Registration of Maternity Homes Bill, 1934—From the Seanad. - Electoral (Revision of Constituencies) Bill, 1934—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–175 of 334. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 11 of 1934 ›
Amendment No. 2 proposes to delete all references to North-East and North-West Dublin and amendment No. 3 proposes to delete the same references and to substitute something else. I am putting the question on No. 2, "That the words proposed to be deleted stand" and if that is affirmed, No. 3 cannot be moved. They will, therefore, be discussed together.
Comment on this
The Minister proposes in his Schedule to divide the North City of Dublin constituency—an eight-member constituency—into two constituencies, one of three members and one five members. I should like to hear from the Minister the grounds upon which he makes this division. The constituency has been accepted as it stands at the present moment, with the exception of small rural additions arising out of the Greater Dublin Bill, since 1923. I do not think any question has arisen, all during the time the constituency existed as such, that the size of the constituency in any way created any particular difficulty. The Minister proposes a division which gives one three-member constituency. I think it has been argued here before that the position which the Minister is creating under this Bill, by which he provides an excessive number of three-member constituencies, is a blow at the particular type of proportional representation which we have had up to the present. I should like to hear what justification the Minister can put forward for dividing an eight-member constituency, which would still continue as an eight-member constituency, into one three-member constituency and one five-member constituency.
Comment on this
The amendment standing in the name of Deputy Norton is aimed at preserving the larger unit. In this particular constituency I do not think it can be alleged that there is any diversity of interests amongst the residents of the area. There is nothing that can be alleged in support of the alteration of the existing constituency, except that it is alleged to be unwieldy. I do not think that could be the case with such a concentrated unit as you have in the City of Dublin, which is so easily traversed by all forms of transport either at election or other times. There certainly could not be any serious suggestion that it would be difficult to traverse that particular constituency. By leaving the larger unit you are certainly preserving the letter and the spirit of proportional representation. Viewed from any angle, seeing that the eventual number in the amendment is identical with that proposed in the Bill, I do not know any reason why the Minister cannot see his way to accept the amendment as put down. It would allow the existing constituency to stand, and, as I said, assures the continuance of the letter and the spirit of proportional representation, which are obviously given better freedom and better scope in the larger than in the smaller constituency. Those are the reasons which actuated the putting down of the amendment, and I certainly think there is nothing to prevent the Minister from accepting it. It does not effect any serious alteration in the proposals. He will have the same number of members as originally intended in the Bill; he will be leaving a larger measure of satisfaction amongst the residents in the district, and will be preserving the spirit of fair play as adumbrated and carried out in proportional representation.
Comment on this
The person we would particularly like to hear would be the Minister on his proposal.
Comment on this
The case for the amendment in the name of this Party has already been made, I think, on the Second Reading of this Bill. We then indicated that we were in favour of maintaining the scheme of large constituencies, because of the fact that large constituencies enable the working of proportional representation to the greatest possible limits; whereas under a scheme of carving up constituencies, dividing them into two, to be represented by a small number of Deputies, the position would be that proportional representation could only be carried on to a very limited extent. As a matter of fact in the three-member constituency proportional representation could only be carried on to an extremely limited extent.
On the Second Reading of the Bill the Minister made a case for trying to reduce large constituencies and make them more compact. I cannot understand on what grounds it is sought to divide up North Dublin, if the principle of making constituencies small territorially has guided the Ministry. West Cork is still to be left as it is, and if one looks at the map it will be found that the constituency is about 120 miles in length. That is a very big factor in considering the task of a Deputy in representing his constituency, but it cannot be said that North Dublin is 120 miles long. One could go from one end of the constituency to the other on a tram or bus in about 20 minutes or half an hour. It cannot be said, therefore, that it is unmanageable territorially, and I do not think that is pleaded by any Deputy. It certainly has not been said by any of the Deputies representing North Dublin that it is unmanageable from the point of view of dealing with correspondence, or interviewing constituents frequently. I think the Minister might agree to leave North Dublin as it is, with eight seats, rather than to divide it up and create two constituencies out of one which is already sufficiently compact. It is not by any means territorially too great, and has been known for a very long period as North Dublin. I think it would be much more convenient administratively; it would be much more convenient from the point of view of the constituents in North Dublin, and would be preferable from the point of view of proportional representation if the constituency were left as at present, instead of being divided up, not for the purpose of reducing the seats but merely for the purpose of having it divided.
I hope the Minister will indicate that he is prepared to accept the view which was expressed by many Parties in this House on the Second Reading of the Bill, namely, that the large constituency is preferable to the small constituency. If the Minister agrees to meet that claim he will make it possible for proportional representation to work much more effectively than it can be worked in the smaller constituency. If the Government does really believe that proportional representation is desirable and has virtues, then there is no reason why it should not be tested to the last and given an opportunity of running the full gamut of its virtues. That can only be done on the basis of the large constituency. On the basis of the small constituency, I do not think any administrative object of any value is achieved, and certainly the principle of proportional representation is seriously interfered with, if, in fact, it is not altogether strangled.
Comment on this
I think I explained on the Second Reading my views on the large versus the small constituency. I believe that the small constituency, such as is proposed in the Bill with regard to North Dublin, South Dublin and certain counties, would be more manageable from many points of view. In North Dublin particularly it would give as good an opportunity of working proportional representation as would the arrangement of eight members at present in vogue. I know there is an opinion in the House that the large constituency is preferable. I do not know whether it is on all sides of the House, but I know it is to a certain extent among members of my own Party. I have heard, since the Bill was introduced, that some of them, at any rate, would like the large constituencies. I do not share that view. I should prefer, and I think it would give fairer results for everybody, that the House would accept the proposition which I have put forward in this Bill. I do not say that Dublin (North) is a constituency that, as it stands at present, is unmanageable. I do not say it is. It is not comparable in size to West Cork or some other constituencies. But with a population of 180,000 it is a very big constituency. I suggest that it should be divided into two. With this eight-member constituency divided into two there would be a better opportunity for all Parties in the two constituencies to work the constituency more satisfactorily and to get no less good results under that system than would be got under the system as at present worked. I think smaller constituencies not alone in North Dublin or Dublin City, but all the smaller constituencies that we have proposed for the several other counties, Tipperary, Donegal, Kerry, Galway, and so on, will give, at any rate, not less satisfactory results.
That is my opinion on the matter, but I know that that view is not shared everywhere. However, I think it ought to get a trial. I think for all political Parties concerned, particularly for the smaller Parties, there will be better opportunities. Take any Party you like—take the Labour Party. I think they would get a better chance with the smaller constituencies. They seem to believe, judging by the amendment here, that their chances would probably be better in the larger constituency. I do not know that that is so. I think it remains to be proved. I think the smaller constituencies would be better, particularly for the smaller Parties.
