We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1935—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–185 of 768. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 15 of 1935 ›

I wonder has the Minister considered whether he will make a statement on this proposal to put a tax of 5/- per cwt. on roofing slates. We have repeatedly pointed out to the Minister that there are a large number of items here which are imposing a very considerable burden on house building, thereby increasing the cost of house building and increasing rents. There was some sort of a suggestion last night that the development of slate quarrying in the country was going on satisfactorily and that therefore the amount of slates imported into the country fell last year considerably as compared with the year before, and fell the year before as compared with the previous year. That being so we want to know why this tax should now be put on? It is a tax that will inevitably increase the cost of the home-produced slates as well as increase the price of the imported slate.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister whether this is a revenue tax or a protective tax?

Comment on this
Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

I have already indicated that it is a revenue tax.

Comment on this

If it is a revenue tax I think it is a great pity to mix up revenue producing items with a whole lot of duties or tariffs for which the home manufacturer may be blamed. For instance, there are types of slates imported into this country that are not produced in any slate quarry here. I refer to ton slates and other special sizes and types. I have already pointed out to the Minister that this is another item which is putting up the cost of building. It is a customs item. I think the collection of this money bulks very large in comparison with the revenue that is to be derived from the tax. I would ask the Minister if he can see his way to do so, to do away with a number of these small taxes. They are only producing confusion. One bad result may be that Irish manufacturers may be blamed or may get the credit for the imposition of these taxes and the consequent raising of prices.

Comment on this

The Minister has just replied to Deputy Mulcahy that this is a revenue tax.

Comment on this

I beg the Deputy's pardon. I replied to Deputy Dockrell.

Comment on this

There are people to whom the Minister will not reply.

Comment on this

I replied to Deputy Dockrell because Deputy Dockrell made that pertinent remark. That is why I replied to him.

Comment on this

Some of the remarks are too pertinent for the Minister.

Comment on this

I am concerned only with the nature of the reply. I do not care to whom the reply was made. The Minister has conveyed the information to the House that this is a revenue tax. There is a complete change of attitude on this tax. I am sure it is immaterial to the Minister but I want to tell him that the Minister and his Government have gone down in my estimation when I find them prostituting the machinery they have at their disposal to help Irish industry. They are using that machinery to tax the people. Along with being a revenue tax this is a hypocritical tax. It is a tax that requires some investigation. I dare say the Minister's knowledge of industrial possibilities in this country is limited. I have it on an authority that I consider is one of the best in this country that from Nenagh to Killaloe and around that area, there are richer slate deposits than in Wales. The best English slate, "Westmoreland Green," is surpassed by Irish slates in the opinion of this technical expert to whom I am referring. I refer to slate which is found in large quantities down around Nenagh and Killaloe. This expert also said that the quarrying there is scamped, for the real good slate is left at the bottom. I know from first-hand information that it is impossible to get Irish slate. No man who is venturing on speculative building can afford to take the risk, even if he had the wish to do so, of roofing his house with slate, because he might be held up in the midst of the work through not being able to get Irish slate. I am speaking now with first-hand information. When I look at this new tax I am beginning to wonder whether the Government have some method in the madness. As in the case of coal, apparently the Government want to get in English slate on which they can collect a tax of £5 a ton. Under the circumstances is it any wonder that the slate deposits in this country are not being worked? What is more, I venture to say that the most of the output is exported. Glasgow has booked orders in Killaloe months ahead. Could any Dublin builder book an order for Killaloe slates? Will it not pay the Minister to export these over to Glasgow? If a person wants to import slates they will be let in, but the Minister for Finance will get £5 per ton on them. So that slates are left in the bottom and doles and free beef are going around.

The Minister and his colleague, the Minister for Local Government, in their generosity, are giving grants for the building of houses. By the time this Bill is in full working order far more than the grants of £50 or £60 now given out of the Exchequer for each new house built will be more than paid back through the operation of this Bill. Slates, copper tubing, sewer pipes, and surface drain pipes are taxed and there is 5/- on cement. The little bit of profit that builders were making out of ground rents was capitalised and almost one-fourth of that has to be paid down. When all those things are taken into account where is the margin of profit unless the price goes up? Of course, there is the inevitable remedy that building will stop. Not only that, but if a man buys a house the oil cloth that he puts on his floors is taxed. The fresh air that he gets in that new house in the suburbs of Dublin is about all that is left untaxed by the Minister. If the Minister is there next year he will have a good try to tax that. Of course, indirectly he is taxing it, because he is compelling unsuitable pipes to be used for drainage.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We must keep on the roof now.

Comment on this

I wanted to bring the Minister to earth and put him near the earth pipe and the tax he is getting out of that. An inferior article is being put in which will pollute the air and even the people.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present. House counted and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

We will be better able to get on now with all the experts in.

Comment on this

Do not drive us out again.

Comment on this

We will have a little discussion on Mayo slates. I am sure the men of the West will not be easily driven out when we are discussing such a subject. Unfortunately, these Mayo slates are small slates, but they are well able to compete with the imported small slates. If the Minister had shown a little intelligence he could inadvertently help an Irish industry. Just as in dealing with other matters he has used a unit that is not known in the trade. Anybody who asked a merchant for a ton of slates would be promptly told that they are not sold by the ton. The Minister did not deal in the units known to the trade; nor did he give us the percentage of the tariff that he proposes to impose. He simply puts down £5 per ton. Quite obviously the big slates will be better able to bear that tariff than the small ones. In the matter of small slates, the Irish industry, without any tariff, was more than able to hold its own, but in the big, good class slates it was not able to hold its own. Good class slates which are thin, consistent with quality and durability, will be able to bear this tariff. Of course, the question of tariffs does not matter now. It is a tax we want—tax, tax, and more tax. All these presents that we were given were by way of encouraging house-building. Now we are on the down-grade and pursuing a course to discourage house-building, and we shall easily succeed as everybody will see as soon as this Bill is in operation. There is no need to pursue the argument about it on industrial grounds as it is purely a revenue tax, as was admitted by the Minister. Does the Parliamentary Secretary suggest that it is not?

Comment on this

Go ahead.

Comment on this

I know where I am going. I would like to be bringing the Parliamentary Secretary into strange land.

Comment on this

Certainly not into that land.

Comment on this

He would be a bit far from his base if he came this way.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us keep to the slates.

Comment on this

All the criticism that may be offered on this is that once more a necessary article of building construction is being taxed for revenue purposes and nothing else. If that tax were put on for industrial purposes I would vote for it, but as it is put on for revenue purposes purely and, therefore, will make industrial protection stink in the nostrils of the ordinary man in the street, for the sake of industrial protection I will vote against a revenue tax on slates.

Comment on this

The truth apparently lies very deep down in the Minister for Finance. His silence during the last few days has perhaps kept it even further down. But he has coughed it up. We were led to believe, as far as my recollection goes, by the discussion which took place on slates yesterday that we were stifling the development of the slate industry here by opposing this tariff on slates. Now we are told that it is for the purpose of getting money. It just emphasises what is perfectly clear to everybody, that this Budget is introduced more in a spirit of gold-digging for the purpose of filling the coffers of the Ministry than for the purposes of assisting Irish industrial development in any way, or making the conditions in the country such that the people can better bear the enormous burden of taxation put upon them. It has been pointed out to me that there is a considerable amount of housebuilding going on and a considerable amount of money spent and that a considerable amount more remains to be done. Having regard to the amount of money spent on housing, taken in relation to the number of houses built, and the achievement in the past, the cost is rather unsatisfactory. The Minister for Local Government and Public Health feels it unsatisfactory, and he was driven, a month or two ago, to state more explicitly the facts in that regard. He was seeking to include in the number of new houses every case in which he gave a grant of £20, £25, or £30 to persons in a rural area who put new roofs on. The figures were being swelled in order to excuse, in some way, the enormous amount of money spent. On top of all that there is the proposal to take at least £30,000 out of the pockets of people in the country who have house property at the present time.

I would like to ask why the Ministry approaches the slate industry in this country in connection with the Budget in this particular kind of way. There has been expressed, in this House, and throughout the country, a general complaint that we are not able to get sufficient Irish slates to meet our present requirements. So far from turning their attention to seeing what could be done the better to assist in the organisation of the Irish slate industry, the Government ignored that altogether. They are content to scrape out of the pockets of people pursuing this very useful work, additional moneys. The Department of Industry and Commerce has a research council. Is it doing anything to assist those controlling the slate industry the better to direct and organise their work? It seems to me that it would be much better that they should do something like that than concerning themselves with trying to turn turf into silk stockings and whiskey.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are concerned with slates here.

