In Committee on Finance. - Financial Motions. Resolution No. 28—General (Resumed).
Contributions 322–484 of 484. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
The Deputy says "they are", and why should they not be? The Government has to get money from where it is.
Comment on this
We will take that in a few minutes. The Deputy with his colleagues went into the Lobby on the other side to vote against a particular tax. Can he get a majority in this House to raise the income tax? Can he get those who went into the Lobby with him to say that income tax should be raised? He cannot. They are only using him for a purpose.
Comment on this
Now, broadly speaking, we have got rid of two wild statements. One was that if you tax tobacco, amusements, sugar, tea that these are per se taxes on the very poor, and only on the very poor.
Comment on this
And you get rid of the idea that there is any privileged class in this country who can refuse to take its share of the burden of carrying on and administering this State. Now the next thing that Bombastus Furiosus said was this: ánything which costs more to produce in this country than we could buy it from elsewhere diminishes the national wealth. That is an amazing statement to make. It was made from the front bench opposite, and I doubt if there is a man behind him who believes it. But an ex-Minister was allowed to come in here and made that statement, knowing full well that there is nothing, I think, in the whole range of our possible production which could not be produced elsewhere and put into this country cheaper than we could produce it, and yet everything that we produce which is dearer than could be imported, is a reduction of the national wealth and, therefore, the only way in which we can increase the national wealth is to cease production. The maximum wealth of this country is in a country which produces nothing under present conditions. Now, that is the Deputy's argument. Yet, knowing all that, at the last general election, when they were offered all these things, when they were faced with all these industries of one kind or another in which, under the protection and shadow of tariffs or quotas, production was going on, they said, "We will not remove one of those." Now, which are we to listen to —Sergeant Buzfuz, or the electioneer? The difficulty we have is to find out which of all the voices that we hear are to be heard.
I shall take another example. As a matter of fact, I think it was the same orator who said that Deputy Davin had denounced the Budget and voted for it. That may be very reprehensible, but certainly it does not lie in the mouth of the Opposition to complain of that. I remember in this House, on a Bill in relation to juries that was introduced here, a man on those benches representing Cumann na nGaedheal getting up and saying: "This is a prostitution of the jury system"—and then he voted for it. Are we to do as the preacher does or as the preacher says? It is just the same if you go back through all of their speeches—one after another they are contradicting one another. Take Deputy MacDermot, for instance. He will not allow us to regard the conversion or redeeming of the Dáil Eireann Loan as a thing which we can convert; and yet he says that he is in favour of regarding us as a free country, capable of carrying on our affairs like other people. Then, Deputy MacDermot also says: "Why do you not raise the income tax?" But when we ask him whether he is in favour of raising the income tax, he will not say a word; he already in his speech has given a reason why he should not. He says that, in his opinion, you have reached the saturation point in income tax. That solves it, as far as he is concerned. Yet, he asks us, why do we not do it? Deputy MacDermot also says—and this is a fine phrase—that he is appalled at the quantity of expenditure. Now, just try and get that one. Expenditure and service are interchangeable terms, apart from the relative efficiency or inefficiency of the Government institution which carries it out. Therefore, he is appalled at the quantity of service. Therefore, he is appalled at all the housing we are doing; he is appalled at even the relief schemes which Deputy Davin regarded as inadequate; he is appalled at the loans and subventions we are making for the purpose of arterial drainage. He is appalled at the quantity of expenditure! He would not tell us, however, what part of it he wants reduced.
Now, the Opposition say that that is what the Government say. The Opposition are complaining that we say: "Point out what you want taken away." We are entitled to do that. We are entitled to ask you to say, if you are appalled at the total quantity of expenditure, what amount of that expenditure you want removed; because, if we remove the expenditure, we must also remove the services.
Comment on this
Deputy MacEoin says: "Settle the economic war." That is one of those abracadabra phrases, one of those open sesames, one of those wonderful words which do everything! Three times in this House I have asked the responsible Opposition to tell us the mysterious terms, that they know and that no one else knows, on which they can end the economic war in a way which would be honourable and satisfactory to Deputy MacEoin, and they have not done so.
Comment on this
Undoubtedly, it was easier to start than to finish. It is always easier to get into a row than to get out of it—and the Deputy is getting into one now.
Comment on this
If I got into a row I would get out of it myself, and not be like the Parliamentary Secretary— always running away.
Comment on this
There was once a very famous man called Demosthenes—I am sure that all the Deputies are familiar with his name—and he was the only man who ever lived who could speak with a pebble in his mouth and be understood.
Comment on this
The whole truth of this debating discussion was told by Deputy McGilligan in the very first words he said in the debate. He said: "I would like to say a few practical words before I get into the usual skirmishing." We have had two days of the usual skirmishing. Each Deputy on the opposite side gets up and contradicts the other man.
Comment on this
Demosthenes again? Take Deputy McGilligan alone. He said that the one thing that is perfectly sure is that the farmer was bled and bled white; and before he had said that, the things he was talking about were sugar, butter, meat, bacon and wheat. Everyone of those are cases in which subventions of a definite character have been given to the farmer. They cannot have them both ways. I do not care which way they have them, but certainly they cannot have them both ways. Deputy McGilligan goes on to say that the purchasing power of the people is reduced. That is simply an assertion. Deputy McGilligan knows that the cost-of-living figures have been published. He cannot be saying such things in ignorance, except in privative ignorance. Then he says: "How long is this rogue's progress going to last?" By the rogue's progress that is required, he means the tax upon butter, that was imposed by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, the tax upon tobacco, which has always been there and was imposed by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, the tax upon this, that and the other thing. Yet, there are resolutions on the Order Paper to-day every one of which would require an additional expenditure which would have to be met in the only place in which it can be met and in the only place where the money is, and that is from the producers of the country. There is no other place from which the money can be got. Deputy McGilligan tells us of our decaying taxable capacity, but he does not show us any proof of it, nor does he face the fact that every single known index—and again I am asking the House to give us another index—by which, in the ordinary way, the prosperity of a country is judged, is pointing, in the Free State at the present moment, in one direction.
I will give an actual experience. That statement was made at the Incorporated Chamber of Commerce and Shipping in Cork last year. Various people, bankers, merchants and the rest got up and told us about mysterious things of they knew which would appal us. Of the secret things that were hidden behind the scenes in any of these indices, we asked each and every one for proof, or to tell us the horrible secrets that were crawling away in the shadows behind them, that showed that this country was going to the dogs, in spite of all the recognised indices, and not one single iota of new information was got from such inquiries. For two years I have been deliberately looking for the bare points in this transaction. I have gone to all sorts of people. I said that what I wanted was not the good cases, but the bad cases, and to give figures and facts which they said we did not know, which controverted all the indications that we do know. Nothing has come out yet to contradict the broad and general indication. One thing I approved of in every speech made— and I hope it will be the burden of the speeches at by-elections—and that is that we are up against it. If we are going to have large schemes of any sort, kind or description, either of a capital character or of an income character, for the benefit of the people they have got to be paid for.
Comment on this
By whomsoever has the money. I agree with that unhesitatingly. I go this far, that I define the taxable capacity of a country as that amount of the total income, over the income required for sustenance of a population, which could be turned to more useful purposes in the development of the life, the prosperity and the industry of the people itself. I do not hesitate at all about that. But it does not help me to say that you can get it all from certain sources. I think a list has been read which represents £8,000,000 or £10,000,000 worth of stuff which Deputies opposite have recommended this session. They want to get rid of the whole of the annuities, and the whole of the rates; they want to have a couple of millions spent on telephones, and someone wanted £250,000 yearly spent on increased wages in the Post Office. All sorts of things were spoken of. Deputy Davin asked me whether we were doing all the public health works that we should like to do. We are not.
Comment on this
Because things have to take their turn. I want to help in the matter. We estimate that to tackle the sanitary problems in the Free State as a whole would cost at least £6,000,000. If that is put into the Budget Deputy MacDermot will not let us borrow for it. If we take the interest on it then it has to be raised by taxation, as well as the sinking fund. But if we did £6,000,000 worth of sanitary work, who is going to tell us that the House is going to accept that as the only thing that is going to be done, or that that work is to get priority?
