We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote No. 54—Lands.

Contributions 147–317 of 461. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Mr. Connolly

It is also my privilege.

Comment on this

We are only where we started and if I were that official, I would take good care to mind my job and carry out the law. The Minister says he cannot deal with the numerous applications he will get. Granted. But how many annuitants are there— 200,000 or 300,000? Suppose they all looked for time, will the head of the collection be able to deal with them all? Would all the officials of the Land Commission be able to deal with them? I will not pursue that any further.

Deputy Donnelly is a great man to make a speech, saying very little, but putting a good face on a bad case and he pretty well excelled himself in that respect this afternoon. To suggest that it is a sign of agricultural prosperity that people are howling to get land for nothing is too ridiculous to come from a Deputy of the intelligence of Deputy Donnelly. Did he ever meet any man who would not take something for nothing? I did not and the people about whom Deputy Donnelly is talking are people who are asking for something for nothing.

Comment on this

I am talking about small farmers' sons.

Comment on this

Are they not people who are asking for something for nothing?

Comment on this

They want farms of their own.

Comment on this

If they have farms of their own and agriculture is prosperous, they should have a little bit left by. Are they prepared to put down even 10 per cent. of the valuation of a holding which the Land Commission is dividing and take responsibility for paying the annuity on 90 per cent. of it?

Comment on this

Quite a number of them.

Comment on this

We know they are not. The only case that was made was that if they get land for nothing, they will take it.

Comment on this

It is one of the conditions of getting land that they would have capital going into it.

Comment on this

I do not follow the logic of this argument on either side. Personally, I have taken up the stand from the beginning that the farmers, as a united body, should have stood against paying the land annuities. I make no apology for saying that, either inside or outside this House. I heard the Minister being severely criticised to-day for the manner in which these annuities are being collected, and I have heard these critics state in this House that any man who is able to pay his annuities should pay them. If you follow that to its logical conclusion, nobody can say that, according to law, a man is not able to pay his annuities until the sheriff comes to his yard to seize, gets nothing there and returns "no goods." That is the operation of the law, as I understand it, and I do not see the logic of the position of anybody who says that the farmer should pay his annuities if he is able, and, at the same time, criticise the Minister for trying to collect them. I do not say that he should pay if he is able. I say that he should not, because the British Government is collecting them. I make no apology for that statement.

Comment on this

If you say it outside, you will be shoved into jail.

Comment on this

I have said it outside, and I was not shoved into jail, and if the farmers stood together on that rock, they could not all be shoved into jail, and this matter would be all over and done with long ago. It was not done, unfortunately. The Minister is collecting these annuities, and while I have not heard him say it, I presume he says it in the chorus of the Ministers and Deputies behind him, that the farmers will not pay their annuities. What are the British collecting £5,000,000 for, and from whom are the British collecting them? The President here a few nights ago admitted that the British are collecting substantially that sum, and all of that sum, except £100,000, comes from the agricultural population. The entire annuities due to Britain were not quite £3,000,000. I challenge any Deputy or Minister to get up and show where the annuities are due. Heretofore, they were collected by the Government in this country and paid over to Britain in a round sum of about £3,000,000. The present Government will not collect them, but the British Government says: "We will collect them from the farmers' produce" and she has stated that she is collecting them and the Minister is sending out his press gang and battering ram to collect them again.

The position I take up in this matter is that the farmers should not pay them, and I go into no conspiracy to make that statement. I would go on a platform and say it. I should like the Minister to get up and openly refute my case. I should like to see more Deputies in this House taking up that attitude with me. There is no halfway house between that attitude and paying them. At least, I see none, and I should like anybody to show it to me. It is the operation of the law that the sheriff goes there to collect them. If we admit that they are due, we cannot object to the sheriff functioning as part of the law, and selling as part of the law—with the Minister providing the buyer, at 15/- or 16/- a head—in the Belfast market by a political supporter of one of his Ministerial colleagues. I ask the Minister to tell us what is his authority for collecting these annuities outside the legal authority that was given him by his machined majority two years ago, when a clause was inserted in the Land Act whereby he could collect them even though the British are collecting them. I do not know of any. The Minister admitted that the farmer is paying practically all that. He admitted further that the loss to the farmer was the difference between what the British collected and the export bounty, and he admitted that that was about £2,000,000. He went further and admitted that the farmers lost roughly the same amount, namely another £2,000,000 by the lowering of the wholesale agricultural prices on the home market. Why is not the farmer recouped by allowing those annuities. and by recognising that they are being paid to the British while this economic conflict continues? Why do the Government not realise the facts which are staring them in the face? Why do they run off at a tangent as the President did a few days ago, saying: "What are we paying in bounty and subsidy for butter? What are we paying for wheat? What are we paying for beet?"

