Registration of Maternity Homes Bill, 1934—From the Seanad. - Electoral (Revision of Constituencies) Bill, 1934—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 176–334 of 334. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 11 of 1934 ›
That amendment to amendment No. 6 would arise only in the event of No. 5 being carried.
Comment on this
I do not see how that can be. The Deputies studied the Bill and they knew what they wanted when putting in their amendments. They had it all clearly before them and evidently they went into it with considerable care, judging by the amendments they have put in. This is evidently what they wanted then and I do not see why they should be allowed to amend it now.
Comment on this
Then, Sir, I again appeal to you to review the order you are laying down. I submit to you that there is nothing wrong, from the point of view of order, in discussing amendment No. 6, even after amendment No. 5 has been passed, because what is enshrined in it is a broad principle of holding the whole of the present County Dublin together. A small portion of it will, in fact, have been cut off if No. 5 is passed but that is a very minor point and a matter which, on Report, might be put right, either by reviewing and amending what was done under No. 5 or reviewing and amending what was done under No. 6. The fact that the two decisions were taken by the House would, in fact, only mean that South Dublin would remain as one constituency and County Dublin as another. It remains then, as between the two decisions taken, to define the boundary between the two constituencies. There is nothing else at issue as between these two amendments but where exactly the boundary line is to go.
Comment on this
Clearly, if you take a decision on No. 5 and then proceed to take a decision on No. 6, and if the decision is in favour of No. 6, you will have two different decisions taken by the House. I could not possibly consider a proposition to have two different decisions taken by the House within a short period of time.
Comment on this
The Minister says that the Opposition in framing their amendments had obviously displayed care. That is quite true but in offering our amendments on Committee Stage, we could not foresee the terms of the amendments that might be submitted by Deputy Norton. The difficulty has arisen out of the coincidence of Deputy Norton's amendment and ours and not out of our amendment itself. Therefore, I submit to the Minister that his opposition to the granting of your permission to amend our amendment should be withdrawn. Had we had Deputy Norton's amendment before us, we would have proposed our amendment in the form outlined by Deputy Mulcahy. It is the presence of Deputy Norton's amendment that makes that amended form necessary and I suggest that the Minister should withdraw his objection.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton's amendment has been before the House for some weeks and there was plenty of time for members of the Opposition to put in a further amendment, if they felt like it.
Comment on this
The Minister's acceptance of it is only a late idea. That is what makes the difference.
Comment on this
Can we get agreement to a discussion of No. 5 and No. 6 together, and to the taking of a decision on No. 5? That is the most generous way that I can see of discussing the matter at the moment.
Comment on this
Might I suggest a more generous way—taking a decision on No. 6, after discussing No. 5 and No. 6 together?
Comment on this
That obviously is impossible. A decision was taken on a certain matter—No. 5. That decision is noted, and clearly we cannot challenge that decision on No. 6, which if it were carried, would, perhaps, alter the decision taken on No. 5.
Comment on this
I agree that if a decision were taken on No. 5, and if it were in any way contrary to what might be taken on No. 6, No. 6 falls. That, I gather, is the ruling. I suggest, however, that it has been put to you, and put with a certain amount of force and argument, that No. 6 does surround a bigger principle than No. 5. It has at any rate been borne in on you by the argument of allowing the discussion to take place on No. 6 and No. 5 together. I suggest that the ruling ordinarily is that the amendment which is wider in scope is taken first, and the one more limited follows, and No. 6 is distinctly wider in its scope than No. 5.
Comment on this
A decision was taken which, as we say, has left a vaccum with regard to South Dublin constituency. I do not know if Deputy Norton is, as I might say, indissolubly married to his amendment, but if he is not—I am not trying to force his hand—and we decide on No. 6, for instance, that Dublin County as we have known it so far remains as Dublin County, then it will really be necessary for the Minister to bring in an amendment on Report Stage, and fill in the gap that has been left by the recent decision made in the Dáil, which might quite easily meet Deputy Norton. Unless Deputy Norton wants the amendment exactly in the form he has proposed it, I think if we decide on No. 6 to keep Dublin County as Dublin County, Deputy Norton would very largely be met. I do not know whether it matters very much to him whether Ringsend stays where it is in Dublin County, or whether he has some special point in having it included in South Dublin
Comment on this
Deputy Fitzgerald's suggestion, of course, is made for the purpose of enabling him to get a discussion on his own amendment, and to throw away the substance you have got in the acceptance of No. 5 for the shadow that you cannot even get on No. 6.
Comment on this
I suggest to Deputy Mulcahy that he can discuss the whole question of County Dublin on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
That is a matter for the Minister. So far as I am concerned I am willing to give the Deputy all the facilities he wants to discuss the question. Would it be possible, Sir, if Deputy Mulcahy does not move amendment 6, to permit him to discuss whatever is happening to County Dublin on Part I of the Schedule?
Comment on this
I should like to say that what would satisfy me in this matter is to accept amendment No. 5, if the Minister would agree that on Report Stage the matter of the present County Dublin constituency, and amendments in regard to it, will be dealt with in Committee on Report. By the ruling that has been given on this particular matter, the discussion on County Dublin would otherwise be forced completely out of Committee Stage, and I think that would be a very wrong thing. As I say, I would be prepared to accept No. 5 now if the Minister would agree to allow the County Dublin position to be discussed in Committee on Report.
Comment on this
I am as flexible as possible on whatever may be called a ruling. I have not introduced any rigidity. I should like to hear Deputy Mulcahy on what he suggests on amendment No. 6 as an ad hoc amendment now. We could then put No. 6 as an amended amendment.
Comment on this
I should like to support that idea. I do not think this House has ever allowed itself by a technicality to be shut off from both discussing and deciding by vote any general principle, and I should be very sorry if we made such a precedent now. There is a big principle involved in No. 6. Quite apart from any details, that principle is whether the County should be cut up into two constituencies or retained as one. I suggest that the Minister should withdraw his opposition. Assuming that No. 5 is carried, and Deputy Mulcahy moves his amendment in a form which refers to the County as modified by the acceptance of No. 5, we could discuss the principle of whether there is to be one constituency for the County or two. I certainly think that would save any grievance.
Comment on this
The amendment would read:—
In Part I to delete all reference to the constituency of "South Dublin" and in Part II to the constituency of "Dublin" and substitute therefor the following in Part II of the Schedule:—
"
DUBLIN COUNTY. | The Administrative County of Dublin and Borough Electoral Division Number Five of the County Borough of Dublin, other than the portion included in South Dublin. | Eight
"
Comment on this
If No. 5 is accepted I will certainly withdraw any opposition to having the amended amendment discussed on No. 6. I understood that No. 5 was to be accepted.
Comment on this
As the person primarily interested, and the person in whose name the amendment is put down, I should like to say that I do not wish to agree to any suggestion that will preclude a discussion on No. 5 on the one point I am interested in, namely, why Ringsend is being taken from the County and put into South City.
Comment on this
The Minister could cut matters much shorter if he would consent to get up and tell us that. He has several times been invited to do so.
Comment on this
Let us put up a straight question. Will you allow a discussion on amendment No. 5, a decision on amendment No. 5; then a discussion on amendment No. 6, as verbally amended by Deputy Mulcahy, and a decision on amendment No. 6, as verbally amended by Deputy Mulcahy? If that settlement could be arrived at we could get down to Ringsend without more ado.
Comment on this
The Minister, of course, has the right to object, but the Chair is entitled to accept an ad hoc amendment of this kind. I think the principle is sufficiently big. As Deputy Thrift said, no ruling creating a precedent has been given that would rule out discussion and decision on an amendment of such interest and importance as this. I think, therefore, that the Chair is quite entitled to accept Deputy Mulcahy's amendment, and allow a discussion and decision on No. 5 and on No. 6.
Comment on this
Might I again ask to be told by the Minister or anybody on the Government Benches the reason why Ringsend is being taken from County Dublin and put into the new constituency of South Dublin? I myself can see no reason for it. I want to know why the Minister is taking this step in regard to a matter which he has himself admitted earlier this afternoon to be a very important one. If it is such an important matter, surely there are important reasons for taking this step. We have not heard those reasons, or any of them, so far. I want to know if the Minister will tell us any of the reasons, or if anybody on his behalf will tell us any of the reasons, why Ringsend is being taken from County Dublin and put into South City.
Comment on this
If Deputy Costello were familiar with Ringsend, as, apparently, he is not, he would know that the locality, in its general nature, and the people of the locality in their occupations, are more closely associated with the people of the City of Dublin than with the people of the County.
Comment on this
The Minister, as usual, when he has no argument to advance, falls back upon suggestions that Deputies who make statements in this House do not know what they are talking about. That sort of argument leads nowhere, and merely emphasises the Minister's own lack of argument. I know Ringsend as well as the Minister does, and, I would say, very coniderably better. I happen to represent it in this House, and I want to know any reason other than my own ignorance of Ringsend—if my own ignorance of Ringsend were admitted—why Ringsend is being taken from County Dublin and put into the City.
Comment on this
Because there is much closer association between Ringsend and the City of Dublin than between Ringsend and the County of Dublin.
Comment on this
Because of the nature of the locality, the occupations of the people, and the general business in the locality.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed be therein inserted."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 6:—
In Part I to delete all reference to the constituency of "South Dublin" and in Part II to the constituency of "Dublin" and substitute therefore the following in Part II of the Schedule:—
DUBLIN COUNTY. | The Administrative County of Dublin and Borough Electoral Division Number Five of the County Borough of Dublin, other than the portion included in South Dublin. | Eight
Since Ringsend has been divorced from County Dublin, and by the act of the Minister married to Fitzwilliam Square, the heart is rather knocked out of me in moving this amendment. I find it a little difficult to understand the relations between Ringsend and Fitzwilliam Square, but the House has taken up that position; and in fact it has taken away the basis of the principle for which I had intended to speak, to-day—the integrity of the old constituency of County Dublin. That constituency has a population of something over 120,000 altogether. The effect of the proposal put forward by the Government is really to deprive the people of that constituency of a seat to which they are entitled on a population basis.
The general principle, as I understand it, is that there should be a member in the Dáil for every 20,000 voters. Under the arrangement proposed here and recently carried, there will be only eight members in the old constituency of County Dublin. Ringsend will be thrown into South Dublin and the population will be deprived of one member to which they are entitled on the basis of their numbers. That is the result of the proposal already carried. My proposal was that there should be nine members for this big constituency. There can be only eight now, even if this amendment is accepted. But the underlying principle is that even taking out the area of Ringsend the old County Dublin constituency should have been left as it stands in its representation. I can see no reason for the proposal contained in the Bill. For the Ministerial proposal to have a new constituency constituted of Pembroke and Rathmines there would be something to be said, if the proposal did not take a portion both of the Pembroke and Rathmines area, and put them into a new area, forming a new constituency consisting of Rathmines and a bit of Pembroke. There was some community of interest in the Pembroke area even between the workers. That is destroyed by the proposal now carried. I fail to see any basis for a constituency consisting of the area Pembroke and Rathmines, except it be for the purpose of creating a three-member constituency.