Comment on this
Yes, it is altogether better if it does not cost you anything more. I want to see them employed. I want to see every man off that dole. I want to see every man who is getting the dole working for every penny of it, and I want to see added to the amount he is getting as a dole an amount of money which will make it worth his while to work. All that cannot be done in a day. As to the extent to which it is done, it means that the Budget is going to be increased; it means that taxes are going to be increased, not to-day, to-morrow, but every other day, and it is a question when and how that can be done. It is a question of the Minister for Finance surveying the whole problem, and asking whether or not the country is being submitted to a greater strain than it can bear. There are people who think it is, and there are people who think it might go much further.
There was one portion of the speech of Deputy O'Sullivan with which I agreed, and which I think was a useful contribution, not merely to this Budget debate, but to the whole question of economic considerations here. He said that there were taxes borne by people which did not appear in a Budget. There always have been. I think all those taxes should be segregated so that we would know what they are. I believe in putting the people up against facts. They have the courage to face facts. As far as is humanly possible, these taxes should be put in in some form in the national balance sheet. We know that our predecessors did not put their taxes into the Budget. Oh, no. They were very careful about that. For instance, they wanted to have an unemployment scheme. A general election was coming, but they were thrown out before they paid for that scheme. They said: "We will give £250,000 as an election bribe, but nominally in the form of unemployment relief." They did not make any attempt, such as we are making, to see that the money went to the people who required it, or to the places that required it at the time it was required. In one case there were ten gangers, every one of whom was a personation agent of one particular Party. At any rate they decided to give £250,000. How did they do it? They said: "The British owe us £250,000, which they will perhaps pay. They owe that to the Road Fund, so we will take the £250,000 out of that Fund." The British have not paid that money since. That Party went out and the present Minister for Finance had to find the money in his first Budget. Then, of course, they would not raise income tax. Oh, no. Such a thing as putting on three extra sixpences was too horrible for words. They would not increase the seven sixpences. What they did was to collect 18 months' income tax in one year. That avoided having to raise the rates in any way.
Then, at a critical moment, the question came up again of finding some new money for the Budget. Of course they would not put any more taxes on beer and stout and whiskey. These were the food of the poor. Oh, no. What they did was to call in an extra two months of the brewers' credit, and to put the £250,000, more or less, into their pockets without any trouble. But it did not raise the taxes.
There are other secret methods of taxing. They have the selling of assets. They have the calling of it "miscellaneous revenue." The old Congested Districts Board, the only good Board that the British had out of something like 54 Boards, the one Board that was abolished, the one that I hope to see set up again had some assets. They had something like £900,000 accumulated funds during the War. That was money which had not been spent by them during that time. Where are these funds? Miscellaneous revenue. The education authority had some stocks, the interest on which to-day should be used for the purpose of relieving this Budget and preventing us putting a tax on tobacco, sugar, tea, entertainments and other things which are only consumed by the widow and orphan. Where is all that stuff? Miscellaneous revenue! As Deputy O'Sullivan said very rightly, very pregnantly and very truly, "all the taxes that the people pay do not appear in the Financial Statement." But here is the amazing thing. This is the complaint that he makes against this criminal here, the Minister for Finance. He said "the Minister had openly and shamelessly imposed taxation," instead of calling it miscellaneous revenue. That is the accusation. That is the accusation against this poor innocent, that he openly and shamelessly imposed taxation; he openly and courageously faced the people of this country, called upon their courage, called upon their sense of responsibility, called upon their sense of realities and said: "These are the things which we as your Government were under your orders sent to do, and for these you shall pay."
Comment on this
And so says Deputy Good. I have said previously in this House on other occasions that there are many occasions in which I have agreed with Deputy Good, but my reasons are very different.
Comment on this
Damn good. There are people who think that the only person who pays income tax is the man from whom the income tax is collected. Why did the Dublin Chamber of Commerce turn down the "No income tax" campaign?
Comment on this
Why did Deputy Good turn down the "No income tax" campaign? If they believed that income tax was paid only by the people from whom it is collected why did they turn down the campaign? It is the old game. It is about time it was exploded. There is a book of Victor Hugo's called Les Miserables and in that book he says that the whole object of the tax collector is to collect the money with as little conscious disturbance and trouble as possible to the people from whom he gets it. He wants the money and he is going to get the money, but the whole object of any taxing system is to get it out of the people with the least possible resistance. One of the very beautiful games that has been worked, and worked very successfully, is that of persuading people that in relation to taxation they are divided into two classes, the first, the people who pay direct taxes and the other the people who pay indirect taxes. It worked beautifully. I am calling Deputy Davin now as a witness. It worked perfectly. Deputy Good, according to Deputy Davin, is perfectly satisfied as long as the money is raised by indirect taxation; and Deputy Davin is perfectly satisfied so long as it is raised by direct taxation such as income tax.
Comment on this
It is a great stunt. These two classes have been persuaded that these taxes do not cross the line. I am perfectly satisfied they do cross the line. For that reason it is to me purely and simply a matter of machinery and convenience how the money is raised. The people who pay large sums in income tax know how to get these moneys back. They know how to pass the burden on. Deputy Davin knows that the one argument which we put forward at that particular time was that the income tax was passed on. The Dublin Chamber of Commerce, knowing that the purpose of that campaign was to put up differential taxation, greatly to its credit, the one Chamber that saw through it, turned down the "No income tax" campaign because the "No income tax" campaign was then the only instrument in the then state of governmental authority which was capable of wrecking all that the Dublin Chamber of Commerce stood for—a country of distributors instead of a country of producers. All the things that the "No income tax" campaign stood for are being done to-day by tariffs, quotas and the rest of it by the whole authority of this Government because the whole object of that was to turn this country into a producing instead of into a merely distributing machine.
In the course of this debate Deputy Mulcahy came along and made the most extraordinary statement. The Deputy said: "It is not the faintest use pretending that the people of this country are getting on well because they are not paying as much for boots as they did." Even though it was proved to him that they were consuming more boots he went on to complain that they were getting too many boots for too little money. That was his complaint. Apart from that, I do not think he said anything.
Deputy Roddy made a contribution whose courage I think ought to be commended. I believe my friend Deputy Corry said he would put that speech in his Bible. It all depends on how far Deputy Roddy is prepared to go on the road which he has blazed for himself. On that depends whether that was the most discreditable speech which was delivered in the House or a speech which was greatly to the credit of the Deputy. Deputy Roddy said quite frankly: "I believe there are altogether too many social services in this country; they are altogether too costly; they are more than we can afford; we ought not to have them at the rate at which we are now having them." It takes a good deal of courage to say that, be it right or wrong. I remember the case of the Deputy in this House who, when we were discussing the 24/- a week wage for relief schemes, said: "I disagree with it; I did not know that that was the wage, or I would not have asked for them. Now that I do know the wage, I will never ask for them again." That Deputy never did. His constituency did not lose anything by it, because they were carried out there. But there was a man who had the courage of his convictions and stood over them, and I have the greatest possible respect for him.
In the same way, if Deputy Roddy does believe what he is saying, and if he is prepared to implement it in the Division Lobby, whether we will agree with him or disagree in the correctness of his conclusion, we will honour him at any rate as a man. If he says: "I do not believe we can afford these things; I do not believe we ought to have them; I think they are going too quickly," and if he then goes into the Division Lobby and votes against their extension, then that man has the same courage that I have commended in a member of a Party here who did not just say a thing and then run away from the consequences. If Deputy Roddy is going to follow the example of the rest of his Party and, while defaming those who have the obligation of collecting the money, votes against every source from which that money comes, is going to go into the Lobby and vote for old age pensions, and vote for widows' and orphans' pensions, and vote for the extension of this and the extension of that while denouncing them, then I say the speech of Deputy Roddy is as discreditable to him as it might be honourable and that the choice rests with him.