Comment on this

An attempt was made yesterday to persuade the House that this tax was for the purpose of assisting the slate industry. We now find it is not, but is for the purpose of getting money. We think that the tax resources of this country would be better able to bear their burdens if the Government would direct its attention to assisting those controlling industry to organise their business better, and to get slates perfectly suitable for house building where they are available.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a matter for the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

When work like that needs to be done it is simply scandalous that instead of doing it the Government should impose an additional burden on the industry. When we take into consideration the imported slates, goodness knows what it will add, and, also, when we take into consideration the rise that will take place in the price of Irish slates inside that tariff. It is a great crime, when the cost of housebuilding is so great as it is, and when houses are so badly wanted by the people, and when there is so little money to pay for them, that this additional burden should be imposed.

Comment on this

When this matter is being considered in regard to slates, we should bear in mind this fact: that the slate industry in this country is not asking for protection against the importation of slates from outside. There was a statement made in the last few months by the manager of a firm engaged in the production of slates, that they need not concern themselves whether any of their slates were put up on Irish houses, because they were not able to produce enough slates to meet the demands of the outside market. So far from any need of protection, the slate industry in this country, because of the high quality of the slates, were in a position not only to meet competition here but to secure a very valuable export market. The trouble is not outside competition. The trouble is that those engaged in the industry have not available the capital necessary for the full development of the slate industry. The gentleman who made that statement referred to the Killaloe Slate Quarry, which is the largest in this country, and he said recently that if he had the necessary capital to enable him to develop his slate resources along the proper lines, he could produce three times the number of slates he is turning out at present, and employ three times the number of men he has engaged at present.

This tax means only one thing. It means that, because of the failure of the Government to help the slate industry to be properly organised, so as to be able to meet the demands of the home and export market, those people who either purchased or rent houses in this country will be saddled with £30,000 or £40,000 extra in order to provide revenue for the Government. That seems to be absolutely inconsistent with the Government's policy of providing houses for the people and providing them at the cheapest possible rent. It must be remembered that the vast majority of the houses being built are to be occupied by the poorest people who have been brought out from the slums. The latest schemes are slum clearances schemes, and surely, so far from doing anything that would add to the rent of the people who have to be rehoused, everything should be done to make them cheaper still. Deputies in this House, who are members of local authorities, know perfectly well that those people who are brought from the slums and have to be put into new houses are, many of them, in receipt of unemployment relief or home assistance and have no weekly wages. In such cases an extra 6d. or even 2d. added to the rent is a very material consideration for these people.

Comment on this

But a very small number of these houses are roofed with slate.

Comment on this

The Deputy is wrong. There are 111 houses in my own town on the point of completion. Every one of them will be roofed with slate. We were enabled to roof them with slate because of the special plea which was made to the manager of the Killaloe slate quarry and because of the proximity of the town to the slate quarry. It was only by going to a certain amount of trouble and by up setting, to a certain extent, the orders which he had from across the water, he was able to oblige the council. I submit to the Deputy and to the House that if the slate industry was properly organised, every house in the country would be roofed with slate without in any way impairing the outside market. It seems to me that less can be said for this imposition than for any other tax in this Budget. I think the Government will find it almost impossible to make a case for it, because the industry is an industry which is able to stand on its own feet. It has not looked for protection and does not need it. All it needs is sufficient capital to organise itself to meet the home and the export markets and to employ three times the number of men employed to-day.

Comment on this

I put it to the Parliamentary Secretary that, as this is a purely revenue tax, it will have the effect of killing the use of slates. Deputy Moore has just said that the houses which are being roofed throughout the country are being roofed with tiles.

Comment on this

Fortunately.

Comment on this

Why? Because they will not get the grant if they do not use Irish roofing material, and if they want Irish slate they find that they cannot get it. Therefore, in order to get the grant, they are putting on inferior material. This is a tax of £5 per ton on slate for revenue purposes and it does not require a genius to see that that is going to discourage the use of slate. It is not helping Irish slate at home, because we cannot get it. If it were helping Irish slate and if the imported slate was displacing Irish slate, I could vote for the tax if it were £10 a ton. But it is not. It is for revenue, and the effect of it will be less use of slate which is imported —the only slate we can get—and the less imported slate you have, the less houses will be roofed with slate and the less revenue you will have. This tax is going to be a suicidal tax and nobody with common sense would vote for it.

Comment on this

Are we not going to hear the Parliamentary Secretary on this?

Comment on this

Would you like to?

Comment on this

On this occasion, yes.

Comment on this

If he knows anything about it.

Comment on this

Charmed. For some extraordinary reason, Deputy Belton has decided to speak ex cathedra on the subject of this tax. He does not agree with the other popes in the House on the matter, but he seems to be absolutely sure that the sole purpose of this tax is revenue.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

The Deputy says that is right.

Comment on this

Your boss, the Minister for Finance, said so before you came in.

Comment on this

He did not say it was for revenue. It is a mixed tax, like most of these taxes.

Comment on this

Like most taxes.

Comment on this

Like most taxes, yes. It is a mixed tax of protection and of revenue.

Comment on this

There is no protection.

Comment on this

The Deputy says there is no protection.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance said there is none.

Comment on this

Not a bit of it and even if the Minister were to tell me that it had no protective effect, it would not have the slightest effect upon the facts, as I know them. It has a protective effect, both on Irish slates and Irish alternative roofing material and no amount of ex cathedra stuff from Deputy Belton will alter that fact. I would certainly like to see a great deal more development of Irish slates, and it has been my job to find money for a considerable number of development schemes in an attempt to get more slate, but the idea that everybody who can get Irish slate is prepared to use it, even on the quality which is specified in the contracts into which they have entered, is a wild illusion. I have one case within my knowledge of a school in respect of which a contract was entered into, and in respect of which Irish slates of particular size and so on from three quarries were specified. Everything that was humanly possible to be done by those who had made that contract to avoid carrying it out was done. At a critical moment, I was told that they could not get the slates and I went to the trouble of finding the slates for them as specified in the contract, and I told them where to get them, and then they would not use them. They put in another objection, and I again found another slate right in the very town in which they were building this school. They were told that “slate of such and such a quality as specified in your contract can be found in such a business place in your own town,” and the answer was that I was denounced with bell, book and candle for attempting to enforce the use of Irish slate which they had entered into a contract to use. That illustration should certainly put a slightly different complexion on the thing. Some day or other, I may tell the whole of this very extraordinary tale——

Comment on this

Tell it to us now.

Comment on this

No, I will tell it later. I am only introducing enough of it to show that there is no basis for this beautiful ex cathedra stuff we have been getting from Deputy Belton. The industry may require protection and to the extent to which this particular tax does give that protection, it is to the good, but not merely is it a protection of Irish slates, a protection which, as I tell you, they need to the extent of the legal enforcement of contracts to make people carry out their obligations——

Comment on this

The law will do that without any tariffs.

Comment on this

The Deputy may be taking the narrow line that tariffs as such are of no use whatever and that putting 5/- a cwt. is a purely irrelevant thing and does not matter. If the Deputy likes to contend that he can, but he cannot go on contending that while saying, at the same time, that if this was put on for the purpose of a tariff, he would vote for it if it were £10 a ton. He cannot have it both ways, and it does not matter a damn which way he takes it. This has been put on for revenue and for protection.

Comment on this

No, revenue only.

Comment on this

Ex cathedra. Pope Belton the first and the last.

Comment on this

Not the last while you are about.

Comment on this

He is the last pope, anyway. The Deputy is like the agriculturists who went into the zoo and saw a giraffe and said: "There ain't no such animal." He saw it, but it was not there because he said it was not there. There is no tariff quality in this particular tax because Pope Belton says there is not.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Belton.

Comment on this

That is like the Fianna Fáil farmer who says there is no war.

Comment on this

Or like the Deputy who wants to get away from this House to some other business which he invented to-day for the purpose of excusing himself from doing his job here. Deputy Mulcahy says that the progress of housing is unsatisfactory. I am taking this only as an example of the degree of strict relevancy which the Opposition desire to introduce. They want all the time possible to discuss this Bill and on a 5/- tariff on slates, they would like to discuss the whole building programme. A lot more building is going on than went on under Deputy Mulcahy and a lot better building; building better distributed, building which goes into the places in which it is more required and building more directed to the purpose of removing from the slums and from the one-roomed dwellings the people who are living in them.

