We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Bill, 1934—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–217 of 439. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Bill, 1934
Enacted

No. 47 of 1934 ›

Sections 19 and 20 are being taken together.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The discussion is on Section 19. I presume there will be no debate on Section 20.

Comment on this

The Minister summed up his Second Reading speech by saying that the problem was one of surplus cattle. I would like to ask him, under Section 19, where he proposes to employ 130 supervisors? Are they the inspectors who are mentioned in this section?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

One hundred and twenty of them are.

Comment on this

And there are ten supervisors, a rank above the remaining 120?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

They are for another purpose.

Comment on this

You will let loose 120 inspectors to mark cattle. What is the need for marking them? What need is there in a country where you have a surplus of cattle to hold them until they reach a certain standard of maturity? Obviously the marking means that, before a fixed date, they cannot be slaughtered. If it were the opposite, that before the fixed date they must be slaughtered, I could see some sense in it, in the case of a surplus. If we had a scarcity of cattle, then I could see reason in the Minister's marking, that before a fixed date they should not be slaughtered until they would be thoroughly matured. If the public taste is satisfied to have them before they are matured, is it not all the better, particularly when we have a surplus? Two or three months ago the Minister found himself authorising the slaughter of 120,000 calves. If he was right then, what sense is there in asking inspectors to mark cattle so that they cannot be slaughtered until after a certain date? I do not see how that serves the purpose that the Minister would seem to have in mind; in fact, I do not see what purpose it serves at all.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It is little use making a Second Reading speech in this House, apparently. That matter was very fully dealt with. I do not know whether Deputy Belton's memory is a bit defective or whether he is inclined to prolong this discussion. I said on Second Reading that there are likely to be times when there may be too many cattle offered for sale, but they could be disposed of if they were carried forward for a period, as happened last spring. The same thing may occur in September or October; we may have too many at one particular period, and by keeping them back we may eventually be able to deal with them all. These marking provisions will only come into operation from time to time. I hope they will not come into operation at all, but it may be necessary to bring this part of the Bill into operation at certain times.

The marking provisions will be necessary in case there is a surplus or a shortage of cattle. In the event of a surplus, it will be necessary to allow butchers to slaughter only the best and most matured cattle, so that we may inflict the least amount of hardship. It will be our endeavour to take the best finished cattle off the farmers' hands, if there is a surplus. If there is a shortage there is also power in the Bill to limit the number that may be killed. I do not know if that provision will be necessary, but it may be. That covers the case in relation to the necessity of marking. Suppose there are 10,000 cattle that the farmers would like to sell for slaughter, and we find we can use only 7,000, is it not reasonable that we would pick out the best finished cattle and let them be slaughtered first? The man with the best finished cattle will get out first, and the man whose cattle will improve in three weeks will be enabled to dispose of them at the end of that period. That is the reason for the marking.

Comment on this

Does the Minister intend to put the marking provision into operation at once?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Not at once.

Comment on this

Then what are the 120 inspectors for?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I stated already that the 120 would be necessary for the other provisions of this Act. That is to say, that they would have to look after matters connected with the fixed prices; they would have to examine, when called upon to do so, any complaints in that respect, and also complaints in connection with the free meat part of the Bill. These are the principal headings under which the inspectors will be required, if the marking provisions are not necessary. If the marking provisions are brought in we will probably want 300 inspectors. This estimate is on the basis that we are not going to introduce the marking provisions—that marking will not be necessary. I hope it will not be necessary to operate this part of the Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister says that if we take as an instance 1,000 cattle that are for sale, and we want only 700, it is only fair to take the 700 that are the most mature, and to kill them, and then carry over our surplus to another period. The Minister knows well that we always have a surplus of fat cattle. He knows also that under the operation of this provision, if it is carried out mathematically, every beast suitable will be finished in the last batch, and consequently the surplus will be increased. The feeders will come under the operation of the law of diminishing returns, and they will be feeding at a loss.

The Minister, instead of solving the problem that he has persuaded himself he has set out to solve, is only making the problem bigger, and is not solving it at all. I still cannot see what useful purpose the marking of cattle will serve. Take 10,000 fat cattle, each of which is within two and a-half or three per cent. of being finished cattle. Obviously they will feed more people than 10,000 cattle which are little better than three-quarters fat. The Minister's reason, as I said before, would be perfectly sound, and I would agree with it, if we were short of cattle. But we have a surplus, and the longer we keep the cattle the more surplus we will have. Instead of getting rid of the cattle before they are heavy, and contain so much meat, the Minister wants to stop us by marking, and allowing nothing but the finished beasts to be slaughtered. He is there increasing the quantity, lowering the profit, and increasing the problem that he is trying to solve, namely, how this country is to dispose of its surplus fat stock. The Minister need not think that I want to stop or delay this Bill, but I simply cannot see any reason in this section. The explanation he has given only puzzles me still further as to the common-sense actuating the Minister in putting up such a provision in any circumstances unless there is a of a meat shortage. If there is a danger of a meat shortage, then every beast standing on four legs should be fed up to the maximum so as to produce the maximum amount of meat. No beast should be killed while he is capable of being increased by another cwt. or even by 10 lbs. In view of the existing surplus the Minister is trying to get rid of 120,000 calves, throwing them into a pit, and getting 6d. per animal for their skins. This section is the most illogical proposal I ever heard put forward by any Minister.

Comment on this

I can assure the Minister I do not want in any way to obstruct this Bill, but as one who will be affected I am very much interested in it. On the question of marking of cattle, what is going to happen in the case of the second and third-class cattle?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Wait until they are finished.

Comment on this

But "finished" does not constitute first-class quality beef; you may have a beast of which you may never make first quality. I am merely looking for information in this matter. When the butcher comes he will want the best, and will take the best. Anticipating a surplus, the inspector says these may wait as they are second and third-class. But the owner may not be able to improve those beasts so as to make the best out of them, and so he carries them over. Then something may happen as happened last winter when the restrictions came out. A number of us had a number of fat cattle, and expected to get licences. The result was that the cattle were, as they say in farmer's language, "eating their heads off." We had to dispose of them for anything we could get, and, indeed, practically gave them away. If we are to have these cattle, and feed them, for another two months, we will have to carry them over, and we will be losing on them all the time.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

There is nothing in this section of the Bill about first or second-class cattle. It deals with finished cattle. If they are second-class cattle, but finished, they can be marked. Obviously if you cannot do more, you finish them.

