We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Business. - Finance Bill, 1934—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–137 of 267. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1934
Enacted

No. 26 of 1934 ›

I should like the Minister to say how it was that they hit upon 100 years in fixing the age of furniture to be imported. I presume "furniture" in that respect means silver, or is it directed exclusively to household furniture?

Comment on this

The Deputy has misread the section. It means any article.

Comment on this

The Minister mentioned, in the course of the Bill, that it had reference to antique furniture.

Comment on this

Not merely to antique furniture.

Comment on this

So far as furniture is concerned, it is the main item. Why it was that they fixed at 100 years I do not understand. The principal artists had passed away about 1820, and the other principal artists were Chippendale, Adam, and Sheraton.

Comment on this

The Deputy is proceeding on a wrong assumption. As a matter of fact the necessity for this clause in the Bill arises out of a different article.

Comment on this

What was it?

Comment on this

A violin.

Comment on this

Is not that a musical instrument?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Does it not refer to furniture?

Comment on this

No, I think the words of the section are clear. They may include furniture. I did not give the House to understand at any time that this section related principally to furniture.

Comment on this

If articles referred to are 100 years old, it will bring in the Victorian era. There was another amendment on this section down, but it was ruled out by the Ceann Comhairle. That would have brought it to the time of the Act of Union. Is the policy of the Government Victorian? I take it it is. I had hoped there would be a prolongation of the period.

Comment on this

As far as this particular section is concerned it could not be wider than it is. The Minister says "any article," and now it is framed to bring in violins. That is a musical instrument and it could have been cited as such. As far as the section stands we can, as Deputy Esmonde says, practically import Victorian furniture free of duty.

Comment on this

If anybody wants it.

Comment on this

The question really that the House is asked to decide is whether we shall allow in shoddy. I do not know whether the Minister intended that or not. There are very good manufactures and great furniture artists in this country. This may hamper and restrict their work. The various tariffs imposed have not materially assisted such persons, but this section may possibly injure their business. There is no indication as to what is meant by the section except the one example given of a violin. Surely it was not necessary to draft such a wide section as this to allow in a single violin? Even a violin is not an antique, I would say, if it were only 100 years old. If you were not likely to injure some furniture makers here, I would have no objection. If people are foolish enough to pay for Victorian furniture and import it here, that is their own affair. But that it should be allowed in to compete with furniture makers here when efforts are being made to stimulate production all around to meet our requirements is another matter altogether. In this case, as I said, there are persons engaged in this business who are real artists. Is there to be further competition allowed in respect of their work and all for the sake of having a particular violin imported? For whom is it? Have we to legislate now so that a single article can be brought into the country?

Comment on this

Yesterday the Deputy complained that most of the speeches of the Minister for Finance were after-dinner speeches. I think we have just listened to a "morning-after" speech because, except on a morning after, I never heard so much confusion of thought expressed in a few sentences as we have listened to from the Deputy. There was a period when the Deputy had very little regard for antique furniture. I think there is on the records of this House pronouncements to that effect.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not in reference to this furniture.

Comment on this

At any rate, I think he regarded a certain assembly then as an early Victorian collection. We are told that there are great artists in this country who are going to be injured because we are allowing in shoddy early Victorian furniture. There are great artists in this country, and I am perfectly certain that every one of them will resent the imputation conveyed in Deputy Cosgrave's speech that, if people had their choice between purchasing their handiwork and what is regarded as early Victorian rubbish, according to the Deputy, they would, even to the extent of the duty, prefer furniture of the early Victorian period to the fine specimens of the cabinet-makers' art which they turn out. If I wished to be uncomplimentary to the cabinet-makers I would put them on the plane Deputy Cosgrave has put them.

Comment on this

I suppose we are now a lot wiser than we were before. I am, fortunately or unfortunately, in the position that I put money into that particular form of manufacture in this country. If the Minister had done the same thing he would probably concern himself more with what is here before us. But, unlike him, I act as well as talk. There was evidence in this Chamber of one particular artist's work long before the Minister ever gave up his nonsense and came in here to admire that work. The purpose of this section, as far as the House is concerned, is to allow a single violin to be imported here. That is all we are told about it. As it is drawn, it will allow in furniture which is 100 years and a day old. As I said, there were four and, perhaps, five notable manufacturers of furniture in Great Britain—Adam, Chippendale, Sheraton, Hepplewhite and possibly Shearer. The last of these died in 1820 and probably the work was done previous to 1800. There was a gap filled up by what is called the Nelson period, during which a ropework design was used.

We are now invited to allow in furniture manufactured from 1800 to 1834 free of duty. That is not antique furniture. I suppose the silver work during the time of the Regency would be very artistic work, but that would last only until about 1812. In this section we are going 32 years beyond that.

If this section has no other purpose than to allow of the importation of a violin, then a very poor case has been made for it. No matter what the Minister said in criticism or otherwise of the furniture manufacturers in this country to whom I have referred, no damage can be done to their work. The people who patronise them and purchase their work know the value of it, and no empty criticism of any kind will affect it, even if it were to come from a much more authoritative source than the Minister.

