We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Supplementary Estimate. Vote 69—Relief Schemes.

Contributions 134–250 of 250. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Or because he would not cut trees?

Comment on this

I do not know of any incident where a man was called on to cut trees. I have nothing to say, good, bad or indifferent with regard to the cutting of trees or telegraph poles. All I know is this, that the misguided youths and men and the responsible people who have done such work are more to be pitied than blamed, and I have the sincerest sympathy for them in their present position. As regards the reference to agricultural wages of 3/6 or 5/- a week, I may say there is no such wage paid in any part of the constituency to an agricultural labourer. In fact, he gets twice the amount in wages and diet as he would draw under the Unemployment Assistance Act. I would like the Parliamentary Secretary to give us an indication of how he intends to spend the £150,000. I hope it will be spent in reproductive work which will be an asset to the State in years to come.

Comment on this

I noticed that nearly every speaker who participated, particularly from the opposite benches, and incidentally, in a very slight way, Deputy Belton, all worked round by some ingenious method and attributed existing poverty and unemployment to the old battle cry of the economic war.

Comment on this

I said nothing about it.

Comment on this

Only a slight remark. Deputy McGilligan one night came into this house and he had an old battle scarred document with him.

Comment on this

It is not destroyed yet.

Comment on this

He tried to use it here with great effect. He quoted from it the promises which he said were made by Fianna Fáil to the electors at the last General Election, on the strength of which we came back as a Government, and on the strength of which we are here now. This afternoon Deputy Belton made a remarkable suggestion. He actually invited the Parliamentary Secretary, or anybody else on these benches, to admit failure as regards the Government's attitude towards unemployment and the finding of work for people who had no work before we came into office. We are not going to admit failure on the question of housing, of industrial development; we are not going to admit failure on the question of peat development. I invited the Deputy on the first big occasion, when peat development commenced in the Bog of Allen, to come down to see it. There is no politics in these things. We will admit no failure in the matter of afforestation; we admit no failure in connection with the drainage of land; we admit no failure in the matter of land division or in relation to the beet industry. We admit no failure as regards finding work for unemployed people, as regards providing factories, let them be big or small; as regards the provision of rubber factories, boot factories and all the incidentals. The only support we ever got from the Opposition, and the only support we are ever likely to get, is to be taunted across the floor of this House that we sabotaged the greatest industry that was in the country, the agricultural industry, and that that was the cause of all the unemployment and poverty. The only thing we ever sabotaged was one export and that was the export of the money of this country to the tune of £5,000,000 a year going to England. We have kept that at home to carry through the economic and industrial programme in which we are engaged.

Comment on this

Do you say you have kept it at home?

Comment on this

Yes, £5,000,000.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must not debate the question of the retention of the land annuities.

Comment on this

A phrase in answer will be allowed?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes, a phrase.

Comment on this

We were taunted, as Deputy McGilligan knows, that we sabotaged the agricultural industry. The only thing we have sabotaged was the exportation of money. That has ceased and the money is now being used for schemes such as was introduced here this afternoon. Last night Deputy Anthony made a speech which was, to some extent, interesting and, from another aspect, amusing. He said the economic war was the cause of the unemployment and poverty. Here is one of the answers this afternoon—the introduction of this relief grant. I agree with Deputy Belton; I would like to see the amount twice as big. The amount is £150,000, and I will be as much concerned as Deputy Belton as to how that cash is going to be distributed. I am not one of those who said that there is no poverty. I am not going to say it to-night. I am aware that in Leix-Offaly there has been poverty and, in order to do something for the people there and to relieve their poverty, I would like to see a substantial amount of this grant going to Leix-Offaly. What is the alternative of the Opposition to the introduction of this relief grant?

Comment on this

This grant is made for the provision of work. A moment ago the Deputy asked if a local authority earmarked, say, £3,000, would the Government cover that with another £3,000, and the Parliamentary Secretary replied that that was one of the strongest points that would be considered in the allocation of relief grants. This money is for the provision of work. The Deputy mentioned something about the provision of food for the people so as to give them at least their Christmas dinner. I am glad to see the mentality changing, and I am glad to see that the question of food is being considered. Let us realise that there are many people who have no land, that there are many people who have no resources and who are obliged to live in the towns. When there is talk about these people getting food, Deputy Belton should remember that there are people paying as much rent for two rooms in a slum district in Dublin and, possibly, in Cork, as would pay the rent of a very substantial farm in some of the rural districts of Ireland.

Comment on this

In Leix-Offaly.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Do not say that in Maryborough.

Comment on this

I was struck also by certain remarks of Deputy MacDermot. I do admire the spirit he displayed when he congratulated the Government in coming along with these schemes. I think he intends to give whole-heated support and help in the allocation of this money, and he is prepared to help the Parliamentary Secretary in the carrying out of his work. That is the spirit in which I should like to see this matter approached. Unemployment will never be remedied in the Free State unless we have the co-operation of every Party in the House. One of the things we did say when in opposition, and when criticism was being hurled at us, was: "We do not care who does good for the country provided good be done." Is not that the main thing that matters? It is easy to come into this House and score a debating point. It is easy to score off a Parliamentary Secretary or a Minister——

Comment on this

Do not say so.

Comment on this

It is easy to come into this House, cull figures from the statistics issued by the Department of Industry and Commerce, and say that unemployment has gone up. Certainly, the registered list of unemployed has gone up. Shortly after he left office, Deputy McGilligan pointed to the returns of unemployed for one town— Ballina, I think—and explained that the registered number of unemployed in that town exceeded the entire population. There was a change of Government, and people had come in from the big hinterland and registered wholesale, because they saw a ray of hope. This explained the huge figures coming from the labour exchanges. The Parliamentary Secretary dealt with this matter last night. The increase in the number of registrations is due to the fact that people who did not bother before are registering now, because they see that there is a chance of getting employment. There was no chance previously. Under all these schemes we have set out to establish employment will increase and, as the cash comes in, the Government will spend, I trust, not £150,000 but double that amount. I hope the money will be spent freely. As regards wages, there is not a solitary individual in our Party whether on the front bench or on the back bench who stands for anything else than the trade union rate of wages.

Comment on this

Question!

Comment on this

There is no question about it. I will put it to a Party vote to-morrow morning. We have never voted for or advocated low wages. The main thing we promised the people was to cure unemployment and to cure poverty. In the economic programme we tried to put into operation, we sought to bring about a blend of agriculture with industry, so that the two could go ahead and put money into circulation. In the distribution of this money, I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will give attention to the places where it is most needed. I agree with Deputy Kent to that extent. I hope that counties which contain districts like Luggacurran, a mountainous district inhabited by people who were evicted from their farms, will receive special attention. There is considerable poverty along the southern portion of Laoighis and, in the allocation of this money for the making of roads or the construction of public works, very sympathetic consideration should be given to that area. I have been among the people of that district and I know the conditions. I know that poverty is so rampant that men who work in the fields during the day have not a change of clothes at night, and that they sleep in their working clothes by the fireside. Our programme has been a programme to provide work for the people. I am glad to see Deputy McGilligan in the House, and I hope he will take the opportunity of saying that we do not stand for the possibility of people dying from starvation.

Comment on this

Neither did I.

Comment on this

What happened in West Cork? You can refute it if you like. What happened the family in Adrigole—people found dead from hunger in the midst of a civilised community?

Comment on this

The parish priest did not say that.

Comment on this

An effort is being made to put an end to that state of affairs. We have kept to every promise we made. We are going to implement these promises more and more every day. As regards Deputy Belton, I do not want to pour water on a drowned mouse. I do not want to say anything to him by way of braggadocio, but we will not agree or admit that we have failed in any of the undertakings given to the people in the last election.

Comment on this

It is helpful to have had from the different sides of the House admissions both to-night and last night that the unemployment problem is very serious. I am not for the moment concerned with one set of figures or another set of figures. Apart from the figures supplied by the Parliamentary Secretary and the figures quoted by Deputy Anthony, a lot of factors have to be taken into consideration. I was interested in the good description of one problem contained in the statement of the Parliamentary Secretary—the problem of chronic poverty. That is a very serious problem the discussion of which would take a great deal of time. To-night, I prefer to confine my remarks to the problem represented by the 80,000 or 90,000 people who would normally be in employment and who are not—to that section of the population referred to in portion of the Parliamentary Secretary's statement. I heard only portion of the speech made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. If the Minister is anything, he is an optimist. His optimism is of a very cheery kind sometimes but it does not always fit in with the facts. The Minister's statement this evening went very wide of the facts in many respects. The Minister seemed to think that in only one or two isolated cases were bad wages—I use the term deliberately— and bad working conditions a feature of the new industries. The Minister will find on examination that his estimate was altogether too conservative. I have been told that in industries in Cork which were boosted to a considerable extent girls are employed at 5/- per week. The fathers of some of these girls are unemployed at present. I know that in Cork City—I cannot speak with knowledge of Dublin because I do not know the conditions—the practice obtains of taking on juveniles for a year or two and, when they grow up, sending them away and employing other juveniles. I heard recently from a very responsible clergyman in Cork City who is, certainly, not unfriendly to the Government, that this practice was constituting one of the greatest evils arising out of the new industrial position in that city. I ask the Minister to examine this whole matter with a good deal more diligence than he appears to have done up to the present.

During the last two years, there has been a great shortage of Irish slate, and slate quarries have been opened in various places. The working conditions and wages in a great many slate quarries are extremely bad. The working conditions in some of the quarries are, to my own knowledge, dangerous and the wages are very low. Again, the practice of introducing boy labour at nominal wages has grown up.

I do not want to draw an unduly pessimistic picture of what is occurring, but I think enough has happened to strengthen our demand to the Government that they should give directions in certain industries, and that they ought to see that industries that were started with the aid of the conditions imposed by the Government are worked under fair conditions. In a short time when things have been in full working order, and when there has been an opportunity of examining the whole position, I think the Minister will find that the trade unions will not require his Department to do their work. But the working class people are entitled to this: that if substantial concessions are given to any industry by the State, as has happened in a number of industries in this country—and many of these industries are very creditable and the Government deserves a great deal of congratulation in connection with the policy that resulted in the origination of them—the working conditions in these places should be such as would be approved by the Government. I do not think that should be challenged. I do not think it was Deputy Norton's intention to convey that the responsibility of the trade unions should be handed over to the Minister for Industry and Commerce. That is not desirable, and the trade unions would not wish it.

I did not hear the whole of the speech made by Deputy Kent, but I heard enough of it to know that many of his statements were not accurate. I know agricultural areas where labourers get three shillings per week.

Comment on this

In what areas?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

In West Cork, and I can verify the cases. Deputy Kent says that that is not correct, but I reply that it is quite correct. I know of cases where people were applying for unemployment assistance because they were getting no wages at all and were only getting food and shelter for the work they did. Deputy Kent talked about agricultural labourers who would not accept the wages that the farmers were prepared to pay them. I know there is no condition of labour worse than the condition of agricultural labourers in some parts of the country. So bad is their condition that not alone have they been prepared to work for no wages, but they allowed themselves to be coerced into going out at night to commit acts of destruction on behalf of people that would not keep them in their employment unless they did these things. That statement admits of no contradiction. It was admitted in open court when counsel appealed for clemency for some agricultural labourers who had been sent out to do these things, and who did them rather than lose their jobs. That is a state of things which may well become intolerable. The House should revise any opinion it may have formed with reference to the agricultural industry and labourers getting good wages but refusing to take employment and preferring to go in for home assistance, as was stated by Deputy Kent. I think Deputy Kent would realise that if he had all the facts in his possession.

I want to draw the Parliamentary Secretary's attention to one regulation that might easily constitute a very great hardship in connection with the execution of unemployed relief schemes. I understand an order was issued to county surveyors engaged in the execution of minor relief schemes this year to the effect that preference must be given to people in receipt of unemployment assistance. If that is carried out strictly there are thousands of people whose cases are subject to appeal, on the means test in connection with their application, that would be debarred from employment. I do not think that that could be the intention of the Department. So long as their cases are pending they ought to be entitled to the same benefit as their more fortunate neighbours, who had been in receipt of unemployment assistance. I submit that specific instructions as clearly as possible in that respect ought to be issued in order to see that no hardship from a position of that kind takes place.

