Wicklow Mining Lease—Appointment of Select Committee.
Contributions 123–249 of 249. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
The Deputy should not, in the guise of a question, prolong the debate, which has already extended over two days.
Comment on this
I know the Minister is sick. If I were in the mess he is in, I would be sick, too, so sick that I would be almost thinking of sending in my resignation.
Comment on this
I want to get after you. There are a few things that I have to say that will make you sick.
Comment on this
There are a few general phrases used here: "to investigate and to report to the Dáil on all the facts and circumstances connected with and surrounding the application for and the grant of the said lease" and "all the facts and circumstances connected with and surrounding the agreement." Where does there come in in that the previous history of the applicants? Will it be in the circumstances surrounding the application for the lease? Is it intended to bring these things in, or does the Minister want to crush these things out? I certainly think that a £25 consideration for putting out this young fellow is a matter that ought to be inquired into, as well as the fact that it had to take a solicitor's letter even to get the £25 from them—a still more important matter.
Comment on this
We have three resolutions for consideration. One is a limited one, enlarged at the request of the people who are, in my mind, accused in this matter. It will not be enlarged at the request of myself, who raised this matter first. It is alleged to be framed in the terms of the allegations made by me, and I deny that it is so. I have quoted what the Minister said, that these are only inferences from my speech. In return I give the statements I made, and I ask that they be substituted.
Comment on this
They are set out in my proposal—(a) and (b). If the Minister likes I will put them in the form of a sentence.
Comment on this
This is how I propose to do it. I suggest that those simple facts indicate a scandal, that men should be allowed to traffic in property that is not their own, the value of which they have not enhanced to any degree by their activities, and that they should be enabled, if the transaction works out rightly, to get their 2¼ per cent. over and above the money they have to pay, as long as the stream of gold lasts, and that they shall get shares worth £12,000 in a company, with whatever these shares will yield to the shareholders after this 6¼ per cent. has been paid. A good, sound sentence! Will the Minister accept it? I do offer the two statements made by me, and if the Minister does not think they contain all the charges, let him add any he likes. Let him not, however, put down charges that are not mine.
The other alternative is, do not take these phrases; do not put them in the terms of allegations, but just take what was said. Is there anything important left out in what Deputy Cosgrave's amendment proposes? There are in that amendment eight sub-paragraphs as well as a generality. Let the generality come first so that it will not be limited by the eight paragraphs. Is the Minister not going to accept one or other of the two alternatives that are suggested, one framed in the exact terms of the allegation and the other giving the gist of everything raised in the debate, whether by way of allegation or debate or otherwise?
I suggest that the Minister ought not to hamper the members of the Committee by limiting the terms of reference. I protest against any matter being sent for consideration to a Committee framed as if it were an allegation of mine when I say it does not represent any such thing. It is not even declared to be; it is not in inverted commas and I am not going to be subjected to the Minister's version of statements of mine. I suggest that the allegations I have made are serious enough and they will give the Committee plenty of opportunity to investigate this scandal. I suggest that the Committee should be authorised to report finally on the settlement of all this type of business in the future on the lines of the public authority legislation.
Comment on this
I want to make one or two observations with a view to bringing before the House what I conceive to be the real and vital issue in the present case. It is not a question of whether the Minister for Industry and Commerce scores over his predecessor, Deputy McGilligan, or whether Deputy McGilligan scores over the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The country is not interested as to whether or not the Minister for Industry and Commerce sits here to-day as he has sat looking like a snarling dog at Deputy McGilligan and anxious to get after him. The public are anxious to know— using the words of Article 11 of the Constitution—whether the "public interest" has been preserved or whether the country has been prejudicially affected by the transactions that have taken place in connection with this lease. The public opinion on this point and the public view on the Minister's conduct will not be determined by the consideration as to whether or not the Minister has scored a debating point by means of his majority, or by getting that majority to pass through this House limited terms of reference in the setting up of this Committee. The Minister can set up this Committee by that majority that he has and he can set it up with the limited terms of reference that he proposes. The only inference that would be drawn from this by outside opinion is that the Minister is trying to side-track the real issue and that instead of letting the public know whether the public interest has been prejudicially affected by this lease, he is endeavouring to score some sort of point over his predecessor, Deputy McGilligan. What the Minister's proposal is endeavouring to do is to set up a Committee with very limited terms of reference. If the Minister were desirous of having the fullest investigation into all the circumstances surrounding this, as he pretends to have, he should ask the House for suggestions as to how the terms of reference should be enlarged in their scope so as to bring in every consideration.