I could go through the whole of the litany of defeatism and disaster, the litany of complaint we have had here, the litany which Deputy McGilligan has described as the usual skirmish, but I will not. I do, however, repeat the appeal which has been made, an appeal which I made to the Chambers of Commerce and they ran away from it, and that is: "If you object to taxation come and tell us what we are spending it on that you do not want done, and if you want the thing done, and if you object to the particular way in which we are raising the money, then tell us where you are going to put the burden and come and agree on it." The imposition of taxation is not at all a nice or pleasant thing. It is a duty and it has got to be done. It is a duty which will be done, but it would be a duty which could be much more easily and much more fruitfully done if, behind the imposition of taxation, there was agreement as to the sources from which that taxation should come.
I have never yet addressed an audience in which I did not believe that every man in it was as intelligent as myself, and that practically every man knew a great deal more about some things than I knew. I believe in treating my own constituents as respectable and intelligent people, and I do not pretend to think that I can fool or deceive them. Deputies opposite cannot fool the people by objecting to taxation and demanding the fruits of taxation. They will not do themselves the slightest bit of harm from an electoral point of view if they will share the burden of acknowledging and accepting the sources from which the money comes while demanding the thing itself. It was I used the phrase here once as a slogan of Fianna Fáil in relation to finance: "Nothing popular in finance." Getting money from people is not going to be popular. Getting money from the people who ought to pay it is not going to be popular. Doing work and telling them that they have to pay for it, is not going to be popular, but it is honest. That is what the Budget has done, and for that reason we stand over it.
Comment on this
As a representative of a constituency in this country which has the greatest number of poor in it, I listened last Wednesday with considerable indignation to the speech of the Minister in introducing his Budget, but I must confess that I have listened now to the speech of his satellite who has just sat down with considerably more indignation. Deputy Flinn has told us that everybody should bear the burden of taxation, and why should not the working classes and the poor stand the burden of taxation as well as others? Has anybody suggested that the working people and the poor should not stand their due share of taxation? I did not hear Deputy Davin to-night, or Deputy Norton, who spoke last week, suggest that the working people and the poor people should not stand their due share of taxation. Deputy Flinn appears to think that when he pays 4d. per lb. extra for his tea he is bearing the same burden as the poor miserable people on whom a tax of 4d. per lb. is imposed on their tea. He seems to think he is bearing his fair share of taxation when a ¼d. per lb. is put on his sugar; that he is bearing the same burden as the working man who is supporting his family when he has to pay an extra tax on his sugar. I have seen various calculations as to what this extra taxation means on the poor. I have seen it suggested that it means 1/6 or 2/- per individual on the poor.
Comment on this
I saw a statement made by a representative of the Postal Union that it represents about 1/6 per head. I do not accept these figures, because I have not analysed them, but I do suggest that the burden on each individual poor person who is paying this extra taxation will be a very considerable one. It will not mean ¼d. per £100 on Deputy Flinn, but it may mean 1/- per week on the £ that the workman earns. Does Deputy Flinn seriously suggest that the poor are only bearing their proper proportion of this new taxation when this extra tax is put on their food? I remember the indignation of the Fianna Fáil Party about taxes being put on the poor when Deputy Cosgrave was President. Deputy Cosgrave's Government was called a Capitalist Government, but in those days the breakfast table of the people at least was free. Now, as a result of the beneficent Government we have got from the Party opposite, we have a £1,000,000 a year taxation paid on the butter consumed by the people of this country, and most of the people who pay that tax are the poor.
Comment on this
We have this tax renewed on tea, and as a result of the new taxation the price of sugar is increased by more than 50 per cent. over what it was then. We have a new tax on tobacco, a commodity which I suggest is also a necessity of the poor. We have a new tax on bread. All the necessaries of the poor are taxed by the Party who were going to reduce taxation in this country by £2,000,000 a year. We were told to-night by the Minister for Education that the Minister for Finance will reduce taxation when he gets an opportunity of doing so. A promise to reduce taxation in the future should be valued from this point of view: who made it? It is made by a Party and by a Government who, before they came into office, told us they were going to reduce taxation by £2,000,000 a year. We have now before us a Budget which shows not only no reduction of £2,000,000 a year but an increase of taxation by many millions of pounds, and yet a Minister on those benches has had the effrontery to get up in this House to-night and tell us that the Minister for Finance will reduce taxation when he is able to do so.
Deputy Flinn told the House to-night that this Budget has brought the people up against facts. It has. It has brought the poor people up against the fact that they are having an ass's burden put on their backs by this Government which posed as the friends of the poor before they came into office; this Government which said that the Cosgrave Government supported only the capitalists and the rich. The poor people are brought up against the fact that an ass's burden is being placed on their backs by the Fianna Fáil Government. There is a tax of 4d. per lb. on tea; there is an extra tax on their sugar; the tax on their butter is maintained. All this is done by those savers of the poor who got into office by promises to reduce taxation, to reduce the cost of living, and to make this a country in which the poor would be a happy people. Not only was there to be no unemployment—they were to bring 84,605 extra people into employment—but in addition to that our industries would be so prosperous and our country would be so happy that we would have to send to America and bring back people to fill all the jobs we would have here to give them. The Minister for Industry and Commerce remembers all about that speech. Those were the promises made. Deputy Flinn, the man who was going to make this country happy by the abolition of income tax, has had the effrontery to get up in this House to-night and say: "Why should not the working classes bear their share of the taxes?" Who ever claimed in this House, on the Labour Benches or on those benches, that the working people should not pay their due share of taxation? Nobody ever suggested that they should not, but I would suggest that when you put a farthing on the sugar for the working people, or when you put 4d. on their tea you are imposing a far bigger tax on them than if you put 1/- in the £ on Mr. Hugo Flinn's income tax.
Comment on this
I have been listening to this discussion on the Budget for a couple of days, and I think I can truthfully say that not a single word has been said in favour of it from that side of the House. Everybody who has spoken from the Government Benches has been making a sort of apology for the Government, and asking the Opposition to show them how to balance the Budget or how to make it a more popular Budget. That is not the business of the Opposition at all. It is the business of the Government themselves to implement their own promises, and not to ask the Opposition to show them how those promises should be implemented. When they made those promises to the electorate they did not say that it would depend on the Opposition to show them how they could be carried out, but now they come pleading to the Opposition to show them how it can be done. I would ask the Executive Council whether they are prepared to carry them out if the Opposition shows them how it can be done. That is the first condition I would impose on the Government—that they should sign an undertaking that they will carry them out. The Opposition will then show them how to implement their own promises.
I must admit that the Minister for Finance had a painful duty to perform in bringing this Budget before the House. It was a painful duty, and his humorous remarks in introducing it were as much out of place as if the judge, on putting the black cap on his head to deliver sentence, began to amuse his prisoner. When the Minister had this painful duty of delivering the Budget sentence on his own victims it would have been more suitable to put on the black cap rather than try to introduce humour into it. His attempt to make it a smiling Budget was an absolute failure. I had an opportunity of viewing the faces on all sides of the House, as well as in the gallery, and I did not see a smile on any face except that of the Minister himself. There were no smiles on the faces of those on his own benches. They did not feel it was a smiling Budget, but after all there is something to be said for it; it is bringing home to the majority of the people who were misled by those promises that now they have got to pay for their own folly. Deputy Davin and the Labour Party, who were prepared to indulge in the luxury of an economic war and all the other nonsense which Fianna Fáil has introduced, were prepared to indulge in it at the expense of others. They did not mind what sacrifies had to be made; they did not mind sacrificing the farmers of the country so long as it did not touch themselves, but sooner or later it had to come home to all Parties. Everybody in the State will eventually feel the pinch, but the poor people will feel it worse in the long run. It is impossible to keep taking it all the time off the farmers. The burden must be borne by all classes sooner or later, and this is only a short step in that direction. The Budget, of course, notwithstanding all that has been said about it, is not balanced because the Minister for Finance knows that it is not sound finance to borrow a couple of million pounds to pay bounties. If bounties were an abnormal condition of things, if they were only a passing phase of government activity, I admit that there might be some justification. In 1934, in referring to them, the Minister said that this thing could not go on for ever, and because it could not go on for ever he felt he was justified in borrowing for bounties. Can the Minister say if we are any nearer to normal relations between this country and Great Britain? Are we any nearer to the position when there will not be a necessity for these bounties? The Minister did not hold out the same hope to-day as he did 12 months ago. So far as the Government are concerned, they apparently regard the present condition as normal and they look upon the economic war as a normal relationship between this country and Britain. I contend that the Minister is not justified in borrowing for the payment of bounties, necessary as these bounties are. If he goes on year after year borrowing to pay them back, where will it all end? What prospect has the Minister in view that will place the country in a better position in the years to come in relation to these bounties? The same thing might be said with regard to borrowing for building purposes. There is a case for borrowing for some projects, but it is not sound finance to borrow for all the things the Government seem to have in mind. This money, it must be remembered, is being expended to relieve the unemployment which has been brought about, partly by the Government's policy and partly by the increase in population.