One of the outstanding features of this Bill, as has been pointed out, is the number of three-member constituencies created, no doubt in the hope that with proportional representation something will be saved out of the wreck. I can see no other reason for having a constituency consisting of a bit of Pembroke and Rathmines except that the Ministry hope to save one seat out of the wreckage. They know that in a big constituency like County Dublin they would be in danger of being worsted on the principle of proportional representation. They propose now to split up this constituency so that no independent representative will have any chance of getting elected. The constituency at present extends from the border of Wicklow to the County of Meath. It embraces very important rural areas and very important and considerably extended urban areas. It has always been found difficult, if not impossible, even under a system of proportional representation to get adequate representation for the farmers of North and South County Dublin. I see no advantage to the rural population in the Minister's proposal of having a new constituency commencing somewhere round about Merrion Gates and ending somewhere in Tallaght.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce on the last amendment spoke of community of interest but it would seem to me that if a person wanted to walk this new constituency he would have to start from Merrion Gates, go round by Killiney, and Dundrum, and skirt the city until he found himself in the North County. It is not possible to give the rural population proper and adequate representation, even, under proportional representation, but whatever chance they have it is where there is a big constituency, and not where there is a constituency consisting of Killiney, Dun Laoghaire, Garristown and the Naul. The principle underlying my proposal is that this constituency of County Dublin, even with the portion knocked off, is a constituency that could be easily worked. It is convenient from the point of view of its areas, running round the city. It is easily approachable. If ever there was a constituency in which the principle of proportional representation should be given full and adequate effect, it is that constituency. The variety of interests included can, I think, only get adequate representation by there being a very large voting power in it. We have workers, members of the Fianna Fáil Party, our own supporters and Independents in County Dublin. Under the proposal of the Minister—and there is no use burking the point—there will be no prospect of an Independent member being returned for the County Dublin. That will not cause me any particular alarm; but even if we are paying only lip service to the principles of proportional representation, the particular class of persons who vote independent and thus believe that by cohesion amongst their fellows they will be able to return one Deputy, ought to be considered. Under the proposal in the Bill, not merely are they not considered but the effect on them is going to be simply annihilation. The reason probably why this proposal is put forward is in order to keep Independent members out of the House. That will be the effect of changing the Co. Dublin constituency. There can be no room under the Ministry's proposal for any Independent representation in this House. That may not cause me any particular alarm but it is against the principle for which we have contended. While the constituency with Ringsend taken off, loses for me a considerable amount of the charm it had, still it should be left as an integral whole. The community of interest is so strong that it should be given free play by allowing as wide a field as possible.
Comment on this
The Minister, in making his apology for some aspects of this Bill, said that he thought the smaller constituencies gave greater advantage to the smaller parties. He did not pursue that. He did not attempt to elaborate it. I do not think that he meant it to be taken seriously. In explaining the difficulties of this Bill, he said that there existed a sort of county loyalty, a desire not to break up counties, on the one hand, while sometimes there was the need of having more or less proportional representation of Deputies per number of constituents. This constituency of Dublin County, from which Ringsend is now being lopped off, has existed for about twelve years. People have got used to it. I do not think that the Minister would attempt to argue that proportional representation operates in small constituencies. Here you have everything you want. You have a county which is also a very small county. Anybody living in Dublin can get to any part of this county in less than an hour. By having a big constituency, you give full play to proportional representation. You have county loyalty operating. It is a very big constituency, partly rural, partly urban and partly suburban. It is the constituency in which you have the most varied representation. At present, there is one Labour member. If this constituency be divided, it is pretty certain that that Labour member will go out. I am not going to pretend that I am much concerned about his staying in but, if we are to have this system of proportional representation. I am interested to see that it should work. If we are to have all the disadvantages of it, we should have whatever little advantage there is in it. This is a constituency in which the Independents have always been represented. There are more varying sections of the community in this constituency than in any other. You have what is called the ex-Unionist vote in the townships. You have the farming population on the north side and south side of the City—particularly, the north side. You have labour represented there. Labour is only represented there by virtue of the bigness of the constituency. I cannot see any argument for dividing this constituency. It is small and compact and it is easy for a representative to get to any part of it within an hour. Whatever may be said about three-member constituencies, it is perfectly clear to anybody who considers the matter that these three-member constituencies eliminate the proportional representation element. If ever there was a county in which a case could be made for having proportional representation operative it is this county. You have at present representing it Fianna Fáil Deputies, Fine Gael Deputies, Independent Deputies and Labour Deputies. So far as the big Parties are concerned, they try to have at least one of their members representative of the agricultural interest. If you divide this constituency up, you make it impossible for the farmers in the constituency to be represented. You, also, as Deputy Costello said, eliminate the Independent representation. The Labour representation will also be eliminated.
I admit that this dividing up is clearly in the interest of ourselves and of the Government Party. Personally, I think that, in a general way, it is the Parties that are likely to form the Government that really matter. But here is a constituency which is peculiar, inasmuch as you have in it all these different sections of the community who have a right to be represented. The same situation does not exist in any other constituency here of which I know. I do not know whether the Government has any objection to accepting this amendment. I do not see why they should. All through this Bill, they have aimed at smaller constituencies and I am ready to admit that, from a Party point of view, that is in our interest. But if there is going to be smaller constituencies, the present system should be abolished, because, with these changes, you are going—pre-eminently in this constituency—to eliminate representation of minorities so far as one can judge from what has happened in the past. You are going to do that and you achieve nothing by it. This constituency is not like Galway, where there was an enormous distance between one part of the county and the other. It is a remarkably compact constituency and I should like to know if the Government has any objection to accepting this amendment.
Comment on this
Deputy Costello addressed himself to the amendment he intended to move rather than to the amendment he actually did move. As I understand it, we are now discussing a proposal to combine in one constituency the two areas described in the Bill as South Dublin and Dublin County, that one constituency to have a representation of eight members. Deputies allow themselves to be hypnotised by the fact that the old constituency was called County Dublin. In fact, a large part of it was not in the County Dublin but in the City of Dublin. The proposal in the Bill is to take that portion which is in the City of Dublin and make it a separate constituency, leaving as the constituency of County Dublin what is, in fact, the County of Dublin. The new constituency of the County of Dublin, with five members, will be the administrative County of Dublin. It will have added to it only a very small part of the area recently added to the City. That has been left in the County Dublin constituency for no other reason than that its transfer to the City would involve a considerable alteration in the representation of each area. The main scheme is to leave the County of Dublin one constituency and to form another constituency of portion of the City of Dublin which was formerly attached to the County Dublin constituency. The case for that seems obvious, apart from general considerations in favour of small constituencies. It is obviously desirable that the County of Dublin should have separate representation. Deputy Fitzgerald made a most extraordinary case. He argued that the present constituency secures representation for minority interests and he mentioned particularly labour and farming. Who is the farmers' representative for County Dublin? Can the Deputy name him?
Comment on this
He is the type of farmers' representative that Deputy Fitzgerald wants to have elected.
Comment on this
The Deputy argues in favour of the existing constituency because he knows quite well that, so long as that is maintained, no other type of farmers' representative can be elected. Who is the Labour representative for County Dublin?
Comment on this
Labour has no representative in the County Dublin. It is because Deputy Fitzgerald knows that quite well that he is arguing for the maintenance of the existing constituency.
Comment on this
The change is going to ensure that both farmers and workers will have a much better prospect of securing representation in the County Dublin than they have at present. Of course, it is obvious that they will. Here is a constituency, partly urban and partly rural. How do you decrease the prospect of the rural population getting representation by taking out of it an area which is entirely urban? Of course, you do not. By taking out an urban area and putting it into a separate constituency, you increase the prospect of the rural population securing a representative from amongst their numbers. They have not been able to do it up to the present. It is only farmers like Deputy Costello who have been able to get elected up to the present. A genuine farmer, who works his land, could not get elected, because he was up against this fact: that in order to get elected he had to secure urban votes, and the prospect of his getting them was very slight indeed. It seems to me that the proposal in the Bill is not merely justifiable in itself, but represents a considerable improvement on the existing position. Henceforth, there will be two constituencies: one largely a rural constituency—although I will admit that there are urbanised portions in it— but it represents the administrative County of Dublin in which the rural population will have a much better chance of securing representation than they have at present; and the other, an entirely urban area, not in the County Dublin but in the City of Dublin, which henceforth will be a separate borough constituency. The Electoral Abuses Act provides for various matters relating to election expenses. There is a different scale in borough areas to that which obtains in county areas. Pembroke is obviously a borough area and the portion of the Act relating to boroughs will apply to it and not the portion of the Act relating to county areas.
Comment on this
The Minister's argument seems to me to be very peculiar. He knows the way the law is that there is one representative for a number over 20,000 or less than 30,000 of the population. The population is very mixed in this constituency. He says that if you take the whole borough —a big constituency with a population, say, of 100,000—the rural population in it are unable to get representation, but that by removing a certain amount of the town population and some of the rural population they are likely to get representation.
Comment on this
I am just speaking of the place as I know it. There is one Deputy per 20,000 or less than 30,000 of the population. Take the whole thing together and say there is a population of 100,000 or 118,000. The Minister's argument is, that if every agriculturally interested person in that constituency votes, he is not going to get one Deputy elected: that is to say, one to represent the proportion of 20,000 of the population. But he went on to say that if you remove a certain amount, then you are going to get a farmer elected. I simply cannot see that.
Comment on this
That is not quite correct. My statement was quite the contrary to what the Deputy has just said. I said that there is no farmer at present in the representation of the County Dublin, and that you increase the farmers' chance of getting a farmer elected by taking out of that constituency an entirely urban vote.
Comment on this
I do not see that you do. Take the position at present in this Dáil. There is no Labour member for that constituency. There have been Labour members for the County Dublin. The position varies a bit from election to election, because Labour is only on the border line of that constituency, as it was after eight Deputies had been elected for it. The Minister's system then is going to be not on the border line but to eliminate the thing altogether. He says that at this moment there is no man who, in his daily life is occupied in agriculture, is a Deputy for that particular constituency. That is true. But that position also varies from time to time. Since this Dáil was established there was one Deputy, if I remember rightly, who, on one occasion, belonged to the Farmers' Party. Speaking from memory, he was also elected on other occasions. There have been men elected for that constituency who, because of their occupation, may be said to be representatives of the farming industry there.
As I have said, the population in County Dublin is very mixed. You have over large areas of it what you might call urban people living almost next door to farmers. The Minister says that by taking out the urban population you are going to give a better opportunity for an agricultural representative to be elected. Now that is clearly untrue. At present there are eight Deputies elected for that constituency. There were eight quotas. The farmers' representative had only to get a proportion of these eight quotas to get elected. Now you are only going to give him the opportunity of getting in the one case three, and in the other case, five. It seems to me quite clear that what is proposed in the Bill is not going conceivably and inevitably to add to the number of agricultural votes that ordinarily would be cast in either of these constituencies for the election of a farmer. The Minister's argument is absolutely devoid of substance. There are going to be no agricultural votes eliminated by accepting this amendment. At the moment there are some agriculturally interested people in the one constituency and, perhaps, some in the other. It may well be that neither of these constituencies will have enough to elect a representative of that interest, but putting the two together it is possible that you may have enough to elect a representative of it. The Minister's argument on that point is absolutely unsustainable, because it is clear that instead of taking any away you will, by accepting this amendment, be adding to the number of agricultural votes in this constituency.