Comment on this
My motion reads: "To report to the Dáil on all the facts and circumstances connected with and surrounding the application for... said lease."
Comment on this
Why does the Minister refuse to accept the terms that are offered in the amendments?
Comment on this
Why not put them in? Why does the Minister insist on his own terms of reference as distinct from anything else? It is clear to anybody reading the terms of reference proposed by the Minister that this is put forward as a restricted terms of reference and that the object is to enable the Minister to score over Deputy McGilligan, to come to the House afterwards and to say: "I told you so." We are not interested in knowing whether the Minister for Industry and Commerce scores over anybody in the House or not. What we are interested in is whether Article 11 of the Constitution under which the Minister was proposing to exercise his powers in the granting of leases has been departed from or whether the public interest has in any way been prejudicially affected. Article 11 of the Constitution is the foundation of the whole business. That Article lays down that all mines and minerals in this country belong to the State, "but may in the public interest be from time to time granted by way of lease or licence to be worked or enjoyed under the... Oireachtas." The governing words in that Article are the words "public interest." The issue is whether in the circumstances surrounding this lease or sub-lease—the whole transaction which has been adumbrated in this House by Deputy McGilligan—the public interest has been safeguarded by the Minister. The Minister is on his trial as regards this case. That is the real issue. The Minister, instead of limiting the terms of reference, should be asking the House to suggest the widest possible terms of reference and to have everything done in the widest and the fullest possible way. But it is not alone the Minister for Industry and Commerce who is on his trial. It is not alone the Department of the Minister for Industry and Commerce that is on its trial. It is the whole question of whether the public interest has been in any way prejudicially affected. The personality of the Minister is of little interest in the whole of that. Deputy McGilligan has given prima facie evidence of a gross public scandal. If there is an answer to that it ought to be given in a public way and in circumstances that will enable every fact to be brought before this Committee. I submit that the terms of reference are not drawn in such a way as to bring in certain evidence that should be available to the Committee. Certain evidence that will be tendered to the Committee will evoke a discussion as to whether or not that particular piece of evidence will be allowed because it is or it is not within the scope of the terms of reference. These terms of reference should be of the widest possible scope and there should be no loop-hole as to whether or not a particular piece of evidence that is tendered is or is not within the scope of the terms of reference. Having regard to the importance of this case, from the point of view of the public interest, there should be no room for discussion. The Minister's proposal in this case, put by way of after-thought, is merely an effort to score off Deputy McGilligan. The public wants the fullest and the freest discussion of what prima facie appears to be a gross public scandal.
Comment on this
On reading the reports of the debates in the Dáil here last week, the ordinary country reader would come to no other conclusion but that a very valuable gold mine had been discovered in the County Wicklow, and that certain Deputies in this House got concessions from the Minister for Industry and Commerce by very fraudulent and sharp practice. Such is the belief of the people at the present moment. I was very strongly under the impression myself when I rushed up here that some very hefty nuggets, discovered in the gold mine, would be flung across the House and that there was a bare chance that some would drop into the seats of the Centre Party. On the contrary, I find that there is not a particle of gold around the House to-day. As regards this Commission, I, for one, would be glad to see it set up so as to satisfy the minds of the people of the country that there is no such practice as suggested carried on in the Department of Industry and Commerce. I do not believe for one moment that there is such a thing at all as a valuable gold mine in the County Wicklow. I have had certainly too much experience of gold and diamond rushes in my time to believe anybody who stands up and says there is a valuable gold mine in Wicklow and that if it is worked properly we would be all millionaires.
Comment on this
And so am I all my life. Deputy Cosgrave suggested that we had some other ways or means of settling this dispute. Perhaps I would be allowed to make a suggestion that would be agreed to by Deputy McGilligan and by all Parties to the dispute and that is that he should go on a pilgrimage to Lough Derg and purge his mind. He may then come back to this House with a yearning and a heart's yearning to bring peace to all the people of the country.