Comment on this

All the more reason why you should not have this tax.

Comment on this

We shall take that now. The Deputy agrees with me. Well and good. That wipes out Deputy Mulcahy.

Comment on this

I say all the more reason why you should not have this tax.

Comment on this

All the more reason why we should not have any tax of any kind or description, a tax on anything we want developed.

Comment on this

This tax?

Comment on this

I am taking the second case.

Comment on this

You are out of order.

Comment on this

You want to choose your own ground.

Comment on this

Of course I am choosing my own ground, with the aid and assistance of the Deputies opposite. Whenever they speak on any subject they give me sufficient variety of range to choose any ground I like. If one comes in with Arabia the other will come in with South America. All I have got to do at any time is to read two or three speeches by the Opposition and I can deliver any speech I like on any subject I like.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I could not do that without the aid and assistance of the Opposition.

Comment on this

The Deputy has a speech for every occasion.

Comment on this

And a number of others.

Comment on this

I came in here to get from Deputy Mulcahy precisely the interruption which I answered. I have come into this House, having written down before I came in seven or eight particular interruptions which I expected to receive, and I have got every one of them—usually from the men whose names I have written behind them.

Comment on this
A Deputy

You are a fortune teller.

Comment on this

I am not a fortune teller but I have that sort of intelligence which enables me to know what I have to face. The next thing Deputy Mulcahy said was that £30,000 was going to be taken out of certain pockets by this tax. He cannot say that without saying that at the same time there is being created a £30,000 inducement for the trade to go into channels other than the channels which are represented by the importation of slates.

Comment on this

I said nothing about profits. I spoke about costs.

Comment on this

The Deputy said that £30,000 more was going to be taken out of the pockets——

Comment on this

Yes, the pockets.

Comment on this

That is exactly what I said before. The Deputy for once is right; he agrees with me. The Deputy said that £30,000 more is going to be taken out of the pockets of the people who are interested in house building by this tax on slates. That £30,000 can only be taken out of these pockets if the imported slates are used to that extent, and therefore the Deputy has said that a £30,000 inducement has been given to those who are engaged in building houses for the purpose of forcing them over to Irish slates or alternative Irish building materials.

Comment on this

They cannot get Irish slates.

Comment on this

Oh dear! I have given to the House a particular case where a man was building and where I found Irish slates for him and he said: "I will not take them." The fact remains that Deputy Mulcahy has given the Minister for Finance in this House to-day a certificate that an inducement to the extent of £30,000 a year is being provided under this tax, for the purpose of transferring the custom from English slates to Irish slates or alternative Irish roofing material.

Comment on this

We have heard extraordinary arguments brought forward in support of taxes but I think this is the first time that we heard the head of a Department bringing forward as an excuse for a tax of 5/- per cwt. on slates, that he is incompetent to enforce the law. He had a legal contract according to which Irish slates were to be used and, apparently, this extraordinary Department and this extraordinary Parliamentary Secretary could not enforce that legal contract because he had not an extra tax of 5/- per cwt. on slates. Assuming for the moment and purely for the purposes of the debate—I confess I am using it for no other purpose — that there were some difficulties as he suggested, it was an extraordinary argument to use. I enter into a contract with a certain school manager to utilise Irish slates and he does not do it. He is legally bound to do it, but I cannot enforce the contract, yet I can do it if you put 5/- of a tax on imported slates. That is the argument that has been used.

Comment on this

That is not the argument.

Comment on this

That is what he said.

Comment on this

It is not what he said.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

I listened to the Parliamentary Secretary stating that this would enable him to enforce the contract.

Comment on this

That is nonsense.

Comment on this

It is nonsense. It is absolute nonsense, but we listened to him here deputising for the Minister and using that statement. I quite admit one thing about the business of this House—that when the Minister is in the House he devotes just so much attention to Culbertson that he knows as much of what occurs as when he is out of the House.

Comment on this

On a point of order; I was sitting nearer to Deputy Flinn than Deputy Professor O'Sullivan was and the inference which the Deputy takes from his remarks could not be read into them.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

I understand quite well that Deputy Corry mistakes himself for the moment as the Minister for Finance. I was not accusing Deputy Corry of studying Culbertson while the business of the House is in progress. I do not think for a moment that he could hope to get any enlightenment in finance from that particular volume. I know that Gevernment Deputies were let loose to-day. They were kept in leash all the week; they are now let loose. The Parliamentary Secretary told us about the manager of a particular school, if it existed at all, who complained of difficulty in getting Irish slates, but I gathered that it was not merely the manager of that school but builders of all kinds who experienced that difficulty. I have not the slightest doubt that if the head of any Government Department goes to a certain quarry and asks for slates he will get them. The owner of the quarry would be very foolish to refuse to give slates to the head of a Department when he puts that request up to him but to say that the ordinary person in the country, who is carrying out a building contract, can get them on demand is an entirely different matter. That is the situation.

We heard from various Deputies that the lack of development in the case of the biggest slate quarry in the country is not due to the lack of protection but is due to lack of capital. There is a sufficient demand for slates; I gathered from the various speakers we have heard in this House that there is plenty of demand for Irish slates, a greater demand than can be supplied at the moment. Therefore when we are asked to choose for the moment as between the statements of the Minister for Finance and those of his understudy as to the purpose of the tax, we shall take those of the Minister for Finance and regard this as a revenue tax. The Minister's deputy here to-day pretended that this was a protective tariff but in reality as we gathered from the Minister himself this tax is meant to be a purely revenue-raising tax. I put it to Deputies, is it anything extraordinary that this Government having gone into every nook and cranny in the House to get money should start at the roof and finish at the drains? In this particular schedule we have it that the Government are putting a tax on every bit of a house and on every house, so that when a man is sleeping he is sleeping under a roof that pays a tax. If that man has not a ceiling in his house, the first thing he sees in the morning are the slates, and he has to pay a tax on them. Again, there is the usual example of the Government alleging that its business is to promote a certain kind of activity—industry—in this case house-building. But in every part of this schedule we find plenty of evidence that its activity is in the opposite direction. How the putting up of the price of building material in various ways, slates in this particular case, is expected not to have an effect on the price of a house, and, ultimately on the production of houses, passes the imagination of the ordinary man. But, apparently, this is one of the methods by which the Minister for Finance thinks he can best help the policy of the Minister for Local Government and Public Health. This, we must take it, is a revenue tax. It was not from an ex cathedra pronouncement, as the ecclesiastically-inclined Parliamentary Secretary would seem to suggest, between popes—about his being excommunicated by bell, book and candle by a school manager and his ex cathedra statement—that we got the idea that this was a mere revenue tax from Deputy Belton. We got it from the tax itself, and from the statement of the man who is supposed to be responsible for this particular Bill.

Comment on this

Very definite attempts have been made by Deputy O'Sullivan to misrepresent what Deputy Flinn said. We have only to look at the manner in which he has twisted Deputy Flinn's statement on one item alone to see that. Deputy Flinn gave the case of a contractor, and Deputy O'Sullivan immediately changed him into a school manager. We know his reason for doing it.

Comment on this

It was not a contractor.

Comment on this

A contractor was referred to in the statement made by Deputy Flinn. Of course, we know Deputy O'Sullivan's reason for doing that.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

That was followed up by a further statement. Deputy Flinn showed how this would be a protective tariff. He gave the example of the contractor who was bound to use Irish slates and who would not either get them or use them. The one thing to be learned from the arguments of the Opposition is this: that they are out to see that the Government's housing schemes will give as little employment as possible to the Irish people.

Comment on this

Bosh.

Comment on this

That is it. The Government are determined to see that if the people of this country are going to finance housing schemes, then those schemes are going to give all the employment possible here. They are going to see that Irish slates and Irish tiles will be used in the construction of houses and that all the employment possible is given to the Irish people. All the arguments of the Opposition are directed against that policy. Because we are endeavouring to protect those employed in the production of Irish slates and tiles, the Opposition are speaking against this proposal and arguing against it. If the 5/- tax brings in £30,000, as Deputy Mulcahy says it will, may I ask him this question: how much Irish money at 5/- per cwt. on slates is going to be paid for those slates if they are purchased from abroad? Our answer is that all that money should be kept here for the production of slates and tiles to roof houses for the Irish people.

Comment on this

This is a 50 per cent. tax.

