Public Business. - Finance Bill, 1935—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 187–384 of 572. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 15 of 1935 ›
The Minister's reply to the arguments put forward here on this tariff and on many others is that they are not really necessary. Yet, they are put there for some reason difficult to understand. But practically in the Minister's own words, this is a tariff on felt which is not felt, inasmuch as the people who are paying the tax are not going to feel it. According to the Minister, certain manufacturers in this country were purchasing felt from abroad——
Comment on this
——and paying the duty on it while they could buy it more cheaply and better at home. I generally find that if you come to analyse a statement of that kind there is a catch in it somewhere. If the Minister gave us the actual details we would possibly find that some of these articles for which people are paying £10,000 are not articles which are made here more cheaply or better or in the form in which the importers desire them. It is inconceivable that there are manufacturers who would expend £10,000 on importing an article which they could get at home more cheaply and better. The House would want further information before swallowing a statement of that kind. I should certainly be glad if the Minister would give us some information as to the particular items on which this £10,000 tariff was paid. Then we would be in a far better position to discuss this tariff. To ask us calmly to accept a statement that a tariff of 50 per cent. is necessary to prevent people buying something which they can buy at home without any tariff, more cheaply and of better quality, is going a bit too far.
Comment on this
I find myself somewhat in the same position as Deputy Belton. I have held the view that a number of our industries in this country would require a certain amount of protection in the same way that a small child, beginning to walk, requires a certain amount of artificial aid. The Minister must know that if we are going to continue spoon-feeding a lot of people in this country, whether they be manufacturers or workers, then we are going to raise one of the flabbiest generations that has ever been raised in any country in the world—flabby industrialists, flabby workers, and flabby capitalists. The flabbiness that the latter will suffer from will be that of increased wealth. The Minister must know that any addition to building costs will produce certain reactions on the building industry. There is a movement gradually growing, not alone in Dublin but in the City of Cork, for the reduction of rents. The people behind that movement say that present rents are altogether too high, but with the cost of building materials increased that must inevitably lead to an increase in rents. We are dealing here with felt which, I admit, is not generally used in house-building, but many of the other articles used in house-building are being increased in cost under this Bill. I assume that the Minister has considered all that, and that having considered it he must have reached certain conclusions. Has the Minister borne in mind the increase in rents that is bound to follow as a result of this proposal? I could understand the Minister's attitude if his case was that he was out to help some struggling industry, but on his own showing this particular article that we are dealing with can be produced of as good a quality and as cheaply in this country as elsewhere. Why, therefore, should it require the large measure of protection that the Minister is proposing to give it?
Comment on this
I appeal to the Party opposite to stop slandering their own industrialists and workers. Irish industrialists and Irish workers are not flabby. Deputy Bennett said that there must be something wrong with the article, and Deputy Belton says it cannot be as good as the imported stuff.
Comment on this
I appeal to the Deputies opposite to stop trying to spoon-feed the foreign importers. There is a duty upon these goods. That duty has led to the creation of an important Irish industry that is now able to supply all our requirements in these goods, and in quality and price they compare favourably with goods of a similar kind produced in other countries. Despite that, Deputy Mulcahy is now moving to reduce the protection which helped to establish that Irish industry, and Deputy Belton and Deputy Anthony are going to support it.
Comment on this
If these goods can be produced as good and as cheaply as elsewhere, why does the industry here want a 50 per cent. artificial aid? Will the Minister answer that?
Comment on this
The position in this House is becoming rather amusing. When the Minister for Finance has no argument he keeps silent, and when the Minister for Industry and Commerce has no argument he shouts.
Comment on this
The Minister is not going to get it over that way—with worked-up indignation misrepresenting every statement made. He might get it over with people who had not seen him before, but those who have watched his form in this House know that his worked-up indignation is pure playacting. As I have said, the Minister for Finance, when he has no argument, keeps silent, and now we have a shouting Minister for Industry and Commerce. Deputy Anthony put a very interesting point. He ought to know that the answer to it is quite simple. Referring to a number of articles in this schedule, all of which are going to increase the cost of living, the Deputy asked what will the result of that be as far as building is concerned. The Minister's answer is quite simple. It is that building will be cheaper. That is what we have been listening to for the last three years. When he puts a 75 per cent. tariff on some article and he is asked what is the purpose of it, the answer is that it will produce something cheaper. Deputy Anthony need not be the least bit uneasy. According to the Minister's argument, the more you put up the cost of living the cheaper the building will be. The Minister has demonstrated that month after month and week after week in this House.