Comment on this
Yes, the Cork farmers are working out their own salvation in the best way they can. It would be well if the Cork farmers were left to themselves to do their own business without any outside interference. It is rather painful to have to listen to the disputes that go on here from time to time. A very valuable lot of time is wasted in abuse flung across the floor of the House occasionally. It is about time that a proper understanding was arrived at between all parties for a settlement of such disputes rather than discussing a motion for the setting up of a Committee to investigate these matters. I think such questions ought to be settled inside the House by the leading Deputies and Members of the Government, and indeed, the leading men of all Parties. I think that would be a more practical way of doing the business than, week after week, having a sort of "Biddy Moriarty" contest as to the existence of a gold mine and as to the presence of certain minerals. I sympathise with Deputy Briscoe and Senator Comyn in having thrown away their money on this matter whoever tempted them to do so.
Comment on this
I should like to say a few words on this question. It is a matter, to my mind, that does not involve any party principle. I do not think it is at all desirable that it should be approached in a party spirit or discussed on party lines. Deputy Costello said just now that the real matter at issue was as to whether the interests of the State had suffered, or were going to suffer by the transaction that the Committee is to inquire into. He was referring, I think, to the financial interests of the State. But there is, after all, a second matter of great importance; that is the honour of Deputies. I think both the question of the financial interests of the State and the honour of Deputies are things that can be approached, and ought to be approached, without party spirit.
I confess I am not familiar with this matter at all. I heard part of Deputy McGilligan's speech upon it the other day and that is all I know about it. I preserve an open mind as to whether or not there was impropriety. But my own feeling is, reading through these three proposals for the settling of the terms of reference of the Committee, that none of them is entirely satisfactory. I think the Minister is right in proposing that the investigation should cover all surrounding facts and circumstances, but I think he is wrong, on the other hand, in setting forth as allegations of Deputy McGilligan things which Deputy McGilligan denies having alleged. I do not think anything is to be gained, from a public point of view, in taking that course, even if the Minister chooses to consider that these allegations were implied. To put up a motion in that form can only serve to darken counsel. I suggest that a new motion should be framed in as wide a form as the latter part of the Minister's motion and that it should give the Committee some guidance by indicating the main points:—for example, the points as to whether the original lease was improper in any way; whether it was improper in the amount the State was to be paid, or improper because of the personality of the lessees or their solidity or anything of that kind. Then the question of secrecy is also being raised. I presume that that would arise with regard to the original lease. Secondly, there is the question with regard to the agreement for a sub-lease, and whether or not there was impropriety in Deputies proposing to enter into such an agreement as that. As I say, we ought not to be dealing with these matters in a party spirit. We ought to approach them with the desire to do our best for the public interest and the honour of this House.
There is one thing I would like to state, though I do not think it would ever become public property if I did not tell it. A reference was made to another lease, a lease made by the Minister to Major Pakenham Mahon, a constituent of mine in the County Roscommon. I think that that lease was made in the early part of last year.
Comment on this
After that lease was made, a syndicate was formed for the purpose of financing the prospecting operations, and I, personally, took a share in that syndicate. Now gold-mining is about the most speculative operation one could engage in, and, in Ireland, it is very speculative indeed. I put £50 into that venture. I do not expect to see a penny of it again. But I think when the honour of Deputies is impugned—whether rightly or wrongly—it is fair that I should make that confession to the House, if confession it is to be regarded. I would like to stress the point, that I have never seen the lease made to Major Pakenham Mahon, and I believe the lease was granted before I became connected with the syndicate.
I think the whole matter should be approached in a judicial spirit by all parties and without unnecessary bitterness. Obviously, people who prospect in what is regarded as a wild-cat proposition, if they put money and energy into it, and if they pull off a long-shot by actually finding gold, may expect to make a considerably bigger profit than would be usual in normal commercial transactions, where the chances of success were greater. To summarise again what I set out to say: I would suggest that the Minister should try to frame a motion which would be acceptable to all parties in this House; that he should withdraw the present motion and take twenty-four hours to think over another. There is no advantage to be got from framing a motion in terms that impute to a Deputy allegations that he denies having made. An enquiry on that basis can only lead to heat and futility. I think he could have an absolutely comprehensive motion, and, at the same time, one which would indicate with sufficient clearness to the Committee the main points requiring decision.
