Committee on Finance. - Vote No. 54—Lands.
Contributions 318–461 of 461. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
On a further point of order, if Deputy Norton travels so far afield, I shall have great pleasure in exercising my rights to make a second speech of enormous length in answer to him. I shall travel over the whole story of the economic war.
Comment on this
Rather than inflict that horrible outrage on the House in the form of another speech from Deputy Dillon, I am inclined to leave the matter where it is.
Comment on this
I think, Sir, I am entitled to deal with the point which has been raised by Deputy MacDermot. He said that his Party have not advocated the non-payment of land annuities. Deputy MacDermot tries to——
Comment on this
I do not question that, but Deputy MacDermot is obviously unfair when, after raising the matter himself, he now tries to prevent any reply being made, because he knows that the reply will tear the whole foundations from under his case.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I am not in the least afraid of any possible reply which the Deputy can make. As a matter of fact I spoke for five minutes, in answer to a violent joint attack by Deputy Donnelly and Deputy Belton on this front bench here, for our alleged attitude with regard to payment of the annuities. If the matter is going to be opened up again, there is no reason why we should not all have a lot more to say about it.
Comment on this
I am prepared to hear the Deputy replying to the statement made as briefly as the statement.
Comment on this
Deputy MacDermot wanted to suggest this evening that his Party had not advocated non-payment of the land annuities. I say that in the face of the facts a statement of that kind is downright hypocrisy. Deputy MacDermot tried to run away from the fact that Deputy Minch in Monasterevan advocated non-payment of the land annuities. Deputy Minch went to Monasterevan in 1933 and said he had advised the farmers last year not to pay the annuities, and his advice to them was the same now— showing his consistency. Over two years he had advised the farmers not to pay their annuities. Deputy MacDermot tries to dismiss that speech of Deputy Minch by saying that it was a hoary old speech which Deputy Minch had made.
Comment on this
That is not all I said. I said that Deputy Minch had withdrawn that point of view in this House, which he had.
Comment on this
I had not heard of the withdrawal before, but I am glad in any case that Deputy Minch has seen fit to withdraw a speech of that kind. But there are other people who made speeches of that nature. Ex-Deputy Heffernan, the ex-Parliamentary Secretary, speaking at Clonmel, used those words.
Comment on this
——by any stretch of imagination an occupant of these benches at the present time. If we are to be called to account for the observations of everybody throughout the country, who may not even have been a member of our Party at the time, where will we end?
Comment on this
Speaking at a Party meeting, as reported and as not contradicted, he used those words:
"He, therefore, said to the farmers, ‘Do not pay'. He knew most of them would not pay, because they could not, but to those few who could, he said, ‘Do not pay'."
There is the element of responsibility that is associated with the Party opposite, advising the people not to pay their land annuities to the Irish Government.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy not aware that I have made speeches in Clonmel in 1932 and since, and in every speech I did make in Clonmel I took exactly the opposite line to that which he alleges Deputy Heffernan took.
Comment on this
I would like to say to Deputy Norton that I was associated with the Farmers' Party since 1932 and I never heard ex-Deputy Heffernan make that speech in Clonmel.
Comment on this
I will hand the cutting to the Deputy, and see if he can make anything more out of it. But there is clear advice.
Comment on this
Bad advice. It is like what Deputy Kelly said about personation. It was not the Fianna Fáil view he expressed on that occasion.
Comment on this
There is clear evidence —evidence through its supporters—and Mr. Heffernan was no chicken in the Party opposite. He was at one time the leader of a Farmers' Party in this House and, like Deputy MacDermot's Farmers' Party, it was duly swallowed up by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. Mr. Heffernan knows perfectly well what he is talking about. We have, therefore, the clearest possible evidence, even if the jails in the country do not supply it, that the Party opposite have been engaged in a conspiracy to advise the people not to pay land annuities to an Irish Government. That cannot be denied.
Comment on this
I will withdraw from the House. The unfortunate people in the country are being robbed and plundered.
Deputy O'Leary then withdrew.
Comment on this
There is ample evidence to convince anybody that so far as the Party opposite are concerned they have been engaged in that conspiracy.
Comment on this
I propose to pass from that to a speech made by Deputy Moore. Deputy Moore stated that while he had no information on the subject, he believed the rates of wages of agricultural workers here were as high as in Great Britain. It is a pity the Deputy had not some information on the matter because he could have ascertained that under the Agricultural Wages Board which operates in Great Britain there is a minimum wage of 31/- a week paid to agricultural workers. I would like to ask the Deputy or the Minister for Lands if there is any county in the Free State where 31/- a week is paid to agricultural workers. Far from a wage of 31/- being paid to them, we find that under the Department of Lands a wage of 22/- a week is being paid in Offaly to forestry workers, while the rates of wages paid on forestry schemes in neighbouring counties is 28/-. There is not even an attempt at justification of the reduction of wages of forestry workers to 22/-. The rate of 24/- paid on minor relief schemes, indefensible as it is, is sought to be justified on the ground that it is relief work, helping the local people, providing accommodation roads and helping to clean up drains. But forestry work such as is undertaken in Offaly cannot be described as a relief scheme, cannot be put into the same category as a minor relief scheme. Thus we find the Department of Lands standing over a wage of 22/- in Offaly, a rate impossible to defend on any standard which could commend itself to a civilised community.
I think a rate of wages of the kind paid by the Department of Lands is a disgraceful headline for a Government Department to set to private employers, and local authorities could hardly be blamed, much as one might disagree with them, if, after that notoriously bad example set by a Government Department, they followed by paying the same objectionable rate of wages. Does the Minister seriously contend that a wage of 22/- a week can possibly sustain a man charged before the law with maintenance of a wife and four or five children? Why, it is humanly impossible for a man to maintain a wife and four or five children on a starvation wage of 22/-. No single man could possibly maintain himself in reasonable decency and comfort on a wage of 22/- a week. The State contends that that rate compares with the local rate paid to agricultural workers. That is a very inadequate yard-stick to use to measure the remuneration which State employees are entitled to expect. Everybody knows the circumstances which result in wages in the agricultural industry being low. But the State ought not to enter into competition with persons who pay low rates of wages in agriculture and try to secure workers at these low rates. The State ought to base its wage policy on some finer and more civilised plane.
Is it seriously believed in the Department that it is possible for a man to maintain a wife and four children on 22/- a week? I suggest the Minister ought to get some of the people responsible for standing over a wage of this kind to try to live on it for one week, not to mind trying to live on it for a whole year. The Government ought to be ashamed to have its name associated with that low rate. It is an indefensible rate, a sweating rate, and if it was paid by a private employer it would command the condemnation of every right-thinking person. The State cannot advance the plea often advanced by the private employer, namely, that he has no more resources to pay a higher rate. I do not know on what ground such a low rate of wages can be defended. I suggest to the Minister that in concluding this debate he ought to give an assurance that this wage will be abolished and that rates such as are paid elsewhere will be substituted for this miserable rate of 22/- a week.
The Department of Industry and Commerce, under the Conditions of Employment Bill, hope to be able to level up rates of wages, making the bad employer come into line with the good employer. Is not this a nice example for the private employer when he comes to negotiate with the Department of Industry and Commerce? He will be able to declare that the Department of Lands regards 22/- a week as a living wage in Offaly. Is there any case for a private employer in Offaly paying more than 22/- when the Land Commission sets its hall-mark on that rate and considers it sufficient for the worker? I hope the Minister will remove that blot from the Land Commission. I hope that the existing rate in Offaly will be increased and that never again will we have reason to complain, while this Government is in office, of an attempt to stand over such a miserable rate of wages as 22/- a week.
Comment on this
This debate has ranged over a very wide field, and I do not propose to follow the line adopted by speakers who have gone before me beyond making the comment that it was very good tactics on Deputy Norton's part to attack members of this Party in connection with the policy of the Minister, and that it was also good tactics on the part of Deputy Donnelly to attempt to put some of the responsibility for the situation that exists in the country to-day on our shoulders. It may be true that some person at some time said something that could be construed into a certain action. The only person mentioned was Deputy Minch, and it has been asserted that he withdrew that statement. I want to say here and now that I have been associated with Fine Gael since its inception, and at no time and at no place did I ever hear anybody suggest that land annuities should not be paid. I declare that definitely. I will go further and say that at several public meetings I asserted that the law of the land was such, and that in my opinion it should be obeyed. I recommended my hearers, whether they were Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or I.R.A., to obey the law. We heard Deputy Donnelly say that it lies in our hands to ease the situation, and one begins to wonder exactly what sort of mentality he has or that he thinks the people of the country have if they would fall for stuff like that.
It is true to say that 60 per cent. of the farmers of the country to-day are unable to meet their obligations, and that is due to no small extent-indeed, it is due to a great extent-solely to the economic war. In 1929-30 the President, when he was occupying these benches, told us that the farming community were on the verge of ruin. There is no question about it they were not well off, but no matter how poorly off they were then, they were at least £20,000,000 or £30,000,000 better off than they are to-day. Without anybody telling them whether they should pay or not, there is no doubt about it they are unable to pay. What is happening at the moment is this, that a number of farmers all over the country are paying land annuities, but not paying their shop debts. Agricultural Credit Loan, and other things like that. The Fianna Fáil supporters throughout the country will leave any creditor without payment in order to pay the land annuities. I do not blame them. But they come then to people like myself and say: "I am unable to meet this payment to the Agricultural Credit Corporation, unable to pay this, that or the other account, and I want you to lend me £5 or £2 to pay these, because I had to pay the land annuities." That is the sort of thing that is happening all over the country. How long it can continue I do not know. I believe you are arriving at the time when neither Fianna Fáil nor Fine Gael will be able to pay or have anything left to pay.
It has been said here this evening that Deputy Dillon was extreme in his statement about the seizures at Fermoy. I hope I am not extreme, but I assert that there is a responsibility on the Government if they seize cattle belonging to a person to see that that person gets a just return for the seizure. The law of honesty governs them as well as anybody else. If they take 80 or 90 head of cattle and sell them for a mere trifle and pretend that is just or honest, I tell them that it is not so. It is an outrage and nobody can be too strong in condemnation of that sort of conduct. When the Government agent steps in and buys property that belongs to somebody for a few pounds, not a tenth of its value, does the Government think that it is right to punish these farmers to that extent merely because the farmer at the moment was unable to raise the money? No matter what the circumstances were that made the farmer take that line, I think it is an outrage and I think it is very dishonest on the part of the Government or any other person who may be guilty of such conduct. The law of charity demands that restitution should be made to that person. I put it to the Government that they are bound to make restitution just the very same as I would be bound if I bought something from a farmer at a price considerably under its value knowing well at the time that it was value for more. That is the position.
Deputy Donnelly tells us that we should apply to the Land Commission or to the Minister for an extension of time for these farmers. I have on several occasions applied for time on behalf of farmers. I have advised farmers to write direct themselves to the Land Commission. In a number of cases the Land Commission granted a month, or two months' or three months' extension of time, but that is all. In nearly every case the farmer having said he would pay at a certain time had to sell his stock at a loss. He tried to keep his word because he had promised he would pay at a certain date. If that man had been able to keep his cattle a little longer he would have been able to secure a better price for them. In a great number of cases where time was applied for there was a refusal by the Land Commission. I would like to ask the Minister how many people have made application for time for the November-December annuity 1934 and the number who made application in the case of the May-June instalment of 1934? How many of these applications were granted? I would like to know the number of orders that are in the hands of the sheriffs all over the country in the case of people who owe only one or not more than two instalments. How many people have had costs put on them and have always paid up their annuities up to this particular time? I would like to know from the Minister the number of people in that position, the number to whom time has been granted and so on.
