We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Financial Motions. Resolution No. 28—General (Resumed).

Contributions 1–163 of 484. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I remember that last year the Minister for Finance, in his Budget speech, struck a very optimistic note as he did this year. He went over all the items producing revenue by indirect taxation, and he pointed out that it was evidence, which I agreed with and still agree with, of the economic strength of our people, and evidence of the fact that conditions are improving. I wonder was the Minister prompted by the opposite feeling this year because, in referring to those items he dealt with them with greater modesty than I have ever heard him do so in this House. Almost apologetically, he referred to the taxes that, in some cases, did not come up to expectations, and to some that were less than last year—some, in fact, that were less than the corresponding figures for 1931-32. Why did not the Minister adopt a plain straight line and take some one year for the purposes of comparison—preferably last year, because we cannot put back the hands of the clock three years? Two or three years have intervened since 1931-32, and the nearest approach to the conditions this year must be last year. I have already said that, taking everything into consideration, it is a good thing for the country that such a Budget has been produced because it is an indication of the present economic condition of the country.

Comment on this

The Deputy will hardly get a Ministry with that kind of speech.

Comment on this

The members of the Labour Party were accessories to, if not accomplices in, producing the conditions that have necessitated this Budget.

Comment on this

The Deputy, I think, advocated the retention of the land annuities in 1926?

Comment on this

And the Deputy is running away from that now?

Comment on this

The Deputy started the row—himself and Colonel Moore.

Comment on this

Yes, but the Dáil had given no sanction to that at that time. I advocated that in 1927, 1928 and 1929 and still by the method of revision but not by repudiation.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy read his Rathcoole speech?

Comment on this

It is revision.

Comment on this

The word is not mentioned in it.

Comment on this

I remember the Deputy started to read it here one day, but he folded it up and ran away from it.

Comment on this

Read it again.

Comment on this

With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, I would be very glad to hear the Deputy read it again.

Comment on this

The Deputy cleared out before the reading of it was finished.

Comment on this

I notice, in examining the Estimates for the year that we are in—the figures relating to estimated expenditure and the Estimates relating to new taxes—that for some reason the Minister consistently seems to overestimate the cost of the Services and to underestimate the produce of taxes. Of course, the Minister can gather the last halfpenny in the country by taxation that way, and balance his Budget though the country may be tottering. Let me take some examples from his Budget speech. He said that the loss to the Exchequer last year, following the reduction of 4d. per lb. in the tea duty, was £400,000, while the reimposition of it this year will only bring to the Exchequer the sum of £320,000. The same applies to a number of other items. Last year the revenue budgeted for amounted to £28,232,000, and the sum collected was £28,770,688. Borrowing was estimated to be £7,212,000, but actually it did not reach anything like that figure. If the Minister set about giving us a balance sheet of all the transactions, I doubt if his Budget would balance. The Minister got authority in his Budget last year to spend considerable sums of money under many headings, but he did not spend the money. The taxation for which he asked authority from this House, however, was given on the assumption that those works were to be carried out. Take one example— the widows' and orphans' pensions. The sum of £250,000 was estimated for the last year for that purpose, but was not spent. There was also a sum of £1,000,000 for the payment of the External Dáil Loan, but only £78,000 was spent. The sum of £4,200,000 was estimated for Local Loans but there was only paid into the Local Loans Fund the sum of £400,000 instead of that £4,200,000. And so on in that way with numerous items.

The Minister knows that, in various branches of local government their budgets must be compiled on the basis of the work to be done, and authority is given to the executive officers to do that work within their appropriations. If they do not carry out the work, they must show a saving to that amount. The Minister has not gone on those lines at all. In many cases this year, for no apparent reason that I can see, his Estimate for last year in actual expenditure was not reached; and yet, in many of those cases, he increases the Estimate for that particular service this year. He estimated the expenses of returning officers last year at £6,000, but spent only £675. Another expenditure was £4,000 below the Estimate of last year and is about £40,000 above the Estimate this year. The Estimate for the repayment of Dáil Loan last year was £1,000,000, of which only £78,000 was spent, and £450,000 is to be paid this year. For the Revenue Commissioners the Estimate was £750,000 last year, of which only £661,000 was spent, and there is an Estimate of £725,000 this year. Local Loans Fund was estimated last year at £4,200,000, but only £400,000 was paid. I should like to know from the Minister if that was not an actual payment from current moneys during the last financial year, or was it simply a book transfer of capital assets that he estimated in conformity with the recent Bill that was passed here? From my reading of the Minister's speech, I take it that that was not a money transaction at all; it was simply on account of the capitalised assets against the revenue that the Local Loans Fund will receive under that recent Act.

The Estimate for Public Works and Buildings last year was £687,000, of which £685,000 was spent; and he has estimated this year for £889,000. Then, take the case of the produce of the taxes that the Minister expects to get from his new impositions. The duty on tobacco is an Excise duty. Roughly, our consumption of tobacco is about 12,000,000 lbs. and, at 8d. a lb. that would give £400,000; but the Minister estimates that the produce of that tax will be only £160,000. What is going to happen to the £240,000? Where does that go? Then, there is a duty of 6d. per cwt. on imported wheat. I should take it as a rough estimate that our requirements in wheat would be about 16,000,000 cwt. Let us say that the home supply would be the produce of 150,000 acres producing an average crop of millable wheat. I have heard, and I am prepared to believe, that the area under wheat this year will be more than 150,000 acres; but, taking it all round, I think that it is a good high estimate to place the supply of home-grown wheat that will be of fairly good millable quality at the total produce of an average crop of 150,000 acres. Assuming that there would be one ton to the acre, that would leave the total import of wheat for our requirements at 13,000,000 cwt, and 6d. a cwt. on that would be £325,000. The Minister, however, estimates only £190,000. I think that if the Minister found it necessary to put on taxes of this kind, he should have gone far more moderately about the taxes. The Minister puts sugar at £175,000—that is, at one farthing a lb. I think that it is a conservative estimate to place our total consumption of sugar at 100,000 tons. A farthing a lb. on that will give us £140,000, but the Minister estimates only £75,000, and he will have £65,000 of a lie-by in that one item alone.

Now, with the consistent policy of the Minister in over-estimating the cost of work to be done and under-estimating the produce of taxes that he is about to impose, and, presumably, under-estimating the produce of taxes in the coming year, he is taking undue precautions about the balancing of his Budget—precautions, which are very significant in my opinion. It is an indication that the Minister is very nervous of the economic position. From existing taxes which produced £28,770,688 last year he wants this year, even with his high estimation, £29,376,000, or about £500,000 more. Why does he find it necessary to impose so much taxation? Does it not betray nervousness? The taxes that produced so much last year have shown a decline. The Minister is frightened that they are going to show a greater decline during the coming year, and consequently he is budgeting for a revenue far in excess of what he might budget for if times were normal, or if he had any confidence in the situation.

I notice that we have £1,500,000 for unemployment assistance this year. That must be food for thought for my friends on the Labour Benches. It must be a sad disappointment for the Minister to find that he has to pay so much money for unemployment assistance and unemployment insurance in the current year, notwithstanding the money he has devoted to relief schemes and the amount that he has decided in this Budget to spend on public works during the coming year which, he says, fairly correctly is an additional help for unemployment relief. But how does that square with his apologia for the decline in the produce of the taxes? He said it was because of the rapid expansion of our tillage and industrial policies. But the rapid expansion of the tillage and industrial policies, if they were rapidly expanding, should be absorbing unemployment to a greater extent, and that absorption should be indicated by a decline in the necessity for relief works, unemployment assistance and unemployment insurance. There is no indication of decline there. Therefore, the demand is remaining about normal. This great expansion of the tillage and industrial policies, which the Minister talks about, seems to make no impression on unemployment. We have still to pay for that. How then does the Minister account for the fall in taxation? The rapidly expanding tillage and industrial policies are not absorbing the unemployed. If they were the produce from taxation should be rising instead of falling. As was indicated in the Minister's speech, it is falling, and, therefore, purchasing power cannot be increasing. Even that item which nearly intoxicated the Minister last year, beer, "had bucked up," to use his own phraseology, in sympathy with all the other items of taxation, and produced not only the quota of previous years that he had looked for, but a figure that far exceeded the estimate for a number of years. This year, when speaking of beer, the Minister did not get intoxicated. His references to it were very sober. It seems that there must have been no advance made in the brewing and sale of light beer. The whole speech of the Minister was a wail, indicative of the economic position in the country. He professed to give us a balance last year and this year. I think the amount of the surplus this year was £120,000.

Comment on this

£10,000.

