We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1935—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 186–375 of 768. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 15 of 1935 ›

Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot take that Motion.

Comment on this

The Deputy should look up the Standing Orders.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 39
·
Níl 22
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 45:—

In Part II, to delete reference No. 15, including relevant references in columns 2 and 3.

The Minister proposes to impose a 50 per cent. tax on paper, without any matter or design printed thereon. To go no further than the paper used by newspapers, this tax is going to impose a very heavy burden upon them. How much does the Minister for Finance expect to get out of this tax? Does he understand that it can have no other result than the reorganisation of overhead expenses by newspapers and the creation of a considerable amount of unemployment? Has the Minister examined the position with regard to any of the big daily newspapers or any of the weekly newspapers? Has he examined the position as far as the daily newspapers are concerned and what the effect of this tax will be? Does he not understand that it will inevitably bring about a reduction of overhead costs, by way of a reduction in employment? The Government and the rank and file of the Fianna Fáil Party have been attacking newspapers for a long time. In some parts, resolutions have been passed calling for the suppression of some of the local Press. Repeatedly, Ministerial statements and the Government organ have indicated that, but for the anti-national nature of all the daily Press in this country, except the Government organ, there would be an end to the economic war.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has no relation to a tax on paper.

Comment on this

When the Ministry set out to impose a tax of this particular kind, they declared that it was a revenue tax. There are certain attacks on the newspapers. This is a financial attack. It follows a long drawn-out period—I do not know what it would be called—of political attacks.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Neither political attacks on, nor the Government attitude towards newspapers, arise on this amendment.

Comment on this

I should like to hear how much the Minister expects to raise by this tax as a whole, and what part of the money will be raised from newspapers. Does the Minister realise that this is going to bring about a certain amount of unemployment in connection with newspapers?

Comment on this

This is, no doubt, a revenue producing tax, for this reason, that we have a certain amount of paper produced here, and if a tax had been put on paper which is competing with the home-made article there would be sympathy with it. I protested here before, and I protest now, against putting a revenue tax on the raw materials of certain industries. Amongst other things, paper is the raw material for manufacturing stationers. We have got protective tariffs running as high as 75 per cent., and if we are going to go on increasing the cost of everything that a manufacturer has to deal with, we are going to find very soon that protective taxes of 75 per cent. are of no assistance to local manufacturers. I have seen instances where a tax or a tariff as high as 50 per cent. was put on raw material. It will not be very long until that will bring about its own Nemesis. Take the case of a professional photographer who gets an order to execute some postcards. The postcards would be his raw material, and there is no manufacturer of sensitised paper in this country. He imports sensitised postcards from the Continent which bear the one word "postcard," rendering them liable to a duty of 50 per cent. as stationery. How can we go on imposing a tax of 50 per cent. on certain peoples' raw material, without affecting the amount of money that is spent in that industry, and the employment given by it? Is it any wonder that a number of people in this country are wondering why it is that it seems as if we had a back door and a front door and that the Government were putting people into employment through the front door and, as a result of a great many of these tariffs not being properly used, that people are being disemployed through the back door as fast as they are being ushered into employment through the front door?

Comment on this

This tax, I think, includes newsprint. I should like to ask the Minister if he is aware that, as a result of the policy pursued by the Government for the last two or three years, many—I think I may say nearly all—of the newspapers and, particularly, the provincial newspapers, have suffered very material losses. I have been told that some provincial newspapers with a small circulation have suffered a loss in valuable advertisements of anything from £5,000 upwards per year. Even the lower sum of £5,000 is a considerable matter to small concerns. A considerable amount of employment, and very well paid employment, is given by these provincial newspapers. It seems to me that the Minister, in his efforts to get revenue, has imposed these taxes without any regard to what the effects may be on employment in this country. This is, of course, clearly a revenue tax. It does not even purport to be a tax to give revenue to any industrial work. It is merely a revenue tax and is just adding another burden to an industry which has suffered very heavily owing to the actions of the Government in the last two or three years. I know of one or two cases where they have just about managed to carry on with the same staff, in the hope that things might get better, but this impost will mean that they cannot carry on with the same staff. If it means the dismissal of only one man on a small newspaper, that would be a very serious matter. Unfortunately, we do not know what the Minister's hopes or views are in the matter.

Comment on this

This appears to me to be one of the most unpleasant taxes, put on for purely revenue purposes, that we have had. It seems to me that this shows a very considerable ignorance on the part of the Minister as to what is actually happening in this country at the present moment; or else it shows a very deliberate design on the part of the Minister to impede the cultural development of this country. Everybody who knows anything about present conditions in Dublin knows that there are many people who have endeavoured from time to time to establish magazines here which would have a really literary and artistic value, and they have known how desperately hard it is to keep alive in Ireland any magazine with a good literary tone. We know that one paper, which was noted for its extreme literary value, died from want of circulation a few years ago— want of circulation combined with a libel action the expense of which it could not stand.

Comment on this

It must have printed some remarks of Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this

If the Minister is talking about libel actions, I can assure him there are some coming on.

Comment on this

There is a magazine, The Dublin Magazine, which is of the highest literary quality but which, owing to its purely literary appeal, has a very limited circulation —so limited that, I daresay, it is unknown to my friend Deputy Smith, and to my friend Deputy Corry, because of its literary value. I made that remark because I saw the Deputy looking around. I apologise. I forgot. Now, what the Minister wants to do is to make the production of high-class literary magazines more difficult than it is at the present moment, or to make the production of any paper that appeals to a small, if select, circulation, more difficult than it is at the present moment, because he will make the production of that class of paper much more expensive when he has put this particular tax upon its raw material.

