We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Business. - Finance Bill, 1935—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 385–572 of 572. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 15 of 1935 ›

I wonder whether the Minister is not arguing against himself in this case? I suggest he should come across to this side of the House because most of his statements now are an argument against this tariff of 40 per cent.

Comment on this

It would be a considerable improvement to that side of the House.

Comment on this

We should have a convert to this side of the House. Every argument he is using now is an argument against the policy he is defending in the case of this tariff.

Comment on this

The Government are now putting a tariff, not merely on sculpture——

Comment on this

This has reference to dog collars, leads and muzzles, which are being manufactured here. They are subject to the same duty.

Comment on this

I think the Minister is a humorist.

Comment on this

I should hate to limit the importation of muzzles.

Comment on this

I am not going to talk about dogs. I am going to talk about the words "imitation of leather." I suggest to the Minister that they form a very objectionable phrase, owing to the difficulty of getting a proper interpretation. In anything I say I do not want to be taken as throwing blame on the Revenue Commissioners, but I think we are putting on them an impossible task, in asking them to decide, in a way that will give any general satisfaction, what is meant by "imitation of leather." Anything could be classed as an imitation of leather in this way—the binding of a book, for instance. One person may say it is cloth, but some other individual can say it is cloth got up to look like leather, whether it is put in that category by the Minister's reference or not. Here is a book which illustrates what I have said. Nobody would ever say right off that it was bound in anything but cloth. It is advertised as cloth bound, sold as cloth bound, and priced accordingly. But I assure the Minister that the Revenue Commissioners could say, with a certain amount of justification probably, that it could be held that it was got up as an imitation of leather just as these other articles to which the Minister referred.

I say it is not proper to employ in our legislation a term which is subject to such a width of interpretation as that term "imitation of leather." Anything could be called an imitation of something else if a person wished to take that line. I suggest to the Minister that he should get some better phraseology than the term ‘imitation of leather." I can assure the Minister that there is nothing in the Customs duties which is causing more dissatisfaction than the way in which the Customs authorities charge a tax upon books which are got up in cloth, which is said to be an imitation of leather. I could give the Minister plenty of examples. I suggest to him that between this and the Report Stage he should look for a better way of expressing the idea in his mind than this term "imitation of leather."

Comment on this

I have no idea of what we could substitute for it.

Comment on this

Remember what you are doing. You are asking a shrinking set of people who were too shy to distinguish between thread and yarn to say what is an imitation of leather.

Comment on this

They will err in favour of the Revenue all the time.

Comment on this

I have seen paper bindings which could be easily called an imitation of leather, and I have not the slightest doubt that a tax has been collected on them as imitations of leather.

Comment on this

Is there white marble to be had in this country?

Comment on this

There is, but it is not being worked at the present time.

Comment on this

Is there workable white marble of the type that is wanted for high class sculpture?

Comment on this

There is white marble available, but at present it is not being worked. At present licences for pure white marble are being issued.

Comment on this

What is the point then of taxing a thing until you have a proper type of white marble ready? You are putting a tax not merely on the sculptured article but on the blocks of marble coming in: on the white marble that is not to be got here. Why do that unless it is a desire to indulge unnecessarily that apparently potent drink that you are so fond of, namely, licences? What else can be in the mind of the Minister or of the Government in doing this? You are putting a tax on the raw material used by the sculptor, or by the ordinary man doing monumental work. I cannot see why you should do this. Are you afraid that the country will be flooded with white marble, or what is the point?

Comment on this

The point is that we do not think that we would be able to get an extended production of marble in the country unless we were in the position to afford the assistance which this duty provides. At present there are only two or three marble quarries working, which were recently started in the County Galway. One is producing green marble, and another black marble. There are other marble quarries in other parts of the country: red marble, white marble, pink marble and so on. They are all available, and our desire is to get all of them working. In order to do that it is necessary to stop the importation of unworked marble, except where pure white marble is required for certain classes of statuary work. Generally speaking, there are many classes of ornamental work in connection with buildings and so forth, for which white and other marbles are being used and for which Saorstát coloured marbles would be quite suitable. This duty imposes some restriction on the importation of marbles where Saorstát marbles could be substituted for them. It will be some time before we can get white marble produced here which will be as satisfactory for statuary work as the Italian marble, and until that happens we will have to allow white marble in, however reluctantly. I say reluctantly, because the Italian Government has imposed an export duty on unworked marble in order to get the whole process of manufacture confined to Italy. That situation has existed for some time.

As far as this duty is concerned, there is no change under (a). That duty on worked marble has been in operation. The only change, apart from the duty on chippings, is the inclusion of unworked marble, which is being made subject to a duty. That is being done for the purpose of taking the initial steps to encourage people to proceed with the opening of the other marble quarries in the West and South of Ireland for coloured marbles. There is some possibility of getting white marble here. There is one white marble quarry, but it has never been properly explored. It is hoped, by the imposition of this duty, to encourage people to have explorations carried out and trial pits sunk. We have not succeeded yet in doing that, but if people should come along with the necessary resources to work this marble, and that their efforts give promise of success, then we would assist them in the way that we have assisted other projects such as the slate quarries. The feeling, however is that the Italian marble is so strongly entrenched on the market that it would be foolish to proceed with the development of white marble here. We must remember that marble quarrying was a very important industry in this country before Italian white marble attained its present position. Irish marbles—green, black and red—were all in demand and were exported. We hope to have a similar revival in the use of Irish marble and to encourage its use at home whatever prospects there are of securing an export business again. It is in order to do that that we are imposing this duty. At the present time white marble is being licensed, and it will have to continue to be licensed until we can get some production of it at home.

Comment on this

The Minister should have no difficulty in getting a definition. He could make it "marble other than white marble."

Comment on this

We intend to use this power to discourage the use of white marble where Saorstát coloured marble might as well be used.

Comment on this

I submit that is a most arbitrary act on the part of the Government. Marble is not used as a common stone. It is used for the execution of works of beauty. If an artist proposes to make a work of beauty, if he has his conception of it in white marble, it would surely be an arbitrary act on the part of the Minister or one of his officials to come along and tell him—he may be another Leonardo da Vinci—that the work he proposes to execute would look much better in green, pink or black marble. It would surely be an arbitrary act on the part of the Minister to attempt to impose his taste on the country. I think that the situation could be met by the Minister inserting in the Bill the words "marble other than white marble." If someone comes to the Minister and says that he has a quarry, the stone in which appears to have all the qualities of Carrara marble, the Minister can, by order, assist that person by a tariff of 40 or even 100 per cent. But I think it is ridiculous to come and in vacuo propose to assist a potential industry for the development of which the raw material does not exist. The Minister, in what he is proposing, is simply cluttering up his Department with an additional licensing process. The only reason he gives for this is to try and force people who prefer an expensive stone which they have selected carefully because it fulfils the æsthetic requirements of the work, to get that particular work done in black, pink or green marble. I do not think the Minister has made any case for this duty. I think he could easily find a suitable form of words which would exclude white marble.

Comment on this

There is a big commercial market for marble other than marble required for statues or works of art. Marble is now largely used for shop fronts and work of that kind.