As I said on the Second Reading, with the larger constituencies you require a very big and, comparatively speaking, wealthy organisation to work them. Unless you have a powerful political machine behind you, you cannot cover a big constituency with the literature that is necessary. You cannot provide the necessary transport and everything else, all of which would be much more costly than in the case of a smaller constituency. Therefore, a large constituency is hampering any moderately-sized organisation. In order to work the small constituencies of three or five you require a far less powerful organisation. I think this is a much better way—to divide the constituencies into moderate-sized constituencies than have constituencies consisting of a county or a constituency with a population like that of North Dublin. I think the system of smaller constituencies is much better.
Comment on this
The Minister does not seem to have considered this matter very much. I notice when speaking here we talk about proportional representation as if the system we have was the only form of proportional representation. Personally I think the system of proportional representation we have is a bad form of proportional representation. You can say about proportional representation in general that it is unlikely to produce a situation in which a Party or a combination of Parties who have received only a minority of the votes in the country are likely to get into office. The Minister says he thinks it is more favourable to have smaller constituencies for the small Parties. Personally, I do not see why one should go out of his way to favour the smaller Parties. Why is a Party small?
Comment on this
Possibly, but not likely to be as small as Deputy Davin's Party. A Party is small because it has a small following in the country. The Constitution demands that the representation of the people shall be one representative to not less than so many electors, and that not more than a certain number of the population shall be represented by one member. Therefore, there is a co-relation between one Deputy and a number of people. The Vice-President says that the smaller constituency is more advantageous to the smaller Party. Clearly that is completely wrong, and his saying this shows that he has worked on an entirely false assumption in producing this Bill.
Take, for instance, the Labour Party referred to by the Minister. In North Dublin or in any other constituency they can get a Deputy elected provided they are supported by any number of units representing between 20,000 and 30,000 of the population. The Vice-President says that the smaller Party finds it much more difficult to work a large constituency. Now the Labour Party can only get one Deputy elected in North Dublin as the system stands. The reason that that is true is that there is only a certain proportion of the population supporting them. Roughly it means that they must be supported by one voter in nine. Let us take it you reduce the number of Deputies, so that instead of having eight Deputies you reduce the area to a voting population equivalent to three Deputies. Now, if the Labour Party could only get one Deputy elected previously, they have not a dog's chance of getting one now when the population is divided.
I think a lot can be said for this geographical representation of the country. Proportional representation has the advantage that it tends to make it more or less impossible to bring about the position you have in a country like England in which the Party receiving only the minority of votes may secure office. If you take the form of proportional representation that the Minister insists upon maintaining, it is perfectly easy to demonstrate that that system does not operate in constituencies of less than five members. Then one of the prime purposes and the one argument in favour of proportional representation, that it prevents a minority Government, has disappeared. When you have constituencies of not less than five, the system in no way prevents the possibility of a minority Government. The real reason then for maintaining that form of proportional representation has gone.
Looking at the Bill as a whole, it is clear that the Government has aimed at three-seat constituencies. In doing that they have eliminated any argument for and eliminated any beneficial effects that could follow from the form of the proportional representation that we have at present. If they wanted these smaller constituencies they could clearly have adopted a different form of proportional representation. What they have done is to eliminate the desirable results of the form of proportional representation we have. They have not got certain desirable results of that form of proportional representation or non-proportional representation. If you take any constituency the position is this: In a three-seat constituency, say, you require one-fourth of the voters plus one to form a quota. In that three-seat constituency the result I have indicated means that, roughly, you can say that the Party with half of the voters plus two is sure to get two-thirds of the representation. If you take the country as a whole, it means that you are just as likely to get the effect that sometimes comes from the non-proportional system of a Government that has been elected by a minority of voters.
This Bill, as it stands, with its three-seat constituencies and an occasional four-seat constituency, means that it is depriving this form of proportional representation of the one good thing that could be urged in its favour. That is the situation. The Government has done this in the case of every constituency. Possession is nine points of the law, and there is a lot to be said for that. It means if a certain thing is that you require less argument for leaving that thing as it is than for changing it. A better case has to be made for changing. The Government is proposing to make a change in these constituencies, and the onus of proof, therefore, was on them to show that the change they were proposing was an improvement on the existing order.
Now, you can take it that big areas have a lot to be said against them. It is very difficult to represent one big area, and there is less personal relationship between the Deputy and the people he represents. North Dublin, in area, is one of the smallest constituencies. With its eight members, it is smaller practically than any of the constituencies made in this Bill. So far as the question of area is concerned, it certainly does not apply here. They have divided the area into two, one constituency of five and one of three. So far as the latter constituency is concerned, it is clearly running completely counter to the object of the present form of proportional representation. The Government could have abolished that form. There are plenty of other forms.
Comment on this
They could have achieved the desired effect in other ways. They could have smaller constituencies. They could have avoided the situation of a Government representing a minority, and they could have provided also that small parties would get representation. Off-hand, I could give you a dozen proposals. You could have a single-member constituency as in England, and then you could provide that the constituencies directly would not send the full number of representatives to the Dáil. If you were to have 120 members in the Dáil, you could have 80 or 90 constituencies each returning one member.
Comment on this
The Deputy surely realises that he is making a Second Reading speech. If the Deputy were to continue on those lines other Deputies could not be precluded from resuming the Second Stage debate.
Comment on this
I quite understand. Here is a constituency approximately the smallest in the country, and the Government has divided it. The division is clearly not in favour of geographical smallness. If that were so, they would have to divide every other constituency into minute fractions. They seem to desire to have three-member constituencies. The Minister has put forward no argument in favour of this. In order to placate Deputy Norton, he said that the three-member constituency is beneficial to a small Party. No one will accuse me of being unjustly preoccupied with the benefits that may accrue to the Labour Party. I want some decent system which will achieve good results. A lot might be said for the English system, and proportional representation has something to be said for it; but the Government has destroyed whatever benefit can be got from proportional representation, and has prevented the benefit that could be got through the English system. I was going to suggest alternative systems under which they could have retained the advantages of proportional representation and could have gone some way towards the position which the Minister desires, that is, more direct touch between the people and their representatives.
In making a change, the onus of proof is on the person who proposes the change. The Minister has made no attempt to justify the divorce in this particular constituency of North Dublin. He said that the smaller constituency was beneficial to the small Party, which is directly contrary to truth. The Vice-President merely said: "I think," and "my opinion is." He implied that on the whole he would prefer that the Dáil would approve this division of the North Dublin constituency. He did not nail his colours to the mast and say that he would resist this amendment to the death. I would like a sound argument for the change. I would like to hear if the Minister is prepared to resist this amendment very strongly. Deputy Donnelly has indicated that he is not in sympathy with this type of thing. Is the Minister prepared to leave the issue to an open vote? I do not think there is any Party question involved. I know that I have not examined the first preferences, nor have I examined whether our Party would have a bigger representation one way or the other. It is quite possible that this change would be beneficial to our Party. Perhaps the Minister will give us some indication that, if he is going to resist this amendment, he will leave the issue to an open vote?