My complaint about this whole position is that while it is indisputable that we are going through an economic revolution, we do not seem to have equipped ourselves in the way we ought to with the means of fighting it or the great dislocation that that economic revolution has caused. We talk of fighting an economic war. The consequences of any economic revolution mean a complete change of our whole national economy, and not merely such as would be necessary to meet the change involved in a dislocation arising out of a momentary difficulty. I do not think that we have set ourselves to the task of meeting the difficulties arising out of a situation of that kind in the way we ought to do. I think in a situation of this kind we must resolve to frame different regulations from those surrounding or governing schemes of unemployment in normal situations. This is not a normal situation and, therefore, the ordinary inter-departmental regulations in regard to schemes of that kind should be completely shelved for the time being. I heard from the Parliamentary Secretary the statement that he would be glad to get schemes that would afford a greater labour content. I do not want to think of some scheme for obtaining work, or of the making of new rules and so on, that in their nature would have only temporary effect. It occurred to me that the whole method of private employment on public works in the country ought to be reviewed. A great deal of the money spent on public employment in this country at the present time is given to contractors. I do not think that the Parliamentary Secretary, if aware of the facts, would agree that there is a fair labour content in public works at the present time, when there is a very substantial profit for one or two individuals. Speaking of certain kinds of work, I find that in order to make sure that the profit is a good one, there is a tendency to limit the amount of labour that could be absorbed on that particular work. I suggest, first of all, that the Parliamentary Secretary, who is, I presume, responsible for schemes of employment generally, would consider a few of the matters I have noted down for his consideration. I suggest the Department of Local Government should be asked to consider issuing instructions to all county councils in the State asking that all roads under their control should be worked by direct labour. That would provide additional employment of a permanent nature. Hundreds of miles of roads in some counties are worked by contract at the present time. That affords employment for one family. If that work were determined more equitably, as under a direct labour scheme, the position would be improved considerably.

It may be answered that the county councils have full power to do things of this kind if they so desire, but the county councils may not so desire in some cases and there may be very obvious reasons from their point of view why they would not so desire. There are some county councils at the present time—some of them are not very far away from where some of us live—that are not very keen on promoting employment. Rather is it their general policy to bring to a standstill the collection of the revenues by which employment could be maintained so that they may be enabled to say "I told you so; that is where your policy has brought us." I think that the Government should take up a strong attitude on this question and insist on the employment of direct labour by notifying the county councils that, in the event of their refusal to obey the instructions of the Department, the grants for the maintenance of the roads out of the road funds will not be payable. I make that suggestion for their consideration.

I would suggest also that the Department of Public Works which is responsible for the erection of many public buildings—schools, barracks and preparatory colleges—there is a work of that kind going on at present in Ballyvourney in North Cork about which I shall have something to say later— might also initiate this direct labour policy and get all works of this kind carried out under the control of a competent clerk of works or an engineer and see that the maximum amount of labour is provided and that the working conditions are fair and reasonable. I am reminded of this proposal by the erection of the preparatory college at Ballyvourney which is going on at present. I understand that that building is to cost £70,000 but the contractor thought that he was going to get the work carried out at a very small rate of wages. The result was that in spite of the fair wages clause which the Office of Public Works has enshrined in the contract, there was no intention to honour that fair wages clause. The trade union in the district had to compel the withdrawal of labour on that particular job and the suspension of the work for five weeks, when the matter was adjusted by the payment of the rate of wages recognised and demanded by the trade union in the district. That suspension of work could not occur if the suggestion I make were carried out.

I do suggest that a good deal of extra employment could be afforded in this way and a good deal of the money that is just private property at the present time in the matter of building work, would be made available for the provision of additional employment and additional wages in the homes and pockets of a good many of the workers. I suggest that the Department of Local Government should also instruct boards of health that all schemes of housing in the country, the erection of labourers' cottages and work of that kind, should also be carried out by direct labour, and that there should be a fair estimate provided. The engineer or a few clerks of works in the different areas would see that the work was carried out with a consequent increase in employment. The same could apply to housing schemes in the urban areas. There is no reason whatever why the Government could not have a word with the Hospitals' Committee people in connection with the large schemes of improvement in the hospitals that are projected at the present time and intimate to them that the giving of grants for the improvement of hospitals, county homes and other such institutions, which the Hospitals' Committee intend to help, should be conditional on the work being carried out by direct labour in order that the maximum amount of labour could be absorbed on the work.

I was glad to hear Deputy Donnelly say that the Government would make no admission of failure in the matter of forestry but I should like to see more done in that connection. I know that a good deal of data has been collected and that schemes are under consideration but I should like if the projected schemes of forestry were speeded up very considerably. On the question of land that is declared to be unsuitable for the timber that the Forestry Department would think best, I would suggest as an alternative that such land might be suitable for another less valuable type of timber and that the Department should consider, if certain lands are unsuitable for the growing of valuable timber, whether they might not be quite suitable for another class of timber that would not be so valuable but that would be an asset to the country also. I think it would be very advantageous if a big push in that direction could be made as quickly as possible.

It occurs to me also that in a number of small towns in the country there are people who have money to put into little industries if they could see a favourable opportunity. I know some such cases myself. I think that the difficulty is the selection of suitable industries for such little towns. Small towns in rural districts, a very considerable distance away from a port, are at a disadvantage in a matter of that kind, and I think the Department of Industry and Commerce could help in that direction. I would suggest that the Parliamentary Secretary should take it up with his colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and indicate his view as to the value of a general survey of the small towns in the country and that something could be done in this connection in pursuance of the policy of decentralising industry. I know of a few places where substantial sums of money could be got for the purpose if suitable schemes could be put up. I am afraid that a great many people have not the industrial knowledge that would enable them to select suitable industries. I know some small towns where employment of a permanent or semi-permanent character could be provided for 30 or 40 people by industries of this nature. I think that that should be well worth considering. I wish I could make a more helpful suggestion in that direction, but I must confess that my knowledge in that connection is much more limited than I should like it to be.

I feel also that in breaking new ground and in trying to provide new employment, the Parliamentary Secretary will have to cut across the policy of the local authorities in many respects. It is, of course, one of the principles under which unemployment schemes are carried out by the Department of Public Works that they do not interfere with the roads maintained by the county councils or the normal activities of local authorities in that direction, but I feel that they will have to get away from that position, in view of the fact that no ordinary methods will give the best results in fighting the difficulty. A great many of our small little villages, notably at the seaside, are very neglected at the present time. One can see at every turn small seaside places that have got no attention—very beautiful places, but there is great need for improvement, the making of pathways, small little marine conveniences, etc. People would visit these centres in large numbers if they had proper facilities. Furthermore, there was some provision of this kind made by local authorities in the past, but lately I know that in our own county of Cork schemes put up for new works each year were totally rejected by the county council, and the possibility of improvements in these and other directions was impeded and obstructed by the rejection of proposals for new works. I think the Parliamentary Secretary will have to take a hand as a result of his own knowledge of the position, and, if necessary, cut across the regulations that preclude the Office of Public Works from interfering with the activities of the county councils in matters of this kind.

Deputy Norton suggested that one of the most advantageous ways to relieve unemployment in the country at the present time would be to reduce the working hours. I have another suggestion to make, and I think it is one that is worthy of consideration. In this connection, complaint arises from the fact that juveniles are at work. In a great many cases it is clear that instead of being at work they ought, in the ordinary way, if it were possible at all, to be at school. I think that in this we might be helped if attention were paid to the demand so often made by the national teachers of the country, that the school-going age should be raised two years. For the wages they receive it is hardly worth while having boys employed between the age of 14 and 16. For their own benefit later in life, as well as for the relief of unemployment by affording an opportunity for the absorption of adult labour in industry, I think it would be much better if both boys and girls had to remain at school until they had reached the age of 16. In fact, I think it would be good for the country as a whole.

In the course of the discussion on this Vote I was reminded of the fact that local authorities, if they so desired might be encouraged to contribute to the relief of this problem. Where a local authority showed a desire to help I think that the Department of Local Government should be in a position to make loans available for them for the initiation of public works. I remember reading in the newspapers some time ago that a county council in some part of the Midlands made application for a loan or a grant for the purpose of initiating schemes to relieve unemployment. The application was refused. I think that the Department of Local Government should be encouraged to make advances out of, say, the Road Fund to local authorities which showed a desire to promote such schemes. Despite what has been said by Deputy Kent in a misguided moment I am satisfied that the bulk of our people are anxious for work. As a test of a view that I hold, I would like to see the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Parliamentary Secretary give some consideration to this suggestion as an experiment to be tried in country districts: that they should take a number of people who are on unemployment assistance and amalgamate their assistance with a grant into a standard wage, and prepare schemes of public works that would absorb 200 or 300 such people. I think if that were tried it would be found to have very good results. In the present situation in the country there would be no difficulty in finding suitable and useful schemes. For instance, traffic on the roads has changed very considerably in recent years. It is a fact that in many parts of the country at the present time the grass margins on either side, taken together, are much wider than the road itself. I do not see why a lot of useful work could not be done in the way of widening and levelling the roads. Work of that kind would not only help to make the roads safer for traffic, but would, I suggest, add considerably to their appearance.

I feel that the suggestions I have made, if carried out, would help considerably to relieve the unemployment problem. I do not see any big difficulty in the way. I offer them to the Parliamentary Secretary as an evidence of my desire to help. We are going through an economic revolution that has brought about very considerable changes. Ordinary methods are not sufficient to deal with the difficulties that arise where you have a situation of that kind. I emphasise what has been so often said from these benches, that this whole question of unemployment has got to be tackled in a big way. Schemes of national reconstruction should be thought out and devised for that purpose because, as I have said, ordinary methods will not suffice. In time the position will right itself, but at the moment it presents very considerable difficulties, and I suggest that some big effort must be made to meet it.

Comment on this

Deputy Donnelly has thrown himself into the arena as the man who wanted to be convinced as to whether there was unemployment in this country now to any greater extent than ever before, or whether there was employment to a greater extent than ever before. He also, I think, wanted some satisfaction by way of an affirmative answer from me, that all his individual political promises had been carried out. I suggest he said that by way of countering anything I might say, as appearing to score over the Parliamentary Secretary or Ministers in this House. I do not know whether they approve of that statement. The Deputy also made play with, and talked of, debating society points. I want to talk seriously on this subject. He can correct me when he thinks I am making debating society points which have no substance.

I want to ask: Is it possible to get this unemployment matter considered accurately and precisely when the people who are in charge of the figures cannot for the same period give us the same figure twice? I do not mind different explanations. When people put up one argument and it is knocked down it is only human nature that they should run off to another, but, at any rate, it should be possible to have from the statistics branch and from the Department of Industry and Commerce, which is in charge of that branch, precise figures for past years. I want precise figures for past years in relation to unemployment. Let me take one or two arguments first. I understand that the Parliamentary Secretary, in his attempt to explain the enormous increase in the unemployment register figures—an enormous increase which disturbs everybody, including Deputy Donnelly's Party— said that there were several things to be adverted to. One was—and this was in the forefront of his statement —that when registration was requested in the old days people had to walk 15 and 20 miles to register. I do not know if there is, within the rules of parliamentary debate, language strong enough to describe that statement.

Comment on this

What about Ballina?

Comment on this

Let me take this point: that in my time people had to walk 15 and 20 miles to register. I say they had not. Here is what they had to do, and I offer the information to the Deputy who, apparently, has not got it. Any man who lived as far away as 15 or 20 miles from an employment exchange in my time had only to do this in order to register. He had to get a piece of paper and a pen. He had to put his name on that piece of paper, and if he was not able to do it himself to get somebody to do it for him. He had to describe himself. He had then to walk to the nearest post box—if he met the rural postman he could hand the letter to him—and without any expense to himself, without even the cost of a stamp, it was conveyed to headquarters. In face of that, the Parliamentary Secretary, who is supposed to know the conditions, said last night that a man, in order to register in the old days, had to walk 15 or 20 miles. The thing is flatly wrong.

Comment on this

I would not accept that.