Comment on this

The Minister is to borrow for export bounties. The Minister suggested that he should also borrow for the other items. I agree that borrowing is sound for all these items, but I do not agree that it is sound to borrow for bounties. My friends on the right suggest that the money should be raised by taxation.

Comment on this

Most of it is.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister, and, through you, Sir, the Labour Party, to deal with that. The British Government told us what they are doing. Roughly, we know the amount of money going into the Exchequer that normally did not go into it some years ago. There has been no relief in taxation because of the land annuities, local loans revenue, and the produce of taxation that went to pay the Royal Irish Constabulary pensions. There has been no relief of taxation there, but the Exchequer is getting the advantage. The sum is considerably greater than the amount of the bounties paid any year since the bounties were started, or greater than the amount estimated for bounties this year. Why are bounties not paid out of that money? In my opinion that shows the rather dangerous economic and financial condition of the country.

The Minister was very careful to warn critics of his Budget against anything that might damage the credit of the country. I do not want to indulge in anything that would be damaging to the credit of the country, especially I want to avoid using any language of a certain nature in this House. Any language of that kind used in this House, no matter who uses it, will be more damaging to the credit of the country than if that person used it outside. I do not want to be guilty of anything in the nature of damage to the credit of the country. The Minister in the course of his speech reminded the House of the rate at which certain bonds or stocks could be marketed in Britain. Some of these run up to 110, while in this country similar stocks bearing the same rate of interest were not even at par. The Minister could not understand why. I will tell him. In Britain the economic life of the country is reviving. In the Free State it is not. If the Minister by overestimation for expenditure and underestimation in the production of taxes could continue balancing his Budget it will avail him nothing. It will avail him and his Government nothing and it will avail this country nothing unless the economic condition of the country outside is being balanced.

The Minister gave us a balance last year. He attempted to balance this year on a net increase in the national assets over the last three years. The Minister showed on paper that we are in a better financial condition now than we were three years ago by £3,000,000 to £4,000,000. But the Minister fails to bring into that statement an account of the money withheld in the shape of annuities and other payments in Britain during that period. I am not saying that the money should be paid out but I am saying that the Minister has the benefit of these moneys and he did not show them in the account. But the country outside has to bear the loss of this. The country outside has to bear the loss in the shape of a capital levy and that is telling on the country now. It is telling in the Budget under review by reduced produce in taxes because of the diminishing purchasing power in the country due to the diminution of national income. The Minister knows that. He has shown it in his mad race to impose more taxation. The amount collected in taxation last year was only £500,000 less than his estimate for this year. The Minister attempted to balance his Budget and says he balanced it for this year. In the course of the year he got a windfall. Every Bill that is passed in the Dáil imposes on the people in the business the necessity to register. In making application for registration one has to enclose a fee. If one looks to the right or to the left, one commits an offence; a fine is imposed. Every twist and turn that one gives means money. Now all that finds its way to the Minister. At the time when the Bill was being passed we were told that all that money will be for the benefit of the industry in connection with which the Bill is enacted whether it concerns agriculture or anything else. When the Stabilisation of Bacon Prices Bill was passing through there was placed an imposition of 10/- per carcase. That was the sum imposed on the pig carcase, of course for the benefit of the bacon industry. That, we were told, was to be only temporary. When the Bacon Bill was enacted and in operation with this imposition of 10/- a carcase was to go out automatically and the other to come in. At the time the Minister for Finance was indignant at the thought that anyone would think he would have anything to do with this, except that as Minister for Finance, he thought it well to have the finances of the Government of the State centralised. The Minister said afterwards, "I will not let this go." Then with the persuasion of the Minister for Agriculture he would let it go, but not yet. During the course of the year he says he will liquidate it and he tells us it will cost the Exchequer £240,000 to £250,000. Now that was in connection with the levy that was supposed to be for the benefit of the bacon industry only.

That fact in itself should set everybody in this House and outside it thinking. How much has the Minister collared out of every Act of this kind that has been passed through the House? I am sure the Minister has his hawk's eye on every Act with a view to getting the most he can out of it. All these Acts which are supposed to be for the relief of agriculture, are primarily revenue-making machines for the Government. This levy of 10/- on pig carcases has produced £240,000 to £250,000 for the Minister for Finance. The Minister used a significant phrase about the remission of that tax. He said he would not remit it finally until the Pigs and Bacon Bill was enacted and in full working order. In other words, if he spoke his mind he would say: "I will not let this tax of £240,000 go until I see how I can collar £240,000 from the Pigs and Bacon Bill when it is an Act." I am sure that is what is in the Minister's mind. He will take good care he will not lose this money. It gives him another nest-egg and will allow him to take so much money from the economic life of the country.

Another nest-egg he has is in connection with the bounty on wheat. Who is suffering the loss there? The Minister should show a reduction in his Estimate and a reduction in the necessary revenue that he wants this year. By taking his own figure, which is on the safe side, we may put the reduction at £260,000. That is a net saving for the Minister in this coming year.

The items for widows and orphans is not an increase, because he estimated for it last year and he collected revenue on the assumption that the Bill would be enacted and in working order for such portion of the year as would cost this Government £250,000. He estimated that for a full year it would cost £400,000, but for that portion of the year it would represent an outlay of £250,000. The Minister estimated that that measure would be in operation last year, but it was not. We are just in the same position this year as we were last year. Still the Minister mentioned it as a new item of expenditure. Probably he has not the cheek to delay its enactment any longer than some time this year. But it is not an increased item of expenditure as far as the Budget is concerned, because the Minister budgeted for precisely the same amount last year that he is budgeting for this year—£250,000.

The Minister will have no new expenditure except £40,000 for the wheat bounty. I do not know where that £40,000 is going to be swallowed up, except it is to cover costs in the early portion of this year before the new harvest comes in. Otherwise, in a normal full year, I see no need for an expenditure of £40,000 from central funds for a wheat bounty, because we are just as we started before the wheat bounty. There is a quota for a certain amount of wheat and then the people compete for the quota. On the whole I think the Budget is the greatest danger signal that this country has seen for a long time.

Comment on this

That is treasonable.

Comment on this

It is not the first time we spoke treason.

Comment on this

I thought you were not to speak any in this debate.

Comment on this

The Minister's speech was the red flag—the danger signal. There is always danger when you see the red flag. I am glad that Deputy Norton is repudiating it now.

Comment on this

I repudiate the Deputy's views on most things.

Comment on this

I must accept some of the responsibility for teaching him to follow on the line of protection. The Minister betrayed nervousness in rushing these taxes. In his boastful speech last year he indicated—I agreed with him then and I agree with him now—that from the bumper harvest he had from taxation he was justified in being optimistic. But the converse is true this year. The taxes that exceeded expectations last year are considerably under expectation this year, and the Minister is budgeting in the anticipation they will be considerably less than during the year which has closed. That reflects the economic condition of the country. The development of our tillage and industrial policy as an excuse for that will not hold water, because if we were developing to the extent mentioned by the Minister, it would be reflected in an increase in many of these taxes in which there was a decrease. Last year, he said that we drank more beer because we were more prosperous. This year we are drinking less beer. Is it because we are more prosperous?

Comment on this
James Ryan Minister for Agriculture (Dr. Ryan) Fianna Fáil

Because we are more temperate.

Comment on this

An empty pocket is the best thing to make a man or a nation temperate, and the "pocket pledge" is what has made us more temperate this year. The Minister for Finance is the man who will administer that pledge. He knows it is operating. Hence the multiplicity of taxes—taxes that normally would produce three times the amount of money the Minister is looking for; but he anticipates a decrease in the other taxes. The case made for industrial development here would be understandable if we were near saturation point— that the taxes from the imports of protected commodities are dwindling. But these are not the only ones from which there is a dwindling return this year. However, I will not take up much more of the time of the House.

Comment on this

Thank God.

Comment on this

I hope the Deputy will give as much thought to it—more intelligent thought than I have given to it. I am sure if he does, and expresses it here we shall all be glad to listen to him. But he will not get over the position of the country revealed in this Budget by any cheap scores or cheap jibes for Party advantage.

Comment on this

You are coming around.

Comment on this

I stand where I always stood.

Comment on this

You have been around the whole show.

Comment on this

On every Bench in this House except here. Are you not finished yet?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order, order.

Comment on this

It is better to change Parties than to change principles. If a man is to hold to his principles, he cannot hold on to a Party in this country.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

If he had any.