Comment on this
I would like to hear the Minister develop the point he makes, that the division of an area like this is good for a small Party and will be particularly good for the Labour Party. If he looks around him in County Dublin he will find that the situation at present is that we have one eight-member constituency north of the river, one seven-member constituency south of the river, and one eight-member constituency in the county. If the boundaries are left practically as they exist, with the exception of the transferring to the City constituencies of the rural parts that have been transferred to Greater Dublin, that would still leave eight members for the North City, seven for the South, and a nine-member constituency for the County. The Minister has turned these three constituencies into six. He provides three three-member constituencies, one four-member constituencies, and two five-member constituencies Interested as I am in giving different sections of the people representation under the proportional representation system we set up, I would like to hear the Minister develop how the change of these three constituencies into six is going to help the Labour Party.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister will at least tell us if he is going to have a Party vote or a free vote.
Comment on this
You are taking the capital of the country and the area immediately surrounding it. You are asking the citizens and the electors in the county to take it that the change now being made is for the purpose of giving a better chance to have proportional representation properly carried out, to have a closer connection with the people and their interests and a closer representation here in the Dáil of what they want. A more detailed review of the situation by the Minister is called for.
Comment on this
Speaking yesterday evening, the Minister said he would resist the amendment moved by Deputy Cosgrave on the grounds that it involved changing the boundaries of constituencies as set out under the Bill. That plea cannot be made against this amendment, because the amendment does not involve any change in the boundaries which would involve a reshuffling of the other contiguous constituencies. All that is involved in this amendment is simply taking out the bar, so to speak, between the two sections of the present North Dublin constituency and making the constituency one as at present instead of leaving the bar in and making the constituency two. Now, the same principle is operating in the case of the South Dublin constituency and in the case of Galway, Tipperary, Kerry, Donegal and Limerick. In all these five cases a bar has just been put in to divide the constituencies in two, for no apparent purpose except to divide them in two.
I suggest to the Minister that since there is a big principle running through the amendments affecting these constituencies, he ought to allow the House to decide, free from Party ties, whether it wants large or small constituencies. I gathered from what had been said that the Minister was expressing mainly his own view and, perhaps, the view of groups in his own Party, but the Minister himself indicated to the House, so far as I understood it, that there were people in his own Party who preferred the present large constituencies to the proposed small ones. If that is the position, and I can well believe that it is the position, I would suggest to the Minister, in view of the fact that there has been a definitely expressed preference for large constituencies from all groups in the House and apparently from his own Party, that he ought to allow the House to decide, free from Party ties, whether the House prefers the large or small constituencies. If he does that, we will get a vote then which will be a fair reflex of the opinion of the House on this important matter. After all, it is not a Party matter in any strict sense of the word and I think it ought not to be made a Party matter. I hope that the Minister will allow it to go to a free vote in the House so that the feelings of the House, apart from Party affiliations, can be reflected truly.
Comment on this
I said on the Second Reading, and I believe it to be correct, that a Deputy representing a small constituency has a greater opportunity of getting in touch with his constituents than in a large constituency, and that his constituents have greater opportunities of getting in touch with him than exist in a constituency like my own and that of Deputy Mulcahy, North Dublin. With eight Deputies representing 180,000 people, the Deputy is in an entirely impersonal position towards his constituents, except in relation, perhaps, to his own particular group of friends and those who know him well and intimately. I believe it would be better for the representative and better for the constituents that the individual representative should be in closer touch with his constituents and with every section of his constituents. I believe that better work would be done. That is my view, but I knew that it was not possible to go the length of doing away, as it would mean, with proportional representation if one were to go back to the single-member constituency. We are in the position that we must preserve the principle of proportional representation, and this Bill does that.
Comment on this
It does. It decidedly preserves the principle of proportional representation. The Deputy knows that there are some other people in the House who know something about proportional representation and who know it, perhaps, as well as the Deputy. Some of these have discussed the Bill with me and have put up a variety of systems of proportional representation. I have examined a variety of systems in vogue in different parts of the world, and I believe that what we propose in this Bill will give us as good a result for all Parties, and for the country as a whole, as any system that is likely to be adopted. I am particularly keen on the small constituency, and I am particularly keen that Deputies should be in the closes possible touch with the community they represent. That is my own view. I know that it is not shared by every member of my own Party. There are some in my own Party who have objected since the Bill has been introduced. I do not know what number in my own Party objected. I did not consult them all, and I am certain that they did not all speak to me about the Bill. A good many did, however, and I heard a good many criticisms from different people. I have no idea what number there would be in my Party who would accept the principles put forward in the Bill as against the system at present in vogue. I believe that it is not a Party measure, and that, as I said on the Second Reading, political opinion in this country is fluid at all times. We do not know with great certainty what any constituency may do at a future election. Therefore, whatever divisions there may be, or whatever recasting of particular constituencies there may be in the country as a whole, it is not likely to alter the opinions of people. The people are usually well enough up in political matters and take enough interest in political affairs to be able to decide for themselves what way they will vote in any particular constituency. Therefore, if there is a strong feeling in the House that constituencies like North Dublin and South Dublin and the other counties that are divided, such as Donegal, Kerry, Galway, Tipperary, and Limerick——
Comment on this
Those counties divided in two are constituencies that have been divided in two. In several constituencies there has been a small bit taken away in order to regulate the population.
Comment on this
Oh, no. Perhaps in Cork a corner has been taken off to enable County Waterford to keep its representation. I would not agree that there should be a free vote concerning these constituencies, but in the other constituencies, where the constituency is being divided in two, I would be content to leave the House absolutely free to decide whatever way it wishes in the matter. My own personal view, however, held very strongly, is that the system I have proposed, the system of smaller constituencies, will give by far the best results from the point of view of the country, from the point of view of the constituency and, I believe, from any Party's point of view.
Comment on this
I cannot accept the Minister's statement that a three-member constituency obtains what was sought to be obtained in this system of proportional representation. The Minister got up and stated that it is desirable that there should be a sort of personal relationship between the Deputy and his electors. I quite agree that that is one of the desirable things to be got. It can be got, however, to a greater degree than he is getting it by these constituencies, and you can retain the proportional representation system. The Minister, however, talks about a case like Roscommon or these other cases he mentioned, and said that it was done there on account of the necessity in respect of the population. In the general election his Party stated that part of their economy campaign was that they were going to reduce the number of members of the Dáil. The Constitution, or the Electoral Act, as far as I remember, provides that there shall be not less than one representative per 30,000 and not more than one representative per 20,000. It seems to me that the Minister, in making that stipulation as to constituencies, is making it because the Government went out of its way to see how it could make the Dáil as big as possible. I think the Minister or the President stated that he did not think that an efficient Dáil could be got with 100 members.
