We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Financial Motions. Resolution No. 28—General (Resumed).

Contributions 164–321 of 484. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

What about the price of pigs—47/- here, while 61/- is the average in Northern Ireland.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy is just as dishonest in his statements as Deputy MacDermot. What does 61/- mean? It means 61/- before all the different deductions; there is a levy to the Government; there is a levy to the Board; there is a levy for freight, and it all comes down to about 58/6d.

Comment on this

I have it from a farmer who sold his stuff.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Perhaps he is as honest as the Deputy himself. Will Deputies opposite tell me why do farmers support this Government if all that is true? Why do they put us back into office? It must be either that they believe we are right, and you are wrong, or that if they believe you are right they still say to themselves: "As bad as they are, they are better than Cumann na nGaedheal."

Comment on this

They did believe that at one time—not now. If you get your two Deputies in North Cork to resign to-morrow I will resign and fight against you.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Let the Deputy control himself.

Comment on this

There is a challenge now.

Comment on this

It is a long time since you were there.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

In 1929 we had an election; in 1930 we had another election; in 1931 we had still another; in 1932 we had a general election. If one were to watch the curve of Fianna Fáil support, it went up every time since 1929, although the people had been listening at the cross-roads and everywhere else to Fine Gael and Cumann na nGaedheal propagandists telling them that we have ruined the farmers. They do not believe you, or at least, if they do, they say: "What we have is better than to get that crowd back again."

Comment on this

You told the farmers you were going to win the economic war. They believed that.

Comment on this

They did not even believe Columcille.

Comment on this

They even believe Deputy Donnelly in some places.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Deputy MacDermot is, I admit, a very good political technician. If he adopted a more honest line with the farmers, told them honestly what this Government has done for them or has not done for them, and what his Party's policy would be if they came into power, admitting that they would have to put on certain taxes and have to cut certain expenses, he would get on better. Of course I am only giving that as advice to our friend.

Comment on this

Thank you very much.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not know who the Minister for Agriculture is going to be on the other side. Deputy Dillon always follows me, I know.

Comment on this

Let us hope he will not follow you when he becomes Minister.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton resigned.

Comment on this

And Deputy Hogan retired.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Even that bait was not sufficient to keep him over there. Deputy Dillon follows me as a rule, and I sometimes think that he has been chosen by the other side as the next Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

He follows every other Minister too.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

That is true. Of course, he follows them all. I think Deputy Dillon, or whoever is going to state the agricultural policy for the other side, could state it in three words. Deputy Dillon will not do it in three words; I admit that. But it could be stated in three words—"the English market." That is the only item of policy they have which is different from Fianna Fáil. It is true that Deputy MacDermot said he does not agree with protection. It is true we got a considerable amount of opposition to our protection policy.

Comment on this

When did I say that?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Deputy MacDermot said that while we had a policy of protection in the country there would be high taxation and lots of unemployment. I interpreted that as meaning that he disapproved of protection.

Comment on this

I should like the Minister to quote my words before he makes those sweeping statements.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Perhaps he does not disapprove of protection. I thought he disapproved of high taxation and unemployment, and that therefore he disapproved of protection, but the Deputy may have another way of looking at it. When we were putting on tariffs the Cumann na nGaedheal Party opposed us very strongly. In all their speeches in the beginning they spoke against protection, but when it came to the 1933 election they said they would not remove the tariffs we had put on; in fact, they would pursue the policy which the Fianna Fáil Government had been pursuing. They resigned rather than give another few hundred pounds to the old age pensioners. We gave that money, and when the 1933 election came along Cumann na nGaedheal put it as part of their policy that they would not take that money away from the old age pensioners. They also very strongly opposed wheat growing when we were trying to push it through here. However, as they were going through the country, they saw some farmers sowing wheat, so they said to themselves: "There is no use in losing those few fellows' votes," and they put it into their election speeches that they would adopt the wheat policy also.

Comment on this

They said that they would give it a trial.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes——

Comment on this

That is a different thing altogether.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

——provided that the men growing it would give them a trial.

Comment on this

It has got a trial, and the Minister knows it has got a trial, too.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I should like very much if some authoritative person on the other side, whether it be Deputy Dillon or whoever the next Minister for Agriculture is going to be, would tell us some day what their agricultural policy is, and how it is to be different from the agricultural policy on this side except in that one respect—the British market. I remember asking here about two years ago—Deputy MacDermot was not a leader of the opposite Party at that time—suppose we were going over to negotiate in London, would they agree that we should pay the £5,000,000 again? They said they would not agree. I thought I might bid them up, so I asked if they would agree to pay £3,000,000, and they said "No"; they would agree to pay nothing. We were to go over and settle with the British Government, but give them nothing; the same Fine Gael policy of popularity with the country—"settle with John Bull but for goodness' sake do not give them £1,000,000 or even £500,000. It would not do for us were we to agree to that."

Comment on this

We suggested a lump sum.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

How much?

Comment on this

The lowest we could get; the best bargain we could make.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Would the Deputy agree to £10,000,000?

Comment on this

On the same lines as the coal-cattle pact.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Do not try to help Deputy MacDermot out. He is quite an able Deputy.

Comment on this

I think it would be well worth £25,000,000.

Comment on this

What was the settlement at Ottawa?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Anyway, we have got something from the Opposition, of which I am very glad. We have it from Deputy MacDermot that it would be worth a settlement of £25,000,000 down. It should not be borrowed, I take it?

Comment on this

Yes—it should be borrowed.

Comment on this

You are paying £5,000,000 a year, anyway.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No.

Comment on this

Yes—in tariffs.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Not exactly. The Deputy should be more precise. Deputy MacDermot also, in speaking on this question, criticised the tax on wheat. Deputy O'Leary says we have got a trial of the wheat policy. We are getting a very good trial. We expect to have about 200,000 acres this year. There were 21,000 acres in 1931, and now we hope to reach an acreage of 200,000 this year.

Comment on this

Would the Minister answer one question, and discuss it on business lines? What did it cost per acre last year to grow wheat?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

What did it cost to the farmer?

Comment on this

No—to the taxpayer. What did it cost in bounty? I think that is a fair question.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I think, as far as I remember the subsidy was 6/6 per barrel, and the average yield worked out, I think, at about seven barrels to the acre.

Comment on this

Eight barrels, I say.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Perhaps it was eight.

Comment on this

That would be 52/- per acre?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes.

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister now who paid that 52/- per acre?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The taxpayer, as I told you already.

Comment on this

Now ask him who got it.

Comment on this

You are robbing Peter to pay Paul. You got a lot of it from the poor people of this country.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We are proposing in the new Bill that is coming along to shift that subsidy from the taxpayer on to the consumer.

Comment on this

And who is the consumer?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I take it that the Fine Gael Party, when that Bill is introduced, will suggest that we should not do it in the way we propose to do it and that it should come out of separate taxation. Perhaps then Deputy MacDermot may be able to suggest what we will get the taxation from. The consumer will have to pay at the rate of 23/6 a barrel for Irish-grown wheat. Year by year it is expected the amount of Irish wheat will be increasing and the imported wheat will be smaller in quantity. Even a bigger tax on wheat might have been justified, because year by year the importation of foreign wheat is decreasing and the position will tend to stabilise as the years go on. If we are going to pursue this policy the tax on wheat is not going to be felt by the consumer. When there was an economic committee sitting here in 1929-30, it was recommended that wheat should be grown by the Irish farmer to a larger degree than it had been grown. We were then dealing with foreign wheat that was costing about 31/- a barrel. Wheat went down in price up to a few months ago and this slight increase in taxation does not bring it back nearly to what it was.

Deputy Dillon stated that it was uneconomic to grow wheat and he even declared that it was uneconomic to mill flour. He said we were paying 36/- as against 27/- in Liverpool. I do not accept the Deputy's figures; I merely quote him. He said the price for flour here was much higher than in Liverpool and, therefore, our policy here was uneconomic. If he is going to make out that it is uneconomic because it is dearer here, then he might also include bread. Bread was coming in here and it was sold more cheaply in certain parts of the Free State than it could be produced at. If we were to follow the strict economic principles of the Opposition, we would stop growing wheat, milling flour and making bread, and we would import it from Belfast or elsewhere. But, following out those economic principles, you would not stop there. We are getting 54/- or 55/- a live cwt. for pigs, and our bacon is costing 89/- or 90/-. You could get much cheaper bacon abroad, and there is no reason why, under the economic principles of the Opposition, we should continue to produce pigs and manufacture bacon when we could import bacon for 45/- or 50/-. The same thing would apply practically to everything—barley, oats, fruit, vegetables, and even meat. According to the economic principles of Deputies opposite, cattle at our present price are uneconomic because we could import Argentine meat at as low as 1½d. per lb. and very good meat, too. Following out the views of Deputies in the Opposition Benches, our cattle are too dear for the ordinary householder.

If the Opposition were allowed to have their way and to put their economic principles into operation, we would, apparently, have a grand country with 3,000,000 of a population and with no production, because we could buy everything so cheaply from abroad. We would have plenty of time to enjoy ourselves, and Deputy MacDermot could tax whatever he liked then. These economic principles set out by Deputy Dillon, and other members of the Opposition, might be very fine for a Budget debate or appear high-sounding rhetoric to their followers down the country, but when they are pushed to a conclusion and applied to everyday commodities, they do not hold. Deputy Dillon does not mean them to hold. Deputies in the Opposition Party would not like to suggest to the people of the country that we should give up producing bacon and cattle.

Tea, sugar and tobacco were always taxed. As long as I remember they were taxed. In some years the tax would be taken off, and in other years it would be reimposed. If a Government has to raise taxation, the members of it must take many things into consideration. They must calculate the amount they require and must endeavour to distribute the burden fairly. They select certain commodities for a tax, such as tea, sugar or tobacco.

Comment on this

Has the tax ever been put on all of them at the same time?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

It certainly was.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The year before we came into office it was on the whole lot of them. The taxes were on already before we came in and we increased them. If Cumann na nGaedheal put 4d. on tea, and we put 8d., does the Deputy think that 4d. is just and 8d. unjust?

