Imposition of Duties (Confirmation of Orders) (No. 2) Bill, 1934—Committee.
Contributions 192–381 of 381. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 55 of 1934 ›
Can the Minister tell us anything more? He tells us now that they are the "bright lights" of industry. Can the Minister tell us what foreign firm is assisting in the matter and what experience or guidance gained in other countries is going to be at the disposal of the people who are putting Irish capital into this factory and which is going to be at the disposal of the people who are to pay for the products of this company?
Comment on this
These are not matters for the Dáil. If I were to give the Dáil information on a matter of that kind I would be abusing my position. It is open to anybody to manufacture lamps in this country at the moment provided they are qualified and provided they put up the money for the purpose themselves. If a particular concern proceeds to do it, it is a matter for themselves what arrangements they make to get the technical assistance or to get into communication with firms engaged in this industry. The one point on which we have to be satisfied is that they will supply us, in accordance with their undertakings, with lamps as good as we are getting at present and at no higher price. Let me say—this is a matter the Deputy might consider— that I had considerable questioning in my mind before I was satisfied with a mere undertaking not to increase the prices because, in the circumstances of this industry one might have expected a decrease in price when the manufacture was undertaken here. The Deputy, apparently, had no objection over a number of years to paying whatever price was charged for these lamps without any inquiry as to whether that price was justified or not.
Comment on this
Dealing with such an ignorant class of people as the Minister is dealing with when dealing with us, will he help us to understand what is being done by giving us some of the reasons which he considers should bring about a decrease in the cost of lamps before he asks us, as he is apparently asking in this Order, to increase the price of lamps by 75 per cent.?
Comment on this
I am not asking anybody to increase the price of lamps. I am telling the Deputy that this duty is imposed and will be maintained so long as the price of lamps is not increased.
Comment on this
This duty has been in force for some time. Surely the House is entitled to consider whether, during that period, the Government is entitled to tax the people to that extent.
Comment on this
I have had no complaint or allegation from any source that anyone requiring electric lamps has had any difficulty in getting them in free of duty.
Comment on this
How does the Minister propose to satisfy himself as to quality? I observe that the Minister, on the first occasion on which he spoke on this amendment, said there would be no increase in price. At a later stage, he said there would be no increase in price and no decrease in quality. That is a very important consideration, because, in a commodity like an electric lamp, the price consists of two elements—one, the quality, and the other the money asked for the lamp. It is quite easy for anybody to set up in this country and manufacture lamps of a kind at a reasonable price and then manufacture other lamps at a much higher price, these latter being efficient lamps. I should like the Minister to make quite clear that the object he has in view in granting this tariff is to secure that lamps of an efficiency equal to those at present imported will be manufactured here at a price reasonably near that at which we are importing at the present time. If the Minister is prepared to give us that guarantee, I do not see what justification he has for imposing a tariff of 75 per cent. Let us assume that, owing to the special circumstances obtaining in the Free State, it would be impossible to manufacture efficient electric lamps as cheaply as they are manufactured in Great Britain or the U.S.A. or Holland. Let us assume that it would cost 15 per cent. more to manufacture these lamps in Saorstát Eireann than it would to manufacture them abroad, and that we want to give the home manufacturer an ample margin in order to reassure him and induce him to invest the requisite capital in the factory and machinery. Let us add, therefore, to that 15 per cent., actual difference in cost, 10 per cent. in order to give him a wide margin of security. If that course be pursued, there is comparatively little danger of the price rising unduly, because, if an attempt were made by an Irish manufacturer to exploit the home market, the corrective tendency of the duty-paid imports would manifest itself immediately. Under this system, we are creating a system whereby the manufacturer in years to come may push the price up or leave the price stationary long after he ought to have reduced it. The 75 per cent. tariff will continue to protect him to an extent far in excess of what the Minister for Industry and Commerce hoped for from the very beginning. To that objection, the Minister for Industry and Commerce will reply: "You can go to the Prices Commission." I think that the Minister for Industry and Commerce is beginning to realise now that reference to the Prices Commission is a very unsatisfactory procedure and that the consumer very rarely gets satisfaction from it. More and more, as time goes on, that will prove to be the case. More and more, as time goes on, this tariff will be made the excuse for a variety of interests in the trade to exploit the consumer in the country.
I put it to the Minister that the imposition of tariffs of these dimensions, far from serving the best interests of Irish industry, are doing it a serious injury for two reasons. One reason is that it sets a premium on incompetence. There is no urge on the man operating behind a 75 per cent. tariff to make himself as efficient as possible, because there is no threat of competition, proximate or remote. The second reason is that the public mind of this country, when the first fervour of economic nationalism has passed away, will begin to ask itself why Irish manufacturers want to operate behind a 75 per cent. tariff. The man in the street will answer that question to his own satisfaction by saying that either the Irish manufacturers are incompetent or they want to exploit the consumer. The men with whom I am acquainted in Irish industry desire to do neither the one thing nor the other. They want to compete freely against the mass production methods of Japan, Czecho-Slovakia and countries of that kind, and to sell their commodities in competition with commodities manufactured under similar conditions elsewhere. If the conditions are different, we should correct that difference by a modest tariff, and the Irish manufacturer and the foreign manufacturer should have an even start. In every case where that policy has been pursued in the industrial development of this country, the Irish manufacturer has more than held his own. When the boot industry was first protected here, the tariff was, I think, 15 per cent. Under that tariff, there grew up a prosperous, thriving, solidly-founded boot industry.