Comment on this

It did not come from me. The innuendo was conveyed in the speech of the Deputy.

Comment on this

Some people gave evidence of the faith that was in them by patronising it. An amendment was put down after consultation with a person who has more experience of this than the whole Front Bench or the whole Party opposite. He told me that there was absolute rubbish manufactured from the end of the 18th century up to the Victorian period. If we want that to come in, very good, this is the way to get it. If the excuse for this section is the letting in of a single violin, it is a very poor excuse.

Comment on this

Once more we are faced with the misrepresentation which Deputy Cosgrave makes his stock-in-trade. I made it quite clear in introducing the precedent resolution on this matter that it was intended to allow the importation into this country of antiques of all kinds. I did not specifically mention a violin, nor did I specifically mention furniture. Deputy Cosgrave, however, for some reason or other, assumed that the only article of virtu we had in mind was a piece of furniture.

Comment on this

That is what the Minister stated.

Comment on this

I told Deputy Cosgrave that the matter was originally brought to my attention in connection, not with a piece of furniture, but in connection with a violin. I certainly did not say that the sole purpose of this was to secure importation free of duty of a violin. If I were to come to the Dáil and put down a proposal of that sort to cover one specific article I would be lacking in my duty. That is not why the legislation is brought in—to cover one specific case. It is because one specific instance brought to our attention a condition of affairs that had existed here for a long time under the administration of the Deputy, who is so concerned about furniture of this kind. He never gets up to make a speech but he reminds me of Poo-Bah clinking his money bags or making a parade of the little knowledge he has. I merely repeat that I would not put on the same level as Deputy Cosgrave has put them the artistic cabinet-makers of Dublin. Deputy Cosgrave put them on a level with the manufacturers of early Victorian furniture. There may be quite good specimens of that furniture. The Deputy has referred to the Nelson period. It is not to be despised. It was carried on until 1834. The point is that, if an article is 100 years old, it is a fair presumption that it has an artistic value. If it has survived the vicissitudes of time for that period it must be because it was highly valued by somebody, and I am perfectly certain if it has not artistic merit no person is going to spend his money bringing it into this country.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister will tell us if the period of 100 years is based on the violin or on any general principle. The Minister has put us into a difficulty in that no reasonable amendment can be moved, because it may be ruled out of order on the ground that it imposes additional taxation on the people, as it were. I think some explanation of the 100 years is desirable, and the question arises as to whether there ought to be this kind of sliding period at all. Again, I will ask the Minister whether, in fixing the period of 100 years, he was influenced by the fact that he had made any reciprocal agreements with other countries. Yesterday the Minister told us that two Tan-Sad chairs had been imported for use in the Galway Telephone Exchange.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

They are not 100 years old.

Comment on this

But, Sir, they will be some time or other.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

When they are we may discuss them.

Comment on this

I am anxious to find out whether there is anything arising out of this section which would mean that these chairs were a capital investment and we could hope to export them as antiques in another 100 years. I would like to know if there is any reciprocal arrangement with any other country directing the insertion of 100 years as the period in the section.

Comment on this

With regard to Section 17, the Minister, when dealing with the Financial Resolution on which this section is based, had something, but very little, to say with regard to the tobacco industry. In view of all the circumstances, I think it would be most desirable that the Minister should tell us something of the position of the tobacco industry and give us some idea as to why the continuance of a rebate of this kind is necessary. The Minister for Industry and Commerce was unable to tell us to-day the number of people who were employed in the tobacco industry on the 1st March of this year. It was possible from 1925 to tell the country every half year the number of persons employed in the tobacco industry until the Fianna Fáil Party came into power. Then the figures were smothered. We got them, with a certain amount of difficulty, in March, 1933, but they are again smothered to-day.

When the Free State came into being, employment in the tobacco industry, in terms of full time employment, was given to 500 people. By November, 1925, the industry gave employment to 1,600 people, showing an increase in full time employment of 1,100 persons. There was an increase in 1926 and also in 1927, in which year employment stood at the figure of 1,868. That meant 50 persons had been added during 1926 and 218 during 1927. Then there was a kind of flat period. There were 12 less employed in September, 1928, and 15 less in September, 1929. In September, 1930, the total employment was 2,081. There had been an increase in the preceding 12 months of 240 persons. In September, 1931, the total number of persons employed in the tobacco industry was 2,317, an increase during that year of 236 persons. Then we come to blind spots and the last figures given us by the present Ministry show that the total number employed was 2,245, or 72 persons less than were employed in the last period of the administration before Fianna Fáil came into power.