Comment on this

It should be 100 per cent. During the ten years that he was in office Deputy Mulcahy did not build a house for the Irish people, and now he is endeavouring to get back on his old game again. The Deputy complains because the Irish people are going to get employment in producing slates and tiles for our housing schemes. He wants all that money to go to some other country for slates to roof our houses. We had enough of that game during the time Deputy Mulcahy was in office, and I am very glad that it is being put an end to now.

Comment on this

During the past few days the criticism directed against the Finance Bill has come mainly from these benches. Those on the Government side of the House did not intervene very often. I am glad to see that even at this late hour some of the Deputies opposite are showing a desire to intervene. They were careful to refrain from making any intervention when the provisions imposing taxes on the food of the people were being discussed. Perhaps they did not think it wise to intervene then. Now we have Deputy Corry, with the indiscretion of a bantam fighter challenging a heavyweight, intervening. I do not know whether this is a revenue tax or a protective tax, or whether it has a touch of both. The Minister for Finance says that it is a revenue tax. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance said that it was not—that it was mainly protective, but that there might be a touch of revenue about it. The Parliamentary Secretary tried to prove that it would help and protect some industry. He did not mention slates. I think he did refer to some subsidiary form of slate production. What strikes me about this particular tariff is that it is going to increase the price of building materials. It is well known that Irish slates cannot be got by many builders. That cannot be contradicted, and yet we have the principal manufacturer of Irish slates exporting slates. It is reasonable to suppose that his reason for doing that is that he is able to get a better price for his slates. He is hardly doing it for fun. It must also be assumed that when there is an export market for Irish slates they must be regarded as a better article than the slate produced in the country to which they are being exported. Another reason may be that by exporting Irish slates the manufacturer is attempting to force the Minister to give him a monopoly of the trade here such as manufacturers in other lines got before. It may not be necessary at all for certain manufacturers to export the goods they produce here, but as I have suggested their reason for doing so may be to endeavour to force the Minister to give them a monopoly so that they may be able to force up prices on the home market. That may be the reason here. I do not believe that we are at all near the day when we will be able to produce sufficient slates to meet the home demand. Therefore, this tariff is going to result in an increased price for slates. The Parliamentary Secretary said that our attitude was to prevent people using Irish materials. That is ridiculous. If people want to use the best materials, then they are entitled to get them and if Irish slates are the best they should be entitled to get them. If people cannot get Irish slates then they ought to be able to get the slate that, in their opinion, is the next best. When people want to get the best material to roof their houses, they ought to be entitled to get it. If they want to have their houses roofed with slates instead of some other material they ought to be able to get them. If people who initiate housing schemes believe that a slate roof is the best roof, surely they are entitled to have slates. There are people who believe that even a slate inferior to the best Irish slate is a better roof than some of the best substitute roofs which are being used. This tax is going to force people to use substitute roofing at, possibly, the price of slates. It is going to increase the cost of building to that extent. We may get an inferior roof at the price the slates would cost. This tariff will have the same effect as all other tariffs. There are cases in which a tariff does not fall on the consuming country. The people in these circumstances can get the goods elsewhere or substitute goods. But, in practically all cases, a tariff will have the effect of raising prices at home. I do not think that there is one tariff which we imposed——

Comment on this

On a point of order, we are not discussing the general policy of tariffs. We are discussing a particular item on which I take a certain line and I want to be consistent in the taking of that line.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is correct in saying that there is only one item before the Committee.

Comment on this

This tariff, in my opinion and in the opinion of many others, will add to the cost of a certain building material, to wit, slates. If it has the effect of making the manufacturers retain at home what they at present export, it will mean that they will put the 5/- on the amount they keep at home. That might be all to the good, but we must realise that this tax is going to add to the cost of building. Whether that is wise or not, is another question. For my part, I think building costs are high enough.

Comment on this

It does not seem to me to be by any means clear how a tariff on an article in respect of which the supply does not equal the demand will raise the price of that article. Surely the opportunity for raising the price is already present, to a large extent. Deputy Belton says that Irish slates cannot be obtained. Several other Deputies said that the supply was not equal to the demand. Why, in these circumstances, should a tariff be required to enable the manufacturers to raise prices?

Comment on this

Is not the price raised on the imported article?

Comment on this

Surely if the demand is far greater than the supply, the oppor tunity to raise prices is already there.

Comment on this

A 5/- tariff is of no advantage to a firm in those circumstances.

Comment on this

Who said it was?

Comment on this

Therefore, the whole case about raising prices seems to be absurd. If it is not, then the case has not been put clearly. If I were in possession of an article for which there were people clamouring, I should be inclined to take full advantage of the clamour and raise the price. A tariff of 5/- per cwt. would not be of much importance to me. I think that the point about raising prices has not been proven. Another point arises. Deputies opposite profess a great desire to see the industries of the country developed. They admit that there are slate quarries in the country. They say that, under present conditions, the slate quarries are not being developed. Deputy Belton referred to the manner —I thought this was very inconsistent from the point of view of his argument—in which slate development was being scamped. There was, he said, no attempt to penetrate deeply into the quarry; development was merely superficial. If all that has happened and if the argument be correct, that capital fails to go where there is a demand for it, how can there be any objection to the Government trying some further stimulus? If this tariff gives a stimulus to proper slate development, I do not think that any Deputy interested in industry should regret it.

Comment on this

But it is a revenue tax.

Comment on this

A rose by any other name would smell as sweet. It ought to have some effect, at least, on the further development, which the Deputy says is required, of the slate quarries. Very few of the slate quarries are being efficiently worked.

Comment on this

If the Deputy said "fully worked," he might be nearer the point. He does not know much about the question.

Comment on this

I have that information on a much better authority than Deputy Morrissey.

Comment on this

I should be interested to hear that statement from the Minister.

Comment on this

There is a quarry in my own constituency awaiting exploitation and, in the present circumstances of the country, it is very desirable that whatever resources of that kind we have should be fully developed. Deputy Belton made a wonderful case for this tariff when he said that there were no better slates in the world than the slates obtainable here and when he said that development was being scamped—that there was no attempt at deep exploration of the quarries for the purpose of getting the best slates. In those circumstances, the further stimulus which this tariff will give should make it worth while.

Comment on this

We can now understand why the Minister for Finance has, for the last two days, been engaged in an attempt to prevent Deputy Corry and other members of his Party from speaking. Having listened to Deputy Corry, Deputy Moore and, to a lesser extent, to the Parliamentary Secretary, I have a good deal of sympathy with the Minister. I quite understand why he wanted to keep them silent. Deputy Corry got up in absolute and complete ignorance of the subject and blazed out with the statement that the Government were going to see that employment on housing would be given. A very profound statement, that! If Deputy Moore proved anything at all, it was that he was ignorant of the whole question.

Comment on this

That is the Deputy's idea.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy get this into his head—that the slate quarry owners have not asked for this tariff and do not want it; further, that the manager of the best slate quarry in this country, a man also interested in other slate quarries, has said, at full production at present, he is not able to meet export orders not to speak about the home market at all.

Comment on this

I said that.

Comment on this

The only pronouncement of the Deputy was that the Irish slate quarries were not being efficiently worked.

Comment on this

And I stick to that.

Comment on this

I happen to know a little about these quarries, because I live adjacent, and I know that they are being efficiently worked within the limits imposed on the owners.

Comment on this

That is not the opinion of people directly concerned.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy get this into his mind—that they do not require protection. Irish slates are able to get sufficient demand on the home and export markets on merit alone. I think it is an insult to those engaged in the Irish slate industry that a tax of 5/- must be imposed to help it. Is Deputy Moore aware that the City of Glasgow would take the whole of the present production of the Killaloe slate quarries?

Comment on this

For the next three years.

Comment on this

When the Deputy talks about £30,000 or about a 5/- tariff, let him get this into his mind —that there is only one way to help the Irish slate industry, and that is if the money was handed over for the further development of the quarries and to give additional employment. The manager of the Killaloe slate quarries appeared before the Commission on Prices recently, and stated that if he had sufficient capital he could produce three times as much slates and find demand for them. This is not a question of assisting a weak and a struggling industry. The position is, perhaps, unique, because we have an industry that cannot produce enough slates to meet the demand. I suggest that it is a reflection on the industry to say that the 5/- is being imposed to help it. Of course, it is not. No one knows that better than the Parliamentary Secretary, who talked around this question very glibly. He talked about everything except the question under discussion. He mentioned a contractor who was legally bound to put Irish slates on the roof of some building, and that he could not get him to do so. He said there was no method of getting that done, except by having a tax on slates.

