We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Business. - Finance Bill, 1934—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 138–267 of 267. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1934
Enacted

No. 26 of 1934 ›

And this year?

Comment on this

How much are you going to make per acre?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must address the Chair.

Comment on this

I put a question to the Deputy that he cannot answer.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must control himself.

Comment on this

I asked a fair question and he cannot answer it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

I only asked him a question.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not entitled to ask a question by way of interruption.

Comment on this

I asked the Deputy what was the number of pounds per acre. It should be very easy to answer that question. He should not need a pencil to answer it.

Comment on this

Deputy Davitt can be satisfied, first of all, that the policy of the Government, in spite of these repeated changes, will not send the tobacco growing industry back again to nothing. Tobacco growing will continue. The Deputy's colleague over here cannot grow enough. He is growing it this year, and he will make a profit this year. As I said, if the Minister would increase the acreage you would have double the amount grown under the present circumstances, which is sufficient proof that there is nothing wrong with regard to the future of Irish tobacco. Some people, of course, will want to get the same profit as they got in the first year, when the tobacco was free of tax. That could not be allowed. What happened was that they were prepared to sell it for 3/- a lb. the first year, but when the tax was put on, the gentlemen who had held on want to get the 5/8, which would have been 8/8. I am not doubting Deputy Davitt's seriousness in putting his point, but I believe that he has been misinformed and does not understand tobacco growing from the practical side of it. When he said that the Minister for Agriculture had stated that 10,000 acres would be grown he is right, but only in so far as the Minister used the word "ultimately." The Deputy took good care to leave that word out.

Comment on this

I never said that the Minister stated it would be grown in one year.

Comment on this

The Minister said that our policy was to grow 10,000 acres of tobacco ultimately.

Comment on this

That is exactly what I said.

Comment on this

Well, then, there is no dispute between us. The Government is going to carry out that promise and to increase the acreage every year until we get the 10,000 acres which it is assumed will cover our total requirements without interfering in any way with the efficiency of the present tobacco manufacturers or discommoding or inconveniencing tobacco smokers. As far as I can see, neither Deputy Esmonde nor Deputy Davitt need worry at all. The Minister is not doing anything at all that is going to kill tobacco growing in this country. In fact, he is doing the one right thing, and that is to see that tobacco growing in this country is going to be on a fundamentally sound basis, and that from that fundamentally sound basis they are going to see that it is put on the basis of a permanent crop and not merely something that is going to come this year and go away next year. Eventually I hope to see the Minister definitely fixing the price and the quality of the tobacco that is to be grown, and to see that each year a proportion of Irish tobacco will be mixed with non-native tobacco until eventually we get a tobacco that will satisfy the needs and the requirements of the industry and the taste of the consumer, and that will cover our requirements from every point of view. If the Deputy would take my advice he would withdraw his amendment.

Comment on this

I am very glad to have had the opportunity of getting a lecture on this question of tobacco from such an authority as Deputy Briscoe. I do not know how many acres in Dublin City he has under tobacco. I know he is a man who has a lot of interests. He started his speech by telling me that I knew nothing whatever of what I was talking about, so I think I am entitled to get a little of my own back. Deputy Briscoe, of course, is an expert on gold-mining in Wicklow and motor car racing in Bray, but I did not know that he was such an expert on the growing of tobacco in the City of Dublin.

Comment on this

I was not speaking of the city but of the county.

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe questioned my figures. All I can say is that my figures were quoted mostly from the Official Reports. Certainly, the Deputy was extremely vague himself. He offered to have a side bet with Deputy Curran that he would go out with Deputy Curran outside the House and give him the figures—under the portico, I suppose—and that Deputy Curran could come back here and tell us the figures if Deputy Briscoe was wrong. Surely the House is entitled to have the benefit of Deputy Briscoe's wisdom.

Comment on this

The rules of the House do not allow it.

Comment on this

The fact of the matter is that Deputy Briscoe does not know his facts, but there is no reason why that should give him authority to criticise me, because I, in association with Deputy Esmonde, have down some amendments to the Finance Bill. I am as much entitled to do so as Deputy Briscoe is. I learned nothing from his kindly criticism except where he said that if they did not limit the number of growers in Saorstát Eireann some Fine Gael supporters might grow tobacco in such a way as to become graziers of tobacco. I think that is the word he used.

Comment on this

Tobacco ranchers.

Comment on this

Well, ranchers. Apparently, what follows from that is that the 750 growers of last year are all Fianna Fáil supporters and the policy of the Government therefore, as Deputy Briscoe said, is to keep the tobacco growers limited to that number so that no Fine Gael supporters may come in.

Comment on this

What about the Deputy on your own benches who is growing tobacco? He is one of your supporters and I am not.

Comment on this

I should like to say a brief word or two as to Government policy with regard to tobacco, since it has been raised on this amendment. It will be remembered that, in 1932, following a decade during which the cultivation of tobacco had been continuously and strongly discouraged in this country, we came into power, and in our first Budget we granted complete relief of duty in respect to Irish-grown tobacco. That was continued in last year's Budget. We felt that it was necessary to take some exceptional step—such an exceptional step as this was—in order to overcome the effect of the preceding ten years and to arouse interest once again in the cultivation of Irish tobacco. The results far surpassed our expectations, so much so that the area which was going to be brought under tobacco this year would have been so large that there would have been a great deal of difficulty in disposing of the crop, in the first instance; and secondly, the effects upon the revenue would have been serious, but more serious still, the effect of putting on the market and compelling the Irish consumer to smoke what would have been, in the circumstances in which it was produced, a very inferior product, for it might have aroused among the consumers of tobacco a complete antagonism to and distaste for the Irish article.

Accordingly, looking at all the facts as we saw them, we felt it was necessary to recast our policy, or, rather, not so much to recast our policy but to adopt a new means of attaining the end which had been enunciated for us by the Minister for Agriculture of ultimately putting about 10,000 acres under Irish tobacco. The new method by which we proposed to attain that end consists, firstly, of taking control of the growing, curing, importation and manufacture of tobacco and, should such eventuality arise, its exportation also; secondly, of making it compulsory—and this is an important element in the scheme, and it is a novel element, an element never introduced into the tobacco-growing policy in this country before—on manufacturers to purchase all marketable tobacco. It is quite true that quite a large amount of tobacco was grown last year and the year before, but one of the difficulties which we were faced with was the disposal of the crop in some instances. An important element in the new scheme is that all the crop which is marketable will be purchased by tobacco manufacturers. No man who grows a consumable article will be left with that article on his hands. Thirdly, the average price at which tobacco must be taken by the manufacturers will be fixed; and fourthly, the imported and the homegrown leaf will be put on the same footing with regard to duty, due regard being had to the costs of production. That, in short, is the scheme and a Bill is at present being drafted and will, I hope, be introduced soon, to give effect to all its provisions.