The Minister told us, when he was dealing with the Financial Resolutions, that a considerable increase in employment had taken place since he introduced his Finance Bill in 1932. There is no evidence good, bad or indifferent in regard to that. The Minister indicated that he has safeguarded, to a very large extent, Irish capital that was invested in industry here, but he has given us no information as to how much Irish capital is invested in the tobacco industry. He has given us no information as to what are the circumstances which make it possible for him to reduce the rebate from 7d. to 3½d., and no information as to why it is necessary to give a rebate of 3½d. now. The only information we have is that in that industry the total value of the production, according to the census of 1926, was £5,033,000. According to the 1929 census the figure was £5,215,000. According to the census of 1931 the amount was £5,746,000, out of a total value of industrial production amounting to about £60,000,000. Since Fianna Fáil came into power employment in connection with that industry has been reduced. The Minister should have something to tell the House about this industry. He had a lot of talk as regards what he is doing. The only evidence the House has had is that in this very important industry there is a falling off of employment.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question is that Section 17 shall stand part.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister, Sir, has he nothing to say?

Comment on this

This question was fully threshed out two years ago, and anything I had to say in relation to this section I already said in my Budget statement.

Comment on this

The Minister said the other day that there had been a considerable increase in employment in the tobacco industry. He said that he discussed in 1932 the position in the tobacco industry, but he did not deal with the position as indicated by a fall in employment in that industry after two years of his administration, nor did he make any further attempt to elaborate to the House the difficulties that he appeared to suggest that he had with the older Irish-controlled factories, to whom he was giving certain concessions. He more or less indicated to the House on the last day that he had some difficulty with these and that, as far as he was concerned, they could go and fish and die out like Gallahers.

Comment on this

Gallahers did not die out.

Comment on this

They were pushed out.

Comment on this

By the Deputy. The Deputy persuaded them to commit suicide.

Comment on this

They were pushed out.

Comment on this

Rightly so.

Comment on this

A Deputy from Galway says "Rightly so"—a Deputy who cannot point to a single development of industry in the Gaeltacht about which the Ministry are so full of talk. It is a Deputy from that district who says "rightly so."

Comment on this

There was never one in the ten years the Deputy was in office, and we have got one since.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

The Deputy may have got one, but if so, it is a deep secret in his own heart and that of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, because this House has not been able to find out whether he has or not. Speaking on the 23rd May, 1934, the Minister for Finance, as reported in Column 1607, Volume 52, No. 4, said:

"There have been one or two concerns that lay on their oars, and refused to do anything. I do not know what their fate is to be in the future. There is only one thing I have to say and it is this: That this Government and people have no use for any manufacturer in receipt of special facilities and privileges from the people of the country who fails to take advantage of them. We do not care whether such a manufacturer closes his doors and folds his tent and departs like Gallahers."

In the face of the reduction in employment in the tobacco industry, and in face of the attitude the Minister takes up with regard to the leaving of this country by Gallahers' factory, I should like to ask him is this a gentle hint to people that they can expect to see a further reduction in the amount of employment in that industry, and that there are a couple of other firms that are going to close their doors and fold their tents? I think that, if the Minister has any difficulties in the matter, he ought to take the House into his confidence and say in the first place, why employment has so fallen off in the industry and, in the second place, what it is that he fears in the future that may bring about further unemployment in that industry?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Section 17.

Comment on this

Again, Sir, I should like to ask the Minister——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has already asked his question.

Comment on this

I should like to put a simpler question, Sir. Why is it, in the case of an industry in which employment was increased from 500 persons—that is, the equivalent of fulltime employment—to 2,317 persons, or an increase of 1,800 persons, during the previous Administration, there has been a falling off in that industry during the Minister's administration?

Comment on this

That does not arise here.

Comment on this

It arises here in so far as this section deals with that industry.

Comment on this

It is a matter for the Department of industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 14, standing in my name and that of Deputy Dr. Davitt:—

To delete sub-sections (1) and (2) and substitute the following sub-sections:—

Sub-section (2) of Section 20 of the Finance Act, 1932 (No. 20 of 1932), shall apply only to tobacco which is shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners to have been grown before the first day of January, 1935.

The excise duties on tobacco imposed by sub-sections (2) and (3) of Section 17 of the Finance Act, 1933 (No. 15 of 1933), and the duties mentioned in sub-section (4) of the said Section 17 shall be charged, levied and paid on all tobacco which is grown in Saorstát Eireann and is not shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners to have been grown before the 1st day of January, 1935.

Amendment No. 15 is connected with this amendment, and amendment No. 21 is consequential. I hope that the Minister is in a more congenial and peaceful frame of mind than he was in a few minutes ago, because I hope that he will see his way to accept these amendments. The purpose of these amendments is, roughly speaking, to preserve for the coming financial year the privileges, such as they were, which had been gained by the Irish Tobacco Growers for the last financial year. The wording of the amendments may be rather obscure to some Deputies, but, in fact, they amount to putting us back to the position in which we were this time last year when the Minister made certain statements in this House which gave hope to the growers of Irish tobacco that their case would be favourably considered by the Government in the course of the last financial year. Unfortunately, statements which have been made since, and the rumours which have been met with, have rather discouraged those who expected to receive favourable consideration from the Minister as a result of his statement last year.