Then we have the question of wages paid to workers. Of course Deputy Norton and the Labour leaders spoke with their tongues in their cheeks. There is no question of doubt about it that a difficulty has been created by the reduction of the wages of agricultural labourers in various districts. No matter how they may try to get out of the responsibility for that, the Labour Party have much more responsibility for that than anybody in this country bar the Government. Deputy Norton said further that Britain was levying a brigands' tribute on our agricultural produce into England. I would like to say one word on that. Britain is levying a tribute through the gentlemen's agreement and not because of any such thing as a brigand's tribute at all. It is being paid because of the gentlemen's agreement. It will take a lot of whitewash to wash away that fact. It may have been good business to do certain things but we are paying the land annuities and a good many things along with them through that action of the Government. A Deputy said that Deputy Dillon in the course of his speech has stated that he would allow his land to go fallow. I think it was Deputy Moore said that. What Deputy Dillon said was that he would carry out his agricultural programme and till his land in his own particular way and in the manner he thinks best; that he would not carry out what the Government thought best in view of their want of ability to direct the people of the country how to till their land.
The division of the land is a very important matter. I submit, Sir, that the Minister should see to it that there is no unfairness in the acquisition of the land. There have been some changes made in that respect. I do not know whether there is any truth in them. I would be glad if the Minister would assure the House that the Act is impartially administered in the matter of the inspection and acquisition of land. The sending of notices to people that their land is to be inspected causes a good deal of uneasiness in cases where there is no reason to have it inspected. Country people think that when the inspector is coming it means that the land is going to be acquired. I am perfectly satisfied with the manner in which the land is being divided. As far as I can see, the division has been carried out in a reasonable manner. There may have been some complaints, but in the division of lands you will always have complaints. You cannot satisfy everybody and the Land Commission can only do its best in that respect. I agree with the request that the evicted tenants and their descendants should get a preference when land is being distributed. Land was distributed in Longford recently and there was an applicant whose father had been evicted from that estate 35 or 40 years ago. For some reason or other he did not get a portion of the land. He had a farm with a very small valuation on the very edge of the estate. I do not know what steps have been taken to right that or whether any steps will be taken at some future date. But, as a principle, I would strongly recommend to the Minister that the descendants of evicted tenants, or the evicted tenants themselves, if they are available, should get preference when land is being divided.
The other question is that I think that even under the best of circumstances an economic holding should not be less than £25 or £30 valuation. There has been some change from that. I admit that in certain cases a small additional plot to an uneconomic holder is often of greater value than a larger one; but where the applicant is a good type of farmer who would be able to work a farm it should be brought up to the £25 or £30 valuation level. It is very definite that even in the best of circumstances a farmer finds it very hard to secure a living out of a farm of less valuation than that.
I want again to assure the Minister that the condition of the farmers generally is very serious; that it is true that whether by a brigand's levy, or a gentleman's agreement levy, or whatever it may be, the farmers are paying, and have been paying, twice and three times over every year. The Government should take into consideration the whole circumstances surrounding the agricultural community and take steps to relieve them as far as possible. I admit there are certain people well able to pay the land annuities and they should pay them, because it is the law. But, like everything else, it is a law that the Government can change, and I believe that they should change it at the earliest possible moment. I ask them, in the interests of the people generally and the country at large, to change it for the period of the economic war, which a number of people at the present time maintain is about to be settled.
Comment on this
There are a couple of matters to which I want to draw attention, and the first is the division of land. I want to tell the Minister that a good deal of dissatisfaction exists at the prices the Land Commission have been paying for land. I know where they have offered only £4 an acre, and, in some cases, I understand, £3 an acre. To bring the matter home more clearly to the Minister, I may say that I know of a holding which was valued for probate purposes at £1,000, and in less than 12 months afterwards the Land Commission acquired that at £350. I do not think that is fair. When the Land Commission set out to acquire land they should do justice to everybody concerned. I, for one, can say that in my county I have heard continual complaints that justice has not been done to the farmers whose land has been acquired. It must be remembered that it is not landlords you are dealing with now, but the ordinary tenant farmer who, probably, if he has an outside holding of 40 or 50 acres, has that land acquired by the Land Commission. It might be land for which somebody before him had paid a good price. In justice to everybody, I think the Land Commission should have regard to these circumstances.
I should like to put before the Minister a particular case which I asked the Parliamentary Secretary some time ago to take note of: It is the case of a labouring man who happened to get a legacy of £500, who bought some land from a neighbour and has been living on that land for the last two or three years, tilling it and so on. The Land Commission, however, have absolutely refused to make him a tenant. I put it to the Minister, even if he did wrong in taking the land, that he has got to be made a tenant and that the sooner the misunderstanding is cleared up the better it will be for everybody. The man is entitled to be made a tenant. He has paid money for the land and you cannot put him out of it. I hope that something will be done in the near future to remedy such cases as that. I handed the case over to the Parliamentary Secretary, but the Land Commission said they would not do it, or they could not do it. I think that is unreasonable.
Now, we come to the question of the land annuities. I listened to Deputy Donnelly for a good while, and he said that we, on this side of the House, have responsibility for the whole thing. He appealed to us to stop the conspiracy that exists amongst the farming community in connection with the land annuities. Deputy Moore stated that only a very small percentage of the farmers objected to paying the land annuities, and that, in fact, so far as he knew the situation, farmers were paying even in spite of the Government. Which of them is right?
I should like to point out to the Minister that a very serious situation is arising in the country at present. It was brought home very vividly to me about a fortnight ago when the agents of the Government arrived at a small farmer's place about a quarter of a mile from my home equipped with lorries and everything else. They saw that farmer's stock, which consisted of five little calves and five cows together with a pony. They gave him two hours to find the money. He appealed to me, but I said I did not want any stock as I had no room for them. Then he appealed to another farmer. The upshot of it was that he has to sell three of his yearlings for £6, because if he was not able to meet the demand of the sheriff in two hours they would have seized his stock and taken them to Castlemorris, and he would not be able to find the money to buy them back. He told me that three years ago he got from £7 to £8 apiece for similar yearlings. It took three of them now to pay his little annuity where one would have done it three years ago. We know, of course, that small farmers and even big farmers do not care their stock in the way they used to a few years ago when they were realising a fair price. I have heard it stated here that the Land Commission is very lenient. I have not heard that statement before in connection with that Department. Have they been lenient in the case of a poor man like that? I have heard Deputy Norton here to-night lashing the Government in connection with the wages paid for work on forestry and everything else, but it would be well for people to realise what the position of that individual farmer is. He has no butter in the morning, or meat for his dinner from one end of the week to another. He cannot have it. Mind you, that is a situation that is occurring in many a farm and many a homestead all over the country at the present time. I may tell the Minister that the man concerned would be the last man to come to me to seek my influence with the Government or with the Land Commission in order to stop that seizure, and I want to tell the Minister, candidly, that I thought that that man was the one small farmer in the district who would be in a position to meet his obligations in connection with the land annuities. There was nothing about that case in the Press. Yet, we have Deputies standing up here and trying to persuade us that we have been trying to put the whole country into turmoil and chaos by advocating the non-payment of land annuities. I want to say that any man, whether from this side of the House or the other side of the House—even a Minister—who will go down through the country and advocate a policy of non-payment of annuities at the present time, will get no support. Such a man never did get any support and he will not get it now.
It is idle to be talking of conspiracy in connection with the non-payment of annuities. Of course, we know that it is only natural, when farmers are in a difficult position, that some farmers will support their neighbours. They have done it in the past. It is only history repeating itself. I know that in the very place in which this incident to which I refer occurred—at least not a mile from it—in the old days one of the greatest battles in connection with the history of landlordism took place, when bailiffs and police were stoned there; and these stories are told to this day in that particular district, of which, I may say, I am not a native. I am only mentioning these things with the object of trying to bring home to the Minister and to the Fianna Fáil Party the seriousness of the whole situation. We have, of course, the usual cross-fire to-night between Deputy Belton and other Deputies. I know that Deputy Belton's whole object was to try to pour ridicule on Deputy MacDermot. That was the whole idea. It is not alone now, but in letters to the Press, that Deputy Belton says that if the farmers had only stood by Deputy Belton, and followed his advice, they would have the fight won by now. That statement is merely ridiculous. I suggest that we should look seriously at the situation. I suggest that we should ask ourselves whether or not the case I am making here to-night is correct. Why not analyse it? I heard Deputy Donnelly talking about what the beet industry would do for the country. I understand that there are about 12,000,000 acres of arable land in this country at the present time, and that 50,000 acres would supply our needs in beet. If that is the only portion of the land in this country which can be made a paying proposition, what about the rest of it? I myself grow wheat and beet, and I know something about the growing of beet, and I know that what a farmer will get out of it will not put him in a position to pay his land annuities unless he is a farmer that can put his whole farm into that. If we were all to do that, however, there would certainly be a curtailment of the acreage under beet, just as there was a curtailment recently under Government policy. This country has got to remember that the wealth of the bulk of the individual farmers is derived from the production of live stock, with very few exceptions. That is borne out by the fact that, when the Government's agents go around the country to collect money from the farming community— to collect the liquid assets—they seize cattle. Yet, some Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches think that it is unpatriotic to have stock at all. They say: "Why don't you till and have wheat and beet?"
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy would put that query to the Minister for Agriculture when the Vote in connection with it comes on.
Comment on this
Well, Sir, there has been so much talk about it, in connection with this Vote, that I am only referring to it briefly. I certainly do not want to prolong the discussion, and I am only putting these few points to this Minister in the hope that even now he will realise the situation. There is one point that I agree with in connection with Deputy Belton's statement. I should like to see some commission or court of inquiry set up to inquire into this whole position. I understood from the Minister that some sort of inquiry had been set up in connection with one side of the matter, but I have not heard of it. All I know is that I can stand over any statement I made here in connection with the position of the farming community in this country. It is idle for Deputies to refer to statements made by ex-Deputy Heffernan. I am not responsible for the statements of every individual supporter or follower of mine through the country, any more than Deputy Davin or any other Deputy is responsible for such statements. It is ridiculous to suggest such a thing. However, I think it is only reasonable and just that the first thing that should be done is to set up some sort of court of inquiry to look into the whole position. The farmers have a grievance, and a very real grievance, because the money undoubtedly has been collected from them. Is it not unjust to collect the money from them again? Unless you want to bring the whole situation in this country into such a condition as none of us would wish to see, it is only reasonable to expect that something should be done in connection with the matter. I have only given a couple of instances. It is possible that, in these cases, the money has been got this time, but, I put it to the Government, will they be able to get it again in these cases, because that is the situation there, and that is the situation that will apply to practically 80 per cent. of the farmers of this country if something is not done to remedy matters.
