Committee on Finance. - Supplementary Estimates—Vote No. 70—Export Bounties and Subsidies (Resumed).
Contributions 1–138 of 291. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When the debate was adjourned last night, I was criticising the various items in this Vote for bounties and subsidies. I was proceeding to state to the House that the dairying industry was not in a very flourishing condition when the Minister interrupted me. His interruption was to the effect that the price of butter on the British market was 67/-. His contention was, I think, that, if the Opposition was in power, the farmer would be receiving 67/- for his butter. I do not know that the Minister had any knowledge of what the Opposition would do as a Government in the present circumstances, with butter at 67/-. I retorted that, with an expenditure of about half the amount in which the Minister has involved himself for bounties and other aids to keep up the price of butter, we could maintain the price of butter at a far higher price than that at which it stands at present. Perhaps it would be just as well if I were to give a short explanation of that statement. I accept the Minister's figure of 67/-, although the Minister said not very long ago that the average price of butter on the English market during 18 months was 80/-. The creameries are getting about 100/- for their butter. Obviously, a subsidy of 30/- or 31/- would keep butter at that price even if the price on the British market were as low as 67/- or 68/-. What is it costing the State to enable the farmers, through the creameries, to get 101/- or 100/- for their butter? The Minister is paying a direct subsidy of, at least, 31/-. I am not so sure that that subsidy has not been increased recently but it is at least 31/-. That sum, in itself, if there were no other complications, would have kept the price of butter at 100/-. Every member of this community who buys butter is paying, at least, 5d. per lb. more than he ought to pay in consequence of the economic war. I leave it to any Deputy who wishes, to ascertain the amount of butter consumed at home, work out the extra cost at 5d. per lb. and see what the ordinary consumer is contributing. The farmer is, furthermore, contributing a huge sum by way of loss in price in other branches of the dairying industry. A loss in production is tantamount to a reduction in price. In the production of butter, a cow is certainly necessary. As the farmer carries on his dairying from year to year, his cows have to be changed. I heard the statement made in the presence of the Minister recently that it costs £10 to replace a cow. I agree with that. If I were making the estimate, I should put it at a higher figure. If we take into consideration the several amounts of £10 for replacing cows, and if we add that to what the farmer is losing otherwise, including his loss in respect of that other necessary adjunct to the dairying industry—the calf—we get an idea of the farmers' contribution to the price. The State is at present contributing a sum which, if there were no economic war, would suffice to keep the price of butter not at 100/- but possibly at 140/- or 150/-. This is the industry which Ministerial spokesmen try, down the country, to persuade farmers is in a flourishing condition.
There is an item in this estimate for £278,000 for bacon and pig offals and pork. If there was any export we should easily have maintained, it was the export of pigs. At one time, it was stated in this House that we could easily maintain our export of pigs. Nevertheless, there has been difficulty in keeping up our export. The Minister has had, I think, to increase the subsidy. He certainly has had to put an Excise duty on home bacon to entice people to ship portion of it, instead of retaining it for home use. Incidentally, I think the Minister said yesterday that he hoped the Excise duty on bacon would produce £270,000, so that the amount shown here—£278,000—may not directly fall on the Exchequer. Whether it falls directly on the Exchequer or not, no Deputy is so dense as to think that the bacon curers will themselves bear this Excise duty of 10/- per cwt. It will fall on the unfortunate consumers of bacon in this country. The bacon consumers will have to contribute, as the butter consumers are contributing, to the maintenance of the export of our produce to a country in which, we are told, there is no market for it. I think everybody, even the Minister, is satisfied now that bounties upon cattle, during the last six months, did not reach the farmer. Recently, the Minister has made an attempt to remedy that state of affairs. Unfortunately, the remedy has not improved matters very much.
Before the recent effort to make exporters pay a certain sum, it was possible in the southern, and perhaps western districts, to sell cattle at a sort of a price—really at a loss. But since the introduction of the new method of compulsion on exporters to pay a certain price one could not sell a fat beast at any price.
Comment on this
Ask me another. I am saying that it is impossible to sell fat beasts at any price in the southern markets at the present moment. If Deputy Davin can give me a remedy for that I shall be very thankful.
Comment on this
I tell the Deputy that if he can produce a remedy for the conditions that I mention he will be doing something that the Minister has not been able to do and, in fact, he ought to exchange places with the Minister. The Minister, I admit, has attempted to find a remedy, but all Deputy Davin can do, apparently, is to ask questions. The real position is that we have fat cattle to sell and cannot sell them at any price. At a recent Munster fair the number of cattle was greater than, possibly, for many years past, and I venture to say that not one lot of fat cattle in that very great fair was sold, except a few bought by butchers for slaughter. It is a most unfortunate statement to have to make, but it is the fact that at one of the greatest fairs for fat cattle in Ireland not a single lot was bought, as far as I know.
Comment on this
Because the exporters could not or would not, if you prefer it, pay the price the Minister says they ought to pay. I leave it to the Deputy to answer whether "would" or "could" is the right word to use.
Comment on this
Originally the expenditure of these moneys now being so lavishly expended was to find new markets, but except a limited market in Germany for a few cows, despite whatever search one makes, one fails to find any market that has been discovered after two years' attempts. I do not want to follow the peregrinations of the chickens into France and Belgium or to deal with other small items. One hoped that some substantial alternative to the British market would have been discovered in two years. But at the end of two years we do not appear to be any nearer to discovering alternative markets than we were in July, 1932. Evidently, the President was right when, on the introduction of the original Grant-in-Aid of £2,000,000, he honestly declared in this House that he had to admit that he had not any hope whatever of finding alternative markets, and he added: "That is the truth," as much as to say that what the Minister for Finance and other Ministers had said before him was evidently not a fact. The President came before the House and candidly stated that he could not see any hope of finding alternative markets, and he added: "That is the truth."
Comment on this
I have not the report before me but I think the Deputy will find that they are very little inaccurate and that the addendum is certainly correct.
Comment on this
No doubt the Deputy is as near to the truth as ever he is.
Comment on this
The Minister says I am as near the truth as ever I am. I said I may not be using the President's identical words, but if there is any doubt of the truth of the substance of what I have stated, I can send for the report and get the President's actual words, and read them out, and I think they will be found to be exactly what I have stated.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy's statement as true as his statement that he could pay his annuities but would not, later?
Comment on this
There appears to be a desire, especially on the part of Deputy Cleary, that we should extend this debate to other matters.
Comment on this
That is so; but I shall stop whenever the Chair tells me. But there seems to be a desire that we should bring up the question of the effect of the bounties and tariff system upon the farmers generally, and the inability of the farmers, for instance, to pay certain debts. What happens to a farmer when he finds himself in the position of being unable to pay? His cattle will be seized, as was my unfortunate experience. Deputy Cleary is evidently desirous that the House should know the exact circumstances of my seizure.
Comment on this
Deputy Cleary, and other prominent members of his Party, have made the statement that I said I could pay my annuities, but I would not. I never said such a thing. I did say after the sale, that I would not find the money, which was a very different thing from saying that I could easily pay. Even if I said that, the finding of the money would have been an extremely difficult matter for me then, and it would be an impossible matter for me now, because at the moment I could not give away some of the cattle I possess. I venture to say that if I approached my bank manager for an extension of credit I am afraid I would not get a very pleasant answer.
I suppose there was a time in this State when one hesitated to admi poverty. The admission of poverty i not really a crime. I am not ashamed to admit in this House or out of it that my position is not much better than the ordinary average farmer in this State; and the position of the ordinary average farmer is a position which I am sure neither the Minister nor Deputy Cleary would wish any individual to be in. We are opposing this motion and moving that it be referred back for reconsideration. Personally, on my own behalf I would oppose it. I would oppose definitely any extension of the bounties or continuation of the existing bounties when other methods of putting the farmer on his feet and of putting agriculture in something of a prosperous condition could be pursued. One can visualise circumstances in agriculture, just as in any other industry, when artificial remedies are needful for a time, either by bounty or tariff, to protect such an industry. I can quite see that there might be such circumstances. But if one can remove the circumstances, it is a saner practice to remove them than to proceed to an uncertain cure. The circumstances that have brought agriculture to its present unfortunate position in this State could be and should be easily removed, and it is because no attempt, or no honest or decent attempt, has been made to put an end to these unfortunate circumstances that we oppose any extension of the bounty system or the subsidy system or the tariff system as an aid to agricultural prosperity.
Despite the fact that for two years bounty on bounty has been added until we have arrived at the situation that every item of a farmer's output is aided by subsidy or bounty, and despite the fact as well that every other member of the community day by day has to bear additions to the cost of every article he consumes in order to keep agriculture in a prosperous condition, agriculture to-day is in a worse position than it ever was at any previous period in the history of this State. If any proof were needed of the failure of the bounty and subsidy system as an aid to agriculture, it is there to be seen as the results of two years' operation of that system in this country.
Comment on this
When I attended the first meetings of this House immediately after the last local elections, I assumed that if there were any commonsense left in the skulls of the Opposition members of this House they would come in here, having learned something from the lesson the people taught them at that time, and change their tactics and do some real work of nation building. I thought that they would then at least help in some constructive way to put this State on a proper financial footing. Listening to, and having read two or three of the recent speeches made in this House, particularly those by Deputies O'Higgins and Dillon, I have come to the conclusion that they represent the mentality of self-appointed spokesmen of a Party which is completely demoralised and disorganised.
I listened attentively to Deputy O'Higgins yesterday evening, repeating the sentences which he has so often repeated in this House before— sentences involving personal accusations of lack of courage against the President and lack of honour against the members of the Government in their dealings on behalf of this State with people on the far side of the Channel. They were the same sentences, repeated in parrot-like fashion, that we have heard so often, with nothing of a constructive nature or sensible suggestion as to what should be done if the Minister withdraws these bounties. The Deputy said: "We never got an honest expression of Government opinion upon any matter of policy affecting the people of this country." I think that what is really wrong is that the Government policy cannot be swallowed by people like Deputy O'Higgins or Deputy Dillon, and, consequently, they have made up their minds that instead of building up they are going to smash up everything all around.
We are told by some of the speakers and some of the Front Bench people opposite that they are going to pass on to the people of this State a sort of Italian ice-cream Constitution— something like what they have in Italy at the present time, or in Germany or some of these other States that are governed by dictators to-day. All I say is that if we ever have the kind of Constitution in this country that prevails at present in Italy, Germany and other countries of the kind, that the people opposite seem to like so much, some of the people opposite who make those speeches would find themselves within the biggest State institution that could be got to keep them within barbed wires.
Comment on this
I am replying briefly to some of the seditious speeches made by Deputy O'Higgins and Deputy Dillon.
Comment on this
I would advise Deputy Brennan, who speaks generally in a constructive and sensible way whenever he takes part in debates here, to appeal to the few colleagues around him to stop talking about civil war spirit to stop strring up the civil war spirit in this country. Deputy Bennett, who, I thought and believed until yesterday evening, knew a good deal about the dairying industry, does not seem to be in touch at all with the dairy farmers of his constituency or with the position of the people engaged in the dairying industry at the present time.