Comment on this
I think that statement is completely devoid of proof. When in certain constituencies the population has diminished the law requires that those constituencies should cease to have the representation that they have had so far. There are cases in which the situation was created that if you wanted to keep the idea of proportional representation the diminished population would reduce the representation of those constituencies to such a point that proportional representation would cease to operate. Apart from that, if you take County Wicklow, for instance, it was a three-member constituency. The population decreased so that it would have ceased to have three. If the Vice-President's idea was right, and, following on the programme they proposed in their manifesto at the last election, they should have said that Wicklow should continue as it is now, and if it had not the required number for three members it could have been left with just two members.
The Vice-President assumes a whole lot of things quite wrongly. He said with regard to some constituencies that a certain portion had to be taken away. I understand that he meant that it had to be added to another constituency so as to make it eligible to have a certain number of representatives. The case cannot be made for making the representation of the country as large as possible. If he was saying that you require each constituency to have a certain number of representatives before proportional representation operates, then there would be some point in it, but the way he has gone with the Bill destroys everything. For instance, he takes a bit from one constituency to add to another. Is that done so that there would be as nearly as possible one representative for every 20,000, when there is a margin up to 30,000 before they need bother about it according to law? It seems that the Minister is aiming at having as many representatives as possible, and that is why this gerrymandering is done.
I do not want to put this into controversial terms, but one of the effects of this is certainly to favour the large Parties. Personally, there is every indication to me that our Party is more likely to gain than to lose. There has been a lot of rot talked about proportional representation. It seems more likely that we shall gain rather than lose. I am not unduly concerned to see Labour with increased representation in this House, because I do not think it is necessarily desirable. What I do want is that we shall have some objective in mind. There are a number of desirable things to be looked for in the system of representation that we have. They are not all obtainable. You have between these to select what you think is more desirable, and in the interests of these, you have to sacrifice what you think is less desirable. What I object to is that the Minister is retaining all that is undesirable and failing to get what might be desirable. He eliminates the good effect of this particular system of proportional representation and he achieves nothing.
By the whole Bill he has put the country in the position that you can have a minority Government elected. I am not going to say that there is anything fundamentally wrong with that, but the argument made for proportional representation is that it prevents that happening. The Minister says that other people have studied proportional representation as well as I have. I do not deny that. All I do say is that the propagandists of the Fianna Fáil Party, who were working out a sum in simple arithmetic, stated that if there had not been proportional representation at the last general election there would have been a 100 per cent. Fianna Fáil Dáil. These people completely overlooked certain facts. They assumed that there were going to be one-member constituencies and that they would be identical with the present ones.
This amendment brings out in a particularly glaring fashion what the Minister is doing. Geographically, there has been no argument put up in favour of it. He talked about one member representing 180,000 people. 180,000 people are not represented by one member in North Dublin. The law provides that one member shall represent a population of not less than 20,000 and not more than 30,000. If there are 180,000 people in North Dublin, they should have nine representatives. The Minister would allow each Deputy to have his election with a circle of friends. As a matter of fact, that comes out very much better with a big constituency, because there are different interests. If Deputy Norton were elected for North Dublin he might have one set of friends in that area, if he could get them amounting to 20,000 and Deputy Mulcahy might have another. The Minister's suggestion that one man representing North Dublin represents 180,000 people is a suggestion that the other seven Deputies are having an easy time and not bothering about their constituents.
What I object to about the Minister's two statements is that both of them have completely misrepresented the position. He has failed to bring up any argument in favour of this and yet he has brought this solemnly before the Dáil as a change that it is desirable to make in order to improve the situation. The only thing it does is to get rid of something that might possibly be desirable and it does not provide anything that could conceivably be desirable.
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
Amendment No. 3 falls, consequently, and the decision will also govern amendment No. 24.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:—
In Part I to delete all references to the constituencies of "South-East Dublin" and of "South-West Dublin" and substitute therefor the following:—
"
DUBLIN BOROUGH SOUTH. | The County Borough Electoral Divisions Numbers One and Four. | Seven
"
I think that the arguments that have been submitted in respect of the previous amendment apply equally to this amendment. The Minister may argue that the Bill causes no mutilation of Dublin as an electoral area, but I think he must admit that it is a slow method of abolishing proportional representation. I would have expected that, on any revision or redistribution of the constituencies, Dublin City would have been entitled to some preferential consideration in the matter of its representation. I am rather surprised that, on the introduction of this Bill now, Dublin is to be cut into four different sections and reduced to a three or four-seat constituency. I think, as the capital city, with its trade, commerce, industry and all that, it would be reasonable to expect that it should receive better treatment than it gets under this Bill. As regards the south-west Dublin constituency, to which three seats are allocated, I think it is too small, and the points that were made yesterday about the work of Deputies can, I think, be well justified as far as Dublin is concerned. I think all Parties or Party representatives have a good deal of work to do, and I think that when it comes to the three-seat constituency their work will be greatly increased. I am afraid, now that the Minister has already expressed himself on the North Dublin amendment, that this will receive the same fate. At any rate, I move the amendment, and I hope the Dáil will accept it.
Comment on this
The Minister made no attempt to answer the questions that were put to him on the last amendment. Again I say, when dealing with a constituency like South Dublin, which ought to have labour representation, which had labour representation at one time, and which, if we were more sensibly led to-day, might have labour representation too, that the Minister, when he parades this Bill as a friend of labour, as it were, ought to make some attempt to explain to the House how the division up of a constituency like South Dublin, which at the present moment has no labour representation, say outside of Deputy Peadar Doyle——
Comment on this
If the Deputy will tell us who the other Labour members for South Dublin are, we will be glad to hear it.
Comment on this
This is a matter which the Minister, if he is not talking entirely with his tongue in his cheek, will make some attempt to explain.
