We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Imposition of Duties (Confirmation of Orders) (No. 2) Bill, 1934—Committee.

Contributions 1–191 of 381. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Imposition of Duties (Confirmation of Orders)(No. 2) Bill, 1934
Enacted

No. 55 of 1934 ›

There was some discussion on this amendment the other day, and particularly arising out of that discussion the Minister had his notice drawn to the miserable wages paid in the Enniscorthy factory, in the first instance. The second point referred to before the House adjourned was that the conduct of the factory is on alien lines and quite alien to the whole local tradition in County Wexford in respect to the observance of Catholic holidays, which has been the custom in the County Wexford.

Comment on this

I suggest that the management of a particular concern in respect to the matter mentioned by the Deputy should not be raised at this particular point. The point we are discussing is whether duties should be imposed on a certain article of manufacture.

Comment on this

This duty is being imposed for the purpose of preventing the import of razor blades in this country and the development of the manufacture of razor blades here. The Minister has taken all kinds of power to put conditions on all kinds of firms who engage in the manufacture of the articles covered by these duties. The Minister is developing in this country the razor blade industry. He has not given us any satisfactory particulars about the factory in Enniscorthy which is for the manufacture of cheaper razor blades. He suggests that there are to be 100 persons employed but he does not in any way make a case for that. In that particular factory objectionable conditions as regards wages and objectionable conditions as regards working are enforced by the management, who are breaking what is an established social custom and an established religious custom in that county. I think these are reasonable matters for discussion on this section.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has put down an amendment to this section—to delete the Emergency Imposition of Duties (No. 38) Order. The Deputy is quite in order in giving reasons why that duty should not be confirmed. But I suggest that an ex parte statement in this House as to the conditions obtaining in a particular factory is not desirable and should not be given publicity here, possibly without proof. I make that suggestion to the Deputy—that the matter might be inquired into elsewhere.

Comment on this

Both of the statements to which I refer were made in this House on Wednesday's debate when we discussed this matter.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Without impugning or reflecting on the veracity of the Deputy in question that was also a one-sided presentation of the case. I suggest that it would be inadvisable to bring in particulars which might be investigated elsewhere. It is not desirable that a statement of that kind should be made and given publicity under privilege.

Comment on this

Very well, Sir. I will content myself by asking the Minister whether he can give some explanation and whether he can tell us if in granting facilities or giving a licence to establish a razor blade factory in Enniscorthy he has attached any conditions with regard to wages or any conditions with regard to facilities for attending Mass on Catholic holidays?

Comment on this

No licence was issued, to that factory.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say whether the factory is such that it did not require a licence under the Control of Manufactures Act?

Comment on this

The factory is run by a Saorstát citizen?

Comment on this

It is run by a company.

Comment on this

Will the Minister consider making it a condition of the granting of a licence that none of these sharp razor blades will be given to the Blueshirts?

Comment on this

They are sharp enough already.

Comment on this

If Deputy Davin either here or in his fortnightly conversations with the Government would take an interest in the conditions under which persons are employed in the new industries or in any other aspect of the question, such as was suggested as a cause of complaint in the Wexford case, he would be much better employed than in making jokes.

Comment on this

In this particular case the Deputy and certain of his colleagues on the front bench might have more influence than anybody else.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin and his friends have influence, but they do not exercise it.

Comment on this

As regards the making of razor blades, these razor blades might, if the Minister is acquainted with the language I use, be all right for pointing scollops, but hardly for——

Comment on this

Did the Deputy try to use them?

Comment on this

He has not grown a beard.

Comment on this

It was a barber shaved me last time. Has the Minister seen a sample of the razor blade made here and sold at a popular price? Does he know what the quality of the article is? You can get the hoop of a barrel and say you will make a razor blade out of it. Then you can seek a tariff and dump them on the market, but the poor man cannot pay for that razor blade. I agree with the tariffs going on and with the making of the blades here, but we should see that the quality of the article we get approximates to the quality of the article which we have been accustomed to use. Did the Minister take any steps in that direction before he imposed this Order? He knows that I am not speaking against the Order or against his power to make the Order. Since I have come in here, I have felt that the imposition of tariffs by Order has become the rule rather than the exception. I should like to know what steps the Minister took to secure that a reasonably good razor blade would be made here at a reasonable price.

Comment on this

I am not responsible for running this industry or, generally speaking, any industry. If the opportunities are afforded, we expect private enterprise to avail of them. An opportunity is being afforded to people to engage in the manufacture of razor blades and, presumably, if one firm does not take full advantage of that opportunity and put on the market a commodity that will satisfy the public, another firm will. The only question which concerns the Dáil is whether we should impose a duty on razor blades in order to encourage their manufacture here. I am prepared to defend that, but I am not responsible for the manner in which any firm is managed or conducted.

Comment on this

I did not raise that question.

Comment on this

So far as I know, there is no ground for complaint with the product now on sale either in respect of the suitability of these products or their price. In any event, the duty imposed here, working out, as it does, at less than ½d. per blade, will not necessitate anybody growing a beard in order to avoid shaving.

