Public Business. - Finance Bill, 1935—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–186 of 572. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 15 of 1935 ›
We oppose this duty on coal because outstandingly it is taxation that, like tea, sugar and tobacco, leans most heavily on the poor. It leans on them, as it leans on the whole of our people for that matter, at a time when those people are in a very bad economic condition as a result of three years of warfare, and that warfare shows no signs of doing anything but making their condition worse and worse. The very proposal out of which this amendment arises, that is, the proposal to continue a 5/- tax on all the coal coming into the country, which was imposed as the big weapon that was going to bring the people who are supposed to be making an economic war on this country to their knees, emphasises all the more the terrible state of affairs economically in which our people find themselves. Is the economic war going to go on? Are our people being protected? Are they being helped to victory in that war? If they were, and if the people were expected within the next month or two to be in twice as good an economic position as they are to-day, then we could listen to the arguments of the Minister for Finance for entering every home in the country by putting this tax on coal. But there is, apparently, no argument to be put up for this by the Minister for Finance. There is no argument that we could expect him to put up while the condition of the people is such as it is.
This tax of 5/- was put expressly on British coal because, as the Government organ said, the British people had struck at the economic life of the Irish people. That challenge was going to be answered, and nearly three years ago the country rang with the claim of the Government that it was successfully defending our people in a war that was being made on them; and one of the great signs of how successfully they were defending them was that 8,000 miners were going to be put out of work in Great Britain. Deputy Geoghegan painted a picture of the hungry miners in Great Britain turning to try and eat their coal. He painted a picture like that to show our people that while the war was on the economic conditions were going to get better here. Every month that has passed, the economic conditions have been getting worse. The people are now being asked to pay 5/- on every ton of coal they have to use.
This morning's paper gives us some idea as to the condition to which the agricultural labourers in South Tipperary are being reduced. There is no use in the Minister saying that they can use turf. There is no question of turf. This is a question of a necessity that enters into the life of practically every person in this country and for which there is no substitute here. If the Minister wants to face facts he will realise that. If he wants to face fancies he can refer to the Government organ and he will realise from reading that organ that the Research Committee is not quite sure whether they will not want all the turf in the country for the manufacture of silk stockings and whiskey. So that turf need not cross this discussion. We are dealing with a necessity for every household; we are dealing with what every household in the country has to purchase. The people who are agricultural labourers in South Tipperary are paying this tax. What do we find from this morning's paper? We find that four cottage rent collectors threatened with dismissal if they do not collect the rents of the cottages have reported to the Commissioner for South Tipperary that they cannot collect these rents. One gives as a reason that the agricultural labourer's wages in South Tipperary have been reduced to 8/- and to 10/- a week. Another reason is that where the labourers are working some of the farmers are not able to pay them and that some of the farmers are actually six months behind time in paying some agricultural labourers' wages in South Tipperary. Another collector pointed out that some of the occupiers of the cottages were receiving unemployment assistance, and another pointed out that some of the cottage rents that existed did not any longer exist. It is on these people that this tax falls heaviest, as it falls on the people in every street in Dublin where you have unemployment conditions that are just as bad. We have the position, therefore, that the people from whom the Government are setting out to collect this tax are not in a position to pay it. This tax that is now being imposed on the people must make this House realise the conditions under which it is being imposed. It reminds the House that these people are every week becoming less and less able to bear the burden of taxation that the Government is imposing on them.
The Minister can look at his import returns and he can see that the conditions are such that coal imports since his Government came into office have been seriously reduced. If one takes the first four months of this year as compared with the first four months of last year one can see that the imports are still going down and they will go down much more in the remaining seasons of this year by reason of the fact that there is this very serious tax on coal. The Minister's import figures do not show everything but they show that there is very little difference in the price of coal coming across to our ports this year as compared with last year. But the Minister was not waiting to be told here in this House what a great increase there is in the price of coal—that is, coal coming over the State border without even this 5/- tax. Then again, in connection with this tariff we have figures placed before us in reply to a Parliamentary question. The Minister was asked a question as to whether there were some people in this country who were allowed to import household and steam coal and all other kinds of coal. The Minister declined to say why these people were allowed to import this coal without paying the tariff. The Minister has told us that since the beginning of the year up to the other day there were imported under licence 5,331 tons of anthracite coal, 288 tons of gas coal, 1,184 tons of household coal and 1,247 tons of steam coal. That is to say some users of steam coal, anthracite coal and household coal are getting their coal in without paying this tax. The Minister will probably agree that they are only being allowed to get it because it would be a very serious imposition on them if they had to pay the tax. But the Minister has turned down rather ignominiously, many local bodies who are struggling to carry on under the present circumstances. He turned down these bodies when they asked to be allowed to bring in their coal without tax and some of the favoured few to whom the Minister gave a licence to import coal are able——
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir. Is not this a criticism of the administration which should arise only on the Vote for the Department of the Minister for Finance?
Comment on this
The Chair agrees with the Minister that it is a matter of administration which should be raised on the Minister's Vote.
Comment on this
The first thing that drives the Minister to grant licences to allow this coal in free is the fact that the tax was a burden on certain classes of people in the country. What is a burden to the strong is infinitely more of a burden to the weak. Surely the Minister realises that. Surely the Minister realises that if he had to give licences to certain classes of people in the country to allow them to get their coal in free, there is no class in the country more entitled to consideration in that matter than the poorest classes of the people, the working-classes. Does the Minister suggest to the House that there is any other substitute available in this country to replace coal in the city home or in most of the homes throughout the country—at any rate in the homes in the country towns? Again, this is a war tax. It is a war tax put on in desperation at a time when the Minister sees no improvement coming in the condition of the people anywhere; if his eyes are not entirely blind he must see very considerable deterioration in the people's position.
When the coal tax was imposed the Government organ told the people that Mr. MacDonald's bluff had been called. That organ told the people that a number of both British politicians and editors seems to have been soothing the British people into insanity. One of the usual symptoms of insanity that organ said was perfect blindness to plain facts. If perfect blindness to plain facts is any sign of insanity I do not know anybody in any country of which we can get any picture in the Press or anybody in this country with whom we can get in touch who show themselves more completely steeped in insanity than the Minister for Finance and his colleagues. Because there are no people about whom we read in the Press here or abroad who are so blind to plain facts as the Minister and his colleagues are blind to the fact that in this Budget they are getting after the poorest class in the country and scraping the last halfpenny out of them in a gamble of which they do not know the outcome or the objects. That is why this Party is opposing this tax.
Comment on this
It is quite clear from the Deputy's speech that he does not know what he is talking about. The Deputy was supposed to be talking to an amendment down in his own name and he did not take the trouble to touch on it.
Comment on this
This Finance Bill has reference to the budgetary proposals of the Government and it proposes to continue a very serious tax on our people. That is a tax that was introduced for the purpose of carrying on a war which was supposed to be for the purpose of hitting a certain country. This tax is now being saddled on the people of this country from one end to the other. I am particularly stressing this tax now by reason of the fact that at the present moment there has been a complete reversal of the Minister's attitude on this point of hitting another country. When the President went down to O'Connell Street or College Green to explain to the people why this tax was put on, there were a number of banners at his meeting. Some of those banners carried slogans such as: "Boycott British Goods;""Do not sail in British Ships;""Do not burn English Coal."
That was the beginning of this particular tax. Now, instead of being a tax on the section of our people who were using British coal, it is now spread over the whole of the people whose national life was being preserved by first introducing it and directing it against the British people in whose favour it is now being turned. That bears on the economic condition and well-being of our people in future. It bears upon the purchasing capacity of our people and their ability to pay their way. It means that their ability to pay their way is going to be less in future than in the past, and that this tax is going to be bigger on them in the future than it was in the past. If the Minister is so anxious to explain what he stood up to explain now, would he reply to the statements made from this side, that our people are less able to bear this tax now than they were 12 months ago and will be still less able to bear it in two months' time? It is a tax which is infinitely bigger at the present moment than it was last year.