There is another angle from which I should like to approach this tax on paper. There is a publishing industry in this country which many persons had hoped would develop. A great number of persons, myself included, had hoped that it would develop, because there is a great deal of literary ability in Ireland and it had been hoped at one time that a publishing industry would ultimately develop considerably in this State. That hope of a publishing industry in this State is being put back and possibly destroyed by the Minister's tax upon the raw material. What chance has a Dublin publisher to compete against an English publisher if the Dublin publisher cannot turn out his book at the same cost of production as an English or American publisher? We know that, at the present moment, books written by Irishmen, books with an enormous circulation, which might have been published in Dublin, are being published at the present moment by English and American publishing firms. Evidently, it is in order to prevent Irish publishing firms from having a fair opportunity of competing with English publishing firms that the Minister is going to tie this mill-stone around their necks and say to them: "You will have to pay duty on the paper which you import—the raw material of the books which you turn out—whereas your English rival, who is able to get Irish writers to publish through him, will be unduly helped by the attitude I am taking up." I wonder if, even amongst his own supporters in Fianna Fáil, there is support for the attitude the Minister is taking up here. I wonder whether this tax, which will have the effect of sending the literary output of Irish writers to the City of London rather than to the City of Dublin for publication, is a policy of which the Fianna Fáil Party entirely approve, or if all members of the Fianna Fáil Party entirely approve of it. If some disapprove of it, I wonder if they disapprove to such an extent that their disapprobation will carry them, dumbly silent, into the lobby to vote against the Minister. I do not ask them to take away the cold chain of silence which has been hanging over them so long. I do not suggest that any single one of them should get up and attack this tax. I do not ask them to do that. After all, in a great moment of prophetic oratory, in a magnificent burst of sublime oratory, a Fianna Fáil Deputy once declared: "Our Party are 77 dumb tombstones." I thought, at that time, that Deputy Beegan was a little extravagant in his imaginative oratory, but I see now that he was not extravagant, but only prophetic. He knew that this discussion upon this Finance Bill would come on, and he knew that the tombstones would all be dumb, even if we have one smiling tombstone opposite. It is a lovely thing to see a tombstone smiling.

Comment on this

What about the kicking cow?

Comment on this

There is another aspect of this matter which also seems to me to be a very serious one. Can certain persons get in stuff under licence which other persons can not? Has the Minister got power to select certain newspapers, let me say, and let the paper that they are going to use come in under licence free of tax——

Comment on this

Before the Deputy goes any further——

Comment on this

With great respect, I am in possession, and I object to the Minister's interruption. I am in possession, and the Minister can only rise to a point of order.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Minister rises to a point of order, the Chair must hear it.

Comment on this

Yes. If the Deputy will refer to the Schedule, he will find that there is no licensing provision.

Comment on this

That is not a point of order. If the Minister wants to speak, if the Minister can speak, if the loud bassoon of the Fianna Fáil band can make a little noise and is not unduly punctured, he can speak after I have finished. If he can speak, I should like to know from him if there is power in the Minister to issue licences.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister quite properly directed the Chair as to the significance of this duty or tax, and to the fact that no licences are involved. The Chair has to be guided by the Minister in such matters.

Comment on this

And the Deputy can see that if he reads the Bill.

Comment on this

If the Chair says there is no licensing power——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair simply accepted the Minister's statement that there is no licensing power.

Comment on this

It is clear from the Bill itself that there is no licensing power.

Comment on this

It is not a bit clear.

Comment on this

Read your brief.

Comment on this

Everything is made entirely clear but the numerous inexplicable statements which we hear from Fianna Fáil. Therefore, I wish to know from the Minister, when he replies, upon what arguments he bases his statement that there is no power to issue licences. This is an extremely bad tax. It is a tax like his other taxes which we had the other night, on prayer books and religious works, when he and his Party were endeavouring as far as they could to prevent the dissemination of religious knowledge in this country. They cannot succeed; they can only make the effort. In this particular tax they are endeavouring to prevent the spread of secular learning in this country also. It seems to me that the effort of the Minister and of the Fianna Fáil Party generally is to lower the whole State to their own intellectual level, so that nobody in this State will be any better or any wiser than the Fianna Fáil Party. If they succeed in that, God help the country.

Comment on this

Write the story of the kicking cow.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

What is the story?

Comment on this

The story of the kicking cow.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That disorderly remark should not have been repeated.

Comment on this

I am sorry I brought the Deputy into disorder. The tax we are speaking about here is a tax on paper without any matter or design printed thereon. I should have thought that the Minister for Finance would have preferred that, if the Fianna Fáil Party should read anything—which God forbid—they should read paper which has nothing printed on it. After all, Sir, that is the raw material of all the silence we have had here for the last couple of days. I cannot imagine the Minister, out of any feelings of humanity or sympathy for his back benchers, deciding that he would prohibit this particular type of paper. However, there is no doubt about it that the questing mind is at work here again, whether the inquisitive mind of Deputy Corry, hunting into all the little kitchens, and deciding to tax everything, or whether that of somebody else with another view, I do not know. Look at the philosophy behind this—get away from the foodstuffs—they are gone. The ordinary houses and the things that go to equip those houses are gone. The Minister is still totting up feverishly, and, after their foolish borrowing and everything else in this Budget, they have not got sufficient to make even a pretence of balancing the Budget. Then the bright idea strikes somebody about breviaries and missals, and there is the bright idea, "we are taxing secular reading; what about taxing non-secular reading?" From that, there flows this idea of taxing paper that has nothing on it. It is a terrible thing to see paper that has nothing on it coming into the country! So paper that has nothing on it, a little sheet of white paper, upon which each of us may write a little line or two—Deputy Corry even included—is not going to be allowed in. Education is bad for certain people, and so we will just have 6d. on it.

Comment on this

You are a living example of it.

Comment on this

A living example of it, and while alive and well I hope I will always be held up to the odious comparison of Deputy Corry—odious from my point of view. We are to have 5 per cent. on paper that has nothing on it. We are going to prevent the dissemination of news. We do not want to appear too completely Boeotian. We do not want to appear thick-witted. We do not want to appear before the world as thick-witted people who do not want to see any print. It is a scandalous thing not to want reading matter, and so we will get a whack at this just as we dipped into the sugar and tea, had a stab at the butter and the loaf, glassware, tumblers and everything else. Last night we said we had put people into the position of not being able to remain in their homes through anxiety on account of the taxes that are walking around them. You drive them out to the taxed pictures. Having driven them back from the taxed pictures, you will not even allow them to have their little bit of reading matter without a tax on it. Paper comes from rags, and that Party has gone to rags.