Comment on this

Possibly not. That means that the Deputy is contradicting my statement. If it is true it is not a debating society point. The explanation of the big drive now is that people can register in places where they were not previously authorised to register, but had to walk 15 or 20 miles to do so. I say that they had not to do that. In order to register in the old days all a man had to do was to send an unstamped letter, as I have described, through the post, and that was conveyed to headquarters. He need not even go to the nearest post box to post it because, if he met the rural postman, he could hand the letter to him and it was sent on. That is the first thing. The Parliamentary Secretary again said last night in his attempt to describe the difference between the old maximum of 30,000 that used to register and the present maximum of nearly 120,000—some 500 short of 120,000 on November 5th— that there was a second reason, after giving that first wrong reason, and that was that in the old days the purpose of the exchanges was to provide willing labour for commercial employers. I do not know that anybody, even the Parliamentary Secretary with his past, is so far removed from conditions in this country as to believe that statement. Relief Votes of this type that we are discussing became a feature of life in the Free State since its establishment. Apart from the fact that people were taken from the labour exchanges for vacancies that occurred anywhere, under relief schemes or anything else, it was well-known that when there was relief going Deputies in this House made an appeal—I even saw those appeals being made in writing, and members of the Labour Party agreed that they did make them in writing— to their constituents, who were poor, to register for the sake of getting whatever relief money was going. Yet we are calmly told that the old purpose of the exchanges was merely to provide for commercial employers labour which was of value to them.

There is a third thing I want to ask in connection with those figures. Supposing even that those two statements of the Parliamentary Secretary were absolutely true, which in fact they were not, there is at any rate a lot of 120,000 people at the moment. We were told that there were new people registering and that those new people twice reacted to a fresh stimulus. The funny thing is that there has been no improvement made even in those fresh registrations. I would not mind the statement being made that at one time people used to register for particular purposes; that a new set of purposes came along, and that new people came in, but what about the improvement that we are told has been taking place in the country? Why has it not made some impression on those figures? Supposing the 30,000 should have been 80,000, why has it gone up to 120,000 while we have had relief schemes, quotas, subsidies and Government helps in every possible way? There is another point which has to be referred to, and it is not a debating point in this matter. Take this amazing increase in the numbers registered. Supposing you find that coincident with that there has been a change in the economics of the country, and that you are, prima facie at any rate, entitled to say that that change and the increase in unemployment have some relation one to the other; have you not something more than a prima facie case—almost a concluded case— when you find that the change in the economic life of the country has brought about a lower productivity, to an extent, as far as the farmers are concerned, of at least £20,000,000? At any rate, we are getting somewhere near the point when we can get figures which we can argue about, and not fantastic explanations about walking ten or 15 miles. Supposing it is a fact that there has been a change. It is also a fact that the figures have risen. Is there any relation between the two? If the farming community has lost money as far as their production is concerned, is there not immediately a relation between the decrease in production, the downward trend in the economic life of the country, and the increased unemployment figures?

Deputy Donnelly was very anxious about the old threadbare document so often quoted here about promises.

The document bears some relation to the promises, if it is threadbare and worn. Let us allow for enthusiasm in promising. Let us allow for the fact that it was necessary to put some sugar on the pill of the Republic. Let us allow for all those things. Still there were promises. Was it those things the Deputy talked about to-night? Was it beet, afforestation, drainage and land division? I thought the Deputy would have shuddered when he said land division. We will get precise figures one of these days for land acquired and distributed. I should like to see the figures. What about the figure of 86,000 people that were to be employed? It was not in housing, afforestation, land division or beet. It was to have been in factories. It was to have been on work of a permanent type; not merely work of a permanent type, but work from which, once you got the wheels of industry started to the extent that you employed 86,000, the outflow was going to be enormous. It was for the 86,000 employed to think of the huge wages fund and of its purchasing power. I might even become lyrical and enthusiastic enough to prove as my own the document which referred to more and more money, and why did it ever stop? There were to be 86,000 in industrial occupation of a permanent type, and, of course, with the growth of industry there were going to be other subsidiary industries. Here is the order in which they come—factories were thrown in— housing, beet, afforestation, drainage, land division, and factories. We have queried those factories over and over again. We want to know about them. We know that the Deputy and the Ministers believe that there is an enormous number of new industries started in the country, and that there is big employment in them. We know that Deputy Norton believes that it is only the demoralisation of children is taking place in the country. I do not think Deputy Norton is any nearer the truth than the Minister who talks about the number of factories.

We should at any rate be able to get from the Minister in charge of the figures a statement as to how many people, say, in the years 1929, 1930, 1931, 1932 and 1933 paid money into the Unemployment Insurance Fund. What did we get? The Minister for Industry and Commerce made a bad mistake one night, and has been trying to get out of it ever since. On the 4th October he took a jump in the dark. Here was the basis of calculation that he took, and, of course, if the figures can be got correctly it is a very good basis; he took the test of the income from the sale of unemployment insurance stamps. Let us leave out unemployment. Let us concentrate only on employment. It is quite true that every person in insurable occupation, who is a week in employment of that nature, has to have a stamp put upon a card for him. That represents 1/7. It used to be 1/1, but more recently it was 1/7. Therefore, if you can get the fund income, and if you can see the change in that income, you have some indication as to the number of people extra or less employed as between the different years.

With that as the correct basis of calculation, here is what results. The income from the sale of insurance stamps in 1928 was £655,000, in 1930, £703,000. If the old rates of contribution had continued, the income in 1933 would be £760,000, an increase of £60,000 which represented 15,000 men getting employment for 50 weeks. The calculation is easy. At the rate of 1/7 for 50 weeks the contribution would be £4. Divide by four whatever the increase in pounds is and you get the number of men. The amount in 1930 was £703,000, in 1933, £760,000. The Minister takes credit for an increase of £60,000, and for 15,000 men. Of course he had nothing to do with the difference between 1930 and 1931. I asked for and got these figures. Here is where I complain and I think properly and rightly complain. Surely there must be some reliability about figures or we will begin to believe there is none, when this sort of nonsense can be carried on. I asked a question before 1933 was complete, so that is had to be an estimate and the Minister agreed that what was given in a group of years for the first nine months did represent accurately and for each year the percentage of the final total. The figures for 1930 were £703,000; for 1931, £744,000—that is my year—for 1932, £767,000 and for 1933, £773,000. That is an estimate and an adjustment. It showed no possibility of error.

In my last year, my decaying year, in which nothing was done for industry and no work provided the fund went up by £40,000 representing 11,000 new people in insurable occupations in the country, between 1930 and 1931. In two years, on that calculation, the Minister had got an increase of less than £30,000, or less than 7,500 people. He made two bad mistakes there. He claimed for a year that was not his, and when found out on that, that what he had done bore such a bad relationship to my last year, something had to be done, and something was speedily done. The next time the matter was debated—and it was only a few months later—the figure for 1933 was found to have risen to £785,000. Still we had this, that in 1931, my last year, it was £744,000 I was given credit for £41,000. In one year the amount was raised from £744,000 to £785,000. That was not bad. The Minister equalled in two years what I did in one. It was not too bad. To-day of course we have to do better. We have done better. I got figures given to me by the Minister showing that in 1931 the exact income was £497,000. These are exact figures, no longer adjusted, and in 1933 they were £553,000. That is £56,000 of a difference. Where was the mistake? Why was I told the difference was only £40,000? I was told about March, 1934 when the figures for the whole year were in. There was no question of an estimate, I was told the difference between the two years was £40,000 and now I get figures which show £56,000. The position is even better than those figures show, for this reason, that when £40,000 was the difference, you had to divide to get that adjusted with 1/7. When four is divided into 40,000 it only gave 10,000 new entrants into new industries in two years, whereas I put 11,000 into industry in one year. Now, when we divide the figure which is based on the 1/1 rate, for 50 weeks it comes to about £2 16s. 0d. It will be found that it represents £56,000 or 18,000 men. That is something to boast about in the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis. It was a good figure to get at this time. Why was the other figure given? What reliance can be put on the figures of men in control of a Department if such serious errors are made? Is it a debating point to say that one is entitled to look with the gravest suspicion on figures produced for these relief schemes. How can we ever get anywhere in relation to this problem if the statistics can be so mishandled as that? Where is the truth? Where are the new entrants to industry? If they are new entrants are they in the sort of industries that Deputy Donnelly speaks of?

Supposing there are 10,000 or 18,000 entrants in two years, are they in industries of the type promised in the old election promises, or are the people engaged in peat, afforestation, drainage, beet or housing. What are they in? It is surely serious enough to ask this question quite properly. In the old promises of employment, the industries were named and the totals given, even down to the tens of the people to be employed. There was no question as far as the 86,000 was concerned about peat, afforestation, drainage or land division. Does Deputy Donnelly think, in face of these figures, that they can claim that the promises about industrial activity have been carried out? I think it was recognised that relief schemes were only a temporary device. Speeches were delivered by those who were in charge of afforestation—which has come under many Ministers—and Senator Connolly told us that it was a method of absorbing the unemployed. He did not talk of it in relation to permanent occupancy. There is another side to be considered, as I was told when defending the unemployment figures. Of course I emigrated a certain number every year. There were no emigrations in my last year. I was told that the average number of people who looked forward to the day when they could leave the country was 30,000. Supposing there are 30,000 who used to, but who cannot leave now, is there not a very serious situation developing? Because the best that this exaggerated figure can show is—let us make the 18,500 into 20,000—that 10,000 new people have gone into some sort of occupation—housing, drainage, peat or factories. That is 10,000 per year for two years. The Government complain that we left them a heritage of unemployed. I do not know what the number which they have fixed to that finally is, but, whatever it was, it is still there, because there are 30,000 being added every year, according to the Government's arguments—that is those who used to leave the country—and there ought to be, if even the old figure is to be kept steady, employment found for a new 30,000 each year, instead of which we have this exaggerated figure of close on 10,000 in each of two years. If the 30,000 are being bred in this country and have no outlet to America, or elsewhere, as they used to have, and the people who are looking for employment are going to remain in the country in numbers which increase at the rate of 30,000 per annum, and if, after two years of a hectic performance of tariffs and subsidies and quotas and closing down of imports and prohibitions and credits and loans, we can only get 18,500 at best into some sort of work, when are we ever going to provide for the 30,000, who, according to that statement, come on our hands? Are we not piling up an enormous surplus? Is it any wonder, if these statements are correct, that the unemployed registered figure has risen to 120,000, and where is the prospect of eating into it?

The Minister for Industry and Commerce got perturbed towards the end of last month about the situation, or, at least, about the figures and about what he called the misconceptions there were as to the unemployment situation in the country, and he issued a statement. He issued that statement, remember, after he had received a report from a special committee of experts from the statistical branch, the employment branch and the trade branch of his Department, "which has had the whole employment and unemployment position under detailed examination." Now, get the atmosphere. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, who is going to establish an industrial community here, gets perturbed about the figures and he tells us, as I think the Parliamentary Secretary said last night, and as Deputy Donnelly more or less hinted at to-day: "You need not bother about these unemployment figures; they do not matter. The higher they go, really the less unemployment there is. It is the employment side we have to look at," but the best the Minister for Industry and Commerce—not the Minister for relief schemes, and not the Minister for temporary occupation, but the Minister for Industry and Commerce—after receiving the experts' reports, can do is to tell us that there is substantially increased employment in this country. Deputy Donnelly to-night claims housing, peat, afforestation, drainage, land division and beet.

Comment on this

And factories.

Comment on this

And factories at the very end.

Comment on this

They could have been put at the front.

Comment on this

You might as well; they will not matter in either case. But what does the Minister for Industry and Commerce talk of? House construction and relief schemes. He throws this into the forefront: "The evidence of substantially increased employment is, of course,"—no figures given—"fully supported by evidence from other sources—the Census of Production returns of employment in tariffed industries and, notably, by the following"—so he reverses Deputy Donnelly's method of procedure and says that we have tariffed industries, but, remember the big thing, and then we come to it—"house building and relief schemes." That is what is claimed by a Minister for Industry and Commerce who promised 86,000 people permanent occupancy of industrial employment in this country.

Comment on this

We promised them the houses, too.

Comment on this

Maybe, but they were both promised, and it is no return to say that while we promised 86,000 people in industrial activity in the country, all we have now got to say in our defence is that we have given notable engagement in house building and we have £150,000 for relief schemes from time to time. Is that a debating point? I think that what the Government promised was not a continuance of subsidies and reliefs, although subsidies and reliefs were going to be used partly to get over a bad period and to help industries to get on their feet, but surely the aim, and surely apart from these fantastic election promises, what every Fianna Fáil Deputy in his heart believed to be possible was the development of manufacturing industries and not reclamation, drainage, afforestation and these things which are aids and temporary aids only? What was promised was industrial development and the best we can get, if we take the best exaggeration of the Minister's own figures, is somewhere about 18,000 people put into employment, and Deputy Donnelly claims that that is due, in part, to factories. The things he stressed, however, were housing, beet, afforestation, drainage, land division and peat.