It is quite probable the increase in population will continue and the necessity for providing money to relieve unemployment will continue in the future so far as we can see, and the Government can hardly submit that it is sound finance to keep borrowing year after year to provide work for unemployed people. It all resolves itself down to this, what are to be the normal conditions and when are we likely to reach those normal conditions when the Minister for Finance will be in a position to balance his Budget and when the country will be able to provide employment for all its people? The necessity for these bounties is due to the economic war. The country cannot be deprived of £20,000,000 through the decrease in the value of our exports without every section of the community feeling it. This Budget is only a beginning. Anyone who looks into the future must realise that this Budget is merely the opening stage of what we are likely to have in future years. The ability of the people to bear further taxation is diminishing every day. As taxation goes up, the ability of the people to meet it goes down and that condition of things is bound to continue while this Government pursues the foolish policy upon which it has embarked. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Industry and Commerce invariably ask the Opposition to show them the way to implement their policy.
Comment on this
We have merely asked them to show us an alternative. We would not be entitled to ask them to show us the way, but if they object to our methods we are entitled to ask them to show us an alternative.
Comment on this
We have shown you the way many times. One of your promises at the last election was that as a Government you would cut down the number of officials. Have the officials been cut down in numbers? Have they not rather been increased in number? How have your promises been kept? Is that the way to implement the promises you made at the election? Every speaker on the Govenrnment side tells us: "No matter what we have done, the people have sent us back." They sent you back in the belief that you would keep your promises, that you would cut down taxation and reduce the number of officials. Is not that the issue on which you were returned? Instead of reducing taxation by £2,000,000 it has been increased by about £8,000,000, and there are still a couple of millions being borrowed. Posterity as well as the present generation will have to pay for the folly of this Government. We have taxation on tea, on sugar, on tobacco, bread and on everything else.
Comment on this
I am glad to be reminded about butter. We are, as a matter of fact, paying a tax on butter. The people in the Free State are paying 6d. per lb. more for butter than the people across the Border.
Comment on this
I agree it was necessary in the circumstances. I want any Deputy over there to tell us what advantage it is to this country to have the people paying more for their butter than people pay elsewhere? When the farmers are selling their milk at the creamery they get 4d. per gallon, while people across the Border who buy their butter at 50 per cent. less are selling their milk to their own creameries at 50 per cent. more than the Free State farmers get. Does any Fianna Fáil Deputy deny that? The Minister for Agriculture had to admit that the price in Northern Ireland for milk supplied to the creameries is 6d. per gallon. He mentioned that that was the winter price. Whether it is winter or not now, that is the prevailing price. The average price paid during the last month was 4.12d., but the Minister in the Northern Government paid the balance of 1.88d. in order to bring the price to 6d. a gallon. We are told that the price is to be reduced to 5d. for the summer months, and I am not going to question that statement. That means that the average price will be 5½d. in Northern Ireland, while the average price here is 4d. It is a little under 4d., with all respect to the Minister for Agriculture. The "advantage" we in the country are getting because the people of Dublin and other towns throughout the Free State are paying extra for their butter is that we have to sell our milk at 1½d. per gallon less than the farmers in Northern Ireland, where they can buy our butter at 6d. a lb. less than the price here. I challenge anyone to contradict those figures.
We were told that people were better off here in every respect, with the exception of cattle. No one has pretended that the price for cattle here is as good as the price in the North of Ireland. In fact they are £6 a head less. The Minister told us that the money received for milk and butter paid the farmers for everything, but I have shown the actual facts in that respect. The small farmers and even labourers go in for poultry rearing and egg production. The price of eggs here is about 5d. per dozen. The price of hen eggs in Northern Ireland is 8d. per lb. and eight eggs make a lb. As in the case of milk, the Northern farmers are getting 50 per cent. more for their eggs than farmers in the Free State and yet Fianna Fáil speakers will tell us that we are losing only on the cattle. We are losing not only on cattle but we are losing to the extent of 50 per cent. on eggs and milk. Let us turn now to pork and pig carcases. The average price in the Free State of pig carcases —and I have the figures in the Farmers' Gazette and other papers—is 47/- per cwt. The price the producer gets for his pigs is 47/- per cwt. dead weight and the average price in Northern Ireland is 61/-. That is the price the farmer gets on the scales and he need not be concerned about the price of bacon afterwards.
That is the position with regard to eggs, pigs and milk as well as cattle. We are told about the price of oats but what does the price of oats or barley matter? Oats and barley are only raw materials in agricultural production for feeding to pigs and fowl. We have no market across the water or anywhere else for our oats and if one farmer gets a good price for his oats, he must get it from his neighbour who is feeding pigs or fowl. You cannot call it any advantage if one farmer gets a good price at the expense of his neighbour.
Comment on this
The position in connection with the production of pork, eggs and these other commodities is that they have to pay more for feeding stuffs in the Free State than in Northern Ireland, and Deputy Donnelly knows that perfectly well. They have to pay more for clothes and boots. For everything they have to buy they have to pay more, and they have to lose 50 per cent. on everything they sell, and all the logic of Fianna Fáil cannot alter one of these facts. There these facts stand, after all is said and done. If Deputies will go down to the Library they will see these facts and figures, and I challenge them to deny them. I will bring the figures in and quote them if any Deputy questions them.
All this talk is only nonsense. There is no use trying to camouflage the situation, and there is no use trying to confuse the public mind, because the public mind is beginning to be aroused, and this Budget is the first thing that brings it home to the people that they have to pay for their folly and that they cannot indulge in economic wars and such nonsense at the expense of other people. They have to pay for such things, and that is the one good thing I see in the Budget. The Minister for Finance at the time of the 1933 election, told us that the economic war was already won. How is it that we are still paying for it now? He also told us in 1933, when he introduced his Budget, that he had saved £92,000,000 or £94,000,000 to this country. If he saved that money, how is it that the Minister in England can say that he is collecting it still? He may have saved it for the Exchequer, but he has not saved it for the country. He has thrown it upon the farmers, and he has run away from his responsibilities. He has relieved the Exchequer perhaps of the load of paying that debt, but he has not relieved his conscience of the responsibility for throwing it upon those who were not liable to pay it, exacting that money in another direction and throwing farmers into gaol when they refuse to pay it the second time.
I think the Government will have to relieve their own conscience before they can say they have cleared this debt. It is a debt we are paying, and paying not only once but three times over. We have paid the entire annuities to Britain, and we have other debts amounting to a couple of million pounds—local loans and charges in connection with the payment of R.I.C. pensions—and all these things are borne by the farmer, if the Minister has relieved the Exchequer. We are losing, at the same time, the good will in the British market, which the President told us was gone forever, thank God. He was very glad to make a settlement and to give Britain a monopoly in respect of coal in return for taking a certain number of our cattle into that market that was gone forever. No matter how long this Budget is discussed, we have to get down to the root cause of the trouble. Deputy Flinn asked the Opposition to show how anything better could be done and how the economic war could be settled. One thing that I will say is that the position could not be any worse since we are paying the whole amount which Britain claims and losing a thousand other advantages in the British market and having quotas and everything else imposed into the bargain. We could not be any worse if we were to pay the whole thing. I do not say that we should pay the whole amount nor that it is necessary to pay the whole amount.
