We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Supplementary Estimate. Vote 69—Relief Schemes.

Contributions 1–133 of 250. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

I move:—

Go ndeontar suim Bhreise ná raghaidh that £150,000 chun íoctha an Mhuirir a thiocfaidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar chríoch an 31adh lá de Mhárta, 1935, chun Síntiúisí i gcóir Fóirithine ar Dhíomhaointeas agus ar Cháthar.

That a Supplementary sum not exceeding £150,000 be granted to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending 31st March, 1935, for contributions towards the Relief of Unemployment and Distress.

In connection with this Estimate, in view of the statements which have appeared in certain organs of the public Press to the effect that the Government had rather underestimated the expenditure for which a provision of this kind would be required in this year, I think it necessary to remind the House of a statement which I made in presenting the usual financial statement to the House in May last. After referring to certain aspects of the matter, I went on to say:—

"In the meantime we have already included in the published Estimates for the year the sum of £350,000 for relief works; we propose to add to that an additional £150,000, making £500,000 in all, which with our existing organisations represents the utmost amount that could be spent within the 12 months upon such works to secure therefrom an adequate social return."

This Estimate now, of £150,000, is being introduced accordingly.

Comment on this

Could the Minister give us some idea of what the allocation of the £350,000 has been up to the present?

Comment on this

It has not been appropriated up to the present.

Comment on this

Can the Minister tell us what general plans have been made for its expenditure?

Comment on this
Hugh Victor Flinn Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Flinn) Fianna Fáil

The particulars in regard to the previous grant of last year—that is, the particulars of the distribution of the money—were published in relation to every single district in the Saorstát. Broadly speaking, it may be taken that this will be on the same basis.

Comment on this

In connection with this Vote for relief schemes, I venture to say that every side of the House will approve the appropriation of more money for relief schemes. It was never more needed than to-day. The benefits of the alternative markets with which Fianna Fáil has provided us; the benefits of the revised agriculture under the administration of Dr. James Ryan, Minister for Agriculture; the benefits of the hundreds of factories, which Deputy Norton aptly described as being carried on under conditions which would disgrace ancient Babylon——

Comment on this

Which were not true.

Comment on this

I leave it to Deputy Tom Kelly to find out whether the conditions were true or not. These benefits, with this half million which will be poured out now for the purpose of counteracting potential starvation, will be very welcome. I want to make special representation to the responsible Minister that the claims of small farmers — particularly married men with families—should receive prior consideration when work is being allotted on the various schemes that are undertaken by the Board of Works in connection with the expenditure of this money.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy aware that that has been done already?

Comment on this

I was just going to refer to the detail that induces me to make that representation here to-day. Let me say at once that, in my opinion, from my experience of the administration of relief schemes in the past, the central administration of relief schemes was never better than at present. I have put forward a number of schemes myself, and I know of a number of persons not acquainted with the Fianna Fáil Party who have put forward schemes, and, to the best of my knowledge, they have all been considered on their merits. I have also found that when I have approached the Board, either directly or by letter, any representations I had to make to it received fair and reasonable consideration. I think it is only right that that tribute should be paid to the central organisation of this relief scheme administration.

The reason I have mentioned the necessity for extending a preference to married men in connection with these schemes is that the central administration is in no sense reproduced down on the site of the works in the country. I fully appreciate the difficulty of controlling these schemes right from the central office down to the actual place where the work is being carried out; but my experience is that gangers charged with the carrying out of the work in remote rural areas have practically placed an embargo on any individual who is not prepared to join a Fianna Fáil club. The Parliamentary Secretary will remember that 12 months ago I said that there was not at that time very much substance in promiscuous charges of gross favouritism in the employment of individual workers. I am obliged to amend that statement now, and, in my opinion, the abuse to which I refer has grown up in the course of the last 12 months. I have heard, from any number of districts, that men have been told—not officially, but nevertheless, effectively—that if they join the local Fianna Fáil Cumann and pay their shilling, they will get work, and that if they do not join they will not get work.

Comment on this

A woman told me that a woman told her.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary is a past-master at making offensive observations in this House. The Parliamentary Secretary need not imagine that by extracting the tribute of raucous laughter from Deputy Corry he will carry conviction to anybody who is honestly interested in the administration of his Department.

Comment on this

We all laughed.

Comment on this

The difference between Deputy Smith and Deputy Corry is not so wide as to call for an express differentiation.

Comment on this

What about yourself and O'Duffy?

Comment on this

I may say, as I have said on previous occasions, that the Parliamentary Secretary, when dealing with his own Department, usually sheds the weapon of insolence. I strongly appeal to him now to do the same thing. I have not hesitated in public to pay a tribute to the administration of his Department. I am now drawing his attention to an existing evil which I fully understand is very difficult to correct, but I would not mention it unless I was absolutely satisfied of its existence. I would not bring his attention to it if I had not a kind of idea that he must really exert himself to make an end of it.

Comment on this

Might I ask a question? I am going to take it that the Deputy is speaking in good faith, as I am speaking in good faith, and that the common purpose of the whole House is to see that these things are honestly administered. It is agreed that the intention of the central administration, by every influence it can exert, is in the direction of that fair play.

Comment on this

That is my impression.

Comment on this

The question of carrying it out depends on whether or not that spirit is carried right down through. It is recognised that it is difficult for us at the centre to know everything that is going on at the extreme ends. The Deputy has knowledge of actual evils. Has he communicated them to me?

Comment on this

No. The explanation is quite simple and the Parliamentary Secretary, in his own experience, must know the difficulty that is involved in these cases. It is impossible for me to charge an individual ganger with having refused to employ an individual man because he is not a member of a Fianna Fáil club. The ganger will say: "Here is John Murphy and there is Pat Coughlan—what is there between these two men?" All I know is that Pat Coughlan is a supporter of Fine Gael and John Murphy is a supporter of Fianna Fáil and that no matter how often that comparison is made John Murphy will get the work every time. But if I went to the Parliamentary Secretary and said: "Here is a clear case of victimisation" he will say: "What is there to choose between these two men? They are both single men or they are both married men. Was not John Murphy just as much entitled as Pat Coughlan?" I would be obliged to say, "I must admit that is true." But the outcome of it is that they are all John Murphys. Is it not a very strange thing that when the claims were equal in all these cases the scale never came down on that side, but always came down on the other.

Comment on this

Might I put another question? We employed somewhere about 20,000 or 30,000 last year on about 2,000 or 3,000 works. These were known to all Deputies. Is the Deputy aware of any particular case in which he has the names of the men who were employed upon a job which can, on investigation, be shown to fall into the category which he declares to be universal? I want one case. I will investigate it. I will go further—I will ask the Deputy to sit beside me and do the investigating with me.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary asked me if I know any relief work where favouritism was shown to supporters of the Fianna Fáil Party. He further invites me if, in future, a case is brought to my attention where a ganger is showing an undue discrimination, that is a discrimination not based on the material needs of the people wanting work, to communicate the case to him and he will undertake to investigate it.

Comment on this

Undoubtedly. He will be extremely grateful to that Deputy or any other Deputy who will share with him the responsibility of carrying out this work by doing that.

Comment on this

I appreciate and accept the undertaking of the Parliamentary Secretary. Many people will say that to seek such undertakings or to accept them is the merest folly because they will not work. I am of opinion that they are worth seeking; that they are worth trying to work; and I fully appreciate that, no matter how conscientiously they are worked, it will be impossible to eradicate the thing entirely. I have no doubt whatever that the concrete offer made by the Parliamentary Secretary to all Deputies will be of material assistance in checking what was developing into a very serious evil all through the country.

Comment on this

The Deputy will, I think, agree that he ought not to say that now. He is now assuming that that is the case because he says that there is a definite evil. We have asked him, out of 2,000 cases, with the aid and assistance of his whole Party organisation, to provide us with one case for examination. I have offered him that not merely will I fully investigate it but I will go further and allow him as a representative of his Party to come and examine some of the records and see how we did try to examine any report made. I repudiate absolutely the suggestion that there is any widespread evil of this kind. If it is there, I am going to be downright grateful to any Deputy who will give me the evidence that it is there in any single case. We have had dozens of debates and we have had these vague allegations. All the time I have tried to treat the House as being as honest in the matter as I am myself, but never yet have I succeeded in getting from those who made these vague accusations any evidence which I could examine.