Comment on this
He has trotted out figures here which would mislead the ignorant—the really ignorant—person outside who knew nothing at all about the dairying industry and the help which the subsidies and bounties have been towards maintaining that very valuable industry in this country. Will the Deputy tell me, or will somebody else who can speak for him tell me, when he is speaking next, what would be the price of milk paid to the dairy farmers of this country to-day, even without an economic war, if the ruling price outside were to regulate the price of milk here? Can the Deputy give me that answer even now to help this discussion and to help the Minister to give a proper reply?
Comment on this
I am at the disadvantage, Sir, that I cannot get from a Deputy, whom I regarded as an expert, a straight answer to a straight question.
Comment on this
I wonder whether the Deputy has been reading any of the papers published in the Dominions, or any of the reports recently published in the Irish papers—in the official organ of his own Party—regarding the collapse of the dairying industry in New Zealand? Would the Deputy say that New Zealand, which is known to be the most loyal member of the British Commonwealth of Nations and which has the most loyal Prime Minister of any of the Dominions, is engaged in an economic war with Great Britain? If it is engaged in such an economic war, I have not heard anything about it. I should like the Deputy, therefore, to look into the position as affecting New Zealand at the moment and say whether the position there in connection with the dairying industry is due to the attitude of the Prime Minister of New Zealand and his Government. Well, what is the cause of it? Has it nothing to do with world conditions?
I have made a fairly careful study of the position of the dairy farmers in my constituency. The reason I have studied the situation there is because a number of creameries have been established in my constituency inside the last three or four years, and I have been in fairly constant touch with the position there because I and my colleagues have been approached on various occasions asking for assistance in various direction for these co-operative creameries. I am satisfied— and the Minister can contradict me if I am wrong—that if we had no economic war, and if the present price of butter, known to the Deputy and to all the members of the House, was the price that should rule the price in this country to-day, the dairy farmers would be getting 2d. or 2¼d. per gallon for their milk to-day.
Comment on this
I leave the Minister, from his Departmental knowledge and information, to say if I am right in these figures. I am not going to allow Deputy Bennett to make my speech. The Deputy challenged me yesterday evening to have the courage to get up here to speak on this Vote. I am now dealing with what the Deputy said, and I am asking the Deputy another pertinent question, and I suppose he will not answer it, because he would not answer the other one.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy get up in County Limerick, where there are a number of these co-operative creameries, and suggest to the farmers associated with these co-operative creameries that they should carry on with them and only receive between 2d. and 2¼d. for their milk? If we had no economic war, if that were the situation with which we would be confronted, what would be the Deputy's alternative for maintaining the dairying industry, which is a very valuable industry from the employment point of view in this country? You have criticised the Minister's policy of bounties and subsidies, but you have given us no alternative. I say that it is the only alternative which we have at the moment to maintain an industry which this country cannot afford to lose. I am supporting that part of the Government's policy with far greater enthusiasm than I support bounties and subsidies for other items affecting the agricultural community.
I have no doubt whatsoever that I am doing right in voting for this Estimate for the purpose of continuing to maintain this industry so as to give the farmers an economic, and in some cases a profitable, price for their milk. I know the value of a cheque to the farmer at the end of the month. A number of these cheques are paid every month in my constituency where the farmers have only in recent years come into the dairying industry. They have been very helpful in enabling the farmers to pay their debts, including, I may say, the annuities, in spite of an attempt to organise them against the payment of annuities.
Comment on this
Life is not long enough to explain my position in the matter to the Deputy and he would not understand it even if I did attempt it. I am coming to the point which is apparently the real bone of contention with the Opposition and which I believe is a matter of serious concern to every Deputy in this House, including the Minister for Agriculture. That is the provision of large sums out of this Vote for the payment of bounties to cattle dealers who engage in the export of surplus livestock from this country. I am not infallible in this matter but I have come definitely to the conclusion that the money voted for this purpose has not been finding its way into the pockets of the livestock producers and I should like to hear from the Minister what his opinion is of that particular aspect of the cattle industry at the present time. I want to have an assurance from the Minister, a very definite one, if we are going to continue to pay subsidies and bounties to cattle dealers who engage in exporting livestock from this country, that in view of the recent legislation, he will take all necessary steps, no matter how drastic they may be, to make these gentlemen pay the price which has been fixed under the Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Act.
I believe a large number of these gentlemen have got licences since this particular Act came into operation. They signed undertakings of a very definite nature that they would pay the fixed price for certain classes of cattle, but I have personal knowledge, obtained from the people concerned, that they have in almost all cases failed to do so. There has been very definitely an organised opposition on the part of British and Irish cattle traders against that part of the Act and these people are determined if the Minister will allow them, to smash this vital section of the Act, that is, the section which fixes the minimum price of 25/- per cwt. for fat live stock. I understand that the Minister has been holding up some licences for the current month in the case of those who have refused to honour their undertakings. I hope that the Minister will not alone refuse to issue licences to people who have in a flagrant way dishonoured their undertakings, but that he will take any other action, no matter how drastic, to compel these gentlemen to honour any undertakings they may have given in a vital matter of this kind.
I wonder could we have from the Minister the percentage or the number of individuals who signed undertakings and dishonoured them and also some indication of what action he proposes to take in future cases where similar undertakings are signed and not honoured? It is ridiculous to think, and I have been informed that it is true, that these gentlemen have been again asked to sign some other kind of a very drastic form of undertaking. I should like to know what exactly is the position in regard to those who got licences for the last month and whose licences up to the present are held up. There is only one cure for these gentlemen and that is to put them out of action and, if necessary, adopt the policy which this Party advocated three years ago—set up a marketing organisation which will deal with the whole export trade, just as Britain and other States have been forced to do for reasons which are not applicable to this State. It is three years ago since this Party, in a manifesto issued after the economic war started, definitely encouraged the Government to set up a marketing organisation, and though I am no prophet, I say that if the present situation continues, the Government will be forced to do it or else admit defeat at the hands of this organised gang of people who have robbed the live stock producers of this country for the past two years. We suggested in October, 1932, that the sale and export of cattle should be undertaken by an organisation acting on behalf of the Government, and that any loss incurred, as between the sale price and the purchase price, should be borne by the State. Supposing such an organisation were set up at that time, one thing bound to happen would be that any price paid for the cattle would be bound to find its way back to the producers from whom they were bought and on whose behalf they were sold.
I listened to portion of Deputy O'Higgins' speech yesterday evening in which he purported to quote remarks attributed to the Minister for Agriculture in a speech delivered somewhere in the country. He then proceeded to quote a speech delivered by Senator Connolly in Kilcock in which he was supposed to pray to God for the destruction of the cattle trade of this country. I remember that Senator Connolly contradicted that version of his speech which was published in the Irish Independent, but, of course, Deputy O'Higgins, for reasons of his own, never read that contradiction. I am fully satisfied that the present serious position affects every occupier of agricultural land in this country down to the cottier who has a cow and rears a calf, and therefore there is no reason for suggesting, as some people do, that this situation only affects the ranchers and the large farmers. I am satisfied that if the new Act came into operation right away and if those who have cattle for sale were to get a minimum of 25/- per cwt. for these cattle, the people who would benefit most would be the large farmers who were lucky enough to buy cattle six months or a year ago. The small farmer or the cottier, who has an animal to sell now and again, would only come to benefit after the surplus cattle has been disposed of in a year or 18 months' time. There is more in the Act to the benefit and advantage of Deputies sitting on the Opposition benches than some of them are prepared to admit. That is why, if there was a proper spirit prevailing in the country, we should have this House assisting, instead of obstructing, the Minister in enforcing the terms of that Act on those who are engaged in the export cattle industry. But, no, they cannot do it. They think of their Party before their country and before the people of the country. If they were wise they would think less of the Party that is now so disorganised and demoralised, but I suppose the demoralisation has crept into their own constitutions. I am satisfied that if this economic war is to be fought out to a finish—apparently, there are some people in the country who say it should be fought to a finish—and won, then the winning of it will depend to a great extent, as far as the farmers are concerned, on the power and willingness of the Minister to enforce payment of these minimum prices, no matter what they may be from time to time.
Comment on this
The Deputy will have an opportunity of making his speech later. I know the farming community of this country, and particularly of my own constituency, as well as any other Deputy. I know them sufficiently well to say that if they can get good profitable prices for their cattle they do not care a tinker's curse where the money comes from.
Comment on this
Probably Deputies will not laugh when I am finished, but that is why I am encouraging, and will continue to encourage, the Minister to take the most drastic action possible to enforce the payment of these minimum prices to people who have fat or other cattle to sell. I have been reading the leading articles that have appeared in some newspapers since this Act came into operation. I read an article in the Irish Press the other day which rather surprised me, in which the writer proceeded to justify the increase of 2d. per lb. in the price of fresh meat to the consumer. I could understand the Editor of the Irish Press, or whoever wrote that article, arguing in justification of some increase in the price of fresh meat to the consumer if butchers had not forestalled the Act to the extent to which I know they have done. I know a butcher who is also a farmer in my constituency—I am sorry that Deputy Finlay has left the House, because he is a friend of his—and I am reliably informed that he purchased 100 fat cattle and 100 sheep before the Act came into operation.
Comment on this
I understand that the number of cattle and sheep that he purchased will enable him to carry on his trade in the town in which he is engaged as a butcher until January next. That gentleman, by his action, has saved himself the payment of £125 in levies. He bought cattle, I understand, in the local market for 14/-, 15/- and not more than 16/- per cwt. live weight. In the case of a 9 cwt. live weight beast—Deputy Bennett can correct me on this if I am wrong, though I do not think that I am——
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is the subject that the Deputy is now discussing relevant on an Estimate for export bounties?
Comment on this
The Deputy has been discussing the Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Act for some time, and should now relate his words to the question of Export Bounties.
Comment on this
I am suggesting that the bounties should not be paid in future to anybody who will ignore the terms of an Act passed by this House. I think, with all respect to the more intelligent Deputies who sit on the front Opposition bench, that this question has some bearing on the money which this House is now asked to vote.
Comment on this
The gentleman concerned saved on an average £4 10s. per head on these cattle. He saved £1 per head on the levies, making a total of £5 10s. per head on the cattle, which he bought to forestall the coming into operation of this Act. In view of that, what justification is there for increasing the price of fresh meat to the consumer by 2d. per lb.
Comment on this
I am not able to say how many he killed beforehand, but I am satisfied that he saved £4-10 per head by forestalling. He saved money on the levies, too, because he bought cattle and sheep before the Act came into operation and killed some before it came into operation.
Comment on this
I do not want public money voted by this House to be paid to a gentleman of that type. I am merely suggesting to the Minister that he should take the most drastic action possible, and I hope that Deputy Belton will agree with me now that he has come nearer to us than he was before. The Minister has been given very drastic powers under that Act, and I suggest to him that he should take every step possible to enforce the payment of minimum prices to the producers.