Comment on this

Nobody can say that with more emphasis than the Minister for Agriculture, and I am glad that he appreciates it. I will be interested to hear the Minister further on his gymnastics in balancing his Budget. I feel very doubtful about it. I would also like to know why he refrained from borrowing this year, and why the £4,200,000 that was to be borrowed and placed at the disposal of local authorities for housing was not borrowed and placed at their disposal. He is saving a very important item of expenditure in the current year in the service of the debt that he is forcing the local authorities to shoulder under the recent Local Loans Act.

The service of that debt he estimates at £1,330,000. Instead of the Exchequer bearing the cost of that in future, the local authorities, who will be borrowing from the Local Loans Fund, will have to bear it. I am sorry I did not hear the Minister for Industry and Commerce on this. When I came into the House he was talking about boots and shoes, about the rapid development of his industrial policy, and stating that because of that rapid development certain tariffs were not producing revenue in the way they were. My view as to why those tariffs are not producing the revenue is simply that the people are not buying, because they are not able to buy on account of the economic condition into which they are driven. The bottom is falling out of the market, and the Minister for Finance is subconscious of that, as is indicated in the taxes which he is imposing in this Budget.

Comment on this

Sir, the two principal speeches which we have heard so far in defence of this Budget have been from the Minister for Finance and from the Minister for Industry and Commerce. While they differed in many particulars they had this much in common, that the passages of both speeches which excited the enthusiasm of their supporters bore remarkably little relation to the actual Budget proposals, and remarkably little relation to the actual facts of the country's economic condition. The Minister for Finance's flowers of rhetoric about the responsibilities of freedom, and the periods of the Minister for Industry and Commerce about the redistribution of wealth in this country which is to be effected by taxation, seemed to have very little to do with the proposals which the Minister for Finance has put before us in this Budget. The truth of the matter is that both of them were conscious of the fundamentally unpopular and, I would say, inequitable character of the taxes which are being introduced, and having a profound belief in the value of bluff, a belief based on their happy experience in the past, they thought that, so long as they went on talking as if the proposals of the Budget were quite different, the gullible public would hardly notice what the proposals actually were; that so long as they went on whistling the "Walls of Limerick" none of us would observe that they were really dancing the Tango. I hope that in the course of this debate there will have been enough in the way of criticism not only from our benches but from those of the hitherto silent Labour Party to enlighten the minds of the people of the country on this topic.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce spoke with more than his usual scorn and arrogance about the shortcomings of the Opposition. We were, taking us all in all, the most depraved and the most incompetent Opposition that ever sat at any time in any Parliament in the world, while he, of course, was the best Minister in charge of the best Department in the best Government that had been known in Europe. I felt properly chastened after the castigation I had received from the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and as it was my intention to take the first opportunity of addressing this House on the subject of the Budget, I determined to try and model myself on him. Accordingly, I examined his speeches on the four Budgets that were brought in by the predecessor of the present Minister for Finance, but, alas! I emerged from that study a disappointed man. I could find there none of that tender care for the credit of the country which is now so warmly recommended to us. I could find there none of that constructiveness in which we are blamed for being so lacking. I found that if I were to model myself on the Minister for Industry and Commerce in relation to Budgets when he was in Opposition I should make wild and reckless statements; I should make predictions which in every case had been falsified; I should make promises which were never carried out; I should enunciate principles which as soon as I came into office I made haste to abandon. If those are to be the qualifications of a successful Opposition I prefer to continue humbly in an unsuccessful Opposition. If our Opposition is unsuccessful, I prefer to continue unsuccessful on honest lines rather than to win elections by hocus pocus and bluff that have to be forgotten about as quickly as possible as soon as you get into office.

There are three questions which I think can properly be discussed in a Budget debate. The first is: "What is the general economic and financial condition of the country?" The second is: "Is the Budget fiscally sound?" The third is: "Is it fair and just as between the various classes of the community?"

The bulk of the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, so far as it was not devoted to rating the Opposition, was devoted not to a consideration of the Budget proposals but to proving that the country as a whole is in a good condition. For that purpose he used a large number of statistics. Let me say at once that I have a wholesome distrust of statistics, and that while I am going to set up against his statistics other statistics, in the last analysis I am much more impressed by actual experience—by contact with the various classes of the community and experience of what they are undergoing—than I am by any sets of statistics. However, I propose to go briefly through the figures which the Minister for Industry and Commerce put before us, and then supplement them by some figures of my own.

One figure on which he laid great stress was the number of people put into industrial employment by the present Government. That is the only one of his figures which I am going more or less to neglect, because Deputy McGilligan is going to speak later in this debate, and that particular topic of employment figures is one from which he derives special recreation and refreshment, so I propose to leave to him the task which he has performed before of analysing destructively the figures in that regard. I will merely remark that even if I accepted the Minister's figures at their face value I would still contend that, considering the enormous tariffs which have been put on, the enormous amount of relief money which has been expended in giving employment, and the general policy of inflationary spending for which the Government has been responsible, the amount of confessed and admitted unemployment still existing in the country is nothing short of appalling. Even accepting the Minister's own figures, the record of the Fianna Fáil Party in connection with unemployment has been a complete disappointment to any of those who were foolish enough to believe their statements and predictions on the subject before they came into office.

Another figure from which the Minister derived encouragement was that of the passenger and goods traffic on the railways which, he stated, was increased this year from last year and last year from the year before. I think anyone will agree, on reflection, that the improvement in the railway traffic has been very largely due to the Transport and Railways Bills which the Government have passed, and which I supported at the time they were introduced. The monopoly thus given to the railways has had a very great deal to do with improving their position. But aside from that, it is a matter of course that the beet policy and the flour policy of the Government have resulted in a far larger transport of sugar beet and flour than was going on before the present Government came into office. That is a thing that followed automatically and mechanically, and, therefore, it is no index of the general prosperity of the country. There are other occasional and fluctuating features that affected the railway traffic. One is the Dublin Tramways strike which has just concluded. That must have been of very great assistance to the railway figures, I should have imagined.

Comment on this

How much?

Comment on this

You did not strike; you let the tram fellows go out.

Comment on this

Then there is the question of the weather. It is the experience of the railways as regards passenger traffic that in the fine weather the traffic increases enormously. People go away on Saturdays and Sundays, especially in Dublin; they go out of town in fine weather—they do not go in wet weather—and the fact that on the whole the weather has been better than the average, doubtless owing to the virtues of the present Government, has contributed towards improving the railway traffic. On the whole, I think there are quite enough of these occasional factors which I have mentioned, and of factors which are automatic as a result of the Government protectionist policy in relation to sugar and flour, to account for the improvement in the railway figures without deriving therefrom any conclusion as to the general prosperity of the country.

Another figure on which the Minister laid stress was that of Dublin bank clearings. I suggest that figure shows next to nothing as to the increase or decrease of the assets of the country. There, too, the greater activity in bank clearings is an inevitable result of a protectionist policy. Payments are made here that would otherwise have been made abroad and the bank clearings are accordingly increased.

Comment on this

The currency did not increase.

Comment on this

Another point on which the Minister laid stress was the increased consumption of shoes, not in value but in the number of pairs that were actually consumed by purchasers during the year. I cannot feel that is a very conclusive figure because, after all, it may mean—I do not say it does—that the shoes are of inferior quality and do not last as long, or it may mean, again, that there is a transport strike on and people have to walk so much that they wear out their shoes quickly.

Comment on this

The figures related to 1933.

Comment on this

Not later than that?

Comment on this

I was merely refuting a statement made by Deputy Mulcahy.

Comment on this

At any rate, I cannot regard that shoe figure seriously as proof of the country's prosperity. Let us turn to some other figures. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has spoken of bank clearings, but there are some other figures available in connection with banks. As a matter of fact, the Irish Independent forestalled me this morning by mentioning them in its leading article. One is the total of bank deposits. The total of Irish Free State deposits has sunk considerably.

Comment on this

As compared with 1931?

Comment on this

As compared with 1931—is that not so?

Comment on this

I was informed, at any rate, on extremely good authority that, as compared with the period immediately before this Government came into office, there had been a considerable fall in deposits of Irish Free State clients of Irish Free State banks. Then there is the banks' excess of sterling assets over liabilities. There is no question that that has sunk as compared with this time three years ago. There has been a fall of about £8,000,000 in the excess of sterling assets over liabilities now as compared with the figure for that excess three years ago. We are £8,000,000 worse off now than then.

Comment on this

The deficiency is even greater.

Comment on this

I have no desire to paint the picture in its blackest form. I want to put it in its most moderate form.

Comment on this

The trend of the American exchange would explain a good deal of that.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce is very fond of telling us that the volume of overseas trade is no index of prosperity at all. I cannot accept that view, not for a moment. I am prepared to admit that, taken by itself, it is not absolutely conclusive, but still it is a very important factor. The value of our overseas trade has fallen calamitously since the present Government came into office. It has fallen by about £28,000,000 per annum.