Comment on this
It developed over a period of years and produced an article that compared with anything that could be imported from anywhere else in the world. They were pushed to that measure of efficiency and success by the constant threat of competition. On that foundation, the Minister, by increasing tariffs, has sought to create a larger development. I seriously apprehend that, far from serving the boot industry, the extravagant system of tariffs at present in operation in that industry will do it an injury in the long run. I admit freely that, at the moment, these mushroom industries are making money, but, in the long run, I believe this system will react against the efficiency of the industries and the excellence of their products, because they will be virtually delivered from competition of any kind. That is a bad system. Every one of the industries that grew up in this country under a low tariff system, only sufficient to protect them from unfair competition, was solidly founded and secured. It is upon these foundations that the present Minister for Industry and Commerce is at present endeavouring to build. If Deputies will consider the matter they will find that in every industry where there is a genuine increase in employment—and they are comparatively few—since the present Minister took charge, it is in those which were founded on a modest tariff basis, and if these industries are now reacting to the tariffs it is due to the manner in which their foundations were laid. If that policy of building only when solid foundations were laid, had been continued, there would be every hope for raising solid structures on such foundations. 75 per cent. of an impost on lamps the Minister can justify, if, as he says, there is no increase in price of the article produced. I think it would be better to have a modest impost on lamp filaments which would give competent Irish manufacturers ample security to compete with foreigners, and not build, from the economic point of view, an inefficient industry which would be no credit either to the occupists or the capitalists.
Comment on this
I wonder if Deputy Dillon has considered every factor in making a case for what he called modest tariffs. I wonder how many people would be induced to embark on the manufacture of filament lamps if they were simply offered a modest tariff. Has the Deputy taken into account that there are combines and rings in connection with the manufacture of filament lamps, and that any of those rings need only order a small reduction in price to wipe out the modest tariff awarded to such a new industry? When Deputy Dillon made that general statement with regard to the establishing of industries in this State, did he realise that there is no such thing as reasonable competition in lamp filament matters? The Deputy mentioned Japan. Can the Deputy say whether Japan is prepared to compete on these modest terms? Can he say if Japan is satisfied to maintain a reasonable price and has no desire to wipe out competing industry in other countries by lower prices? Further, when he speaks of maintaining the quality of the lamps with those imported, what quality had he in mind? I do not know if there is such a thing as standard quality for filament lamps. There is scarcely a householder in the country who has not used dud film lamps, not merely once, but many times.
Comment on this
It has not shaken them up to the present and it has not given them many grey hairs. I do not see why the Deputy should be so worried now that Irish manufacturers are going to turn out these lamps. I think this proposal is particularly welcome. I know one town where there is a great welcome for it. The people of Bray would have very little patience with the Opposition in this present instance. If you take a town like Bray, with no industry and a population of some 12,000 people, you will find they are very glad to see the Government making this effort to give their idle men employment.
Comment on this
General Mulcahy also should be glad to see these people getting a chance of some work rather than have the problem that was there in his time, at least as much as in the present time, continuing without any effort being made to cope with it. Deputies opposite talk a lot about people profiteering and about the extortion that may be practised by Irish manufacturers. Surely Deputy Dillon does not forget the other phase. If there was anything like free competition at the present time the bulk of the people of this country would be producing butter at 65/- per cwt. to sell wholesale in England. That is Deputy Dillon's idea——
Comment on this
How does this come in on film lamps? I do not see that it has anything to do with it.
Comment on this
It has a lot to do with lamps if Deputy Dillon's theories are to be acted upon. British imports have to be considered as well as exports.
Comment on this
Very well. I welcome this proposal, and I hope the industry will be a success. There is one further remark I would like to make. It is stated the bulk of the labour to be employed will be female labour. I would like if the Minister could make representation to the proprietors that as far as possible they should employ male labour. It is of course very good that even female labour should be employed, but it would be wonderfully good if male labour could be employed. There is a big surplus of unemployed men in the neighbourhood, and it would be a very much more important matter to ensure that this work was done mainly by male labour.
Comment on this
Deputy Moore seemed to be in a state of confusion. He talked of dud lamps. Of course we all know there are dud lamps. I have used several kinds of lamps, and when not satisfied with one make, I go on to another. I have used Phillips, Osram, Mazda, and so on. If I buy Mazda and get a couple of duds, I may still buy Mazda, but I will get a few Osrams as well. If Osram fail me I will get Phillips.
