In Committee on Finance. - Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Bill, 1934—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 218–439 of 439. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 47 of 1934 ›
We might say that no cattle will be allowed out except under licences, these licences being given to buyers in certain counties, and we might allow the cattle to go out only through certain ports.
Comment on this
I know that is very galling on the Deputy—"Up de Valera." The terrible thing about it is that an increasing number every day are shouting "Up de Valera." Remember the 36 to 12 yesterday.
Comment on this
I understood from the Minister that it is his intention to send a certain number of buyers into certain parts of the Free State in order to export cattle out of certain counties, and this particular section gives him power to do that. I consider that is a very extraordinary power for the Minister to ask.
Comment on this
And prohibit the export of cattle from other counties and concentrate, say, on Kerry or Clare, and declare that no cattle are to be shipped out of this country except from a county which the Minister will name? You say you have that power already?
Comment on this
No, but the one power I am looking for is so that I may say also you must take a particular class of cattle.
Comment on this
If the Minister restricts the right of certain countries, is it not possible that they may retaliate as in the case of the economic war? If the Minister interferes with the export of cattle he may stop the export of cattle altogether. He says that certain countries are subjected to these quota restrictions. I question that and I think if the Minister will look the matter up he will find there are certain limitations on the part of Britain in regard to these quotas.
Comment on this
The Minister told us that the object of this Bill was to dispose of our surplus cattle. One way that the Minister is going to dispose of them is to seek power to prohibit their exportation. England in her trouble to find markets in the East for her cotton trade had negotiations and conferences with Japan in the past 12 months. Their case was that they wanted fair play for the British cotton trade in the East. I wonder what the English public would think of a British Minister who would seek power from the House of Commons to limit their cotton export——
Comment on this
We care because of the tomfoolery that is going to ruin this country. We have something to sell.
Comment on this
Deputies must address the Chair, and must not address one another in the second person across the floor——
Comment on this
Neither do we here, but we do care what they are doing. We care for business deals in special transactions. It is a business proposition to find a market for our surplus cattle. So much has that agitated the Government and the country that the Bill we are now considering has been introduced to deal with the problem of our surplus cattle. Yet here we have a section in it in which the Minister asks for power to prohibit the export of cattle. That is the kind of gesture made. When the British announced, on the 20th September last, that there would be a quota reducing the numbers of Free State fat cattle in the following three months that Britain would allow in as compared with the previous year, our Minister for Agriculture, playing the strong man, retaliated by saying "We will give the British none." Of course, that joke did not last long. If it had lasted long, neither the Minister nor the Ministry would last long. They had to give way because there was no outlet, and the decision come to was that the Minister had to introduce this Bill. It is not in consequence of the tariffs, because on the preceding section he informed the House that this Bill was not dealing with tariffs at all, but with the quota position.
The Minister has not given any reason why he should seek such powers. England would not want such powers to prohibit the export of her cotton trade. France would not think of seeking powers to prohibit the export of wines or artificial manures. The German Government would not think of taking power to prohibit the export of iron or of coal or various other articles. Similarly, the American Government would not look for such powers. The one thing that we have to export is cattle, and the way we solve our problems in connection with it is that the Minister for Agriculture asks the House, solemnly, to prohibit the export of cattle. He told us in his speech on the Second Reading that what prompted him to introduce this Bill was to find a market for our surplus fat cattle, and then he asks for power to prohibit the export of fat cattle. I do not think that outside Grangegorman Mental Home there was ever heard such a proposal. However, it is all of a piece with the rest of the Bill. The Minister said he wanted power to prohibit the export of cattle from certain areas and to encourage it from other areas. The John Browns will be dug out, through his Bill, and the Attorney-General, who has just entered the House, will be able to supply whatever the Minister forgets, and the John Browns and the Paddy Killeens will again turn up. Of course, it is a good way to use economic distress for political advantage. If it were on the eve of an election, anyone that wanted to export cattle from Wexford or Wicklow would be facilitated.
Comment on this
Or North City? Yes, sure; and they do more farming in the North City than Deputy Donnelly ever did, and they have not so many broken gates on their farms as the Minister for Agriculture has on his.
Comment on this
Speaking on the section: power is given under this section to the Minister, wherever an export prohibition order is in force, to issue an export licence, if he so thinks fit, to any person to export a particular animal specified in the licence to which such export prohibition order applies. The brazen effrontery of the Minister for Industry and Commerce has been used repeatedly here in this House to meet reasonable representations in respect of the setting up of a register of licencees. That brazen effrontery has been used to assert that there was no good reason for the establishment of such a register. Would the Minister for Agriculture venture to maintain that a considerable amount of public dissatisfaction has not manifested itself in regard to the administration of the export licences for cattle that he has been administering for some time?