That is, at any rate, the situation. I am stressing these figures because I want the accurate figures. Once we get the accurate figures we have ground to stand on, and we can argue why they are at such a point; whether there is a seasonal peak; what the figures mean; and how they are going to be reduced. I want to get questions asked immediately about this land division on which Deputy Donnelly laid so much stress as being one of the points at which employment is given. We can take off this figure of 18,000 something for land division and something for beet and peat. We want to get from that to industry, and then we will get at Deputy Norton's side of it. Even if we have so many in industry, are they adults or children? Is there a wages fund being created? Is there more purchasing power going through the community, and is it permanent or likely to be? Surely it is only when these figures can be answered—I think, all of them, affirmatively—that the Fianna Fáil Party can claim that their promises have been carried out.

I notice that the President recently went to Limerick and confessed that he knew then more about employment and unemployment than he had ever known before. This is in the region of debating points, if Deputy Donnelly likes, but these things were said, and said to excite and dope an audience. The President said we had a permanent cure for unemployment here staring us in the face which no other country had. He said that at a time when he was aggravated by an advertisement we produced which set out that Hindenburg and Hoover had failed to solve the unemployment problem but that he claimed he could, and, being aggravated, he said that he could, and also said that comparisons with Germany and America were futile because—and I am quoting his own words—"we have a permanent cure for unemployment staring us in the face that none of those other countries have." I am here definitely in the region of debating points. He said that the country can support 17,000,000 of population. Thank goodness, he did not put any time for getting those 17,000,000, but 17,000,000 population is the aim, and his Minister for Industry and Commerce, who gives us these outrageously magnified and outrageously varied figures, said that if we went about providing, as we should do for our own people, for the manufacture at home of clothing, boots and shoes and housing materials—I think those were the three things he referred to—there would not be enough idle hands in the country to do all the work and that we should have to send away to the countries to which they had emigrated and get back some of our people who had gone. Those are debating points, if you like, but they were debating points used with great effect to the mob. That is what got the votes. It was not any nonsense about Republics; this was the stuff—the 86,000 people placed out according to industrial groups, the 17,000,000 population that we are aiming at, the permanent cure for unemployment that no other nation had. Men said that soberly, or, at least, men who are reputed sober said that, and that we would have to send abroad to bring back men to occupy themselves at home because there would be so much work that we would not have enough idle hands to do all the work.

We have, at any rate, got some sense of reality at least. The President says, as he did say in Limerick, that there had to be, even if this country was industrially developed, a fringe of unemployment, and then they were going to be occupied for some time until the fringe was shorn from us in these relief schemes and afforestation and so on. I could deal with this Vote. Deputy Donnelly has asked to-night— and I am glad that somebody did put it—for co-operation. He said that they want co-operation, and rather sheered off by saying—I think the hint was thrown—that the co-operation they wanted was the sort of co-operation that they as a Party gave when in opposition. I remember a Vote of £250,000 being introduced about this time of the year in 1929. What was the method of dealing with it then? The present President said that this idea of giving three weeks' occupation about the Christmas time to starving men was trifling with the subject. The present Minister for Finance did not want to go so high as that. He cut down the three weeks' occupation to a fortnight. It represented about a fortnight's work about the Christmas time, according to him. The present Minister for Justice—probably coached in the meantime by the mathematical President—divided that amount by the number of constituencies and said that it represented so much per constituency. As to the present Minister for Industry and Commerce, his variation of it was that he took the figure of those in the live register and trebled it, which, he said, was his estimation of what was the correct number we should be registering, and he divided that into the sum that was to be given and said: "Here it is—a few pounds into the hands of every man on the live register."

I will make that calculation now— 25/- and the 125,000 on the register looking for work for themselves and unable to get it. Of course, I know that that is a fantastical way of dealing with it, but it is the way that Deputy Donnelly and the members of his Party dealt with it when they were in opposition. We had an idea of the extent of the problem of the unemployed in these days and of the scanty resources we had to deal with it. It is a good thing that the present Government are learning that, too, and it would be a bad thing, in view of the extent of the problem, to criticise these relief schemes too severely. Surely, however, it is possible for somebody, who is not considering the points he is going to make in the debate or who is not remembering the mistakes he made previously and trying to cover them up, to sit down and find out and tell us what was the increase in the unemployment insurance fund arising from the sale of stamps in the years, year by year, from 1929 to last year. Then we would have some test of the extra money going into that fund, and we would be able to divide that money into what I call proper industrial activity and these other things.

Comment on this

From 1929?

Comment on this

Yes, 1929, 1930, 1931, 1932 and 1933. I suppose it is a credit to the Minister that they have not proved each time to his favour, but there ought to be something to show besides the mere manipulation of figures. There is one other side to it. I notice that Deputy Donnelly is taking notes and I hope that the Deputy is not taking notes with a view to getting these figures cooked. There is one other thing, as I say I tried to get it for various years and I got it for one comparative period—when you are speaking of the money that goes into the fund, that is one thing. That gives you the number of people going into insurable occupations—it may be intermittently. But supposing they are going in very intermittently, indeed. That will be shown by another side of the account. What is the draw on the fund? This is a matter about which Deputy Donnelly might enquire and get the figures accurately for us. At least, if we are not going to get them accurately Deputy Donnelly might be able to see that they will be cooked accurately. In the first year in which the Deputy's Party became a Government, the draw on the fund—that is, those who had been in insurable occupation and left it—increased by over £100,000. That has got to be taken into account when discussing this matter, because you may have a fictitious increase—a certain number of people going in and more people going out irregularly than ever before. In the end, I think that the Minister ought to get away from this test of the sale of unemployment insurance stamps and get a proper test, and that is what is the surplus income of the fund year by year since 1929. In my time—1929 and 1930—the surplus was so big that I found I was clearing off a debt that had accumulated mainly in the British days. I was writing it off at a certain sum per annum, but I considered that that was not a good idea in the condition in which industry then was. Accordingly, I said that we would fund it and pay it out over a period of ten years. That enabled me to reduce the contributions from 1/7 to 1/1. Now, the State gained a little by that, but, in the main, industry gained in, I think, equal proportions as between employer and employed person, £250,000 per annum. That was a fairly healthy condition to have got that fund to, because of increased industrial activity and because of decreasing draws upon the fund.

This year we went back to the 1/7. I had reduced it to 1/1, thereby saving that much to the employers of industry and the employed, but this year the present Government have gone back to the 1/7 rate. They take again the £250,000 from those employers who were keeping people in occupation and from those employees in occupation and hand it over to the Unemployment Assistance Fund. That, surely, does not show any tendency towards a bettering of the industrial economic conditions in the country.

I hope that Deputy Donnelly will agree that those are not debating points. I suggest that they are matters to which a serious-minded man like Deputy Donnelly might apply himself, and about which he could excogitate and get the accurate figures for us. Then we can refine upon them and argue about them. We can see where they have dropped and in what periods of the year they have improved and so on. Can anyone believe in the seriousness of the Minister for Industry and Commerce when he presents us on three separate occasions with three distinct sets of figures? Can anyone believe in the seriousness of the Parliamentary Secretary's arguments, when presenting his case, when his main argument as to the increase in the numbers depends on the thing to which I have previously referred—that in the old days a man had to walk 10 or 15 miles to register —which is a complete mis-statement— and that more recently he had greater facilities for registering?

I do not think that this will end with this debate, but, possibly, it will mean that when we next come to debate on unemployment we will know clearly what were the figures on which improvement was calculated, say, in 1934. If we are now in the dark as to the figures, there is no reason to argue from this that we cannot get the figures for a single year. How can the people believe in any of the Government's figures if they cannot give us a single figure for that one year? I think that it is a statutory obligation to give the figure. It should not be capable of change. Let us get the truth about it.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan did not seem perturbed about the question of unemployment; but he was perturbed evidently that there were no figures available to prove how many unemployed were registered during his term as Minister for Industry and Commerce. If the figures were not available, the crowds that were to be met with in the country districts were evidence enough to prove that unemployment was much greater during his term of office than at present. Although people might be asked to sign a paper and put it into the nearest post office during Deputy McGilligan's period of office; although that practice continued for a long time, that registering of their names in the local exchanges through the medium of the post office did not bring any employment in its train. People now realise that when they register they have a chance of getting employment; that they stand a fair chance with every other person registered. The relief schemes are not now confined to ex-members of any army. They are for the benefit of the people who need them most. When preference was given to ex-members of the Army starvation in other homes meant nothing to these people who now seek for figures with which to taunt the members of the Government, if they can get them. They do not care how these figures are made up or what inducements are held out to the people to register. They want them for the purpose of debating; for the purpose of arguing, as Deputy McGilligan tells us.

Although we ask for these relief schemes we know that when land division is speeded up we will not have the same amount of unemployment in rural areas. We have the statement of the Minister for Lands that he expects that 100,000 acres will be divided before 31st March next. We have at present a start being made in the County Meath and 90 men who were unemployed this time 12 months are now in employment there making roads and building houses. Although land division has not been speeded up as much as we would like to see it, we realise the difficulties and the delay consequent on waiting for the Land Bill and the Land Bond Bill to be put through. Now, when a start is being made and when the Minister expects 100,000 acres to be divided before March, I think we may safely conclude that something is being done in a Department where nothing was being done for a number of years past.

It would appear to me that Deputy McGilligan was more concerned with convincing himself that no unemployment existed when he was in office than with suggesting a scheme for the Parliamentary Secretary that would be likely to solve unemployment. The electors, however, will be the best judges as to whether we are keeping our promises or not. The result of the last county council elections is ample proof that the electors believe we are carrying out our promises, if members of the Opposition need any further proof of that. We know that our industries have not been established to the full extent of which they are capable. We know that we will have still further expansion. We know that there are mills which had been idle during the régime of the last Government now being opened, and further ones being inquired for. We know all these things, and we believe that the development of the home market is the permanent cure for unemployment.

Deputy McGilligan and his Party would, of course, believe, as the Evening Mail of this evening states, that the economic war has ruined the farmers. That paper states that they have not a shilling's worth of credit now, “because land, once a valuable asset, has become a liability that nobody wants.” I wonder does Deputy McGilligan subscribe to that view—that nobody wants land? If nobody wants land, why is it that there are so many appeals lodged with the Land Commission against the acquisition of land? If nobody wants it, why do not the supporters of the Opposition hand it over to the supporters of Fianna Fáil, who are willing to take it and to till it and to give the people themselves and their families and the people in the neighbourhood a decent living out of it? We want a straightforward tackling of this problem; we do not merely want figures. We in the country, who are in close touch with the people, going into their homes and knowing their difficulties, realise that a great deal has been done by this Government. We know that the people are satisfied that a great deal more will be done by the Government in the effort to provide work for the people.

We, in Meath, are asking for a relief grant now, because of the chronic state of unemployment we found there; unemployment that we are tackling, unemployment that we are reducing. If I wanted to make a debating point, and to paint a very black picture of County Meath, I would only have to refer to the leading article in the Evening Mail, where it says that the wolf is at every man's door in the County Meath; that wage-earners of every class and grade are now worse off as a result of the economic war, and that sort of thing. In asking for a portion of the relief grant for County Meath, I do not feel that I am at liberty to paint the conditions in County Meath as black as all that. The wolf is not at every man's door. We have the Unemployment Assistance Act. Although the giving of unemployment assistance is good in itself, it is not sufficient to meet all the needs of the working man's family. We need relief schemes until we are able to place these people in permanent employment. We know that we have schemes almost ready, and I expect that by this time 12 months, when the relief grant comes up for discussion again, we will not be applying for as much money as we are at present.

The County Council of Meath has requested a loan, probably to be supplemented by a relief grant, for the doing of permanent work; for the taking down of corners on our main and county roads; for the improvement of county roads, and the making of horse tracks along the main roads where the surfaces are so slippery that the carting of agricultural produce is a problem in itself.

We are asking for that grant so that we may be able to give employment to a number of people who are unemployed at the present time. The system that was in operation in the greater part of the County Meath was a system of raising bullocks for the English market. As a result of that system we in Meath know the conditions of poverty that existed there. I can safely state here to-day that the poverty that existed in Meath during those ten years was on a par with the worst poverty in any county in Ireland. Any Deputy who wishes to come down there can see the conditions under which some of the people were living. If they examined the condition of their houses, for instance, they would realise the terrible conditions to which the people had been reduced. Even though we are looking for a relief grant I am glad to say to-day that the conditions have been improved, and I say that even though men were cast upon the roadside and turned out of their employment during the past year because of their political faith. Despite this we are in a position to state to-day that the conditions have been improved, and with the opening up of industries and the division of land we are satisfied that in the very near future these relief schemes will not be required.

