We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote No. 54—Lands.

Contributions 1–146 of 461. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

I move:

Go ndeontar suim ná raghaidh thar £797,974 chun slánuithe na suime is gá chun íoctha an Mhuirir a thiocfaidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar críoch an 31adh lá de Mhárta, 1936, chun Tuarastail agus Costaisí Oifigí an Aire Tailte agus Choimisiún Talmhan na hEireann (44 agus 45 Vict., c. 49, a. 46, agus c. 71, a. 4; 48 agus 49 Vict., c. 73, a. 17, 18 agus 20; 53 agus 54 Vict., c. 49, a. 2; 54 agus 55 Vict., c. 48; 3 Edw. 7, c. 37; 7 Edw. 7, c. 38 agus c. 56; 9 Edw. 7. c. 42; Uimh. 27 agus Uimh. 42 de 1923; Uimh. 25 de 1925; Uimh. 11 de 1926; Uimh 19 de 1927; Uimh. 31 de 1929; Uimh. 11 de 1931; Uimh. 33 agus Uimh. 38 de 1933 agus Uimh. 11 de 1934).

That a sum not exceeding £797,974 be granted to complete the sum necessary to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1936, for the Salaries and Expenses of the Offices of the Minister for Lands and of the Irish Land Commission (44 and 45 Vict., c. 49, s. 46, and c. 71, s. 4; 48 and 49 Vict., c. 73, s. s. 17, 18 and 20; 53 and 54 Vict., c. 49, s. 2; 54 and 55 Vict., c. 48; 3 Edw. 7, c. 37; 7 Edw. 7, c. 38, and c. 56; 9 Edw. 7, c. 42; Nos. 27 and 42 of 1923; 25 of 1925; 11 of 1926; 19 of 1927; 31 of 1929; 11 of 1931; 33 and 38 of 1933 and No. 11 of 1934).

Comment on this
Minister for Lands (Mr. Connolly)

The title of the Vote for the "Land Commission" is altered this year to the Vote for "Lands," owing to the inclusion for the first time of salaries and allowances of the Minister and Parliamentary Secretary and their personal staff. This follows on the redistribution of Fisheries and Gaeltacht Services, and is merely a matter of administrative convenience.

The amount of the Vote, as a whole, shows an increase of £132,444 on the previous year's total (as adjusted to include the Supplementary Estimate of February last). This is attributable mainly to increased and progressive activity in regard to the division of untenanted land, as will be seen by the provision under sub-head I (Improvement of Estates, etc.) which is increased by £80,000.

Salaries, Wages and Allowances under sub-head A are increased by £21,026 on account of an increase of staff both indoor and outdoor, necessitated mainly by the expanding policy of land division. The total staff is augmented in number from 862 in the previous year to 984 in the present year. The largest increase is naturally in the Acquisition and Resales Division, where 36 extra officials are required to deal with the indoor work in connection with land settlement. The Inspectorate and Survey Staffs are increased by 19 to deal mainly with the outdoor work. The Purchase Branch, which is principally concerned with the vesting of tenanted land, is increased by 34 officers.

Under sub-head B, the amount for travelling expenses is up by £3,000 on last year, consonant with the increase in the numbers of the inspectorate staff and their extended activities. The slight increases under sub-heads D and E (Office of the Public Trustee and the Solicitor's Branch) represent mainly ordinary increments in salary of the staff. An increase of £1,500 is put down for sub-head F (Incidental Expenses of the Solicitor's Branch) which includes among its various items costs awarded in cases of appeal against prices fixed by the Land Commission in proceedings for the acquisition of land under the Land Acts, 1923-'33.

The increase of £2,222 under sub-head H (Payments under Section 11 (7) of the Land Act, 1923) represents the normal additional liability of the State for interest and sinking fund on new land bonds issued under the Land Act, 1923, for contribution to the price of tenanted land and for the Costs Fund.

The big increase under sub-head I (£80,000) (Improvement of Estates, etc.) has been already referred to, but it may be well to emphasise that this expenditure serves the dual purpose of land improvement and the provision of useful employment in agricultural districts. This is an inevitable corollary of the big increase in the division of untenanted land.

The provision under sub-head J (Advance to meet deficiency of Income from Untenanted lands purchased under the Land Acts 1923-'33) remains the same as last year, and does not call for comment. The amount provided under sub-head K (payments under Sections 42 and 46 of the Land Act, 1927) is increased by £1,224, mainly to make provision for any State liability arising in connection with new committee cases for which advances will be made under Section 42.

As regards the Section 46 cases, three more co-operative farming societies have been wound up during the past year and only two of these societies still await dissolution. Sub-heads L (Deficiencies on realisation of Land Bonds) and M (Loss on Unoccupied Holdings) represent only nominal provision, and the same applies to sub-head Q (Payments under Section 34 of the 1931 Act).

Sub-heads N ("Additional Sums" Advances) and O (Provision for cases where Purchase Proceedings are Dismissed or Purchase Price reduced) remain practically unchanged and do not call for comment. Estimates under all these heads are largely problematical. In regard to sub-head O, for example, it is quite impracticable to forecast to what extent the recovery of over-issued bonds may prove to be impossible.

Provision under sub-head P is increased by £500 in order to provide for contingencies, but precise forecasting of such an item is impracticable. The amount provided under sub-head R is increased by £5,000 in order to meet deficiencies in the Land Bond Fund arising from the revision under Part III of the Land Act, 1933, of further annuities, as they are set up.

The amount under sub-head S is reduced by £5,000 as some of the proceedings pending under the Land Acts of 1903 and 1909 have been disposed of during the past year, and the amount of £15,000 is estimated as sufficient to finance in the current year transactions pending under these Acts. Sub-heads T (Payments under Section 14 (4) of the 1933 Act) and U (Advance for payments under Section 17 (J) of the 1933 Act) remain the same as last year and do not require comment.

Under sub-head V, this year a sum of £11,200 will be required to meet the deficiency in the Church Temporalities Fund, due to the funding of arrears of annual payments and the reduction of annual payments under the 1933 Land Act, which deficiency is to be made good out of voted moneys, under Section 18 of that Act. Last year only a nominal sum of £100 was put down under this head, as no reliable estimate of the deficiency could be framed. This deficiency is now estimated at £5,600 for the year 1934-35 and a similar amount for the year 1935-36 so that the sum of £11,200 provided covers the deficiency for the two years. Of this sum £1,000 is in respect of arrears in excess of three years remitted and the balance represents loss of revenue in consequence of reductions in rentals.

Under sub-head W (Fees payable under Section 28 of the Land Act, 1933) an increase of £2,000 is shown. The amount required under this head cannot be accurately forecast, but the round sum of £30,000 will probably be sufficient. The amount required under sub-head X (Writing off of Annuities on submerged lands) is also difficult to estimate, but a round figure of £1,000 is put down. Last year's estimate under this head was only a nominal figure.

The amount of £300 provided under sub-head Y for assistance to migrants from the Gaeltacht is the same as last year. As explained in the course of introducing the Supplementary Estimate for the Land Commission in February last, this sub-head is provided to meet exceptional expenditure to be incurred in connection with the migration of congests from the Gaeltacht to the new colonies to be established in County Meath.

In the course of the debate on the Supplementary Estimate taken early this year I dealt at some length with the Gaelic-speaking settlement near Athboy, which has aroused a good deal of public interest. I may say now that 16 families from the Gaeltacht have been successfully installed in their new homes and are rapidly adapting themselves to the new conditions. This particular settlement is to be completed in the course of this year by the migration of 11 further families, making 27 families in all, as soon as houses and accommodation are prepared for them. We are leaving nothing undone to make this experiment a success and hope that it may set a headline for further schemes of a similar nature and serve the dual purpose of relieving congestion in the Gaeltacht and preserving and extending the use of the Irish language in other areas. Other schemes of a similar nature are at present under consideration.

As regards the Appropriations-in-Aid of the Vote, the total amount for the current year is expected to be less by nearly £9,000 than last year's figure. This reduction is mainly attributable to the reduced amount to be received in repayment of advances from sub-head N of the Vote in respect of "Additional Sums" under Section 28 (3) of the Land Act, 1923, and Section 51 of the Land Act, 1931. The bulk of these advances was made in November, 1931, and as the final instalments of these Additional Sums fell due last year this item will be considerably diminished in future.

As regards the general work of the Land Commission, the past year has witnessed a great advance in the work of land settlement. As stated in the course of the debate on the Supplementary Estimate taken in February last, the Land Commission staff, both outdoor and indoor, have put in a year of exceptionally hard work and have broken all records in the matter of land division.

There has not been time yet to have a final audit on the returns for land division up to the 31st March last, but these returns may be taken as representing accurately the work of the Department for the financial year ending on that date. Taking the nine years, 1926 to 1934, the average amount of untenanted land divided (under the Land Acts, 1923-'33) was 44,534 acres per annum and about 8,000 acres on the C.D.B. and Estates Commissioners' Estates.

Last year—i.e., from April 1st, 1934, to March 31st, 1935—the amount of untenanted land divided was over 102,000 acres. In addition, there were divided on Congested Districts Board and Estates Commissioners' Estates 21,500 acres, making a total division of almost 124,000 acres for the year.

Over and above this there was during the year a re-arrangement of 545 Congested Districts Board holdings amounting to over 20,000 acres. During the year 100.468 acres were acquired under the 1923-'33 Land Acts, which contrasts favourably with 48,000 acres, which was the average per year for the previous nine years.

The expenditure on "Improvements"—i.e., on all building repairs, fencing and development work consequent on division—was £318,723, against an average of £200,000 per annum over the same period.

When it is noted that this enormous increase has been secured at an increased staff cost of approximately 11½ per cent., Deputies will, I think, agree that the work of the Department for the year has been more than creditable. No effort will be spared to maintain and increase land settlement during the present year.

Activities in the other branches of the Land Commission have been well maintained during the past year. The organisation of the purchase branch, which deals with estates of tenanted land, has been strengthened with a view to providing adequate staff for the work of finally re-vesting in the tenants the large number of estates vested in the Land Commission under the Land Act, 1931. In this matter, it is a wise policy to "hasten slowly" and to give the tenants the full benefits of improvement, proper definition of appurtenances, and re-arrangement of their holdings where necessary, prior to vesting. The placing of the tenants on a purchase annuity basis under the provisions of the Land Act, 1931, has obviated the necessity for hasty vesting, as delay does not involve the tenants in any financial loss.

As regards allotting new holdings of untenanted land, vesting does not and will not take place for some considerable time after allottees have been installed. There is a definite and, I think, a sound reason for this delay. It gives the Land Commission an opportunity to see that the new holders will make every effort to make good and not simply turn their lands into cash either by sale or by letting. So long as lands are unvested possession can be retaken and they can be reallotted to other applicants who will use them in a proper manner. In practice, it is expected that at least six to seven years will elapse before vesting takes place. In the meantime the tenant suffers no hardship, as delay in vesting does not prevent all annuity payments being credited to the tenant purchaser in just the same way as if the lands were vested.

Considerable progress has also been made during the past year with the resale of the remaining unvested holdings on the estates acquired by the late Congested Districts Board, and the intricate work of improving and re-arranging these holdings preparatory to vesting has been well advanced.

Good progress is also being made with the distribution of the land bonds representing the purchase prices of estates vested in the Land Commission under the Land Acts, 1923-33. As regards tenanted land a total of £6,500,000 in land bonds—nearly half of the amount representing the price of the estates vested in the Land Commission under the provisions of Section 9 of the Land Act, 1931—has already been distributed. During the past year, taking tenanted and untenanted land together, a total of about £2,500,000 in land bonds was distributed.