Comment on this

Some of us grow moustaches, or try to do so. The Minister has not dealt with the point I raised. I agree that it is not the Minister's concern to inquire into the affairs of any individual firm unless that firm is in receipt of a trade loan or moneys from some Government Department. The private individual must be allowed to squander his money if he wants to do so, instead of using it for profitable purposes. However, it is not the individual we are concerned with now. A duty is being imposed upon an article which is made here, or about to be made here. In the case of an article which was not made here and on which a duty is to be imposed, I suggest that it would be only ordinary business procedure on the part of the Minister to satisfy himself that a case had been made for the imposition of the duty. In making that case, it should be demonstrated to the Minister that a reasonably good blade would be put on the market. The Minister argues that the duty means only ½d. per blade and that we will not go without a shave because we have to pay 2d. or 2½d. for a blade. I am sure that the Minister does not believe in that argument, that he has a different idea of his duty as a Minister. When he imposes a duty, he imposes it to help industry. If a reasonably good article is not put on the market, we shall have to pay an extra ½d., and this duty, instead of helping an Irish industry, will only provide the Minister for Finance with more revenue. Surely, that is not the object of protection, as conceived by the Government. If it is, I do not think it is a good one. Speaking commercially, I have been looking for good Irish blades, and I have not yet found them. I should like the Minister to give me privately the addresses of people who could provide these blades, because I could put a good deal of business in their way.

Comment on this

The only address I can give you is that of the only firm producing them at the moment.

Comment on this

They are very bad ones.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand part of the Schedule."

Tá 41
·
Níl 21
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 7:—

To delete in page 2, the reference to "The Emergency Imposition of Duties (No. 39) Order, 1934."

This amendment refers to the imposition of duties in the Imposition of Duties Order, No. 39. The Order purports to impose a duty equal to 50 per cent. ad valorem up to the 30th June, 1934, on manufactured hay-forks, manure-forks, potato-forks, digging-forks, and, secondly, on component parts, whether completely or partially manufactured, of any of those types of forks. I asked the Minister, on the 5th December, to give us information as to the total value of the articles imported into the Saorstát in the twelve months ending 30th December, 1933, and in the six months ending June, 1934. The Minister gave no information in reply to that question. He gave no idea as to the extent of the market for these articles in this country. I asked him to say what the revenue anticipated would be as a result of this duty in the first twelve months following the dates on which protection came into operation. The Minister gave no information in regard to that. I asked him the total number of firms engaged in the production of these articles in the Saorstát, and the average number of persons employed. The only information he gave in reply to that was that the matter would be dealt with in the Bill. As to the production of agricultural forks and component parts, he said there is more than one firm established, but the principal one is located in Galway, and is in production. No information, however, as to the number of these factories or their location, or the extent of the employment they give, is given in any of them.

The Order gives power to the Minister to issue licences to persons for the import, without payment of duty, of these articles; and the Minister was asked, on 5th December, for information as to the extent to which licences were issued, and also as to the extent to which licences were refused. Again, the Minister gave no information with regard to that. Now, the imposition of a 50 per cent. duty on articles of this particular kind, used in agricultural work, may be important from the point of view of the process of these articles. We want to know from the Minister to what extent there is an increase in prices; to what extent the duty in that way is fully operative as far as a rise in prices is concerned. We ought to get from the Minister some information as to the extent of the market for these articles, the extent to which there is already an industry in the country; and, further, we ought to get information as to the development the Minister expects in that industry, both in the value of the additional output and of the additional employment that he anticipates will be given in that industry when the effect that he expects from this Order will have fully taken place; and, in the meantime, what is the effect of the Order at the present time.

Comment on this

It is, of course, entirely incorrect to say that I refused to give information concerning the previous imports of these goods or the extent of the market for them here. I told the Deputy what is the fact, that that information is not available. There is no means of ascertaining what the extent of the market is, or what the previous imports were, and full information on that point cannot be ascertained until the existing firms have been in operation for some time supplying the demand, whatever it is, and are able then to speak with authority upon the normal requirements of these goods. Until that has happened, however, there is no means of getting the information. It was not refused to the Deputy. He was told precisely what the position was. The manufacture of these goods has been undertaken in Galway. I have had no complaint whatever concerning either the price or the quality of the goods produced. The prices are competitive, and before the duty was imposed the Department of Agriculture was consulted on the matter, and expressed themselves quite satisfied that the duty should be imposed. I, personally, am quite satisfied that in this industry we have an industry of value, and one that should be fostered.

Comment on this

What does the Minister mean by saying that the prices are competitive?

Comment on this

I mean precisely what the words convey: that the prices are competitive with the prices of similar articles produced anywhere.

Comment on this

With 50 per cent. on?

Comment on this

50 per cent. on does not apply.

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain what he means when he asks us to pass an Order imposing a duty of 50 per cent. and then tells us that it does not apply?

Comment on this

These goods were being made by this concern before the duty was imposed.

Comment on this

What concern?

Comment on this

By the concern in Galway.

Comment on this

Why put on 50 per cent.?

Comment on this

In order to keep out the imported articles.