Comment on this
I do not think I need say anything on this amendment. We have debated the subject on the last amendment, and I suppose the same question—in principle at any rate—will be up before us again. I should like to make a remark about a statement made by Deputy Fitzgerald. He said that in certain constituencies—he mentioned Wicklow—where the population had fallen, all we need do, if the constituency had three members and was no longer entitled to three members on account of reduction of the population, was to leave it so. We could not do that, as long as we try to put into operation the terms of Article XXVI of the Constitution. Deputy Fitzgerald said that we were bound, according to the terms of the Constitution, to have not less than 20,000 and not more than 30,000 of a population per member, but there is a little more than that in the Constitution. It says here: "Provided that the proportion between the number of members to be elected at any time for each constituency and the population of each constituency, as ascertained at the the last preceding census, shall, so far as possible, be identical throughout the country." That made it necessary to keep within certain limits—within the bounds of 20,000 and 30,000. As far as possible, you have to make it identical; therefore, you cannot let every county stand on its own. Let us take the case of Wicklow, where the population had fallen. The Deputy did not suggest, I think, that it should be kept a two-member constituency under the present system of proportional representation. After all, the present system is one of the few remaining systems in the world to-day. There was one system that was praised and recommended, not alone to this country but to many other countries, and that was the German system. It did not last very long, and one of the reasons why it did not last may have been because of the type of proportional representation it was. We here are anxious to keep proportional representation. We believe it works well for the country and for the Parties as a whole. To keep proportional representation, you had also, remembering the principles laid down in the Constitution, to try to take from the neighbouring area a sufficient amount of the population to keep the constituency where the principle of proportional representation could operate.
Comment on this
Does the Minister say that he talks in those terms of proportional representation when he puts before the House a Bill which contains 20 three-member constituencies?
Comment on this
May I judge from what the Minister says that in this Bill, within the margins of 20,000 and 30,000, the Minister sought to have more or less uniformity of representation through the country, and that this was the best way of getting uniformity in the country, and maintaining the reality of proportional representation? First of all I main tain that the reality of this form of proportional representation is gone under this Bill. Secondly, I am quite satisfied that there would have been less of what I might call arbitrary changes by allowing a margin of between 20,000 and 30,000; but if you want to have as many representatives as possible, and if you are aiming at a representation of one to twenty rather than one to thirty, then it seems to me this would explain some of the things done in this Bill. The Minister says that in Germany the system of proportional representation went. One of the things that were obviously in mind in this system which we have here was a pretence that Parties did not exist. That is clearly pretence. I could give a dozen quotations from the President's speeches showing that it is perfectly ridiculous to maintain this pretence. This system of proportional representation is to my mind wrong for a number of reasons. For one thing, the idea of a Government is to make for unity in the country. The idea of this proportional representation is to translate into the Dáil, as far as possible, all the divergencies that exist in the country, whereas the very idea of the Dáil is to disregard divergencies, and to recognise a substantial unity in the country. There is no excuse for clinging to this particular form, except the pretence that Parties do not exist. In Germany it may be that the existence of rival Parties had to be wiped out, and that would be a very good reason for abolishing the German form, but in this country is it necessary for us to pretend that Parties do not exist? The President, time and again within the last two months, has got up and, in effect, said that it is perfectly ridiculous to pretend any such thing. The recognition of this particular form which the Minister speaks of is based on the assumption that the existence of Parties is in itself bad, and that the law and the Constitution should refuse to recognise any such fact. If it is a fact the best thing one can do is to recognise it. One could overcome all the defects of proportional representation or one could have all the benefits of small constituencies by merely recognising the fact that Parties exist.
In arguing this matter, I am not moved by Party motives at all because I think that whatever the Fianna Fáil Party is doing at the moment to benefit themselves would ultimately actually be a benefit to us if there is any advantage in getting more representatives than one is due to have. There is an assumption somehow or other that once a Party has a majority, it matters a great deal how big or small that majority is. Personally, once the Fianna Fáil Party has a majority of one, I see nothing to rejoice about in the fact that it may have a majority of a dozen. Once I knew the Fianna Fáil Party was going to be the Government, it would make no difference to me if they had a majority of a dozen. There is no doubt that it is by virtue of the majority of one which they got that the Party are carrying out their present policy but they would have done exactly the same thing if they had a majority of a dozen. The Minister seems to be making statements on what I might call an inadequate consideration of the facts. I regarded Wicklow, Meath and Monaghan, even under our régime, as counties in which proportional representation did not operate because each had only a representation of three Deputies. I could quite understand the Minister's saying that because the system was ineffective in these counties, apart from any changes in population, something should be done about these three constituencies but I say that within that margin which the law permits, of between 20,000 and 30,000 electors per member, these arbitrary and definitely harmful changes that have been made in the Bill could have been easily avoided provided whoever was drawing up the Bill had had in mind that the only thing to be aimed at was uniformity of representation within 20,000 and 30,000 electors for each member.
Comment on this
It is not quite correct to say that the only condition is that the number of population per member must be between 20,000 and 30,000. That is conditioned by the other circumstances.
Comment on this
The proportion must as far as possible be identical throughout the country. You must remember that, in arranging the number of members, you must try to bring them as close as possible to the number of persons that each Deputy would represent. If we take the country as a whole the population is 2,900,000 odd. If we took the whole area of the Free State and divided it up on the basis of that Article in the Constitution, we could have as many as 149 members. You would disregard county boundaries. Deputies must remember the fact that the leader of the Opposition Party brought in an amendment to this Bill proposing that it should be thrown out because it disregarded certain county boundaries. There is a feeling rightly or wrongly in the country, that county boundaries should be recognised.
There are some areas more than others in which there is a kind of feeling that county boundaries are sacrosanct and that, for Parliamentary purposes or local government purposes, it would be a sort of treason to the locality not to have regard to the county boundaries. There is a certain sentiment attached to county boundaries in some areas, and it is one which cannot be entirely disregarded by anyone. It has been disregarded in some cases unquestionably, but that was unavoidable because of this condition laid down in the Constitution, that we must not exceed 30,000 per member or have less than 20,000, and that we must have the proportion throughout the country identical. We did not produce the Bill, as was suggested, to get in as many members as possible. If we did, we could have elected 13 more members, and it would have provided a reason for anger to the Party opposite, if the leader speaks for the Party, possibly to a greater extent than was expressed when the amendment was being debated in which it was proposed that the Bill should be thrown out because it interfered with county boundaries.
Comment on this
The Minister suggested that in drafting the Bill he had to consider the sacrosanctity of county boundaries, but he has not done that. I have not gone into the question of uniformity of representation to see how far he has achieved it, but what I do say is that as far as county boundaries are concerned they have been disregarded. I can point to what has happened in my own constituency. There are county boundaries there which have been established for quite a long time, and which have a definite meaning. If the Minister applied the standard of between 20,000 and 30,000 electors per member, and sought as far as possible to achieve uniform representation, he could have avoided an enormous number of anomalies——
Comment on this
I would like to hear about the other anomalies that would have been created. It is clear to me that this Bill is the result of more limitation than was really necessary, because the limitation of boundary was no hindrance to the Minister. We have the most extraordinary things happening, such as taking a bit of Galway and putting it on to Clare. There were certain things that the Minister should have had in mind, things laid down by law and by custom. There was the existence of the present constituencies to which the people have got accustomed, and which have a certain meaning. There were county loyalities—another thing to keep in mind. The Bill is not in its present form merely by virtue of that limitation, as many boundaries have been disregarded altogether. There are other limitations which were not imposed that are clearly answerable for the changes.