Comment on this
No, except a political complaint, and I have heard that kind of complaint from time to time.
Comment on this
The Minister explained on that occasion that it was very natural for anyone to imagine that undue discrimination was being displayed. He went on to say that after he had allotted licences in accordance with the powers given to him, a few were left over and that these had to be administered according to his own discretion. We are all aware that when cattle are seized and sold at a sheriff's auction the John Browns and others of that ilk get every facility for any export licences they may require.
Comment on this
I do not care to say anything severe about bailiffs. Thanks to the Minister, they have found their homes in the ranks of Fianna Fáil and have learned to expect everything from Fianna Fáil, and are getting it. But the Minister will know that, whether his benevolence is being exercised on behalf of the bailiff or of his own political supporters, from a variety at least of his own supporters complaints have reached him about this. Again and again the Minister's attention must have been drawn to the trafficking that is going on in licences. He must be aware of cases where men sold those licences, for a consideration, to somebody else. His attention must have been drawn to the fact that it has been manifest to everybody that persons, who were notoriously supporters of the Fianna Fáil Party, could get, over and above whatever licences they were entitled to, a very substantial share of that surplus of licences which remained in the hands of the Minister for Agriculture. It is hardly necessary to explain that these individuals, who are getting that special consideration, did not come to me to tell me about it. The only source of information to which I can apply is the people who did not get licences.
Comment on this
All I ask the Minister to do is this: to take the reasonable course, in order definitely to allay for all time public suspicion in this matter, of making a register of the exporters' licences and making it possible for every public man to say to everybody who comes with a complaint that his neighbour is getting a surplus of licences while he has been denied a licence:—"Go out and look at the register and, if you can furnish the facts to me showing that that is so, I will raise the matter in the Dáil and have it fully thrashed out." That is the only possible way of making an end of that kind of thing. At present a man comes to me in Donegal and says: "I have applied for licences again and again and have got, perhaps, two; yet I met So-and-So in the fair, who never shipped a beast, and he has got a dozen or twenty licences, and he was selling licences in the fair." There is no use in my going and asking the person concerned if that is true or not. I have no means of finding out. The only possible thing I can do is to raise it here in the House. I shall be told by the Minister that these are general charges, and I shall be asked to state the full particulars and they will be investigated; but the full particulars are not investigated.
Comment on this
I regret, Sir, that I have been led into disorder by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I am simply asking the Minister for Agriculture to provide everybody with a weapon whereby they may allay suspicion or misapprehension in regard to those licences. That weapon is to prepare and make public a register in which there would be a record of everybody's licences. In that way, everybody will know what is being done, and if a man goes into the cattle exporting business he will know that that information will be available to everybody in the trade, and he will know, having gone into the business willingly, that there will be a public register of his transactions and that he is liable to have the matter of the licences granted to him raised, by name, here in this House, and that the Minister will be questioned as to why somebody got licences when his neighbour did not get them. If that were done, the Minister would be able to say that if So-and-So wants additional licences, he has got to remember that if he gets them the matter, almost certainly, will be raised in Dáil Eireann, and his business thrashed out across the floor of the House. The Minister also would have the added relief that anyone, who would attempt to approach him with a corrupt proposal for more licences than he is entitled to, would know that there was no use in asking him, because all the licences have to be recorded on a public register where everybody can examine them.
I have warned the Minister that so long as these transactions in connection with the issue of licences are hidden under a veil of secrecy, so long will there be public distrust and public suspicion; and that the only remedy and the only way to allay that suspicion and that distrust is to give full publicity to every licence issued and to the conditions attaching thereto. This licensing provision under Section 28 is more drastic than any I have seen so far, because in this case the Minister may, "whenever an export prohibition order is in force, if he so thinks fit, issue to any person a licence in the prescribed form to export a particular animal specified in such licence to which such export prohibition order applies, and may attach to such licence such conditions and limitations (including conditions as to the route by which the animal is to be exported) as the Minister shall think proper and shall specify in such licence."
Is it necessary to elaborate the urgent necessity of making the terms and conditions of licences that will be issued under that section public? Suppose a shipping company gets into some labour trouble and their cattle shipments fall off for some entirely ulterior reason, the first thing that will spring to their mind is that the Labour Party have brought pressure to bear upon the Minister for Agriculture, to impose a condition that cattle will be shipped by another route and the Minister will be immediately put upon his proof; whereas if the conditions attaching to the licence are published in a public register, no such suspicion for such a thing could exist. I throw that out as one conceivable occasion of misapprehension. There are thousands of such. Passing this section, as it is, will breed distrust, suspicion and apprehension of corruption through the country. I press the Minister most strongly that he should see that the fullest publicity should be given to the terms upon which these licences are issued. In the event of such publicity being given the major objection falls to the ground.