We got from Deputy Moore to-day a new conception of protection which was clearly illustrated by the Minister. Protection, according to the new conception, is no longer to help industry to stand on its own feet: to allow an industry, subject to competition from countries where industries are longer established, a chance to get on its feet. That is no longer the purpose of protection. We have passed beyond all that. According to the Minister, this is quite an important industry that we are dealing with here, one that can produce a better and a cheaper article than can be produced elsewhere, and yet the proposal is to give it a 50 per cent. protection. For what? Nobody can answer. If there is any truth in what the Minister says about people being willing and anxious to give 50 per cent. more for a worse article that can be got over by some methods other than by this resolution. Let us see what the effect of this is bound to be. Assume, for the moment, everything that was said by Deputy Belton and Deputy Anthony and others who spoke about flabby industrialists. There was no denial that they were producing a better and a cheaper article. Therefore, the policy of the Minister is to make those who are producing a cheaper and a better article flabby industrialists. His policy can have no other effect. If you put on a 50 per cent. tariff on an industry that is already producing a better and a cheaper article, what must be the result of that? It must either be a gradual approach to that 50 per cent. level or a gradual deterioration in the value of the article. That must be the inevitable result. I submit that the Minister is doing the very worst thing that he could possibly do for the future of industry by this new conception of protection that he is putting before the House.
I remember that many years ago, long before the Minister came into power and before even we had an Irish Government in this country, circumstances gave almost a monopoly in this country to a certain article that I personally do not consume. Those who do consume it told me that about 12 months after the monopoly was given the article deteriorated in quality. People who consumed the article told me so.
Comment on this
That was the unanimous opinion of all of them. That, as I have said, happened many years ago, and I suggest to the Minister that he is playing for the same thing here. He is playing for a worse article. He is doing a real disservice to our policy of protection and of building up industry in this country. What we complain of is not so much that the Minister has three or four policies—the Minister for Agriculture has quite a number, each one pulling against the other—but that he has one policy, and that the Minister for Local Government and Public Health has another, though as Minister for unemployment the Minister for Industry and Commerce has certain interests in building, so far as these figures are concerned. There is no doubt that you are going to interfere with business by taxing a number of articles in this Schedule. You are subsidising, on one hand, and taxing on the other hand. Contradictory conduct of that kind is what we have good reason to expect from the Ministry in connection with the finances of the country.
Comment on this
I take it that Deputy Mulcahy would advise a mother to put her baby out naked in a snowstorm saying: "You will probably die but, if you survive, you will be a hardy infant."
Comment on this
I do not feel as competent to give advice to mothers as I do to give advice to Ministers. I advise the Minister for Industry and Commerce, when discussing subjects like this, to tell us the truth. Let him not come in and say that he is raising the tariff from 37½ per cent. to 50 per cent., when the effective tariff at present is 25 per cent., with the preferential rate. What he is doing is raising a 25 per cent. tariff to 50 per cent. He is doing that because we are, according to him, producing here goods that are better than the imported article and that are also cheaper. If he wants to go on that line of argument, he should first tell us the truth. When he speaks of an existing Irish industry which is producing good work and giving good employment, he should, speaking from the vantage point of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, tell the House something about it. He has not told the House anything about it. He has merely put absurd arguments forward as to why we should tolerate on a necessary building material in a country where there is a considerable amount of building and in which a great deal of building will be necessary, an increase in duty of 50 per cent.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 25:—
At reference No. 7, in the 3rd column, to delete "40 per cent." and substitute "20 per cent.".
I want to know exactly what this reference is intended to do. There is a tariff of 40 per cent. on metal doors and window frames. I should like to get some idea of the amount of employment given in the industry to which the tariff is to be applied.
Comment on this
I thought the Deputy would give some argument in favour of the amendment. Apparently he could not think of one.
Comment on this
When I hear what the Minister says this is intended to do, I may have some argument against it.
Comment on this
There is a duty of 40 per cent. on metal frames. If they are imported with glass it is not possible for the Revenue Commissioners to charge upon the value of the glass. One of the main purposes of the proposal is to rectify this position, so that the full duty will be charged whether the frames are imported with or without glass. The section is intended to give protection to the stained glass industry. At present when stained glass work is imported duty can only be charged on the metal frames. As the Deputy is aware the stained glass industry is a very old one here, and has been conducted for some time with conspicuous efficiency. A fair proportion of the products of the industry are exported, although there is a duty on such goods sent to Great Britain. Persons interested in the industry are of opinion that without protection of this kind it is in danger of dying out. It is considered desirable from that point of view, that it should be preserved, with the imposition of this duty. There are a number of firms engaged in the manufacture of leaded lights used in houses, and this proposal is extended to such leaded lights, as well as to the frames of such leaded lights as can be manufactured here.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 26:—
At reference No. 9, in the 3rd column, to delete "50 per cent." and substitute "20 per cent."
This proposes to put a tariff of 50 per cent. on tape to be used instead of twine, and on articles used for tape. I should like to know the necessity for this tariff of 50 per cent.