Comment on this
On a former occasion, when the Land Commission Estimate came before this House, I expressed dissatisfaction at the progress that had been made in connection with the acquisition of land for division. The Minister at that time informed me that it was necessary to await the introduction of the 1933 Land Act: that he was not prepared to pay the price that was hitherto paid for land, and that he would not feel justified in saddling the incoming tenant with a burden he would be unable to bear. I must say that, during the past year, there has been a great quickening of activities in connection with the division of land, and I must say that inspection and acquisition have been carried out at an accelerated speed. Deputy Dillon read out this evening a statement showing the number of acres divided each year from 1926 to 1931. He boasted of the amount of land that the previous Administration divided in these few years. During the past year, in County Meath alone, approximately as many acres have been divided or acquired by the Land Commission as had been divided in any one year from 1926 to 1931 by the former Administration. In his opening statement, the Minister referred to the introduction of the Gaeltacht colony into Meath. We, in Meath, welcome the people from the Gaeltacht. We wish them success in their endeavour to make their homesteads provide the necessaries of life for themselves and their families. They will have the co-operation and the sympathy of the people of Meath in that effort. Already, the social services have been extended to them. Still further facilities will be afforded them. I should, however, like to request the Minister, when introducing further schemes of migration—I understand that he has schemes at present under consideration—to give attention to the internal migration of a number of people from congested areas in Meath. I am quite aware that the policy of the Land Commission is to withhold the settlement of these people until the land in their immediate vicinity is available for division. That may take some time because of the difficulties, legal and otherwise, that confront the Land Commission. I suggest that if the Minister is, in the future, introducing another Gaeltacht colony into Meath, he should, at the same time, institute a colony of migrants from the congested areas in Meath. The land is available. We have nine acres for every man, woman and child in County Meath, including those living in the towns. That will give an idea to Deputies of the amount of land available in Meath. I ask the Minister, when introducing the next Gaeltacht colony, to give sympathetic consideration to the setting up of a colony of Meath residents. These people could be drawn from any of the congested areas that, as the Minister by now is quite aware, exist in County Meath. These people would have been working in the same district previously and I am sure that, if a number of them got holdings in the same area, they would make good. The Minister has promised that he will provide land for all eligible local people where land is being divided and that he will not bring in a colony until such people are provided for. He has carried out that promise and I have no reason to believe that he will not carry it out in the future.
The expenditure upon improvement works during the past year in County Meath provided very useful employment for a number of people. In some instances, it gave employment to people who had received holdings and it provided them with the necessary cash to start out on a new life on these holdings. I hope that the Minister will not be deterred from proceeding with his programme of land division by the remarks made by Deputy Dillon this evening. Deputy Dillon said that he would work his farm as he wished, that he would not adopt the wheat or beet scheme or any of the other schemes put forward by the Government. If Deputy Dillon is utilising his farm to the full and if he is providing the necessary employment, he is quite entitled to work it as he pleases. Under all laws, he is quite entitled to use his farm, in these circumstances, as he wishes and in such manner as is likely to prove most beneficial to him financially. But his statement appeared to be a glorification of the rancher. He said that if there were any farmers losing their land, he would stand in the door for them until he would be blown to pieces. His speech sounded like a defiance of the Minister. In fact, he did defy the Minister to come down and take his land if he was not working it as it should be worked. I hope the Minister will not be deterred from proceeding with his scheme for speeding up the acquisition of land by Deputy Dillon's remarks.
In every area in which I have been, the people are crying out for division of the land. The broad ranches that Deputy Dillon glorifies have not given the necessary amount of employment. It is felt in the country districts that, if the land is not brought under cultivation, the countryside will not be able to carry the population as it will be increased in the near future. The Minister has done a great deal of work during the past year. He has speeded up the acquisition of land and I look forward to the day when all the available land in Meath will be divided amongst the uneconomic holders, the cottage holders, the pre-Truce I.R.A. men who have given good service in the national cause and the landless men who are in a position to work it. The Minister is doing his utmost to have this work brought to a speedy conclusion. I can assure him that the majority of holdings which were divided during the past year are in a very creditable state, indeed. Instead of having land in grass and a number of farms derelict, we have the land brought into tillage. We have new houses being erected and, in fact, the countryside is taking on a different aspect. I appreciate what has been done by the Minister and I trust he will not lose sight of the point to which I alluded regarding the establishment of colonies to consist of the residents of the congested areas in Meath.
Comment on this
I wish to refer first to the collection of the land annuities, which is causing a good deal of turmoil and dissatisfaction and a very bad feeling amongst the people. As I live in the country I know exactly the position the farmers are in. I do not live far away from Castlemorris where a new industry has been established. To a pound, there, day after day, cattle are brought and sold at one-fourth or one-fifth of their value. I know farmers whose cattle were taken and sold in this pound whose position at present is beyond anything I could describe here. These people were left practically without any means of living and their families are practically hungry. It has been stated by some Deputies that we have advocated the non-payment of land annuities. I deny that. We have disputed, and we will continue to dispute, the payment in this way of land annuities to the British Government. We are forced to pay the British Government and then we are forced to pay here. That is what we protest against; that is what we are up against. Until this Government took office the land annuities were paid in full by the farmers, because they had an opportunity of disposing of their cattle and the produce of the land. They had then sufficient money to meet their obligations. The majority of the farmers are now unable to meet their liabilities, or to pay the land annuities. While they were able to do so they paid, but they are now in the position of not being able to pay. We have protested against the collection of the land annuities by the two Governments. We have never protested against the payment of land annuities to the Free State, and we never will. While we are forced to pay them to the British Government, with an additional £1,500,000 to what we were originally paying, as well as a further £2,000,000 to the Free State, we will oppose that.
We have no desire to continue paying land annuities to the British Government. We would much prefer to pay them at home in the Free State. But we are forced to pay the British Government. That situation was not brought about by any action of the farmers. The action of this Government is largely responsible for it. This Government is responsible for the taxation that has been imposed and for money being deducted from the farmer's produce sent to the English market, amounting to between £4,000,000 and £5,000,000. Consequently, I think it is the duty of this Government to relieve us of our obligations for the payment of land annuities here. I look upon the position in this way, that the Government have little or no respect for the farming community. Farmers worked hard in the past and they are prepared to work hard in the future. It is not one or two members of the farmer's family work. Every member of it, from 12 or 13 years of age, helps on the land. As farmers are now in the position of not being able to meet their liabilities, that has been brought about through no fault of theirs. They are being forced to pay land annuities in the Free State after having paid them to the British Government. An appeal that was made on a few occasions to this Government for relief was refused. Farmers asked for relief while the economic dispute is going on and were refused. I look upon the action of the Land Commission in sending out warrants to the sheriffs, and sending sheriffs, bailiffs, harriers and lorries into the homes of the unfortunate farmers to take away the few animals on their farms as open daylight robbery on the part of this Government. I look upon it in that light. It is nothing short of taking away from the people the few cattle or cows with which they wanted to provide themselves with milk or butter and leaving them practically without any means of livelihood.
I do not want to exaggerate the case. I do not want to create any bad feeling amongst the people. God knows it is bad enough. Remember that the ordinary man can stand a certain amount of provocation, and a certain amount of persecution, but I think it has gone to the limit in connection with the seizures from farmers. I would be the last man to advocate anything that would bring about unrest, create bitterness, or be responsible for bloodshed or for murder of any sort. I appeal to this Government to realise that they have gone far enough and that they should bring home their harriers and their lorries and leave the unfortunate farmers alone until the Government puts its own house in order and settles its own affairs. It is not the fault of the farmers that they are unable to meet their liabilities and the land annuities. It is the fault of this Government which has ruined men who were trying to live on the land. Before there is trouble or before feeling gets worse in the country, I ask the Government to withdraw the pressure that is being put upon the farmers. I know how easy it is to create disturbance. It is the last thing I would advocate. I look upon this question in the same way as other farmers who are forced to pay the land annuities twice, or I might say three times, because of the action of a Government that has no respect whatever for the farming community. If they had, they would not send sheriffs and bailiffs out to confiscate the last few animals to be found on the farms, leaving the unfortunate people without any means of living.
What hope is there that for the future the people will be able to meet their liabilities? What hope is there that the land annuities will be collected? There is no hope whatever. Farmers can hardly get sufficient means now to maintain themselves and their families. I appeal to the Land Commission to pull easily, and to take home the lorries and the bailiffs, and to leave the farmers alone so that they may have an opportunity of making a living for themselves and their families. After being forced to pay the annuities to the British Government, whether this Government likes it or not farmers are called upon to pay a second time to their own Government. That is not fair. It is the most unjust action that could be taken by a Government if it wants peace and security. When they were needed in the past the farmers did everything they could to help this country out of its troubles. It seems to me now, that anything they did in the past is forgotten by this Government, which is piling on the taxes day after day. I want to say, before I conclude, that the Government have gone quite far enough with regard to their seizures for land annuities. In the beginning there were only a few people who protested and were not in a position to pay. Now, they are going around to people who cannot possibly pay because the position is far worse, and yet there is no change in the policy of the Government. I see no bright future before the farmers while this Government is in power; in fact, I do not see any prospect for them whatever. We do not want trouble, if we can avoid it, but we have at any rate a right to protest against injustice. Look at the number of unfortunate farmers who are in jail at the present moment because they made an effort to protest against injustice. I will not say anything on that just now. The Government have examples of the injustice that is going on every day and yet they take no notice of it.
Comment on this
I want to call attention to the delay of the Land Commission in the acquisition of certain estates in Mayo. Petitions have been forwarded time and time again to the Land Commission requesting the acquisition of these estates, yet nothing has been done. The first is the estate of the Marquis of Sligo at Westport. It is in the vicinity of the town and there are 700 acres of land there required for the relief of congestion and also, for the purpose of giving allotment to the town tenants in Westport. The owner has time and time again refused the Urban Council of Westport to give permission to use a road going through that estate even when the Minister for Local Government had allotted £10,000 for the repair and improvement of the road. Still the Marquis of Sligo refuses permission. I think it is the duty of the Land Commission, now that they have the power, to take over the whole of that estate with the exception, of course, of the house and its amentities, and give the people an opportunity of getting a road to the sea. At present they have to go by a road a mile and a half longer, up a steep hill, the grade of which is something like one in ten. Deputies will understand how difficult it is to bring merchandise along a road of that nature from the quays of Westport to different parts of the county. This is one of the things necessary for the development of the district and the Land Commission should take it over.
The next estate is that of Lord Oranmore and Browne in the neighbourhood of Claremorris. There is acute congestion especially near Claremorris and Castlemagarrett. Petitions have been sent up time and again but nothing has been done. The moment, of course, a petition is received, an inspector is sent down and he applies the usual poultice, telling the people that something will be done.
The next is the Lambert estate, Rookhill, Claremorris. Three years ago, I forwarded a petition to the Land Commission in connection with this estate. The Land Commission sent down an inspector and did nothing. Two years ago the same thing happened. About a year and a half ago, I sent a letter to the Land Commission telling them the position in respect to that estate. The estate was put up for sale by the owner and a number of people walked in and six or seven bought allotments for about £500 each. That particular matter was brought to the notice of the Land Commission, but the Land Commission waited until the owner got the money into his pocket and then served the usual notice, upon people who purchased, to the effect that they would take over the land from them. The Land Commission has now taken that land at one-third of what these people paid for it. The Land Commission knew all about the negotiations going on and the sale of the estate to the purchasers. I have proof of that and I asked questions at the time. I think it is very unfair to wait all that time until the owner had sold; now the unfortunate purchasers will get about one-third of what they paid. The next matter I want to refer to is the question of vacant holdings in Crossboyne. Quite an agitation is going on there now. These farms have been "driven"; walls have been knocked down; fences damaged, and the whole matter has been brought to the notice of the Land Commission. The owner is dead for some years. I do not know who the owners are now, but the Land Commission knows all about it. They have been asked to take over the land, and one would have thought they would have shown more judgment in respect to this.