One of the most difficult tasks of the Land Commission during the past year has been the punctual collection of land purchase annuities. The returns up to the 31st March last show that since the coming into operation of the Land Act, 1933, as from the November-December gale of 1933, a total amount of £2,771,890 has been collected on account of revised land purchase annuities, leaving arrears of £880,690 at that date over the three gales. That is to say, over three-fourths of the total amount collectible had been already collected on March 31st and the arrear is being steadily reduced. I may mention that since March 31st approximately £150,000 has been collected.

That, in brief, is a summary of the year's work up to March 31st, 1935, and I hope and think you will agree with me that it has been a splendid year's work on the part of the entire staff of the Land Commission. From the Commissioners down to the junior members of the staff there has been constant and consistent loyal service and tireless energy. To the staffs, outdoor and indoor, I attribute the results that I have outlined and I, at least, wish to record here publicly my keen appreciation of and thanks for the efforts they have made.

Mr. Brennan rose.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is a motion in the name of Deputy Davin that the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration.

Comment on this

I put down this motion: "That the Estimate be referred back for consideration," for the purpose of drawing the attention of the House and seeking the support, if I can, of Deputies with the object of persuading the Minister to review the decision given by him, a decision which is contained in the answer to the question addressed to the Minister in the House here on the 7th May. On that day I addressed the following question to the Minister for Lands: "To ask the Minister for Lands whether men employed at forestry work at Kinnity, Offaly, have been paid at the rate of 22/- per week, and, if so, if he will state how this figure was arrived at or fixed; whether men employed at the same kind of work in adjoining areas in the same constituency are paid at the rate of 28/- a week; whether he will issue immediate instructions for the men concerned to be paid at the rate of 28/- a week and also for payment of any arrears due to any of the men who were paid at any lower rate since the commencement of work in this area."

The Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy O'Grady, replying for the Minister, said:—"The Deputy is correct in stating that the rate of wages paid at Kinnity Forest, Offaly, is 22/-, and that the rate of wages paid at Mountrath Forest, Leix, a few miles distant, is 28/-. This is, however, explained by the fact that the rate for Mountrath was fixed some years ago when the rate of wages for agricultural labourers, to which the matter is related, was higher than at present, but the rate for Mountrath forestry workers has not been reduced. The lands at Kinnity have only recently been acquired, and, accordingly, the rate fixed has relation to the existing rate of wages paid in the district to agricultural labourers. The question of a revision of the rates of wages paid to labourers generally is under consideration at present, but until the review of the whole position is completed it is not possible to state what alterations will be made."

Then I asked the Parliamentary Secretary a supplementary question as to whether he could cite any other case in any of the midland counties where the rate at present paid is as low as in this case, and the Parliamentary Secretary said he could not. I think it is very unfortunate that this new low rate to be paid to forestry workers should have been fixed and put into operation at a time when, as stated in the answer to the question, the question of the revision of the rate of wages paid to labourers generally is under consideration. I hold the view, and the members of this Party share that view, that the revision of the rates of wages to be paid to labourers is being prejudiced by the putting into operation of this low payment of 22/- a week. I suggest to the Minister that he should agree to pay the rate in the adjoining counties until such time as the report of whatever body is investigating this matter has been received and considered by the Minister. It is ludicrous at a time when the House is actually engaged in the discussion of a Conditions of Employment Bill to come along with proposals of this kind. The Conditions of Employment Bill has been brought in by the Government for the purpose of dealing with bad employers and for the purpose of improving, where it can be done, wages and working conditions of men and women engaged in industrial occupations. I think it is a very bad example for the Government—which is supposed to be the best employer in any country—to come along as they are doing and fix this low rate now. I think it is especially a bad thing at a time when we are promised by the Minister for Agriculture that he intends to set up an agricultural wages board for the purpose, I presume, of improving the wages of agricultural labourers and stabilising them at a higher figure than that at which they stand at present.

It is also a very bad example to whatever reactionary local authorities there are in the country. We have had other examples of the same kind of thing in the County of Offaly. There are local authorities only too willing to take advantage of any indications of this kind for the purpose of bringing down the wages of their own workers. In this County of Offaly there was a dispute some time ago regarding the wages paid by building contractors to unskilled labourers engaged in the erection of houses for the county board of health. It was discovered that wages as low as 24/- per week were being paid to these unskilled workers. After a good deal of contention and argument the board of health raised the minimum wages to 30/- per week. I say it is a bad example for the Government to set at a period when we are discussing the improvement of the conditions of workers generally. I understand that this action has been taken by the Minister as a result of a recommendation or decision of what is known as the Wages Advisory Committee. I should like to know whether that committee is more powerful than the Minister in a matter of this kind. If not, then the Minister has power, if he thinks it is right to do it, to revise in an upward direction the decision or recommendation of this secret Wages Advisory Committee.

I can give the Minister particulars of another case where this committee recommended a reduction of wages and where the Parliamentary head of the Department concerned did not accept their decision. It was in connection with the carrying out of an arterial drainage scheme in Laoighis. When the scheme started, 28/- per week was paid. When the work was being completed last year the Wages Advisory Committee, for reasons similar to those given by the Minister in answer to the question, recommended the payment of 24/- per week. The men concerned left their work as soon as they heard they were only to get 24/- instead of 28/-. The matter was brought to the attention of the Department concerned, and the Parliamentary head of the Department, after going into the information at his disposal, made an offer of 26/- per week. That offer was turned down by the men and, finally, the Parliamentary head of the Department concerned — the Board of Works — agreed that the wages to be paid on this particular scheme should be 28/-, as was paid when the work commenced. I suggest, and I hope the Minister will not deny, that he has as much power, if not greater power in matters of this kind, as the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance. If he has, I hope he will exercise it in the same way as it was exercised in the case I referred to.

Another reason, and perhaps a more important reason than any of these given, as to why this policy should not be adopted in present circumstances is that, if this policy is pursued by this Department or any other Department of the Government, it means that the Government are deliberately using their machinery to force down the wages of the lowest paid workers in the Government service, at the same time, as the Ministry well know, that the cost of living of these people is going up. The operations of the Budget, as well as other resolutions recently passed by this House, have put up the price of tea, sugar, flour, bread, and butter, articles which are consumed by people such as those employed on work of this kind.

Comment on this

I hope the Deputy is not forgetting tobacco.

Comment on this

I voted for the tax on tobacco because I look upon it as a semi-luxury. In any case, Deputy Dillon heard from these benches the reason why we voted for a tax of that kind. We are not as foolish as the Deputy. We believe that money must be found from some source for the maintenance of the existing social services. The Deputy can have a present, for the second time, of the admission that I voted with my eyes open for the tax on tobacco in existing circumstances, and he can make as much political capital as he likes in the country and in my constituency out of that matter. However, I would ask the Minister to realise that it is a wrong thing, at a time when the cost of living has gone up, to bring forward proposals of this kind for reducing the wages of workers employed on forestry schemes.

I am led to believe that this secret Wages Advisory Committee arrives at its conclusions or recommendations in regard to wages on information supplied as to the agricultural rates prevailing in those areas. I understand they get somebody to furnish them with particulars as to the wages paid by representative farmers in the areas where the work is being carried out. I have seen evidence in the case I refer to where they were supplied with wrong information. It was admitted that wrong information was supplied and, therefore, the decision of the Committee was based on wrong information I suggest that the same thing may possible apply in this case.

Comment on this

By way of information, I should like to know if we are discussing all the Minister's Estimates together.

Comment on this

I am deliberately dealing with the one issue.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I understand that the wages referred to by the Deputy were paid in connection with afforestation. The Vote before us is a Vote for Lands. There is a separate Vote for Forestry.

Comment on this

I suggest that this is a matter of policy to be raised on the Vote for the Minister's salary.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not know whether the House desires to debate the two votes together.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is a motion to refer the third Estimate back. Nos. 1 and 2 could be discussed together.

Comment on this

We would prefer to take them separately.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

General policy is usually discussed on the Vote which includes the Minister's salary. The purpose of the motion to refer back is to enable the policy of the Land Commission to be discussed.

Comment on this

I put the motion down because his salary comes under that sub-head. This is a matter of policy and Deputy Dillon ought to know that that is the only way it can be raised in this House. When the Deputy interrupted me, I was referring to what I believed to be the procedure adopted by the Wages Advisory Committee. I want to say that I am personally aware that many farmers, if not all the farmers in my constituency, pay higher wages than those paid in this particular case. It would be most unusual in my constituency for any farmer employing agricultural labourers causually, for instance for the pulling of beet, at a lower wage than 4/- per day. In addition to that, I can give the names of representative farmers who give these men their dinner as well as paying them the 4/- per day. Consequently, I think there is no ground whatever for the recommendation or decision of the Wages Advisory Committee in this case.

I hope the Minister will take further steps to find out the facts regarding the existing rates of wages paid to agricultural labourers by representative farmers in the county concerned. I should like to point out to the Minister that three miles away from the very place where this work is being carried on other men, doing the same class of work, have been and are still being paid at the rate of 28/- per week. There is no case which could be cited where a rate so low as in this case has been put into operation. The county council for the county concerned pay their road workers 30/- per week, and that has always been taken as the general standard for work of this kind. The building contractors who are employed in erecting houses for the Offaly Board of Health are obliged by the terms of their contract to pay a minimum rate of 30/- per week and the Irish and General Transport Workers' Union have a dispute on demanding a payment of 36/- instead of 30/- per week. I may say, for the Minister's information, that the rate paid in North Tipperary is 35/- per week and in the adjoining County of Leix it is 38/- per week.

Comment on this

It is £2 per week in Tipperary.

Comment on this

I am obliged to the Deputy for his information. I was informed that it was 35/-. I cannot believe that the Minister himself is in favour of forcing down wages under present circumstances, and I must confess that I know of no case where the Minister himself has been a party to that policy at any time. I appeal to the Minister now to reconsider this whole question and, without prejudice, say that he is prepared to pay these workers, in this isolated case, at the rate normally and previously prevailing, and leave the matter open until the report on the general revision of these cases comes before the Department for their decision. I believe that their final report is being prejudiced by the rate of wages paid in this particular case, and I appeal to the Minister to exercise his personal influence, and to exercise his authority, which I believe he has, to rule favourably on this particular case.

I saw where the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs delivered a speech on a recent occasion at Boyle in the County Roscommon, and where, apparently under pressure from his own people, he made the statement that the present rates of wages and salaries paid by the Government in this country could not be carried by an agricultural country such as this. I was wondering what class of worker the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs had in mind when he made that statement, and I was wondering, in that connection, what was his responsibility for the recent decision of the Government to pay a salary of £2,000 a year, free of income tax, and with other perquisites, to the chairman of the Sugar Manufacturing Company and a salary of £3,850, also with perquisites, to the managing director of the same company. Surely, the ratepayers and the farmers of the country will have to bear that. I have nothing to say against the individuals concerned. I dare say that they are experts and the best that could be found in any country for their particular job, but the civil servant who was taken out of the Department of Agriculture had his salary doubled at the same time when these ordinary workers, to whom I am referring, have had their wages reduced. If it is good policy to pay these increased salaries to the chairman and managing director of the Sugar Manufacturing Company, I suggest that the Minister will not disagree with me when I say that the same policy should be applied in the case of the lowest paid workers in the Government service.

