Committee on Finance. - Supplementary Estimates—Vote No. 70—Export Bounties and Subsidies (Resumed).
Contributions 139–291 of 291. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I find myself in agreement to a very great extent with the last speaker in dealing with the lot of the townsman. Theirs is not the lot to be acclaimed with brass bands or pipers' bands in the sufferings and the ills that have been theirs for so long that they seemed to reckon that there was to be no salvation for them, but I recognise that, under the new system, certain alleviation has come to the town worker, notwithstanding all that has been said by the previous speaker, which may largely be attributed to the bounties and subsidies with which we are now dealing and which represent, in my opinion, the weapons that had to be adopted to make the transition from a system which enslaved our townspeople in perpetual bondage.
Deputy Anthony wonders how the Labour Party, with their common-sense otherwise, can reconcile themselves to the inevitable fate that is going to come on the people whom they profess to represent if this system is persisted in. He can see the widows' and orphans' pensions, which have not yet come into operation, being robbed in advance and coming to a nullity. I should like to suggest that, previous to the time when bounties and subsidies were found necessary, when we had no economic war and when the cattle trade and our export business with Britain was at its peak, it was not found possible by the Government then in power even to consider seriously the lot of the widows and orphans in this country. We had not reached a period of prosperity sufficient to warrant giving any relief to that particular class of the citizens. Notwithstanding all the "Dismal Jimmies" and all the terrible things we hear—that bankruptcy stares the country as a whole in the face; that you cannot take more out of a pint pot than what is in it; and that there is only a common pool from which we all draw—those town workers and widows and orphans of town and country, have had to look blithely or patiently at a very small section of the country who were prosperous because of the old system without any hope of their sharing in it.
The process that is taking place now, in my opinion, is one which causes certain pre-natal pains in transferring from one system to another, but, even in anticipation, we find that social services are improved and that the lot of the town worker is improved. I am intervening in the debate particularly because of the references of the last speaker that he, while springing from farmer's stock, is mainly concerned with the workers of the cities and towns. I share a very similar position with him. I am the second generation only in the town and there are very few people in this country who are remotely removed from the land and who can forget their connections with the land, but my sympathies are with the poor both in the towns and in the country. I recognise that the present system of subsidies and bounties paid by the Government is incidental to, and necessary, if they are going to pursue to a successful issue, the determination of the people of this country as a whole to transfer from the position in which we were for many years of being a rich farm for the produce of beef to be exported to just one customer, with all our eggs in one basket and at a price which could not be measured by the price paid to the producer. The price had a bigger reaction than that for it meant that we, in the towns and cities, were doomed to be the importers of the shoddy manufactures of other countries which were paid for by the fat of the land and to which we were denied access.
We who have been evicted from those lands and doomed to live in the towns and cities, in slums and hovels, found the small farms growing into ranches and the number of wealthy people becoming fewer while the number of paupers was becoming greater. We are expected to have a miracle performed and to have this position changed in a night. It is only natural to expect that this change-over to a position of self-sufficiency and to a different form of agricultural economy which would make for the producing from the soil of Ireland, which is essentially agricultural, the maximum benefits on behalf of the maximum number of the population and not for the few, was bound to entail certain hardships on some sections of the community. I am quite sure that the Government, who have come back here on a couple of occasions with the overwhelming voice of the people behind them, to give effect to a new policy and a new doctrine, are applying their remedies to the best of their ability and skill in order to cause the minimum of hardship to any section of the people in their efforts to bring about that desired ideal.
I think it is manifestly unfair to select a single instance like the price of turkeys. Deputy Anthony speaks not only of British merchants but of British philanthropists who are prepared to give a guarantee of a maximum of 1/6 per lb. to the Irish exporter and that the minimum will not fall below 11d, even though they are only worth 9d. These philanthropists are rare and I know lots of people who would be glad to get in touch with the particular gentleman of Deputy Anthony's acquaintance. I think it is manifestly unfair to relate the activities of one particular day or one particular month to a matter which is nation wide in its application and which seeks to remove an age-old grievance from which our country has been suffering. It was referred to last night in another debate and very trenchantly dealt with by Deputy O'Reilly of Meath who pointed out that as long as we had the old system of agriculture, depending almost completely and entirely on the raising of beef for export, we had a dwindling human population. I regretted to hear last night from the Opposition Benches a titter of laughter when the Deputy complained that our trouble was that we had not sufficient people. I think that was thoughtless laughter. We want more people here. Anybody who has read the history of this country or any other country will have to admit that as the cattle population increases the human population correspondingly decreases.
Whether we like it or not, we are faced with the maintenance of an additional population of from 25,000 to 30,000 per year, the best and bravest of our boys and girls, who hitherto regretfully had to be exported, as we exported our cattle, to build up the fortunes of other countries. Now they are left on our hands to be maintained. They are entitled to the best the country can give them. There certainly was no hope for them under the former regime. If there is a hope held out that Ireland can improve its human population and that we can by any means whatever provide them with a decent livelihood, in the development of the soil, in the promotion of industries, then even if these bounties or subsidies are being paid for the moment, I believe that any sacrifice is justified as a temporary measure. I am certain, as I said at the outset, that the Government, or any Government charged with the administration of this particularly difficult time, will use the subsidies and bounties carefully and well, imposing the minimum of hardship on any special section of the community, for the realisation of that ideal. If, as has been said earlier, there was any kind of unification of thought amongst the rival political sections as to whether or not it was desirable that we should increase our human population, that we should distribute the wealth of the country more equitably than it has been hitherto, then the application of the remedies would be much more easy, would cause less hardship to any particular section of the community during the time when we are striving to achieve our economic independence.
It is suggested that the economic war is one which can only be fought by this country for a very brief period; that if it is not brought to a speedy determination, then we automatically must lose. I think that is a very wrong conception on the part of anybody entering into a fight, whether economic or physical. I should rather hope that the people who have entered into this test, not lightly, but as a solemn duty which has been conferred upon them to do the best possible, according to their way of thinking, for the majority of the people of the country, are not reckoning on a speedy end to this particular war or conflict, but that they have set their feet on this path in the belief that it leads to the rightful solution by extracting from the soil and the wealth of the country its maximum, whether the people on the other side like it or not. We have had just one market. We are told that we are now paying subsidies and bounties to get a depleted amount across to that market, which somebody is alleged to have said was gone, thanks be to God, never to come back. I do not quite share this view, but I go this distance: that if that market was only to be maintained at the price at which it has hitherto been maintained, namely, the constant and continual diminution of our human population, then I fervently thank God that it has gone.
I do not think it is the function of any Government to exploit the riches of our soil to make rich a small and dwindling number through ruining the greater majority of the people and reducing them to pauperism and desperation. That, too, would have its retribution, and, with or without a brass band, the hungry people of the towns and cities would demand their rightful place in the sun from any Government in power. I am glad that the Government have seen fit in time, and before the situation became too desperate, to take the necessary steps, by providing such bounties or subsidies as they considered necessary for the transition period, to bring us from the position that we were in, a position of helplessness, solely depending on that one market. We are prepared to send them as much as they are prepared to take from us. We are prepared to exploit any other alternative markets; but, above and beyond all, even with that market or any alternative market, we are determined that Ireland will be exploited to the maximum of its capacity for the production of wealth from the soil, for the manufacture of the things we can manufacture for our own use, and in the sincere hope, which we already have evidence of, of an advance and improvement in the social standard of our people in the towns and cities and rural areas, who hitherto have had little part in the wealth and prosperity of the country as a whole.