Comment on this
The fact is that these various types of lamps vie with one another, with a view to producing one of such excellence that there will be a demand for that in preference to some other type. The Minister says that these are all covered in a ring, and that they are the one manufacture. If that is so, it is a great evil. But that is the very thing the Minister is going to do here in the Saorstát; he is going to create a virtual monopoly in Bray. I do not want the Minister to hesitate about setting up a factory in Bray, and making it possible for that factory to pay a fair rate of wages, and to make a fair profit. But having provided for that, I warn him to provide a margin against inefficiency; I want him to provide a fair market to pay a fair wage; and, these being secured, I want him to leave in the offering the threat of competition, if the quality of the commodity falls below the standard, or if the price tends to rise too high.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not opposed to having this industry established, but he is going to vote against the imposition of the duty.
Comment on this
I am going to vote against an imposition of 75 per cent., because the Minister has made no case to this House for it.
Comment on this
In other words, the Deputy would sooner be supplied with lamps by a foreign combine than by an Irish firm.
Comment on this
That is another of the unsavoury and odoriferous red herrings produced from the Minister's bosom, but I am not going to be drawn away by it. As I was saying, I am going to vote against this imposition because the Minister has made no case to this House that a 75 per cent. tariff is necessary——
Comment on this
——in order to give adequate protection to the firm which it is proposed to set up in Bray for the manufacture of this commodity. By all means, manufacture something which would be of advantage to the community. But when you are going to do it, in your anxiety to wield the tariff sword do not wield it to such effect that you cut the legs off all the industrialists in the country for the purpose of setting up one individual in Bray; because if you do that for one individual in Bray, to-morrow, when you start wielding the sword over a gentleman in Arklow, you will cut the legs off the gentleman in Bray. All that I want the Minister to do is to use commonsense.
Comment on this
I do not wish to be unkind, but my experience of the Minister's undertaking is of such a character that I would be reluctant to reciprocate. Perhaps, however, Deputy Moore sees what I am getting at now. By all means, as I say, set up an industry and impose a tariff that will be adequate for its protection; but when setting it up and fixing a tariff, do not leave a wide margin, beyond what protection is necessary, wherein to promote either incompetence or profiteering.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Deputy how he would propose to deal with the question of a ring or a combine that was prepared to operate and make a sacrifice for a time in order to wipe out a little industry such as that in Bray.
Comment on this
I am quite prepared to explain that to the Deputy. It is possible that the Deputy may not have sufficient experience in business to realise that it is undesirable and imprudent to bid the devil good morning until you meet him. It is quite competent for the Minister to come into the House and even to demand the sympathy of the House by saying: "We have determined to set up a factory for the manufacture of these lamps. We consider that under the existing circumstances 75 per cent. is a fair amount of protection and will provide sufficient margin to prevent a factory in Holland, America, the United Kingdom or anywhere else from engaging in dumping activities here." The Minister often has elaborated on the fact that he has the right to stop a ship coming up the Liffey under this Act. So that, if any attempt were made to dump goods here with a view to putting the factory in Bray out of business, he could impose a duty of 150 per cent., if he liked, when the boat was at the bar of the River Liffey, and could serve any ring or combination with full notice that if any attempt was made to do this thing he would have no hesitation in imposing a duty of this kind so as to make it impossible for them to carry on.
Now, the heads of these rings are big business men. They are not fools and they realise that there is no use in battering their heads against a stone wall. Provided that this Oireachtas puts on record that it is prepared to give a certain measure of protection to a factory and to maintain that measure of protection, no matter what any external merchant or manufacturer proposes to do, these men are not going to run their heads against a stone wall. What I maintain will be done under this and what is, in fact, being done, is that somebody rambles into the Minister, or the Minister sends for somebody, and the Minister says: "Will you manufacture lamps?" The person says: "Yes, if you will make it worth my while," and he asks for 50 per cent. or 75 per cent., or whatever it is, and it is whacked on by the Minister.
Comment on this
And an undertaking is given that the price will not be increased. That answers the Deputy's whole argument.
Comment on this
The Minister says that an undertaking is given that prices will not be increased, but he was not at all so sure, on a former occasion, that in addition there was a guarantee that quality would be maintained.
Comment on this
The Minister did not think that when he was steering his Cement Bill through the House. He learned it in the course of the passing of that Bill through the House, and if he looks it up he will see that there was an amendment by the Opposition providing not only as to the price but as to the quality as well. He will find that the Minister for Education said that such a proposal was absurd as to stipulate for quality. When the Bill went to the Seanad the quality proviso was put in and it was from the Seanad that that recommendation came down here, and it was put in as a recommendation from the Seanad after being rejected by this House.
Deputy Moore has some business experience and should realise that if people engage in the manufacture of filament lamps with an undertaking that the quality will be maintained, somebody will have to be the judge of the quality. Who will judge the quality? Is the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the Minister for Finance going to examine into it once a month?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy aware that the Minister for Industry and Commerce has the one Department that is qualified to judge them? But what is the use? Do we have to sit here all day for this? I am tired listening to the Deputy.