Comment on this
I presume it would be too much to expect the Minister would in any way endeavour to justify this tax. Perhaps the Minister's melancholy, or rather I should say, his despairing silence, is due to the fact that he regrets that he is not now in opposition. What a glorious time he would have. When we remember the time the Minister occupied these benches and endeavoured to attack the Budgets then introduced, I am sure he must regret that he is not here now when every single article of food and every single item of wearing apparel is being taxed. Not alone that, but we have a tax on wheat which means a tax on bread. Now, under this we are going to continue a war-time tax upon coal for the cooking of these foods. As Deputy Mulcahy pointed out, this was a full-blown war-time measure inaugurated by the present Government to hit England back for the penal tariffs. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, or the Minister for Finance—I do not know when —informed us quite recently that it was expected to get £600,000 from this tax. Perhaps, after all, when we come to consider it, we ought to be thankful that air and water are still free. They are about all that is still free in this country at present.
When we remember the Minister's protestations from this side of the House and the glorious reductions we were promised in our Budgets when Fianna Fáil became the Government, and when we see the inglorious finale to that, it is no wonder that the Minister would feel despairing and melancholy over the business We have been treated during the discussion of these amendments to silence by the Minister and one wonders whether it is sympathy or contempt we ought to have for the Minister. After all, if the Minister feels, as he really ought to feel considering the position he is in, perhaps he is entitled to some sympathy. But does the Minister know where he is going? Has he any idea where we are drifting to? Does he think this country can continue to pay taxes on all foodstuffs and on coal? To my mind, this tax on coal, which we are endeavouring to wipe out by this amendment, is the most iniquitous tax of the whole lot.
There can be no pretence that this is a tax to protect Irish industry. Here we have British coal and British coal only. Twelve months ago it was unpatriotic to burn British coal. Twelve months ago we were called traitors on this side of the House if we attempted to say that, because our kith and kin were, to a great extent, working in England and dependent on English industry, that because the English people were the buyers of our live-stock, they should be supported in any way. To-day, it is the patriotic thing to do. Let us admit it is the patriotic thing to do. But is it a patriotic thing to see that no coal comes in here but British coal and that we have to pay at least 5/- per ton tax to our Government for the privilege of using that coal? As was pointed out by Deputy Morrissey and other speakers last night, this coal is not alone 5/- per ton too dear to the consumers here, but very possibly 10/- per ton, because we made a rough-and-ready bargain, which does not come up for discussion at present, but which, at the same time, contains no safeguard on our side.
Comment on this
I agree. Notwith standing the fact that we do not know what we are getting, that there is no standard price and quality, we have to pay 5/- per ton tax to our own Government for the privilege of using it. That is the position to which the Government has brought us. It is certainly a very inglorious finale. After all the fine things Fianna Fáil were to do for us, and all the deductions we were to have in our Budgets now we have a tax on bread, butter, tea and sugar, and on the coal to cook them. That is the position we find ourselves in, and it is certainly a very inglorious finish.
Comment on this
This is an Irish Parliament and we are discussing a very heavy tax on our people at a time when their general condition was never worse and when their future was never blacker. Fianna Fáil Deputies can snigger, but it would be much more in keeping with their protestations of concern for this country and the well-being of the people in the future if they spoke their minds, even though they did stand for taxing our people up to the hilt to finish this war in some way or other. Our people struggled to get an institution like this for the discussion of their economic and national matters. What we are dealing with now is a tax put upon a certain commodity coming into this country and put upon it with long and elaborate statements made to the people that this was one way of protecting their interests. By a turn of the Government this way of serving their interests has been completely thrown away and the machinery that was being operated, allegedly in their interests, has been turned to put a very heavy burden of taxation on the people.
The Minister sits there as if he was in a dug-out. But the people of the country are in the front trenches and are suffering the effects of his taxation and of his general policy. Is the position this—that we are going to have a front bench in an Irish Parliament used as a dug-out to protect the leaders of the Party opposite, and enable them to sit there in silence while the people of this country have to bear the evil results of their policy?
Comment on this
It has very much to do with the main subject before us, which is the capacity of our people to bear taxation.
Comment on this
The matter before the House is an amendment proposing a new section, not a question of general policy.
Comment on this
On a point of order, may I submit that it is as the direct result of the Coal-Cattle Pact that this taxation has to be borne. If the Coal-Cattle Pact was not concluded people could obtain coal free of tax from the Continent, but because of the Coal-Cattle Pact they can only obtain it from Britain.
Comment on this
The question why we voted for it does not matter. I am raising a point of order. I submit that but for the Coal-Cattle Pact the people of this country need not now be paying this 5/- per ton on British coal, and that, therefore, this discussion is in order.
Comment on this
The Chair does not accept the Deputy's submission. Apart from that, the Deputy who was in possession was speaking of the general policy of the Government and its effects upon the people, their ability to pay, and so on. If the Deputy's point was that the repercussions of the Coal-Cattle Pact bring that pact into the discussion, were adopted, then we would have a debate more appropriate to another Ministry, in fact, repetition of an earlier debate.
Comment on this
This specific point, I think, does arise. This tax is imposed upon the people because of the fact that supplies are limited. Prior to this, people could go for their supplies to the continental suppliers whose coal was free of duty. Now they are compelled to get their supplies from Britain. I submit you cannot divorce the discussion of this from the question of the Coal-Cattle Pact.
Comment on this
The Chair has not prevented Deputies from referring to one result of the pact, namely, the fact that people are compelled to import coal from one country only. The Chair did, and will, prevent Deputies from discussing the terms and merits of the Coal-Cattle Pact.
Comment on this
I recognise your difficulty, A Chinn Comhairle, and the difficulty of the House in this matter. When I referred to the general policy of the Government I simply intended it to be a reference to their general attitude with regard to coal, which was the principal weapon they used. If we cannot discuss certain aspects of the matter here, the country is getting into the position that action can be taken, such as putting a penal tariff of 5/- a ton on coal, which is used all over the country, without any possibility of the House discussing the merits of the situation. It is true that the matter was before us in the nature of a Quota Order, but what the country was faced with when this Coal-Cattle Pact came up was this: The unfortunate farmers had stock to get rid of, and it was thought better to get the Order through rather than leave them in the position that they were in at the time. They got some small relief and this House could not refuse that small relief especially when we were told we would have the opportunity on the Finance Bill of discussing this tax on coal.
Comment on this
I shall not keep the House very long. This coal tax was put on under one pretext, though no defence has been made for its imposition. This is a tax, amounting to £600,000, roughly speaking, which is being kept upon the people, though at no time was any defence put forward for its continuance. As now imposed it is something independent of the economic war. No defence was given from the Government Benches. I put it that it is an abuse of the whole idea of Parliamentary institutions that an important tax like this, and other taxes that we have been discussing here for the last few days, should be put forward without one single word of defence being urged by the Minister, who is supposed to be responsible for the finances of this country.
On previous stages of this Bill the Minister prophesied that there would be plenty of opportunities for discussing the various taxes imposed upon the people. So far as he has been able to do so, he has tried to deprive the House of every opportunity of discussing these heavy burdens by continual interference and trying to stop discussion on the one hand, and by an absolute refusal on the other hand to give the slightest justification for the imposition of these taxes. This tax is now put on as a revenue raising tax. The Coal-Cattle Pact was voted for by this Party because of the position to which the Government policy had reduced the farmers. It was an entirely distinct question. The question before the House now is, the keeping on of this tax on coal independent of any connection with the economic war. I hold in such an event it is nothing short of scandalous and complete contempt for the House, and Parliamentary institutions, that the House should be compelled to witness the conduct which it has had to witness on the part of the Minister for Finance and on the part of the Government for the past couple of days.
Not one single attempt has been made to defend the taxes imposed in this Budget. The only contribution from the Minister for Finance, when we tried to find out what justification there was for these taxes, was interruption, and interference with the Chair, and efforts to stifle debate. Coming from a Party that calls itself a majority Party in this House, such an attitude is very ominous for the future Parliamentary institutions in this country.