Comment on this
The motion before us deals with the question of the postponement of this Vote moved by the Minister for Finance. I hope, in dealing with this motion, that I will get some little latitude in replying to Deputy Keyes on the matters to which he referred. Before answering Deputy Keyes, however, I should like to mention the reasons which have prompted me to support the motion to refer back this Vote. I do so from the point of view of an ordinary, humble type of Irishman, who does not go about the country, like some of my friends on the Fianna Fáil Benches, exploiting their great patriotism and, what I consider, their sham Republicanism. I oppose the giving of bounties and subsidies, because I am convinced that if the Government would only display a little commonsense in dealing with the British Government there would be no necessity to-day for bounties and subsidies.
Before I give a vote—even if this Estimate never appeared on the Order Paper—I would like, as an ordinary, humble Irishman, representing a county which has always been loyal— just as loyal as Limerick—to the national traditions and to the national sentiments of our people, to have an expression of opinion from the President of the Executive Council of the Irish Free State, that he will come here to this House and make a statement to the effect that he could not make a settlement with the Government of Great Britain unless he was prepared to lower the dignity of the people of the Irish Free State. I should like to know from the President whether the real reason for this economic war is the fact that he has refused to transmit the annuities which were transmitted by the previous Government, or whether the President has introduced other matters outside the question of the annuities altogether, namely, the complete independence of this country?
The reason I should like to have that statement from the President is this: that as an Irishman I would be prepared to live on potatoes and salt if the President were man enough to come here and state to the members of this House that the reason he will not settle the economic war is that he is out for the complete independence of this country. Is the President or his Minister for Agriculture or Deputy Cleary or Deputy Smith, or Deputy Rice from Monaghan and the others who go through this country and talk at the cross-roads about Republicanism and about the Republic they themselves have let down—prepared now to come here, and state that the reason they want this Vote passed is because they want to fight for independence and to restore to the people of this country their complete independence? If the President does that, we will know who are the Irishmen and who are not Irishmen in this country. But until the President does that I shall certainly vote against the giving of either bounties or subsidies, because I am convinced that an honourable settlement of this economic war could be effected if the President had only the courage of his convictions. There would be a settlement honourable to the people of this country if, in a word, the President would look for the co-operation and the goodwill of the vast majority of the Irish people. But to my mind, the President prefers the cheers of that very small minority of the people who are out for what they themselves call an Irish Republic of the Soviet type—a Republic which, I am sorry to say, if not publicly supported, is at least, privately supported by the members of the Labour Party, including Deputy Keyes. I, as a worker, as one who knows as much about the miseries and wants of the workers as any member of the Labour Party, am here to tell Deputy Keyes that the policy as adumbrated and pursued by the Government for the last few years has not been any advantage to the working classes. In proof of that, I can point to the recent motion introduced here by the Labour Party, in which the words appear that owing to the abnormal amount of unemployment prevailing and owing to the terrible want that is prevailing amongst thousands of our people, the Government should forthwith take the necessary steps to put into operation large schemes of employment. Now, they cannot have it both ways. Even the Labour Party cannot have it both ways. They must have one thing or the other. They must be manly and honest in this thing. They have not been so up to the present, because when it suited them they have criticised the Government, and when it suited them they have praised the Government.
What I want to know is this: can this economic war be settled, and thereby the introduction of this Vote avoided? Is the British market of any use to the farmers of this country? I was listening last evening to Deputy O'Reilly from Meath talking about the prospects of the British market as it exists at the moment.
Whilst I do not want to be discourteous to any Deputy, I should like to tell Deputy O'Reilly that, as far as the cattle industry is concerned, if he had been a success at that industry there would be no necessity for him to be a T.D. to-day. But when he gets up in this House and states that the British market is of little or no use to the farmers of this country he is saying a thing which in his own mind he knows is absolutely false. Deputy O'Reilly took good care, when making comparisons as between the prices paid for Irish cattle and the prices paid for cattle in Great Britain that he referred to the prices paid for cattle in Wales. He figured that price at from £2 to £3 lower. He also quoted speeches made by the British Minister of Agriculture. Both he and Deputy Corry told us that the position of the British farmer was such that the British Minister of Agriculture was bound to take the steps he is now taking in order to preserve the industry in Great Britain. But Deputy O'Reilly and Deputy Corry forgot to tell the House here that in addition to the restrictions placed upon the cattle industry there was also the tariff, which amounted to £6. There is no mention of that by Deputy O'Reilly or Deputy Corry or by other Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches. Do not the Ministers and do not the back-benchers on the Fianna Fáil side know that a cattle dealer who buys a 10 cwt. beast at 25/- a cwt. pays £12 10s. for that beast. On top of that he has to pay a duty of £6. In addition, there is £1 10s. for freight, etc. These three items make £20. Unless the cattle dealer is a lunatic, philanthropist or millionaire, he has got to get £20 for that beast in the British market before he can call a halfpenny of that his own. Yet we have on the Fianna Fáil Benches well-educated men like Deputy O'Dowd stating publicly that even if the economic war were ended in the morning there would be no difference between the price received here now and the price that would be paid on the expiration of the economic war.
We are asked by the back-benchers on the Government side to have a little charity and to display a little co-operation. I have, on many occasions, gone out of my way to show that charity and sympathy and to give a little co-operation. But in return what do I find? Nothing but insults from the Government Benches. We have things said here that have absolutely no relation to the point at issue, and have absolutely no relation to the condition of affairs that exists in the country at the moment. Why cannot the members of the Fianna Fáil Party be honest like the rest of us, and admit once and for all that the British market is the only market in which the Irish farmer, be he United Irelander or Fianna Fáil or Labour, can get a fair return or a fair price for his surplus agricultural produce?
Again, we are told by the members of the Government that, during this transition period, it is necessary that the people should make some sacrifice. We are told also that, if the people want to be free, they must be prepared to make sacrifices. I am one of those who would be prepared to make any sacrifice for country and always was prepared to do so but I am prudent enough to ascertain beforehand whether these sacrifices will be made in vain. I want to have some information from those in power that, at the end of a given period, there will be some prospect of bringing to an end the present deplorable state of affairs. There is absolutely no doubt that, if the situation develops as it has been developing for the last two or three years, there will be only one end to it. I do not want to adopt the rôle of pessimist but, in my opinion, that end will be bankruptcy for a very large section of our people. That may not be a matter of regret to certain people. I know, and many of the men on the Government Benches know, that there is a type in this country who would be glad to see other people go bankrupt to-morrow, who would be glad to see the big farmers or the ranchers, as they call them, go bankrupt so that they would have to leave their lands and these people would get in in their stead. Having nothing going in, they do not care three straws if they have nothing going out. That is the philosophy that is being preached behind the closed doors of the Fianna Fáil clubs. I am perfectly certain of that. I charge them now that they tell their dupes down the country "When So-and-so, the big farmer, goes bankrupt, you can take possession of his house and lands." That is the policy pursued and that is how the Party opposite are getting the votes. It is not on their national policy or on the question of fighting England that they are getting votes but it is on the doles—free milk and free beef. "Vote for the man who gives the free beef." We hear a lot about the dignity of labour from the Labour Benches. It is a peculiar characteristic of the Socialist that he loves doling out other people's money but, at the first sign of danger, he is the first to skip, as was the case in Austria. Deputy Davin, being near Dun Laoghaire, would not have far to go to catch the first boat for Holyhead.
I am opposed to any more subsidies or bounties because I am convinced that the President does not want any settlement. He is afraid. He has not the moral courage to stand up against that very small section of shouters who call themselves "Republicans" and with whom the members of Fianna Fáil and, in particular, the back-benchers flirt in secret, not having the courage to come out into the open. That is the reason why the decent element amongst the Irish people, the hardworking honest people are being completely robbed at the present time. That is why the section of the Irish people that specialised in the raising of cattle are suffering. Everybody who knows anything about farming knows that the cattle industry is to the whole agricultural industry what the keystone is to the arch. Remove the keystone and you at once destroy the whole solidity of the building. In like manner, destroy the cattle industry and you destroy the whole fabric of the agricultural industry. That is an aspect of the question that has not received sufficient attention from the members of the Government. They say that they secured the confidence of the people even at the recent county council election. Again, everybody knows how votes are got. Sixty per cent or 70 per cent. of the votes cast for Fianna Fáil are not cast because of a desire to fight England. We know how they are got. I am not speaking from the point of view of a West Britisher. I am not speaking from the point of view of a traitor. I am speaking the honest sentiments of one who loves his country as well as President de Valera or any member of the Fianna Fáil Party does and who is prepared to fight, suffer and endure for his country. But I am not prepared to make others suffer for the mere sake of suffering or to enable people to have their way in continuing a war which, in the opinion of all right-minded men, can have but one end— the utter collapse of the agricultural community.