Comment on this

As Deputy Fitzgerald has said, all these restrictions have a deleterious effect on trade and on industrial work generally. Let me give an example. On a previous occasion the Minister was good enough to exempt scientific apparatus from duty if it could be shown that the apparatus was required for use, in an educational institution, on scientific work. For a time that concession of his worked more or less with difficulty. The Minister gave exemptions from duty in many cases, but I think that if the Minister, through the Revenue Commissioners, makes inquiries he will find that the applications for such exemptions have got definitely fewer. The matter came under my notice in this way. Those who are responsible for the use of such scientific apparatus found that it took so much time to get this concession through the Customs and through the officials concerned—again I am not blaming the Revenue Commissioners—that the exemption from the duty was not worth all the time lost. While on paper the giving of the concession might appear to meet the argument put up to the Minister, in practice it was found that it was not so at all because of the delays and red-tape that come into play in such things. Here he is saying, in the same way, that he is prepared to give licences generally where applications are put in for importation of unworked white marble. In fact, every such application takes a very considerable time and causes a great deal of trouble to the firm making the application. This adds to the costs of the firm and puts very serious difficulties in its way. I doubt very much if the Minister realises the handicaps under which commercial firms and firms engaged in industrial work generally are suffering from these restrictions. I doubt if he realises that the getting of articles through the Customs takes up such an amount of time and involves as much labour as it does. Quite apart from the duty involved, these restrictions definitely increase the cost of almost every article which the public has to buy. The Minister proposes to operate a licensing system, though there is no sign or sight of the white marble to which it applies being available in an Irish quarry. Surely, it is time enough, as Deputy Fitzgerald says, to put these difficulties in the way of firms when there is some prospect of the material required being available in an Irish quarry. To make this provision so long a period ahead is only causing trouble and difficulty where there is no occasion for it and where no advantage is gained by anybody.

Comment on this

I agree with practically everything that Deputy Thrift has said. A number of us in this House would shrink from the use of a licensing system which, I think, is a bad system. With a certain policy in operation, you cannot avoid that system in certain instances, but I think it should be used as little as possible and avoided as much as possible. A sane Government which had the welfare of the country at heart would shrink from inviting opportunities for using it, but this Government, at first opportunity, plunges into it. I could imagine a situation in which there would be a question of the importation of white marble and in which there would be a contest between two strong, silent men—the Minister for Finance and Signor Mussolini. On application, the Minister for Industry and Commerce might say: "Can you not get this white marble elsewhere than in Italy?" I have heard of people applying for licences and being asked where they were going to get the material. They replied that they were going to get it in Great Britain, and they were then asked: "Can you not get it from Germany?" I understood that there was to be certain freedom——

Comment on this

Different duties apply in some cases.

Comment on this

It was not a question of duties. This was a question of the importation of a certain piece of machinery which could be had from Great Britain or Germany. The duties were the same.

Comment on this

The duties are not the same in all cases.

Comment on this

This was not a question of saying: "You cannot import it." It was a question of putting difficulties in the way of its being imported from a certain country.

Comment on this

I suggest that the reply given by the Department was that the machinery could be imported from sources to which the duty did not apply.

Comment on this

That was not so in the case I have in mind. This was a question of inducing the person concerned to take the machinery from a particular country in preference to another country. That will spring up inevitably, and it is the least of the abuses to which this system is open. I, like Deputy Fitzgerald, was amazed to learn from the Minister that he is going to undertake aesthetic, educational propaganda and to teach the people what is beautiful and what is not beautiful. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has one view upon this question, but it would be patently absurd to have a Government Department advising on a question of taste. The Department of Industry and Commerce would be, with the possible exception of the Department of Finance, the last Department to which I would resort for a ruling on questions of taste of that type. Apparently, that is what the Minister is going to do.

To-night we had the argument used that a 40 per cent. tariff should be imposed because an industry is existing. Now we have 100 per cent. tariff because an industry is not existing and is not going to exist. The Minister did not explain why 100 per cent. tariff is given in the case of unworked white marble. He spoke of giving assistance. The assistance, I took it, was the tariff. Is the price going to be doubled from these quarries which the Minister hopes to set going as a result of this protection? If not, why the 100 per cent.? Already you have a tariff put on by the Italian Government on the material coming out of Italy. Now, when the Minister gets this æsthetic flair, 100 per cent. is to be imposed, not on the original price, but on the tariffed article. What is the "assistance" meant to be? We have had 40 per cent. tariffs imposed because industries were established and capable of standing on their own feet. Now we have a 100 per cent. tariff because an industry is not even in embryo. What is the justification for the attitude taken up? Why is the Minister introducing a licensing system when he could effect his purpose by definition? Why make the tariff 100 per cent. when there is no immediate prospect of starting the industry?

Comment on this

The tariff is fixed at 100 per cent. because it is intended to be prohibitive.

Comment on this

The Minister spoke of "assistance." What did he mean by that? Does that mean that they can charge up to 100 per cent.?

Comment on this

Who is to prevent them?

Comment on this

The fact that there are a number of quarries in competition.

Comment on this

I understood that the Minister's main aim was to get them going.

Comment on this

There are three or four working at the present time.

Comment on this

Can they not keep working?

Comment on this

We want to keep them working.

Comment on this

They cannot keep working without this 100 per cent?

Comment on this

They cannot keep working without a tariff?

Comment on this

Is there any white marble being produced?

Comment on this

There is no white marble being produced.

Comment on this

But it is in the country.

Comment on this

So I am informed.

Comment on this

The Minister knows that there are certain things for which white marble is required and that the 100 per cent. tariff will not really be prohibitive.

Comment on this

I have already explained that, for statuary work or other class of monumental work for which white marble is required, the licensing provision will be operated to allow the marble in free of duty.

Comment on this

I suggest that even at this stage, the Minister should consider the withdrawal of this duty until the prospect of getting white marble here is somewhat nearer. He is only putting difficulties, trouble and cost in the way of firms who are trying to carry on industries to the best of their ability.

Comment on this

I do not think that there is any artistic merit in a fish-monger's slab.

Comment on this

I am glad to have the Minister's assurance that he will not refuse licences for unworked white marble but I suggest that he make inquiries in his Department as to whether that practice has been rigidly adhered to.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy Mulcahy, I move amendment No. 35:—

To delete reference No. 25, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 and 4.

I suppose this is another industry which produces better and cheaper.

Comment on this

It produces very good stuff.

Comment on this

The Minister does not make the same boast here. We have not the usual boast that it is cheaper and better. As a matter of fact, it is much dearer. Anyone who has to bind books of any type knows what an extraordinary expense it is. I do not question the quality of the binding, but the expense in many cases for a large number of people who have unbound books is really prohibitive. The one thing that emerged from the previous stage on the discussion of this tariff was, first, the unnecessary character of it, and the futility of it. It was typically the Minister's tariff. I think the Tariff Commission estimated that it would give, roughly speaking, one and a half men work. Is not that more or less the indication, as far as Missals are concerned? Like everything else, there has been no advertence to the cost. The Minister never even thinks of the consumer. This is a class of tariff that hits a large number of people who are not by any means the wealthier class, men who have had already to go to considerable expense, very often beyond their means, perhaps, to perfect themselves in a certain calling. I think the Minister was warned, when he was imposing this tax, that it would put a very unfair burden on a number of individuals. Listen to what the President of Maynooth College says on the matter. He speaks from personal experience and, hence, we have not now the airy persiflage of the Minister that it is cheaper and better, because we have an instance where that is not the case. It is what everyone expects from these tariffs when worked out. I have no doubt that in the great majority of tariffs it will be found mutatis mutandis that they are absolutely useless and are only trifling with the matter.

Comment on this

Is that what the President of Maynooth College said?

Comment on this

I have not quoted anything yet.

Comment on this

The Deputy has merely drawn in the President's name here.

Comment on this

Has the Minister broken his vow of silence? If we have two of you maybe we could get on with a lot of business. I believe that this is one of the most absurd tariffs that has been introduced by the Minister. This is what the President of Maynooth College said:—

"Monsignor MacCaffrey referred to the heavy financial burden imposed on ecclesiastical students by the new Customs duty on liturgical books and bibles. With the tax on prayer books he was not going to deal, as he wished to confine himself strictly to that part on which he had a right to speak."

That is where he had personal knowledge. Therefore, the Minister cannot say to him: "This is a matter you know nothing about." In this case 60 books were £74 dearer.