Comment on this

I asked the Minister if he will tell us how much money he expects to get by this tax, and the Minister is, apparently, prepared to tell us nothing but what is in the Schedule. If any reliance can be placed upon the statisties recently published with regard to the imports of this particular class of paper into the country, the Minister expects to raise about £16,000 on paper brought in here for printing purposes. Does the Minister think that he can take £16,000 out of the newspaper business and out of the publishing business in this country without its bringing about a reduction in the number of persons employed in the country? Does he think that any review of overhead expenses, in the way in which both publishers and newspaper printers will have to review their overhead expenses, is likely to bring about economies to that extent in any other way than by a reduction in staff? If the Minister knows anything about the matter he must realise that a reduction of staff will inevitably follow the imposition of this tax on paper used for printing. The tax that will be raised under the proposal will be considerably greater than that; there is a tax on paper other than printing paper. I wonder has the Minister considered that there are in this country publishers and printers who are competing successfully with printers outside, and has he considered in what way those people are going to find themselves when they have to pay part of this additional tax on paper coming into the country. Are those people going to be allowed any relief? Will they be repaid the taxation where duty has been paid on paper coming into the country, and books upon which printing has taken place are exported out of the country? Will there be a rebate to such firms, and can the Minister assure us that the printers in this country who are competing successfully outside will not be prejudiced by bearing their particular share of this burden? That might involve possible loss of employment, but perhaps the Minister can give us an assurance in that respect. The principal thing that stands out is the fact that there is bound to be a reduction of staff in the printing trade, particularly in the printing of newspapers, if this tax is persisted in. Are we going to get any information?

Comment on this

I have already pointed out that there is a method of procedure in this House for getting information of that sort. There is the method of the parliamentary question.

Comment on this

That means that debates should collapse into parliamentary questions? I take it that is the principle that is asserted.

Comment on this

The House has sufficient experience of what can be done in a matter of parliamentary questions when it refers to industries and when it refers to seizures. The Minister will not choke up this House.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 39
·
Níl 23
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 46 and——

Comment on this

Before you pass from item 15. I want to give notice——

Comment on this

Is the Minister moving on a point of order?

Comment on this

We are discussing this schedule; am I entitled——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is another amendment to the schedule.

Comment on this

It is only that I want to give notice that on Report Stage I will have an amendment to item 15.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 46:—

In Part II, to delete reference No. 16, including relevant references in columns 2 and 3.

As the Minister went along with his Budget statement we were able to check off one, two, three, four, five, six, down to 14 or 15 jokes. We have now passed a fairly long litany of jokes put upon the House and taxes to be put upon various things that people entering new houses will have to pay. I do not know whether there is a sufficient number of jokes to have each of these jokes covered by a laugh. I do not think there were sufficient laughs for the Minister's jokes which ran to 14 or 15. It would require a big laugh to cover item 16, which reads:—

Paper which has a design or pattern printed thereon, and is, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, primarily suitable for use as wallpaper.

That paper is being taxed at 5 per cent. A person leaving a tenement area in the City of Dublin comes to a new house or a new flat on which there has been a considerable subvention granted both by the rates and by the State. That person is going to walk in and see the white walls of the new flat or the new house as if a notice was written on them saying: "You cannot put wallpaper on these walls until you pay a tax to the Minister for Finance." The people who are going to read these notices in future are the people who are most hit by the general circumstances that, in the first place, makes the Minister search every corner of their pockets to take money out of them to keep this Government going. In the second place, these are the class of people who are most hit by the kind of policy the Minister is pursuing. In the matter of housing, and in relation to the people going into the new houses, we have described some of these taxes as brutal and some of them as mean. I do not know how to describe the tax imposed by the Minister in this way except, as I say, by posting up a notice in the new houses to say: "You cannot put wall-paper on these walls until you pay a tax to the Minister for Finance." Will the Minister say how much money he intends to squeeze out of the pockets of these people before he is going to allow them to paper their new walls?

Comment on this

The tax in this item is on "paper which has a design or pattern printed thereon and is, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, primarily suited for use as wall-paper." How is this to prevent Fianna Fáil Deputies running around with this wall-paper, and trying to read it? After all, are you prohibiting them getting blank stuff and making pot hooks and things like that on it? Otherwise they might have this paper scattered around the country covered over with the economies they promised; or they might be driven to the further amusement of trying to work out cross-word puzzles with that wall-paper. Deputy Mulcahy has opened up with a speculation about the walls of the new houses. Perhaps they would be driven to write up on the walls "Up the Republic." I suppose reading these things on the walls would satisfy some of them. I have no doubt "Up the Republic" would satisfy some of them even if they did not get it. There are people who are in the future to go around in hair-shirts; these people will not want wall papers. They will have amusement enough sitting on the floor trying to conceal their irritation with the garments to which they are not accustomed. The irritation produced in that way would not tone in very well with the inspiration produced by the English wall-paper. Again, we might inquire and look around and ask what else is to be taxed? Something that the people want. That is a new way of searching for new taxes.

Comment on this

You always have to tax what the people want.

Comment on this

Yes, tax what they want and the more they want it the more you tax it. That is Deputy Corry's philosophy. I notice that Deputy Donnelly is now joining in that school. Tax the things the people want and the more they want these things the more you are likely to get in the way of a yield from the tax.

Comment on this

What is the alternative?

Comment on this

"Fianna Fáil has scrutinised the Estimates with minute care and they are satisfied that £2,000,000 can be saved without doing injury to any service." Give us the £2,000,000 and then get wall-paper anywhere you like. That is my alternative to Deputy Donnelly. There might be some other way of getting taxes on gold mining, but that is neither here nor there at the moment. There is a desperate philosophy behind Deputy Donnelly's inquiry: "What is the alternative?" The philosophy of the ordinary community is different from that. The ordinary Government says: "We will tax luxuries; we will tax the things that the well-off people will buy." But when you find that the people whom you think have money are not buying certain things and that ordinary revenue is falling, you have to get away from what used to be the strong back to the backs of the multitude. Of course, the more people you have buying certain things, the smaller the tax can be. That gets down to the subsistence level, to the things that people must eat and drink and have about them; the ordinary items of a sort of primitive life—food, drink, and something in the way of shelter. Everybody must have these. They are the things covered by the subsistence allowance in the income tax. Their position is: "We have given a subsistence allowance in the income tax; we have to break that down, but we do not like to say it; we will tax everything, even the man getting two or three pounds a week, and the way to do that is to tax the things on which a man will be spending the subsistence part of his income—bread, butter, sugar, etc."

Comment on this

You get your tax.