I have no doubt whatever that the scheme is acceptable to the great majority of tobacco growers—all the skilled tobacco growers at any rate, and all those who are concerned to go in for the crop on a permanent basis and not those who merely want to go into tobacco growing as a catchpenny venture to get what quick profits they can and then to get out, leaving the industry to fend for itself after they have taken their pound of flesh out of it. I say that I have every reason to believe that the new policy is going to be acceptable to the tobacco growing industry as a whole for the following reasons. It was first announced in February of this year before the seed-beds had gone in and before the plants were ready. Deputy Esmonde, I think, said that because of the change of policy on the part of the Government, communications had been received by him pointing out that the price offered was inadequate and not likely to encourage the cultivation of tobacco. The price for Irish-grown tobacco was originally fixed in February at ? per lb.—this Bill will enable the average price to be raised to ? per lb. but the original announcement was that the average price would be ?. Did the people who had been growing tobacco in the preceding years think that was an inadequate price and was the effect of the announcement to discourage the cultivation of tobacco? On the contrary, between that announcement and the end of March applications were received from over 7,000 prospective growers for licences to grow tobacco. They would have wanted to grow the 10,000 acres but, as I said, one of our problems is to secure the production of a consumable crop and accordingly, when we came to the allocation of the licences, the licences were only allocated to people who had grown tobacco in the years 1932 and 1933 as it is quite reasonable that they should.

One of the facts to which the Government, as I said, had to give consideration was the undesirability of allowing an unsuitable crop to be grown and, accordingly, we very wisely decided that only people who had previous experience would be allowed to grow it this year. We did not know what the political affiliations of those people were. We never asked what they were, and Deputy Finlay has already testified here that he is one of the people who is growing tobacco. He received a licence along with a considerable number of others, including, in County Cork, at any rate, a certain number of prominent members of the Blueshirt organisation, some of whom made as much as £200 out of tobacco last year. I merely rose to put before the House the scheme which the Government had in mind and to indicate that, before the end of the present year, a Bill which will give effect to our comprehensive proposals will be brought before the Dáil.

Comment on this

Nothing the Minister has said has altered my original contention that this amendment should be put before the House. The Minister, in his concluding remarks, stated that a Bill may be introduced before the end of this year.

Comment on this

Will be.

Comment on this

We were promised this Bill in January, in February and in March. The Minister has announced that before the Budget was introduced he received thousands of applications for licences, but I do not think he has received many since the Budget was introduced. In any case, the object of these amendments is that the status quo should be preserved until such time as the Minister produces his Bill. This is his third financial year and one might have thought that he and the Minister for Agriculture could have made up their minds as to the relative claims of the revenue and of the tobacco growing industry and could have struck a medium.

The Minister has not in his remarks contradicted the statement made by his associates throughout the country with reference to the improper control of Government policy by civil servants. It is a matter which he should approach. I am not only referring to what has been said in Meath, but to public statements made in the County Wexford and to which there has been given wide publicity—that the Minister and his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, however willing they might be, are overridden by the action of the permanent civil servants. This is a matter which really deserves an answer from the Minister. He is responsible for Government policy. According to his supporters in the country his policy is decided by permanent officials. That is a matter that should be cleared up, because it is not right.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I submit the proper place to raise matters of this sort is on my Vote. Anybody who has experience of the House should know that that is the proper place to raise it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That statement was made by certain Deputies, and Deputy Esmonde's statement is in reference to what has been said by them. I am willing to allow him to repeat it.

Comment on this

Owing to the publicity that these statements have received throughout the country I raise this matter now. The Minister is apparently unwilling to contradict the statement of his associates and supporters. Therefore we are assuming that his silence means consent. Probably he is not responsible for the policy, but that he is dominated by his civil servants.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is always responsible for his Department.

Comment on this

But he disclaims responsibility.

Comment on this

I wish to say that that is a lie. I have not disclaimed responsibility.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a term that may not be used by any Deputy or Minister.

Comment on this

I did not disclaim responsibility.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is quite a different thing.

Comment on this

Do I understand that the Minister for Finance has withdrawn the charge that Deputy Esmonde has uttered a lie?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister, I assume, has disclaimed the statement of Deputy Esmonde's that he was not responsible.

Comment on this

Whether it was untrue or not, the Minister has not assumed the responsibility and he does not disclaim the statements of his associates and supporters. I will just leave it at that because I do not think that one could do much in the way of comment on such a situation which is quite unsatisfactory from the point of view of the responsibilities of the Minister. The Minister has announced to-day the provisions of the Bill which is to come in some time before the end of 1934. Probably it will be postponed to 1935 or 1936. The provisions of this Bill include the fixing of prices and the compulsory purchase of the crop by the manufacturers in this country. It is not right for us at this stage to discuss its proposals. We can only wait for the Bill when, if ever, it arrives. The whole object of those amendments is to preserve the status quo until such time as that Bill is introduced. If we do preserve the status quo we should certainly manage to give certain concessions to tobacco growers at some slight expense to the revenue; that might hasten up the process of persuading the Executive Council to put forward their permanent proposals.

The statement made by Deputy Briscoe here would lead one to believe that the restrictions on tobacco growers were brought about because of political reasons and that there was to be a Fianna Fáil political monopoly in tobacco growing. The Minister has disclaimed that. I do not think that was the ultimate intention of the Government, but certain statements made by Deputy Briscoe were to the effect that the prohibition against extending the number of tobacco growers was in order to prevent supporters of the Opposition from becoming tobacco growers and restricting the monopoly to members of the Government Party.

Comment on this

That is not right.

Comment on this

The Deputy gave that impression. The Minister has certainly corrected him. I would not like it to go out that that is the real Government policy and that the reason why the restrictions had been brought in was in order to close the doors and to preserve the monopoly for supporters of the Government policy. During the last ten years I have on many occasions brought forward motions in this House in favour of tobacco growing. I have insisted on divisions against my own Government and I will certainly insist on a division against the present Government. I upheld the claims of the tobacco growers when the Government Party were sulking outside and not attending to the duties they undertook on behalf of their constituents. I certainly think that the Government should preserve the status quo until such time as they release their permanent scheme for the cultivation of tobacco.