Comment on this
I do not think this is as big a matter as it seems to be on the surface. Certainly it brought forth a lot of information about new investors. I may say, at the start, I invested no money in this project. I had no loose money to invest, and if I did invest, if I had money to invest, I would expect some return for it. What I would like to know at this stage is: was there an obligation on the Minister before granting this lease?
Comment on this
If there is a division on this motion and if the motion was lost there would be no Committee and there would be no chance of asking this question.
Comment on this
Paragraph (b) of Deputy Cosgrave's amendment reads: "the evidence produced to the Minister as to the mining experience, technical equipment and financial resources of the Senator and Deputy aforesaid." I should like the Minister when replying to state whether there was an obligation on the Minister to make such inquiries. I certainly did not follow all the arguments very closely but I do think that one point made by Deputy McGilligan should be considered by the Minister, otherwise I do not see much use in having these investigations by the Committee. That is the statement, the accusation, allegation or whatever you may call it, that Deputy McGilligan says he made and stands up to. If you do not get that basis of agreement for the investigation, I do not see what object there is in investigating the matter at all because the Committee cannot be asked to carry out an investigation into a charge when the accuser, so to speak, says he never made such a charge. The charge that he acknowledges that he made, and which the Minister says is, in effect, a reflection on him and on his Department, he wants to have investigated. I think that should be cleared up before anything is referred to a Special Committee, otherwise I do not see what the Special Committee would inquire into.
Comment on this
Having listened to this debate there is only one point I should like to place before the Minister. I accept that he is only too anxious to have a full inquiry into this matter and to have it cleared up. There is no question that the public mind is worried over the whole matter and the point I want to put to the Minister is this. If he does not set up a Committee of Inquiry that is going to satisfy the public, no matter what verdict it brings in, it is not going to satisfy the public. He must feel assured that the Committee of Inquiry which he sets up is going to satisfy the public as a whole. If that is done, whatever decision the Committee arrives at will satisfy the public. After listening to the debate I am not satisfied that the mere acceptance of the motion as proposed by the Minister, and the ignoring of the amendments, will satisfy the public that the Committee is going to have the full scope it should have to inquire into a matter of this kind.
Comment on this
Deputy Costello said that this Committee is not going to be set up to try the Minister for Industry and Commerce or his Department. That is quite correct. It is set up in the first instance to try Deputy McGilligan. Deputy McGilligan made a number of serious allegations here and the Committee is being set up to find out if he had any foundation for these allegations.
Comment on this
This Select Committee is going to be set up to find out if there is, in fact, any foundation for Deputy McGilligan's charges or if he is able to produce the slightest evidence to justify his making them.
Comment on this
Deputy MacDermot said that this is not a political matter and he wants it considered apart from Party rivalries and without any partisan spirit. I never heard such nonsense in all my life. Deputy McGilligan came in here on Friday week, two days before the County Dublin by-election and four days before the Galway by-election, and he threw out a number of charges against the Department of Industry and Commerce, wild charges, charges that he is now running away from, charges that he now states he never made, charges that he made in the most vindictive and malicious manner. He was not afraid, knowing that the Dáil was going to adjourn at 2.30, knowing that no member of the Executive Council was going to get an opportunity of replying to him and knowing that the by-election was going to take place in two days' time before his lies could be overtaken. This Committee is being set up to ascertain if there is the slightest shadow of foundation for these allegations.