Comment on this
The existing duty applies to tape which is printed or which is imported for the purpose of being printed. The definition is "tape intended to have lettering printed thereon." The duty has been evaded by people importing unprinted tape, and declaring that it is not intended to have any letters printed thereon. As a matter of fact, the printing and weaving of the tape is being done here at present. This is really an amendment of the duty in order to prevent the type of evasion to which I have referred.
Comment on this
I am afraid I cannot give very definite information, because separate particulars were not kept by the Revenue Commissioners for previous periods. It was not listed separately in the imports, and therefore separate figures are not available.
Comment on this
It is not so much statistics I want as to know how near we are to producing our requirements.
Comment on this
Has the Minister any idea of the relative quality of what is produced and of the imports? Has he even a vague idea?
Comment on this
Those engaged in this industry prepared this estimate of the size of the market, and knew that their new factory could supply the whole of that market. They started off by importing unprinted tape for printing on while the machinery for weaving was being erected. Then they proceeded to manufacture the tape. Owing to the phraseology of the Resolution which imposed the Customs duty a person could avoid duty in respect of unprinted tape by declaring that it was not intended to have that tape printed on. We are merely removing that method of evasion by this tax.
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied that a margin of 50 per cent. is necessary to protect the home market? If not, can he say what is the minimum margin necessary to do so?
Comment on this
50 per cent. is considered necessary to protect the home market. It is felt that with a lower duty imports would continue, and persons supplying the market would cut prices to meet the duty.
Comment on this
Does the Minister anticipate any reduction in the cost of production? If we are in a position to produce all our requirements, then, unless by increased efficiency or by the manufacturers being prepared to do with less profits, or the operatives being prepared to accept less wages, I see no hope of a reduction in the cost of the article to the consumer. Take this 50 per cent. When we have reached the stage of producing all our own requirements, unless we can export that article we cannot increase the volume of our production and thereby reduce the cost. Is it not a very high figure to leave to any producer as a margin of profit over the production cost and margin of profit in other countries?
Comment on this
The Deputy is not affected by Cumann na nGaedheal propaganda. The Deputy learned his economics long before the Minister thought of them.
Comment on this
I did not forget them. I never forgot them, but I am trying to instruct the Minister now, if he can be instructed. For instance, if the Minister gave me a market for potatoes, and gave me 50 per cent. of a protection, does he think I would sell them at any less than the present price plus the 50 per cent?
Comment on this
I can quite appreciate what the Deputy might do, but, of course, the great majority of the people of this country are honest.
Comment on this
Honest? Would not that be an honest transaction? Of course, it would; and if it would be a dishonest transaction, the responsibility would lie with the Minister who gave me the facilities to be dishonest. If we apply that to this printed tape, is not the Minister equally dishonest in giving those people that opportunity to exploit the public to the tune of 50 per cent? A little joke by the Minister will not get away from hard fact. Here we are producing all of this material that we want. We are at full production, and, according to the Minister, we can only keep that market secured here by an addition of 50 per cent. above what, let us say, the British producer is getting for it. That does not make for efficiency, and the sooner the Minister starts breaking down some of the glass-houses he has built around some of these so-called manufacturers, the better it will be for Irish industries.
Comment on this
The Deputy will appreciate, I am sure, that it is sales that determine the price. If the price is too high the article will not be sold.
Comment on this
The Minister appears not to appreciate the fact that people will use this nearly at any price.
Comment on this
Yes, because it is an advertising medium for them. A parcel tied up with twine, which can be got anywhere, has no advertising value, but every parcel tied up with this tape has on it the name and address of the firm where that parcel was bought, and that is an advertising medium for them. For instance, a person may get into a bus, or walk along the road, open up his parcel and throw away the tape. Somebody else gets that tape, and that is an advertisement for the firm.
Comment on this
Yes, and it contradicts the Minister's assertion that if people have to pay too high a price they will not buy. The only thing that competes with it is plain twine, because there is no indication on it of where the article was purchased, and the Minister has given 50 per cent. to keep out a competitive article. The Minister should realise that the way to build up a substantial industry is to give it that amount of protection which will make it compete with the imported article: sufficient protection to give it a chance to compete on equal terms. That is what I want the Minister to do.
