Wicklow Mining Lease—Appointment of Select Committee.
Contributions 1–122 of 249. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:
That a Select Committee consisting of eleven Deputies, to be appointed by the Committee of Selection and with power to send for persons, papers and documents, be established publicly to investigate and report to the Dáil on the following allegations made by Deputy P. McGilligan:—
That the demise of the State Mining rights in respect of certain lands in County Wicklow, made on 1st November, 1934, by way of take note or prospecting lease, to Senator Michael Comyn, K.C., and Deputy R. Briscoe by the Minister for Industry and Commerce was—
(a) made to Senator Comyn and Deputy Briscoe because they were political associates of the Minister,
(b) made under conditions of secrecy, and
(c) made at a time that the Minister was aware that another party or other parties were proposing to seek a demise of the same rights, on terms more advantageous to the State;
and that the action of the Minister in making such demise was improper; and further, publicly to investigate and to report to the Dáil on all the facts and circumstances connected with and surrounding the application for and the grant of the said lease, and all the facts and circumstances connected with and surrounding the agreement made by the lessees for the assignment of their rights and obligations under the said lease.
The motion proposes the establishment of a Select Committee to investigate certain allegations, set out in the motion, made here last week by Deputy McGilligan and also to investigate and report to the Dáil on the facts and circumstances surrounding the application for the mining lease in question and the facts and circumstances surrounding the agreement made by the lessees for the assignment of their rights and obligations under that lease. I do not know if it is intended to have any discussion upon this motion at this stage. I have framed this motion in the widest possible terms. It covers wider ground than that covered by the motion in the name of Deputy Cosgrave. I do not know if the motion in the name of Deputy McGilligan is to be taken seriously.
Before, however, dealing with that matter, I should like to make one or two corrections which, I think, it is necessary to make. In the course of the Dáil discussion on Wednesday last, I stated that the company known as Irish Prospectors, Limited, approached the Department of Industry and Commerce in 1930 concerning certain gold prospecting plans and that Mr. Joseph McGrath was a member of that company. I find now that while Mr. McGrath was associated with the group which included Mr. Summerfield and Mr. Heiser, now members of Irish Prospectors, Limited, and which contemplated the registration of a company under the title of Consolidated Goldfields of Ireland, Limited, and which approached Deputy McGilligan, as Minister for Industry and Commerce in that year, he has no connection with the company called Irish Prospectors, Limited, which latter company was only formally registered quite recently. In fact, I am informed that when certain action, taken early this year by Irish Prospectors, Limited, left the impression on the minds of certain people that Mr. McGrath was associated with them, he took definite action to remove that impression.
The second matter relates to a report which appeared in the Irish Times yesterday and which created an impression that, I think, in the public interest should be removed. The report is as follows:—
"Further prospecting in what is rapidly becoming known as the ‘Wicklow Gold Rush' has just been revealed.
"Borings are now being made in the townland of Glenogue, on the borders of the Counties Wicklow and Wexford. It is understood that they are being made on behalf of Captain H.P. Mahon, of Strokestown, Co. Roscommon, and the work is being directed by an Australian mining engineer.
"The prospectors are reticent about their activities, but it is believed that they are hopeful of striking gold in the southern end of the Wicklow lode, most of which is controlled by the licence granted by the Minister for Industry and Commerce to Senator Michael Comyn, K.C., and Mr. Robert Briscoe, T.D.
"The townland of Glenogue, where the shaft is being sunk by the new group, is south of the townlands and south of the mountain where the deposits are located in which Senator Comyn and Mr. Briscoe are interested."
Captain Packenham Mahon made application for a prospecting lease on the 15th July, 1930. He repeated that application on the 23rd December, 1931, and the prospecting lease was issued to him on the 30th June, 1932—that is, four months before the lease was issued to Senator Comyn and to Deputy Briscoe. With regard to the statement that most of the Wicklow lode "is controlled by the licence granted by the Minister for Industry and Commerce to Senator Michael Comyn, K.C., and Mr. Robert Briscoe, T.D.," that statement is entirely incorrect. The licence granted to Senator Michael Comyn and Mr. Robert Briscoe covers three townlands in the vicinity of Woodenbridge in the County of Wicklow. The licence granted to Captain Packenham Mahon covers eight townlands and part of 19 townlands in the County of Wexford, and part of one townland in the County of Wicklow, an area of about ten times the size of the area covered by the lease given to Senator Comyn and Deputy Briscoe.
The allegations which are stated in this motion which appears in my name as having been made by Deputy McGilligan were not, of course, made in so many words. Deputy McGilligan did not, in fact, make any specific allegation, but merely implied that charges of this nature could be laid against the Department of Industry and Commerce. Now, I gather from the terms of his motion, in which he repeats, not his allegations but his insinuations, that he is disposed to deny that he made these charges at all. I am afraid, however, that I cannot be satisfied with a denial expressed in that form. In the interests of the country, in the interests of the Government and in my own interest it is desirable that the implications of his speech should be definitely cleared up. Deputy McGilligan's speech definitely implied, (1) that I gave this licence to Senator Comyn and Deputy Briscoe because they were political associates of mine; (2) that I gave it under conditions of secrecy; and (3) that I gave it when I knew that other parties might have taken a lease of the same property on conditions more advantageous to the State.