Comment on this
I do not know the Deputy's exact position at the moment, but I am delighted to see him coming a little bit nearer to us. Ours is the only Party in the House that he has not been associated with. So far we have not received any application from him. There are some points on which I agree with Deputy Belton, but there are more, perhaps, on which we agree to differ. The Minister has taken steps to reduce in the future the amount of bounties that will be paid out to those previously engaged in the export of our surplus live stock. The Minister has introduced and passed through the Oireachtas this Act, which will increase the demand in the home market. While on this subject, may I say, for the information of Deputy Dillon, that I am not in the least ashamed, as he apparently thinks I should be, of being associated with the Minister and with this Government in passing an Act which provides free meat for the poorest of the poor? Deputy Dillon suggested in the speech that he made here the other evening— I had not the pleasure of listening to it —that "Deputy Norton and Deputy Davin, who did not know one end of a cow from the other, were partially responsible for the brilliant scheme of giving free beef to the poor." I would be glad if Deputy Dillon would come down to my native parish——
Comment on this
——and ask the greatest Blueshirt there, if there are any Blueshirts still left, what I was engaged at in my early days, whether I did any work at all. If he does he will probably be surprised to learn that I had more to do with cows in those days than he had, and that when I was working on a farm he was outside this country in a college getting an Irish education. That is all that I have to say on that.
Comment on this
I have been waiting for Deputy Finlay to come back to the House because I am aware that he knows more about this kind of business than some of the gentlemen who are trying to interrupt me. Strange as it may appear, I am advocating, if necessary, and I believe it will be necessary, the establishment of a marketing organisation rather than the paying out of these bounties to people who will not honour the undertakings they have given to the Government. There may probably be some doubt as to the desirability of that proposition, but I was amazed to find that there is a motion on the Order Paper in the name of Deputy O'Higgins and Deputy Belton who has now left the Party. The motion to which I refer has to it the names of Deputies Patrick Belton, Thomas F. O'Higgins, Sydney B. Minch and Alfred Byrne. It proposes "that the Dáil requests the Government in order to maintain the present area under tillage and to prevent wholesale unemployment, to take immediate steps to secure a market for our 58 per cent. of surplus stall-fed cattle"—and here is the point that I want to bring out—"and failing to do so, to purchase the said cattle from the feeders at the price ruling in the British market." I am glad to see from the reading of that that I have with me the extinguished and distinguished spokesmen of the Fine Gael Party, and that in putting forward the suggestion for the establishment of a marketing organisation the Minister will have the knowledge that he will have all parties in the House backing him whenever he finds it necessary to take such action. There is the proof of it on the Order Paper.
Comment on this
I feel it necessary to say, in view especially of the criticism which has been levelled at members on this side of the House and in view, particularly, of the speech made by Deputy Dillon criticising the actions and activities of this Party, that on this question I am speaking for the Party. I want to leave no doubt in the minds of Deputies, such as Deputy Bennett, as to our attitude and support of the Government in this matter. I believe the bounties are justified, and I will challenge Deputy Bennett, in conclusion, to go down to the County Limerick and state there that he stands for the removal of the bounties from those who are engaged in the dairy farming industry at the present time. If he has the courage to do that, he can give them the alternative which he has not given to the members of this House.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin has a rather happy knack of introducing a bit of hilarity into the proceedings of this House. I do not know if that is his intention, but, however, I think it is good. He has made one statement to-day which, I am afraid, shows that the Government Party do not let him into a knowledge of all the little things which a man like him ought to be let into. For instance he has said "if we are to fight this economic war to a finish", while the Minister for Industry and Commerce——
Comment on this
Would the Deputy please quote me correctly, if he proposes to quote me—not three or four words from a sentence?
Comment on this
Deputy Davin said "if this economic war were to be fought to a finish." I want to quote against that what the Minister for Industry and Commerce stated recently at Trinity College—that the economic war was over.
Comment on this
And won! In order to divide the spoils we are here to-day to provide fresh bounties and subsidies, to fight the economic war!
Comment on this
Thanks very much. It is decent of you. The unfortunate thing about it is that not alone have they not let Deputy Davin into the know but the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Agriculture have not even let the Minister for Industry and Commerce into the know.
Comment on this
He has been kept in the dark also, because if the economic war is over, as the Minister for Industry and Commerce said, it is rather peculiar that to-day we are engaged in this motion to provide bounties and subsidies in order to fight this economic war, because that is what they are for. Before we provide bounties and subsidies it is up to us as responsible people, and as Deputies of this House, to examine the situation, firstly to find out if those bounties and subsidies are a necessity; secondly to find out—and this is the more important thing—if a solution of the present conditions and the present circumstances can be found in any alternative way. Consideration of the second really comes before the first. We must satisfy ourselves firstly that this economic war, which is the immediate cause and the only cause, I maintain, of the necessity for bounties and subsidies, is of itself a necessity, and that it cannot be ended favourably to ourselves. Are we satisfied of that? Now there are some people in this country who so far forget the responsibility of those who are opposed to them in politics that they seem to imagine there is only one thing to be done in this matter, and that is that everybody should support the Government because we are having a fight with our old enemy, England. I want to examine that question. As far as I am personally concerned, and I can speak for my colleagues here, we feel that citizenship, much less being elected a Deputy, carries not alone its privileges, but its responsibilities. We feel that we have our responsibilities in this House; that we have our responsibilities as citizens of this country, and that if anybody attempts to do anything which to our minds means the ruination of the country it is our business—even in face of unfair criticism and even though we may be a minority—to condemn it. Even though I might be a minority of one, if I felt that the Government were doing anything which to my mind would ruin the industry upon which the country was standing, it would be my business to stand up and say "You are doing wrong." That is the position.
Are we satisfied that the present conditions must continue? Are we satisfied that they cannot be ended? The Government ought to satisfy itself on that before it further attempts to bolster up the position of the farmers in this country by bounties and subsidies. What steps is the Government taking to end the economic war? Have they taken any? What steps have they taken to see that this country gets a decent quota on the British market? Have they taken any?
Have they in any other respect, dealing with any other country, treated the industries of this country in the same manner as they have treated the farming industry and the agricultural community? Take, for instance, quite a short time ago, when America went wet this country thought it was good business—and rightly so—to send across to America the secretary of one of the Departments to see that the interests of this country were properly watched with regard to the fixing of a quota for the export to America of drink and spirits. We have had quite a lot of money expended in expeditions of one kind or another to Germany. What have we done with regard to Great Britain? Have we done anything? Is it not an extraordinary thing that although in 1931, out of our total exports amounting to £37,000,000, the British market took £35,000,000 worth, yet that is the market we propose to ignore. I do not know whether Dr. O'Higgins was right when he said it was lack of courage or lack of statesmanship. I do not know what it was, but certainly there appears to me to be a wanton neglect of the interests of the main industry of this country. Even in 1933, after the economic war had continued here for about a year and a half, our total exports amounted to £19,500,000. Of that £19,500,000 Britain took £18,500,000 pounds. Somebody will reply, as the Minister did last night, "But Britain has fixed her quota. We could not get over that." Have we any evidence to show that we could not? What attempt has been made by the Government or anybody else on behalf of the agricultural community of this country to see that we got a favourable quota in the British market. It was worth an attempt in the case of America and in the case of Germany for a very small sum, and surely to goodness it is worth doing in the case of the one market which absorbed practically all our exports. It is surely worth doing there.
After all our searching for alternative markets, what do we find? In the returns for 1933 the net effect of all the searching for markets was that the purchases of countries other than Great Britain amounted to £200,014 —less than they did the year before. Considering these figures and the situation that confronts the Government, is it not time that they took stock? Does the Minister, does Deputy Davin, or anyone else think that the main industry in this or in any other country can be supported by bounties and subsidies? It cannot be done. It is absurd. Agriculture is the main industry, here, and no matter how long this goes on the main industry will determine the purchasing power of the people. There is no use in erecting factories all over the country unless we have somebody to buy the products. If the Government is convinced that we cannot get any more cattle into Great Britain than we are getting now, and if they are convinced that the economic war must continue, then I say the only logical thing to do is to drop the bounties and subsidies at once, and to bring down the standard of living here, to bring down the prices of boots and clothes and to pay labourers a wage that they will barely be able to live on, as the farming community cannot afford to pay more. You are coming to that. Every bounty and subsidy provided for the subsidisation of agriculture, unless the phase is temporary—and according to the Minister it is not—unless we are going to get back the British market, is a further load on the back of agriculture.
If the main industry in the country is the gathering of cockleshells you cannot afford to subsidise it indefinitely. A country may be likened to a man in a business which includes ten departments. The owner could well afford to make up a loss on one department out of the profits on the others, but he could not afford to subsidise the main department out of the others. That is impossible. When the Minister for Agriculture was dealing with a kindred motion, condemning the Government for neglecting to secure a quota for the export of cattle, he took very good care last night that he kept far away from this question. He did not say what the Government had done, or had tried to do; whether they failed or succeeded, or what representations they made regarding the securing of an adequate quota in the British market. Why did he not do so? Is it because it would be a humiliation for the President to have to ignore what he said on a previous occasion, that the British market, thank God, was gone? Was it to save Senator Connolly, who said it would not take long to kill the cattle trade; was is to save the Minister for Finance, who talked about traitors in this country; or was it to save the Minister for Agriculture, who stated definitely in this House on the Estimate for Agriculture last year, that he was perfectly well aware that any increased tillage meant increased live stock? The Minister repeated that statement. Were these the reasons why they did not approach the British Government? The present Government is bound by the chains that they have forged around them. They cannot do it. We have information though that certain representations were made with regard to cattle, and according to information which I received only two days ago they were successful. I put the following question to the Minister on 21st March last:—
"Míchéal O Braonáin asked the Minister for Agriculture if he is aware that exporters of cattle to British markets whose cattle have been confiscated for alleged wrongful classification, have in addition been compelled to pay the special duties on the same cattle, and if he will state what representations, if any, he has made to the British Government to have this hardship remedied.
Minister for Agriculture (Dr. Ryan): The reply to the first portion of the question is in the affirmative. Informal discussions on the subject have taken place between representatives of my Department and of the British Ministry of Agriculture. It is understood that the matter is under consideration by the British Government. I do not propose to consider what action may best be taken until the decision of that Government is announced."
I am informed—and the Minister can correct me if I am wrong—that the decision of the British Government was that they would refund and did refund to those cattle exporters the amount which they had collected by way of penal tariffs. Is that so?
Comment on this
No, they have not given a decision yet. As a matter of fact, I have been told that we may expect a decision in the near future.
Comment on this
For the Minister's information I may say that I met the gentleman who gave me the information on which I based the question at Roscommon cattle fair yesterday morning, and I asked him if there was any result. His answer was: "Yes, we have been paid back our money." So that there is evidence that satisfactory representation can be made to the British Government with regard to the cattle trade. There is evidence that it is not idle to do so. The Minister for Agriculture did one thing last night. He admitted that the Government is not able to retain in this country the £5,000,000 which they thought they would retain. Of course, at any time the idea of retaining the £5,000,000 here was idiotic. It could not be done. You could not actually retain the money and put it into circulation. Some people imagined that the retention of the money meant holding it here. That could not be so. The £5,000,000 included annuities and other items. That money was earned by Irish farmers before being paid to anyone. It was earned on the British market. As it is not being earned now it is not there. The Minister admitted that it did not really matter whether we paid the money out in cash or paid it by way of live stock.