Comment on this
I am not going to say whether this money is due or not, but we have as good a case for a settlement as Britain has for a settlement with America. We have as good a case as France, Germany, Italy or any other country in Europe has for being relieved of their debts to England, and I think the Government should not be afraid to enter into negotiations with British statesmen who are themselves negotiating for a settlement of their own debts. The Government is suffering from an inferiority complex. Otherwise, they would not be afraid to meet British statesmen face to face. They have a good case but they are running away from their responsibilities. They are throwing the responsibility on the unfortunate farmers and throwing them into gaol instead of going like men to meet British statesmen and putting the position before them.
Comment on this
I should like to remind Deputy Flinn that after the Ottawa Conference, when the statesmen of the different countries of the Commonwealth met, every one of them came home with a good settlement for his country. They improved their trade positions and they got good settlements except our representatives. What did our representatives get at the Ottawa Conference? If the Minister for Industry and Commerce will study the statisties supplied by his own Department, he will see that the exports from this country to all the countries of the Commonwealth have gone down at an alarming rate, while the trade between all the other countries has improved. Why did this country send representatives to that Ottawa Conference at all if that was the result? I think it was a terrible mistake to throw away the hard-earned money of the taxpayers of this country in sending representatives to that Conference when they could bring nothing back.
The Minister has tried to make the Budget as little felt as possible and tried to make the country believe that, although they are paying something like £36,000,000 in taxation—if they are not paying it in full at present they will have to pay it in the future—they are not paying much taxation at all. He reminds me of certain dentists who used to go around extracting teeth. They brought a band with them and kept the band playing. When the unfortunate patient was undergoing the operation, nobody felt any pain. They were all amused except the patient and, with the noise of the band, nobody heard his moans.
Comment on this
They called that painless extraction. However the Minister may pretend that nobody is suffering by this taxation, the fact remains that everybody in the State is paying. They pay when they go in to buy shoes, cloths, butter, sugar, tea or eggs. They pay it across the counter. The Minister is getting the money and they are paying it, no matter how they feel it. They may blame the shopkeeper because they think he is charging them too much for tea, tobacco or sugar. The Minister, however, is making everybody in the State his tax collector, so that the people may not believe he is collecting the tax at all. The levy upon butter and all the other charges are going into the Minister's Budget and yet he is not able to balance it, because when the State is deprived of its annual income, it must come out of the pockets of the people. These taxes are not being paid out of income; they are being paid out of capital. The result is shown in the bank returns. The "Economist" has shown very clearly how the assets of the banks are affected this year as compared with a year ago. These have gone down in one year by £17,000,000. The effect of the first two years of Fianna Fáil Government were not felt. It is only now that the effects of the Fianna Fáil policy are being felt. It is necessary that any policy should be in operation for some time before its effects become evident. For the next 20 years, the effects of the policy of the present Government will be felt. For many years, there will be difficulty in getting this country on its feet again. I do not believe that any Party man can bring the country right. It will be necessary that all Parties co-operate and try to pull the country out of its difficulties. That is my opinion.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce asked for the co-operation of all Parties in this House. I am quite sure that he can have that co-operation in any business proposition he puts up—whether the conversion of the first National Loan into a new loan or any other proposition. But if the Government want the co-operation of the House, they must get real co-operation if it is to be of any use. For that reason, they should not put up a foolish policy to the Opposition and expect the Opposition to assist them in that policy. The Opposition do not believe in the policy of the present Government. They cannot be expected to fall in behind the Government and assist in giving effect to Fianna Fáil policy when they know in their hearts that that policy is wrong. We have been told that the English people set an example in co-operation. What did the English people do? They formed a National Government. In that National Government, the Opposition joined in order to pull the country out of its difficulties. The English people set an example which this country might well follow. Are the Government here prepared to do the same thing and are they prepared to have an agreed policy? If they were prepared to take the Opposition into their confidence and have an agreed policy, I am sure that the Opposition—I am speaking merely my own mind— would not be found wanting. It remains to be seen what the present Government really want when they speak of co-operation. Anybody who has the interest of the country at heart will be only too glad to help the Government out of the difficulties in which they find themselves. There is no question that they are in difficulties. Every day, they are getting into deeper water and, eventually, the country will be in such a position that no Party will be able to extricate it. The surest means by which the country can be relieved is by the genuine co-operation of all Parties. There is hardly any other way out of the situation and the sooner all Parties realise that the better.
We heard some remarks about the adverse trade balance but we do not know exactly what view the Government take with regard to this adverse trade balance. When they were in Opposition, an adverse trade balance of about £13,000,000 was regarded as very serious. Now that it has gone up to about £20,000,000 and is still increasing, it is of no consequence at all. When we had an export trade of about double what it is to-day, an adverse trade balance of £13,000,000 was very serious. When our export trade has been halved, an adverse trade balance of £20,000,000 has no significance. That is Fianna Fáil logic. The Minister for Industry and Commerce made a very poor defence of this Budget. He was driven into a very tight corner when he had to charge the Opposition with things of which they were never guilty. In trying to make a case for the Budget, he charged the Opposition with voting against the Unemployment Assistance Bill but it was proven that, in that, he was wrong. He is not very particular in his figures, either. He arranges them to suit his own purpose and they would no more stand investigation than his statement with regard to the Opposition voting against the Unemployment Assistance Bill. The only defence that the Minister for Industry and Commerce, the Minister for Agriculture or any other speaker on the Government benches had for this Budget was to ask the Opposition to show them how to carry out their own promises. It is the business of the Government and not of the Opposition to find a means of implementing their own promises.
Comment on this
I have been in some doubt as to whether there was need of any further speeches from this side of the House. When I was in Opposition, I always felt a certain amount of sympathy with the Minister for Finance on occasions like this. I used to think that it was rather unfair that the Opposition should be free during the greater part of the year—practically all the time—to advise expenditure in directions that might be popular without having any real responsibility for facing the cost when the time came. When it fell to the lot of the Minister for Finance to raise revenue to meet the expenditure, I used to think the position was hardly fair to him. Having sat here during the afternoon and having listened to some of the speeches from the opposite benches, I am inclined to think that my sympathy was altogether misplaced. At no time, in my opinion, does the Opposition show itself to the people in a more unfavourable light than it does on occasions such as this. The representatives of each section of the community cry out against their section bearing any part of the burden which they were so ready to suggest should be imposed.
Anybody listening to the arguments put forward by these representatives on behalf of the different sections, must come to the conclusion that there can be no real sincerity behind their criticisms. In fact, very often they appear to be absolutely ridiculous. They bring themselves to the position that was exposed by the Minister for Agriculture to-day when he pointed out that there were demands from the opposite benches for schemes which would involve the raising of several million pounds: that these demands had been but recently made, and that if they had been accepted by the Government they would involve not merely taxation on the present scale, but taxation on a vastly increased scale; or they would lead in such directions as we heard from Deputy Davin this afternoon. The Deputy, on behalf of the Labour Party, tried to suggest that a needless burden was being placed on the poorest sections of the community, and said that the means to provide for these services could have easily been obtained from other sources. I sat here during the course of the Deputy's speech, and I noted points to which replies could be more easily made than I think I have ever heard from any speaker in the House.
The bounties, we were told, were not going to the farmers, and it was said that they should be replaced by derating. I should like to hear some of the gentlemen on the opposite benches if we came in and proposed that there should be no bounties this year. I should like, for instance, to hear Deputy McGovern on that. The Department concerned is examining that whole matter most carefully, and they are perfectly satisfied that the bounties as regards eggs, poultry, butter, bacon, live pigs and horses do go to the farmers.
Comment on this
Live stock is but a small fraction of the whole. I think it is only about 20 per cent. There is a question with regard to live stock, a question that has arisen mainly on account of the operation of the quotas. That matter is under consideration, and actually at the moment, apart from what action may be taken by the British with regard to the quotas, the Department is engaged on the preparation of a Bill the purpose of which is to amend the Slaughter of Animals Act.