Comment on this

I must be dense if I have not been able to grasp the point that the Minister has made a couple of times, that it is only in exceptional circumstances that Part IV. of the Bill will be put into operation.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is so.

Comment on this

What are the special circumstances?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Whenever they arise.

Comment on this

Does it not follow as a matter of course?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No. The fixed price can operate with the marking.

Comment on this

I am looking for information, and I am trying to understand this section. I would be glad to see an end of the Bill, one way or another, and so would more than I. But I cannot see while we have a surplus of cattle, the necessity for the marking of them in order to keep them up to the maximum limit. Any attempt the Minister has made to clarify that does not convince me. Does not the Minister agree that the longer you keep cattle and finish them the more meat there will be?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

But the better meat you will have.

Comment on this

The Minister's problem is one of surplus meat. Is he not increasing his problem the more meat he has? When there is danger of an increased surplus any practical man will tell you that to get rid of your cattle before that stage will leave you with more money. Why charge something upon the owners of that stock by making them keep their cattle for a certain period? If they do so they are losing money and your problem is only made bigger. I think that is quite clear. I do not want to corner the Minister on it; it is a matter of business. There are two Deputies here with more practical experience of the live stock business than I have— Deputy Curran and Deputy Haslett. I am sure they will corroborate what I am saying. It is seldom the really finished article passes into the last stage here. What better proof have you than this, namely, that beef was never as big an industry as store cattle. In many cases the stuff we were selling as beef here was bought by the Scottish buyers, kept for six or eight weeks, and then turned out on the market as best British beef. Ask any practical man in this country who knows the English market and he will tell you the best Irish beef is sold before slaughtered. Opportunity and experience, locality and time to dispose of the article brings the feeder the most money. Now, the Minister is increasing his problem. He is depriving the producers or the farmers of an opportunity to sell their stock at a time that, in their opinion, will pay them best. The Minister wants to force them, in some circumstances that I cannot visualise here, to keep them longer, so that they may put on more meat, whereas his problem is that we want to get rid of them.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I think that both my views and Deputy Belton's views are on record already, and there is no use in repeating them. We will have to wait to see who is right. It is impossible for Deputy Belton to convince me that he is right, and I am sure that it is equally impossible for me to convince him that I am right. However, if a man had 1,000 cattle and only 500 were to be killed this week, is it not only fair to allow a man the opportunity to get out?

Comment on this

But what are you going to do with the other 500?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Well, then, the other man must still hold on.

Comment on this

But then another 1,000 will come along and there will be another 500 extra. That is the Minister's problem. It is his funeral.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Well, I am hoping to be able to solve it.

Comment on this

But we are here, 21 years of age and upwards, and we would like to know how the Minister is going to solve it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I have stated already that I believe we can deal with the cattle as they come for slaughter for the home market and for the free meat supply.

Comment on this

What market is the Minister providing for the surplus meat, after he deals with the 180,000 here?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I gave the figures on the Second Reading of what we consumed last year, and exported in the way of fat cattle. I also gave the figures of the proposed consumption in the way of free meat. I shall not repeat those figures. Otherwise, Second Reading speeches would be useless.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I move amendment No. 7.

7. In sub-section (1) (a), after the word "slaughter" to insert the words "for sale."

Comment on this

Would the Minister explain the section?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Deputy Curran raised a point here about the buyer and the seller and I spent a rather sleepless night considering his point. I think I can move to have this section deleted on the Report Stage, so that the seller of the beast will not suffer unless there is a charge of collusion.

Comment on this

I remember the Minister saying that the seller can sell at any price to the butcher.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is a different point.

Comment on this

Anyway, the meaning I took out of it was the opposite of what the Minister says.

Comment on this

Is not the penalty under Section 20—£10—very extreme?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not think it is very extreme.

Comment on this

This deals with a number of cattle required for slaughter for human consumption.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

As a matter of fact, it is doubtful whether that was necessary at all in the Bill. It says, merely, that I must send to the inspectors the number that they may mark. I say to them to mark 10,000 or 20,000 cattle, as the case may be.

Comment on this

And a good deal too.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

If you like to delete the section, I have power to do it.

Comment on this

There is a lot in what the Minister has said now to the effect that it depends on the number of cattle marked. Is the Minister going to regulate the supply according to the demand? Is he going to hold two stopcocks and turn on one, and if the other is not able to let it through, stop the flow? The number that will be slaughtered depends on the number marked. You might deduct from that the number that the Minister gathers from other sources of information, such as the Minister for Industry and Commerce and so on, will be the number that will be marked and no more.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

You may be sure that I will not allow a shortage.

Comment on this

No, but I am thinking of the man that will not be marked; just as we had the experience last spring of a number of cattle held up and no licences issued to tie on to their tails or their horns. The Minister said just now, in an absent moment I daresay, that the number that will be slaughtered will depend on the number that are marked and vice versa.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

If I said that, I do not think it was right.

Comment on this

Well, will we wait to delete that nonsensical section?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I move amendment No. 8:—

In sub-section (1), after the word "may" to insert the words "with the consent of the Minister for Finance."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is the first of a series of consequential amendments—Nos. 10, 11 and 26, and some others.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes.

Comment on this

We would like to say something on this section before it passes.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is merely on the question before the House.

Comment on this

I want to hear the Minister on this section. I want to know, here and now, from the Minister, what steps he is going to take, or what statistics he is going to act on, in connection with the fixing of a minimum price. The whole Bill, in my opinion, hinges on this section and on the powers that the Minister takes to himself for the fixing of a minimum price and what will be the determining factor in arriving at what we call a minimum price, having due regard to every interest and every element concerned. The Minister, last night made all sorts of accusations against me. I do not want to delay the House too long, but I want to know from the Minister here and now what he is going to do in connection with the fixing of a price. I might say, in connection with this section, that I have been asked about this Bill and this section, and if I cannot get information from the Minister, who is guiding this Bill through the House, from whom will I get it? Therefore I want information from the Minister himself.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

What is the Deputy's difficulty?

Comment on this

I want to know how you are to arrive at the minimum price? That is the point I want cleared up.

Comment on this

The Deputy found it very difficult to say it.

Comment on this

I said it more than once.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We had a discussion on this last night——

Comment on this

Not on this question.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It was the principal point on the Second Reading. I stressed the point that this was the big item in this Bill—the fixing of the price. I said I wanted to get back to the position before the quota was brought in against our cattle in Great Britain. That is the position to which I want to get back. I want to set the producer the price he would ordinarily get for his cattle if the quota had not been brought in against us. Previous to the quota being introduced there had to be deducted from the price that our cattle made in England the cost of transit and commission expenses as between this country and Great Britain; in addition to that there had to be deducted the difference between the tariff imposed by the British and the bounty we gave. Bearing these things in mind, the price will be fixed at the export value of the cattle or at the nearest possible figure to the export value of the cattle.