Comment on this
I submit that this is the first time the House has been asked to give legislative effect to this 5/- tax on coal. The position is that the Government have been collecting this 5/- duty on the imports of coal since the conclusion of the Coal-Cattle Pact, but this is the first time the House got an opportunity of discussing the matter fully on the Finance Bill. Nevertheless the Minister refuses to give any information, or to give any reason as to why the people should be asked to bear this additional tax. He has in no way attempted to justify his position. I think we can only come to one conclusion, and that is that the Minister feels he cannot justify it, and that it would be impossible for him, glib as he is, to justify this tax. I stated last night that I was driven to the conclusion that the real reason for this tax is the present condition of the revenue. I might remind Deputies, when they talk about this tax yielding £600,000 to the revenue, that the quota orders issued by our own Government here are quota orders for £2,800,000 tons of coal at 5/- per ton. That is £700,000. There is then the other matter that arises also, of the half-crown per ton paid to boats of a certain size. It seems to me that the Minister is creating a rather dangerous precedent. This attitude of the Minister on the Finance Bill, the most important Bill which comes before this House in the year, and the Bill, above all others, which affects all sections of the community——
Comment on this
May I call your attention again, Sir, to the matter before the House? It is that the duty of 5/- per ton imposed on coal shall cease to be charged, levied and paid. It is not the conduct of the Minister for Finance in this debate or any other of his functions.
Comment on this
The Chair cannot preclude Deputies from criticising the Minister for not replying. It is not a function of the Chair to direct or request a Minister or Deputy to reply.
Comment on this
It just shows that the Minister is treating the House with the utmost contempt when he gets up on an absurd point like that, which he knows himself is not a point of order. It seems to me that it only goes to show what little feeling the Minister and his colleagues have as to the effects of this tax. My charge against the Minister is that, on this section which we are discussing, he has refused to give any information to the House, and I say again that the Minister is failing in his duty as Minister, and if he persists in his present——
Comment on this
On the amendment, I want to protest against the Minister's irrelevant interruptions.
Comment on this
The Minister is failing in his duty, and if he persists in his present attitude, I say that he is unfit, more unfit than he was, to occupy the position he does occupy. I say that it is the duty of the Minister, or of any Minister, or of any person occupying the position he occupies, to give his views on and his reasons for this. Remember that this is a matter of £700,000, and the idiotic grin of Deputy Smith is not going to make it softer on the people of this country.
Comment on this
If you say so, Sir, I withdraw it. I do not know how to describe it, but shall I say his intelligent grin? It gives an indication as to the rather cool way in which the Party, which talked about £2,000,000 reductions, put £2,000,000 extra on to these three items, tea, sugar and coal, and that without a single explanation from the Minister or an attempt on his part to justify it. That seems to me to be treating the House with the utmost contempt and by treating the House with contempt, he is treating the people of the country with contempt, and is unfit to continue in the position he occupies.
Comment on this
Deputy Smith's opinion of me does not cost me a thought. I would be sorry if the Deputy had a good opinion of me.
Comment on this
Amendment put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 14:—
Before Section 25 to insert a new section as follows:—
The fee per ton payable in respect of import licences under sub-section (1) of Section 36 of the Cement Act, 1933 (No. 17 of 1933), shall be 1/- per ton, in lieu of the fee of 5/- per ton now payable as on and from the passing of this Act.
This is another instance of the pickpocket tactics of the Government. In July, 1933, the Cement Act was passed and it gave the Government power to impose a licence fee on persons bringing cement into this country. That was all right until the Minister started to deal with his budgetary situation. The night before he revealed to the people the total amount of taxation he was going to impose for the coming year and the amount of money he was going to spend, he apparently had a back-door conversation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce and he said to the Minister for Industry and Commerce: "It would be very useful if I could get about £80,000 a year in some way or another. About £65,000 would do me this year. Is there any way by which you could pick up £65,000 this year to help us balance our Budget? We have screwed every ½d. we could out of the poorest people in the country but we find that we are not able to make ends meet." Then the Minister for Industry and Commerce, either on his own initiative or with the help of the Minister for Finance, found Section 36 of the Cement Act of 1933 and the necessary order was made out imposing 5/- per ton on every ton of cement coming into the country after that night.
The Minister for Finance came into the House next day and expounded his views on the financial position of the country. He told us he was going to get a certain amount of money out of the old sources of revenue and that he was going to impose additional taxation to the amount of £1,085,000. He completely hid from the House the fact that £65,000 was going to come into the Treasury as a result of the arrangement he made the night before in regard to cement. No one knew anything about it until persons applying for a licence to import cement were informed that they would have to pay 5/- per ton on every ton of cement they wanted to import. That is the method that the Minister for Finance and the Fianna Fáil Government adopt when they want to fool this country as to the amount of money they are taking out of people's pockets to run the Government. This tax they estimated will bring in £65,000 this year and in a normal year will bring £80,000, but they walked into the Dáil next day and kept their tongues in their cheeks and said nothing about it. They presented us with a statement of receipts and expenditure totalling £29,386,000 but the £65,000 that is to be received from cement was completely hidden from us.
In the first place, we do not want to tolerate that type of conduct in carrying on the financial business of the country and in levying taxation. In the second place, we consider it scandalous that a tax of 5/- per ton should be imposed on cement. Part of the great Fianna Fáil policy is to provide everybody with their homes. It has been pointed out that an enormous amount of public money has been spent and that we are getting a much smaller return for the money that is being spent now in the number of houses that are being erected than the previous Government got. If the Minister wants to say: "We are spending too much in that way, and we shall have to take £65,000 off that expenditure or we must get £65,000 by this tax in order to put it against the money we are spending on housing, let him say so. But the tax, as it stands, means that having gone into a labourer's cottage in the country and put a tax on the linoleum, on the wallpaper and on the glass, he took a last look at the wall when going out and said: "There must be something in that that we could put a tax on," and here we have a 5/- tax put on every ton of cement. The Minister is so ashamed of his tea tax, his sugar tax and his coal tax that he dare not open his mouth in the Dáil to defend this. He is, apparently, so much ashamed of the other taxes, so much ashamed of digging inside, that into the wall of the labourer's cottage he is now putting a tax. He is putting a tax on the occupants of labourers' cottages and the local authority that is trying to provide the houses that he cannot provide himself. The Minister is so ashamed of that, that not only will he not open his mouth here but that when he came before the House with his budgetary statement and circulated his table explanatory of his expenditure and income for the year, he did not dare to show in that what he had planned to do as part of his budgetary arrangements. He did not dare to say in it that he was going to take £65,000 out of the cement coming into the country. The Minister has shown that very little would make him talk here if he could get the opportunity of talking. He has been butting in every second minute when we endeavour to present a case here. I do wish that the Minister's shame would drive him into making some explanation as to why this tax is being put on, and why it has been put on in the exact way in which it is being put on.
Comment on this
I would like to support this reduction in the duty imposed on cement. I do not know what the Minister calculates it will add to every house that is being put up, but certainly £5 per house is a moderate estimate of the increased cost that will be occasioned.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I do not know whether the Deputy has adverted to the fact that this import licence fee is levied under Section 36 of the Cement Act, 1933, which gives the Minister for Industry and Commerce power to fix, with the concurrence of the Minister for Finance, the licence fee which will be payable on the importation of cement. I cannot see how the remarks of Deputy Dockrell can be made relevant, even if this amendment were in order, on this particular Bill, because I do not see how the amendment could be given effect to unless by amendment of the Act of 1933 and there is no mention of that in the amendment.
Comment on this
The Minister has raised a point of order. The amendment was considered by the Chair to be in order. Consequently Deputy Dcokrell is in order in asking for a reduction of this duty on cement.
Comment on this
What would be the effect of the amendment, if passed, on Section 36 of the Cement Act of 1933?
Comment on this
All that it would be necessary for the Minister to do would be to withdraw the Order imposing his particular licence. It would not be necessary to amend the Act.
Comment on this
If the amendment were an express attempt to amend legislation, the Chair would have a different view on it, but I understand the Minister has power to regulate this charge.
Comment on this
But this is not a request to reduce it. This is an attempt, over the heads of the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance, to reduce this licence fee from 5/- to 1/-, the power to fix the fee at 5/- having already been conferred on these Ministers by an Act of the Oireachtas. There is nothing in this amendment which purports to remove that power from them, and, therefore, I cannot see how, if the amendment were carried, it could be given effect to. I am not pressing the point, but I submit that it is z matter that ought to be considered.