Comment on this
As regards the boundaries of Carlow, I shall deal with them when my own case comes along.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton drew the Minister's attention to the position in West Cork where the constituency extends over a very wide area. It was mentioned that the constituency is left as it is, although parts of it are 70 miles distant from each other. No one knows, again, how long these miles may be. They would be known locally as mile móra fada— long Carberry miles.
Comment on this
At any rate, the miles are long and the miles are many. Nevertheless, when we come to the position in a seven-member constituency, in a fairly compact city, we get the constituency divided into a four-member and a three-member constituency. One of the principles on which the Minister, or at any rate the Minister for Industry and Commerce, stands, is that he is opposed to a four-member constituency. Yet we have a fairly big constituency divided up like that, a constituency which was admirable for the purposes of proportional representation. The Minister's proposal, so far as we can see in this matter, is nothing but gerrymandering, and he has the support of the Labour Party in his gerrymandering.
Comment on this
I should like to hear the Deputy upon the matter of dividing South Dublin into a four and three-member constituency, and I should like to know whether that has not been done by arrangement with the Labour Party. The Minister told us that he did not want to have a Party vote, but the division that has just taken place showed us that he had his whole Party lined up behind him in favour of the splitting of South Dublin.
Comment on this
We could have carried the amendment only the Deputy Belton section of the Party opposite had left.
Comment on this
We could have carried it only that some of the farmers are in the Mansion House, at this moment, discussing the conditions in which their industry has been placed by the Fianna Fáil Party and the Labour Party, acting together.
Comment on this
I think it is not the time for Deputy Norton to raise these matters when, as a matter of fact, he should be afraid to mention them. We are now discussing a serious question, and the Deputy has responsibilities in the matter. If the Deputy has nothing to say on this particular point we must only take it that some arrangement has been come to between the Party at one of the fortnightly conferences that take place.
Comment on this
I only wanted to give Deputy Mulcahy an opportunity of displaying his eloquence, of which he is so proud, or else I should have spoken before now. He has a high regard for his own eloquence, and I did not want to do anything that would be considered to be putting an embargo on it and preventing the House hearing him. I wonder whether Deputy Mulcahy was more concerned with the amendment or with the Labour Party. He made it perfectly clear that the Labour Party is coming between him and his night's rest. The Labour Party has nothing to do with this proposal.
Comment on this
And the Deputy feels that he has overslept himself, and he is going to put some of the responsibility on the Labour Party when he talks of gerrymandering. He says the Labour Party are in collusion with the Government in gerrymandering South Dublin. The other day we had Deputy Bennett going down to Limerick and stating that 75 per cent. of the people are behind him and his Party, and will be at the next election. Now what is Deputy Bennett's position in regard to this Bill? Section 8 of this Bill provides that it shall come into operation immediately on the dissolution of the Oireachtas, which shall occur next after the passing of the Act. This Bill cannot come into operation until the present Dáil is dissolved. We have Deputy Bennett, the mathematician of the Party opposite, announcing that 75 per cent. of the people are behind his Party. What does that mean? Is it not quite clear that if this Dáil dissolves and 75 per cent. of the people of the country are backing Deputies opposite, that will amount to such an electoral force that you cannot gerrymander the constituencies? I want to know whether Deputy Mulcahy or Deputy Bennett is right.
Comment on this
Deputy Bennett says 75 per cent. of the people are behind the Party opposite, yet Deputy Mulcahy talks about an attempt to gerrymander the constituencies. Which of them is right?
Comment on this
I knew Deputy Fitzgerald would have a different point of view from any normal person.
Comment on this
I am very glad to know that. Deputy Mulcahy was, I think unnecessarily, peevish about this amendment. He has not had time to restrain his impetuosity. I asked the Minister to leave to an open vote the question of taking out the central bar in Galway, Donegal, Tipperary and Limerick. I was not in favour of taking out the central bar. Having assured the Deputy of that, I hope he will not be unduly concerned about the situation from the Labour Party point of view and that he will be able to concentrate more. I think there is a very strong case for leaving South Dublin as one constituency. I think both the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Local Government, on the last amendment, committed themselves to the principle that even-member constituencies were administratively and electorally, from the parliamentary point of view, awkward and not desirable constituencies, and that the desirable constituency was an odd-membered constituency. Here is an amendment now designed to eliminate the principle of even-member constituencies by substituting seven in South Dublin for two constituencies of four members and three members. I think it is a good amendment. We have the contention of both those Ministers for accepting this amendment and eliminating the principle of even-member constituencies, and substituting an odd-member constituency. Quite apart from that, the Minister again urged, in the case of North Dublin, where it was sought to substitute eight seats, the creation of two constituencies and dividing them into five-member and three-member constituencies. The Minister might have made the section read so as to show that he did not want even-member constituencies and that odd-member constituencies were desirable, and to that extent he might have preserved the virtue of odd-member constituencies.
Comment on this
Given the principle suggested, can the Deputy divide seven into two without having an even number?
Comment on this
The Minister will not deny that on the last occasion he had different views about even-member constituencies.
Comment on this
And large constituencies; but let us at least now confine ourselves to even-member constituencies. We contend that in the substitution of a four-member constituency and a three-member constituency for a seven-member constituency the four cancels out whatever virtue there is in the three. The Minister tells us that he is against large constituencies. How can he possibly claim that South Dublin is a large constituency? It stretches from Inchicore——
Comment on this
That is the extreme end of the constituency. The populous end of the constituency could be covered on a 2d. or 3d. tram ride. One could go from one end to the other on a bicycle in half-an-hour. If one could get a motor-car, one could go from one end to the other in less than 20 minutes. In view of the fact that the Minister is leaving the whole of County Clare as one constituency, and the whole of West Cork as one constituency, by what process of reasoning is it held that a constituency that can be covered on a bicycle in half-an-hour is a large constituency? Clare and West Cork are deemed to be small constituencies suitable for retention in their present form. If the desire was to avoid large constituencies, I do not see why Carlow-Kilkenny was torn as it was, nor can I understand why that elongated constituency of Carlow-Kildare has been created. Possibly, the Ceann Comhairle would not permit me to discuss that now, but I may be permitted to say that, while the Minister for Industry and Commerce is against large constituencies, we have a constituency like Carlow-Kildare which stretches from Leixlip to Bagenalstown. If the Minister refers to the map, he will find that that constituency is the most curious looking one in Ireland.