Comment on this

I am not going to permit Deputies Esmonde or Davitt to misconstrue any statement of mine. What I said was that the Party opposite advised their followers not to follow our policy and not to grow tobacco. They did not, consequently, avail of the offer of the Government in the matter of tobacco growing and they got no licences in previous years. If licences are now to be given to those who grew tobacco, the majority of them will be given to Fianna Fáil supporters because they availed of our policy last year and the year before and grew tobacco. I say good luck to them. I am glad and happy about it that our supporters have got something for once.

Comment on this
Division

Question—"That the sub-sections proposed to be deleted stand"—put.

Tá 39
·
Níl 25
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Mr. Lynch

I move amendment No. 16, in the name of Deputy Morrissey and myself:—

In line 21 to delete all words after the word "persons" and substitute the words "or that the entertainment consists solely of a race or a number of races between greyhounds released from a box-trap in pursuit of a mechanical hare.

The effect of the amendment would be to relieve greyhound racing from the entertainments tax. Greyhound racing is to-day the only outdoor sport in the Saorstát subject to this tax. Section 19 after the word "persons" states "and does not involve the use or participation of horses, dogs or other animals or the use of mechanically propelled vehicles." In fact, horse racing is to-day relieved of the entertainments tax and, as far as mechanically propelled vehicles are concerned, I understand that if there are any such contests in the Saorstát now, onlookers have not to pay for witnessing them. So that it is true to say that greyhound racing is now the only outdoor sport in this country that is subject to the entertainments tax. It has been removed from horse-racing on certain extremely good grounds. But horse-racing is, after all, the sport rather of the more well-to-do part of the community. Greyhound racing is the sport of the plain common people to whom Deputy Rice referred last night. It is the sport of the poor people, the small farmers and labourers in the country districts. A concession was made in the case of horse-racing in order to give a fillip to horse-breeding, which is an important industry. Greyhound-racing is just as important to the greyhound industry as is horse-racing to the horse-breeding industry. The greyhound breeding industry is nothing to be sneered at. In 1931 our export of greyhounds had reached, in the very few years of its existence, the extraordinary figure of nearly £500,000.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

In 1931 our export in greyhounds reached in value almost half a million, and it would be fair to say if it had gone on unrestricted by the tariffs imposed across Channel it would have reached very nearly the million standard to-day. The economic war has undoubtedly been the big factor that has killed that export. But apart from England, other countries are taking to this sport. Continental countries have taken it up. I see the latest recruit is Spain, and that is a particularly friendly place in the hearts of the Front Bench opposite, especially if we are to take cognisance of the very tactful Mr. Hugh MacLean who spoke on a platform at Letterkenny last Sunday. He told us there that presumably the President's ancestors were some of those Spaniards who had helped Ireland in the past. Probably they produced the Spanish ale that brought such hope to dark Rosaleen. Anyhow, Spain has now become one of the countries that has taken to greyhound racing, and we can hope to export dogs there if the tracks throughout this country are allowed to carry on.

I think the Minister said, in the course of the Budget debate, that some 70 per cent. of the greyhound racing tracks in the country were exempt. I do not know whether the Minister had consulted anybody before he made that statement, but the fact is that every licensed track has had to pay tax. The exemption put forward on the Report Stage of the Finance Bill had no effect so far as last year was concerned. It came into operation on the 1st November when the racing season was over, so that every track in existence here got no exemption for the year 1933-34.

Comment on this

Who said it had? I did not say it.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

The Minister flourished something last year as if it were a concession. Some of those tracks have paid comparatively small amounts by way of tax, but whether the amount is small or large it is injurious to greyhound breeding. The persons who breed greyhounds are mostly very small farmers and labourers. Around a certain belt in North Kerry you will hardly find a labourer's cottage without some greyhounds about, and almost every small farmer throughout County Kerry goes in for greyhound breeding. The track at Tralee is, to all intents and purposes, their shop window. It is the only place where they can show their dogs. Running a dog carries with it a considerable amount of expense. The dog has to be trained, certain fees have to be paid for entry, and so on. Every penny taken from the tracks by way of entertainment tax means so much taken away from the prize money. They depend on winning a prize with their dogs in order to be in a position to carry on. If you reduce the prize money below some figure that would make it attractive to them, you will eventually succeed in killing greyhound breeding.

A remission of this tax will not mean such a great loss to the revenue. As the Minister admitted, it would be almost negligible. I think the Minister said the amount was about £6,000. Last year the figure was actually £8,720, most of which was paid by the two Dublin tracks. There was a sum of £6,124 paid by Shelbourne Park and Harold's Cross. Other tracks paying smaller amounts included Clonmel, Cork, Dundalk, Mullingar, Limerick, Tralee and Enniscorthy. If Tralee is liable for only £106 in the next year, presumably the £100 will be refunded, but only that amount. In the case of Shelbourne Park, Harold's Cross and Clonmel, they will be liable for the payment of substantial sums. I think the provision is that a sum not exceeding £100 will be refunded. That will still leave Clonmel, if its figure remains the same—in 1933-34 it paid £543—paying £443. That would be taken from the money available for prizes.

Comment on this

Dividends.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Or from dividends if you like. You may take it the dividends will probably be secured, and it is the prize money that will suffer, and every penny taken from it will make the racing less interesting to the persons who indulge in that sport, and it will consequently be detrimental to breeding. I cannot understand what is the mentality behind retaining this tax on greyhound-racing when it is gone in the case of horse-racing. There is no justification for it. Exactly the same arguments that were used for relieving horse-racing can be made in the case of greyhound-racing. Greyhound-breeding is an industry that was never subsidised. It never got any State help. Contrast it with the horse-breeding industry. The greyhound industry is a non-subsidised industry. It is merely looking for fair-play, and if it is put on an equal footing with other outdoor sports it bids fair to become an extremely important industry.

Comment on this

I would like to support this amendment. I think it was in the Budget debate we asked for that concession from the Minister. I understood from him that, with very few exceptions, the amount of revenue collected from greyhound-racing tracks was very small.

Comment on this

From the smaller greyhound-racing tracks.

Comment on this

I learn now that the track in my constituency, in Clonmel, which I may say I have never attended yet, has paid over £500 by way of tax. I was simply astounded to realise that it was possible for what I consider an important industry to be taxed to the extent of £500.

It was rightly said by Deputy Fionan Lynch that greyhound-racing is an industry in this country, and that the amount realised from the sale of greyhounds was very considerable; that it was a business that was likely to expand very much, but that like a good many more things, the economic war has given it a very serious setback. I notice that the Minister is smiling, but he knows that that is true. I want to tell him that in the town of Clonmel, in my constituency, it is the one industry that has been started there of recent years. It is self-supporting and employs up to 50 people. If there were another industry put up there and supported by or under the régime of the Government, what a flourish of trumpets there would be if it had given employment to the same extent! That is the one live industry that has been established there, and it is only reasonable to expect that it should get a fair deal from any Government. The least that could be expected in connection with this greyhound-racing is that it should be put on the same basis as horse-racing. The tax was withdrawn from horse-racing owing to the fact that it was found very difficult to carry on on account of the tax. I know that the present situation in connection with greyhound-racing is just the same. They are finding it very difficult to carry on, and I think that on this occasion the Minister ought to accede to our request in this amendment, and put greyhound-racing on the same basis as horse-racing and other sports.