A year ago, when speaking on the 10th May, 1933, in this House, the Minister, in referring to the scale of charges which were to be imposed on tobacco in this country, said—I am quoting from volume 47, column 737, of the Official Debates:—

"I should like to emphasise that it is the desire of the Government to establish this industry on a firm basis. With that end in view an experimental period has been allowed during which any person who thought he could make a success of the crop might try his hand at it with the assurance that his venture would be a financial success."

Later on he said:

"It has been decided to impose an excise duty on all Irish tobacco grown after the 1st of January, 1934. This duty, however, is fixed at such rates that a very high measure of protection indeed will be given to the native product. The standard rate of the duty will be 6/8 per lb. as compared with 9/4½ per lb. on foreign grown tobacco. It will be charged on all Irish tobacco sold to manufacturers who use both the native and the foreign grown article. As an additional concession a preferential rate of 5/6 per lb. will be charged in the case of tobacco sold to manufacturers who use only Irish tobacco for their products. It is hoped that this special reduction will encourage some people to specialise entirely in the manufacture of home grown tobacco."

The Minister said that last year; and then there were rumours that legislation was to be introduced to control that and to regulate the growing of Irish tobacco. It was announced that a Bill would be introduced last January, but that announcement was not carried out. On the 6th of February last there was an announcement that a new restrictive policy was to be introduced by the Government to prohibit to a certain extent the growing of tobacco except by certain privileged persons. Since then we have had these further announcements by the Government that they would introduce a Bill, but so far no Bill has appeared.

The purpose of these amendments is to continue the present state of affairs until such time as the Government announce their policy. By embarrassing the growers of tobacco, they are putting them in a false position, and they are, in fact, breaking faith with them in view of the fact that they are not carrying out the undertaking to produce a permanent Government policy with regard to encouraging the growth of tobacco.

It has been suggested by supporters of the Government throughout the country that the failure of the Government to carry out its promises has been due not to the Ministers themselves but to permanent civil servants. The statement has been made throughout the country that the Ministers are innocent of any hostility to the tobacco growers, and that it is the permanent civil servants—the Revenue Commissioners and others—who have usurped the powers of the Minister and have imposed their will against the better judgment of the Ministers themselves. These statements have been made publicly in various parts of the country, and they have not been contradicted by any Minister. That naturally raises the question as to whether the Minister agrees with his supporters in the country that it is the permanent civil servants who have interfered in Government policy and have prevented a generous and adequate consideration of the claims of tobacco growers, or whether the Ministers themselves are prepared to stand over their own actions. It is not fair to them to hide behind the permanent civil servants and to suggest or to allow their supporters to suggest, that it is these civil servants who are preventing proper Government assistance being given. I wonder if the Minister would be willing on this occasion to state whether there is any ground whatever for the statements that have been made throughout the country by their supporters that he, in this case, has been overruled and impeded by permanent civil servants in respect of intentions which were publicly announced by various members of the Government to encourage the home-grown tobacco industry.

The three amendments roughly can be taken together. It has been pointed out by those interested in the tobacco growing industry that the price offered under the present Government régime is inadequate and certainly is not likely to encourage those who have been interested in the matter to continue their efforts to grow tobacco. The price offered is a price which would be remunerative only in a very few cases, with exceptional land, exceptional circumstances and exceptional technical skill on the part of the grower. For the average grower, the price available under the present arrangement is not a paying price. I see no reason why the Government should not continue the status quo until such time as they are prepared to bring before the House and before the country a reasoned and thought out policy for the encouragement of tobacco. They started off first with a gesture in remitting all duty. They then found that that was rather an unscientific way of approaching the situation and they put on certain duties. They are now increasing those duties. First, the tobacco growers were treated generously, or over-generously; then they were treated perhaps fairly reasonably; and now they are being treated definitely unreasonably and in the Fourth Finance Bill by this Government next year, we may look for regulation and taxation which will practically amount to prohibition and the closing down of these experiments in Irish tobacco growing. Every year has been worse than the year before. That has been the experience we have had during the three financial years of the present Government. The suggestion in these amendments is that they should at least maintain the situation as it was a year ago until such time as they come forward with their permanent proposals for the regulation of this industry.

Comment on this

Just before last Christmas, at the invitation of the Meath Tobacco Growers' Association, I went down to a place called Randalstown, near Navan, to attend the formal reopening of the tobacco rehandling station. This reopening was carried out by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. There was the usual ceremony, followed by a social function and it was all very pleasant and I left with the impression that a new era was in store for the Meath tobacco growers and that so far as the rehandling station at Randalstown was concerned, under the guidance and benevolence of the Minister for Finance, it need have nothing to fear for the future. All the speeches that day, including the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, tended to give the tobacco growers of Meath that impression. Since then the actions of the Government have been such as to destroy any hopes that might have existed at that time amongst those who, at the instigation, one might say, of the present Government, had gone into the cultivation of tobacco on a large or small scale, as the case might be. So great was the indignation that resulted from the change in Government policy that one of my colleagues in County Meath, Deputy O'Reilly, who was here a few moments ago, but who has left, was driven—and, naturally enough, because he is a man who has always been intensely interested in the cultivation of tobacco in County Meath—to comment unfavourably on the changed policy of the Minister for Finance. I think, however, that if he was correctly reported, it was unfortunate that he attempted to save the Minister for Finance by putting the blame for that changed policy, as Deputy Esmonde said, upon the civil servants. I think the Minister for Finance made a slight effort to correct that impression, in reply to a question by Deputy McGilligan here, but I do think it should be made quite clear to the tobacco growers in Ireland that if the Government changes its policy with regard to tobacco, it is because the Minister for Finance directs that policy and not because he is ordered to do so by civil servants under his control. The fact, however, remains that the tobacco growing industry is in a very precarious position at the present moment. If we just look over the history of tobacco growing during the last few years we will see that, whereas when Fianna Fáil were in opposition, people like the present Minister for Finance were enthusiastic in their condemnation of the treatment by the last Administration of the tobacco growing industry, but notwithstanding their vehemence in opposition, they have, since they came into power, done more by their chopping and changing to destroy permanently the future of the tobacco growing industry in this country than one would have thought possible.