Comment on this

Will it be the price at Birkenhead or at Belfast?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Let us take an example, if you like. A beast sold in Birkenhead, say, at £16——

Comment on this

Or so much per cwt.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I would rather take it the other way. I am not quick enough that way. Take it, say, at £16. The ordinary expenses on that beast, previous to the tariff, were about £2. That was the difference then between the Birkenhead and Dublin markets. That brought the price of the beast down to £14. Off that £14 had to be deducted the difference between the tariff of £6 and the bounty of 35/-. That was £4 5s. So that that brings the price of the beast really down to £9 15s. to-day. I will go back to the cwt. calculation, if you like. We will take it that the £16 beast weighed 8 cwt. Whatever price was to be fixed on the 8 cwt. beast would be roughly the price per cwt. This price would not be fixed on one beast, but on a number. In that way the person who has a licence would find that that licence is of no value to him other than the ordinary value of the exported cattle. I believe that a man made, perhaps, 3/- or 5/- a head on the export of cattle, and he sometimes lost. The person who has a licence will not be able to sell it then for 20/- or 30/-. I do not know if that explanation will satisfy the Deputy or whether it makes it clear to the House.

Comment on this

We know the basis on which the Minister would turn round and fix the price. Does the Minister think that that is a fair basis?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is another question.

Comment on this

That is really the question. Will not the producers want a fair price as well as anybody else? Does the Minister think that—taking the tariff and the bounty—that taking this £4 5s. off the price of the beast will leave the farmer a fair price? I ask this, having regard to the fact that the Minister and his supporters in this House have been telling the people that the British have no use for beef any longer. But now the Minister turns around and says that the farmers here should take £4 5s. for the beast less than they have been getting or that they would get but for the tariff. In view of the fact that the British Government themselves have introduced a Bill to enable them to pay the producers of beef in Great Britain what they consider a fair price for it, does the Minister think that the farmers here are being fairly treated? I tell the Minister that his calculation is not a fair calculation, and that it should be compiled on some other basis than the basis he has put before us this evening. I am sure the Minister himself knows that too.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I think it is unfair in a way for the Deputy to raise that point on this section. I could argue against him. If the Deputy wants the question of the £4 5s. 0d. remedied, what he should really do is ask for a higher bounty. We can only operate this Bill by fixing the export price of the cattle. We cannot operate this Bill by fixing a higher price for export. Take butter, for instance. We could not fix a higher price for butter here for export than the price at home. If you want to raise the price of cattle then the Deputy ought to argue the case by saying that the levy and the bounty is too low and ask that the bounty should be raised. We are only discussing how this section should be operated.

Comment on this

I do not think I can follow Deputy Curran's reasoning in this matter. The home price will be determined by what the beast actually makes in the outside market. If the home price is raised higher, then there would be no inducement to export the cattle. Is the Minister sanguine about the operation of the export price and the carrying out of it? It would be all right if there were a shortage. But we have a surplus and we are likely to have a surplus for some time to come. Possibly the dealers and maybe the farmers are very ingenious. I do not see that this section will be very satisfactorily worked. Take, for instance, a licensed butcher who goes to buy cattle. The Minister said in his Second Reading speech that the number of grades would be limited. He cannot have a whole lot of grades. Now, the butcher, the would-be purchaser, says to the farmer: "Well, your cattle will suit me, but there is a number of them there that are not worth the price fixed to me." Suppose, for example, that the price is fixed at 25/- and the butcher says they are not worth more than 22/- or 23/- to him and the farmer wants to sell the cattle at that price, what is going to happen? What is to prevent the farmer saying: "I will give you a certain figure as luck-penny"? That is one of the loopholes in the Bill and I am not very sanguine about how it will work out. I put it to the Minister to say if he is hopeful of carrying out this minimum price satisfactorily.

Comment on this

Might I inquire if Deputy Haslett's criticism is that there will be evasion, that the slaughterer will commit an illegality and that he will offer a lower price than the minimum price?

Comment on this

No, no, but the beast is not worth the price.

Comment on this

And the luck-penny may be bigger.

Comment on this

I followed the Minister's reasoning to-day and yesterday. I think he dealt with this matter at some length on the Second Reading. I see his reasoning all right. I see the two problems with which he is confronted. One is the fixing of a price and the other problem is the one that has been mentioned already—a thing that runs through the whole Bill—the surplus. The Minister separates the two knocks that the trade has got. This Bill is only going to recoup the farmer for part of the second knock and does not touch the first knock at all. The first knock was the British tariff. I think I interpret the Minister aright when I say—I need only repeat his words—that he is not touching that at all. He is not touching the loss inflicted by the British tariff but he proposes in this Bill to meet the situation that arises from the quota, but so far as I have read the Bill he has not dealt with the surplus. We shall leave that aside for the moment and we shall deal with the price and the formula upon which the Minister is going to work to fix the price. The Minister cannot fix any meat price, nor is any meat price fixed by any statistician in the world, except in relation to feeding prices, cereal prices. He will find that back to the beginning of records on cereals and meats, that they go up and down together in double harness. The formula that the Minister adopts for cereals, he must adopt for meat. He is confronted with this, that if the farmer is going to get no remedy under this Bill or any other Bill for the British tariff——

Comment on this

He is not.

Comment on this

If he is not going to get it, then that position must be reflected in the price of oats and barley. You cannot get away from that. I quote the following figures from a reputable journal, perhaps the most reputable in the world, the Economist, dated August 4th, the current number. Taking cereals and meat in 1927 at a price of 100, they rise and fall together, and on September the 18th, 1931, the figure is shown as 64.5, as against 100 in 1927. In April, 1934, the figure was 67.8; in July, 1934, 73, and in August, 1934, 73.3. The Minister is going to regulate his meat price, as he told us a moment ago, by taking the Birkenhead price, deducting from that £2 for the cost of shipping the beast and other sundry charges, and then taking £4 5s. off to represent the difference between the tariff and the bounty. He is going to fix his price at that figure. Why take the £4 5s. off, if you want to do justice? Is not the price, before that amount is deducted, the level of prices that would obtain here if we had no economic war? Where is your moral right now to collect the annuities if you insist that the farmer must pay that £4 5s.? The consumer, the butcher and all the rest, who are not producers of meat, must get meat at a rate of £4 5s. per beast of 10 cwt. live weight, roughly, less than the world market price. The Minister knows my views on the question of rates and annuities. We are not going to discuss that question now, but I am going to say that there is no man on these benches who will not go out and tell the farmers to pay their rates and annuities immediately——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is very like a discussion on the question, which the Deputy promised to avoid.