We may continue for some time. The financial resources of the country were great. One must pay tribute to the late Government for that. When they went out of office they handed over a country that was financially very rich. That has been proved up to the hilt by what the present Government have been able to do. They have been able to do these things because of the sound financial position established by their predecessors. I say that persons who have any love or respect for their country should endeavour to inflict as little hardship as possible on any section of the community. I go further and say that it is the duty of the President and members of the Executive Council and, to a lesser extent, of the members of the Fianna Fáil Party not to impose any hardship that can be avoided even on one individual, not to speak of the thousands on whom hardship has been inflicted as a result of this dispute with Great Britain. I, as a humble member of this House, will not support the giving of any more bounties or subsidies until I hear from the President's own lips what is the real cause of the prolongation of the economic war and whether he has taken any steps to arrive at a settlement that will be honourable to the people of both countries.
Comment on this
I expected yesterday that the Minister, when introducing this Estimate, would have told us something more about the details or would enlarge on them, so as to give us sufficient information in order to make a comparison with the paper issued. We are told that this £750,000 is required in addition to the sum of £2,250,000 already voted for export bounties and subsidies. The statement of the details set out that "additional provision" is required "for bounties and subsidies on agricultural and industrial commodities exported from Saorstát Eireann and for expenditure connected with trial consignments of such commodities to external markets. The payments will be made," we are told, "in respect of such commodities at such rates and subject to such other conditions as the Minister for Finance may from time to time approve." I asked the Minister yesterday, by way of segregating one item, what were the industrial commodities on which bounties were paid and for which portion of this sum was likely to be required in the future. He promised to get these items. I would, also, expect that he would come prepared with the statement as to the trial consignments upon which this money is to be spent. In that connection one would think that we should hear something as to the results that have accrued from these trial consignments up-to-date.
We do know that the Minister sent cattle to Belgium and lost on that transaction. Here we have a Minister, not operating as an ordinary commercial man, and, I presume, not subject to the ordinary circumstances that surround a trade concern in the ordinary way, having everything of the best, yet he did definitely confess a loss, which was infinitesmal compared with the losses incurred every day in big matters which form a very big percentage of the amount of money risked on such consignments. We know that butter was sent to the Continent and we know that in certain consignments of butter trials there was serious loss. But no one told us the true story about certain butter which certainly was prepared for export to the Continent. The circumstances, as I heard them detailed, are that a certain biggish consignment of butter, lying in Cork for some time, was opened, and was discovered to have round it a thick black scum. When an attempt was made to take it off, it was then found that the scum went deeper than the mere opening of the receptacle revealed at first glance. The story went on that this consignment of Government butter was sold, at a big loss by the Government, to certain blenders in this country on the condition that they would not export any of what they had blended. In other words, that this partly decomposed substance was to be blended with certain other butter in this country and then sold to consumers in this country. That, in every sense of the word, was a dirty trick, apart from the fact that that loss was incurred.
Again I do not know if there is complete truth, or some truth, or any truth at all, in the rumour which gained great currency in Berlin regarding a certain trial consignment sent out to Berlin in charge of a rather respectable, highly paid civil servant acting, more or less as a commercial traveller. I understand that one of the items in this consignment was geese. We had a reputation for "wild geese"; they were known on the Continent before. But we sent some domestic ones this time. They were apparently not taken there in the height of their bloom, or apparently the bloom had gone off. The story was current in Berlin that the geese went high. That was only to be expected, as they had been kept a certain time not in a refrigerator; so the articles of this trial consignment had, in fact, to be destroyed. They were not condemned as a nuisance. I understand they did not go to that point. Have we had any estimate of the loss incurred there? There certainly was a loss, a financial loss and there was a terrible loss of prestige. I do not know whether that is to be regarded as an indication of the success of other activities such as cow testing activities, butter grading activities, and so on, with a view to preparing for market produce of the highest possible standard. But these are the trial consignments one has heard of.
We heard in relation to a Vote discussed here last night that statistical experts who visited this country during the year were regaled with great stories as to the magnificently progressive department of statistics there was in this country. They used to be progressive, and they used constantly to turn out figures which Ministers are rather sorry to see. These figures we get no more. They are not presented to us as information when the information is requested here in the House. We are left without any indication as to what has been the result of the trial consignments which the Minister has ventured to send abroad. We have no balance sheet and we have no idea as to whether the consignments were sent in such condition as indicated that they had a chance of success, apart from financial success, in exploiting foreign markets in which we have to sell. I do not mind about financial success—because nothing has been done on a financial basis—if you can get our produce in a good condition, have it sold or slaughtered or given away, so that, by some method, you can get rid of it. It does not matter a whole lot who pays if some ordinary commercial consideration is brought to bear upon it, some activity as to costing and prices, and some attempt made at striking a balance between these things. The Minister did, however, tell us one very interesting thing last night: that this country had a unique experience in the summer of this year, when there arrived the millenium in one small matter. He said that we had reached a position in this country in regard to some article of pig production when it was more profitable to sell at home than to sell abroad. And the Minister immediately took steps to redress that. He found that although it was more profitable to sell at home, a certain factory—and he described this as one that took the long view—preferred to sell even at a less profit abroad, which in this instance meant England. It can hardly be said of the Minister for Agriculture that he wants to destroy our trade with England. The people with the long view decided it was desirable to sell at a less profit in England, and he complimented them by describing them as the people with the long view. He did more than compliment them with having that view. There was a bigger bounty given to ensure that when they took the economic circumstances into account, which made it more desirable to develop that trade than to sell at home, they would not lose, and there was an extra inducement offered to those who wanted to take the long view.
Now, why should it be regarded by the Minister, with all his other activities, as having the long view when one decided to sell, not at more profit at home, but at less profit in England? We had to keep the quota. Whatever figure had been given, we had to see that that was filled. Otherwise, there was the chance that the British might take us at our word when we said we did not want their market. They might take us at our word when we said that at times it was more profitable to sell at home and they might decide to leave us to our home market. Why is a thing right in regard to pigs and wrong in regard to cattle or to cows? What is the terrific difference? If self-sufficiency with regard to wheat and beet is a proper aim, and if it is so definitely the aim that we have got to slaughter surplus cattle, why should we not be content with self-sufficiency in pigs, particularly when we get to the stage that it is more profitable to sell at home than abroad? Why not try to develop that and see that that circumstance will always last instead of being a very odd phenomenon? How is it reconcilable to say of people who produce pigs that those with the long view will keep open the British market, and then to speak, of those who wanted to take the long view, say, in regard to cattle, in the way in which the Minister did?
Deputy Dillon already referred to this speech. It is worth reiteration. The Minister, as reported in the Irish Press, on the 30th June, said: “The Government had been accused of being in favour of tillage and out for the destruction of the live stock industry. The person who made that accusation,” said the Minister—this was the striking speech he made before the Irish Farmers' Protection Association—“was either a fool or a knave to think that the live stock industry is to be destroyed, for if we till we must have live stock; otherwise the farmers cannot use up their barley, straw, or other products, or get manure.” And the conclusion was drawn that we must at least maintain the amount of live stock we have.