Comment on this

I am not directly concerned with greyhounds, but with another branch of dog—gun dogs. We generally find, on the whole, that the dog-breeding industry, in both branches of greyhounds and gun dogs, is carried on by very small men on the average—very good men who pursue it purely and simply out of the native love of dogs. I am sure that that applies to greyhounds, and I know that it certainly applies to gun dogs. In connection with the training of gun dogs, a man may win an occasional stake in field trials and so on, but the winning of such stakes would never recompense him even if he trained the dogs himself, and if he did not train them himself it would simply rob the ordinary man to enter dogs for these trials. Deputy Fionan Lynch said that greyhounds are honoured by sporting men and by the poorer classes such as labouring men and small farmers. As a matter of fact, these are the classes who have put money into this, and they have done that out of pure love of dogs. If in a small place like Clonmel— small as compared with towns in England—they pay £450 annually, surely that is a very considerable sum which is taken from the poorer class of the community in order to try and maintain an industry. It may be said that there is nothing in this thing. I am of opinion that there is a whole lot in it. I saw in the newspapers where a man from the city here was fined, I think, £250 in London the other day for the smuggling of a dog, and the man who had bought the dog from him had to pay a very large sum in duty. Hence the value of the dog in that case was very considerable. Apparently the dog was smuggled across the Border and then shipped to London. Take the case of the famous dog, "Mick the Miller," and all those other famous dogs. The tariffs were not on when that dog was exported, but we can take it that we will be able to breed as good dogs in the future. If the value of such a dog can be £1,000, that is a very considerable sum of money, and it is a sum that might easily go into the pockets of a very poor man. £400 is deducted in tariffs. Does that not represent a fortune to a poor man? I think that when there is a general remission of this tax it is only right to see that it should be remitted in the case of dogs also. The dogs with which I have been connected are gun dogs. Nearly the entire export of Irish red setters was done through England, at least indirectly. That is, the people who had these huge kennels in England went to the various shows and saw Irish dogs on exhibit there and bought them from Irishmen or else put some foreign agents in contact with the Irish owner of the dog. That industry is killed now. There is not a solitary kennel worth twopence.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This amendment deals with greyhounds.

Comment on this

Yes, Sir, but I hope I am justified in relating the two classes of dogs in order to impress on the Minister the importance of this thing even in a small way. The most famous kennel for Irish red setters is wiped out. I suppose that there are not six dogs in it, and not one dog that could be exported. I think that this amendment is a genuine one and that it should be met by the Minister.

Comment on this

I only propose to deal with one or two extraordinary statements made by Deputy Lynch. He said that the value of dogs exported in 1931 was £500,000. I should like to know where he got his figures.

Comment on this

I got them from a source that, I am sure, is better informed than the Minister—from the Secretary of the Irish Coursing Club and the keeper of the Greyhound Stud Book.

Comment on this

I am not prepared to take that gentleman's statements as authentic.

Comment on this

Has the Minister any other statement to the contrary?

Comment on this

I am perfectly certain that the Deputy is not in a position to get a statement which would be authentic on the matter. At any rate, the total value in 1931 could not have exceeded £200,000, if it was that much. Then the Deputy proceeded to say that exports had been killed by the economic war.

Comment on this

What stopped the export of greyhounds was the fact that the English Government had decided to prohibit the Totalisator on the English greyhound racing tracks. Since the prohibition was partially lifted in regard to some tracks the price has gone up, so that one person alone succeeded in disposing of a number of dogs—I would not call them first-rate dogs—in the last three weeks at a good price, and the economic war is still going on.

Comment on this

But he would have got that sum plus the tariffs were it not for the economic war.

Comment on this

The fact of the matter is that the moment the British proposed to permit the Totalisator to operate on the tracks, the export trade has revived, and very substantial sums have been got for greyhounds. These greyhounds were not fed by small farmers or labourers.

Comment on this

That does not matter.

Comment on this

I am merely shattering one of the arguments advanced here. Like King Charles' head, the economic war is dragged into all this, when it has nothing to do with it. What stopped the price of greyhounds going up was the British decision to prohibit totalisators on their tracks. When speaking on the Resolution, I said, in effect, that virtually all the small tracks in this country—I did not say all tracks—are free from the greater portion of the duty. I still stand to that.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

You suggested all the licensed tracks, of which there are ten.

Comment on this

I said that virtually all the smaller ones, the ones outside the large cities, have been virtually released of this duty. It is quite clear that some of them in the end will not have to pay any duty this year. They have to pay duty in the first instance, but they claim exemption, and get a rebate up to £100, if they fulfil the terms. An attempt has been made to draw an analogy between our treatment of greyhound racing and the treatment of horse racing. The fact is this, that greyhound racing is an entertainment, just the same as horse racing. The difference between them is that when we came into office we found horse racing in so perilous a state that virtually all the race meetings were losing money. That does not apply to greyhound meetings. Most of the tracks have made substantial profits, and as they are entertainments, making substantial profits, why should we forego the Entertainment Tax? The plea was made that the smaller tracks met the needs of small farmers and labourers, because they were living close to these meetings, and that these were tracks upon which the puppies could get preliminary trials, before the owners decided to send them to Dublin, or before they attracted sufficient attention to induce other people to pay the tax and to bring them to run in Dublin or Cork. In order to meet that objection, we granted a concession last year, and substantially relieved the smaller tracks of the Entertainments Tax. For the others, there are no such reasons. They have been making substantial profits. If dogs are any good they will be sent there to run. As Deputies know very well, the attraction is not the prize money but the amount which might be secured by betting, and by the price subsequently got for the dogs. In any event, we have not any guarantee that if the Entertainments Tax was taken off the prizes would be increased. We never had any guarantee to that effect, nor have we had proof that the prizes have been reduced owing to the incidence of the Entertainments Tax. The sport is as popular as ever. The same numbers go to see it. The majority of the people who go to these tracks do not own dogs, and do not go because they are interested in dogs. They are interested in getting good bets and in picking winners. It is they would be relieved, and not greyhound breeders. The people who go there for entertainment would be relieved. And, since greyhound racing is an entertainment, it is a proper subject for this tax. As the attendance at the meetings is substantial, and as many tracks are making substantial profits, there is no reason why we should forego the amount of tax we are getting out of it.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