Comment on this

It is in this way, a Chinn Comhairle. The Minister, in fixing his minimum price for meat, through the sale of which annuities and rates can only be paid, should fix that minimum price at the figure that would rule here if there was no economic war—in other words, if England were not collecting the annuities. If he can take the price at Birkenhead as his formula and deduct the cost of transit and sundry charges, and forget about the £6 tariff, he then would have the price that people would have to pay for meat if the economic war were not on. If there are people in this country who want the economic war to go on, let it go on, but let this one section which is producing meat not have to bear £4 5s. per beast of a loss. Fix the standard price with due regard to the world price, apart from any question of a tariff, and there is no man in this country has any moral right to withhold his rates or annuities from the Government.

I challenge the Minister to show the equity of the basis on which he proposes to fix his prices now. The economic war is there. It is a fact that a tariff of £6 has to be paid on each beast. True, the Minister comes in with a bounty of 35/-, leaving a net loss of £4 5s. 0d. per beast. Why is that to remain? Is not that reducing the level of prices here as regulated by the world market? Is it not reducing, on the average, the wholesale price of ten cwt., live weight, of beef by £4 5s.? The rest of the community get the benefit of that. Why does the Minister not remedy that? Why does he not take that into account in fixing the standard price? Where is the equity in fixing a price which makes the producer carry that loss? The Minister comes along and says "Our one concern is to help the farmer, the producer. The £1 per beast will be borne by the butcher." Of course, it will not be borne by the butcher. Then, the producer has to bear the £4 5s. to which I have already referred. The Minister, coming along to help out the producer, fixes a price which perpetuates that fixed loss per beast to the producer and he makes no bones about it. He makes no apology for standardising the price of that fixed loss. Then he wants the butcher to pay £1 into the revenue. This is the way that the problem is going to be solved. If the Minister wants to tackle this problem seriously and wants to start by fixing prices, let him fix a price based on world market prices and deduct the expenses that we must incur by sending our stuff into the world market. Let him remember that if he fixes that price on anything else, everything grown must bear that loss of £4 10s. per beast. It is attempting the ridiculous and the impossible to separate the price of feeding stuffs from the price of beef. It is nothing more than saying that you will charge a high price for cloth to make a suit but that the suit will be cheaper. You must transmit the loss due to that British tariff to your cultivated crops-oats, barley, feeding potatoes and roots. Their price must be reduced by that amount. Unless the Minister is going to fix this figure at the world price, less the cost of getting into the world's market place, he is going to devalue the market price of every crop grown on Irish soil while the economic war lasts. I do not want to discuss the economic war and I am not discussing it. I am discussing its effects and those effects should not be ignored in fixing the price of our meat. By fixing the price of our meat at the world price everybody will bear a fair share of the burden of the fight. Nobody will have more right than another to squeal. The Minister has admitted that the result of the British tariff is not dealt with under this Bill. He suggested to Deputy Curran that the only way by which that problem could be tackled would be to increase the bounty. Increasing the bounty would not affect the case at all. An increase in the bounty would affect the return from the beef we export but it would not affect the price of the beef for home consumption. The price will remain that which the Minister will fix, according to his formula, but if the bounty is cut out altogether, if our Government pays the British tariff and fixes the price at the world price, less the charges of sending over, then the people who export will get the world price and the people who consume at home will have to pay the world price and no more. In the case of butter, they are paying more than the world price. There is no analogy between the two things. What we want done is to have the price fixed at the world price, less the cost of sending our stuff into the world market. In other words, to keep the level of the home meat market at the world level, less the charge of sending out our stuff. If the Government want an equitable distribution of responsibility, let them pay the British tariff and fix their price at the world price. If the Minister neglects to do that, the country must inevitably collapse. It cannot carry on. I should like to have reasons from the Minister as to why he is deliberately refusing to fix the price at the world price, less the charges of transportation.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

When Deputy Belton is not talking utter nonsense, he is spending his time reading economic journals. We have to suffer for that. We have to suffer speeches about world prices, primary products, raw materials, and finished products from a man who knows nothing about them. A child going to school would understand these economic questions better than does Deputy Belton. Why does not the Deputy sit down and study a Bill like this so that he will know what he is talking about? How could you fix a price that would not be the same as the export price—whatever the export price may be? Whether or not the export price is subject to a tariff or a bounty, we must operate this Bill at the export price. I think that Deputy Curran understood me perfectly when I said that. I think that every other Deputy here understood me save Deputy Belton.

Comment on this

I did understand you, and I disagreed with your formula.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is the Deputy who is destined to lead that Party into the jungle. Deputy Belton does not understand this question. He says the bounty makes no difference in this case. That shows his utter ignorance.

Comment on this

Will the Minister quote me correctly? I said that the bounty would make no difference if you fixed the price at the world price, less the cost of sending our stuff into the world market. Neither would it make any difference.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy should realise that one requires a little knowledge before he studies these economic journals. One should not try to understand them unless he has that little knowledge.

Comment on this

Do not hide your ignorance that way.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

This section cannot be operated unless we fix the price at the export price. If the Deputy wants to have export prices raised to what they would be if there were no tariff, then he should agitate for a bounty or a settlement of the economic war and do away with the tariff. If the tariff were done away with, then we would operate this section at export prices, paying no tariff. Suppose the tariff is increased, then we must operate this section at the price here, paying the full amount, whatever it may be. What we pay in tariff and what the bounty is going to be is quite a different problem. That is a problem in itself and should be argued seperately. It was argued very often here, and it should hardly be necessary to argue it on this section. I wish the Deputy would understand that the question as to whether the farmer is going to get enough for his cattle or not cannot be raised on this section. All that can be raised on this section is the question the Deputy has not raised—whether it is possible to operate the section or not. Surely there is only one way of operating it. That is to get the best export price that can be got after paying the tariff, if there is a tariff, and after getting the bounty, if there is a bounty. If these factors are present, they must be taken into account in operating the fixed price. Whether they should be there or not is a different question and should be argued on another section, if argued at all on this Bill. The Deputy should not take advantage of every section of this Bill to make that economic speech, which I regard as the greatest nonsense but which the Deputy, no doubt, regards as being a very profound pronouncement from the Opposition benches. We do not object to it, but we are sick of it.