That was the 30th June. When the Minister began to speak this year on the Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Bill, he gave us a somewhat different picture, but I think that all the while he held on to that—that it was necessary to keep cattle, at the present level, or, as the odious phrase has it, that the cattle population of the country should be kept more or less what it is now. Deputy Dillon had already called attention to the contradiction, within a year, by a colleague of the Minister, Senator Connolly, who, at Kilcock, said that although it had taken one hundred years to establish the cattle trade in the country, with God's help it would not take 100 years to kill it. That was on the 9th June and, as if that were not sufficient, he hied himself away to Strokestown, in the West, within ten days, to say that it was a damn good thing that the market for cattle in England was disappearing. We need not go, however, to these rather minor lights of this House for examples. The President said that the market had gone and he thanked Heaven for it.
That is one side of it. We are told, in relation to cattle, by the Minister for Agriculture, that we must at least maintain the live stock that we have. His colleague, Senator Connolly, who has been reduced to the woods and forests of the country, speaks differently. He wants to kill it; and the President, if he does not exactly want to kill it, at any rate explains what is happening, with the best possible grace, by saying that the market has gone and thanks Heaven for it. The answer may be that we must maintain the live stock of the country, that as we have them in their numbers there will always be an exportable surplus, but that there need not be dependence on England. Hence the trial consignments and hence the extra losses. That thought ran through many a head before the elections.
Deputy Kennedy sometimes bills himself as an agricultural expert on the Fianna Fáil side. Speaking in 1931, in the month of October, he said:—
"They tell you you have no market but the British market. It is an extraordinary thing that Canada is sending cattle to France and every other European country as fast as they can send them, and we are within two days' reach of these places. Why should we not do the same?"
I wonder does Deputy Kennedy stand in an interrogative way in front of the Minister for Agriculture from day to day, when he is talking of subsidies and bounties with regard to exports to Great Britain, and remind the Minister that Canada is sending cattle to France as fast as they can and that we are only within two days' reach of the country; and I wonder has he answered satisfactorily as to why we cannot do what Canada is doing?
Deputy O'Reilly, I think, is recognised—his solitary qualification is agriculture, I think—as the real agricultural expert in the Fianna Fáil ranks. I think that his biography says that he has travelled many countries in search of information on agriculture. The weight of his information on agriculture in 1931 was declared to this effect:—
"There were people in Meath who would say that Fianna Fáil means to destroy our present market, the only market which gives us a living. It was not their intention to destroy that market. It was their intention and business to develop any market which would buy from them to the fullest extent possible. That was their policy and their duty."
That is rather in line with the Minister for Agriculture, who wants to maintain live stock at their present level; but it is contrary to what Senator Connolly and the President desire.
Is there really a policy with regard to this cattle matter? I think it was on the Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Bill that the Minister for Agriculture, in answer to an interjection, said that he had always admitted that in respect of cattle the farmers of the country are suffering, and that when one touched on that article of the farmers' production and its sale, he had to admit that there was a definite setback for the farmers of the country. In the speech that has been referred to, however, he has to join up cattle with everything else. If they till, they must have live stock. Otherwise, he said the farmers could not use up their barley, straw and other products, or get manure. So when the Minister for Agriculture says, as he has said from time to time—and which he must still hold if he has not changed—that his view is that the live stock industry is the only thing in which the farmer can be set back, he is pointing to the basis of all agriculture in this country, judging by his own comment. He has said that tillage and the live stock industry go together. Surely, he must realise that when these two things are so related, and when he says that it is only in relation to live stock that the farmer is suffering, he must also recognise the deduction that if there is suffering in that, all of agriculture is suffering.
Now, is there a policy that sooner or later, and the sooner the better, we must stop exporting cattle to England? The Minister for Defence says "yes," because he at any rate has realised this—I think it is the only economic argument he has indulged in—that as long as we continue to send cattle to the English market, so long will England be able to exact the land annuities and that, therefore, we must stop exporting cattle to England if we are to be able to hold the land annuities. Is that the policy? If that is the policy, is it also the policy that we must maintain live stock at around about their present price? If so, and if that means an exportable surplus, does it mean the further addition to policy that we must get a market elsewhere? If all these things are correct, where is the market to be got?
Deputy Dillon pointed out the other night that not merely are we suffering because there has been exacted, in a rather roundabout and destructive way, the full amount of money that used to be paid without any of this obstruction or destruction of the market. Deputy Dillon pointed out that not merely is the money being taken from us as before but that, in addition, there is a serious change taking place. The Deputy pointed out that there has been a quota put from time to time on various types of cattle but that the British, at any rate, have not been so blind to their advantage as to do one thing, that is, they have put no quota or restriction on the export of the herds of the country—the milch cattle of the country. One has only to count and to get an analysis of what crosses from time to time to find out that within a comparatively short time we shall not merely have paid, up-to-date, the annuities and the R.I.C. pensions; we shall not merely have done that at a greater cost and suffering to ourselves than if the moneys had been handed over freely, but we shall have made an exchange of greater value to the British, and at a greater loss to ourselves, than is represented by the cash value at the moment. For years the British have been driven back upon this country because their herds were deficient. They are now getting, as more or less worthless animals, all the carefully-selected and bred herds of the country. If it is recognised that that is happening and if it is agreed either that we cannot prevent its happening or that it is a good thing that it should happen, why do we not get at any rate the best value for the animals? They are worth more than merely sale as they are going out at the moment. Why would not the Minister make an offer to the British that we would transfer from time to time, say, quarter by quarter, so much of the herds as the English want? Let us openly and clearly know what the sacrifice is and what the future is going to be.
It is very hard to discern any deliberate line of policy through the activities of the Government. In a debate here the other day, one of the Deputies, who ordinarily speaks on these matters, said that, at any rate, the export of money from this country had been stopped. Almost immediately there was the revelation made, that as far as money is concerned, all the money he talked of, in italics, all the annuities and the R.I.C. pensions, is being collected on the other side. Everybody knows it is being collected except the Fianna Fáil supporters, who blind themselves to it. In addition to that peculiar view, which is accepted from time to time by Deputies who do not want to see the opposite—the truth —we get the other type of phrase which was used in the debate quite recently: "There is no good in our sending cattle to England at the moment, the Englishman cannot get a fair price for his own cattle in his own market, and if that market were free and open and there were no tariffs, it would not pay."
The obvious answer to that is the Border. Are we to assume that cattle are being driven and smuggled across the Border just simply for love of excitement? There is no bounty that we know of being paid on smuggled cattle. There must be some inducement to send them across, and the inducement, presumably, is the ordinary one of gain. But Deputies will seriously use, apart from the restricted market, this further argument, dealing only with the value we may get in the English market for whatever scope it may have, that it is no good, because the price to be got at present for cattle in England is so small. Unless there is going to be the allegation that in the Six-County area they would fetch a higher price than they do in England, or that the Six-County buyer, through sheer bewilderment or some peculiar idea of self-sacrifice, pays a higher price than our cattle would fetch in England— unless that argument is put up, there has been as yet no attempt to meet the argument which faces Ministers immediately. Cattle are being regularly run across the Border. There is no bounty paid on them. They are sold simply on account of the ordinary law of supply and demand. We must conclude that they are sold at a more advantageous price than could be obtained here. The ordinary law of supply and demand rules the price.
Comment on this
We shall take that argument, that they are not going. The Minister cannot see cattle crossing the Border, but he can see factories where other people cannot. He has a blind eye and a good eye, and that results in a distorted vision in most things. So that is the new argument: there are no cattle getting across the Border! Is that seriously argued?
Comment on this
I suggest that if cattle are being smuggled into Northern Ireland from the Free State, that fact would be reflected in the shipments from Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
If it were only 100, why are the 100 being sent in that way? Is it for the excitement of the thing?