A still more significant guide to us is the adverse trade balance. At present the adverse trade balance is over £20,000,000 a year. I am quite aware of the fact that that is not the whole of the picture, that there are invisible items to be taken into account, too. To resolve what is really the adverse balance, taking visible and invisible items, is a very difficult problem, a problem on which I think all the experts are waiting to hear the conclusions of the Banking Commission which is at present sitting. But what you can do is to see the general trend of the last few years, and there is no question at all that that trend has been unfavourable. When the present Government came into office the adverse trade balance was less than £12,000,000 per annum. Even at that figure it was made a very great deal of by the propagandists of the Fianna Fáil Party. Nowadays they treat the adverse trade balance as something of no account at all, but they used to take a very lurid view of it. When the volume of our overseas trade shrunk by 33? per cent., you would naturally have expected the figure of the adverse balance to shrink proportionately. Instead of being £12,000,000, you would have expected it to go to £8,000,000. As against that, it has, in fairness, to be admitted that our position on the invisible side was improved by the retention of the land annuities and that the visible trade balance was made worse by the fact that the English collected the land annuities in the shape of tariffs which meant lower prices for agricultural goods, so that I take it that it would be fair to add on approximately £5,000,000 to that £8,000,000. If, therefore, the adverse balance to-day stood at £13,000,000 instead of the £12,000,000 at which it stood when the Government came into office, we might perhaps have said that the figure showed no deterioration; that it showed no improvement but it showed no deterioration. It stands, however, in fact, not at £13,000,000, but at over £20,000,000.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce attempted to prove that a part of that was accounted for by the fact that we were making exceptional importations for the purpose of founding new industries which would not recur in future years. I do not believe that. I believe that if the industrial policy of the Government goes on and has any success, similar importations will have to continue for a great many years to come, and for so many years to come that it is no use for us to look forward to a period when such importations will not be taking place. Consequently, I cannot agree that we should wipe out a portion of that £20,000,000 on that score.

That is the situation so far as it has gone up to the present. What is it likely to be for the future with regard to that adverse balance? I suggest that there is every reason to expect a progressive deterioration if things go on as they are going at present. It would have been a problem, even if the present Government had not come into office at all and even if they had not started their disastrous policy of ruining agriculture and ruining our export trade, that tended to get more serious than it was, for this reason, that very large payments are coming into the country at present which will, by degrees, be extinguished. The money coming into this country from Great Britain for Army pensions and for R.I.C. pensions will not be coming in for ever. Those moneys run into £3,000,000 or £4,000,000 a year, and they make a very substantial item, of which account has to be taken. Then there is money coming into this country from America that will tend to diminish because emigration to America has stopped. It is the young people who have gone out to America who are the people likely to send home remittances to their fathers and mothers, and, as their aged relatives die off, these remittances will stop. Then there is the question of residents in Ireland who derive their incomes largely from investments out of Ireland. Is it not a fact that those people will tend to diminish in numbers so far as we can see? There are many people, elderly people, still living in this country because they have always lived in it, and because, at their time of life, they do not feel inclined to change, who will not be succeeded by their children and whose children will tend to live elsewhere because their presence in this country is not encouraged and because they are not sympathetic, rightly or wrongly, with the general political trend of the Party now in power. Of course, the day may come when the Party which is now in power will be out of power, and when there will be a more sympathetic feeling on the part of such people as I describe.

Comment on this

But the children do not believe that. They will not stay.

Comment on this

At any rate, people act on what the conditions are at the present time and not on what they hope conditions may be in a year or two, and the Government certainly which is formulating the Budget and which hopes and expects to stay in office indefinitely must proceed as if it was going on with its own policy.

That suggests to us another reflection. The Minister for Finance talks about expenditure such as we are presented with as an example of shouldering the responsibilities of freedom. What additional expenditure must we expect when we come to shoulder the responsibilities of the larger freedom? It was a bit of a shock to hear a member of the present Government referring to our present condition as freedom at all, because they are fonder of painting us as slaves and asserting that we have not yet attained independence and that we have, in some mysterious way, to conduct a fight for it; but is it not plain that if they have any spark of belief in their own predictions about the Republic they should be preparing for the day when our financial system will have to stand even greater strains than are being imposed upon it at present, and when such matters as the adverse balance, which we have just been discussing, are likely to be very unfavourably affected by the political developments for which the Fianna Fáil Party hope, or pretend to hope, to be responsible?

So much for the balance of payments, visible and invisible. Before I turn to the indications given by the Budget itself, there is one more test which appears to me of very great importance, which Government spokesmen have neglected altogether. What is, even to-day, in the opinion of every Deputy in this House the main source of wealth in this country? Is it not land? Is there any single person who would deny that? What has been the effect of the present Government's policy on the value of land? How is it that neither the Minister for Finance nor the Minister for Industry and Commerce in their very lengthy speeches ever thought of even alluding to the effect of their policy on the value of land? Is it not a fact that, in most parts of the country, land has become almost completely unmarketable and that it certainly would be on the conservative side to say that land had depreciated 35 per cent. in value——

Comment on this

The very opposite.

Comment on this

——since the present Government came into office.

Comment on this

The Land Commission are giving £2 10s. an acre for it down in Meath.

Comment on this

It has increased in value 50 per cent. in Cork County.

Comment on this

Absolutely untrue.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy ever try to buy half-an-acre for a police barracks?

Comment on this

Or a labourer's cottage?

Comment on this

I do not think that is a fair test. Did the Minister ever try to sell any to a private party or to the Land Commission?

Comment on this

Take the Roscommon land down to Cork.

Comment on this

Take the Meath case which the Land Commission have in court to-day—£2 10s. an acre to buy it out.

Comment on this

Let us turn to the indications given by the Budget itself and to the speech of the Minister for Finance in introducing the Budget. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has spoken as if this country was flowing with milk and honey and as though we were having a boom here unprecedented in the annals of the Irish people. If that is so why is there a deficit at all—because, do not let us forget, a deficit there is. When we say that the Minister for Finance has a surplus what do you mean? You mean that if the taxes were maintained at the same level as the preceding year, there would be more than enough to pay the expenses in the year to come. If you say he has a deficit you mean that if the taxes in the year to come were maintained exactly at the same level as the year before, they would not be sufficient to pay for the expenses. The Minister for Finance talked a few weeks before his Budget of being in the position of having a comfortable surplus. Instead of that we find him piling on extra taxes.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce said the yield of taxation had been well maintained. Is that true? Which are the taxes that gave so much satisfaction? What is the description of the Minister for Finance himself of the situation with regard to income tax and estate duties, which are perhaps as good an index as any? His description of the situation is that there has been "a notable shortfall." And mind you, the Estimates of the Government as pointed out in this House over and over again by Deputy McGilligan, in regard to the yield of income tax were extremely pessimistic, compared with the Estimates in former years, as to the amount produced by threepence or sixpence on the income tax. Yet from these pessimistic Estimates, there has resulted a notable shortfall from income tax and estate duties. There has been an increase in the yield of corporation profit tax, but after all that is only to be expected, because there has been an increase in the number of corporations, owing to the protectionist policy of the Government. With regard to corporation profit tax I wish to repeat what I said two or three times before, that I regard it as one of the most unjust and indefensible taxes and one that ought to be abolished because it is a case of imposing income tax twice over— first on the corporation and then on the shareholders. There has been an improvement in the yield of excess profit tax, but that throws no light whatever upon the present economic condition in the country, because it is a tax that has been abolished and it is merely a question of collecting arrears. As regards the drop of the yield in the liquor taxes, I personally would not attach as much importance to it as other speakers have done, because I agree there is a trend away from consumption of liquor. But it must in fairness be said that if one admits that there is a world-wide trend towards decrease in liquor consumption, that is balanced by a world-wide trend towards increased tobacco consumption. Therefore, if the Minister is not to be humiliated over the reduced yield of the liquor taxes, neither must he boast of any increased yield in the tobacco taxes. Both one and the other may be representative only of a fashion. So I personally am aware of no taxation result that deserves to be accepted as a proof of the prosperity of the country.

The speech of the Minister for Finance contained references to the sugar situation and to the motor car situation which were decidedly ominous. He described the future of the sugar beet industry in this country as uncertain and insecure, unless they achieved a drastic lowering of costs which would enable them to contribute more abundantly to the Exchequer. And he later referred to the motor car industry in this country as being in the same position as the sugar industry in that regard. These remarks of the Minister for Finance received very little attention from the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who seemed very little concerned about the spirit or the letter of the Minister for Finance's speech as a whole. There you have another example of the complete recklessness of the statements that Fianna Fáil Deputies are in the habit of making beforehand, and the frequency with which their predictions and calculations are falsified by the events.