The only circumstances under which I would agree to the Committee not being set up for the purpose of considering these allegations would be a very explicit statement made here by Deputy McGilligan that not merely did he not make these charges but that nothing which he said is to be taken as implying these charges. Unless we get a clear and explicit withdrawal of these charges, or of these implications, by Deputy McGilligan I must insist that the Committee be set up to investigate the allegations.
It is true that when I first circulated my motion it contained only a reference to these allegations. My intention at the time was to confine this inquiry to the allegations made by Deputy McGilligan, but as we have had here in the past a number of allegations of that description unsupported by evidence made against different members of the Government, I felt the time had come when the baselessness of these allegations should be definitely exposed. I felt that Deputy McGilligan had gone one too far, and that it was desirable that he should be given the opportunity of proving his allegations or withdrawing them. Since then, however, I have been approached by Deputy Briscoe and Senator Comyn, who urged me strongly that I should agree that the investigation should cover not merely the actions of the Department of Industry and Commerce in relation to this lease but also matters with which I as Minister am not concerned, namely, the circumstances surrounding the agreement made by them with another party for the demise of the rights and obligations under their lease. I felt it was fair to these parties that no implication should be given by confining the inquiry that they had anything to conceal. I felt, as they had urged, that it was in their interest that all the facts surrounding this matter should be made public so that the members of the Dáil and the public would have a full opportunity of judging for themselves whether there were any circumstances in relation to this that either they or myself or the officers of the Department of Industry and Commerce dealing with this matter had reason to be ashamed of. I am quite satisfied that the investigation will show that their conduct throughout was most honourable, and I, therefore, decided to amend the terms of my motion, and on their representations to widen the scope of the inquiry to cover these other matters: that is, the circumstances connected with and surrounding the application for the lease and the granting of the lease, and also the circumstances surrounding the agreement which they inform me that they had made with other parties for the assignment of their rights and obligations.
I am rather disappointed that Deputy McGilligan did not avail of the opportunity which that motion afforded to him, either to state his charges in specific terms or to withdraw them. He has done neither one nor the other. Instead of doing that, he has put down a motion purporting to contain extracts from his speech here on Wednesday last, and by doing so makes it clear that he is insinuating certain things and not alleging them. It is, I think, the most disgusting motion that has ever appeared on the Order Paper in the House. It is possible, of course, for anybody to make insinuations, but it takes somebody with a little more courage to make allegations and to offer to prove those allegations to be correct. Deputy McGilligan did not do that. Insinuations, however, can be made in a manner in which they can be met, but there is one method of making insinuations which it is almost impossible to meet, and that is by making them in the form of a question. That is what Deputy McGilligan is doing in his motion. It is the old example that has so often been quoted in this House. If you ask somebody "has he stopped beating his wife?" he obviously cannot give a "yes" or "no" answer without admitting the implication contained in the question. These are precisely the tactics which Deputy McGilligan has resorted to: of making allegations in the form of a question to me. In doing so, he shows conclusively that he does not wish to be put in the position of having to produce any proof in support of his charges.
There is just one matter that I want to deal with in connection with this question here and now. One of the allegations made was this: that a lease was issued by me under conditions of secrecy. Now, that allegation caused me a certain amount of amusement, because this is not the first occasion on which we had a debate here as to the amount of publicity that should be given in connection with leases made under the Mines and Minerals Act. When the Mines and Minerals Act was before the Dáil in the form of a Bill in 1931, Deputy McGilligan was Minister for Industry and Commerce and I was a Deputy in Opposition. On the 19th November in that year, according to the Dáil debates—Volume 40, No. 5, Column 1893—I proposed an amendment to that Bill, which afterwards became an Act. The amendment read: "That no lease should be made until each House of the Oireachtas had, by resolution, authorised the making of such lease." That amendment, which I moved in 1931, was vigorously opposed by Deputy McGilligan. In the course of his speech in opposition to it, he contended that, in the case of a prospecting lease, secrecy was essential. He said:
Trading of any kind by the method of a lease being laid before this House, not to be passed unless there is a vote of acceptance—trading in respect of anything under that method would be impossible. When you come to a matter which must be secret, such as mines and minerals— a lot of matters material to such a discussion must be concerned with a discovery somebody has made and is trying to keep the fruits of—trading under these circumstances would obviously be impossible.