Comment on this
Oh, that is the way out, to deny there is even 100! Deputy Haslett first made that case here one night. There was nobody present to put the answer that the Minister for Industry and Commerce has now made. The more brazen that particular reply of the Minister, the more effectively people can assess the argument at its true value. There are no cattle sent across the Border! Is that believed by anybody? There are not even 100 going, because 100 will justify the argument I am using. Have there been any prosecutions in respect of smuggled cattle that would tot up to 100, revealed in the Press? If so, why have these cattle been sent?
We have the other side of the argument that the market is restricted and that it is not restricted by any activity on the part of a British Government necessarily hostile to us, even thinking about us at all, but just simply because they want that market for themselves. I think that is another side to it. When we speak in this House of the Ottawa arrangement that might have been made but that has not been made, we are told that the British Minister for Agriculture has said something rather derogatory of the market as a market for exporters. That is waved here as if it is an answer to the argument that was used. Has the Minister for Agriculture looked at the figures of the increased entries into Great Britain of Dominion goods? Does the Minister realise that the other Dominions have in the last 12 months got, through export to Great Britain, at least the £15,000,000 odd that we have lost? Has the Minister any idea of what we used to sell to Great Britain and of what Great Britain used to consume, and will the Minister tell us just how far the gap has been narrowed between what the British used to produce themselves and what they consumed.
In the matter of meat products alone, I will go back six years to get figures. In 1928, in meat of all types, eggs and butter, the British imported £330,000,000 worth of goods. They produced about £140,000,000 worth of their total consumption of goods, amounting to that £330,000,000, plus the £140,000,000 worth produced and consumed at home, we supplied some. The entire import into Great Britain of meat of all types, eggs and butter, was £33,000,000 worth. We sent in less than £30,000,000 worth. Let us assume that the British are narrowing the gap between that £140,000,000 of what they used to produce at home and their consumption. Have they got to the point that we are narrowed down from the £30,000,000 worth that we used to send in in 1928—meat of all types, eggs and butter—and, if not, until we come to that point, can it be said that the market is unnecessarily and by nature, by circumstances over which we have no control, restricted against us? How is it in those circumstances, with the British expanding their own production, that the other Dominions have been enabled to send into Great Britain in the last twelve months £15,000,000 worth more of products than they used to send? Why cannot we enter into that market except for the simple reason that we are making the British take from us in taxation on our goods what they used to get openly?
Now we are going to give export bounties. We are going to have trial consignments. I am assuming that these two things are divided: that the bounties mean, just as the Minister had to do in the summer when he found that big economic circumstances had come about, that it was more profitable to sell at home than to send abroad and had to meet that by extra bounties, and the bounties are to induce either the continuance of the same sales or of more sales to Great Britain at more cost to us. The trial consignments mean the same sort of business about sending, or attempting to send, bad butter to Belgium, high geese to Berlin and cattle at a loss to Belgium. How are we developing these trial consignments? This is a big sum that is being asked. It is somewhere about £750,000. Is there in mind any very big experiment through trial consignments, and what is it going to relate to? Is it industrial goods? I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce at one time thought that we were going to supply the whole of Europe with confectionery. That was in the very early days of the tariff régime. Are we going to have trial consignments of sugared buns to some place on the Continent? Is there any industrial activity looked to in connection with these trial consignments, or is it all allocated to agriculture? Where is the philosophy, where is the proper policy, the line of thought that enables the Minister for Agriculture to say that we must maintain our present number of live stock as it is at the moment, and that enables the Minister for Woods, or whatever he is, to say that we have got to break down the cattle industry, and that enables the President to say that the market in Britain for cattle is gone, and thank heaven for it.
These things are not reconcilable in themselves. Are any of them reconcilable with this taking of sums of money from the people of the country through taxation and spending them so as to enable people to sell in a market which, in the main, we regard as failing? The Minister for Agriculture alone is sticking to the other policy. We think it is degrading and that it is nationally weakening to have it there. We look forward to the day, and we want it to be speeded up, when we will no longer either be able to, or need to, sell in that market.
I may be told that this is, of course, a transition period. We are building up a vast industrial structure here. We are getting in, according to the newspapers, all sorts of capital goods which the Minister cannot segregate. We are going to build up a huge industrial community here, and we will require probably some of this live stock now going abroad for the feeding of this new industrial population. But while the transition is on we must keep in the British market. Is that the situation that we are at? We were told by the Minister last night that we had an enormous increase in the acreage under wheat and under beet. We were told that the farmer had gained enormously by that change. From the Minister's statement it seems that even for wheat and beet we must maintain the amount of live stock that we have. But, supposing that is not an embarrassment and that we can leave live stock aside, the Minister says that there is a big improvement now in relation to beet and wheat, and a big improvement in the farmer's income. If that is so, and if it is desirable to get speedily to the position in which we will not have a surplus of live stock to send to England, why not take the time to reach that when the farmers are well off and when they have gained enormously under these schemes as the Minister said when defending another proposal last night? But has there been such an increase as that which the Minister talked of last night, and are the farmers so much better off? Is there any sign of that?
I have seen the latest statistics published with regard to the acreage under crops of different types. From these you can certainly see an increase in wheat and some increase in beet, but if you look further down the list you can see that, in the main, it is only substituted tillage, and that only a very small percentage of it is new tillage. So that what we have is this: we are substituting for a particular type of economy in which people produced what paid and sold under ordinary conditions a certain acreage with some increase in crops that do not pay unless the consumer or the taxpayer subsidises them. While we are doing that, the taxpayer is still asked to put up certain extra moneys in order to assist in maintaining, I suppose it is, the numbers of live stock at their present figure. We are assisting in doing that by selling in this market which we recognise as disappearing, and which we want to disappear even faster. We are doing it in the teeth of the difficulties that Fianna Fáil Deputies will speak of from time to time—that the price in the British market is no good, and that, in addition to that, whatever market there is even at that small price is being gobbled up by the British themselves, and the other Dominions. Was there ever a more illogical programme than that, and was there ever greater folly than to ask people to pay for the carrying out of that programme? If the prices were so bad, as Ministers tell us, for all those things in the British market, why are the Dominions so keen on getting their footing in that market? They are being cut out. They are still anxious to get in. They are further removed from it than we are. We are told it is not worth our while sending beasts to that market. The Minister tells us to-night that he does not think there is even sufficient inducement to make people smuggle across the border, and yet we are now being asked to pay in order to keep that bad and decaying market open.
The Minister for Agriculture, when it comes to speaking of pigs, says it was people with the long view who decided to take less profit on the sale at home and to keep the quota open. There must be some line of thought; somebody must have a reason for all this; somebody must be able to tell us that the trial consignments on which we already spent money had sufficient results to make us want to go on again. As far as I remember, when this talk of alternative markets first came along, the President frankly said that there were no foreign markets available, and that he thought it was going to be a matter of extraordinary difficulty to get them. The Minister for Finance said first of all that the British market was gone, joining, of course, in the thanksgiving in relation to that, and then said that he wanted to warn people of the difficulty of getting alternative markets. Six months later he said that we were not without hopes of getting them. We can always get markets in the way in which the Minister for Agriculture gets them—by simply exporting irrespective of whether there is a price paid equal to what we send out. The Minister for Industry and Commerce in the old days had a completely different view of this matter. He never envisaged subsidies. The Minister must remember the interview he gave to the Daily Express, in which he said that nobody could believe that the British would ever put on any tariffs against our goods, because everybody knew that we were in such an extremely advantageous position in relation to exports to Great Britain; we were the only people, in relation to trade with England, with whom there is a balance favourable to England, and the Minister said that we could go to Ottawa able to exact more than any other Dominion a good settlement and a good trade agreement. In the Daily Express article he said that of course some people thought if the annuities were retained at home the British might retaliate by putting duties on exports from this country, but that everybody knew that was mere nonsense.