Comment on this

I said nothing of the kind. I compelled the contractor to use Irish slates in spite of himself. I am going to continue doing that.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary could have done that if the 5/- tax was never mentioned. He will have the same power to-morrow.

Comment on this

If Irish slates are specified in the contract, whatever may be the prejudice of the contractor, he must put Irish slates on the roof. Apart from this section, the law is there to compel him to do so. I say it is unfair to make use of the Irish slate industry on which to hang this tax. It is not required. The position is that the City of Glasgow alone could take the whole production of the Killaloe slate quarries, and they are the biggest quarries in this country.

Comment on this

Deputy Moore, and other speakers, want, apparently, to repair the damage that the Minister for Finance did, by his frank admission, perhaps in an unguarded moment, that this is purely a revenue tax. Deputy Moore asked me if the tariff would not help the production of Irish slates. My answer is, not in the least. The trouble is that we are not looking for a market but want to get Irish slates. If I was building a house to live in and wanted Irish slates and could not get them, I would have to import slates. Apart from the price, I would buy Irish slates. I cannot get them. Deputy Moore's argument is that we should not be allowed to get any slates if we could not get Irish slates. The Parliamentary Secretary was looking for an excuse, and he drew on his imagination about a contractor for a school and the trouble there was to get him to carry out the terms of the contract. Does anybody believe that the Parliamentary Secretary did that? Of course not. I am not a Parliamentary Secretary, but if I was in a position to give a contract, I would enforce it by going to a solicitor to have it carried out. That is what the Parliamentary Secretary would do if there was any substance in what he said. I will give another instance, where I was building 24 houses in two terraces. Before I started I decided to arrange about the slates. A traveller from one of the biggest firms in Dublin assured me that he could get Irish slates. I had trouble before about finishing houses with Killaloe slates, 16 by 8, and in the end, after searching Dublin, I had to buy job lots. I had to buy slates 22 by 10 and to pay a man to cut them back to 16 by 8 in order to finish the job. I was unable to get Killaloe slates 16 by 8. It was essential for the development of the place that the 24 houses should be slated. I told the traveller that I had got a "sickener" before and that I should have the slates on the ground before I started. He came next day and assured me that he could get small slates 11 by 7. I consulted the architect who said that the best thing to do was to lath and board the roofs. I went to the trouble of having that done but could not get small slates. The firm wrote and wired to the quarries and they could not get an answer. I will give the name of the firm to anyone who is curious to know it. Finally, I had to abandon Irish slates and to order Blue Bangor, which were delivered in an hour. When I asked if it would be safe to put Blue Bangor slates on boarded roofs, I was told that it would not, and that I would have either to take off the boards and laths or to put on felt. I had then to go to the expense of putting on felt for use with Blue Bangor slates. Deputies say that our opposition to this tariff is because we do not want to help Irish industry. Deputies are going to vote for this tax as a revenue tax. They are afraid and ashamed to admit that they are going to tax slates in order to produce revenue.

Comment on this

Let the House have some explanation of your attitude. You cannot give it. I repeat that if a tax of £10 a ton on slates would help Irish industry, I would support it. I will not support a tariff of ten farthings a ton to help production when we have not enough slates for our own development. The Minister said that this was revenue tax and he cannot get away from it. When the Minister went out the Parliamentary Secretary came in. Perhaps the Minister saw that he put his foot in it. Possibly, he may have suggested to the Parliamentary Secretary that he should take him out of the hole that he had got into. The Parliamentary Secretary failed miserably to do so. Now the back benchers want to support this tax on slates that we have not got. Deputy Moore said that the tax would help industry. If a tariff of £1,000 was put on imported slates it would not help, because there is a greater demand for Irish slates than can be supplied. It is for those responsible for the development of the country to help the Irish slate quarries. It will not be necessary to put a penny tax on slates if they can be produced in sufficient quantities here. It is not that help is wanted for Irish slates but to have them made available when required.

Comment on this

We have listened to the most peculiar and amazing arguments I ever heard. First, we had it stated that Glasgow was buying all the Irish slates. Evidently the charge is that the Killaloe people are so unpatriotic that they will not supply Irish builders, but would rather export the slates to Glasgow. If sufficient slates are not being produced, how is it that they are being exported? As the Parliamentary Secretary said, people here have either a bee in their bonnets, or they are not prepared to use Irish slates, unless they are made do so. Surely to goodness the Killaloe Slate Quarries are prepared to supply the Irish people with slates first before they export them. Apparently, the whole thing is that they must be exported, and then we have Deputy Morrissey trying to camouflage it by saying that the whole object of the people over there is to create all the unemployment they can. There is enough roofing material being made in this country to roof every house that is being built. If it would give employment to our own people, I would vote not alone for 50 per cent. but for 100 per cent. I would like to know how the Killaloe people are exporting to Glasgow and will not supply the Irish people with Irish slates and, on the other hand, why you are so anxious to import foreign slates here.

Comment on this

I wonder where the idea sprang up that this was a tariff. The Minister for Finance, in that remarkably long speech he contributed, said that it was a revenue tax. It is. The purpose of a tariff is quite clear, and that is to secure the home market for the slates, but it is quite obvious that there is a sufficient home market for the slates produced in this country. There is no necessity, therefore, for the tariff.

Comment on this

Why, then, are they being exported?

Comment on this

I always knew that it was unpatriotic to export cattle, according to the Deputies opposite, but now I understand it is unpatriotic to get even Scottish money, not to speak of English money, for Irish slates. The whole thing is absurd and ridiculous. We cannot get money for the goods we export, and, according to Deputy Corry, it is unpatriotic of the Killaloe Quarries to sell Irish produce outside the country. That is the latest Fianna Fáil doctrine or policy of self-containedness. Not merely are we to take nothing from other countries, but apparently we are not to export to other countries. We dare not sell abroad. We are unpatriotic if we do. This is purely a revenue tax and nothing else. I am not relying now on the Minister's own statement to that effect, but on the actual facts of the situation. This is not a case of protecting or securing the home market for Irish produce. That market is already secured and more than secured. There is a much greater demand for the Irish produce in this case than there is a supply. The difficulty is, not to find a market for the Irish slates in Ireland; the difficulty is to find Irish slates for the market that is in Ireland. To speak of protecting that market in this connection is simply a complete misconception of the whole purpose of protection. The idea of protection is that, when the home-produced goods are being driven out of the home market by foreign competition, you try to keep out the foreign article, but emphatically, that is not the case here.

Comment on this

That is all very interesting.

Comment on this

We have heard it so often.

Comment on this

At any rate, the Deputy who spoke last does not seem to be attending to the business of the House. He seems to be reading letters, instead of attending to it. We had then the extraordinary statement that there can be no increase in prices because there was a greater demand than supply in the home market. That was Deputy Moore's argument. Apparently, the 5/- a cwt. on slates, which amounts to 50 per cent. of an increase, is paid by nobody. It is just given away with the slates. Surely, it means an increase in price and in building costs. I suggest, however, that the whole debate has been most interesting in so far as it allowed us to see the extraordinarily muddled point of view of the people opposite on the question of finance, protection, tariffs and taxes. We cannot wonder at the state the country is in when such matters are in the control of a Party such as that. They speak of protection without knowing what it is for. When a mere revenue tax is imposed, they speak of it as a protective tariff. This tariff is not a protective tariff. It is nothing of the kind. It is a tariff purely and simply for revenue purposes.

Comment on this

If I were Pope!

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 42
·
Níl 24
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 42:—

In Part I, to delete reference No. 10, including relevant references in columns 2 and 3.

Under reference No. 10 the Minister proposes a tax of 9d. per cwt. on glazed pipes made wholly or mainly of clay or earthenware, and glazed connections, for pipes of any kind, made wholly or mainly of clay or earthenware. The Minister for Finance told us, when dealing with the Resolution on the Second Schedule on Report, that he knew those were not made here, but this was mainly a revenue-producing tax; there was just this aspect of it, that there were purposes for which glazed pipes were being used at the present time, and for which perhaps glazed pipes need not be used, and he proposed to some extent by this tax to force people to use unglazed pipes where at present they were using glazed ones. He said that this tax, however, was mainly imposed for revenue purposes. It is not easy to see how much this is going to impose, but it may impose anything between £8,000 and £10,000, another of the many burdens upon house building costs which the Minister is imposing under the various proposals in this Finance Bill. Again, the House has to consider whether it is going to stand for the elaborate policy that is being pursued in those regulations of raising every single halfpenny which the Minister can raise by means of import duties on materials which are absolute necessities in connection with the building of houses. There is a considerable amount of housebuilding going on here. A lot of it is more than necessary. There is a considerable amount more to be done, which is even more necessary still. The Parliamentary Secretary has drawn attention to the type of person for whom houses are being provided at the present time——

Comment on this

But not on this Bill.