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

"Yes," said Deputy Donnelly. I am glad that he nodded assent to that. I should like to put this to the Deputy; was not the promotion of that agricultural economy a part of the celebrated plan before the present Government came into office? I think the Deputy will agree that it was. The Deputy will agree that under the ordinary operation of economic laws here for half a century or more the trade in cattle developed as the most profitable end of farming, a circumstance which the Deputy knows I regret as much as anybody in this House or in the country. I am as much opposed to the developing of the cattle trade as any man in Ireland, but those are the facts. The Government comes in and wants to alter that natural evolution or direction of agricultural economy. It says to the people: "We want you to grow wheat, beet, tobacco, and so on." Will not the Deputy appreciate that that can be done only at a loss, as compared with the previous economy which the farmer was pursuing under the operation of the natural economic laws?

Comment on this

He often pursued that at a loss too.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest that we pursue the Estimate for a change.

Comment on this

I submit that the relationship of this is——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Very strained.

Comment on this

I want to support the case which I have made that the Government should not be collecting those annuities while the British are collecting them. The contra case to that has been made before, and I am endeavouring to answer it now. The contra case has been an admission that the British are collecting the land annuities, but that the farmer is recouped in other directions by Government aid to the extent at least of what he pays to the British. I am trying to controvert that, and to show that the Government is taking undue credit for the giving of a subsidy for wheat, beet, turf and one or two other things, because those subsidies are not in any way arising out of the economic war but are given because of the fixed and deliberate change of agricultural economy introduced by the Government. They cannot have that change of agricultural policy in any other way than by subsidising it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is referring to Government policy and not to the Estimate.

Comment on this

My purpose is to refute the claim made by the President here a few evenings ago that the farmer is being recouped. The President admitted £4,000,000 of a loss. He then went on to show that by giving those subsidies, which are really because of the change in agricultural economy, he was recouping the loss to the farmers.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy cannot keep answering the President all the year. We must come down to the Estimate which is before us. The Deputy is referring to general Government policy.

Comment on this

The Estimate before us is to provide, in the picturesque language of Deputy Donnelly, the bailiffs and battering rams to collect the annuities which I hold are not due because the British are collecting them. Any assistance which the Government is giving is being given in order to help the change in agricultural policy here, and it is not an off-set against the double collection of the land annuities. A very material consideration in acquiring land and redistributing it is, first of all, whether agriculture is a paying proposition. I should like if some Deputy opposite would make the case that it is.

Comment on this

It is of course. The Deputy is himself the best example.

Comment on this

I should like if some farmer would come into those benches and tell us that agriculture is a paying proposition. I should like Deputy Hales from West Cork to tell us whether agriculture is a paying proposition. I will listen very attentively to him from the time I have finished until 10.30 and it will take him all that time to convince me that agriculture is a paying proposition, either in West Cork or anywhere else. What branch of agriculture is a paying proposition? Do not tell us about wheat. That is subsidised to the tune of 7/-. Do not tell us about beet, while the price of sugar is 2¾d. or 3d. per lb.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture.

Comment on this

The Land Commission is going to acquire land for distribution. The distribution of land has been taken by Deputy Donnelly as the test of the work done by the Minister, whom he described—because he had redistributed 100,000 acres in, I think, the last year—as showing that he was not allowing the grass to grow under his feet. I am afraid the grass is growing very high on that land, because there is not much to eat it.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

Then it must have been bobbed. Before the Minister starts acquiring that land for redistribution he should tell us where similar land and similar holdings are paying, and on what sort of economy? I have tried every farming trick in the bag in order to extract all the money I could out of farming, and I know it is not paying at the present time. The Minister looks doubtful about that, but he can take my word for it. If it is paying, where is it paying? If it is not, is the Minister justified in acquiring land and redistributing it? I wonder is he satisfied that dairying is paying? I will not go into the details of that. I am satisfied that it is not paying, and I could give very good reasons, but on this Vote it is sufficient to say that it is not paying. We will meet the people opposite at another time and under other auspices of discussion to show whether it is paying or not. I hope I will not be accused of law breaking when I say that we should not collect the land annuities. I should much rather say—because that is the logical position to take up—that the British are collecting them off the farmers, and that the farmers are not being indemnified by the Government. Therefore our Government should not set about collecting them again. I take that stand because that is my belief, and I would have taken that stand in a more pronounced manner if the farmers, instead of grousing and grumbling, stood together. They did not stand together, because they got wrong advice. They were told to pay if they were able, and that it was their legal duty to pay. Anybody who has told the farmers it was their legal obligation to pay those annuities has no ground for complaint if the sheriff, operating according to the law, goes to his yard and seizes his cattle. That is the machinery of the law. If I believed that they were due I would not object to the sheriff going there—why should I? but I do not believe they are due.

Comment on this

Did you pay?

Comment on this

Of course, he did.