Now, let me come to the suggestion of derating instead. I think I should deal with this question of derating, because it is just as well that we should have it out. When the land annuities were being paid over to Britain I told the people that if these annuities were retained here, as we intended if we got into office to retain them, a sum of at least £2,000,000 would go back to the agricultural community, and when we came into office we had to decide whether that money should go in the way of derating or not. We decided deliberately that it was better for the farmers generally that it should go in the halving of the annuities than in derating. I, for one, am opposed to further derating, and for this reason: that if we are going to have local government at all we cannot relieve the rates to any further extent. Already the sum that is being paid from the central Exchequer to meet local charges is so great that, if we give any more, we will have to give up local government and take away from the people the responsibility of spending unless they have the responsibility for providing the money that is spent. Therefore, on this matter of derating we have to make up our minds on this: do we want local government or do we not? If we do not want local government; if we do not want the people to have responsibility for their own local services, then we can cetralise and meet the whole cost from the central Exchequer. But if we do want local government, if we want the people to have local responsibility we cannot meet the cost of local services to any further extent from the central Exchequer. That is definite. By the reduction of the annuities to one half, we have given to the agricultural community——
Comment on this
I was saying that we promised that if we got the annuities we would make available out of these moneys about £2,000,000—the sum was specified—for the agricultural community, and that was done. It was one of our first acts. We made the deliberate choice of doing that as against derating, and I say that there will be no further derating. That is definite as far as this Government is concerned. There will be no further derating if we are going to continue local government. If the people are going to have local services, then they must have the responsibility locally of providing the money for these services and at present a very substantial proportion of the local charges is being met by the central Government. So much then for the first point about derating. Derating was not, I should point out, suggested by Deputy Davin by way of addition, because if it were then the money would have to be got here, and it is not the present sum that would have to be provided for derating, but a further sum of money would be necessary. Deputy Davin suggested it by way of substitution for the giving of the bounties which, he said, did not go to the farmers.
Comment on this
I think the expression the Deputy used was "bounties." If the Deputy wishes to correct himself I say all right. As I have said, the cattle bounties represent only 20 per cent. of all the bounties and that matter, as I have said, is being examined. It is admitted that there is a question as to whether all the bounty in the case of cattle does go back to the farmer.
Comment on this
I am sure that the President does not want to misrepresent me. I rely as to what I said on the Official Report, which I think will prove that I spoke all the time about the cattle bounty.
Comment on this
Very well, I accept that. I say again that it only represents about 20 per cent. of all the bounties. That matter is under consideration. So far, there is an admission on the part of the Department that it is possible that all the bounty does not go back to the producers. The matter is under consideration and an amending Bill is in course of preparation. We were told that another source that ought to be taxed so as to relieve the poor of their burden was the ground landlord. One of the Financials Resolutions—Resolution No. 6— deals with that very matter. The practice has been, in the case of builders of houses, to estimate their income on the capitalised value of the ground. It is considered that that is getting after them to the extent that it is possible, at any rate at the moment. Therefore, any suggestion that they are not being taxed, and taxed heavily, is not right.
Comment on this
I have said that in estimating the profits of house builders, their income—the reserved portion of the rent which they get—is estimated not at its simple value but at its capitalised value. Therefore, there is a heavy tax on them. It has been suggested that we might put a tax on motor cars.
Comment on this
Very well. The users of private motor cars at the moment are paying a very heavy tax on the petrol—8d. per gallon. There is a very big question whether, if you increase the rate of tax, you will increase the total yield, and that is a matter that is carefully considered by the Minister for Finance when he is framing his Budget. In addition, there is the tax for the Road Fund— according to horse-power or whatever way it is calculated—which is also a substantial annual sum on the users of motor cars. Therefore, it is a mistake to say that the section of the community which uses motor cars are not taxed. They are, and the only consideration is whether, if the Minister increases the tax, he will have a greater total yield. These are all the points made by Deputy Davin, I think.
We have been asked why it is that the grants for the local schemes which the Minister for Finance and, I think, the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, said were available, were not being availed of. I have made inquiries and I am satisfied that, in so far as it is possible for the central authorities to drive the local authorities to do this work, they are doing it. If there have been delays it is due to the fact that the local authorities have not put up schemes or are not prepared to bear their share of the amount these schemes would cost. As far as the central Government is concerned, the Minister for Local Government and Public Health would be only too glad if the local authorities would accept his suggestions in this matter, and then these schemes would go ahead much more rapidly.
Comment on this
I have been talking, not half an hour ago, to the responsible Minister for that, and he has no complaint about the Department of Finance in the matter. His complaint is that the local authorities are not able to co-operate rapidly and quickly enough with the central authorities.
Comment on this
I have heard the Minister immediately responsible on the matter. We have been asked about the Guarantee Fund.
Mr. Davin rose.
Comment on this
Deputies have all got their opportunity, for the last two or three days, to make their speeches, and I think I should be allowed to make my speech. I shall answer questions at the end. I have here a note of what was said about the Guarantee Fund by some Deputy. A question was asked: Could not some Department use its imagination and get some way by which those who paid their rates would not have the burden imposed upon them of meeting annuities for those who have not paid them? The Deputy who made that remark said that I smiled when he said it. I said to the Deputy—I think it was Deputy Davin—that he should use his own imagination on the matter and give us the fruits of it. Unfortunately there is no scheme, that we can see anyhow, to remedy that matter, and if any Deputy here can devise one, we should be very glad to put it into operation. If a person is unable to pay, the putting of increased rates on him is not going to make him pay, and the only way payment can be guaranteed is the way in which it is at present guaranteed. Undoubtedly, it puts a burden on other people, but we have that kind of thing constantly occurring. In every community some of the drones have to be brought along, and other people have to take the share of the burden that the drones will not bear. Some Deputy spoke about the Volunteer Force. I do not know whether it was Deputy Davin or not.
Comment on this
Well, Deputy Davin spoke about the income tax. I shall come to the question of the Volunteer Force later on. We were asked: Why do we not increase the income tax? Deputy Hugo Flinn asked Deputy MacDermot why he did not come along with his suggestion, as he had already indicated a reason, and a very good reason, why the income tax, in the circumstances, should not be increased. The Deputies on the opposite benches know very well what would be the result, in all probability, if we increased our rate of income tax over that of the British at the present moment. Certainly the yield from income tax that the Minister could look forward to at the end of the year, with certainly anyhow, would be less and not greater than it is at the present rate. Therefore, you have not got any opportunity of further increasing the tax in that direction. The old age pensioners, we are told, and the unemployed, have to bear this burden. The only thing we are doing in the case of old age pensions is this. We have reduced the Estimate for the year to the amount that, with rigid administration, will be required provided no one is allowed to benefit from it who was not intended by the Oireachtas to derive benefit from it. Rigid administration in that matter is necessary, because the more liberal we are, in trying to meet the need of those who are in need, the stricter we have got to be to see that nobody, who is not in need, should benefit by it. It is putting too big a strain on the community to expect them to meet the needs of those who are not in want as well as of the people who are in actual want. It is the same way in the case of unemployment, but in the latter case it must be remembered that we have provided for employment schemes in the Budget and we believe that, as a result of the operation of the economic policy of the Government generally, there will be less need for unemployment assistance in the coming year.
I have some figures here to indicate some of the increases in expenditure over last year that have been provided for. They are as follows: for new public works—principally schools and barracks—we have provided a sum of £142,600 over and above what was provided last year; for afforestation, which will give a considerable amount of employment—practically all of it, I suppose, will go towards giving employment—there is a sum of £110,000 provided in addition to the sum provided last year; for housing grants there is a sum of £236,000 in addition to what was provided last year; for the improvement of estates by the Land Commission there is a further sum of £80,000—all making a total sum of over £568,000 extra. Then there is the employment which, it is anticipated, will be given in preparing the industrial alcohol factories, which will probably amount to about £100,000 given in employment. We are providing for an increased amount of employment, and the Minister, therefore, feels that he is justified in writing down the amount he originally intended for unemployment assistance by the amount he has already indicated it will be written down by.
The Volunteer Force was mentioned by some Deputy. We were asked: Why is it that we are undertaking such expense as there is in building up that force? We are doing it for this simple reason: that we want to be in a position that, if there should be a European war, we will give no excuse to anybody for suggesting that we are not able to defend our own territory. I think that is a sufficiently good reason.