"In regard to liturgical books or quasi-liturgical books or bibles, whether printed in Hebrew, Latin, Greek or English, he pointed out that the Tariff Commission which examined this question recently reported that only a very limited quantity of these were required in the Free State annually, and that owing to various considerations, the printing of these books in the Free State was utterly out of the question. The whole problem then was concerned with the binding of these volumes. On the one hand, even if all such books were imported in sheets and distributed amongst the various bookbinding establishments, he would not say in Ireland, but even in Dublin, they would not give an extra half hour's employment. On the other hand, he doubted if the increased cost to the buyer, when all the factors were taken into consideration would fall far short of the present Customs duty on the bound volume.

"Yet, this new tax, doing little or nothing as he believed to ease the unemployment situation, imposed a heavy financial burden on ecclesiastical students as illustrated by the fact that on a recent consignment of about 60 breviaries the college book store paid over £74, all of which was passed on to the individual student.

"All these books were absolutely essential for the professional training of priests. He did not claim any exceptional privilege or immunity from taxes for clerics, but he objected to unfair discrimination."

He did not say that there should be preference for priests, but that ecclesiastical students should not be taxed unfairly, compared with other students, for any books that their calling required. You will notice here how fully borne out is the contention, that has been raised again and again from these benches, that if you put on a tariff the price of the article will go up by the amount of the tariff. Of course, the Minister, if we are to judge by his statement, would blandly say that we were getting a cheaper missal or breviary than ever before. What has occurred? The cost of the article has gone up by the amount of the Customs duty. The Minister is not suggesting that the only dishonest traders and the only dishonest manufacturers are book-binders. The Minister's idea is that if a man takes advantage of the tariff he is dishonest. That is the argument that he used in this House, notwithstanding the pronouncement of Deputy Dowdall and the experience of practically every business man. It is inevitable that they will do so. Here we have the case proved up to the hilt. It is bound to occur. None of the persiflage of the Minister will get over that fact. Prices have gone up, practically speaking, by the amount of the tariffs. Possibly people do not know that when they are buying. In this case, on 60 books they had to pay £74 extra. Anyone who has any experience of these things will know that that must inevitably occur. At an early stage that was pointed out and the Minister could have remedied it, in view of the fact that the amount of work it would get was negligible, that it meant inconvenience and that the amount of loss that was being inflicted was considerable for the chance of putting 1½ men into employment. But this had to be done irrespective of the consequences. After all, what the Minister expects is clear from his previous statement that the manufacturers come to him and state that unless they are given these tariffs they could not carry on. It was stated there was only an examination into cost. There was no consideration whatever for the consumer or for prices. There was a vague and an absurd belief that prices would not go up. Luckily, we have a case which refutes the Minister, and shows clearly that what everyone expected has occurred. I suggest certainly that this is a tax that the House should oppose.

Comment on this

As far as I remember, when this tax was first put on the Minister tried to dodge stating what it was for. There was the usual trouble about a definition as to whether it referred to books bound in leather or in imitation leather. I have never been able to find out why this tax was imposed. Most of these books are printed for world circulation. Some time ago I spoke to an expert with regard to a book of this nature. I knew the price of it—it was bought here before the tax was put on—and I asked him how much it would cost to produce it here. It was a book of a kind that required 32 processes in its production, and the potential make here named a price that was more than three times what it cost to buy it in a shop here, which price, of course, also included the trader's profit. The futility of trying to produce articles of that kind in this country where they can only be sold at over four times the price at which they could be imported is made abundantly clear by that example.

It looked to me as if this tax were an attempt to force the Irish people to take their spiritual pabulum according to the Minister's dictation in the same way as the Minister would like to dictate to artists the medium in which they should work. It looked to me like an effort to make the people of this country a unit, as if they were part of a machine, and to make them accept the same spiritual pabulum for everyone as if there were no difference between them. I confess that I was charmed to see the statement from the President of Maynooth College because I knew that it would have more effect than anything we could possibly say here. The futility of this tax has been made abundantly clear to everybody by that statement. In Belgium and other countries they turn out these missals and breviaries beautifully printed on excellent paper and perfectly bound, and they produce them, not for one country, but for universal consumption. To attempt, in view of the limited unit of consumption here, to compete with these firms is perfectly ridiculous and most unjust to anybody who has to buy these articles.

I am glad, at any rate, that the Minister is now frank, as he tried not to be a few years ago, and that we do know now that the articles taxed are prayer books, missals, breviaries and hymnals. I should like to know from the Minister whether or not this tax is in relation to binding only or in relation to printing and binding. When these books are made en masse the binding can be done much cheaper than over here. My experience, before this tax was imposed, was that these books were bound ever so much cheaper. Of course, the Minister may say that the binding is superior here. My experience, however, was that they were produced much better as well as cheaper outside the country than in the country. It must be remembered that it is not a big and important industry, nor is it likely to be, because this type of binding is usually what they call stiff covers, and not bound at all. It is a very small market and there is no prospect of relieving unemployment here or of improving the economic condition of the country by getting that work done here. It cannot possibly be put on any parity with what is done abroad unless it is expected to develop it sufficiently so as to provide an export market to other countries.

When this matter was first debated, I think the Minister said that certain printers here had got contracts for printing books for general circulation. As far as I know these contracts have not come in since. I am not saying that that is because the tax was put on. My point is that the Minister put up an argument in favour of this tax, or an analogous tax, which had no reality in it whatever. The case he gave had no bearing in relation to the tax he was putting on. The President of Maynooth College has stated his case in relation to 50 or 60 books. He pointed out that the College had to pay £74 for these books, which had to be passed on to the students. I fail to see how the Minister can justify that. I suggest that in this case the Minister is penalising students only in the interests of the Revenue. Why should the Minister select these articles for a tariff which can only be a revenue tariff? It is not going to be an industry here. Why should he put this very heavy tax—this 30 per cent. as it works out—on things which, with regard to certain people, are absolute necessities? Breviaries and missals have to be bought by every priest; and the Minister, most arbitrarily, has put this tax on these articles, and the only possible good that it does, that he can point to, is that it raises revenue. It has no relation whatever to a possible flourishing industry in the country.

Comment on this

The question of imposing a duty on prayer books was the subject of an inquiry by the Tariff Commission, and the report of that Commission is available to the public. The primary object of the duty is to relieve, as far as it is possible to do it, the unemployment existing in the book-binding trade. Generally speaking, the effect of the tariff should be to afford increased employment to book-binders, although a certain amount of increased employment for printers may also result. For various reasons, it is not always feasible to have all the printing, for the various classes of religious books used in the Saorstát, done at home. Consequently, we are taking power under the Resolution to permit the importation, free of duty, of such printed sheets for binding in this country. I am aware, of course, of the statement made by the President of Maynooth College, but I am also aware of the fact that, since the duty has been imposed, a number of religious communities in the Saorstát have made arrangements to have all their prayer books, breviaries, missals, hymnals and other religious books, which were formerly imported complete, bound in the Saorstát and, so far as I understand, they have not experienced difficulty nor do they anticipate any substantial increase in cost as a result of the new arrangements. Heretofore, prayer books printed in English and bound in leather were liable to 30 per cent., but that is now being removed by this Resolution. In general, the duty is not heavy and it affords a certain amount of protection.

Comment on this

When the Minister says that the duty of 30 per cent. is not heavy, is he referring to this duty we are speaking of?

Comment on this

Yes. It is not heavy if arrangements are made for the binding of these books here, and these arrangements can be made without difficulty and actually have been made by a number of religious communities in the Saorstát.

Comment on this

Take the production of a missal by a certain well-known Belgian firm. The Minister says that he is taking power to allow the printed sheets to be brought in here, free of duty, and bound here. Let us take the case of a missal which could be bought for, say, 15/- here. Does the Minister suggest that, by importing the printed sheets and having them bound here, there is going to be no additional cost?