Comment on this

Why should it come in if the Galway article was competitive and better and cheaper? Is it not obvious that the Galway article was not cheaper than the foreign article? That seems to me to be manifest. The putting on of a tariff may be justified in certain circumstances, I admit, in order to protect a firm, say, in Galway, that was engaged in the manufacture of some agricultural process; but what is the object of a 50 per cent. tariff? Surely the object is to open the way for that company, or for any other company to extract the largest price that it can possibly get out of the agricultural community for these commodities. I should be glad if the Minister, when he is dealing with these duties, would tell us whether this Order applies to the factory that supplied him with fork or shovel handles, or whatever it was that we heard so much about in County Cavan recently; and if so, whether that factory has gone out of production as a result of this tariff or prior to the imposition of this tariff. I think that the House should be informed on these questions and, furthermore, I think that the House should be reluctant to consent to a 50 per cent. tariff on any commodity of daily use in this country unless they are satisfied that it is not going to be used for the purpose of profiteering and in order to pile up more expenses on the backs of the people.

Comment on this

Such a tariff is necessary in order to offset the prejudice against Irish industries which Deputies opposite are fostering in every speech that they make on the subject.

Comment on this

That kind of ramáish deceives nobody.

Comment on this
Donnchadh Ó Briain Donnchadha O Briain Fianna Fáil

"Ramáish" again! It is raméis.

Comment on this

All that they say largely consists of rámaish. One expects it from them. I think, however, that the Minister ought to try to use commonsense and discharge his common duty to this House. His duty is to tell us why it is necessary to put a 50 per cent. tariff on an article produced in the country already, and whether its object is to give that company an opportunity of extracting approximately the entire amount of that tariff from the agricultural community. No doubt, the Minister will reply that he is doing it in order to secure that a profitable industry will be set up so as to secure a living wage for everybody engaged in it. But if it is going to provide a wage of £2 a week at the expense of the agricultural labourers, who, his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, says ought to be able to get along on 6d. an hour, or 27s. a week, for a 54 hour week, it is time that Deputies there should realise that and should realise that while it may be desirable and necessary to put on tariffs in certain circumstances, it is neither necessary, desirable nor just to secure 40s. or 45s. a week for labourers in the City of Galway at the expense of labourers in rural areas, who, their agricultural spokesman, the Minister for Agriculture, says, ought to be able to get along well enough at 27s. a week for a 54 hour week. Let justice be done on both sides. It is a monstrous thing to be driving the agricultural community and the agricultural labourers in this country down into destitution, and at the same time to be piling up on their backs further expenses in order to provide fair rates of wages for the workers in the city.

Comment on this

Does not the Deputy think that there was an obligation on him to make some inquiry as to the real facts of the case before coming in here and making this charge against a private firm—that they were engaging in profiteering and exploiting the agricultural labourers? The Deputy should make some inquiries before making such a charge. I notice that the members of his Party have had the grace to stay out of the House while he is making these speeches. The Deputy, as usual, is completely wrong in what he says, and there is no foundation whatever for the speech he has delivered. I suggest that if he is a member of a responsible Party, he should do what commonsense and justice would dictate: get some information from some reliable source before making these charges. He did not attempt to do that. He never does. I am quite certain that he need not have put himself to any trouble to find out the facts, because any Galway member of his Party could have given him the necessary information to prevent him making a fool of himself.

Comment on this

We had better get this straight. The Minister, whenever he is driven into a corner, always tries to kick up a row. That is his great refuge. He prays that the public will forget the net point that he was called upon to answer, and that he is unable to answer. This is the procedure that is at present being followed: there is to be a scene in Dáil Eireann in which the Minister for Industry and Commerce attacks Mr. Dillon. "Truth in the News" is to come out in the morning with grand headlines and the essential point is to be forgotten. The essential point is this: the Minister is putting a tariff on to start an industry.

Comment on this

That is the first point on which the Deputy is wrong.

Comment on this

Then the Minister is putting on a tariff to preserve an industry. The Minister will not undertake to preserve the industry at the expense of the public unless he is satisfied that fair wages are being paid in that industry. The Minister will agree with that. The Minister will agree with me, too, that £2 a week is not, to say the least of it, an excessive wage for factory operatives working a full week.

Comment on this

Is that the Deputy's information that £2 a week is being paid?

Comment on this

I am not asking the Minister to assent or dissent from his proposal. What I am asking him to do is to assent or dissent from my proposal.

Comment on this

What has £2 a week got to do with this proposal?

Comment on this

Does the Minister consider that £2 a week is a fair wage for factory operatives in this country?

Comment on this

What has that got to do with it?

Comment on this

I take it that the Minister is protecting the industry on the condition that the industry pays fair wages. I notice that the Labour Benches are empty. They are conveniently withdrawn.

Comment on this

Your own were empty too. That one did not come off.

Comment on this

The Minister contends that a factory or an industry protected at his instance must pay fair wages. Will the Minister contend that £2 a week is an excessive wage?

Comment on this

What has that got to do with this?

Comment on this

Will the Minister contend——

Comment on this

Will the Deputy contend that the moon is blue?

Comment on this

The Minister does not negative the contention?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is not under cross-examination. Neither is the Deputy, and that fact should be realised.