Comment on this
Will the Minister inform the House as to how he proposes to allocate those licences in the future? This matter was referred to by Deputy Dillon to-day, and I put it to the Minister yesterday that a register of these licences should be kept and that it should be open for inspection. In January last the Minister agreed that it was demonstrated to him that it was possible and practicable to issue those licences to the feeders. He agreed to give the licences to the feeders later on. Will he agree now that in future under this Bill, when it becomes an Act, that the feeders will get the licences? I do not see anywhere in this Bill where the price is fixed for export. I would be glad to know if any provision is made in this Bill for it? I have not seen any. Supposing the exporter, the dealer gets a licence as dealers get them now. We know that licences are being trafficked in in County Armagh. Does the Minister deny that?
Comment on this
I do not know whether the ambassador from Armagh here is responsible for sending these licences to Armagh. But they are there to be bought at a price as the Minister boasted yesterday. English shippers are getting the licences. Is there any condition attaching to the licences that these shippers get or is there a condition that they will have to pay the minimum price for the cattle. I do not see that anywhere in the Bill. I would be glad to be informed if it is there. I have not seen it. We will have a surplus of fat cattle.
Comment on this
The Deputy has told us that he has not seen it in the Bill. Is that needless repetition?
Comment on this
What is the matter with the Minister for Finance? Will the Minister for Finance become audible? Surely there is no subject on which he can better exhibit his ignorance than on agriculture.
Comment on this
Neither the Minister nor his colleague will divert me from the point with which I am dealing. Perhaps they would be glad if they could.
Comment on this
They would like to, but neither can Deputy Smith divert me. There will be a separate stock of fat cattle. Licences will not be given to the producer. Licences will be distributed with the same sleight of hand, the three card trick business. Exporters will get them. They are not buying cattle for sale and when they are not buying cattle for sale they are not bound by any conditions. To buy those cattle the Minister accommodates them with licences and they can buy them at any price. That is the position as I read the Bill. That is not the end of it. I would like if the Minister would point out where in this Bill is any control over the price except in the case of the price of cattle that will be bought for slaughter here. Even though the beast is marked, that beast could not be killed until, say, the 1st of September next and not before. It will be an offence to sell it to the butcher and it will be an offence for the butcher to buy that beef for slaughter before the 1st of September.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the facilities given to the exporters— facilities that are not given to the consumers at all, and I am dealing with the method in which those licences will be handed out.
Comment on this
This section deals with the issue and the method of issue of export licences and nothing else.
Comment on this
These licences are issued following presumably present practice. Presumably they will be issued to the dealers who are not controlled by the Bill, and who will make what they made last January and the half of February—fabulous profits. I would like that an assurance from the Minister would be issued to the producers and to the producers only. The Minister has no way out of that position but to issue them to the producers. In order to have the thing done fairly and equitably, there should be a register kept in the Minister's Department, and that register should be open to inspection by anybody who wanted to inspect it so as to see who got the licences. That will be a test of the sincerity and the anxiety of the Minister in administering the Act fairly to all citizens. Will the Minister keep such a register? He has no case whatever for continuing to give licences to the shippers. When we met him on the 19th of January in his own office or in the boardroom of the Department of Agriculture——
Comment on this
How often is the Deputy to be allowed to repeat himself?
Comment on this
The Minister agreed that it was the producer who should get the licences, and he put that into practice a month after. When the summer came he said it was impracticable to give licences because it was impossible to take a census of the cattle on the land which were then fit for slaughter. This Bill provides him with the machinery by which he will know at any moment the number of cattle ready for slaughter, the number of cattle permitted to be slaughtered, or the number of cattle fit for slaughter. So the case is perfect, and there is no way out for the Minister but to give these licences to producers. Then if the producer sells for slaughter, that is controlled by the Act. He must sell at the minimum price. Anyhow it is his funeral to sell at any price he likes. He will get the value of the licence, and in no other way is he going to be assured of a price——
Comment on this
I told the Deputy before that this section dealt with the licences and the method of issuing licences. There is nothing about price in this section.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the method of issuing the licences, and the only method that would be equitable to the producer would be to issue the licence to him.
Comment on this
Reverting to the matter of prices, as the Deputy is inclined to do, is not relevant to the section.