Comment on this
That is a matter that can be regulated by a Quota Order, and the issue, either as to the Act or the Minister's discretion, is not affected.
Comment on this
I would like to suggest to the Minister for Finance that the 5/- duty imposed by his colleague is, as we have been endeavouring to point out, adding considerably to the high costs of building in this country. It is quite unnecessary to point out, I submit, that an increase of £5 in the cost of a house must occasion some increase in the rent, and from that point of view this charge will fall on the working classes of the country. The Minister is aware, taking cement under the three main headings— British, Danish and Belgian—that there is a 5/- emergency duty as well levied on the British. If one looks up cement imports for 1933 he will see that the effect of that has been that British imports have fallen by 36,000 tons and that Danish imports have increased by 38,000 tons. I do not suggest that the Minister had any wish to throw the British cement trade into the hands of Denmark, but that has been the effect. I do not wish to enlarge on the fact that cement boats that have come over from Denmark have in certain instances, probably in many, brought back coal from England to Denmark in order to enable Denmark to fulfil the undertaking to increase imports from Great Britain. I suggest to the Minister that one part of the tax ought to be done away with. As regards the second part, namely, that levied on the British, I suggest to him that he ought to try and see if the British, in return for taking that off, would not allow in free some exports from this country that are at present subject to tax. That is all that I have to say on this, and I hope that the Minister will deal with it when replying.
Comment on this
The Minister seems to be going on the assumption that there is no obligation whatever on him to pay any heed to the wishes of this House. He seems to think that when a Bill is passed here conferring certain authority on the Minister for Industry and Commerce and himself to do certain things, and when matters under it, such as this tax, come before the House for review, that there is no obligation on him to pay any heed to the views of Deputies. Is it the Minister's contention that if the House decides, by a majority, to pass this amendment that he is not under any obligation to obey the wishes of the House? If that is the Minister's assumption, it is a very arrogant assumption, indeed. I do not know whether the Minister for Finance or the Minister for Industry and Commerce realises what this provision means. Considering the other taxation imposed, we need not wonder at this tax, but it is certainly going to have the effect of increasing the cost of the erection of houses and of increasing the rents of houses. As Deputy Mulcahy pointed out, there would be some sense in the Government saying that they would reduce their grants for housing. Instead of that, they say they will get the money in another way, by taxing cement. The effect will be the same. I do not know whether the Ministers concerned realise the extent to which cement is used on the farm. Anybody acquainted with the country knows that the use of cement has done more to tidy up small farmers' places than any other article ever manufactured in this or any other country. Cement is still being used extensively by the farmer but, apparently, the Minister cannot keep his hands off anything that will bring money to the Government. It is not a happy state of affairs for any of us that food, clothing, cement and other items of common use should have to be taxed to meet the Government's extravagant requirements.
Comment on this
A very active organisation is agitating in the country districts with a view to bringing before the Government the question of the buying out of labourers' cottages. This tax on cement has only one purpose. That is to help in raising revenue. It is not going to help any cement industry about to be started in the near future. When it is realised that cement is being deliberately taxed to provide money for the running of the Government and that this tax will fall on the future owners of the cottages which are being built in the country, the pit into which the Government have fallen financially will be appreciated.
Comment on this
The duty to which the Deputy refers was imposed by an Act of the Oireachtas and the purpose of the amendment before the Committee is to have that duty reduced. I may also say that the Chair had some doubts as to whether this amendment and, on the same grounds, a Government amendment No. 20, were in order. If one were ruled out, both would have to be disallowed. I allowed both amendments.
Comment on this
I want to make an appeal for the abolition of this tax on behalf of local bodies. Local bodies are endeavouring to lay permanent ways for the convenience of traffic. The most successful way of dealing with heavy traffic is to lay down substantial concrete roadways. The ratepayer and the taxpayer will be mulcted in increased cost by this tax in connection with the laying of these permanent ways. Public bodies, such as the authorities of mental homes and hospitals, as well as private individuals, will have to dig deeper into their finances because of this taxation. Mr. Lloyd George said, after the war: "Search their pockets to the uttermost farthing." That is what the Minister is doing. It is a pity we have not a Kaiser here, because he could say: "Hang the Kaiser" as well.
Comment on this
The Government would be well advised to consider this amendment before rejecting it. This provision puts a tax upon industry and initiative and affects practically every type of institution required in the development of the industry and commerce of the State. A later amendment seeks to deal with a situation which might arise in connection with contracts. If there is one thing more inadvisable than another, it is that contracts should be the subject of dispute between the persons who enter into them. In this case, we have the imposition of a licence duty which amounts to a tax. The Dáil, when it passed the Bill, never thought it would be used in this fashion. In the Minister's opinion, there is, apparently, the possibility of disputes between the contracting parties. To obviate resort to the courts, the Government have introduced amendment No. 20. If this Finance Bill passes without the amendment proposed by Deputy Mulcahy, a further warning will be given to persons who are about to enter into contracts. In the normal course, people can calculate a certain percentage as representing the difference between the estimated, or even accepted, cost under a contract and the ultimate cost. If, by reason of an Act of the Oireachtas, the parties are not able to appraise that percentage but have to fall back upon a speculative amount, you will interfere with the making of contracts, and you will hinder any expansion or improvement in business premises or in factories or other institutions. It so happens that, amongst the requirements of the community, building has, perhaps, advanced more in cost during the last few years than anything else. It may be urged that this particular provision was not intended to increase the cost of building, but, owing to the manner in which this portion of the section is drawn and has been operated, there can be no other result. It is one of those provisions of the Act which might be re-considered.
It is not impossible for the Minister to fix a quota in connection with this amendment. If he wants to secure his object, that can be easily done. He can ensure that there will be no increase in the stocks normally required and, if the aim be to make a market for cement manufactured in this country, it can be done in that fashion. One can draw no other conclusion from the manner in which this licence fee of 5/- per ton is imposed than that it is a customs tax. It is a customs tax which, according to the Minister's speech on the Budget, is not required to balance the Budget. Therefore, it is either a plum or it has been imposed to meet some service or expense of which we have not heard. If such moneys are required they should be got from some other source than taxing such necessaries as housing, the construction of factories or buildings, or the extension of business premises. The Minister would be well advised to reconsider his attitude with regard to the acceptance of this amendment.
Comment on this
The Minister objects to this House taking cognisances of the fact that he came in with his Budget statement and withheld the very serious fact that he had put on £65,000 in taxation the night before. He objects to the House discussing the fact that he did that, or discussing the nature of the tax, as he considers that the House is interfering with the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance. The House gave the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance power to do certain things in connection with the putting on of a licence fee on cement. It gave them that power in the open daylight, and neither the Minister for Industry and Commerce nor the Minister for Finance ever gave the slightest intimation that they were going to utilise it in the way it has been utilised.
Comment on this
I do not know if it is worth while raising a point of order again. The Deputy is now criticising the conduct of the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance. The Vote for the Minister for Finance will be before the House, and it is usual on that Vote to criticise his conduct as an administrator. The Vote for the Minister for Industry and Commerce has been passed, and I do not think any further opportunity will arise to discuss the conduct of that Minister.
Comment on this
May I submit that I am discussing the effect of their attitude on the people of this country, financially?
Comment on this
The administration of the Department of Industry and Commerce does not arise. The effect of this tax, if considered such, does arise.
Comment on this
I am commenting on the way in which the Minister for Finance is treating this matter.
Comment on this
His attitude. The Minister by this tax is raising the cost of housing, raising rents and the cost of road making. He has done that in the dark of night with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and we want power to limit the great stars, Castor and Pollux, so that the tax on cement will not exceed 1/-.
Comment on this
Will the Minister say a few words now? The Minister can be very nice, very polite, very plausible, and very dignified. Surely he can give us a little of that now. He has given very little of it in the last few days. Out of politeness to the House, and for dignity of the House, will he not say something now by way of explanation?