By refusing it, all you can possibly do is, either to leave it as it was or to take from these agricultural votes. There is no substance whatever in the Minister's arguments. He says that at the moment no person who gets a living out of agriculture has a representative of that constituency here, and that no representative of Labour in that constituency is here. That is quite true. But that is the result of the last election. At previous elections we had representatives of the farmers and of Labour. It is possible, and it has been demonstrated historically, to have those interested represented. With a change I maintain that it is either going to be impossible to have them represented—I think that is clear—or, if not impossible, it is less possible than heretofore. I think the Minister's arguments have no substance whatever.
Comment on this
The only thing I can say to the Deputy is that the area it is proposed to include in the proposed constituency is entirely urbanised and is under the administration of the City of Dublin.
Comment on this
That does not prove it. In the administrative area of the City of Dublin there were, even before Greater Dublin was created, agricultural people living within the area of the city. That area is an administrative thing. It is arbitrarily a legal thing. You do not have a boundary put just around the streets. It always includes parts of the country or does not include the whole town parts. The Minister confuses two things, the fact that urban and rural areas are arbitrarily and legally in the administration area of the City of Dublin.
Comment on this
Amendment put.
Do you agree with this result?
Amendment No. 7 falls, since the House has decided that the words "South Dublin" stand.
Comment on this
We have already accepted amendment No. 5. The description in the Schedule is "South Dublin," and there is another "South Dublin" here now.
Comment on this
And I suggest that matter could best be rectified on Report. An amendment on Report Stage would be more satisfactory than informal discussion now.
Amendments Nos. 8, 9 and 10.
Amendment No. 8.—In Part II to delete all references to the constituency of "Meath-Westmeath," page 5, and of "Athlone-Longford," page 6. and of "Roscommon," page 6, and substitute the following:—
"
LONGFORD-WESTMEATH. | The Administrative counties of Longford and Westmeath. | Four
MEATH | The Administrative County of Meath | Three
ROSCOMMON | The Administrative County of Roscommon | Four
"
(Mícheál Ó Braonáin.)
Amendment No. 9.—In Part II to delete all reference to the constituency of "Meath-Westmeath" and substitute therefor the following:—
"
MEATH | The Administrative County of Meath | Three
"
(Robert E. Davitt).
Amendment No. 10.—In Part II to delete the references to the constituencies of "Athlone-Longford" and "Meath-Westmeath" and substitute therefor the following.
"
LONGFORD-WESTMEATH. | The Administrative County of Longford and the Administrative County of Westmeath. | Four
"
(Charles Fagan; Seán MacEoin.)
Comment on this
In the regretted absence of Deputy Brennan, through illness, I wish to move amendment No. 8, standing in his name. That amendment, together with amendments Nos. 9 and 10, affects the four counties, and the three constituencies of Longford-Westmeath, Meath and Roscommon. On the population basis there was no need to make any change in the County Meath, nor to make any change in the County Roscommon. A change had to be made in the representation of Longford-Westmeath because the population in that constituency is no longer entitled to five members. But the only change that was necessary, and the simplest change that could have been made, would have been to reduce the representation of Longford-Westmeath from five to four Deputies. That would not have been a very drastic reduction. It would still have left Longford-Westmeath with one Deputy for every 24,100 persons. It is true that that would give rather more persons to each Deputy than in other counties. Nevertheless, the Constitution has provided for that possibility. The Constitution provided that the figures should be between 20,000 and 30,000. If a constituency has any figure, for each Deputy, between these two it has no right to complain so long as that arises from the natural course of things out of the general electoral law as it stood.
But what the Government are proposing to do in this Bill with reference to these counties is hardly natural. County Meath is a three-member constituency and three-member constituencies are especially dear to the Government. They have sought to create as many of them as possible, so that even from their own point of view there is no case for interfering with the County Meath on the merits. In Longford-Westmeath there had to be a change but the obvious change was the simple one of reducing the representation from five to four. There remains Roscommon, and I venture to think that on examination in County Roscommon we find the solution of the eccentric course that the Government followed. Roscommon returned four members to this House. On its population it is fully entitled to return four members to this House. Moreover, the County Roscommon in, I think, the last four general elections returned two Fianna Fáil Deputies, one Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy and one Independent. So that constituency is not behaving in the manner that justifies the common accusation against four-member constituencies of always resulting in a dead heat aid having two Deputies belonging to one Party and two belonging to another Party. It so happens that an event since the last general election has resulted in the fact that two Deputies now belong to one Party and two to another Party but the constituency has rather the tradition of favouring Independent members. Now, what are the Government proposing to do to it? They are proposing to cut off the southern section of the county and hand it over to a new constituency called Athlone-Longford. In doing that they are not only inflicting an injury on the County Roscommon, but on the province of Connaught. They are handing over a piece of Connaught to Leinster, just as in the case of Galway they are handing over a piece of Connaught to Munster. Under this Bill the province of Connaught has fared particularly badly. It is being reduced from a representation of 29 to a representation of 24. On the population basis according to the last census, Connaught is entitled to 27 members. It is being defrauded of the membership to which it is entitled as a province by the fact that a section of it is being handed over to Munster and another section is being handed over to Leinster.
Returning to the particular grievance of County Roscommon, the County Council there has twice considered the subject of this Bill as affecting the county and it has passed two resolutions strongly protesting against what is being done. On the first occasion the resolution was unanimous. On the second occasion there was only one dissentient. I think Deputy Brennan was in the Chair on the first occasion. On the second occasion Deputy Brennan was absent, ill, so that the question of his personal influence can be eliminated. The County Council of Roscommon is by no means a body that can be regarded as partisan in the sense of being favourable to the cause of the Opposition and feeling about the dismemberment of the county is the same among all sections of political opinion, with the exception of the one councillor on the second occasion. That councillor is a lady and, I think, the fact, that there was that single exception is merely evidence of the tendency of the female sex to be more partisan than anybody else.
No other county in the Free State is being treated quite as badly as Roscommon is under this Bill. You have a situation where Roscommon is perfectly entitled to retain the representation that it has at present. In spite of that a piece of it is being taken away and is being given to another constituency. In taking that piece away the representation of Roscommon is reduced to three and in reducing it to three you are actually putting the Roscommon elector in a worse position than an elector in any other county. It is going to take more people in County Roscommon to elect a Deputy than it will do in any other county in Ireland and that is something that has not arisen just naturally by the mere operation of the Constitution. If it arose in that way one could not object to it. It has arisen because of the deliberate act of the Government in doing something quite unnecessary and unnatural.
Under this amendment I am proposing that Roscommon and Meath be left as they are, that the change made should be limited to the simple and natural one of reducing the representation of Longford-Westmeath from five to four. I hope very much that the Government will see their way to accept this amendment. The new constituency which they are proposing to create of Athlone-Longford is a very eccentric one. Longford County is made to penetrate into Westmeath and then to turn around and penetrate into Roscommon. As I said on the Second Reading debate, the resulting constituency is the sort of constituency that originally gave rise to the expression "gerrymandering," and it was, in fact, referred to by a Deputy in this House as Gerry-Bolandering.
Comment on this
I will say nothing more on this at the moment, because I hope the Minister will relent and allow Roscommon to remain as it is. If he puts forward any arguments that are capable of discussion, I shall discuss them.
Comment on this
Deputies interested in amendments Nos. 9 and 10 may, if they desire, speak on amendment No. 8, since the decision on amendment No. 8 will govern the other two. On No. 8 I shall put the question: "That the words proposed to be deleted, stand"; and if that is affirmed, Meath-Westmeath, Athlone-Longford and Roscommon stand, and it will not be possible to have a separate constituency of Meath. It will also have been decided that there will be a constituency of Athlone-Longford, including Longford, parts of Roscommon and Westmeath; Longford-Westmeath cannot, therefore, be joined as proposed in No. 10.
Comment on this
In supporting this amendment, which aims at leaving Meath a three-seat constituency as at present, I wish to state that from my personal point of view it does not matter very much to me whether the representation is changed from a three to a five-seat constituency. I think the three constituencies must be taken together, and there seems to be an undoubted injustice to Roscommon under the Government plan. Deputy MacDermot has set out the mutilation that the Government propose and he has emphasised that it will not effect any change for the better. I cannot see why it is necessary for the Government to adopt such a complicated change when a much simpler one would achieve the same reduction of seats. If No. 8 is accepted it will leave Meath with its normal natural boundaries; it will leave Roscommon in a similar position, and it will leave Longford and Westmeath in a position that will not necessitate mutilation. Instead of a five-seat and two three-seat constituencies, we shall get two four-seat constituencies and one three-seat constituency.
The population of Meath is 62,969. We suggest the retention there of a three-seat constituency, which will mean one seat for every 20,990 of the people, conforming, therefore, to the Constitution. The population of Roscommon is 83,556. We suggest four seats there, which will mean a seat for every 20,889 of the people, which will also conform to the Constitution. The population of Longford-Westmeath is 96,665. If there are four seats, that means one seat for 24,166 people, or a little more. There are more people to be represented by one seat in that case than in the case of Roscommon or Meath, but if we are to compare that with the Government's conception we see that, according to their idea, they do not leave any of the counties with a normal boundary. They are all mutilated. Meath is mutilated, and Roscommon is mutilated and part of it given to the Longford-Athlone constituency, while part of Westmeath is added to the Longford-Athlone constituency. Under the Government plan, in that constituency, on the basis of population, three seats mean one seat for each 21,000—practically the same as the present situation with regard to Meath where there is one seat for 21,000 people.
The population of the new Roscommon constituency is reduced to 71,348. The three seats suggested by the Government for that constituency result in one seat for every 23,782 people. In the Government plan also, there is a difference in the number of people that are called upon to fill one seat. In the case of Roscommon there are a greater number of people under the Government plan than in the case of Athlone-Longford or Meath-Westmeath; and the new Meath-Westmeath constituency, under the Government plan, will have a population of 105,890. It will be the biggest of all. Five members are suggested for that constituency, which means one seat for 21,178 people. Figures, at any time, are a very boring thing to read, but if one compares the two suggestions there seems to be absolutely no reason why the Government plan should be adopted, from a numerical point of view, as against the amendment moved by Deputy MacDermot; and, in addition, by accepting the amendment moved by Deputy MacDermot, there will be no mutilation of counties at all. Therefore, why mutilate counties when you are gaining nothing at all?
From the point of view of Meath, we we are going to be changed into a five seat constituency. I have heard the Minister suggest here that he is against the idea of large constituencies. As a matter of fact he said that to-day. Now, it is far harder for a Deputy to keep in touch with a constituency which has a large area than with a constituency which, although having a big population, is comprised within a small area. The suggested new constituency for Meath-Westmeath, however, will stretch from the Irish Sea to very near the Shannon and, in spite of the handsome and rounded appearance of Meath at present—at least it has not the ugly and constricted hour-glass appearance of Leitrim or the appearance of Cavan which has a long tail up to Fermanagh, whereas there is a fairly equal distance from a central point in Meath, such as Navan, to the borders of the county— we are now going to have the constituency stretching from the Irish Sea almost to the Shannon. I do not know what will happen to Deputy Kelly when he has to set out from, say, Duleek down to Moate. It will be very expensive certainly, I suggest, both for Deputy Kelly and myself. As I say, we will probably have to pool our resources and travel together.