Comment on this

No. As a matter of fact, I think that Maynooth College can do a lot in this matter because they always placed the largest orders. I understand that they require something like 200 here—that a single order would be for 200. If they were to place an order with any firm here for 200 copies, that firm could make arrangements to import the sheets and bind them here.

Comment on this

Is the Minister suggesting that Maynooth College has not done its business properly because they never made arrangements to bring them in and because they paid this high price which has been referred to by the President of the College.

Comment on this

The consignment to which the President of the College referred was a consignment ordered before the duty was imposed. It would not have been possible to make arrangements to deal with that particular consignment, but arrangements could be made for the future.

Comment on this

Do I understand the Minister to say that the reason they could not deal with this was because the order for this consignment was made before the duty was imposed? I understood that that tariff has been on for three years.

Comment on this

No, the tax was only on prayer books printed in English.

Comment on this

Suppose he paid £10 for one volume coming from abroad, does the Minister suggest that by getting the sheets over and getting them bound here instead of having to pay the tariff to the Minister he would actually have got it at roughly the same price as he bought it ready bound from abroad?

Comment on this

I do not think so. It might be a slight increase in the price of the binding, but it would not be as much as the tariff.

Comment on this

I question it. I had a certain amount of experience.

Comment on this

I should not like to say what would be the position in regard to an individual volume.

Comment on this

I cannot really follow the Minister. First of all, there is one thing which he avoided answering, namely, whether there was any increase at all in the price here if you get the printed sheets in. Again, assuming that he uses his favourite device of a licence, and gets in the printed sheets, he did not indicate what employment the binding of missals was calculated to give. There is no good in saying that the binding of missals and prayer-books goes together. It does not; they are different things. The price of binding varies according to the format of the book. If you get ten books of exactly the same format it is one matter, but if the format varies it is a different thing altogether. The Minister, first of all, was careful to avoid telling us how many extra men the binding of loose sheets of Latin missals would put into employment. My recollection is that it was a man and a half. Let us be generous and say one and two-thirds.

Comment on this

Let us say only one man.

Comment on this

That is the kind of industry the Minister has established. The same thing applies to everything else, except that here we can follow it a little more clearly, that is the difference. He puts one and a half men into employment, or to avoid unnecessary dispute, let us say one and two-thirds, and for that, all this inconvenience is being caused. First of all, there was the Maynooth experience. The only thing I could gather from the Minister's statement was not that there was no truth in Monsignor MacCaffrey's statement but that there was no justification for its coming out. He need only have waited until next year. He need only have gone to one of the leading firms in Dublin; he need only have conducted his business the same as other communities conducted it. I take it for granted, with all respect to the Minister, that a man in that position will not make a statement in an assembly of that kind without very grave reason. The mere fact that it occurred once would not, to my mind, seem an explanation. He knew that he was faced with this particular thing in this year and every year. The Minister made another statement. He said that a number of Religious Orders had determined to have all their missals bound in the Saorstát and they anticipated no increased cost. May I ask on what the Minister bases that statement? Had he evidence of that? How many new missals does he anticipate that a Religious Order will have to get in a year? He spoke of quantities. How many new missals does he calculate they will have to order every year? We are told that the Orders came to the Minister or to the Minister's Department and said they had no difficulty about this. They can get them as good and at the same price. That is the position taken up by the Minister up to now. I suggest that he mend his hand.

Comment on this

I suggest that the Minister should agree to abolish this tax.

Comment on this

I opposed this tax before, and I should now like to support those who spoke against the proposal. I think we are making a huge mistake in regard to this book tax generally. If there is one thing above all others that we should try to do it is to encourage people to read instead of putting every possible difficulty in the way of such reading. The whole tax on books is fundamentally objectionable. It is objectionable in itself because of its effects. It is objectionable and obnoxious to the public generally. The result of it is shown by the facts. Despite all the attempts to make cases about revenue on the one hand, or employment on the other, the effect simply is that people who read have to pay more for what they read. The amount of revenue got hardly compensates for the cost of getting it. The amount of employment certainly does not compensate for the vexation and extra cost in which the book-reading public are involved. The whole tax on books is unworthy of any Government, and I suggest to the Minister that he should seriously consider even at this stage not only cutting out this tax but cutting out the whole tax on books, which has come down to be the mere shadow of what it was when the Minister first introduced it. For all the good it is doing him from any point of view, it is not worth while. It is only causing, throughout the intelligent book-reading public, a general feeling of lack of intelligence and proper motive on the part of the Government.

Comment on this

I do not know whether the attention of the Minister has been called to the fact that the tariff on books is actually interfering with a number of people in earning their living or supplementing their earnings. I know a number of cases of people here who review books for publication in England. I know one case of a literary editor who agreed to send a man books only when he was given to understand that the Government would probably make a special arrangement with regard to them. I know the case of another man—I have this only secondhand—who periodically went over to England to review books on the radio. Owing to the delay caused by this interference on the part of the Customs people it was necessary for him to go to England three days before he need ordinarily go. The books would only reach him here after he should have given his criticism, so he had to go over a few days before in order to read the books. I have been told—although I have no exact figures —that quite a fair amount of money comes into the country in this connection. To my own knowledge in the case of two copies of the same book there was a five days' delay caused by the Customs. One copy came through straight away; the other was marked "opened by Customs" and came five days later, although it was sent on the same day. The Minister should consider all that inconvenience. I am not saying that the revenue which he gets is not more important than the money earned by people here, but I have been told by people who know something about this that quite a considerable number of persons here who add to their incomes in this way have been so handicapped. One editor told me that he could not send books to a certain well-known Irish author because he could not be sure that the man would get them in time. I think that is a matter in connection with which the Minister ought to make some arrangement. It is most unfair that there should be inconvenience which actually means that people lose some part of their living.

Comment on this

I do not know if anybody will agree with the contribution which I am going to make in regard to this particular matter. A number of bookbinders had employment here in Dublin. The number is diminishing. They did very good work. They were craftsmen of a high order. It is rather a pity that they cannot find employment, and they will not find employment by charging £74 on 60 books coming in here. I suggest to the Minister that there was an opportunity of doing something for the bookbinders here. The matter was rendered much easier by reason of the fact that religious communities in such places as Maynooth College could have been communicated with, and asked what were their requirements. There could then have been an arrangement whereby the books would be imported without any covers, and bound here. Nobody would grudge paying whatever the difference would be here by means of a vote, if it were needed. It would be advisable to maintain the bookbinding industry. I presume the Minister has seen quite a number of works produced by bookbinders in this country and in other countries and I think he will agree that it would be a great pity if the industry were lost here. The Minister is not likely to help it to be retained by collecting the type of tax he proposes to collect.

In reference to what Deputy Fitzgerald has said, I know of a case in which a book was sent from America. It was sent purposely to get the opinion of a person on how it was written and bound. It happened to be bound with shark leather. The recipient here got a notification from either the Revenue Commissioners, the post office or somebody else asking for £1 on the book and intimating a fine of 2/6 for not having given notice that the book was coming. That sort of thing is not going to help the bookbinders. If the intention is to help the printing industry, that is not the way to do it. Further, in connection with printing, I wonder if the Minister has examined the results of printing here and the export of books and compared the figures with the inflow of books? If he does so, I think he will find that before this Government took office a large number of books were printed in the country. In fact, one firm specialised in that direction and it was able to beat a number of competitors. If the Minister wants to help the bookbinders he ought to endeavour to do it in some way that will give them real help. He should not try to put himself in the position of saying: "I put on a tariff and I made them pay for not employing people at home." The Minister should be interested in employing the bookbinders, but collecting this type of tax is not going to do it.

Comment on this

I do not think the advantages to be derived from this tariff are going to be so great. So far as we can understand, something equivalent to the present occupation of the Ministerial Bench, 1½ men are going to be absorbed. Where it concerns books connected with church services, a tax is highly objectionable and I think this House should set its face against such a thing in principle. I think the Minister might modify this tariff to meet some of the objections that have been submitted. He might draw some distinction, for instance, between books purely of a liturgical kind, books that will be used by religious orders, communities and clergymen, and books that will be used by the public in connection with religious worship. He might be able to draw a distinction that way. I think the Minister should make an exception in favour of such things as breviaries and missals used by clergymen and ecclesiastical students.