In those days the Minister did not think that the British market was a disappearing one; the Minister did not think that the British market was not a desirable one, but the Minister did think that the British could not get their supplies from anywhere else. Now, if Deputy Corry were here he would tell us, of course, that the difficulty is that everybody wants to export to Britain, that apparently everybody is likely to be treated better than this country, and that we have no hopes of a market there. Deputy Donnelly and others will join in saying that even if the market is open to us it is open to us on such disadvantageous terms in relation to actual price that it is not worth while sending our goods there. However, apparently we have got to export. We have got to have the long view. We have got to have people praised in relation to their activities towards the British market, and we have got to have further, apparently, not merely praise but material consideration. £2,250,000 is the first amount of money asked for in relation to those export bounties, and now we have a request for an additional £763,000, bringing the revised estimate up to this tot of £3,000,000.
Can the Minister tell us, before he closes to-night, whether it is merely because there is a transition period that this money is required. Is it a transition period between our present situation and the time when we will not want to export surplus cattle at all, or is it only a transition period between whatever we are at at the moment and the time when we will have another market than Britain to which to export our surplus? Whichever of those situations we are moving towards, will the Minister tell us how fast we are going? When will we have reached the stage when we will not want money like this voted for export bounties? We may want it for trial consignments, but we will not want it for export bounties because we will have reached the stage of either having no cattle to export or of having another market. If we are going to have another market for the cattle at present exported to Great Britain any further questions, as far as I am concerned, do not arise, but if the situation is that we are moving towards a time when we will not have an exportable surplus of cattle at all then what is to replace the cattle? Is it subsidised crops, and if so, would the Minister tell us when this expenditure has disappeared what will be the expenditure proportionate to it in relation to subsidised crops? If our aim is to get away from what the Minister said on the 30th June—that we must maintain the amount of live stock we have, and that we are not going to export at all as far as cattle are concerned—then what is going to be the agricultural economy here, and how will the Minister meet the situation that will then develop? As far as that situation is concerned, he said on the 30th June that only a fool or a knave would think the live-stock industry is to be destroyed, because if we till we must have live stock; otherwise the farmers cannot use up their barley, straw or other products, or get manure. Where is the live-stock industry going to end? If it is going to be cut down below the present supplies how are we going to provide manure? How otherwise are farmers to use up their barley, straw and other products? Instead of the moneys that will come in from the sale of cattle what moneys are the farmers of the country going to live upon? Is it the moneys they will derive from wheat and beet? If so, are those going to be subsidised for a long time, and what will the amount of the subsidy reach at the time when that change over in agricultural economy will have been made; when the cattle industry will have disappeared as far as exports is concerned, and we are self-sufficient as far as wheat and beet are concerned?
If there is a plan with regard to agriculture, which does not include the perpetuation of these subsidies as long as the economic war lasts, there should be some detailed idea with regard to the time and with regard to the results of the things I spoke of. Surely it is time in the third year of the attempt to change the economy of the country from what it was to something new that we should have a clear statement as to what is the aim, when we will arrive at the objective, and what it will cost us when we are in the new situation. Nobody objects to the payment of this amount of money. People who take a long view take a different attitude to that of the people who take the long view of the Minister. I think it is wise to keep that market for whatever it is worth, even at a big cost. I say that because I see that market there to be expanded and developed. We should pay something in this awkward situation that we have got into, in order to keep a position at any rate upon which someone else can build in future. If the Minister has not that view will he tell us if that expression of his about the long view was limited to the situation at the moment, or brought about by other considerations or, will some attempt be made to clear up the mystery of an agricultural policy which makes us appear foolish in the eyes of people who consider the situation, because we appear to be paying money to send goods into a market which is valueless, and which is being destroyed in ordinary circumstances, and which we rejoice to see destroyed? That is a supremely foolish piece of work, and there must be some other explanation of it than merely folly.
Comment on this
In a rather long speech Deputy McGilligan asked for certain particulars to which I think he is entitled. I promised to get a list of industrial goods for which an increased vote is required, owing to the fact that the exports of these goods have been higher than was anticipated. They include linen and cotton piece goods, woollen and worsted manufactures, feathers and curled hair, horticultural and nursery goods, biscuits, margarine and edible fats, smoking pipes, sausage casings. Certain animal feeding stuffs and mine and quarry materials. The Deputy also asked for particulars with regard to tripe. That item is not very large. It covers losses on tripe consignments from the beginning, amounting to £1,783 5s. 2d.
Comment on this
The full volume on which this loss was made amounted to £30,521. The principal head under which the losses occurred were:—No. 1, the opening of a market for both cattle and butter in Belgium; No. 2, the opening of a market for Irish eggs in Spain; No. 3, the opening of a Moroccan market for cattle and potatoes.
Comment on this
The returns in the case of cattle and butter can be got in the ordinary Trade Returns. I do not know what they are. I could give them if the Deputy had asked. As regards No. 2, eggs for Spain, a definite arrangement is being made under which we will sell a considerable quantity of eggs there during the year. We sold there during 1934, and will export during 1935, because, as Deputies are aware, a quota has been put on eggs going to Great Britain, and it is quite possible that we may have a surplus of eggs which we will have to get rid of.
Comment on this
It is quite evident that the Opposition are not a bit anxious to get markets for our surplus produce, but are very much more anxious to make political capital. The alternative markets are a source of great amusement to Deputy Dillon and others. The £70,000 we got for eggs from Spain is nothing to be laughed at.
Comment on this
No. I am only mentioning the ones on which there were losses.
Comment on this
That does not arise. The £70,000 we got from Spain for eggs had the effect, not only of absorbing them, but had the effect of raising prices, because those buying for the Spanish market were able to get a better price than those exporting to Great Britain. That had the effect of stiffening prices.
Comment on this
I do not know. It would be got under many headings. Deputy McGilligan asked a question which he was entitled to ask whether any big amount was contemplated in this Vote for further trade consignments. There is not. I do not think there is going to be any great loss on further trade consignments, certainly not more than £100 or £200. There was no loss bigger than £200 to any country. It should be remembered that sometimes ordinary traders will not take the risk of exporting to these markets, and the Government has got to do it, to see if there will be a loss or not. When the Government proves that we can sell eggs in Spain or cattle in Belgium at a profit then the private trader comes along and takes over the trade. The Government does not get a chance of recouping its losses, because it hands over the business at the time it begins to pay.
Comment on this
Not now. They are buying cattle in competition in the Dublin market. They are buying at the ordinary price and doing business on the ordinary basis. That is all that arises on this particular Vote, on Deputy McGilligan's speech. I attempted last night to instruct Deputies on the opposite benches as to the policy of this Government with regard to cattle. Evidently Deputy McGilligan did not take in what I said. I shall be speaking again when we resume on the other motion, and I do not mind reiterating what our policy is regarding live stock. It is on that motion it should be done. That, of course, will come on in about half an hour and I expect Deputies will have some patience.
Deputy Anthony wants to know how long can this country continue paying out these subsidies. I do not know, but at any rate it is able to pay them for the present. We are asked further—two or three Deputies raised the question—whether this is purely what might be termed an economic war measure—this payment of export bounties. I do not think it is, exactly. There is no doubt what Deputy Moore said is true. Even if the economic war were over, and if there were a collapse in bacon, beef or some particular item, it is quite possible any Government might pay export subsidies in order to keep the level of prices in that particular commodity up for a temporary period, if there was any expectation that prices might improve. We sometimes have a product which we may be consuming to the extent of 75 per cent. at home, exporting the remainder, and a small export bounty might keep up the export price and at the same time keep up the home price and in that way it would be of benefit to the producers. Take potatoes, for example. We produce a great deal of potatoes in this country, but we export very little, comparatively. By paying an export bounty of a small amount, £12,000 or £15,000 a year, we keep the level of prices up.