Comment on this
Yes, and the same kind of thing will happen in the case of Deputies in similarly mutilated constituencies. Speaking seriously, however, the new constituency has a very ugly appearance, and, as I have said, it stretches half across Ireland—it is, roughly, about 80 miles, as the crow flies, from the mouth of the Boyne to, say, Moate, which is the extreme southwest corner of the proposed new constituency. Of course the point might be made that a five-seat constituency is more ideal, from the point of view of proportional representation, than a three-seat constituency. Listening to the different arguments on this Bill, one finds that on one occasion the Minister will use one argument to suit him, and on another occasion he goes in the opposite direction. I suppose that could be said, to a large extent, about all speakers on this Bill. I propose that the administrative County of Meath should be left with a three-seat constituency. Of course, we have heard that such constituencies are undesirable under proportional representation, and it has been stated and held, and it is the belief of a majority of our Party, that that is so. It may appear anomalous, accordingly, for me to be supporting a three-seat constituency, but I am doing that because it is the lesser of two evils. Under the Government plan there will be mutilation of counties, whereas there will be no mutilation of counties under this scheme. Under the Government scheme, Roscommon is being very badly treated, and is being mutilated as well, and Westmeath is being mutilated and joined up with Meath. As regards the question of local administration, I do not want to say anything about it because Deputy Kelly is here, and he is a member of the Council, and can give us his views on that. I do not see what point has been made or can be made for this suggested change. I hold that you can get the same reduction of seats by adopting the same plan as is embodied in this amendment. By adopting it, you do not offend local county patriotism, and you achieve exactly the same result. If you go through the numbers of populations, you can see that there is nothing to be gained by the Government plan. Accordingly, I should like to hear what excuse the Minister has to offer for the serious mutilation he proposes to effect, as contained in this Bill.
Comment on this
What is proposed in the Bill with regard to the constituency under discussion has arisen because of the decrease in population in some counties. There had to be a rearrangement somewhere, and, as I said earlier on other amendments, portions of county boundaries had to be violated in some cases in order to arrange for suitable populations for other areas. In some cases, where there was a surplus, a portion had to be taken in order to try to regulate, in accordance with the provisions laid down by the Constitution, the numbers required for other areas. It is regrettable that Roscommon has suffered, but it has not suffered more than some other counties. Take the case of County Carlow. I am sure I will hear a great deal about it as the debate goes on. I have heard a lot about it already and, as I say, probably will hear more during this debate, but that county has suffered to a much greater extent. I have mentioned all along that the smaller constituency of three members gives a better result than the large constituency. I would much rather have a three-member constituency than a four-member one, because we know the difficulties in the constituency of four members. An even number, whether it be four or six or eight, creates greater difficulties than would an odd-number constituency.
Comment on this
It has a very considerable interest to the country. The country might be kept in a state of turmoil for a very long time if whatever Government was elected could not have a majority. If you had a majority of even-number constituencies that result might follow with very serious consequences for the country. Therefore, it is desirable, whatever the number be, that the odd-number constituencies should be in the majority. It does not necessarily follow, I admit, that if you have even-number constituencies even numbers will be elected by the electorate, but you would help in that direction by having even-number constituencies, and it is better not to run that risk. Therefore, I would much rather have three three-member constituencies than two four-member constituencies.
It is not correct to say that we have inflicted injury on the province of Connaught. The population of Connaught had diminished between 1910 and 1926 and several counties were bound to lose members. As Deputy MacDermot properly stated, we did take an area off County Galway and put it on to County Clare and we have likewise taken a certain area from Roscommon and added it on to Longford. In doing that with regard to Roscommon we have gone back to a certain extent to what was usual, so far as local government was concerned, in days gone by, when Athlone, as a union, went to a very considerable extent, almost to the same extent as we have gone, into the County Roscommon, and the people of that area have had the habit for a great number of years, and continue to have the habit, of using Athlone as their market town. In any inquiries I have made I have been told that there is no resentment in the minds of the people in that area at what we have done. I know it is true the Roscommon County Council passed a resolution against what they called the mutilation of the county. I have, however, made inquiries from people whom I believe can speak for the area and they tell me that the people they have consulted have told them that there is not any considerable resentment. In some areas they said they have gone further and stated that they were quite happy at the thought that they have been restored to the old habit of going into Athlone to vote as well as going in there to market.
The population of the province of Connaught at present is 552,907 and, if you take an average of 22,000 of a population per member, that would give a membership of 25 to the province. Therefore, I think it can be shown that any reduction in the numbers is due to a reduction in the population, and not to any effort on the Government's part to deprive the province of Connaught, any more than any other province, of the number of Deputies that, by population, it is properly entitled to. It is true, as Deputy MacDermot said, that in the proposed arrangement with regard to Roscommon, it does require 23,786 of a population to elect a Deputy. The average number is 22,783, but there is not very much difference between that and some other counties. In Kilkenny, for instance, it is 23,663; in South Tipperary, 23,637; and in North-East Limerick, 23,498. There is not very much difference between what Roscommon requires and what is required by at least three other counties. One or two others go fairly near it. In South-East Cork, for instance, it is 23,585. So that it can be called fairly average, although, strictly speaking, it is true that it is the highest average required.
I cannot see that any injury has been done to Meath, Westmeath, Roscommon or Longford by the proposal made. If we go back to historical precedents, as Deputy MacDermot was anxious to go back when discussing the Bill on Second Reading, we find that Meath and Westmeath were one at one time and were called the Royal Province of Meath. Both Meath and Westmeath are very largely composed of rural areas. They have the same type of people and the same type of industries—they are very largely agricultural areas. I think it is quite proper to associate two counties of that kind. As long as we have to associate counties and areas in trying to get a proper proportion, those two counties can very well go together. The same thing would apply to Athlone and the district of Longford that is associated with it. I cannot see that anything that can raise serious complaint has been done to any of the counties concerned, and I certainly think that in the smaller constituencies we are likely to get better representation than in the larger constituencies. I do not want to labour that point, as I have spoken several times on it already. As I said, the areas of Meath and Westmeath are similar in type. The same can be said of Athlone and Longford. Roscommon is not being deprived of any member that it is entitled to. On the contrary, if we take each of these counties separately, on the present figures, there would be a very big disparity between the populations of Meath with 62,000, Westmeath with 56,000, and Roscommon with 83,000. If we did what the amendment suggests a very big disparity would arise and we would be obliging some counties to pay much more dearly than others for the members to be elected. We would be departing to a very considerable extent from the principle laid down in the Constitution which we have endeavoured to follow. Not alone must we keep between the limits of 20,000 and 30,000 per member, but, as far as can be possibly done, we must have an average number per Deputy. I do not know whether the word "identical" is used in the Constitution, but it must be as close as possible. The word "identical" is used, I think, in the Constitution.
Comment on this
The remarks of the Minister make it very difficult to believe that the arrangement of these counties proposed in the Bill has been arrived at on account of any other considerations except electoral considerations. That those electoral considerations are there, there is no doubt at all, because it has been the subject of acute anguish to Fianna Fáil organisers in County Roscommon for years past that they have not been able to do better than to secure two out of the four members for the county. I believe that the persons who have informed the Minister that there is no resentment in County Roscommon are ardent Fianna Fáil partisans, who wish to see this thing done because they resent so much seeing two members returned for the county who are opposed to them.
The Minister says that no injury has been done to the province of Connaught. That statement of his seems to me to have absolutely no meaning. Connaught used to have 29 members. It has declined in population and the most it could now be entitled to would be 27 members. Under this Bill, it is to get only 24 members. If the Government had not interfered with County Galway, as they have done, by giving a bit to Clare, and if they had not interfered with County Roscommon, as they have done, by giving a bit to Athlone-Longford, Connaught would have 26 members. Therefore, to put the case at its lowest, the Government have reduced the representation of Connaught quite unnecessarily from 26 to 24 members. So much for Connaught.
As regards these counties affected by this particular amendment, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, speaking on the Second Reading of this Bill, admitted that it was the sort of Bill where Party organisers might exercise an undesirable influence, and he said that the Government was so determined to avoid that kind of thing that they had fixed on certain basic principles and from these basic principles they were not going to be induced to depart in deciding on the new alignment of constituencies. These principles were, firstly, reduction of the number of Deputies; secondly, the preservation of county boundaries as far as possible; and, thirdly, the abolition of unduly large constituencies. As regards the reduction of the number of Deputies, there is no difference between the Government proposal and ours as to the number of Deputies to represent the area affected. Therefore, that particular point does not come in. As regards the preservation of county boundaries, the second fundamental principle in the Bill, our amendment honours that principle, while the Government proposal departs from it, departs from it flagrantly and departs from it as affecting, not one county, but two or three. The third principle is the abolition of unduly large constituencies. Under our proposal, where is the unduly large constituency? Neither Roscommon would be an unduly large constituency nor Longford-Westmeath, nor Meath, but it is now proposed to make Meath and Westmeath one constituency and there is considerably more case for saying that that is unwieldy and difficult to manage than any of the areas proposed in our amendment. Consequently, the Government are clearly convicted in this matter of having departed from what they have alleged to be their own fundamental principles.
Why have they done it? I say they have done it for electoral reasons. I am not going to suggest that the Minister for Local Government himself has done it for electoral reasons. I will assume everything in his favour, but I do say that the people who have urged this arrangement on him must have been influenced by electoral reasons and that all those who are familiar with conditions in County Roscommon are convinced that they were influenced by electoral reasons and that that is why this arrangement has been introduced.
As regards the number of inhabitants that would be required to return a member for Longford-Westmeath being high, if our amendment were accepted, I admit that, but it is not very much higher than the number required in Roscommon, if the Government's arrangement is accepted and there is this great difference, that the one grievance, if it can be called a grievance, would have grown out of the county's own situation and development; it would have arisen, naturally, whereas, under the Bill, the grievance is going to arise from the direct act of the Government and one county is being made to suffer because of another county's declining population. I press on the Minister, once again, that there is no respectable reason, no defensible ground, for the arrangement of constituencies proposed in this Bill in relation to these counties and I ask him to get back to the fundamental principles of his own Bill, as they were so forcibly expounded here by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and to accept the amendment standing in Deputy Brennan's name.
Comment on this
The Minister, in his reply, made no case whatever, I thought, in defence of the Government's suggestions, except the point that he, personally, was against four-seat constituencies and that, therefore, since our proposal creates two four-seat constituencies, he was prepared, in order to defeat that idea, to go ahead with all this cutting up of counties. If we examine the Bill, which he has presented to the Dáil, we will see that there are nine four-seat constituencies suggested, and in the discussion which took place with regard to the South Dublin constituency we had it shown that the Government were deliberately getting rid of the seven-seat constituency, which is probably the ideal constituency for proportional representation, and substituting for it a four-seat and a three-seat constituency. I suggest that that is a case in which the Minister was deliberately creating a four-seat constituency which we could easily have avoided.