Comment on this
There is no use in making a statement as to why a certain thing should be done if I do not support it with solid reasons. On the one hand, if the licence is issued to the dealer, there will be no control price for the dealer buying fat cattle for export. He can buy them at any price he likes. He is not controlled by the minimum price, therefore he is going to buy them by robbing the producer, and his instrument in robbing the producer will be the licence issued by the Minister. He makes his extra profit by selling in the Birkenhead market from which the Minister starts to fix his price. The only equitable way to allot licences is to allot them to the producer. That licence gives the producer a permit to offer for sale for export, with the passport into the British market tied on the beast's horn, or he can export the beast himself to the British market, and he can get there the basic price on which the Minister builds up his price for the home market. On any grounds you want to take this section, the continuance of the Minister's method of issuing these export licences to anybody but the producer, has nothing to sustain it. The only argument that the Minister was able to put up for the change over——
Comment on this
Yes. I think there is a Standing Order which states that a Deputy who is guilty of needless repetition, irrelevancy, or obstructing the business, should be asked to resume his seat. The Deputy has got 25 minutes on this section. The purport of his speech, I gathered, was to restrict the issuing of licences by the Minister to feeders only. If the Deputy seriously intended that point to be discussed, he has had sufficient time, I submit, within the past four days to have put down an amendment to the section compelling the Minister to do that, but he has not done so. On the last section nearly half an hour was occupied by the discussion, and at the end the section was not challenged, even though the Minister did not reply. I think the Deputy is obviously trying to obstruct the business of the House.
Comment on this
There was no unnecessary repetition. If we had not the unnecessary interruption from the Minister for Finance, I was just about to conclude. I have made my point. I have supported it by arguments, and have shown the reason why certain people should get licences in preference to anybody else. The Minister agreed that these people should get the licences last January.
Comment on this
This Bill provides the Minister with machinery that he had not had at that time or that he had not had when he changed the system in April or May. There is no excuse left for the Minister. I should like to hear him as to whether it is his intention to give licences to the feeders in future, both winter and summer. If the licences are not given to the feeders, what control will this Bill exercise over the shippers to pay the minimum price for fat cattle?
Comment on this
If the Deputy had asked that question in the beginning and waited for a reply, we would have saved 25 minutes. We can fix the price for the exporters.
Comment on this
Under this section. If the Deputy read the section instead of making a 25 minutes speech we would get on much more quickly. He makes his 25 minutes speech——
Comment on this
The section states:
"Whenever an export prohibition order is in force, the Minister may, if he so thinks fit, issue to any person a licence .... in the prescribed form to export a particular animal specified in such licence to which such export prohibition order applies, and may attach to such licence such conditions and limitations .... as the Minister shall think proper."
I can put in a condition that he must pay the same price as is paid for home beef. If the Deputy had sat down after asking that question, we would have been saved 25 minutes, because all the rest of his speech was ráméis, but, of course, he wanted to make his usual 25 minutes speech.
Comment on this
Why does the Deputy, like Deputy Curran or any other Deputy, not ask his question first and then make his speech? He wants to be sure, of course, to make his speech at all costs. We can fix a price for the exporters.
Comment on this
Why, then, do you ask for powers in the Bill to fix a price definitely for home consumption when you can by order fix the price for export? I question it very much. It is only an afterthought of the Minister's, because I raised the point now.
Comment on this
The Minister may have afterthoughts, but the Deputy has fore-thoughts—speaking before he knows anything about the question. If the Deputy ever became Minister for Agriculture, which God forbid——
Comment on this
——he would go to the draftsman and say: "I do not know exactly what I want, but you can draft the Bill," but I go to the draftsman and I tell him exactly what I want, and the draftsman puts it in that way. I am not the draftsman, but he knows what I want. One does not need to be a draftsman, however, to understand this section.
Comment on this
I can attach any condition I like to any licence I issue, including a condition as to prices.
Comment on this
"The Minister may attach to such licence any conditions," and Part II of the conditions may have reference to the price. I can issue a licence to a man, saying: "You can buy 50 fat cattle on this for export, but you must pay 25s. per cwt., and that is part of the conditions of the licence." In any case it is not necessary to fix the price. That is another thing. If the home butcher is paying 25s. per cwt. for fat cattle, how is the exporter going to get cattle at a lesser price? It is not necessary at all. We come then to the point as to why we should go to the trouble of issuing all these licences to dealers other than the ordinary exporter who can do the business better. The ordinary exporter has connections on the export market. He can get a better price for these cattle than the feeder would. If the feeder gets just as good a price, why should we give out the licences to the feeders?
The method of distribution will be as I explained last night. The Consultative Council on the Export-of-Cattle Quota, in consultation with me, lays down a certain basis on which these licences are issued. That basis will still be used. Any member of that Consultative Council who has any complaint to make about the issue of licences to any particular person can find out what that particular person is getting. At their meetings, they have a look at the register. They bring in a list of the complaints they receive. They find out what the person concerned has got, and not one of them has yet found an irregularity. They always find that the licences are given on the basis drawn up by them in consultation with me.