Comment on this

This section deals with minimum prices. I am in agreement with the Deputies, who contended that the minimum price, whatever it will be —I am not going to refer to it at any great length—will not be a fair price. I do not think that the Minister, by means of this Bill or any other Bill like it, can create that price, having regard to the cost of production. The Minister is attempting in this Bill to fix minimum prices for fat cattle. The question arises on this section how that is to be brought about. If we were to arrive at a fixed price, at a price that would please everybody and that would put an end to the tariffs and all that, then there would be no necessity for this Bill as far as prices are concerned, because they would regulate themselves. But, unfortunately, that is not the case, and, therefore, this Bill is necessary.

This section deals with minimum prices. The question that agitates me is this: is the farmer guaranteed the minimum price, whatever it is? Is there any certainty that the seller of cattle will get the minimum price? To me it appears doubtful from my reading of this section. Take the feeder of grass cattle. The cattle will be marked by an inspector to be sold at various periods. I do not grumble at that. There will at least be this disability in some cases: that a man will have his cattle marked for sale at a late date, possibly at the end of the grass season, but he will have no certainty under this or any other section of the Bill that he is going to sell them at any price, not even at the minimum price. Grass cattle may, at a certain date, have deteriorated to such an extent that when the winter season sets in no butcher will want to buy them, marked or unmarked. In such a case, if cattle are marked for sale at a late date, the owner has no certainty that he will be able to sell them at the minimum price.

Take another case. The minimum price is to be fixed on a certain basis, whether by weight, hand or otherwise. The Minister said on the Second Reading that it would be by weight where there were facilities for weighing them, but that in other cases it would be by hand, or, to put it another way, by guesswork, the inspector or supervisor to determine the weight of the animal in that way. Some of us on this side of the House argued that to determine the weight of an animal by hand, in other words, by guesswork, was not a very easy matter. There are very few men in this country capable of accurately determining the weight of a beast by hand. I do not know if there is one. Some of the most prominent cattle buyers in the country will tell you that they could not do it, but in this Bill, in the absence of a weighing machine, an inspector or supervisor is to be the determining factor as to the weight of an animal.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not under Section 23.

Comment on this

Section 23 fixes the basis of whether it is to be by weight, hand or otherwise. I am trying to argue what the consequences will be of fixing the weight by guesswork. If, by any possible chance, the inspector was a superman, and in determining the weight of the beast by hand arrived at a figure that was fairly correct, there is still no guarantee that the farmer can sell the beast, because when the butcher comes along he might say that the weight put upon the beast by the inspector is not correct, and there is no compulsion on the butcher to buy. If the butcher thinks that the weight of the beast has been overestimated, he will leave the beast severely alone. There is no compulsion on him or on anybody else to buy. He will not take the beast.

On this section somebody spoke about collusion. This leaves everything open to collusion. In some cases, if a man is to sell, he has got to have collusion with the butcher, but I am afraid he will not be able to have that because the butcher, bearing in mind the provisions of this measure, will be afraid to trade with him by any underhand means, fearing that the consequences of his action, or of his good nature if you like, may fall on him six or eight months afterwards; that he may be prosecuted for buying a beast under the stipulated weight. There is no guarantee whatever under this Bill that the owners of cattle are going to get even the minimum price. I doubt if it could be arranged as a certainty that they would get it, even if it were possible for the Minister or anybody else to so arrange it.

These are the two types of cases that I want to deal with particularly. The first is that of the man with grass cattle which may be marked for sale at a late date. He is not being given any security that he will be able to sell at any price. Then there is the case of the man who sells cattle by weight, the weight being determined by the inspector. It may be right or it may be wrong. There is no compulsion on the butcher to buy and it is almost certain that he will not buy if the cattle are graded an ounce too high. One thing is absolutely certain and it is this: that if a farmer does sell his cattle, the weight being determined by guesswork, he will sell them at a loss, because unless the beast is definitely graded at a less weight than it really is, no butcher will touch him, and if the error happens to be on the other side, the butcher will also leave the animal severely alone, so that the odds are against the farmer getting even the minimum price. This Bill aims at getting a certain minimum price for the farmer. What we want to see in it is the certainty that farmers will get that minimum price, but as the Bill stands there is no such certainty.

Comment on this

This section is a complete fraud. This is Fianna Fáil's gesture. By our tomfoolery over the last two years we wrecked the market for cattle and ruined the price for cattle, and now we are going to produce a fortune for every man out of a hat by fixing a price for cattle. It is popularly reported now by the exponents of Fianna Fáil doctrine that the cattle market in Great Britain is gone. It was not Fianna Fáil's fault at all. It was gone, and in any case there is no use looking for it. What are the facts? We were told by the President that the entire British market was gone, thanks be to God.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This section deals with the restrictions on the price of cattle and sheep and has nothing to do with our position in the British market.

Comment on this

Yes. This section is supposed to be the Fianna Fáil sop to the men whom they have beggared by destroying their market where they could get the value of their beasts on the open market without any fixation of price. The Minister himself admits that the price he is going to fix is the price ruling in the market that his folly keeps our cattle out of. This same Minister, having proclaimed to the world that the British market has gone, thanks be to God, is writing letters to the bacon factories of this country at the present time imploring them to ship all the bacon they can to the British market, or else——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The shipping of bacon to the British market is not relevant to this section, nor indeed to this stage of the Bill.

Comment on this

Surely I am entitled to make the case that as between the recovery of our markets, or this section which is for the fixation of prices, a far better remedy for the cattle trade of this country would be to get the market back, the open market on which we can get a price without the Minister proposing to fix prices.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is the Committee Stage of a Bill. The established practice is that discussion on this stage is confined to the particular section before the House and it is not in order to discuss alternative markets or alternative measures.

Comment on this

Surely, Sir, I am entitled to argue on this section that, if the object of the section is to get a fair price for the farmer, there is a better method of doing this than that which is vouchsafed in this section.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On the Second Reading of the Bill the Deputy would have been entitled so to argue, but may not do so now.

Comment on this

The Deputy was on holidays then.

Comment on this

Am I to be precluded from criticising this as ineffective?

Comment on this

The Deputy is now disputing the ruling of the Chair.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair rules that discussion of the British market as an alternative to the proposals set out in this section is not relevant.