He says he likes a three-seat constituency. We have one already in Meath and why not leave it that way? If he does leave it as it is, although our suggestion creates two four-seat constituencies, it does not lead definitely to this mutilation of counties and the setting up of a huge constituency such as the new Westmeath and Meath constituency will be, with 105,000 inhabitants, and it is not so much a matter of the inhabitants but of the widespread area and the awkward nature of the constituency. I followed the Minister closely and I could not see that he was making any case at all, except in so far as he said that he did not like four-seat constituencies, and that, in this particular case, he did not want to introduce that arrangement, although, taking the Bill as a whole, he has introduced nine four-seat constituencies.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 11:—
In Part II to delete all references to the constituencies of "Sligo" and "Leitrim" and substitute therefor the following:—
LEITRIM— SLIGO. | The Administrative County of Leitrim and the Administrative County of Sligo. | Six
If the Minister for Industry and Commerce were to be taken literally in his statement that the one consideration that weighed with the Government in the preparation of this Bill was the preservation of the county boundaries, Sligo is an outstanding example of where that consideration has not been observed. Apart altogether from the desire of the Minister to observe, as he alleges, the county boundaries, the boundaries of Sligo are formed by a chain of mountains which run from one end of the county to the other. Notwithstanding that fact, the Minister proposes in this Bill to transfer portions of the county across that chain of mountains into the neighbouring County Leitrim. I noticed, on looking up the figures relating to the population of Sligo, that according to the census of 1926, Sligo is entitled to three representatives. In fact, Sligo is entitled to slightly more than three representatives. I should like to know from the Minister why in these circumstances he has thought fit and proper to transfer 5,000 electors from County Sligo across the Arigna Mountains into County Leitrim? I know that the Minister in the course of the discussion tried to make clear and plain to the House that in his preparation of the Bill he was not animated by any political motives, but it is an extraordinary coincidence that the areas which he proposes to transfer across the chain of mountains into County Leitrim are areas where his Party certainly did not receive very much support.
I admit that this rearrangement of the county will possibly help his Party. Certainly it will help one Deputy in his Party, but I doubt if it will help another Deputy in his Party. So far as I can understand the latter Deputy is as strongly opposed to this rearrangement of the constituency as I am myself. If the Minister will look at the map for a few minutes and study the proposed rearrangement of the county I think he will appreciate that it is, on the face of it, a very absurd rearrangement. He starts at one end of the county, cuts off a slice of it and transfers it across the mountains into County Leitrim. Then he stops, proceeds a little further and the chopping process begins again. Along the whole chain of mountains, until he reaches the end of the county, he transfers quite big areas into the neighbouring county. I could understand that proposal if there was any affiliation or any sort of common sentiment between the areas which it is proposed to transfer from County Sligo and the neighbouring county of Leitrim. As a matter of fact, there is no affiliation of sentiment, business or anything else, between the people in these districts and the people of County Leitrim. If the Minister, when making this arrangement, were animated by a desire to align together people with some sort of common interest, he should have transferred these areas into County Roscommon, because it is in towns like Ballyfarnon and Boyle that the people of Kilmactranny, Geevagh and the adjoining districts do their business, and not in County Leitrim.
My proposal is that the alliance of Sligo and Leitrim as one constituency should continue and that the Minister should drop the mutilation of the county which appears in this Bill. The Minister mentioned in his reply to Deputy MacDermot regarding the rearrangement of County Westmeath, Longford and Roscommon that he was animated by motives of economy, but I cannot, for the life of me, see how this rearrangement in Sligo is going to effect any economy. In fact, I am satisfied from my knowledge of the county that this rearrangement will mean increased expenditure in the county. It will mean that when the elections come along you will have two separate staffs instead of the single staff which performed the work heretofore. My proposal, as embodied in this amendment, is that Sligo-Leitrim should be left as it is, one constituency, with one seat less than heretofore. In other words, instead of the seven seats which Sligo-Leitrim has at present in future that we shall have six. I think that is a sensible arrangement. That is a much better arrangement, a much more satisfactory arrangement and a much more economical arrangement from the administrative point of view, than the arrangement proposed in the Bill.
Another absurd thing about the Bill is that it is proposed to transfer an island situated about eight miles out in the Atlantic, into County Leitrim. There are several islands to be transferred but one is a very important island. I was wondering whether the Minister when he was arranging the County Sligo took that fact into consideration at all. In the course of the Second Reading when I was dealing with the peculiar situation of Sligo-Leitrim. I was under the impression that I rather impressed the Minister with the fact that it was a constituency that deserved special consideration. At least, I gleaned that impression from the Minister's attitude and I am hopeful that, in view of the opportunity he has had since to study the conditions of that constituency more fully, he will agree that the amendment is a reasonable one. I hope he will see his way to accept the amendment and allow Sligo-Leitrim to remain as it is, a single constituency with six members instead of seven.
Comment on this
I desire to support the amendment. I think it is very unfair on the part of the Minister to take this slice off Sligo and put it into County Leitrim. It means practically disfranchising 5,000 electors. If the people of the different electoral divisions which it is proposed to transfer—Ballintogher East, Ballinakill, Ballynashee, Cliffony North, Cliffony South, Drumcolumb, Killadoon, Kilmactranny, Rossinver East and Shancough—want to make representations to one of their representatives in the Dáil in future, they will have to go miles into County Leitrim to meet their representatives there. I think it is very unfair, therefore, to cut this slice off Sligo and put it into Leitrim. The Minister should adopt the suggestion which Deputy Roddy has put before the House, that is, to give three seats to Sligo and three to Leitrim and allow the constituency to stand as it is at present. We have two members representing these areas on Sligo County Council and they are also represented on the Board of Health. You will, therefore, have representatives from these areas operating in County Sligo. I would strongly urge on the Minister to agree to the amendment now before the House with regard to this constituency.
Comment on this
I think the arrangement in the Bill proposed for Leitrim-Sligo is obviously within the set of principles that we initiated, and have tried to keep to in rearranging the constituency. I argued at the time of Second Reading, and again on the various amendments, in favour of smaller constituencies. It happens that these two counties of Leitrim and Sligo were associated for a considerable time. In my thinking—I travelled through the constituency a few times during general elections—it was a very unwieldy constituency—one of the most unwieldy in the country. I cannot say how far it has been the custom to associate the two counties together, but I cannot see any reason for allowing that to continue. It is true that a small area of Sligo is taken over to provide Leitrim county, which has only 55,900 of a population, with the necessary numbers to enable it to have a population of the required size for three members. I am not nearly as well acquainted, as either of the Deputies who have spoken with that area, but I assure Deputies this much: I, personally, do not know the area; I had it examined by persons who had no political bias in the matter. We decided it was necessary to take off some area. The Deputy is quite right in saying there are people in my own Party, as there are in his Party, who object to a slice being taken, for political reasons and for reasons of convenience. But it was suggested by us for no political motives. I have not the slightest idea, until I heard to-night, what the political opinions of the people in that area are. It is an area contiguous to the County of Leitrim.
When taking out an area we have to get an area that will suit for electoral purposes. You cannot easily divide electoral areas. We have to remember what the custom of the people is in going to vote in certain areas. Taking all these matters into account, I accepted the recommendation made, that if the making of a cut of any kind was necessary to provide Leitrim with the necessary number of members, the best that could be done was done in the area that was taken. I believe two three-member constituencies will give better results, from the point of view of proportional representation and from the point of view of the country in general, than continuing the practice that exists in Leitrim-Sligo at present and in the past. I do not think that is to be recommended. I think experience will show that the results from smaller constituencies will be better for the country as a whole.
Comment on this
The Minister has said that under this proposal he adheres strictly to the principles that were laid down to guide him. I assume he referred to the principle very explicitly acknowledged by the Minister for Industry and Commerce (1) the reduction of members; (2) the preservation of the county boundaries, and (3) the abolition of unduly large constituencies. The amendment here would make the reduction in the number of Deputies quite as effective as the Minister's proposal. If the Minister's proposal is accepted it not only separates Leitrim from Sligo, but it mutilates the County of Sligo. The mutilation of the history of counties is highly undesirable. The County Sligo has boundaries with which I am fairly familiar, and I have not the slightest hesitation in saying that they have no connection whatever with Leitrim. It would be true to say they have more alignment with the County Roscommon. I think some of the people in Sligo would have considerable trade relations with the town of Boyle, but whatever may be said for an alignment towards Roscommon I do not think there is any bond at all between this particular part of the County Sligo and the County Leitrim. So that in regard to the second principle—the preservation of county boundaries—this proposal of the Minister is as bad as it could well be. Personally, over and above the convenience of the people living in these areas, I think there is the important historical argument against the reckless mutilation of counties with considerable history behind them. That history has given rise to considerable county pride which in itself is a good thing.
The next objection to this principle is that it is going to create two constituencies that will each return three Deputies to the Dáil. Deputy Fitzgerald pointed out earlier in the day that with the system of proportional representation we have in this country, the three-member constituency negatives the whole effect of proportional representation. A five-member constituency is better. But a seven-member constituency gives even more satisfactory reflection of the voters' feelings in any constituency. I think one of the Minister's colleagues said that the ideal condition would be a five-member constituency. It was the Minister for Industry and Commerce who said that and, of course, the Minister's loyalty to his colleague will prevent him opening out upon that statement. I think, so far as the Minister took that view, it is right that we should preserve the principle of proportional representation. But I urge upon the Minister that there is no necessity, and that no strong, potent argument can be used, for the mutilation of a county, and that he ought to allow the preservation of a county boundary to weigh with him. Suppose we leave Leitrim-Sligo together what, in practice, will happen? The populations of these two counties, though not identical, are pretty nearly the same. You will find you will probably have three Leitrim Deputies and three Sligo Deputies. In a certain election it might turn out that you had four Sligo and two Leitrim Deputies, but generally you will find the division very similar to the division created by this Bill. You will have avoided the destruction of the historical boundary of the County Sligo. You will not have increased the number of Deputies returned by these two counties, and you will have met the wishes of the people who, after all, know the conditions that obtain in this area better than anyone in the Custom House knows them, or, as the Minister himself said, better than he knows them. In the face of these accumulative reasons for accepting Deputy Roddy's amendment, I suggest that the Minister should reconsider this question and allow Sligo-Leitrim to remain as it has been heretofore, one constituency, but returning one member less than it has returned in the past.
Comment on this
The Minister said that Sligo has been associated with Leitrim for a number of years. I agree with that statement. Sligo has been associated with Leitrim, as a single constituency, since 1922. My amendment proposes that that association should continue. The Minister has not advanced a single argument for declining to accept my amendment. It is all very well for the Minister to talk about proportional representation. The effect of proportional representation on three, five and six member constituencies was argued at considerable length on the Second Reading of this Bill. The Minister knows as well as I do that, to get the full effect of proportional representation, you must have at least a five-member constituency. I propose in my amendment to go one better and make this a six-member constituency.