Comment on this

I wonder do you in the end. The Deputy approves of that. It is not the civilised theory. It is a theory that most Governments try to get away from. The only Governments brought down to that are Governments that are on the rocks. Eventually, when a Government goes on the rocks the people go on the rocks. Because if you do tax the subsistence level you are trying to wring money out of people who have not got it. You are trying to stop them paying for the things they live on, and trying to make them pay into the Government instead. That breaks down eventually. The ordinary source of revenue that the community used to be able to support itself out of is gone. Deputy Donnelly, apparently, has not merely accepted that, but has deluded himself into believing that this system of taxation is the ideal one—to get after the things the people must buy. Undoubtedly, that is a certain way of getting taxation up to a point, but only up to a point. It breaks down also.

Comment on this

You get the money.

Comment on this

We are getting the money. That is the point. Surely the Deputy has some idea of the way taxation is apportioned. Generally speaking, Governments who are in any way human try to apportion it against the people who are getting most, make them bear the brunt of the taxation. You only move away from that when that source of revenue is gone. Income tax is not yielding what it used to. Ordinary excise duties are not yielding what they used to. People have not money to spend. Therefore, you are going to dig down under the subsistence point, you are getting down to the bread and butter line, or below it; at any rate into it. I am glad the Deputy is trying to make up his mind. I suppose it is the cheeriest thing to do in the circumstances—to say that it is the best thing and not make any apology; not to say, "We would do something else, if it were there to be taxed" but just, "This is the way to get it." In connection with the tax on bread I said I did not know if history showed an example of a tax on this type of ordinarily used article.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That tax has been passed.

Comment on this

Deputy Donnelly drew me into that.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

An interruption by Deputy Donnelly does not put a thing in order.

Comment on this

It is generally the other way about. I consider wall paper to be one of the things ordinarily used. I do not know whether Deputy Donnelly will put me out of order by denying that. Nobody would ordinarily invite a person into a room which had not wall paper on the walls, unless you are going to have some mural decorations to adorn the bare walls. I suppose if we all fly to that there will be a tax on home decoration, and you will not be allowed to draw pictures on the walls of your own residence. At any rate, the Minister will get after it by taxing the wherewithal of the trade. We have got to the point of taxing wall paper—a thing which is ordinarily used. History does not hold any example of the taxation of things ordinarily used except in a period which has been shown to be a prelude to revolution, and revolution caused by the fact that the people have been battered down below the ordinary level of subsistence and there is nothing else to do except in despair to kick over the traces. I do not know whether Deputy Donnelly will regard that as a sign; whether he thinks the old theories of taxation are wrong and that this new one should be accepted.

It is simply a case of what Deputy Donnelly says, "We are going to get the money." We have flying squads belting into the kitchen, grabbing the stuff on the walls, the things on the table and the things on the dresser; the foodstuffs and the things around the people. Everything that goes to raise life from the primitive a little bit, that is what we are going to tax, because that is what the people have to get. But the end is in sight. It is the same as if the Government were forced to bring in an income tax on incomes say of £50, as was done in some countries. But it was only done in countries where they were in desperation. Some countries in the post-war period, suffering from inflation, as a last resort decided to have direct taxation on incomes even of £1 per week, or at any rate £2 per week. If we decided to do that the people would have no difficulty in recognising it as a sign of, "All hands to the pumps." Instead of that they take 10 per cent. here and 5 per cent. somewhere else, in the hope that the people will forget. But the cumulative effect of these will lead in the end to a break down by its own weight and we will be in a worse condition in a year than we are in now.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Donnelly has gone back to his school days. I think that he sat there just considering the days in which, I hope not too painfully, he was compelled to read the Satires of Horace. He might remember, and evidently does remember, the advice which a bad father gave to his son: Make money; make it honestly if you can, but make money. That is precisely the philosophy of Deputy Donnelly and the whole Fianna Fáil Party. Of course, we do not get it in the continuous spoken word, but we get it in the interjections from the courageous men who venture to interject: "Let us tax anyway we like provided we get the money; let it be a just tax or an unjust tax." Justice or injustice has nothing to do with the Fianna Fáil system of taxation.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not think the Deputy was here when I said that a remark or interjection by Deputy Donnelly, who has not interfered otherwise in this debate, on one specific tax, does not put a debate on the taxation system of this Government in order.

Comment on this

If I might say so, I respectfully venture to agree in that ruling. But my argument is completely and entirely relevant, because I say that this tax is an unjust tax, and that the Government have not got a right to impose any unjust taxation.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair was waiting for the Deputy to come to the matter under discussion.

Comment on this

I thought I was relevant the whole time because I submitted this was an unjust tax. The policy of taking money, wherever you can get it, is the policy of the Government. It is a policy of taking it wherever you can get it by just means or unjust means. What is a just tax? It is a tax which does not weigh with undue harshness on any member of the community. An unjust tax is one which weighs with undue harshness upon a class of the community which is least able to bear it. The Government has no right, not merely to impose a tax which weighs with undue harshness upon a section of the community; but it is an immoral action on the part of the Government to impose such a tax. I venture to say that when a tax is in itself obviously, and palpably, unjust it is a matter which must affect the consciences of persons, whether Ministers or otherwise, who introduce unjust taxation or whether members of the Party who vote for it. I say it is a matter of conscience, and they are bound in conscience to make restitution for the amount they raised in unjust taxation.

These are plain, simply unanswerable doctrines of Christian ethics. This is not a doctrine which anybody with elementary knowledge of Christian ethics, or of the doctrine of the Catholic Church, could for one moment venture to contradict.

Comment on this

What has this to do with wallpaper?

Comment on this

This tax is one of the series of taxes that press upon the poorer members of the community and is obviously and patently a tax which is unjust. It is a tax which presses unduly upon the very poor. Everybody is entitled to live in reasonable comfort with the little luxury that their particular state in life provides for them. Every person, whether labouring man or woman, in Dublin or in Cork, or whether agricultural labourer or small farmer, in our country districts is entitled, as of right, to the ordinary means of subsistence and the ordinary decencies of life. These people are entitled to a home which in itself will be pleasant to them and into which they can introduce their friends and visitors. You cannot take a tax like this, segregate it, and say there is to be an extra tax on wall paper and on nothing else. You must take the Budget as a whole. And every particular little straw that you put on is coming nearer and nearer to the fatal straw that will break the camel's back in the shape of the Irish people. This is a tax which will not hit people who are well off to the same extent as it will the working classes. That is patent. But wallpaper is a necessity to one as to the other. You may talk about it from a high æsthetic point of view. Some people may distemper their walls in order that their pictures may be shown off, but the ordinary person with one living-room wants to keep it dry and well-papered, not merely from the artistic sense, but also because he likes his room comfortable and warm. I leave it to the sense of the House, if there is any sense of right in Deputies opposite, and I leave it to the sense of justice of the House, if there is any sense of justice in Deputies opposite, as to whether an accumulated system of taxation of this nature is a just system for the Government to adopt in order to get money. Their policy seems to be to get the money by fair means or by foul, by fair taxes or foul taxes. If that policy is to receive the approbation of the Party opposite I am sorry for the state of consciousness that obtains in that Party.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