I think that the Minister should accept this amendment. It cannot be claimed that South Dublin is a large constituency. It cannot be claimed that it gives you an even number of members; it gives you an odd number. The constituency is represented by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. We can have the assurances of himself and his colleague that it will not be overlooked so long as he represents it, because, according to all the Press accounts and according to the tributes from Deputy MacDermot, the Minister possesses an enormous reservoir of energy. That will, I am sure, find itself in service on behalf of people who might otherwise be overlooked, on the reasoning of the Minister for Local Government and Public Health.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce has an extraordinary way of reasoning. He agrees that even-member constituencies should be avoided.
Comment on this
By interjection. Even-member constituencies, he says, are bad. How can you divide a seven-member constituency into two, without having one over, he asks? When he is asked "why divide?," he asks "why not?" He gave the answer himself. You cannot divide seven into two parts without having an even number and he says that even-number constituencies are bad. Deputy Norton said that Deputy Mulcahy said the Bill was a gerrymandering one and that Deputy Bennett said that 75 per cent. of the people of his constituency were supporters of his own Party. One, he says, contradicts the other. That is perfectly ridiculous. I imagine that the most extreme object of a gerrymandering Bill would be to make it possible for a minority party to get elected as a Government. I myself believe—at the same time, I do not want to run the risk of being unjust to the Vice-President—that there is a very considerable gerrymandering element in this Bill. The treatment of constituencies in which I have been particularly interested makes that, in my opinion, perfectly clear. I think that the gerrymandering will fail because Fianna Fáil will not be able to get re-elected even with this Bill. As some people think it matters a great deal whether a Government has a big majority or a small majority or whether the Opposition is a big or small party, they may want to create representation for the minority when the election comes. I regard that as silly because, as I said before, once a Government has a majority, it does not matter whether it is a majority of one or a majority of 11.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
It is proposed that the words in amendment No. 4 be inserted instead of the words set out. If amendment No. 4 is rejected, amendment No. 5 will be put. As the House may desire to discuss amendments Nos. 4 and 5 together, I shall allow some discussion on the general point, but the question will be put on amendment No. 4.
Comment on this
It is just a question of the difference. The amendment standing in Deputy Doyle's name would leave South Dublin constituency with the boundaries that it has at the present time. The amendment standing in Deputy Norton's name would add part of what was the old County Dublin, part of Ringsend, to the South Dublin constituency. There is an amendment standing in the names of Deputy O'Sullivan and Deputy Costello, the intention of which would be to leave County Dublin as it is at present, that is, with Rathmines and Pembroke, and County Dublin would remain as one constituency. That position dovetails in with the position now as regards South Dublin, and what the House is faced with deciding now is whether the South Dublin constituency as it stands at present should remain with its present boundary or whether it should be enlarged by having the portion of what was Pembroke added to it.
Comment on this
May I ask for the ruling on this? Is it proposed now, if I move amendment No. 5, the question that will be put to the House is to substitute No. 5 for the amendment of the Bill brought about by No. 4?
Comment on this
Amendment No. 4 must be decided first. If No. 4 is carried, No. 5 falls. If No. 4 is negatived No. 5 will be moved. What has been decided is that the words in the Bill do not stand. No. 4 has now to be decided.
Comment on this
I would prefer No. 5, because it is the present constituency rather than a divided constituency. If there is to be any change, and the House has indicated its desire for a change, I would rather have the present constituency with the present boundaries that are proposed in the Bill, and that would be No. 5.
Comment on this
I submit the Minister would desire that, for the reason that he wants to divide up County Dublin.
Comment on this
The Minister, in saying that he prefers No. 5 to No. 4, indicates that he would like to take a piece away from what would otherwise be County Dublin, and add it to South Dublin.
Comment on this
Will the Minister give any indication as to his reason for taking from the constituency of County Dublin a portion of Ringsend and Sandymount in a purely arbitrary fashion? It runs down along the proposed new line, cutting off portion of Ringsend, and it runs in an arbitrary fashion along the Shelbourne Road, cuts off portion of Landsdowne Road and runs down over the railway line towards Ringsend. What the reason is for that I cannot understand. It cuts into the old Pembroke area for no reason that has been given in this House, so far as I know. The Pembroke area consisted of Ringsend and Sandymount, and why it should be put into the City passes my comprehension. Perhaps the Minister will indicate why he proposes this lopping off from the Pembroke area of this portion, and why he would prefer it to the proposal that has already been carried by the House.
Comment on this
May I put this point? If No. 6 is defeated a curious difficulty will arise if No. 4 is carried.
Comment on this
In these circumstances No. 5 would be better perhaps than the position that would thus be created.
Comment on this
But if No. 6 is defeated, notwithstanding all your Party and our Party can do, a difficulty has to be met, and No. 5 may well meet it.
Comment on this
I suggest that if the Minister would be prepared to let an inconvenient position stand at this stage, I would be quite willing to reinsert No. 5 on the Report Stage if No. 6 is defeated. That will have the advantage of enabling the House to study the position after the Bill has left Committee. The inconvenience will last only a week.
Comment on this
I do not see any reason why we could not have now whatever debate there will ultimately have to be on the section before us. Let us have it now rather than a week hence.
Comment on this
It would if No. 4 is carried. That is that. Then we will come to deal with the county and if the holding together of the county by No. 6 is defeated, then the Minister will have to look, on the Report Stage, at what he is going to do with the county. He might, in dealing then with the county have certain things to say with regard to the extension of South Dublin.
Comment on this
I submit that by far the most convenient thing would be to put amendment No. 4 to the House now. It has been fully discussed and, as Deputy Mulcahy has explained, in the event of amendment No. 6 being defeated, the matter can be ironed out on next stage. The regular and natural thing is to go on with the first amendment on the Order Paper, which is No. 4.
Comment on this
The main point is that to accept No. 5 now as against No. 4 would be to invite the defeat of No. 6.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 5:—
In Part I to delete all references to the constituencies of "South East Dublin" and "South West Dublin" and substitute the following:—
"
SOUTH DUBLIN. | The Fitzwilliam, Merchants Quay, Mansion House, New Kilmainham, Royal Exchange, South City, South Dock, Trinity, Ushers Quay and Wood Quay Wards, and the portion of the County Borough of Dublin bounded by a line drawn as follows:— | Seven
Commencing at the point in the River Liffey where the Northern boundary of the South Dock Ward meets the Eastern boundary of the South Dock Ward and proceeding thence in a Southerly Westerly and Southerly direction to Grand Canal Street Upper and thence in a South-Easterly direction along the middle of Grand Canal Street Upper to Shelbourne Road and thence in a South-Easterly direction along the middle of Shelbourne Road to Lansdowne Road and thence in an Easterly direction along the middle of Lansdowne Road to Newbridge Avenue and thence in a North-Easterly direction along the middle of Newbridge Avenue to Sandymount Road and thence in a South-Easterly direction along the middle of Sandymount Road to Seafort Avenue and thence in a North-Easterly direction along the middle of Seafort Avenue to the Coast and thence in a North-Westerly, North-Easterly and (to include the Pigeon House Fort and Poolbeg Lighthouse) Easterly and (round the Poolbeg Lighthouse) Westerly and Northerly direction to the point in the River Liffey where the Eastern boundary of the North Dock Ward meets the Southern boundary of the North Dock Ward and thence along the said Southern boundary of the North Dock Ward to the starting point.