Another matter to which I object very seriously is that the Land Commission are leaving people who have estates of 1,000 or 1,500 acres, and not interfering with them, while they have notified tenants whose valuation is probably between £10 and £15 a year and whose land amounts to 25 or 30 acres, that they are going to acquire this land for the relief of congestion. I really think these people must have gone mad. Let me give one case. There is a man named J. Higgins in Claremorris. All the land he has is 24 acres. He was brought up three or four years ago before the judicial commissioner. The Commissioner said he would not interfere, and he really thought the man should have got more land. Now the Land Commission have served another notice upon this man to the effect that they will acquire his land for the relief of congestion, although in the vicinity of his holding there is no congestion. The people in the neighbourhood got land before and there is nothing like an uneconomic holding there.
I would like to know also what is the extent of the grazing lands held by the Land Commission in Mayo. I understand that thousands of acres of such land are held by the Land Commission and let at exorbitant rents. At Ranahard there are two holdings that belonged to persons named Gibbons and Morley. These people have migrated for years. The holdings are let by the Land Commission; they never took any steps to divide that land. I brought the matter before the Land Commission but they will not do anything, and, as I say, there are thousands of acres of grazing land in Mayo in the hands of the Land Commission. They should speed up the division of these lands. The next matter that I want to bring to the notice of the Parliamentary Secretary is this: two years ago the Land Commission sold premises in County Mayo for about £1,400. The house was burned down about three months ago. After the burning, the Land Commission put in a malicious injury claim to the Mayo County Council for £3,000 for the burning of the house, while the person to whom they sold the land put in a claim for £10,000. When the Minister is replying, he might let us know what the Land Commission mean by putting in a claim for £3,000 for premises which they had sold two years ago and for which I suppose they got the money. The people of Mayo are very anxious to get that information. Were they under the impression that the county council would not defend the claim? There is a claim against the Mayo County Council for £13,000 for property which the Land Commission sold for £1,400.
There is little more that I desire to say, but I would urge the Minister to do something in connection with the division of the Sligo and Oranmore Estates and also the Brookhill Estate. Acute congestion exists in the vicinity of the Sligo Estate, near Westport. Similar congestion also exists in the Claremorris district in the vicinity of the Oranmore Estate. I understand that the matter of the Brookhill Estate is before the Land Commission at the moment. I also wish to bring under his notice the necessity for the division of the land in the Hollymount and Kilmaine areas, in the parish of Kilcommon. There are hundreds of acres of land there in the hands of the Land Commission even since the days when the old Congested Districts Board were operating and they have not been divided yet. I think the Land Commission should speed up their division.
Comment on this
I should like to say a word or two on the administration of the Land Commission. I was interested in the Minister's statement to-day on the division of land but, to my mind, land is not being divided as quickly as it might. There is no reason why there should be so much land undivided while there are so many people waiting to make use of that land and put it into commission. I am sure it is known to the Department that in my own county there is a great deal of land that is rotten ripe for distribution. There would not be very much difficulty in finding out the proper titles and in getting it immediately under the control of the Land Commission for distribution among allottees and put into cultivation. I think it was Deputy Kent indicated that there were many farms lying about the country which are not alone a source of loss to the country as a whole, in that they are not in commission, but are also a loss to local authorities because rates cannot be collected on them. There is a fairly large number of such holdings in certain parts of the country, but I am speaking particularly about my own county. There is an opportunity for speeding up the division of what are known as ranches and also an opportunity of putting into commission some of these derelict farms.
I should like to say a word on the matter of how the land is to be distributed and who the allottees should be in the case of two or three farms in the southern portion of Clare, Ardnacrusha and other places, where there are people who are most land hungry, people were brought in from Tipperary and Limerick to take over certain allotments. I know two or three instances within the last month in which this has happened. Although there are uneconomic holders and landless men in the area, people who have been engaged in agriculture all their lives and who are quite competent to manage these places and quite entitled to the land from any standpoint, they are left without that land, to carry on as best they may in a state of semi-distress, whilst other persons are brought in from the neighbouring counties of Tipperary and Limerick and put on these farms. That I am sure is also known to the Land Commission. I suggest that is not the way to tackle the problem of land distribution while there are men on the borders of these estates who are entitled to the land. That is not the way to encourage the people to take an interest in the country.
There is just another matter to which I should like to refer. I do not know whether it has been dealt with to any great extent but it interests me. I was very much surprised to hear the Minister say that the Land Commission had brought only 27 families from the Gaeltacht into County Meath. If that is the way the Land Commission intend to tackle that problem, they had better leave it alone. I had the good fortune or the misfortune to be a member of the Gaeltacht Commission in 1924. We examined that problem from every angle, and whilst we favoured migration into the fat lands of Leinster, we certainly did not envisage the migration of only 27, 28 or 30 families. If there is any idea in the minds of those responsible for Government policy that these 27 families are going to Gaelicise Leinster they are making a mistake. What we had in mind was the migration of a complete communal unit, where you would have everything necessary for a community and where you would have at least 100 families living that community life. We envisaged a community with an Irish-speaking priest, an Irish-speaking doctor and an Irish-speaking teacher. We envisaged the presence of all such people as are necessary to community life—not 25 or 26 families. This is not spreading the language; it is killing the language for these people and the experiment is not going to be a success under such conditions. I do not wish to criticise harshly any experiment which aims at trying to spread the language into the Pale, but this experiment operates in one's mind as not being likely to Gaelicise the Pale. I hope the Minister will consider the question of the speedy division of the land in Clare and also consider the position of allottees. He should remember that there is a sufficient number of allottees in Clare without going into the neighbouring counties for them.
Comment on this
In the interests of a common understanding and perhaps of a better understanding in the Dáil, I would suggest that two words should either be cut out of the Parliamentary vocabulary or else that an official definition of their meaning should be issued. One of these words is "duress" and the other is "ranch" I frequently hear people in public utterances make use of the word "duress" and certainly the meaning I attribute to that word appears to be totally different from the meaning attributed to it by some users of the word. Similarly the word "ranch" is very often bandied around in statements in this House and in political speeches outside but no one or two people appear to have any common point of view as to what area of holding constitutes a ranch. It is quite easy to understand that the agricultural labourer who has an acre of land in the country appears to be a rancher to the person living in a back-room tenement in Dublin and that to the agricultural labourer, with his acre holding, the 50 or 100 acre farmer across the road appears to be a rancher. To the 100 acre farmer, the 200 acre man is a rancher, and in between the whole lot the Land Commission now and then takes a very unfair advantage of the absence of any definition of the word "ranch" or of what class of holding constitutes a ranch.
Deputy Nally referred to a case where the Land Commission, on the plea of relieving congestion, interfered with a 20-acre holding, with a valuation of in or about £10. That may or may not be so. The Deputy may be misinformed, but every one of us knows of comparatively small holdings that have been taken over by the Land Commission under the powers given to them. Deputies advocating the cause of a political Party will refer to those people as ranchers without ever feeling that there is any responsibility on them to give what was the area or the valuation of the holding. Now, with this unsettled state of the public mind with regard to the activities of the Land Commission either just now or in the future, I think we are rapidly approaching the time when there is a definite responsibility on the Land Commission to say that so much land, or land up to a certain valuation, will escape acquisition. One result of the unsettlement with regard to the type of holding that is next going to be attacked will be a very serious deflation in the value of land as a whole. A bank manager would laugh at anybody coming in to him asking for a loan, or to bolster up his credit, by leaving the deeds of even a very valuable holding with the bank at the present moment. Deputy Corry may laugh, but it is very bad national policy to deflate or reduce the value of the nation itself, no matter what Government is in power. You are reducing the capital value of the country itself by doing that, and if land ceases to be an asset in a country such as ours, then nothing else is worth while discussing. Unquestionably land has ceased to be a commodity on which any man can raise money, get an overdraft, or bolster up his credit.
Deputies from the country know that in the past a farmer with a fair bit of a holding, who was working hard and living closely, was never in a position to amass money, but by hard work and close living he was in the position to keep out of debt. The time came when his daughters grew up. He had not put by enough money to facilitate them in getting married, but he was always able to raise money in the bank on the land he held, and that enabled him to make provision for their marriage. Deputies are aware that all over the country at the present time it is regarded as a joke if a man brings into a bank the title deeds of land, free from all incumbrances, and asks to raise money on them. That is due partly to economic circumstances, but to a very great extent it is due to the doubt in the public mind as to what type of holding is going to be raided or acquired compulsorily by the Land Commission. The time has come when we ought to have some clear-cut statement of policy with regard to the valuation of holdings below which exemption can be definitely claimed. The banks will say: "Oh, yes, that land may be free from incumbrances; it may be yours, but can you give us any kind of a business assurance that it is going to be yours this time 12 months?" No farmer can do so, and, therefore, the value of that type of property has been blown sky high.
Comment on this
By the general uncertainty as to the activities of the Land Commission, and by Ministerial statements such as were made by the Minister for Defence in the constituency represented by Deputy Davin and myself. The moment that you have a responsible Government Minister telling his hearers from a public platform and, through the Press, bankers and the world, that their policy is to take a holding off any man who does not work his land according to the way they tell him, well, that is an end to all vested interest in land. It is an end to tenure in land and an end to everything that better men than any of us fought for. It is the end of title. No land war, and no victory at the end of a land war, is worth while if a political chief can stand up and tell the farmers of Ireland, years after the land war was won: "You people will do what you are bid by us or we will take the land off you."
When you have a statement of that kind, what value is there in title? A week after that statement was made, Deputy Davin asks me who was responsible? The Minister I have referred to is one of those who are responsible, and I say it is a serious matter to have the value of that type of property tumbling and tumbling.
Another agency responsible for that is the absurd price which is being offered by the Land Commission. We have only to see the results of appeals to their own Tribunal to get an idea of the way in which prices given by the Land Commission have been increased by the Court of Appeal, to realise that there is something wrong.
Comment on this
Was not that done during the period that the Administration which the Deputy supported was in power?
Comment on this
Deputy Davin is a great catechist. He gets himself into more trouble by his attempts at catechising others than any other member of the House. He is long enough in the House to know that every Deputy, be he good or bad, has the right to make his own speech without these sometimes highly irrelevant and very frequently, decidedly ignorant interruptions.
Comment on this
The Deputy, of course, always comes to the rescue of the people on whom his Party turns its little wooden rifles and fires blank charges at now and then for the benefit of the man outside. A few moments ago we had his leader, Deputy Norton, attacking the Land Commission as if it were the worst and the vilest institution that ever cursed this State. All this is quite in keeping with the play-acting of the Labour Party, and, of course, that must be undone. Some other member of the Party must come in in sackcloth and ashes to make friends again with the Government, to blow a few kisses across the House at them. It would never do if the last impression before a division was taken were to be Deputy Norton's attack on the Government, because then possibly the Party might have to vote against the Government. It is easy to understand Deputy Davin's interruptions. As I was saying, this deliberate devaluation of land is bad national policy. Ministerial pronouncements are responsible; Land Commission activities are responsible, and all around, as a result of both, there is very grave and growing unrest in that particular industry, which, when all is said and done, will always be the mainstay of this country.