I want to impress on the Minister the nature of the mutilation to which he is subjecting the County Sligo. I asked the Minister, in the course of my Second Reading speech on this Bill, to study the map for the purpose of satisfying himself that the picture I painted of the mutilation that is taking place in Sligo was not in the least degree exaggerated. The transfer of the areas which he proposes to make to Leitrim is entirely unnatural. In the case of one or two areas, it may be natural enough but, in the case of the majority of areas which the Minister proposes to transfer to the County Leitrim, the arrangement is entirely unnatural. The people living in these areas have nothing in common with the people of Leitrim. All their affiliations and associations, so far as they are outside the county, are with the people in the neighbouring county of Roscommon. I listened to a great part of the debate on the Committee Stage of this Bill and I cannot understand why the Minister rearranged County Roscommon in the way he did. If he was anxious to transfer portions of Sligo to a neighbouring county, he should have taken into consideration the sentiments of the people in these particular areas, their affiliations and the relationships which exist between them and the people in the neighbouring counties. If he had done so, I am certain he would not be proposing, as he is in this Bill, to transfer the people of, let us say, Geevagh and Kilmactranny to the adjoining areas of County Leitrim. The arrangement is, I suggest, entirely unnatural and, as I pointed out when moving the amendment, will lead to a considerable amount of additional expense. This arrangement will mean that the expense of carrying out an election in that constituency will be doubled. Two staffs will be required to work the election and two sets of counting officers will be required to count the votes after the election. That will mean double expense to the Government. In rearranging constituencies the Minister should take into consideration the question of economy as well as other questions.
Seemingly, this Bill was prepared in haste. No proper consideration was given to the rearrangement proposed in the Bill and I doubt very much if the Minister himself ever had an opportunity of going over the map and relating the arrangement proposed in the Bill to the map of the Twenty-Six Counties. If he had done so, I am certain that he would not have given his imprimatur to the extraordinary rearrangement proposed in respect of certain counties. Apart from what the Minister for Industry and Commerce said on the Second Reading—that it was one of the main desires of the Executive Council to preserve the county boundaries—it is unnatural and inconceivable for the Minister to sanction the mutilation of a county like Sligo in the manner proposed seeing, as I said on numerous occasions already, that that county is surrounded by a chain of mountains. I ask the Minister again to consider this question of the transfer of areas from County Sligo to County Leitrim. I ask him for the sake of his own administration, as well as for the sake of economy, to allow Sligo-Leitrim to remain as one constituency with six seats instead of seven. I suggest in all seriousness to the Minister that he should accept my amendment now or, if he is not prepared to do so now, that he should defer further consideration of the matter to the Report Stage.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
This amendment stands in our joint names. It is Deputy Norton's desire that I should move this amendment, which is directed to prevent the partition of the County Donegal.
Comment on this
I have called on Deputy Norton. Am I to understand that he has given way to Deputy Dillon?
Comment on this
I understood that Deputy Norton gave way. I turned round to know if he wished to move the amendment.
Comment on this
The amendment in question deals with my constituency. It is one directed to prevent the partition of County Donegal. Those of us who represent northern constituencies are only too familiar with the problem of partition in the national sense of the word. When we find it threatened in respect of a county which we represent we are naturally concerned to prevent it. The proposal here is to change Donegal constituency, which is now represented by eight members, to two constituencies represented by three and by four members respectively. That immediately gives rise to the objection to a three-member constituency, that the effect of proportional representation, which was so eloquently dealt with by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, would not be felt. Admittedly the county is a large one, and as a one-constituency county involves the covering of considerable distances. I am satisfied that the vast majority of the people there would prefer to have the county maintained as one electoral unit instead of being divided up as is proposed. The principal objection I see to the proposal is that you will have this three-member constituency. It is not necessary to waste time repeating the arguments advanced against that scheme. In this particular case, that is the prime argument against the proposal of the Government. The amendment is directed to remedy that defect and, at the same time, to secure that whatever economy might have been effected by the Government scheme will be secured by the alternative proposal.
Comment on this
I think the chief recommendation for the proposition in the Bill, to have two constituencies, is that it divides a very considerable county; and, secondly, it gives us two small constituencies. These are the two considerations that recommended themselves to me. Deputy Dillon says that we have had the same priciple argued at great length on several other amendments, and that it is, therefore, not necessary to go into details now. I do not know what the views of the House in general may be, except to accept what Deputy Dillon said for his Party, that he is anxious to have the division taken away. I do not know what the opinions of Deputies in my own Party are. I know that there are some Deputies in the Party who wish the divisions to remain and that others in the county wish them to be taken away. For that reason I announced at an earlier stage of the debate that if there was a division of opinion and if it was fairly general throughout the House, amongst all Parties, I would leave it to all Parties to deal with it.
Comment on this
From the point of view of a Deputy representing Donegal, I think Deputies there will welcome the change that is proposed. The area of the county is something like 400 square miles with a population of over 150,000. It is impossible for a Deputy to keep in touch with all parts of the constituency. While it might serve the interests of a Deputy that the area should be large, when all is said and done, I think the suggestion of the Minister provides a fair division, a division which will make Deputies' work in the Dáil much easier than it now is. At the same time, it will keep them more in contact with their constituency. I live in the southern end and I find it impossible to keep in contact with the rest of the constituency. I am in the county every week-end and when the Dáil is in recess. I dare say the other Deputies have the same feeling. If the area was more compact it would be better, and, accordingly, I am prepared to vote for the division of the county into two.
Comment on this
I regret that a young man like Deputy Brady is prevented from going around Donegal. One would expect that so young a man would have no difficulty in doing so, more particularly in these days of rapid transport. If the Minister looks at a map of County Donegal he will see that a three-member constituency is going to embrace the entire congested area. It is unnecessary to point out that the heavy part of the work of representing the people there will devolve on three members, and that the four-member constituency, which includes East and North Donegal, from Churchill into the borders of Tyrone and Derry and into Inishowen, was never included in the congested areas, except a very limited portion of the peninsula of Inishowen and Fanad. None of that is included in the Fíor-Ghaeltacht. When I learned that the county was going to be divided up, the obvious thing was to look at the division, and to consider the amount of work that there would be for the four-member constituency, as against the three-member constituency, in order to represent the people. The order should be reversed. It is unnecessary to point out that where you have a huge congested area, as you have in the three-member constituency, the heavy work will fall on three men. Perhaps for that reason Deputy Brady prefers to undertake the excessive burden. That is all very well in theory, but it is different in practice. In a huge area, where there is congestion, it would be better, from the point of view of the wellbeing of that area, that the entire constituency should remain one, and if the advice of all the Deputies could be secured when any grave issue arose involving the welfare of the area. For that reason I will support the amendment.
Comment on this
I assume that in the consideration of this important amendment we will have the assistance of Deputy H. Doherty, who is familiar with conditions in the Gaeltacht. I am happy to see that he has arrived, and that he will give us the benefit of his counsel.
Comment on this
Is Deputy Dillon allowed to call on me to speak? All I have to say is that I quite agree with the arrangement proposed by the Government, as being a sensible and proper one, for the division of the county. I hold that the argument of Deputy McMenamin only strengthens the necessity for such a division, and I will vote for the Government's proposal.
Comment on this
Having drawn bashful Deputies from Donegal, it is interesting to hear that they are in favour of the partition of the county.
We poor innocents still believe that partition is as objectionable in the County Donegal as it is in the nation as a whole. But over and above that the effect of this partition is going to be to split the Donegal Gaeltacht. That in itself is objectionable because I think even Deputy Brady will himself agree with me in this, that there is absolutely nothing in common between the interests of the vast bulk of the people living in East Donegal and the people who live in the Gaeltacht. So the result of the proposal, which Deputy Brady recommends to the House, will be that a very small part of the Gaeltacht is going to be lumped in with East Donegal and the vast bulk of the Gaeltacht will go to West Donegal——
Comment on this
Yes and that part will be well looked after by those three hardworking Deputies, whoever they may be, who will be elected for West Donegal. There will be small bits of the Gaeltacht left in East Donegal to be represented by Deputies who will have absolutely nothing in common with the Gaeltacht at all. They will be representative of the type of farmer and business man living in the bulk in East Donegal. These men know comparatively little about the peculiar problems that affect the Gaeltacht and the result will be that you will have, perhaps, the most defenceless section of the community in that part of the county, not represented in the House. At present where you have a man representing more or less West Donegal under the existing arrangement, it is well recognised that any resident of the Gaeltacht, no matter what part of the Gaeltacht he comes from, will turn to him naturally in preference to somebody who represents East Donegal, or South Donegal. When I say South Donegal I mean Bundoran, or Ballyshannon. The person living even north of Milford would turn, more naturally, to the Deputy representing Gweedore than he would to the Deputy representing Raphoe, though Raphoe would be nearer to him. Geographically the exact appearance of the map escapes my mind at the moment, but I think Milford is going to East Donegal. Now take the case of Milford, where you have a little regular fragment of the Gaeltacht and that will be completely isolated. We might safely describe the Fanad peninsula as the Gaeltacht. The result of this arrangement will be that that peninsula will be completely isolated from that part of Donegal to which it culturally belongs. I wonder did Deputy Brady and Deputy Doherty consider that aspect of the situation before they rushed in to place their support behind this proposal? However they can mend their hand. The Minister is going to take the muzzle off and he is going to take the dog-collar and the chain off for this division. They can run wild this time. It is good to take a little exercise every now and then. They can take one chase across the country now. I suggest in this case when you have an opportunity of preventing the isolation of a small, defenceless section of the Gaeltacht, when you have got a chance of going on record as against the principle of Partition, that naturally you ought to throw off the dog-collar, the chain and the muzzle. If you do not do it you may not get the chance again for years and years. Now you have got the chance. Take it.
Comment on this
It is amazing to hear Deputy Dillon talking about partition in Donegal. I am sure if he spoke to Deputy McMenamin he would tell him it is not the first occasion that we had a West Donegal constituency. I think if he turns to Deputy McMenamin he might find that Deputy McMenamin would tell him all about the sting in West Donegal.
Comment on this
I suggest that the arguments used by Deputy Dillon with regard to the isolation of the Gaeltacht could be used in favour of turning the entire Gaeltacht into one constituency. That is the logical conclusion with regard to what he says about Donegal. I do not see why they should not pick one, two or three representatives to represent that portion of the Gaeltacht. The case made against the division of Donegal into two constituencies seems, to my mind, as having nothing practical in it. But the Minister's proposal seems to me to be a proposal that should recommend itself to the House.
Comment on this
Question put: That the words proposed to be deleted, stand.
Do you agree with this result?
The Chair exercises a casting vote in the case of a tie, and there is a precedent as to how the casting vote is to be given. In order to give the House a further opportunity of considering the matter, the Chair gives the casting vote against the motion before the House, so that the House will have an opportunity again of considering the position. The motion was: "That the words proposed to be deleted, stand." I am voting against that motion.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Will the Leas-Cheann Comhairle say under what Standing Order a Leas-Cheann Comhairle can exercise a casting vote?
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy would refresh my memory by quoting the Standing Order which precludes the Leas-Cheann Comhairle from giving a casting vote?
Comment on this
I am entitled to ask the Standing Order. Of course, I am accepting the decision of the Chair.
Comment on this
The amendment on the Paper, therefore, now has to be put to the House so that the House may discuss it and decide on it. The motion, "That the words proposed to be deleted stand," having been defeated, the amendment has to be put to the House now. Therefore, if there is no further discussion desired on it, I am putting the amendment. The question now is: "That the words proposed be therein inserted."