I do not want to delay the general discussion on the other questions that will naturally come up for consideration on a Vote of this kind. I do not think it should be necessary for me to use any further arguments or to give any further figures in order to try to convince the Minister that this case should be reconsidered for the purpose and object of giving the men who have been working or who still work on this small forestry scheme the same consideration in regard to wages as has been given in all the other cases to all the other men employed in other parts of the country on the same class of work. I want to make it clear also that, so far as the general administration of this Department is concerned, I have no reason to complain. Deputies from these benches will raise other matters under the various sub-heads, I am sure, but I think that the issue raised by the Minister, in answer to my question on the 7th May last, was sufficiently serious to justify me, on behalf of the members of this Party, in asking the Minister. if necessary, to take back this Vote for the purpose of favourably reviewing the decision announced in the reply then given.

Comment on this

There are two matters of administration, Sir, which appear to be a settled policy of the Land Commission Department at the present time, to which I want to draw attention and with which I am in entire disagreement. One is with regard to the size of holding which is considered to be an economic holding at the present time. Some years ago, when agriculture was prosperous and when, even before depression set in either here or in any other place all over the world, and before we had an economic war on, it was considered that any holding under £15 valuation was an uneconomic holding. If a holding of a valuation of £15 was considered to be an uneconomic holding when agriculture was in a good and sound position and was paying its way, what are we to think of a holding of £10 valuation to-day? That is what we have at the present time. We have the Land Commission dividing the land in County Roscommon, where I live, and the valuation of each holding there is about £10. That is considered to be an economic holding and sufficient to enable a man to live in comfort and bring up his family on. I do not agree with that at all. I do not think there is any reason for assuming that what was an economic holding three, four, or ten years ago is to-day an economic holding. Surely, the Minister for Lands is convinced now that agriculture is not able to pay its way. Agriculture at the present moment is living upon a dole, and it is a case of feeding the dog with his own tail, and that is bound to come to an end. Surely the Minister and the Government know that. How the Land Commission can consider that under the altered circumstances or under any circumstances, a holding of £10 valuation is now an economic holding, is more than I can understand. We have farms of land being broken up wholesale and divided up into holdings of £10 valuation. The State is building houses and stables on such holdings, and a man is expected to be able to occupy that holding and bring up a family and support them in comfort on such a holding.

Comment on this

What would be the average acreage?

Comment on this

It depends on the valuation. It varies according to the quality of the land. For instance, in my own locality, at a place called Oran, it is about 9 acres for a £10 valuation. In other places it would be, perhaps, 15 acres, according to the quality of the land.

There is another matter to which I wish to draw attention. I want to take the Land Commission to task for the manner in which they are treating local authorities with regard to tenants of labourers' cottages. Some of these tenants in labourers' cottages will, I have no doubt, make excellent farmers if you give them the opportunity, but the Land Commission is giving them land at present and making farmers of them, when it knows, or ought to know, that once those people come into possession of land to any extent, they are immediately ineligible for occupation of labourers' cottages. If the law were to be carried out, boards of health would be obliged to evict all those people.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. P. Hogan (Clare) Labour Party

There would not be many to evict.

Comment on this

There would be quite a number in my county. In the 1927 Act, that difficulty was foreseen and a clause was inserted whereby the Land Commission can buy those cottages from the local authority, pay them whatever valuation is fixed, and make these people tenant farmers, if you like. In Roscommon, in my immediate vicinity, no fewer than eight of these cottiers have been given land lately. We have a number of applications for these houses, and we want to build the cottages very badly. The Land Commission are holding back and will not do anything with regard to these houses. If they came to the assistance of the local authorities by making an allowance for these houses, it would enable us to build further houses for the labourers who require them.

I drew attention to this matter when the Local Government Vote was going through some time ago. I think some pressure ought to be brought to bear on the Land Commission to see that they do their duty in this respect. The tenants themselves are in a very insecure position. They are the tenants of the local authority, in the first instance, and they are irregular tenants once they become owners of land. If the Land Commission would carry out the provisions of this section in the 1927 Land Act, it would enable local authorities to go ahead with the work of building cottages which are very much needed. There is no use in one Government Department shouting about housing while some other Department holds it up.

The figures given by the Minister with regard to the collection of annuities were very interesting, but I am afraid that the Minister scarcely realises the very heavy responsibilities he has at present in being the Government agent for the carrying out of certain very distasteful duties in the country. In view of the hopes expressed by the Minister with regard to the collection of the annuities, it is rather interesting to note that, while he expresses the hope that the collection of the land annuities will improve, and says that, as a matter of fact, it is steadily improving, we have figures in Iris Oifigiúil of June 4th, with regard to certain annuities that have been paid. From 1st April, 1934, to 1st June, 1934, there was paid in under a certain heading a sum of £88,720; for the same period this year the amount paid in was £38,774, or a drop of £59,946. Those figures are taken from Iris Oifigiúil of two days ago. They are very interesting figures and I am afraid they do not bear out the hopes expressed by the Minister with regard to an improvement in collection of land annuities.

The Minister told us that he has collected a sum of £2,771,890, leaving a balance outstanding from 31st March of £880,690. In reply to a question which I put down on 21st March, 1935, asking for particulars with regard to the Annuities Fund and the sums credited to that Fund, both from the collection of land annuities and withdrawals from the Guarantee Fund, I got the following figure: from 31/7/33 to 31/1/34 and on to 31/1/35, there was collected a sum of £1,869,904. There was, however, in the Suspense Account, as I think it was called at the time, on 30th March, 1933, after the passing of the 1933 Act, a sum of practically £3,000,000, which, of course, the Government duly collared for the Exchequer. Further, there were transfers from the Guarantee Fund, on foot of unpaid annuities. On 31/1/34, £337,000 were transferred from the Guarantee Fund to the Annuities Fund; on 31/7/34, £496,000; and on 31/1/35, £517,000. There was an increase all the time. These sums were sums that were deducted from the grants due to local authorities and, all together, we find that although the amount collected to date, according to the Minister to-day, was only some £2,771,000 odd, the Exchequer has benefited from the annuities by the extent of £7,100,750. They have benefited, firstly, from the £2,900,000 which they got from the Suspense Account and, secondly, from the grants withheld from local authorities.

They claim credit also, of course, for doing a very generous act towards local authorities by making a payment of £1,403,371 into the Guarantee Fund on 31st July, 1933. There is no credit due to the Land Commission or the Government for doing that. It was money which ordinarily would have gone into the coffers of the local authorities. It was money which it was computed at the time would arise on the funded arrears. Notwithstanding the fact that the Government has benefited to the extent of over £7,000,000 from this Fund, we find that the collection of annuities is being carried out all over the country by the Land Commission and the Government authorities with great harshness, and, so far as we can see at least, without any enquiry into the condition of the people who are supposed to owe this money. I remember hearing it stated from this side of the House when the present Government were in opposition and variously stated by the President in election speeches, that one of the things the Government were going to do when they came into power was to enquire into certain estates which were bought up at an enhanced price, and annuities fixed much above the value of the land, and see to what extent they could remedy that state of affairs. I want to know from the Minister what inquiries have been made in that respect, and if it is not possible, and very probable, that some of these people whose stock are being seized to-day and who are being driven to the verge of ruin are the people whom the President endeavoured to convince the country he had in mind when he made those statements.

The present position with regard to the collection of the annuities in the country is not satisfactory. It is very unsatisfactory. Nobody on this side or any other side of the House wants to condone violence or resistance to what is, for the time being, the law of the land. I think that the Land Commission has a very heavy responsibility in this matter, and that they certainly ought to make some inquiry and very seriously consider what is going to be the net result of all this. There is one thing that this country need not go anywhere to learn, and that is that violence and physical force have been the result of injustice. It does not matter what the law of the land is, it does not matter what the people's obligations are towards their own Government, you will find people who will always meet injustice with violence. Even though we do not condone that, we can very well understand it, when a man finds his very livelihood being taken from him for a debt which is undoubtedly being paid to two people. We have, for instance, the statement made by Mr. Thomas the other day with regard to his collection. The President, here in the House, admitted that Britain was collecting those annuities. It is certainly an injustice to ask any man to pay the one debt twice. Until this injustice is removed or met in some way—and I say the responsibility in this matter rests largely on the Land Commission as the agent of the Government—I am afraid you will possibly have opposition of a type that people do not wish to see in this country. It is a sorry sight at this hour of the day to see the stock belonging to people who have worked hard on farms, people who have been born on them, being brought in, and not sold but given away. I am afraid that when the history of the present period is being written, when we are all dead and gone, it certainly will not cast any credit on the present Government.

I think that there is one thing due to this country from the Land Commission, and I would say also from Local Government, and it is that in this matter of the collection of land annuities the reactions of the uncollected annuities are so great on local authorities that there ought to be some consultation between, say, the Land Commission and Local Government to see that local authorities are put in possession of the proper figures, so that they will know where they are when they are drafting their estimates and striking their rates. The Minister for Lands told us to-day that since 31st March a sum of £150,000 has been collected from land annuities. That may be a source of some solace to the Minister for Finance, but it is none whatever to the local authorities. They did not get it. It is held up until next February or March, or till some other time. I think, in fairness to local administration, that the Government ought to be able to devise some means whereby credit will be given to local authorities for the sums of money which come in and which originally have been denied them. This is a matter which concerns everybody, no matter what politics he has or what Party he belongs to. If the local authorities fail because the Land Commission will not do its job, or is not able to do its job, or is not doing its job properly, the whole country is going to suffer. I think that some attempt ought to be made, even at this hour of the day, to meet the situation which exists with regard to local authorities and the withholding of grants.

There is no use in thinking that while the present condition of affairs exists you are going to have an improvement in the collection of land annuities. In previous days I remember when certain officials of the Land Commission held the view that if they seized people's stock for the year's annuities they took away those people's stock-in-trade and way of living, and it simply gave them no chance whatever of collecting next year's annuities. I am afraid there has been a departure from that. I am afraid that to some extent—to a very large extent in some parts of the country— there is victimisation. I should like to know if live stock and furniture are being seized for one half-year's instalment in some cases, while in other cases people who owe two, three or four instalments are not bothered about it at all. Surely if a Government Department like the Land Commission sets out to discriminate between people in this way, and I am told they have done so, it has come to a very poor time of day.

With regard to the Government's migration policy, I hope it will be a success, but in expressing that hope I have a certain amount of fear. However, as far as I am concerned, I wish them good luck in it, but it will take a lot of courage, a lot of time, and I am afraid a lot of money to make it a success of such a kind as is apparently contemplated by the Government. Another matter which the Minister mentioned was that he does not think it wise for the Government to proceed with vesting the land in the new tenants for at least six or seven years. I think I remember very fierce onslaughts being made on the late Government from this side of the House about the non-vesting of land for anything like six or seven years. After all, if you are going to give a tenant the interest which he ought to have in his holding, you ought to fund it for him. The Minister made a statement in that respect which I do not understand. He said that, although the holding would not be vested, the payments could be credited towards the tenant. I wonder what exactly does that mean? Does it mean that if a man gets a holding of land from the Land Commission, and if it is not vested for six or seven years, eventually when it is vested the payments made during those years will be put to his credit with regard to repayment of the loan? I should like to have that matter cleared up. If that is not so, I should like to know what the Minister means. If it is so, I should like to know what machinery he has for dealing with such a matter as that.