Comment on this
I am quite aware that the Minister will think twice before he arranges to sit for the whole day here.
Comment on this
Before the Deputy sits down I should like to ask him to explain why it is that he and his Party accepted the Control of Imports Bill unanimously, which provides for monopolies with regard to industry?
Comment on this
I do not know, sir, whether or not it is strictly relevant to discuss the Control of Imports Act now.
Comment on this
If it were relevant, I should be glad to discuss it now or to-night, or on any other occasion if the Chair would permit me. We can have it out in full and, doubtless, the Minister will join us in discussing it.
Comment on this
However, I think it comes ill from the Minister to complain that he is tired. I warned him at 10.30 this morning that he would be tired before the day was out.
Comment on this
I did not say that I was tired. I said that I was tired listening to the Deputy. After all, he must remember that there are other Deputies over there who may want to speak. He should not monopolise the whole debate.
Comment on this
There is plenty of time for other Deputies. I have no doubt that Deputy Moore will join in again and give us his view. Perhaps Deputy Moore will agree with me that the protection afforded in this case is a little excessive. If he will agree with me on that, that is all our case amounts to, and if he will join with me I shall have great pleasure in welcoming him into the Lobby with us, if he has the moral and the physical courage to come.
Comment on this
I suggest that an obvious explanation of all this is forthcoming. The Party opposite are merely trying to demonstrate their difference with General O'Duffy who, apparently, supports the Government's industrial policy; but I suggest that it is not necessary to waste the time of this House in demonstrating their present independence of the General.
Comment on this
There would be no necessity to waste the time of the House, or to even appear to waste its time, if the Minister would put his proposals before us in a decent and orderly way and tell us something about what the Government are proposing to the House. Deputy Moore drags across the discussion here what a terrible thing it is to deprive the people in Bray of an industry. He says that the people in Bray are looking forward anxiously to the development of this industry. Why would they not? Their condition, as a result of the policy of the Government for the last two years, made them anxiously accept doles of free meat and free milk and unemployment assistance. They are looking anxiously forward to the day in which some way or another they may get a day's work. What we are anxious about is that they will be sure of that day's work, because whether the duty is 75 per cent., 80 per cent. or 100 per cent. what is important is that we shall have sound industries that serve the people satisfactorily. The Minister is asking us to impose this duty on people already burdened with many other duties. They are burdened with very heavy taxation which has reduced them to their present economic condition. The Minister does not give us any indication that this industry is being established on anything like secure foundations. He knows that it is a highly technical industry, and that it has been developed to a high extent in a number of countries, so much so that he is afraid of dumping from highly organised countries. He, apparently, has neglected to inquire about the technical guidance that the people who are setting up this industry are going to have. He has given them the protection of a 75 per cent. tariff without enquiring how they are going to root their industry without satisfactory technical guidance. I think that it is a crime against the people who will have to bear the duty and against the people who are expecting continuous employment in this country.
Comment on this
The Deputy is complaining that the Minister is asking the House, in the case of a highly technical industry to impose a 75 per cent. duty, and he gives the House no information at all as to the experience and training that are going to guide the development of this industry.
Comment on this
In other words, that it is not a foreign firm. I invite the Deputy to say out plainly what precisely he means. I am not going to answer him. The speeches from the other side are being made simply for the purpose of wasting time, arising out of a policy of obstruction. If the Deputy wants to waste time he ought at least to be frank about this. He ought to develop that point and say what he means. His main objection to the industry is that it is going to be undertaken by an Irish firm.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Minister has just made the statement that the speeches from this side are for obstruction purposes.
Comment on this
Is the Minister in order in saying that the speeches from this side are for the purposes of obstruction?
Comment on this
I am not concerned with what a Minister says except in so far as it is relevant to order.
Comment on this
The Minister, I am sure, remembers with astonishment that what he said on the Emergency Imposition of Duties Order No. 37, setting up a factory for oils and fats in Drogheda, that it was being set up entirely by a foreign firm and with foreign capital.
Comment on this
Under Order No. 37, but he assured us that it was a firm that had very extensive experience in the matter. The Minister knows very well that we are anxious that Irish industry would be established here on Irish capital, and that one of the difficulties that we feel with regard to the establishment of Irish industry on Irish capital is the policy pursued by the Government which is destroying the main source of the production of capital in this country, namely, the agricultural industry. The objection taken to the imposition of this duty is not either to the size of the duty or to the fact that the industry is being established by a group of Irishmen, but rather to the fact that the Minister plans to encourage the setting up of a very technical industry here, one which will impose a heavy duty upon the people, without taking any steps to inform the House or himself as to the technical experience that is going to be at the disposal of the people setting up the industry, or where that experience comes from.