In asking that the Parliamentary Secretary would give some of the relief to Meath, I would like to remind him that the mussel fishing industry in Mornington needs relief badly at the present moment. Owing to circumstances that have been stated here on many occasions, the mussel fishing industry in Mornington is not providing employment. The erection of the mussel cleansing tank has not been pushed forward as it should. I would now ask the Parliamentary Secretary to keep in mind the great need for giving a grant from this Vote to the fishermen in Mornington. I would say that any fishing grants received there have given a great deal of necessary employment. I hope that in the very near future such grants will not be required.

Comment on this

In connection with this grant I would like to ask the Parliamentary Secretary one question, and that is, whether a very large portion of the sum of £250,000 is already earmarked for works in operation or works contemplated. My experience in calling to the Office of Public Works in connection with certain minor schemes is that most of the money given by way of these grants had been already spent. I ask that question because I would like to make sure, before going to the trouble of preparing any schemes, that the money was not already spent.

The next question I would like to ask the Parliamentary Secretary is this: What procedure does he intend to adopt in the preparation of these schemes? It was a well-known fact that last year the schemes which had been put into operation in the county I represent found their initiative, in nine cases out of ten, in one or two people who were supporters of the Government. I presume the same applies to every county in the Free State. I do not say this by way of criticism, but I would like a change in regard to that matter on the present occasion. I would like to suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary that he should consult with the county surveyor who, by virtue of the position he holds as well as the experience he has had in the different counties, is a man who is in a position to advise the Parliamentary Secretary as to the nature of the works, the largest amount of employment that can be given, and also in regard to that very important factor—the giving of a return from the moneys expended. There is another point that I would like to press upon the Parliamentary Secretary, and that is in regard to those people who will secure employment as a result of the passing of these relief schemes. Am I to understand that a person must be in receipt of unemployment assistance in order to get a job on those works?

Comment on this

No. A person in receipt of unemployment assistance will get a preference.

Comment on this

Well, that is tantamount to saying that he will get the job.

Comment on this

No, unfortunately it is not.

Comment on this

Well, he will get a preference.

Comment on this

What I would like to bring to the notice of the Parliamentary Secretary is this:- I have very great experience since The Unemployment Assistance Act was passed and put into operation that a very large number of people who have made claims for benefit under the Act did not have their claims adjudicated upon although these claims had been placed with the various labour exchanges since the passing of the Act. This has been already referred to by Deputy Murphy and I would like to impress upon the Parliamentary Secretary that these people should have the same opportunity of getting work on these relief schemes as those who are actually in receipt of unemployment assistance. The reason for the delay in their case is through ignorance in regard to the various sections of the Act. For instance many of those unfortunate people when asked when did they work, stated that they were idle for three or four years when as a matter of fact they had been working weeks on and off through all that time. In consequence of that their claims have not been finally adjudicated upon and they have been left without this benefit. I would like the Parliamentary Secretary to take that factor into consideration in connection with this question of unemployment. We are all aware that this question of unemployment comes up each year and we are also aware that most of the Deputies——

Comment on this

Get round to their own constituencies.

Comment on this

——never face up to the situation; while they speak in general terms of the poverty prevailing throughout the length and breadth of the land, in every case at the end they generally want to get the relief for their own constituency. I do not propose to adopt that policy. Neither do I propose unduly to criticise the Government for their failure in dealing with this important problem. What I do criticise very severely is the fact that very few Deputies have paid any attention whatsoever as to the causes of unemployment. In other words, they have not faced up to the situation. All the Deputies speak here on this question of unemployment and I regret to say that one particular idea is very noticeable amongst the back benchers of Fianna Fáil. When speaking on this question of unemployment they all speak as if this country were one great empire full of riches. Consequently, in order to gain political advantage over their opponents, they do not hesitate to make very rash promises at the cross-roads, thus giving their political opponents an opportunity of criticising them severely for not having fulfilled their promises.

I was never prone to criticise this Government or the late Government in regard to their failure to solve unemployment, for the simple reason that, unlike the members of Fianna Fáil and the members of the Labour Party, I never believed that a Government could solve the question of unemployment. Neither do I subscribe to the doctrine that it is the duty of a Government to solve unemployment, for the simple reason that I know its solution is an impossibility, and I am very slow to ask people to do the impossible. At the same time, I think I am entitled to criticise this Government for not dealing more successfully with the unemployment question, because the dead walls in the various cities and towns, as a result of the use of the whitewash brush, gave us the slogan at the last election: "Vote Fianna Fáil and end unemployment." It was not a question of solving it at all, but of ending it.

This evening Deputy Kelly, who represents a County Meath constituency, told us how employment is going to increase in that county as a result of the division of land contemplated by the present Government. Yet it was only last week he spoke about the farmers there and about their dereliction of duty in not giving work to the labourers. Deputy Kelly, accompanied by Deputy O'Reilly, headed a deputation to the Minister for Agriculture to procure more licences in order that the fat bullocks might be exported to the British market which, to use the words of the President, has gone for ever. Unfortunately for themselves, Fianna Fáil Deputies speak with two voices, one for the Dáil and one for the cross-roads. During the last two or three years they have told the people that, if elected, they could solve the unemployment question, that it was a question of a decent living—good wages.

The present Government is the only Government that has stipulated that before a relief scheme would be put into operation it should be arranged that the rate of wages should not exceed 24/- a week. I, as a member of the Louth County Council, have been asked to subscribe to that doctrine through the medium of a memorandum sent out by the Parliamentary Secretary. It was a question of "Will you come in to my parlour said the spider to the fly." I object absolutely to any Government fixing rates of wages for the workers. I would object equally strongly if the Government fixed wages at £10 per week, not to mind 24/- a week. That should be left to the individuals themselves, and I do not think it is right that the Government should make it a condition preparatory to giving the money for relief schemes that the members of any public board should subscribe to the doctrine that 24/- is sufficient to maintain a man and his family. I do not think that is right or fair, yet that is the policy that is being pursued vigorously by the Parliamentary Secretary in connection with various relief schemes throughout the Free State.

As regards unemployment, I would like to help whatever Government is in power, if it were possible for me to do so, if there were a little more honesty in dealing with the matter, if men were prepared to say what economic pressure will compel the whole of us to say in the near future, to speak the truth in regard to this question. Instead of making it a Party question, it might be well if all came together and admitted freely that we are endeavouring to do the impossible, namely, to maintain almost a war-time standard of living on a pre-war earning. The sooner they admit that the sooner will we be on the road at least to a partial solution of this very vexed question. I know this is about the worst place where one could debate a matter of this nature, but I hope the time is not far distant when men will be got who will tell the truth and tell the people that certain things which have been promised cannot be realised, when one considers the resources of the country. I would like to ask in connection with this vote, which will be welcomed by the people of the various areas in which the work will be started, that above all there should be no discrimination as regards who will receive employment.

Unfortunate references have been made to Blueshirts. It is about time, and I am speaking now candidly and honestly, that Deputy Corry and other Fianna Fáil T. D.'s should drop that gutter language altogether and recognise the fact that there are just as good men in the Blueshirts as there are in any other section of the community. It is about time those cheap jibes should stop in this Assembly and Deputies should face the situation fairly and squarely. It might not be safe for some Deputies to use the same expressions outside that they have used here. So far as I am personally concerned, I hope the day will never come when I shall raise my voice or use any influence I have to keep a political opponent out of employment. I only wish I could be the means of getting employment for every workless man in the country irrespective of politics. I hope and trust everything in connection with the working of these schemes will be done above board and, in conclusion, let me say that I would be prepared to give the Parliamentary Secretary and the officials of the Board of Works who are entrusted with the carrying out of these schemes, all the help I possibly can give them.

Two things I should like to emphasise—that we should be given an opportunity of knowing beforehand the procedure to be adopted in regard to the starting of any schemes in the various counties, whether it is to be left to the people to whom it was left last year or whether the Parliamentary Secretary is going to consult the county surveyors. Secondly, I should like that all people who are unemployed should have an equal chance, and that there should be no differentiation, whether a man is in receipt of unemployment assistance or not.

Comment on this

I am not anxious to delay this vote and I shall, therefore, confine myself to a single point. I should like to ascertain from the Parliamentary Secretary whether, in connection with these relief schemes, the subject of mining has been considered and, if so, to what extent. The Parliamentary Secretary has, again and again, expressed himself—and rightly so—as being eager to get productive schemes. In that connection, it is obvious that mining, which is a very small industry in this country at present, should offer scope, for, at least, investigation. It is admitted, I suppose, that, owing to the world price of the common minerals, the working of most of the Irish mines would not be remunerative if carried out as an ordinary commercial transaction. It might, however, be otherwise if the experiment were considered as a relief scheme or if mining were regarded as a protected industry, same as other industries. I am constantly being asked, for instance, why it is that now, when there is a very rigid system of protection in operation, there should be no mining whatever in Avoca when, under free trade, there was, I am assured, never a year in which there was not a considerable amount of mining done. That continued up to 1928.

Comment on this

What was mined?

Comment on this

Ochre, sulphur and copper. Copper was mined as late as 1928 by a British company. I think that the sulphur mines had something to do with the winning of the Great War for the British. The Arklow Explosives Factory depended, I understand, very largely on the sulphur produced in Avoca, while the fertiliser manufacturers were obliged to depend upon it. I am constantly being asked why it is, when that condition of affairs obtained under a free trade system, now that there is a Government in power which stands for protection and is not prepared to accept the principle of supply and demand as the last word on any question, there is absolutely no mineral activity in that area. Mining would seem to offer an obvious opening for work designed to relieve unemployment, because one would think that the labour content should be very high and that there would be genuine results from the point of view of production. In that area—I do not want to make the debate parochial, but it is the area with which I am most familiar—there are men whom nobody could accuse of lack of desire to work. It is said that there are 100 men, more or less, unemployed there at present. All these men have worked at mining at some time. They are as keen as men could be on that class of work. So keen are they that, although they are drawing unemployment assistance, they devote themselves every week to the cleaning up of old mines and to digging for new minerals. Their one desire is to work at an industry of that kind. I should be much surprised to learn that the Parliamentary Secretary has not explored the possibilities in that direction.

Some small efforts have been made. A grant of £500 was given last year, but I do not think it was followed up or that there was ever any real intention to ascertain what the results would be. I doubt if the material produce—I understand it was sulphur —was ever sent to a fertiliser-manufacturer. In any case, £500 worth of effort would not furnish any appreciable test. To my mind, this would seem to be one of the things most deserving of consideration in connection with the relief of unemployment. If it were found to be in any way economic, it would be very easy to transport men from other areas and, instead of giving them work which is, admittedly, not urgent work and, certainly, unproductive work, afford them an opportunity to produce results and increase the national income. If that be the position, these mines should be worked by the State. The attitude of the Department of Industry and Commerce in regard to mines and quarries seems to be to wait until private capital is forthcoming. With so many countries ready to dump their mineral products in any market in which they can get an opening, it does not seem likely that private capital will develop an interest in our mineral wealth. We all admit that our mineral resources are not sufficiently rich to encourage the investment of private capital to any extent, especially under the present conditions. Matters may have been different when there was less dumping and when other countries were less inclined to subsidise their exports than they are to-day. Under present circumstances and considering that there is at least an implicit admission that there is great difficulty in getting anything like suitable enterprises on which to extend relief moneys, I suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary that, if he has not done so yet, he should explore very fully the possibilities of mining. I ask him further to send somebody to that area, which is relatively the richest mining area in the country, to ascertain from the people there their experience of mining and what they think the possibilities are. Further, the person so sent to investigate should report as to the ability and willingness of the available labour. If the Parliamentary Secretary does that, the report which will reach him will be one which, I think, should encourage him to proceed with mineral development.