Comment on this

I say it is unjust to raise practically all of your extra taxation by taxes on tea, sugar, tobacco and bread. All those hit the same class.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

They all hit every class. The amount raised in that way is only a very small part of the £26,000,000 we raise in taxation.

Comment on this

But this is extra taxation. Why do you not raise the income tax?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Perhaps the Deputy will make that constructive suggestion? If you do raise that tax, where will you take it off—what other tax will you take off?

Comment on this

I have already asked why do you not raise the income tax. Why not answer that question instead of asking me fresh questions?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy would encourage me very much if he made a constructive suggestion as to what tax would be relieved in lieu of an increase in the income tax. What I want to get from Deputy MacDermot is this: the Deputy, or perhaps some other Deputy following him, might be able to tell me why it is considered rather a criminal thing for this Government to put a tax on tea, sugar, tobacco, and even on wheat? Why is it considered to be unjust and unfair to the small farmer? When Cumann na nGaedheal put a tax on tea and sugar—and those articles were dearer at that time—did they not hit the small farmer at all? One would imagine from listening to the Opposition speakers that they would not ask the small farmer for anything.

Comment on this

You said you would reduce taxation.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We have reduced taxation in certain ways.

Comment on this

That is a good joke all right, but nobody believes it, not even yourself.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The tax on property is, I think, admitted by everybody—I do not think it was even criticised by Deputy MacDermot—to be a just tax. The only other taxes we have raised are protective and are justified by reason of their being protective.

What I would very much like to have, and what all of us over here, because I think I can speak for this Party, would like to have, is a considered and agreed criticism of the Budget, with constructive suggestions. We do not want one Opposition leader saying one thing and another leader saying another. We should like to have an agreed attempt to criticise the Budget and to tell us what changes they think should be made, if we should have taxed one thing more than another. Perhaps we should have increased income tax and taken the tax off tea. If that were an agreed suggestion from the Opposition, I think it would have considerable weight on this side of the House. We would be so surprised to get a constructive suggestion that we would think there was a change of attitude and we should like to encourage that. I think it would be very good if they would make a constructive suggestion of that kind, but it is not so easy to get such a suggestion from them.

Apart from that, there is the general criticism of the Budget that we are raising too much taxation, and, from some speakers, the criticism that we are not spending enough in certain directions—for instance, we are not doing enough for the farmers. I wonder would there be any chance of getting a constructive suggestion as to where we should take off taxation, if we want to reduce it, and where we should increase expenditure, if we are to increase it. If they started to increase expenditure, we should like to know where the extra taxation is to be got.

Comment on this

Would the Minister allow me to answer that? You made a statement when going to the country that you would keep the land annuities here. Will you keep them now?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We have kept them.

Comment on this

Do not be making yourself ridiculous. After all, you should have some respect for the country which sent you here.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Deputy MacDermot talked in a general way about the amount of taxation we were raising, and said that the aggregate amount was too high. I should like to get from the Deputy— it will not, perhaps, commit him very far—what the aggregate amount should be. If it is £28,000,000 now, should it be £26,000,000, £24,000,000, £20,000,000 or £18,000,000? I wonder would the Deputy commit himself even that far and take the risk——

Comment on this

That would be very far.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

——in the eventuality of his ever having to put his figure into practice, of mentioning the amount it should be? The great difficulty we have is to get any sort of agreed criticism or agreed policy from the Opposition and, especially, to get anything constructive. As I said in the beginning, when we were on the Opposition benches we were never afraid to do the unpopular thing or to make a suggestion even though people did not like it. In the first place, we were honest, and in the second place, we were good psychologists, and we knew that the people would respect us for it.

Comment on this

Can the Minister mention one thing which his Party suggested when they were in Opposition which they expected to be unpopular?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes, I mentioned one here to-day. There was a proposal brought in here to reduce the tax on beer and spirits. That was a very popular thing, and we, as a Party, voted unanimously against it. As I said in the beginning, if the Opposition is over there for the next 40 years, I am quite sure that they would never do as courageous a thing as that.

Comment on this

We went in against it.

Comment on this

The Government of the time proposed it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No, it was a member of the Party.

Comment on this

That was not anything originating from your Party.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I am afraid there is no great hope of getting any constructive criticism from the Opposition on this Budget. I listened to three or four of the principal speakers on this Budget, and their speeches were intensely political. The others, of course, did not actually say that they had the Galway and Dublin by-elections in mind as Deputy MacDermot did. He was honest so far as that went.

Comment on this

I said the Minister for Industry and Commerce had them in mind.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Deputy MacDermot said that he was not going to be pushed into making suggestions with regard to decreased expenditure in view of the pending by-elections.

Comment on this

No; I said that that was what was in the Minister's mind.

Comment on this

You said you were not going to be pushed, anyway.

Comment on this

He will be pushed.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Deputy MacDermot went on three points. He talked about the financial position of the country, but he certainly did not convince anybody that the country was financially worse off than it was three or four years ago. I am not going to spoil the speech of the Minister for Finance, but I think he will produce figures of bank deposits which will show Deputy MacDermot to be wrong in some of the figures which he gave. It has not been shown that the country is in any way financially worse off than it was three or four years ago. Secondly, Deputy MacDermot spoke about a sound Budget. It has not been shown by the Deputy, or anybody else, that the Budget is not sound in respect of having a balanced estimate of expenditure and income for the coming year. Nobody can defend the principle that you must pay for every single thing, such as the external loan and property losses compensation, out of current revenue. The question put to Deputy MacDermot by Deputy Belton was, I think, very relevant, as to whether the British were supposed to pay all the war debts out of current revenue in one year. The external loan and the property losses compensation arose out of a war in this country.

Comment on this

I did not suggest that you should do it in one year.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Surely we are not expected to pay those in one year. Deputy MacDermot did not prove that the Budget was not sound. Thirdly, he tried to prove that the taxes were not equitable. Anybody who examines his speech and studies the various things which he said should not be taxed—sugar, tea, tobacco, and so on —will see how ridiculous Deputy MacDermot would make his own position if he were sitting here as Minister for Finance, paying all the things which we are paying—£3,500,000 to old age pensioners from the age of 65 upwards and £1,200,000 for derating—out of current revenue and paying out of central taxation, what we are raising by the butter and bacon levies. If he says he is going to do that on £13,000,000 or £15,000,000 and that he will not put a halfpenny on tea, sugar, tobacco, wheat, bread or corporation profits tax, I do not know where he is going to get it. I think it is a pity he cannot make another speech.

Comment on this

I think this Budget could be described by the average intelligent citizen who understands, and has been following, the activities of Government in this country as a banker's Budget, and I have no hesitation whatever in describing it as such. The framework of this Budget has been founded upon the idea of capturing the imagination of the investor; and I believe, as far as I can see from the trend of the speeches from the Government Benches, also for the purpose of endeavouring to secure the co-operation of the Opposition Party in this House in connection with the new conversion loan which is to be floated. There is much similarity between the speeches from the Front Opposition Bench and from the Government Benches; and that appears to a certain extent in the speech we have just listened to from the Minister for Agriculture.

When I was voting, with my colleagues, for the election of this Government, I was quite clear that we were doing it for the purpose of giving the country an opportunity of getting an alternative Government, which the people had indicated they were prepared for. The people in 1932 made it quite clear, and they made it more clear in the subsequent election, that they did not want the imposition of a Cumann na nGaedheal Government extending beyond ten years. They were prepared to pay for an alternative Government in the hope that they would fulfil the public pledges that they had given to the country. When I was voting for that Government, I was quite clear in my own mind that I was doing so, personally, because I had sympathy with the national and the international policy of the Fianna Fáil Party. But I was clear in my own mind, and my colleagues and myself made it clear to the leader of the Fianna Fáil Party that we were not prepared to give a blank cheque for every item of policy that they were prepared to pursue. On the vote for the election of the Cabinet, on the nomination of President de Valera, in 1932, knowing, as I then knew, the economic policy of the Fianna Fáil Party, I never thought that I would find in this House a Republican Minister for Finance being congratulated in a public speech by Deputy Good. Deputy Good in his broadcast speech on Saturday night is reported as having said:—

"While many business men might object very strongly to some specific taxes imposed, it could not be denied that the Minister had succeeded in distributing taxation over a wide field."

And he goes on to say much more complimentary things:—

"Most business men——

and Deputy Good speaks for bankers and traders, and heads of Chambers of Commerce—

"——who were in favour of sound finance would have to compliment him on having the courage to tell the people that if they wanted certain services they must pay for them. Also he had the courage to impose all-round taxation to emphasise the fact that these services must be paid for."

Of course, anybody could understand from the past history of Deputy Good, and the mentality he represents in this House, and in the country, that he and those associated with him and those for whom he speaks were delighted because taxes were to be put on tea and sugar and other necessaries of life, and that income tax and increased profit tax and super-tax were not interfered with. I would like to hear more from the back benchers of the Fianna Fáil Party in the way of defence of these impositions and of the increased tax on tea, sugar and tobacco and coal and other commodities while income tax and super-tax were left as they were last year. I would like to hear Deputy Corry or Deputy Donnelly tell the House and the country and their constituents particularly how they can justify the imposition of taxation on tea, sugar, butter and coal upon the people of Ireland and on many who have the miserable sum of 6/- a week in the shape of home assistance to live on. I mention Deputy Donnelly and Deputy Corry because they speak often in this House, and are regarded as No. 1 and No. 2 Government yes-men. They know perfectly well the position in rural Ireland to-day, of people in receipt of 6/- a week home assistance, and that such people exist upon bread and tea. They are not allowed, because their financial position would not allow them, to buy butter at its present price. Here we have Deputy Corry and Deputy Donnelly getting up and backing up the imposition of taxes on tea and sugar, knowing, at the same time, that it will deprive those people of the necessaries of life, while they are prepared to leave income tax and super-tax and corporation profits tax alone.

Comment on this

What about free beef?