Comment on this

It is lucky for Deputy MacDermot that Deputy McGilligan is not at the moment on the benches opposite.

Comment on this

Let me add further that some light may be obtained on the question of the prosperity or otherwise of the country from the fact that there is such necessity for providing relief and work for the unemployed out of Government funds. To have to provide, not only relief, but an ever-increasing amount of relief for the poor throughout the country is far from being an indication of increased prosperity.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce has expressed the view that it is outrageous for the Opposition to object to the total figures of the nation's expenditure. He says it is outrageous for them to object to the imposition of new taxes unless they are prepared to make definite suggestions in regard to economy. Of course, I understand his motive. Nothing would please him better than to drive the Opposition into making wild utterances about taking away much of the social services at present in existence. For example, such utterances would be a great service to the Government in the approaching by-elections, about which the Minister had so much to say. I should like to know where it has been found to be the duty, or the custom of an Opposition to make proposals for economy or savings while in opposition. In no part of the world do Oppositions do that sort of thing. On the very rare occasions that it has been done, it did not turn out so well. If we had nothing else to deter us from making such suggestions, it would be sufficient to have the example of our predecessors when they were in opposition. In my perusal of the speeches of the Minister for Industry and Commerce before he became Minister, I found he was very glib about the possibility of immense reductions in the cost of the Civil Service, in the cost of the Army and in the cost of the police. It is true that, as a general election approached, all the statements of those who are now Ministers with regard to economies became less and less specific. While the economies were still insisted on as possible, they were to be accomplished by some vague procedure, described as "reorganisation," which was not to take a penny piece out of the pockets of anybody except a few highly-paid officials of non-national sympathies and non-national records. Once the Government came into office, the complete futility and insincerity of all their statements about economy were amply proven, and I should be very sorry that we should tread the same paths that they trod.

We are, however, perfectly entitled to say this, and we do say it—that we believe a very large proportion of the misery and destitution existing in this country is caused by the general policy of the Government and that we do sincerely and honestly believe that a great deal of the expenditure in relief of that misery and destitution would be avoided if the general policy of the Government were reversed. More than that with regard to economy, there is no obligation on us to say. We are, however, entitled to note, and do note, that not only have the Government not reduced the cost of the Army and the police, but they have very considerably increased it. We are entitled to question, and do question, whether that increase was necessary or was desirable. The other day the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, under pressure from his constituents, was induced to foreshadow economies in the Government services at some date when the remnants of the British régime—the highly paid officials protected by the Treaty—should have been got rid of. Even for that expression of view, which he probably hoped would not be reported in the newspapers but which was, he received an appalling drubbing in this House from Deputy Norton. He swallowed the leek quite meekly without venturing to utter a word in reply. With the best will in the world, I can find nothing in the record of the present Ministers while they were in opposition, or in the relation between what they said when in opposition and what they now say, to encourage us to imitate them.

Now, having dealt with the general economic condition of the country, I turn to the question whether this Budget is fiscally sound. The first point to which I ask the House to direct its attention is that of borrowing. The last speaker, like several others, objected to borrowing for bounties, but expressed his approval of borrowing for the other items for which the Government do borrow. I do not agree with him. I entirely disapprove of borrowing for bounties, but there are other borrowings of which I also disapprove. The Minister for Industry and Commerce himself used to take a very austere view of borrowing when he was in Opposition. He was not at all content that the Government of the day should borrow even for nonrecurring items unless they made quite sure that there were not to be other non-recurring items of similar size in future Budgets. I think that that principle has rather been lost sight of now. The principle I should like to see enforced in regard to borrowing is that there should be borrowing only for objects that would be, in fact, revenue-producing. I think that borrowing for housing purposes is certainly justified if the houses are going to be let at economic rents. What about property losses compensation? Why should we saddle posterity with responsibility for compensation for property losses?

Comment on this

Why pay it all in one year?

Comment on this

It was borrowed for by the previous Government.

Comment on this

I do not care what was done by previous Governments. I remain of the same opinion, that it is unsound to pay the bulk or, as has been done, the whole of property losses compensation by borrowing. It seems to me that we are putting a great deal on the shoulders of posterity. I think it was a member of the Irish House of Commons, before the Union, who once exclaimed: "What has posterity done for us that we should consider posterity?" I am not prepared to take quite so selfish a view as that. I think we are asking posterity to shoulder a great deal as it is. It is very doubtful if posterity will be thankful to us for all we have done in this country for the last 20 years.

Comment on this

They will have forgotten you.

Comment on this

We are tending to pile more and more burdens upon their shoulders and to take away the assets that should be theirs. Take the case of the annuities that have been funded. I do not see why these annuities should not be left to posterity as an asset, or why we should anticipate them and borrow on their security.

Comment on this

It is only bounties for which they propose to borrow.

Comment on this

I am speaking of the security on which the borrowings are being made. Let us turn now to the industrial alcohol plant. Is it sound to borrow for that? The answer to that question depends on your view as to whether it is a sound business or not. If it is unsound, it should not be borrowed for. If it is a highly speculative business, it ought not to be borrowed for. We ought to take a conservative view and pay a considerable amount, if not all, of that out of revenue. To borrowing for the purchase of land for afforestation I have no objection. It is proposed to borrow half the cost of the halls for the Volunteer Force. Is it sound finance to borrow for that purpose? The excuse of the Government is that if they ever wanted to sell the halls they would get half the original cost of them. Is that sufficient justification? Will they ever want to sell the halls? Under what circumstances will they want to sell the halls? They will not want to sell the halls. Halls are being built at present, and other halls will be built in future years. It is no more justifiable to borrow for this purpose than it would be to borrow for any other item of expenditure. It seems to me that that expenditure should be met out of revenue.

Comment on this

They will get the whole cost out of the local authorities when the halls are burned down.

Comment on this

If they are depending on that, of course borrowing is all right. We come now to repayment of the Dáil External Loan. Is it right to borrow for that? I cannot see that it is. It is another case of shoving our responsibilities on to posterity. That is not a revenue producing item in any shape or form. We should make a beginning, at least, at paying that off out of revenue. In support of his proposal that we should borrow to meet the whole of it, the Minister for Finance said that we were turning an external loan into an internal loan. It is a bad loan, an unhealthy loan, a loan without any economic basis.

Comment on this

What did Cumann na nGaedheal do?

Comment on this

I do not care twopence what Cumann na nGaedheal did. I am talking of principles which seem to me to be sound. Frankly, I have not examined to what extent these principles were carried out by former Governments. I think we should be entitled to consider any question that affects the interests of this country, with fresh minds, as it crops up, without having to adhere blindly to precedent.

Comment on this

How does it differ in principle from the British War Loan, which is not a revenue producing asset to Britain?

Comment on this

I do not understand the Deputy's argument.

Comment on this

I think it is quite clear, and if the Deputy likes I shall explain.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting that there never should be such a thing as a War Loan. There has to be such a thing as a War Loan. In this particular case it was not really due from us. It was, as we all know, a loan repayable in the event of certain things coming to pass, but these things have not come to pass.

Comment on this

It is posterity's debt.

Comment on this

The Deputy is now on different ground altogether.

Comment on this

At any rate, I frankly admit that the case on that is not near as strong as it is on some of the other items, but even on that I personally take a conservative point of view, and would like to see a considerable portion of it met out of revenue.

Comment on this

Should we pay it at all?

Comment on this

As we have agreed to pay it there is no use talking about that.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy suggest that we should pay it all in the one year?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should not interrupt. He was afforded ample time to put his case.

Comment on this

Turning to the question of export bounties and subsidies, the excuse given for borrowing for this purpose is that the conditions are transitory and abnormal. Are they transitory and abnormal? What evidence is there of it? What leads the Government to think that they are transitory and abnormal? Is there anything to lead them to suppose that the present British Government is going to alter its point of view in the matter of our dispute with them? Are they banking on the present British Government being replaced by a Labour Government in the next general election, and if they are replaced by a Labour Government in the next general election, are the hopes of this Government likely to be fulfilled? My own notion on the matter is that if a Labour Government came into power in Great Britain our Ministry would be extremely embarrassed, because, I think, it is very likely that a Labour Government would offer them international arbitration on the whole financial dispute, and I think that is the very last thing they would like to be offered.

Comment on this

That is all we want.