What are the allegations which Deputy McGilligan made on Friday, June the 15th, and which were made again to-day in the form of a question? Deputy McGilligan thinks that he avoids making an allegation because he puts it in the form of a question. He is a lawyer and he ought to know that a libel can be expressed in the form of a question. Many a successful libel action was taken by parties who felt that they were injured by questions such as Deputy McGilligan is fond of asking. The Deputy's charge was that a Deputy of the Dáil and the Vice-Chairman of the Seanad were given a concession in regard to a certain gold mine in Wicklow, "merely to hawk it round London." What is the implication there? That this concession was given to these people because they were members of the Fianna Fáil Party in the Dáil and the Seanad. Deputy McGilligan says that he did not say that. He did not say it in so many words but certainly that is what he implied. When I asked him to-day if he would now say that these words were not to be taken as implying that allegation, what was his answer? His answer was: "I believe that allegation is correct." We shall give him an opportunity of supplying the foundation for the allegation or justifying his professed belief that the allegation is correct. Deputy McGilligan will not be able to run away. I take it he sticks to his allegation that it was made under conditions of secrecy.
Comment on this
That is not an allegation against me but against Deputy McGilligan, who framed the legislation under which this lease was issued and who resisted in this Dáil an amendment proposed by me that no lease should be made under that Act except with the prior concurrence of each House of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
Very well, the Deputy can endeavour to produce whatever proof he has to support that insinuation also. Deputy McGilligan also denies that he made the charge that I could have made a demise of the same rights on terms more advantageous to the State. Is he making that charge now or is he not? If he is not this whole thing falls to the ground. What is the basis of these allegations——
Comment on this
I shall read it myself— except that I have given these people the concession on terms less favourable to the State than could be got from somebody else? If it is admitted that these concessions were given on terms more favourable to the State than could be obtained from somebody else, then there is no substance in Deputy McGilligan's allegation. The implication which I have read into his allegation must be inferred from it even though he says it must not.
Comment on this
I shall deal with the Deputy's phrases later. I am sorry that Deputy MacDermot made the plea that it should be considered in a non-Party spirit, because it destroys my belief in his sincerity. The allegations were made from despicable Party motives, and they are going to be refuted and all the odium that is going to result from their refutation will fall on the Party opposite. Deputy MacDermot stated that he had himself subscribed £50 to another gold prospecting venture in County Wicklow. It is a good job the Deputy is not on this side of the House or a member of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
I shall deal with Deputy McGilligan in a minute. Deputy Cosgrave thinks that I am a bit thin-skinned because I resented these allegations. I resent them, and resent them very much. I have one asset in life, and only one, and that is my reputation for honesty. When Deputy McGilligan is trying to take that asset away, Deputy Cosgrave is surprised that I resent it. Deputy Cosgrave was thick-skinned himself apparently. Because he was associated with Deputy McGilligan for so long he developed a crocodile hide. Fortunately or unfortunately I resent allegations of that kind. When allegations of that kind are made against me, by Deputy McGilligan or anybody, they are going to be afforded an opportunity of proving them or withdrawing them.
Comment on this
I will deal with the terms of reference in a moment. Deputy Cosgrave also spoke about my extreme haste. I am in a great hurry to give Deputy McGilligan an opportunity of proving his allegations. I am in a great hurry to have this whole matter investigated and all the facts made available to this House and the public. Deputy Cosgrave also wants to know what objection I have to his terms of reference. My objection to Deputy Cosgrave's terms of reference is that they are deliberately framed to exclude from the scope of the inquiry the people who briefed Deputy McGilligan to raise this matter here.
Comment on this
They are added. Deputy McGilligan talked last week about Deputy Briscoe crossing to London. He was wrong. But there were people who went to London and represented themselves as the owners of a sub-lease and entered into an arrangement for the sale of that sub-lease on terms which secured for them £10,000 in cash and 50,000 in shares in a company to be formed, and who came back and found that Deputy Briscoe and Senator Comyn would have nothing to do with their deal, and then threatened Deputy Briscoe and Senator Comyn that the matter was to be raised in the Dáil; and it has been raised in the Dáil. They are coming in here before this inquiry, and all the facts concerning their association with this agreement are going to be made public.
Comment on this
The reason I object to Deputy Cosgrave's terms of reference is because they are deliberately framed to keep these people out of the picture. They are coming into the picture.
Comment on this
I have drafted the widest possible terms of reference. I listened with astonishment to Deputy Costello stating that my terms of reference were narrow and restricted. The speech which we heard from him must have astonished anyone who had heard something of his reputation as a lawyer. It was an appalling and painful exhibition. Listen to the terms of reference which he says are too restricted and too narrow for him:—
"to investigate and to report to the Dáil on all the facts and circumstances connected with and surrounding the application for and the grant of the said lease, and all the facts and circumstances connected with and surrounding the agreement made by the lessees for the assignment of their rights and obligations under the said lease."