Comment on this

I hope the Parliamentary Secretary is bearing fully in mind the very difficult element that enters into it—that very frequently it is impossible to demonstrate beyond doubt that the preference has been exercised on political grounds and not by mere chance. That accounts very largely for the difficulty in bringing concrete cases under his notice heretofore and will complicate the situation in future. I have no doubt, however, that some useful work may be done along the lines he is suggesting. He asked from time to time that suggestions should be sent to him of new kinds of work on which money might be profitably spent. I have made suggestions from time to time and on each occasion I have found them adequately and reasonably considered. I want to make a further suggestion now. There are certain parts of the country, notably in the congested areas, where main roads or country roads that ought to have been maintained have fallen into such a state of disrepair that the money which is available for their maintenance is barely keeping them in a passable condition; in fact, the gradual tendency for them is to become worse and worse. I am particularly familiar with the situation which obtains in Gweedore in the Lower Rosses, and I have no doubt also obtains in parts of Connemara and West Kerry. There we have a situation in which the roads leading down to Burtonport and in the neighbourhood of Kincasslagh are becoming almost impassable. Recently the county surveyor pointed out the difficulty under which he found himself labouring—that without a substantial sum to restore those roads to a really proper condition it was almost waste of money to try to maintain them. There does not seem to be any fund from which the local authority could get a lump sum in order to put a road of that character in repair.

I am going to suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary that it would be money well spent over a wide and necessitous area if a road of that character was taken in hand and put into really tourist condition. It is of scenic value; it is a part of the country to which tourists would ordinarily be drawn. Unless a road over which a motor can conveniently travel is provided in that area, the tourist traffic will be absolutely destroyed. I suggest that he should consider ways and means of making a substantial grant to a local authority where he was clearly satisfied that exceptional conditions obtained and that it was worth while to put the road in real repair, provided also he was satisfied that, having put it in repair, the local authority would appropriate sufficient money from the rates to keep it in the condition in which he would have left it. Inevitably with the expenditure of money for relief purposes there is bound to be a certain substantial loss, inasmuch as there will be no economic return for some of the money laid out. It is the object of us all, while endeavouring to relieve unemployment by the expenditure of public money, to secure as large economic returns as can be got out of the expenditure. The Parliamentary Secretary will have noticed in travelling around the country over the schemes he has in operation for a considerable time that there is a lot of land which badly requires drainage. I do not mean arterial drainage or that kind of thing in connection with the rivers. I refer to land that has gone to rushes and flaggers which ought to be drained. That land is very largely in the holding of tenants in the congested district areas. These tenants would be very glad to be able to drain that land and to hire the sons of their neighbours to do so. But they cannot do that. They cannot afford it.

I know there is a prejudice in the minds of members of the House against the using of public money for the improvement of private property. Nevertheless exceptional circumstances require exceptional treatment. I think there are schemes operating in other countries under which the tenants of small holdings are allowed to carry out certain works in accordance with regulations laid down by the central authority, and on their satisfying the inspectors of the central authority that the work has been done in accordance with their regulations they are paid by the central authority the money spent on the work.

Comment on this

£10,000 was spent on that last year. What we do is we practically employ people to do their own improvement.

Comment on this

That is an extremely valuable kind of work. I would like the Parliamentary Secretary to advise the House in what form applications should go forward to him with a view to having that sort of work carried out. I know there is a certain difficulty in suggesting that the Board of Works go into Pat Martin's land in order to have this work done, while his neighbour's land is just as much in need of being drained. Therefore, I suggest to the Minister that applications be invited from the people in a particular area who want their lands drained in accordance with the scheme laid down by the Board of Works and that in April or May, or at whatever particular time the Board of Works have to be satisfied the work should be carried out, these people would receive so much money for draining the land. There are some people who may have exaggerated ideas as to the carrying out of the instructions of the Board of Works and it may be found when these people have carried out the work to the best of their ability that they may not get any grant at all. How this side of the question is to be got over I cannot now suggest. But if we could get the individual holder—small tenant purchaser —to drain his land by means of this assistance, the eradication of rushes and flaggers, which are a very considerable menace to small holders in rural areas, would be a work which would give the country a considerable advantage out of the money spent in the relief of unemployment. I do not know that there is any other comment on this matter that I can profitably make here to the House. Such other schemes I propose to communicate to the Parliamentary Secretary in the way I have done in the past.

Comment on this

I may say for the information of the Deputy that the particular scheme he has adumbrated now is actually at present under consideration by the Public Works Committee.

Comment on this

Everybody who knows the serious unemployment problem which exists in the country will welcome the introduction of this Relief Scheme Vote. The Parliamentary Secretary last night in a very discursive discourse on the unemployment problem and after a very lucid display of the extent of that problem by means of curved graphs told us that we had a certain unemployment problem to meet. I was rather disappointed in the line the Parliamentary Secretary took last night; for, while his speech was interesting, from the point of view of portraying the problem, he sat down without telling the House of one single proposal for dealing with it. I rather think that the graphs were used more for the purpose of minimising the serious unemployment problem than for enabling the House or the Government to realise its responsibilities in the way of providing a solution for that problem. The outstanding fact that emerges was that the extent of unemployment is greater than it was before. As a matter of fact according to the figures published by the Department of Industry and Commerce there were 52,000 people in receipt of unemployment assistance benefit on the 1st October, 1934. On the same day there were approximately 18,000 people in receipt of unemployment insurance benefit. We find, therefore, that there were 70,000 unemployed people who satisfied the rather rigorous and curtailed form of test applied in order to secure benefit under the Unemployment Insurance Act and under the Unemployment Assistance Act.

Every Deputy in the House knows that a large number of people might be added to the number who are eligible for unemployment assistance benefit because there are thousands of appeals against the rejection of the claims at present awaiting decision and there are large numbers of people who are also unemployed and whose means calculated under the peculiar formula used in the Unemployment Assistance Act is such as to bring them slightly outside the scope of the Act. Consequently, while those people are unemployed they are not shown as unemployed on the register of those receiving benefit. That is a very serious problem to be dealt with and no graphs and no disputes or dialectics between one Party and another can possibly minimise the gravity of the unemployment problem which I should suggest to-day is in the vicinity of 100,000 persons. The contribution of £150,000 will make a very small impression on so widespread an evil of that kind. I am rather doubtful as to whether the Ministry are wise in imagining that relief schemes of this character are likely to make any impression on a problem of that kind. In my view it is necessary that the Government should look much deeper for a solution of that problem. They should look much more deeply and much more courageously for a solution than they are apparently disposed to do to-day.

This Relief Vote will, I rather gather, be used mainly in rural areas; will be used probably for making bog roads, accommodation roads, drainage into turbary and other schemes of that kind, much of the character indicated by Deputy Dillon. But there is a very real problem which is not being met at all and that is the problem of dealing with the people in the cities and the large and small towns. What is the Government's proposal in that respect? I know towns in my own constituency where destitution stalks naked, where people cannot secure employment. There are no industries there and there is no hope of industries being established. What are the proposals of the Ministry for dealing with the large numbers of unemployed in those places? At one time the Government hoped that its policy of decentralised industry would absorb large numbers of these people into employment, but I think that by now the Minister for Industry and Commerce must have lost a good deal of enthusiasm for his scheme of decentralised industry because it is almost impossible, except to a very limited extent, to have decentralised industry on the basis of competition in industry. You can have decentralised industry, as in the case of flour milling where you allocate to each factory a quota and where you ensure it will be a guaranteed quota. But where you have unrestrained, unrestricted competition in industry there is no hope of the rural industries surviving. They cannot do so in competition with the highly organised and highly capitalised industries of the same character established in cities and towns.

While on the subject of decentralised industry, let me give an example to the House of just the kind of industry we are getting under this form of decentralisation which the Minister advocated. Deputy T. Kelly is behind me and I hope he will take special notice of this in view of the statement he made a few minutes ago that certain remarks made by me in connection with conditions in the new industries were proved to be untrue. They were not proved to be untrue to my satisfaction, and if they were proved to be untrue to Deputy Kelly's satisfaction, he has not the sagacity for which I always gave him credit. Let me take a case that was brought to my notice recently. A certain person desired to establish a new industry in a certain town and he proposed to manufacture a commodity protected by a heavy tariff. He acquired a factory building and he proceeded to employ about ten people to adapt that factory building for the purpose of the proposed new industry. The people whom he engaged in adapting that building, to do work that was really proper to builders' labourers and for which one shilling per hour ought to be paid, were put on a totally different basis altogether. As I say, work of this sort should be paid for at the rate of one shilling an hour, although that is less, as a matter of fact, than the local rate. Instead of paying one shilling an hour for building work of that kind this particular industrialist employed ten people for nine and a half hours a day and paid them 18/11 for that work. It was a condition of their employment that they signed a declaration to the effect that they were satisfied with the 18/11. If Deputy Kelly disputes that or if the Minister for Industry and Commerce disputes it, I will take them to this particular town and get the workers there to produce their wage dockets and I will get hundreds of others to declare that they knew the conditions under which they were invited to do this work.