Comment on this

I think the imposition of this duty will cause no inconvenience of the kind suggested if the persons desiring these books place orders through the Irish book-binding firms. If they decide to carry out all the arrangements themselves, that is, the importation of the printed sheets, the application for the licence and the making of a contract with some book-binders here, undoubtedly there will be inconvenience; but if they place an order for so many of these books to be produced here they will be able to get them without inconvenience. There may be, in respect of some classes of books, an increase of price.

Comment on this

They will pay more.

Comment on this

They will, but I do not think the increase need be very substantial. Whatever inconvenience they may suffer, it will be confined to that. It is entirely misleading to say that the employment given in this connection will be employment only to one or two book-binders. The Tariff Commission referred to the employment give in connection with missals. We are not imposing a duty on missals only, but upon all classes of religious books which are mentioned in the Resolution. As regards some classes of books, they can not only be bound but also printed here and arrangements are being made by different firms to market prayer books of various descriptions which will be printed and bound in this country. Some excellent examples of prayer books printed and bound here can be purchased at the present time in book shops in the city.

Comment on this

These are ordinary prayer books as distinct from liturgical works.

Comment on this

If the sheets cannot be printed here the arrangement is to facilitate the importation of these sheets free of duty to be bound here, and I have no reason to believe that the book-binding will not be done excellently. Even though I will admit that some increase in cost may result, the increase will be nothing as considerable as the duty. The matter raised by Deputy Fitzgerald was not quite relevant to this, but I would like to take the opportunity of saying that while there may have been some ground for his complaint some time ago, I do not think there is any ground now. Some time ago, definite arrangements were made to enable books to be imported for review with very small delay; certainly the delay would not be more than one day in any case.

Comment on this

Second-hand books, of course, come under this, too —second-hand books of this type?

Comment on this

And leather-bound books come under other tariffs.

Comment on this

The tariff imposed by Section 11 of the 1932 Finance Act will not apply to these books.

Comment on this

Already there is a tariff on leather-bound books.

Comment on this

Printed in English.

Comment on this

If a scholar in this country wants to get a copy of the Keltische Zeitschrift and Celtic Review, bound in Halbfrazband, or half-leather, he will pay 30 per cent. on that, and cannot get it otherwise.

Comment on this

The Minister does not seem to appreciate that there was more than a day's delay in the instance I was referring to and there was considerable vexatious difficulty as a result of the delay. I wonder will the Minister consider the operation of this whole book tax and the vexation and trouble it has caused?

Comment on this

I have asked for a report on the working of it.

Comment on this

Let me give one instance. A parcel of books was held by the Customs. A notice was received two or three days later by the person to whom the books were addressed. He was told there was a parcel of books subject to a Customs duty. When he arrived at the offices he found the parcel had been sent back to England and the result was he never got the books at all. I could give the Minister dozens and dozens of instances. I have here a book sold elsewhere by the hundred thousand at a cost of 5/6 to the purchaser. It was sold here in Ireland to hundreds of people who had to pay, in addition to the 5/6, 4/4 duty to the Customs, because, in the first place, it was stated to be imitation leather, which it is not, and in the second place, because it is valued, not at the price at which it is sold but at the price the Customs officials believe a customer would give for it. Who knows what a customer would give for such a book? One man might give £10 for it. I want the Minister to go into the whole question of the operation of the book tax and the difficulties it leads to in practice. He will then, I feel sure, get some idea of the vexation caused to the general public, and it is a vexation of very considerable magnitude.

Comment on this

The book was advertised as being worth a guinea.

Comment on this

And so are Beecham's Pills, as I told the Minister. The Customs officials refused to take one kind of advertisement and they chose another which is obviously an exaggeration, a kind of puff on the part of the seller.

Comment on this

Apparently, the Minister and the Department are going to make up their minds how many sheets of a certain book are going to be printed in this country before they give a licence.

Comment on this

No. Practically speaking, the licence will be given in all cases except for books of which a considerable quantity are likely to be used, such as prayer books.

Comment on this

Most of the ordinary prayer books are already printed in this country?

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words and figures proposed to be deleted, stand."

Tá 62
·
Níl 32
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 36:—

At reference No. 26, in the third column, to delete "75 per cent." and substitute "20 per cent."

This relates to reference No. 26, under which it is proposed to put on a tariff of 75 per cent. on copper tubes, tubing, pipes, and piping of certain dimensions, with a provison that in certain circumstances the Minister may allow them in without any tariff. This is one of the many taxes put on articles that affect the cost of houses, and I should like to hear from the Minister the circumstances that suggest to him that he should put this enormous tax on copper pipes.

Comment on this

The duty on copper tubes is imposed because their manufacture is about to be commenced at Galway and a Saorstát company is being formed for the purpose. The factory is being constructed and will, I understand, come into production during the course of the present month, giving a considerable amount of employment. As regards the price, the arrangement made between the company and the Department resulted in a guarantee being given that the price of tubing would not exceed by more than one penny per lb. the price of corresponding tubing in Great Britain.

Comment on this

What percentage will that be?

Comment on this

It is not a very high percentage. The main reason why the additional penny in the lb. was required is because of the decision come to, on the representations of the Government, to locate the factory in the West of Ireland. It is estimated that about 50 lbs. of copper tubing are used in an average house, so that the additional cost per house will be not more than 4/2. The duty of 75 per cent. is necessary because substantial supplies of inferior grade copper tubing are available from Continental sources, and recently there has been a tendency to import such copper tubing, which is sold at a very cheap rate, and is of a very inferior quality. It was felt that with a lower duty than 75 per cent. it would not be possible to secure the market in the Saorstát for this Galway concern. Having regard to the fact that the arrangement made involves an easily enforceable guarantee in respect of price, the amount of the duty can be fixed at such a height as will ensure that the imports will be restricted. The licence provision, of course, is necessary at present because production has not yet commenced and imports are at present being allowed in under licence, and also because certain classes of copper tubing, such as are used in breweries, distilleries and hospitals, that is tinned or coiled copper tubing, will also have to be allowed in free in future.

Comment on this

The Minister said that there was not to be more than one penny per lb. difference between the price here and the price in Great Britain. How is the price in Great Britain to be measured?

Comment on this

The prevailing price in Great Britain.

Comment on this

Where, or for what?

Comment on this

The Deputy is possibly aware that associated with this factory in Galway is a firm which is probably the biggest producer of copper tubing in Great Britain.

Comment on this

I am aware of that. But, is it the price fixed in Great Britain?

Comment on this

From time to time.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Minister measures a penny per lb. at. Certainly 75 per cent., when they have been promised that only one penny per lb. will be the difference in price, seems too wide a gap. In other words, I should like to know why 75 per cent. is necessary to protect the industry when it has been promised that there will not be a greater difference than one penny per lb.

Comment on this

Because we feel that a lower duty would not be operative in keeping out certain inferior grades of copper tubing that can be imported from the Continent.

Comment on this

I should like to emphasise the point made by Deputy Dockrell. We have a whole litany of these things that we have been told we can do as well as or better than is being done elsewhere. Yet, we are not satisfied with a small margin. Is the Minister so foolish and so green that he accepts the statement that these people who are going to make the tubing in Galway will turn it out at a penny per lb. above what it can be imported at? It is curious that the Minister should adopt these units, when tubing is not sold by weight. I wonder is he adopting them for confusion. Anyway, I should like to know if he accepts the statement that they are going to turn out good-class tubing at a penny per lb. above what it can be imported at.

Comment on this

From England?