Comment on this

The Minister, fortunately, is not under cross-examination. I hope to expose his latest attempt to draw a red herring across the floor of the House. The Minister holds himself out as an apostle of fair wages, and I fix a fair wage for factory operatives, working a full week, at not less than £2 a week. I do not know whether the Minister wants to have a lower rate of wages, but we shall assume that he assents to my proposal. I object to laying a burden on the backs of the agricultural community——

Comment on this

What burden?

Comment on this

——in order to secure those wages for the operatives in that factory, so long and only so long as the Minister's colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, says that for a similar 48-hour week the agricultural labourer, who is going to use the fork, is only entitled to 24/- a week. That seems to be a perfectly plain, simple case. When I make that case to the Minister he gets up and says that Deputy Dillon attacks an industrialist in Galway and charges him with being a profiteer. I might use a nasty word to describe that misrepresentation. All I will say is that the Minister is either so stupid or so deaf that he did not hear what I said. I made no reference at all to the profits of the enterprise in Galway. I made reference only to the fair wages condition which the Minister presumably exacted before he undertook to protect the industry. I repeat that it is not justice that fair wages of £2 a week should be exacted for the operatives of Galway from a community of people whom the Minister for Agriculture says are entitled to no more than 24/- a week for a working week of the same duration. Now that is a dilemma to which I invite the attention of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and that is the question he has got to answer.

Comment on this

The Deputy has asked no question at all. He knows nothing whatever about the conditions prevailing in this industry in Galway. He does not know if there has been an increase in price and, I am sure, will be surprised to learn that there has been a decrease. The Deputy's method is to assume a number of facts, about which he knows nothing and which I may say are all incorrect, and then proceed to base an elaborate argument on that. That is typical of him. My advice to him again is that before committing himself to public utterances here on any question of public importance, he should try to find out something about it. There are other members of his Party who could have given him information on it. As I have said, if he had got the information he would have the wit, I think, to say nothing here this evening.

Comment on this

Is not the man paying fair wages?

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

In regard to price. If this man is manufacturing at a price lower than that at which these things can be imported, what is the necessity of putting on a tariff of 50 per cent.?

Comment on this

I told the Deputy.

Comment on this

If the Minister desires to attempt to put it over on the House that he would be justified in putting on a tariff of 50 per cent. in order to off-set the prejudice against Irish industry in this country, he is simply fooling the House, and the House knows it. That is the kind of stuff that might be good enough for a secondary school debating society, but it ought not be good enough for the Minister for Industry and Commerce in Dáil Eireann, because it is manifestly untrue, to begin with.

Comment on this

That there is a prejudice against the products of Irish industry?

Comment on this

That the Minister has to pretend, in justification for putting on a tariff of 50 per cent., that it is to counter the prejudice that exists in this country against Irish manufacture. No such prejudice exists in any part of the country to my knowledge, and these are commodities, hay forks, etc., in which I have been trading for many years. Where supplies are available from Irish sources it is both more convenient and desirable from every point of view to get them here than to import them. In certain circumstances, as I have already said, it might be legitimate to put on a modest tariff in order to compete against American and British products, which are produced on mass production lines. The Minister has made no case at all for the imposition of this 50 per cent. tariff.

Comment on this

Then vote against it.

Comment on this

We are now at amendment No. 7, and I just want to draw the attention of the House to this, that there are 13 amendments on the Order Paper to this Bill. The first and, of course, the last, are in the name of Deputy Dillon, and the remaining 11 in the name of Deputy Mulcahy. I submit that there is not the slightest substance in any of them. They have been put down as sheer obstruction and nothing else.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputies were entitled to table these amendments.

Comment on this

We have just had from the last speaker a sample of the Ministerial tactics in this matter. The Minister for Industry and Commerce puts on a tariff of 50 per cent. on a certain number of articles as set out in the Order, and then comes to the House and asks us to pass that duty.

Comment on this

Is not the Deputy in favour of protection?

Comment on this

We are in favour of Irish industrial development, but we submit that a sheaf of importation orders and of quota orders or stuff of that kind that will afterwards go into the wastepaper basket is no substitute for Irish industrial development.

Comment on this

Do you want the Minister to stop in his activities?

Comment on this

We want him to tell us what else there is in this question of Irish industry with regard to these forks other than that bit of paper that I hold in my hand.

Comment on this

My remark was intended to convey that that is your attitude to everything.

Comment on this

I would like the Deputy to assist us in finding out whether it is reasonable for the Minister to come before the House and say "Pass that Order." When he is asked what is the extent of the market for these things he says he does not know.

Comment on this

I think that is what he really ought to do.

Comment on this

Ought to do what?

Comment on this

Put them through or bludgeon them through.

Comment on this

This is Ministerial policy.

Comment on this

Minorities have no rights.

Comment on this

Deputy Donnelly says minorities have no rights.

Comment on this

We never had any, none whatever.

Comment on this

We have seen an instance to-day of majorities having no rights when they are told by their Front Benchers to shut up. We have also seen a kind of second line of the majority Party being told that they have no rights when they are made to shut up. We discussed the condition of the agricultural industry and the financial position of local bodies——

Comment on this

Not on this motion.