Comment on this

Was it 18/11 amongst the nine workers or did they get 18/11 each?

Comment on this

Good heavens, no. It was 18/11 per week for working nine and a half hours a day.

Comment on this

I thought it was 18/11 amongst the whole nine.

Comment on this

So Deputy Kelly thinks the employer might have been generous! Conditions such as I have related are bad; they are evil, and this is something that the Ministry will have to deal with. I enquired further into the matter and I found that this new industrialist got a few thousands of pounds guaranteed to him under the Trade Loans Guarantee Act so that Irish workers could be sweated.

Comment on this

What did Labour do about it? Surely it has some responsibility in a case of that sort.

Comment on this

Quite so.

Comment on this

If that is the attitude of the Ministry, well and good. But a Department which gives a gentleman of that kind a few thousands of pounds in order to exploit the workers and impose upon them such conditions as I have described without taking steps to ensure that he will pay fair rates of wages and recognise fair conditions of labour, is adopting a very unwise policy.

Comment on this

Surely Labour has some responsibility in respect to permitting any employer to do that with the workers?

Comment on this

You are referring to the trade union?

Comment on this

I am.

Comment on this

How is the business going now—has the place been built?

Comment on this

Deputy Traynor suggested that this is a matter that should be dealt with by the trade union. It is because employers of that kind exist that it is necessary to have trade unions in order to defend the workers. Deputy Traynor, who is a trade unionist himself, knows well the difficulty in relation to the workers in rural areas. He knows it is impossible to establish branches of trade unions in rural areas where there are only 12 or 20 people. Deputy Traynor, with his knowledge of the trade union movement, would not, I feel sure, suggest that you can establish branches of unions all over the rural areas, and this particular place was a rural area. What has Deputy Traynor's Party to say with reference to the continuance of an industrial system which enables workers to be exploited, to work so hard for a very low rate of wages, and which gets facilities under the Trade Loans Guarantee Act to carry on that form of exploitation? I know that Deputy Traynor does not agree with that, and he has no use for the type of mentality which advocates that kind of a scheme. But there is a definite obligation on the Ministry to deal with cases of sweating of that kind. Unfortunately that is altogether too common a feature in many of the industries that are growing up.

Comment on this

Is there any reason why Deputy Norton should not give the name of the concern to which he has referred?

Comment on this

I do not want to give it in this House.

Comment on this

Why not?

Comment on this

I have made the Minister aware of the circumstances of this case already.

Comment on this

I suggest the best preventative in cases of that kind is publicity, and the names of the individuals who behave in that manner and the concerns should be given.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair suggests that the names of firms should not to be mentioned here. It is a matter to be investigated outside.

Comment on this

I want to get back to the Government's policy for helping to relieve unemployment in the cities and the large and small towns. Relief schemes find their way into the rural areas, but in the cities and the large and small towns there is a very serious unemployment problem to be faced. It is perhaps a more acute problem than that existing in the rural areas. One is compelled to admit in the rural areas there is a very serious situation. The last thing I would like to do would be to put the rural areas in competition with the cities and towns over relief moneys. There is an obvious obligation on the Ministry to formulate proposals which will provide work of a constructive character in the towns, where there is abundant work to be done and where unemployed men and women are craving for an opportunity to do something. In some respects this Estimate looks like planning the disposition of furniture in a house already on fire. If the Government would take its courage in its hands and if the Minister for Industry and Commerce, in particular, would give effect to some of these fine, industrial sentiments which he expresses outside the House, we would be nearer to a solution of the unemployment problem. The Minister, in the course of a very fine speech recently at a Fianna Fáil assembly, told the audience that he rather believed that a reduction of working hours would produce some impression on the problem of unemployment. Does the Minister still believe that? If he does, there is an obvious obligation on him, charged as he is with dealing with industrial matters, to formulate some proposal to this House for reducing the working hours in industry. I know of no way in which it would be possible to make a more effective and a more immediate impression on the problem of unemployment than by the reduction of working hours in industry. If the Ministry would take its courage in its hands and reduce working hours so as to ensure the absorption of additional workers in employment, I believe a greater impression would be made on the unemployment problem than can possibly be made by a relief vote of this kind. Deputy Dillon, when here, referred to the fact that I said that certain industries employed an undue proportion of youthful and female labour. That is perfectly true. If the Minister does not know that, or if his Department does not know it, I shall give him a list of trade unions which will produce absolutely undeniable evidence that an excessive proportion of youthful and female labour is being employed in many industries. If investigations are made into that matter, there will be no hesitation whatever in producing the most convincing evidence that a large number of industries are being carried on by exploiting young girls, young boys and adolescents at rates of wages which nobody could possibly stand over as Christian rates of wages. Here again I suggest to the Minister to accelerate the introduction of legislation designed to get rid of that undue proportion of female and youthful labour in industry. If legislation of that kind were introduced, I believe it would help to provide employment for many fathers of families and many breadwinners who are to-day being maintained on the small pittance received by their children in many of these factories where they are being exploited. I do not deny, and nobody but a certified fool would deny, that there are good industries in the country where decent rates of wages are paid, where trade union conditions of labour are observed and where the relationship between the trade unions and the employers has been, and continues to be, of a harmonious character. But these new industries which are exploiting juvenile and female labour are a menace to the old-established industries, a menace to the rates of wages paid in these industries, and a menace to anything approaching a civilised standard of life. If the Ministry are anxious to get a short-cut to the relief of the unemployment problem, I suggest that that short-cut can be found, not by introducing relief schemes of this kind, though they are good in their own way, but by taking steps to reduce the working hours in industry and to eliminate unnecessary and economically unwanted youthful and female labour in industry. If the Ministry have the courage to do that, I believe it will make a greater and more lasting impression on the problem of unemployment than if this estimate were for £1,000,000 instead of for £150,000.

Comment on this

Is not that, to some extent, an international question?

Comment on this

I agree that large portions of this problem are international in character, but, at the same time, Deputy Moore will realise that many of our industries are being protected by prohibitive tariffs from the blast of international competition. We are protecting these industries from foreign competition, but we are not doing anything as a legislature to protect the human material in these industries from exploitation and competition, which is ever worse than the foreign competition which these industries have to face.

Comment on this

I was thinking rather of the firms with an export trade.

Comment on this

Firms with an export trade have, of course, to meet keen competition elsewhere, but the industry I gave as an illustration, which pays 18/11 for a week of nine and a half hours per day, has not to meet any export competition in the matter of adapting a factory for use. Yet this legislature stands hopelessly by while that form of exploitation is permitted to continue. It is all right to tell the House and the country that we are animated by the best possible intentions towards these people and that, ultimately, it is hoped to evolve a social system in which that form of exploitation will be unknown, or will be dealt with drastically if it should appear. However, the ordinary unemployed man or woman in the country, or the unemployed people in the towns and cities who are compelled to pay fancy rents for insanitary hovels, cannot wait for ever for a solution of that problem. They want a solution with the utmost possible expedition, and I should wish that, instead of debating an estimate for £150,000, which will not touch even the uttermost fringe of the problem of unemployment, the Ministry would take up the time of the House in dealing with proposals for legislation to eliminate child and female labour from industry and to reduce the working week of those employed so as to enable those who are idle to find a proper and constructive place in industry.

Comment on this
Seán F. Lemass Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

I intend only to intervene for a short period in this debate in order to give Deputies information which, I think, they should have when discussing any proposal having a bearing upon the unemployment problem. I do so more particularly because, quite recently, I came upon evidence that certain wild statements made by members of this House—members of the Party opposite—and in the columns of certain of our daily newspapers were doing definite damage to the credit of the country. On that occasion I published, in the form of an interview with certain newspaper representatives, information which had come to me officially concerning employment and unemployment here. I regret that one particular newspaper —the Irish Independent—only published that statement in a garbled form and, in leading articles subsequently, and in an associated newspaper on Sunday, actually misquoted the statement in order to maintain their campaign against the credit of the country. I take this opportunity of giving the information at first hand to Deputies so that they will not be misled by the reckless misrepresentations which that particular newspaper has indulged in concerning the position in respect of unemployment here. That paper represented me on Sunday last as having endeavoured to excuse an increase in unemployment on the ground that population had also increased, whereas, in fact, I had proved by figures that there had been, despite an increase in population, a decided decrease in unemployment.