After the Minister has taxed every raw material used in the construction of a house, he follows it up when that house has changed hands. Generally, when a new house changes hands, the walls are bare. The Minister, presumably, knew that a woman's taste will not put up with bare walls. She must have them decorated at any cost and, in her enthusiasm in going into a new house she does not mind spending a little more money on it. The Minister, therefore, thought he would put a little more on. I wonder is there any pretence at helping an Irish industry in this? Deputy Dockrell might, perhaps, enlighten the House—he is a more reliable source of information than the Front Bench—as to whether there is any wallpaper made in this country, or is it likely to be a business proposition, in the near or distant future, to manufacture wall-paper here in view of the limited market and the numerous designs of wall-paper there must be. I fancy this is purely a revenue tax and nothing else, just like all the taxes on raw materials used in the construction of houses, and I hope that when the Minister boasts again of all he has done, is doing and will do, for house-building, he will couple with that all he has done, is doing, and will do to soak the people who build houses, buy new houses, or repair old houses, by way of taxation.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That reference No. 1 stands."

Tá 39
·
Níl 25
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

The Minister emphasised with a certain amount of heat that there was no licensing provision that would enable paper to be brought in without the payment of this tariff of 5 per cent. I would ask him whether that statement refers to the whole of the 17 various items that are covered here and if so, has he given any special consideration to reference No. 1, in respect to asphalt and bitumen, and reference No. 5 with regard to starch? Are we to understand that local authorities, in connection with their work on road making, are not to be allowed to import asphalt and bitumen free of this tax and that, therefore, the tax will fall as an additional burden on the rates throughout the country? In the case of reference No. 5, I should like to know if he has given any consideration to the position of the linen industry in the country and if he has taken into consideration the amount of tax on the linen industry that this duty of 3/- per cwt. on starch involves, if the persons who are conducting the linen industry are not going to be allowed to import starch free of duty.

Comment on this

If reference No. 5 relating to starch, has any bearing on the starch factory that is being established, we should like to know it. We are not told if it is a protective duty. If so, it would be interesting and understandable. Some of us would now like to know if there is likely to be any outlet, as a compensation for this tax, for the rapidly accumulating quantities of small potatoes we have or has all this talk of our starch factory been no more than a prelude to a tariff on imported starch? Of course the tax on bitumen and tar of 3d. per cwt., as the previous speaker pointed out, is fairly substantial. It is the thin edge of the wedge and is adopting a very bad principle, the principle of taxing something we want and that is produced here only in very limited quantities. All the trunk roads of the country and the link roads—in fact every road except the very small by-roads—are now being tarred and this is a serious consideration for local authorities. It seems to me that such taxes will gradually bring back to the Exchequer the grants that are being given by the Exchequer and which, it was claimed, have been so generously given by the Exchequer.

I fail to understand also why there should be a tax of 1d. per lb. on grapes. Is that going to be a national crop in this country? Grapes are used in hospitals very largely for invalids. Many healthy people also like grapes but I presume there will be no discrimination as to the people who use them. They are a delicacy used largely by invalids. Very often they are recommended for use by invalids when no other solid food can be recommended. Still 1d. per lb. is going to be put on them. I am not aware of any discrimination as to the value of the grapes. Sometimes grapes are sold at 4d. or 5d. per lb. and the import wholesale price of such grapes must be very small when they can be retailed at that price. 1d. per lb. on such grapes is a very large tariff, especially when we consider that we cannot produce this tariffed product here except more or less as a luxury product in glasshouses. They are certainly never going to be a commercial product in this country. I suppose like all the other commodities that have been taxed they are taxed for revenue purposes and nothing else.

Comment on this

I do not know what principle has been followed in the division of these tariffed commodities into the different Schedules, but I think that this is a Schedule that we can describe as the house Schedule. I do not say that taxes in other Schedules do not fall on houses as well but the variety of taxes embraced in this Schedule are chiefly aimed against houses, against the people in their homes, against the adornment of their homes, against articles that they will have to purchase for simple adornment and practical use. There are, outside these, one or two matters that have been referred to. Deputy Mulcahy and Deputy Belton pointed out that the tax on asphalt and bitumen will mean that the Government are going to get something back out of the grants which they have given to local authorities. Similarly, that portion of the Schedule embracing what I call house taxes, will enable you to withdraw what has been given in the way of subsidy, the subsidy, of course, to be paid eventually by the ratepayer.

Comment on this

It withdraws more than the subsidy.

Comment on this

I have often heard of a dog being fed on its own tail but I never saw a Minister for Finance trying to pull more tail out of the dog in order to give it more feeding stuff. That is what this comes to. It is a ghastly picture. That is what is happening. It is only when one goes through a schedule of this kind, sees the variety of articles that are covered by it, and tries to find the mentality behind it, that the realisation dawns upon one of how completely down at heel the Ministry are. Just now there was a reference to the tax on grapes. I suppose the one place where one sees grapes most frequently is the sick room, the invalid's room. They are regarded as a luxury by some people, but they are not a luxury that most people enjoy. They are a sort of ordinary accompaniment for the sick bedside, the invalid's table. We are going to get our 1d. per lb. off them— 1d. per lb. off the invalid's bedside table. That is what the Minister does.

Comment on this

Most moving!

Comment on this

So the Minister can open his mouth.

Comment on this

The Minister says "Most moving." It is not anything like so full of crocodile tears as the Minister would have bedewed his speech, if he were in opposition. The fact of the matter is that the Minister has been driven to silence. There is not a Deputy of his Party who can stand over any of these taxes. Not even one of them can tell us why it was necessary to delve into the household in the way in which he has done. Are the other taxes so really badly exhausted as to make it necessary to have a grab at the bedside grapes? I do not call that moving at all. I think it is a degrading business—1d. a lb. I do not suppose a national budget was ever so completely composed of scrounging as this. There is the example of the poor man who had to live on the crumbs that dropped from the rich man's table, but here the community is reduced to the position of being asked to give social services on the scrapings of the invalid's room. It is no wonder that a discreet silence is much the best thing. The only justification for that was the justification given by Deputy Donnelly and Deputy Corry—sheer, acute necessity, the fact that we want money despite all that was promised about more and more money. Why should it ever stop flowing? The economies have not come off. They are, therefore, driven to tax these things. Grapes is an item that is full of woe. It is a small thing. It is not going to bring in very much in the way of taxation. It just shows how wide the net is being flung and how desperate the need is of the people who flung it so widely. It is a big thing because it hits socially and, as such, is a retrograde thing.