Comment on this

Not on this motion. But the Labour Party were then told to shut up. The Ministerial Benches were told to shut up.

Comment on this

There was a lot of good advice going round if you listened to it.

Comment on this

Now we have the Ministerial benches coming to the rescue of the Minister. They want to impose on the Opposition Party, whose help they say they want so very much, the same type of silence as is imposed on themselves. We here are interested in industrial development and we are questioning the Minister on these points. We know that the only decent industrial development that has taken place here since the new Government came into power has been on foundations solidly laid by the last Government. We think it unreasonable that the agricultural community should be asked to face this tariff of 50 per cent. without being told something about it. All we are told is that the Minister does not know the extent of the market here and that he does not know the extent to which forks of this kind came into the country in the past. He says that there are more firms than one in Ireland making forks, but would he tell us in what county they are? Would he tell us what employment is given in them and what is the total production? The Minister has apparently some information in regard to it. We should have as much information as the Minister can give us.

Comment on this

I have given it.

Comment on this

The Minister has mentioned Galway. He has put one spot on the map. Outside that we do not know how many firms are making these forks. We do not know what the production has been or what the number of employees is. The Minister has not given us the slightest suggestion as to what increased employment will be created. The Minister simply draws a veil over the whole question. He does not tell us whether the Order is operative at the present time. We infer that it is fully operative. We infer that no licences have been issued to import these articles without duty. We are left to infer all that, but when the Minister is asked specifically about it, he does not tell us. All we know now is that the duty is being imposed.

Comment on this

As I said before, the Deputy wants a prophet and not a Minister.

Comment on this

The Minister may be vacating the position of being a prophet. Like the Minister for Education he may be repudiating his former prophecies. It is not asking the Minister to act as a prophet when we ask that in introducing this Order, he should give us some general statement on the position, give us whatever facts he has and indicate that in some way he has examined the position. The Minister has said nothing that would indicate that he has examined the position. All that we are left to infer is that he is approached by a certain number of people who say: "We are running a particular line and we want a tariff on these goods" and the Minister says "Here is your tariff, I will cover up your tracks, I will give them no more information than I gave them in respect of other things."

Comment on this

What are the Deputy's reasons for not imposing the tariff?

Comment on this

My reason for opposing is that the Minister has clapped on the tariff and has given no information as to the present position, no evidence that he has examined the position at all or that this tariff is imposed as a result of his examination of it.

Comment on this

Might I suggest to the Deputy that his Government refrained from putting a tariff on these goods for ten years without examining the position?

Comment on this

The Minister takes up the attitude that people who oppose these things are opposed to Irish industrial development. I tell the Minister what he already knows, that any decent Irish development that has come about has been raised on foundations which were securely laid by us.

Comment on this

I want to ask the Minister this simple question and I want an answer to it. When this question of hay forks first engaged his attention and he first excogitated the question of whether he would impose a duty under an Emergency Imposition of Duties Order, somebody must have come to him and said "We can produce these hay forks at such a price. They cost so much to produce abroad." Somebody must have said to him "Hay forks cost so much to produce in Ireland and so much to produce abroad. To secure that Irish firms will get a monopoly of the market such and such a tariff is necessary." Can he give us, from that information, what approximately the cost of production of hay forks in Ireland is and what the cost of production was heretofore, free to quay, Galway or North Wall? Has the Minister got that information?

Comment on this

If the Minister has not got that information, or if he will not say whether he has or has not it, he could perhaps tell us in what other county besides Galway are these forks being manufactured. He has said there is more than one factory established but that the principal one is located in Galway.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

Column 599, Official Report of the 5th December, 1934:

"The factory for the production of razor blades was established in Enniscorthy and is at present in production. As to the production of agricultural forks and component parts, there is more than one factory established but the principal one is located in Galway and is in production."

Comment on this

It is only in Galway that complete manufacture has been undertaken up to the present.

Comment on this

That is not a correct statement then. Will the Minister say whether, in imposing this duty, he had in his mind other counties, not to be too specific, where he hoped or had reason to believe that the manufacture of these forks would be begun?

Comment on this

Again the Deputy is asking me to appear before him in the role of prophet. I am aware that other people are considering the manufacture of these goods and, in fact, a very large number of external firms have applied for licences to manufacture these goods, but the only firm that is in production for the complete manufacture of these articles is located in Galway.

Comment on this

Was there not another firm in Cavan?

Comment on this

The Deputy's information about that particular matter is as incorrect as his information about most other matters.

Comment on this

Was there ever such a firm in Cavan?

Comment on this

There was not.

Comment on this

For the manufacture of broom handles.

Comment on this

If the Deputy had studied the Encyclopaedia Britannica and other well-known sources of information he would have discovered that broom handles are not made in a fork factory.

Comment on this

We were told they were making fork handles.

Comment on this

The Minister is only prepared to refer to the Galway factory. The Galway factory has branched out into this particular line of industry because it was a factory that existed before for making other agricultural implements. In his survey of the position before he imposed the tariff did the Minister ascertain that there were in the country any other factories of the nature of the factory that was then in Galway? Will the Minister say, if he found factories of that particular kind, in what counties he found them?