Each week I have published the figures showing the number of persons on the live register at the employment exchanges. The publication of these figures was undertaken by the present Government. Previous to this Government coming into office these figures were not published. Misunderstandings concerning the position have been created by attempts to compare the present-day figures with the figures for last year, and for earlier years, without any recognition of the fact that there have been very substantial changes both in the administration of the employment exchanges and in the legislation affecting employment exchanges in the interval. The first of these changes was, of course, the regulation requiring that all employment under schemes financed, in whole or in part, out of State funds should be offered through the employment exchanges; that administrative regulation necessitates every person in the country, hoping to get employment, to register with the employment exchanges. And there was, of course, a very substantial rise in the number of persons on the register—a rise which was reflected in the fact that the number of persons placed in employment was increased from 17,000 in 1931 to 100,000 in the following year.

This year there was a new factor, which also had a bearing upon the registered figures, and that is the coming into operation of the Unemployment Assistance Act, which has created the position that there are now registered at the employment exchanges, not merely those persons unemployed but also persons who are owners of farms or businesses which are conducted by themselves but which yield an annual income, calculated in accordance with the terms of the Act, of less than the maximum stated in the Act. I have said that not merely has unemployment not increased in the Free State in the past two years, but it has decreased. I make that assertion despite the change in the unemployment register figures, which are frequently referred to when this matter is under discussion. The difficulty in proving that assertion arises out of the fact that there are no statistics at all relating to unemployment in the years between 1926 and 1931. Any comparison that is to be made for the purpose of comparing the present-day position with the earlier years, must be made with the position in the year 1926—that is, the year in which the census was taken and from which fairly extensive information concerning the position in respect to employment and unemployment in the country was obtained.

The census of 1926 showed that 78,000 people described themselves as out of work. It was contended, and I think rightly contended, that that figure was inflated for various reasons. But any of the causes which operated to inflate that figure are still operating to inflate the live register figure and operating with much more definite effect. For example, it was contended that a certain number of farmers and farmers' sons described themselves as out of work on the occasion of the census for some reason not quite clear. It is quite possible that some of them did so although there was no particular advantage to be gained by such misdescription in that year, whereas in subsequent years and last year there was a very definite advantage to be gained in so far as a man made himself eligible to receive employment and eligible to receive unemployment assistance. An examination of the live register figures, carried out by my Department, showed that 10 per cent. of those on the live register admitted that they were landowners. It was contended in 1926 that 10 per cent. of those who described themselves as out of work were farmers or farmers' sons. I think that was an overestimate; but when we come to the year 1933, 10 per cent. of the live register admitted that they were farmers and that 10 per cent. does not include farmers' sons at all.

In addition to the 78,000 that described themselves as out of work in 1926, there was, roughly, 75,000 persons returned as land holders of the class that are qualified now to receive unemployment assistance under the Act. These holders of small farms had an average income from them which, if calculated in accordance with the Insurance Assistance Act, would work out at £39 a year or less. If the same procedure for the registration of the unemployed operated in 1926, as in 1934, if there was the same administrative requirements in respect of the employment of labour through the exchanges, and if the Unemployment Assistance Act was in operation, bringing into registration all those persons claiming, and entitled to claim, unemployment assistance the live register of the census of 1926 would be something over 150,000 persons, and would be something in the neighbourhood of 154,000 or 155,000 persons. At the present time, which is, of course, the time of the year at which unemployment is normally greater than in April when the census was taken, the number of persons on the live register is 118,000 and the number of those claiming unemployment assistance, or unemployment insurance benefit is about 108,000. The number actually receiving payment of assistance or benefit is only about 78,000. There is always, of course, a considerable difference between the number claiming and the number actually receiving benefit because of the operation of the waiting week.

As I explained, one must not take the figure of registered unemployed as representing the number of persons permanently out of employment. It also represents a large number of people passing from one job to another. Our investigations show that about 16 per cent. of those on the register, at one particular time, have been unemployed for less than a week and 25 per cent. for less than two weeks; and that fact, together with the waiting period which a person must undergo between claiming and receiving benefit, means that there is always a larger number of claims than there is of persons receiving assistance and benefit. It is clear, therefore, that even allowing for the abnormal registrations now taking place, in so far as every person who considers he can make a claim to unemployment assistance is doing so, and that those people will disappear off the live register when they find they are not entitled to unemployment assistance, nevertheless there is in that figure an indication that the unemployment situation is less serious now than it was in 1926. It is, I think, commonly admitted, and all the available figures appear to substantiate the fact, that in 1930 and 1931 the situation was much more serious than in 1926. The world depression had begun. The slump in prices had begun to operate, and the effects of these on the situation were being felt here, so that if we are satisfied that the situation now in 1934 is less serious than in 1926, then it is obviously much less serious than in 1931.

Comment on this

More power to your elbow for that piece of information.

Comment on this

It is necessary to make things very plain so that the Deputy may understand them. However, it is not necessary to rely upon these deductions from the unemployment register figures in order to prove how preposterous was Deputy Dillon's statement that relief schemes were never more urgently needed in the Saorstát. There is other evidence to show that they were never less urgently needed although I agree that they are needed. The best means of sizing up the unemployment situation is to size up the employment situation. There is fairly reliable data upon which to base assertions concerning the number of persons in employment. There is on the one hand the contribution income of the Unemployment Insurance Fund. Everybody employed for wages, other than those employed in agriculture or domestic service, is required to be insured under the Unemployment Insurance Act. For every week's work such a person does, a stamp has to be purchased and affixed to his card so that the income of the Unemployment Insurance Fund from the sale of stamps is a reliable index of the number of weeks worked by all persons in such occupations in any one year. The contribution income of the Unemployment Insurance Fund in the year 1931 was £497,000. That represented, on the average, 178,000 stamps per week. If every person was fully employed for 52 weeks there would have been 178,000 people so employed in the year 1931. In the year 1933 the contribution income was £553,000, representing average weekly contribution of 198,000.

Comment on this

When was the change in the contribution made from 1/1 to 1/7?

Comment on this

On the 1st April, 1934. The Deputy cannot make any capital out of that.

Comment on this

I am not trying to catch out the Minister on that. I just want the information.

Comment on this

It is clear, therefore, that the number of persons in employment covered by the Unemployment Insurance Act calculated on the basis of whole-time employment was 20,000 greater in 1933 than in 1931 and was 43,000 greater in 1933 than in 1926, the Census year.

Comment on this

Is that based on the stamps too?

Comment on this

What was the income from them in 1926?

Comment on this

If I give that to the Deputy I might confuse him because the rate of contribution was 1/7 in 1926 as compared with 1/1. The approximate number of weekly contributions in 1926 was 155,000.

Comment on this

What was the income?

Comment on this

I can give him the adjusted figures, that is the figure which would have been secured if the rate of contributions in 1926 was the same as in 1931. It is £434,000. That is the adjusted figure.

Comment on this

Not the actual figure?

Comment on this

No. There is another index by which we can check up on that and that is the contributions under the National Health Insurance Acts. All persons in employment, not merely in the same occupations as are covered by the Unemployment Insurance Acts but also persons employed in agriculture and in domestic service, are required to be insured under the National Health Insurance Acts. For every week's work done by such persons, a stamp has to be purchased and affixed to his or her card so that we can get from the number of National Health stamps purchased a fairly accurate indication of the number of persons in employment in all occupations and any changes in that number. The contribution income of the National Health scheme in the year 1926 was £485,000 representing average weekly contributions of 279,000. In the year 1931 the income was £554,000, representing average weekly contributions of 320,000. In the year 1933 the income was £605,000 representing average weekly contributions of 349,000. It is clear, therefore, that employment in such occupations, calculated on the basis of the average number of persons employed weekly, was 29,000 greater in 1933 than in 1931 and 70,000 greater than in 1926.

Comment on this

Do the National Health Insurance figures include relief work?

Comment on this

All persons in employment.

Comment on this

Are men employed on relief work included in the unemployment insurance figures?

Comment on this

Some would be and some would not.

Comment on this

What was the increase based on the unemployment insurance figures?

Comment on this

I think I gave the Deputy the figures before—20,000 greater in 1933 than in 1931, and 43,000 greater than in 1926.

Comment on this

So that the increase is greater if you calculate it on the basis of the National Health Insurance contributions?

Comment on this

Would the Minister explain that?

Comment on this

Presumably more persons got employment in work insurable under the National Health Insurance scheme than in work insurable under the Unemployment Insurance Acts.