There is one point which eclipses all others in public importance at the moment and that is the activity of the Land Commission with regard to unpaid or arrears of land annuities. Let us admit that there is a fairly serious situation growing up in the country with regard to the increased arrears and non-payment of land annuities and let us, there again, try to face up, each one of us, to our own responsibilities for that situation. There is no good in this cheap kind of claptrap that it is a political conspiracy, initiated, spread and fostered by the Political Opposition in Dáil Éireann or by the Fine Gael organisation outside. That is not true; it is silly and groundless. Statements may have been made here and there by an individual here and there. I do not want to go back into even comparatively recent Irish history, but if I did, I could dig out hundreds of thousands of statements, and not only statements, but orders, issued by men who are now Ministers with regard to the non-payment of annuities. Deputy Corry is the one man who swore here in this House that he always meant that the farmers should not pay when the whole Fianna Fáil Party was advocating non-payment.
Comment on this
If the Deputy denies it, I accept his denial, but there was a time when the whole Fianna Fáil Party, in a noisy, bellicose way, advocated the non-payment of land annuities. That has since, in a retrospective way, got a coat of respectability by rather laboured explanations to the effect that, when they were telling the people that their policy was the non-payment of land annuities, they never for one moment meant that the farmer would retain the annuities, but that they meant all the time that the farmer would pay just the same as ever and that they would retain the annuities. But, be that as it may, that campaign, carried on diligently for ten long years, resulted in an accumulation of arrears of land annuities, and if we were all as rigid in our respect for the law as some of us pretend to be now, we should never have condoned illegalities by bringing legislation into this House to remit arrears of land annuities. Understanding human nature as we should, what result could be expected from such a course? Some people had been paying their way in bad times as well as good, living close, depriving their wives and children of some little luxury, some little comfort, in order to keep level with their annuity obligations.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows of course that legislation may not be criticised in discussing this Estimate.
Comment on this
Might I just point out what I am getting at? I am not presuming for one moment to criticise legislation. I am merely replying to charges that were made here to-day in my presence—I was in only for a very little of the debate—to the effect that the non-payment of annuities is due to the policy or statements of this Party.
Comment on this
When the Deputy was not in the House, I prevented two Deputies from speaking for more than five minutes on that topic and I would ask the Deputy not to pursue it too far.
Comment on this
All I can say is that I am sorry you were not in the House all the time because I listened to that for the best part of half an hour. I will not pursue that particular point any further, beyond saying that if the whole of a Party is to be held responsible for the statement of an individual, it is a two-edged sword and the last person in this House who should play with that particular sword is any member of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Arising out of the non-payment of annuities, we have a policy being pursued by the Land Commission which, to my mind, is not only unjust but thoroughly brutal. It is no answer to say, "The law is there; we have a right to do that." Very often, there is a very big difference between having the right to do a thing and being right in exercising that right. The law can be abused as much by excessive, indiscriminate use as by breach of the law itself and the way in which the powers given to the Land Commission are being overused amounts, to my mind, to a very grave abuse. We have, in certain cases, at all events, untold suffering and hardship as a result of the seizures carried out by the Land Commission for non-payment of annuities. We have examples of people seized on for a sum less than the Government owed these people. The Government, whether it was money due for wheat or money due to the farmer for other purposes, have effected seizures for sums less than they, the Government, owed the individual. The Government take their own time in paying, but the Government lose no time in seizing.
At the beginning, it was the comparatively prosperous people who were seized on. Now we have the poorest of the poor being seized on and we have too many stories to disbelieve them all of the amount of suffering and hardship and actual bodily lack of nourishment that followed in the wake of the sheriff and his possé. We have all this campaign of terrorisation carried out, certainly with the powers of the law behind it, but at the time when there is this at least to be said, that the farmers may be excused (1) if they look on that particular payment as being at the moment thoroughly unjust and (2) if they have a reasonable case of inability to pay owing to what they believe is Government action. They say, "The Government interfered with my markets; I cannot get sufficient profits to pay my way; I have got to pay the butcher and the baker and that is all the money I have in the house" and they leave the Land Commission last. Some others place the Land Commission first. They pay their land annuities and let the butcher and the baker go without, but not one of them is able to pay all the demands on him at the present moment. If anyone likes to examine county records, he will see that here is one county at one time with a very bad return for the payment of annuities but a good return for the payment of rates. That county improves the following year in the payment of annuities and slumps in the payment of rates. Anyone who asserts that that state of affairs all over the Free State is due to a political conspiracy is automatically charging every farmer in this State with being at heart a tool for any politician. If we are carrying out the law and looking out for our pound of flesh irrespective of the wound left behind, we have got to be careful with regard to our own legal position. When the powers of seizure were given by law to the Land Commission in order to secure the payment of the annuities, there was also another clause in that particular piece of legislation inserted to protect the farmers. The Land Commission were entitled to seize in order to get the amount of their debt, but the very same law secured, or thought it had secured, that the farmer got the full competitive price for the goods seized. Hence, in the very same piece of legislation, you had it laid down in black and white that the goods would be sold by public auction.
Is there anyone—Minister or Deputy —over there, or in any Party in this House, who is going to honestly assert here or outside that the police ringed area where the beasts are sold constitutes a public auction place, or that that is the kind of arena in which the unfortunate owner is going to get a world competitive price for the goods seized and sold? If the farmer is not getting the market price for the goods sold, then he is not getting his rights in law. He is not getting his rights under the particular Act by virtue of which his goods are seized. There were two parties safeguarded in that legislation—the Land Commission and the farmer. Owing to the way in which the thing is being exercised at the moment only the Land Commission is being looked after, and the farmers' rights are being ignored. In addition to that, we have what appears to be a thoroughly corrupt monopoly established in this State in respect of public auctions. We have an individual or two or three individuals selected by goodness knows whom, toted around the country with a police escort and given a monopoly for the purchase of the seized goods; the general public being kept away by a display of force, while the favoured individual is allowed in to buy the farmers' cattle and other property at one-twentieth or one-fiftieth the market price of those goods.
We have the whole weight and force of the State machine thrown in, in the first place to create a monopoly; in the second place to select the individuals; in the third to exclude the public, who might insist on the farmer getting a fair price for his goods; and in the fourth place to escort that individual and his illgotten stock across the border, where the stock will be sold in the market that our President thanked his God was gone. Knowing that there is no farmer in this country, no matter how poor or hard pressed, who would touch the goods sold at such a type of farce as that—goods which had been seized from a comrade and sold inside a police ring, the public being excluded —we have the whole machinery of State at the disposal of the individual to bring him across the border and escort his cattle out of the country, where he will sell them at the full world price, making a profit of 90 or 95 per cent. on the goods seized for about five per cent. of their price from a farmer in Cork or elsewhere. That is all done in the name of law and in the name of justice. If that is either law or justice, law should be ashamed to march through the country, and justice should be ashamed to hold up its head.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins made several rather strange charges here to-day. The first was that owing to the manner in which the Land Commission were resuming holdings the bank managers were refusing to advance money on land. I wonder did Deputy O'Higgins live up in the clouds for the last 15 or 16 years, or did he actually live in the Free State. Does he not know the actual position in regard to banks, and loans of money on land during the past six or seven years? Is he aware that the bank managers at one period, from you might say 1915 to 1922, went mad; that at any place where a farm was being sold you had two or three bank managers at the side of the bidders saying: "I will stand by you for another £10." That kind of thing went on. Farms were bid up to five times their actual value, owing to the fact that bank managers deliberately came in there and offered to advance money to the man who was buying. I have met hundreds of cases of that description in Cork County, and I am sure that every other Deputy has had the same experience. I have settled dozens of them in which the bank managers were very glad to take 5/- in the £ and get out. One would think that Deputy O'Higgins never heard of a thing called a frozen loan. Was he ever in Tipperary? Did he ever attend any of those meetings held in connection with bank debts— money advanced on land? We have got them all over the country. That is the reason why bank managers at the present day will not advance money on land., Then we have a complaint about the price being paid for land taken over. What was the position in regard to that? You might say that in particular from 1923 onwards the Land Commission took over large quantities of land all over the country at four or five times its actual value. I admit the Land Commission may not be absolutely responsible for it. There was a gentleman at that time at the head of affairs who saw that when an estate was being purchased the State were bled through the nose, and any appeal to that gentleman meant: "Well, if these mere Irish are going to get the land, we will make it worth very little to them."
Comment on this
That was the position and probably Deputy Morrissey knows it as well as I do. I could give you the names of estates in my constituency where people would not take a present of the land during the last ten years because of the annuities that were on it. There is land 11 miles from Cork and seven miles from the nearest railway station and it has 15/- an acre annuity.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I do not wish to enter into the merits or the demerits of the Deputy's charge, but purely on a point of order may I say that a charge of corruption against a judge of this country such as was made by the Deputy should not be made in this House and should not be allowed to go unchallenged.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey has rather aggravated the charge, because the Chair did not know who was being referred to at all. If the Chair had any idea that the person the Deputy was referring to could be identified by anything the Deputy said, the Chair would have interfered and prevented the Deputy making the charge. Deputy Morrissey has rather aggravated it by indicating who the person is.
Comment on this
There was only one person to whom it could apply, on the statements made by the Deputy, only one person who had the power to do what the Deputy charged him with doing. That is quite clear. I am not concerned with the merits or demerits at all.
Comment on this
The point is that estates were taken over at ten times their value, and the Deputy knows it.
Comment on this
I am answering the charges that are being made that estates are now being taken over at one-fourth or one-fifth their value. There has been very little consideration within the last ten years for the man getting 30 or 40 acres. He was expected to rear a family and pay the annuities on the land. I could keep quoting cases, not alone until half-past ten to-night, but all day to-morrow, in connection with estates that were handed over and divided. The unfortunate men got into possession and in several cases the first half year's annuity was paid and there was nothing more paid for seven years until the tenant was turned out.
Comment on this
Has all this arisen under the Minister's administration? If it has not, it is not relevant to this discussion.
Comment on this
I want the Deputy to realise that he will have to relate his remarks to what is before the House or otherwise discontinue.
Comment on this
I will relate it very quickly. It is very easy to relate it. That was the position of affairs when we came into office. The Department of Lands had to remember the derelict holdings thrown on their hands while the gentlemen who owned the estates were in England or Monte Carlo spending the loot, the cash they had got off the Irish people for these estates. Steps had to be taken to see that the people got fair value for the land taken over. Of course the people have a remedy. If they are not satisfied with the price the Land Commission pays, they have the judicial commissioners, a court of appeal, where they can get the price rectified.
It is only nonsense to think that the Land Commission inspector under Deputy Lynch's régime has a completely changed viewpoint as to the value of land. That is only ridiculous and it is equally ridiculous to think that because the court of appeal has been strengthened by putting two experienced men on it—that those people are not going to give a fair value for estates taken over. The only complaint I have to make of the Land Commission is that it seems to have gone to pieces in Cork County. There are thousands of acres lying there idle. With regard to Deputy O'Higgins' statement as to what does constitute a ranch, it is really very hard to decide. I thought 20 acres of land lying idle in a tillage district, with the owner living somewhere else, driving in a number of bullocks every year and leaving them to a herd, would be described as a ranch.
Comment on this
All the inspectors who were in Cork County seem to have been shifted out of it. There seems to be no move made to divide land there. I have sent particulars of thousands of acres in my constituency to the Land Commission, recommending division, and there seems to be no move made.