In connection with housing, the Government are now trying to fill up the gap created by their own activities previously. They say that they are going to give subsidies, but they are going to get some part of the subsidy back. They are spreading the net in such a way that they hope that their activities in that connection will not be noticed. Sometimes there is a certain amount of admiration in the world for the big thief, the gigantic embezzler, the man who indulges in company promotion and wrecks thousands of homes. But for the man who robs a sacristy or takes money out of the blind man's tin, there is nothing but contempt, and it is appalling to think that the Government of a country should be reduced to that level of meanness.

Comment on this

It is strange that the Minister should have remained mute of malice this afternoon.

Comment on this

Not mute of malice. That is a plea of not guilty and he will not make that plea.

Comment on this

It is a pity that the Minister should have left it to Deputy Donnelly to make the admission that the idea underlying these taxes is to get money, to scrape it in any way he can. Of course, that might be all right for a footpad or a burglar, but one would expect that a national Budget would be framed on better principles and with greater consideration for the sources from which money is got and the sufferings that these impositions are going to cause the very poor. The plea has not even been put forward that this money is to be used as a protective tax for industry. In connection with starch, at the moment we have no starch factory in the country. Not many years ago we had a couple. It has been stated that it is proposed to start a factory here soon. The raw material for starch is rice, so that if this factory is ever established there will be a tax of 2/- per cwt. on the raw material required for it. Rice is also an important article of food. Starch is also used largely in other manufacturing industries, in the linen industry, for instance. Rice flour is used largely in the bakery trade. The tax on rice is, therefore, going to add further to the cost of the production of bread. The tax on wallpaper has been referred to. It will hit the poorer classes of the community very severely. They use wallpaper to a much greater extent than the better off people. I know myself that the little cottiers down by the seaboard paper their houses very often.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Has not the House already come to a decision on that?

Comment on this

We are now discussing the schedule.

Comment on this

I protest against this tax on wallpaper, and indeed against all the taxes in this schedule. They will all press very heavily on the poorer classes.

Comment on this

Can we get any reply from the Minister on the question of licences? We pointed out that there is likely to be a reduction of staffs arising out of these impositions.

Comment on this

May I point out that the Deputy is merely wasting time. I have already indicated that there is no licensing provision in this schedule.

Comment on this

The tax on asphalt, bitumen and starch are likely to mean the paying off of persons employed by local authorities on roads, and may seriously prejudice employment in the linen industry in this country.

Comment on this

There is no foundation for that.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That Reference No. 4 stand."

Tá 41
·
Níl 23
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

On the Third Schedule, one would imagine after the items which have been brought forward that it would be utterly impossible to require moneys——

Comment on this

On a point of order, has not this question been disposed of on Section 12?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I want to hear what the Deputy has to say.

Comment on this

I consider that this schedule should not be passed because of the burden it imposes on the buyer of sugar. It puts the final touch to an attack on the purchaser of sugar which began in February, 1934.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I desire to elucidate the position relative to this schedule. If Deputies look at page 1 of the Bill, they will observe that Sections 10 and 11 refer to the imposition of duties in the First Schedule and Second Schedule respectively. These duties are not there specified. Consequently a detailed discussion of these two schedules was quite in order; more particularly owing to the fact that numerous amendments were tabled. If Deputies now turn to Section 12, it will be observed that Section 12 deals specifically with the alteration of the various duties on sugar. The House has decided that Section 12 should stand. Section 12 sets out that the duties shall be as prescribed in Schedule 3. The House has, therefore, decided and in some detail the principle of Schedule 3. The House cannot now canvass that decision without stultifying itself. Therefore, no discussion of the principle arrived at on Section 12 could now arise unless by way of amendment. No amendment has been tabled. That is the position.

Comment on this

If that be so, I shall await an opportunity when we can discuss the schedule with amendments. I shall simply content myself now with voting against the section.

Comment on this

We should be able to discuss all these degrees of polarisation on the schedule.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Discussion on the principle would arise by way of amendment. The House decided that Section 12 and the schedule mentioned should stand, unless Deputies tabled amendments. Explanation of items may, of course, be asked for.

Comment on this

I suggest that it has been the practice of the House, where there has been a lengthy Schedule to discuss details, irrespective of the section passed, in order to get clarification of the details of the Schedule. No one knows the tax when Sugar is of certain degrees of polarisation.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies are not precluded from demanding any explanation or elucidation of that character, but, the principle agreed should not be re-discussed.

Comment on this

A lot of the discussion that has gone on could have been obviated if answers were given, in place of having a completely dumb Minister. I suggest, in order to have the proper point of view, a Deputy has to run over a variety of explanations that might possibly occur, in the hope possibly that he will eventually get light on them. There is no use in asking questions as the debate is conducted.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It seems to the Chair that much of the matter referred to would come within the province of the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

From a certain amount of experience, I suggest that discrimination as to polarisation and the special taxes attached are entirely matters for the Revenue Commissioners, and would also be matters for the Minister for Finance. The Minister for Industry and Commerce would not have anything to do with that. The sugar question was debated before when different rates were attached. Certainly, in my experience, it is a matter for the Revenue Commissioners to put up a recommendation, which went to the Minister for Finance, and then the Minister for Industry and Commerce was asked about it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy's query is in order.

Comment on this

The Deputy's contention is all trash. He knows that there is a basic rate for sugar and that the rest of the Schedule is dependent upon that. The House decided the basic rate and the rest follows.

Comment on this

That is the first attempt at explanation since 10 o'clock. I knew nothing of the sort. Whether I knew it or not this House is the place for giving information. It is not enough that So-and-so knows it. Whether I know it or not, the House does not know it. I did not know that the basic rate determined the matter. I certainly do not know what is the reason for discrimination in the molasses and glucose section. An explanation is required and I would like to have it. I will ask again for information with regard to sugar polarisation.