Comment on this

In introducing this Estimate I could see that the Minister was very anxious as regards the giving of land to the migrants from the Irish-speaking areas of the Gaeltacht. Deputy Brennan has stated that he wishes that policy every success. So do I, but I also wish to point out to the Minister that in those areas where land is to be divided up he should give primary consideration and first preference to the tenants or their descendants who have been evicted out of their lands during the land war in this country. We have a great number of those people in the country. Thousands of them were thrown on the roadside during the land agitation and many of them had to take the emigrant ship and seek a living in foreign countries. Now when we have our own Government those people should get first consideration. The Government should put back the wounded soldiers of the land war, or their descendants, on the lands their people formerly occupied. I hope the Minister will give that suggestion serious consideration. We have a lot of derelict farms that are white elephants to the Land Commission. I should like to know what the Minister intends to do with these farms, which are now in an uncultivated state. There are thousands of unemployed drawing unemployment assistance benefit, and great numbers of these people could be employed to great advantage if they got plots on the derelict farms to till and so enable them to raise the necessaries of life, growing potatoes and other vegetables.

Comment on this

They would be well employed doing a little work of that sort on the derelict farms instead of sitting down from morning till night contemplating mischief and devilment. It is a well known fact that the devil tempts the idle. As regards the seizing of cattle from defaulting land annuitants, it is painful to see the sheriff's officers going round seizing cattle, depriving farmers of their means of livelihood. I should like to have some commission set up to investigate those cases and, where farmers are not in a position to pay, they should be assisted by the Government to restock their farms. Instead of seizing their cattle, that is the policy that should be adopted, and in that way a lot of employment would be given. I hope the Minister will give my remarks serious consideration, particularly with regard to the redistribution of lands and the breaking up of estates. I would be very much interested to see the evicted tenants, the remnants of them, and their descendants, put back on the homesteads of their ancestors. We must remember that they fought one of the greatest wars ever fought in this country against landlordism and tyranny. Now when we have a national Government, the least compensation the descendants of those people should get is to reinstate them in the homes of their forefathers.

Comment on this

Would it not make a cat sick to watch Deputy Kent getting up here and talking about the evicted tenants, the soldiers of the land war, when in his own constituency, at the present time, the stock and other property of his own neighbours are being taken out at the orders of the Minister whom the Deputy has been addressing and sold for a tithe of their value? His neighbours are being reduced to destitution and misery of a kind that was never inflicted upon the Irish people by Clanricarde or Barrymore or any other landlord, and Deputy Kent has not the courage or the manliness to say one word in their defence. He gets up here rambling about the setting up of a commission to enquire into the capacity of the people to pay. Why has he not got the courage to speak for the man whose cattle were taken from his own neighbourhood, brought into Fermoy and sold there, 87 of them for £90, to a Government agent? The same cattle were brought to Belfast and sold there by the agent for £725 and the money was put into the Government agent's pocket. Has Deputy Kent anything to say about that? Would it not be better for him to talk about the oppression carried on throughout the country by Fianna Fáil than to be rambling about what happened in 1885? What happened in 1885 was met by a united people and overcome. What is being done to-day to the sons of those farmers by the Fianna Fáil Party could be overcome too if gentlemen like Deputy Kent would only put their shoulders to the wheel and make it clear to the Government that they were not prepared to stand for activities of that kind.

Here we have the Deputy rambling about a commission of enquiry. Does it need a commission of enquiry to prove the fact that it is legalised robbery on the part of the Minister for Lands to take the cattle belonging to any farmer in Cork and sell them for less than £1 apiece and line the pockets of his own bailiffs at the fairs and markets of Belfast? These men are being robbed under the shadow and the cloak of legality by the Minister for Lands. I say that every Deputy of the Fianna Fáil Party who stands for highway robbery of that kind is a disgrace to his country and is deserving of the censure of every decent man. I have heard Fianna Fáil Deputies laughing at the description of the seizures going on in Cork. I have heard them laughing when scenes were being described where farmers tried to buy their cattle back. Cattle were bid for and they were knocked down, but the farmers were obliged to say "We could not raise the money" and the cattle were then sold to an agent for £1 or 30/- a head, brought to Belfast and there sold for £7 10s. 0d. to £10 apiece. Deputy Kent will go rambling here once a month telling us that the failure to pay the land annuities is due to a conspiracy by the Imperialists. Would it not make a cat sick to hear hypocrisy of that kind and to hear tub-thumping orations about the glorious days that are gone? God help this country that it has not in it now men of the same type as were in it 50 years ago. If we had, that kind of conduct would not be going on, and any Government that would attempt it would not survive six months, not to mind three years.

Is it by the Minister's authority or with his approval that the bailiffs or agents are taking cattle from the farmers around Fermoy, selling 79 of them for £90, then taking them to Belfast and selling them there for £725? I want to ask the Minister does he stand for legalised robbery of that kind? That is only one case, but there are many others of exactly the same kind. I do not care whether a farmer or an agricultural representative in this House is sitting on the Labour, the Fianna Fáil or any other Benches— does he stand for robbery of that kind? —because it is robbery. Does he imagine Clanricarde or Barrymore in their worst days, when they were turning people out on the side of the road, were treating their tenants with any greater savagery or any greater inhumanity than Senator Connolly is treating the farmers of this country at the present time?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy means the Minister for Lands.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon, the Minister for Lands. Deputies have before them conclusive evidence that it is not a question of any of these men rightly or wrongly withholding payment out of any sense of loyalty to their neighbours; but it is a case of men who literally are unable to raise the money to pay the annuities.

I say here with the fullest sense of responsibility that never during the whole period of the land war, and taking the most vindictive landlord that ever appeared in this country, has such tyranny and barbarity been practised on the small farmers of this country as has been practised by the Minister for Lands to-day. In itself, the thing is evil. In itself, the thing is wrong, but it has inherent in it a danger which ought to be present to the minds of anybody who was born in rural Ireland. I do not expect the Minister for Lands to understand this, for he knows nothing of rural conditions in this country. He is completely out of sympathy with the people who live on the land. He cannot realise that there was a land war in this country, that there was a great agrarian movement stirred up which was directed against the British Government. So far as it was directed against the British Government it was so much to the good, for that Government was acting against the interests of the Irish people. But to-day there is imminent danger of reviving the spirit of a similar movement and directing it against the national Government elected by the majority of the people of this country. So far as that spirit may be evoked and roused with a view of bringing pressure to bear against the Government elected by the majority of the Irish people, it would be an unqualified evil.

There is no use closing our eyes to the fact that anyone who has been brought up in the spirit of the Land League atmosphere or in the movement to smash the landlords, knows perfectly well that if the Minister for Lands takes up the methods and adopts the role of the evicting landlord in any area in this country, that Land League spirit is going to be revived, and you are going to have a desperate fight to the finish between the victimised farmers and the Government elected by the majority of the Irish people. To my mind, no greater evil could be brought upon the people of the country than that the splendid movement which reaped so much for the Irish people should be revived in a fresh form to-day, because it would be associated in the minds of the people with a movement ending up in the establishment of anarchy. Nobody but a fool is going to set out to reduce thousands of farmers in rural Ireland to destitution without knowing that he is going to bring down upon his back the same spirit which faced the British authorities and the landlords when it was necessary to do so.

I appeal to the Government now to stop this wholesale victimisation of the agricultural community. Where the people fail to pay their annuities let the Government proceed by ordinary process of law, let them get writs against the farmers in the courts, and proceed to collect the annuities by legalised process. Let them put an end finally to the system of sending out the sheriffs and the bailiffs to people who are unable to feed their families. I read in this House some time ago a case where a farmer in the President's own constituency was brought before the local courts in Clare; a civil bill had been issued against him for rates. That man was a small tenant purchaser in rural Ireland and I have no doubt that under the Land Commission system a warrant would issue against that man for his land annuities, and whatever cattle he may have would have been seized. We would have been told that that man was acting as part of a conspiracy to withhold the collection of land annuities and rates. That would be said by men without knowing the local conditions. I am asking the Government to issue civil bills in the old form and give the farmers an opportunity of putting their cases in court. Here is the case as it came before the Ennis District Court: "John Clune, Ballymarkham, Quin, was sued for non-payment of £10 14s. 10d. rates. He said that he and his eight in family were actually starving. He had a loan of a cow from a neighbour for some time but even that had now gone back. He had not eaten a bit of meat for the past two years, and his children had to walk to school every morning after eating dry bread at their breakfast. The rate collector said there was no doubt about it the man was actually starving, the price of cattle being reduced to a couple of pounds has hit them very much. They had only young cattle and had to sell them to feed their children. They had no money then to replace the stock."

Now, that is one case that has come into court. You are asking the officials of the Land Commission and this House to go to the house of people of that kind and seize anything which they have got and sell it. When these facts are brought to the attention of members of this House they jeer and sneer at the despised farmers and charge them with conspiracy to withhold the collection of the land annuities. Are the Fianna Fáil Party gone mad or have the members of the Fianna Fáil Party lost all sense of decency and responsibility? I do not want them, if they had been publicly equal to it, to get up here and make the case in the Dáil for these farmers, but I want them to go to their own Ministers and tell them that these are the things that are happening in the country and tell them that something has got to be done by way of relieving the strain on the people. Unless they take action like that I warn these Deputies and I warn Ministers that that situation will wind up in anarchy and that it will develop into war. I say such a development would be nothing less than a disaster of great magnitude.

It devolves upon every public man in this country to exercise all the influence he has got with every individual supporter whom he can reach and warn him of the dangers of violent action against the Government elected by the majority of the people and warn him against attempting Land League action against that Government. But whatever each of us may like to do with our individual supporters we are powerless unless the members of the Fianna Fáil Government can persuade Ministers of the facts of the situation. We cannot make the Minister believe what the real situation is but he will believe his own colleagues, and if the Fianna Fáil Deputies bring pressure to bear on him and bring him to realise the truth of the situation that exists then there is not the slightest danger of disorder accruing in the country. I say that because I know those people as the Deputies on the other side of the House know them. They are anxious to pay their annuities as they always paid them. Not alone are they anxious to meet their obligations and pay their annuities but they have a sentimental obligation to honour the bond that their fathers and their grandfathers entered into. They will pay every penny of what is due. But if you drive them into poverty, starvation and destitution you have to face the fact that no matter what I say, and no matter what you say, the neighbours of these men will rally round them. If one individual is to be victimised every decent man will get up and say, "Injustice of that kind will not pass without protest and if the Government want to destroy that man, then we will all be destroyed together." I ask Deputies on the opposite side to face the facts. Let them ask themselves do they stand for the taking of 78 cattle from two or three farmers, selling them at the sheriff's sale in Fermoy, for £90 and leaving them to be sold at a subsequent sale in Belfast for £725? Do Deputies stand for robbery of that kind? Then if you do not, go to your own Minister and make him mend his hand.

There is another aspect which I do not intend to raise on this Vote. It is a matter that could be more appropriately raised on the Attorney-General's Department or on the Vote for Law Charges. Leaving out the question of legality and facing it only as an issue of morality and common Christianity, ask yourselves if any human being can be expected to endure treatment of that kind in silence? Ask yourselves if you would wish that to be done to any of your own neighbours? Ask yourselves is it not a strange thing with that happening almost at Deputy Kent's door that he would not have the courage to come here and warn the Government that that sort of thing has got to stop and that he was going to do everything in his power to put an end to it?

I want to ask the Minister another categorical question: Does the Minister for Lands stand for the statement made by the Minister for Defence during the week-end in which he said that he would warn the tenant purchasers of this country that if they did not use their land in the way he thought they ought to, the Government would take the land from them and give it to somebody else?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is responsible for the administration of his own Department and not for the pronouncements of any other Minister.