Comment on this
The Minister made the statement, in an interruption while Deputy Belton was speaking, that the price will determine, that if the price is too high the article will not be sold. The Minister does not believe that. Otherwise, why the 50 per cent.? Then, when you ask the Minister the reason for the 50 per cent., he says that it is because there are certain people here who would prefer to pay that high price for a foreign article rather than use an Irish article. That is his case. He has given us no idea, however, as to what proportion of queer people there are in this country who are willing to pay 50 per cent. more for a foreign article than for one produced here. He has given us no indication of the number of such extraordinary people who are willing to pay 50 per cent. more for a foreign article even though that article is produced here and is quite as good as the foreign article. The Minister has given us no idea as to that. Even supposing the margin was only 20 per cent., look at the position into which you are putting your manufacturer here. You are giving him 20 per cent. There are a number of people here who buy Irish manufactured goods, no matter what the price is—even if it is dearer than the imported article—and, as the Minister knows, they have done so for years and years, long before protective tariffs were put on. But the ordinary person who is not stirred by patriotic sentiments of that kind will buy according to the price. Then the manufacturer says: "I can put up the price of the 1/- article to 1/5 and it will still be 1d. cheaper than the foreign article at 1/6." The Minister, evidently, does not rely on the general trend of economics. Deputy Dowdall, his colleague, in repudiating the statement he was supposed to have made, repeated it. He recognised that that was the ordinary trend of economics in any country in the world. That is the inevitable tendency in any country, and it has been the tendency for hundreds of years, certainly for a couple of hundred years. I do not see how you can escape that. The Minister has given two sets of argument, and one set completely cuts the ground from under the other. In this case he has certainly given no justification for his 50 per cent. any more than he has given justification in the other cases. He says that he must do this because there is a threat that the country will be flooded with tape of this kind before this factory gets going. Is the factory going yet?
Comment on this
Then there is no danger of the country being flooded with this tape? He is afraid of under-cutting now. Has there been any evidence of under-cutting? If there is evidence of under-cutting, has he not, at the first sign he sees of it, the quota to help him to deal with a temporary emergency of that kind? If there are these extraordinary people in this country, to whom the Minister refers, who think it better to pay 1/6 for a 1/- article in order to be able to buy it from abroad, why not use the quota until they are weaned from that extraordinary anti-patriotic feeling that they have? Why not use the quota instead of putting up the price to what the Minister admits is an increase of 50 per cent. over what the article is actually worth?
Comment on this
There is another aspect of this matter which the Minister has avoided, and that is the 50 per cent. tariff on articles designed, constructed, and intended for use as holders of such tape, and the licence provision by which the Minister can give a licence to anybody to import these things.
Comment on this
The whole thing is a joke. The position seems to be that there is one person manufacturing these articles. A person, we are told, came to Deputy Moore and asked for a 75 per cent. tariff on such-and-such an article. He was a supported of the Opposition, and astonishment was expressed that the Opposition would oppose the suggested tariff. Apparently, that was a thing that could not be thought of—that when representations were made by a person who was a really live manufacturer, that he had difficulties and wanted a tariff, the Minister would dream of refusing him the tariff. The whole principle of 50 per cent. tariffs, in the absence of a detailed case stated in a White Paper circulated to the House, is, in my opinion, entirely wrong.
Comment on this
What is the purpose of the consultation between the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce? If we are producing all the stuff we want here, why should there be any consultation between the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance to import any article other than what can be imported in the ordinary way by paying 50 per cent. extra? Does not that betray the weakness of the whole case, and cast a doubt on the reply of the Minister to my question: "Are we able to produce here all of this article that we require?" He said "Yes." Does not that cast a doubt on his answer?
Comment on this
I explained to the Deputy that this was an old duty which has been re-enacted with a new form of wording to prevent evasion.
Comment on this
Then what is the need for a consultation between the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance if we are producing all we require?
Comment on this
I gathered from the Minister that this factory has been set going in the last twelve months. When was this duty put on?
Comment on this
Therefore it is in a different position altogether now. You put it on then in order to start the industry. You now say it is started and is producing cheaply, so there is no longer the same case for the duty.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27:—
At reference No. 10, to delete all words and figures in the third column and substitute "20%".
Reference No. 10 on the Schedule proposes to put a tariff at the rate of 50 per cent., or 5d. the article, whichever is the greater, on portable vacuum flasks for containing food or drink, and component parts of such flasks, excluding component parts made wholly or mainly of cork, with a licence provision. This is again, I think, the tale of those fellows who went around to workers' houses to see what things should be taxed in order to scrape in a few final pence to balance the Budget. One of the things they saw, when they had finished looking at the mug on the dresser and the glass on the window, was the vacuum flask which some of the children of the house used to take with their lunch to school, and here we get a 50 per cent. tariff put on it. Will the Minister tell us what on earth is the reason for putting a tariff of 50 per cent. on such articles as that?
Comment on this
The reason is that the articles are being manufactured very efficiently and in adequate quantities in the country, and that it is desirable to turn the demand to the products of the factory established here, so that Irish workers will be employed in producing those goods, rather than that they should be imported from abroad.
Comment on this
The factory at Nenagh, County Tipperary, is quite a large one, and manufactures aluminium goods of all kinds. There is a duty of 50 per cent. on the aluminium covers of vacuum flasks at the present time, and the reason this duty of 50 per cent. is imposed is because it is desirable to keep all the aluminium duties at the same level. The minimum duty is the most important part of this particular proposal, because there are other cheap types of flasks which are imported from certain countries much cheaper than they can be made here, having regard to the standard of living and the rates of wages prevailing, but in the case of flasks that are sold from a shilling upwards, the price of the Irish made flask is no higher than the price of flasks available elsewhere. A shilling is the cheapest priced flask that can be produced here.
