual role of an old sandwich-board decked around with old and worn-out advertisements. We did say when we were in Opposition that we would reduce taxation by £2,000,000, because it was clear to us that any Government doing so little for the Irish people as the Cumann na nGaedheal Government was doing, and doing it so inefficiently, was at least wasting £2,000,000 of public money. Accordingly, we promised the people that we should do the same work as they were doing for £2,000,000 less. But we are doing much more. I recited yesterday what additional benefits and what additional projects we proposed to carry through in the coming financial year. I pointed out that in one vote alone, the vote for the Local Loans Fund, we were providing mainly for the housing of the people a sum of £4,539,000 as against £730,000 provided by Mr. Cosgrave. For the relief of the unemployed this year we are providding £1,500,000. And there is not any comparable figure or any comparable service that we can point to under Deputy Cosgrave's Government because, as you know, one of the things that most of all turned the people of this country against them was their callous disregard for the sufferings of the unemployed. We are providing, I pointed out, the sum of £102,000 for an experiment in the manufacture of industrial alcohol. We are providing additional money for the teachers. We are providing £350,000 for public works, and we are providing a host of other benefits and advantages for the people of this country, which bring the total bill up, according to the Supply Estimates, to £29,709,000.
It is a large sum. It staggered Deputy Dillon and it staggered one or two other members of the Opposition; but we asked them to point to one out of all those manifold services that they would do without and to tell us what it was. What was their rejoinder? Deputy Dillon pointed to one—an insignificant item, something less than a mere flea-bite—the vote for the Secret Service amounting to £25,000. He said that that was one service we could do without. £25,000 out of £29,709,000 is the only item of expenditure in the whole of that list that Deputy Dillon would forego. That was the one he emphasised most and the one to which he referred most often.
Comment on this
What do we want the Vote for the Secret Service for? We do not desire it at all, but one thing which has distinguished this Government from its predecessors is that whatever other qualities it may lack, at any rate, it has the quality of foresight. When we see an organisation growing up in this country, telling its members that they must establish a secret service, that they must have their intelligence agents working in every branch of the Public Service, that they must enlist in its ranks postmen and others; and when, on top of that, the man who is the head of this organisation tells us that he has had advance information as to when bank robberies and other crimes were being planned and suggests that in regard to these he had the same sources of information as he always had; when we know that the only political Party in this country that is likely to benefit from outrage or robbery, loot or riot, is the Party of which that gentleman is the titular head, and when he admits an association and connection with bank robbers and other criminals, then, I think, it is time for any Government to take steps to ensure that at least it will have the same information as he has. We do not want to increase this Vote for the Secret Service but it is being made necessary. Possibly none of the money will be spent, but possibly the whole of it may have to be spent, and perhaps more in addition. We are going to put down and curb and deal with the illegal associations which at the present moment are being set on foot in this country.
Comment on this
With what illegal associations? There is only one illegal association in the country at the present moment according to the Attorney-General.
Comment on this
What other services would Deputy Dillon forego? He mentioned the Department of Industry and Commerce. Why? He has apparently; since he has always got the worst of his bouts with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, a wish to abolish him altogether merely in order to gratify his injured feelings. We are to dispense with the service of the one Minister and the one Ministry which, by common acclaim, is held up to be the most successful Minister and the most successful branch of a successful Government. I have heard present supporters of Deputy Dillon state positively that whatever else may go in this country, they wish to see the present Minister for Industry and Commerce remain in that position.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon, because he comes off second best in his encounters with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, wishes to abolish the Minister even if, at the same time, he had to wipe out the whole of the Department of Industry and Commerce. What would be the extent of that saving? About £120,000. Then the Deputy says: "We can do without an increase in the Army." He suggested that substantial economies can be made in the Army. How? When Deputy Fitzgerald was Minister for Defence here he emphasised over and over again that an efficient army could not be maintained in this country on a less expenditure than £1,500,000. Even with the provision we are making for the new Volunteer Forces the expenditure on the Army is well below £1,500,000, and a large part of the additional expenditure on the Army will be represented by the provision of Volunteer Halls throughout the country which will, from a social point of view, meet a crying need in some districts. The other services with which Deputy Dillon would dispense is, I think, the bounties on exports. Does Deputy Dillon want us to drop the bounties? Is he one of those who, unlike Deputy Keating, believes that the bounties do not go back to the producers.