Comment on this
I should like to say that I do not think the amendment suggested is the best arrangement. I certainly think that a division of the county is desirable, both from the geographical point of view and from the point of view of proportional representation. I think that it will be agreed that the county covers a very wide area and is very scattered. Geographically, it has considerable difficulties that other counties, even as great in extent territorially, have not got, and I certainly think that the principle of the division of the county ought to be adhered to.
Comment on this
I submit, Sir, that the House already has expressed clearly its view that this county should not be divided. The Minister gave what was practically an undertaking that he was prepared to let it go to a free vote and to accept the recommendation of the House on such a vote. On his side not a single vote was cast, outside the members of his own Party, against the division of the county. All the members of this Party, all the members of the Labour Party and every Independent member in the House recorded their votes against him. I feel sure, accordingly, that on reflection the Minister will recognise the justice of accepting this amendment without putting it to a further vote. Otherwise, certainly, I have misunderstood the spirit of the undertaking which the Minister gave, that this would be left to a free vote. If, after having given that undertaking and after a free vote having been secured, the Party Whips are to be put on now to gather up a majority in order to force through the rejection of the reconsolidation of the county, I cannot but think that it is a departure from the spirit of the Minister's undertaking. We provided in our proposal that there should be no increase in the number of Deputies returned by this county, and the only thing we wanted to secure is that the partition of the county proposed in the Bill should be undone. I urge most strongly on the Minister that having got this free expression of the House's opinion, he should accept it and recognise that the county should be left intact, and the number of Deputies as agreed upon between us.
Comment on this
As the Deputy knows, opinion was evenly divided on the matter. As I said before, in discussing this and other amendments, I hold strongly that a division of the county would be better. I am strongly of that opinion and, for my part, I should like to get a very clear decision from the House as to the House's view on this matter. It is not true to say that the Whips were put on.
Comment on this
My own opinion is that, were it not for the fact that our own members for Donegal spoke as strongly as they did, the vote might have been different. I did not know what their views on the matter were, but I should like to get a clear decision of the House on the question of whether Donegal should be divided or not.
Comment on this
I submit, Sir, that we got a clear decision already. The Minister now admits that the members of his Party were influenced to vote on Party lines by the representations of Deputies Brady and Doherty. As I pointed out already, every member of the House who was not a member of the Fianna Fáil Party voted the other way. I cannot see that that indicates anything except that on a free vote of the House the sentiment of the House was against it, and, as the Minister says, but for the intervention of Deputies Brady and Doherty, some others of the Fianna Fáil Party might have joined the Opposition in recording their votes. So, we got the worst vote we could get on the first division. In view of that, I hope that as a result of the vote we have had, the Minister will accept our amendment. I cannot make him do it. The Minister may say that the Whips will not be on, but, in effect, the Whips will be on because he joins issue a second time. I have no means of making the Minister honour, as I think, the spirit of his undertaking. If he wants to force a division, I wish him luck of it, but I submit that we are entitled to have our amendment accepted now as it is on the Order Paper. All I can say is that, if the Minister wants his division we will try and vote him down.
Comment on this
I must say that I do not understand the Minister's attitude. The inference from what he had said previously is that he admits there was nothing serious or vital involved in the matter, and I suggest, from his attitude now, that he took that line merely because he felt certain that the division would result otherwise than it did. Now, having said first that the issue involved was not vital and having been, in effect, beaten on it, he gets up and says that it is all-important that this county should be divided. I suggest that what he is doing is mending his hand. He now sees his opportunity of doing so and, whereas before he said that there was really no vital difference between the one method and the other, he now says that it is absolutely necessary that the members of his Party should stand solidly against the amendment. He is just trying to mend his hand.
Comment on this
While I am not personally interested in this particular matter, I should like to bring the House back to the realities of the situation. What happened was that there was a tie in the House and the Chair announced that there was a precedent for the Chair exercising a casting vote in the case of a tie and that in order to give the House a further opportunity of considering the matter the Chair would give the casting vote so that the House would have another opportunity of considering the position. The specific purpose of the procedure which has been adopted was to enable the House, which had not decided, to decide.
Comment on this
Question put—"That the words proposed to be deleted, stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 13:—
In Part II, page 7, to delete all reference to the constituencies of "East Galway" and of "West Galway," and in the second column to delete all words after the word "Clare" in the reference to the constituency of Clare and substitute therefor the following:—
"
GALWAY | The Administrative County of Galway | Eight
"
Galway constituency formerly elected nine members. The Bill proposes seven and the amendment proposes eight. The number of votes per member, if the amendment is accepted, will be 21,787, and the Constitution provides for something over 20,000, so that from that point of view, the amendment is quite in order. If the Minister will examine the figures, I think he will find that 21,000 would be about the average per member down through the counties. I have a list of the counties here in alphabetical order, beginning with Dublin and ending with Wicklow, and I will just run down the numbers, leaving out the odd figures. They are 22,000, 20,000, 20,000, 20,000, 23,000, 21,000, 20,000, 23,000, 20,000, 23,000, 22,000, 21,787, which is Galway—practically 22,000.
In other words, if our amendment is accepted, and if Galway is permitted to elect eight Deputies, the number of votes per Deputy will be at least the average number of votes, namely, practically 22,000. On the other hand, if the numbers stated in the Bill are allowed to remain, the number of votes per Deputy will be extremely small indeed and very much below the average. I think we are entitled to an explanation of that. There is no doubt that 22,000 votes per Deputy is a little above the average, if you take all the constituencies, but why should it be brought very much below 21,000? I should like the Minister to deal with that point when he is replying.
I want to draw the Minister's attention to another point. There is a part of Galway going in with Clare, that is, with Munster. I am living in the centre of the county, and it is a very big county, and that part of Galway that goes into Clare is within 17 miles of me, although I am living in the direct centre of the county, which is 100 miles long, and the particular portion of the county which is chosen to go into Clare is within 17 or 18 miles of the very centre of the county. It is not a peninsula or anything like that: it is not adjoining the sea and it is not cut off in any way from the rest of the county. It is extremely hard to understand why that particular part of the county should be cut off and thrown in with Clare, that is to say, it is extremely hard to understand it if you face this problem on its merits, but really if you look at the figures I think it is perfectly clear, so far as Clare is concerned, anyway, that this problem has not been faced on its merits.
I pointed out to the Minister that if the amendment we propose is accepted and if Galway elects eight members, it will take practically 22,000 votes to elect one Deputy, whereas if the Bill becomes an Act, as it is, it will not take anything like that number. I pointed out that on reading down the list, it seems that, roughly, 21,000 votes, taking all the counties, elect one member and we are asking that one member should be elected by 22,000 or practically 22,000. If you turn to Clare, what do you find? You find that there are 23,766, or very nearly 24,000, votes to each member. That is a very extraordinary state of affairs.
Comment on this
Any Deputy who goes up for election in Clare has to have practically 24,000 votes to elect him, whereas an unfortunate Deputy like Deputy Jordan or myself, in Galway has only 21,000 votes or thereabouts to depend on. These are figures which I do not think you can deny and there must be some reason for that sort of discrimination. It is perfectly clear why Galway is being carved in the interests of the Clare constituency and I do not think I need state why the Clare constituency is being made safe for democracy. It is quite obvious to everybody. Here is a considerable number of votes taken out of Galway and given into Clare, the particular constituency which the President represents, and I suggest that that is the reason for this extraordinary carving. There is no geographical reason; there is no reason whatever connected with the numbers. The reason is the reason I suggest and no other reason. The net result of it is that Galway, which formerly elected nine members, is now to elect only seven and the old Clare constituency formerly elected five members and the new Clare constituency is now to elect five members. I do not think I need develop that point any more, with regard to the relations between Clare and Galway, but having regard to that particular comparison of numbers, I think an explanation is required from the Minister who is in charge of the Bill.
Comment on this
I should like to say a word in support of Deputy Hogan's amendment. The case of Galway is not nearly so bad as the case of Roscommon, but still it is bad. No respectable explanation has so far been given for the proposal to take a piece of Galway and throw it into Clare. I am sorry that the Minister for Industry and Commerce was not here when we were discussing Roscommon, Longford and Westmeath, because I had no difficulty in showing that the division proposed in that case by the Government offended against the principles which had been laid down by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in his speech on the Second Reading. Let us consider these principles in connection with this amendment. The Minister for Industry and Commerce told us this was a very dangerous kind of Bill; that it was a Bill which would set up temptations for the Party in office if they were so misled as to listen to the pleadings of Party organisers and that there would be temptations for them to draw out the new constituencies on Party lines; but, while some Governments might easily yield to temptations of this kind, this Government, of course, had not done so and had protected themselves against such temptations by arriving at very clear principles. From these principles they had not departed and from these principles they would not depart. The principles in question were three. One was a reduction of the number of Deputies. Now, in point of fact, the number of Deputies in this Bill has been maintained practically as high as the Constitution permitted the Government to maintain it.
Comment on this
A difference perhaps of two. It would require very great ingenuity to retain a larger number of Deputies than has, in fact, been maintained, and it would have required no ingenuity at all substantially to reduce the number.
Comment on this
If all county boundaries were ignored? That is an inconceivable hypothesis. The Government has got into trouble by what it has done in ignoring county boundaries but it could hardly venture to set the whole country against it by ignoring all county boundaries.
Comment on this
The Deputy has said that according to the Constitution we have included in this Bill as many members as we could have, with the possible exception of two. Article XXVI of the Constitution does not mention county boundaries. It mentions only the population. Taking it on a strict population basis we could go up 13 members.
Comment on this
It is a fact, and with all respect, the Deputy misrepresents the position if he says that this Bill proposes to give as many members as the Constitution allows. It does not do that. It does not go within 13 of doing it.
Comment on this
With all respect, it is not the Deputy but the Minister who misrepresents the position, because what is possible on paper is one thing and what is practicable is another. Allow me to amend what I said and, if necessary, to make it formally correct, by saying now that the Government have maintained practically as many members as it would have been practicable for them to maintain, in view of the terms of the Constitution, and in view of the political inconvenience of abolishing county boundaries all over the country. Then we have the second principle. As a matter of fact, I was forgetting for the moment that the second principle was preservation of county boundaries, so that if we attach any importance to the genuineness of the second principle the Minister's point as regards the first principle disappears altogether. The second principle was preservation of the county boundaries. How does that apply in this case? What zeal has been shown in preserving the county boundary of Galway? The third principle was the abolition of unduly large constituencies. That is the only one that could possibly be pleaded here in dealing with Galway, but it is one that has been ignored by the Government elsewhere and, therefore, I do not believe they attach any real importance to it themselves. As far as I can make out, the view of the Government is that the proper size of a constituency is determined solely by electoral considerations in connection with that particular constituency. They created a most unwieldy and widespread constituency in Meath-Westmeath, quite unnecessarily, because they thought it suited them to do so in connection with the Roscommon readjustment. As in the case of Roscommon, we wait with interest to hear what defence the Government will produce for the gift of a bit of Galway which they propose to make to Clare. The province of Connaught has been atrociously treated in this Bill. It had to have its representation somewhat reduced because of loss of population, but it need not have been reduced below 27 and, at any rate, it would only have been reduced to 26 if the Government had not gone out of their way to take a piece of Connaught and give it to Leinster, and gone out of their way to take another piece of Connaught and give it to Munster. So I have no hesitation in joining with Deputy Hogan in protesting on behalf of both Roscommon and Galway.