Comment on this
The Minister has the same notions as other people. I should like to hear the views of the Minister for Finance on that—that there was no difference between the tariffs which the British put on our cattle and the tariffs put on here on coal and other commodities. The Minister for Finance endeavoured to make the case here that if the Irish people had to pay the tariffs which were imposed by the Irish Government on coal, then the British Government had to pay the tariff on our cattle. That seems quite plausible, but, is not the incidence of both tariffs absolutely different? A man who imports coal or any other British commodity pays at this side, but, in the case of our cattle, the exporter pays at the other side. Is not that what is happening?
Comment on this
That is absolutely what happens, and the Minister knows it. The exporter of the cattle, the gentleman who is named as the exporter from this country, has to pay the tariff beyond; he has to give the cheque. In the other case the gentleman from beyond sends his coal here, and the importer pays the cheque. The Minister need not try to put it across the House that there is any similarity in the two cases. Although I had a great personal regard for him, after the exhibition he gave last night I have nothing but the greatest possible contempt for the Minister for Agriculture, absolutely the greatest contempt.
Comment on this
It is really no wonder that agriculture has got to the pitiable condition in which it is with such a pitiable Minister in control. Last year this gentleman told us that he firmly believed that any extension of tillage meant an extension of live stock. On another occasion he said that anybody who declared that the Government was out to injure the live stock trade was either a fool or a knave. As was pointed out last night, he ought to have pulled up Senator Connolly who was a very serious offender in that matter. The Minister made that statement that he knew perfectly well, as well as I or other Deputies, that any extension of tillage meant an extension of live stock, and he stood up a few minutes afterwards and said that he did not think that way at all. I would like to ask the Minister what are we going to do with our produce if we have not live stock?
Comment on this
Yes, if we have no live stock. Deputy O'Reilly told us last night that Great Britain was endeavouring to feed her own population, and that eventually she would do it.
Comment on this
I would like Deputy O'Reilly and the Minister to compare the population in England and the arable land there with our population and our arable land, and see if in Great Britain they will be able to cultivate the land to such an extent that they will be in a position to feed all the people they want to feed there. Let them then consider the Irish position and observe where we are likely to be landed if we produce food off the land in this country for our population. If they investigate that matter they will find that the figures will be very staggering. There is absolutely no contradiction of this, and the Minister for Agriculture knows it as well as anybody else, that you cannot have any extended tillage in this country unless you have live stock.
Comment on this
You must have something to consume the tillage. At present we have more than we require of live stock.
Comment on this
Now, we are going to reduce that number and we have no place to put them. What about the increased tillage then?
Comment on this
Are we not importing 6,000,000 cwts. of maize at present?
Comment on this
Even so; calculate the amount of wheat and beet and put it against the live stock and you will see where you are. The Minister realises the position perfectly well.
Comment on this
I remember the Minister, when he was on this side of the House, assuring us that there was nothing to prevent prosperity in the pig trade with the exception of one thing, and that was the admission into the country of foreign bacon.
Comment on this
Have we more pigs? The test of the improvement is, are you inducing the people to feed more pigs? Are you inducing the people to produce more? That must be the fundamental basis of your policy. There is only one thing that could induce them, and that is a better price. I have never used foreign bacon; I use my own bacon, but I do not see anything wrong with the farmer who sold his excellent pig to make excellent bacon for sale on the British market, the farmer who got £5 for that pig, and who bought enough bacon, no matter where it was made so long as it was good and sound, for £4 to feed his family. There was nothing economically bad about it. What was the net effect of keeping out the foreign bacon? I am not making the case that it ought not to be kept out.
Comment on this
The Chair would be interested to know what case the Deputy is making. The subject before the House is export bounties. The Deputy referred to an alternative which might obviate the need for export bounties. He has dealt with the burden of rates and annuities, with cattle quotas—the subject of the next business on the Order Paper—and with the retention of land annuities which, if my recollection serves me aright, was discussed for a score of days in this House within the last 12 months. Now, the Deputy has proceeded to discuss an embargo on the import of bacon. It is really difficult for the Chair to know what aspect of the export bounties he is now dealing with.
Comment on this
It might be of interest to know that it was the Minister who brought in the annuities question in connection with this matter.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not perhaps realise that the House is now dealing with a Vote for export bounties and subsidies. He is replying to what the Minister said when speaking to the motion on quotas. Perhaps members of the Opposition now desire to dispose of several motions in one debate. It would seem that such is the intention.
Comment on this
I do not want in the smallest particular to go against the ruling of the Chair or infringe any of the rules of the House, but I will say that in the course of his remarks last night the Minister definitely gave us to understand that he was dealing with the two matters and it was permitted. Those were his prefacing remarks, that he was going to deal with the two matters, that is, the export bounties and the quota. When endeavouring to deal with the two matters he brought in everything, so far as I can remember, relating to agriculture.
Comment on this
The Minister spoke for exactly seven minutes and it would be difficult to discuss everything in that time.
Comment on this
I regret very much that the two matters should have been mixed up, but the Minister was the one who mixed them up; he mixed them up in his speech about quotas.
Comment on this
I may have mixed them up in my reply to Deputy Dillon.
Comment on this
He definitely stated that he was going to deal with them. As a matter of fact, the line of demarcation between the two was so slight that he could scarcely determine it.
Comment on this
I desire to be strictly in order and I do not want to follow the Minister's line of argument. Indeed, I would be sorry to follow him in some of the ramblings into which he went last night. Before we agree to a further replenishing of the war chest for the purpose of bounties and subsidies, I think we are obliged to ask the Minister for Agriculture if he is perfectly satisfied with the way in which the sums from that particular fund have been administered up to this. I remember one occasion on which a judge of the High Court commented adversely on the way in which the fund was manipulated. I think the Minister ought to tell this House what steps he has taken to correct the alleged dealings by people who hold licences and who get the bounties in the cattle trade. I think we are entitled to know that. The Minister ought to tell us how he proposes to deal with it in the future.
There is no doubt that in relation to this, as in relation to other matters which the Government is endeavouring to carry out, and which are most difficult matters, there is a tendency and an inducement, not deliberate on the part of the Government, but by the very terms of the work which is being done, to fraud by people who hold licences, and, under the new Slaughter of Animals Act, I am afraid there is a further inducement. What guarantee can the Minister give the agricultural community that, although he fixes a price of 25/- or 22/- a cwt. for the people to hold the licences, we are going to get that price? He says he is relying on the honesty of the farmers. I met a man in Dublin this day week who was in the cattle market and who, to the best of my belief, is a supporter of the Minister. He told me that he had a certain number of cattle at the Dublin Market. They were good cattle but they were not first-class cattle. We discussed the price of 25/- and he told me honestly that if he got a man to take them off his hands, it would not be 25/- a cwt. he would be looking for. I am not blaming the Minister for that; I am not blaming anybody, as a matter of fact, but I believe that behind all that there is any amount of fraud being perpetrated and that the thing itself lends itself to it.
Before we agree to this money being voted, I think we are entitled to know from the Minister what steps he proposes to take to tighten up the machinery which he has to deal with this. I should like to say that, so far as I am personally concerned, I have no faith whatever in bounties and subsidies as a cure for our ills at the present time. As I said a while ago, there is only one alternative, one sensible alternative, to the present position. If we cannot get our cattle on the British market, and if we have no other market, drop the bounties and subsidies and come down to hard facts, to which you will have to come in a year or two and come down to a standard of living we can afford. You may keep it up as long as you can, as long as you have money to do it, but if we are going to do what the Minister for Finance threatened in his Budget speech before last, but which he did not carry out because it was impossible—to borrow on the asset created by our retained annuities for the purpose of providing bounties and subsidies—we are simply mortgaging the future of agriculture in this country, if agriculture is our main industry and the Minister says it is and I say it is. We are all agreed on that and the Minister ought to get it into his head, once and for all, that subsidies for wheat and subsidies for beef, bounties for cattle and for sheep and all the rest of it cannot by any manner of means, or by any stretch of imagination, put agriculture on its feet or into the position in which it will be able to determine, which it must eventually determine, the purchasing power of the people. It cannot be done. We may, of course, continue for some time borrowing upon the resources of the country. The Minister for Industry and Commerce tells us now—a great change, of course, since he was on these benches— that the adverse balance does not count and that it is really of no importance in this country. We may borrow for bounties and subsidies but all our borrowing is adding a further burden to this country and the sooner we realise that the better.
The Minister said last night that the country is behind Fianna Fáil in this policy. I do not like to say what I really believe about all that. It was natural, of course, that the people of a country like ours, who had been so long fighting for freedom in one form or another, should be carried away by the cry of war and by the glory of war. The President, being a good psychologist, knew where to strike and he struck, and I tell the Minister for Agriculture and I tell the President that there are plenty men down the country who are supporting him in his war with our old enemy England on the cry: "England must be fought; there is a war on." That is the cry, and that is what got the people, but they are not behind the Government's agricultural policy and they do not believe a bit of it except that the glory of fighting a war must be secured. I say that somebody will have to answer for this some time.
I do not think there is very much more I have to say except to state that, so far as I am concerned, I am prepared to give any assistance—and so are all the people on these benches —to any aids that agriculture needs or any other industries in this country may need. There is no use in the Minister or anyone else saying that we are endeavouring to sabotage the industries of this country. They know that that is all nonsense. We ought to recognise that we are all citizens of this country and that we are all endeavouring to do our best for it so far as we can. If a genuine mistake is being made and if somebody endeavours to point it out it is quite all right and, not alone that, it is their business to do so. Because we endeavour to point out, as we believe firmly, that the present policy of the Government is absolutely ruining this country, we are told that we are West Britishers; we are Englishmen and we are everything but Irishmen. We ought to get away from that, and we ought to get down to hard facts and stare the situation in the face, and the Government should not say that we cannot get any more cattle on the British market until they are able to show us that they have made some effort to get more cattle on the British market. I hope that when the Minister comes to reply he will at least be able to give this House some assurance that with regard to bounties and subsidies there will be no need for people to be afraid of fraud. I do not know that he can do it. His own personal ability may, perhaps, be very good, but I do not think that the Act or the whole system is such as to lend itself to any kind of administrative effort without a lot of difficulty and I do not think it can be carried through without a lot of fraud.
Comment on this
My contribution to this very interesting discussion will be very brief indeed. We used to hear in the old times that the three great crimes in this country were: killing a man, robbing a church, or stealing a cow. It seems to me that at the present time the sacrifice of a cow is considered a very trifling and negligible affair. Yet the cow is the most useful of animals. It supplies us not only with milk, cheese, beef and butter, but even with the very comb with which Deputy Davin trims his hair every morning. Unquestionably, the cow has been, from the earliest ages, a most important asset to the human race; and it has always played a very important part in the history of Ireland. I need not go back and tell you of the veneration in which it was held in India, Egypt and other countries. I am sure you all know that one of the greatest Nabobs of Hindustan is the Gwaekar of Baroda, and Gwaekar means cow-keeper. The Italians who built on the yellow Tiber the eternal city of Rome were so called because they were calf or cow-men. To come down to our own times.
Comment on this
I am coming to the Vote. I want to show the importance of the cow and of the cattle trade to this country.
Comment on this
That is my intention— and how it may be affected by the question of bounties which is under consideration at the present moment.