Comment on this
I think it is a great pity that a tax of this kind should be imposed. It was pointed out by Deputy Brennan and by Deputy Minch that that tax will seriously affect the activities of local authorities. At the same time, I think it right to say that it will not affect the cost of housing to the extent Deputy Mulcahy or Deputy Brennan anticipate. The ordinary four-room cottage takes about 10 tons of cement. With a tariff of 5/- per ton that would mean an extra cost of about £2 10s. per house, or, calculated on the basis of what it costs to borrow money for housing from the Local Loans Fund, it would mean that the tenant would be charged one-third of the one-fortieth part of £6 13s. 4d. per year.
Comment on this
I am going to vote with the Government on this question. That is exactly what the tax will represent.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy consider, after having made a careful calculation, that it would only impose an extra cost of £2 10s. 0d. on four-room houses?
Comment on this
About that. I do not think that labourers' cottages would take ten tons of cement. I was speak-of four-room houses in urban areas.
Comment on this
We are protesting against all these taxes being imposed in this way, having regard to the condition of the people. I do not know if Deputy Corish is a member of the Wexford County Committee of Agriculture. The body with which he is connected is responsible for the setting up of that Committee, and for four months running, in the early part of this year, Wexford County Agricultural Committee appealed to the Government to come to the rescue of agricultural labourers in County Wexford, and to extend to them the benefits of the free meat scheme, on the ground that the average wages paid labourers in Wexford were only 8/- weekly. We are going to put a tax on cement which is going to take 1/- out of the 8/- that they receive weekly.
Comment on this
As I pointed out with regard to coal, the same condition is reported to exist in County Tipperary.
Comment on this
Question put: "That reference No. 3 stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 15:—
In sub-section (1), to delete all words from and including the word "Where", line 15 to and including the word and bracket "Act)" line 17 and substitute the words, "Where, either before or after the passing of this Act, a sum of money exceeding £100 is lodged or deposited (otherwise than on a current account) in Saorstát Eireann."
This amendment is designed to ensure that current accounts will not be caught by the section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:—
In sub-section (1), line 22, to delete the word "produced" and substitute the word "furnished."
The object of this amendment is merely to enable the banker to retain the certificate as a safeguard after the money has been released.
Comment on this
I pointed out that the object of this amendment is merely to enable the banker to retain the certificate as a proof that it had been furnished to him and that the money was properly released.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:—
In sub-section (4) line 37, to delete the word "produced" and substitute the word "furnished."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:—
Before sub-section (5), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"Where a banker is charged with an offence under this section, it shall be a good defence to such charge to prove that, at the time when such banker made the payment of money which is alleged to constitute such offence, he had reasonable ground for believing that none of the persons in whose joint names such money was lodged or deposited with him was dead."
I think the purpose of this amendment is self-evident.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 19:—
In sub-section (5), after line 43, to add the words—
"the expression ‘current account' means an account which is customarily operated upon by means of cheque or banker's order."
This is merely a drafting amendment consequential upon amendment No. 15.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say whether there is any other legal interpretation of "current account" than that?
Comment on this
I do not know, but I think the Standing Committee of the Banks are satisfied that the proposed amendment will safeguard them sufficiently.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:—
Before Section 36 to insert a new section as follows:—
Whenever the importation into Saorstát Eireann of any goods is prohibited by or under an Act of the Oireachtas (whether passed before or after this Act) and provision is made by the same or any other Act for the issue of licences for the importation of such goods notwithstanding such prohibition. Section 10 of the Finance Act, 1901, as amended and extended by Section 7 of the Finance Act, 1902, and by Section 43 of the Finance Act, 1932 (No. 20 of 1932), shall apply and in the case of licences issued under an Act passed before this Act, be deemed always to have applied to any fee which may be chargeable by statute or under statutory authority on the issue of such licences, and to any increase or decrease in the amount of any such fee, and to the repeal of the statute or statutory authority under which any such fee is chargeable, in like manner in all respects and as fully as if such fee were a Customs import duty within the meaning of the said Section 10.
Section 10 of the Finance Act, 1901, provides, among other things, that where a Customs duty is imposed on any commodity delivered under a contract made before the date of the imposition of the duty the amount of the duty paid in respect of such goods may be added to the contract price. This section does not apply to import licence fees. It is proposed here to extend that in order to alleviate any hardship which might be caused to contractors or others by placing import licence fees on the same footing as Customs duties in the matter of contracts.
Comment on this
So that the whole of the Minister's objection to the previous amendment by Deputy Mulcahy falls to the ground?
Comment on this
The Minister was making a case a short time ago that import licences were not taxation, and that in consequence an amendment to reduce the import licences was in his opinion out of order. He went perilously near the domain of disorder when he was challenging the House as to whether it was competent for it to consider the amendment. Now he proceeds to recognise a licence order of exactly the same character as an imposition of Customs duty. A licence order, according to this, is equivalent to a Customs duty. In order to get round that particular matter it is branded now as a Customs duty. The position we are in with regard to cement is that, while in the Minister's mind we were out of order in discussing it a few moments ago as a Customs duty imposition, now we are at liberty to regard it as such as soon as this amendment is passed. This raises the question which I dealt with a few moments ago that contracts are now scarcely worth the paper they are written on. They relate only to a set of circumstances before interference by the legislation, and before the alteration took place with regard to duties, Customs and so on. Deputy Corish said here a short time ago that the cost on a labourer's cottage of the imposition of this cement duty would amount to one-third of the one-fortieth part of £6 13s. 4d. He did not tell us where he got his figures.
Comment on this
As far as this particular thing is concerned it has a bearing on it, because it means that the contractor — that is in essence the occupants of labourers' cottages in future—is going to pay this. Until this is passed the liability is on the builder. It will be on the occupant of the labourer's cottage directly this is passed. Am I not entitled in those circumstances to mention that this is a tax on the occupants of labourers' cottages?
Comment on this
To mention the matter, yes, but not to reply to arguments advanced in the debate on a previous amendment.
Comment on this
I always understood it was the first law of natural philosophy, having acquired a knowledge of one's duty, to communicate it to others.
Comment on this
The mistake was very nearly passing this House that the interest on £2 10/- would be a shilling a year.
Comment on this
I am dealing now with the occupant of the labourer's cottage, and he is going to suffer because of an increased cost of £2 10/-, taking it from a source that is not ex-cathedra, I suppose.
Comment on this
The Deputy will have to be content with that. A discussion on cement would not be in order.
Comment on this
This really deals with cement. The obvious intention of this particular amendment of the Government is to ensure that the licence duty is now to be regarded as a Customs duty, and as such it will affect contracts in future to that extent. Before this amendment passes——
Comment on this
On a point of order, may I call your attention to the fact that there is nothing in this section which states that a licence duty is to be regarded as a Customs duty.
Comment on this
So the income from it will not be disclosed in the Budgetary statement every year? Does the Minister mean that?
Comment on this
The terms of this particular amendment are:—
"... Section 10 of the Finance Act, 1901, as amended and extended by Section 7 of the Finance Act, 1902, and by Section 43 of the Finance Act, 1932 (No. 20 of 1932), shall apply and in the case of licences issued under an Act passed before this Act, be deemed always to have applied to any fee which may be chargeable by Statute or under statutory authority on the issue of such licences, and to any increase or decrease in the amount of any such fee, and to the repeal of the Statute or statutory authority under which any such fee is chargeable, in like manner in all respects and as fully as if such fee were a Customs import duty within the meaning of the said Section 10."
Comment on this
It makes it a Customs import duty for the purposes of this Act, which is all we are concerned with, and so far as the licence duty in respect of cement is concerned this is intended to cover it. It is no longer, in so far as this Act is concerned a licence duty but a Customs duty, and must be regarded as such. As such, it transfers the burden from the shoulders of the builder to the shoulders of the occupant of a labourer's cottage, of the man who is extending his premises, or of the man who is building anything to which the cost of cement will enter in. If that point is clear—and it is not easy to make points clear to some people—we can proceed to deal with the matter. It so happens that there is no member of that front bench over there who is building a house, or perhaps who has ever built one.
Comment on this
A resumption of the discussion on the cement duty is not in order. This is a general resolution with no particular application to cement. Surely the Deputy would not suggest that the fact that a contractor might employ any material that might come under this amendment would justify the Deputy in entering into a detailed discussion on the costs that might be entailed by using such materials in industry.