Comment on this
I should like to know what is meant by the "conditions and limitations" which the Minister may impose.
Comment on this
I could, for instance, say that cattle must be exported direct to Britain by sea rather than by rail and sea. I might even say that they must be exported from a particular port. If we wanted, for instance, to get Kerry cattle bought, we might say that they must go by a special port.
Comment on this
No, and these are the only additional powers I am seeking. I can specify certain classes of cattle for a certain port.
Comment on this
The Minister said he can issue licences and attach to them any conditions as to price that he likes. I question if he has that power and he is certainly not asking for it in this Bill. Why should he have power to fix a price below the minimum price paid here? Does the Minister claim that he will have power under this Bill to fix an export price before he fixes a minimum price for beef in the home market? He goes along childishly and says that there is no need to fix a price because when the home butcher will have to pay, say, 25/- a cwt., the exporter will have to compete with him and pay that price. I think I am quoting the Minister with substantial accuracy.
Comment on this
Does not the Minister know that there are two beasts offering for every one that the home butcher wants? Is not the problem which gave rise to this Bill that there are too many fat cattle for home consumption?
Comment on this
The Minister says that because the home butcher wants one beast and must pay 25/- a cwt., the exporter who comes along must compete with that butcher, although there may be two, three or four beasts offering. If you had two butchers or dealers endeavouring to get the same beast, there would be competition in price but when you have three or four beasts and only two buyers there will be no competition.
Comment on this
It refers to the imposition of conditions and limitations in connection with the licences.
Comment on this
You thought it necessary to refer specifically in that section to the route, but the part of Hamlet— the price—is left out. When dealing with purchases for the home market, whole sections were devoted to the regulation of prices, but nothing is said here about export prices.
Comment on this
It is a pity you did not study law in addition to other things.
Comment on this
I have enough commonsense to read an ordinary document and discuss it. The Minister is not going to get out of this corner with back answers. He cannot point to any part of the Bill in which he has got this authority. He will not give licences to the producers. He will give them to the shippers, as he is doing at present. Then the shippers can come in on a glutted market and pay any price they like for the surplus stock. That is the Minister's only solution of the quota problem, and no remedy is being provided in respect of the surplus fat cattle.
Comment on this
We are dealing, on this section, with the issue of export prohibition orders, and are concerned only with licences pertaining to the prohibition period. I do not anticipate that these prohibition orders will be put into force very often. I think that the number of licences to be issued during the currency of these prohibition orders will not be very great. There may be some point in what Deputy Belton said, that if the Minister is only going to issue an export prohibition order when it is necessary to keep the cattle in the country, he will issue licences to export only in exceptional circumstances. The licences will not be general. If that be so, there will be an advantage given to some person or persons. It is obvious that the general run of exporters would not get licences in such circumstances or there would be no need for a prohibition order at all. I do not know how that could be obviated. There would have to be some discrimination. As regards price, when I first read the section I did not perceive that the Minister had power to fix export prices. The section deals with the power of the Minister to issue licences for export when a prohibition order is in force and I took it that the section merely purported to regulate the manner in which these licences would be issued. That is what the reading of the section conveyed to my mind, as I think it would convey to the mind of the ordinary man. The fact that the provision as to specifying the route by which animals might be exported was put in parenthesis rather suggested to me that it was regarded as something extraneous to the provisions of the section, which had to do merely with the issue of licences. As I am admitting that the Minister has power to fix prices——
Comment on this
There is a reference in the section to "conditions and limitations" which the Minister may attach to the issue of licences. He might think it proper to provide for the payment of certain prices. I suggest that the matter should be made clearer and that an addendum should be made to this section so that it would be in this form: "including conditions as to the route by which the animal is to be exported and the price to be paid for the animal." If the Minister would make that addition, I think he would be making it clear that he was going to safeguard the price.
Comment on this
Would the Minister make clear the position of shippers, and losses that they may sustain. How would they stand if there was a bad market in England for fat cattle, and that they had to pay the fixed price and also the tariff on the cattle? What would their position be if they were not able to make their money in England? Would the Minister take their position into account?
Comment on this
I take it that these people very often buy cattle here and do not know what price they are going to get in England for them. They make sure to make up their losses the next time. The same thing happens in the case of men who buy pigs. At the time that they come to sell the bacon on the British market the price of bacon there may have gone down. In order to make up their losses they fall the price of pigs. We are in the same position. We could not make up to a shipper for the losses that he would have on particular animals. We would have to watch the British market closely, and if prices come down there we would have to come down in our fixed prices. We cannot make up to the shipper for the loss that he has sustained.