The Minister has made some extraordinary statements. He challenged my figure of £500,000, although he has nothing whatever to put forward in the way of a figure. I quoted the man who keeps the Greyhound Stud Book, who is secretary of the Irish Coursing Club, and who is an authority on Irish greyhound racing. He should be in a position to know what he is talking about. He says that in 1931 our export figure for greyhounds was in the neighbourhood of £500,000, and he estimates that were it not for other matters, which have arisen since, presumably the decision as to the totalisator, to which the Minister referred, and including the economic war, the figure for exports would be £1,000,000. The Minister says that the economic war has nothing whatever to do with this matter, that it was like King Charles' head brought into everything. Is the Minister suggesting that seriously? The Minister mentioned a person who had sold dogs in the last few weeks at a good figure. Does he seriously contend that that man got the same price that he would have got if there was no economic war? Does he seriously suggest that the person who bought the dogs did not deduct from the purchase price the amount that had to be paid in tax? It is rubbish to suggest that he did.

Comment on this

I can assure the Deputy, from the knowledge I have of this transaction, that if that person had asked twice as much as he did ask he would have got it without difficulty. I happen to know that.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

I met very few fools dealing in dogs. The Minister says that virtually all the small tracks have been relieved of all duty. I will give some figures.

Comment on this

We are talking about this year. I said they have been relieved.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

The Minister said that these tracks will get a rebate to the extent of £100.

Comment on this

Some have got very substantial rebates in the present year.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

In the year 1934-35 the rebate they can get is not to exceed £100.

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

We will assume that Clonmel will be as well patronised as it was last year, when £543 was paid in entertainments tax. Supposing there is the maximum rebate of £100, Clonmel would still have to pay £443.

Comment on this

Clonmel is not one of the small tracks.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Next in order is Cork which paid £526 last year. I suppose it will have to pay £426 this year. Dundalk paid £406 last year. Supposing it keeps at the same figure it will pay £306, allowing for £100 as a rebate. Mullingar paid £370 and will now pay £270; Limerick with £392, will pay £292. Enniscorthy paid £121 last year. That is one track which will benefit by having to pay only £21. Galway paid £190 but will only pay £90, and Tralee, which paid £106, will only pay £6 if they keep at the same figure. There are three tracks, Enniscorthy, Galway and Tralee, out of the ten tracks which will be largely relieved of the entertainments tax. The remaining seven licensed tracks will continue to pay very big sums.

Comment on this

I said smaller tracks.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

There are eight small tracks, outside of Shelbourne Park and Harold's Cross. As a matter of fact, Clonmel is bigger than Cork from the point of view of entertainments tax. Five of these will not be relieved to any great extent. If Galway keeps to the same figures it will be relieved to the extent of 50 per cent. of what it paid last year. I do not consider this rebate as of great relief to the industry as a whole. The Minister said the position in regard to horse-racing was different, and he adumbrated an extraordinary principle. He said that they found that horse-racing was being carried on at a loss at various race meetings. No industry is to be given a fillip, or a leg up in the way of putting it on an equal footing with other sports, as this one undoubtedly is, unless it is dying. If an industry has been able to stand on its own feet and to develop without a subsidy on the capital invested and without any Government help, then it is to be kicked as much as possible. But a subsidised industry, which may also be a sport, if it is sufficiently moribund may get relief. I think we ought to see that an industry such as greyhound breeding should get every encouragement. I would be more inclined to encourage it than even horse-racing, because of the fact that, unlike horse-racing, it has never required a subsidy and it is never likely to require one. All that it requires is that it should get a fair chance just as other forms of sport.

I do not at all agree with the Minister that the attraction of greyhound racing is not the prize money but the bet which a man is going to have. I know a big number of persons who run dogs on the Tralee track, labourers, and I can tell the Minister perfectly plainly that they breed very good dogs and get very good prices for them. If the Minister said that the attraction in racing was to show how their dogs could run, I might agree with him. The attraction of the greyhound racing track is that it is the shopwindow, as I said before, for their products. It is the place where they can display their dogs and where agents from abroad are present to see how the dogs shape on the tracks. That is the main attraction but a very large part of the attraction is the prize money because these men could not afford to run their dogs-afford the entrance fee, etc.—if there was not some hope of winning a prize or if there was not a fair likelihood of winning a prize or two during the season. The betting end, as far as most of the breeders are concerned, is negligible because most of them could not afford to have a five shilling bet on their greyhounds. I have been on a greyhound track only three or four times in my life but I understand that the odds one gets on dogs are very small. You rarely get three to one on any dog, unless he has no earthly chance. Betting is not the attraction. The prize money is the attraction. No matter what the Minister says there is no question of doubt that the entertainment tax has interfered with the amount of prize money. Naturally, these are commercial concerns and I wish them well of it, if they are able to pay dividends. They certainly have a right to see that they get dividends on the money they have invested. Nobody can find any fault with them for that. Of course they will continue to see that their dividends are paid. The dividends will be the last things presumably to suffer. The prize money will certainly suffer before the dividends suffer and when the prize money suffers greyhound breeding will also suffer.

Comment on this
Mr. Lynch

Will the Minister allow a free vote?

Comment on this
Division

The Committee divided: Tá,

Tá 40
·
Níl 24
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 17:—

Before Section 33 to insert as a new Part of the Bill a new section as follows:—

PART IV.

Corporation Profits Tax.

Section 52 (which relates to charge of corporation profits tax) of the Finance Act, 1920, as amended by subsequent enactments is hereby repealed and it is hereby enacted that no corporation profits tax shall be chargeable, leviable or paid in respect of any accounting period ending after the passing of this Act.

In moving this amendment I would point out to the Minister that the corporation profit tax is really an anachronism. It was introduced during the war period and was really an additional income tax. At the time it was called a corporation profit tax and put on industry, when industry was making good profits, in order that the Government might be able to say that the income tax was no more than 5/- in the £. Now times have changed and in other places the corporation profit tax has been abolished. The position here is that, with the 4/6 income tax and 6d. corporation profit tax, there is really a 5/- income tax on industry at a time when industry is not doing very well. It hits manufacturing firms in this country exceedingly hard, because it has to be paid out of the residue of their profits, and, really, comes out of a fund which is very largely used to finance extension, repairs to plant, etc. I would like to appeal to the Minister to take this into account. Some Irish manufacturing firms go even further than this and consider that Irish manufacturers should be granted more extended privileges than they enjoy at present, and that they should receive favourable consideration in income tax and various other matters. While I agree with them, at the same time this is a tax that I might describe as a flagrant injustice at the present. I would like to urge the Minister to consider how far he is really hitting industry in this country by continuing this tax. Many firms have to go to considerable cost to prove that they are exempt from corporation profit tax, and, although the procedure is very largely along the lines of the income tax procedure, still it is not the same. Considerable sums have to be expended, even where firms are not liable. I would like to urge upon the Minister, taking all these circumstances into account, that the time has arrived when the corporation profit tax should be abolished.