Under the British régime there were various subsidies given to tobacco growers. I think no name is better known in connection with the efforts to establish tobacco growing in this country than is the name of Sir Nugent Everard. He was a pioneer in that line. His old rehandling station at Randalstown was formally reopened last Christmas, and there is there a modern readaptation of the old rehandling station which he started himself. Subsidies were given by the British under the old régime of about 1/- per lb. or a limit of £50 per acre, and later of £25 per acre. In those days there was no settled policy with regard to tobacco growing, and the tobacco industry suffered accordingly. Now we have changed again. First of all, we took off the excise duty altogether in 1932. The Finance Bill of 1933 put on a duty of 6/8 per lb. on the manufacture of foreign tobacco or 5/6 per lb. duty on Irish tobacco to be used by manufacturers. That is a duty of 5/6 on firms manufacturing Irish tobacco and 6/8 per lb. on firms using both foreign and the native leaf.

This time last year I moved some amendments in order to see if we could persuade the Minister for Finance to reduce those impositions from 6/8 and 5/6 to 3/4 and 2/8 respectively. He refused to accept those amendments, saying that it would cost the Exchequer a sum of about £500,000. It is a peculiar thing that when the question of tobacco comes up the Minister for Finance falls back upon that argument which he regards as a final declaration. But if such an argument is used against any imposition of taxes on any other industry, the people using it would be called traitors to the country, and people opposed to the development of industry. That kind of remark comes very often from the mouths of the leaders of the Front Bench opposite. We should, consequently, be entitled to regard the Minister for Finance as an enemy of the country because he says he will not give more protection to the tobacco industry because it would be a loss to the Exchequer. It is strange that that kind of argument should be brought in by a Fianna Fáil Minister. This year we have taxed the Irish grown tobacco to practically the same extent as the imported leaf.

The position, therefore, is that in the space of three years there has been a change from the time when there was no tax at all on Irish grown tobacco to a tax of 8/6. Whatever may be the position as regards the economics of providing the whole Irish market with Irish grown tobacco—and I believe that matter has not been fully inquired into —the fact remains that this change from year to year is bound to have a very detrimental influence upon the tobacco industry in Ireland. According to the Fianna Fáil spokesmen during the 1932 election, previous legislation allowed Irish tobacco growing to drift into utter neglect. If that is so their present attitude is going to kill it. Taking off the tax was a great stimulus to the farmers to enter into tobacco growing, thereby making up for the losses they had incurred in their main industry. The present change of attitude is a more severe blow to the farmers when they had been promised such an era of prosperity, but that cup of prosperity is now to be dashed from their lips. Such action is bound to do more harm than if no steps at all had been taken in 1932. Even the most enthusiastic supporters of the Government who have gone into tobacco growing will be disgusted with the whole thing. Before the experiment has been properly tried out those who were persuaded to go into tobacco growing will probably be fed up with the whole procedure. We had a statement by the Minister for Agriculture some months ago about tobacco growing. That statement was to the effect that the Government aimed at the production of 10,000 acres of tobacco in the Free State. Whether he stated that that would be an advantage this year or not, the fact remains that the impression given to the people in the country was that the Government wished to attain to that stage as soon as possible In other words, 10,000 acres of Irish grown tobacco would supply all the tobacco consumers in the Free State. The people in the country naturally believed that it was the policy of the Government to reach to this stage of production as soon as possible, and that that policy would not be interfered with by any such trifling thing as the loss of money to the Exchequer. Undoubtedly that provided an outlook for those farmers who have been so badly hit by the economic policy of the Government. At any rate we thought that was one single gesture towards the farmers, one rift in the cloud, the only one thing that the Government were doing for the farmers. We got the impression that they were going to develop the production of tobacco in the country.