Comment on this
Plenty of people want land. If you put up a farm for sale you will see the price at which it will go. I suggest the Minister ought to take Cork County in hand and see if he could not divide up the large estates into small holdings. It would be no harm to clear out the ranchers with 1,200 acres, the poor people Deputy O'Higgins referred to with 300 and 600 acres, who will not pay their annuities, and see if we cannot put into possession some people who will be prepared to work the land and pay the annuities. The Minister will soon find that is the best remedy. Deputy O'Higgins talks about the non-payment of annuities and facing up to responsibilities. I am glad to hear that some Deputy on the opposite benches is going to face up to his responsibilities. They were rather late in facing up to them now.
You heard of gentlemen advising their neighbours not to pay, and when their neighbours' cattle are seized they advise them to let the cattle go. But when their turn comes, and when the sheriff drives along, they pull out their cheque books and ask how much is due. The neighbour's 15 cattle are sold for £15, but the cattle belonging to these gentlemen are not going to go. A gentleman in that position makes up his mind to pay. He writes out a cheque for the full amount, with costs, and smiles at the unfortunate dupe whom he leaves in the lurch. You have that kind of thing going on all over the county. There are very few cattle seized in Cork County from certain farmers who pleaded in the first instance that they were unable to pay. I saw some cases last week in my own parish. Cattle were seized from a gentleman who refused to pay a few pounds. Of course he would not demean himself by buying the cattle at the sale. When we hear about reducing the price of cattle and the reduction in the present value of cattle, I wonder what increase in value do the letters L.A.D.A, in big print across a bullock's back, mean? They are printed out in big black type and I expect that means an extra £10 note in the value and that is their assistance to a competitive price. I save seen the gentleman I have mentioned go out and say he would not demean himself by going into the sale to buy. He did not, but he bought from "John Brown" or "Mr. Cash" or whatever they call him. He called up to him afterwards and he bought from him and he was able to pay in full and no bother at all about it. The very individual has a holding which he rents at £5 a year, but he collects from the unfortunate people in the village rents amounting to £5 15s. a week. That is the type of man we have heard about. These are the unfortunate starving wretches who cannot pay. We have had them alluded to in feeling terms by Deputies across the floor.
That campaign was carried out and it was pushed with all the strength of the Fine Gael Party behind it. With the full strength of the Fine Gael Party it failed. One other matter to which I referred was the charge made against me by Deputy O'Higgins in connection with the land annuities. I never asked any man to do what I was not prepared to do myself. During the Tan War I remember farmers coming to me for advice about their rents or annuities. I told any farmer who was paying rent to the landlord not to pay any more, and I stood by him and fought it out and got him 40 per cent. reduction. The friends of some of the Deputies got weak in the knees and settled with the landlord. But in the case of any man who was paying annuities to the Land Commission I advised him to pay them. I carried on the same policy since. Deputy O'Higgins tried to bring in our campaign about the non-payment and the refusal to hand over to Britain £3,000,000 a year that the British were neither legally nor morally entitled to.
Comment on this
Mind your bullocks. We found that position of affairs; we never advised any man not to pay his annuities. I never did anyway. I always paid my own and, whilst I did that, I never advised a man to do what I was not prepared to do myself. I was never one of those who advised their neighbour to allow his cattle to be seized, and then when it came to his own turn afterwards, when his cattle was seized, to take out his cheque and pay for them. That has been our position with regard to the land annuities. I was glad that I was here present to-night when Deputy O'Higgins tried to fasten the old controversy on me. If I said that I would stand by it. Our position with regard to the land annuities is this: we guaranteed to hold the money here and we guaranteed to give the farmer as much as we could out of it. We reduced the land annuities by 50 per cent. Now, in 1931, when there was a big fall in agricultural produce and when the value of our exports had dropped by millions the Leader of the Opposition went across the water and he asked for a reduction of £250,000 in the payment of the land annuities. He was refused that reduction. At the last General Election he was able to offer the farmers a reduction of 50 per cent. on their land annuities. That is a position that I would like someone to explain. How was he able to do it? We are entitled to that information anyway? What guarantee had he that we were to get a reduction of 50 per cent. and that he would be able to give the farmers a reduction of 50 per cent. on their annuities? Who was to pay it? Was he to get it out of the tenants in the labourers' cottages or was he to get it out of the moon? These are things we would like to know. Perhaps An Leas-Cheann Comhairle will say that these things are not in the Estimate so I will not refer to them any more. I would like to know from the Minister what steps he is taking for the acquisition and division of land in Cork County? When is he going to send to Cork the inspectors he removed from the county?
Comment on this
If there is any great unrest in the country at the present moment, and if the reason for that unrest is to be ascertained, attention should be directed to the activities of the Land Commission. Much has been said about the non-payment of land annuities. I want to say here now that we of the Fine Gael Party, never preached the non-payment of land annuities. I do not know any Deputy on our side who did. But the non-payment of land annuities was definitely preached by the Fianna Fáil Party when they were in Opposition. They won one election practically on the policy of the non-payment of land annuities. Deputy Corry denies that it was ever preached by his Party. As a matter of fact, the Cumann na nGaedheal Government allowed them to preach the non-payment and we allowed them to fight an election on it. There was not a single Fianna Fáil member jailed because he preached it. Though President de Valera denied it, there was at least one honest Deputy on the Fianna Fáil side who had the courage to get up in this House and say, "I preached it and I am not ashamed of it." What that Deputy admitted was practised by many other Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party who are much more guilty than he. They are engaged now in their usual programme of prevarication. Deputy Holohan, Deputy Wall, Deputy Fagan and myself are being accused by the Government Party of being lawbreakers and of having enticed people to rebel against the payment of their lawful debts. There has not been one shred of justification for any of these charges. We all admit that the activities of the Land Commission are unpopular. We admit that certain laws passed by this State were unpopular. If there is to be an expression of any unpopularity it must be in two ways, first, vocal expression of dissatisfaction with the Government or with a particular Government Department. If people are to acquiesce in whatever is happening, if they are to submit to it without any expression of their disapproval then the Government are entitled to say that the people are satisfied with what they are doing. The least harmful expression of dissatisfaction is the vocal expression of dissatisfaction. If the farmers of this country and their friends wish, in a peaceable manner, to make vocal their expression of dissatisfaction with the actions of the Government they are perfectly entitled to do it and Deputies here are entitled to act with them in their expression of dissatisfaction. If some Deputies on this side of the House, when the farmers were being persecuted, and in want, went to them and expressed their sympathy with them they broke no law and they were justified in every action they took. The present Minister for Lands can proceed too far along the lines in which he is proceeding. The tenant farmers of this country in other days fought for three F's—fixity of tenure, fair rents and free sale. I said on another occasion in this House what I will repeat now, that the Government seem determined to upset now what the farmers of the country gained in the previous fight, and to substitute this other power, another set of F's, power to fleece, filch and forfeit. It appears that I was a true prophet for, by Heaven, they have fleeced, filched and forfeited. If any Department is responsible for any unrest that is in the country it is the Department of Lands under the Fianna Fáil Government.
I will admit that the present Minister for Lands is perhaps not responsible for that. Some Deputy pointed out earlier in the day that the group of old landlords was substituted by a single landlord — the State. The Minister for Lands is the agent of the State and just as a group of landlords did their dirty work through their agents in the days gone by, in the days of the seizures and persecutions, so the great landlord of to-day, through its agent, the Ministry of Lands, proceeds to outdo the terrorism of the agents of long ago. The Minister for Lands is perhaps ignorant of farming conditions in this country. I believe he is not very well acquainted with the conditions of many of the people who are being persecuted. But his assistant, the Parliamentary Secretary, is well acquainted with the conditions prevailing in the southern districts where there is most trouble and he could easily advise the Minister. I should like to hear the Parliamentary Secretary make the case that there is no justification for the action the tenant farmers are taking at present against being mulcted for the payment of a debt for which at least they can make a moral and just case, if not a legal one, that they have paid the debt twice or thrice and should not be called upon to pay it again, and that even if they are called upon to pay it again, they have not the wherewithal to pay it without inflicting injustice and perhaps hunger on their families.
Remember, that these seizures of stock, while they may enforce payment in one or two instances, are going to leave the Ministry in the position that they will not be able to collect the annuities on a subsequent occasion. Farmers' stock are being seized and sold for nominal sums as was proved in this House. Does the Minister believe that farmers, with their lands denuded of stock, are going to be able to provide the subsequent annuities? If he does, he has more faith in what the land can produce in the way of seizable products than I have. The capacity of many farmers to pay has vanished. Some people have a little stock left, but none of them is overstocked. The people whose cattle are now being seized are going to be understocked and will be unable to pay their subsequent annuities. To the list of people already unable to pay, will be added numerous others who will be unable to pay. Remember that the farmer's power of borrowing is gone. If the Minister seizes his cattle he has no means of replacing them.
I said that the Ministry had created a certain state of affairs, that they were filching, fleecing and forfeiting, and they are. As Deputy O'Higgins said, the farmer is in the perilous position that he does not know whether he is secure in his title or in the possession of his land. Deputy Corry knows as well as I do that no matter what extent of land a farmer may have, no matter how unencumbered he is, he could not borrow £20 unless he had solvent security besides the land at his back. The Fianna Fáil Government have brought the farmers to that pass. The farmer who is in need at present has no way of borrowing except from some commercial friend. They sneered at the man who produced a cheque book. Remember that cheque books, like stock, can diminish in value and that the possession of a cheque book does not mean that its possessor has a lot of money. I have a cheque book and I am willing to give it to any member of the Government for a fair bid. Are there any bidders for my cheque book? Will the Minister offer me anything for my cheque book fully signed? I will give it to him with a heart and a half for a fair bid. There is an offer for the Minister or for any Fianna Fáil Deputy who assumes that I have sufficient means to be able easily to pay my land annuities, my rates, and other individual debts. My cheque book is there for a bid. There are no bidders. A farmer's cheque book is worth nothing.
Comment on this
The Deputy, perhaps, backs more winners than I do, and more losers too. He is backing a loser when he is backing the Ministry in persecuting farmers, as they are persecuting them to-day.
Comment on this
You will not offer your cheque book for sale. There will be unrest in this country as long as the Ministry pursue their present methods. None of us on this side of the House has preached any direct opposition to the law, but if the Government, in administering an unjust law, proceeds to take active measures to administer it, then the probability is, nay the certainty is, that it will be met by people who believe that the law is unjust with active measures of resistance. If people are to be precluded from the ordinary methods of vocal resistance they will adopt methods of active resistance. There is a danger that active resistance to coercive measures will be pursued and neither I nor any other Deputy on this side of the House will be able to stop them, and the people, especially the farmers, are being driven to take those courses.
Are we to stand by when we know farmers are on the verge of destitution —I will give the Minister the names of some of these farmers, if he wishes; I do not want to parade their names in the House, but I can give their names —and see their stock seized when perhaps they are unable to make provision for their families? I know of such cases. I know of a case in which the Land Commission, when one of these unfortunate individuals asked for a little time, referred him to the sheriff. They did not offer clemency, but they let the sheriff extend clemency to him if he liked. We are told here that any needy case will be considered. If all the needy cases were considered, there would be very few land annuities paid, and the Ministry know it, because they know that the great bulk of the farmers at the present time are in need and would find it difficult, if not impossible, to pay their annuities without self-denial and worse than self-denial—denial to their dependents of the necessities that should be provided for them. Practically every member of the Fianna Fáil Party knows that that is true. They will get up and prate about every other subject, but when it comes to the case of the farmer, of his dire necessity, of his circumstances, there is generally a silence on the Government side of the House, with the exception of Deputy Corry, and, perhaps, Deputy Donnelly, who generally keeps very far away from the direct subject and talks all around it.