Comment on this
I was taking potatoes as an example and evidently Deputy McGilligan is now learning something. Where you have an export surplus, as in the case of potatoes, the price of the exported article does rule the home price, at least to a great extent. In the case of potatoes there may be some little difference as between Dundalk or Dublin, but the export price has a very big influence on the home price. If there is an export at Dundalk the export price rules absolutely the price at Dublin. By paying an export subsidy, in that case, it may amount only to a small sum but it not only raises the price for the person exporting, it also raises the price for those selling in the home market. If there was no economic war, and if we thought world prices were not sufficient for our home producers, there is no reason why we should not continue to pay export bounties.
Comment on this
It might not be necessary to pay them to this extent. Before ever there was an economic war we brought in a Bill, but it was opposed by the Party opposite. The Bill had reference to the raising of butter prices by giving a bounty on exports, in that way raising the price of exported butter and so raising the price at home.
Comment on this
But I brought in a Bill and Deputies opposite opposed it. They would not like to admit that now in Limerick.
Comment on this
I brought in the Bill here. I sponsored it, but the Deputies opposite opposed it.
Comment on this
They opposed it at every stage. They would not like to admit that in Limerick now. In those circumstances it will be seen that it was not when the economic war came along that we started this export bounty system.
Comment on this
Are you sure now? Let me remind the Minister of a phrase he used—that if our butter lost a particular flavour because of any trouble that might arise, then this would be necessary. Did the Minister not say that?
Comment on this
I will put it this way, that if our butter lost the Imperial tang it was going to be set back in the British market and this was going to be necessary.
Comment on this
We suggested export bounties before the economic war.
Comment on this
We came in here in the eyes of the British as an anti-British Party, the others being the pro-British Party. That was before the economic war.
Comment on this
The Bill to which I have referred was brought in in March, 1932. I should have mentioned that Deputy McGilligan talked about consignments of butter with a scum on it. I have never heard about butter with a scum on it. Of course the Deputy would hear about something with a scum on it. Neither did I hear about the geese going to Berlin. Somebody is playing a joke on the Deputy.
Comment on this
It must have been, because they know you would believe anything of that sort. Even if the economic war were to stop, that does not mean that export bounties would stop. I believe, with Deputy Anthony, that they would probably be reduced to a great extent, but a number of export bounties would have to remain. I think practically every country has been driven to the policy of export bounties in order to maintain a level price in the case of some of their commodities. Deputy Coburn wants an expression from the President that he could not make a settlement with Great Britain unless he were to lower the dignity of the people of the Irish Free State. As he said he wanted the President, there would be little use if I were to say anything about it. I am quite sure though, that if the President were here, he could give the Deputy that assurance, but I do not think that that would make the Deputy withdraw his support from Deputy Dillon. The Deputy says he believes that the whole trouble is that President de Valera will not give in on the question of the Irish Republic. At the same time he says that Fianna Fáil Deputies are suffering from a sort of sham republicanism. If he is right about the President, then it is no sham. If it is true, as Deputy Coburn says, that the President will not give in on the question of the Irish Republic, that is no sham. It is very serious.
Comment on this
I drew attention to Parliamentary expressions. Will Deputy Smith's expression be allowed?
Comment on this
If Deputies, by interrupting, provoke disagreeable interruptions in reply, the Chair will not take notice of it. Neither Deputy had the right to interrupt when the Minister was on his feet.
Comment on this
What is Parliamentary will be decided by the chair, and not by dictation from any side.
Comment on this
Deputy Bennett said that the admission of poverty is not a crime in this country. It never was. As a matter of fact, it is becoming a virtue with the United Ireland Party. We hear about nothing but the poverty of the people. Deputy Bennett was indignant because I said that down at an auction of his own cattle in Limerick he said that he could pay but would not. I had to look up the Cork Examiner to see what he really did say. I may have wronged him somewhat but he started his speech by saying that the reason his cattle were sold was that he was in a political fight. That was a good start for saying he would not pay his land annuities. He would not pay his land annuities; he was standing behind Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy MacDermot in this political fight in not paying his land annuities. That was the inference and the inference also was that anybody listening to him who wore a blue shirt or was a follower of the United Ireland Party was to resist, as Deputy Bennett did, because he was in a political fight. “His cattle were sold because he did not find it convenient to pay,” according to the Cork Examiner.
Comment on this
Deputy Holohan could not pay his annuities and yet, when his cattle were put up, he went in and bought them. Why did he not pay at first?
Comment on this
It is easier for a man to pay without costs than with costs. I am giving him that advice.
Comment on this
But if you are in a political fight, you must make a protest even though you have to pay costs.
Comment on this
Deputy Bennett stated that he would not say he could not have found the money but there were other people to whom he owed money also. At any rate, his reason was that he was in a political fight. That was the big reason for his not paying his land annuities, led by Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy MacDermot.
Comment on this
Deputy Cosgrave did not disown him in this political fight.
Comment on this
If you are quoting a Deputy's speech, do not add to it and pretend that it is his. Be truthful for once.
Comment on this
I wanted to give the Deputy an opportunity of disowning Deputy Bennett.
Comment on this
I know. That is all very nice, but just try to be truthful, although I know it is a very hard job for that Party, sometimes.
Comment on this
I will not depart from truth. You may be sure of that. Deputy Bennett said in this speech that he would oppose any continuation or extension of bounties. Unqualified opposition! He will not have them at any cost and he is going into the division lobby against this Vote, whether Deputy Dillon leads him into it or not. He will not have any continuation or extension of bounties. When he was asked by Deputy Davin what the farmers would get for their milk, if Deputy Bennett had his way, he said that the cure for all this was to have no economic war, no tariffs, no subsidies and no bounties. That is what the Deputy wants and he represents Limerick constituency. Deputy Davin asked him what would the farmer get for his milk in Limerick during the last year, if he got his way. The price of butter here was 67/- per cwt. and the average expense of working a creamery is 20/- a cwt., which leaves 47/-. It takes two and a half gallons to make a pound of butter, which means that they would be getting 2d. per gallon for their milk.
Comment on this
For goodness' sake, have I to listen to this sort of imbecility again?
Comment on this
I must not forget what Deputy O'Higgins said. I am coming to the calves, as a matter of fact, on the other motion, because I am asked to say more about our policy on cattle.
Comment on this
Deputy Bennett complains also that the ordinary consumers in this country are paying 5d. too much for their butter on account of all the levies and subsidies we have here, and he afterwards said that, to make the thing pay, the farmers in Limerick should be getting 150/- instead of the 102/- they are getting, so that he would not mind asking the consumer to pay 4d. more if he got his way. I quite agree with Deputy Keating that it is very difficult for the farmer to carry on and it did happen, as he said, that the price quoted for bacon in the papers one day was 40/- a cwt., and the day after, when the farmers brought out their pigs, they found it had dropped to 33/-, a fall of 7/-. It is very difficult for a farmer to carry on under those circumstances, but, as Deputies are aware, we are preparing legislation on that matter in order to try to make the price more stable. That Bill was prepared as a result of the work of the tribunal set up to enquire into it. The tribunal was set up as the result of a motion introduced in this House opposing which Deputy Dillon, during Spring Show week, to the delight of his friends in the gallery, made a very brilliant speech and led his Party into the Division Lobby against it. That is another indication that the Party opposite are anxious to promote the interests of the live-stock industry. There is nothing ever done in this House for the benefit of live stock that Deputy Dillon and those with him does not oppose and bitterly oppose. However, in spite of them, we have done these things and we need not thank them for them.