Comment on this
I think I must lodge a formal protest against Deputies opposite purporting to quote speeches by me without reference to the text. Deputy MacDermot alleged that I stated that the Government was in sore temptation under pressure from its Party organisers in the preparation of this Bill.
Comment on this
I did not allege that. I alleged that he had stated that Parties in general might be, or could be, subject to such temptations.
Comment on this
My recollection of the speech I delivered on the Second Reading of this Bill is that I went to considerable pains to prove that it was not possible in this country to jerrymander constituencies. I pointed to the fact that the State had only been a short while in existence; that during that short while there had been considerable fluctuations of public opinion; that it was not possible, under the electoral system here, to ascertain with any accuracy how votes were cast in any particular district, and that, in any event, proportional representation would defeat any attempt at jerrymandering. I pointed to the fact that the proper time for the introduction of this Bill was as early as possible after the results of the 1926 census were published. I expressed my opinion that the then Minister for Local Government, Deputy Mulcahy, in fact, considered the introduction of this Bill soon after the 1926 census was published. I expressed the opinion that he had had many consultations with his Party organisers, and had discussed with them the possibility of a jerrymandering Bill which would be in the interests of his Party, but that he had discovered—as others have discovered after him — that, because of the reasons I have stated, jerrymandering was not possible. He took the course of not introducing the Bill. We took the course of defining certain principles and drawing up a Bill in accordance with those principles without regard to Party considerations.
Deputy Hogan quoted certain figures. He was, of course, wrong in those figures. It was only to be expected that Deputy Hogan would not stick too closely to the facts, because he was making his case, and a few thousands here and there would not make any difference, provided the case was established. The population of Galway, according to the census of 1926, was 169,366. On the basis of eight members—it has at present nine members, but it could not possibly have nine members in future in accordance with the Constitution— there would be a population per Deputy of 21,171, which is substantially below the average for all the constituencies provided for in this Bill. The average for the constituencies provided for in the Bill is a population of 21,853. The two constituencies into which it is proposed to divide Galway will have a population in East Galway of 87,348, electing four members and having in respect of each of these four members almost exactly the average for all constituencies, and in West Galway 69,799, electing three members and having a population per member substantially in excess of the average.
Comment on this
The average is 21,853. What is the case for dividing Galway, we have been asked, and also, what is the case for including in County Clare a certain contiguous portion of County Galway? Both reasons are fairly obvious. Galway, as Deputy Hogan has remarked is 100 miles long. It is a very large county. It was, in fact, the largest constituency in the country. When I speak of large constituencies, I am referring not so much to the geographical area of the constituencies as to the population. From the point of view of administration and representation the important consideration is the population of the constituency which each Deputy represents. Galway was one of the largest constituencies in the country—not quite so large in population as Dublin County, although under the system of election which prevailed it elected nine members. The proposal is to divide that constituency in accordance with the very excellent principles to which I have referred and which Deputy MacDermot has just quoted. It was decided to divide it into two constituencies. We were then up against the question of Clare. Clare has a population of 95,000. As pointed out, if it were to be maintained as a separate county without addition we would have the position that it could only elect four Deputies, but it would have, in relation to these four Deputies, a population per member very much in excess of the average.
Comment on this
Yes. Having regard to the situation in Galway and the situation in Clare, on the one hand Galway with eight Deputies would give an average per Deputy substantially lower than the average for the country as a whole, while Clare would have an average per Deputy substantially above the average for the country. It was decided finally to attach to Clare a certain portion of Galway which has very definite associations with Clare, thus creating a position in which you had in Galway and in Clare an average for each Deputy approximating closely to the average for the whole of the country.
Comment on this
In the case of Clare the average will be 21,468 for five Deputies. The population of Clare plus the population of the added area from Galway will be 107,343. That works out at an average of 21,468. It seems, therefore, that although it was with considerable reluctance the county boundary was departed from, it was nevertheless the best system, having regard to the considerations to which I have referred— the desirability of securing uniform representation, the desirability of having constituencies which were not too large and the desirability of having an odd number of Deputies wherever that is possible. To maintain Galway with eight Deputies and Clare with four would give two constituencies of the undesirable kind whereas under this arrangement there will be only one such constituency. At the next election that situation may not arise. As Deputies are aware the Ceann Comhairle is automatically elected in one of these constituencies. The Ceann Comhairle is at present a representative of County Galway and there will presumably be an election for one less than the prescribed number. It was a difficult situation to arrange the various constituencies, particularly in the West of Ireland, in a manner which seemed to meet as many of the principles we had laid down as possible. It was not found practicable to maintain all these principles in every case but we tried to strike a balance and arrive at an arrangement which would conform as closely as possible to the general ideal. It is for that reason that this arrangement in respect to Galway and Clare was arrived at and I think it will be found that it will work out excellently in practice.
Comment on this
In supporting this amendment, I do not at all agree with what the Minister for Industry and Commerce has said. He has stated that Galway is a very large constituency, but even after this carving up of the county he has reduced the mileage very little. If you take the West Galway constituency, you will find that we start away at the island of Boffin and come exactly within four miles of the old Clare border. The constituency runs right on from Clifden to Galway and from Galway practically into Kinvara. Where the new border commences is just four miles north of the county border, so that you have the western constituency running from Boffin almost right into Kinvara, a distance of about 76 miles. The Minister says that the Clare people and the Galway people have much in common. If you like, take even the actual road connection with Clare. You have a range of mountains, practically about 50 miles in length, running from Portumna right on to Gort, and in that range of mountains you have no roads. You have really only passes, and nobody knows that better than the Fianna Fáil Deputies. You have only one connection with the County Clare and that is the main road between Gort and Ennis. The Galway people have no associations with the Clare people. Their market town in that district has been Gort while the market town of the Clare people has been Ennis.
If we take even the conditions under the G.A.A.—it might be no harm to mention them—we find that for years there has been only one county hurling team in Connaught, the Galway hurling team. It was proposed on a few occasions that either the Galway team should go in with the Munster team or that the Clare team should come in with Galway in order to give Galway more play. It was the one county hurling team in Connaught and it had to represent the province against teams which had the advantage of playing several other counties previously. Although that has been talked of for years, nothing has been done. Neither the Munster Council nor the Connaught Council made any move to put Galway in with Munster or to take Clare in with Galway. That shows that there is no affiliation whatever between the two peoples. On the other hand, Clare is a dairying county, while Galway is a tillage county. We have then the Minister for Local Government saying that he does not like even-numbered constituencies, although he proposes that East Galway should have four seats. All we are asking is that he should give Galway eight seats. I think he also mentioned that he does not like to break up the county electoral areas, but I find that in Galway, Loughrea county electoral area, of which Gort forms a portion, has been cut right across. A population of about 12,000 has been taken from that electoral area and put into Clare. We have a resolution from the Galway County Council, the members of which certainly have very mixed opinions, showing that the County Council is totally opposed to the mutilation of the Galway constituency. I ask the Minister again to give this matter consideration. We have to travel from Boffin to Kinvara, a distance of 76 miles. By giving us special constituencies, with four Deputies in the east and three in the west, it means that Galway will have a representative for every 22,500 people. Clare, by taking over portion of South Galway will have a representative for every 21,175 people. I think that is a big difference amounting to about 700 electors more for each representative in Galway than in Clare. I think our amendment is a very reasonable one. Although the Minister is against even-member constituencies, Galway is one that should receive special consideration. It is bounded on the south by a range of mountains 50 miles in length with only ordinary mountain passes through them. There is not one main road connecting Galway with Clare and for that reason alone I think it is a good argument for leaving Galway as it is.
Comment on this
Anyone acquainted with Galway must have wondered why it has been so long allowed to remain as one constituency. It is a big, huge constituency, 100 miles in length. From Inishbofin in to Kilmacshane electoral division is 100 miles. Kilmacshane is about ten miles nearer to Carnsore Point and about 30 miles nearer to Howth than Inishbofin. No one could work a constituency like that as one electoral division. I am in entire agreement with the subdivision of the county. Of course if we were to do it our own way we might have a different line of demarcation. As to the part that is to be given to Clare, I do not quite agree with that particular area. Deputy Hogan said that at the next general election County Clare will have something like 24,000 to each representative, while Galway will only have 21,000 electors to each representative. The county that will have only 21,000 to each representative may be much reduced, but it would be as easy to get elected by 21,000 or 22,000 electors as by 25,000. As the quota would be much smaller, Deputy Brodrick rather contradicted the calculation about 25,000. He said that the Galway Deputies would have more constituents to look after.
Comment on this
Divide it up and you will see that that is so.
Comment on this
Yes, but we cannot have it both ways. If their men are to have 25,000 electors at the next election, and we can only get 21,000, I think it is right and proper that this constituency of Galway should be sub-divided. I think it will make matters easier for all parties concerned. It will make it as easy for the Labour Party to return a candidate if the constituency is sub-divided as if it remained one. At the last election their candidate only got a small number of votes. I think if they have two candidates, one in each of the divisions, each candidate would be more interested in his own election, and would have a better opportunity of organising than if he had to be travelling from Clifden to Ballinasloe and from Loughrea to Ballygar and only hitting the constituency in spots. It was that kind of thing, I think, that militated very considerably against Labour in the Galway constituency. I am in favour of the division of the county, and the Minister may, perhaps on Report Stage, reconsider his decision as to the portion that is to be ceded to Clare. I would like our county to be left intact and I am strongly in favour of having the constituency sub-divided.
Comment on this
While the speech of Deputy Brodrick is fresh in the minds of Deputies, I am glad to have an opportunity of replying. I had no intention of speaking on this amendment because if every representative of Galway were to get up and speak it would be rather monotonous. One purpose I had in rising was to remind Deputy Brodrick of his mention of the G.A.A. in connection with the amendment. I am a bit of a sportsman and I think I know a little about the G.A.A. One of the outstanding things the Deputy said was that there was no affiliation between Clare and Galway and that they had nothing in common. He mentioned the G.A.A. and what Galway attempted for the preservation of the national pastime. I would remind deputy Brodrick and the House generally that Clare and Galway have very much more in common in connection with the G.A.A. than he thinks. Because I am glad to say that Clare gave birth to Michael Cusack and when he wanted men to assist him in organising the G.A.A. and putting it upon a proper basis he came to Galway. In Loughrea he interviewed Bishop Duggan and got his blessing for the project, and Bishop Duggan sent him from Galway to Tipperary to Dr. Croke, and as a result of which we have the association of the G.A.A. that Clare and Galway with other county representatives founded which gives common ground not only to Clare and Galway but to the 32 Counties of Ireland. Having made that point clear I trust that the Minister will be satisfied with the division of Galway into two constituencies and leave the border as it was.
Comment on this
Having experience of what the Galway constituency is, I must say I am opposed to this amendment on the ground that it proposes to leave Galway in one constituency. Such an arrangement I think would be against reason. As Deputy Beegan mentioned, Galway is over 105 miles from east to west, and 90 miles from north to south. While I oppose that part of the amendment that is against the division of the constituency, I am strongly in favour of the part of the amendment which proposes to leave Galway boundary intact. I move the adjournment of the debate.