Comment on this

I think it is in the highest degree imprudent of them, if that is their expectation, to assume that they will win the arbitration and act as if there was to be no question of having to pay, as a result of arbitration, a sum equivalent to the amount of these export bounties and subsidies.

Comment on this

What will happen if the Deputy's Party comes back?

Comment on this

I suggest that so far as we can see these export bounties and subsidies are not transitory and are not abnormal. Therefore they ought to be met out of revenue. I suggest, moreover, that the land annuity arrears which are being relied upon to replenish some day or other the Guarantee Fund are a very doubtful asset, bearing in mind the present condition of the country and the prospect of a further deterioration in that condition. For all these reasons, I repeat that the export bounties and subsidies ought to be met out of revenue. The Minister for Industry and Commerce made a great point of this: that only £1,500,000 had so far been provided by borrowing for export bounties and subsidies. That relates to last year, but there is to be another £1,350,000 found for the same purpose this year. How long it is intended to continue the practice of unsound borrowing in respect of export bounties and subsidies I do not know, but I think it ought to be recognised that it is unsound.

Now let me turn to another matter in connection with the soundness of the Budget: that is, the deduction of nearly £1,000,000 for overestimation in the case of Supply Services. It has been pointed out by several people that that is really a very odd item indeed. I am quite aware that an item similar to that—I do not say the same figure—used to appear in the Budgets of the last Government, but that does not reconcile me to it, and it did not reconcile Ministers to it when they were in opposition. I found a passage in a speech made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce on a Budget that was introduced in a year before his Party came into office, in which he described the custom of having such an item at all as thoroughly unsound and unhealthy. I agree with him. I think it is unsound and unhealthy, and that being so I am amazed—or I would be amazed if I had not so many examples of similar conduct on the part of Ministers in relation to other matters—that his views on the subject have not been reflected in the Budget of his Party, now that they are in office.

Let us turn to the taxes and to the question of justice and equity. The Minister for Industry and Commerce gave us an eloquent period about the redistribution of the wealth of the country. He told us that this Budget was not merely in accordance with Fianna Fáil policy, but that it was an instrument of Fianna Fáil policy. All I can say is, that if this is the redistribution at which Fianna Fáil policy has been aiming it is a very rum sort of redistribution. Let me look at it from the point of view of Ballinameen. Is this a Budget for subsidising Ballinameen at the expense, shall we say, of Ailesbury Road, or is it a Budget for subsidising Ailesbury Road at the expense of Ballinameen? It looks to me much more like the latter, and if that is the kind of redistribution of wealth at which the Fianna Fáil Party are aiming, then I think the country is entitled to be more clearly informed about it than it has been up to the present.

I would like the Minister for Finance, when he is concluding, to tell us frankly why, faced with the necessities with which he says he is faced, he has not increased the standard rate of income tax? I think we are entitled to be told clearly about that.

Comment on this

Because it is too high already.

Comment on this

It may be that he thinks that the yield would be less, or no better, if he did increase it, but if so I would like to have him say so—I would like to have that put on the records. Or it may be that he is thinking about the conversion of the National Loan and that this is what one might call a rich man's budget or a banker's budget for the purpose of getting investors into good humour for accepting the conversion, and that he intends, having successfully reconciled them to a reduction in their income, to fleece them good and proper in the Budget of 1936. It would be very interesting, if that is a fact, to have it clearly stated.

Before the present Ministers came into office they were perfectly clear that there was too much indirect taxation in this country. It was a favourite theme of the Minister for Industry and Commerce: that nothing should be done to add to indirect taxation, and yet this Budget piles on new indirect taxation. If the Minister had gone specially out of his way to choose the items that would hit the poor hardest he could not have chosen otherwise: bread, tea, sugar and tobacco. The social justice of this Budget is certainly not apparent to me unless it be that the Minister has really arrived at the end of his tether in the matter of direct taxation. If he has, as I have said before, it would be very well indeed for us all that that should be plainly stated. If, on the contrary, the country is flowing with milk and honey, as is alleged by the Minister for Industry and Commerce—if we are in the middle of a boom—I cannot imagine on what grounds it is possible to defend making these additions to the annual budget of the small farmer in Ballinameen or the like of Ballinameen.

I should like to hear from some Deputy who is familiar with the budgets of the small farmer what are the amounts of tea, sugar, bread and tobacco that the small farmer has to buy in the course of the year, and what is the amount that will be added to the small farmer's expenditure by these taxes. If we could get authentic figures on that, I think it would be a shock to the House. Not alone do these new taxes bear with undue severity on the poor, but the new taxes and the new economies, taken together, bear with undue severity on the agricultural areas as compared with urban areas— on the areas that are most depressed at the present moment. Is it not the agricultural areas that will principally suffer, for example, from the tightening up of the regulations with regard to old age pensions? I imagine, too, that it is the agricultural districts that will principally suffer from the decrease in the amount to be given for unemployment assistance; and it is certainly the agricultural areas, rather than the urban areas, which will be hit most hard by the indirect taxes on tea, tobacco, sugar, and bread.

We are told by Ministers that, at any rate, there is one thing we cannot complain of, and that is the total volume of taxation. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has discovered now, what he never knew before he was in office, that it does not matter how big taxation is so long as the spending is good spending; that the total figure of taxation really does not matter; that it just redistributes wealth and keeps money circulating. Now, I do not accept that point of view. That is the point of view that brought the last Labour Government in England to destruction.

Comment on this

It was the banks that did that.

Comment on this

The weakness of that point of view, is, in the first place, that capital is, to a large extent, mobile and can be frightened away by heavy taxation; and, secondly, that there is a proved and direct connection between high taxation and unemployment. There is no doubt of it. High taxation produces unemployment. There is no question of it. It has produced it in every country.

Comment on this

Yes, but the unemployment produces the high taxation—not the reverse.

Comment on this

Sometimes it is the one, and sometimes it is the other. The two phenomena are closely connected. If a man's spirit is broken by heavy taxation, he has less initiative and less courage to employ money in industry and commerce and he has less of that unselfish desire to help one's brethren, which causes men to give employment that is necessary neither for their own comfort nor their own well-being. There is a very large amount of employment of that kind which is given primarily out of good nature and out of the desire to be helpful to one's fellow-citizens, and there is nothing so destructive of that kind of employment as high taxation. Therefore, I am quite satisfied that high taxation is an evil; but even if high taxation in itself were not evil, I would still maintain that in this present Budget the sort of new taxation which we are being asked to agree to is necessarily bad taxation. I object to the provisions of the Budget, not alone because I am appalled at the quantity of the expenditure that we are asked to meet, the quantity of revenue that is to be raised from our people, but because I am appalled also at the quality of the taxation that is being imposed.

It is a favourite contention of the present Ministry that Ireland was fleeced to the tune of £300,000,000 or thereabouts by the British Government during the period between the Union and the setting up of the Free State.

Comment on this

That is true.

Comment on this

What is that contention based on?

Comment on this

Facts and figures.

Comment on this

It is not based on the theory that more was got out of Ireland than was spent in Ireland. It was not on that basis that the Childers Commission came to the conclusions it came to. The Childers Commission came to its conclusions, whether they are right or wrong, on the basis that a nation as poor as Ireland is suffers more from taxation than a richer nation; that there ought to be a different scale of taxation altogether. The Commission depended for its conclusions on the principle that taxation was, in itself, a great evil, no matter how the money arising from that taxation was spent. If we are now to adopt the principle that taxation is not an evil at all, so long as the money is well spent, the whole of the case against Great Britain, with regard to our financial history since the Union, disappears, and I think it is just as well that that fact should be borne in mind. If any Deputy doubts what I have said about the findings of the Childers Commission, he has only to read the material that exists about these proceedings and the various references made to the Commission by historians.

I hope, Sir, that I have gone some way towards establishing that the general financial and economic condition of the country is bad and tends, so far as we can see, to get worse and not better: that this Budget is, in many respects, unsound: that this Budget exacts a volume of taxation from this country, that, according to all opinions held hitherto—and perhaps sincerely held even now by Deputies opposite, although they dare not express them—is out of proportion to our resources: and, furthermore, that the kind of new taxes which the Government is imposing are especially calculated to press upon the poorest classes and the classes who are in the worst situation as a result of the dispute of our Government with Great Britain. The Minister for Finance sums it all up by saying that we are shouldering the major responsibilities of freedom. I think that if these are the responsibilities and fruits of freedom, freedom is something that will tend to become discredited, and, as a lover of freedom, I should be the last man to wish to see that happen.

Let us remind ourselves for a moment of the situation of Ballinameen, and the like of Ballinameen.