I did not fully agree then with the arguments advanced by Deputy McGilligan. I do not agree with them now, but it is obviously ridiculous that Deputy McGilligan should be making allegations against me—allegations of corruption—because I am doing in 1935 precisely what he said must be done in 1931. The lease in question was issued in strict accordance with the provisions of the Mines and Minerals Act. That Act was not proposed by me. It was proposed by Deputy McGilligan, and whatever safeguards he, in 1931, considered necessary in the public interest were presumably inserted in that Act. It was in accordance with that Act that the lease was granted. The Act does not provide for publication of the terms of a prospecting lease. Deputy McGilligan stated, on Wednesday, that if I had made the lease for two years and one day, instead of for two years, I would have had to publish it——
Comment on this
If the merits of this question were to be gone into, the debate would, in the first place, be out of order, and, in the second place, of long duration. The matter for decision is whether a Select Committee should be set up and which of the proposals on the Order Paper should constitute the terms of reference. It is not permissible to enter into the merits of the question which the Committee is being set up to investigate.
Comment on this
I bow to your ruling. In these circumstances, I have not much more to say. It is obvious that this Committee must be asked to investigate the charges made by Deputy McGilligan, even though those charges were made by way of insinuation rather than by way of allegation. The impression left upon the minds of members of the public and members of the Dáil was that these charges lay against a Department and that impression must be removed in one of two ways—either by their complete withdrawal by Deputy McGilligan or by this method of investigation by a Select Committee. Furthermore, at the request of the lessees in this case and certain other parties who have been interested in the matter, I have agreed to extend the scope of that inquiry to cover all the facts and circumstances surrounding the making of the lease and the making of the agreement under the lease. I think that that inquiry should take place as quickly as possible. It is obviously not in the interest of any Party in this House, and much less in the interest of the country, that there should be any general impression that charges of this kind can be made, with any foundation, against a Department of State. Therefore, I would urge on all the Parties in the House who will be associated with the setting up of the Select Committee that it should be established as quickly as possible and that the members of it should be asked to carry out their investigations and report at the earliest date, so that the full facts will be available and the foundation for the allegations made clear.
Comment on this
The Minister had before him a motion in my name on which he might have given his views. Taking his own statement and his own conduct in connection with this motion, it would appear that he drafted a motion last week and circulated it to members of the House. He has since amended that motion on, as he has just told us, the representations of the lessees. If I interpret his speech correctly, his original intention was to have an examination into the implications of certain statements or insinuations made in this House by Deputy McGilligan. Is the Minister the best judge of what was insinuated or implied in that connection? He belongs to a Party that has not been free from the making of insinuations or implications in respect of other people. It has battened upon them for a number of years and now it is developing a very thin skin. It is not creditable to the Minister or to the members of his Party, who have been so glib in that respect in the past, that they should feel so much upset when there is a case made against them in this House. What answer does the Minister make in reply to the implications or insinuations or allegations? Where in the course of the various allegations that have been made is the statement that this lease was given to Senator Comyn and Deputy Briscoe because they were political associates of the Minister? I am at a disadvantage in this case. Most of my information has come from the Press. The Official Report will not be published until to-morrow. I happened to see an early issue of the Report, but I could not read that in the space of a few minutes. If the statement to which the Minister alluded is contained in the Report, it escaped my notice.
The Ministry take a rather serious view of this question. On the first day the Minister for Finance said that it was a matter the seriousness of which was evident. Obviously, it is regarded as serious by the Ministry, If it be regarded as serious, what is the proper method of dealing with it? The Minister's first proposal was to have an inquiry into the insinuations or implications and not into the allegations. At the behest of the lessees, he enlarged his proposal. May I suggest that the Minister, in his handling of this business, has been signally unfortunate. The Press report contained the statement by the Minister that some of the people who were, in the first instance, interested in this mining question got into temporary financial difficulties. It would appear that, at least, one of them subsequently appeared in connection with the sub-lease, if I am not mistaken. It is a very serious thing to make statements of this sort in the House regarding anybody's financial position. Then a certain qualification must be made in respect of a statement affecting a former Minister of State and a very reputable gentleman. The correction of these statements never reaches all the people whom the first statement reached. I suggest to the Minister that, in these cases, he should address himself impartially to the subject of his Department and see what is the best method of settling this question.