Comment on this
Will the Minister confine himself to the flasks? How many workers are engaged in producing them here?
Comment on this
I cannot give the Deputy a separate figure for the number of people engaged in manufacturing flasks. They are made as one product of a factory which is manufacturing a number of articles, and no doubt the workers are changed from the manufacture of one product to another as the demand fluctuates. The industry is an important one, and gives male employment. It is a new industry in this country; there is considerable scope for development, and therefore it deserves every encouragement.
Comment on this
Certain articles are very cheap, and the people are not to be allowed to get them cheaply. I am speaking of the 5d.
Comment on this
There are people to whom a shilling is a lot. Those people will not be able to get a cheap flask.
Comment on this
The question is whether it is better to have a few Irishmen employed on this work at Nenagh than a few Japanese in Japan.
Comment on this
This Japanese argument is a grand argument, but what we are tariffing here are portable vacuum flasks for containing food or drink, and the component parts of such flasks. Now we have it from the Minister that this is aluminium ware. I was under the impression when I saw it that this was an article that was neither tariffed—and I take it that it is not tariffed—nor was it manufactured in this country, and I take it that it is not manufactured in this country.
Comment on this
According to this directory the aluminium hollow-ware manufactured here consists of cafe tea pots, cafe tea sets, coffee percolators, colanders, cream jugs, cutlet pans, double milk boilers, frypans, hot-water bottles, hot-water jugs, kettles, maslins, milk cans, porringers, pudding bowls, saucepans, stewpans, steamers, sugar basins, and tea pots, but it stops at that and does not go on to vacuum flasks. Will this catch vacuum flasks that are flasks having a vacuum in them? It seems to me that this is a reference which is spreading itself very much wider than the article which the Minister implies it is intended to cover. Some particular type of vacuum flask that is manufactured or that is intended to be manufactured——
Comment on this
I do not want to interrupt the Deputy, but the aluminium company at Nenagh are making flasks other than aluminium flasks. They are making flasks from other material as well.
Comment on this
Did I undestand the Minister to say that we can produce a flask at a shilling as good as the flask that we can buy for a shilling?
Comment on this
I accept the Minister's statement on that, but when we are in a position to do that I certainly question the prudence of the Minister's policy in offering a 50 per cent. inducement for profiteering. It will not help the industry here. Everybody will get flabby if they are getting it too easy. The man who has to fight for his livelihood, for his existence, will always be a better man than the man living in the lap of luxury.
Comment on this
There is a living example—Deputy Tom Kelly—in the lap of luxury, of course. I think it is not a sound policy.
Comment on this
Question put—"That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 28:—
At reference No. 11, in the third column, to delete "50 per cent." and substitute "20 per cent."
Reference No. 11 is again one of these references which tend to raise the cost of house-building. It proposes to put a duty of 50 per cent. on ridge tiles, hip tiles, and other roofing tiles made wholly or partly of clay or of Roman cement, Portland cement, or any other hydraulic cement. I think it is my recollection that tiles of this particular kind have been made and made successfully for many years in this country. Here is a proposal to put a tariff of 50 per cent. duty on them, coupled with the usual queer arrangement by which certain people, by licence, may be allowed to import them without paying any of this duty. I want to protest against the height of this tariff as tending to increase the cost of house-building, particularly in the circumstances in which house-building stands to-day.
Comment on this
Since 1932, under the regulations made by the Housing Board, no houses in respect of which a subsidy is given can have any other but Irish-made roofing material—slates or tiles—used on it. Whether the roofing material is slates or tiles or anything else, they must under the regulations be Irish-made. The duty upon these goods made of clay or cement has been in operation since the beginning of 1933. The duty, however, did not apply to tiles which were subjected to a process of glazing. The duty is therefore to some extent being evaded, because by a special process a slight glaze is put upon the clay tiles and they are thus exempted from duty. The real purpose of this duty is to prevent that kind of evasion as well as to see that the full demand for roofing materials will turn to the very many excellent Irish roofing materials now available.