Comment on this

What has he to talk about, so?

Comment on this

I am sorry that the Deputy has spoken.

Comment on this

I am not a bit sorry I spoke.

Comment on this

The Deputy will be sorry when I have finished. I said I do not believe these annuities are due and that the Minister should not collect them for no other reason than that they have been extracted from the farmers already by the British Government. In support of that attitude, on one occasion I moved this resolution: "That this convention is satisfied that the farmers should not be asked to pay land annuities, rates or rent, as these are being paid through the medium of tariffs; further, that the Government be requested to pay all fee-farm rents, leasehold rents and all local rates on agricultural land." The Deputy opposed that. That was at an open meeting at which the Press was present and, in order to keep the farmers from making a stand, Deputy MacDermot sent this secret circular to carry a vote against that resolution——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister has no responsibility for what Deputy MacDermot did.

Comment on this

I accept your ruling. A Deputy who, when I volunteered to make a stand on behalf of the farmers, would not co-operate with me and voted against my resolution, now asks me did I pay my land annuities. I did, and I would pay them a million times before I would start the hypocrisy of getting my cattle seized in order to make myself a cheap martyr and then go and pay the annuities after the cattle are seized. If you are going to fight, fight, and if you are not prepared to fight, you mights as well surrender. I put forward that proposal about three years ago and I am prepared to put it up again to-day. The Deputy knows that his leader of that day went around the country telling the farmers to pay if they were able. How can he say a man is not able to pay a debt if he has cattle? When he has cattle, is not that a visible sign of means? My point is that the farmer should not be asked to pay a second time. I say to them "Do not pay our Government when the British Government has collected them and our Government is not stopping the British Government from collecting them." That is the attitude I take up. I am not going to cut off my head for somebody else to laugh at my headless body. Will you stand together and then I will stand with you?

Comment on this

Why did you not stand in Naas?

Comment on this

I did, and no other man went to Naas but myself, and no other man stood at Linehan's Pound but myself, and the Deputy knows that. I am sorry Deputy Curran thought fit to throw in that interjection. I would have let the incident pass, but I know what is behind such things.

Comment on this

I do. The Deputy need not sneer and feel that he has scored any point, because he has not.

Comment on this

I never scored off anybody.

Comment on this

I am sure you did not; you play for safety always. I accept the position that the Minister has the law on his side to collect. I do not accept the position that he has equity on his side. The President went a long way last week in admitting that contention, but he went away from it at a point to which I have referred already, and I am not going to go back on it again. Does the Minister not realise that the whole business of collecting and the manner in which he has to collect are something that require attention and examination? People are not allowing their stock to be seized and members of their families arrested for nothing. Is it not a matter that should be inquired into? Some time ago it was suggested that there should be an inquiry as to whether the farmers are right in their contention that they have paid their annuities to the British and are not recouped for the amount they have paid and that that thereby they are bearing the whole cost of the economic war. I would be surprised if the Minister did not feel sympathetic towards that suggestion. If he is sure of his ground that he has a moral as well as a legal right to collect the annuities not withstanding what is happening in connection with British tariffs, he might not be afraid to put that to the test of an inquiry and I am sure that every fair-minded man in the country would abide by the decision of that inquiry. I put it to Deputy Donnelly, who has talked so much here about conspiracies against paying lawful debts, is not that a fair suggestion and a fair way out of this position to have the Minister take steps to have a tribunal set up to inquire into the case made by the farmers that they have already paid and discharged their full obligations on foot of the land annuities through the tariffs they have paid the British? The Deputy will not accept that as a reasonable suggestion. Well, the Deputy having spoken, I suppose he cannot speak again but I would like to hear the Minister on that particular point. Will he consider or entertain that suggestion? If he has a good case there is nothing for him to fear through carrying out the suggestion. If he has a bad case, and I am sure he has a bad case, I know he will funk it. It will be a test of the Minister's sincerity if he will adopt that suggestion. If the Minister is afraid that the findings would be against him he will not adopt them. If he is satisfied that the findings will be for him, he may.

As the whole country by a majority supports the economic war, I am quite satisfied farmers will have no grievance if they are forced to pay annuities to the Minister's Department, if the Minister sets up a tribunal to consider the farmers' case and that tribunal finds against the farmers. But if the Minister will not set up a tribunal, then he is afraid of the issue and he feels that he is not on solid ground in collecting those annuities.

Comment on this

I cannot concede that Deputy Belton's appeal for a tribunal to consider what has been enacted already by the Dáil in the matter of the land annuities is a proper subject for debate on this Estimate. But I suggest to the Deputy that there is no demand whatever for the setting up of any such tribunal. There is only a very small number of farmers objecting to pay annuities. The overwhelming majority of the farmers are satisfied to pay their annuities.