Can the Minister say for what reason the motion tabled in my name is objectionable, and if in the answers that would come from this committee there is not all that might be expected from examination in his particular case? In his motion as it stands we have certain items set down, (a), (b) and (c). I will admit that the Minister has added on other things at the behest of the lessees. It so happens they were added on also after my motion was handed in. Was this motion handed in in time at all? There is extraordinary haste and amendment in connection with the whole business, which does not reflect well on the Ministry in this case. It will have to learn that with the responsibility of office it should not be excited; it should do its business without excitement and haste. If there are allegations and insinuations and so on, they were pretty slick themselves, when they were not in a responsible position, about making allegations and insinuations. The Minister might have given the House his views on the amendment. The case he has made in respect of (a), to my mind, is not clear; it is not convincing. It is a sort of case in which he wants to have something dealt with which was not raised here. Naturally, in any case of this kind, public confidence and the public mind must be set at ease with regard to the lettings. If lettings are made to members of the House more than usual care should be exercised. It is a principle of local administration that contractors are not allowed to be members of local authorities. That has been dispensed with in connection with this House. Ministers and the Administration generally should be extra careful in these matters if a situation should arise in which a member of the House gets either a contract or a lease or anything of that sort. In order to get the Minister's explanation of what his objection is to my motion, I formally move the amendment:
To delete all after the words "Select Committee" to the end of the motion and substitute therefor the following:—
"consisting of eleven Deputies, to be nominated by the Committee of Selection and with power to send for persons, papers, and documents, be established publicly to investigate and to report to the Dáil upon the facts and circumstances generally connected with and surrounding the application made by Senator Michael Comyn, K.C., and Deputy R. Briscoe to the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the grant to the Senator and Deputy aforesaid by the said Minister in respect of the exclusive rights of mining vested in the State in or under certain lands in County Wicklow, and, in particular, so to investigate and report upon the following:—
(a) the area in County Wicklow covered by such applications and/ or grant;
(b) the evidence produced to the Minister as to the mining experience, technical equipment, and financial resources of the Senator and Deputy aforesaid:
(c) the other applicants, if any, for such or similar mining rights in or about the same area;
(d) the procedure adopted in considering and granting the concession;
(e) the terms and conditions on which the concession was granted;
(f) the subsequent developments as to the agreement by the Senator and Deputy aforesaid for assigning their rights and obligations under the said grant;
(g) the consideration to be received by the Senator and Deputy aforesaid and the consideration to be given by them;
(h) the necessity for ‘middlemen profits' in relation to this concession and the number of members of the Oireachtas found to be placed as such ‘middlemen' in this transaction."
The following amendment stood in the name of Deputy McGilligan:—
To delete all after the words "Select Committee" to the end of the motion and substitute therefor the following:—
"consisting of eleven Deputies, to be nominated by the Committee of Selection and with power to send for persons, papers and documents, be established for the purpose of investigating and reporting to the Dáil on allegations made by Deputy P. McGilligan in regard to the granting by the Minister for Industry and Commerce to Senator Michael Comyn, K.C., and Deputy R. Briscoe of the exclusive rights of mining in respect of certain lands in County Wicklow in the following words:—
(a) ‘That under conditions of secrecy a valuable piece of State property was parted with to members of the Oireachtas belonging to the Minister's Party, and that those members of his Party, known to him, are going to get £12,000 and 2¼ per cent. in return for the giving by them to an outside company of State property... That the Minister knows of it; that he knows it is intended to be done; and that he will not tell these people that he will not allow it.'
(b) ‘Does the Minister consider it a proper thing that men should be allowed to traffic in property that is not their own, the value of which they have not enhanced to any degree by their activities, and that they should be enabled, if the transaction works out rightly, to get their 2¼ per cent. over and above the money they have to pay, as long as the stream of gold lasts, and that they shall get shares worth £12,000 in a company, with whatever these shares will yield to the shareholders after this 6¼ per cent. has been paid?"
I suggest that those simple facts indicate a scandal.
Comment on this
The procedure is to put the question "that the words stand." If that is defeated the House will have an option between the two amendments.
Comment on this
The Minister's proposals are not the ones set up under ordinary rules. Which one is to be put?
Comment on this
If the Deputy had put that question before the motion, and one amendment had been moved, the Chair might have had something to say on the point raised. It is too late now.
Comment on this
On the point that it was not raised by anybody, then the motion can be discussed and put as a substantive motion to the House. Is that the situation?
Comment on this
The situation is exactly as stated. If the Deputy had put a question earlier the Chair might have expressed some doubt as to whether this motion had been handed in in time. The motion and one amendment having been under consideration, no answer can now be given.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I want to say that I was interested to hear the Minister's statement. The Minister went on to explain that he had a notice of motion and he described the reason for it. At the earliest opportunity it occurred to me I made it.
Comment on this
Then the whole matter is in order? If it is in order, the motion is grossly unfair, and has been drawn to be unfair—deliberately. I suggest that if we are going to discuss a motion framed in terms of reporting on allegations made by a Deputy we should see whether these are the allegations made. I have been able to survey part of the debate. The only part of that debate in which I can find these words occurring is when the Minister was speaking—not when I was speaking. The Minister, very near the concluding portion, said:—
"Of course it would be a serious charge if it could be contended that the Minister for Industry and Commerce had given to certain political friends, for the purpose of enabling them to re-sell it, State property that could be disposed of more advantageously elsewhere to anybody else."
That is his summing up. Will the Minister attend to what follows:—
"Nor did Deputy McGilligan say that in so many words. He left it to be inferred."
I gather the statement was that I simply implied this. Why take the Minister's views when what I implied in my direct statement is now proved? The chairman of Kerry County Council is conversant with the Minister and his capacity for twisting statements. I am appealing to him as a political associate of the Minister, who has found him out. That is a good thing. As one dissociated, I found him out often. Here is an opportunity of finding him out and I asked for a committee to go into the allegations made. I was asked at one time would I state my allegations. "What is the allegation against the Department?" said the Minister. Later in the debate he said: "I do not know it yet." I retorted: "I shall tell you." It is:
"That under conditions of secrecy a valuable piece of State property was parted with to members of the House belonging to the Minister's Party."