Comment on this
Whether in this House or Galway or anywhere else, I am prepared to say the same thing.
Comment on this
Well, Sir, we, at least, have the honesty to say anything we have to say in this House and in Galway afterwards. Let them meet us there and we will answer them there just the same as in this House. I want to warn the Ministry that if they proceed in a process of what I can only call by the name another Deputy called it in this House, a process of daylight robbery, then they will have trouble; and they are looking for trouble; and anybody who is subject to that inquisition will have the sympathy of Deputies here, and I am not ashamed to offer such a man my sympathy.
Comment on this
I am tempted to intervene in this debate for two or three reasons: principally, because I want to add my plea and also my protest to that made by Deputy Davin and other members of this Party against the miserably inadequate wage paid to the forestry workers that has been referred to by these speakers. There are a few other reasons also that encourage me to say a word in this Vote. One of these reasons is because of the appeal made earlier this evening by Deputy O'Higgins to the effect that we should face up to realities in examining this whole question. I think Deputy O'Higgins might have added the term "facing up to realities" to the two other terms that he sought to have excluded from the language used in this House, because if there is any term that is very much abused and disregarded it is that term "facing up to realities." I wish that some attempt had been made to do that during the course of this debate to-day, because if this debate was noticeable for anything it was noticeable for the very large degree of irresponsibility that characterised it during the whole of the evening. For instance, we had the tears of Deputy Dillon this evening over the plight of the agricultural labourer—one of the most transparently hypocritical performances we have ever listened to in this House. Although it is not unusual for Deputy Dillon to talk in that strain, he certainly excelled himself this evening. He posed as the friend of the agricultural labourer, for whose plight he had nothing but pity. I seem to be reminded that he did not always fit into the rôle of the good employer that he would like us to believe he was and that he actually stated he was this evening. I seem to remember that, in the not very far distant past, as a result of endeavouring to enforce a wage-cut of £1 a week on his own employees, his employees who picketed his premises were taken into court and prosecuted. For a man to come in here and pose as the advocate of high and good wages after endeavouring to take a substantial slice off the wages of his own employees——
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir, I submit that, unless the Deputy to whom Deputy Murphy is referring is present, he is not in order in making such statements. Deputy Dillon has already informed the House what he pays his agricultural labourers.
Comment on this
I think it is relevant to this extent: that Deputy Dillon referred to the wages paid to agricultural workers and employees of the Land Commission, and I think that Deputy Murphy is entitled to make a reply as to how the Deputy acts in accordance with the statements he makes.
Comment on this
I submit, Sir, with all respect, that Deputy Murphy is referring to Deputy Dillon's agricultural employees, and Deputy Dillon said that he paid to his agricultural labourers no less than 30/- a week. It may be that the Deputy is referring to shop employees.
Comment on this
I know that it is inconvenient to be reminded of this matter, but I do not think a Deputy should be allowed to pose in the manner in which Deputy Dillon endeavoured to pose this evening without something being said about it. The man who would have us believe that he stood for everything that was generous in employment, and who asked us to bear witness to the honesty of his tears for the plight of the agricultural labourer, does not like to be discovered for what he really is—a wage reducer and a man who was the direct cause of invoking the law to prevent his employees asserting their rights, through their Trades Union, to their wages.
Comment on this
I submit, Sir, that if Deputy Murphy wishes to deny that Deputy Dillon pays his agricultural labourers 30/- a week, he should say so like a man, and I submit, with all respect, that if he does not do that, it is out of order.
Comment on this
The Chair does not know to what particular kind of employees Deputy Murphy is referring. The Chair has had no opportunity of finding that out.
Comment on this
The Chair has no means of judging to which particular type of employees Deputy Murphy is referring. The Deputy himself has not made it clear. However, I think that Deputy Murphy should pass from that subject now.
Comment on this
I only intended, Sir, to make that comment on the newfound friends of the poor. Although we are told that the poor do not make any new friends, they made some new friends judging by the speeches this evening. A significant omission from the speeches delivered this evening, noticeably from Deputy Dillon's speech, was the omission of any reference to the fact that very large numbers of men were dismissed from their employment in agriculture because they would not vote in a certain way. I must say that it is all to their credit that, even facing dismissal and the consequences of what dismissal would mean to them, they insisted on voting at the local elections in the way they wanted to vote, and with the consequences to the Party opposite that Deputy Dillon well knows.
Comment on this
I pass from that to refer to what is easily the most disgraceful speech delivered here this evening. I refer to the speech delivered by Deputy Professor O'Sullivan. One would expect from a man who had borne for a very considerable time the responsibilities that Deputy O'Sullivan had some sense of responsibility but, if I could read anything into his speech, it was the most direct incitement to disorder and violence that could possibly be made in this House in the guise of a plea for certain afflicted people in certain areas. Surely, Deputy O'Sullivan must realise that it is a grotesque exaggeration to describe the Minister for Lands and the Land Commission as the successor of the landlords. Nobody who wants to realise the truth of a position of this kind need be reminded that, in the past, rents were put up at will. The landlords were empowered to make what increase from year to year in their rents they desired. Not alone that, but even when the highest rent was charged, there was no security for the tenant. In spite of occasional wild statements to the effect that the title of the tenant is being impaired at the present time, there is no foundation for a statement of that kind. I regret that Deputy O'Sullivan lent himself to a campaign of this kind in the language he did this evening.
If some of the speeches made here this evening mean anything, they afford, in my opinion, the most convincing proof that the campaign against the payment of land annuities has definite political sanction and support from members of this House who ought to be responsible and who ought to be more guarded and deliberate in their utterances. I think it was Deputy O'Sullivan who said that we were sneering at the farmers. We do not sneer at the farmers. Neither do we deny that the present time is one of very considerable difficulty. It does not give us, on this side of the House, any pleasure to know that the farmers are hard pressed. But we do believe that the difficulties of the present time are difficulties that will pass, that the whole position we are going through is a changing and a transitory one and that, in the end, the farmer and the agricultural labourer will be better off than they were before this difficulty arose and better off than they could be if any policy other than that pursued at the present time was being pursued. We have no desire to add to any difficulties that the present situation has caused. But we do desire to express our contempt—there is no other term which would be suitable— for people who would advise their misguided followers to take up a certain course and carefully refrain from following that advice themselves. That is the position. I have heard responsible people, including the Vice-Chairman of the Cork County Council, state at a public meeting of the county council that he had not paid his annuities and would not pay them. When his neighbours, who were less fortunately placed than he was, took that advice literally and acted upon it, that man was in the happy position of being able to run away from that position and meet his liabilities immediately on call from the sheriff.
My experience as regards the making of appeals to the Land Commission in cases of difficulty has been different from the experience that some Deputies state they have had. I have found the Land Commission willing to give time. I think that that is right and I hope they will continue that policy. I have also found the sheriff prepared to carry out that policy. I think it is right that that should be stated here. If people have not taken the trouble to ask the Land Commission to give an extension of time in deserving cases, then they ought not to make statements that, so far as my experience goes, are not in accordance with the facts. It is entirely unfair to suggest that we have any desire to worsen the position of either the farmer or the agricultural labourer. We belong to the people who are referred to and we have more definite interest in the future of the country than some of our critics. One of our critics in this House this evening was told by one of the Deputies who sit on the same bench that his interests in this country were not deeply rooted or very fixed, that it was quite possible for him to pull up his roots, pack his case and leave the country. We are definitely interested in the future of the agricultural labourer. We believe that the agricultural labourer will have better opportunities in the future than he has had in the past. Employment for the agricultural labourer was uncertain and casual not for two or three years but for several years past and wages have been poor and unsatisfactory for a number of years. It is our hope, aim and belief that he will be enabled to get a better wage in future and that, when the difficulties of the present situation shall have passed, as they are bound to pass, he will share in the benefits that will arise. It is futile to argue that it is untrue that certain people advocated non-payment of annuities. Very prominent people are in prison at present for having advocated the non-payment of annuities. They got the opportunity in court of denying that policy and they refused to do so. They got the opportunity of apologising for that policy and they refused to do so.
Comment on this
In court. They were met at the station as conquering heroes when they returned to Cork. They were visited in the prisons and agricultural fixtures, including shows, all over the County Cork, are being suspended as a protest against their imprisonment for advocating the non-payment of annuities. That is very definite proof that this campaign against the payment of annuities is a fact and is a reality. It has been very bad advice for the people who took it. They have had their difficulties and they have paid for them but, surely one can have nothing but contempt for the authors of that campaign, who sheltered behind speeches made at a safe distance, and refused to take any of the consequences that the unfortunate people who followed their advice had to take.
Before I conclude I should like to support what Deputy Corry said about the need for more activity on the part of the Land Commission in examining into and dividing land that may be available in County Cork. It would be well if a good deal more could be done in that direction. Like Deputy Corry I am not in a position to congratulate the Minister upon the activity of his Department in that county. In certain parts of the county the opportunity is not there, but in other parts there are considerable quantities of land available for breaking up. I hope the Minister will look into that at an early date. I hope too that this will be the last occasion we will have to refer here to the miserably inadequate wage paid for forestry work. The State should be a good employer. The State should be honest about it, and at least the claim could be made that the forestry section should pay the same rate of wages as local authorities. In spite of the fact that the Party with which many of our critics have been associated, has been endeavouring to back down the wages paid their employees by local authorities, I ask the Minister not to take that advice and not to continue a policy which is manifestly unfair to the wage earners concerned. The criticisms we have offered are honest. We are not afraid to express our views on low wages and wage reducing whenever the opportunity occurs. That is one of our main functions in this House, and no amount of criticism, ridicule or personal insult, will deter us from doing our duty.
Comment on this
Has the Deputy the courage to repeat the dirty attack he made on me when I was not here?
Comment on this
I will repeat it as soon as I get the opportunity.
Comment on this
Any rat would do the same. I understand that Deputy Murphy made a dirty personal attack on me in my absence.
Comment on this
I heard Deputy Dillon calling attention to what he alleges was a dirty attack by Deputy Murphy. Whatever Deputy Murphy said was said within the rules of order. That is all the Chair is concerned with.
Comment on this
The Chair did not hear any such remark. If it was made, it should not have been made.
Comment on this
I was rather pleased but astonished to hear Deputy Murphy roundly denouncing persons who he suggests made speeches in favour of the non-payment of land annuities. I am sure Deputy Murphy will agree with me on a matter of history, that the very Party that he is now associated with, namely, the Fianna Fáil Party, now the Government, were the first people to proclaim the policy "Pay no land annuities," which afterwards developed into the tail end of the disputes about land annuities and so on. That immoral and dishonest campaign was carried on down the country for a number of months, until such time as we had a general election, and it was on that slogan the present Government came into office. I listened with great interest to what the Minister had to say to-day, and what amazed me was that, while we heard that a big campaign was proceeding against the payment of land annuities, the Minister made the most satisfactory and pleasing announcement that relatively a large sum of money had been collected, and that there remained only a very small moiety of the land annuities to be paid. If the campaign that was talked of was of such large proportions, and was so generally advocated, one would have thought that less than half the land annuities would have been collected. Yet, we have the Minister in authority saying that most of the land annuities had been collected, and that there remained only a very small proportion to be collected. That does not show any disposition on the part of farmers not to pay their rents.