Comment on this
Or should be. I really think that my remarks so far have been perfectly relevant. To come down to our own times, even the very name of his Excellency the Governor-General means a cow-boy. I was simply quoting these remarks and will not go any further with them. I could speak for hours on them, if the House were anxious to hear, without coming to the real object of the few words which I intend to say.
There are certain matters in reference to which undoubtedly bounties and subsidies are necessary, legitimate, and useful, but I do think, and I am sure the majority of the members of this House realise, that in the case of the staple and key industry of this country they are a confession of failure. I would ask the Minister for Agriculture, in all sincerity and in no partisan spirit, what is the meaning and object of these bounties? Is the object to retain or maintain our hold on a market which we have been assured is gone, and which we have been told is dead and damned and thank God for it? There can be no other object. If the Minister for Agriculture were called in in the morning and found a man suffering from a bad pain which had probably been brought on by himself, I have no doubt that the first thing he would do would be to give him an injection of morphia or some other palliative. The same applies to bounties. Bounties simply relieve the symptoms. They put off the evil day; but they do not get down to the rock-bottom, and they do not effect a radical cure. That is, I am sure, evident to every thinking and sensible man in this House. Any country cannot long survive on bounties, doles or subsidies, free beef, free milk, or anything else of that description; and the sooner the Government, or any Government that may be in power, realise that fact the better it will be for this country and for its future.
There is, in my humble opinion, one and only one cure, and that is the settlement of the economic war, or the so-called economic war. I believe that it can be settled by peaceful negotiations and without any sacrifice of principle or compromise of national dignity or national honour; that peace would be the result of a real conference at which the people would gather round a conference table with a real will to peace. Nations as well as individuals are bound to forgive; it is a Christian duty to do so. It will make for the welfare and advancement and progress of this country to have it done and done immediately. By the map of the world, and by the decree of Almighty God himself, England and Ireland are next-door neighbours. We carry on, or have carried on, extensive dealings with each other; and it will pay both, and it will be honourable and an advantage to both to come to a settlement that would reflect honour on the good sense and patriotism of both countries.
I am not going to continue any longer; I have trespassed too much on your time and patience; but I do say in conclusion that the attitude of the present Government reminds me of a fellow who meets another in the street and, whatever he means it or not, gives him a clout in the eye. That is what the Government has done to the farmers of this country. They may not have meant to do it; I am not charging them with any mala fides whatever. They may have done it in what they conceive to be the very best interests of the country. But, having given the farmers a clout in the eye, they get the Minister for Agriculture, as a medical practitioner, to give them a soothing plaster and some French powder as a palliative; something to soothe the pain they are suffering from as a result of the attitude of the Government. I hope an end will be put to that state of affairs. I appeal to the Minister for Agriculture and the Executive Council, in no spirit of partisanship, bias, or prejudice, but as Irishmen and Irish citizens and as people who, I am sure, are as much interested in the welfare of the country as I am.
Comment on this
I only intervene for a moment to ask for more definite information than seems to have been forthcoming from the Opposition during the last hour or so. The last speaker, for instance, finds fault with the whole question of the bounties: and Deputy Brennan gave the impression that he has a very strong objection to subsidies as well as bounties. I would like if some speaker would try to reconcile that attitude with the Motion down on the Order Paper in the names of two Opposition Deputies:—
That the Dáil is of opinion that owing to the increasing distress of the farming community arising out of the continuance of the economic war, the Executive Council should take steps to relieve agricultural land of rates during the financial year 1934/ 35.—Thomas O'Higgins and T.J. O'Donovan.
I wonder if both these things are genuine? I wonder if the attitude of Deputies Burke and Brennan on the bounty question can be reconciled with the attitude of Deputy O'Higgins and Deputy O'Donovan, whose names are on this motion? If both are seriously meant, how is one to reconcile them? In one case there is an objection to Government assistance and in the other case there is a demand for Government assistance! In one case there is an objection to receiving a bounty, which means an increased price for agricultural exports, and on the other side we have a demand that owing to the distress that prevails amongst the farming community the farmers should be relieved of the ordinary liability to pay their rates! It does not look as if these two things could sleep in the same bed. I listened very carefully to Deputy Brennan's speech. That speech was apparently very carefully prepared and was very admirably uttered. But to my mind the Deputy is very much astray with regard to the whole position in this country, and he is very much astray with regard to what is likely to prevail in the future. The Deputy wants the Government to consider and take immediate action on this line—that if we cannot find an opening in the British market for the whole of our surplus agricultural produce, we should cease to give bounties or subsidies and take steps to reduce the standard of living in the country.
That is surely a counsel of despair. But is it a reasonable counsel? Is it not likely that, even if the economic war were favourably settled tomorrow, there would be for a period, and probably for a prolonged period, a surplus of some particular item of agricultural produce that would have to be exported? We cannot make a price for our surplus agricultural produce. The question before the country would be—would the country abandon the production of a surplus? Or would it not be the duty of the Government to ask the population generally to give some help towards making the production of that surplus a paying proposition? There is nothing inherently unreasonable in offering a bounty on surplus agricultural productions. In my opinion, it would be very much to the advantage of the country, rather than have a number of people entirely unemployed, that they should be producing a thing which they might not be able to market in this country but for which there might be a market abroad under certain conditions—say, at a low price. Surely anybody with responsibility for the population as a whole could not find fault with the proposition that items of agricultural surplus should be subsidised, under these conditions, so far as it is expedient.
It is quite easy to arrange between the different sections of the population with regard to the price at which goods which are intended for the home market should be sold. But when it comes to the items for export I cannot see anything unreasonable in saying that a subsidy should be given if ther is a net advantage thereby. It is the most natural thing in the world. I wish there were other things which we should produce in this country at a reasonable cost and which could be exported under a subsidy. It would be a very much better thing to have resources of that kind rather than to be paying out the sums that are being paid in unemployment assistance and from which no returns come. The Deputy who dreams that we will have in the near future a Government in power that will not find it necessary to take steps of that kind is living in a fool's paradise. I take the item mentioned by Deputy O'Neill on yesterday for which he asked for a subsidy—shell-fish. Will Deputy O'Neill say that shell-fish would be a paying proposition apart from the economic war? Shell-fish is an article for which a subsidy should always have been given if the people engaged in that industry were to enjoy a living wage. I do not think that Deputy O'Neill would hold that the people engaged in the shell-fish industry were ever given as reasonable return. Similarly as regards any items of agricultural or industrial production, the time may come when we will have to decide between the closing down of such an industry and asking the population generally to come to its help. It seems to me that, so far as the theoretical arguments advanced here against bounties and subsidies on exportable surplus goods are concerned, these are unconvincing arguments.
Deputy Brennan, in order to support his argument against bounties and subsidies referred sneeringly to guaranteed prices and subsidies for wheat. Deputy Brennan did not explain why it is reasonable for a manufacturer to sell his goods at a price fixed by him—a price which gives him a fair margin of profit—and why it is unreasonable for the State to intervene with regard to wheat to ensure a suitable price in order that the farmer may get the cost of production? Surely if the Deputy were going to dethrone the whole business of subsidies for beet and wheat and so on, and the whole idea of guaranteed prices, he might have gone further and tried to convince us where it is wrong. To very many people in the world at the present time subsidies are simply the obvious things. It seems to them right and proper that the main producers of the country—the people who are producing things that are most required by the general population—should be guaranteed a price, and that the State should see that they get that price. I did not hear any speeches other than the speeches of Deputies Brennan and Burke. So far as my poor judgment goes, I am satisfied that these two Deputies, at all events, have not made a case for the rejection of this Estimate, but that, in fact, the bulk of Deputy Brennan's remarks were an absolute justification of export bounties and subsidies, and were really support for the Government in this matter.
Comment on this
I cannot understand why any Deputy in this House, especially farmer Deputies, should have any opposition to this Estimate. If it comes to an actual reconsideration of the question I hope the Minister for Agriculture will increase the Estimate to a far greater figure than that at which it stands. A great deal has been said about the bounties which have been paid to the farmers for the past few years. A great deal was said about the grievances which the farmers of this country had when they sold their cattle to buyers in the fairs and markets. It was said that not one penny of the bounty which was paid by the Government ever came near the pockets of the farming community. Deputy Burke has spoken about the sacred cow. Everybody knows that the cow and calf were always the mainstay of the farmers of this country. When two big political parties get hold of that cow, when the Fianna Fáil Party get hold of her horns, and the United Ireland Party get hold of her tail, they dismember her in a very short time, and leave the Centre Party looking on in utter helplessness. We cannot go to the farming community's rescue.
I am going to support and vote for this Estimate. In doing so. I may say that the Minister for Agriculture is doing a great deal to assist the farming community to go through the trying times in which they find themselves just now. We had a subsidy of 5/3 a barrel for wheat last year. I grew nine acres of wheat last year and it was a profitable crop. It returned nine barrels to the statute acre and I sold the wheat for 18/- a barrel. I am now waiting for my bounty from the Minister. I also grew beet, and that has to be sent on to the Mallow beet factory. By extra tillage I was able to employ extra labour. As regards the tillage policy of the Minister, farmers who are in strict opposition to the Government at present have shown a considerable number of acres of wheat during the past couple of months and they are going to increase appreciably the area under wheat and barley. It may be said that the Government find it difficult to obtain an alternative market for our surplus cattle. There is an alternative market to be found, and that alternative market is here at home. If the Government would give full de-rating in respect of agricultural land, it would enable the farmers to kill and consume some of the surplus stock which they are trying to export to England. There is no doubt that the farmers of this country are badly hit at present. They have a very poor market for their cattle. They get a very poor price from the co-operative creameries for their milk. Deputy Davin said that, were it not for the subsidy given by the Government to the dairying industry, milk would be selling at 2d. a gallon. He may be right in that, but is 4d. a gallon an economic price for milk supplied to the co-operative creameries, when the farmer has to employ labour to milk the cows and to send the milk to the creameries, considering that the consumers in the towns and cities are paying up to 2/- a gallon? I think that it is time for the Prices Tribunal to examine the whole of this profiteering business.
As regards the economic war, I believe that, were it not for the action of the two big parties, it would have been settled long ago and the farmer would not be looking for subsidies or bounties. This country is torn to pieces by political intriguers and it is not for love of the people that these spouters, politicians and orators are going around the country. Nor is it for love of country or for the welfare of the farmers that they are keeping on the dispute when they ought to be united as one man and put forward a united demand for our just and lawful rights which, I think, we are bound to get from Britain. We were paying £5,000,000 a year to the British Government. Will that have to be handed down to generations yet unborn? Are we to place a millstone around the necks of future generations? This economic war could be settled if the two big parties would come together, as they will have to come together sooner or later to find a solution and present a united demand to the British Government. Everybody in this country must remember that the soil of Ireland belongs to the Irish people "without rent or render, faith or fealty to any foreign power under heaven." If we had our just rights, for which we fought for several generations, there would be no need for the Minister to bring in a Supplementary Estimate of £763,000 for subsidies and bounties to enable the farming community to eke out an existence. I hope that, in the very near future, these bounties and subsidies will cease and that the farmers will get an opportunity to work out their own salvation, to earn a decent livelihood and be put in a position to pay a decent wage to their workmen. Then there will be no necessity for any further bounties. So long as the present state of affairs continues, I see little hope for the farming community or for the building up of industries. I see little hope for the future so long as we have the Dublin politicians engaged in mud-slinging and abuse on every occasion degrading and disgracing the Irish people. I hope that, in the near future, there will be an end to all the abominable nonsense that is going on at present.