Comment on this

Might I be allowed to correct Deputy Moore on that matter? None of the farmers are objecting to pay their annuities, but they are unable to pay them.

Comment on this

We have here very unexpected support for my contention that the farmers are willing to pay their annuities.

Comment on this

What I have said is, that the farmers are quite unable to pay them.

Comment on this

At any rate I think the great bulk of the farmers are quite anxious to pay their annuities directly to the State, knowing that the titles to their farms would be very poor titles if they did not pay their annuities. Even if there were no other reason but that, the farmers would want to pay their annuities. The Deputy knows that during the period when the Government decided not to collect annuities, quite a number of farmers insisted upon paying them.

Comment on this

When did the Government decide that the farmers were not to pay their annuities?

Comment on this

In the autumn of 1932.

Comment on this

When they knew they could not enforce the civil bill.

Comment on this

That is an argument. The Deputy asked me a question and I have answered him. During that period I think it will be found in the Land Commission's accounts that very many thousands of pounds were collected from farmers who knew they were under no obligation to pay and that the Government were not asking them to pay.

Comment on this

Then why did the Government receive these moneys?

Comment on this

But I think all that is somewhat out of order on this debate. I only intervened to call attention to the very extraordinary speech we had from Deputy Dillon this evening. That speech was sheer anarchy. Deputy Dillon lashed himself into a fury about the infamy of farmers being expected to fall in with the national policy on the question of agriculture and threatened a tragedy in Ballaghaderreen if anybody attempted to carry out that idea in his part of the country. I submit that therein he was speaking in a most reckless way. He was asserting definitely that while property had its rights, it had no duties whatever, and that each individual farmer in the country was quite entitled to let his land go fallow, to grow any crop he liked; that he had no duty to the public with regard to that land; in fact, that there was no social obligation imposed on him in his title to that land. I think the Deputy was preaching a principle that his colleague, Deputy O'Sullivan, will not support. I would be surprised if any of his colleagues would support it. It is surely not to be asserted at this hour of the day that the farmers as a body are entitled to do what they like with their land regardless of the needs of those who have no land.

Comment on this

I hold we have a right to do with our land what we think is best in the interest of ourselves, our families and the country.

Comment on this

That is very interesting. We have, I am sure, heard very different doctrines from the Opposition. I think I heard Deputy Fitzgerald quote from Papal utterances on that subject, and though I cannot attempt to quote from these utterances myself, I can assert with absolute confidence that in some Encyclicals there is laid down the duty of people of property with regard to their neighbours—the social duty that is imposed with that property, and consequently the duty of those owning land to respect the needs of their neighbours and to comply with what is required from them by the community with regard to the use of that land. Again I say that I believe Deputy Dillon's statement to be absolute anarchy, and that it has no authority whatever behind it. In fact, it is in conflict with the teaching of the Catholic Church.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Dillon, who has come in now, should be told the charges that have been made against him by Deputy Moore.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Unless Deputy Moore gives way to him, Deputy MacEoin has no right to intervene.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon lashed himself into a fury also on the question of agricultural wages. But he gave us no particulars of what rates of wages prevail in neighbouring countries with which we are in competition as regards agricultural produce. I assert that the rate of agricultural wages in this country at present, taking into account the difference in house rent is practically as good all round as the rates of wages in Northern Ireland and in Great Britain.

Comment on this

I see Deputy Norton taking notes.

Comment on this

Would Deputy Moore quote the figures?

Comment on this

I could not, and neither did Deputy Dillon. Deputy Dillon got very angry over the statement of the Parliamentary Secretary for Finance, Deputy Flinn, that any man who would interfere with people in congested districts earning 24/- a week would be torn to pieces. Surely Deputy Dillon was calling attention to a statement that was not altogether flattering to his own Party, because what Deputy Flinn obviously conveyed was that these people never before in their lives had a chance of earning 24/-, and that 24/- a week was such unheard of prosperity to them that anybody interfering with it would certainly have a bad time.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Moore believe that?

Comment on this

Of course, I believe it absolutely. Surely Deputy Dillon, with his knowledge of the people who have been going to England year after year, and who have been working at a wage of 30/- a week, having often to pay for their own accommodation out of that wage, should not have any doubt about the truth of the statements. He, at all events, should not be the one to find fault with a wage of 24/- a week.

Comment on this

I challenge the Deputy's accuracy with regard to the wages obtaining in British agricultural occupations.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy challenge the wage of 30/- in England?

Comment on this

And that the labourers have at the same time to get their accommodation and victuals.