Comment on this

Free beef, as Deputy Donnelly must know, has recently been taken away from a large number of people eligible to receive unemployment assistance. To me all this is very bad policy and discloses a sad state of affairs. I shall endeavour to prove by quotations that the Government have taken steps in the last few months to force down the wages paid to persons employed on public works while at the same time increasing the cost of living to those people. I have a case here which I raised in this House. I was requested to draw attention to the fact that on a recent occasion workers engaged on a forestry scheme were paid, until now, the unknown minimum rate of 22/- per week. One person, when this was discovered, remarked that it must be simply a book-keeping blunder; that there must be something wrong in the office, and that someone who must be responsible for paying the proper rate, namely, 28/- a week, had blundered. I put a question to the Minister for Lands, and I asked whether this rate of 22/- had been officially sanctioned, and the reply that I received from Deputy O'Grady, acting for the Minister, is as follows:

"The Deputy is correct in stating that the rate of wages paid at Kinnitty Forest, Offaly, is 22/-, and that the rate of wages paid in Mountrath Forest, Leix, a few miles distant, is 28/-. That is, however, explained by the fact that the rate for Mountrath was fixed some years ago when the rate of wages for agricultural labourers, to which the matter is related, was higher than at present."

Is not that an extraordinary statement, especially in view of what we have listened to from the Minister for Agriculture? The Minister, in his speech, enumerated items of agricultural production where, he says, and I believe in some cases he is right, that farmers to-day are receiving a higher price than when the Cumann na nGaedheal Government was in office. There is something wrong with the action of the Minister for Lands in forcing down the recognised rate of 28/- paid in every other county, to the previously unknown minimum of 22/- a week. That is done at a time when this Government comes to the country and asks us to back a Budget that proposes new taxation upon tea and sugar and other necessaries of life. I ask Deputy Donnelly to explain that, if the Minister for Finance will not come in and explain it, and especially to explain it in the line of the speech of the Minister for Agriculture. We had other cases brought to the notice of the House recently, when the rate of wages paid to-day by the Land Commission to workers engaged in the building of houses in Kilkenny by direct labour has been reduced from 28/- a week to 24/- a week. Some explanation has been given in support of the action of the Land Commission in that matter. I listened-in to the speech—the rather amusing speech—of the Minister for Industry and Commerce on the wireless last night. Everybody who listened to that speech must have been highly amused at the audacity of the Minister when he said:—

"The cost of living has gone down and is still going down."

If the Minister knew what he was talking about last night, or if he had sought information as to what was going on in the country, he would have found that the price of flour has gone up all over the country and that the price of bread has, in some cases, gone up by a 1/2d. per 4lb. loaf. The price of tea and sugar has gone up as a result of the Government's proposals. The price of farmers' butter in the area where these low wages are to be imposed has gone up and will go up by 3d. or 3½d. per lb. under the legislation which has been introduced. "The cost of living is still going down." That statement could only be made by the greatest political bluffer this country has ever heard on the wireless or in this House. That is what I call the Minister for Industry and Commerce for making a statement which he had no authority for making in the light of present conditions.

Comment on this

I congratulate you. You are a convert.

Comment on this

I do not understand what you have said, but I see you have a lot of documents before you, and I dare say you are going to make your own contribution to the debate.

Comment on this

I am quite sincere in my congratulations.

Comment on this

The Budget proposes to impose new taxation on tea, sugar, flour—and, as a consequence, bread— jams, and tobacco, while, as a result of a previous decision by the Government, the price of coal has been increased by 5/- per ton. A great many people say that the poor are not affected in any part of the country by this tax of 5/- per ton on coal. I imagine that Deputy Flinn is going to speak in this debate, as he has been taking notes of the speeches. I should like to ask Deputy Flinn whether he is satisfied that in the slum areas of Dublin—Cork Street, the Coombe and Gloucester Street—the people have sufficient accommodation to store turf even if they were willing and anxious to burn it. Why should these poor people be forced to buy coal upon which a tax of 5/- per ton has been imposed by the Government? That 5/- per ton has to be paid by the consumers, including poor consumers who are unable to burn turf for the reasons I have stated. I am sure that other Deputies have had the experience I have had when visiting certain parts of the slums of Dublin. The people in the slums live in one-room tenements where they have no room to keep more than a few stones of coal. They could not possibly find the accommodation which would store the equivalent quantity of turf, from the point of view of calorific content.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce, in his broadcast speech last night, criticised Deputy McGilligan, Mr. Duffy, who spoke for the Labour Party, and, to a lesser extent, Deputy Good, for having failed to indicate the sources from which they would draw the taxation required. So far as I am concerned, I would certainly advocate the reduction, if not the total abolition, of the bounties presently provided for live stock exported from this country. I would advocate the reduction of the bounties because I am satisfied—I am sure that anybody who has made a study of the way in which the bounties are allocated and administered is equally satisfied—that these large sums, amounting to over £3,000,000 last year, are not finding their way to the people for whom they were intended by this House. Does anybody suggest that the bounties provided by the taxpayers for live stock exported from here are finding their way in full to the live stock producers in the rural areas? Most of the money, so far as I can see, is going into the pockets of the cattle dealers. Very often it goes into the pockets of cattle dealers who come over here from England and take our cheap cattle away with them from Thursday's cattle market. I should be prepared to advocate here and to defend in my constituency a reduction of the bounties on live stock before I would face the imposition of taxes on tea, sugar, or any of the other necessaries of life. I should be prepared to devote the amount now devoted to bounties to derating, because, if the £3,000,000 now raised at the expense of the taxpayers was set aside to help the farmer by way of derating, every penny would go into the pockets of the farmers without any additional administrative expenses. I have a strong feeling, and have so informed my colleagues, in favour of a motion which is down on the Order Paper in the name of Deputy Curran in connection with that matter. I feel that the taxpayers are being mulcted for bounties which are intended to go to the farmers but which are not going in that way because of the method by which they are administered and because of the activities of the middlemen. I am also prepared to advocate here and defend elsewhere the imposition of taxes on other classes of people rather than face the proposition of imposing taxation on the necessaries of life.

What about the ground landlords who are increasing their revenue by leaps and bounds as a result of the operation of the Housing Acts? What about the hundreds of speculative builders around Dublin, Waterford, Cork and Limerick and other provincial centres, who, as the Minister for Finance knows better than anybody else, have bought out land at fairly low rates and built houses with grants provided by the taxpayers and the people of the country, who have got the benefit of the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act and who come along now and, without any interference by this Government, create ground rents of from £7 to £15 per house? In the constituency represented by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, 200 houses have been built at the back of Tyrconnell Road in Inchicore by a public utility society— it does not matter to me by whom they were built—which got grants under the Housing Acts and in respect of these houses ground rents of not less than £7 per house have been created. What about searching the pockets of those individuals who are getting rich quickly at the expense of the taxpayers and who have to make no contributions of any kind in this country? Later, I presume there will be a demand, which will be accepted, for a Town Tenants Purchase Bill. Some of the gentlemen now gambling in these ground rents will then be paid doubly or trebly by a section of the people or by the country as a whole. There is any amount of gambling going on in these ground rents in the City and County of Dublin. If President de Valera does not believe me, let him ask the Minister for Finance, who knows more than anybody else about this matter, representing, as he does, the County of Dublin. I also am prepared to advocate—every member of my Party will always advocate and in spite of anything will defend—the imposition of increased taxation upon income tax payers, super-tax payers, and on those liable for the payment of corporation profits tax before we face the proposal to impose taxes on food, and especially on the food consumed by the poorest of the poor. I am also prepared, and would be prepared if I had personal responsibility, whether it was popular or unpopular, to put a higher tax on private motor cars which are increasing in number in this country before I would agree to put a tax on the necessaries of life for the poor. I would also agree—the Minister for Finance has already done it to a certain extent —to face up to the proposition of increasing the amusement tax before putting a tax on the necessaries of life. I and my colleagues are prepared to defend a reduction in the existing amounts provided for bounties on the live stock exported from this country, and to search the pockets of ground landlords with a view to seeing what we could get from them in order to find the money which it is now proposed to get by taxing the necessaries of life for the poor. We would be prepared to do that, and to achieve the same end, we would, as I have already indicated, be prepared to take steps to secure the additional money required by increasing the taxes payable by income tax payers, super-tax payers, as well as on those who pay corporation profits tax, as well as to increase the taxes on private motor cars and the amusement tax. That is the reply that I, on behalf of my colleagues, give to the invitation that was extended to us last night by the Minister for Industry and Commerce on the wireless.

We have been told from the Front Opposition Benches and from the Government Benches, and I agree, that every Party in this country should co-operate in maintaining or increasing the credit of the State. What does the credit of this State represent? I had thought that it did not represent quite the same thing to Deputy Good and the Minister for Finance. The credit of the State to me depends upon this: our ability to put all our able-bodied citizens into useful and profitable occupation rather than having over 100,000 of them placed on the back of the taxpayers. Apparently, Deputy Good and the Minister for Finance—I am judging the Minister for Finance on this Budget— seem to think that the credit of this State depends on the rate of interest which an investor is able to get on his unearned income. That is the difference between Deputy Good and, if you like, the Minister for Finance, and the members of this Party on that question. If contributions and sacrifices are to be called for from the people of this country as a whole, then I suggest that, in the first instance, those sacrifices should be borne by the people who are best able to bear them —the people who are represented in this House by Deputy Good and others like him. For that reason I quoted— indeed, I never thought that I should be able to give such a quotation in this House—the complimentary remarks made by Deputy Good in his broadcast speech on Saturday night on the form of this year's Budget. I am sure that quite a large number of the poor people of this country, if they heard that broadcast and were able to pick up the sense of it, must have almost fainted when they heard Deputy Good congratulating the first Republican Minister for Finance of this State on the Fianna Fáil Budget that he introduced this year.