Comment on this

Then I have no further concern in addressing the House.

Comment on this

I expected something better than personalities from the Minister in reply to the case I made. It ill becomes the Minister that when he is concerned he indulges in personalities. If I read economic journals I understand them.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not think you do.

Comment on this

I do understand them. If I read medical journals I would understand medicine as well as the Minister.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not quote them here.

Comment on this

No, because it would probably be beyond the Minister to quote them.

Comment on this

No personalities.

Comment on this

That is evidence of the fact——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should return to the section.

Comment on this

The Minister ought to remember that this matter is of more importance than what I consider about it, or what he considers about it; of more importance than what I spend my spare time at, if I have any, or what he spends his spare time at. The price which he is going to fix for beef and mutton is of great importance to the whole economic position of the country. Eighty per cent. of all the stuff that can be produced in this country must be consumed as food for live stock. Eighty to 90 per cent. of the produce of the soil of this country —whether you plough it or whether you graze it; whether you are a tillage farmer like the Minister, who does not till; whether you are a rancher, as I am accused of being, but I till all; it does not matter which type of farmer you are, or what you produce —must be fed as animal food. The price that is fixed for those animals regulates the price——

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

More world economics!

Comment on this

Yes, and it would be a good job for the Minister if he knew something about economics, and a good job for this country, too. More economics! If we had more economics and less of highfalutin cod like what we get from over there, it would be better for the country.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

And less talk!

Comment on this

And more work. The Minister's work, if he wants to work——

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

When do you work?

Comment on this

Every day.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Corporation, the General Council, the County Council, the Dáil, and the Blueshirts!

Comment on this

I am able to find about £300 a week in wages, which all Fianna Fáil does not pay, and I have neither sought nor got any loans from any Government. It ill becomes the Minister to ask any Deputy when he works. As long as that Deputy pays his way, and carries on his business, he can look the world in the face. It shows the ignorance of the Minister who put up such a question.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Only curiosity—not ignorance.

Comment on this

Curiosity?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is curious about the section.

Comment on this

I do not look for curiosities. If I want to see curiosities I always have a few of them over there. The curiosity of the Minister for Agriculture——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should take this Bill seriously.

Comment on this

I am taking it very seriously.

Comment on this

The country will not take you seriously.

Comment on this

Another industrialist is speaking.

Comment on this

Listen to big business!

Comment on this

The Minister will not accept the formula which I put up. I am going to repeat it. I asked him to refute the equity of it, and the only way he could do that was to indulge in personalities. Well, the public will know the difference. A very strong point made by Deputy Bennett here has not been replied to by the Minister. I will not repeat it, or ask the Minister to reply to it, if there is any other section on which it can be more appropriately raised, but I do not see any such section. I refer to the point about the surplus beef. We know that half our beef is surplus.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Not at all.

Comment on this

When the Minister is operating for another year that half will not be surplus. We know that, because beef will not be produced. Half the beef is surplus, and the Minister knows that. He knows also that that was the basis of our discussion at the conference on the 19th January. More than half is surplus.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

58 per cent.!

Comment on this

Is surplus?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is what the Deputy says.

Comment on this

58 per cent. is surplus? Let it be anything you like; we will not go back to that any more. What is to be done with the surplus? I do not want to press the point if there is any other section on which it would be better to raise it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I think it could be raised on Section 39.

Comment on this

When do we get to that?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

In about 20 minutes.

Comment on this

It would be better if we never reached it.

Comment on this

You are doing your best.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that that would be the appropriate time to ask him how he proposes to use up the surplus?

Comment on this

I do not know whether the Minister is giving any information in connection with this section?

Comment on this

He cannot, the poor man.

Comment on this

Let us take sub-section (c) of this Section 23—"fixing the basis, whether by weight, by hand, or otherwise, on which the price of cattle is to be calculated." I take it that "fixing the basis" means the basis on which he made the calculation on the last section?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes.

Comment on this

How does the Minister expect to fix the basis by hand? How can that be done? I am sticking to the words of the section—"fixing the basis, whether by weight, by hand, or otherwise, on which the price of cattle is to be calculated." I take this section and this Bill as meaning that it is the intention of the Minister to use the powers which he has under the words which he puts in the Bill. I am just asking the Minister how he is going to fix the basis by hand? I do not see how the Minister can do it, and I should like an explanation.

Comment on this

Before the Minister replies I should like to say that I think the same thing is agitating everybody's mind. The Minister was understood to say in introducing this Bill that, generally speaking, there is throughout the country very little facility of any kind for selling cattle by weight. Most of the cattle, as the Minister knows, are sold by hand or on foot. A bargain is struck between the buyer and seller, and a price is placed on the weight as they guess it. Under this Bill they must either be bought by weight or by hand. Otherwise there must be a standard arrived at as to the weight or the price of a beast. I am sure the Minister had something in mind before these sections were drafted, and he might give us the benefit of the information. Deputies on all sides appear to be very much in the dark as to how this is to be done. If the sale is by weight I presume it will be per cwt. according to the market quotation. If by hand will it be by the height or girth? The price must have some basis, and while the Minister has talked of a fixed basis, he has not given any indication of what it will be. It is important that it should be known if there is to be a possibility of working the Bill. Sub-section (3) prescribes that in any bargain made the buyer and the seller can act only on the basis laid down. It will not be sufficient for a buyer to offer £5 or £10 for a beast. There must be a staple agreement based on something. I understand that some documents must be interchanged because a register of sales must be kept. The time-honoured custom of buying in the open market and coming to a perfect understanding is going to be ended by this section. In sub-section (4) there is a little matter introduced that might be made reciprocal. If a butcher buys a beast from a farmer or a grazier and gives less than the minimum price, he is, in the first place, committing an offence in doing so and, in the second place, the farmer can recover the difference between the price paid and the fixed price, as a civil debt. But supposing that the butcher paid too much, he is not able to recover the difference. In equity, this section ought to cut both ways, and if a man pays too much there should be some power to get back the difference. The whole section appears to want clarifying.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I stated on the Second Reading that in cities and towns where there are facilities available weighing will be compulsory in the sale of cattle for slaughter. They will be sold by weight and the fixed price will be so much per cwt. There are areas where we know scales are not available, and for these we will have to make other regulations.