Comment on this

Apart from the drawbacks, there is a matter of some importance that I wish to refer to. I presume we are dealing with the whole Schedule. Section B deals with the drawback on sugar and molasses in bonded warehouses and which were made exclusively in Saorstát Eireann. If sugar is made from beet, with the bounty, it is much more expensive than imported sugar. It is obvious when imported sugar can be bought for something under £6 a ton, while sugar made here costs £21, that an undue charge will be made in respect of imported sugar for use as ships' stores. It is particularly desirable that we should have an arrangement to get as much goods as possible for that purpose bought in this country. The drawback in that case should amount to the export duty charged upon sugar. No loss will be occasioned the Revenue if such an allowance was made. In connection with the sugar problem it could be arranged that at a particular time, when sugar is available from the beet factories, and when supplies of imported sugar are stopped that the transfer of the sale from one to the other would be immaterial. The point to be noted is that the goods should be bought in this country for ships' stores. At first sight it would seem as if there would be a loss by giving the full Customs duty, rather than the Excise duty, but in practice no loss whatever would occur. It simply means a transfer from imported sugar in bulk to sugar made here. In other words if the Customs duty were allowed, no loss is sustained. We consume all the sugar manufactured here, and whatever sugar is imported comes in at a smaller price. The duty would be charged on that. If the full Customs duty was allowed, that would ensure that purchases would be made here. Purchases in respect of vessels trading from here, as anyone who has been on these vessels knows, are of some importance. It is particularly desirable that ships' stores should be purchased here as largely as possible. If it is known that when ships require sugar, and none is available but sugar made from the beet grown here, if imported sugar was available there would be no loss in doing what I suggest. There will be a gain if they can be persuaded that they will not have to pay £15 as against £6 a ton. There will be a gain to general business as well as in the sale of ships' stores generally. If a bias is likely to arise against purchasing goods at Irish ports then we may lose a great deal more than these regulations would gain.

Comment on this

On the Schedules, I ask the Minister to say how much it adds to the price of sugar to the consumer, over what the cost was in February, 1934. Up to the present, the Minister has done nothing but shake his head when it was pointed out that £980,000 had been added to the sugar bill, by his action in imposing a duty on sugar, since February, 1934.

Comment on this

May I call attention to the fact as you, Sir, have already ruled that the principle of the section cannot be discussed.

Comment on this

No one is discussing it. Will the Minister say what the effect of the Schedule will be, and what interpretation is to be put down for a shake of his head, when Deputies say that £980,000 has been added annually to the cost of sugar bought by consumers over the figures for February, 1934?

Comment on this

The Deputy is one of those who overloads the Order Paper of this House with Parliamentary Questions. He should understand the procedure and appreciate what a Parliamentary Question is intended to do, namely, to elicit information of the sort that he is asking for now. If the Deputy puts down a Parliamentary Question I will provide him with the information.

Comment on this

It is not necessary to put down a Parliamentary Question to know that the increase in the price of sugar, to the extent of a penny a lb., on the amount consumed in this country, means that the people have to pay £980,000 more than they paid a year age. It is a new theory that the Parliamentary Question paper——

Comment on this

I submit, Sir, that this does not arise.

Comment on this

——is intended to stifle discussion of important matters in the House.

Comment on this

The Deputy took great advantage of it, at any rate.

Comment on this

That may be, but the Deputy may not get the advantage of the precise type of answer that should be given to the type of Parliamentary Question put down. If the proper type of answer had been given in the first place, so many questions might not have to be put down.

Comment on this

You get the answer in tabulated form.

Comment on this

The tabulated form gives no information of the type required.

Comment on this

You get the information.

Comment on this

That is what the Parliamentary Question was intended for; but take the number of questions that have been asked about duties, factories, workmen, licences, and so on. No information has been given. Can the Deputy tell me of any occasion upon which information about a licence was given?

Comment on this

Have a look at the Report.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy discussing now? I submit, Sir, that the question of licences is out of order.

Comment on this

I was discussing Parliamentary procedure with Deputy Donnelly who, apparently, was backing what appeared to be a relevant remark by the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

Again, I submit, Sir, that the Deputy is entirely out of order.

Comment on this

I am glad, at any rate, that the Minister for Education is submitting that matter to the Chair, because up to now you have been parading yourselves as the judges of order and good manners in the House. If it were a question of bad manners, the Deputies opposite would certainly qualify.

Comment on this

Ill manners consort more with what the Deputy is familiar with.

Comment on this

More than often I have kept the Minister for Finance in his place by keeping after him on account of his bad manners. At any rate, if the Minister for Education is rather tired of this, I suggest that he should return to the slumber from which he has been, rather unaccountably and, apparently, too early, aroused. In any case, his Department is not under consideration at the moment and he has slumbered on that so long that he might as well continue to slumber on it. With regard to the relevant matters in this schedule, Deputy Mulcahy has asserted here on many occasions—and has got no intelligent reply denying the facts—that since 1934 there is a sum of £980,000 to be collected from sugar. With regard to that sum of £980,000, I want to know how much of it will come from sugar under the different polarisations, from molasses, glucose, and saccharine. Surely, the Minister ought to be able to reply to that without exciting the annoyance of his colleagues.

Comment on this

The answer is "None," because it is all coming from the purchaser.

Comment on this

That is the answer. It is the consumer who will pay, and that is why all this parade of customs duties is so much nonsense, because, in fact, these customs duties, as far as sugar is concerned, are only a farce, since the situation is—and the Minister knows it well—that the way the consumer is going to be fleeced in this matter is a simple enough performance. When there is no competition, the factories or the company can charge what they please, and polarisations and polariscopes are all nonsense, and all this long business, which we are told is founded upon some basic figure, is not worth wasting the paper over which the printing extends, because, in the end, the whole thing relates to taxation of the consumer, on what is a vital necessity, because of the price he will be charged; and that price will be whatever the company decides to make it since there is no competition. I have referred previously to the pennies in the blind man's box. The Minister for Finance used that phrase himself previously in relation to a duty.

Comment on this

I knew the Deputy was not original.