We have all this additional taxation which is to be put on the people who are least able to bear it. In addition, we have the Minister's proposal in his Budget to cut the old age pensioners by the sum of £100,000 as well as a reduction of £300,000 in the sum hitherto available for those in receipt of unemployment assistance. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has endeavoured to explain away the proposed action of the Government in reducing the sum available for old age pensioners by £100,000. He explained it in this way: that he said it was being done for the purpose of cutting out waste. I hope that the Minister for Finance when replying, or some other Minister, will explain what is meant by waste, and what sections of old age pensioners are going to suffer as a result of the proposed savings of £100,000. They might explain also the reasons for the proposed reduction of £300,000 in the amount heretofore available for unemployment assistance. Everyone knows that the Unemployment Assistance Act was not in operation over the whole of the last financial year. It is, therefore, impossible to know what the actual commitments under that Act would be if the 30,000 appeals pending had been disposed of under the machinery set up under that Act. I do not know what the actual expenditure would be if these appeals had been disposed of but at any rate that was the number of appeals awaiting decision at the end of the financial year. I am prepared to admit that perhaps a very high percentage of the appeals pending concerned people who were in receipt of some payment at that particular date.

We have been told that all this additional taxation must be provided. Apparently the poor must bear a big share of it in order that money may be found for the social services, including, I presume, more money for relief works throughout the country. I would like to know from the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance whether, in the last year or two, a reasonable amount of money was placed at his disposal to enable him to carry out all the useful public works which had been put before his Department for consideration. I am asking that question because I know that in my own constituency a number of waterworks and sewerage schemes were submitted to the Department of Local Government and Public Health. I am sure that the Parliamentary Secretary is aware that the carrying out of those schemes has been held up because of the failure of the Government to give financial assistance so as to make it easy for the local authorities to go ahead with the schemes proposed. The Minister for Local Government and his predecessor have admitted in this House that it is impossible for a local authority to carry out sewerage or waterworks schemes which are urgently required, not only in provincial centres but in our smaller towns and villages at the expense of the ratepaying community in the dispensary areas concerned. Therefore, a grant is necessary from the Central Government to enable a local authority to carry out such schemes, bearing in mind that the people living in the benefiting area are only able to contribute to a moderate charge arising out of the execution of such schemes. I would be glad to hear the Parliamentary Secretary or the Minister for Finance explain why a number of these schemes has been held up if, as we are told by the Minister for Finance, the money is there just for the asking. Why are the schemes held up in areas where there is an urgent necessity for them? Why is there such a large amount of unemployment locally, with large numbers of people either in receipt of home assistance or of unemployment assistance? Before raising matters of this kind in the House I always take the precaution of corresponding with the Department concerned in relation to such schemes. Since I became a member of the House I have never come here and raised a question of this kind without first acquainting the Department concerned by means of correspondence. It was only when I failed to get satisfaction in that way within a reasonable period that I made a complaint here. I have been continuously pressing the Department of Local Government and the Minister for Finance for grants for schemes which have been held up during the last two or three years. So far as I understand it, these schemes are being held up only because financial assistance has not been made available for their execution from the Central Government. This Budget, of course, has all the appearance, like previous Budgets, of making provision for the needs of the people of the country, according to the point of view of the Government, for another year during which, I presume, the economic war is to go on. I would like to know from the President, and I think the country would like to hear a statement from him—the Government has been in office for three years—whether, as head of the Government that is responsible to the people, he is throughly satisfied that it is impossible to secure a satisfactory settlement of the economic war with the British Government. I am asking him to make that statement, because I find in going around the country, during the past year or two anyway, that a number of people, farmers and others, are living from day to day, from month to month, and from year to year in hopeful expectation that a satisfactory result is going to be found inside a week, or a month, or a year. I think that if, in the opinion of the head of this Government, it is impossible to secure a satisfactory settlement, then it is better to tell the people in a straightforward way. I am sure that the President will do that if he feels justified in doing it, because then the people can make their arrangements to carry on as if it was impossible for the people to get a satisfactory settlement. The people will settle down and face the facts with greater certainty as to where they are going in the future if they know where the Government and the country stands on that matter. I, personally, should feel more satisfied if I thought it impossible to secure a satisfactory settlement, because everybody would then know where they are and would know that the Government had made every attempt, short of surrender, to make a settlement of the kind which they have the authority of the people of this country to secure.

When the President's Vote was being discussed in this House last year, I made reference to the unfair attitude of the Government in compelling the farmers of the country, who are paying their rates and annuities and working hard, to bear the additional rates imposed on them under the present policy for the people who are either unable or unwilling to pay their rates and annuities. At the end of a particular period of this year—perhaps it was the end of January—a sum of £700,000 was outstanding in land annuities, and, under the present unfair policy of the Government, the local authorities are directed to increase the rates in the present financial year in order to make up for the losses on annuities in the previous financial year. I feel considerable sympathy with the farmer in the country who, after all, as everybody on both sides of the House will admit, is in the front line trenches in this economic war and who has his coat off and is working hard and paying his rates and annuities; and I think it is very unfair that that farmer, under this ridiculous and unfair policy, should have imposed upon him the duty of paying the annuities and rates of his next-door neighbour, who is either unable or unwilling to pay his rates and annuities. I should like President de Valera to look into that matter and to see whether or not some fund could be established to prevent the honest and hard-working farmer, who pays his annuities, from having to pay for the farmers who are either unable or unwilling to pay. If the local authorities in my area carried out the instructions that they received from the Local Government Department under the existing policy, and if they made provision in the current year's local estimates for the amounts outstanding in annuities at the end of the last financial year, it would have meant imposing an additional rate of 2/6 in Laoighis and 2/11 in Offaly. Why should any farmer, who pays his annuities, have to pay for the fellow who is either unable or unwilling to pay? I hold that it should not be beyond the powers of the Government's financial advisers to find some other means of dealing with that situation than the means they are adopting at the present time.

Comment on this

Why should not the Deputy try his own imagination on it?

Comment on this

Perhaps, as the Minister for Agriculture did on a former occasion, he will get up now and say that Cumann na nGaedheal did the same. I never thought, when Fianna Fáil was coming into existence, that the time would come when they would merely reply to complaints made against them: that their predecessors had done the same. I never thought they would ever take up the attitude of asking: "What is wrong? If you did it when you were in office, it is all right for us to do it." Deputy MacDermot referred in a passing way, as I intended to refer to it, to a statement made by the Minister for Finance at a dinner on St. Patrick's night. I think that the Minister for Finance was the principal guest on that occasion, and I understand that the dinner was given by the Clothing Manufacturers' Association. He stated at that dinner— apparently he spoke without figures or facts before him, and apparently he blundered—that he looked forward to a comfortable surplus in the coming Budget. I wonder who pulled the Minister's leg on that particular occasion, and I should like to know whether the comfortable surplus that he prophesied on that particular occasion was a surplus on top of the taxation imposed in the last financial year, or whether he intended his remarks to be taken as meaning a surplus in the present financial year? I should like to know who prompted the Minister in what now appears to be a singularly wrong statement.

Comment on this
A Deputy

The Deputy should remember the speech was made at a banquet.

Comment on this

Well, perhaps it depends on the stage of the dinner at which the Minister spoke.

Comment on this

What was wrong with the statement?

Comment on this

The surplus now appears to be £10,000 on top of taxation of £1,185,000.

Comment on this

That is not much.

Comment on this

It is not much when you say it quick, and provided that the additional taxation has to be borne by the people who can laugh and bear it.

Comment on this

Another Document No. 2.

Comment on this

I freely admit that this Government has gone a good way towards redeeming its promises to improve social services. I freely admit, and I think that every fair-minded Deputy in the House will have to admit, that there is no comparison between what this Government has done in that respect and what their predecessors left undone or promised that they would do. I believe also that it is possible to maintain, and even extend, the existing social services by finding the necessary money from the sources I have indicated, but the members of this Party cannot and will not subscribe to any proposals which, instead of taxing the people who can bear it better, have the effect of putting the taxes on tea, sugar, and other necessaries of life while, at the same time, cutting the allowances of the old age pensioners and those entitled to receive unemployment assistance. I want to say, on behalf of this Party, that while we are prepared to give, as we have loyally given—and we have no apology to make for it—loyal support to this Government on its national or international political policy, and also having given every chance to this Government to allow it to develop its economic policy, because we are satisfied that the people, who voted the Government into power, should get a fair chance of seeing that policy developed, we are not prepared to vote for the imposition of a tax on tea or sugar for the reasons I have given, and we reserve the right, while voting for the general resolution, to vote against these particular items, and we will move to have these proposals deleted from the coming Finance Bill.

Comment on this

I heard Deputy Davin say, at the finish of this speech, that while offering no apology for his and his Party's support of the Government, he was prepared to disagree with them on some items. I believe that the support he and his Party are giving to the Government in this policy is bringing destruction to the country, and I believe that, in their hearts, no people know that better than the people on the Labour Benches. I am glad that the Minister for Agriculture spoke, because I like to have a crack at him. The burden of the Minister's speech was: "How are you going to reduce the taxation?" That is not our job. The Fianna Fáil Party, before they came into office, promised that they would reduce taxation by £2,000,000, when the taxation was about £8,000,000 less than it is to-day. I have a few extracts here that I should like to read. It is always easier to read than to think. I refer the Minister for Agriculture to the statements made by the Deputies whom I am going to quote, and I ask him how it is that they are not carrying out the promises they made when they were in Opposition. Mr. MacEntee, speaking on the Finance Bill, on the 17th May, 1928 (Vol. 23, col. 1549, Official Debates), said:—

"I take it that at this stage of the Bill the discussion is to confine itself to the principle of the measure only. Therefore, I intend to confine myself to considering the purpose of the Bill and the method of securing it. This Bill proposes to increase taxation, and to aggravate the already too heavy burden upon our people and upon their industry. We must ask ourselves whether such an increase is justifiable and unavoidable, and whether also it is equitably distributed. According to the figures supplied to us, the minimum amount to be raised by taxation in the current year is £20,735,000. The actual amount raised last year was £20,396,000, so that at the very lowest computation taxation during the current year will be heavier than last year to the tune of £339,000."

The present Minister for Finance, who was then Deputy MacEntee, went on to ask—

"Can we impose such an additional burden? Will industry sustain it, for if industry cannot sustain it I submit that we are not justified in imposing it."