Comment on this
I find it difficult to say whether I agree or disagree with the last speaker in his attitude towards these bounties. I certainly agree with him that the necessity for these bounties arises from the economic war and that, were it not for the political policy of the Government, there would be no need for these Supplementary Estimates, because it would not then be impossible for the Government to know where they were at the beginning of the year in reference to such important items of expenditure as this item. When the Deputy speaks in favour of the bounty system, and, in the next sentence, declares that the main grievance of the farmers is that not one penny of the bounties goes into the producers' pockets, it is obvious—apart altogether from the economic war—that that is a rather severe indictment of the bounty system. I know that the Minister for Agriculture takes up the attitude that there is nothing in that charge. But the charge is made by more than the Minister's political opponents. I do not know, at the moment, whether or not I can number Deputy Kent amongst the Minister's political opponents. However, I think that any appointed public body in Kerry can be described as being wholeheartedly Fianna Fáil. Yet, in the newspaper of yesterday or the day before, I found the following:
"Kerry County Committee of Agriculture called upon the Government to reconsider the whole question of bounties with a view to ensuring that the producers get the benefits. Mr. Hegarty said that, undoubtedly, the farmer did not get the benefits."
Therein he agrees with Deputy Kent, so that even those loyal bodies can see the futility of the present Government policy, if they have a policy. I always confessed a certain amount of sympathy with the Minister for Agriculture, because I believe he is not allowed to have a policy for agriculture. In certain matters he has—the growing of wheat, the subsidising of wheat—that is the Minister's policy, and he believes in it. But when it comes to agriculture as a whole, I do not believe he is allowed to have a policy. Otherwise, I find it impossible to understand how, when it comes to a question of the general Estimates and Supplementary Estimates, he enunciates, at different dates, entirely conflicting policies. Listening to the Minister in the summer of 1933 we might consider that we knew where we were; and listening to him later, in March, 1934, and not remembering what we heard in the summer of 1933, we might still think that we knew where we were. If we listened to him yesterday we, and all those people in the country interested, would certainly find it difficult to know where we were as regards agriculture. The House is not so short in its memory as not to remember the solemn statement of the Minister in the summer of 1933, when he twitted members of the Opposition on not seeing what he said was patent to everybody. According to the Minister, in 1933, what was patent to everybody was that his policy then, and previously, had been more tillage, and, therefore, more cattle. Yet some nine months afterwards he told the same House, speaking from the same bench, that the policy of the Government was more tillage, less cattle. From the report of the newspapers to-day I gather that his latest policy is, "let the farmers produce as good cattle, and as many cattle as they can sell." I believe that the policy of July, 1933, is what the Minister really believes in, because he admitted the force of the argument that more tillage inevitably meant more cattle. He admitted that that particular argument was insuperable. How then his policy of last March is to be brought into conformity with his policy of more tillage, more cattle, is more than I can make out.
It must be remembered this is the same Government which asks for these bounties in order to enable us to keep our hold on the British market, but that at the beginning of the year indulged—I think that is the proper word to us—in a policy of calf slaughter in order to ensure that in the future we would not have that exportable surplus which cannot now be exported at a profit owing to the economic war. What is the Minister's policy? I have my own views as to the policy of the Government in regard to the agricultural industry, and so far as it is concerned. Most of us complain that the Government have no policy. As I say, I do not blame the Minister for that. I sympathise with the Minister, because, in these matters, I believe he is not allowed to have a policy. He thinks it a sound agricultural policy for this nation that the more cattle they were able to export the better, because he admitted that in the summer of 1933; but he is not allowed to have that policy. That sound policy, from his point of view, was sacrificed in order to win the economic war at any cost. That is the reason of all the chopping and changing and the killing of calves; that is the reason of the obvious inconsistency and incoherence in the actual agricultural policy outlined by the Minister. I do not think that the Government of which he is a member is capable of framing any sane agricultural policy at the moment. Anything that the Government has done in that respect in the last 18 months, apart from what I might call its sheet-anchor, such as the growing of wheat, so far as existing agricultural economy is concerned, has been done as a hasty expedient, not as an assistance for agriculture, but to hide, for the moment, the disastrous effect of its general policy. That general policy is making impossible, not merely an economic policy as a whole, but is certainly making impossible any consistent policy on the part of the Minister for Agriculture. It practically means that no man in the position of the Minister can frame any same economic policy.
In his capacity as Minister for Agriculture he must believe in what he proclaimed in the summer of 1933—more wheat and root crops, therefore more cattle, and the more cattle the more wide the markets necessary. But that is cut across by an entirely different set of considerations. There is the policy of winning the economic war, which, in the minds of every member of the Party opposite, from the President downwards, means we must get rid of the cattle trade at any cost. That policy was enunciated by the President as far back as 1927. It was reiterated by him and his colleagues when they rejoiced in the destruction of our foreign trade. They rejoice in the destruction of our foreign trade, while, at the same time, they are paying bounties in the hope of holding that trade. Why these increased Estimates? In order that we may get into markets that we believe to be worthless. We are spending millions in order to keep our hold on markets which we are told are worthless. Why should we continue to spend money to get into these markets when we are told that those markets are gone? What is the real view of the Government? Is it that the English market is gone, and gone for ever, and, thank God, that it is gone for ever; or is the real voice and policy of the Government, what one would imagine would be the policy behind a system of export bounties—to get into that market and no other market? How is it, if that market has gone—how, even if it is disappearing as a commercial asset—that the other Dominions are able to increase their imports very substantially, as they have increased them in the last three or four years to the extent that we have lost? How is it that they have been able to increase their exports to that market that is gone, or, if not gone, that we are told is going? The thing does not bear examination. Either you have belief in the particular policy that the English market has gone and that we cannot get it back, or else you believe the policy that we must pay, as we are paying indirectly, the land annuities in order to keep our hold on that market.
I understand that yesterday the Minister referred to the wisdom of certain bacon producers in this country in refusing to sell at a satisfactory price here in order to keep their hold on that market—that market which has gone and for which a bounty is now given in order to enable them to keep their hold on it. Is the policy of the Government more tillage, less cattle; or more tillage, more cattle? Is the policy: Keep out of the English market which has gone, or keep in the English market and pay very heavily for it? Remember—and Ministers were particularly alive to this particular argument before they became Ministers—remember that, when you have bounties of this kind got out of the public purse, it is the producer that will pay in the end. Here, still, the farming community is the producer. We may wish to change that. We cannot do it in five or ten years to any appreciable extent. Farming, unless we go into bankruptcy, must continue to be the main producing factor in this country. That being so, the Minister's own doctrine should have told him that if we come to the assistance of the farmers by means of bounties, it is the producer that will pay in the long run—in other words, the farmers will pay it themselves. And all for what? To get into a market that we are kept out of on account of the economic war.
Let us leave aside who is responsible for that war. It is none the less obvious that no effort is being made to settle it, and the country pays for that. The Government goes from expedient to expedient and the farmer is, more or less, like the camel, living on himself. He is eating up the resources he had put aside. When I say the farmer, I mean not merely the big farmer but the small farmer, if by him you mean the farmer with 30 or 40 or even 10 acres. The small farmers are hit as hard as the big farmer. Deputy Moore spoke of a certain inconsistency. He must know that there are complaints, and complaints not confined, as I have already pointed out, to the opponents of the Government, not confined to the neutral Party——
Comment on this
Well, the Centre Party, as Deputy Kent called it. Deputy Moore must know, as I was saying, that there are complaints that these bounties do not accrue to the advantage of the producer. Take the question of relieving rates. The farmer gets the direct benefit there and it is idle to say that that is not a heavy charge. Within the last couple of weeks I have met a couple of farmers whose rates in Kerry formerly, under the Commissioners, were between £15 and £16, but which have now gone up to between £30 and £40. That relief, surely, would be direct benefit to the producer. Are the Government serious—or is the President, as the only director in the last resort and every resort of the policy of the Government—are they serious in maintaining that the English market is not worth holding and that it has gone? What other market are you going to get? It is obvious—these very bounties are a confession of it— that there is no other market, and it is equally obvious from the trade returns for every month that there is no other market. These bounties are being used—must be used—to get us into the one market and into that market only. Look at the trade returns for the month of October and see our trade with other countries. What do our exports to other countries amount to? They amount to a few thousands in comparison to our exports to Great Britain.
We have some countries, I admit, where there is an increase of exports and imports. For instance, let me take the case of Russia. I will admit that our import trade from Russia increased from £14,000 in October, 1932, to £53,000 in October, 1933, and to £80,000 in October, 1934. I will admit, further, that our export trade with Russia increased also. It increased even four times—from £1 to £4. Surely it is not the serious policy of the Government any longer, whatever they may have said at election times about alternative markets, to hope to secure alternative markets! These very bounties show that they have no hope of any alternative market, and we know perfectly well that there is no alternative market. The trade returns, published every month, show that not merely has no alternative market been achieved, but that there is none in the offing. And remember, it is a long time ago, at least it is a long time as the minds of Ministers work—it is a long time ago comparatively since the Minister told us he had got these alternative markets. I think that was in the June of 1933; but when he was asked what these alternative markets were, modesty overcame him and he refused to reveal them. He would not reveal them to the Opposition, because the Opposition might crab them! He was challenged to mention where the markets were. He would not tell the Opposition, because they might sabotage the markets! The farmer has waited, and the exporter has waited the 18 months between that time and this, and the export returns issued every month fail to reveal any such alternative markets. The returns show very often an increase in our imports from other countries besides Great Britain, but they show no increase worth speaking of in exports to them.
Now, what is the purpose of it all? These bounties help to pay the land annuities. Indirectly, they help the farmer of this country to pay to Great Britain the land annuities. Therefore, although the economic war is taking place on account of the land annuities, the land annuities are being paid with the help of these bounties and the tariffs that are being imposed by Great Britain. Remember, it is not the game of the Irish farmer that is being played by this Government. The game that is being played by this Government is the game of the English farmer, or at least of a small set of English farmers. It is to their interest, as was pointed out on one occasion by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and again and again by other speakers—it is to the interest of a certain number of English farmers to keep Irish cattle out of England.
The Ministers have helped them, and we have played their game for them. The Government has played their game for them, so that they are consolidating their position. So far as the cattle we are exporting are concerned, we are helping them to build up their herds and make them more independent than they are at present of Irish cattle. That is not playing the game of the farmers of this country. It is playing the game of the English farmers or a certain knot of the English farmers, at all events. This question of bounties is merely an attempt not to deal with the position. It does not get to the root of the situation. It is merely an attempt, together with other measures of the Government, to prevent the wound smarting for the time being. That is all, practically, it comes to. It is not dealing with the real evil that is making the position of any farmer in this country intolerable, so far as he is a farmer. Agriculture has ceased to be an economic proposition. No farmer, great or small, of five acres, ten acres or 50 acres, can live at present if he confines himself to his farm. He has to seek help elsewhere. He has to get work on the roads or on something else to keep him going. His farm no longer supports him. Road work and all that may be extremely useful, but in the ordinary sense it is not productive. We are losing our trade, losing it not merely steadily but quickly, and the unfortunate farmer in the long run will have to pay these subsidies himself, while the taxes to meet them need not have been imposed were it not for the policy of the Government.