Comment on this

As there is money about to be distributed, I think I should make a little demand for my constituency. At present, there is an organisation in existence called the Cumann Cosanta na Gaedhilge. I believe that they have been in touch with the Minister for Lands with regard to getting a bounty on feeding stuffs going into an area in my constituency. The Minister was down there recently and he said it was a difficult problem and that a committee should be appointed to put up a scheme. That is throwing a big responsibility on what I might call unfortunate people in the country who have not the assistance of civil servants, as the Government have. I believe there is some talk of putting up a mill. I do not think there is any necessity for putting up a mill. I do not see why a portion of the grant should not be used for giving these people a bounty on the feeding stuffs they have to buy. At present, they are being driven out of existence because they cannot afford to buy feeding stuffs. They are in a part of the country where they could not grow feeding stuffs. It is not fair to my mind to subsidise people who live upon rich land and can grow feeding stuffs. I suggest the Parliamentary Secretary should enter into a contract with a big mill in Cork to supply people in these congested areas. In that way, by subsidising the mill, people could get the feeding stuffs at reduced rates and would be enabled to produce bacon before the winter is out. There is no great encouragement to people to produce barley, oats and wheat for feeding cattle. They will not be encouraged to produce beef and they cannot get good prices otherwise. I am putting these suggestions to the Parliamentary Secretary and I think they are worthy of consideration.

I understood the Parliamentary Secretary to say that preference will be given to people seeking employment, in receipt of unemployment assistance. I do not think that is fair. It is quite understandable that people in receipt of unemployment assistance are most needy people. I heard the case of a man who got no relief and who was refused employment, although he had three sons at home idle.

Comment on this

Did you bring that to the notice of my Department?

Comment on this

I brought it to the Parliamentary Secretary's own notice in this House.

Comment on this

But did you bring it to the notice of my Department?

Comment on this

That is not my job; that is the Parliamentary Secretary's own job. He has people here in charge of these matters. I know what I am talking about. When our Party were in power I always made it a point to tell gangers to give employment to the people most in need of it. I believe that the Government, by their policy, are responsible for the bulk of the unemployment that exists in this country to-day. I remember the time when Deputy Norton, criticising the Cumann na nGaedheal Party when they were in power and their attitude towards the 86,000 unemployed at that time, said that the Fianna Fáil Party when they came into power would solve that problem, and if they did not they would not remain 24 hours in office. The fact, of course, is that the unemployment position is far worse to-day than it was on that occasion. Deputy Murphy made reference to statements made by Deputy Kent with regard to the wages paid to farm hands, and said that in West Cork farm hands were paid only 3/- or 4/- per week. I think that that condition of things demands inquiry. I believe there must be something wrong in such circumstances. Either the farmers are doing the work of the labourers, or, else the farmers are not in a position to enable them to pay their labourers. The agricultural industry is, of course, the most important industry in this country. Deputy Kelly talks about the bullock and that we ought to divide more land. I have seen some land divided and I find that the bulk of it to-day has been let out for grazing. Many of the people who got land could not grow potatoes enough to feed themselves. In dividing the land men should be selected as tenants who are fit to work it. There is no use giving land to people who have no experience of farming. I met people in Dublin who never stood on a farm and yet they could teach me my business. If I ever belonged to a Party again that gets back into power I would take these people out of their offices, put them on the land, and compel them to live on it, and then, perhaps, they would be in a position to criticise the farmers.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Deputy Corry and myself agree. I do not want to be rid of the Party opposite too soon. I have always said that it is only right that they should get a full trial. I believe myself the people are getting a bit of experience of them, and before the winter is over they will have more experience. I am very keen upon this question of the land. Deputy Kelly, as I pointed out already, talked about the bullock, but I say if you destroy the cattle trade in this country you destroy the whole agricultural interest of this country. I challenge any Deputy on the Government Benches opposite to get up and say otherwise.

I would like to find out from Deputy, Norton whether he has worked out his ideas about the reduced hours for labour that he proposes? Has he prepared any scheme for the farmers? I would like to see how he is going to reduce the working hours for the farmer and what is the capacity of the farmers to pay under the changed conditions. Would the farmer require two sets of men to milk his cows—one set for the morning milking and another for the evening? Farmers can only pay a certain rate of wages, so that I am afraid Deputy Norton's scheme would be hardly workable. The fact is that it is simply bluff. When Deputy Norton makes a statement of that kind it is only right that the farmers should demand from him a statement as to how he is going to work out this policy. Again I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to consider this question of giving grants to those unemployment people in congested areas by granting a bounty or subsidy on their purchases.

Comment on this

Deputy Coburn in his appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary pointed out that he was one of those who maintained that it was not the duty of the Government to provide work for the unemployed. I was sorry Deputy McGilligan was not present to agree with him. That was the argument that Deputy McGilligan put to this House when he was in office. He said it was not the function of the Government to provide work, or to give any relief towards unemployment, other than the small amount then allocated each year under pressure. I am one of those who maintain that it is the function and the duty of any Government to relieve unemployment.

While we admit that this Government, realising that we have a war on and that the resources of the country should be united in winning that war, has made an effort at least to look after a number of those people who had been engaged in the battle, other sections of the community, of the soldiers—the dockers and others—are not yet provided for. We hope that Deputy O'Leary will find that the Government will adopt the suggestion put up to the Parliamentary Secretary last year, that instead of there being a wage of 24/- per week, there should be less hours worked. I have not advocated any minor relief schemes for the reason that I am opposed to the wage of 24/- a week which is allowed for minor relief work. That is a much lesser wage than a man receives for similar work under the county council. I notice that £150,000 is provided in this estimate for local authorities which is to be repaid with interest. I should like to know what the Minister for Finance will charge public bodies who are prepared to help the Government in providing schemes for the relief of unemployment. Will the money be given on the same terms as moneys advanced from the Local Loans Fund? Will the terms be that we shall be charged 1/2 per cent. less than the bank rate? If so, that will be very little encouragement to public bodies. I suggest to the Government that in cases where they see that a public body is really interested and is anxious to provide at least two years' work for a large number of men unemployed at present, they should assist that public body by granting it a loan even without any interest. The rates can then provide any balance necessary for such relief work.

I should like to point out to the Parliamentary Secretary that where public bodies are engaged in the development of lands for housing schemes, they have to make roads and lay down sewerage in the development area and they are obliged to charge the cost of making these roads and laying down the sewerage, against the housing scheme. I advocated in another place that that work should be treated as a different matter and that the development of the area together with the cost of the sewerage should be a separate charge. I believe the Government ought to give loans to public bodies to enable them to provide work in this way whilst providing houses for the working classes. In that way it will be possible to absorb a large number of men in a year or a two years plan.

The adoption of a direct labour policy in connection with housing schemes has been advocated here to-night. Being one of the first boards to avail of the O'Kelly Act, the Wicklow Board of Health has some experience in this matter. In the rural area we provided some 700 or 800 houses for agricultural labourers. We are faced with the difficulty that we are up against a combine of contractors who are trying to fleece the board of health and to charge £300 for a four-roomed country cottage. We faced that problem. These high prices meant that higher rents would have to be charged to the tenants of these houses. We had to get together in certain areas to compete against the contractors and we had to impress on the Local Government Department that we were prepared under a direct labour scheme to provide houses from £50 to £60 cheaper than the contract price and to supply better material and give more employment. I shall take one area in Greystones where a contractor tendered for erection of houses. The board of health built these houses in Greystones by direct labour. We were able to pay 1/- an hour to the labourers, 1/10 per hour to the plasterers—the full Dublin union rate—and to put in extra material and to provide more accommodation. Yet the houses were built at £50 less than the contract price. We also gave more employment than would be given under the contract system. A similar thing happened in Avoca. In other areas we were allowed to proceed by direct labour on giving a guarantee that the work would cost less than the contract price. Not alone are we doing it less than the contract price but we are putting in extra material in the way of window sills and door steps. I therefore hope that the direct labour system will be encouraged by the Government.

The Minister for Finance made provision in the Budget to enable county councils to open new roads which would connect one portion of a county with another. We have prepared a scheme to connect West Wicklow with East Wicklow, on which we hope to give at least twelve months' employment to both agricultural labourers and small farmers. If the Minister gives us a loan at a cheap rate of interest we are prepared to embark on further schemes of this kind which will assist the Government to provide work for the unemployed. Many schemes have been put before the Parliamentary Secretary in connection with the development of harbours. I am one who appreciates the work the Department is doing in that direction, and I recognise the efficiency displayed by civil servants in doing their part to assist public representatives. I am one who never went into a department, even since the present Government came into office, to ask for any favours to advocate any particular scheme. I leave these matters to the officials and I am certain that no political favour or political pull is shown. Each county is treated fairly and if I found that it was not I would be the first to criticise the activities of the Department.

Last year the Parliamentary Secretary gave us a small loan to carry out a plan on which he seemed to have some misgivings in connection with coastal erosion. That was a plan put forward by an Irish engineer, and, with the aid of a small sum of £500, granted by the Department, which was supplemented by the county council, some thousands of pounds' worth of property has been saved. I only hope and trust that a further sum will be provided to continue that work. The Parliamentary Secretary has not seen that protection work since. I would be glad if he would inspect it and see the result of an Irish engineer's plans. He will have to admit that they have at least been successful and that they have saved very valuable property from the ravages caused by gales from the South-East and NorthEast. I hope he will be able to give us encouragement to approach the Government to give us a further loan as 70 per cent. of the money is spent on labour.

Another matter that has come to my notice is that in selecting men for work on the roads, one condition of the grant is that a man must be in receipt of unemployment assistance before he can be considered. We had a large number of men in receipt of home help whose claims for unemployment assistance had not come back from the Department concerned, with the result that these men were debarred from getting this work although we have to continue giving them home help.

I would ask that that condition should be waived pending the hearing of the appeals which these men have lodged and pending the consideration of the schemes that applicants have submitted. It is most unfair that a large number of genuine workers should be deprived of the opportunity of getting work from the county councils owing to the enforcement of that condition. They cannot be accepted for work unless they are able to produce a certificate from the manager of the labour exchange that they have been in receipt of unemployment assistance. I am not saying that the Parliamentary Secretary has any responsibility for that. The Local Government Department introduced that in connection with the administration of grants for trunk roads. But I would ask that the condition should be waived pending the hearing of all these claims.

As regards the minor relief schemes I cannot understand why the Parliamentary Secretary should have followed the bad example of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government in the matter of the non-stamping of unemployment cards of the men engaged on these schemes. I know, of course, that the Parliamentary Secretary will argue that this is agricultural work. But is there any fair-minded man who would say that work on the roads or in a quarry is agricultural work? Nobody could convince me that it is. It may be correct to say that if farmers' sons are engaged repairing a lane leading to their farms that it is agricultural work, but they are in quite a different position to men engaged on repair work which is carried out under the control of the county surveyor. These men have to work alongside county council employees. They do the same class of work but their cards are not stamped, while the cards of those working beside them, because they are in the employment of the county council, are stamped. It has to be remembered, too, that the men engaged on these minor relief schemes are in receipt of a smaller wage than the county council workers and they have to suffer the further disability of not having their cards stamped. I know, of course, that there was a legal decision on this some years ago, but I think it should be waived in favour of these workers. We have a war on now, and I think it is about time we got away from all this red-tapeism. The Government, I suggest, should help public boards that are prepared to initiate useful schemes that will provide employment for our people.

Deputy Moore referred to the mining district of Avoca. That is one of the hardest hit areas in the County Wicklow. There is very little agricultural work there. The workers there have to depend on the employment they get on the roads and in the mines. The making of our main roads is almost completed. If the system of direct labour was employed on the by-roads it would help very considerably to ease the unemployment problem in that particular area. I agree with Deputy Moore that something should be done to relieve the distress due to unemployment that prevails there. The Parliamentary Secretary invited Deputies to suggest schemes of useful public works. The schemes that I have suggested, if put into operation, would provide work for 12 months or two years. The harbour boards in Arklow and Wicklow have made appeals to the Government for assistance to carry out dredging and an extension of their docks. When application is made to the Board of Works for assistance the harbour boards are referred to the Department of Finance which, in turn, points out that certain loans are due by these harbour boards. I do not suppose it would be in order for me on this Vote to deal with the question of the repayment of loans, but I might point out that many of these old loans were obtained during the British régime. I would like to know why these loans should not be funded as the land annuity payments have been. The position at the present time is that public boards are called upon to pay penal interest in connection with many of those old loans as well as other charges that are supposed to be due but that are not being paid to England and that I hope never will. Their repayment means an increased rate on the ratepayers in these little towns. We have had many complaints about the position of the farmers. Deputy O'Leary spoke about it a short time ago. But what about the men living in labourers' cottages who are paying more in rent and rates than some of the farmers in West Cork who have 40 and 50 acres of land. These farmers are threatening to go to jail rather than pay their annuities which, in many cases, only amount to £5 or £6 a year. In proportion to their income, the men in the labourers' cottages are paying more in rent and rates than these farmers. There is a large number of small uneconomic holders in my area. I would urge on the Parliamentary Secretary to use any influence that he has with the Land Commission to divide up some of the big ranches in my county. I am not advocating the case now of the landless man, but recently I have come across cases of small farmers in my area trying to make a living on 20 acres of land. These men have told me that if they had another 20 acres they would be able to live well, and would not be obliged to seek road work from the county council with their horses and cars. They could leave that work for others who are unemployed.