Deputy O'Higgins made his usual speech — common honesty, courage, open diplomacy. The first thing we found after coming into office that was not done by open diplomacy was that Deputy Dr. O'Higgins was getting £600 a year for being nominally on some board in England which was never told to the Irish people.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin wanted to know in regard to the Cattle Act, the number of those who signed the undertaking to pay the fixed price and the number who dishonoured that undertaking. The number who signed was practically 100 per cent. of the exporters in this country—I think only about 7 per cent. refused and said that they could not export cattle at that price. So far it has not been proved definitely that any of those exporters has disobeyed. Some of the export licences have been held up, pending investigation of complaints made, but so far it has not been definitely established against any of them. If it is, of course, the licences will be withdrawn for all time from these exporters. Deputy Davin thinks it would be better if there was a Government organisation set up to deal with the cattle export business. That is a very big question and, I think, a step that no Government would take except as a last resort, and if we are able to compel or induce those cattle exporters to give as fair a price as they can, under ruling conditions, I think we would prefer to leave the matter in their hands, rather than to set up a Government organisation for exporting.
Deputy Brennan asked a question which, I think, would also be better answered on the next debate, as to whether we have taken any steps to end this economic war or to get an increased quota. In connection with the Cattle Act, some other Deputy mentioned that, before the minimum price was fixed, farmers were able to dispose of their cattle at 15/- and 16/- a cwt., but that since the minimum price was fixed, they cannot dispose of them at all. That was said fairly generally both in newspapers and by many people throughout the country, but there is really some fallacy behind that argument, because our butchers are killing all the cattle they require. There is no doubt about that. The export licences are being used to the full, so that we could not dispose of more cattle, either by killing at home or by exporting, if there was no minimum price fixed, than we are able to dispose of at present. If we kill all we can and dispose of all we can under the quota, it is the most we can do, and we have the advantage that those who are selling are, at any rate, getting a minimum price, so far as we know. There may be, as was alleged here, a great deal of evasion of the minimum price. Possibly there is, but Deputies will realise that we, in the Department of Agriculture, are working under a very severe handicap, because we estimated in the beginning that it would take 120 inspectors to get this Act working properly, and these inspectors are not yet available. They are being appointed and will probably be at work within a couple of weeks. They are not, however, yet at their jobs. If they were there, it would make a big difference because they could attend fairs and markets and see the cattle weighed.
Deputy Brennan advocated the dropping of all subsidies and bounties. Of course, there is no subsidy in the ordinary sense on beet. Beet is regulated very much the same as a manufactured product, that is, by protection of the market. By a certain protection duty on sugar coming in, it is possible to produce sugar at home and sell it against the imported article. The price of sugar is regulated in that way and the price of beet is regulated in that way also. There is not a subsidy as understood in this connection, at any rate. There is a bounty paid to the producer of wheat.
Comment on this
If the Deputy regards that as a bounty then practically everything manufactured in the country is getting a bounty.
Comment on this
That is all right if you hold that view, and I would not be surprised if you did hold that view. Deputy Brennan advocated that we should cut out all these subsidies and bounties and let the cattle and everything be exported at whatever price they might get in the British market. He said we should be satisfied with the world price. We would not get the world price in the British market for some of these things, because the British market is itself protected and quotaed and so on, so that in many cases the price there might be higher than the world price and in many cases—it is not lower, of course, but it certainly is as low in the case of butter and other things like that. There was a good lot of talk that more tillage means more live stock, or that more tillage means the present live stock. I thought I had made myself sufficiently clear on that matter last night without having it brought up again. If I have not made myself sufficiently clear it can be dealt with on the next motion.
Deputy Belton said that the country voted twice for the economic war and that we should accept that vote and go on and fight it to the best of our ability. He is evidently a man of sense and intelligence which explains why he has left the Party opposite, because he probably could not stand it. At any rate, I want to refer to the figures he gave. He says that we are withholding from Great Britain £5,000,000 and that according to some return which he saw they have collected £4,500,000. I am not sure if these figures are correct, but I will assume they are. He says that the producers should get the same amount in bounties, that is £4,500,000 instead of the £3,000,000 that we have voted or are voting. He appears to be satisfied that the farmers would be getting what is due to them if £4,500,000 were paid in subsidies and bounties. Of course, he does mention the fact that if the farmers lose the £1,500,000 difference between what they pay on tariffs on the other side and what we pay in bounties here that they are not only losing £1,500,000, but also losing by the reduction in prices here, and might be losing £3,000,000. That is true, of course, if, as I say, his foundation figures are correct. I am not sure if they are correct. I want, however, to put this to Deputy Belton—that we are giving the farmers back more than the £4,500,000, because we are giving £2,000,000 in the reduction of annuities and £3,000,000 in bounties, which amounts to £5,000,000 as against £4,500,000 which Deputy Belton claims they have lost; so that the farmers have gained really. That is, of course, on Deputy Belton's argument.
Comment on this
It is remitted entirely. If a farmer had to go forty years he has still to go forty years with the half; so it is remitted entirely.
Comment on this
The Minister says he gives the farmers that which he never had to give—which was not in existence.
Comment on this
I am very hard set to live myself and I have nothing to give.
Comment on this
It is not. The State has forgiven half the annuities. Did not the Deputy himself offer to do the same at the last election?
Comment on this
Are the Government carrying on the redemption of the sinking fund for the annuities due under the Hogan Land Act?
Comment on this
The half paid is put to wiping out the sinking fund on the lot and to further development of Land Commission work in respect of estates, etc.
Comment on this
It has been stated. Is there a sinking fund in relation to all the annuities payable?
Comment on this
I do not think there is any sinking fund here. There is under the 1923 Act.
Comment on this
You say that if a man was bound to pay off in forty years, if he pays off half he will be finished?
Comment on this
There is sufficient coming in. There are £2,000,000 or so coming in altogether. There is probably due under the 1923 Act—I do not remember the figure—something over £1,000,000.
Comment on this
No. There is under the 1923 Act. That is the Irish people's money. You mean the Suspense Account. There have been a number of matters raised on this Estimate that I shall refer to in the next debate which I hope to continue as soon as this is finished. I have not heard from the other side what this Estimate is to be referred back for. Nobody has stated why it should be referred back.
Comment on this
As the person responsible for the motion to refer back I may say that one of the very many reasons mentioned was to ascertain from the Minister whether Senator Connolly was a rogue or a fool. We have not heard that.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister if he heard the statement read by Deputy O'Sullivan from the Kerry County Committee of Agriculture with regard to the administration of the bounties. They object to the manner in which they are being given. They say they are not reaching the people who rear the cattle. I come from a constituency adjoining Kerry in which the people live in much the same way and I should like to ask the Minister what he is prepared to do on the question of the bounties. Is he not aware that in Cork——
Comment on this
I am asking a question. Is the Minister not aware that in Cork and Kerry two-year-old and three-year-old cattle are being sold at from £1 to 50/-? It is admitted that the export price is the ruling price. As that is the case, is it not a fact that these people are paying on these cattle going into the British market a tariff of £6? Does he not think it unfair that these people should be at such a terrible loss? Does he not see that these people do not get the bounty? It is the people who ship the cattle who get it. I would ask the Minister what he is prepared to do in order to remedy the grievánces of these people.
Comment on this
The Deputy is probably aware that one thing has been done— that is, that firms have been asked to put in plans and specifications and so on, for a tinned and meat extract factory, and they are being told that they must take the cattle from such places as the Kerry hills, the Connemara hills and so on. These are the type of cattle that are to be taken.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Minister the very question which was put to him at first in this debate—is it the Government policy to maintain the cattle industry and to protect the market for that industry? If it is not their intention to maintain the cattle industry, as Senator Connolly says, how are you to dispose of the produce of your tillage, how are you to carry on your tillage policy, how are the people to get the manure which the Minister for Agriculture says is essential for the prosecution of a tillage policy? These questions have not been answered.
Comment on this
I answered them last night. Our policy is to rear as many good cattle as our market can absorb. I am prepared to expand on that when speaking on the next Motion on the Paper, Item No. 14.