Comment on this

A penny per lb. dearer than the price fixed in England for the same article. Then there is the transit over here, and that narrows the gap. I wonder is that right?

Comment on this

The price here is to be not more than one penny higher than the price in England.

Comment on this

And the Minister puts on a tariff of 75 per cent. He says that a lot of inferior piping is coming in from the Continent, and that is why he fixes it at 75 per cent. If he wants to keep out that inferior piping, could he not propose a preferential duty for Great Britain which would bring the effective duty, with a small margin for safety for the Irish manufacturer, above the penny per lb.? I do not know what percentage a penny per lb. represents, but, say it represents 15 per cent.: if the 75 per cent. tariff were allowed to stand, with a preferential rate of 55 per cent. for Great Britain, that would leave an effective duty of 20 per cent.. and a profit duty of 5 per cent. to the Irish manufacturer beyond what the Minister says he can produce the article at. What more does he want?

When the Minister says inferior piping is going to come in here from the Continent, has he taken any steps to have good reasonable drain piping produced here? What internal pressure has he set as a standard? It is a very serious thing for people who have to turn out articles from these materials if the Minister concerned does not take any steps to provide standards. The automatic steps that the industry itself would take to provide these standards, namely, ordinary competition, does not apply here. Of course, I know this is a matter for ridicule in the mind of a man of such high technical qualifications as the Minister for Finance occupies in the building world. He can afford to smile at us poor ignorant people working in the dark down on a lower plane.

Comment on this

The Deputy flatters himself. I am not listening to him.

Comment on this

If the Minister has such superior intelligence and knowledge he has no need to listen. It is not for the Minister's edification that I am speaking, but for ordinary people. He is a man of superior intelligence, and with a poetic strain too. How are people to be satisfied that they are to get any value for their money? Seventy-five per cent. tariff cuts out all possible competition. In the case of tiles, we were told there were so many firms producing them that they are in competition one with another. But here is a firm that is going to start making these copper tubes which are required in every house, and that firm will have nobody to compete with except with a preference of 75 per cent. If they are able to make these tubes at practically the same price as those outside, why this 75 per cent. preference? It does not make for industrial development here, or for efficiency in the turning out of an article which is the raw material for new houses.

This is about the worst of the percentages put into this Schedule. They are all bristling with evidence of the incompetence of the Minister concerned. I cannot understand what is the object. Of course, the Minister for Industry and Commerce will get up and tell us that those who are objecting to this are condemning their own countrymen. He will tell us that we do not want work here for our own people. That is what the Minister tries to get away with. If we want to have efficiency we must have competition. We do not want to give away people's money in the way it is proposed to be given away here. There is to be 75 per cent. preference for a firm that will have a monopoly of making these copper tubes. No engineering standard is provided, no engineering pressure which these pipes should stand is specified. All that has to be done is to make anything in the shape of a tube, dump it on the market under a 75 per cent. tariff, and the man who is to use it has got to take it or else pay 75 per cent. more in the way of tariff.

If the Minister had any experience in these matters he would know something of the trouble that is caused by inferior piping in houses. The piping has to be put in before it is tested. Before the water test is applied the whole house is finished. If the piping opens or bursts, the whole house is wet, the ceiling may come down. Who is to blame? The incompetence of the Minister, I think. But it would be no explanation for me to say that the Minister for Finance was grinning when I was making this protest. He says he was not listening. Of course not; and he will not have to pay the damage. Why does the Minister offer such a protection as 75 per cent.? The whole thing is like a fairy tale. No one has made this piping yet, but a few fellows will come along and say it will only cost 1d. more. There were many things I was anxious to make in my time. I drew great plans on paper, and figured out the money I was to make. But then I began to discover the number of flaws there were in my plans and my eyes were opened. These people will have their eyes opened too, but no matter, we will have a new factory—a new gold mine.

Comment on this

I just want a little information from the Minister. Perhaps I misunderstood what he said. One thing interested me. Did I gather rightly that the Minister's excuse for this high tax was that he was establishing this new factory in a place which was not economically a good position?

Comment on this

I did not say that at all. The sole reason why the tariff is 75 per cent. is to prevent the importation of very inferior copper tubing from the continent.

Comment on this

Then I apologise.

Comment on this

I said one of the reasons that might operate to raise the cost by 1d. per lb. was the location of the factory in Galway.

Comment on this

Is not that an important principle? If you establish a new factory you should establish it in the most suitable place, regardless of political consideration. I press that point upon the Government. I am interested, and rejoice as much as the Minister that our industries should be successful, but we should keep this before our minds. Liverpool would not be such a great place for the cotton industry if the climate and also its geographical position did not suit. The same applies to any other industry. I think it is a mistake to establish an industry in any place that is not particularly and specially suitable; otherwise you are putting a handicap on the industry.

Comment on this

I do not believe the Minister's argument that the necessity for this 75 per cent. tariff is because there is coming in inferior stuff from the Continent, and because of the utilisation of that inferior stuff in houses. We have had slanders to-day on our wholesale merchants, that they discriminate against Irish products. We had what practically amounts to a slander upon bodies like the Irish Federation of Industries and the Irish Industrial Development Association to the effect that these highly organised bodies, representatives of very wide-flung sections of the commercial and manufacturing community, and persons in public life and the public generally, are ignoring the good they might do, and are not stepping in to try and provide a remedy. Now we have a slander on another class of people in the community, namely, our builders, architects and clerks of works.

In all these matters, there is a standard to which architects and builders work, and, where the houses are being erected under contract for local authorities, you have the fullest examination and the fullest supervision of the type of stuff being put into them by a clerk of works specially selected.

We hear talk about the Japanese and cheap this and cheap that, but I do not believe a single word of it. The Minister is simply adopting the easy way of running away from the facts of the situation, while throwing dust in the eyes of Deputies and in the eyes of the public. The fact is that he is here providing that this copper tubing shall cost 75 per cent. more than it need cost. The manufacture of this tubing cannot be very difficult, and I submit that a 20 per cent. tariff is quite a reasonable tariff. It will be manufactured by people who are engaged in other classes of work, and there is not the slightest reason at all for inducing the abnormal fixing of the cost of these things. The Minister tells us that it is going to cost 1d. per lb. more. The Minister has very carefully refrained from reducing that 1d. per lb. to anything like a percentage of the total cost of the article. What we are asked to do here is to acquiesce in an increase in the cost of these things by 75 per cent. It is only one of the items upon which a tax has been imposed which is adding seriously to the cost of house-building, and I think the House ought to oppose it.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the figures proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 54
·
Níl 29
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 37:—

At reference No. 29, to delete all reference in column 3 and substitute "20%".

I desire to ascertain from the Minister what is the position with regard to the manufacture of pencils and pen-handles here. It is proposed to impose the considerable duty of 33? per cent. with certain minimum charges, on imported pencils, pen-handles and things of that kind. There is also a provision that certain persons may be given a licence to import these articles without a tariff.

Comment on this

A factory for the manufacture of lead pencils has been established at Mullingar, and it is hoped that it will come into production shortly. It is not in production yet. In the meantime imports are being licensed. It is estimated that it will give employment to 60 persons, a considerable proportion of whom will be men. An undertaking has been given that the average selling price of the various grades of pencils will be approximately the same as the prices charged by British manufacturers under like conditions.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say whether licences to import pencils free of duty are being issued to all persons applying for them at the present moment?

Comment on this

I think so. Perhaps I had better not say that definitely, as I am not quite certain. If the Deputy wants information in the matter, he will get it by putting down a Parliamentary question. They are either all being granted or refused.

Comment on this

I shall withdraw the amendment and put it down for Report Stage, to give the Minister an opportunity of supplying the information.

Comment on this

The Deputy can use the machinery of a Parliamentary question to get any information he requires.

Comment on this

The ordinary Parliamentary question is not a very satisfactory way of getting information. It would be more satisfactory if the Minister would take the opportunity on the Report Stage to tell the Dáil what is the position. It is for that purpose that I intend to put down the amendment for the Report Stage.