Comment on this

I am just asking him the question: does he make himself responsible for that? If he says: "The Minister for Defence is only an irreresponsible ass and I do not take any responsibility for what he says," that finishes that, and I say no more about it. He has not said that. I take it that the Minister for Defence, speaking on an occasion of that kind and with full knowledge of what he was saying, had consulted the responsible Minister for Lands. The Chair will remember that for a long time the Minister for Defence was Acting-Minister for Lands and is, no doubt, conversant with the policy which dominates that Department. Does the Minister stand for that policy? If he does, do Deputies behind him stand for the doctrine that if a neighbour differs from them as to the most advantageous method of conducting the agricultural industry on their holding, the Minister for Lands is entitled to come in and take the holding off them and give it to somebody else? Or does he stand for the traditional view that obtained in this country heretofore, that fixity of tenure was an essential part of the new Irish land tenure system?

I remember when the Land Bill of 1933 was passing through the House I went so far as to say on the Second Reading of that Bill that it meant the end of fixity of tenure in this country. I remember the Minister for Defence getting hysterical at such a suggestion being made. I remember Fianna Fáil Deputies saying that I was concerned for nothing but to make cheap political propaganda out of a trivial section which was there only for administrative purposes. But now we discover that, having deluded this House into vesting powers of compulsory acquisition of land purchased under previous Land Acts, without any obligation to provide the tenant with an equally suitable holding, on the pretext that it was merely an administrative necessity to simplify the routine work of the Department, the Acting-Minister for Lands, who piloted the 1933 Act through this House, announces that he is going to use that power to strip any man in this country, who does not agree with that cracked agricultural policy of Fianna Fáil, of his land and to evict him and give the land to a covetous neighbour.

I will give the Minister a challenge. I hold land bought under the Land Commission. I would not be seen dead carrying out in detail the present Government's agricultural policy on my land. I would blush for shame to admit that I converted one acre, or one rood, or one perch of it to wheat growing, or to beet growing, or any other of the tomfoolery that masquerades as the Fianna Fáil agricultural policy, and I dare you to come down and take an acre off me. I speak for hundreds and thousands of farmers in this country.

Comment on this

What are you doing?

Comment on this

Let me say this: if under that section the Government attempt to take the land off anybody I will be prepared to go and stand at his gate and contest their ability to do it. We fought for fixity of tenure in this country, and I do not believe there is a single voter in the whole of Saorstát Eireann who ever voted in Fianna Fáil to take that fixity of tenure from us. If you do it, you do it by fraud and false pretences. That principle has been defended before and it will be defended again. So far as I am concerned, let the Minister for Defence come down and take the land off any man who has raised his family upon it and is trying to get a decent livelihood out of it, and see what will happen. Let the Minister have the courage to say: Does he stand for what the Minister for Defence said or does he not? I prefer to think he does not.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister for Lands is not answerable for the speeches of other Ministers. The speeches made in the current by-election campaigns might, I submit, be answered on the hustings.

Comment on this

I quite agree that speeches made by the rank and file of the Party are not appropriate for discussion here, but a Minister of State is a very different person. I desire to bring my observation strictly within the rules of order, and so I put it to the Minister for Lands: Is it the policy of the Minister for Lands on this Estimate, which contains the money sequestered for his salary, to take land off anybody who is not prepared to cultivate it in accordance with the Fianna Fáil agricultural policy and to give it to somebody else who is prepared to do it?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

In asking that question the Deputy is quite in order; but in issuing a challenge to the Minister for Defence on the Vote of the Minister for Lands I submit he was not in order.

Comment on this

I am prepared to conform to that. If, in the heat of the moment, I was carried outside the scope of order, I desire to express my regret. The question which I have now put to the Minister is the categorical inquiry which I adumbrated at the beginning of my observations. In introducing the Estimate, the Minister dwelt at some length on the distribution of land by the Department of Lands in the financial year 1934-35. These figures were not quite easy to understand. I think he said that in that period he distributed over 100,000 acres of land. That, I take it, includes the land given to persons who already had holdings, to enlarge their holdings, and land given to new tenants, given to persons who did not hold any land heretofore under the Land Commission. I think the Minister would help us greatly if, instead of referring to the average distribution of land over the ten-years period, he would give us the actual distribution of land on the same basis as the 100,000-acre figure for the years since 1924-25; just as he did in his Parliamentary answer of 13th February, 1935, as reported in column 1833, Volume 54 (No. 6) of the Official Reports, where he set out the amount of land which was distributed in each county to persons who were provided by the Land Commission with new agricultural holdings as distinct from the enlargement of existing holdings for the relief of congestion and from the ordinary rearrangement of tenanted land.

I should like to ask the Minister did his statement to-day apply to the distribution of land as to new agricultural holdings, plus enlargement of existing holdings, plus land distributed for the relief of congestion and the rearrangement of existing tenanted land; or did his figures apply only or purport to apply to new holdings? If his figures applied to the first category which I have suggested, would he be good enough to give us the total distribution of land for each category in each year from 1925 to 1935, either by way of memorandum or in his concluding observations on this Estimate? I think it is right to draw the attention of the House to the fact that, when the Minister is rejoicing in his achievment in that distribution of land, we all remember that the great object of Fianna Fáil was to restore the people to the land. Now, what are the facts? The facts, as revealed by the Minister's own Parliamentary reply, to which I have just referred, are that, in the first three years of Fianna Fáil's administration, they distributed less land than Cumann na nGaedheal distributed in any year since Cumann na nGaedheal came into office.

Comment on this

That is extraordinary.

Comment on this

Well, here are the figures. The following are the figures for new holdings created by the Department of Lands in each of the years from 1925 to 1931, inclusive, and it must be remembered that these are new holdings; that they do not contain a lot of other distribution of lands that was in hands by the Department. These are the figures for the new holdings:—

1925 | 42,726 acres

1926 | 22,835 ,,

1927 | 31,643 ,,

1928 | 31,480 ,,

1929 | 23,276 ,,

1930 | 27,553 ,,

1931 | 23,122 ,,

Now, these figures relate to the calendar year. I will ask Deputies to note that, because the Christian Government came into office in January, 1932. When they landed, the first year of Christianity produced 18,434 acres; the second year of Christianity produced 15,085 acres; and the third year of Christianity produced 14,396 acres. So that, compared with the three first years of the Christian Government, the Pagan Government was able to outshine them all along the line. Now, so far as individuals accommodated with these new holdings are concerned, let us compare the records of the Christian Government with the Pagan Government. The Pagans, in 1926, put 684 new families on the land. In 1927, the Pagans put 864 new families on the land; in 1928, they put 982 new families on the land; in 1929, they settled 711; and in 1930 the number of new families put on the land by the Pagan Government was 1,013.

Comment on this

All Pagans?

Comment on this

No, Sir, the practice of putting one's political followers on the land, to the exclusion of everybody else, started with the advent of the Christian Government in 1932. To continue, however; in 1931, 614 new families were put on the land. Now we come to 1932. In 1932, the Christians arrived and the number of new families put on the land dropped to 456. In 1933, the Christian Government put 517 persons on to 15,000 acres of land, and in 1934 they put 485 persons on new holdings.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy give us the figures for 1926 again?

Comment on this

Can he give us any indication as to the size of the holdings?

Comment on this

Now, let us not follow it too closely.

Comment on this

It would be very advisable for that.

Comment on this

I gave the House the total acreage for each year and the total number of persons put on the land for each year. My object in quoting these figures is to show that, when figures are being quoted for a particular purpose, credit should not be withheld from anybody, and the facts should not be obscured. If we want to find averages and so forth, let us not, when striking an average, only bring into the calculation the three years of Fianna Fáil administration which, as I have shown, according to these figures, were very much worse than the years while their predecessors were in office. The Minister's comparison was made for the very obvious purpose of reflecting on the Minister's predecessors, although it was suggested that it was made for no other purpose than to pay a tribute to the zeal and efficiency of the Land Commission officials. The comparison, however, was made without comment. If there is to be a comparison made, let it be an honest comparison, and let the figures for each year be given on the same basis. When we get them we will be able to discuss the figures laid before us somewhat more intelligently.

There is one last matter to which I should like to refer. It has been ruled that this is the appropriate moment to raise the question of the rates of wages paid on the forestry schemes. I understand that the rate of wages is 22/- a week.

Comment on this

That is only in one place.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is agreed that this aspect of the debate will not be resumed on the Forestry Vote?

Comment on this

I am sure, Sir, that you will deal with that when it arises, but I submit, Sir, with all respect, that you decided that this would be an appropriate place for the discussion of this matter of the rates of wages paid on forestry schemes, and I have no doubt that, if anybody attempts to raise it later on, you, Sir, with your usual impartiality and prudence, will direct them from the error of their ways. Deputy Davin worked himself up into a passion about the 22/- per week paid in Offaly. I do not blame Deputy Davin for working himself up into a pother about it. But does Deputy Davin know that in County Wexford, the Minister for Agriculture's own county, they are paying 18/- a week? Does he know that all over this country agricultural wages have been steadily beaten down until, I venture to say, 24/- a week would be a high figure to take as the wages paid generally? I venture to say that in some counties, such as, for instance, Wexford, Laoighis or Offaly, he would find that a wage of more than 24/- would be the exception rather than the rule.

Comment on this

For casual labourers.

Comment on this

For any kind of labour, and Deputy Davin knows it well.

Comment on this

For agricultural work.

Comment on this

For casual work.

Comment on this

I do not mind whether they are casual or permanent workers. Take a man who is working 12 or 14 hours a day, as we all know they have to work at this time of the year in the country, such a man, at the present time, would consider himself lucky to get 24/- a week. I know of cases where they are getting 20/- net and no perquisites. I know of other cases where they are getting 18/- and milk, and I know of other cases where they are getting 16/-, with milk and potatoes. These cases have come under my personal notice. I say that any man who is working eight hours a day, not to speak of 14 hours a day, for 16/- a week, with milk and potatoes, is very little better than a slave, and any country which allows such a state of affairs to exist——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy referring to the Land Commission?

Comment on this

Well, Sir, these are the agricultural wages which are taken as the foot-rule by which the Land Commission measure the wages they are going to pay. Deputy Davin protested that 22/- a week was a monstrous wage, inasmuch as it was lower than the agricultural wage. Whether it is lower or higher, I say that it is a public scandal that anybody, who can afford to pay more, would pay that wage. If I knew of anybody in this country who would pay 16/- a week and who had in his pocket money over and above what was needed for his wife and family and withheld it from the labourer, I believe that such a man is guilty not only of lack of charity but of a gross violation of the elementary principles of justice.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not believe what he is saying.

Comment on this

The insolent imbecilities of certain Deputies will not deter me from exposing this.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

The Deputy does not believe a word of what he is saying.

Comment on this

Sir, is it Parliamentary to describe a Deputy of this House as a cheap fraud?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No, it is not permissible.

Comment on this

Very well, Sir, I shall then refrain from describing Deputy Murphy as a cheap demagogic fraud.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

And insult from the Deputy would be a compliment coming from the source it comes from.