Mr. Lemass, speaking at column 548 of the same volume, said:—

"As most Deputies know, it is much easier to slide on the downward curve than it is to climb the upward one"—I am sorry Deputy Flinn has left the House—"and unless we can rectify the present position, if the nation does start sliding, it will be pretty hard to stop it. I think it is generally admitted by all who have the least knowledge of the industrial conditions existing in the country that the main cause of our lack of progress in industrial matters has been the burden of taxation. As Deputy Flinn pointed out here, the people of this island have not merely to keep up the Government that operates from this Chamber but it has also to keep up another Government in Belfast and to maintain a third Government in pensions. The burden of maintaining the three Governments is so heavy that it is impossible to expect any revival of prosperity or any considerable increase in business productivity in this country. We cannot acquit the Government of the Saorstát of a large share of responsibility in maintaining that unequal and unbalanced burden of taxation which has brought about this general stagnation in trade."

Deputy O'Reilly, speaking at Rath more on November 21st, 1931, said:—

"The country had no need for increased taxation. Numerous economies could be effected that would not be any disadvantage to the community."

Speaking at Baltinglass on November 28th, Mr. MacEntee, as he then was said:—

"The proper way to meet the deficit was by cutting down expenditure, not by the imposition of further taxation. If they had the £1,230,000 paid the ex-R.I.C. pensioners, the £1,500,000 spent on an Army which General Seán MacEoin had said was useless for any national defence, and the land annuities, there would have been no need to throw fresh burdens on any section of the community."

Deputy Cleary, speaking at Athleague, on December 5th, 1931, said:—

"Let none of them think this was a poor country. It was the richest country in the world as a taxpayer. No people in the world, black or white, were paying such high taxes per head of the population, but the millions collected from the people were spent in squandermania.

"In the Free State the farmers were paying 75 per cent. of the total taxation. In Northern Ireland the percentage paid by the farmers was only 25 per cent., and in England 17½ per cent. of the total taxation. How could those in the Free State compete with the farmers in England or the Six Counties while this state of affairs existed."

Mr. Derrig, the present Minister for Education, speaking at Enniscorthy on December 19th, 1931, said:—

"No real effort has been made to reduce the cost of taxation in conformity with existing conditions. Neither has there been any serious attempt made to provide security for the producer, who is crushed by high taxation and the disparity between income and the high cost of living as well as the decline of the English market."

"So far as the agricultural labourer was concerned it was no exaggeration to say that he had no place in the economy of our present rulers."

I should like if Deputy Davin would listen to this:—

"But with the lowest wage standard in the community, and no prospect even then of regular employment the labourer was expected to pay high taxes on his wearing apparel, on his drink, his tobacco, to bear, in a word, the high cost of living forced upon him by a Government that refused to make any effort to enable him to bring up his family."

The Minister for Agriculture spoke about the British market, pointing out that the position there was not as a result of the economic war but as a result of the quotas. Speaking in the House, before Christmas, the Minister for Defence stated that he was satisfied that the Minister for Agriculture could do no more than accept the quota given to this country by the British Government, and that the British were not in a position to buy any more cattle from the people here. But some time after that a pact was arranged by someone that the Government had not the courage to stand over. The President stated that it had not been signed. He had not the courage to stand over it. Naturally he was ashamed of it when everyone of his followers criticised it. Under the Pact the British were to take 150,000 cattle and we were to take 1,250,000 tons of their coal. As a result of the pact Mr. Thomas stated that the British authorities had been able to collect £700,000 in addition to what they claim. There was a tariff of £6 a head on cattle and a tax of 5/- on every ton of coal which came in here. Taking the tariff on cattle at £5 each it meant a payment to England of roughly £750,000, and a tax of 5/- per ton on 1,250,000 tons of coal would amount to £312,500, or a total sum of over £1,000,000. There is nothing about that in the Budget. The people have been blindfolded, but we are not going to let the Government escape the responsibility. The Minister for Agriculture spoke about the agricultural policy. What is meant by the agricultural policy? I asked Deputy Davin to deal with that and to say how the rate of wages for agricultural labourers compares with what it was three years ago.

Comment on this

The Deputy can tell the Minister.

Comment on this

I intend to. How is it that Fianna Fáil farmers are reducing their staffs and reducing the amount of wages that they pay if the country is as prosperous as they say it is as the result of their policy? When he was questioned about the bounties the Minister for Agriculture said that the taxpayers had been paying them, but that in future it was the consumers who would pay. Did you ever hear such nonsense. At one time the Minister stated that farmers paid 80 per cent. of the taxation. That is on the records of the House. Is there any regard at all for the capacities of farmers to pay such taxation? Deputy Davin talked about the land annuities. I am sorry the President has left the House, as I should like to hear what he has to say in reply to the statement of Mr. Thomas as to the amounts that had been collected from farmers, namely, £4,200,000. The President stated that only £2,900,000 went towards the payment of land annuities, so that the farmers are paying the difference between the two sums. I say that an additional burden has been put on the farmers since then, and that sheriffs and bailiffs are going all over the country seizing cattle in lieu of payment of land annuities. Will Deputy Davin deny that the farmers have paid these annuities already?

Comment on this

Deputy Flinn will answer that.

Comment on this

The people will answer it very soon. At Ballyvourney fair I asked a man what he would get for ten heifers and he said £2 10s. each. He remarked that a neighbour who had asked him the same question inquired if any of the calves he sold him two years previously were in the lot and he said "Yes." I asked him what he had paid that neighbour for the calves and he said £3 apiece. If these cattle were shipped John Bull would have to get £60 out of them. Another man said he bought four cattle and paid £8 apiece for them two years ago. That man sold them at the end of the two years at £4 apiece. I said to him: "Pat, what is your annuity?" and he said: "Formerly it was £10, now it is £5." He lost £16 apiece on these four cattle and he has against that saved £8 in his annuity.

Does the Minister for Finance think that that situation can go on; or that in two or three years' time his Budget will be even as good as it is to-day? The Minister for Agriculture said that in this coming year we will be growing 200,000 acres of wheat. I put him the question what is the bounty per barrel and he said the bounty would be 6/6 per barrel which, estimating eight barrels to the acre, would mean £2 12s. per acre bounty. If we multiply these 200,000 acres by £2 12s. we get over £500,000 and that is what this bounty will cost the people of the country. The total acreage of wheat sufficient to satisfy the needs of the people is 850,000. If that area which the Government is aiming at is reached the year after next it will mean £2,125,000, which the country will have to make up in bounties for this item alone. I understand that the estimate of the number of sacks of flour required to satisfy the needs of the people is 2,600,000. If we reach in a couple of years' time the goal at which the Government are aiming, that is 850,000 acres, it will mean a tax on the people for this item alone of £2,125,000.

The Minister for Agriculture told us that we were getting a better price for the grain. I asked him to tell us where is that price coming from? Where is the foreign market to give that price for the grain? Who is paying that price for it? I have a letter here from a merchant in the County Donegal. He is a man well-known in this country and in this House. He wrote me this letter on the 7th of May and he says:

"In reply to your letter of yesterday's date, the price of maize meal in Derry yesterday, Friday, was £5 15s. per ton, retail 5/9 per cwt. or £5 15s. per ton. The price of the admixture here is £8 5s. per ton retail or 8/3 per cwt. There is an allegation that some of the Free State millers are at present putting no oatmeal in the mixture and are getting away with it."

Our people are paying this extra tax. It is the unfortunate poor people who are not in a position to grow these crops who have to pay these extra moneys. I have already raised this question in this House, and as long as I am here I will raise it and I will condemn the injustice of it. The Minister talks about the tillage policy of the Government. Some time ago the Minister said the people should increase their cattle production. He said they would require more cattle to eat what was produced on the land by the increased tillage. He has changed from that now and his policy is to kill the calves. My friend in Donegal in his letter continues:

"I have 45 tons of oats at present and cannot sell them. No miller wants them."

I mentioned that matter to the Government in the hope that they would take the matter into consideration and get this man and people who are in the same position as he is a market for their oats. The Minister tried to do away with the British market. He said the British market was no advantage to us. How is it then that the Government finds £3,433,000 to give in bounties for maintaining the British market? Does not that clearly point to the dishonesty of the Government and the dishonesty of their whole policy.

Deputy Davin at last is beginning to realise the position. The Deputy and other Deputies must soon realise that the policy of the Government is leading to more unemployment in the country. Was there ever a time in the last 13 years when there were so many unemployed as to-day? I invite any Deputy on the Labour Benches to look into the matter for themselves. I invite the Labour Deputies, if they like, to come to Cork. Let them go round to the farmers' houses. They will there find out how many farm labourers and farm girls have been put out of employment in the last three years. This is the case amongst the followers of the Government just as it is amongst the opponents of the Government. The people are being put in the position that they cannot pay wages. I strongly appeal to the Labour Party to study this matter themselves and to realise what is happening. I hope Deputy Everett will carry out the pledge he gave last Sunday in Baltinglass, and that is at the first opportunity to remove the present Government from office.

Comment on this
Thomas Derrig Minister for Education (Mr. Derrig) Fianna Fáil

We have had two points of view expressed in the Debates to-day. One point of view was represented by Deputy Davin, and the other by Deputy MacDermot. Deputy Davin condemns the present Budget as a bankers' Budget. In his view it stands condemned by reason of the fact that it means increased taxation which the whole community will have to pay. Deputy MacDermot tells us with all the keenness of a good banker and a sound financier that the Budget does not go far enough, that there is too much borrowing. Borrowing in Deputy MacDermot's scheme of things should be absolutely confined to projects which would return revenue. I think that in this discussion on the Budget the Minister for Finance has had a disadvantage, in so far as the unpleasant duty falls on him of collecting the cash by means of which the administration of the country is to be carried on for the next twelve months. On that account the Minister for Finance is naturally driven sometimes to do very unpopular things. But look at the other side of the picture. Look at the purpose for which this money, no matter how unpopular the means by which it is raised, is being raised. The purpose for which the money is to be raised should be brought into the picture. I was glad therefore that my colleague the Minister for Agriculture referred to the fact that under the present administration, social services have been increased to double what they were under the previous administration. Not alone have there been substantial increases in regard to Old Age Pensions for example and entirely new schemes in connection with Unemployment Assistance, but a Widows' and Orphans' Pensions Bill has been introduced, any one of which would in itself be acclaimed by any Government functioning in a small country of this kind as being a wonderful achievement. But in addition to this achievement, the Government is carrying through a very advanced programme in regard to its housing policy. It is forgotten by the Opposition that a very substantial liability lies upon the State in connection with that housing policy. It is forgotten that the State has to pay two-thirds the cost of a large amount of the building that is going on at the present time. In addition to that the Land Commission are carrying out a most intensive campaign for the division of lands. They are placing the population from the congested districts upon large estate in the Leinster counties. That is in progress at present. This year three times as much land will be divided as has been divided in any previous year. In addition there is a very substantial programme in connection with afforestation being embarked upon. In my own Department, a Department that has not made any great claims in the way of extra expenditure upon the resources of the Minister for Finance, we are spending £200,000 on new schools, the provision of proper accommodation, and the whole of that amount has been raised from taxation. I do not think that these examples which I have given can do anything else than convince the ordinary citizen that this money that is being raised, even if it is being raised in an unpopular manner, is certainly being spent in a most useful way.