At the present moment the farm of a man holding 30 or 40 acres cannot pay. He cannot make it pay. That is the situation that confronts him this year, as far as he can see, as long as the Government continues this policy. Unless there is a very radical change in the policy of the Government, that is going to be his situation next year, and for some years to come. It is not merely that he is ruined or that his farming is uneconomic for him at the present day. He might be able to tolerate that and to meet extra expenses out of any sum he has been able to put aside, if he has been fortunate enough to have put something aside out of more fruitful years, if there was any prospect of improvement, but his prospect for the coming years has driven him into a position of despair. To meet him, and to cope with that particular frame of mind into which he cannot help getting, you have nothing except contradictory statements and continued somersaults on the part of the Government as regards the main industry of the country. One policy in June, 1933, or in the summer of that year, quite definite; another policy in March, 1934, equally definite but absolutely contradictory of the policy of June, 1933, and then the policy of yesterday that nobody can understand. Unless the real situation is faced, there is no prospect for the farmer of this country and that, Deputies of all parties had better see and face squarely.
Comment on this
When one finds a substantial farmer like Deputy Professor O'Sullivan so enthusiastic about the subject of agriculture it gives one great courage here and it should be a source of great encouragement to the Minister. The Minister appears to have done one thing anyway and that is to make agriculture a very interesting subject, even for a University Professor. But even as a University Professor, speaking of agriculture in the role of a Deputy, one would think that he would take some kind of trouble to make some little suggestion upon which the dummy of a Minister for Agriculture—to use the words of another statesman on the Opposition Benches, Deputy Dillon—might be able to go on. Having listened to Deputy Professor O'Sullivan I have been trying to make up my mind whether at one moment he was speaking as a farmer, substantial or otherwise, another moment as a University Professor, another moment as a Deputy or another moment as a private individual. However, I thought he might, even by accident, let slip some sort of suggestion by which the dummy Minister for Agriculture might find some way out of the present crisis, but he was just as futile as some other speakers on the subject from the Opposition Benches, although I think he is just as qualified for the position of shadow Minister as any other speaker who appears to have spoken with that end in view.
We are handicapped here at the moment in that the Party who are criticising our policy have no leader who could outline a policy. They have four big men, four leaders, with no policy or four different policies but they have no shadow Minister for Agriculture, unless we are to regard Deputy Professor O'Sullivan as shadow Minister and, to my mind, he would be more a blot, speaking physically, than a shadow in that respect. I think it is rather hard on the Minister for Agriculture, if we are in such an apparently hopeless position, that the Opposition would not be able even as a result of our huge failure from that particular point of view, to formulate some kind of policy. Even if they had not our huge failure for the past two years to go on, they had ten years of office themselves and might they not try to attempt to formulate the policy they had during these ten years or the policy they wished they had tried during the ten years they were in office? It is a hopeless mess both for the Government and the Opposition— the position of this Opposition.
Deputy Bennett, who is an experienced agriculturist, stated that this question of the cause of economic depression here, should and could be easily removed. He did not tell us how it could be done. He did not know himself apparently. The cause of agricultural depression is a very serious thing, and if it is so apparent as they appear to think it is, why not tell us about it? Why not expound it here and, if it is too precious a policy to be discussed across the floor, why not ask to meet the Minister for Agriculture in private and tell him the wonderful plan they have for building up agriculture? On their statements their policy as far as the present Government is concerned is a policy of non-co-operation. It was stated months ago that their policy was absolutely one of non-co-operation. They have since that expounded that policy. It was first expounded by Deputy Dillon in my own constituency and they have carried it out to the letter. They have carried it so far that their supporters now are able to go out and smash the country in every possible way they can and hold, at their private meetings, that they are carrying out the policy of non-co-operation enunciated by their leaders. Their leaders, because they have tied their hands with these statements, have been forced to remain silent when they might otherwise condemn such action of smashing up the country.
Deputy Professor O'Sullivan appears to have a very long memory as far as thinking of things that were said or supposed to have been said by the Minister for Agriculture or the President is concerned. Sometimes a long memory is a blessing and sometimes it is a very great cause of worry and trouble to the people gifted with that long memory. I think if there is anything that some members of the Opposition might try to get away from it is the long memory that they appear to have, because if they continue to cultivate it it will bring them back to the time when they put into operation a certain policy that was absolutely turned down by the people.
We have heard many speeches from the Opposition condemning the policy of the Minister for Agriculture, referring to the ruination that this Government have brought on the country, how the Irish farmers have been destroyed and so on, and yet it is strange that we heard no challenge from them to go to the farmers and go to the country. It used to be a great gag with the Opposition: "Go down to the country, go down to the people; we insist that you face the people." In spite of all the condemnation that we have heard from them of the policy of the Minister for Agriculture, they have not issued the challenge: "Go to the people." I think they are wise in that respect. They would be wiser still if they realised that, when in the recent past the Government did go to the people, when the question of bounties and subsidies, the agricultural policy of the Government, the economic war and all the rest of it had all been thrashed out here for almost a year—when all these questions had been explained to the people—the Opposition Party was absolutely wiped off the map. Surely that ought to be sufficient lesson for them. It is no consolation for the country to learn that the Opposition, having been wiped off the map by the people, should begin to destroy themselves under the pretence that it was they themselves were the cause of the whole mistake or that it was their leader or their shadow Minister for Agriculture ruined them at the last election. It is no consolation for the country to be told that only for these two they would have got back. Having listened to the Opposition for some time I am encouraged more than ever to feel certain that the policy of the Government and of the Minister for Agriculture is absolutely right.
There is no challenge now from the Opposition about going back to the people. We hear them talk about the English market being gone, thank God. We can thank God that there will be no going back on the old policy that was in force in this country in their time. There has been a complete change in our economic policy, and I am disposed to believe that there are members of the Opposition who are just as thankful for that as we are. If they got back to office again I believe many of them would be just as enthusiastic in pursuing that policy as we are. One of their leaders, Deputy Bennett, stated in Limerick some time ago that they were in a political fight; that no matter what policy the Government adopts, be it good or bad, they had got to be against it because their hands were tied in a political fight. They are not out for the good of the country. They are in a political fight, as they say themselves, and their whole policy is to destroy the Government even though in doing so they destroy the people.
The question of the bounties is an important one. I believe myself that there are many matters in connection with it that could be better regulated. I think that if we had a helpful Opposition, with a national outlook and policy, that we could, having accepted the economic policy of this Government, as the Irish people have accepted it, make very rapid strides forward. I do not agree with the view expressed to-day by Deputy Brennan. He said that if only in a minority of one he is entitled to continue to obstruct the policy of the Government. I always thought it was the policy of the Opposition that majority rule should be accepted. Since the vast majority of the people of this country have accepted the policy, agricultural and otherwise, of this Government, I think the Opposition, as a minority, and a vast dwindling minority, should agree to that policy. They might criticise it, but they should not obstruct its being put into operation. I think if we had a nationally-minded Opposition that, with their co-operation and our work as a Government Party, this bounty question could be regulated in a more satisfactory manner. It has not been satisfactory and even the Minister for Agriculture has stated that at times. I have the greatest sympathy with the Department of Agriculture. The Minister and his officials have had to tackle one of the biggest problems which this country has ever had to face. It was preceded by a struggle that politically brought about great changes in the whole economic situation. The people had to be gradually accustomed to these changes. In view of all that it was impossible to have a perfect bounty system from the start. What I am convinced of is that this bounty system could have been better regulated and have been much more satisfactory to producers if we had got decent co-operation from the Opposition.
I do not deny that many farmers are in a precarious position, particularly those who are supporters of the Party opposite. I know quite a number of farmers, political supporters of theirs in the County Mayo who, in this present month, would be awaiting a cheque of from £17 to £22 from the beet factory in Tuam were it not for the fact that they acted on the instructions they received from their leaders. They prevented these farmers from growing beet, not because the price that was offered was uneconomic but because it was a Government scheme. They also prevented these farmers from growing wheat and barley for the same reason: not because the price offered was uneconomic but because these were Government schemes. I know many farmers in Mayo, supporters of theirs, who are very sorry men to-day because they accepted the advice that was given to them by their political leaders and did not grow beet, wheat or barley. I had a meeting in part of my constituency and I encouraged these men to grow beet. I got the names of over 60 men who were prepared to do so. Some nights afterwards their local political leader from Kiltimagh held a meeting and he got these men, who are members of the Fine Gael, or whatever they call it now, to withdraw from the scheme. These men are grousing and grumbling to-day, not against the Government but against the political leaders who misled them.
Comment on this
Personally I am opposed to bounties. There is an amendment on the Order Paper to the effect that this Estimate be referred back for consideration. I hold an open mind in this matter so far, and if it goes to a division, I have not made up my mind as to what way I will vote.
Comment on this
I have consulted my Party. I should like if Deputies here would consult their intelligence, if they have any. I should like to hear reasons advanced as to why this Vote should be referred back. I have not heard any. The whole gamut of the agricultural policy has been traversed, and the whole cause and effect of the economic war have again been discussed here. I think the Government have laid a snare in which some people have been caught; whenever any matter of a particular nature is raised here, useful criticism of it is lost by bringing too many matters under discussion. We have a situation here produced by the economic war. I am opposed to the economic war. I have given as much effort in opposing it on political platforms as anyone, but I admit the contention made here that in at least two successful elections the country has voted for the economic war. I would vote against it to-morrow if it were a political contest, but here we are not engaged in politics. We are engaged in administration and law making, and in working the country in the political situation in which we find it.
I should be less surprised if an amendment were introduced that the bounty instead of being increased by £763,000 should be increased by £1,500,000. In considering this matter we should confine our attention to the object of the bounties. Wheat, beet, peat and the agricultural policy generally have, in my opinion, no relation whatever to the subject of bounties. When an ordinary agricultural Vote is on, a Deputy is entitled to criticise and justified in criticising the agricultural policy, but in the matter of bounties, as I understand them, they are given for one reason, and one reason alone. I am inclined to agree with the last speaker, Deputy Cleary, that the bounty system has not been handled properly. I suppose it is a matter on which opinions can be given here. Are there alternative ways of meeting and easing the situation other than by bounty-feeding exports? In my opinion and, as I view the situation, bounties have arisen in this way: Certain payments that had been made to England were withheld and a dispute arose which has been called the economic war. The responsibility for that economic war, as far as it rests in this country, is a matter, I think, which should be fought at the polls, but while the economic war is on, the country is losing a certain amount, and sections within the country are losing a greater amount than they should be called upon to lose. I would have been glad if the criticism of those bounties was directed to that point, instead of rambling over the whole field without hitting any point. The payments that were withheld from Britain amounted to about £5,000,000, which included over £500,000 for sinking fund. When those payments were withheld, the British set about in their own way to collect those payments by special tariffs. The audited figures of their collection, on the authority of the British Chancellor of the Exchequer, show £4,500,000—to be correct, £4,552,000. I put it to the Minister for Agriculture that the principle underlying the bounties is that as far as the exporters of produce and ultimately the producers of produce are concerned, an amount equivalent to that taken from them by the British tariffs should ultimately find its way into their pockets. In other words the equities of the case demand that if this particular situation is to be relieved by a bounty system, it can only be relieved 100 per cent. by voting £4,500,000 for bounties instead of £3,000,000.