Comment on this
I have dealt, accordingly, with the points that have been raised by Deputy Davin, and I say that there is no way in which we can meet by taxation the expenditure which we are making except by the methods that have been suggested by the Minister for Finance. If these burdens do extend to all sections of the community, it is not because we want it to be so, but because it must be so; because there are no alternatives to the situation. We have got to do it if we are to provide all these social services that have been voted here in this House. We have Deputy Morrissey, of course, crying out. I think, however, that it was he who moved a resolution here in this House that those who did not get employment should get subsistence. As to the complaint against the amount that we are providing in this Budget for subsistence, Deputy Morrissey is in the ridiculous position of people who adopt the tactics he adopted here. He wants these services but he does not want the money provided for them.
Comment on this
£300,000 is not being taken away. We made it clear from the start that our policy was to provide work, and only to provide unemployment assistance to the extent that we failed, and while we were in that position——
Comment on this
That plan is being put into operation. God help this country if we had not that plan for the last three years, when we had an increased population of 20,000 people each year.
Comment on this
The Deputy says plenty at times other than the present. We are providing the money necessary to meet these services. We are supposed to be inflicting very heavy taxation on the poor and to have no regard for the poorer section of the community. What are the services we are providing for? The list of services for the relief of the poor includes old age pensions, State contributions towards widows' and orphans' pensions, and unemployment insurance fund, State contribution towards unemployment assistance, purchase of beef for distribution, milk for necessitous children, school meals, child welfare, welfare of the blind, contribution towards the rent of allotments for unemployed; and provision of seeds for allotments. It is not intended or suggested that that is an exhaustive list. We are providing this year a sum of £5,174,300 for the relief of the poor, while the comparable figure for 1931-32, the last year our predecessors were in office, was £2,959,270, showing an increase on services for the relief of the poor of £2,215,030 on the items mentioned. For housing and public works, we are providing this year £3,619,413. In 1931-32, the expenditure under that heading was £1,660,473, so that there is increased provision of £1,958,940. In regard to public health, we are providing £410,205 against £369,402 provided in 1931-32, or an increase of over £40,000. For disablement and Army pensions, we are providing £375,270 against £194,691 provided in 1931-32, or an increase under that heading of £180,579. For education, we are providing £4,587,322 against £4,471,288 in 1931-32 or an increase of £116,034. For the relief of agriculture, provision is made for an increase of £2,563,259 over the amount provided in 1931-32. I will talk about the agricultural situation when I am dealing with the economic war. The amount provided for the relief of agriculture in 1931-32 was £2,014,536, while we are providing £4,577,795 in the present Budget.
Comment on this
The provision made for agriculture this year shows an increase of £2,500,000. The Deputy should not be talking nonsense. For the relief of local taxation, other than agricultural grants, the amount provided in 1931-32 was £1,159,245. In the present Budget, provision is made for £1,579,363, or an increase of £420,118. For export bounties on industrial and fishery products, a sum of £105,000 is being provided. There are increases shown in our Budget for the services I have enumerated and, in the main, they are to assist either the poor or those suffering hardship as a result of the economic war. The increases amount altogether to £7,599,763. How can anyone who is sincere suggest that this Government has not cared? Let them take their choice and take the other step. Let them vote for the alternative Government if they are dissatisfied.
Comment on this
We are quite willing. I take it that the Labour Party is not voting for the present Government, as individuals, but is doing so because they believe the policy is a good policy for the section of the community they represent. That is the position as I see it, and I expect the day that position changes the members of the Labour Party will vote for the other side. That is the position we are taking up in regard to it. Out of the resources of the community we are doing what we set out to do. We came here, not as some of the Deputies on the opposite benches would suggest, when the country was flowing with milk and honey, but when agriculture was thriving and prosperous. We came here after we had been pointing for years to the position that was being arrived at in regard to agriculture. We pointed out that, as a result of falling prices, the figure of two-thirds had arisen before we came in as a Government. Prices having fallen to two-thirds of their level in 1924, it was clear to anybody that the old policy would have to be scrapped. We had people from the opposite benches pretending to us that there would be no trouble if only the old policy had been adhered to. What did that policy mean in the past? I am quite willing to admit that if the former Minister for Agriculture—the Minister for Grass, as he was called—had still been in office, if the old policy had been continued, with a diminishing population, if the ports of other countries were open for emigrants, and if we could get rid of the surplus population we might have a higher standard of living for a very much smaller population than we have. I doubt that myself. I believe we ought to be able, and I believe we will be able, to organise ourselves so that a human being as a producer will to an extent produce more than he consumes. That was not the position that obtained in the past. As a result of the old policy we were losing our population at a rate unparalleled by any country in Europe. We had lost half of our population in a period of 80 years. That, and lower prices, was what was facing our country if the policy had not been changed. We went to the people and asked them to put us into office to change that policy. We saw that outside markets were being closed, and we were already warned by the statements of British Ministers, in which they pointed out that in the Argentine and elsewhere there was scarcely an agricultural product that could not be produced and landed in Britain more cheaply than Britain could produce it.
If that were the position and if there were to be protection of British industry, was it not obvious that, some day or other, you were going on to the Major Elliot period with a policy of protection for British agriculture. One would imagine it is because we have refused to pay a debt that was not due that all this thing has come about. The people of Australia are complaining because the British are buying goods from the Argentine that they expected the British would get from them. So are the people in New Zealand. What is the answer of the British to them? Even though New Zealand was prepared to take their manufactured goods from them, the British were not prepared to give them any protection in their market which would enable the producer in New Zealand to sell at a profit. We were absolutely dependent upon British policy in that regard. The British have a right to restrict imports if they want to, just as we have a right to put on tariffs. They have that right and they will exercise that right at any time that it is convenient to them. Whenever it is expedient they will put a tariff on our products. If this question of the debt that they are claiming had never arisen they might have done that. I am not absolutely asserting, but I believe that if this question of the payment of land annuities had never arisen these quota restrictions would have been put on. They cannot expect to get from us money which this Government will not admit is due.
Comment on this
We are not paying it. It is being stolen from us. There is a difference between paying a thing and having the money taken out of our pockets by force. The money is being stolen from us.
Comment on this
There is a difference between paying money voluntarily and having that money taken from you by force. It is one thing for me to pay money and it is another thing when somebody comes along and takes that money by force out of my pocket. We know that they can take it.
Comment on this
How does the President justify the Cork seizures for land annuities which the people have already paid twice over?
Comment on this
The policy on which we went to the people in 1932 was this: There was a sum of £4,000,000 to £5,000,000 being paid to Great Britain by the previous administration. We said that the money was not due. We can prove it was not due, and we can prove that before any impartial tribunal.
Comment on this
Because we are not able. We are quite frank about it. We are not going to pay that money until it is proved before a tribunal in which we have confidence that we owe it.
Comment on this
And the farmers from whom Britain has already collected the money have to pay again to you? Why are you collecting the money twice over?
Comment on this
We went to the people and told them that this money was not due, and because it was not due we would not pay it. Our predecessors got the Attorney-General to secure an opinion from a number of lawyers. That opinion was to the effect that the money was due. That was the case our predecessors put to the people. Later, when we asked the British Government why they were claiming that money, we found it was not on any of the grounds that were set out in the opinion given by the lawyers. They claimed it on a document that was hidden from the people. The principal claim made by the British is based on a document that the Irish people had not seen or heard of until nine years afterwards.
Comment on this
If we were strong enough to prevent the British from taking it we would prevent them.
Comment on this
The farmers are not strong enough to prevent the court messengers from taking their cattle for a debt they have already paid twice over.