Comment on this
The Deputy believes he gets no share of the bounties, and that the producer gets the lot. He believes——
Comment on this
Does Deputy Dillon differ with his follower, and does he, on the contrary, believe that the producers get none of the bounties? Is that the argument that is put forward? Is that why he wants us to drop the bounties? I should like to know if that is the only contribution that Deputy Dillon can offer to the farmer in his present difficulties—that we ought to drop the bounties? Is that the Deputy's one contribution?
Comment on this
Is it the case that the exporter collars the share of the bounties which, according to Deputy Bennett, should go to the farmers?
I have only a moment or two left, but I want to say one or two things about the state of the country. In the course of his speech yesterday the Minister for Industry and Commerce pointed out that every economic index indicated that conditions were improving in this country.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce pointed out that we were buying more meat, more vegetables, more potatoes, more tobacco, more tea, more sugar and more drink than before.
Comment on this
If the Minister sets up a factory for blue blouses I can promise him he will want no subsidy or bounty to be given to them.
Comment on this
We are spending more money on drink, more money on betting, more money on entertainments, more money on matches, more on petrol, more on watches, more on clocks, more on meat and more on everything——
Comment on this
That is a very apt remark, but the Minister might well say to his colleague:"Et tu Brute.”
Comment on this
And yet we have Deputy Dillon getting up here and talking about the unfortunate people being driven to despair. I can tell the Deputy that not only are we spending more on entertainments, on drink, tobacco, tea, sugar and meat than ever before, but that the revenue is exceeding the estimate under practically every head.
Comment on this
We know that nothing is going to enlighten the gloom that enshrouds the members on the opposite benches.
Comment on this
I think the only thing the members of the Opposition read is their own speeches. I do not think they read the speeches of the Dublin business men. There was a case tried in the Dublin courts recently and it got a great deal of publicity. In the course of the testimony given by the manager of the firm, one of the largest concerns in Ireland, he stated that the depression which they had anticipated in 1932 had not materialised and that the depression anticipated in 1933 had not struck Clerys yet. Deputy John Marcus O'Sullivan said that the Government was the only expanding business in this country. But that business is expanding and other business is prosperous. We are told, in the words of the manager of Clerys, that this depression, of which Deputy Dillon and Deputy O'Sullivan seem to have some foreknowledge, has not struck Clerys yet. What was said by the manager of Clerys was repeated yesterday by the chairman of Todd Burns & Company, who told the shareholders that while they had a large loss in trade in 1932, that loss was changed in 1933 into a profit of £9,200. He went on to point out that, notwithstanding their expanding trade, the amount of money which they had lying out with their debtors was much less than would be warranted by the increase which had taken place in their business.
Comment on this
I think that would put them under a disadvantage as compared with competitors, and that they are waking up to the fact that it might be better for them to discard the manufacture of that unpleasant looking garment. What was said by the chairman of Messrs. Todd Burns was also said by the chairman of another rather different concern. Speaking yesterday at the shareholders' meeting, the chairman of Messrs. J.G. Mooney & Co., Ltd.— no doubt Deputy Dillon knows them well—a firm with a very enviable reputation the world over——
Comment on this
——pointed out that the profits for 1933 had exceeded the profits for the year 1932 by no less than £700. A shareholder, seconding the adoption of the directors' report, stated that in 1932 they had the benefit of the Eucharistic Congress, which brought tremendous crowds to the city and benefited it, and that cognisance of that should be taken in considering the accounts for 1932. In 1933, the year they were told conditions had become worse for the farmers, Messrs. J.G. Mooney & Co., Ltd., had even a better year than what they all thought was the bumper year of 1932.
Comment on this
The Deputy can put all the gloss on it that he likes. These are the facts. There is not a single economic index that can be taken, whether the consumption of food, increased expenditure on clothing, on entertainment, on amusement, upon betting and beverages, no matter what type of concern it may be, which does not show that the country is more prosperous and better this year than last year. That is true I say of the country as a whole.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?