The one thing I feel about the present position is this—and the Government and the Minister must be aware of it—the position regarding the farmers' title to the land. In my view, in a short time the farmers' title will not be worth the paper it is written on. I am sorry Deputy Murphy has left the House. He must be aware that there exists in his own constituency a club, the members of which have already partitioned, to their own satisfaction at any rate, a good deal of the land of farmers in the area. Of course that never came before the Land Commission in the way of a concrete proposal. I am sure if it came before the Land Commission, from what I know of the very courteous and efficient officials there, any such proposal would get short shrift. Remember that that movement must have had its roots in the days when Fianna Fáil were preaching "Pay no annuities," because many humble agricultural labourers were led to believe that, if and when Fianna Fáil became the Government, land in their respective neighbourhoods would be split up and divided amongst landless men and uneconomic holders.
There are other cases in which farmers' title to the land will be challenged, and have been challenged, though perhaps not through the channel of the courts. At a public meeting it was stated that certain farms would be taken over by the Government and distributed amongst landless men, if the present owners did not conform to the policy of the present Government. I deprecate frequent references in this House to farmers with motor cars and cheque books. Have not farmers as good a right to have cheque books as members of the Labour Party or any other Party? Have not farmers as good a right to have motor cars as members of the Labour Party? The fact that a man has a cheque book is not a sign of wonderful wealth. A good deal has been said about the demand for land. I think Deputy O'Sullivan stated that that was a tradition in nearly every agricultural country, and that because there is a great demand by many landless men land has appreciated in value. That will be admitted by everybody except members of the Fianna Fáil Party and the Government. One thing I do not like, no matter what side of the House it comes from, and that is the attempt to shift the blame from Ministers to the officials in the several Departments. My experience of the Land Commission is that whenever I went to the Land Commission and examined into the complaint I had to make with the man in charge, if they found that my statements were correct, then, in cases of hardship relief was always given. I think it only right to pay that tribute to the officials of the Land Commission and I think what I have said is the experience of most Deputies in this House.
I denounce a wage of 21/- per week for workers in the Forestry Department. I cannot understand how it is that the Minister does not take his courage in both hands and pay what is called a living wage to the men in that Department. It is said that agricultural labourers are in receipt of less than 21/- per week. That is true; it cannot be denied. I see that some Deputies shake their heads as if denying that that were true. But it is true. There are many farmers who cannot afford even to pay £1 per week, and there are agricultural labourers working in Cork for less than £1 a week, and no perquisites. We all know cases of that kind. If the Labour Party were sincere they would get up an agitation that would destroy a system of that kind. So long as you have the agricultural industry—the Cinderella of the industries as it is sometimes called—so depressed it follows that everything else in the country is sure to be depressed also. The depression that exists at the moment in the agricultural industry is the cause of the payment of such small wages in the country. But it does not follow that because agriculture is a depressed industry, the Department of Lands should take it as the standard upon which to apportion wages. I appeal to the Minister to see that this is rectified as soon as possible. It is a very bad headline to set to private employers who have enterprises in the immediate neighbourhood where these low-paid Government employees are at work. I feel that a good deal that is said in matters of this kind in this House is dishonest and is spoken with the tongue in the cheek.
We cannot get away from the fact that the morale of our people is almost gone. It is easy to say on a platform, "Pay no annuities." The morale of our people is so bad because the Fianna Fáil Administration have men amongst them who get up and say, "Pay nobody" and these men have since got into office. The present Administration has brought about that breach in the morale of our people. The first people to yield to that were the farmers. Long before the economic war that was the doctrine preached by the Party which is now the Government in this country, and while it is true, as I believe it is true, that there were a number of farmers who did not fulfil their legal obligation, for one who could have done so 99 cannot do so to-day. I know men myself, hard-working, industrious men and who were at one time relatively well-to-do, that have not 5/- in the bank to-day, and are literally unable to support themselves and their families. Under these circumstances Ministers might press the soft pedal and not enforce the law to the very letter. I know some farmers who were arrested and thrown into prison, and who never encouraged the non-payment of the land annuities. These men, through the action of some agents of the Secret Service, and it is even suggested through the action of agents provocateurs, have been thrown into prison. To-day we see flying squads rushing up and down the country. People availing of the railway service or the bus service must be surprised at the number of men they see wearing civilian clothes but with rifles thrown over their shoulders. These people, we are told, belong to the flying squad. I would be the last to offer any opposition to the law, or to suggest that men who could discharge their obligations and pay should not do so, but the fact is that these people cannot pay.
There is another thing I would like to emphasise. We had a long land war in this country. The farmers after years of turmoil, strife and agitation entered into possession of their own land. The Land Commission is now in the place of the farmers' former landlords. The Land Commission is our own native institution. I have never advocated that people should refuse to pay the Land Commission, and the men who can pay, and who refuse to pay the Land Commission, should be compelled to pay. I do not care how far the law is put in force against men like that. But by far the great majority of the unfortunate farmers cannot pay, and have proved to the satisfaction of the Land Commission that they cannot pay and their stock should not be seized. I would regard in the same way the taking away of the stock of the farmer for debts which he cannot pay as I would the taking away of the plant and machinery of the builder and then expecting him to build houses. There are numerous cases in Cork where poor farmers have had their stock seized, with the result that their means of earning is gone. No one could support that line of policy. Farmers are worse off to-day than ever they were under the Balfour régime. I shall give one illustration of the plight of some farmers. I had occasion to take a case recently to the Land Commission. I was met with the greatest possible courtesy which is characteristic of the Land Commission and of all the officials of that Department with whom I have come in contact. This man endeavoured to pay his annuities for a number of years past. He then got into arrears through no fault of his own. He wrote me a letter in which he stated that he and his wife and five children would have to go into the county home if his cattle were seized. I put the case before the Land Commission. I get an interval of six weeks for the man to pay. I mention that fact to clear up any misapprehension or doubt that may exist in the minds of some Deputies as to whether a legitimate straightforward case when presented to the Land Commission will be seriously examined into. My experience is that it certainly will. I always felt, on such occasions, even though I could not get all I wanted, that the Department, with all the information at its disposal, and knowing more about the facts of the case than I could, have done their best to meet the representations made to them.
I want to say to clear any doubts that may exist in the minds of Deputies that in the Department every care has been taken, both under this and the last Administration. I mention that fact to clear any doubts that may exist in anybody's mind in regard to the way the Department is administered. Again, even if the officials of the Department had to enforce the law, they are just enforcing the policy they were put there to enforce and the policy they are paid to enforce. If hardships have been inflicted on any members of the agricultural community it is not the fault of the Land Commission but the fault of the Executive Council and the policy of the present Government. Having said that, I do not propose to say any more except once more to register my objection to the miserable wage paid to these workers in the employment of the Land Commission in the Forestry Department and to ask the Minister to consider his attitude in relation to these wages.
Comment on this
I listened with a good deal of attention to Deputy Murphy's contribution to this debate and I must confess that at the end of the Deputy's speech I was wondering for what purpose he had got on his feet. The Deputy, in my opinion, devoted the greater part of his speech to matters that should not be of primary concern, anyway to a member of the Labour Party. He devoted just the tail-end of his speech to what should concern him more than anything else—the scandalously low wages that are paid by Departments under the immediate control and direction of the Minister. The Deputy could only utter a qualified condemnation of the Minister with regard to these scandalously low wages. He talked about members of the Opposition on public boards whose policy it was to force wages down still further. Does Deputy Murphy remember the speech of Deputy Hugo Flinn regarding Government policy on wages? Does he recollect that Deputy Flinn defied any member of the Labour Party in this House or outside it to stand between him and any unemployed man and 22/6 per week? Deputy Flinn said that if they did they would be torn from limb to limb. I must confess that I find it very difficult to understand the attitude of a Party that in one sentence denounces the Government and in the next praises them. You cannot have it both ways. The Minister is either administering the Department properly or he is not.
Then we heard all this very vehement and very indignant protest from Deputy Murphy and other members of the Labour Party with regard to what they are pleased to call the conspiracy against the payment of annuities. I am satisfied, because I know it in person and because of the contact I have with the country, that there is not a single member of the Labour Party—with the possible exception of the leader, who because of his position does not come as frequently in contact with rural conditions as other members —but knows quite well that men who two years ago were able to meet these payments are not able to meet them now. There is not a single man in this House, I do not care on which side he sits, who has stood at any fair within the last three years and who has watched the prices that were offered for cattle, who believes for one moment that these men are able to meet the full charge of annuities and rates. I want to ask the Minister does he recollect what happened in the President's own constituency within the last few months? Does he recollect reading in the public Press—I just give this to illustrate the conditions to which the farmers have been reduced—a case where farmers were brought into Court for non-payment of rates and where one rate collector had to admit that these men were on the verge of starvation?
Comment on this
I do not want it glossed over but I do not want it repeated. It is already on the records.
Comment on this
Apparently the Deputy does not like it. I say that that can be taken as an indication of the position in which many farmers to-day find themselves. I am surprised that all this talk about a campaign for the non-payment of annuities should come from Deputies on the opposite side. Deputy Corry here to-night denied that he ever in any way suggested that annuities should not be paid. There is not a newspaper in the country—go into any newspaper office in any town and look at the files—in which you will not find, not only one reference but hundreds of this kind. We know quite well that the whole claim of the Fianna Fáil Party was that they should not pay annuities. The President himself on one occasion said that they should not pay.
Comment on this
He said so on the very famous occasion of the interview given to the Manchester Guardian, which perhaps the Deputy would not read. What are the facts? The facts are that the land annuities due to be paid to England are less than £3,000,000, but within the last year, as the President himself admitted a few nights ago, England has collected in tariffs on our agricultural produce £4,692,000. When you charge the farmers with not paying annuities you should face the facts. The facts are that the farmers are paying not only the £3,000,000, but they have paid £4,692,000 to England and the President is trying to collect a further £2,000,000 from them. He is trying to force that from them in conditions such as I have described, when they are probably getting less than 50 per cent. of what they were getting three years ago for their live stock. There is not a farmer Deputy sitting on the Fianna Fáil Benches who does not know that that is the case, because when he goes into a fair he is not going to get a higher price for his bunch of two-year-olds or three-year-olds simply because he is a member of the Fianna Fáil Party. There are farmers who are members of the Fianna Fáil Party who know that they are not able to make farming pay at the present time.
Comment on this
Unless they smuggle their cattle across the Border.
Comment on this
They cannot all smuggle them. I am talking of facts. The man who has got to live on a farm, who has got to go into the ordinary fair or market and accept the best price he can get for his cattle, is not able to meet these charges. He is not able to meet the demands made upon him by the Land Commission on top of the £4,700,000 which he has already paid to England. That should be remembered when we have all this loose talk about the non-payment of rates and annuities. We had cheap jibes about certain members of this Party. As far as I am concerned, I made my position in regard to the land annuities question clear three years ago. I say that if the money is not due to the people who lent the money in the first instance, it is certainly not due to President de Valera who never lent the money. That has been my attitude for the last three years, but perhaps the question does not arise now. Not only are the farmers expected to pay one-and-a-half times the amount of the annuities to England but they are expected to contribute a further £2,000,000 to the Government here.
I move to report progress.