Comment on this

Quite a number. There is the Galway foundry, and there are foundries in almost every county.

Comment on this

But the Minister is not in a position to say that he hopes for the development of the manufacture of these in any other county?

Comment on this

My hope is that all our requirements in forks and implements of this kind will be manufactured in Ireland efficiently and cheaply.

Comment on this

Perhaps the hope is as general as the Minister's remarks?

Comment on this

Perhaps already it has been realised.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted, stand."

Tá 39
·
Níl 22
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 8:—

To delete in page 2, the reference to "The Emergency Imposition of Duties (No. 40) Order, 1934."

This is the Order which imposes a duty of 30 per cent. ad valorem on machines which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are completely or substantially assembled and are designed, constructed and suitable for the automatic sale, by means of the operation of a mechanism set in motion by the insertion of a coin in the machine, of all or any of the following articles, whether exclusively or in addition to other articles, namely, tobacco in any form, matches, sweetmeats, including chocolates in any form, and articles which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are substantial assemblies or parts of any such machines as described in the foregoing. In connection with this, too, the Minister was asked if, in regard to the imposition of this duty, he would tell us the value of these articles imported during the 12 months ended 31st December, 1933, and the six months ended 30th June, 1934, and the Minister gave no information. He gives no information as to the value of these articles that are taken annually into the country.

He was asked if he would state the total number of firms engaged in the manufacture of these articles; the employment they gave; and the extent to which licences had been issued for the purpose of admitting these articles free of the duty he imposed. Again, I ask the Minister if he considers it reasonable to impose a duty like this and to give no information, good, bad or indifferent, as to the circumstances existing in the country which induce him to impose this duty or the circumstances which he hopes to bring about in the country.

Comment on this

The duty in this case was imposed on general principles. A number of these automatic machines were coming in and it was felt that the firms concerned should be encouraged to do the assembling of them here. There is no information as to the value of the importation in previous years and nobody has yet started assembling.

Comment on this

So that the position at the present time is that the Minister imposes a revenue duty on these articles coming in here, but he does not see any prospect of the development of an industry here arising out of his action.

Comment on this

I have not said that. I said that nobody has yet started assembling these machines.

Comment on this

Was there any consultation with interested parties prior to the imposition of this duty by Order?

Comment on this

No. When I say no, I should like to qualify it by saying that interested parties, to wit, traders in various towns of the Saorstát, have for years been agitating for the prohibition of automatic machines altogether, but the Order made here would permit, of course, the utilisation of automatic machines, either machines imported subject to duty or machines assembled here on which no duty was paid.

Comment on this

Observe that it is very important to cross-examine the Minister on an Imposition of Duty Order, because we were told first that this Order was made in pursuance of general policy, to promote the manufacture or assembly of anything in this country that can be sold. We then pressed for further particulars, and we now discover that the purpose for which this Order was made was to prevent the use of automatic machines in rural towns.

Comment on this

I said nothing of the kind.

Comment on this

At least the Minister said this, that that weighed with him in making the Order.

Comment on this

I said nothing of the kind.

Comment on this

The Minister just mentioned that fact for the fun of mentioning it. It had no particular relevance at all to the Order in question.

Comment on this

I mentioned that fact in the vain hope of giving the Deputy some information, the value of which he would appreciate.

Comment on this

The fact is that the Minister made an entirely irrelevant observation. He might just as well have said that pigs have not wings——

Comment on this

A most intelligent remark. Now we are getting on—pigs definitely have not wings.

Comment on this

We have now subsided, I take it? The Minister might just as well have said that pigs have not wings as to inform us at this juncture that the rural shopkeeper wanted to exclude these automatic machines——

Comment on this

Does the Deputy remember the question he asked me?

Comment on this

——because he hurries on to observe that that factor did not weigh with him at all in imposing this duty. Of course, it is manifest that it did weigh with him when he imposed the duty, and it now transpires that the duty was imposed for a purpose entirely other than that which he first suggested to the House. I invite the Minister to make up his mind as to why he did impose it——

Comment on this

Just to give the Deputy an opportunity of making a speech.

Comment on this

——in order that we can make up our minds as to whether it ought to be confirmed or not.

Comment on this

Apparently, from what we have now ascertained from the Minister, the proposal in this Order is neither fish nor flesh, but just a good red herring. He is drawing a red herring across the track of his inability to make up his mind as to what he wants to do. This is supposed to be Irish industrial development and he does not know whether it is simply revenue he is making; whether he is putting a stop to the use of automatic machines; or whether he is developing an Irish manufacturing or assembling industry here. It is no wonder that when the subject of Irish industrial development is approached by the Minister in that nebulous state of mind, he is not able to come before the House and, with each Emergency Imposition of Duty Order, give us a clear statement of his intention or his hopes.

Comment on this

I just say that this is the type of thing we like to do, because it is something in respect of which we cannot lose. Either the machines will not be imported, which I think is all to the good; or we get revenue, which is equally good; or we get some employment in assembling them, which is also good.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 39
·
Níl 23
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 9:—

To delete, in page 2, "The Emergency Imposition of Duties (No. 44) Order, 1934."