Comment on this

——the type of person who is not able to pay anything like an economic rent for the houses that are being built, and who day by day is becoming less able to pay the rent that is being charged. This tax must inevitably force higher rents out of those people, or impose higher rates on the ratepayers who are subsidising the building of houses. The Minister for Finance is making his side of the question safe. He is taking back some of the money which he is pretending to spend on houses. Ultimately he is taking this money at the expense of the very poorest class of the community, who will have to pay increased rent.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present. House counted and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

I had just concluded the remarks which I desired to make.

Comment on this

I would like to draw attention to the fact that the Minister is imposing a tariff on a material the trade in connection with which he knows nothing of. As Deputy Briscoe probably is aware, nobody would go into a business house in Dublin and ask for a cwt. or a ton weight of glazed pipes, because he would be laughed at. It is not by weight that these things are dealt with; they are dealt with from the point of view of design and description—bore, glazed or unglazed. On a rough estimate, judging from the items proposed to be taxed by this Bill for revenue purposes, I would say a £700 or £800 house would be increased by £100. Of course, houses of different costings will be put up proportionately. I observe the antics of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance. His little tricks will not deceive anybody and will not draw anybody. It is a very serious matter for people who have to live in this country, have all their interests in this country and have even their banking accounts in this country; it is a very important thing for them to consider where we are drifting.

Comment on this

It is a nice thing to have a bank account, no matter in what country.

Comment on this

When we have one it is time to protect it and not when we have merely a debit there. Perhaps some people have their debits here and their credits elsewhere. So far as I am aware, those articles specified in the Bill are not manufactured here. I would like to know if, when an attempt was made to make those here and to divert the attention of people to the use of substitutes, the architectural profession was consulted. Anyone who knows anything about drainage is aware that the best type of sewer is one with the smallest possible fall that will move. The glazed pipe was not an accident nor is it to be regarded as a superior pipe to do a neat job or anything like that. It was produced definitely to bring about this result, to keep a move on the load with the smallest possible fall. As Deputies can easily appreciate, the smallest fall that can be produced and that will be efficient, the better, and it lightens the cost because every sewer must have a fall from beginning to end or otherwise it must move into some depot where an elaborate and expensive pumping station has to be erected.

An attempt has been made to produce alternatives here in the form of concrete pipes. These concrete pipes, I understand, will require a greater fall and it is questionable if the efficiency will be as good. However, that is immaterial for the men out recklessly looking for money. I do not suggest that the Minister for Finance would do anything reckless, but there are people who, when they are hard up for money, break a bank and get it. I do not suggest the Minister does anything as reckless as that. But this differs from breaking a bank only in degree. The Minister taxes a commodity that is not made here and that is absolutely essential for the public health. It puts up the cost considerably and I have not seen any case made for it. It would be interesting if somebody could make a case for it now. If we have suitable clay here, and I believe we have, it ought to be exploited and the industry should be developed. That should be done by way of bounty until we see if the proper article can be produced.

This is a very serious thing for the sewerage systems that are being installed throughout the country now at a cost of hundreds of thousands of pounds. It is a serious point that we should be rushing out to experiment on those systems, using concrete pipes instead of the earthen pipes that have been used heretofore. All this work is being completed at a great cost with an article that is at present only in its experimental stage. It is a matter for very serious consideration. There are some members of the Corporation here and they are probably aware that the concrete pipe recommended to bring water from the proposed waterworks in the Upper Liffey to Belgarde Reservoir in Clondalkin is not manufactured in this country and the process, I understand, is unknown to engineering in this country except through books. How much more careful must we be when carrying out sewerage systems with concrete pipes that are only in their experimental stage? Four years ago you would not see one of them and now they are dumped everywhere.

We are taxing glazed pipes that have done the job efficiently up to now and we are not making any definite effort to produce pipes here as a substitute for the foreign glazed pipes. As to whether the concrete pipes are durable enough, I am not in a position to say. I am referring now to concrete pipes forming a main deep down under the ground. There is no question, however, that every architect in Ireland will tell you there is only one pipe that will give satisfaction and that is the glazed earthen pipe used for house connections to the main. This is the proposition, to tax that without making provision for Irish glazed pipes.

Comment on this

The Minister told us he knows a lot about pipes but that he was not going to tell us all he knew. I would like if the Minister would tell us if there are sewerage mains being put down in the country at the present time with unglazed pipes?

Comment on this

That query should be addressed in the form of a Parliamentary question to the Minister for Local Government and Public Health.

Comment on this

Is it not a matter of great public importance if sums of money are being spent either from the rates or from the Exchequer in the putting down of sewerage, and is it not important to know whether that is being put down with unglazed pipes? I do not believe for a moment that they are. I believe that the position is as the Minister has indicated—that he is scraping in all the revenue he can and that these taxes are for the purpose of providing revenue. This means taking money off the ratepayers every day of the week. The Government are doing so not only in the matters of household necessaries but in matters of their water schemes and sewerage schemes.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That this be the Third Schedule of the Bill."

Tá 42
·
Níl 25
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 43:—

In Part II to delete reference No. 13 including relevant references in columns 2 and 3.

Another few halfpence have been collected here in increased rents because we are dealing with another imposition on housing. Reference No. 13 imposes a tariff of 10 per cent. on glass of all kinds imported in sheets or strips whether flat or bent or otherwise shaped. The Minister for Finance—he has subsided again into silence—told us when dealing with the Report Stage of the Resolutions embodying the taxes in this Schedule that the imposition of the duty in this Bill is due entirely to revenue considerations. But the Minister has not told us how much he expects to raise the general rents in the country by the imposition of these taxes. I suggest it will be anything from £7,000 to £10,000. The Minister has sat silent while tax after tax has been imposed which increased the cost of house building at a time when both rates and the ordinary revenue are being utilised in a big housing campaign to house the poorer sections of the people. Here again he dips further into the pockets of the ratepayers, who are contributing substantial amounts towards this housing campaign, to help to keep going the miserable and disastrous war policy that is being kept going at present. We have the people becoming less and less able to bear the burden of rents and taxes being saddled with this tax this year with every prospect of its being continued.

Comment on this

We are gradually coming nearer to the end of the litany of the Minister's folly. It is strange how silent an important member of the Dublin Corporation, who sits behind the Minister, is on this important matter. It is putting up the cost of building construction in the aggregate by from 10 to 20 per cent. Whatever opinion I had of the Minister, I never thought he was so reckless. It shows the desperate straits to which he must be reduced when he proposes to tax the light. He has taxed the air, I might say, by making us use inferior sewer pipes, inasmuch as the good air will be polluted by bad drainage. Now he is going to tax the light. It is extraordinary how the Minister thinks he can get away with such reckless taxation. When he, of all men in this country, knows the financial condition with regard to housing, he is putting another load on it. The Minister heard of the Dublin Corporation's housing programme which, as Deputy Briscoe is aware, was enunciated one night in this way: "Why stop at 1,000, why stop at 2,000; why not 10,000 houses per year?" That was before the Deputy and his senior, the Minister for Local Government, thought of supporting a tax on light. The Minister for Finance knows as well as anybody how he has put up the costs by these taxes. He knows what the general public does not know, that all this talk about 5,000 or 10,000 houses per year to be built by the Dublin Corporation has now ended in smoke. I would rather I had not to say this, but it is time that the public should know that there is not a bob now for any new houses, and the Minister knows it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We must keep to glass.

Comment on this

We cannot have houses without glass. I want to relate it in this way. The position is as I have stated and is known to the Minister, because there has been a request from the Dublin Corporation to receive a deputation as to how we will get money to go on.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must not continue on that line.

Comment on this

In face of these circumstances, with no money to go on with, the Minister says: "Building will cost more; I will tax roofing material, drainage material, and cement that is used in the construction of houses."

Comment on this
A Deputy

And putty and copper tubing.