Comment on this
I think in this matter, if the tiles that we get are up to a standard—and I have no reason to say or think that they are not—if they fill the bill as regards quality, we get from the home supply our requirements or very nearly our requirements. Again, I have the same objection to this 50 per cent. tariff as I had to the previous one—that we ought to bring our own producers, by having them on safe ground, to the point of having them compete with somebody else. I have no knowledge of the relative cost of the home and the imported article. Perhaps Deputy Dockrell might. I have no knowledge, as I have used nothing but the home material. But I feel convinced that you will get a better article and get the work better done and put Irish industry on a better foundation when it grows to a certain size by letting it develop as a man develops and not as a hothouse plant develops. The only way to do that is to have it on the border-line of competition with the imported article. It would do an Irish industry no harm if an odd consignment did come in, so as to make the producers of this and every other Irish article, too, buck up. I think it is a terrible mistake to give a 50 per cent. tariff. I say that, subject to this proviso, that I am entirely ignorant of the relative cost of production here compared with the cost in Great Britain or in France. I would like to know from the Minister how are prices, goods for goods and quality for quality, comparing in the case of the home and foreign-made article? If the Minister has any information on that, and if he has similar information about other matters on which tariffs are put, we would like to have it. We would like to know if we get for, say, £5 a certain class of ordinary roofing tile to cover a certain number of square yards of roof, at what price would we get the same surface of British or foreign tiles of similar quality? If the Minister has that information we should have it. If we can produce an article as good and as cheap I would give to the Irish manufacturer a margin of security, but I certainly would not make it as high as 50 per cent. I would like now to know from the Minister if he has any information as to whether we can produce an article as good and as cheap as the imported article? If we can do that, I would be quite willing to give the home article a small margin of security, but certainly not 50 per cent.
Comment on this
A very large number of Irish firms are engaged in the production of tiles. That being so, it is inevitable that competition will be keen. That would keep the price down. As far as slates are concerned, there are a number of people engaged in their production, and in proof of the quality of the slates I might mention that a very substantial export business is being done——
Comment on this
Yes, to the inconvenience of the home users of slates. Is net the Minister aware that if I placed an order for Irish slates in the morning I could not get them? Is not the Minister aware of that?
Comment on this
Well, to stick to the tiles —I know that a number of firms are producing here, but does not the Minister see anything in the point I am endeavouring to make? Would it not be well to have Irish firms producing up to the point where they would be competing with the article that is imported?
Comment on this
That is not the sort of competition I mean, because the standard is a local standard. I would like to see an international standard. The only way to do that is to have a margin to save the Irish producer—to give the other fellow, the importer, a chance of coming over the barrier now and again and make the man at home attend to his business. I do not want easy money for the native manufacturers so that they can spend their holidays in the Mediterranean at the cost of the users of these articles. I am sure it is the Minister's idea to develop the industry in a proper way—not only to have all our requirements produced here but to produce a good article here. Local competition will not be sufficient. Local competition will not be certain of producing the proper standard unless we knock up occasionally against other countries in competition. I am opposed to a 50 per cent. tariff. Any information that I have convinces me that a 50 per cent. tariff will exclude all possible competition from foreign countries. We are living here in glass houses, only competing with one another, and perhaps, after a while, we might learn to combine to keep up prices to the neighbourhood of 50 per cent. over international prices.
Comment on this
It does not make things easier for a person who objects to a tariff of the size of 50 per cent. that the Minister will not deal honestly with the House when discussing it. He tells the House that there is a tariff of 50 per cent. on various kinds of unglazed tiles at present. But there is a preferential tariff of 33? per cent., so that the effective tariff at present is 33? per cent. He proposes to put a 50 per cent. tariff on these tiles now. He will not be honest with the House. He attempts to mislead the House by saying that there is a 50 per cent. tariff on already.
Comment on this
I could not say, but a substantial portion of the imports of clay tiles come from the Continent.
Comment on this
There is a 33? preferential rate and that can be taken as the effective rate as far as the import of these things is concerned and as far as fixing the price here is concerned. So that the Minister leaves us no way out except to oppose a tariff of this kind. There is no doubt that there are plenty of people engaged in this industry in this country who would simply be delighted to get a tariff of 60 or 70 per cent. But there is no person to speak for the ordinary consumer or the business person who requires these things for his trade. There is no person to provide any kind of reasonably full information with regard to the situation for the protection of these people. The Minister is obscurantist in his attitude and, naturally, the people looking for benefit from these tariffs are going to be careful to withhold any information which might be used to look at the facts as they are. As I say, the Minister's whole attitude leaves us no other line to take but to oppose tariffs of this size.
Comment on this
Surely the Deputy will admit that there is considerable internal competition amongst a number of firms who are capable of supplying much more than the requirements of the country. The amount of the tariff does not matter provided it is effective to keep out imports.
Comment on this
In fact we are doing that. In fact there is prohibition so far as subsidy houses are concerned.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not appreciate the value it would be to industry to have a chance of even remotely competing with the products of outside factories?
Comment on this
Will the Minister tell the House what guarantee the users of these tiles have of their efficiency? If a man builds a house and if these tiles are not satisfactory who will be blamed? Is it the Minister or the maker of the tiles? No, but the man who builds the house. It is his reputation is at stake and he has to give a two years' guarantee that everything will be right.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the ‘50 per cent.' proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 29:—
At reference No. 14, in the 3rd column, to delete "40 per cent." and substitute "20 per cent."