Comment on this

Therefore, the obvious deduction is that employment in agriculture and in domestic service has increased to a greater extent than in industries?

Comment on this

Quite. Deputies, I think, know that it has been revealed in statistics from time to time that a change has taken place in the nature of employment given in agriculture. There has been for a number of years a steady increase in the number of persons working for wages offset by a decrease in the number of farmers' sons assisting their fathers on the farms. That is a change which has been going on for a number of years, and it is, of course, reflected in these figures. That increase in employment took place between 1931 and 1933, despite the fact that in the same period there was an increase in population. The funny leader writer of the Independent, of course, assumes that the increasing population was represented by a number of additional babies. That is the type of argument that one expects in a leading article of the Independent. In fact, the birth rate decreased during these two years. The increase in population was due entirely to the stoppage of overseas emigration and represented an addition to the number of people in this country between the ages of 18 and 25: that is, of people who would be most energetic in seeking employment. The increase in population, however, was less than the increase in employment, and on that account, unless a number of people have come from outside to take up employment here, there must have been, in 1933, a decrease in unemployment as compared with the year 1931. I will admit that the figures I am quoting relate to the year 1933. The figures for the year 1934 are not available, but when they are, then from the indications which have come in already, they are going to show an even greater increase in employment between 1934 and 1933 than between 1933 and the previous year. For example, it has been estimated that the number of persons engaged in house construction at the beginning of August, 1934, was 11,000 greater than at the beginning of August, 1933.

Comment on this

Is the Minister giving the total figure?

Comment on this

Obviously, the figure is an estimate. The estimate of employment in house building is calculated in relation to the number of houses actually under construction at a particular time. It is assumed, I think, that each house gives employment to a man and a half every year. Consequently, the estimate is based on that assumption—the actual number of houses under construction. That relates, of course, to direct employment in the construction of houses and does not take into account the employment given in slate quarries, in brickyards, in foundry works, in paint shops or anything of that kind, and I may say that all that class of employment has shown a corresponding increase. I have this unemployment situation under continuous review by experts in my Department: by representatives of the Statistics and the Employment and Trade branches. The information which they make available in their periodic reports indicates that unemployment is decreasing, not decreasing very rapidly, but, nevertheless, decreasing, and that employment is substantially increasing, increasing sufficiently not merely to absorb the increase in population, but also to effect the decrease in unemployment to which I have referred.

The figures relating to the live register are entirely misleading and, in fact, an analysis of them shows quite clearly that what has happened between October, 1933, and October, 1934, is that there is going on to the register for the first time all the small landholders of the western and southern counties. In fact, the number of persons registered has hardly increased at all in the cities or in certain of the eastern counties despite the coming into operation of the Unemployment Assistance Act. The whole increase has taken place in the western, northern, and in certain southern counties, and it indicates that the Unemployment Assistance Act has brought into contact with the employment labour exchanges, for the first time, a very large number of persons who, ordinarily, did not regard themselves, and were not regarded, as unemployed. They were persons occupying small holdings of land which, at certain seasons of the year, were sufficient to provide them with a livelihood, a livelihood occasionally supplemented by the earnings which these landholders were able to secure by work on the roads, work at harvest time for other farmers or something of that kind. These people never had occasion to register before. It is, indeed, a rather startling fact that from the 98 branch employment exchanges situated away from the larger towns over 60 per cent. of the payments of unemployment assistance are made by postal order. Deputies, who are familiar with the working of the Act, will realise the significance of that. Persons residing within a radius of six miles of any of these 98 branch employment exchanges must attend personally at the exchange for the purpose of signing the register and receiving payment. It is only persons living in remote districts who enjoy the privilege of receiving payment by postal order. They are exempt from the obligation of attending personally at the exchanges, but the fact is that over 60 per cent. of the total payments of unemployment assistance made from these branch offices are made by postal order.

There is one other fact, arising out of some of the things that were said, that I want to bring to the notice of the Dáil. It was stated that there were thousands of appeals against the rejection of claims to unemployment assistance, and that the unemployment register would be further inflated if these appeals were dealt with. That, of course, is entirely incorrect. Every person who has an appeal pending must, in fact, be on the register, and it is on that precise account that I believe there are now registering a number of persons who will cease to register when their appeals are rejected, because they are not entitled to unemployment assistance. Of the 225,000 people who have applied for qualification certificates, over 200,000, or 91 per cent., have had their applications disposed of one way or the other. I do not want Deputies or others to get confused about that figure. Everyone is entitled to a qualification certificate, whether employed or unemployed. That figure is no indication of the number of persons unemployed or of the number of persons employed. Everybody is entitled to have a qualification certificate. The certificate is only of value when a person becomes unemployed and makes a claim for assistance. But of those who applied for certificates 91 per cent. have had their applications disposed of. A number of these were granted and a number rejected. The position is that 91 per cent. have been disposed of, and only 9 per cent. are outstanding. These are being disposed at the rate of 2,000 a week. Of the 20,000 people whose applications were rejected, appeals are pending before the Unemployment Appeals Committee. Some four thousand have had their appeals dealt with and the remainder are being dealt with as expeditiously as possible.

As I am on my feet I will take advantage of the opportunity to deal with some remarks made by Deputy Norton. My resentment of the type of statement that Deputy Norton occasionally makes and that Deputy Mulcahy occasionally makes about Irish factories being centres of juvenile employment, centres where bad conditions operate and children are employed—child farms is, I think, the common phrase—is that such statements, when applied to Irish industry as a whole, are grotesquely untrue. It may be that here and there there is a factory owner who is dealing in an unsatisfactory way with his employees: either compelling them to work under bad conditions or paying them unduly low wages, but such factory owners are the exception and not the rule. Deputy Norton, I think, proved that himself in the manner in which he presented the one example that he gave of a certain factory owner. I will admit that before he raised it here that he brought the case to my notice personally. He said that a certain factory owner was paying men what appeared to be an extremely low rate of wages for doing construction work —a rate of wages, he said, which is substantially lower than the district rate. When he used that phrase he immediately indicated that the case he was referring to was an exceptional case, and could not be advanced as indicative of the situation in respect of the industrial movement generally. Deputy Norton having referred to his one case, and having in my opinion rightly denounced the person who paid such a low rate of wages, if Deputy Norton's information is correct, then proceeded to make the statement which I object to. He said that type of thing is all too common. I submit that it is not all too common, and that in fact those individual cases are very much individual cases indeed. It is true that there are certain industries where employment is given in the main to juveniles, and that there are other industries where employment is given in the main to women, but it is necessary to emphasise that that position is not peculiar to this country. The industries in which those juveniles or women are employed are industries in which juveniles or women are employed all over the world. I make this statement without the slightest fear of contradiction—that in every one of those industries, and particularly in those of them which are subject to Trade Board regulations, the standard rate of wages prevailing here is higher than the standard rate of wages prevailing in Great Britain. I am not saying that it is too high. In some cases I might even think it is too low, but if we are to judge Irish industry by comparison with industry in other countries, then I think we can stand that comparison. If we were to judge it by some other standards then we might have something to say. It is, I think, necessary and desirable that the State should have power to regulate employment in industries where there is a growing tendency to substitute adult labour by juvenile labour, or male labour by female labour, but I should not like it to be thought that the conditions here in any industry are substantially worse, or even slightly worse, than in industry anywhere else, where in fact in most cases they are better, even if Deputies may not think they are good enough.

Deputy Norton urged that the employment situation could be remedied by a reduction of the hours of work in industry. Deputy Norton is very foolish, I think, to rush in with a positive assertion of that kind on to ground which has been fully explored without anything being discovered, at a number of international conferences recently. There are people—people not unfriendly to the Labour movement— who have expressed their opinion as to their ability to prove beyond question that reduction of the hours of work in industry would not merely not produce an increase in employment, but would operate to decrease employment, in so far as it would produce an increased tendency amongst employers to adopt labour-saving devices. When the labour item in production costs increases there is always a tendency on the part of employers to substitute human labour by machines, if machines are going to produce the same article cheaper. By reducing the hours of work and consequently producing an automatic increase in labour costs, the tendency to adopt labour-saving devices will be strengthened, and you might well have in some industries a reduction rather than an increase in employment. On general grounds it might be contended that the increase in labour costs resulting from a reduction in the hours of work would produce an increase in prices; that the increase in prices would depress consumption; that the decrease in consumption would in turn reduce employment, and that in fact you would be merely, as it were, turning a wheel fixed to a stationary axle, which would simply alter the situation slightly but mean that no progress has been made. On the whole, however, I am inclined to think that a reduction in the hours of work is something which we should strive to secure, not because we believe it is going to mean, as Deputy Norton believes, an immediate and effective improvement in the employment situation, but because the benefits of technical improvement in equipment and machinery should be reflected in increased leisure for the workers without increased unemployment. If the reduction of the hours of work merely operates to reduce unemployment resulting from those technical improvements it will have been justified, but even in that regard we have to remember that our country is in a peculiar position, dependent still to a considerable extent upon an export trade, and we cannot afford to embark upon changes of that kind on our own without taking the risk of certain adverse consequences. It was noticeable that the great majority of the countries represented at the Geneva Conference this year who were prepared to agree to legislate to reduce the hours of work in industry as a whole made their agreement conditional on all other countries agreeing to do the same thing, because it was felt that unless there was international action it was not possible for any single country to make a move of this nature.