"House" is wrong. It should be "Oireachtas."
"and that those members of his Party, known to him, are going to get £12,000 and 2¼ per cent. in return for the giving by them to an outside company of State property. That is a serious charge and it is against the Minister I make it."
The Minister retorted: "What is the charge?" and I continued:
"That the Minister knows of it; that he knows it is intended to be done; and that he will not tell these people that he will not allow it."
That is my charge. The Minister asked for it and got it. He got it in the words I quoted which are taken from my motion. Why must the Minister hide remarks in the debate said to be mere inferences and which to-day he said were simply left to be implied? I will give another quotation. This was earlier, when I was challenged. I put it later in my reference because it includes an important point:—
"Does this House consider that it is a proper thing, in relation to the sale of State property, that certain people should be given a concession and that these people should, to the knowledge of the Ministry, at a later stage at all events, have sold that property for valuable consideration to others, with no increased consideration to the State? If ever there was a case in which middlemen's profits should be decried and scouted, surely that is the case."
That was a very definite charge. The whole gravamen of my charge is in that.
"Does the Minister consider it a proper thing that men should be allowed to traffic in property that is not their own, the value of which they have not enhanced to any degree by their activities, and that they should be enabled, if the transaction works out rightly, to get their 2¼ per cent. over and above the money they have to pay, as long as the stream of gold lasts, and that they shall get shares worth £12,000 in a company with whatever these shares will yield to the shareholders after this 6¼ per cent. has been paid?"
I wound up that phrase by saying—I think these were the words I used— that these simple facts indicated a scandal. There is the allegation. The Minister does not want to face that one point. That is the one point, however, from which he must get away. The Minister even goes so far to-day, in answer to a question which was addressed to him as to whether or not a lease was granted, as to say, I believe, that the answer was in the affirmative. I asked him again whether or not he was aware of that, and again he said he was not. The Minister was asked was he aware of it. What has been his answer? The gravamen of the whole charge is that, being aware of the trafficking in property of the State, the Minister handed over to two members of the Oireachtas the power to deal with such property: that the Minister, knowing that that was the case, did not stop it, although he has the power to stop it: and that he did not indicate to these two people that they would not be allowed to go on with it.
The special point that I want to make is that the Minister knows that this thing is intended to be done and he will not tell these people that he will not allow it. The extra point I have added—and I think it should be added—is as to whether or not the value of the State property concerned has been enhanced to any degree by the activities of these people. Now, the Minister's challenge to me was that he wanted this whole matter inquired into. Of course, I am quite prepared to believe the Minister is not ready to stand up to that challenge, any more than he was prepared to stand up to the other challenge where the Minister said that his Department was open to investigation by anybody in this House. It is easy to see that you can issue a challenge if you know it is not going to be accepted; particularly, when, even if the challenge were accepted, you are prepared to run away from it. The proposal of the Minister was, that, with the consent of the House, a Committee should be appointed to consider this whole matter. It must be borne in mind that that is not a question of considering whether or not the Minister had at any time granted this lease, or whether it was made at a time that the Minister was aware that another party or other parties were proposing to seek a demise of the same rights, on terms more advantageous to the State. I do not believe that I ever said that other people were interested in getting the demise of this property. It is possible, however, that I said that these people finally appeared on the scene. At any rate, they have not disappeared afterwards.
Comment on this
I object to the Minister's refractory mind playing on suggestions of mine and putting down what he thinks are to be inferred from my remarks.
Comment on this
I say that two members of the Minister's Party got this lease. That is not denied. If anybody asks whether or not it was because they were members of the Minister's Party, I shall not ask the House to decide the matter; I shall ask public opinion.
Comment on this
I did not say that it was because they were members of the Minister's Party that they were granted the lease. I did say that they were members of the Party and that I would be prepared to ask public opinion to decide whether or not it was because they were members of the Party that they were granted the lease. I will go further now and say that I believe it was because they were members of the Minister's Party, and I will ask public opinion to decide upon that. However, as I said previously, what I want the proposed Committee to agree upon is as to whether or not the Minister was aware of what was being done. It is not denied. Deputy Cosgrave's amendment asks whether there is any necessity for "middlemen profits" in relation to this concession and the number of members of the Oireachtas found to be placed as such "middlemen" in this transaction.
Comment on this
You ruled; Sir, I think, that only the terms of reference, and not the substance of the charges, should be dealt with.
Comment on this
One of the motions before the House is to demand the production of all documents, papers, etc., in relation to this concession.
Comment on this
I submit to the Deputy that the number concerned is a matter to be investigated by the Committee, and that it is not a question of a number alleged in this House.