Comment on this

I adhere to my statement. But I say also that from the general human point of view everybody finds fault, not merely with wages of 24/- but of 30/- and even £2, because it is difficult for any family to live on a wage of £2 per week. But, are we not finding fault with human nature and the general incompetence of communities, rather than with the Government or the policy which prevails at the particular moment? Notwithstanding the tremendous capacity for producing wealth that we enjoy, we are in the position and we cannot find a way— no country has yet found a way—of being able to share that wealth so that people will not have to put up with miserable wages and miserable condition of life. I suggest that the Government during the three short years of its existence has made as big an effort to try and overcome that peculiar fault in human nature, as you might call it, as any Government in the world. They have faced that condition and, with regard to the principal features of these bad conditions, they have been successful at all events in showing that improvements can be effected. We had a Government in power, for instance, that thought it could do nothing whatever in regard to a shocking and a big problem in this country—the problem of housing. Then you had a Government that came into power and all of a sudden it was discovered——

Comment on this

Is this in order?

Comment on this

I think it is rather related to the question of wages. I make the point that those who are finding fault with the lower rates of wages for agricultural labour are not merely finding fault with the Government of this country but with the Governments of all countries—finding fault, in fact, with the capacity of human beings to make proper use of the bounty of nature. I do not think I was altogether out of order.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We cannot discuss housing unless it is housing carried out by the Land Commission.

Comment on this

I merely quoted that as an instance; I did not attempt to discuss it generally. The Minister is to be congratulated upon the very great progress that has been made with the division of land. I would suggest to him, however, that there are certain parts in the country which have not yet shared in that development, and that these parts of the country should not be left in the cold. There is a keen demand in many places for the division of land that is at present giving no produce, employing no labour, and that is practically worthless to the community. While the Minister has gone a long way in the past 12 months towards remedying that state of affairs I hope there will be no slacking off, that he will continue that work, and that he will not merely devote himself to areas most in need of such activity, but that he will also attend to other districts which are waiting eagerly for the opportunity of that development.

Comment on this

I think the United Ireland Party and, in particular, the Front Bench of the United Ireland Party, are really being very hardly dealt with in this debate. They are attacked, on the one hand, by Deputy Donnelly and, on the other hand, by Deputy Belton because of their attitude towards the collection of the land annuities. Deputy Donnelly attacks us because he says we have been encouraging the people not to pay; Deputy Belton attacks us because he says we have been encouraging the people to pay.

Comment on this

I do not want to be misrepresented by the Deputy. I knew well what his misrepresentation was going to be; I could see it coming. What I did say was that the Deputy, with other colleagues, went around the country telling the people to pay if they were able. What I say to them is that in the operation of the law nobody can be his own judge; and it cannot be stated that a person is not able to pay until the sheriff goes to his yard and comes back and returns "no goods." That is the operation of the law, and in the eyes of the law such a person is not able to pay. Deputy MacDermot advocated, "Pay if you are able," and "Pay if you are able" means, in Deputy MacDermot's policy, that the sheriff goes and finds no goods; or if he does, you must pay because you are able. If he does not find any goods you need not pay. But the sheriff must not be interrupted, according to Deputy MacDermot.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy MacDermot to continue.

Comment on this

I do not want to be misrepresented—certainly not by Deputy MacDermot.

Comment on this
A Deputy

He was your leader.

Comment on this

He was never my leader. He would lead nothing.

Comment on this

I think the House will recollect having heard every word Deputy Belton has just uttered in his long-winded interruption, not once, but a dozen times in speeches made by him. It remains true that he complained of our having advised people to pay if they could. Our attitude on this subject of the land annuities has been perfectly logical.

I hope I shall live long enough to see the history of the economic war written by Deputy Belton. If such a thing comes to pass it will be a most entertaining work, and will bear a strong resemblance to the well-known literary masterpiece "How Bill Adams Won the Battle of Waterloo." He has the most extraordinary faculty for thinking that any idea which he has succeeded in grasping is an idea that has never occurred to anyone else before. The injustice of calling upon the agricultural people of this country, in effect, to pay their annuities twice or more times instead of once, has been insisted upon by everyone on this side of the House, not only from the very start of the economic war, but by many of us before the economic war started at all. In the General Election of January and February, 1932, I personally pointed out over and over again that that was what the Government policy would lead to; and after the policy had started I pointed out over and over again that that is what it had led to.

Before we know our own minds on the subject of liability for the annuities we have to distinguish between what is morally due and what is legally due. I hold, and have always held, that these annuities are not morally due from the farmer to the present Government, in view of the fact of the economic war and in view of the fact of the British tariffs; but, on the other hand, they are and always have been legally due, and I am not prepared to advise the people of this country to resist the laws of this country, passed by their own Parliament, merely because they are unjust laws. Is that position clear or not?

Comment on this

You supported it.