Comment on this
Could he not illustrate the effect on the cost of cement by one particular example? Surely that is in order.
Comment on this
The Deputy was not prevented from so illustrating his argument. The transfer of the costs from contractor to owner and consequent costs on housebuilding, are matters which should have been raised on another amendment, and were in fact so raised.
Comment on this
Then we will come back to the matter in this fashion, that this amendment is going to resolve any doubt that there was in anybody's mind as to who is going to pay the 5/- tax. This amendment will ensure that it is going to fall upon the shoulders of the poor people in the country. It is going to fall on the occupant of every labourer's cottage which is going to be built from this out, and in respect of which a 5/- licence duty is paid on cement. It is a monstrous state of affairs that that sort of thing should go on. The money is not required, as I said before, in connection with the Budget, or the Minister cannot be relied upon in connection with his Budget speech.
Comment on this
This amendment is in general terms, but what in fact it seeks to do is this: When the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance met to discuss what was wrong with the Budget and to find £65,000 on cement, there were local bodies throughout the country, and private persons, who had entered into building contracts. If we take County Wexford, where they have been building a lot of labourers' cottages, it is quite possible that there are some outstanding contracts between the Board of Health and builders in connection with some of the labourers' cottages that were in process of building then. The amendment here seeks to transfer to the Board of Health, and in fact from them to the labourers, the increased cost over the cost that the Board of Health had arranged to build the cottages for. I consider that to do that is absolutely unjust. With the limited amount of money at the disposal of the Board of Health, and with the limited capacity of the labourers to pay their rents, the increase of £2 10/- per house did raise a question for them which necessitated a review of their general housing position before entering into commitments to go ahead perhaps with more houses. I think there was a previous occasion upon which action of this kind was contemplated by the Minister in connection with the tariff put on steel, where they adopted a different method and where they allowed a certain amount off, where they took off at least the burden of a tariff in certain instances. I think what the Minister should do in connection with housing contracts and road contracts—generally, wherever there are contracts affected by the imposition of a tariff on cement from 14th May—is that instead of upsetting the contracts in this way by putting the cost of cement on top of them, that the cement should be admitted free of the cost of this licence in respect of such contracts as are caught. That is a more reasonable and a fair way of doing it; it would be the fairer way of doing it in respect of any licence of this kind.
Nobody knows now, or at any time, where he stands with regard to any contract. A licence duty, or an emergency tariff, in respect of the various things upon which the Ministry have power to impose a tariff, may catch a contract in any particular stage. It may be the building of a house or the manufacturing of an article, or a set of articles. It means playing ducks and drakes with the small amount of business there is in the country if this want of confidence that is brought about by the insertion of a general clause of this kind is going to operate on the commercial community, or on the section of the community requiring constructive work to be done. I am opposed to this amendment and I think the House should oppose it. There is another and a more reasonable way of dealing with the matter and that is by granting licences for the free import of such things as are involved in the actual contracts.
Comment on this
I would like to support the attitude taken up by Deputy Mulcahy. The Minister and my friend, Deputy Corish, must realise what difficulties are going to present themselves in relation, for instance, to the building of cottages. Take the estimate given by Deputy Corish to-day that ten tons of cement will build a labourer's cottage.
Comment on this
There was an amendment before the House dealing with cement and it was disposed of. The Deputy should realise that.
Comment on this
I quite agree. The point I want to make is this. What safeguard is there for local authorities in this matter in view of the Minister's amendment? Deputy Corish tells us that it takes ten tons of cement to build a house. Suppose a contractor in Roscommon says "No; it takes 20 tons of cement," the extra charge must go on the local authority. Who is to act as arbitrator?
Comment on this
May I suggest that if the Minister has any remarks to make it might be more conducive to orderly debate if you could induce him to make a speech and not to be interrupting continually? It has occurred here repeatedly and he has never stood up to reply to anyone. I merely make that suggestion.
Comment on this
I am perfectly serious in what I am saying. Apparently, the Minister is not very serious in his remarks. There are various contracts being given all over the country by private persons and local authorities for cement houses, and quite a large amount of cement is being used. Suppose a contractor says he has to use a certain amount, who is to determine whether he has or not? Are we not at the mercy of the contractors? So far as the local authorities are concerned, who is to arbitrate? The Minister asked me had I heard of a quantity surveyor. Of course I have heard of a quantity surveyor. But I am sure the Minister is well aware that quantity surveyors are not always engaged on these jobs. There is no safeguard for the public, so far as this matter is concerned.
Comment on this
The Minister, this year, has already permitted the importation of 108,000 tons of coal without the payment of duty. Why can he not remit the amount of the licence on cement caught by contracts on the 14th May last? What is the difficulty about doing that? Would it not be a great relief for the community generally if that arrangement were adopted? What is the difficulty in doing with regard to cement or any other article that is caught in this way what has been done in respect of 108,000 tons of coal?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:
Before Section 36 to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) Sub-section (2) of Section 38 of the Finance Act, 1926 (No. 35 of 1926) is hereby amended by the insertion of the word "five" in lieu of the word "three" where it occurs in that sub-section and the said Section 38 shall be construed and have effect subject to the provisions of this section.
(2) This section shall come into force and have effect as on and from the 5th day of August, 1935.
Under the Finance Act of 1926 it is provided that in respect of persons who are in receipt of wages they are exempt from receipt stamp duty if the amount of their wages does not exceed £3 a week. Formerly, the position was that a person whose wages exceeded £2 a week was required to pay from those wages receipt stamp duty measured at the rate of 2d. a week. In 1926 the Dáil amended the relative Act, I think it was the Stamp Act of 1891, in such a way as to provide that the amount of wages necessary to require the fixation of a receipt stamp would be raised from £2 a week to £3. This amendment now seeks to raise the amount of wages for which receipt stamp duty will be required from £3 to £5.
The imposition of a tax upon the wage earners for the mere privilege of drawing wages which he has already earned by his toil is something I have never been able to understand. If the State feels the worker must subscribe his signature for the receipt of wages, it ought to pay the cost of his doing so. If the requirement is in the interest of the employer, the employer ought to be obliged to make a contribution. Under the Stamp Act it is the recipient who is required to make the contribution in respect of the fixation of the stamp. The requirement, in my view, is unfair to weekly wage earners, inasmuch as the more frequently a person is paid wages the more often he is required to make this contribution. Weekly wage earners make it 52 times a year, whereas in the case of a person paid monthly he makes only 12 contributions, and the amount of the contribution is the same. People paid quarterly make only four contributions and, although the sum they receive may be 50 times more than a weekly wage earner receives, the amount of the contribution is just the same.
In Great Britain and Northern Ireland this requirement has long since been discontinued, but in the Saorstát, although we inherited the legislation originally from Britain, we have continued it long after Britain abandoned it. I hope the Minister will accept this amendment. In fixing £5 I have endeavoured to confine the exemption to those properly described as the wage earning classes.
Comment on this
I regret I cannot see my way to accept this amendment. I do not know how general the practice may be of employers requiring employees to give receipts for the weekly wages, or salaries, paid to them, and until I have some further opportunity of looking into the matter I would not be in a position to agree to the principle proposed in this amendment. I will, however, look into the matter further and possibly—I do not want to be told next year that I said probably—we may be able to do something on the lines indicated by the Deputy.
Comment on this
When the Minister speaks about looking into these things does that mean knocking around to look into them and possibly seeing some other thing on to which he could stick a tax and out of which he could squeeze a few more halfpence? There is not a particular class in the community that the Minister has not got in already so far as this Budget is concerned. The main people he is getting after are people who would be saving a couple of pence a week by the proposal which Deputy Norton has put down. The Minister may coo about this proposal. I think it would be a very small concession to give to a class of people from whom he has squeezed so much. But I may say that I feel some apprehension as to what may happen to the class in which Deputy Norton is interested when the Minister looks into this question.