Comment on this

A good deal might be said to justify the retention of this tax upon its merits and, consequently, to justify the rejection of the amendment. But I think the really practical argument is that if we were to accept this amendment it would mean that we should have to sacrifice over £400,000 of revenue. I think that renders the proposition an impracticable one from my point of view.

Comment on this

I think it is high time that this tax was justified upon its merits, if it has any merits. The fact that the tax produces £400,000 in revenue is not sufficient excuse for it. It appears to me to be an unjust tax and an inexpedient tax in a country which is trying to organise an industrial revival. If there is anything to be said for the tax on its merits, the Minister ought to say it.

Comment on this

It has 400,000 good points.

Comment on this

By that remark the Minister has confessed that, to all intents and purposes, there is nothing to be said for it except that it produces £400,000.

Comment on this

A good deal more could be said for it, but I do not think that it is necessary to waste the time of the House saying it.

Comment on this

The time of the House is valuable, but it is not so valuable as all that. There is nobody engaged in industry who does not regard this corporation profits tax as an outrage. It appears to me to be a penalty on people who wish to use their money in a specially productive way. It taxes the same profits twice over. It seems to me to be an immoral and unjustifiable tax, and, if the Minister has anything to say for it on its merits, it is time he said it.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 28
·
Níl 41
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 18:—

In the second column opposite reference No. 4 after the word "character" to add the words "but excluding boilers forming an integral part of a range or grate at the time of importation."

I would like to know if these reference numbers are going to be taken separately. May I speak now only to reference No. 4?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We will take No. 4 for the present.

Comment on this

The Minister is here putting a duty on boilers and cylinders. When those are made in the country I shall not have a word to say against protection being afforded to them, but I want to put this to the Minister: that a number of ranges and grates which are not manufactured here are being imported. At the moment there does not seem to be any prospect of their being manufactured here. I would like to point out to the Minister that the boiler dealt with here could not be manufactured in this country. It would mean that special tools and appliances would have to be made for a very small number of special boilers if a decision to manufacture were come to. In opposing the amendment the Government are really only adding to the cost of a building without in any way promoting industry. There is no use, I would point out, in giving Irish industry a bad name by putting up the cost of items coming here and which cannot be made here at the moment. In saying that, I am not suggesting to the Minister that if certain types of ranges and grates are about to be manufactured here he should not extend his preference to them if the boilers are also going to be made in the country.

Comment on this

It was not intended that the duty in reference No. 4 should apply to boilers which were an integral part of a range or grate, and I understand that the reference was so interpreted by the Revenue Commissioners. On examination, however, it does appear that there is a doubt as to what is the proper interpretation of the reference, and in order to remove that doubt I am prepared to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I desire to make some observations on reference Nos. 5 and 6. Reference No. 5 deals with "articles of any of the following descriptions made wholly or mainly of galvanised wrought iron or galvanised steel," and then follow a number of items. Reference No. 6 deals with "cast-iron articles," and then follow a number of items. I would like to point out to the Minister that, apparently, galvanised cast-iron is not provided for at all, and would, therefore, appear to be duty free. In reference No. 6 there is mention of "smoke pipes, ventilation pipes and other similar pipes." That is cast-iron. Apparently, wrought iron smoke pipes would be free. I would like the Minister to consider these two points. I take it also that the articles under reference No. 5 are subject to a 30 per cent. duty, and those under reference No. 6 to a duty of 25 per cent. I take it that the emergency duty on steel is gone, and that there is no question of an after duty. I should like the Minister to deal with that point. I take it that these are the only duties these items are subject to.

Comment on this

In so far as the Deputy's remarks relate to reference No. 5, it is correct that the duty does not apply to galvanised cast-iron goods. It applies only where wrought iron or steel galvanised is used in the construction work. With reference to his remarks on reference No. 6, it is correct that the emergency duty no longer applies to these goods. In so far as the general emergency duties on manufactures of steel are concerned, they apply only to machinery. It does not apply to any of the items enumerated in that reference.

Comment on this

What about wrought iron smoke pipes? These would not be covered?

Comment on this

No. They are free.

Comment on this

Might I point out that the wording leaves that doubtful. If a thing is cast-iron, it remains cast-iron, whether it is galvanised or ungalvanised.

Comment on this

There are two references. The items from (a) to (g) at reference No. 5 are dutiable when they are galvanised wrought iron or galvanised steel, and at reference No. 6, cast-iron articles of the type set out.

Comment on this

The ordinary interpretation of cast-iron would be anything that is cast-iron whether it is galvanised or ungalvanised. I suggest that the Minister should look into the point, because it is open to question on the present wording. Provided that the article is cast-iron, it remains cast-iron, and, under the strict wording of that Schedule, is liable to duty, whether galvanised or ungalvanised. It is cast-iron still, whether galvanised or not.

Comment on this

I take it, following Deputy Thrift's remarks, that that would be so if they were not in two separate sections, but the Minister obviously treats galvanised articles as one section—and I think I know the reason for that—and cast-iron articles as another section.

Comment on this

I am not challenging the Minister's interpretation. I have no doubt that what is intended is that it should be galvanised wrought iron and ungalvanised cast-iron, but I suggest that the meaning of the English word "cast-iron" is that so long as it is cast-iron, it remains so, whether you galvanise it or not, and as cast-iron galvanised, in the strict interpretation of the words, it becomes liable to duty. I think that a change in the wording to show the Minister's intention is necessary.

References 5 to 12 inclusive, agreed to.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 19:—

In the second column opposite reference No. 13 to insert the words "or educational" before the word "nature".

I do not want to take very long over this, particularly because I think the principle underlying the words I propose for insertion is already admitted. That is made perfectly clear in various places in our Finance Acts, but I think the words, as they appear in reference No. 13, "technical or scientific" would be improved by the addition of the words "or educational". The word "educational" only brings in films which are of the same character as the technical or scientific ones, but I think that the word is necessary to make it explicit. Of course, I should like to go a great deal further and press on the Minister that this particular tariff is one of the most irritating and vexatious of tariffs, while being productive of very little useful result. These films are very frequently used in ordinary parochial work. They are used sometimes for mere entertainments and very frequently for entertainments of a semi-educational nature and often for entertainments of a truly educational nature, and it is extremely vexatious to find, when you want to get up some small semi-educational entertainment, that your costs are raised because you must import from abroad slides of that particular kind. They are not made here at all, and they are frequently used for such lectures as I am referring to. The position, however, would be improved if the Minister would agree to the insertion of the words I suggest.