The Minister speaks of the discussion on these Orders being obstructive. The Minister was told when the Orders were under discussion the other day, and he can be told again now, that discussion is taking place on them for the purpose of extracting information from him as to what he is doing under the Orders. Until these amendments were put down no information of any kind was to be obtained by means of question from the Minister. He pretends that he gave information to the Press but he gave no such information. We have to admit failure to a very large extent to extract information from the Minister in the discussion on these amendments, and the only thing that the Opposition can do is to drive the Minister by question to expose his attitude in this particular matter; to get him to change his attitude, to give the House more information, and to examine proposals intended to develop Irish industry more carefully in the future than apparently he has done so far as the Orders that are before the House at the moment are concerned.
Comment on this
The Minister has brought most of this discussion on his own head because if, at the beginning, he had given the explanations which have been reluctantly dragged from him it might have shortened the debate.
Comment on this
It was not terribly attractive, and perhaps I was not paying attention. The Minister has been very economical in the use of his words here this evening, but I observed that he had to make some explanations three or four times.
Comment on this
I think I had to make them oftener in order to get some of the Deputies opposite to understand.
Comment on this
However, I think the Minister would have been very well advised if he had dealt with this matter at the beginning. It is a highly technical matter, but the Minister did not deal with it in a technical way. The first shock which the consumers of electric current got in this country was about 24 or 25 years ago. I do not know whether the Minister was born then or not.
Comment on this
The introduction of the Osram lamp marked a very important improvement not only as regards durability but the light that it gave. In consequence of its introduction the consumption of electricity dropped to a marked extent. The Dublin Corporation had to increase its prices at that time to make up for the drop in consumption. Things have improved even since then. It is not a question of the price of the lamp. It is the quality and durability of the lamp which is of account. I had one lamp in use for about ten years, which is a very unusual thing. All consumers are concerned with is how long a lamp is going to last. The Minister will admit at once that it is rather difficult to have an examination of this kind and for a firm to stand the test. The question of price is an immaterial consideration if you get quality and durability.
A tariff of 75 per cent. is rather a frightening imposition. The Minister should have taken the House into his confidence from the very beginning with regard to that. He could have said that there would be an imposition of 15 or 25 per cent., or some lower percentage than what is being proposed, and that would be on the present catalogued price of lamps. I presume there is such a thing. An imposition of 75 per cent. gives one the suspicion at the moment that this industry will require more than the usual amount of protection. Assuming for a moment that the factory does not come up to the Minister's conception of what it should be, and that it is found necessary to add 15 or 20 per cent. to the current price of lamps, will the Minister be bound by the statement he made here this evening that he is going to compel them to sell at the present price? Does not everybody know that after the factory is established, when it is giving employment to 200 or 300 hands, if it is otherwise successful but, that by reason of the small area of supply, prices have to be increased by 50 per cent., the Minister is not going to close that factory?
Comment on this
It is that sort of bargaining that has made the world what it is at the moment. It is utterly unfair to ask such a factory to go into competition with the ring and to expect it to turn out goods at the same price. Anybody who believes that it will be able to do that is no businessman or has no experience. Just contemplate for a moment the resources of this ring and the population which it has to supply in Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Here we have one-fifteenth of that population. Perhaps the relative figure would be more like one-thirtieth. The firm here in Bray, started under the circumstances under which it has been started, is expected to be equal in efficiency with firms such as I have described. The Minister shakes his head.
Comment on this
I expect them to be able to sell lamps at the same price or at a lower price than the ring price.
Comment on this
Well, I do not and I think that that particular frame of mind when approaching a transaction of this sort is unbalanced, absolutely unbalanced. It is that sort of thing that keeps us here considering these matters for over an hour when they might have been disposed of much more quickly if the Minister had taken the House into his confidence and had given us the information which we require.
Comment on this
I would not have risen to speak in this debate at all were it not for the lecture that has been given us by Deputy Cosgrave. Many of us have experience of purchasing lamps, good and bad lamps. Some of us have a good deal of experience, and technical knowledge also, of this particular matter. We have, I am sure, much more experience than Deputy Dillon except that he sells them at a good price. In spite of the lecture which we had from Deputy Dillon, I would not have attempted to speak only for the attitude taken up by Deputy Cosgrave on this question. It is the same attitude which he has taken up on all matters connected with industries started in this country. It is by no means a special thing. Deputy Cosgrave would lead us to believe that the delay caused is due to the fact that Deputy Dillon asked the Minister for certain information and did not get it. Have we not had this ordeal of listening to the inferiority of the Irish worker on every occasion here on which it was proposed to impose a tariff to build up Irish industry? Have we not had the same exhibition on every occasion? We were not able to assemble motor cars. We were not able to do anything at all which would come up to the standard of the product of the foreigner.