Comment on this

It is an important place.

Comment on this

I said at the beginning of my remarks that I was less impressed by statistics than by actual human contacts. What has Ballinameen to say on the whole question? It says:—

"From our experience for two years past as people living on the land, we find it impossible to carry on under present conditions. We consider there must be a change in the internal economic policy in the Twenty-Six Counties, so that if it is a war it must be a war for all, each having to bear a proportionate share. Peace and content cannot be in this country while one section is working hard and cannot work out a living, and another is getting 400 per cent. over pre-War rates of pay. We hope the Government will consider any reasonable proposal put before them, and not drive the people into the other organisations, which might not be for the good of the country."

There speaks Ballinameen. And what is the effort of the Minister in reply?

Comment on this

That has been repudiated at Ballinameen.

Comment on this

No, Sir. It has not. It has been repudiated by one national teacher, one of the class so keen on the economic war that they made the fiercest fight of all classes against the Minister's temporary economies. They were quite willing that the farmers should pay but not that they should contribute. What was the answer of the Minister to Ballinameen? "No doubt, in time, there would have to be more balance in the economic war than there had been." Does this Budget represent the beginning? Is this Budget going to produce more balance in the economic war than hitherto? This Budget has increased the cost of bread, tea, sugar and tobacco on the poor man. If that is the sort of thing that is to be associated with freedom, I am indeed afraid that freedom will be discredited and that every spark of idealism will disappear from this country. I for one would be extremely sorry to see any such thing happening. The real responsibilities of freedom are to tell the truth to your own people, to throw off delusions and to help them to throw off delusions, to be reasonable and honourable in your dealings with foreign countries, to administer justice impartially, to ensue peace in deed and not only in words, and to acquire and to try to help others to acquire, an adult political mentality.

There is a famous parable in Plato's Republic about a cave in which prisoners are so chained that they can only look in one direction. From childhood they have been compelled to look only at a blank wall and at the shadows on the wall. Behind them there is light, and people and objects keep passing between them and the light. They never see these people and objects; they only see the shadows on the wall. All their ideas of reality are derived from these shadows. When they are freed and brought towards the light they refuse to believe that real things are real, and they refuse to regard the people leading them out as friends. They regard them as enemies whom they wish to stone or to kill. They regard them, in our terminology, as traitors and Imperialists.

The real responsibilities of freedom, if we have attained freedom, and if Ministers admit that we have, consist, not in taking the line of electoral advantage, not in sharing the delusions, or pretending to share the delusions, of the prisoners from the cave, but in renouncing these electoral advantages and playing the part that freedom and education really impose upon you. Teach the people to set their feet in the pathway of reality. When the Government do that they will have full co-operation from the Opposition.

If in the by-elections, or any other elections that are before us, the Government, who are such expert electioneerers—and I make no concealment of the fact that electioneering is their strong suit—if they choose to maintain and to propagate mischievous delusions they are welcome to any benefit their Party may derive. We do not propose to imitate them. We welcome the opportunity which the Minister for Industry and Commerce said that the by-elections will afford us to set our ideals once again before the electors. We welcome that opportunity with considerable confidence, confidence enhanced by the impositions in this Budget. Whether the electors act with common sense or patriotism, or whether they do not, I want to assure the Minister and his colleagues that no electioneering considerations will shake us in the very least in the propagation of sound principles and in the conduct of public affairs on lines that seem to us patriotic, and calculated to lead to the peace and prosperity of the country.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I am afraid Deputy MacDermot must have been taking his revenge on the House for having rejected his motion to confine speeches to one half-hour, because I think what the Deputy said might easily have been said in half an hour or, in fact, less. He set out at the beginning to make a very clever political speech. He said that the taxes were fundamentally unpopular and inequitable. The fundamental thing about them was that they were unpopular, and he expressed the opinion that perhaps they were inequitable. He hoped that continued criticism of the Budget would enlighten the people on that point; that they were unpopular taxes. That was the point Deputy MacDermot and every speaker on the Opposition Benches tried to emphasise when dealing with the Budget.

Comment on this

That is what the Minister for Industry and Commerce said.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We all say they are unpopular.

Comment on this

And you are not making a political speech.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Deputy MacDermot and other Deputies when criticising the Budget tried to play on the unpopularity of the taxes, but did not attempt to show that they were in any way inequitable. He said that they were unpopular. That is the only thing the Deputy could say in his speech of one and a quarter hours' duration. He ended up with an appeal to the electors of Galway and County Dublin. He said, of course, that they could not improve the position, and talked of economies in view of the pending by-elections. That finished that point. Instead of making points or suggestions that would be for the good of the country, the Deputy suppressed them, as the by-elections were of much more importance to the Fine Gael Party. I am sure Deputy MacDermot believes he could make suggestions that would be for the good of the country. But why should he consider the good of the country when by-elections are pending and when there is a chance that Fine Gael might do well out of them.

Comment on this

If the Minister will allow me to interrupt him, I may say that what he says is not at all a fact. I suggested that the increases made by the Government in the Army and in the police were unnecessary, but I said, in the main, that our point of view was that the general economic policy of the Government made a large part of the expenditure in the Budget necessary, which would not be necessary if that economic policy were abandoned. I did not say that I had any suggestions to make that I suppressed, because of the by-elections, nor did I imply that.

Comment on this

That is not what Deputy Roddy said.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy said that we could not succeed in getting him to make suggestions for economies in view of the by-elections.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We will wait until we see the Official Report. In the speeches of the Opposition from the commencement there was a demand for a decrease in taxation and a general demand for increased expenditure all the year round.

Comment on this

Did you ever suggest that yourself?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes, but we suggested it intelligently and pointed out how it could be done. Here we have an Opposition that has shown neither intelligence nor common sense in suggestions about cutting down taxation and increasing expenditure, on the gage thrown out by Deputy MacDermot and others, not to make any suggestions until the by-elections are over. That is the sort of game they are carrying on. When we were in Opposition we used to make positive statements——

Comment on this

What were they?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I remember on one occasion making a positive statement with regard to the beer taxes, that is that they were not to be lessened. The Opposition over there may be sitting in that position for the next 40 years if they are 40 years in the House, but they will not be in office, and I am quite sure in all those years they will not have the courage to make such a positive statement.

Comment on this

The Minister is not aware that I voted against a reduction of the beer tax.

Comment on this

That was when you were in a different Party.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Opposition, I am sure, will admit that the greater part of the increase in expenditure under this Government has been in the way of social services. If one were to go through the list and take out the items that come under the heading of social services, such things as unemployment assistance, relief schemes, housing, old age pensions and so on, one would find that they would come to £9,000,000 sterling. Under these particular headings the expenditure has been doubled since the Cumann na nGaedheal Government were in power. We have in these items of social services an increase in expenditure of between £4,000,000 and £5,000,000. No member on the Opposition Benches has attempted to suggest that a single item under these headings should be cut out. I know they will not, though some of them may feel that we should not give so much in old age pensions or that we should not be bringing in a Bill to give pensions to widows and orphans. Naturally Cumann na nGaedheal will not agree to increase old age pensions seeing that they resigned office in 1931 rather than do that. Now when they are in Opposition they will not do it.

We must be reconciled to the fact that the Opposition will still play politics in discussing the Budget as well as in discussing anything else. Deputy MacDermot talked about high taxation, the quantity of taxation and the aggregate amount of taxation paid, and he said it is too high. But he does not suggest that we should cut down any of our expenditure. He did suggest, perhaps, a small saving in the Gárda Síochána and in the Army. Perhaps a saving could be made in the Gárda if Deputy MacDermot had more influence amongst his own followers; but I will leave that aside for the moment. If we take up the Fine Gael election address we find that they are promising to give old age pensions at 65. That is another £3,500,000.

Comment on this

How much did the Minister say?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

£3,500,000.

Comment on this

Where did the Minister get that figure?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

By calculation—how do you get any figure except by calculation?

Comment on this

Now we know the origin of the old age pensions at 65.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

They also suggest that there should be derating. That item, with the old age pensions at 65, is going to add £5,000,000 to present expenditure. If Deputy MacDermot is Minister for Finance, as we are told is to be the case, there is going to be no borrowing for property losses compensation, for external loans, for volunteer halls, and for none of these things mentioned, so that another few millions is going to be added to the taxation. Deputy MacDermot, in that case, would have to meet a bill of about £7,000,000 more taxation than we are meeting at present. The Deputy will not tax sugar or tea or tobacco or corporation profits. He will tax nothing, but notwithstanding that he is going to get £7,000,000 more. Did anybody ever hear such an idiotic speech? I did not expect to hear such a speech from Deputy MacDermot.