Perhaps the Minister will explain what price this means to the farming community. Why is it 40 per cent.? That is the usual question. Does "binder twine or yarns" include the ordinary binding used on hay? I presume it does, and for binding corn as well, so far as the description goes. Will the Minister say what is the justification for this particular tariff and the amount of it, and what he has in view? I believe he can not, because, up to the present he has no general appreciation of the effect of these tariffs on other industries, except the actual industry on which it is to operate at the moment. What additional cost it will cause in other respects is a matter that never enters his head. Why, also, is fibre tariffed, and why is coir not taxed?
Comment on this
The reason for the 40 per cent. duty is because 40 per cent. is the duty in operation on cordage, ropes and twine, and now on binder twine, which was formerly excluded. The manufacture is being commenced by one of the principal rope and cordage manufacturers in the country. They have given a guarantee that whatever the price here it will not exceed the price fixed by the English manufacturers. We understand that the price is fixed at the beginning of each year.
Comment on this
I am speaking of the price in relation to quality. At any rate, the firm is very up-to-date. It has machinery and processes in operation which are the very latest in the market, and used in very few of the older rope and cordage factories. This year there will not be enough binder twine produced here to satisfy the requirements of the country. Next year we hope the full amount will be available. The duty is also being imposed upon fibres and yarns. We were not able to get a definition of binder twine which does not also include yarns. So far as yarns are concerned they are also produced, but not in sufficient quantities to supply the rope manufacturers. They have been duly notified that at the end of a certain period which is considered to be reasonable, they must spin their own yarns, or procure their supplies from sources within the country. The importation of fibre, of course, will be continued under licence.
Comment on this
No, because it is possible to exercise supervision and to withdraw the licence from the firm if it is doing anything wrong. The industry is considerable, and a considerable amount of employment will be given. The whole cordage and twine industry is developing. The next stage is the manufacture of binder twine, which, also, involves yarns. The only thing we will have to import is the fibre.
Comment on this
I understand the difficulty of the definition if the two things are identical but if there is an actual difference in substance would it not be easy?
Comment on this
Again, there is the question of 40 per cent. Here, at all events, for the first time, there is a guarantee given that the tariffed article is not going to be dearer. In other cases we had nothing of that kind; we had some prophecies.
Comment on this
Yes, but we have heard that so often, and we have found the facts different from those the Minister puts forward here. The ordinary consumer, unfortunately, has not the same experience as the Minister's statistics. That is the difficulty. However, I am dealing now with the fact that, for the first time, we have a regular guarantee. This is the only time we have got it. Again, it is quite obvious that in respect of every industry, there cannot be such a number of people here so wrong-headed as to pay 40 per cent. more for the same article merely because it is foreign. That is the assumption running through all these tariffs.
Comment on this
Again, can the Minister not deal with that when it arises? He has power to do it; but no, he allows the temptation, as we have said already, of producing a worse article at an increased price. That is bound to be irresistible, and you will have deterioration of the article and increase of the price gradually. That is inevitable. He is doing that with his eyes open and, in this case, at all events, without necessity. In a couple of years or in a certain time—it may be a couple of months—he is going to insist that they take the yarns altogether from at home. He will have procured in the meantime that they will be produced here. I took that for granted, but the Minister more or less threw the obligation on the unfortunate manufacturers——
Comment on this
They cannot be all taken here unless they are all produced here. I object to this on the ground that there is no justification for it, except the Minister's lack of faith in his policy. I have heard people saying that they expect, as a result of the Minister's policy, to see, after a number of years, a lot of tumbledown houses in which industries had been established, owing to the way he has done it, and it is obvious that the Minister believes that himself.
Comment on this
Like Deputy O'Sullivan, I cannot follow the Minister's reasoning in this, any more than I could in previous cases. He has a guarantee that we will have as good an article and that we will have our requirements, or a considerable portion of them, and that the article will be as cheap. What is the justification for a 40 per cent. tariff? I think I am right in saying that this is only one of the products of the rope works started in Newbridge, I think. If they are sure of turning out as good an article and of turning it out as cheaply as the imported article, why does the Minister say "I will give you 40 per cent. of a present by way of an additional trading profit"? I think the Minister threw in an interjection to the effect that there might be a danger of dumping here below cost. If there is, and if that was what the Minister had in mind—evidence that this stuff was dumped in here below cost or 40 per cent. below a reasonable price and a reasonable profit—I would agree with the 40 per cent. Even if it were dumped in at 35 per cent. of a loss, I would agree with the 40 per cent. in order to protect the industry here from unfair competition. If the Minister said that to build up this industry it is necessary to have 40 per cent. protection for a time, I would still agree with the Minister to give 40 per cent., but he says that he has a guarantee from the makers of this twine to turn it out as good and cheap as the imported article. What on earth then is the justification for giving them a present of 40 per cent.? I think it should be opposed in the interests of genuine industry in this country.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 30:—
At reference No. 15, in the 3rd column, to delete "40 per cent." and substitute "20 per cent."