Comment on this

I want to point out to Deputy Davin that the agricultural situation in this country is justifying farmers in paying as low as 16/- a week. I want to justify it by the argument that they have not literally got the money to pay any more and that there is no other argument that could justify it. I have argued repeatedly in this House, in the presence of Deputy Davin and his colleagues, that it is a gross injustice that, when the beet scheme was inaugurated, the men working inside the factory would get a trades union wage while the same was being denied to the men working outside the factory. I pointed out that if we fix the wage of a man working in a factory at £2 a week for a 48-hour week, we are not breaking our hearts. Making all due allowance for the legitimate difference that might be made between a factory operative who is working inside in somewhat more unhealthy surroundings that his fellow-labourer on the land, the difference between £2 a week and 18/- or 16/- a week is intolerable. Let me not over-state a good case. I do not believe it would be legitimate to say that less than £1 net, without perquisites of any kind, is being paid generally, but that figure is being paid. I say that is slavery, and I say that any body of men in this House who deliberately subscribe to the continuation of a political and economic policy which puts into the mouth of the Minister for Lands justification for a wage of that kind are betraying the interests of the people whom they ought to be representing in the House.

I remember well, when the labourers on the Shannon scheme had their wages fixed at 32/- a week, the upright, consistent Deputy Murphy made the welkin ring. He was bawling up and down the country that this was slavery, that the poor were being trodden down by a bankers' Government, and the same gentleman is supporting a Government to-day which espouses a wage of 22/- a week on the ground that that is all that is being paid in the neighbourhood. There is no question but that the Minister for Lands to-morrow could fix the wage on these schemes at 30/-, 28/- a week, or whatever would be deemed to be a fair wage, and the effect of that would be to raise agricultural wages on the land of anybody who could afford to pay them. Does Deputy Davin not agree with that? If there were afforestation operations or relief works going on in Leix-Offaly and the Minister said "Our rate of pay is 28/- or 30/- a week"—and, personally, I never paid less than 30/- a week in my life—"I do not care what is being paid in the neighbourhood; other circumstances may operate to make it impossible for the ordinary farmer to pay that figure, but that is my wage," would not any farmer who had good workmen and wanted to keep them and who was meanly and unjustly withholding from them a fair wage for a fair day's work have to pay the wage of 30/- if he wanted to keep those workmen and prevent them going to the Land Commission or the Forestry Department?

I do not believe any of the plaster that goes on from some of the Labour Deputies about raising the wages of the worker. It is all nonsense and it only reacts, in the long run, on the wage-earners themselves. There is no use hoping to get out of industry more than industry will produce, and wages and profits should bear a fair relation, one to the other. In my opinion, so far as agriculture in this country is concerned and so long as I remember, they always have borne a reasonable proportion one to the other, because very often the labouring men are the farmers' own neighbours. I believe in giving a fair wage for a fair day's work, and I believe that any political or economic policy which results in 80 per cent. of the labouring community of this country being reduced to a 22/- or 20/- a week basis stands self-condemned. Perhaps Deputy Murphy will get up and tell us why it is he continues to support a policy which is producing a state of affairs which makes it physically impossible for the employers of agricultural labour in this country to pay any more than the scandalous rates that are at present being paid.

It is no defence for the Minister for Lands to say that these are the prevailing rates of agricultural wages. He made them prevailing rates of agricultural wages; he is making them the prevailing rates of agricultural wages; and he is driving them down day after day and week after week. If there is any doubt in the mind of any Deputy in this House, let me remind him of what the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance once said—"If anyone tried to take this wage from them, they would fear him to pieces." Why should they tear you to pieces? Because the fact is that agricultural wages have been driven down below that level; because the fact is there is less and less employment on the land, and men are to be found in the country now who were independent, self-supporting and dignified individuals who are driven back now to the borders of destitution, and have to take anything in order to keep body and soul together. Unless that situation obtained, the Land Commission or the Forestry Department would not be able to get the people to work for these slave wages. Let the members of the Labour Party ask themselves this question: Who is responsible for bringing the people of this country down to a level at which they are prepared to work for 16 hours a day for 22/- a week?

Comment on this

Who told you it was 16 hours a day?

Comment on this

What would the Deputy say—14 or 12 hours?

Comment on this

Go back to school again.

Comment on this

What will the Deputy say is his experience in Leix-Offaly? How many hours a day does the agricultural labourer work in the harvest and seeding time.

Comment on this

Give us a case in proof of what you say.

Comment on this

I said, originally, 12 or 14 hours a day. Deputy Coburn said 16. Leave it at the 12 hours.

Comment on this

The small farmer and his sons will work day and night.

Comment on this

Yes; we know they work from dawn to dark. When the weather is fine and there is hay to be cut and saved, they go on working until the light will not allow them to work any longer, but leave it at 12 hours a day and drop the longer hours altogether. I ask the Deputy to tell this House what is it that has produced in rural Ireland a population of men who are prepared to work for 12 hours a day for a pound a week? Is it not the policy at present being pursued by the Government and if it is, why does he go on, with his eyes open, helping them to reduce our people to that condition of affairs? There is no use in sneering at the farmers; there is no use in pretending that it is their fault the rates of wages are not high; and there is no use in the Minister coming in here and trying to justify himself by comparing himself with the small farmer. He has almost unlimited funds at this disposal and if he takes the standard set up by the rural farmer as the standard for his own wages, it means that, on Monday, he beats down the farmer's rate of wages and, on Tuesday, follows them himself. The Labour Party have got to realise what is the fundamental thing that is wrong; the Minister for Lands has got to realise that the people of this country will not be content to employ their labourers under slave conditions of labour; and the whole House has got to realise that if agriculture is reduced to a condition in which it cannot afford to pay more than 20/- a week for a 12-hour day, the whole country is going to come down in ruins about us and there will not be money to pay 22/-, 20/-, 18/- or 16/-, not only to the labouring men who are working on the forestry schemes, but to any public servant or any other person living within the jurisdiction of Saorstát Eireann.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon, in opening his remarks, was not even ordinarily characteristic; he put a little extra into the introduction of his speech. I remember during the last general election—and I hold no brief for Deputy Kent at all; he does not belong to this Party—looking at some of the newspapers and finding big headings across the front pages to the effect that Deputy Kent was standing for the Party led by Deputy MacDermot and Deputy Dillon. He has fallen from grace, apparently, according to Deputy Dillon, but even though he did disagree with him and left that Party, I fail to see why such a tirade of abuse should have been launched against him simply because he mentioned a matter which ought to appeal to Deputy Dillon, possibly more than to any other Deputy in this House—the subject of the evicted tenants. We all know that Deputy Kent is interested in that subject, and I had a good deal of sympathy with him while Deputy Dillon was abusing him. Deputy Dillon was strangely silent, however, when Deputy Kent last addressed this House and pointed out the state of affairs in his constituency in East Cork, in which people were being followed for their annuities who had been invited not to pay these annuities. Those dupes who refused to pay fell under the lash of the sheriff. The people who advised them not to pay had paid their own.

Comment on this

They had cheque books.

Comment on this

They had cheque books, and they took them out and paid, but they told the others not to pay. If Deputy Dillon thinks there is one Deputy on the Government side of the House who gets any satisfaction from the seizure in Cork of 87 head of cattle, which were sold for £90, and afterwards sold in Belfast for £726, he is labouring under a great mistake. It does not give one man on this side of the House any satisfaction.

Comment on this

Why do you not stop it?

Comment on this

That is a fine question from a front bencher in the Opposition. Quotations from speeches of members of the Opposition have been given here. Deputy Minch's speech at Monasterevan is on the records of this House. He said: "While the economic war is on, pay no rates and pay no annuities." Now, after you have led men into destruction, after you have been responsible for driving people into such a state of panic that they invade even this House, you appeal to the rank and file of Fianna Fáil to take you out of the position which you brought yourself into, and to try to rescue the dupes whom you first drove to ruin by the advice you gave them, and then deserted.

Comment on this

You never had to pay rates or annuities.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

They are talking about cattle—people who would not know a cow from a bullock.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will resume his seat.

Comment on this

Not while that fellow is talking.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy, having flouted the authority of the Chair, will withdraw from the House for the remainder of this day's sitting.

Comment on this

There is a man who would not know a hen from a cow if he had one.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy does not withdraw at once the Chair will be constrained to name him.

Mr. Finlay withdrew from the House.

Comment on this

That is part of the intelligentsia we have to meet in the country.

Comment on this

The Centre Party.

Comment on this

I was saying that no one got any satisfaction whatever from the state of affairs which exists. I do not think we will live to see the day when we will derive any satisfaction from a state of affairs like that. Apart from all those things, there is a matter under this Vote that I do want to refer to. I do not want to delay in discussing things which are unpleasant, such as seizures in any part of the country. I do not want to do it. Deputies in the Opposition should realise that they have a very serious responsibility to try to end that state of affairs; to advise their followers to do what is sensible and legal, and to mend their own hand so far as they possibly can. I do not want to give quotations from speeches delivered by Deputies——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That matter has been debated very frequently. The Deputy might now get down to the items of the Vote.

Comment on this

Towards the end of his speech, Deputy Dillon seemed to become rather enthusiastic on behalf of the workers, and in regard to the wages that are being paid to people working under the Land Commission. I candidly admit that 22/- per week is not a very great wage for anybody. I do not say that it is, but we have got to consider many things. In some of those areas there was no work at all. The Minister for Finance has got to find cash. He has got to find money to subsidise all those schemes. A Budget was introduced in this House to try to cover all this expenditure. We were practically told that we had ruined the country, and will continue to ruin it if we go on financing those schemes at the scale on which we are financing them at the moment. Another point of criticism is that the wages paid are not considered enough. I admit that 22/- per week is not a very high rate of wages for anyone.

Comment on this

The Budget makes it lower.

Comment on this

At the same time where is the money going to come out of? Must not some kind of balance be struck? We have not been living in the moon for the last 40 years. We know that receiving a rate of 22/- per week is better than walking about doing nothing. I do agree with the appeal to the Minister to try and give an increased rate, if it is possible to do so. If I may come back again just for a moment I should like to reply to a point arising out of Deputy Dillon's speech. The affair in Cork was a terrible affair. I admit that it is going to create a certain amount of disturbance all over the country. I admit that it is going to create unpleasantness, not alone in Cork but in counties along the Border. I admit all that. I think that Deputy Coburn was one of the people who were visiting those cattle on the night before they were sent to Belfast. I am not sure whether or not that is right. If it is, I hope he went there for a good purpose, and not for the purpose of helping in any way to create any further unpleasantness than there is at the present moment. If those people will not pay their land annuities——

Comment on this

If they will not pay their land annuities and if the law is such that there must be seizures in order to realise the amount of annuities due, that is a situation which must be faced up to. In my opinion it is the work of responsible Deputies on the other side of the House, coming from those constituencies, to try and bring about such a state of affairs that a recurrence of those events will be impossible.

Comment on this

That is for the Government to do.

Comment on this

Can the Deputy suggest anything that could be done on this side of the House?

Comment on this
A Deputy

Stop the conspiracy.

Comment on this

Deputies in the Opposition could go to the County Cork, and point out to the people there that they should consistently pay their annuities. They could help in seeing that victimisation, such as has been described by Deputy Dillon, does not occur. Surely you are not bereft of funds? Did ever any responsible political party embark in any direction on a campaign such as was embarked upon in this country a short time ago, where the question of non-payment of annuities did arise and the question of the non-payment of rates did arise? Surely to goodness Fine Gael is not so bereft of funds, and, now that Deputy Cosgrave has returned, is not so bereft of leadership that they cannot try to help their own supporters, and bring them out of the position in which they find themselves?

Comment on this

Would the Deputy allow me to ask him a perfectly sincere question? In the case of persons who literally cannot pay their land annuities, such as this man Clune to whom I referred, what does the Deputy suggest that we should do if seizures are made?