Deputy Davin suggested that some other sources of taxation could have been tried out. I leave that point to the Minister for Finance. I think we can rely upon the Minister to ascertain for himself where the money can be secured, and if he has been driven to tax the ordinary necessaries of life, we know that it is not from choice, but from compulsion, because he feels that the money cannot be secured elsewhere. There would, of course, be an alternative in reducing these social services that this Government pride themselves upon and that they have set such a valuable headline in introducing. We are not in favour of that, and the reductions, as Deputy Davin calls them, that have been made are because we are satisfied that the intentions of the Government and of the Legislature can be fulfilled both in regard to unemployment assistance and old age pensions, and that no hardship need be inflicted upon any person who is properly and fully entitled either to unemployment assistance or an old age pension by administering the law in a somewhat stricter manner. That is the position with regard to these two services.

It is also forgotten in connection with this question of the raising of revenue that, apart altogether from the social services which the Government have introduced, new services are being created every day. The State is being asked every day to interfere in industry and commerce, to interfere in agriculture, to interfere in matters of public health, and in connection with practically every Department of State and every aspect of the life of the community the State is being constantly asked to carry out additional functions. All these additional functional cost money and necessitate additional staff and additional taxation. Furthermore, the sums that we were accustomed to raise in the past from some of the well-known taxes are beginning to disappear. In the case of sugar, for example, the Minister for Finance pointed out that he has lost about half a million pounds. It is obviously quite impossible for the Minister to carry on, in view of the constantly increasing services and the constant demands being made upon him, unless he is empowered, when he loses a source of revenue in one direction, to seek an equal amount of money in some other direction. Not only in connection with sugar, but in connection with Customs, there has been a great reduction in the amount collected, and in the future, owing to the successful operation of the industrial policy which the Government are carrying out, we may expect to see a still further decline in Customs duties.

In connection with land annuities, Deputy Davin tells us that the Guarantee Fund, which ensures to some extent the collection of land annuities by imposing a penalty upon the ratepayers of the counties in which the annuities are not paid, to the extent that they are not paid, can be abolished. I should like to point out to the Deputy that, had the annuities been paid in full, I think that some of the extra taxation which is being imposed during the present year might have been avoided. Furthermore, the Minister for Finance could have taken a more cheerful view generally and might have been able to do something further for the benefit of agriculture if the land annuities situation had been somewhat better. But we all know that the land annuity situation has meant increased cost upon the State in the collection of annuities, and that in some counties there are very heavy arrears indeed. If the Deputy or anybody else can suggest that the position of the Government, if the Guarantee Fund were not there, would be anything else but a particularly unfortunate one, and that the position of the collection of annuities would not be very much worse indeed than it is at the present time—I would be glad if any Deputy could show that. The position is that, due to the steps which the Government have had to take in order to try and avoid extra taxation and further impositions upon the people who are not annuitants to make up for the default, the annuities have come in and there has been a very substantial improvement. The extraordinary point about that whole situation is that the poorer counties like Mayo, Leitrim and Donegal, where we have holdings of £2 and £4 valuation on an average maintaining large families, counties which, as Deputy MacDermot mentioned, have suffered severely by the reduction in the American remittances and by the fact that they have to provide for these large families, have been in the forefront in the payment of both rates and annuities, and the richer counties have been not at all what they should be.

Deputy MacDermot referred to the fact that under a free Ireland taxation would still be greater. As the Minister for Finance pointed out in his opening statement, we have to pay for the privileges of self-government and being able to control our own affairs. When we remember that old age pensions, amounting to between £3,500,000 and £3,750,000, education, amounting to something more, the police, the Army, and all these other services I have referred to, which have been introduced since the Irish Free State Government came into being, I think all of us, no matter what our political views may be, have reason to congratulate ourselves on the marvellous strength of the Irish people, on the way in which they have faced their responsibilities and on the splendid manner in which the State has met its obligations and has succeeded in weathering the storm so far, when we see so many large, wealthier, and much greater countries—some of the great powers of Europe—in a much worse position and not knowing where they stand. We, at any rate, while giving the fullest possible benefits to our people, while remembering always our first duty was to the unemployed and to the poor, have also in our minds the fact that we have to try and pay our way, that we have to try and meet our obligations.

In some years, as last year showed, when the position is favourable and the occasion is propitious, the Minister for Finance, if he can do it, certainly will reduce taxation. In other years, of which the present is an example, when extra taxation is necessary in order to maintain our services, and the only alternative is to have a wholesale reduction in these services, the Government have faced up to the situation and have imposed extra taxation knowing that the Irish people will fully understand the position and knowing that they will appreciate the duty all the more because it is unpleasant, because it is unpalatable, but because it has to be done for the benefit of the whole community.

I should like to remind Deputy MacDermot and those like him who talk about the dangers of freedom and the responsibilities it involves and the possibility that we may not be able to shoulder our burden, that we in the Free State, at any rate, faced as we are with the consequences of the economic dispute, and with the serious position among our farmers, and admittedly other unfavourable factors in the situation, have reason to congratulate ourselves when we compare our position to that of others not so far away who have to be buttressed and subsidised by people across the water in order to enable them to maintain their position. So long as it is a question of maintaining our independence here, of maintaining our institutions and of maintaining our services, I do not think we need have the slightest doubt but that the Irish people will respond when they are called upon. They will give in regard to social and economic affairs that leadership which they all would like to give, that leadership which will show that this country, small as it is and poor as it is, but with a fine democratic spirit among our people, can give services and show a record of achievement in our State affairs which very few small countries in Europe can show.

Comment on this

I think during the course of the speech which has just been delivered the Minister for Finance must have felt very unhappy indeed—that is during such portions of the speech as the Minister for Finance listened to—because I think it would be very hard to put forward a more damning indictment of Fianna Fáil and its Government than the damning indictment that the Minister for Education has just made against the policy of his own Government. The Minister for Finance, we are told by the Minister for Education, does not like his own Budget. The Minister for Finance hates his own Budget, according to the Minister for Education. He has been driven to tax the ordinary necessaries of life, not from choice but from necessity. Now what does that phrase mean? Is not that the most complete and entire admission that Fianna Fáil has so mismanaged the affairs of this country that there is no tax to be derived from any other source except from the pockets of the very poorest members of this community? What are those extra taxes? 4d. on tea, ½d. on sugar, 8d. per lb. on tobacco, and 6d. per cwt. on wheat. Everything that the poor want, everything that the needy require, is taxed here. Everything that the person living on an old age pension requires is taxed here. Every necessity of the person living on outdoor relief or on the dole is taxed here. And the Minister for Finance is driven to take that course, we are told by the Minister for Education, because there is no other possible or conceivable source of revenue left to him.

We have the same cry coming from all the Fianna Fáil Benches: "We have exhausted every source of revenue; there is nothing left. If there is anything left, for goodness' sake come out and tell us what it is." That is the cry of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, as well as of the Minister for Education. It is also the cry of the Minister for Education to-day: "Tell us what else we are to tax"—an appeal to the Opposition to frame a Budget for them. We discover at any rate that there is nothing which they can think of for themselves, no scheme that they can devise for themselves, except this ruinous and cruel Budget which the Minister for Finance has introduced into this House. I say "cruel Budget" because it is a cruel Budget, at this time when, through the mismanagement and through the misgovernment of the present administration, there are more people hungry or in danger of being hungry than there has been in the lifetime of the oldest man in this generation. That is the very time at which it is the moral duty of the Government to see that the cost of living is reduced, and that is the very time at which the Government, by their own admission, are driven to increase that cost of living. What is the use of the Minister for Agriculture getting up in this House and informing us that the whole country is prosperous, that the farming community are wonderfully well off and that there is no poverty of any kind? What is the use of that? By some extraordinary method of self-hypnotism, the Minister for Agriculture may possibly drive himself into a belief in the truth of his own words, but there is not one other person either on the Fianna Fáil Benches, the Labour Benches, the Independent Benches or on our Benches who does not know that that statement of the Minister for Agriculture is absolutely false in fact.

But, says the Minister for Education, we are spending such a lot; we have all those new services other than the social services; we have all those new inspectors to whom we must pay those salaries. Why have them? Half of them are unnecessary. We have, says the Minister for Education, all this Army to keep up, all the Guards to keep up, and all those other extra expenses. If the Guards are costing the country now more than they cost the country before Fianna Fáil came into office, that is due to the misgovernment of Fianna Fáil. The Minister for Education says: "We have got to support this Army." Why increase it? Why start your Volunteers, so called? Why people who receive pay are called Volunteers, which is certainly a contradiction in terms, I do not know. But why establish them? What good are they doing? What useful purpose are they serving, might I ask? At a time at which the poorer members of this community are struggling to exist, certainly in the country areas, that is the time at which the Government proceeds to take and keep for a considerable time at the public expense a certain number of young men, doing nothing, serving no purpose, and never capable of serving any useful purpose. If you want them there for ornament, by all means have them there and spend your money on that ornament at a time when the country can afford such luxuries, but this is not a time at which the country can afford anything of the kind.