There is one other point which I wish to deal with and then I will stop. Deputy Norton, when recording the circumstances of the employment given by the individual whom he mentioned— the person who was paying less than the standard rate on construction work, said: "That is something which the Government should deal with." I am not going to quarrel with that particular statement at the moment, but I want to put to Deputy Norton, through Deputy Norton to the members of the Labour Party, and through the Labour Party to the members of the Trade Union Congress and the trade union movement generally, that if they want the Government to take powers to regulate wages the Government is prepared to consider it, but when we have got that power I cannot see what room there is going to be left for trade unions. Both of us cannot set out to regulate wages without producing all the elements of a conflict.

At the present time the trade unions obviously prefer to do that themselves. They profess to be capable of doing it, although they probably admit that here and there difficulties arise which prevent their effective operation. In my opinion under present circumstances, at any rate, the rates of wages in industry as a whole, or any particular occupation, should be regulated by trade union action—by agreements made between trade unions on the one hand, and organisations representative of employers on the other. But if the trade unions feel they cannot do that effectively, or if they have got tired and want to pass on the job to the Department of Industry and Commerce, the Department of Industry and Commerce is quite willing to consider undertaking it, but only on condition that they are left alone to do the job, and that there is not going to be another organisation behind it claiming to do the same thing in a somewhat different manner, because that situation would be obviously ridiculous. If Deputy Norton was speaking the mind of the Labour Party, and of the trade union movement, when he said that the regulation of wages was something which the Government should deal with, then we have a situation which is, I think, a new situation, in so far as that opinion has not been expressed authoritatively on the part of a trade union movement before, but possibly Deputy Norton was merely trying to link up the particular case which he was referring to with his general criticism of the administration of the Department of Industry and Commerce. If that is so, well and good; we know where we stand; but if he really means that he wants to see the Government undertaking wage regulation generally, then I should like him to make his proposal much more definite, and to tell us precisely where those trade unions would stand if the Government undertook to do what he asks.

Comment on this

Very near a corporative State.

Comment on this

Which corporative State? There are two of them now.

Comment on this

Like the Minister for Industry and Commerce I am tempted to intervene for a moment in this debate, but unlike him, my moment will be really a moment. It is all very well for the Minister to brush aside the case quoted by Deputy Norton as so singular as to be of no importance. But the disquieting fact is that, according to what Deputy Norton said, that is a case in which a Government loan was made to the individual in question. I would like to remind the Minister that when we last had under discussion here the Trades Loans Act, which empowered him to make such Loans and guarantees, I put down amendments, one providing that the progress of any concern getting such a loan should be brought under review in this House from time to time; and another amendment providing that such loans should not be made to men of straw, but to men or concerns with adequate capital for the enterprise they were trying to start: capital corresponding to the importance of the enterprise, and corresponding to the importance of the loan going to be made to them. Where very bad wages are paid to workmen it is nearly always the case that the persons and the concerns that pay them are poverty stricken and inadequately supplied with capital.

I was not here when Deputy Keyes was speaking on the unemployment debate last night, but I believe he said that a number of persons in this country showed lack of patriotism, by not bringing back capital from investments in other countries and investing it in Irish concerns. So far as I am aware, that reproach is completely unfounded, because when an issue of capital is made here for any Irish business of any promise, the capital is immediately available, and if everybody who at present possesses investments in Great Britain or America were to sell them and to bring the money back to Ireland, and seek to invest it, they simply could not find new concerns to invest it in. I do not believe there is any backwardness at all amongst citizens of this country, of any political complexion, in investing their money in promising Irish businesses, and, therefore, it is all the more unnecessary and undesirable that the Government should encourage men of straw, who are not properly equipped with capital, and probably not properly equipped with experience and intelligence, to start new industries, and to bring about such results as Deputy Norton described here to-day.

A Deputy on the Fianna Fáil Benches interrupted Deputy Norton to say that the Labour Party had a certain responsibility in the matter. I agree with that Deputy, though the responsibility I am thinking of is slightly different from what he was thinking of. I remember when Deputy Norton introduced a motion here with regard to the imposition of tariffs, calling upon the Government to accompany every proposition for a new tariffs, with measures designed to secure proper conditions for the people employed by businesses benefiting from the tariffs. He very weakly agreed to drop his motion because the Minister for Industry and Commerce assured him that he accepted it in spirit. Furthermore, the Leader of the Labour Party has frequently announced to the country that he is in constant conference with the Government, and, if so, he is surely in a position to take preventive measures behind the scenes, without having to denounce the Government after the mischief is done. The Labour Party are surely in a position to make sure, especially in tariffed industries, and where the Government is going to give loans and guarantees, that proper conditions for working people shall prevail. Finally, in connection with the whole question of unemployment and poverty, they have got a more serious responsibility still in that they are as much to blame as the Government are for the economic war which has created most of our economic difficulties here.

With regard to the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, I am only going to say one word. I have been absent for a considerable time from the political arena and so I am not qualified to deal with the mass of statistics which he presented to us, but, at any rate, I am enough in touch with things to say this—that the ordinary man up and down the country has not the impression that this Government has met with the success in dealing with the unemployment question that the Minister says it has. We had some discussion here about the Milk Bill yesterday, and we were told that there was some difficulty about defining "dirty milk." We were told that no milk could be considered as "dirty" unless the dirt was actually visible. One rather has the feeling, especially in view of all the Government's promises and predictions, that we have a right to expect an improvement in the unemployment situation that is visible to the naked eye of the average unprejudiced citizen up and down the country; that it does not have to be proved by means of doubtful and highly contested statistics.

Certainly, to the eyes of most people, poverty appears to stalk through the country even now, and it seems almost miraculous, with the immense expenditure that has taken place since the Fianna Fáil Government came into office, that so little impression had been made—even accepting everything the Minister for Industry and Commerce has said—on the unemployment question. Before they came into office they held the belief that merely by tariffs they could conquer unemployment. So far as financial policy was concerned, they were committed not to an inflationary policy but to a deflationary policy. They were going enormously to reduce expenditure. Instead of that, they have followed an inflationary policy, immense Government expenditure, grants for housing and all the rest, great activity in every sort of employment dependent on or operated by the Government, and tariffs that have gone I am sure at least as far and as fast as anyone expected them to go, in protecting our industries. In spite of all that, the impression made on the unemployment problem here can only be described as pitiable—even assuming that any impression has been made upon it at all.

I am not going to tire Deputies by traversing old ground, but I suggest to them that they might reflect upon that fact and might consider once again whether there is not something fundamentally wrong with their policy of creating ill will between ourselves and other nations, and in creating ill will between various classes in this country, and with their policy of apparently deliberately impoverishing certain classes in this country. I suppose from their point of view the destruction of the medium-sized farmer or the large farmer should have no effect on employment, because we are told that none of these people give any employment, that they are ranchers, who run their farms with a stick and a dog; and therefore the economic war ought really to have had no effect at all in making the unemployment question more difficult. Yet it has. Surely they must admit it has, when they see that all the measures they relied upon have had so little effect.

Comment on this

The economic war has had a great effect on unemployment.

Comment on this

There is only one other thing I want to say. Deputy Dillon said that a grant such as this for relief had never been more needed than it is at present. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said it had never been less needed than it is at present. Anyhow, we are all agreed that it is needed, and I hope we are all agreed on this, too—I am very glad to find Deputy Hugo Flinn has been emphasising it a good deal in more speeches than one—that there are large tracts of country in Ireland where, from time immemorial, poverty has been intolerable and almost inconceivable. I come from such a part myself, one of the very poorest parts of Ireland, and it has always struck me that the people of more favoured parts of the country have shown much greater ignorance and much more lack of imagination than one would have expected about the condition of their fellow countrymen living in these poorer districts and certainly the Government have my very warmest good wishes in so far as they devote themselves to unremitting war on the sort of poverty to which I refer.