Comment on this

We will come to that. Deputy Donnelly again has attempted to make the case that we have advised the people to break and to disregard the law. All that Deputy Donnelly had to support that statement was the hoary old allusion to a speech by Deputy Minch, which Deputy Minch has since withdrawn in this House as regards that part of it, and which speech, so far as that part of it is concerned, has been repudiated by this Party as a whole. While I do not want to carry this discussion too far afield—and I know that it has been carried too far afield already—I am compelled, by the remarks Deputy Donnelly has made, to repeat that this Party, as it is now constituted, and the individuals who now compose it before they were members of it, missed an opportunity that could not be surpassed for throwing this country into chaos, and we would have done it had we not realised that it would be morally wrong to do so, because it would have meant the destruction of the country and because it would have meant throwing the country back into the abyss out of which we had so recently come, and would have meant the justification of everything that was done by people calling themselves the I.R.A. or any other people who claim the right to resist the laws of our Parliament by force. That is a perfectly clear and logical position.

If Deputy Belton is under the impression now, or if he ever was under the impression, that the land annuities were not legally due to the present Government, it passes the wit of man to conceive a good reason for his having paid them. If Deputy Belton merely means that they were not morally due we are agreed about that. If that is the case, we are all agreed about it, and we are agreed about it on the ground that was discovered long before Deputy Belton discovered it; that is, that the effect of the economic war was to call upon the farmers to pay their annuities many times over. The fact, however, that it is morally wrong to collect the annuities, would not mean that it would be morally right to resist the payment of the annuities.

Comment on this

Then, logically, the Deputy supports what is going on in Fermoy?

Comment on this

Nonsense! That is absolute nonsense. I completely disapprove of the action of the Government in exacting these moneys.

Comment on this

Are they not acting legally?

Comment on this

Certainly they are acting legally. If the law with regard to sheriff's seizures proves to be as they say it is, they are acting legally but I understand that there is an action before the High Court at present which may upset the powers which they believe they possess in connection with the sheriff. I am not capable of deciding upon that. Assuming, however, that they are in the right about the law in that matter, it none the less remains true, in my opinion, that they are acting outrageously in collecting these moneys from the unfortunate people whose sustenance they have destroyed. It is not fair to say that it is quite all right for them to do it as long as the people have cattle on which the sheriff can distrain. These cattle represent the only capital that is left of the Irish agricultural industry. In seizing these cattle, you are destroying the future of these people. They cannot make an income now. You are destroying the possibility of their ever making an income by taking away everything they have got, and you are doing it in face of the fact that it is your own policy which has brought about a situation in which, in effect, they are called upon to pay the rent of their land many times over. We shall continue always to urge as strongly as possible that the Government should drop that policy and do justice to the farmers. In the meantime, I think that any fair-minded Deputy on that side of the House ought to admit that, to use an American expression, we on this side have leant over backwards to encourage respect for the law and to discourage anarchy. Despite Deputy Belton's reproaches, I do not repent in the least anything that I have done to inspire respect for law, because, God knows, respect for the law is a thing that is sadly needed in this country.

Comment on this

If that is so, the Deputy must be in favour of the seizures.

Comment on this

Is there any Deputy in the House who fails to see the absurdity of Deputy Belton's remark? It is time that we had enough logic——

Comment on this

——to realise that although a law may be bad and unjust, it may yet be the duty of a God-fearing, law-abiding citizen to obey it. Is not that a plain point? It is the point I put to the House.

Comment on this

I am more tempted to intervene in this debate by some of the statements made by Deputies in the course of the discussion than by anything else. Deputy Belton, of course, has been most refreshing here this evening.

Comment on this

One could not help having a certain amount of admiration for Deputy Belton now that he has got back into that delightful isolation which enables him to find fault with all the Parties of which he has been a member. However, hearing the pleasantries between himself and Deputy MacDermot, one wonders what kind of a Party Fine Gael was when Deputies Belton and MacDermot were both members of the same Party. At any rate, we got a glimpse through the curtains this evening of what it must have been like, and I am inclined to think that there is much more than a mere chip-breaking, as Deputy Cosgrave would call it, in the Party. Deputy Belton delivered himself of the philosophy that the farmer is not legally liable to pay the land annuities, but although he spent 40 minutes in a contribution to this House, never once did he tell us on what his argument was founded. Probably his case resides in a contention that, because the British Government is collecting bounties and tariffs on our agricultural produce, the farmer is not legally liable to pay the annuities to this Government.

Comment on this

I did not say that they were not legally due. I said that they were not morally due.

Comment on this

Very well, let us take it that the Deputy's case is that they are not morally due. The Deputy has a short memory, however. I remember, in the merry days of 1926, when the Deputy was down in Rathcoole, and I remember him telling the Cumann na nGaedheal Government of the day that the eyes of the whole community were on that Government to see whether they were willing to continue to export the land annuities to Great Britain. I remember the Deputy eloquently advocating in a hall in Rathcoole—in fact, it was in the District Court Hall—that the land annuities should not be exported to Great Britain.

Comment on this

Well, what is wrong with that?