I know that the Parliamentary Secretary will not agree with the suggestion I have made as regards introducing a 40-hour week. That however, is a question that we can debate on another occasion when a certain Bill that has been promised by the Government comes before the House. We have a large population in the country at the present time, and I believe that if my suggestion for shorter hours were put into operation by the Government it would help very considerably to relieve the unemployment problem.

As regards the rate of interest on loans that is charged to public bodies, I will be glad to have some information on that from the Parliamentary Secretary. If lower rates were charged, and if more assistance was given to public bodies than has been given hitherto, I believe that many useful schemes of work would be put into operation. These schemes would go a long way to provide work for large numbers of men who at present are in receipt of unemployment assistance as well as for those who are not in receipt of any assistance. The public bodies would be quite willing to give every co-operation to the Government in the carrying through of such schemes. The high rates of interest charged at present bear very heavily on the ratepayers in our little towns. They should get some consideration as well as the farmers who have had their land annuity payments halved. If loans were provided at a cheaper rate of interest than that which prevails at present, local bodies would have no excuse for not going ahead with useful public works to provide employment for the people. If my suggestion were adopted by the Government it would, I believe, mean that in my county employment would be provided for over 1,000 men for the next two years.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Parliamentary Secretary to conclude.

Comment on this
Hugh Victor Flinn Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Flinn) Fianna Fáil

"Even the weariest river winds somewhere safe to sea." This debate opened with a compliment to myself personally and to the immediate headquarters staff engaged in the administration of these schemes. As far as the headquarters staff and headquarters attention was concerned, it was agreed by the leader of the Opposition that these schemes were being better administered than they had ever been administered before and administered with the intention of fairness. Unfortunately, when the bouquet was thrown, the pot was thrown with it. In other words, it was said once again that while the good intentions of the Parliamentary Secretary and his staff were unimpeachable, there was widespread throughout the country a campaign of victimisation. Now I allude to that because the yellow Press will come out to-morrow, as it always does come out at the end of those debates, with a heading, "Victimisation on Relief Schemes." In every single debate which we have had the Press has just grabbed hold of some expression of that kind and used it as a headline to describe the discussion which took place here. Typical of all other debates in this matter, the man who made that insinuation, on being asked whether he had personal knowledge of any single particular case or whether he had, having that knowledge, brought that particular case to the Department for the purpose of examination, said "No." Now we have had that in every debate. In the last debate we had it from Deputy MacDermot. On being asked whether he had any case he said:—

"No, but where there is smoke there must be fire."

Again I pointed out that in his case— like the leader we were dealing with to-day, and that leader has intended to be fair—he had behind him the organisation and machinery of a party; that he had his fingers and his eyes on the ends of the earth as far as this country was concerned; that in relation to 2,500 claims going on at the same time there was intimate local knowledge in the possession of the representatives of that party. The same thing held to-day. It held in the last debate. It held in the debate previously. In every single case in which a man has been asked to deliver the goods and mention a case which was given to us and not investigated he has failed to do so. Now I have had a studied patience in relation to matters of this kind. I have felt that it was a duty on my part in both the tone and manner of the discussion here in dealing with cases of this kind to do everything that lay in my power to encourage every Deputy of the House who had facts to bring them to us with absolute confidence that they would be treated fairly. But I am not entitled to remain patient if in every debate we are to have a repetition of that calculated insinuation, with in every case absolute lack of any evidence of a sense of responsibility behind those who make that accusation. Deputy O'Leary at the end had another case, but he had not brought it to us. Deputy Murphy last year gave me a case and we investigated it. There was a lot of truth in the case put up by Deputy Murphy. I would challenge anybody in this House to come and examine the file, see the care and trouble we took to get to the bottom of the case, and then say that he is entitled—knowing or suspecting that there is any malpractice on the part of any man in administration of this fund, every single penny of which belongs to the poor—to hold back from his deliberate and definite and bounden duty to help those who are anxious to get the thing cleared up.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Parliamentary Secretary a question?

Comment on this

Not at present. I will not give way to anybody for the present. I have one subect to deal with.

Comment on this

Might I ask a question?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Parliamentary Secretary has not given way.

Comment on this

What I want to make perfectly clear is that if we have a repetition on another occasion of the conduct which we have had to-day, and in all the debates in relation to this matter, that is the reckless insinuation by those who ought to have the facts and who ought to have brought those facts to us, then we will not be entitled in honour to treat with patience or to treat with respect those who indulge in conduct of that kind.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Parliamentary Secretary would he pledge——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has no right to ask a question unless the Parliamentary Secretary gives way. He will have his opportunity when the Parliamentary Secretary has concluded.

Comment on this

I want to make that perfectly clear. I am not looking for a whole series of repetitions of those shameful insinuations against our subsidiary staff, covered by compliments to our personal service. Now I will listen to any question which the Deputy has to ask.

Comment on this

I just want to ask the Parliamentary Secretary whether, if I bring abuses to his notice and am prepared to prove the abuses, he will pledge his word here that he will in future appoint a local committee, apart from all political Parties, which everybody will be satisfied with?

Comment on this

I will give no pledge except that there will be a most rigid examination of any evidence of abuse that is produced, and that I will give every co-operation in stamping out that abuse if it exists. I do not belive it exists.

Comment on this

You would not believe it if it were proved?

Comment on this

The Deputy is now just following the line which we have a right to object to. He is another Deputy who apparently thinks he is in possession of evidence, but he has never made an attempt to give us an opportunity of dealing with it. Let him give us the evidence and we will deal with it.

Comment on this

If you will pledge your word I will do so—not otherwise.

Comment on this

I will pledge my word that the case will be fully investigated.

Comment on this

Oh, that is no use.

Comment on this

Deputy McGovern was not in the House when that pledge was given.

Comment on this

I think that was practically all that mattered as far as Deputy Dillon is concerned. Deputy Dillon has at different times sent me cases which I have investigated. He has also sent me suggestions which have been investigated. If Deputies have any suggestions to make, or any cases to be investigated, let us have them. The House might recognise that I am not here to-night administering an indefinite amount of money. I am not concerned with what could be done if I had an infinite amount of money. I am concerned with the administration of £350,000 which was put into my possession by the Dáil, and £150,000 which is being voted to-night. It is merely a question of how that can be best distributed. Deputy Dillon suggested that scenic roads would be roads to which attention should be given; that is, roads having indirect economic value for tourist traffic. Those roads, to any extent of which we hear of them, would undoubtedly be considered. Three or four valuable roads from the scenic point of view have been created. The Deputy suggested farm drainage. A scheme in relation to that has been put up to the Committee of Public Works, and it is now being investigated. Land reclamation has been already done. It was done under the old régime, and has been continued to the extent of £10,000 or £15,000. Therefore, the principle of using public money on private land, where it is clearly understood you are dealing with congests, or people otherwise in uneconomic holdings, is already accepted, and it is only a question of its extension. The Deputy desired to know how application for such money should be made. In the first instance, it should be made to the Department of Agriculture, who will make the recommendation to us.

Deputy Norton was anxious to know what would be done for large towns. Up to the present £70,000 has been allocated this year for public health schemes, practically all in towns, and there is probably another £30,000 which will be allocated for public health schemes, mostly in the cities and towns. The Deputy suggested as a solution a reduction of the hours of labour. That is simply a question for argument, on which people differ very much. The argument has been stated by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, that one of the effects of reducing the hours of labour, where an employer desires to keep up production, is that he puts in machinery to do it. When you begin to get production by increased machinery the tendency does not stop with the first success. It is certainly a serious question to be considered. I am only saying this from the point of view of argument, to show that there are two sides to be considered. A reduction of hours does not increase the wealth of a community. What it does is to redistribute, to some extent, the wealth of the country. I am perfectly satisfied that what this country wants, more than the redistribution of wealth, is the creation of wealth. Personally, I do not see along the lines of the mere reduction of hours. I cannot see that you are going to ameliorate conditions. You are going to divide the labour amongst more people. Honestly, I cannot see further in present conditions. All I am suggesting is that it is obviously not a case where all the arguments are on one side.

Comment on this

We will convince you of the necessity for it.

Comment on this

I shall be most happy. I change my opinions every day. The real definition of a strong man is one who changes his opinion on sound arguments.

Comment on this

Miracles are not happening in Ireland lately.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce gave certain figures showing that in 1931, 17,000 people were placed in employment and in 1932, over 100,000. I can bring out later, in relation to a question which we are going to have all over again, the significance of the actual hours in employment. Probably I would be inclined to let that slide. I am afraid Deputy MacDermot wandered away. He told us he was an unprejudiced observer. I do not think I need go any further. Deputy Corry suggested that under this scheme there should be preference for victimised farm labourers, for men who had been definitely thrown out of employment as a result of political pressure. That would be a perfectly legitimate thing for a Government to do by a vote ad hoc. If it could be shown that a particular section of men had been victimised for political opinions, and thrown out of employment, it would be a legitimate move for a Government to deal with, but it would have to be dealt with ad hoc. I do not see how you could include machinery of that kind in the ordinary regulations for the purpose of fairly recruiting labour purely on distress work out of ordinary unemployment schemes.

Comment on this

A special rate for that particular area.

Comment on this

If done ad hoc.

Comment on this

A special rate on the area.

Comment on this

The Deputy means to collect money and to give it to a special account. Deputy Kent spoke of labourers who refused to work because they were getting unemployment assistance. It is a duty everybody owes to the State, where they know of cases of that kind, to report them. We have had already, from the very limited scope of the archaeological works, run up against a couple of cases of men who refused to work on these jobs, but who turned up to claim assistance. In all such cases unemployment assistance has been withdrawn, and the men left with the obligation to appeal and to show cause why it should be restored.

Deputy Kent does not want the work-shy to "get away" with it. We are going to have a certain small proportion of people who prefer to have 7/-, 8/- or 10/- a week and to do nothing rather than work for higher wages. It will be our business, and I think it will be a difficult and onerous one this year, to see as far as possible that people who are prepared to misuse the Unemployment Assistance Fund in that way will not "get away" with it. We propose to do our best in that matter. I am not clear to what degree we will succeed. It may be found, for instance, that in certain areas there will not be registered for home assistance a sufficient number of men to fill up the gangs in those areas. You might not find people turning up who ought to be doing work. It is not going to be an easy job this year. The job I have is one that no one in this House envies, certainly on the principle on which we are going, of being individually responsible for recruiting and standing over the recruitment on the merits of, perhaps, 30,000 or 40,000 men, without the formal intervention of the labour exchanges as our protection, as to a large extent they were this year. It is certainly not going to be a pleasant occupation. However, it is a job and we will do the best we can.

Deputy McGilligan referred to the fact that I had said that a man had to walk 15 miles. I should not have said that a man had to walk 15 miles. What I meant was that a man was a considerable distance away from, and out of contact with, labour exchanges under the old position. What we did was to bring the labour exchanges to his door and the bringing of the labour exchanges to his door was something which had a very great influence upon the fact that he did register then when he had not registered before. The proof of that is that the vast majority of the new registration did not take place at the central office but at the local offices which we provided. Deputy McGilligan also referred to the fact that there was an economic war on, starting somewhere about the time we came in, and that the actual figures of unemployment registration had risen during the period of that war, and asked whether we were not bound to take into account the connection between those two figures. There is all the difference in the world between post hoc and propter hoc. Two things may run parallel to another thing without any causal connection. If anyone will study the actual graph showing the rise and time and rate and shape of the curve of the rise which took place in the two cases in which the two big jumps came, he will find that it has no connection with the gradual development of the economic war. He will find that the whole of the first rise took place within the two months in which the three new conditions were brought into being—local exchanges, a large unemployment grant, and the understanding that the registrations at the labour exchanges were a definite title to being employed and to getting benefit from relief.