Comment on this
Mr. Rice

Would the Minister tell the House what the manufacturers meant when they said that the prices would be approximately the same as the British prices? Did he inquire what the difference in price would be?

Comment on this

Is the amendment being withdrawn, or has it been moved?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It was moved, and is before the House at the moment.

Comment on this

By saying that the price would be approximately the same as the British price, I meant that, subject to the conditions being the same, the price would be the same. We may have a higher rate of wages here, or some other circumstances may operate which would not correspond with conditions on the other side.

Comment on this

The only information I want from the Minister is a clearer statement as to whether licences to import these articles are being issued to all persons who apply for permission to import reasonable quantities without the tariff. I want to know whether it is his intention to continue to grant licences for the importation of these articles free of duty until such time as the factory is in production.

Comment on this

I think they are all being granted, but I had better not say definitely without looking into the matter.

Comment on this

I do not press this amendment, but I shall put it down for Report Stage in order to give the Minister an opportunity of stating the exact position. That is the only question I want to ask in reference to it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 38:—

In Part I, to delete reference No. 2, including relevant references in columns 2 and 3.

It is proposed under Reference No. 2 to impose a duty at the rate of 6d. per square yard on any article, not otherwise liable to duty, which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, is linoleum. Linoleum is imported into this country and sold at prices ranging from ? per square yard to 10/- per square yard. The ordinary worker purchasing linoleum at the rate of ? or 2/- is going, as a result of this tariff, to pay 2/- or 2/6, as the case may be, whereas the person who can buy linoleum at the higher rate of 9/- or 10/-, is simply going to pay an extra 6d. per square yard. The position at the moment is that the greater quantity of linoleum imported into this country is priced at the cheaper rates. This is one of the many items that is being taxed as a result of the Minister's inquiry to see what exactly could be taxed in the working man's home. It has been pointed out repeatedly here that there is hardly an article required in the working man's home which is not being taxed. A tax of 6d. per square yard is now being imposed on any linoleum that the working man may want to buy in future. It is one of the taxes, taken in conjunction with the tax on butter, bread, tea, sugar and coal which shows the extremity to which the Minister is driven although he will not admit it. It shows the extremes to which he is prepared to go in fleecing the last halfpenny from the poor.

Comment on this

Would I be in order at this stage in asking a question about Reference No. 1?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We had better dispose of the amendment first.

Comment on this

I merely want to know whether this is to be regarded as a purely revenue tax. We are not likely to discover any lake of bitumen or asphalt in this country and this is a tax that will press very heavily on the taxpayers. Asphalt and bitumen are used in many ways. This tax of 3d. per cwt. seems to be a purely revenue tax.

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

I take it that bitumen would be the raw material for the damp course and there seems to be no sense in putting a tax on the finished product and then on the raw material. The Minister may say that 3d. per cwt. is not a great impost but it all tots up. If you take the 5/- charge for Customs entry, that would be as heavy as the charge on a ton of bitumen. I think that the Minister should try to keep off taxes on small amounts of raw materials, especially where the cost of passing the entry and collecting it will probably amount to much more than the amount of the duty. I should like if the Minister would give us an explanation, from that point of view, as to what rhyme or reason there is for sticking a tax on the raw material of these finished articles.

Comment on this

Already, in reply to Deputy Alton, I have said all there is to be said in regard to this tax. It is a revenue tax.

Comment on this

Does the Minister realise that the mere passing of this revenue tax will amount to what he will collect off a ton of the material? In the light of that, the Minister should consider the incidental expense to the importer which is involved in a number of these small collections.

Comment on this

The Minister has slipped off along the asphalt path——

Comment on this

On a point of order, are we discussing the amendment moved by Deputy Mulcahy or are we discussing something else?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We are discussing amendment No. 38.

Comment on this

Because we are discussing amendment No. 38, I want the Minister to address himself to linoleum and not slip along the asphalt path by telling us that this is a revenue tax. The tax on linoleum is a revenue tax, but the Minister carefully refrained from saying so. It is a revenue tax imposed on the working classes. The greater amount of this tax is going to be raised from the worker. I want to know from the Minister why, in addition to all the other taxes put on the worker, he imposes this linoleum tax.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the reference proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 56
·
Níl 35
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 39:—

In Part I, to delete reference No. 3, including relevant references in columns 2 and 3.

The Minister's inquirer who visited the standard worker's house to see what he could tax spotted a bit of oilcloth, and on that oilcloth the worker will have to pay 2d. per square yard in tax. I am moving this amendment to delete that tax. It is one of the long litany of taxes that the Minister has imposed on the poorer classes of the community. It is a revenue tax. It is simply taking 2d. a square yard on any oilcloth that the worker may require for household use and transferring it to the Treasury. The Minister, I suppose, will be as silent about this as he was about the tax on linoleum. He is simply stuck in his dug-out while his agents scour every corner of the workman's home to get an odd penny or an odd twopence to keep going the condition of affairs that he calls a war in this country, a war that can bring about nothing but worse conditions for every worker.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say whether we make oilcloth in this country, and, if so, where?

Comment on this

The Minister is in his dug-out and his ears are stuck.

Comment on this

I have asked the Minister a question. Is he refusing to answer?

Comment on this

The Deputy can put down a Parliamentary question if he wants an answer. This is a revenue tax.

Comment on this

Common courtesy demands that when a question is asked it should be answered. If the Minister is going to adopt such a contemptuous attitude to the House and the country and to be so discourteous—well, that is his funeral and there will be a day of reckoning for him. I asked him if we made oilcloth in this country, and, if so, where? He does not know. He is too stupid to know.

Comment on this

Is not the position this: that if we did make oilcloth in this country, and if the Minister could not get his twopence per square yard on it, then he would select some other item in the worker's home and put a tax on that that would bring him in his twopence?

Comment on this

Or do what the Deputy did, allow people to walk around starving.

Comment on this

Will the tax on oilcloth that we do not make give them many square meals?

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the figures stand."

Tá 57
·
Níl 33
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 40:—

In Part I, to delete reference No. 6, including relevant references in columns 2 and 3.

Various sections of this Bill, and various references in the Schedule contain many brutal tariffs, involving considerable cost, particularly on the poorer classes of the community, but if any of these taxes could be described as mean taxes, this is the meanest in the Bill. The Minister's agent, having surveyed the houses of workers in town and country, and having taxed everything in the place that could be taxed, apparently ran his mind over the taxes on bread, bacon, meat, butter and all the main items in the ordinary food list, and then he thought that in many workers' homes, particularly in the towns, there is a small break in the weekly fare when there is rice pudding for Sunday's dinner, and a tax goes on the rice pudding. The Minister proposes to put a tax of 2/- per cwt. on "rice, rice flour and rice meal, excluding any preparation which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, is made from rice husk." There are many brutal taxes there, and probably some mean ones, but this tax stands out as the meanest one of the whole lot. It stamps the Minister's whole plan for taxation this year with the stamp of meanness, as well as with the stamp of brutality.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister could tell the House where rice is grown in this country. Is this tax of 2/- put on to help the production of native rice? The Minister was quite indignant when the last amendment was being discussed. He said that if I put down a question I would get an answer. I wonder would he make the same promise here, and, if I put down a Parliamentary question, would I get an answer as to where rice is grown in this country and as to how a tax of 2/- per cwt. on rice will help the production of the native crop? What industry is this tax designed to promote? Deputy Moore has attempted many apologias to-day in defence of high tariffs and tried to construe them as giving some pretence for the help of native industry. I think, however, that to find a good case for this tariff will tax the ingenuity of even Deputy Moore. Of course, the Minister for Finance will keep silent. In his silence, he presumes, there is strength. I would give it another name, however— not strength—but I will not mention it. This is purely a revenue tax on the household. As the proposer of the amendment, Deputy Mulcahy, said, if there is one simple pudding that finds favour in the poor man's and the ordinary man's home, it is a rice pudding, and now even that is going to be taxed.