The Minister for Education tells us that the poorer counties are paying their annuities. They are, but why? The poorer counties, and I invite the Minister to go to his home town and check my words, are paying their annuities, and the fact that the annuities are better paid and the poor rates are better paid in such a county as Mayo is due to one cause. There has been a very great agricultural and industrial revival in England; there is an enormous number, much more than there has been at any time since the Great War, of young men from Mayo working in England, and it is out of the wages they are receiving that their parents are paying the annuities and rates. Not only are those young men working on the agricultural farms in England, but great numbers of them are receiving employment in the building trade. It is not because of any prosperity that Fianna Fáil has brought to Mayo that Mayo stands in the forefront of the counties that have their annuities paid. Fianna Fáil has brought nothing but poverty of the direst type to the County Mayo, and, except for the English earnings, Mayo at the present time would have been plunged into complete ruin.

But, says the Minister for Education, with a great flourish of trumpets, the first duty of the Government is to the poor, and he adds that in this Budget they are carrying out their duty to the poor. What is the duty to the poor? It is not what one would expect it to be defined as. At a time of stress and trial, when the cost of living should be cheapened to them, they carry out their duty to the poor by adding to the cost of living, increasing the burthen of taxation upon the poor and driving the poor to do without the necessities of life. That is the duty as defined by the Minister for Education. That is what the Government are doing, and that is what the Minister calls doing their duty to the poor. The Fianna Fáil conception of that duty appears to be this: "Tax the poor; make life unendurable for them.""And then," says Fianna Fáil, "we will have performed our duty to them."

The Minister for Agriculture talked a great deal about the benefits which farmers are receiving or are supposed to receive. He talked a great deal about the area of wheat being increased. I would like to point out that an increase in the area of wheat does not increase the national wealth, but actually decreases the national wealth. Whenever, by a subsidy, you make an article dear, you are decreasing the national wealth, and every acre of wheat which is grown at a loss, and cannot be grown otherwise than at a loss and cannot be grown without a subsidy to make it in any way profitable, may be a source of wealth or it may not; it may be a source of wealth to the individual who is cultivating the particular field in which the wheat is grown, but it is obviously a lessening of the total wealth of the community. On the other hand, when you had an industry self-supporting—and you had a splendid one here—when you had a great agricultural industry self-supporting, as it was, then the produce of agriculture, needing no subsidy, standing on its own feet, was adding enormously and was giving almost the total addition to the national wealth. But you have struck it away. You have deliberately put an axe to the root of the tree. You have deliberately, by your policy, ruined Irish farming, made it utterly impossible for any branch of Irish farming to stand on its own feet profitably, made it absolutely impossible for any farmer to make money out of his land unaided by subsidy.

It was quite the other way before you came into power. If you do manage to get here and there a certain area tilled at a profit to the individual, you are covering a very small area indeed of the whole Free State. This Budget must have driven home into the minds of every supporter of Fianna Fáil who has got intelligence that unless agriculture is put upon its feet again, as it can be put, it means a national bankruptcy. You must put agriculture again on its feet or you will soon come to your very last resort, a tax upon the food of the poor. You can put agriculture on its legs and make it again a profitable industry when you end the economic war into which you rushed so blindly and of which you fired so exultantly, in President de Valera's own words, the first shot.

It is high time that sense came here. It is high time that the policy which President de Valera announced before he became President of the Executive Council, the policy of non-co-operation with England—a stupid policy—should be driven out of the President's mind and out of the minds of his Executive Council. You have got your non-co-operation, if you like, and what good is it to you? You have lost the English market, but you can get it back—I do not believe anybody doubts that—by reasonable negotiation. You can take the £5 or £6 a head off Irish cattle and you will not have to slaughter your calves, because you can sell them profitably. Fianna Fáil used to declare that the quota system could never be changed, and yet it is perfectly obvious from the treaty which has been entered into that it is far easier to get the quota removed than to get the import duty taken off the stock going in. There is one way in which this country can be saved, and that is by putting agriculture on its feet. Agriculture cannot be put on its feet until there is a proper system of mixed farming in this country. That is the whole solution of the problem, and that is the thing which you have made absolutely impossible. You have killed mixed farming, and in killing mixed farming you have, for the time being, at any rate, knocked out Irish agriculture.

Comment on this

We helped to kill the ranchers, too.

Comment on this

Well, kill them.

Comment on this

Off with their heads.

Comment on this

I have no objection to Deputy Donnelly carrying out any bloodthirsty designs he has in his head. He can be as bloodthirsty as he pleases. Another interesting speech which we heard this afternoon was the speech from Deputy Davin. I was very interested in Deputy Davin's speech. He began so bravely and finished so meekly. He was all passion and all fury in his denunciation—and quite a good denunciation—of this Budget. Of course, every denunciation of this Budget must be a good denunciation, because the thing is so intrinsically bad that, to mention it at all, must be sensible. We had Deputy Davin proudly stating that they voted for the Government's national policy, but that they would never give the Government a blank cheque. Oh, no! I rather hoped that there was going to be from the now empty Labour Benches some little show of spunk, some little courage and something to show that all these brave words meant—I will not say brave actions—ordinary non-cowardly actions.

We get Deputy Davin winding up, and what is his attitude to this Budget which he has so vigorously denounced? He is going to vote for it. So, we have the example—great courage in the talk, with no blank cheque, but, much as we hate this Budget, we are going to vote for it. That is the courageous attitude taken up by Deputy Davin, the spokesman of the Labour Party. You have the Labour Party beautifully, and I congratulate you for what they are worth. They may talk against you and they may growl, but let Fianna Fáil whistle and Labour will give up its growling and come to heel pretty quickly. You have trained them beautifully and I congratulate you—I beg your pardon, Sir; I see reproof in your eyes—I congratulate the Fianna Fáil Party on the admirable way in which it has trained the Labour Party to obey its whistle.

I do not wish to detain the House at any greater length. This Budget stands self-condemned. It is such a weak Budget, such a hopeless Budget, that I do not believe a stronger or more damaging speech could be made against it than the speech nominally made on behalf of it, to which we listened a few moments ago, by the Minister for Education. Let the country take that speech and study it, and if there is anybody left in the country who is not convinced that Fianna Fáil, by its policy, has destroyed the financial resources of this State, the financial resources which they received in such a splendid flourishing condition a couple of years ago, that person must be bereft of all intelligence.

Comment on this

This Budget is remarkable for two things. In the first place, it reveals the fact that the Fianna Fáil Government is beginning to find out that promise and fulfilment are two different things, and, in the second place, the fact that it has come to recognise that, while it is generally regarded as a truism that you cannot place a burden on any industry which that industry is not able to bear, neither can you place on the shoulders of the taxpayers any increased taxation which the community is unable to bear. It is also an indication that Fianna Fáil have gone through at least two stages of their political and economical development, and notwithstanding the laboured jokes of the Minister for Finance in introducing his Budget, he has had to have recourse, in endeavouring to balance his Budget, to various artificial aids. It was alleged against the Government that preceded this Government, namely, the Cosgrave Government, that they were extravagant, that they were parsimonious, and that, in fact, they did not react to the many demands made upon them for increased social services and so on, but this Government, while admittedly having made some advancement along the lines of giving somewhat improved social services, have adopted, in my view and in the view of anybody who has given even a very small amount of attention and reading to the policy of the present Government, a policy of robbing Peter to pay Paul.

In a speech made recently by Deputy Norton, a strong supporter of this Government, he said that in their endeavour to make the Budget balance, this Government had raided the old age pensions and several of the other social services. I have the exact words here, if the Minister wishes me to quote them. Notwithstanding that adverse criticism of the Budget, and notwithstanding the adverse criticism of the Minister's action in raiding, as he called it, the old age pensions and the other social services, the Labour Party, in my view, were quite inconsistent in going into the Lobby and supporting, for instance, the impost on tobacco, the impost on sugar, the impost on amusements and also in giving every indication that by their support of the Government, they favoured the continuation of the 5/- tariff on coal. It must be admitted, even by the Minister himself, that all these things are regarded by the working-class people of this country as necessaries, with the exception, perhaps, of one, namely, the cinema. That may be regarded, if you like, as a luxury, but in any case, it is a luxury enjoyed by very large numbers of the population and it is not always to the cheaper portions of these houses of entertainment that the working-class people go. It is well known that, in many cases, for the extra comfort enjoyed in those theatres, they patronise some of the higher priced seats. I cannot understand the attitude of the Government after making such great professions of their desire to give us better social services. Here, at one stroke of the pen, they almost negative some of the good legislation, or, at all events, some of the legislation having for its object the alleviation of the wants of the poor, the aged and the infirm.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce, in a broadcast speech, alluded to some of the things said by those people who broadcast before him. He took to task the speaker who spoke on behalf of the Labour Party because perhaps there was an error in his speech suggesting that a sum of over £300,000 would be taken away from old age pensions by the Minister for Finance in order to balance his Budget. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, in his broadcast speech, admitted that a sum of £100,000 will be saved on the administration of old age pensions. I am at a loss to know how, or where, that amount of money can be saved unless by curtailing or limiting, in some way, the number of people who would in ordinary circumstances—and by ordinary circumstances I mean the circumstances under existing legislation—be entitled to receive these pensions. £100,000 is the estimate of saving under that head. Certain economies are to be effected which are represented by that sum.

We are told that a sum of £250,000 will be required to finance the Widows and Orphans' Pensions Bill when it becomes an Act. I have always regarded the principle underlying that Bill as one of very great importance in this country. I welcome that Bill, but, at the same time, I feel that it is more than offset by the raid which is about to be made on the Old Age Pensions Fund. Again, we must estimate, because this is a contributory scheme, and I think it would be a fairly conservative estimate, that the sum that would be subscribed over a period of two or three years by those insured for that purpose would be at least £250,000. I have even heard it suggested that almost in the first year a sum of £250,000 would be subscribed by the persons who will be affected by this Bill. I do not see anything very generous in that. It is simply paying back to those contributors the sums for which they have insured. There is nothing very generous in the attitude of the Government in that respect.