Comment on this

Do not be following his bad example.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I did not catch what the Deputy said. I would like to get a constructive suggestion from Deputy MacDermot, because naturally we are all interested in the Budget. Every Minister has to weigh up and take responsibility for the Budget, and I would be glad to have a constructive suggestion from the Deputy. However, he made it very clear that pending the by-elections in Galway and Dublin he will not make any constructive suggestions. The suggestions he made were destructive as far as the Budget is concerned but, perhaps, they are constructive suggestions so far as Fine Gael is concerned. That is all I dare say Deputy MacDermot is concerned with.

There were two Bills before the House lately. Deputy Belton took a keen interest in these Bills. The Opposition opposed those Bills because I was trying to raise money by levies. They said I should not raise money on butter and bacon by levies, and that I should take these things out of taxation. A division was taken on the question, and every member of the Fine Gael Party voted against me. The result of that, if carried to a conclusion, would be that Deputy MacDermot if he were Minister for Finance, would not only have to raise £7,000,000 but, in addition to that, £800,000 in lieu of the levy on butter, and £500,000 for the levy on bacon——

Comment on this

But the Minister is going to raise all that now.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes, but you must raise it in another way. It must not be raised off the butter consumers or the bacon consumers, or by a tax on wheat or tobacco, or tea or sugar, or corporation profits tax. In that way Deputy MacDermot, when Minister for Finance is going to have the job of getting £8,500,000 extra. The duty on tobacco is £3,000,000. The new taxation that Deputy MacDermot would have to get would reach £15,000,000, but he tells us he will not touch any of these things I have named. Then where is he to get the money?

Comment on this
A Deputy

He must be a currency reformer.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

One cannot have any respect for a Party who will vote for popularity and will not care about any other issue. Popularity is the only issue that has any weight with the Fine Gael Party. We bring in a Butter Bill and a Bacon Bill, and if Fine Gael see that we are going to give anything to the creameries they are all in with us. But when we say we are to raise this money in a particular way they are all against us. It is popularity with Fine Gael every time. Deputy MacDermot, in a most deliberate speech here to-day could not have given a better example than he gave as to how Fine Gael is affected by the idea of popularity. What concerns them is the question whether it is a popular thing; make no mistake about it, all that concerns them is whether the thing is popular. They will tread on no one's corns until they get into power, "and then you can do what you like."

I remember saying shortly after we came into power, when we had a very slender majority, that people need not be afraid that we would be beaten. Our big trouble then was putting on tariffs, and it is only on these questions they would vote against us. But in the case of every tariff there would be three or four Cumann na nGaedheal members who would stay away, because they were interested in those tariffs themselves. In other words, these people are so many opportunists, and none of them would vote against the interests of their own constituents. They are sticking to that viewpoint and they are just as much opportunists now as when Deputy MacDermot joined them. I do not think Deputy MacDermot's presence is going to improve things very much, judging by the speech to which we have just listened. In preparing this Budget as well as the other Budgets we have brought in, we considered all these social services, and we considered all the other items of expenditure to see where, if possible, any savings could be effected. Having made out the bill that was necessary to meet expenditure, we then had to consider raising the money to pay what was necessary for the year. I think any Government that can say to the people that they have doubled the amount spent on social services in their three years in office, as we have done, have something to be proud of. We put up the expenditure on these services by £4,500,000. If we had to go to the country we could say we had to raise this money in order to pay for these social services. We should be proud of this Budget, and I say we are proud of it. That is why the Minister for Industry and Commerce said the other day, that we were prepared to fight the by-elections in Dublin and Galway. I think the people of Dublin and Galway, when they see that we have the courage to bring in a Budget like this, will appreciate it no matter what the popularity seekers on the Opposition side may say about it.

The people are going to see through it. They are not a bit impressed with that sort of talk, such as: "Do not tax tea, do not tax sugar, do not tax tobacco, do not take anything off the profits of corporations, but, of course, you must raise this £5,000,000 or £10,000,000 or £15,000,000 that we are going to give you when we come into power." Deputy MacDermot may think that there are foolish people in County Galway and in County Dublin, but they have sense enough to see through that sort of thing. If they do ever pluck up courage to move these writs, as I suppose they will, because they will be more or less shamed into it, when the by-elections are over the Deputy will see that I am right, perhaps then he will have the sense to change his tactics, because the only thing that will make him change his tactics is a reverse.

Deputy MacDermot went on placidly talking about the destructive policy of the present Government with regard to agriculture, but he did not seek to prove that there was anything in that assertion. He evidently took it for granted. I will ask him, as he has evidently a taste for research with regard to figures, to go to the Library or some other place and look up the prices for farm products for the last twelve months and compare them with the prices in Great Britain and Northern Ireland and see whether the agriculturist here can complain that he was very much worse off as a result of the tariff policy of Great Britain against this country. He will find he is not worse off as a result of the economic war, as it is called. Prices are bad in agriculture. That is admitted the world over. But the Opposition, in their political way, try to impress on the people of this country that if the economic war was over everything would be all right. It is the only argument they have left as far as their policy goes. For some commodities we are getting a much better price than if we had an open door to Great Britain without any tariffs, or subsidies or bounties from this side. Every Deputy will admit, for instance, that we are getting a better price for butter and milk products.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Due to Government policy.

Comment on this

We are paying for it ourselves.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

What is wrong with paying it? The Government are criticised for not doing enough for agriculture. I will tell you what we are doing for it. If agriculture is in a bad way, if we are getting poor prices, it is due to the low level of world prices and not to the economic war.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say what price the farmers in Northern Ireland are getting for milk from the creameries?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I will.

Comment on this

Do not answer any prophecies.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not know anything about Columcille's prophecies. When we brought in a stabilisation scheme for butter the Opposition Front Bench voted against us and spent three years afterwards trying to deny that. Leaving that aside, however, as a result of that we had a price ranging from 4d. to 4½d. for milk at the creameries, and in Northern Ireland it was about 3d. until they brought in a stabilisation scheme of their own last year. For two years they were a long way behind us.

Comment on this

What about this year?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

This year they are paying 5d. against our 4d.

Comment on this

Sixpence.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Sixpence in the winter. We have a much better price in the winter, too, considering we are paying 114/- for our butter and no levy taken off it in the winter.

Comment on this

They are not skinning calves in the North.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No; why should they?

Comment on this

There are 26,000 of them for sale by one merchant in Limerick, waiting for the bounty.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy is perhaps better informed than I am. However, I will come to the calf skins later. No Deputy will deny, at any rate, that if there was an open door for milk products into Great Britain with no tariffs there, and no subsidies or bounties or anything else here, we would be getting less for milk products now than we are getting under present circumstances. Two or three days ago the price quoted for New Zealand and Irish butter was about 76/-. We are providing under our scheme here for a price of 100/- to the creameries, as against 76/- and 76/-, less 2/- or 3/- for landing charges the very best they could get if there was not a stabilisation scheme.

Comment on this

New Zealand gets 95/- because of the exchange advantage.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I cannot follow the Deputy on the currency question. Our 100/- might be worth 200/- if Deputy Belton had his way. I am talking about 100/-. They would be getting only 76/- if there was no tariff in Great Britain and no subsidy or bounty here. We are getting a better price for fruit and vegetables and a much better price for all sorts of grain. The price of wheat goes up to 26/-, namely, 14/- more than if there was no Government policy of protection. Barley is a much better price; oats are a much better price—there is smuggling of oats across the Border. As a result of our policy, three new beet factories were established and we are delivering beet to four factories instead of one. This protective policy has, in a number of cases, put agriculture in a better position than it would be under the free trade policy of Fine Gael, to which Deputy MacDermot evidently hopes to get back.

Comment on this

How does it affect agricultural wages?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is a hard one. I will not mention tobacco at present, because it is only a small item; but we are getting more of tobacco than if there was no subsidy. I invite any Deputy to examine for the last year the prices of bacon, eggs and poultry, and he will find that we were getting as good a price for these three items as we would have got if there was no tariff, and no subsidy or bounty on them going out of this country. We were getting all round as good a price.

Comment on this

The Minister is getting £250,000 out of it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes, in addition to giving these good prices. We are getting almost as good prices for sheep and horses. The only one item for which there was a much lower price than if there had been free trade was cattle; but it must be remembered that the quota, which would have come in any case, was more responsible for the reduction in the price of cattle than any tariffs or any economic war. Against that reduction in the price of cattle we gave the farmer the benefit of halving the land annuities, which brought the amount down by £2,000,000.

Comment on this