Comment on this

Yes, everything used in the construction of houses. Judging by the way things are going, there will soon be nothing to tax, because the building trade will just sit down. I do not see many of the Government Deputies from the City of Dublin here. We should remember that 2,000 people are earning their living on the Dublin Corporation housing schemes, and there is nothing staring them in the face except the sack in a couple of months. Another 1,000 people are working on housing schemes which are being carried out by private speculators, and they are dribbling out gradually. The Minister knows that, apart from this taxation, they would dribble out because of financial stringency. There is no money to purchase houses. The sources are being dried up.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The relevancy of this is rather obscure to me.

Comment on this

That is because glass is being taxed.

Comment on this

I relate it in this way. We produce articles for sale in a market where there is money. If there is no money in that market and the cost of production is increased we very soon come to the end of our tether. There is no money in the house market now and the Minister knows it. A lot of people are employed in the building trade in Dublin—more than are employed in any other one trade in Dublin. The market for the houses is dwindling because of money stringency, and the cost of constructing houses is going up because of the Minister for Finance poking his nose into that dying trade in order to get revenue out of it. This is nearly the last word in absurdity —to tax glass. Then, of course, he is going to tax the tumbler after that and the glass jug.

Comment on this
A Deputy

And the mugs.

Comment on this

He has all the mugs taxed already. The mug may turn out to be a jug the next time the Minister comes to drink out of it. The proposal on the face of it carries with it its own condemnation, and I do not think it is necessary to add any more except to say that I shall gladly vote against it.

Comment on this

I have often expressed the view, in the course of these discussions, that if the Minister would indulge, as from time to time, in blocks of the Finance Bill, and tell us what was the motive that induced him to bring forward these items for discussion it would save time. We have dealt with most of the big taxes of the savage type upon the articles and necessaries of life that always have, and always will bring in, without any doubt, a certain yield of taxation. Whether they will continue to so yield is a matter for speculation. Apart from these, it is not surprising that the Government should find that they are coming to the end of their resources. But it is surprising that the Minister should scatter through his Budget a series of taxes that will prevent the only industry found here as elsewhere in which the Government can properly intervene, where private enterprise has failed, namely of housing making progress. Governments are endeavouring everywhere in the serious state of unemployment, due mainly to economic barriers and national frontiers, to enter into the project of house building from which private enterprise has just marched out. Private enterprise did not so much march out as that it was thrown out because in the war period people were taken off the building of houses and put on to munitions work. Then there was a dearth of houses; rents had to be raised and Governments had to come to the rescue of those suffering from the rent raising. Private enterprise not being able to assist, Governments in various countries in the world, decided to take a hand. Economists noted this fact that in the building industry private enterprise had handed over the work to the State. In that enterprise the State has worked and successfully worked in most countries. It is the only enterprise in which the State has worked even with a degree of success, in this country.

I need not go into the figures, but the position is, according to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, that out of 21,000 persons employed in May, 1934, it is clear that the house building industry has found employment for 15,000 out of the 17,000 that got new employment in three years. That particular enterprise has been placed beside road-making, one in which State intervention has been attended with success. It should therefore be the duty of the Government, agitated about unemployment, to see that that particular branch of employment would not be blocked or impeded in any way. Yet it is impeded in this Budget. Everything in connection with house building is picked out for taxation. It does seem as if Deputy Corry's philosophy is permeating the whole of the Government financial problem. If you are in a bad way and your main sources are dried up you must go to what the people must of necessity get in order to get assistance. Then you have the other surprise, that the State that wants to give certain subsidies towards house building, with one hand, are collecting with the other hand, and abstracting through taxation, a certain amount of the grant they are giving. This tax can clearly be regarded as one of the impediments to house building. Again I say that point is clear. If you put a big weight of taxation on a particular industry the yield in the long run is bound to disappear. It gives a red light, a sure indication and pointer towards danger. The Minister believes that by abstracting 1d. here and 3d. and 6d. in another place he will be able to hide his failure. But he must realise that the accumulation of the pennies and the threepences put on at one end on particular items are likely to have a pronounced effect in the long run. I do not think the Minister has any other method of relieving unemployment in this country or any method of finding alternative employment for the 15,000 persons out of the 17,000 that the Government has been able to find occupations for in the building trade in the last three years.

The result of this taxation will be that the building industry will display a downward tendency like everything else; it is somewhat peculiar and I think requires an answer. We have a method here where the very lowest level—articles that most communities regard as sacred—are taxed to the fullest. Foodstuffs, necessaries, and things which sustain life are all taxed. Now we get to the shelter for the people which is only one step up and these are taxed. People may live in the open if they get enough food. Even the story books talk of people landed on desert islands and tell us that those people know that if they are able to find food they will be able to do some rough job of housing. We have got to this second step by attaching taxes to what, according to the idea of Deputy Corry, the people must have. The accumulation of these taxes on glass, on pipes, on slates and the rest of it represents the Minister's most facile way of getting himself the amount of money he wants for the coming year. The accumulation of these taxes will have a fatal result and much earlier than he thinks.

Apart from all that, I should think that glass as a subject for taxation would be the last thing that the Minister would tackle. I thought it would be recognised as a national monument. I think it was behind a wall of glass that President de Valera sat when he wanted to do nothing. He wanted to display himself as a man who saw clearly but could do nothing. Is that the position that the Minister for Finance wishes to take up? Glass dulls sound as well as prevents action.

There is a further point. We are going to tax this glass whether in sheets or strips or whether bent or otherwise shaped. Is this clearly for revenue also? A more promising Minister at one time wanted to tax flat sheets of corrugated iron, and announced that he was going to get employment for people in bending this material. I do not know whether the Minister for Finance is going to engage people in bending glass and putting it into shapes other than those in which it was brought in. The Minister has not at all told us what his object is. The calculation is made that about £7,000 will be the yield of this tax. A small mining concession, if the State handled it properly, would bring in at least as much. Indeed, if it was properly handled it might bring in three times that amount. Perhaps the Minister is going to put forward an idea of properly handling this matter. We have got the idea that by abstracting pennies in the form of taxation from breadstuffs, butter, tea, sugar and everything else the multiplication of these pennies will get the Government that promised everything out of its difficulties. And now we have come down to this, that we have to try to stop the rot from going on for another year in order to prevent a spectacular collapse.

Comment on this

There is one point I want to bring out very briefly. It is regarded as one of the signs of a progressive Government that they look after the housing conditions of the poor, and it has been the aim of all Governments in recent times to provide better housing accommodation for the poor. This tax is a retrograde tax. It brings the position back to the position that existed over a century ago when there was a tax on windows. It was regarded as a sign of progressive times when that tax was removed. We are now going to put a tax on windows and thereby reduce the entrances of the light and the air into houses, by means of that tax, so that we are going back, or endeavouring to go back, or leading the way, by this tax to the position that existed some century, or so, ago. It may be that there is another reason for this tax. The Opposition Party have certain premises in this city, and elsewhere, and it is the habit of some of their opponents, supporters of the Government, to throw bricks at these windows as they pass by. We have to buy glass to replace them and we will increase the revenue of the State by that means. That may be the real reason for this tax.

Comment on this

It will cost us £1 a year in North City.

Comment on this
Division

Question put—"That the Fourth Schedule be a Schedule of the Bill."

Tá 43
·
Níl 23
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 44:—

In Part II to delete reference No. 14, including relevant references in columns 2 and 3.

We have seen quite a string of cases in which the Minister proposes to tax nearly everything he could think of which goes into the make-up of houses for the working class. We have seen a string of things, upon which he imposes a tax, which the working man will have to get when he goes into a new home. If the resident in a tenement area in Dublin, about whom the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance spoke so feelingly a short time ago, is transferred to a new Corporation house, and, if reviewing the family chattels, the woman of the house finds that she requires a little bit of new linoleum or a little bit of oilcloth, she will, when she goes to purchase them, find that the Minister for Finance has levied a tax on them. Now, if she wants a few glass runners or a few glass vases, the tax gatherer meets her at the door and says: "You cannot go in here; you cannot make your home the kind of place you think it should be, from the point of view of equipment or furnishing, without paying every tax that has been imposed in the Finance Bill this year. I must get my hand into your pocket again before you can buy a couple of new runners to put on your tables." This is the proposal that is made in this reference under which the Minister proposes to put a tax of 10 per cent. on

"glassware not otherwise liable to duty and not containing any goods at importation which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, is suitable for domestic or household use or ornament."