Comment on this

I am glad that this £150,000 Vote has been introduced, for there is undoubtedly a large amount of unemployment still existing in the country. Taking the argument put up a few minutes ago by Deputy Dillon, I would urge against this money being spent on roads as he mentioned, because it is placing a premium on local authorities refusing to put up sufficient money for the proper maintenance of roads. I was rather amused at the old story he brought out about preferential treatment being given to particular individuals on account of politics. I have found it working the other way round, and so far as the Parliamentary Secretary is concerned, it is enough for him to know that a man is a member of the Fianna Fáil organisation for him to kick him out the door without any work at all. That has been my experience at any rate. What I have found operating in districts in which these relief works are being carried out is that the men are drawn from the Labour Exchanges, which are manned absolutely by ex-officers of the National Army and British Army who differ completely in politics from the present Government, and surely those people are going to show fair play to their own. I know that in the town of Midleton, in the town of Cobh, and in the town of Youghal, the Labour Exchanges are manned by ex-members of the National Army——

Comment on this

Who are not members of Fianna Fáil, I presume,

Comment on this

——who are very strong supporters of, and come out at every election to support, the other Party. I cannot imagine that those people are going to say: "He is a Fianna Fáil man and we will give him the job," and that another man is—I do not know what we can call him now—Blue Shirt, Black Shirt, or Red, Black and Blue Shirt.

Comment on this

Call him a split pea.

Comment on this

Or a split shirt. At any rate, I cannot imagine how these people are going to make a distinction between one and another. If he has any little preference to show he will naturally show it to his own supporters and comrades. I was rather amused at Deputy Dillon's innocence. He pretends to be very innocent at times. I wonder has he ever seen a Blueshirt local authority in full operation? If he has not, I would invite him to come down to Cork and have a look, and he will see the manner in which a local authority in Cork County is working to ensure that no Fianna Fáil supporter gets any employment whatever and has even gone so far as to wipe out the one thing that was always the pride of Cork County local authorities—competitive examination. Competitive examination for rate collectors and everybody else has now gone by the board in Cork County, and when Deputy Dillon gets up to tell us about what the old woman told the other old woman, as the Parliamentary Secretary so very aptly described it, I would invite him to come down to Cork and see the full machine in operation.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not on relief schemes. I think the Cork Deputies should settle the problems of the the County Council locally.

Comment on this

I would urge that a preference in respect of these relief schemes should be given to agricultural labourers who have been victimised for their political views and thrown out of employment because they are not prepared to wear split blue shirts and fell trees. I would seriously suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary that a percentage of the employment should be set aside particularly for these men.

Comment on this

Feeding the sea-lion.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon need only look at the position and read the statements made here last night and to-day by Deputy Kent to realise the situation and to have it brought home forcibly to him what the actual situation is. Deputy O'Leary last night told how one man left his employment in order to draw unemployment assistance. Deputy Kent made a complaint here to-day that certain individuals will not work because they will get unemployment assistance. Unemployment assistance would usually work out at some 12/- to 14/- a week at the outside. I have known labourers working for 5/- and 6/- in my district for Blueshirt farmers who have cut them five times since the economic war started; and when we hear the statement here of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, in connection with that particular matter, as to men being offered work, we wonder at what wage. Is there any limit to the wage at which a man can be offered work? If, for instance, a man is unemployed— suppose it is a local Blueshirt—and I want fairly good satisfaction out of him and I tell him: "I will give you three bob a week, and you can work for me," is he then deprived of unemployment assistance, because I am offering him employment? I know local farmers in my district whose wage at present is 4/6 per week.

Comment on this

I will give Deputy Dillon the name at the door. I will not give it in here. I think there is a rule against it. I will bring him down and show him the farm, and I will show him that farmer driving out three days a week to Cork in a motor car, if he wants any further insight into it.

Comment on this

He must be a Blueshirt.

Comment on this

I know what colour his shirt would be if I had my way. There is one other matter I would like to impress on the Parliamentary Secretary. It is the condition of affairs in the town of Cobh. I am sorry to say that it contains at present practically the largest population of unemployed relative to population of any town in the Free State. Circumstances, unfortunately, have brought that about. I would also point out to him that the economic position in the town of Cobh is so bad that recently the ground-rent landlords gave a reduction of 40 per cent. in the ground-rents, which is very definite proof of what the actual situation is there. I would tell the Parliamentary Secretary also that he should make some fairly adequate provision for substantial relief for that town for this winter. The same condition, practically, exists in the town of Midleton. Those two places in particular are very badly hit.

As far as the rural areas of the constituency are concerned—and I was rather amused at Deputy MacDermot's statement here about unemployment on the land—anybody taking up the local papers down in Cork in the last few weeks will see any amount of advertisements there at the present time for ploughmen, inserted by the type of farmer who never ploughed before. They are looking for ploughmen now. The land is getting reddened up. I admit that, owing to the very complicated and antiquated machine that was handed over in the Land Commission, the division of the ranches in that particular area is not being speeded up; but we hope to oil the cogs of it in the next few weeks and to get a move on. I could show both Deputy MacDermot and Deputy Dillon cases down in that particular area where four so-called farmers hold between them 1,800 acres of land and give employment to five men on the 1,800 acres. I admit that they employed some men cutting trees recently, which may help to employ more of them, and that through their activities they gave employment to the Ministry of Posts and Telegraphs which I hope will give some relief in putting up the telegraph wires and posts that were knocked down. All these things will help, but I hope within the next few months to get down a few inspectors from the Land Commission into those ranches and see that they are split up and some employment given so that the sons of small farmers in this country will get some of the land they fought for and be enabled to earn a livelihood out of it. And I will guarantee that these men will work the land and pay the annuities out of it.

I regret that the antiquated machinery of the Land Commission is preventing the abolition of the unemployment problem in that district. I do not wish to infringe further on the time of the House. I think I have dealt with all I wish to deal with, except one matter, and that was the matter raised by Deputy Norton. I think that the Government should definitely interfere in that. I think that where it is proved that an individual who has got a loan by guarantee from the Government starts paying 18/11 a week, as Deputy Norton stated, to labourers engaged in construction work, the Government should immediately step in and withdraw the guarantee from that individual. The Minister has stated that they are only isolated cases, but, unfortunately, they are isolated cases that leave a very bad impression on the whole. We have had industries started in Cork recently and I was more than pleased to see the wages paid in those particular industries. I have been in there frequently—once in a fortnight or three weeks—and have visited these factories, and when I am there I make it a special point to inquire what the workers are getting. I have seen young girls there—and with regard to juvenile labour, a large proportion of the work which has to be done in some of those factories is skilled work and, naturally, it is far easier to train a young person in work of that description than a person of from 25 to 30. I admit that, on that account, there is a fairly large amount of juvenile labour employed. By juvenile labour, I mean anything from 16 years of age upwards. But I can say this much: that I have seen the girls who have been in that factory for a year and a half and the lowest wages they are earning are from 35/- to £2 16s. 0d. per week. These are not bad wages. It reflects great credit on those who started the factory and started it after being refused a Government loan.

Comment on this

What are they making?

Comment on this

Come down and I will show you. I will show you a lot of things you never saw before. I would nearly show you Sing Sing if you came down.

Comment on this

What a fascinating creature!

Comment on this

I am sure the Deputy would have to be very fascinating before he would get out of it. I consider that in particular cases like that the Minister for Industry and Commerce should interfere and withdraw the guarantee of the loan. That is the only way I can see by which sharks can be prevented from taking advantage of the situation here, and, undoubtedly, there is an odd shark still left in the country prepared to step in and take advantage of the anxiety of this Government to provide employment for the people.

Comment on this

The case made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce is one that I would like to see analysed and tackled in order to see what substance there really is in the claim made by the Minister that employment is not only on a sufficient increase in this country, but that, in addition to effecting a reduction of the figures representing the unemployment figures of 1931, according to the case made by the Minister, the increase in population has been absorbed into employment. It was news to me to hear that, and I should like to have challenged and tackled the Minister on it, but that is hardly my job at the present time in the altered circumstances. I hope, however, to see it tackled and properly analysed.