Comment on this

Machines are available in very few places.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

They are available in most of the big towns and in other places. We know that in the Department of Agriculture because we got particulars. Apart from that there are two ways of dealing with the matter. There is one way, letting an inspector go to the market and getting the butcher and the seller to agree to a certain weight. They will not have to make any bargain about the price. There will be a fixed price. The inspector will have to agree about the weight, or alternatively, he may wait until the beast is killed and have the deadweight, so that we would have a fixed price for dead as well as live weight. In the end it works out that the price will be by weight. We could not possibly have it by hand.

Comment on this

Why is "hand" in the Bill?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is necessary. A beast is technically sold by hand or sold, in the opinion of the inspector, at a certain weight.

Comment on this

Do I understand that inspectors will fix the price all the time?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Minister fixes the price.

Comment on this

I understood the Minister to say that the inspectors would do so.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The inspectors give an opinion as to the weight when the sale is by hand.

Comment on this

You will want many more inspectors?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No.

Comment on this

Would an inspector not want to be present at the slaughter of every beast? The Minister stated that it would be principally by weight transactions would take place. I take it that all the cattle slaughtered will not be of the same weight?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No.

Comment on this

When an inspector comes along afterwards, how is he to know if one beast was 6 cwt. dead weight and another 8 cwt.? How can he turn round and say that the provisions of the Bill are being carried out? Will not the whole thing be open to grave fraud, if they are so inclined, on the part of butchers? What is to prevent a butcher saying that he had only two beasts weighing 6 cwt. each, when he might have one weighing 6 cwt. and another weighing 8 cwt.? I cannot see how the section can be properly carried out unless an inspector is always present to see that a particular beast is the beast that he had seen previously. I will give an example. I happen to be chairman of a mental hospital committee which made regulations——

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I hope the Deputy will never go down any lower.

Comment on this

I am satisfied with the position, whatever the Minister thinks. I have nothing to regret in connection with my association with the position I occupy there, and I think the Minister would be well advised to leave these cheap remarks out when we are discussing the Bill. I tried to keep to the section. It would be well if the Minister would do the same thing. I want to put the position to him as I see it. Regulations were made by that committee so that every beast should be sent in for inspection and a mark was put on it for identification purposes. If that was not done, nothing could prevent a beast being exchanged after inspection. The same thing could happen under this Bill.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Supposing there are two farmers in question, A and B, having beasts weighing 6 cwt. and 8 cwt. respectively. Do you think the farmers would allow their beasts to be exchanged?

Comment on this

No, but the butchers could easily do so unless an inspector was present.

Comment on this

In the case of a beast being bought by dead weight, as far as I can see, it would be almost necessary for a farmer to be present at the weighing and killing. Otherwise he would have grave doubts in his mind that he was being "had." In the other case it would be unfair to the inspector. I see the Minister's point, and I agree that there is something in it, but I cannot see how any inspector could fulfil the task placed upon him. A sale may be by hand or by live weight. Many farmers have 20 or 30 cattle, and many have more. Men with 20 or 30 cattle will sell one or two at a time, and their neighbours will do the same, so that the poor inspector would be running day and night in order to carry out his duties properly. It would be impossible for him to do so, as the number of inspectors specified would not be sufficient to do the work.

Comment on this

Will the Minister consider the suggestion about getting back money when too much has been paid?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That could hardly arise.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It does not refer to this section.

Comment on this

This section deals with restrictions on feeding and time of weighing. Sub-section (a) fixes the minimum time. Is the Minister going to do that by order, or is it to be a matter between the butcher and the vendor?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I think this section is not of very great importance, but if we had not put it in, there might be a possibility of disputes. The butcher might say that the seller had given a feed to the beast before he brought it in, and that it was unfair that he should have to buy it by live weight. We will probably issue regulations so that a certain number of hours must elapse between feeding and weighing the beast in order to prevent disputes.

Comment on this

Would it not be a simpler way of settling disputes to quote the dead weight and live weight prices?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The dead weight is more troublesome. We may have to attempt it in some cases.

Comment on this

Would it not be more troublesome to fix a time within which a beast should not be fed? If a flock of sheep come into Ballinlough how are you to know when these sheep stopped grazing along the roads, or how are you to know when they were taken off grass? Unless they were taken off grass within the prescribed number of hours before they started on the road, there will be a conflict with the regulations, whereas if a butcher says to an inspector that it is unreasonable to fix the live weight price for a beast, because the animal had just got a huge feed, the inspector will say that the equivalent dead weight price is so much, buy it at the alternative prices, live weight so much per cwt., dead weight so much per cwt.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We very probably will.

Comment on this

The question was raised as to whether the restriction on the place of slaughter meant that you could not have a slaughterhouse on the same premises as you had a shop for retail distribution. There is another section which makes provision that the business of slaughtering and distribution will not be carried on in the same place.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That means they could be under the same roof, but not actually in the same room as it were.

Comment on this

Section 9 (3) says: "Premises registered in the register of slaughtering premises shall not be capable of being registered in the register of victualling premises" and vice versa. Is the Minister satisfied that the word “premises” there will not have a wider meaning than one apartment under a given roof? I have no doubt whatever that licensed premises means any part of the building in respect to which there is a licence to sell alcoholic liquor and to which there is free access from the licensed part. For instance, if you have a licensed house and a door freely communicating with the residential portion the whole house is licensed and the only way you could exempt the residential portion from the licence is to seal up the door and have two separate entrances. I submit that in this case you will find, unless extensive structural alterations are carried out in most of the existing butchers' shops, that no butcher will be able to get registration as a victualler and as a slaughterer in respect of the premises which he at present occupies.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

If the Deputy looks at Section 9 (2) (b) he will see it is provided that there shall be entered in the several registers "a description of the situation of the premises sufficient to identify such premises and the limits and extent thereof." So that the person can limit it if he likes to one room or one building, as the case may be.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance can probably give us valuable information in this regard. I think I am right in saying that a licensed premises under the excise provisions is the whole structure under one roof which is accessible all through. Unless you have two separate entrances for two different parts of one house the whole house is licensed if any part of it is licensed. That will probably be the legal precedent followed in defining "premises." Sub-section (3) of Section 9 says: "Premises registered in the register of slaughtering premises shall not be capable of being registered in the register of victualling premises...." We know the Minister's mind and his intention and therefore I do not make a point on this, beyond saying that I think it is a matter the Minister should take counsel about between this and the time he will be dealing with this measure in the Seanad and, if necessary, introduce an amendment which will clearly define what is in his mind. I take it what is in the Minister's mind is that you cannot slaughter a beast on the floor of the shop.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is quite right.

Comment on this

Sub-section (3) of Section 25 says that an animal may be killed which is suffering from pain caused by injury or disease. What is to become of the meat of that animal? It cannot be sold.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It can be sold.