Comment on this
The Minister now pledges himself about this matter, and he says he would require about 12 months to look into it. Apparently that means that it is only after 12 months' cogitation on the matter that the Minister can give a decision. I think I can produce a letter from the Minister, dated 1934, in which he said he would look into this matter, so that he has had already 12 months to do so. The Minister now comes to the House as if he had never written that letter. But the Minister has committed himself in writing already 12 months ago. He promised to do so last year; he will hardly contend that it requires a further 12 months' examination after having made a very specific promise that he would look into it. It is a very small concession, it is definitely measurable, and its cost to the Exchequer will be small. At the same time, it will remove from the wage earners a constant cause of irritation. I hope the Minister will expedite the process of looking into it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 22:—
At reference No. 1 in the third column to delete "75 per cent." and to substitute "20 per cent."
In this Schedule we have the beginning of a cycle tax. In his last extremity when going around the house of the worker the Minister's agents saw a bicycle and they saw a pretty light at the back. Then it was that they realised that it was necessary to have rear reflectors on a bicycle. The Minister heard the various suggestions that are being made with regard to a cycle tax and he hit on the magnificent idea of putting a tax on bicycles—a tax that would not be noticed. I searched the latest and the most up-to-date official directory ever published——
Comment on this
I must say that my remarks there were in inverted commas. The Minister has decided on putting a tariff of 75 per cent. on rear reflectors intended for use on bicycles or tricycles. I say this is nothing but a bicycle tax. If the Minister wants to say that since the issue of his directory a factory for the manufacture of rear reflectors for bicycles and tricycles has been set up I would like to ask him how many people are employed in it and whether he could give us some particulars about it. He should tell us why these reflectors cannot be manufactured in this country and sold at satisfactory prices without this enormous tariff of 75 per cent. being imposed on imports.
Comment on this
Rear reflectors intended for other purposes than for bicycles are at present subject to the same rate of tax as is proposed here. There seems no reason why the same duty should not apply to rear reflectors for cycles. These can be made equally well here. The company that was engaged in the manufacture of these articles ceased operations in consequence of the dumping of rear reflectors from other countries. There is no reason why these articles should not be manufactured here at prices which are very satisfactory. It is necessary to afford protection in order to prevent undue competition from external sources.
Comment on this
I think a tariff of 75 per cent. is an outrageous tariff. I do not know what the Minister means by rear reflectors being made at suitable prices.
Comment on this
I do not know what the Minister means by suitable prices, but I take it he means an addition of 75 per cent. to the present price at which they are sold.
Comment on this
The Minister seems to have an extraordinary mind in approaching these matters. His method of reducing prices seems— somewhat like in the case of the cutlery and knives—to decrease the present price by putting on a 75 per cent. tariff. If reflectors are sold at anything like the same price as the present price and if they are to be of the same quality, what is the necessity for this tariff? Why should there be any need? Why should traders introduce large quantities of a dearer and worse article when they can get as suitable made at home? The Minister has made no case for imposing the high tariff of 75 per cent. The Minister's only method of decreasing the cost of an article here seems to be to put on a tariff of 75 per cent.
Comment on this
The Deputy asked why should traders import large quantities of a dearer and worse article. I do not know, but the fact is they do.
Comment on this
One reason why they were imported is that persons dealing with Germany in the matter of accessories generally brought in general accessories in bulk and rear-reflectors were part of that consignment. I remember when that industry was in existence a couple of years ago hearing it discussed. I remember that the man who was running the industry was described as a very enterprising man with a very efficient establishment. At the same time he found it impossible to carry on. He was not in a position to advertise his goods. In order to get a connection with existing wholesale traders he would have had to spend money; he would have had to provide working capital that was not available to him. At the same time, traders who had it in their power to make or mar his industry had established connections and they were importing large quantities of accessories, including rear reflectors, and were getting them, I was told, at extraordinarily cheap prices. But the plea that I heard for protection for this industry was from a man, I may say he was a political supporter of the Opposition, who simply had observed there was an industry that ought to be protected. At the same time, he prophesied that if it did not get substantial protection in the circumstances in which it found itself it would inevitably go out of existence.
Comment on this
I should like to assure Deputy Moore that if any political supporter of this Party came to us and said that there should be a tariff on such-and-such an article we would require to hear a case for putting on a tariff of 75 per cent. We have heard no case either from Deputy Moore or from the Minister.
Comment on this
I should like to ask Deputy Moore if the position is that cycle accessories are coming in here, part of them being a rear reflector, and if under this proposed tariff, the 75 per cent. is going to operate on the whole part—that the whole part is going to be treated as a reflector?
Comment on this
It is quite obvious that a different case is being made by the Minister and by Deputy Moore. The Minister tried to get out of it by saying that they are being sold cheaper. It is obvious that if wholesalers get them cheaper they can sell cheaper. Therefore, the case is that there is going to be a dearer price charged than need be charged as a result of this. That was not the case put up by the Minister at the start. As usual, they were to be got cheaper. Deputy Moore gets up and blows the foundation from under that by saying that they were dumped. It is the very opposite case to what the Minister put up.
Comment on this
Question put: "That reference No. 6 stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 23:—
In reference No. 3, second column, after the words "and bandaging material" in the last line of the reference to insert the words "and also crepe bandages and bandaging material."
Comment on this
The amendment is unnecessary as the articles mentioned in it are not subject to duty.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment No. 24:—
At reference No. 5, in the 3rd column, to delete "50 per cent." and substitute "20 per cent."
Reference No. 5 here proposes a tariff of 50 per cent. on felting and felting substitutes and other like substances intended for use as roofing material or as a damp course. There is a very considerable amount of housebuilding going on and much of it is financed by the State. Unlike the financing of housing carried on by the previous Government, a great deal of the finance is carried on to-day on borrowed money. A very considerable amount of debt is being piled up for a comparatively small number of houses. Numbers of houses are still required and need to be built. This is one of a series of taxes tending to raise the cost of small classes of building material, some important, some not so important, by a considerable amount. There does not seem to be the slightest reason at all why a tariff as high as 50 per cent. should be imposed upon felting, or on a variety of substances coming into this country. The Minister can perhaps tell us to what extent these things are being manufactured here, and the amount of employment that is being given. He may be able to give some reason why the cost should be increased so much as in the case of this particular tariff. There is certainly no reason known to us why that should be done. There are many reasons connected with the housing programme in existence that go to show why this tariff should not be raised to more than 20 per cent.
Comment on this
The fact is that Irish made roofing felt is cheaper and generally better than the imported material; that is generally agreed. For some unexplained reason there is still an import of something like £100,000 worth of roofing felt. Roofing felt is manufactured in this country by two firms, one in Dublin and the other in Waterford, and between them they could supply all our requirements. In making the statement that Irish roofing felt is cheaper and better I do so after consultation with those who are competent to express an opinion.
Comment on this
To say that because an Irish article is cheaper and better than the imported article you must put on a 50 or 75 per cent. duty on the imported article is simply absurd. I am quite willing to believe that Irish felt is cheaper and better, but the Minister is not taking an opportunity of advertising that fact. He is telling the country that it is neither cheaper nor better by his conduct in this matter, and he is thereby doing damage to Irish industry rather than otherwise.
Comment on this
In the few remarks that he made I am not clear that the Minister made any case for this 50 per cent. duty. There is one extraordinary aspect of this that perhaps deserves to be mentioned. I think one member of the Government Party, when this Finance Bill was introduced, said that these duties were of course put on for protection purposes and that there was no such case as putting on a duty on raw material, and putting a lower duty on the finished article. I should like to point out that under this heading precisely that state of affairs will be brought about because felting and felting substitutes are subject to a 50 per cent. tariff, but when you print anything on them they come in free as felt base floor coverings. I do not know if anybody has noticed that some enterprising builder is using what some persons might take to be carpets for damp course, which, on investigation, prove to be merely felt base floor covering which had been cut up because it came in free. If that situation is brought about, it would render this section Gilbertian. It seems extraordinary that linoleum and oilcloth should be subject to a duty and that felt base floor covering, which would be felting with a pattern printed on it, should be free. Perhaps the Minister will tell us the reason for that because, from the Minister's remarks, it seems as if there was no necessity for any protection at all and in fact, the stuff can come in with the printing on it free.