The Minister has given figures from the stamp revenue of Unemployment Insurance and National Health Insurance. I take it that he did not come in here to quote official figures from the Stamp Revenue Department—his own Department—without being sure of his figures and quoting them accurately or substantially accurately. Having done so, that case made by him should be tackled directly and refuted, and I hope to see it so tackled. I do not want to go into the wider aspects of employment and unemployment on this Vote. We have in office a Government that claimed, out of office and in office, to accept responsibility for providing employment for the workers of this country or full maintenance. The workers of this country who are unemployed cannot get work. The Government is not providing them with full maintenance. I wonder if the Government are going to admit that they have failed, after two and a half years, to carry out that essential plank of their social and economic policy. If they do come forward now with a grant for the relief of unemployment how far will that grant go to bridge the gap between the unemployment assistance provided by the Government and full maintenance? That is a matter of first rate importance to the ratepayers and the local authorities, particularly the county councils.

I listened yesterday to a debate between the members on the Opposition Benches and the Government Benches on the condition of the farmers and to the boast that was made, punctuated with applause from the Government Benches, that they are able to put rebellious farmers in jail and that they consider that a victory. We have now a depleted Government Front Bench with no Minister in the House; but there were many Minister here yesterday to announce triumphantly to the House that—to quote a Dublin humorist—"The felons of our land are in hand." I look upon this £150,000 as a little retribution or conscience money on the part of the Government to relieve the unemployment that their policy has created in rural Ireland—to relieve the agricultural ratepayer by reducing the amount paid in home assistance, which has reached such alarming proportions. It is a little conscience money given back to these people for the £2,000,000 a year plundered from them by the Government. If we have not a Minister present, we have the very enterprising Parliamentary Secretary in charge of the Board of Works. He knows that he receives from local authorities over £600,000 a year for local loans which he keeps. He does not transmit that money to its former destination. I am not finding fault with him for that; I am not saying whether he is right or wrong. I will say that he has got a mandate from the electors to hold it. He has also got a mandate from the electors to give the citizens protection.

Comment on this

When they conduct themselves.

Comment on this

I hope the Deputy will conduct himself and listen for a moment. Every citizen has a right to protection from all marauders, both foreign and domestic. If an Irishman plunders a bank or robs any——

Comment on this

On a point of order. I do not want to do anything that would unduly limit the discussion, but I do suggest that we are getting a little bit out of order.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I agree with the Parliamentary Secretary's suggestion that it would be very difficult to relate the citizen's right to protection to the Relief Vote before the House.

Comment on this

If that is his trouble, I will try and do it. I was on the point that the Parliamentary Secretary's Department collects £600,000 a year from local authorities and private individuals which heretofore was paid to the British Government. I am not saying whether it should or should not be paid; but it is paid to the appropriate Government Department here. The British Government, which heretofore got the money, are not satisfied that it is not still transmitted, and the British Government have collected that £600,000 from the agricultural ratepayers of this country. I wonder the Parliamentary Secretary did not get a bigger jab of conscience and hand at least that £600,000 over to agriculture through the county councils to help the unemployment that exists.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy's argument is very ingenious but would be equally applicable to the land annuities and various other sums in dispute, not relevant to the Vote.

Comment on this

I accept your ruling, though I do not know whether to appreciate the compliment about ingenuity. However, we will pass away from it. I should like to know if the Government are going to honour their bond to provide full maintenance; if this £150,000 completes that contract and provides for the unemployed in rural Ireland full maintenance or full employment. I do not think it does. I suggest that it would be far more in keeping with the popularly elected Government to provide full maintenance from central funds that have been so augmented in the manner I have described but which I dare not describe again owing to the Ceann Comhairle's ruling. They should provide sufficient to give whole-time employment to the unemployed in each county area or provide them with full maintenance.

I am sorry the Minister for Industry and Commerce is not here, because we in County Dublin find a very much increased number of unemployed there. This is contrary to the case made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Before the Minister is a requisition to give us the figures in the County Dublin, so as to help the unemployed in the county to get a Christmas dinner. We in the County Council will go 50-50 with the Minister. The Minister stated that in October of this year there were 11,000 more employed in the building trade than in October of last year. I accept those figures for the building trade. I accept the statement that the building trade is more flourishing than it was last year, and that more people are employed in it. Feeling that way, we must accept the Minister's figures, and we are glad of it. But that effort is not due to any spending of money or any administrative achievement on the part of the Government. It is an administrative achievement by the local authorities; and outstanding amongst them is the Dublin Corporation. The operation of the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act in Dublin City and County is not only responsible for that activity, but it is responsible for practically the entire building trade of Dublin City and County. I would like if possible to get some indication as to what way the Government intends to spend this money, or whether they would be inclined to help generously local authorities who are prepared to co-operate in this matter themselves, For instance, if a local authority is prepared to put up £3,000 or £5,000, that shows their interest, and it shows the determination of that local authority to help to relieve unemployment. I would suggest to the Government that such local authority should be met by them in the same spirit, so as to help unemployment, especially around Christmas, as our local authority is taking up the matter. I would like an expression of opinion on that from the Government Benches.

Comment on this

The contribution from the local authority is always considered the bull point in relation to applications for a grant.

Comment on this

Well, we attempted it last year, and we did not score any bull's eye.

Comment on this

Bulls are cheaper this year.

Comment on this

I hope if we fire a similar shot this year we will score a premium bull's eye. At any rate I am glad of the expression that I have drawn from the Parliamentary Secretary. Again, I hope to see the case made by the Minister met with a frontal attack. As I have said before, I would like in every circumstance to make a frontal attack on it, but I will leave it to my deputy—Deputy Kent.

Comment on this

I thought you were the sole Centre Party.

Comment on this

We are the only full Party in the House.

Comment on this

We have the same hardy annuals again this year. A considerable sum of money is being passed in the House for the relief of the unemployed in this country. Undoubtedly the solution of the unemployment question is a serious problem for this, or any other, Government. I must admit that there is a great number of unemployed in the towns and cities of the Saorstát who are unemployed through no fault of their own. I know that a lot of deserving cases have been helped under the Unemployment Assistance Act, but to my own knowledge there are cases in the rural areas where men are drawing unemployment assistance who could be very usefully employed at agricultural work. I heard a remark passed here this morning: "What is the wage which a farmer would give to an agricultural labourer?" I must say that under the agricultural policy of the Minister for Agriculture farmers have considerably improved their position this year, and they are paying wages far greater than what the unemployed would get through the Unemployment Assistance officers. But the position is that you have a certain class of men in the country, and it is not wages that would satisfy those workshys. It is a question of idleness, the drawing of unemployment benefit, and having the easiest time they possibly can.

Coming to this Estimate, I would like to put up a few concrete proposals to the Parliamentary Secretary. I hope when this money will have been spent in the relief of unemployment in the country that we will find it has been spent in reproductive works. I would like to see a considerable part of this money spent on re-afforestation, a thing that would add greatly to the health of the people in the country and that would, at the same time, beautiful the country. In addition, it would be the means of bringing tourists into the country. Planting the country with trees and shrubs would add greatly to its scenic beauty. A lot of money has been spent on useless works for which there has been no return while we badly need waterwork schemes throughout the country—

Comment on this

May I ask if the Deputy knows of any useless work being done in his constituency out of the relief moneys?

Comment on this

Useless work?

Comment on this

There has been so much useless work in my constituency——

Comment on this

Let us come to the point. The Deputy alleges there has been a lot of useless work done in his own constituency out of the relief grants. Has there been any useless work done in his own constituency which he desires we should not do?

Comment on this

By useless work I mean work in which there is no return.

Comment on this

Give us an example.

Comment on this

I know of examples on the roads there.

Comment on this

Give us the particular road.

Comment on this

There are a lot of roads in the constituency.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy give me any road or any particular work in his constituency which he thinks is useless and I will have it examined?

Comment on this

I could show the Parliamentary Secretary where there was a grant given towards a road in my constituency. When the engineer came to inspect the work done there he found that the men broke a few of the stones on top of the heap. They idly sat there. Only the top of the heap was broken, while the stones in the centre and bottom of the heap were untouched.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will give me particulars of that case in writing, I will have it examined.

Comment on this

I will. There is one other matter to which I would like to draw attention. There are several schools all over the county which badly need a water supply. I can give the Parliamentary Secretary several instances where schools are in a very insanitary condition. I think if money were expended on remedying that state of affairs it would be well spent from the point of view of the health of the children. When it comes to employing the unemployed I hope the genuine unemployed will get work in preference to workshys whom we find here and there in the rural areas. Deputy Corry stated that farmers had disemployed workmen because they belonged to a political organisation. I do not know of any such case in my part of the county; I know of no case where a labourer was disemployed because he belonged to a political organisation.

Comment on this