That was the first rise, and as you move along, you find that you drop back to the ordinary seasonal characteristic at the higher level, until you come to January of 1934. In January of 1934, instead of a fall taking place, as should have been the case, according to the seasonal change, it rose. It rose against the law and it rose precisely from the time at which it was announced that at a particular date this Act would come into operation and that benefit would accrue. The first rise actually stopped, the first rush of new registrations actually stopped, on the date on which it had been scheduled that the Act was to come into operation. In other words, any honest inquirer, as distinct from a purely political examiner of the question, will find a direct connection between the rate of the rise and the place of the rise and the new artificial stimuli that were introduced.

The other thing the Deputy said was perfectly true. He spoke of his last year as Minister for Industry and Commerce. Deputy Murphy, and I think, Deputy Everett also, raised the question of whether or not a man was prohibited from getting employment on these relief schemes because he was not on unemployment assistance. We shall probably take into temporary employment somewhere between 30,000 and 40,000 men. They will not be all on at the same time, but the actual total number of people in this country who have at the present moment certificates that they would be entitled to unemployment assistance, if they were out of work, is 180,000. Every one of those has a statutory title to be regarded as a person entitled to work out of this, in preference to other people, and I am inclined to think that, apart from the probable irregularity of distribution of registration, we ought to be able to get, out of those 180,000 people, most of the people who are going to be employed on unemployment work. Of the remainder, of the whole of the other people who are applying for certificates—and the gap is not very big— 220,000 as against 180,000—all those people will be registered or ought to be registered at the labour exchange if they are unemployed. Of course, it is quite obvious that they cannot be because you have 180,000 certificates out already and you have only 119,000 on the unemployment register, and that unemployment register probably includes nearly 30,000 people who would not have, and would not be qualified for certificates at all. Therefore, it seems to me, in the first place, that the people who have a certificate from the State that their total income is below a certain level have undoubtedly a right to a preference when unemployed.

Comment on this

I wonder if the Parliamentary Secretary has got the point I was trying to make or if it is my fault that I did not make it clear? There would be a large number in various districts of persons who got qualification certificates which would entitle them perhaps to a shilling or two. They have not drawn any benefit and their cases are the subject of appeal at the moment. I was anxious that the fact that they were not actually in receipt of benefit and that decisions in their cases were pending would not prejudice their chance of employment. I think I understand from the Parliamentary Secretary's reply now that they would be eligible?

Comment on this

So far as I can see, they would. The first people who would get it would be the people who are actually getting unemployment assistance. Take, for instance, the archaeological returns. We attempted to use those as an idea of how the thing was going to work and we asked those in charge to divide the employees up into people who were on unemployment assistance and people who had certificates granted. They were either one or the other and, therefore, I take it a person with a certificate granted would be eligible. Of course, a man with a certificate granted would be on unemployment assistance if he were unemployed.

Comment on this

It is only right that the Parliamentary Secretary should know that, in some cases, when a man is appealing, his benefit is stopped. I have the case of a man who had 6/- a week and who appealed against it and his card was taken from him pending the appeal.

Comment on this

What we will do is to try to get the atmosphere, that while the first preference goes to men who are on unemployment assistance as far as possible, the rest of the employment will go to those with qualification certificate. I just want to know whether it is the will and judgment of the House that as far as possible employment on unemployment schemes should be given to those who have statutory qualification under this Act. Is that the general desire?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Yes.

Comment on this

While I cannot say that that will be carried out to 100 per cent., I will say that every effort will be made to bring it as near to that as we possibly can. There may be cases of people who have not applied for unemployment assistance at all. You may find—certainly in some of the farming areas—people who say: "I will not go in for unemployment assistance at all." I do not want to be put in the position of saying that a man of that kind would not get a chance of employment even under that.

Comment on this
A Deputy

They would be very rare cases.

Comment on this

They may be very rare, but the more rare they are the more I think everybody would feel that people who took that point of view should be entitled to consideration. Deputy Murphy was also strong on the question of direct employment in various ways. All the cases he raised were local authorities' schemes, I think, with the exception of cases under the Office of Public Works. I think that the number of cases that were done by contract on relief work by the Office of Public Works are very few. Personally, I can only recollect one case, although there may be more.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Would the Parliamentary Secretary keep it in mind as a general line of policy for the Office of Public Works?

Comment on this

I will, but as far as the Office of Public Works in its general capacity is concerned it must be remembered that its business is to get value for State money and to treat State property as something out of which the State has to get full value.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

The two principles can be very well reconciled.

Comment on this

To the extent to which they can be reconciled they will be sympathetically considered. Deputy Coburn asked whether all the money was allocated. It is not. I am going to give you certain figures, but if anybody at any time wants to tell me that I have given a solemn and sacred promise that money is going to be distributed in this manner, they had better think again. Broadly speaking, the intention is to distribute it between public health, mineral development, peat schemes and minor relief schemes, and the rest. Public health, probably, will get £100,000— perhaps a little more. From £7,000 to £10,000 a year will be spent on minerals. That may be an answer to Deputy Moore also.

Comment on this

That is not much.

Comment on this

Oliver Twist! At any rate, to the extent to which it is being used, it is used not so much on mining as in the discovery of the places in which you could mine, in the removing of over-burden on places, in opening and investigating deposits, and, in addition, certain money has been and will be spent on roads into mineral workings. The peat schemes depend altogether on what they will be able to carry. It may be anything from £50,000 to £100,000. Probably £100,000 will be spent on minor relief schemes.

While the whole of the money is segregated out in sections of that kind, the actual amount which is definitely allocated is not within £150,000 of the total, but the whole of that £150,000 will be allocated more or less on those lines. What I am saying is that if there are any schemes which anyone has in relation to particular places, money is still available; but if you want a Local Government scheme, send it through the Local Government Department; if you want a mineral development scheme, send it through Industry and Commerce; because the procedure is that each of these Departments send up to us recommendations for grants in relation to schemes which they themselves are responsible for, having technically examined them, and we then allocate moneys to them on the basis, to a certain extent, of their desirability, and, to a certain extent, as to whether they fall in these areas in which unemployment money of that kind is required.

Deputy Coburn also wanted to know about the initiation of schemes. The difficulty is that I have got to tell the same story time after time. On every debate in connection with this matter I have told the House that everybody is entitled to put forward schemes—county councillors, county surveyors, Deputies, Senators and so on—and we will be glad to consider them. We have already considered some thousands of schemes and tried to sift them out on their merits and I do not think that there is any Party in this House that has submitted schemes that have not been examined and dealt with on their merits.

Deputy Coburn said a most remarkable thing. He said one of the most hopeful things I have ever heard as a testimony to the comfort and safety and comparative stability and lack of anxiety which we would all feel in relation to the present state of the country and its future.

He said that economic pressure would compel us all to tell the truth. I suppose, therefore, that the proportionate lack of truthfulness which is now, according to political opponents, universal in this country, must be a measure of the country's prosperity and the lack of economic pressure.

Comment on this

It is an awkward quotation.

Comment on this

It is unpleasant but it is hopeful. Deputy Moore is interested in minerals in Wicklow. We do make a rule here that no one gets any advantage by using debates of this kind for the purpose of pushing particular schemes in relation to his own constituency. As a result, we have reduced to a minimum the speeches made for the purpose of local newspaper consumption. In so far, however, as Deputy Moore has raised, as he always does raise, some questions of public as well as local interest, the matters will be considered; but the particular schemes which he has in view I would advise him to send through the regular channels—that is, the Minister for Industry and Commere, who will send them along.

Comment on this

They were sent there long ago.

Comment on this

If they have been there long ago, the Deputy must know that there they are sent to geological experts, and the fact that they have not yet come forward to us does not necessarily mean that they are particularly good. I suggest that Deputy Moore should start again. I am rather prejudiced in favour of the area to which he belongs as my mother comes from it. Deputy O'Leary, of north-east Cork, suggests that there should be a local subsidy on feeding stuffs for that particular district. Now, I am frankly of opinion that there are certain areas which the general policy of the Government in relieving agriculture has not touched, and where a specific remedy that will attack a specific problem is available I think we should all be very grateful to get it. Whether the particular proposal the Deputy has made is practicable or not I do not know, but it will be referred to the Minister for Agriculture, who will consider it.

Deputy Everett wants to know at what price the Minister for Finance will give him money. If he gets it through the Local Loans Fund, he will get it at 4¾ per cent. Where you ask for a different rate of interest, what you are asking for is an additional subsidy.

I cannot give it to you out of the £150,000. The Minister for Finance calculates that in distributing the total amount of income that he has to give for all benefits in the country he has given to the particular activity in which the Deputy is interested all that in fairness he could give relative to others. It is the business of the Deputy to put up a special claim for that thing as against some other claim. There is an idea—it is quite a natural idea—that the Government has a sort of bottomless sack out of which it produces stuff. That is not so. It has a limited income. It is a question of how much it will give to one interest or activity without taking too much from another. I think the Deputy will understand that what he has to do in that particular case is not to put up a case simply on the basis of its absolute desirability, but of its relative desirability, relative to other things. Any reduction of interest by the Minister for Finance to a particular activity is, on a given income, a reduction of his capacity to give benefit to some other activity. The Deputy can put it up on that basis.

The Deputy also raised the question of the stamping of the unemployment cards of people on relief works. The whole question is whether in doing that you are anxious to benefit the people employed upon these relief works or not. Our chief reason for not doing it, apart from the fact that there is a legal definition against us in the case of their being agricultural labourers, is that the people themselves would not benefit by it. All that would happen in relation to a person engaged upon a minor relief work would be that he would be charged up with the unemployment stamps but would get no benefit from them. You have to have 12 stamps before you can get benefit. From our experience of the people whom we have employed, the vast number of people engaged in minor relief schemes are not employed for 12 weeks on that work. A great many of them are small farmers or farmers' sons, especially in the poorer congested areas, who have no other stamps to their credit, and the only effect of giving them four or five weeks' work on an unemployment scheme would be to reduce their wages by the amount of their own contribution to the unemployed stamps. I do not think that is what Deputy Everett wants.

Personally I prefer to keep a debate of this kind strictly to the Vote itself, and I have simply dealt as honestly as I could with the questions raised. I am frankly not looking forward very much to the administration of this year. There has been a considerable change in relation to the position from the point of view of the unemployment assistance and the rest of it. There has been a withdrawal from the relief schemes due to the unexampled pressure which the administration of the unemployment assistance and now of the free meat scheme has put upon the employment exchanges. There has been necessarily for this year a withdrawal from co-operation. We have now to recruit our people through a great many different and separate agencies. The employment exchanges are prepared to give us every help that they can, and we are prepared to avail of every help they can give; but it is going to be a complicated position. At the end of the year we will be asked to stand over the actual circumstances under which we have employed some 30,000 or 40,000 different men. It is against all human reason to imagine that there will not be mistakes made in that. All I can tell you is that, as far as the Department is concerned, as far as every officer of that Department as far down as we can reach is concerned, no mistake will be made that can be avoided by people who fully and definitely regard this money as a trust put in their hands to be administered fairly for the benefit of the poor.

Comment on this

Is the same machinery as heretofore being utilised in the expenditure of this money on road work?

Comment on this

As far as work is done on county council roads it will be a grant made to the county council and administered by the county surveyor as such. In so far as it is work done upon roads which the country council did not maintain—by roads, bog roads, etc. —it will be done through the county surveyor acting as the agent of the Board of Works.

Comment on this

I understood the Parliamentary Secretary to say that portion of the money would be allocated for the purpose of peat development. That would involve road-making also.

Comment on this

There will be £50,000, £60,000 or £70,000 spent on the development of peat in the sense of making peat available on a commercial scale, as distinct from the ordinary bog roads which are intended to make peat available for the owner of the bank in the bog. These schemes also are being done through the county surveyor as the agent of the Board of Works.

Comment on this

That is the making of bog roads for the purpose of facilitating peat development. Will not the county surveyors be responsible for the making and supervising of these?

Comment on this

The schemes for roads into bogs for the purpose of commercial development of peat are prepared by the engineers of the peat development section. They are then handed to us and by us transferred to the county surveyor, who carries out the work as our agent.

Comment on this

I got a qualified undertaking from the Parliamentary Secretary in a former debate that works that were partially completed last year would be completed this year. I should like the Parliamentary Secretary to keep that in mind so that works that were partially done and were utterly ineffective for that reason will be completed.

Comment on this

The Deputy may take that assurance as being carried out in practice. I have been through the plans and arrangements for 200 or 300 works and I am satisfied that the proportion of works which are in continuation of last year is very high indeed.

Comment on this