Comment on this
Very good—so long as the number is fixed. The Minister can be very happy. The Minister can laugh, just as he could laugh in the same way when he said that he challenged investigation of his Department, but when the challenge was taken up, we had a sickly smile from the Minister, and we would have the same sickly smile to-day if we asked the Minister to make good his boast.
Comment on this
The Minister's smile is rather sickly at the moment. Just hold that please! At any rate, we have these motions. I want this to be clear: that there is going to be no question as to the people additional to the folk mentioned here who are in on this thing. I gather that we have had an apology from the Minister here to-day as to some person who, according to the Press, was engaged previously. The Minister told me that that was wrong. There is not much question of responsibility in that. I am told now, that so far from there being anything considered in that way, there has been no such application. Evidently, these applications are like many other myths of the Minister. None the less, it was pushed out as a statement over the week-end, with some attempt to do good for the Minister and his Party during the week-end. Then, this is only thrown off afterwards in a debate in a statement issued by the Department for which the Minister takes responsibility. On this matter, Sir, I should like to know just what has been attempted and what does this Committee start with. The question that I put in last week, in order to give the Minister the earliest possible opportunity of answering it, has been put off until to-day. I asked the Minister was he aware of the sub-lease, and the Minister does not answer that question. That is definitely the fact. The Minister evades the question by saying that he did not sanction it, but the real question is whether or not he was aware of such a sub-lease.
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir, I suggest that we are discussing a motion and not the answers to a Parliamentary Question.
Comment on this
What I am referring to deals with the motion. In a question put to the Minister to-day, the 25th June, the Minister was asked if he was aware of this sub-lease, and his answer was that the part of the question concerned described, in general, the terms of an agreement for certain sub-leases between the lessees of the lease and the Chairman of a certain syndicate. Last week the Minister said: "It is true that the lessees have supplied us with the copy of an agreement which they have made with Risberget, Limited, for the formation of a company to carry out the commercial working of the minerals in the area." Is that this lease? Evidently, the Minister does not know even yet whether it is or not.
Comment on this
The Minister said that no application had been put before him. Later on, the Minister said: "An application in respect of a mining unit in the area was submitted to the Minister but it was not considered necessary to require his approval under the original lease." That was not before him on the Friday on which he issued the statement——
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir, I think that, if Deputy McGilligan is to be allowed to follow this line, I should also be allowed to follow it.
Comment on this
The merits of the case may not be discussed now, nor the existence, or otherwise, of a sub-lease. That would anticipate the matters which this Committee is being selected to investigate.
Comment on this
I want to find out if the Committee are, in fact, being asked to investigate whether such a sub-lease exists, because I cannot see it.
Comment on this
"To investigate and report to the Dáil on all the facts and circumstances connected with and surrounding the application for and the grant of the said lease, and all the facts and circumstances connected with and surrounding the agreement made by the lessees for the assignment of their rights and obligations under the said lease." I am asking the Chair if, under that term, it is possible for anybody to doubt the existence of the sub-lease.
Comment on this
An agreement for a sub-lease. What is the good of quibbling about this? There is no sub-lease; there is only an agreement for one. There is a sub-lease subject to a condition. Do not make any mistake about it.
Comment on this
There is a sub-lease subject to a condition, so far as two members of the Oireachtas——
Comment on this
The Deputy may not go into the merits of this case. He is entitled to ask the Minister whether certain things come within the scope of the motion submitted by him, but not to debate the question. Something might be left for the Committee to investigate.
Comment on this
What we are trying to get at the moment is the submission to the Committee. The matter has been discussed already, and, arising out of the discussion, terms of reference have been framed. They are framed supposedly on allegations made by me. They are not my allegations. I did make allegations and I have set them out in writing, and I am asking the House to substitute these, and I am asking further to have it made clear whether, in fact, this Committee is going to be free to discuss everything in connection with this, which was the Minister's first challenge, or whether it is going to be hidebound. I object to any Committee which is going to report with the pivot of its report a statement that I never made—Item (c) of these terms of reference. I never made that.
Comment on this
I cannot withdraw what I never made. If the Minister will point out to me where I did make that statement, I will consider the withdrawal of it.
Comment on this
If the Deputy will say that nothing he said here is to be taken as implying that allegation, I will take it out of the motion.
Comment on this
Would the Minister also say that nothing he said is to be taken as implying that the Deputies were not guilty of mishandling public funds or public property? It is the same sort of absurd hypothesis. Why throw out challenges on matters that are not alleged against me? Can I be shown the phrase of mine which is the foundation of this? I have said this and I repeat it, that these people had previously registered themselves as folk who were interested and these people subsequently came on the scene. The Minister can join the earlier and subsequent matters, but I have nowhere said, because I am not aware that it is a fact, that at the moment the lease was given, other parties were proposing to seek a demise of the same rights.
Comment on this
That, of course, is fantastic. Will the Minister put that in the terms of reference now so that we can get one falsehood nailed? That is not right; it is not the truth. The Minister will not say that it is the truth now that he is challenged.