It is also said, on the authority of the Minister for Finance himself, that a further saving is to be effected under the head of unemployment assistance. I cannot for the life of me see why these funds should be raided at all. We find the only excuse that can be put forward by the Minister is that he was driven to his wits' end to balance his Budget. I made reference a moment ago to the speech made by the leader of the Labour Party condemning the Budget. He said: "The Budget would make dismal reading among the poor. it raided social services, it raided the unemployment assistance benefits funds, it raided the old age pension fund, and it imposed upon needy people taxes on tea and sugar and possibly taxation on flour." Notwithstanding this declaration by Deputy Norton, he and at least two other members of the Labour Party, by their action in the Lobbies of this House, acquiesced in the very things that Deputy Norton complained of on behalf of that Party. They acquiesced in the taxes on flour, tobacco and entertainment. These mean dearer tobacco, dearer flour, dearer entertainments. Of course, they will tell their followers in the country that they voted against the taxes on tea and sugar. All this must be regarded by the Fianna Fáil Government themselves as merely a gesture, because the moment the Government were in any danger the Labour Party, I regret to say, did not show the backbone that was at one time traditional in the Party, and did not translate their speeches into action by going into the Lobby against those imposts that most of them had condemned so eloquently.

Comment on this

That was only when Deputy Anthony was in the Party.

Comment on this

Deputy Anthony showed a bit of pluck that might well be imitated by members of the Party opposite. I do not want to misrepresent anybody but Deputy Everett declared that he would vote against every impost that would affect the working people of this country. It is rather remarkable that when the occasion of translating these views into action arose, and when the occasion for defending the poor, the needy and the working-class people arose, the Labour Deputies went into the Lobby in support of the Budget with which we are now dealing.

I am not disappointed with this Budget, but I am certainly dissatisfied with it. I am not disappointed because, without wishing to repeat a charge so often made, and repeated, in this House, we know that Fianna Fáil when seeking the suffrages of the people proclaimed that if they got into office and into power they could run this country for at least £2,000,000 per annum less than the Cosgrave Government. We all know now what has happened. That is the reason I opened by saying that there is a big difference between promise and fulfilment. I also regard this Budget as showing that neither this Government nor any other Government can go on extravagantly and recklessly spending money without having to face the day of reckoning. I would commend this particularly to the Labour Party: every penny, shilling and pound spent upon unnecessary undertakings, such as extra police force and additional armies, lessens by hundreds of thousands of pounds the amount of money available for social services in the country. I am glad that Deputy Davin is now in the House. I want the Labour Party to take to heart a few words of advice that I am offering to them gratuitously.

Comment on this

They gave them to you once.

Comment on this

The Labour Party pretend a wonderful solicitude for the working class, the poorer people and the aged and infirm. Any tyro in economics—Deputy Flinn, for instance —will tell them that one cannot take out of the common pool more than there is in it. The wealth of this country may be compared to a large sum in gold or notes contained in a pool. The more you take out of that pool, containing the common wealth of the country, to devote to services such as extra military and extra police forces, the less you will have in the pool for the things that were so dear at one time to the Labour Party. The less there will be for old age pensions, for widows' and orphans' pensions, and the less the poor man will have to spare for tobacco, food and amusement —items which are taxed in this Budget. I want to know what Deputy Davin and the Labour Party have to say to that? How wrathful they used to be at the imposition of even one penny on the poor man's breakfast table. Now, we have a tax on sugar, a tax on tea, a tax on amusement; and all these things are necessaries, as Deputy Davin and the Labour Party know. Yet Deputy Davin and the Labour Party will go into the lobby to-night or tomorrow night with the Government Party, because they are tied hand and foot to Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

To whom are you tied?

Comment on this

A very decent man— myself. I am sure that Deputy Davin in his heart and soul would like to be with me, but he cannot.

Comment on this

The division list shows to whom you are tied.

Comment on this

The Budget has one redeeming feature. It will open the eyes of the electors to the fact that some of the promises of Fianna Fáil have cost the country very dear. Some of their promises have landed us into an economic struggle with the people across the water. I do not want to dilate upon that. I pass to another item in the Budget. It is contained in Financial Resolution No. 10. Reference No. 15 refers to "paper without any matter or design printed thereon". On that class of paper there is to be a duty of 5 per cent. charged. I should like to know from the Minister whether that duty is applicable to what is commonly known as news print? The Minister does not reply, so I propose to develop that point.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I suggest to the Deputy that the Report Stage of these Resolutions, or better still, the Commitee Stage of the Finance Bill, would provide a more suitable opportunity for going into the details of the different Resolutions.

Comment on this

I shall defer what I have to say until the Finance Bill is before the House, but I should like to know from the Minister now what he means by the phrase, "paper without any matter or design printed thereon"? Many persons in the newspaper industry and general job printing trade fear that this item will involve a tax on newsprint. I am sure the Minister never intended to put a tax on an industry which is giving so much useful employment. A tax of that kind would only result in reducing the number of persons employed in the industry. What I have to say further on that item I reserve for the Finance Bill.

A number of people feel much aggrieved at the new burden placed upon them in relation to their ground rents. The tax the Minister thought fit to impose is going to press very heavily on a number of thrifty persons. A large number of working-class people have made arrangements to purchase their houses over a period of 25 or 30 years, dependant on the amount of deposit they were able to put down. Numbers of these people will be unable to bear this extra burden.

Comment on this

There is no tax on ground rents.

Comment on this

Even the President has to contradict Deputy Davin. The Deputy ought to read the Resolutions. I think the Minister should consider a proposal for taxing the rents rather than levying the tax on the valuation. I quite understand that, in respect of building ground, the tax is heavy enough already. Is it not on the valuation that the extra tax is put? Perhaps the Minister will say if I am correct.

Comment on this

Several taxes are being increased.

Comment on this

Numbers of people have built houses through the medium of public utility societies and other agencies and they will suffer most. I should like the Minister to consider— if he can do so at this late stage—how he could make up for the losses sustained by these people.

Comment on this
Hugh Victor Flinn Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Flinn) Fianna Fáil

Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenny is, unfortunately, beginning to cultivate not merely a gramophonic manner but the manner of a gramophone running down. When the wind is running out, the tone gradually falls and falls until it seems to get down below the instrument altogether. Mentally, physically and spiritually, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney is cultivating that particular habit. What he dragged in to-day for his gramophone record were the poor—the poor upon whom all these taxes are being put, the poor who are to be taxed out of existence, the poor whom he never taxed, the poor, the taxing of whom he would not tolerate. Now we are all familiar with this: that whenever any vested interest is challenged such, for instance, as breweries, all the shares are held by the widows and orphans. In exactly the same way, when any tax is put on which is an indirect tax the only people who pay it are the very poor. Now, everybody knows that is not true. The one thing that I agree with in the whole discussion, on both sides, is the fact that this Budget has brought people up against the facts, and I am glad they are brought up against the facts—both sides of the facts. One of the facts is that all the tobacco, all the butter, all the bacon, all the tea and all the entertainment is not consumed by the poor. Tobacco, sugar, tea is eaten, consumed or drunk by every member of this Dáil, by every member of the Strangers' Gallery, by every member of the Reporters' Gallery——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Who should not be referred to in debate.

Comment on this

—by every member of the Seanad, by every member of the Chamber of Commerce, by every member of every golf club in the country, by every one of the thousands of people who have been storing up knowledge of the doctrines of Cobden in the last few weeks. Everybody knows that, and why anybody should have the effrontery —Deputy Davin is not the only one, not by any means—to get up in this House and keep on speaking, deliberately ignoring the fact that every member of the House knew he was talking nonsense, I do not understand. Does anyone now deny that all of these things which we are supposed to be only extracting from the very poor are consumed by the whole community, and, if they are consumed by the whole community, on whom better, or more rightly, should the taxes be put? Deputy Anthony says that these are taxes which fall upon the working classes. Why should they not fall upon the working classes?

Comment on this

And no income tax.

Comment on this

We will take income tax later. Is there anyone saying that taxes should not fall upon the working classes? I think we were told by Deputy Davin that the only asset to the country were the people who are working. We believe, Deputy Davin believes, the members of the Opposition and members of the Government all believe that three-quarters of the population of this country are made up of the working classes of one kind or another. Is anyone here going to say that three-quarters of the total population shall be exempt from taxes, and, if they are not going to say that, what is the grievance? But, perhaps, they will say, could you not choose taxes none of which would be paid for by the poor?

Comment on this

Why tax food above all things?

Comment on this

Why was food taxed before?

Comment on this

Not to this extent.

Comment on this

Why was food taxed by Cumann na nGaedheal when they put a tariff on butter? Because it paid them to do so. Why should people be exempt from taxes? Why put a tax upon beer? Some people regard it as a food? I am told there are people who say that beer "is food and a night's lodging to you." I am trying to get down to basic fact. Is there anyone in this House who says that taxes should not be put upon the working classes? Is there anyone here who says that tea, sugar, tobacco and amusements are preponderantly consumed by the poor, and no others?

Comment on this

Why include food?

Comment on this

The Deputy and everybody else did. I absolve the Deputy from that scandalous accusation. But Sergeant Buzfuz did.

Comment on this

Why should we pay more for food than the people in Northern Ireland or Great Britain?

Comment on this

Why should we have taxes such as we choose to put on, not such as other people choose to have? Why have we the power to vary taxes?

Comment on this

Why should we have to pay 1/3 and 1/4 per lb. for butter when the people in Great Britain can have our butter at 8d. and 10d. per lb.?

Comment on this

We could get Irish butter a good deal cheaper if Cumann na nGaedheal, after a two days' debate, having definitely refused to put a tariff on, had not held a Party meeting and came down the next morning and put a prohibitive tariff on. That was for the purpose of increasing the price of butter and increasing the price of food.

Comment on this

I asked the Parliamentary Secretary why we should be paying more for our butter than the people in Great Britain and he has not answered the question.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

What I like about this Budget is that it brings everybody up against the facts, and I again ask the question: Is there anyone here who says that the working classes per se— because they are the working classes— should be exempt from taxes?

Comment on this

Nobody says that.

Comment on this

That is exactly the complaint of Deputy Anthony.

Comment on this