Even though we have only one-thirtieth of the purchasing power of the people across the water, I do believe that Irish brains will be capable of turning out as good lamps as any combine. Let nobody be misled by statements such as we had from Deputy Dillon about goodwill between Irish firms and foreign firms. The Deputy suggests that if you tell the combine that you will only put on 10 per cent. or 20 per cent. they are going to be good fellows and will not undersell you. They will say: "You were jolly decent to us. You would not put on a high tariff and therefore we shall not undersell you." If business were usually conducted on these lines, we might be able to accept that, and I, perhaps, would be thoroughly in agreement with Deputy Dillon, but Deputy Dillon knows, like everybody else, that no combine in any country would accept that jolly-good-fellow, hail-fellow-well-met idea, and that they are going to smash any business they can. Every Deputy on the opposite side knows that the 15 per cent. tariff on boots was not a success from the Irish point of view. Outside firms were able to undersell our producers the whole time. This is not a matter, as Deputy Cosgrave would have us believe, of simply trying to get information. It is simply an attempt to waste the time of the House, but since it is only in comparatively recent times that Deputy Dillon could attempt to delay the work of the House or the country, we can afford to sit here until 12 o'clock.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I beg to move amendment No. 11, referring to the Emergency Imposition of Duties (No. 46) Order, 1934:
To delete in page 2, the reference to "The Emergency Imposition of Duties (No. 46) Order, 1934."
This Order imposes a duty of 5/- in the £ on all edible extracts, essences or juices (not including soups), prepared or derived wholly or mainly from animals (including birds, but excluding fish). We have been able to get no information on this subject from the Minister. I would be glad if he gives us some information at this stage.
Comment on this
The Deputy is, as usual, incorrect. This is the one subject on which I did give him information. The imports of these goods last year were valued at £150,000, and the duty is imposed as a preliminary to the manufacture of edible extracts in the country. The manufacture has not yet begun and licences for normal quantities are being issued.
Comment on this
The Minister gave us the importation figures in respect of these goods. The amount was £151,846 for 1933, and £76,000 for 1934. I do not know whether the Minister gave up those figures in error or whether he was asked for them.
Comment on this
Can the Minister tell us the number of firms engaged in the manufacture of these articles and the number of persons employed?
Comment on this
So that this duty of 5/- in the £ on certain articles for which the Minister has given no information is simply a shot in the dark? He asks the House to accept the imposition of this duty, but gives the House no information as to the class of persons likely to develop the industry as a result of its imposition.
Comment on this
I am certainly pressing for the rejection of an Order introduced in this particular way, without any information being given to the House as to the circumstances in which the Order is introduced and the type of development that is expected to result from it.
Comment on this
Would the Minister then say whether this Order is in any way connected with the setting up of the Roscrea factory?
Comment on this
The Roscrea factory is simply for the purpose of taking the cattle and reducing them to meal?
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 12:—
To delete in page 2, the reference to "The Emergency Imposition of Duties (No. 48) Order, 1934."
The Imposition of Duty Order (No. 48) imposes a duty of nearly 40 per cent. on the value of the article on rope, cord, twine, thread made of cotton, flax, hemp, ramie, jute or coir, or any like material or a combination of any two or more of those materials, but excluding binder twine and plaited or cable-laid sash-cord, and also excluding any article which at importation forms part of another article. The Minister suggested that he had given information with regard to the import of edible fats, but I think if the Minister looks again he will find that the figures he quoted were in respect of rope.
Comment on this
I have the information, but the biggest blank in the lot is with regard to the edible fat position.
Comment on this
Well, whatever the Minister makes them. The Minister told us on the Second Reading that there was a factory at Kildare for the production of cable, ropes and twines. He said it had been in production for some time and was increasing its production as it made progress. Would the Minister tell us the amount of employment given at Kildare and the amount of employment which he expects will be given in the country if it is his intention that this Order is going to be a prohibitive one—40 per cent? Will he say what is the position with regard to the issue of licences at the present time, and whether there is anything in the present situation which would mean a rise in the price of ropes or twines either now or later on?
Comment on this
First of all, I should point out to the Deputy that he got the information concerning edible extracts from the Minister for Agriculture on the 5th December. He got the information, or some of the information, which he desires concerning cordage, cables, ropes, twines and threads made subject to duty by this Order. Next, I should inform the Deputy that the duty imposed by this Order on cordage, cables, ropes and twines is not a new duty. It has been in operation for some time past. These goods are included in this Order merely for administrative convenience. The effect of the Order is to extend the duty which has been in operation upon those goods to cotton and linen thread. There is nobody yet manufacturing either of those threads in the country. A factory for the manufacture of cotton thread is being constructed at Westport, and a factory for the manufacture of linen thread is being constructed at Dublin. It is intended that each of those factories will produce the whole of the requirements of the country, but it is not yet possible to say what will be the total employment given in either of them, or what the total output will be. The employment, however, is quite considerable, and the firm in each case has the benefit of the association with them of competent external firms, of which no doubt the Deputy will be glad; it is a British firm in the case of the cotton thread and a Belfast firm in the case of the linen thread.
Comment on this
Is binder twine made in this Kildare factory which the Minister says has been in production for some time?
Comment on this
It is not 12 months ago since I knew it to be looking for a site in Dublin. Would the Minister tell us if this is a factory to which a trade loan has been given?
Comment on this
Oh, no. One of them has been established 100 years. I was not responsible for that one!