Then their next announcement is that there is going to be a limitation of the growers of tobacco to a figure of 750 or 1,000, and a limitation from 10,000 acres to 1,500 acres. I presume that is roughly correct. I wonder what the exact number of farmers in the Free State is, and what proportion would 750 or 1,000 bear to the total number engaged in farming? If the policy of the Government, as regards tobacco, is only going to benefit that many farmers, I should like to know how the Government can expect such a policy to be of any real benefit to the country as a whole? I do not wish to say that those farmers who are getting the privilege of growing these 1,500 acres would disapprove of it. They have taken their chance of growing it and I am glad for their sake. But we must remember that the policy is only benefiting the few and that it is not much good for the country as a whole.

That announcement of the limitation of the acreage under tobacco was considered by the people of the country as a deliberate betrayal of the promise given to the farmers in 1932 and 1933 as to tobacco growing in this country. I leave the matter to the intelligence of the Deputies here to say whether it is or not. I do not think that anybody can deny the fact that the Minister for Finance has changed his policy with regard to tobacco growing in this country. It is a great pity, however, that this change of mind should be accompanied by such distress to the tobacco growers, and that it should result, as it will undoubtedly result, unless he changes it back again, in killing the enthusiasm which existed up to last year, and to a certain extent exists up to the present time, for the revival of the tobacco industry in this country. What happened really, of course, is that, in their anxiety to achieve power in 1932, the Fianna Fáil Party flung out promises wholesale, amongst which was this promise about tobacco. They fulfilled their promise for one year.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy quote the promise we made about tobacco?

Comment on this

I cannot quote it at the moment. On the other hand, I am quite sure that if I read some of the speeches made by Deputy O'Reilly in County Meath I would find the promise that great consideration would be given to tobacco growers. I could not remember even all the speeches made by the Minister in 1932.

Comment on this

Why manufacture one then?

Comment on this

He is better at manufacturing statements than I am.

Comment on this

Does the Minister deny that these promises were made?

Comment on this

Of course. these statements were made. The fact that I cannot quote a speech made by a Fianna Fáil Deputy in 1932 does not prove that they were not made. In any case, I was going to congratulate the Minister on carrying out the promise during the first year. He remitted the tax for one year. Then, when he had more experience, he found that he had to save the revenue to a certain extent, and he is now again bringing it back to the position where there is practically no protection given to tobacco growing. That hurried legislation is typical of a lot of the policy of Fianna Fáil in other respects. It would be a pity, however, if hurried legislation of that kind resulted in breeding a feeling of disgust amongst those who, no matter what Party may be in power, are genuinely interested in the promotion of such an industry as tobacco growing.

It is on that account, therefore, that I wish to support Deputy Esmonde in these amendments. If it was right to give that protection of the difference between 5/6 or 6/8 and the 9/4½, which was on the imported leaf last year, surely it should be the proper thing to keep it at that rate for this year, especially until we have a pronouncement made by the Minister for Agriculture, after due consultation with the Minister for Finance, as to the considered opinion of the Government with regard to tobacco growing here. A commission was set up before, over which the last speaker, I think, presided. That commission was limited to a certain extent. I think it had no power to consider the marketing of tobacco. Would it be unwise to suggest that, before changing the duty on tobacco back to 8/6, the Government should institute another commission of that kind to inquire into the whole system of growing tobacco, the selection of proper seeds, the cultivation of types of leaf which would succeed in attracting smokers in this country, and the marketing possibility of native-grown tobacco? If an effort of that kind were made, it would have the effect of giving a fillip to the growing of tobacco here and of persuading growers already in the industry that the Government mean to benefit the industry and not merely to get out of a promise made some years ago for the purpose of catching votes.

Comment on this

There are various kinds of tobacco growers in this country: the farmers who grow tobacco, the experimental tobacco growers, and the academic tobacco growers, such as the proposer and seconder of this amendment who know very little about tobacco—in fact, I think they know nothing.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy grown any tobacco?

Comment on this

Yes, in a window box.

Comment on this

The Deputy may be surprised to know that I was one of the original experimental growers in this country and grew tobacco every year until last year.

Comment on this

You started the country.

Comment on this

If Deputy Mulcahy had been interested in tobacco growing in the ten years prior to 1932 he might have grown tobacco to satisfy himself that the President of his Party at that time was wrong when he said that if any man told him tobacco could be grown in this country it was time to call a cab and take him to a lunatic asylum. That statement is on the records of this House. To that statement every member of that Party subscribed. For the ten years they were in office, their cry was: "It is nonsense to talk about growing tobacco; it could not possibly be grown here." They saw to it that no tobacco was grown. Now we have the academic tobacco growers attacking the Minister on his tobacco policy. They know nothing about the history of it at all. Deputy Esmonde, of course, had some academic experience of tobacco growing when he presided over that commission. He also represents an area in which a great deal of tobacco continued to be grown when it was discontinued elsewhere, and in his constituency at present, and for a number of years past, a great deal of employment has been given, not only in tobacco growing, but in the manufacture of cheroots and tobacco from pure Irish-grown leaf.

Comment on this

I think I am right in saying that there is a certain amount of tobacco grown in Meath—a little more, I think, than is grown in the Deputy's constituency of South Dublin.