In the matter of bounties, without questioning or opposing the principle of the bounties, or without opposing the policy of the Minister in principle, I should like to hear from the Minister why his contribution to the agricultural community to meet a loss acknowledged at £4,500,000 should be only £3,000,000. There is a loss there of £1,500,000. An equal quantity or value of goods consumed in this country produces a similar loss to the agricultural producers in this country, and produces it in this way: the general price level is lowered to the extent of an amount represented by the difference between the British tariffs and the total bounties given by the Government.
If the consumption of agricultural produce in the Free State is equated 50 per cent. with the exports, the total loss to agricultural producers would be £3,000,000. A great deal has been said, and I agree that it has been justifiably said, about attempts to obstruct the collecting of annuities that are here acknowledged to be collected by the British Government. Our Government is after going through the farce of putting up the case to this House that the £3,000,000 are to be given for bounties. But they are collecting these annuities again or, if it is a Parliamentary word, I should say they are carrying on the plunder by collecting them from an industry that is being robbed to a greater extent than it was ever robbed in our grandfather's time by rack renting and absentee landlords. Statements were made about communistic efforts being made to bring the law into contempt, by the obstruction of roads and by the felling of trees. I am not one of those who believe in preaching one thing and doing another thing. One hundred per cent. of my sympathy is with those who went out to block roads, and who were men enough to stand up to it when they were up against the Tribunal.
Comment on this
We are dealing with the matter which produced these things. We are dealing with the condition of agriculture.
Comment on this
We are not dealing with any campaign or any alleged campaign against the payment of annuities. The question is whether the bounties should be paid.
Comment on this
What has produced the cause, or has given rise to the bounties is something that we cannot get away from. If there was no economic war there would be no case for bounties. These bounties are not in the same category as subsidies for wheat growing or for beet. Wheat and beet are, if you like, new lines of agricultural policy that cannot be dealt with except by subsidies. Here is a trade interfered with to the extent I have mentioned—the figures I gave are incontrovertible—to the extent of £4,500,000. I will not develop that aspect of it any further, because there are motions on the Order Paper on which it can be more appropriately developed. Although I do not agree with bounties, still as the paying of bounties, in the circumstances that have arisen, is a fixed policy, I see no reason why I should not vote for this increase. While we have bounties I am satisfied that we should have this increase but I believe it should be for another £1,500,000. Therefore, unless a very good case is put up, I must vote for increased bounties.
I take it that under this heading other important matters dealing with the cattle trade properly come under discussion; those who got licences to export cattle and got the export bounties. The Minister knows by now that the producers, the farmers, who, theoretically he claims he set out to benefit by the bounties, and their first cousins the licensees, did not get the benefit of either. When the question of licences arose during the stall-feeding season of last year the Minister dished out licences to the dealers— not to the stall feeders. The dealers swarmed around him and apparently convinced him that they were "it"; that no one else counted. The Minister "fell" for that. To give him his due, when a case was put before him, the Minister remedied the situation, but I have still to learn why he changed the policy which he decided on partially on February 1st and finally on February 8 of this year, namely, to give the licences to the producers. Though licences are not mentioned here, indirectly they are affected because the bounties go to the exporters. I should like to hear the Minister defending his future policy on licences. Perhaps on some of the motions on the Order Paper he might get more scope there. Deputy Cleary talked very wildly about politicians preventing farmers growing crops that would pay them. The politicians have fooled the farmers considerably for a long time but it would take more than any politician I know to prevent any farmer growing a crop that he was satisfied would pay him. Incidentally, I should like to know what area Deputy Cleary had under beet in the newly discovered gold mine in Tuam——
Comment on this
—— or how much peat he put on the market. This is a narrow question and I do not wish to take up more time discussing it. I can understand voting against the principle of bounties or voting for a lesser sum. That would be a negative to the motion. I can understand an amendment asking for a larger sum or asking to have the proposal referred back for reconsideration, if it was based on the ground that £763,000 is not enough. I would vote for such an amendment. But, unless some tangible reason is given for referring it back, I must vote for increased bounties.
Comment on this
I intend to be very brief. I cannot help, by way of preface, remarking that Deputy Davin, whose speech I listened to with a good deal of attention, suggested that there had been no constructive proposals put up during the debate on this Vote for export bounties and subsidies. Deputy Cleary stated that the Opposition had not formulated and could not formulate a policy, and he went on to suggest, in one of the wildest statements I think I ever heard Deputy Cleary making—and he is rather remarkable for making wild statements— that the Opposition was wiped off the map. The question I would like to address to the Minister, particularly as I believe he is one of the few Ministers with any sanity left, is this: Is there anything to be gained by wild statements of that character? Analyse the position of this House, and all it means is that the Government of to-day are kept in office by the Labour Party. They have exactly a majority of one. Let me appeal to that highly-intelligent Deputy, Deputy Kelly. Does he suggest that that connotes that the Opposition to this Government is entirely wiped out?
We should have some regard for the value of words. A little knowledge of the King's English would do some Deputies on the Government Benches a lot of good. Deputy Davin and everyone of his colleagues must know that the most constructive suggestion that can be put up, which would have for its object the ending of these export bounties and subsidies mentioned in the Order Paper, is to bring about a settlement of the economic dispute with our neighbours across the Channel. Surely it is not beyond the range of possibility to get four or five sensible, intelligent men from the Government Party to sit down and discuss the ways and means by which this dispute can be ended?
We must also have regard for the capacity of this country to pay. How long does the Minister believe this country will continue to be able to pay out subsidies and bounties to the extent of £1,500,000 per annum? How long does he think the country will stand it? Have we illimitable financial resources? Have we any wonderfully capacious pool into which is poured, through the productive efforts of our people, millions upon millons of pounds to enable us to continue to give this kind of dope to the farming community, for it is nothing less than dope? It galvanises, perhaps for a few weeks or a half season, representing two or three months, the agricultural activities of the country. The agriculturist is allowed to fall into a sickness, a stupor, and an attempt is made to rouse him temporarily by means of these subsidies and bounties.
We have heard a lot said about the home market. Deputy Kent and, perhaps, other speakers have talked about the home market. The Minister has admitted that the requirements of our home market at present and for many years to come will be rather easily satisfied. It will be relatively easy, at any rate, to satisfy home market requirements. We have been told about alternative markets. I believe that these subsidies and bounties are meant to enable us to get across to the other side of the Channel our agricultural produce, to get it to the country whose market we were told was gone for ever. I do not want to repeat these phrases, because they have been repeated ad nauseam in this House. Obviously, this sum of money is required for the purpose of getting our produce into the English market. I am anxious to know from the Minister or his advisers where are the alternative markets. The only alternative market I can see and that the ordinary student of politics and economics in this country can see, is the British market. Do we expect to get a market for our surplus agricultural products in Germany, China or Peru? All the alternative markets that we heard about from the public platforms are rather slow in coming to the front. Some time ago I examined trade returns and I found that most of those foreign countries we hear so much about in the Dáil and outside take very little of our produce but that we take a relatively large amount of their produce. That kind of adverse trade balance is not good for any country. Added to that, we have a continual drain on our resources in order to get into a market that we said was already gone.
I would like to give the Minister some idea—possibly he must have observed it in his Department—of the kind of market that exists for one commodity, namely, poultry. I have seen, no later than this week, an order given to one trader by a very large firm of importers in London to supply him with at least 15,000 turkeys for the Christmas season, guaranteeing to that trader at least 11d. per lb., and if at any time the price went below 11d. the trader would not be disadvantaged; but if and when the price would rise to even 1/6 a lb. the trader would get that 1/6. I would like to know of any alternative market for that commodity or of any other business man in any country such as Germany, China or Peru who would deal in the same way with our business men as the English trader to whom I have referred. I feel sure the Minister will agree with me that all these subsidies and bounties come out of the pockets of the ordinary people of the country. In that connection, I would like to commend to the sound—it may be otherwise—common sense of the Labour Party that every penny that is taken out of the common pool in this country, whether it be for subsidies or for any other purpose, represents money that certainly will be diverted from the purpose which the Labour Party pretend to serve, namely, social services such as widows' and orphans' pensions and other matters of that kind. Out of the common pool, as I have suggested, you can only take as much as is in it. You cannot get more out of a pint pot than a pint, and if this continual frittering away of the nation's financial resources is to continue, I certainly feel that it will be a very nervous and anxious time, not alone for traders and business people and the agricultural community but for the workers of this country.
There is another point which I should like to emphasise before I sit down. I feel that the ordinary consumer or citizen in the cities and towns of Saorstát Eireann is in exactly the same position as the farmer who says, and says with a good deal of reason and truth, that he is paying his annuities twice over. I feel that the ordinary citizen is now paying twice over. For instance, in the boroughs, he has been taxed to the extent of 1/6 in the £, imposed on the ratepayers for the purpose of the operation of the Unemployment Assistance Act. That Bill had hardly passed through the Dáil when the price of beef in the cities and towns to which I refer was put up by 2d. per lb. Let us take the case of Mr. Consumer in the city, who, for his wife and family purchases, let us say, nine pounds of beef every week. That would be a fairly small consumption for the average family of five. He is now paying 1/6 extra for that meat which proves that he is paying not alone the 1/6 extra on his rates for the operation of the Unemployment Assistance Act, but 1/6 extra for his meat because, as a direct result of that Act, Mr. My Friend the Butcher puts up the price of his commodity of beef by 2d. per lb.
I say that the citizen and the townsman, the ordinary working man here in Dublin, the man who lives in the slums and the man who is not in receipt of unemployment assistance, has every bit as big a grievance against this Government as the farmer. I sympathise very deeply indeed with the lot of the farmer to-day, but I have always felt that the townsman is suffering, and he will not be met with any brass bands or Brian Boru pipers or Phil the Fluters if he is evicted out of his tenement house, while the farmer will have all that panoply of war, and all the decorative pipers, etc., if he is evicted from his farm. Remember that in thousands and thousands of cases, the poor struggling working man in the city and the town has paid in rent the purchase price of his little home three or four times over, and still, there is no sympathy for him if he is thrown on the roadside.
I do not want to take from the position of the farmer. I come from farming stock myself, and I am not taking from or belittling his sufferings in any way, because I think he has been made to suffer very severely by the present administration, but I want to suggest to the Minister that if he cannot go on ad infinitum paying these bounties and subsidies, there does not appear to me, or any student of present-day politics or economics, to be any chance of an early settlement of this economic dispute. I feel on this matter that the term of our endurance of this position will be measured only by the patience of our people in being prepared to adopt a system of robbing Peter to pay Paul, and it is certainly robbing Peter to pay Paul to ask the taxpayers of this country to vote huge sums of money to get our goods into the British market, a market which the spokesman of the present Government told them was gone and gone for ever. It is a dishonest policy and a policy that can only end in disaster for this country.