Comment on this

That is a straight question. I hope that the Deputy will give me credit, at any rate, for answering it in such a way as will convey my own personal feelings honestly and sincerely. If a man cannot pay, if he has not got the resources with which to pay at the present moment, that is no reason why that man should be encouraged by his own Deputies going to the constituency and telling him: "You are not able to pay because the present policy of the present Government has reduced you to the state of poverty in which you are." That is no remedy. Deputy Morrissey may laugh——

Comment on this

Tell us your remedy.

Comment on this

I have told you my remedy.

Comment on this

You are responsible in this way——

Comment on this

They are given time.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister for Lands to say now whether, if I come to him personally—I am prepared to do that, although it is a very distasteful thing to me to approach any Fianna Fáil Minister—and lay a case before him in which people cannot pay, he will give them time?

Comment on this
Minister for Lands (Mr. Connolly)

I have deliberately abstained from interfering with regard to the collection of annuities. We have a department which collects annuities. If a Deputy writes to me about annuities in a case where the allottee is in difficulties, the correspondence is sent to the gentleman in charge of the collection department, irrespective of what Party that Deputy belongs to. It then lies with him, in his discretion, whether he ought to exercise leniency or not, and, so far as I am aware, where a good case has been made to the gentleman in charge of collections, that leniency has always been extended.

Comment on this

And Deputy Dillon knows it too well.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Donnelly realise that the position is that the advice now given by the Minister is to refer us to the collection department? It is neither expedient for me nor for anybody else to start discussing individual members of the Civil Service. I am dealing now with the Minister. Will he personally take responsibility for dealing with what Deputy Donnelly describes as a desperately serious situation? Heretofore he left it to the permanent officials. We cannot attack them here. If a man cannot pay, will the Minister say that he will order the collection department to wait?

Comment on this

I expect I have had as many communications with the Minister as any other Deputy. Possibly I have made myself a great nuisance in trying to get things done. I will say this of the Land Commission generally, that in a particular case, where it is found practically impossible for a man to meet a demand made upon him, then surely to goodness, under conditions of that kind, people ought not to be victimised. I may say I have been fairly met by the Land Commission, and I believe if Deputy Dillon takes the trouble to correspond with them he will be fairly met, too, and I think we will go a longer way towards getting over the present situation as regards the non-payment of annuities and rates if, in our dealings with the Land Commission, we met them in a constructive way rather than devote our attention to the making of bombastic speeches for the benefit of the voters in Galway and Dublin.

Comment on this

If the Minister will only repeat your words and accept his responsibility, the difficulty will be solved, but he will not do it.

Comment on this

I have many times criticised the Land Commission, and possibly I will do so again. I have told the Minister many things verbally, and I have written to him in regard to various matters. If there is any member of the Executive Council who deserves the sympathy of this House, it is the Minister for Lands. I understand perfectly well the amount of correspondence he receives daily and the numbers of people who make applications for land. They come at him from every angle, and one would want to be a superman to stand up to the strain of conducting the affairs of the Land Commission. It was only since I came into close contact with the conditions in that Department that I fully realised the difficulties that have to be confronted, particularly with regard to the applications for land.

Comment on this

That is not a matter in which the Minister is directly responsible, according to the 1933 Act.

Comment on this

Somebody must administer the Act, and in Deputy Cosgrave's own Government there was a Minister for Lands. That ends that. The present Minister is pulled at from every angle. He is the person to whom we must address our arguments in this House. Deputy Cosgrave is too good a Parliamentarian not to know that the Minister is the bush in the gap, the man to attack when we want to say anything about his Department.

Comment on this

What other person should you attack?

Comment on this

We must attack the Minister.

Comment on this

But the Minister has shifted responsibility to a civil servant, and that is a cowardly attitude.

Comment on this

In one case he has no statutory responsibility, and in another case he puts the responsibility over on a civil servant.

Comment on this

I have found fault with the Land Commission mainly in regard to the speed of land division. According to the Minister, 120,000 acres were divided last year. That compares very favourably with the average of 44,000 acres when our predecessors were in office. If the Minister can go ahead dividing 120,000 acres per annum he will be doing good work and the people will begin to have faith in the Land Commission. Whenever I go to Leix I am surrounded by applicants for land. I am continually in correspondence with the Minister's Department on that subject. From every angle you are bombarded with applications for land. Deputy Brennan—and I have a great respect and a deep regard for his attitude in these matters—talked about economic and uneconomic holdings. Why is there this urge for land if land is such an uneconomic proposition as we are told? If you go to Stradbally and South Leix, you will find a great urge there for the acquisition of more land. I am sorry Deputy Finlay is not here because he would agree with that, and I believe Deputy Davin and Deputy O'Higgins could bear me out in that connection also. There is a great demand for land there, and the desire is to use it for tillage farming.

The real urge for land in South Leix and portion of North Leix is because they want to utilise it in connection with the beet industry. They sent their quotas to Carlow and Thurles—the railway returns are there —and, in addition, they sent 12,000 tons of beet to Tuam. These people want more land. I have been a source of annoyance to the Minister trying to get the Lord Castletown and other estates divided. The people are going in for intensive tillage. I suggest to Deputy Cosgrave that he should get for his own information a copy of the report of the chief home assistance officer for Leix last year, and read his remarks as to the state of affairs in the county. He pointed out that home help had gone down by £6,000 a year. He pointed out the advantages that were being derived by the farming community. My complaint is this, that in the Midlands, the best tillage areas in Ireland, there are still estates that can be taken over and divided, and they should be given to men who will work them to the advantage of the country.

Comment on this

Will they pay any money for them?

Comment on this

These people are the best judges of what pays best.

Comment on this

My point is, does the Deputy want to give it to them for nothing?

Comment on this

I take it that if a man in a certain industry is losing, he will not be prepared to continue very long in that industry.

Comment on this

A lot of fellows want to get land for nothing.

Comment on this

The people want the land divided, and I hope there will be a speed-up in the division of land. I wonder if I would be in order discussing afforestation?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Afforestation is being taken separately. The only question raised in relation to it was the question of wages referred to by Deputy Davin.

Comment on this

There is another reason for speeding up the division of land in South Leix. There is a section of the community living in the area stretching from Stradbally practically to Carlow. I am sure the Minister knows the area well. It is what we refer to as the Wolfhill area. I am particularly anxious about that area. I do not know what can be done in connection with the holders there. We have seen where people can be taken from Connemara and placed on holdings in Meath. That scheme is going to be an economic success. Of course, it is backed by a desire to spread the language. I would like to point out that there are holdings in the Wolfhill area, and it is impossible for people there to make ends meet. I suggest that some time or other the Minister might deal with that question and seriously consider the plight of the people there, with the object of remedying their position.

Deputy Dillon made a nasty and misleading analogy when he was dealing with the question of the non-payment of annuities. The Deputy talked about that, and said it was quite possible that an anti-Government agitation could be got up, and have public opinion behind it. He pointed to the days of the Land League, when there was a big agitation started against a foreign Government operating here. Now we know that there is no analogy whatever between the present state of affairs and the condition of things that existed in the days of the Land League. It is clear that there is none whatever, for this reason—that the people of that time were fighting for the possession of their homesteads, fighting against rack-rents, against emergency men, against the crowbar brigade and the rest of it——

Comment on this

Just the same to-day.

Comment on this

Wait a moment. At that time they were fighting against the system which was set up and mapped out by the Government of the day to destroy the smallholder and make the small holdings into ranches. They said that farming was being carried out on too small a scale. That was why the agitation started, and if Deputy Belton goes to Stradbally he will find the place surrounded with ranches——

Comment on this

I will meet Deputy Donnelly on that argument at Stradbally.

Comment on this

There is no analogy between the fight which took place in the days of the Land League when the people were fighting for their homes and preventing the country from being turned into ranches and the fight to-day. The policy of the Government to-day is to put the people back into the land, to put the land under tillage and to have human beings where formerly there were bullocks. That is our programme and our policy, and that is why I say the analogy drawn by Deputy Dillon between what is happening to-day and what took place in the days of the Land League is a misleading analogy. There is no comparison between the two things—between the fight then waged and the fight that is waged to-day by the Opposition against the National Government. I do sincerely hope that the Opposition will accept one or two suggestions I have made to them for what they are worth. That is, that they get in touch with their followers and try to put a stop to the agitation that is already dying down, and if there is any more of it left, kill it at once and get back to common sense. If Deputy Belton takes the ordinary trade journal dealing with agricultural conditions he will find that there are 17,000,000 acres of land in the Saorstát. Of that, 12,000,000 acres are arable and 3,200,000 acres are being tilled to-day. What is to become of the other 9,000,000 acres? That is the problem that is before the Minister for Lands. What is to become of that 9,000,000 acres?

Comment on this

That is what we would like the Deputy to tell us.

Comment on this

The Minister is making a big effort to deal with that question. The Minister has succeeded in dividing 120,000 acres of land in the last year. He has not let the grass grow under his feet. His job is a big job, and instead of Opposition criticism that is not helpful the Minister should get all the constructive and genuine help of every Deputy in the House. He is entitled to get that at the present moment. Is not every country in the world sending its population back to the land? Lloyd George made a speech yesterday in which he said the land of England is yearning to be tilled. He spoke of that as one way in which unemployment could be solved. It is one way in which unemployment can be solved in this country. While estates are not being divided as quickly as we would wish, still we are making an advance towards self-sufficiency and towards putting into practice our programme. The Minister for Lands has made a great effort during the past 12 months in achieving the division of 120,000 acres. I know that the Land Commission is an unpopular institution in many places. It was in 1881 that it was first established. I happened the other day in the Library to look up the history of that institution and I read the speeches made in the House of Commons attacking the Land Commission. The Land Commission is being still attacked. The reason is because the Land Commission holds the key to the future prosperity of the country and to the solution of many difficulties under which we are labouring to-day. The careful and wholehearted administration of that Department of the Government might be helped by constructive and intelligent criticism by Deputies, and that would go a long way to help the Minister and help the policy of the country. I congratulate the Minister in what he has accomplished during his last year's work, and I hope he will pursue the policy he has been pursuing. I say that because I am convinced of its truth from what I have seen of the operations of the Minister and his Department in Leix-Offaly. That is one of the most intensively tilled constituencies in the country except Wexford. I am urging more speed in the division of land and I am urging, if possible, the appointment of more inspectors to push forward the work of land division in that area.