Comment on this

The Deputy cannot make any definite statement. He read out from his notes suggestions from A to Z that he was going to make. What is the position? When the Government came in they decided that they would try one year of tobacco growing. They had to face the opposition of the Party opposite, who advised the people not to grow tobacco and told them it could not be grown. The Government allowed the people to grow tobacco without any restriction, and in that year a certain acreage was grown. Every person who grew tobacco during that year made a great deal more money than he ever expected to make out of the growing of any crop. That cannot be denied.

Comment on this

Some of them.

Comment on this

Every person who grew tobacco which was marketable or useable. I make this statement, which cannot be contradicted, that anybody who, in the first year of the Fianna Fáil Administration, grew tobacco which was useable for the purpose of making something to smoke, made a very great profit on what he grew. In some cases, as much as £200 an acre was made. What happened? The first year's experiment proved to the country that tobacco could be grown as a useable commodity, a marketable commodity, a profitable commodity, and the danger was that the Cumann na nGaedheal farmers who listened to the gentlemen opposite might in the following year go into the growing of tobacco as they had gone into the raising of cattle—they might have ranches of tobacco—and then we would have a country of tobacco and nothing else. The Government wisely said that they would have to restrict the growing of tobacco, not for the purpose of the revenue as the Deputy suggests but for the purpose of getting tobacco grown here on a firm basis; first of all, to decide on what classes of tobacco were to be grown; secondly, to make sure that the farmer will get a price that will pay him; and, thirdly, to see that the tobacco grown would be used in this country and thus lead on towards the aim and object of this Party, namely, that eventually a certain acreage of tobacco would be grown here and that we would go as far as possible in supplying our home requirements of tobacco. The Government then said this year, the year that is causing so much comment, that they would allow only those people who had grown tobacco in the free year to grow tobacco in the succeeding years. They limited them not only to acreage but to those who had taken a licence out in the previous year and had grown tobacco. Anybody who cannot get a licence now to grow tobacco has no grievance, because he never grew tobacco. The point is that the man in former years who thought the people who were growing tobacco were only lunatics now discovers that he was really the lunatic for not growing it. He now has a grievance. The other fellow took the risk, and the claim is now made by Deputies opposite that he should be shoved out in order to be replaced by the fellow who never grew tobacco before and who is now endeavouring to take advantage of the fine opportunity that is being offered by the Government.

Comment on this

Can the industry not expand without crushing out those already engaged in it?

Comment on this

Only a limited acreage of tobacco can be grown here to provide for the requirements of the people.

Comment on this

We will not reach that acreage very quickly.

Comment on this

The complaint of the Deputy's colleagues is that we are not allowed to reach it now. Deputy Curran says we will never reach it.

Comment on this

I never said any such thing.

Comment on this

Then what did you say?

Comment on this

I said it would be some years before you would reach it.

Comment on this

Yes, by the design of the Government. When we advance with the acreage we will be advancing with the tobacco we can use in this country. First of all, we must satisfy the manufacturers so as not to impose on them a tobacco of a different class to what they have been using. We must get the people's tastes accustomed to the home-grown tobacco and, by a gradual process, we will reach the position where our tobacco will be grown to the full limit and used here to the full limit. Deputy Mulcahy laughs. I do not think the Deputy even smokes.

Comment on this

No, he merely fumes.

Comment on this

As long as I know him I cannot say that I have seen him smoking.

Comment on this

There is quite a lot about this country that you do not know.

Comment on this

It surely will be a great loss to the people to know that Deputy Mulcahy does not smoke.

Comment on this

If he does not smoke he caused plenty of smoke in the country in his time.

Comment on this

Some other people did with petrol tins.

Comment on this

The Deputy used a good many petrol tins himself, if I know anything.

Comment on this

It is about time we stopped talking about petrol tins. Cut it out.

Comment on this

Since we came over to those benches it has been cut out.

Comment on this

Just as long as it suited you. Will there be a change when you leave?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

A change for what—for the worst again? Surely Deputy Mulcahy should be better informed in regard to tobacco. For the whole ten years when the Deputy was on this side of the House the people were not allowed to grow tobacco. Apparently there is now a threat that if the Party opposite come over here again tobacco will be prohibited.

Comment on this

When we were on the benches opposite the Minister for Agriculture or some other responsible person who knew something about it would deal with tobacco, whatever he had to say about it.

Comment on this

And when we were on the opposite benches we had some one who knew something about tobacco sitting on the Front Bench.

Comment on this

But where is he now?

Comment on this

I do not know who is your Front Bench agriculturist at the moment, whether it is Deputy Hogan of Galway, Deputy Belton or Deputy Curran. Including Deputy Brennan, there were at least three of the Deputies opposite placed in the Front Bench to deal with agriculture, but there is none of them here now to discuss agriculture or anything else.

Comment on this

Wait until you get the local elections results.