Comment on this
Felt and felting substitutes and other like substances, intended for use as roofing material or damp course, are liable to duty whether printed or not. It is possible that people have evaded the duty by false declarations, but that is a matter which could be rectified if specific instances are brought to the notice of the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
It does not cost 50 per cent. more, but the duty of 37½ per cent. has not been adequate to stop imports, and we have decided to raise it.
Comment on this
Would the Minister tell the House that there is not a duty of 37½ per cent., in fact, because there is a preferential duty of 25 per cent., and the Minister's proposal in fact is to increase the duty, not from 37½ per cent., but from 25 per cent. to 50 per cent., that is, doubling the tariff on this particular article.
Comment on this
Nevertheless, the Minister tells us that the people here are producing more cheaply and better. Surely the Minister does not take us for a pack of children. We are putting it to the Minister that we will not support the imposition of a tariff on goods that are of importance to the building industry here to the extent of 50 per cent. The Minister has all the machinery at his disposal for persuading us that it is necessary. He has made no attempt to give us any idea of how much of this stuff is manufactured here; how many persons are employed; or to give us anything about costs or any reason why it is necessary to raise the tariff from an effective figure of 25 per cent. to 50 per cent. He wants us simply to swallow his statement that really is not necessary because the stuff that is made here is cheaper and better than the stuff imported, but for some queer reason, connected with atmospherics more than anything else, he wants a 50 per cent. tariff.
Comment on this
The Deputy is speaking in respect of one of two different attitudes. I say that if there are Irish firms, employing Irish workers and producing these goods as cheaply and of equal quality as those produced any where, they are entitled to the Irish market. The Deputy, on the other hand, wants to refuse the protection which enabled that industry to be brought into existence and kept in existence.
Comment on this
The Minister's own statement is quite clear, that this industry can stand on its own legs, but the Minister's conduct shows that he does not believe that. There is a variance between his estimate of the value of his product and his conduct in the House. That is the case we are making. The Minister's only method of keeping down prices in respect of every one of these tariffs is to put on 50 per cent. and 75 per cent. tariffs. He always admits that the article is cheaper and better and still his only method of getting over that fact to the public is to say "the duty is 75 per cent. if you want to buy a competing article." That does not show much belief in the article in question. I am not questioning the value of that article, but I say that the conduct of the Minister is. This is one example of many in this particular schedule. It is an example of which we have had so many in this House in the last couple of days—we had one yesterday—of one Minister going one way and another going another, one Minister trying to encourage housing and the other trying to put every obstacle in the way.
Comment on this
If we have an article produced at home, which is as good and as cheap as the imported article, what do we want a 50 per cent. tariff for? Is it not overgenerous to give them 20 per cent.? The Minister cannot believe—he could not be so stupid as to believe— that the article can be turned out as cheaply as the foreign article. Otherwise he would be as stupid to offer a 50 per cent. preference. That is the very way to get an inferior article turned out. Make a man fight for it, and if 37½ per cent. is to be the line the Minister mentioned a moment ago, give them 40 per cent. and make them fight for their existence. The Minister says they wanted the protection of 37½ per cent. I do not know what they want, but that was what the Minister said, but he followed that up by saying that the article can be turned out as good and as cheaply here. Then 20 per cent. would be overgenerous. If 37½ per cent. is the fighting line, give them 2½ per cent. and they have ample. I will never get anything any good in this country and no man will produce it, if you put him in a glass house and protect him from any competition. He will grow up a delicate plant and will be unable to stand the rough and tumble of the outside world. If you take him out he will get pneumonia and die, and the Minister's industries will get pneumonia and die if he overprotects them. Give them a fighting chance and no more. There is something wrong if they do not win when they get it. I do not want to say any more on this, but I should like to know if the Minister has taken the comprehensive view of all these matters that is taken here. There is not a thing I know of in connection with the building trade which is not now taxed, and I suppose the next thing will be an excise duty on things we have here, such as gravel, sand and lime. We are making tiles and putting them on houses, but the Minister has shoved 5/- a ton tax on cement. We cannot make tiles without cement.
Comment on this
We give a 50 per cent. preference to an Irish producer of an article, and, according to the one man in this country who should know—and I do not question his knowledge of the matter—this article can be produced of, at least, equal quality and as cheaply as we can buy the imported article. Deputy Mulcahy, I think, is too generous in offering 20 per cent. While I go the whole of the way to support the Minister in his general policy of protection, I would not go one inch with anybody to give any man more than a fighting chance. In view of the Minister's statement that we can produce this article as cheaply as we can buy it, it is not consistent with good business to offer 50 per cent. on top of that. You are making a present at the community's expense and at the expense of the building trade, which has already been sufficiently handicapped, through shortage of money and various other things, as the Minister and his colleagues know very well. They know of the knocking at their doors for more money for various departments of the building trade, and here is a tariff of 50 per cent. which, according to the Minister's statement, is not warranted. I cannot fathom the Minister's attitude; it is one that requires some explanation.
Comment on this
The Minister said, a few moments ago, that these articles could be produced here and sold more cheaply than the imported article. He probably knew what he was talking about when he said that, but I should like to know how this comparison was based. Did he mean that they are cheaper than the imported article with a 50 per cent. tariff, or cheaper than the imported article at the point of production?
Comment on this
In my opinion, there is nothing whatever inconsistent in the statement that an article is as good and as cheap as an imported article, and that at the same time it requires a high tariff. It is not at all unusual to have goods that are even superior, far superior, to goods imported at a similar price boycotted in this country. Deputies opposite must know that a very small number of people in the wholesale trade hold the key to success for numbers of manufacturers. In the case we were discussing a while ago, I mentioned a particular industry which had practically to go out of existence because it was not able to obtain access to wholesale houses. That is so with a great many industries in this country. Wholesalers have their trade connections; they are a conservative body very often. They do not want to be diverted from the routine they have followed for years, and even though a native manufacturer offers them an article which is as good and as cheap as the imported article, they are not prepared to give him any consideration. If Deputies opposite were in office to-morrow and wanted to industrialise the country, they could not do so without high import tariffs. High tariffs are absolutely essential if we are to proceed with industrialisation. There are many inconsistencies in what Deputies opposite have said. While they themselves talk about inconsistencies between the statements of two Ministers here, there is a very big inconsistency in the assertion of Deputy Mulcahy that Ministers were searching around in every hole and corner to exact a few pounds from the people and in now protesting that the Minister will not accept this chance of getting a little revenue from imported goods. Surely, they cannot have it both ways. Either Ministers are anxious to develop industries by high tariffs or they are merely anxious to collect revenue by means of tariffs.
Comment on this
Deputy Moore seems to be slandering quite a number of groups of people in this country. He is pleased to slander the wholesalers in this country, and I would say that he is also slandering such bodies as the Irish Federation of Industries and the Irish Development Association. The Deputy cannot deny that into these two organisations there has come particularly recently, a very considerable body of persons connected with Irish industry, the distribution of Irish products, and Irish public life generally. It is, I say, simply a slander on these persons as well as on the wholesalers, to state that materials of this kind which are necessary for housing are produced in this country as good and as cheaply as the imported article, and still that they can be squeezed out of circulation by a boycott. Surely, the Deputy would never expect people to swallow a statement like that.
Comment on this
Where did we get the word "boycott" in this discussion but from the Deputy? He told us that there was a boycott of these things on behalf of certain wholesalers.
Comment on this
The Deputy certainly did. It would never have entered my mind if he had not. The Deputy talks about developing industry by a system of high tariffs. He has no doubt that that is the best possible way, that we should put on a 75 per cent. or 100 per cent. tariff when we want to get anything manufactured here, and so shut off everything coming in that we did not want imported here.
Comment on this
Exactly. If the Minister tried to shut out certain things that are now coming, he would have to make a case for it, and we would know definitely what the result was, but here the Minister is trying to persuade us that we are getting goods manufactured here at a price that is absolutely rock bottom, but yet the Government want to impose a tariff of 50 per cent. on them. Deputy Moore says that if they were concerned with revenue they would not have these tariffs so high, and that what they are really concerned with is the development of industry. Would the Deputy look at the amount of Customs which his Party has been collecting for the last three years?