Comment on this

I gather from the close of Deputy Donnelly's speech that the Land Commission to-day is the worthy successor to the Land Commission of fifty years ago. And really the Deputy need not be quite so wroth with Deputy Dillon, as I understand he was, because Deputy Dillon drew an analogy between the present campaign of the Government and the campaign of the British Government and the landlords 50 years ago. I can understand the Deputy's objection to that analogy but I cannot accept the grounds he gave for objecting to it. For the analogy is very applicable. There is one essential difference between the position to-day and the position in the days of the land agitation in the 'eighties. To-day, as the result of Government policy, you have one big landlord. But the habits and arguments and measures and ruthlessness of that one big landlord in dealing with his tenants at the present moment are precisely the habits and arguments of his predecessors in the 'eighties. When Deputy Donnelly suggests that the agitation against the landlords in the 'eighties was due to the desire to prevent the establishment of ranches, he only shows that he must not have been living in the country at the time or that he knows nothing about it. That agitation was due, as the Deputy in a portion of his enumeration let slip, to the rack rents and uncertainty of tenure and to the impossibility of the farmers paying these rack rents that were demanded. That agitation became serious, it became nation-wide and a menace to the whole peace of the country. Why, and following what? Following the drop in the agricultural prices in 1879, as a case precisely parallel to what has occurred in the last few years. What was the answer then? "The law is there, you must pay." Some people could pay, in those days of the 'eighties. To-day we have the Minister for Finance jeering about motor cars and some Deputies jeering about cheque books. But, as Deputy Davin and every Deputy in this House knows, in the 'eighties an effort was made to split the farmers, and had that effort been successful it would have been to the ruin not only of individuals but of the whole farming community. At that time it would have been an easy thing for many men in comfortable positions to save themselves by standing with the landlords and paying up. They would have saved themselves immense costs but they would have deserted the cause of all the other farmers in the country. Now when sneers are indulged in here by the Minister for Finance, who never loses an opportunity of interjecting some remark about somebody having a motor car, and some people having cheque books, let us remember that exactly the same arguments, the same taunts, were hurled by the landlords of those days against those from whom they were extracting the last penny, the penny that the bulk of the farmers could not pay, even if some were still in a position to do so.

I wonder is it the contention of Deputy Donnelly that farming is a paying proposition at present, that it is an economic proposition for the bulk of the people. If that is not his contention then he has failed to see the root of the whole trouble. His attacks on the Opposition are quite on a par with what we have heard from that side. He must know well that neither in the 'eighties of the last century nor in the 'thirties of this century was there any necessity for anybody to stir up the farmers. Instead of that every effort had to be made to keep them quiet when, from the nature of the case, they were goaded often beyond ordinary human limits by the conduct of the Government. The fact that the Government is now the one landlord only means that they have a great deal more power and are a great deal more ruthless than at least some of the landlords were in those far-off days. To attack the question of agricultural wages and the question of the collection of the land annuities and leave out of account altogether what has happened in connection with the price of farming produce for the last three years is simply shutting your eyes to the main cause of the trouble, and everybody must know that who knows the country.

What is the good of pretending that anybody is capable of blooding the people up if the cause of serious trouble was not there in the actual situation? If a case is brought forward of one or two people who can pay but who refused to desert their fellows, as upholders of the law we may object to that, but when a whole class is threatened with extermination, as the Deputy knows, very often they stand or fall together. Whether we regret the conduct of these men or not in refusing to abandon their fellows, we must remember that they have in that respect, at all events, a tradition behind them. The Opposition did not stir up this agitation, and the Deputy ought to know it. This agitation was there and was not stirred up by the members of the Opposition. It was pointed out to the Government where they were going. At a time when they were throwing money out on all sorts of things they were begged to stop and not collect these annuities while the present crisis was on. The landlords were begged in the 'eighties not to collect their rents. But they had on their side the law and they insisted on collecting them. The result was a crisis. That was not due to the agitators of that particular time; the crisis was due to the actual economic circumstances of the time. Precisely the same arguments that are used now by Deputy Donnelly and others, against some members of the Opposition, were used at that time by those who stood by the landlords' cause.

You do not get rid of the habits or the procedure of landlordism by putting the State in the place of the individual. Everybody will admit that the State has certain rights, but, as was pointed out long ago, it also has certain duties. When there is a crisis facing the whole agricultural community it is nothing short of criminal that the State should utilise its powers to the extent that it has done. The Minister may get rid of some of his responsibility by saying that he has handed this over to the machine. That is precisely what is wrong. The machine is set going, and the machine grinds everything. What we want to know is, was there an instruction sent out by the Minister in the present economic situation, with ruin staring the farmers in the face, to be extra lenient and not to proceed except in the very worst cases; not merely that they should refuse to proceed where a good case could be made— that is not enough—but that they should not proceed except in the very worst cases. The machine will act; it is bound to act; it is bound to be impersonal and to be crushing in that respect.

The Deputy is probably quite right when he foretells a serious expansion of this unrest. He knows the country to some extent at all events. Though he may make speeches in this House, backing up the policy of the Government, he knows where that policy must lead. Where else can it lead but to a very serious crisis? I have again and again put to Ministers and Deputies opposite this question: what hope is there and what future is there for the farming community in this country? Can they pay their annuities this year? If they can and pay them out of their savings, or even their cheque books, if some of them have them, which excites the sneers of Deputy Davin and his colleagues, will the same thing have to be done next year?

Comment on this

You have mentioned me three times, but I never said that at all.

Comment on this

I am sorry for libelling Deputy Davin, and I withdraw that, but there was such a continual fire of interruption going on from himself and Deputy Murphy——

Comment on this

There was not.

Comment on this

I should like to know what is a fire of interruption if that was not one during Deputy Dillon's speech coming from these two Deputies. Anyhow, it was used by his neighbour and colleague. I have heard a similar argument from the Minister for Finance. It is not merely that you are making impossible demands at present from the farming community, but you are depriving them of the one thing which will enable them to struggle on, namely, any hope for the future. That is quite as serious as the situation you are dealing with and creating at the present time. It is useless for the Minister or Deputy Donnelly or Deputy Davin or Deputy Murphy to discuss this situation and refuse to get at the real basis of the trouble.

We are told by the President that everything in his policy is working out according to plan. Is this his plan? If it were the intention of the Government to break any spirit of independence in the farming community, to see that no person on the land will be able to have a sense of independence, I know no better way to go about it than the way they are proceeding at present. There may be one or two Deputies and there may be many people among their supporters in the country who may think that that is a goal devoutly to be sought for—to break that spirit of independence. I have seen that happen in other countries. I have seen it happen in one particular country to which the Minister for Finance referred in his Budget speech. He compared this country in some respects with Russia. In that country the Government pursued exactly the same campaign against the independent farmer and smashed them out of existence. There was nobody left on the land except the agricultural labourer and he did not own the land. It was State landlordism carried to the extreme limit, just as you are trying to carry it here. I have often been struck with the extraordinary analogy between the policy of the two Governments. If Deputy Davin could spare a little time he would probably find that the analogy is sometimes rather appalling.

Comment on this

You are keeping bad company.

Comment on this

You do not get rid of troubles by shutting your eyes to them. We have to keep our eyes open about certain developments. Deputy Donnelly has suggested that, after all, land and farming must not be so bad if the people are so anxious to get land. He has cited that desire for land as a proof that the condition of farming cannot be so bad. The people were anxious to get land in 1879. They were anxious to get land in the 'eighties. Can Deputy Donnelly tell me of any time in the history of this country in which the people of this country were not anxious to get land? Can Deputy Donnelly tell me of any time in the history of Europe when the people were not anxious to get land? I say nothing about America, because the position is different there, but so far as Europe is concerned, can Deputy Donnelly tell me of any time, no matter what the conditions of the farmers or of the people living on the land were—whether they were serfs bound hand and foot to the landlord or not—where the people, and even the serf, were not anxious to get land or to increase the stock of land they already had? The desire for land is altogether independent of such circumstances, and Deputy Donnelly ought to know it. That desire is there, and it is altogether independent of the question of whether or not the land is a paying proposition. That desire for land is in the blood of the people of this country and in the blood of the farming communities of most countries, and the Deputy ought to know it. That desire for land is there, and it will be there whether the land pays or not. The Deputy knows that perfectly well.

I was glad, anyhow, to learn one thing: that, in so far as the expenses of this country are concerned, Deputy Donnelly has not been living in the moon for the last 20 or 30 years. I suggest, however, that it is only within the last two or three years that he came down from the moon, so far as that is concerned. I venture to say that we heard every eloquent pleas from this side of the House, several years ago, which seemed to leave out of account altogether the necessity of providing money for the running of the State. What, however, is the situation facing the people? Moreover, what is the situation that they were led to hope for? You have, as I say, not merely the appalling situation in which they find themselves, the complete lack of hope for the future, but the complete dashing of whatever hopes they placed on the present Government as regards the remunerative quality of their land. I forget now what it was, but I think that every farmer was to get £15 or £16 more per year. Has that been justified? The facts are there, and, so far as this country is concerned, the facts are there in connection with the value of land. You may be able to secure a certain amount by the employment of the Crowbar Brigade, to which Deputy Donnelly referred, by the seizures of cattle at one price and selling them at six times the value; you may be able by these and other such methods to screw a certain amount out of the people, but do you think that such methods can continue? Do you think that they can continue indefinitely? That is the question that every farmer in the country, no matter to what Party he belongs, is asking himself at the present time. Every farmer in the country at the present time, no matter to what Party he belongs, is asking himself: How long is it going to continue and how long can the farming community afford it?

Comment on this

I was very interested and surprised to hear the Minister, whom I always looked upon as possessing courage, saying, when he was put up against a situation arising out of a suggestion made by Deputy Donnelly, that if farmers sought for time they would get it. The Minister intervened and explained that there is an officer in the Land Commission—the head of the collection department—to whom all queries of that kind are referred, and that that officer acts within his discretion and deals with those questions as they are placed before him. I think that is a fair summary of what the Minister said. I should like to know from the Minister whether or not he has given instructions, over his signature to this particular officer, laying down certain conditions in which he should show leniency; and, if he has not given such instructions, what is to safeguard this officer if he shows leniency and if his ideas of leniency do not happen to coincide with the Minister's ideas or with the ideas of leniency of the Minister for Finance? I think that the Minister for Lands would have improved his case in that particular if he had remained silent. It is for Ministers, who are directly responsible to the people, to shoulder the burden and the responsibility and not to try to throw that burden and responsibility on to the shoulders of officials. As I said, I was surprised at the Minister's attempt to throw his responsibility on to an official. I say that it is not fair to the official, or to any official. I have heard politicians on platforms say that it was not the Minister's fault. I have heard members of the Dublin Corporation say that it was not the Minister's fault.

Comment on this
Mr. Connolly

On a point of explanation, Sir, if I may be permitted to intervene. I explained here that there was a collection department in the Land Commission. Numerous applications come to me from all sources and from all Parties in which it is impossible for me to judge the merits of the case. These are sent to the Department for the consideration of those responsible. I am not in a position to judge the merits of the particular application which asks for time. What would be the position if I intervened and asked the Department to give time to "A" and to refuse time to "B"? Would not the suggestion be that I was only favouring those applicants who were supporters of my own Party and ordering the Department to go against those who were opposed to me? Does not any sane man know that? Party politics being as they are in this country at the moment, the only clean and decent thing to do is to refer all such applications to a Department which can judge impartially.

Comment on this

While I give the Minister credit for the best intentions, and while I accept his statement of good intentions, I suggest this to him. My view of what I should expect a Minister to do in such circumstances would be to issue, to the officers concerned, instructions that, if applications for time came within certain categories, the official should then give time and that he should not be called upon to exercise any more discretion than to determine whether or not the particular application for time came within the category laid down by the Minister. I would think that the Minister should do something of that kind and not throw the entire onus on any official. It is an invidious position for an official to be in and it is quite easy—I do not suggest that the present Minister would do it—for any Minister who wanted to avoid odium to throw the onus on an official and remove the official, perhaps, in disgrace, to some other Department. I would suggest to the Minister that he should seriously consider proceeding by instruction to the Department concerned, specifying certain conditions and if these were fulfilled in the application made for time, the officer in charge could give time and his discretion would end entirely with interpreting whether the circumstances of the particular applicant fulfilled those conditions.

Comment on this
Mr. Connolly

I have sufficient confidence in the Department responsible to come here and take full responsibility for anything that they do, even though they do it without my intimate knowledge.

Comment on this

That is your duty.

Comment on this