Comment on this

There is nothing wrong with it. As a matter of fact it is a perfectly sensible policy. That is my point.

Comment on this

Did I say anything else?

Comment on this

Yes, plenty, but nothing contrary to that.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Would the Deputies kindly speak to the Chair and not to one another?

Comment on this

I am sorry, Sir. Deputy Belton, apparently, was so innocent then that he never even contemplated the possibility of some economic or military reprisal by England if she found that she was not to be able to collect these payments with the same ease as in the past. That was Deputy Belton's attitude at that time, but because England now puts levies and brigands' tributes on our produce going into Britain, Deputy Belton says that the farmers are not morally bound to pay them to this Government. There was no such suggestion, however, in the speech he made at Rathcoole. The subject of his speech at Rathcoole was: "Hold on to the land annuities. They belong legally, morally and historically to the people of Ireland." I remember the Deputy using very threatening language that night to a member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government if that member dared to suggest supporting the payment of these annuities.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton is depending on hearsay now. He was not there.

Comment on this

The facts can easily be found out. On that occasion, however, Deputy Belton delivered himself of another speech.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I would remind the Deputy that it is not Deputy Belton's administration——

Comment on this

God forbid!

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

——or Deputy Belton's opinions that we are discussing now. We are discussing the administration of the Department of the Minister for Lands.

Comment on this

But, Sir, Deputy Belton urged to-night that agriculture did not pay, and surely, Sir, I am entitled, in all reason, to spend a few moments dealing with that contention.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I would remind the Deputy that I have already given him quite a few moments.

Comment on this

The Deputy cannot know anything about it.

Comment on this

Well, you do not represent the farmers in any case.

Comment on this

I represent more than the Deputy does.

Comment on this

In 1926, Deputy Belton was holding forth and urging that the country should grow more and still more corn.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

And now, when the country is adopting the policy which Deputy Belton advocated in 1926, Deputy Belton says it does not pay to grow corn.

Comment on this

The question of growing corn or the Government's general agricultural policy does not arise on this Estimate and I did not deal with it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is quite right.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Deputy mistakes the growing of corn for the payment of land annuities.

Comment on this

The Deputy had a fairly good innings in respect of the Government's agricultural policy——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Belton endeavoured to traverse Government policy in respect of agriculture and I did not allow him.

Comment on this

And his past and my past!

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow Deputy Norton to discuss what I did not allow Deputy Belton to discuss.

Comment on this

There are some pasts which cannot be penetrated.

Comment on this

Under your ruling, Sir. I will pass from Deputy Belton's viewpoint in 1926, asking the House, in doing so, to mark the fact that he then advocated the retention of the land annuities and the growing of more corn.

Comment on this

I did. "Speed the plough"—do you remember that?

Comment on this

I remember your being defeated as a speed the plough candidate. The Deputy told us this evening that he believed the farmers should stand together and that if the farmers did stand together, they would make sure that this Government did not collect the land annuities. It is not so long ago since Deputy Belton, with Deputy MacDermot, was telling us that all the farmers were standing together within the Fine Gael Party. Have they all left now with Deputy Belton? Or are they still in that Pary and have they disowned Deputy Belton? If Deputy Belton's statement some months ago that they were all in the Fine Gael Party is true, it seems rather strange that Deputy Belton should now complain that they are not in the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this

They joined the Labour Party.

Comment on this

We will consider application from some but not from others.

Comment on this

They are very scaree, I am afraid.

Comment on this

This evening, Deputy Dillon delivered himself of his usual hysterical tirade against the Labour Party. It was the kind of tirade which in this House is becoming associated with Deputy Dillon. He accused the Labour Party of being responsible for the low rates of wages paid to agricultural workers. I should like to ask Deputy Dillon to face up to a few facts in connection with the position. In what way does Deputy Dillon suggest the Labour Party is responsible for the low rates of wages paid to agricultural workers? He can plead, of course, that because we supported the retention of the land annuities in this country, all the consequences of that have flowed from the retention of the land annuities. He may say that as a result of the retention of the land annuities, punitive tariffs have been imposed on our agricultural produce by Britain, and, as a consequence, the farmer here has been severely hit by the resulting fall in the price of live stock.

Comment on this

Pursue that now.

Comment on this

Have we not got the endorsement of the Fine Gael Party for the retention of the land annuities here?

Comment on this

Deputy MacDermot says "No," but long before Deputy MacDermot became the prominent leader of the Fine Gael Party that he appears to be to-day, we had General O'Duffy, the titular leader of that Party, proclaiming, at a meeting in the County Monaghan, that no future Government in this country would pay the land annuities to Britain. Is it denied that that speech was made?

Comment on this

Is it denied that it was contradicted?

Comment on this

What speech did General O'Duffy make that he did not contradict?