Comment on this
I know, but does he not pay the fixed price now, in effect? He pays whatever the market price is.
Comment on this
On the section, is it clear that a butcher can make sausages, corned beef, etc., from meat products without a licence?
Comment on this
In the definition section the expression "marketable product" includes meat preserved in a barrel, tin, jar, or other container, but does not include fresh meat or meat preserved and sold otherwise than in a container. Under that definition corned beef would be exempt.
Comment on this
Unless they are sold in a container they would not be a "marketable product."
Comment on this
The Minister understands the way that a butcher handles the products of a beast in order to get rid of them. Would he require to have a manufacturer's licence for that?
Comment on this
Is the Minister certain that a sausage would not be included? As well as meat you have other ingredients in it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:—
In sub-section (1), after the word "Minister" to insert the words "with the consent of the Minister for Finance."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:—
In sub-section (2) after the word "Minister" to insert the words "with the consent of the Minister for Finance."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 12:—
In sub-section (3), to delete the word "so" where it occurs in the first line of the sub-section and to substitute the word "do."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:—
In sub-section (3), to add at the end of the sub-section the words "but the Minister shall give to every such officer and person a statement in writing defining his duties and the extent of his authority."
Comment on this
On the section I want to say this: We have been discussing certain restrictions that are to be placed on butchers and other classes of business people. They are being restricted in their trade as to what they may and may not do. Under this particular section we are giving power to the Minister himself to do all the things that any ordinary trader may not do. I just want to call the attention of the House to that: that the Minister himself is being empowered to do all the things that an ordinary trader is being prohibited from doing. The position, therefore, is that to-morrow the Minister may set up in various classes of business which traders are to be debarred from carrying on. He is to have a monopoly of certain classes of business. It is only fair, I think, that the House generally should understand that, and that Deputies should realise that they are voting definitely to place such powers in the hands of the Minister or of any future Minister.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:—
In sub-section (1), after the word "sell" to insert the words "lease, let or otherwise dispose of."
There is a provision similar to this in the Cereals Bill. For instance, the Minister, having taken over some land, might consider that some ordinary commercial individual might carry on the business as well as he would, or, perhaps, better, and he might be inclined to sell or lease or dispose of the land for the purpose. Amendment No. 15, which follows, is consequential and amendment No. 16 is also consequential.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:—
In sub-section (1), after the word "price" to insert the words "and on such terms and conditions."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:—
In sub-section (2), to delete the words "on a sale."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:—
In sub-section (2), to delete from the word "audited" to the end of the sub-section and substitute the words "transmitted to the Comptroller and Auditor-General, who shall audit, certify and report upon such accounts."
A provision similar to this has been inserted in the Cereals Bill
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:—
In sub-section (3), to delete the word "auditor" and substitute the words "Comptroller and Auditor-General," and to delete the word "auditor's" and substitute the word "his."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 19:—
In sub-section (1) to delete the words "profits made," and substitute the words "moneys received by the Minister."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:—
In sub-section (2) to delete the words "in so far as they are not discharged out of the earnings of such business," and substitute the words "to such extent as shall be sanctioned by the Minister for Finance."
This is also a consequential amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:—
In sub-section (3), after the word "include" to insert the words "all or any of the following provisions, that is to say:—(a)," and at the end of the section to add two paragraphs as follows:—
"(b) a provision requiring or empowering the Minister to purchase, either at any time or in specified circumstances, all or any part of the issued share capital of a company for the promotion and formation of which such money is so lent;
(c) a provision whereby the Minister agrees to supply cattle, either free of charge or on specified terms, to the person to whom or the company for the promotion and formation of which such money is so lent."
This is an amendment which is necessary under this particular section, so that we can vary the investment from loan to shares issued, or make other arrangements with a company to whom we may have issued debenture, or lent money in any way. We may subsequently convert that into shares.
Comment on this
Under this section the Minister can lend money to any person engaged in any business to which this section applies. He can vary the conditions of the loan after the loan has been made. He can vary the rate of interest. He can vary the time of payment. He can vary the sum to be repaid. He can remit the whole thing. I wonder is it good business to give up the credit of the State which we hear so much about. General O'Duffy was taunted with being responsible for the failure of the National Loan. If we are contemplating the issue of a National Loan is this the way to do business? We borrow, and we lend the money to people on certain conditions. After the money has been lent —to very wild cat schemes too—on certain conditions, we can vary those conditions after the contract has been signed. If we lend State money, at a rate even lower than we pay for the money, we can remit the interest altogether. We can even remit the principal altogether. This is the power which is sought in this section. It is a monstrous proposal.