Comment on this
We hold they are taking this money from us unjustly. Then we are told by Deputies to settle the economic war. On what terms? We pointed out definitely to the British, in our dispatches which were published, that we were prepared to settle the thing and to consider the whole merits of this situation and argue it out before a tribunal in which we had confidence. We are open to argue it. We said we were prepared to let it go to arbitration. We said we would not agree to a tribunal that would compromise our position. When we met them in conference what did they say? The nature of what they said was this: If we agreed that this debt was due— though in our hearts and consciences we believed it was not due—if we admitted it was due, there might be some mitigation of the payments. Everything that can be done by people who are interested in the rights of our people has been done by the present Government in this matter. The aim of the British is quite clear to anybody. Their aim is by this particular method to try to secure a surrender on vital national issues. It was obviously in trying to secure a surrender that they made these proposals to us, but they will get no surrender of that sort from this Government anyway. That is their aim. As long as they had the people on the opposite benches going around the country preaching to the farmers not to pay their annuities, and misrepresenting the position to the farmers, they had hopes that if they did not force a surrender from this Government, they would get the Irish people to put in a Government who would surrender.
Comment on this
That is not so. If a robber comes along and forces money out of my pocket, I am not in the same position as regards him as if I gave him the money, admitting it was due to him.
Comment on this
The Irish farmers are faced with two robbers. They have the British Government robbing them and their own Government.
Comment on this
The people of this country are not going to be misled. The Opposition tried to mislead them after the first year when the whole thing was put before the Irish people and the Opposition failed. They will try it at the coming by-elections and they will fail again. The Opposition is making the suggestion that they can make a good bargain. But it will be a bad and a poor bargain for the Irish people ultimately if you surrender the national position. These are the terms on which it can be settled. We are supposed to have been complimented in his speech by Deputy Good. I listened to the Deputy, and I did not notice any particular compliment in it. I did notice it was not as wild as the other statements to which I listened, but I did not see in it very much of a complimentary nature. The Deputy did not appear to me to be very complimentary and I wonder what Deputy Davin found complimentary in it.
Comment on this
That we had the courage to face up to the situation and to tell the people that if they were going to have these social services the money should be found somewhere. Was that it?
Comment on this
I repeat that I did not see very much of a complimentary nature in it. Perhaps it was part of Deputy Davin's strategy and scheme to make it appear that we were very hard on the poor but that we were so considerate to other sections that we can get encomiums from Deputy Good——
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey will have got a complete answer if he reads a list of the social services that we are giving to the people.
Comment on this
One passage in Deputy Good's statement which struck me was: "To ignore one's neighbour when we could make trade with him mutually profitable is not a business proposition." There again you have some suggestion of misrepresentation. I am not suggesting that it is deliberate misrepresentation but it is a misrepresentation nevertheless of the whole position, that we deliberately ignored our neighbour when we could make trade with him mutually profitable. Was there any basis for that suggestion? We are not ignoring our neighbour. We have indicated more than once to our neighbour that we are prepared to make trade agreements with him on a basis that would be mutually profitable. We have suggested that more than once. We have indicated quite clearly that we are prepared to do business on that basis, but we have never been met on that basis. We have been told: "Oh, yes, we will trade with you provided that you surrender the national position and that you will agree to certain arrangements"—arrangements which the Irish people do not want.
Comment on this
One of them was that we were bound by the Treaty in a way that even our opponents would not suggest that the Treaty binds us.
Comment on this
I think if the country was taken into the President's confidence we would be unanimously with him on that.
Comment on this
The Deputy has spoken for a long time, and I ought to be allowed to complete what I have to say without constant interruption. I say that there has been no ignoring of our neighbour, such as is suggested. We are not so stupid, to say the least of it, as to ignore him. We have time after time pointed out that up to recently, at any rate, and even now, we occupy one of the highest positions in the British market, that we are buying more goods from Great Britain than any other country in the world. I do not suggest that we are doing it simply for the good of the English people. We are doing it because it suits us and for no other reason—because we get better value there than elsewhere. If we could get better value elsewhere, we would go elsewhere. Not only are we buying more goods from Great Britain than we buy from any other country, but we buy more goods than any other country buys from Great Britain, with the exception of one or two—there was no exception a few years ago. We produced so little industrially for ourselves that the three million people in the Twenty-Six Counties bought more British goods than the three hundred millions in India. We have a very big trading business with Great Britain.
On the other hand, Great Britain bought more from us than any other country—almost incomparably more than any other country bought. The difference between the two positions— the difference, of course, from a fighting point of view and a resisting point of view putting us in the weaker position is this—it is nothing new; everyone recognises it—that we are her best customer and although in the present situation any country looking for external markets does not want to lose a good customer, although we were her best customer, she had so many others that the amount we bought from her was not a big percentage of her total trade, whereas the amount we sold to her was a high percentage of our export trade. Therefore, from a fighting point of view, we recognise that we were relatively in a weaker position. It is well to see the facts as they are. We have seen them and faced them, and we put this to the Irish people—if they want to make a trade settlement by the surrender of the national position, then they must get another Government. If they want to maintain the national position, as we have presented it to them, then they will have to support this Government and support the position that this Government has taken up. They cannot have it both ways. That is the position. It has been suggested that we should have some national Government and some agreed policy. How can you have agreement on those terms?
Comment on this
We have not suggested it. We suggested that Deputies on the opposite benches should cease sabotaging. When we are in what is really a very difficult struggle, not less difficult because it is going on silently, not less difficult because you cannot go out and stir up people's blood about it; when we are in a difficult position and trying as quickly as we can to organise our economic life to meet the struggle, we should not have people on the opposite benches going out and trying to make it impossible to win. The only way really to win it is to reorganise our national life on a different basis. We are trying to do that as rapidly as we can.
Comment on this
That is what we are trying to do. We are doing it with a comparative measure of success because the position is not the position that the former Minister for Industry and Commerce—who when in office was simply a laughing-stock from the point of view of industrial development— would like to have it appear. There has been industrial development since the present Government came into office and since his office was occupied by somebody who had an outlook to try and develop.
Comment on this
All over the country it is to be seen. It has been seen constantly all over the country. What we are talking about is plain and obvious. The very fact that the Minister for Finance has to find alternative sources of revenue, instead of the revenue which the previous Administration used to get out of Customs duties—when they imposed Customs duties not to protect industries, but Customs duties that were really sources of revenue—is a proof that we are producing here the things that formerly we paid other people to produce.
Comment on this
It is quite definite that we are producing here millions of pounds' worth of goods that were formerly brought in from outside.
Comment on this
The debate on this Resolution has lasted for 14½ hours, and I think no section of the House can state that it did not get a fair opportunity of putting its views before the House. Deputies elected by the people should have sufficient control over themselves to hear the President stating his views. Whether they agree with him or not is another matter.
Comment on this
I say it is not even arguable. It cannot be contested that there are produced in this country today millions of pounds' worth of goods which formerly were brought in from outside. That cannot be contested, because the facts are there—the returns are there to show it.
Comment on this
I say that is proof that somebody with initiative, who knew what he was after and got after it, was laying the foundation for future incomes in this country. We are not going to get incomes in the first year. When you start industries you do not expect they will pay dividends and make profits in the first year. We are only two or three years in office. The full effects of the present policy of building up industries, so that our farmers will have some other producers besides themselves to share the burdens of administration, will not be seen in a year or two. You have to wait until the industries establish themselves. At present what is happening is that factories are being built and being organised and that factories are being extended. The position in the milling industry does not obtain with regard to other industries, because there we were in a position in which we were able, by an extra drive at the end, to complete it, so that we are practically self-sufficing in the milling industry. There are a number of other industries, such as the boot and shoe industry, which are rapidly reaching that situation.
Therefore, the position is that we went to the people and we made definite promises. I issued an election address, and can the Labour Party, or any other Party, come along and show me a single one of these items to which I pledged myself on behalf of the organisation to the people that we have failed in? I pointed out many times during the election campaign that we could not produce miracles. I said that, on account of our backwardness in industrial development, we were in a relatively better position to face the situation than other countries that were already beyond saturation point in industries and that had to deal with unemployment. The fact is that visitors to this country who spent some time in it—I am not talking of those who spent a few days here—who have gone round the countryside and spoken to our people—some of them belonging to our own nation who lived in the homes of the people—who have been in other countries and who are in a position to make a comparison, are satisfied that, as we anticipated we would be in regard to the whole economic situation which is affecting every country, we are in a much better position than other countries. At any rate, that is our belief. We do not intend to change our policy in the matter and we are satisfied that the Irish people at the next opportunity they get will again support that policy.