Comment on this
That is what I am proposing now. My first motion dealt only with Deputy McGilligan's allegations. I thought Deputy McGilligan would take the excuse of running away from these allegations by saying that the Committee was not given wide enough terms of reference, and, therefore, when the lessees came to me and urged that in their interests the terms of reference should be widened, I agreed in my own interest also, because I am not going to let Deputy McGilligan get away with it. I am going to hang all these allegations round his neck for the rest of his life so that they will rattle in his ears on every occasion that he stands here to slander somebody else.
Deputy McGilligan tried to make a point arising out of his motion here— the point that I know an agreement has been made of a particular kind and that I will not tell the people who made that agreement that I am not going to allow it. That is the only allegation he stuck to to-day and what does that consist of? On 25th April this year the lessees sent me a copy of an agreement which they had made. They furnished a copy of that agreement, not for the purpose of asking my approval of it, but in a different connection altogether, which will become apparent to the Committee. They did not ask me to approve of it, and I gave them no reply concerning it. I have expressed no opinion on it one way or another. I was not asked to express an opinion. That is the allegation. But Deputy McGilligan's friends wrote to me and asked me for an assurance that if such an application for a sub-lease were made I would not withhold my consent, and I refused to give that assurance. That is why this matter is before the Dáil to-day.
Comment on this
It is a statement of fact. Deputy McGilligan's point No. 2 is this: Do I consider it a proper thing that men should be allowed to traffic in property that is not their own? That is obviously a type of question to which you cannot give a yes or no answer, because if you give a yes or no answer you imply that somebody is in fact trafficking in property which is not their own; and there is nobody doing that, that I am aware of, or doing any of the other things to which Deputy McGilligan referred here. I am saying here, although my knowledge of this agreement and the surrounding circumstances is perhaps only a limited knowledge, that such as it is, it convinced me that not merely are Deputy Briscoe and Senator Comyn going to come out of this inquiry clear of Deputy McGilligan's charges, but they are going to come out of it honourably; and that it will be revealed there that they, in fact, refused to take for their interests in this matter what was offered to them by the people who briefed Deputy McGilligan.
Deputy McGilligan made reference to the fact that I had to apologise to Mr. Joseph McGrath for having said something here on Wednesday last which conveyed the impression that he was associated with Irish Prospectors Limited. I did apologise to Mr. McGrath for having made that suggestion about him, and I think it is well to be clear that he has had no association with this particular development at all. He had association with an earlier gold project in 1930, but, as I stated already, as action taken by Irish Prospectors Limited created the impression in certain minds that he was associated with them, he took very definite action to have that impression removed.
Deputy McGilligan stated as a sort of additional charge that we had not sent notification of our willingness to accept applications for a mining lease of this property to a person who was within a stone's throw of Government Buildings, but that we sent it to a firm of solicitors in London and that is why we got no reply. On the same date that notification was sent to the firm of solicitors in London, a copy of the same letter with a covering note was sent to the individual in question —Mr. Summerfield.
Comment on this
I thought Deputy McGilligan was making another charge which was not covered by the terms of reference here. However, I think it is.
Comment on this
I am not sure whether it will or not. I am not clear as to its relevancy; but the Committee will be the judges of that.
Comment on this
The Deputy need not bother. I do not know that there was anything else said that I need refer to now. Deputy McGilligan made statements here which, even though they did not state in so many words the charges set out in the motion, nevertheless conveyed that impression to the minds of Deputies outside his Party and the members of the general public, as the statements by Deputy The O'Mahony and Deputy Kent have in fact indicated. When I challenged him to-day to say that his words were not intended to convey that impression, he refused to do it. On the contrary, he repeated the insinuation in each case and, consequently, I must insist that these charges are going to be investigated by the Committee. They can bring Deputy McGilligan there and they can ask him to produce whatever evidence he has, if he has any evidence, to support his allegations. When they have got rid of that, they can turn to investigate these alleged charges, having at their disposal all the information available in the Department of Industry and Commerce, all the departmental records, all the officials of the Department, and any members of the public whom they may think fit to bring before them.