Comment on this

That goes against the provisions of Section 20. Supposing it was an unmarked beast, will the person be allowed to sell the meat? Sub-section (a) of Section 20 says that a person cannot slaughter for human consumption any unmarked animal. The animal which met with an accident might not be marked.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Section 20 says nothing about selling the meat. It says you cannot slaughter unless it is marked when the marking provisions are in force. If a beast breaks a leg, it can be brought in to the butcher to slaughter although not marked. There is nothing to say that he cannot sell the meat. There is nothing against that.

Comment on this

Sub-section (3) gives exemption in so far as the beast is suffering from pain as a result of injury or disease. I take it the court would hold that any beast suffering from a demonstrable disease would be presumed to be suffering from pain. Many tubercular beasts are not in the least and could not be demonstrated to be in any pain and are merely slaughtered for the purpose of protecting the rest of the herd.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

You must remember that if tuberculosis is demonstrable the animal would be condemned in another way. It would not be allowed to be used for human consumption. This refers more to injury.

Comment on this

This deals with the power of the Minister to prohibit the export of cattle to an external market, and the only market which he ordinarily could prohibit us from exporting cattle to is the British market. It is true that he could prohibit us from exporting cattle to Germany, but I venture to say that it will require very little inducement to anybody who can sell his cattle anywhere else on the face of God's earth to refrain from selling cattle in Germany at the price Irish cattle command in Germany at the present time, and have commanded for the last two years. What strikes me particularly about this section is the commentary it affords on the powers the Minister has in connection with the bacon trade. We are told that this market, which he seeks power to prohibit us from exporting cattle to, is worthless, and at the moment he is telling us that he is sending us letters exhorting us to ship all the bacon we can during those months to the British market. Why? For fear we will lose it. I saw a letter from the Minister about a week ago saying that he besought every bacon factory to ship every available cwt. of bacon during the months of June, July and August.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Does this arise under this section?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think it has already been indicated to the Deputy that references to the exports of bacon are not relevant to this Bill.

Comment on this

It was indicated to me that a certain argument I was making on Section 23 did not meet with the Chair's view of relevance, and I immediately abandoned it. We are now dealing with the power of the Minister to prohibit us from exporting to the British market.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Cattle and sheep, not bacon.

Comment on this

No, but I am drawing an analogy between the power he has to prohibit exports of other agricultural products, meat products, to the same market, and from that I am evolving an argument to suggest that it is an extremely erratic procedure for the Minister to ask powers to prohibit us from exporting the cattle.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

A passing reference may be allowed, but I could not permit the development of an argument on those lines.

Comment on this

I merely want to place it on record that while the Minister is explaining the steps that may be necessary—even the prohibition of exports to this market are, according to him, justified because the market is of trivial value—at the same time he is telling us in private correspondence that we must ship every hundredweight of bacon we can, irrespective of the effect on the prices to the home consumer, in order to preserve this market that we are to value at the snap of our fingers when we come to consider Section 26 of this Bill. When you are face to face with a situation of that kind, when neither the Minister nor anybody else here knows what is in the Minister's mind, it becomes extremely difficult to evaluate a section of this character. If there were any constructive scheme in the Minister's mind and into that scheme he could fit the alleged necessity for this right to prohibit exports, one could consider it on its merits; but when you find that such powers are exercised and diametrically contradictory according to whatever political wind may be blowing, then you realise that to place such powers in the hands of the present Minister is nothing less than suicidal. I can remember the Minister telling us repeatedly that he was going to build up a structure here behind the bacon tariff which would make us absolutely independent of all the markets of the world. I have his letter before me now telling me that the whole future of the pig industry in this country depends upon that market.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must not bring in the bacon industry by a side wind on this Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister is now asking us to give him power to prohibit exports of cattle. On Monday he will tell us he will prohibit all exports because the British market does not matter a rap; and on Tuesday he will be telling us that it is of vital urgency to ship every beast in order to fill the quota Great Britain is allowing us. When you are dealing with a man of that kind, with a weathercock mind, who makes one declaration on Monday and declares it to be the only patriotic thing one can do to lend a hand in starving John Bull into submission, and on Tuesday says the only patriotic thing is to ship all of this commodity one can lay hands on, it is nothing less than suicidal to give him the discretion he seeks in this section. If he wants to make orders prohibiting the export of cattle, let him get the consent of Dáil Eireann. I venture to say that when he does come to Dáil Eireann looking for an ad hoc resolution to prohibit the export of cattle or anything else, he will not be able to tell the reason why except that President de Valera sent him a message that this was the correct political gesture to make at the moment and that there was an obligation on him to exhort people to export agricultural produce to the extent of the quota. Unfortunately in this case the Minister had to send out a confidential circular and I am happy to be able to say that I have been able to expose it.

Comment on this

You got it off your chest.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Deputy Dillon took the opportunity of making what he considered a very profound statement. The trouble with the Deputy is that he does not recognise consistency when he sees it. This is perfectly consistent with what we are doing in the bacon trade. We have talked about the British market having gone. I gave an illustration of what we meant by that. That market is going. We said that just the same as we say Cumann na nGaedheal has gone and Fine Gael has gone. They are going, but we say they are gone, and that is only an expression. It is the same way with the British market.

Comment on this

Then one is as true as the other?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Just the same. The only thing is that I regret one as much as the other—just as much, because I think this place would then be very uninteresting.

Comment on this

Very dismal, if it is left to you.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We have to appeal to the bacon curers because, if they do not keep up the quota, that part of the British market is gone.

Comment on this

Why do you not thank God for that?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It is going week by week and we cannot hold it. It is the same with every other country—if they drop their quota, that part of it is gone.

Comment on this

And then it goes to Denmark.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Denmark has been reduced just as much in the matter of bacon as we have been.

Comment on this

If we lose part of our quota, who will get it?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I have already told Deputies that this matter of bacon is irrelevant to the Bill.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It may be necessary from time to time for the Minister to prohibit exports of cattle. As a matter of fact, the Minister has the power already, and on the 1st January last he used it.

Comment on this

And he soon stopped it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Then he made an order allowing them to export again. We want power now specifying a certain kind of cattle. We may think it suits us at certain times to export a certain kind of cattle, and it may suit us at times to export cattle from a certain area and through certain ports. There are parts of this country, such as the West and other distant parts, where the people are not getting rid of their cattle as quickly as places nearer the big ports.

Comment on this