Comment on this
The whole matter, I think, refers to State rights and that, of course, is a considerable lopping off from the whole country. This throwing in of fatuous interjections does not help us to get the terms of reference clear. I do not make that allegation and I never did. I do say that they were on the spot first and that they came in afterwards.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not recognise the difference between saying that people were there first and that Deputy Briscoe and Senator Comyn were able to get that and saying definitely that they were ready to apply at that moment? Is there no difference?
Comment on this
I make no such implication. I say that they were there previously and came along later. Join those two things any way you like. I might say that the Minister for Finance was a sound financial critic before he came into office or that he might become one afterwards but that does not imply that he is one now. We can easily make analogies.
Comment on this
Debate can only proceed in a picturesque way by analogies and that, I consider, is a fairly good one on the Minister. He is smiling in a grim fashion which shows exactly what he thinks about it. I put it again that I do not want terms of reference framed on allegations of mine unless in my words. If the Minister wants to get these allegations in, let him put them in. I will accept them as such but not in my words.
Comment on this
Am I to take it that Deputy McGilligan is saying that he never made the allegation that I could have made a more advantageous letting?
Comment on this
That you could have. At the same time, the words clearly are "made at a time when he was aware that they were proposing to seek." It does not require an awful lot of analysis of the English language to see that there is a big difference there. My proof is, and I gave it, that a better bargain was possible as Deputy Briscoe and Senator Comyn made a better bargain.
Comment on this
After, certainly, and that is what I said, but why, when I said that and related it to the subsequent period, put it down in this motion as "made at a time when he was aware that they were proposing to seek"? Does the Attorney-General want to say anything? I thought I was going to be questioned. Why say that when I did not say it? Who is going to prove that the Minister was aware at that time that they were so proposing? What the Committee can easily decide on is did they make application previously and did they come along afterwards or were they invited to come along at the time and what happened and was an invitation sent? There are four people named. One was within a stone's throw of Government Buildings, but the letter was sent to a firm of London solicitors.
Comment on this
It will not be before the Committee because that term of reference does not allow it; because it ties it down to the time the Minister made the lease.
Comment on this
You have a special thing. We know very well that particular words can have a very narrowing effect on more general words that follow. The particular words are here in the first place and refer to certain dates. Cut out the date. Let the Minister put it in the terms of reference if he likes, but do not attempt to put against me allegations which I say I never made. Let him say "the following allegations"; let him say "the following inferences"; let him say anything he likes, but he is not going to put against me allegations I never made.
Comment on this
Allegations which you led the country to believe you did make and which you had not got the guts to make. Is that not it?
Comment on this
Even the peat-besodden mind of the Minister for Defence can take this in, that I did make allegations. Here they are. I was challenged: "What is the allegation?""I will tell you," I said.
"It is that under conditions of secrecy a valuable piece of State property was parted with to members of the House belonging to the Minister's Party; that these members of his Party, known to him, are going to get £12,000 and 2¼ per cent. in return for the giving by them to an outside company of State property. That is a serious charge, and it is against the Minister for Industry and Commerce I make it."
Query by the Minister: "What is the charge?" My reply was that he knows of it; that he knows it is intended to be done, and that he will not tell the people he will not allow it. Is that a serious enough charge for the Minister for Defence?
Comment on this
Where is the phrase in the Minister's motion as to the Minister knowing about this and not stopping it? Point that out to me, and I will argue on it.
Comment on this
Why not pick it out, rather than something which was not said? Why not get down to bedrock? Why put in the precise term I did not use, and object to putting in the precise term which I used?
Comment on this
And the accusation against me is that I did not answer a question which I was never asked.
Comment on this
If that is the Minister's answer, the Minister can find it in my terms of reference.
Comment on this
I am not saying you were. I have never said that. That is a very serious thing—to say that he knows of it; that he knows it is intended to be done; and that he would not tell those people he would not allow it.
Comment on this
And the Minister will not say until he is asked? I am going to suggest that the only thing the public are concerned about is that the Minister knew of this mishandling of State property by two members of his Party, and he did not stop it. That is the only thing which the public are interested in. The concession that these men got, which is a fact, is not surprising. The conditions under which it was given really are not surprising; I mean they should surprise and shock but they do not; but the big outstanding fact is that the Minister found that State property, not enhanced in value by the efforts of those men, was being traded for their personal benefit, and he did not stop it.
Comment on this
I am suggesting that my terms of reference, which contain that, should be put before them. The Minister for Defence asked me is not that in the Minister's terms of reference, and I say it is not.
Comment on this
Your charges are covered by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. You have not the guts to say——
Comment on this
Let us leave those entrails which the Minister is so fond of dabbling in. Would the Minister put the clear light of his intelligence on the official report, and tell me where did I say what is alleged here?
Comment on this
The Minister, so to speak, is Shakespearian in his remarks, but what about a little intelligence? Give me the time I said that, or anything like it? There is a request from the right that the Minister should shut up. Would he attend to it? Apparently his intervention is not wanted in this debate. The Minister for Industry and Commerce wants him to stop.