Comment on this
A Chinn Chomhairle, the Deputy perhaps does not realise that when the Minister makes an agreement it is extremely difficult to make any alteration afterwards. When a private individual or a banker makes a loan and the person comes along in 12 months afterwards and says "I cannot pay on a particular date, but if you extend the period for a year longer I will be all right," the alteration may be made. The Minister is in a very difficult position in regard to a variation like that unless he has the power. That is really what the power is for. We will not, of course, make the variation unless there is agreement between the two parties. The agreement of course in all cases is likely to be for a relaxation, because the other party is not likely to ask for more severe terms. If the other party asks for a relaxation or an extended period then by this section we have the power to make the variation.
Comment on this
I quite see the difficulty which the Minister would be up against. When somebody who has fallen on bad times comes to the Minister, he would like to help him out. But let us see how this reads:—
"Whenever the Minister has lent any money under this section it shall be lawful for the Minister to do all or any of the following things, that is to say:
(a) With the consent of the Minister for Finance, to vary in any manner all or any of the terms and conditions on which such money was so lent;
(b) with the consent aforesaid, to compound for or wholly release all or any part of such moneys or of any interest or other payment payable on or in relation to such moneys;
(c) to take such steps (including legal proceedings) as the Minister may think proper to compel payment of or to recover all or any part of such moneys ..."
The Minister is asking for power to lend money and forgive it if he likes?
Comment on this
Well if the Minister is afraid of that, it shows that his business foresight is bad.
Comment on this
I think the power asked for by the Minister in this section is altogether too drastic. As pointed out by Deputy Belton, he may vary in any manner the terms and conditions under which money is lent, after the arrangements have been made to lend that money. As Deputy Belton also said, he is looking for power from this House to lend money, and at the same time he is looking for power from the House to forgive it if he wants to. That is a power which the Minister, or any other Minister, should not seek from this House. If the occasion arises that the Minister is not able to collect the money, he could seek for power then, but it is not right that he should look for power to lend money, and at the same time look for power to forgive it. I cannot see why he should seek such powers, or why legislation should be so devised as to give the Minister the powers which he seeks under this section. I certainly will not agree to it. I will challenge a division if I cannot get any better explanation.
Comment on this
I really cannot see why this section should be inserted at all. It is a section which is absolutely unbusiness-like, and I do not think it will ever be necessary. I cannot see the Minister ever using it. If there is any necessity to forgive or wipe out a loan there are ordinary channels through which it can be struck off as irrecoverable, or wiped out in some such manner. The powers asked for are very wide, if they were interpreted strictly, and put into force strictly. I am not concerned so much about the forgiving part of it, because I do not think that would ever be put into operation, but I am concerned with the powers for increasing the rate. Having lent somebody money at 4 per cent. for a period of ten years you might come along next day and say, "I will charge you 6 per cent. and you must pay in three years." I do not say the powers will be used.
Comment on this
Of course, you cannot break the agreement without the consent of the other party.
Comment on this
The sub-section says "... it shall be lawful for the Minister to do all or any of the following things." I take that as meaning that he is now taking power to do all or any of those things.
Comment on this
"It shall be lawful for the Minister to do all or any of the following things." If the Minister wants to make it strict he might insert "not" and add "otherwise than by agreement." I am not concerned so much with the releasing of people from obligations, because I do not believe that could be done except under exceptional conditions. I should like to see some addendum inserted in regard to those varying powers—something to this effect: "Other than increasing the interest or reducing the period of the payment." I should like to see some safeguard in the section to satisfy me in that respect; otherwise I have no desire to change the section very much, because I do not think it will ever be used. Even with the addendum I do not think it will be used, and the proper method would be to wipe out the section altogether.
Comment on this
If the section were wiped out I would not have power to lend money at all for those purposes.
Comment on this
I am convinced of that. But I will make sure and if necessary propose an amendment, if not here, in the other House, on that point.
Comment on this
To the effect that I cannot break an existing agreement without the other person's consent.
Comment on this
I move amendment 22:—
Before Section 38, but in Part 8, to insert a new section as follows:—
Whenever, under a scheme whereby compensation is payable out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas for cattle slaughtered or surrendered for slaughter in pursuance of such scheme, the Minister becomes possessed of any cattle (whether alive or dead), it shall be lawful for the Minister to dispose of such cattle in whatever manner he shall think proper.
I thought there was power in the Bill to do this but it is doubtful if there is power to dispose of cattle under the circumstances. I stated several times that old cows for making meat are worth very little in ordinary circumstances and naturally if we were to buy them we would have to give more than we could afford to give. The system we propose to work would be to buy these old cows from farmers at 50/- or £3 and sell them to the factory for very much less.