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy will himself be surprised. I hope he will not be putting forward the excuse submitted by Deputy O'Higgins, that all their voters had died and that was why they did not win. I have great sympathy with Deputy Esmonde in putting down this amendment. The reason I sympathise with him is because the leader of his Party at one time described any person who suggested the advisability of growing tobacco as a lunatic, a dangerous lunatic, and he would almost go to the extent of calling a cab immediately to have that person brought to Grangegorman. That is why I am sympathetic with the Deputy. So far as Deputy Davitt is concerned, he does not know the first thing about tobacco growing in a practical way. On the subject of tobacco, I think, if possible, greater profits should be given to the growers in Ireland, but it should be all done with a certain amount of care. Care is advisable in order that you will not have the whole country growing tobacco. We have heard Deputy Mulcahy's suggestion about the people of Dublin growing it in window boxes. Tobacco can be grown anywhere in this country, in front or back windows or in gardens.

Comment on this

It is a weed.

Comment on this

Exactly, but it is a weed that we proved could be profitably grown where Deputy Mulcahy's Party said it could not be grown. What class of weed is going to give the best results to the growers, manufacturers and users? Until we get to the most satisfactory quality of weed I think the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Agriculture are quite wise in moving slowly. Nobody is losing anything. This year I was precluded from getting a licence because I did not grow tobacco last year. I wish I could get a licence to grow an acre of tobacco.

Comment on this

The Deputy is too busy grazing.

Comment on this

I am grazing a few cattle, too, because I do not believe, as the Deputy and his colleagues do, that there is no future for some of the cattle of this country. I believe this country is going to be all right.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

So the British market is not killed?

Comment on this

Is Deputy Briscoe becoming a rancher?

Comment on this

If you graze a few cattle it does not say you are a rancher. The Deputy apparently is one of those who is very sore and sorry that I have been successful in grazing a few cattle in order to sell them to a foreign country, not England. The Deputy is one of those who felt there was no other market but England for our cattle, and there was no other place for tobacco but Virginia in America or South Africa for the Empire tobacco. Now he is grumbling because this Government has proved that good tobacco can be grown here, and that we need not depend on England.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

So well you can graze cattle when you can buy them at the very low prices now ruling, and of course, you can then sell them at a profit.

Comment on this

Deputy Lynch is talking about buying cattle at any price. When he was Minister for Fisheries——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Tobacco.

Comment on this

I am keeping to tobacco.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Two or three Deputies are persisting in interrupting. I shall not warn them again.

Comment on this

It is no harm if they bring all my private affairs to the Table of this House.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should stick to tobacco and not provoke interruptions.

Comment on this

Am I provoking them?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Tobacco.

Comment on this

I agree entirely with all that is being done by the Minister for Finance in connection with tobacco growing. Regulations will have to be made. Deputies opposite must not forget that they built up a system whereby the country receives some £1,750,000 to £2,000,000 per year by way of duties on tobacco. We are not anxious to destroy that means of indirect taxation. We are gradually building up the collection of that taxation without any disturbance of home-grown tobacco. The Deputy said that people will not grow tobacco. I throw out this challenge. If the Minister for Finance were to increase the acreage, with the present restrictions, to the extent of another 1,000 acres I will guarantee that that extra 1,000 acres would be planted immediately.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy say that I declared the people would not grow tobacco?

Comment on this

Yes. The Deputy said they would be disgusted, and the tobacco industry would be thrown back to where it was under the British.

Comment on this

I pointed out that if there was not a definite, a settled policy in relation to tobacco, the whole industry would be ruined. As far as I can calculate there is a clear profit of approximately £75 per acre on tobacco grown under present circumstances.

Comment on this

How does the Deputy arrive at that calculation?

Comment on this

If Deputy Curran wants to know, I can produce the figures for him. I will bet him an even £5 that if he will come outside the House with me I will prove to him inside half an hour that I have given him a very modest estimate.

Comment on this

I do not bet.

Comment on this

No. The Deputy says he does not bet, but he was betting what would happen to this Government when he was down shouting about the cattle. He will not bet now on this matter, because he knows he may lose the bet. I ask him to come outside the House and I will give him the figures. If I am wrong, I will give him permission to come back inside the House and say that I am wrong. Does the Deputy accept that?

Comment on this

I want to hear the figures.

Comment on this

I will give the figures to the Deputy.

Comment on this

Why keep the figures between yourself and Deputy Curran? Why not give them to the House?

Comment on this

Does any one of those tobacco growers over there know the amount of tobacco they would get per plant from tobacco?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise here. The Deputy should confine himself to the matter before the House.

Comment on this

I only want to give information to the House on this matter.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy can supply the information at the proper time.

Comment on this

Can the Deputy say how many pounds per acre can be got?

Comment on this

I am not allowed to do that.

Comment on this

Tell us how many pounds per acre.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There was a Bill dealing with this matter, and Deputies had their opportunity then of discussing every aspect of it.

Comment on this

The Deputy has been speaking of the amount of tobacco per plant. I want to know how many pounds per acre. It should be easy to make it up both ways.

Comment on this

I cannot understand the Deputy.

Comment on this

How many pounds——Interruptions.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants to know how to grow tobacco I will teach him.

Comment on this

I have grown it for the last two years.

Comment on this

Did you grow it last year?

Comment on this