In the first place, this Order imposes a duty on all tanks, cisterns, drums, barrels and kegs which are made wholly or mainly of iron or steel or a combination of iron and steel; are of a cylindrical or elliptical shape; have a capacity of not less than three gallons, nor more than 50 gallons, and are imported empty. The rate of duty is equal to 33? per cent. of the value of the article. Secondly, it imposes a duty on all other tanks, cisterns, drums, barrels and kegs made wholly or mainly of iron or steel, or a combination of iron and steel, and imported empty. The rate of duty here amounts to 15 per cent. of the value of the article. In the third place, it imposes a duty on component parts (made wholly or mainly of iron or steel, or a combination of iron and steel) of any such tanks, cisterns, drums, barrels or kegs as are mentioned in either of the foregoing paragraphs, at a rate equal to 15 per cent. of the value of the article.

We endeavoured to get from the Minister some information as to the market for these things, the extent to which they were imported during the last 1½ years, the extent to which they are being manufactured here, and what exactly is the licensing position. The Minister has given no information in reply to the questions asked him. I want to know what the purpose of the Order is.

Comment on this

The purpose of the Order is to increase the existing rate on cylindrical metal drums, the best known of which, I think, are the ordinary tar drums. The duty has been increased because the manufacture of these goods on a mass production scale has been undertaken in Dublin by a very well-known firm which is capable of supplying all the requirements of the country. There is no information as to previous importations of these goods because they were not listed separately in our import list. On that account it is not possible to state with accuracy what the market is. In any event the market varies considerably from year to year. The position is that a well-known factory is turning out these goods in whatever quantities they may be required, and considerable additional employment is given on that account. The purpose of the duty is to discourage the import of these things.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say how many persons are employed in the production of these goods at present? He says that the consumption varies considerably from year to year. Will he say what is likely to be the effect of that, or the employment that will be given here? What is the position with regard to the issuing of licences to import these goods at present without duty?

Comment on this

The Minister has mentioned that these drums are principally used for containing tar. I do not think there is any Customs duty on tar.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say if there have been any imports of tar in the past, and if the increased price of containers would put tar produced in this country at a disadvantage as compared with tar from foreign sources, in cheaper containers?

Comment on this

I do not think there was any tar imported, worth talking of. Most of the tar is got at home, and is, as Deputies are aware, a by-product of gas works. We have certain production which is probably all that we require. It is not possible to state with any accuracy the number of people engaged in the concern manufacturing these drums, as they make a very large number of other goods. In case of fluctuation in demand that would not mean less employment for those in the concern, as individuals would be put from one process to another, as demand fluctuated. The equipment installed in the factory for the production of these goods is as up to date as that in any part of the world, and is on a mass production basis. I do not think it is correct to assume that there will be any higher cost of production here, other than the cost of raw materials which may be somewhat higher.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say how soon production will keep up to requirements?

Comment on this

I have no reason to believe that the firm concerned is not capable of meeting all requirements at present. Licences are not being issued under this Order, except occasionally for some odd article of special design, or intended for a special purpose, or of such a description that it could not be manufactured here.

Comment on this

In fact, the duty applies now as far as the ordinary type of cylinder is concerned, and yet the Minister is not in a position to tell us about the increased amount of employment that will be given, or that there is not a rise in prices, as a result of the imposition of the duty.

Comment on this

There has been a considerable increase of employment, but I could not say the exact number.

Comment on this

Has the manufacture of a 2-gallon cistern been attempted at all, so that it could be used instead of the 3-gallon cistern, which has always been used here?

Comment on this

In relation to the cistern the Deputy has referred to, the Order does not impose any increase of duty. Theoretically there is a decrease from 22½ per cent. to 15 per cent. The duty on these goods has been 22½ per cent., with a preferential rate of 15 per cent. In future there will be a flat rate of 15 per cent. on these articles. It has not been varied in the Order.

Comment on this

In view of a possible water shortage, would not the question of having a 2-gallon instead of a 3-gallon cistern be worth taking up and pushing on, as has been done extensively elsewhere?

Comment on this

Do I understand that this Order covers cisterns used in connection with the water system attached to houses?

Comment on this

It does not increase the duty. It decreases it. There has been a duty of 22½ per cent., with a preferential rate of 15 per cent. on all cisterns. The duty is increased on cylindrical tanks and made a flat rate on all such containers.

Comment on this

That still leaves us with an important question unanswered —the amount of employment that will be given by the Order. The Minister says that a considerable amount will be given. What about the difference in price, brought about as a result of the imposition of the Order.

Comment on this

I do not anticipate that there will be any difference in price.

Comment on this

Apparently there is.

Comment on this

I say that subject to this qualification, which must always be made in relation to industries of this kind, where imported raw materials must be used, that there may be higher raw material costs for concerns here than for concerns abroad. But the process of manufacture need not be any higher. in fact, it is possible that the cost of production here is somewhat lower than in other concerns. The most up-to-date method of production has been installed.