Comment on this
No. But anyone who has cows worth not more than £3 might send them along and I could take them. If they were worth more than that they could keep them.
Comment on this
So that it is open to a farmer to get all he can for them. If your price is £3 you are bound to £3.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister will pay the Minister for Finance £1 per head for these old cows.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 23:—
After the word "means" where it first occurs in the section to insert in brackets the words ("subject to the provisions of this section.")
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 24:—
To add at the end of the section two new sub-sections as follows:—
(2) The Minister may, with the consent of the Minister for Finance, at any time by order declare any particular class or description of necessitous persons to be recipients for the purposes of this Part of this Act, and whenever any such order is made, the word "recipient" shall, so long as such order is in force and subject to any amendment thereof, be construed and have effect in this Part of this Act as including the class or description of persons declared by such order to be recipients.
(3) The Minister, with the consent of the Minister for Finance, may at any time by order amend or revoke any order previously made by him under this section.
This proposal arises out of a suggestion made by Deputy Cosgrave that we were confining free meat to two classes, recipients of home assistance and of unemployment assistance. The Deputy stated that there might be other classes, so far unforeseen, which should be included and this amendment is to allow the Minister, by a future regulation, to bring in any other class that should obviously be brought in.
Comment on this
I am very glad that the Minister has brought in the amendment to deal with what was an obvious blank in the Bill, so that benefit should be given to people other than those in receipt of home assistance or unemployment assistance. This is an attempt to meet that position. I do not know how the Minister is going to effect it. He will have to put in some regulation. Obviously people whose means do not amount to a certain sum would be included. There are numbers of workers who are neither in receipt of home assistance nor unemployment assistance who are in necessitous circumstances but too proud to live at the State expense. If there are privileges to be given to certain classes there should be machinery to extend them to others. The Minister should provide for that power in some other form. There should be some local authority with power to give such people relief without any order or appeal to the Minister. Deputies will have in mind the type of cases I am referring to. There are in every constituency numbers of these people. While I am glad the amendment has been brought in I am not quite certain that any order made would not be bound up with such regulations as would debar many persons who have never been defined as necessitous persons, from benefiting. It should be within the discretion of some body like a county council or the Society of St. Vincent de Paul to give relief to necessitous persons, other than those receiving home assistance or unemployment assistance.
Comment on this
That can be done. I am sure we could frame some sort of order defining the class of people who might be on the lists of the Society of St. Vincent de Paul.
Comment on this
I stated on the Second Reading that we exported about 240,000 fat cattle in 1933 and consumed about 120,000. I said that home consumption is about 180,000 and that export licences will account for 120,000, which brings the number up to 300,000. If we dispose of 60,000 by way of free meat and some other schemes that we are providing for, for instance, tinned meat, we will dispose of as many cattle as in 1932 or 1933. Our surplus cattle problem amounts to that. We calculate that the free meat scheme can be made to absorb 78,000, if pushed to the limit.
Comment on this
The people are there, and why not give them enough?
Comment on this
We can solve this problem if this Bill can be administered. I admit that it is a hard Bill to administer. That is why the Minister is asking for such drastic powers.
Comment on this
We exported in 1933 240,000 cattle and we consumed 120,000. The Minister now estimates that consumption will dispose of 180,000 and export 120,000, while 60,000 will be distributed free.
Comment on this
We have to deal with 60,000. We contemplate a tinned meat factory, as well as the free meat, and between all the 60,000 will be disposed of.
Comment on this
Of course, the Minister realises that these people to whom free beef vouchers will be issued ate meat in 1933.
Comment on this
You are hardly worth it after this Bill. However that is the Minister's statement. I am afraid he will be disappointed. I hope not. All I have to say is that it is a poor solution that we have to start the profession of pauperism here in order to get rid of our surplus produce, instead of having the people, with their heads up, walking in to buy that meat. Now we have to send them in as paupers.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 25:—
In sub-section (1), before the words "by order" to insert the words "with the consent of the Minister for Finance."
This is the same as amendment No. 8.
Comment on this
Does the butcher contract to pay the ordinary price for the beef he will have to supply?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 28:—
In sub-section (2), to delete the words "and take such other steps as appear" and substitute the words "as appears."
As the section stands, the inspector is the person who would be empowered and expected to take up a case and see it to the end. That is not usual in legislation of this kind. The inspector should report to the Department and then the Department would take the proper action through the Chief State Solicitor. This amendment brings it into line with other legislation in that way.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 29:—
In sub-section (2), to delete all from the words "for securing" to the end of the sub-section.
That deals with the same thing.