Comment on this

What does it matter at the moment, anyway?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy want to forget all the other ghosts that veered around the Party? We have the endorsement by a former leader of the Fine Gael Party that the retention of the land annuities in this country is fully justified. He held the confidence of the Party when he said this——

Comment on this

He did not say that, either.

Comment on this

——and held it for quite a while after making that speech. It may, of course, be, that, as a result of making that speech, the resignation he did not submit was accepted, but the fact remains, at all events, that, speaking in the name of the Fine Gael Party, he said that no future Government in this country would export the land annuities to Britain. That is the viewpoint clearly expressed by the then leader of the Party.

Comment on this

Quite true.

Comment on this

Even Deputy Belton supports me in that contention. Is it suggested, therefore, that we should continue to export the land annuities to Britain in order to rehabilitate our farmers in the British market in respect of live stock, even though a majority of the people of this country have declared that the land annuities are neither legally, morally nor historically due? The Party opposite had an opportunity in 1933 of asking the people to elect them so that they might, as Deputy Cosgrave suggested, get a settlement within three days, but notwithstanding the promised settlement within three days, notwithstanding the fact that these very attractive markets in Great Britain were to be reopened to our farmers in respect of their live stock, the people of the country, farmers included, did not believe that the Party opposite could get a settlement within three days or, if they did, they were very suspicious of the kinds of settlement the Party opposite bring back from Britain. Apart from live stock, which is admittedly being severely hit by the British tariffs——

Comment on this

Keep to it.

Comment on this

——because of the fact that Britain is levying a highway man's tribute on our agricultural produce——

Comment on this

And our Government a highwayman's tribute on the farmer.

Comment on this

——will Deputy Dillon deny that the price of other agricultural produce which is produced here is better than the world price which can be got for that produce in Britain or elsewhere? Is it denied that the price of wheat to-day is better than the world price?

Comment on this

Is this not carrying us rather far from the subject?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is, of course. Deputy Norton is fond of the bad habit of following the examples other speakers endeavoured to set. He is traversing the Government's general policy. He will have to come down to the Estimate before us.

Comment on this

I could not follow these bad examples unless they were set.

Comment on this

I am only replying to statements made in the course of the debate.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think the Chair said that bad examples were endeavoured to be set.

Comment on this

The fact remains that Deputy Dillon, in the course of his speech this evening, suggested that the Labour Party was responsible for the low rates of wages paid to agricultural workers.

Comment on this

He apparently bases that contention on the fact that we supported the retention of the land annuities here. I submit, Sir, that this is in order on the Land Commission Estimate. We did support the retention of the land annuities here, and we will continue to support the retention of the land annuities here, and I believe that the majority of the people of this country will continue to support the retention of these moneys in this country.

Comment on this

Would Deputy Norton allow me to put one matter to him? He is using a very peculiar phrase. He is talking about the retention of these moneys here. I have before me a speech made a few nights ago in this House by President de Valera, and he does not seem to give quite the same point of view as Deputy Norton. He says:—

"Undoubtedly, these moneys or their equivalent are being extracted from us. They are being extracted up to the present in, perhaps, a way that hurts even more than direct payment would hurt. I am willing to go that far, and to say that the dislocation and interference is probably heavier for the moment...."

Comment on this

Of course, I am not responsible for the speeches made by the President.

Comment on this

Nor am I responsible for the speeches made by Deputy MacDermot. I suggest that what is taking place is that the land annuities, as land annuities, are being retained here, and that, as a punishment for their retention here, Britain is imposing punitive tariffs upon our agricultural produce. Because we have advocated the retention of those moneys here, to be used for the benefit of our own people, we are accused by Deputy Dillon of standing for a low rate of wages for agricultural workers. I suggest that those statements are quite contrary to the facts of the situation.

Comment on this

Well, nobody will believe you.

Comment on this

Nobody who wants to believe the contrary will believe me. The retention of the land annuities here has been fully endorsed by the people at two elections.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And the Chair submits that it has been fully discussed in this House.

Comment on this

Let him go on.

Comment on this

I am answering a number of points which have been raised in the course of this discussion.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

All right.

Comment on this

And I want to point out to Deputy Dillon that it is too late now for him and his Party, having been defeated at two elections and at the local elections, to wail about the annuities not being sent to Britain.

Comment on this

They are being sent to Britain.

Comment on this

They are not being sent to Britain.

Comment on this

President de Valera says they are.

Comment on this

On a point of order,——

Comment on this

I can dispose of all this——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On a point of order.

Comment on this

I submit that the Deputy is carrying us a good deal further afield than we have been up to the present. You, Sir, were here in the Chair and heard Deputy Dillon's speech for yourself. The Deputy is now purporting to answer Deputy Dillon and not anybody else, and I suggest that he is going much further afield than he is justified in doing.

Comment on this