Comment on this

It will help carrageen.

Comment on this

You have killed carrageen.

Comment on this

The Minister for Lands, who is also the Minister for carrageen, tells a different story: that it would take more than rice to help carrageen. In any case, what harm would it be if we had a little more of both carrageen and rice? Would not the mixture be good, and do you not think that the ordinary man should be left some little choice as to taste? But no, he will be charged 2/- a cwt. on rice. I am usually well informed on agricultural matters, and generally arm myself with the necessary statistics, but I am not sufficiently interested in the price of rice, and, therefore, cannot speak very accurately as to the effect of this tax with regard to general world prices. Not being aware that rice was a native product in this country, or that any tax on it would be a help to the native crop, I must confess to ignorance as to the general trend of prices in the rice crop. However, I can say that it is about the worst tax of the lot, because it is a tax on the wee bit of luxury, if you could call it so, that the working man has in his Sunday dinner.

Comment on this

I am surprised at you.

Comment on this

Well, of course, rice pudding may not have spread down to Cork yet, but it is gradually going that way since the Minister has determined to stop his onslaught on corn.

Comment on this

What about your rhubarb?

Comment on this

As far as that goes, rice and rhubarb go well together.

Comment on this

In practically every one of these taxes, we had the Minister for Industry and Commerce getting up—he is not here at the moment, but we have the Minister for Finance here—and giving, generally, as a reason for the particular tax concerned, that it was being put on because some article could be produced here cheaper and better than it could be produced anywhere else. Surely, he cannot advance that plea on this particular tariff. I do not know if it is proposed, by some method or another, to grow rice in this country, but I think that Deputy Mulcahy put the proper description on this tax when he described it as, possibly, the meanest tax that could be devised. And it is! Possibly, one explanation for the tariff is that the Minister, in bringing in the extra tariff on sugar and making it so dear, particularly to the poor, thought it as well to do away with rice because rice would not be very tasty without sugar, and that, having done away with the condiment, he might as well do away with the article itself. Unless one is to assume that the Minister is so hard up that he could not get a few pounds extra in revenue in any other way, it is difficult to understand this tax. One finds it hard to defend this tax in any way. It will take away one of the only luxuries that the very poor have in the way of an after-dinner sweet, and most of them have a very meagre dinner. It is a particularly selfish tax. Most of us here can afford some substitutes, but the people who use rice largely will be placed in a tremendously bad position owing to this tariff. I do not think there is any reason for supporting it. I am sure that Deputy Corry himself has partaken of this wholesome dish at times, embroidered with a fair quantity of good sugar. Now that he has a sugar factory in Cork, at Mallow, it ought to be to his interests, if not to the interests of other Deputies, to encourage the increased use of sugar through the use of rice.

Comment on this

That is why. We want more for Deputy Belton's sugar.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say how much he expects to get from this tax?

Comment on this

I cannot give the Deputy the details.

Comment on this

He expects £5,000.

Comment on this

Is there any other reason for this tariff except the revenue to be derived from it? I do not see that there is any reason for this tax at all. It is an article of food consumed by the very poor people and, apart from that, it is used in the manufacture of starch, which is a household commodity. It is used in very many ways, apart from its use as a food. It will affect even the price of bread. Perhaps the Minister is not aware that rice flour is used in bakeries and that this will probably mean an increased cost per sack in the price of flour here. I think that this tax is going to have a very bad effect on the cost of producing bread and other articles into the manufacture of which rice enters, altogether apart from its being another tax on the food of the poor.

Comment on this

The Minister has not a word of explanation or a word of apology to offer to the House for this particularly mean tax. Deputy O'Neill raised another aspect of the matter. There was a time when the President was addressing himself to certain matters in a way which led us to think that we might get a progressive outlook on nutrition fostered by the Executive Council. It was considered by the President that light beer and milk would be a very excellent substitute for tea. While that actual proposal in itself did not mean very much as an intelligent start-off on a nutrition policy, nevertheless, it seemed that something might come of it. Now the Fianna Fáil Deputies laugh at the idea of rice pudding finding itself on the Sunday dinner table in any workman's home.

Comment on this

We did not laugh at anything of the sort, and the Deputy knows it.

Comment on this

I should like to hear Deputy Kelly——

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

You are not going to hear Deputy Kelly at all.

Comment on this

We cannot hear Deputy Kelly, nor can we hear any other member of the Fianna Fáil Party on this subject. But we are up against this question, that here we have a commodity which has a nutritive value in the food of our people, and which is almost a tradition with the poor classes in many parts of the country, and there is a tax put on this particular commodity, which is used, as I say, at Sunday dinner. If there were any other substitute for it easily available it might be said that it was the orange, but since the Spanish oranges have been forced into the position which they were forced into by the recent agreement with Spain, the orange is cut out, and the people are driven back more to rice than ever they would have been if the orange market were left free. I should like to ask Deputy Kelly will he or any member of his Party address himself to that aspect of this particular tax, if they consider the tax itself too mean to address themselves to the actual taxation side of it.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That reference No. 2, proposed to be deleted, stand."

Tá 55
·
Níl 36
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 41:—

In Part 1, to delete reference No. 8, including relevant references in columns 2 and 3.

This is another of the taxes that hit the house-building industry very hard. In reference No. 8 it is proposed to put a tax of 5/- per cwt. on roofing slates and by doing so the Minister imposes £40,000 by way of taxation on one of the necessities for house-building. I would like to hear the Minister, who is a member of an Executive Council that prides itself so much on what it is doing for housing, explain why it is that he proposes to take something like £40,000 out of house-building by putting this tax on slates.

Comment on this

Because we have very good slates here.

Comment on this

Tell us about them.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that the Irish slate quarries are able to meet the home demand? I think the Minister ought to be aware that, as regards the principal slate quarry in this country, most of the slates which it produces are exported and that they have a very valuable export market. Is the Minister satisfied that under the present production the slate quarries of this country are producing a sufficient number of slates of the type required by the builders for our housing schemes? There is a certain amount of doubt in that respect and I have been informed by those engaged in the building industry that because of the foreign contracts which the principal slate quarries have entered into they are unable to meet the home demand. If that is so, it seems to me that the Minister will want to consider carefully the imposition of this heavy duty. If the builders have to import slates for houses we are building here and pay the heavy duty, it will mean an increase in the price of the houses. If the Minister can assure us that the Irish quarries are in a position to supply all the slates of the type required for the home market, then there is a case for the proposal in the Bill. But unless he is able to assure us of that, there is no case for what he proposes.

Comment on this

In reference No. 11 we have ridge tiles, hip tiles and other roofing tiles made wholly or partly of clay or of Roman cement, Portland cement or any other hydraulic cement, and the rate of duty there is 50 per cent. The Minister adopts another method here and he places the tariff at 5/- a cwt.

Comment on this

Which is 50 per cent. Indeed, it is something more.

Comment on this

Why does not the Minister help the country to understand what the percentage in his tariff means? Why does he not put it so that it will be more clearly understood? Is he not aware that these things are not sold by weight, they are not accounted for anywhere by weight? Neither is the material referred to in reference No. 10, and yet he puts a duty on the weight. Does he not want to help the building industry? Does he not want to help trade? Does he not want to help merchants who make their living by trading in these articles? He has confused and upset their whole accountancy system by the introduction of what I term pure camouflage. He should have given us some information about his tariff, but he leaves us to guess. These articles are of different values, and a percentage tariff would be far more equitable than a flat duty of 5/- a cwt. I wonder if he intends to get any revenue out of this? Deputy Morrissey referred to slates. I wonder why slates are not given more attention here, where so much roofing material is required, and where we have the natural product, slates, in abundance.

Comment on this