In the case of this amendment, and also in the case of the amendment to No. 17, I want the justification of the Minister for these tariffs.
Comment on this
This tariff was really imposed in order to remove an anomaly. The material from which sun-blinds are made has been liable to a duty of 33? per cent. for some time, but sun-blinds and parts of sun-blinds were free of duty, and the situation reacted to the detriment of the sun-blind manufacturers. We are imposing this duty on sun-blinds in order to rectify this position.
Comment on this
That is, the Minister put a tariff on the material, and, therefore, put a tariff on practically against his own manufacturers. That is the way it worked out?
Comment on this
Yes, it is being made. I would not say it is being made in adequate quantities yet. The linen and cotton cloths, subject to duty under the general duty on linen and cotton cloths, cover a wide range of varieties. I do not say that all are being made in sufficient quantity, but they are being made, and the quantity has been very considerably increased recently.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 31:—
At reference No. 17, in the 3rd column, to delete "40 per cent." and substitute "20 per cent."
Comment on this
This duty is imposed in consequence of a definition difficulty which I have already explained to the House. A duty was imposed here on thread, but, when it came to be administered, it was found impossible to distinguish thread from certain classes of yarn, and, in fact, a considerable quantity of thread was imported as yarn. We had many consultations on the matter, and we found that it was impossible to get a satisfactory definition of thread which did not include yarn, so it was decided to include yarn in order to make sure that the duty was effective and to admit the yarn under licence to the persons who used yarn in the course of a process of manufacture, until yarn is produced here. We hope, in due course, to have cotton yarn produced here also, but that will not be for some time.
Comment on this
Could ply yarn be used for other purposes besides being manufactured? Could it be used as thread?
Comment on this
What I ask is: Can the yarn be utilised otherwise than for that purpose? Can it be used as thread?
Comment on this
The trouble was that when thread was consigned as yarn, it was impossible to say: "That is not yarn; it is thread," because the definition could not be precise enough. We have reason to believe that quite a lot of thread was imported as yarn.
Comment on this
We are asked to believe that the Revenue Commissioners allowed goods in on the ground that they thought they should be allowed in.
Comment on this
On the ground that the definition of thread, which had been embodied in the Resolution, was not sufficiently definite and was held to include yarn. Now we have to include yarn in the definition.
Comment on this
The same body of men that was capable of declaring a map a piece of furniture, because it had two sticks, one at the top and one below, could not stop thread coming in as yarn.
Comment on this
What have you done? You have increased your licensing system and I have insuperable objections to the licensing system, as the Minister knows——
Comment on this
——independent altogether of who is administering it. I can tell you that in a very short time you are going to have a desperate condition of affairs in this country as a result of it.
Comment on this
Am I to understand that it is the intention of a group of manufacturers to establish a factory here for the purpose of spinning yarn?
Comment on this
Is there any truth in the rumour that a group of persons are about to establish a factory in the near future for the purpose of manufacturing woollen and worsted yarns?
Comment on this
I think that the Minister knows that material represented as Irish material is being made out of foreign yarn in the majority of cases.
Comment on this
I welcome the statement of the Minister that it is the intention to manufacture these yarns in this country in future.
Comment on this
This has reference to a new duty imposing a flat rate of 40 per cent. on straps and belts made of leather, or imitation leather. The manufacture of watch straps from imported hides has been undertaken by firms in the Saorstát. These watch straps are being sold at the price recently charged for imported articles.
Comment on this
Yes. There will be no increase because of the change over. I do not mean that they are being sold at exactly the same price as they are sold in England, but at the price charged in England, plus the cost of transport over here.
Comment on this
In addition to watch straps there is an enormous variety of leather straps and belts, the manufacture of which is already established, or can be readily undertaken by firms engaged in the business at the present time. So far as we have been able to discover, there is no substantial difference between the price prevailing here and the price at which these articles have been imported. The duty is being imposed for the purpose of providing protection to firms already established and to encourage the entrance of further firms into the industry, with a consequent increase in the available employment. The rate of duty has been fixed at the rate applicable to all leather goods for the purposes of convenience and in order to secure uniformity in its application. Just as I pointed out before, all aluminium goods are subject to the same rate of duty, all goods made of leather, or imitation leather, will also be subject to the same rate.
Comment on this
Do I understand that an effort is being made to supply all our demands from firms established here?
Comment on this
That is a departure from the policy pursued up to the present. We were told in the case of other goods that the market is so small that you have to limit the number of firms.