Comment on this
The Deputy overheard me incorrectly. I said I hoped that if he did not interrupt, in due course you would stop.
Comment on this
We will take that as the Chairman of the Kerry County Council took it, when he said "it was ‘shut up' to you." There is a very narrow point at issue. I made certain allegations. I am charged to state precisely what they are. I retort in the middle of the debate. I have not to wait and fumble for a phrase. I give exact allegations.
Comment on this
Absolutely! They bear scrutiny, which some of the Deputy's words might not. I do not seek, as the Deputy does, for wild words. I say those things in the middle of the debate. They are on record. If the terms of reference are to be phrased in my allegations—I do not know why they should be, but if you want them phrased in my allegations—phrase them accurately. They are quite serious. Why not have them? I do not see why the Minister wants to run away to a phrase that was not used. I have given two fairly lengthy quotations made in answer to the query "what is the charge?" The (a) matter is shut out. Supposing it is intended not to take this form, then what is wrong with the details of the amendment to this motion suggested by Deputy Cosgrave? We want to know the area covered. We want to know the evidence that was produced to the Minister as to the mining experience, technical equipment and financial resources of the Senator and the Deputy. The Deputy told me that he had four years' digging. I want to get evidence of it. We want to know the applications, if any, for said or similar mining rights in or about the same area. The Minister can get all the information put before the Committee on that. We want to know the procedure adopted in considering and granting the concession. Were there alternative ways of doing it, and why was this one chosen? We want to know the conditions and terms on which the concession was granted. Were there limitations? Did the subsequent conditions appeal to the Minister at that moment, or were they before him, and why did he not choose them? What were the subsequent developments as to the agreement by the Senator and the Deputy for assigning their rights and obligations under the grant? We want to know the consideration to be received by the Senator and the Deputy, and that given by them. My statement is simply that they operated with valuable State property, added nothing to it of their own, and in addition, got shares, 2¼ per cent., and so on. Finally, we want to know the necessity for middlemen or middlemen's profit, and the number of Members of the Oireachtas now established as such middlemen. I suggest, as Deputy Cosgrave suggests, that the big principle which all this has got to lead up to is whether members of this House or of the other House, put into a peculiar position because of their representative capacity here, should be allowed to trade on that position.
Comment on this
Except under conditions. Let me go on. Deputy Cosgrave referred to legislation still operating with regard to local authorities. I am not to be taken as phrasing the law accurately or comprehensively at this moment, but the late Chief Baron Pallas delivered many a lecture from the Bench on what he called "the public mischief" of those Acts. If any member of a local authority is discovered to be making a profit out of any transaction found to be connected with his position as such public representative, he is disqualified, and stands disqualified from standing for election for seven years. I think on one occasion when the County Council in Clare——
Comment on this
I am referring to what is at the back of this. What is the use of having a discussion——
Comment on this
The Minister was precluded from doing so, and the Deputy must confine himself to the motion before the House.
Comment on this
The Minister would not be allowed to answer the Deputy, nor may the Deputy continue on that line of argument.
Comment on this
There is a principle behind this debate; I am not going to argue the principle. I have already stated two examples and I am going to give one other. The other has reference to Deputy Donnelly's point. It is a definite matter of company law that if a director of a company makes profit when he is a director of that company in his dealings with another company he is disqualified unless— sometimes Articles of Association put this in—before making that profit he gives public notice to the Board that he is interested and is likely to make a profit. That ought to be applied to members of the Oireachtas. It should be made apply to a Deputy who is going to make a profit. We can meet that. I suggest that what the country is agitated about, arising out of this whole matter, is: Have men made use of their representative positions to get concessions which they otherwise would not get, and are they being allowed to make profits which the ordinary man would not be allowed to make?
That is getting to my point, that the gravamen of all this is, when the Minister found property, not enhanced by the activity of these people, being traded by them for benefit to themselves, he had the right to come down at the first opportunity he had and say "I will not permit this; cut that sub-lease out; you will have to apply to me for sanction and I warn you it will not be given." That is the whole gravamen of this charge and if you crush this out from the consideration of the Committee, the Committee will not be worth while setting up. If you cut it out of the terms of reference it will simply obfuscate the issue. Without it, the terms of reference are not much good and your Committee will be scarcely worth while.
This appears in the Minister's proposal: "... all the facts and circumstances connected with and surrounding the agreement made by the lessees..." So far as the terms of reference are concerned, they only talk about the facts and circumstances surrounding the application for the lease and the facts and circumstances surrounding the agreement made by the lessees. What about the previous history of the lessees? What about their digging? Will that be investigated? What about the experience they have had? The Minister told us, somebody told us, that there were three names in the application for the lease. The lease is given to two people only. The third person has disappeared. The third person is the only one who is not a member of the Oireachtas. Will we be told why he disappeared? Will the Committee be able to investigate the circumstances under which he was bought off? Does the Minister know he was bought off, that he assigned all his rights in this lease that might be coming to him for £25?