The house cannot have that little bit of new equipment that the woman of the house requires if she wishes to make the new home the home of her desires, without the Minister's agents waiting at her door to pilfer her pockets of a few pounds or a few shillings.

Comment on this

The Minister still continues his weary way. There are still a few more steps to take. He has now got from the roof through the drainage, and through the windows, to the linoleum and the oilcloth, and he has arrived at the few little articles of glass furniture. The Minister must know how all these enter into the housekeeper's budget if he has a little experience. I shall try to give him some idea of how people in need of houses are circumstanced. A few years ago, the Dublin Corporation had about 500 houses completed for house purchase. Advertisements were inserted in the papers for applicants and there were somewhere about 12,000 applicants. There was some trouble about paying the rents, or the instalments on the house-purchase schemes, and calculations were made which showed that to liquidate the loss to the corporation it would be necessary to clear out those who were not paying and then order a flat rate for new tenement purchasers of £45 per house. The applicants then amounted to 3,000 or 4,000. That was a rough census of people who wanted houses and who were in a financial position to take houses. From experience, we know that there are some thousands of people in and around the city who can afford to put about £100 cash down; but in every case, when you come to close quarters with them, they say: "Well we do not want to get a house and keep it as an empty house. When we go into a new house we want to get some new articles of furniture." One would have thought that these people must have gone round, whispered into the ear of the Minister, and that the Minister must have taken note of their remarks. Of course, he preserved that stoical silence he preserves here. He did not tell them what he was doing it for, but he selected these things to tax. He is now taxing the tumblers and a few odds and ends of ornaments, thus increasing the tenant's outlay by 10 or 20 per cent. It is extraordinary that, when a matter of importance like this is being discussed—the taxation of the household requirements of the people— there is not a solitary Labour Deputy present. With the present trend of things, no power on earth can prevent 2,000 or 3,000 building operatives being thrown out of work in the City of Dublin in the next two or three months. The Minister goes on his weary way taxing building materials from top to bottom of the house, taxing the bit of oilcloth——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We are now dealing with domestic glassware.

Comment on this

He is now taxing glassware. That is as far as we have got yet. Of course the next step will be the wallpaper whether or not it is designed. I think the best comment I can make here is just to stop and let all these things sink in. I hope they will sink in to the vacant Labour Benches.

Comment on this

I would like if, for once, the Minister would break silence and let us know if he is going to appoint an æsthetic adviser to the Revenue Commissioners. It appears to me that will be necessary if he is going to enforce this tax. The Minister is putting a tax on glassware "which is suitable for domestic or household use or ornament." I want to know who is to decide whether the glassware is an ornament or whether it is not. Suppose, for instance, a certain bit of glass comes from Venice, the great glass-blowing centre to-day. So far as I know, no rival is going to be set up to it here. Who is going to decide whether that bit of Venetian glass is ornamental or ugly? Who is going to be the adviser to the Revenue Commissioners in order to decide whether a thing is pretty enough to carry a 10 per cent. tax or ugly enough to be exempt from all duty? That seems to me to be a rather heavy burden to put on the Revenue Commissioners. The Minister, no doubt, considers himself extraordinarily æsthetic. Of course, we all know that he cultivated the mount of Pegasus in the days of his youth, and I suppose he is pursuing the other arts in his more mature years. Will he inform us if he himself is going to give assistance to the Revenue Commissioners, and is to be the infallible judge as to whether a thing is ugly or beautiful. If it is ugly it will be exempt from duty, but if it is beautiful a 10 per cent. tax goes on.

I understand that there is rather the view at the present moment that artistic beauty should be considered in this country; that we do not consider quite sufficiently, or value highly enough, artistic effort and artistic output, but if we are going to tax what is beautiful and let in what is ugly that surely is suggesting that the Minister for Finance will be putting a premium on ugliness and undoing all the work which the æsthetic members of the community are endeavouring to carry out. There seems to me to be another difficulty. This speaks of glass suitable for domestic use or ornament. We discover a little later in the Schedule that amongst the things that are not considered to be of domestic use are glass bottles. No one in an ordinary household is to be allowed to have for domestic purposes any glass bottle, because these come in under reference No. 17. I am very anxious to know what is meant by "domestic or household use or ornament." A rather necessary thing in a household, one would imagine, is a cruet stand which contains bottles. Is not that to be regarded of domestic use?

Comment on this

I am in disagreement with two things that have been said by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. He reads this reference number as calling for some aesthetic judgement on the part of the Revenue Commissioners. I do not agree. The Deputy founded his phrase on the definition: glassware suitable for domestic or household use to which is attached a bit of an ornament. I understand that such things as gargoyles, not remarkable for beauty, are considered to be ornamental, and here we find one of these ornaments on the front bench. Someone spoke of the Minister's stoic silence, but anyone who has read a little history or philosophy must know that the stoics were a rather brave type of people. This is cowardly silence from a man who cannot defend anything. Neither can he get any of his back-benchers to defend this, and so we have these orphan taxes running through. No one in the House will give them their benediction or stand for them.

Comment on this

Would it make any difference if we did?

Comment on this

There has not been a particle of argument for them. The point is that the Deputy cannot speak in this House. The Minister spoke once to-day, and three other members of the House had to come to his assistance because he said the wrong thing.

Comment on this

A vote is more substantial.

Comment on this

And any blockhead can vote. Why glassware, whether ornamental or suitable for domestic use, should be taxed in preference to something else requires some explanation. One would like to hear why these things have been chosen. I thought Deputy Smith was going to break silence again. I am sure he has heard of the heroic type of sentimental novel where the hero and the heroine get lost in the great wide spaces. Nearly all around is silence, and after a bit they think that they alone are alive in a world that is otherwise dead.

Comment on this

And there is one man on the ice floe.

Comment on this

The Minister says that I am the one man on the ice floe. He would not sit so quietly on the ice floe. It might be too uncomfortable. Has the Minister any reasons he can give for these taxes? Why, as Deputy Belton has asked, has he decided to batter in on the whole scheme of house construction? This hits not merely the people engaged in moving into new houses who have to consider such things as the replacement of ordinary domestic ware. It hits particularly the people who are house-hunting, those who are going to set up house for the first time. It is going to eat in on the little, in the way of resources that the activities of the tax-gatherer have left them to spend on equipment. To come back to the definition, it is simply another way of saying that whatever articles the Revenue Commissioners decide to be glass are to be taxed. The phrase used is very comprehensive — any glassware which is not otherwise liable to duty. If otherwise liable to duty, the Revenue Commissioners will have to bring their judgment to bear on it. Something that is a little bit transparent and that anyone recognises as glass will be subject to duty. Something that the Revenue Commissioners will pass as glass, something that one can see directly through, will be subject to this tax. As long as there is some idea of transparency or some possibility of opacity the thing will be classed as glass.

Comment on this

Then clearly it is brass.

Comment on this

The brass Minister is absent, but we have got the dumb one instead to-day. Surely there should be some consideration before piling up this ten per cent. tax on all these items. No doubt, as far as ordinary commodities are concerned, the Budget is a pickpocket Budget, but one would have thought that the Minister would not have been so vigilant in scrounging around small households to see what he could get his hands on. No doubt this Budget was largely inspired by back benchers on the Government side. In preparing his Budget the Minister must have relied very much on them. It is not the Budget of a man living in a middle class way in Dublin. It seems to be inspired rather by someone who knows the interior of the ordinary two-roomed house. Someone who had got a fairly good picture of everything in it, of everything used on the walls and floors, in the rooms and on the dresser in the kitchen. The Corry mind is distinctly evident here again. There is this very comprehensive view: "We will take in everything." Remember, there is no idea of protection in respect of this item. In the speech to which Deputy Mulcahy referred, made here on the 23rd May of this year, we were told that these were revenue tariffs. The idea is that we must get in these pennies, twopences and threepences which we are to pay back to certain people in a certain way, and then we are to describe ourselves as brave fellows, tender-hearted people, for giving these benefits to certain folk. There is an O. Henry story, to which I referred before, of a man who was refused admission to heaven. He saw other people passing. One other person was held up and he excused himself, saying he only took the pennies out of a blind man's tin. He got in as against the other man who had been held up. If the Minister for Finance and the man who took the pennies out of the blind man's tin were running neck for neck for heaven, I believe the fellow who took the pennies out of the blind man's tin would get in.

Comment on this

I move the adjournment of the House for lack of a quorum.

Comment on this