Comment on this

Nevertheless, the position is that, together with the inquiries made by the Minister, he had three months' operation of the Order before carrying on discussions with the people manufacturing these goods. Yet he cannot give the information asked for.

Comment on this

I have given the Deputy a large amount.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 38
·
Níl 22
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 10:—

To delete in page 2, the reference to "The Emergency Imposition of Duties (No. 45) Order, 1934."

This Order imposes a Customs duty at the rate of 75 per cent. ad valorem on all electric filament lamps consuming not more than 500 watts, but excluding electric filament lamps which are, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, designed, constructed, and intended for use in hand lamps energised from a dry battery, or for use exclusively for scientific or for medical or surgical purposes. The Minister was asked to state in this case the value of the electric lamps imported into the country during the 12 months ending December 31st, 1933, and for the six months ending 30th June, 1934. He said he cannot give the House this information. He cannot tell the country from which these lamps were imported. We are told the Order is a completely new Order. The Minister was asked if he would state the total number of firms engaged in the manufacture of these articles, the average number of persons employed, and he has not given us the information under this head either. The Minister has been asked what is the position with regard to the licensing arrangement. He was asked if there is a free importation of electric lamps at the present time, and whether there is anything in his Order which would warrant the rise in the price of electric lamps. The duty is a very considerable duty. The suggestion is that it is a prohibitive duty in order to allow of the development of the manufacture of electric lamps here for the fuller requirements of the country. We have not been told anything about that either. Again, I say it is absurd to put a proposal before the House without such information. We expect some facts from the Minister as to what the actual situation is and what he expects will be the result of it.

Comment on this

It is not possible to state precisely what were the imports in previous years in the matter of electric films and electric lamps which are made subject to this duty. Nor is it possible to state precisely what the annual requirement in lamps is to be. Nobody has as yet manufactured these lamps. At present the normal requirements are imported free of duty, under licence. There is consequently no occasion for a rise in the price nor will there be after the duty has become operative. The concern which is erecting the factory for their production has agreed that their products will be sold at the standard price now prevailing. It is anticipated that the firm will come into production early in the New Year and the duties will become operative simultaneously. It is not possible to say exactly the number of persons who will be employed, but the number will not be inconsiderable and may possibly increase as the manufacture is extended to other classes of lamps than those which are now being made the subject of duty.

Comment on this

I should like to get some information from the Minister on this matter. I do not know if he has already issued licences. Perhaps he may tell me if he has issued licences or given a right to any firm to manufacture these lamps? Perhaps he would also tell us if a loan has been granted to the firm which proposes to make these lamps?

Comment on this

No licence to manufacture these lamps is required by a Saorstát company. The company which is now about to manufacture is entitled to manufacture without a licence. No licence has been issued to anybody to manufacture these lamps, nor, so far as I am aware, has any financial assistance been given.

Comment on this

Does the Minister tell us that a tax of 75 per cent. will not make lamps, bulbs, etc., dearer?

Comment on this

What I said was that the company had given an undertaking in respect to the sale of lamps. If that undertaking were departed from I think the Government would have to consider removing the duty or they would take some other method of dealing with the question.

Comment on this

Does the Minister suggest that a tax of 75 per cent., which is a prohibitive duty, as he already said himself, is to be put on the taxpayers of Ireland and that nothing but the word of the firm is to be given to the people of Ireland that the price will not be increased.

Comment on this

I think it is quite good enough.

Comment on this

What assurance will the people of Dublin and the people of Ireland have? We are talking about a brighter Dublin and a brighter Ireland. What assurance have we that a brighter Dublin and a brighter Ireland will not cost us more?

Comment on this

I have told the Deputy, on the one hand, that there is an undertaking given by the manufacturers and, on the other hand, the control is in our own hands and not in theirs. If that undertaking given by the firm is departed from to the prejudice of the public interest measures can be taken to remedy the situation.

Comment on this

Who decides on the methods to be adopted or the procedure to be taken?

Comment on this

The Government in office from time to time.

Comment on this

On what grounds?

Comment on this

On the grounds of commonsense.

Comment on this

Commonsense there means that the people of Dublin and Ireland will have to pay the 75 per cent. tariff.

Comment on this

Is it not 75 per cent.?

Comment on this

There is this tariff of 75 per cent. on electric bulbs simply because the Government in control at the time think they should do it. There is no explanation from the Front Bench as to why or how or when——

Comment on this

Or where.

Comment on this

——this can be controlled?

Comment on this

There will be no increase in prices.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister is trifling with the House. The establishment of an electric lamp industry is important for this country. But does the Minister ask anyone who was ever inside an electric lamp factory to accept his assurances here that a number of Irishmen are to set up an electric lamp factory here and that they are not going to raise the prices? The Minister tells us that there is going to be considerable employment here and that that is why he is clapping on the 75 per cent. Surely the Minister is trifling with this House and trifling with the people of the country who require the lamps. He is also trifling with the men who are putting Irish capital into an industry who, if I understand the Minister properly, are putting Irish capital alone into this industry. I expect to hear from the Minister something as to the technical tradition of the people who are going to establish and develop this industry here.

Comment on this

They are the bright lights of industry.

Comment on this