"
Is the Minister accepting amendment No. 5?
Comment on this
I made a point, when discussing amendments Nos. 4 and 5, that if amendment No. 5 was accepted it would annihilate the hope of passing amendment No. 6. I do not know if Deputy Norton realises that, or if he is withdrawing amendment No. 5 now.
Comment on this
I realise that both amendments Nos. 5 and 6 cannot pass. My amendment is to preserve South Dublin as one with seven seats. The Minister is accepting that amendment. It is not possible, after accepting an amendment of that kind, to pass or accept amendment No. 6.
Comment on this
The position I am concerned with is the preservation of a single constituency representing County Dublin, so that, as well as having a single constituency in South Dublin, we will have a single constituency in County Dublin.
Comment on this
May I have a ruling, Sir? Suppose we acquiesce in the acceptance of amendment No. 5, will we be debarred from discussing amendment No. 6?
Comment on this
On what ground will it arise that if amendment No. 5 is accepted a discussion on amendment No. 6 will be debarred?
Comment on this
We have already dealt with it by accepting amendment No. 5. That would be included in amendment No. 6, if that amendment were accepted.
Comment on this
The position could not stand. There is one area that would be included in the County that has already by vote been included in the City.
Comment on this
I would argue, on the point of order, that that is a small detail. The area, in so far as it is involved in that, can be amended on Report. There is no reason why circumstances such as that should prevent amendment No. 6 being discussed, when it is taken into account that what is involved in amendment No. 6 is a discussion on the principle of keeping the whole, or practically the whole, of what was the County Dublin constituency as one constituency and not dividing it up into two. I submit that no detail such as the Minister speaks about should bring the discussion of an important matter like that within the restricted discussion allowed on Report. The fact that certain subsequent amendments of a minor kind might have to be made in amendment No. 6 on Report should not prejudice its acceptance by the House in Committee in its present state, if the general principle enshrined in it is acceptable to the House.
Comment on this
I cannot see how it could be called a matter of detail. There is a question of several thousand persons involved. The House has already decided that these persons are to be included in one constituency, and I cannot see how we can come to a decision reversing a decision already come to, as would be the case if amendment No. 6 were carried. I cannot see that the Chair can rule that that would be in order—that there would be a possibility of reversing a vote already given, because that is what it would mean if we accepted amendment No. 6. It is true that it is only a small portion of the total constituency of County Dublin, but in numbers it represents several thousand people.
Comment on this
There is nothing, as far as I understand, to prevent the Minister reversing a decision on Report.
Comment on this
I wish to protest against that, because we were connecting up this other matter as between amendment No. 5 and amendment No. 6.
Comment on this
As to whether the House has or has not accepted amendment No. 5, the mere acceptance by the Minister, I suggest to you, Sir, is not an acceptance by the House. There must be some discussion at least allowed on this matter. The Minister cannot closure discussion by merely accepting an amendment proposed by a private member. I want to know, in particular, on this matter, which the Minister has now stated is a very important matter, what are the reasons inducing the Minister to take Ringsend out of County Dublin and put it into South Dublin. He says it is a very important matter. It is so important that it almost brings in its train——
Comment on this
If you rule that the Minister has accepted this amendment and thereby the House is precluded from discussing the amendment, I cannot get from the Minister the reason why he has put this provision in the Bill. The House and my constituency do not know, and we will never know the reason. It is just put into the Bill by the casual acceptance of it by the Minister from Deputy Norton without giving any reason.
Comment on this
The Chair, I take it, has not ruled that the acceptance of the amendment by the Minister in charge debars further discussion. If you indicate at any stage in the debate the acceptance of an amendment, that does not preclude us from discussing it. Another question also arises. If the House adopts amendment No. 5, will the Chair then rule that amendment No. 6 cannot be discussed? There can be no question whatever, I take it, that we are entitled to a discussion on amendment No. 5 the moment it comes before the House. On the net question, if we accept amendment No. 5, shall we be debarred by the Rules of Order from discussing amendment No. 6?
Comment on this
Is that not giving a decision in advance? I do not know what the House will do with regard to No. 5.
Comment on this
Will you allow us, for the purposes of discussion, to take No. 5 and No. 6 together, and to say on No. 5 everything that might have been said on No. 6?
Comment on this
If the House decides on No. 5, there is clearly matter in it by reason of which, if the House were to discuss No. 6, it would be discussing a decision taken on No. 5. That is accepted.
Comment on this
I do not know what the Minister would say to taking No. 5 and No. 6 together, letting the discussion range over them and taking a decision on No. 5.
Comment on this
If you take a decision on No. 5, you preclude No. 6; but if you take a decision on No. 6, it need not necessarily rule No. 5.
Comment on this
The House has carried amendment No. 4 and rejected amendment No. 3, and if it proceeds to carry amendment No. 5 it will have created a position in which there will be no South City constituency at all.
Comment on this
It will not. It will merely have left what the Minister is so accustomed to fill, a vacuum.
Comment on this
It is going to be rather hard to know what you are deciding, when you come to decide.
Comment on this
I suggest the best way out is to take No. 5 and No. 6 together and to have the vote on No. 5.
Comment on this
No. 5 would have to be taken first; and if No. 5 is taken, there will be a decision.
Comment on this
There will be a decision, and if you take No. 6 afterwards you will be interfering with the decision on No. 5.
Comment on this
Might I, on behalf of my own constituency, say that while I regard Ringsend as very important, it is only a very small portion of the constituency of County Dublin, and I do not want the question of the integrity of the constituency of County Dublin to be decided on a small portion of Ringsend, because that is what would happen if a decision is to be taken on No. 5 and not on No. 6.
Comment on this
I am sure that Deputy Costello will agree that if there is a decision taken on No. 5, you clearly cannot traverse a certain portion of that decision.
Comment on this
I should like to make this proposal, that we be given the permission of the House to amend amendment No. 6 to read, so far as the description goes: "...the administrative County of Dublin and borough electoral division No. 5 of the County Borough of Dublin, other than that part included in the constituency known as South Dublin," and that the number of members be changed from nine to eight. Then, we could discuss, without prejudice, the passing of amendment No. 5 and we could have a discussion on No. 6 in a satisfactory way. It is simply a matter of getting the leave of the House to amend the description for County Dublin in accordance with the decision which would have been taken in respect of South Dublin.