Comment on this

I think the introduction of the words, instead of having the effect of making the definition explicit, as the Deputy suggests, would have quite the contrary effect. The term "educational" is obviously a very wide term, and could be used to cover a multitude of things. We are excluding from the scope of the duty slides or films of a technical or scientific nature, and that, I think, is as far as we could go, leaving it to the Revenue Commissioners to determine what is a slide or film of a technical or scientific nature. Apart altogether from the administrative difficulties that would arise from the use of a general term, such as the Deputy suggests, there is the fact that Saorstát firms engaged in the production of these goods, for whose benefit this duty has been imposed, claim to be in a position to supply whatever educational slides and films may be required.

Comment on this

They are not doing it.

Comment on this

We have not had any reason to doubt their claim in that regard as yet. The main objection, however, to the Deputy's amendment is the administrative difficulties that would arise from the insertion of such a very general term as the Deputy suggests. I think he can rely on the fact that the Revenue Commissioners will give a liberal interpretation to the words that are, in fact, used.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider adding the word "artistic"?

Comment on this

That is a still more general term.

Comment on this

I hope the phrase will be interpreted very liberally. I have a letter here drawing attention to a real grievance that arises in this matter. It is a letter which says:—

"I use these slides for popular lectures on animals and birds for children's entertainments. They are now liable to a duty of 33? per cent. A large number of the slides are used by people I know, and many of them are simply not to be got over here."

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Is the Deputy withdrawing the amendment?

Comment on this

I wonder would the Minister consider making it clearer?

Comment on this

I can vouch for the liberality of the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

I will take that.

Reference No. 13 agreed to.

References Nos. 14 to 21, inclusive, agreed to.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 20:—

In the second column opposite reference No. 22 after the word "towelling" but within the bracket to insert the words "and webbing cloths used in the manufacture of collars and fancy piqué used in the manufacture of dress shirts."

Yesterday we dealt with some of the general aspects of the effect of the Minister's general proposal on the shirt manufacturing industry and, to some extent, I dealt with the class of industry that is carried on in the City of Dublin. This amendment proposes that there shall be excluded from the tax "webbing cloths used in the manufacture of collars and fancy piqué used in the manufacture of dress shirts." The Minister declares that licences will be issued to persons until such time as they are able to get the material that is tariffed here in the ordinary way. Whatever may be said about the fabrics that were mentioned yesterday, it is stated very explicitly by people in the shirt industry, and who have been in touch with manufacturers, that the fabrics mentioned in this amendment have no chance of being produced here, the market for them is so small and the cost of production would be so great and that the fact that, to a large extent, that part of the shirt industry which is using these, particularly here, is dependent for its well-being on a certain amount of export trade means that the tariff remaining on those particular classes of goods is going to do them a very considerable amount of harm. The people who were particularly affected and who I understand are affected in the whole of their trade very much are the Donegal shirt manufacturers who make the better class of tunic and shirt collars. They have already approached the Minister and laid their case before him. They want exemption from duty in respect of linen for dress shirts and webbing cloths for collars and marcella fabric for dress shirts. The immediate difficulty that some of these manufacturers suffer under is enormous. I told the Minister yesterday that there are firms here in which the workers are standing idle because they cannot get the material for which they are waiting and which is not a large part of the material used. The Minister was very emphatic yesterday in saying that if persons did not get licences and get them rapidly it was their own fault. I have here a long statement from a Donegal firm, in which they say that they applied for a licence on the 4th June for five pieces of webbing for the making of collars and at the time of writing—12 days afterwards—they had not got an acknowledgment of their application. That manufacturer told me this morning that on the 16th June, 12 days after, he had written to the Minister for Finance without having received an acknowledgment he wrote again. He has had no acknowledgment of the second letter since. Here is a man who is dealing with the export trade in which he gets ten days for delivery of the goods and he is waiting now since the 4th June for a licence to get some of his material coming to him to carry on his business and he has no acknowledgement from the Minister for Finance. The Minister has had represented to him by people engaged in the trade that those goods set out in this amendment are not made here and are not likely to be made here in view of the amount of stuff likely to be used. The part of the industry that is particularly hit is that part of the industry depending upon exports. In imposing a tariff like this and doing it in this particular way and giving this industry the kind of shock that it is getting now, the Minister ought to bear in mind the type of industry with which he is dealing and the history of it.

The position with regard to the shirt making industry is that in 1924, before the original tariff was put on, there were 410 persons employed in shirt-making. That is, the employment given in the shirt-making industry was equivalent to 410 whole-time employees. At that time there were imports of shirt material to the extent of £345,000. The previous Administration put on a tariff and the number of persons employed in the industry rose very rapidly so that in September, 1926, instead of 410 persons there were 1,572 persons employed. The imports of shirts had fallen in that year to £105,000. There was a general kind of fluctuation and a gradual rise until in September, 1930, the total number employed was 1,844 persons. The imports for the year 1930 were £59,000; so that you had an increase in the shirt-making industry from 410 to 1,844 persons between 1924 and 1930. Then there was a slight fluctuation downwards and there were 82 persons less employed in September, 1931. The position with regard to the industry in the country in 1931 was that we imported that year £64,000 and we exported £75,000 worth of shirts.

The Minister I think will generally agree that as far as the market here was concerned, beyond a certain amount of imports that might be cut off, nevertheless, we balanced all the imports to a greater extent so that the situation here was saturated as far as the industry was concerned and there was not much room for expansion. During the last few years there has been a certain amount of expansion. According to the Minister's latest returns the total number of persons employed in September last was 2,066 or an increase over the 1931 figures of 280 persons. But it is an industry saturated like that, dependent on an export market and situated in a district which the Minister will admit cannot very easily be provided for by any other type of industry, that is being hit.

The position with regard to our exports has been that the exports for shirts for 1929 was £67,000; 1930, £83,000; 1931, £75,000; 1932, £38,000 and 1933, £13,000; so that during the last two years the exports have fallen from £75,000 to £13,000. We have one particular branch of the industry and an important branch situated in Donegal and this portion of the industry is to a large extent depending on its export market to enable it to carry on; yet it is being prejudiced at this time of the year and terribly upset by the imposition of tariffs. In the matter of an essential part of their material, however small, they are going to be tied up looking for licences quite unnecessarily or they are to be forced to accept a class of material which is not the class that they are expected to use and which will be dearer than that which they are accustomed to use. They are being forced into this position when they are competing in the outside market for the better class tunics.