Comment on this
Not a long rope factory? The Minister, I am sure, knows that a complete rope factory must be able to spin a rope 300 yards long, and there was no such factory in this country a year ago.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not misinformed; he had good reason to know. The factory at Kildare was primarily established to do that job.
Comment on this
If I am not mistaken I think there are two in Kildare, so I do not know which the Deputy is referring to.
Comment on this
I do not know whether or not I should ask this question; the Minister will know whether or not he should give an answer. I do not want an answer if it is a matter which should not be made public. Have trade loans been given for those rope factories?
Comment on this
Well I am sure the Minister made the necessary investigations. I will not pursue my question any further.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:—
To delete in page 2, the reference to "The Emergency Imposition of Duties (No. 51) Order, 1934."
Attention has already been called to the fact that the machinery of the Emergency Imposition of Duty Order has been invoked in this particular instance to impose a Customs duty. By enshrining it in this Bill now, the Minister asks us to permanently create a situation that will, as it were, draw a line after the Government's action in respect of sugar during the last 12 months. They put on an additional Customs duty in February last and now we have this Excise duty under this Emergency Order. The present Government are taking an extra £735,000 out of the people's pockets for what both the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce have recently characterised as a very necessary article of food for the people. £735,000 a year is to be taken out of the people's pockets for their sugar as a result of the actions of the present Government during the last calender month. Without any review of that position, we are asked to make that permanent decision under the guise of an Emergency Imposition of Duties Order. I should like to hear what members of the Fianna Fáil Party have to say on the subject of taking an additional £735,000 yearly from the people's pockets. They have been very silent all day as regards the condition of local authorities, the condition of the people generally, and the prospects of industry.
Comment on this
I should like to protest against the imposition of this extra Excise duty on sugar. If there was any tariff originated by the late Government that was furiously opposed by the present supporters of the Government, it was the tariff on sugar. That tariff has now been increased beyond what anybody ever expected. This proposal is certainly putting an imposition on ordinary consumers, which they are ill able to afford at present. I should like to ask the Minister to consider how this imposition will affect certain industries which are struggling to compete with industries in other countries. For instance, what would be the effect on a large concern, that may be called a semi-Government concern, the condensed milk factory? I have no brief for the factory, and I do not know the position there, but as an ordinary member of the community, it strikes me that any extra duty on sugar must bear heavily on a factory which is endeavouring to create an export trade against tremendous world-wide competition. There must be other concerns, with which I am not acquainted, but with which other Deputies may be, which will be affected by this increase, especially at a time when the Government is endeavouring to create new industries. An imposition such as this must affect their policy. Deputy Mulcahy made the case for the ordinary consumer, which every one of us could and should make, that this increased tariff falls more heavily, perhaps, on the poorer sections of the community than any other imposition that could be conceived. The case for the poor people has been made a hundred times in this House by Deputies on these Benches and, in particular, by the Deputies who are now on the Government Benches. The effect on industry generally has not been dealt with. While I am opposed to the increase on these grounds, I have the opinion that this tariff is going to have a very ill effect on a great many industries that we are trying to develop, such as the condensed milk industry, which has to meet considerable competition.
Comment on this
Is the Minister not going to give any explanation why the price of sugar should be increased?
Comment on this
The Minister set that out very early in his speech on the Second Reading of the Bill.
Comment on this
The Minister does not think it worth his while to explain to the House, or to the country, why he is putting a duty of a halfpenny a lb. on sugar.
Comment on this
When a tariff of a halfpenny a lb. was put on sugar three years ago, which indirectly helped revenue here, and had the effect of reducing the subsidy given to the Carlow sugar factory, the Minister was one of the loudest critics against the imposition of that extra halfpenny, even though the total proceeds from the halfpenny were going to help agriculture, which the Minister and his colleagues shed so many crocodile tears over now. Three years ago the imposition was put on to do a good service. The Minister and his Party, when they came into office, showed consistency in their opposition, by taking the Customs duty off sugar and putting it on tea, saying that they were doing that because sugar was an article that was much more required by poorer people than tea. The duty on tea still remains, while the duty on sugar goes up, for no earthly reason that I can see, except to provide revenue. I wonder if the Minister has thought how this will affect various industries that are dependent on sugar. What about protected industries, such as jam making, condensed milk, to which Deputy Bennett referred, the curing of bacon and hams, as well as numerous other industries that I cannot enumerate? Apart from being an essential food, sugar finds its way to a great extent into every industry. It is an article that we produce ourselves. If there is one article that should not be unnecessarily taxed in this country, it is sugar, because we are coming to a production of 100 per cent. of our requirements. No country in the world has been able to produce beet sugar at a price that will compare economically with cane sugar. It has to be subsidised in every country. Now, when we are beginning to produce it on a large scale, we are going to have it taxed to provide revenue. Is there nothing else to tax but sugar? Hemmed in on all sides by prohibitive tariffs, when no more can be extracted from these tariffs, we start internal taxation, and there is not a word of explanation. The Minister's Department is now in receipt of about £3,000,000 more from Customs duties than his predecessor was in receipt of three years ago, when sugar was little more than half the price it is to-day. The Minister shed crocodile tears over the poor of this country when he was against the imposition of an additional halfpenny per pound.