Comment on this
This has only occurred to my mind now; it is not the result of any conference: has the Minister faced this possibility, that if he insists on framing the terms of reference, as they are framed here, on the basis of saying that Deputy McGilligan alleged certain things which he says he did not allege, the result may be that Deputy McGilligan and others in this Party may refuse to have anything to do with the Committee?
Comment on this
I am prepared to withdraw that part of the resolution now on this condition and this condition only: that Deputy McGilligan stands up here and says that not merely did he not make those charges but that nothing that is contained in his speech is to be taken as implying them. Only when he says that will I withdraw it.
Comment on this
Is there anything else which I did not say that the Minister would like me to withdraw?
Comment on this
If the Deputy is not prepared to withdraw that, then those charges go for investigation.
Comment on this
I asked the Minister to give me a phrase. He said he would give me one. Get me one now.
Comment on this
The Deputy said that to-day. He said in relation to the first charge that these people were members of the Government Party— the people who got the lease. He said "I believe they got the lease because they were members of the Government Party." The Deputy said that to-day. That is charge No. 1. I take it that No. 2 stands.
Comment on this
Charge No. 2 was made. Charge No. 3 was that other parties were interested in these deposits before, and that they subsequently became interested in them after the lease was issued.
Comment on this
The Deputy left that to be implied. That allegation has got to be investigated. The three charges are going to the Committee and let them report if they will. Deputy McGilligan made no effort to substantiate those charges.
Comment on this
I am prepared to do a much more difficult thing. As Deputy McGilligan, who is a lawyer, well knows it is easy to refute charges: to prove that particular charges are not true, but I am prepared, in relation to these or any similar charges, to prove a negative: to prove that they could not possibly be true.
Comment on this
It is in full in the terms of reference which I have prepared for the Committee. They can investigate anything and everything that is associated or connected with or surrounding the lease or agreement. Deputy McGilligan is not going to get from me an excuse for running away from his charges.
Comment on this
I will drag the Deputy before that Committee, and if he does not turn up, then we will have to consider whether we will not set up a judicial inquiry before which he can be brought on warrant either to sustain his charges or withdraw them.
Comment on this
You will find it difficult to drag me before a Committee to sustain charges I did not make.
Comment on this
I will cure the Deputy of his habit of making wild charges here and then running away from them.
Comment on this
I asked the Minister to give me a phrase which would cover (c). When I called attention to the terms of the motion, the Minister said that he would give me a phrase to cover (c), but we have not got it yet.
Comment on this
I mean paragraph (c) of your own motion. I was told that a phrase would be got for me to substantiate (c), which is an allegation of mine, and I am pointing out to the Minister that he has omitted to do that.
Comment on this
The implication in the Deputy's speech was that these people were interested before the lease was given.
Comment on this
The Minister said that my motion was deliberately framed to exclude certain people from this investigation. I know nothing about these people except what I gathered from the Minister in the course of his observations. I am not aware of anything in connection with this except what appeared in the Press. Does the Minister accept that?
Comment on this
I accept what the Deputy says, that the motion was not deliberately framed to exclude them, but, accidentally, it has that effect.
Comment on this
I am surprised at the Minister refusing to accept my suggestion. It surely would be possible to frame terms of reference that we could all agree to. I am genuinely anxious to have all this explored in a temperate and judicial spirit. I do not believe that we should have a party fight. It would be futile, I think, if the inquiry were to proceed on the lines laid down.
Comment on this
Have an inquiry to investigate all the facts and circumstances connected with and surrounding the transaction. That would include the propriety of the original lease and the propriety of the sub-lease which these people were proposing to enter into. Have that, and add anything else you like to it, but why bring in this controversial matter?
Comment on this
The main purpose of the inquiry is to ascertain what justification Deputy McGilligan had for making these charges.
Comment on this
And which he says he did not make. Before the motion is put, may I refer to a statement I made with regard to a particular sum of money that was collected? Deputy Briscoe said it was not true. May I be permitted to read a paragraph from the letter of the solicitor who collected the £25?
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?