If the Minister will turn to the issue of the Trade Journal for January, which is not the latest issue, he will see that there are 17 shirt factories in Dublin, 9 in Cork and 14 in Donegal. No doubt the same complaint will be made by the collar makers in the City of Dublin as is made by the Donegal manufacturers at the present time. The Donegal manufacturers have a terrible grievance. If the Minister is going to take reasonable precautions to attract their export trade there is no other way out of it but to remove this type of fabric from his Schedule. I cannot say how much the total value of the imports of that material would amount to. But compared with the Harvard shirt, the Oxford shirt and the Drill shirt the import of this particular stuff will be negligible as far as the cost is concerned. As far as these other items run the whole cost of the imports as shown by the 1929 Census returns runs to about £60,000. They are the main shirtings used, particularly in the City of Dublin where the heavier shirts are turned out. The others are only the webbing and stiffening for particular classes of shirts and collars. The effect on the manufacturing trade here of the new cotton goods can be nothing, but the amount of upset which can be done to an industry which, I suggest, is in a somewhat perilous position or can be easily put in a somewhat perilous position, is very great.

Comment on this

I rise to a point of order. This is certainly a record. I see the Minister for Industry and Commerce sitting there with empty benches behind him and no member of the Labour Party present.

Comment on this

It shows the absolute confidence they have in the Minister.

Comment on this

Is the Minister accepting the amendment?

Comment on this

The Deputy's case is based on the information supplied to him that the licensing section of the Department of Industry and Commerce is not functioning as efficiently as it should. These cloths are not made here, but a licence can be got for their importation and any firm engaged in the manufacture of shirts and collars requiring this importation can get a licence for that purpose without difficulty. It would be impossible to accept the amendment in so far as it affects webbing cloths, because the definition is one which those responsible for the administration of the duties would not be prepared to accept, as they could not identify the cloth contemplated. It is to meet definition difficulties of that kind that the licensing provision is there, as well as to provide for the temporary importation of the other classes of cloth until home production has been increased to the point at which it can supply the home demand. The position might be different in respect of piqué cloth, but I hardly think it is worth while to provide for the specific exemption of that cloth from duty, in so far as the licensing provision has been operating to permit of free importation. That is a matter which can be examined further.

The principal item to which the Deputy has referred is the webbing cloth and it is not possible to get for the cloth which is used by collar manufacturers a precise definition which would permit of its identification from all other cloths to which that definition might apply. The Deputy can be assured that if there has been any temporary delay, due to absence or illness of staff, in the licensing section—and I am not aware of any—it will be very speedily remedied and firms dealing with that section of the Department will have their representations very expeditiously attended to.

The particular case to which the Deputy referred of a firm in Donegal, who wrote to the Department and received no reply for ten days, is one which I should like to investigate, and if the Deputy will give me the name of the firm I will be very glad to look into the matter and find out what is the cause of the delay in that particular case. On the whole, I must say that very few complaints of the kind are received in the Department, which is a noteworthy fact, having regard to the position which arises immediately after the imposition of new classes of duties in each Finance Act, when a number of people, who never before had experience of dealing with the Department in these matters, came for the first time seeking facilities, and occasionally caused delay by not knowing the precise procedure to adopt. The procedure, however is rapidly regularised, and so far as I know the staff of that Department is quite adequate to deal with the work coming to it at present.

Comment on this

The Minister seems to admit the position. Here we have in County Donegal a most important industry being strangled because of the limitations of an alien language. The Minister cannot, within the framework of the English language, provide a description for a certain type of cloth that must be very well known to the manufacturers and could easily be very well known to the revenue officials. I think we might leave the question of licences aside for the moment. If there is a case for exempting this class of cloth from the tariff list, because the amount imported is very small, because the likelihood of its being made here is very slight, because if there was a likelihood of its being made here the profit to the manufacturers would be very small compared with the rest of their trade, then there certainly is a case for making a clean sweep of that fabric from the tariff list when the Minister takes into consideration the interests involved in it. There is no doubt, from all I can hear, that the interests of the Donegal manufacturers as a whole are very seriously jeopardised by the difficulties they are going to be placed in with regard to these cloths. In the first place, if there is an attempt to manufacture them here, they will have to be bought at the prices and in the qualities made here. I do not think that the matter has been sufficiently considered.

Comment on this

I will undertake to consider it further and see if we can get a definition which will exempt them. I think that can be done for the piqué cloth all right, but I am not very hopeful about the webbing cloth. We can administer the licensing system with a certain amount of elasticity, but once you put a definition in the Act it becomes much more difficult to administer it if there is any looseness in the definition. In so far as we put anything in the Schedule, it must be a precise definition about which there must be no uncertainty. That is why we prefer to operate the licensing provision rather than have a definition. If the Deputy will leave the matter over I will consider it.

Comment on this

I shall leave the matter over to give the Minister an opportunity of having a further consultation with the manufacturers concerned in the matter.

Comment on this

With regard to reference No. 22, I want to mention that we propose on the Report Stage to insert in the fourth column of the Schedule certain words which will exempt bookbinding cloth from the scope of the duty.

Comment on this

With regard to reference No. 39—whiting—I should like to point out to the Minister that he has put a duty of £1 per ton on this article. No doubt that is with the object of encouraging the native product, but there seems to be some doubt as to whether the native product will be suitable for putty in all instances. I suggest to the Minister that he ought to look into that and see how far he can stand over the native product for all the uses for which whiting is intended. I am not in any sense asking him to come to a decision at the moment, but I am asking him to look into the question.

Comment on this

We delayed imposing this duty on whiting for some time, while certain experiments were being carried out with the Clare product. The stage has now been reached when we can say that the whiting is suitable for most purposes, but there is some doubt still as to whether it is altogether satisfactory for use in connection with the manufacture of putty, although there is reason to think it is when mixed with certain proportions of imported whiting. At present we permit under licence the importation of whatever quantities of whiting are required in the manufacture of putty, and we will continue to do so until it is clear that the Clare whiting can be used without difficulty.

Comment on this

With regard to reference No. 40, I take it that the articles that are not going to be manufactured in this country are going to be imported free under licence?

Comment on this

I refer to aluminium.

Comment on this

Yes. At present all requirements are being allowed in under licence in normal quantities because production has not yet commenced.

Schedules 1 to 8, inclusive, and the Title agreed to. Fourth Stage fixed for Tuesday, 26th June.

Comment on this