Now the price of that sugar, in order to protect sugar production in this country, had to be raised, but on top of that the Minister is now putting on another ½d. or ¾d., and there is no explanation. He said that he gave his reasons for it on the Second Reading of the Bill. I am afraid the reasons the Minister gave are so flimsy that he is afraid to repeat them.
Comment on this
The Minister states that he made clear on the Second Reading of the Sugar Bill that a tax would be necessary. That is not so. In introducing the Sugar Bill the Minister will recollect that he stated that the price he was assuming to pay for beet was 35/- per ton and that, with the return of certain of the bye-products valued at 3/9, it was 38/9. Now, he is not paying 35/- per ton.
Comment on this
The Deputy has made a mistake. I said 35/- for beet, with 17½ per cent. sugar content.
Comment on this
The Minister said in the course of the Second Reading speech that it would not be necessary to put on more than ¾d. of a protective duty and, further, that ½d. only might be necessary and that ¾d. would not be required. He said "The extension of this factory will not cost the consumers that additional ½d. or ¾d. per lb." Now ¾d. has been added before the sugar is for sale. The sugar is not yet for sale.
Comment on this
Assuming that is so, the total requirements which it was anticipated would have been provided by the factories are not being provided. It is unlikely that much more than 50,000 tons will be provided out of the 80,000 tons anticipated, and, if that be so, what is the need for the additional protection duty imposed?
Comment on this
I have only one thing to say and that is, that the attitude which the Opposition Party has taken up in this matter is consistent. They have fought tooth and nail against the extension and development of any industry in this country from the moment they went into opposition. I quite clearly indicated, when the Sugar Bill was before the Dáil, that, in certain circumstances, it might be necessary to put an additional duty of ¾d. per lb. on sugar, and these circumstances have arisen. The fact of the matter is that, even with the additional increase on sugar now, the total revenue to be derived from tea and sugar in this year will be almost £200,000 less than our predecessors derived from sugar alone in the financial year which ended on the 31st March, 1932. In addition to that, we have the four factories working turning out 80,000 tons of our sugar requirements.
Comment on this
The position is that in every Budget the Minister introduced since he came into office he largely increased taxation upon the people, as well as collaring moneys that were properly due to be paid in another way, and in the year ending 31st December, 1934, he will have put his hand deeply into the pockets of the ordinary people and taken out as an increased price for sugar an additional £735,000. It is no wonder that he tried to remain silent.
Comment on this
The Minister is taking that additional money out of the pockets of the people for sugar, or, at any rate, plans to take it annually. When the Minister touches the question of sugar, he thinks of Napoleon and he would be Napoleonic in all his actions. At Dun Laoghaire the other night it was Caesar was talking.
Comment on this
When he comes within ten miles of a sugar factory then Napoleon is the part that has to be played, and if Napoleon was digging his hands into the people's pockets he would take nothing less than £735,000 per year. The Minister suggests a denial of that. If it is not so, I should like to hear the Minister on the subject.
Comment on this
If the statement made by the Minister is correct, and I am not doubting it, that the revenue from sugar in the current year will be £200,000 or £300,000 less——
Comment on this
It is good enough for my argument that it will be less than the total revenue from sugar alone in 1931-32. Is that the Minister's statement?
Comment on this
Then I want the relative prices of tea and sugar. What are the wholesale and retail prices in the current year, and what were they in 1931-32? Are they not far higher, due to the policy of the Ministry?
Comment on this
The Minister has made a little explanatory statement at the end of the debate. He made play with the fact that the revenue derived from tea and sugar is some £200,000 less than the duty on sugar alone two years ago. Everybody knows that the policy of the Minister has practically been to wipe out the import of sugar into this country. That policy might be quite correct, but it does away with his revenue. He is not going to get away by drawing that red herring across the track and trying to persuade the people that they are saving £200,000 when everybody knows that sugar alone is costing them ½d. or ¾d. per lb. more than at that particular time.
Comment on this
And the State has to provide one million for building factories. The Minister cannot get away with it like that. Any talk about a reduction in revenue, when the consumers have to pay more for the article protected, is not going to cut across the fact that the people are being imposed upon and are bearing a greater burden than they should be asked to bear.
Comment on this
If the Minister's second observation was as reliable as his first, that we have opposed the extension of industry in this country, it is just in keeping with his observations on any subject. We have done more for industry in a few years than the Ministry would do in a lifetime. There is no originality, conception, generosity or anything else about the proposals. There is one thing they cannot get away from, that they are taxing the unfortunate people of the country beyond their resources.
Comment on this
I should like to challenge the Minister on this, that he is arranging to take £735,000 more for sugar out of the people's pockets annually as a result of his proposal this year.
Comment on this
Question—"That the words proposed to be deleted stand part of the Bill"— put.
Do you agree with this result?