Comment on this

No, I sometimes follow a simple lead. When the Simple Simon of the Party was talking on the occasion to which I have referred, he said that it was like dropping a penny into a blind man's tin in order to make it rattle. The circumstance in which that remark was made was where some benefit was being given to the farming community and it was being taken from another source. In fact, it was in relation to old age pensions. Think of what is happening now. We have now a drop in old age pensions and a tax on practically every necessity of life. If the other was a case of dropping a penny in the tin in order to make it rattle, this is giving the tin a kick, not to make it rattle, but to knock the coppers out.

Comment on this
Division

Question—"That the reference proposed to be deleted, stand"—put.

Tá 38
·
Níl 22
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

On the Fourth Schedule, when the section dealing with this schedule was under discussion, it was understood that the tariff proposed on these raw fruit, apples, pears, plums, cherries, strawberries, raspberries, currants and gooseberries, was for the purpose of helping Irish fruit growers, on the one hand, and Irish farmers, on the other; Irish fruit growers, by protecting a certain type of fruit and Irish farmers——

Comment on this

What is the point of this?

Comment on this

I am looking for information. It was understood that Irish farmers would be helped by putting a tariff on certain fruit——

Comment on this

On a point of order, the relevant section to this schedule is Section 14. That section was before the House, and any information which was wanted could have been asked for then.

Comment on this

It was asked for.

Comment on this

Information is available to us now that was not available then.

Comment on this

The House has already decided that this schedule should stand.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I quite agree that the House has decided that the tax should be imposed, but I am waiting to see what line Deputy Mulcahy is taking.

Comment on this

Are we to be allowed to vote on the Fourth Schedule?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is for the House to decide—not for me.

Comment on this

If there is a division challenged will there be a vote taken? Does it not seem illogical that a vote should be taken on a matter which cannot be discussed?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Oh, no.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy ever heard of a closure?

Comment on this

I have heard of a close person. You have been a very close one lately.

Comment on this

I wish to give reasons why I rather change my mind with regard to this duty on fruit. As I say, we understood that the tariff here was imposed for the purpose of assisting the fruit growers and farmers here—the fruit growers, by putting a tariff on the fruit that they were actually growing here, and the farmers by putting a tariff on particular fruits, giving a preference to oranges. We were anxious to assist the farmers by——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is getting into the realms of the rights and wrongs of what has already been decided on the section.

Comment on this

I want to draw attention to the fact that information is available to us now which, if the Minister for Finance has not some comment to make on it, will mean that we will have to vote against this schedule whereas we allowed the section to pass. It is announced in the Irish Press of this morning that Spanish oranges are quite out of season, and have no juice in them; that the season for Spanish oranges lasts from December to March, inclusive, and do not let anybody sell them to you after that.

Comment on this

Is not this a question of whether we are putting a tax on imported fruit?

Comment on this

No; but why are not oranges in this schedule?

Comment on this

The House has decided that only articles which are in the schedule will be taxed.

Comment on this

Not at all. It has not. Surely, there could have been amendments put down?

Comment on this
A Deputy

But there were not.

Comment on this

But the Minister says that the House has already passed it as it is. I am arguing against that. Clearly it did not.

Comment on this

The House has passed the relevant section.

Comment on this

But the section does not rule that that schedule should be the schedule to the Bill.

Comment on this

The schedule, as passed by the House——

Comment on this

But the Minister's suggestion that the House has precluded all discussion of this by passing the section is absurd.

Comment on this

It would save a lot of time if the Minister would listen to my point, which will not entail a long speech. When we passed the section with reference to this Schedule we understood that what we were doing was protecting home industries. By means of a tariff on other fruit, and a preference to oranges, particularly Spanish oranges, we understood that we were helping the farmers and fruit growers. We are told to-day that you should not let anyone sell you a Spanish orange.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Let me point out to the Deputy that what is in the Irish Press does not affect the Bill, does not affect the discussions in this House.

Comment on this

If we are not going to have the possible advantage of an alternative fruit that we expected to have, then I oppose taxes at this particular rate on the fruits that are there.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Mulcahy realises that it is the principle of the tariff he is discussing.

Comment on this

I suggest that the House might easily have passed the section, referring to a Schedule which did not include oranges, but it might now wish to have oranges included.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

But there is no amendment of that character.

Comment on this

There will be. But I am not on oranges at the moment; I am not dieting. I want to ask a few questions and I will direct them to the second dome of silence who has crept into the House. Why are plums, which include damsons, prunes and greengages, to be taxed at 2d. per lb. between certain dates and only 1d. per lb. on other dates? Do plums always include damsons, prunes and greengages, or is it only in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners that damsons, prunes and greengages are plums? Are we not going to allow anything off for prunes, because they have a certain elocutionary effect when joined with prisms, or will that only be in the season when the 1d. per lb. is on, so that people who are dumb ordinarily will get the use of these articles to enable them to be more vocal and perhaps more intelligible?

I do not know why the delectable cherry should be picked out for the terrible slap of 3d. per lb. when damsons, prunes and greengages are charged only 2d. and, in their best season, go as low as 1d. The same thing will apply to raspberries. Raspberries, I observe, are to include loganberries. It might have saved paper and probably would have been quite as intelligible if cherries, strawberries, raspberries, loganberries and gooseberries were put together instead of being placed in different categories. Is there any real discrimination relating to the dates upon which these particular fruits mature, or is there any particular discrimination based on the time when a competitive article here would come on the market, or is it just again Deputy Donnelly's idea that we want the stuff and here are the goods that will give it to us? Oranges are not on this, and oranges, I think, should be counted. My main appreciation of oranges is derived from attending football matches, and certainly there one would gather that they are the fruit of the democracy. Yet, we will not tax them. We give people something they can apparently wash their faces with instead of eating. It is a sort of dry pulp at this time of the year and it is given as a——

Comment on this

It is not a solace; it is an irritation. You get people at football matches in the autumn and oranges will be hawked around amongst them and they will be sold, these Spanish dried-up skins with really no juice, or the matter that the people like, inside them. There is not a word of explanation given to us about the Schedule. We are not told what is aimed at, how the taxes have been selected, how even the fruits for the taxes have been selected. We are just presented with this on the take-it-or-leave-it principle. Deputy Donnelly's idea is that you cannot leave it, so that you have to take it. It is all getting at what the people enjoy.

Comment on this

What about a duty on crab apples?

Comment on this

Crab apples would certainly be the sort of thing to attract the present Minister for Finance, because it is the fruit young people enjoy and generally get free. Crab apples may not be very good for them. The whole idea of the Budget is to get down as far as you can to what the people commonly use. The Minister has got after those things and imposed harsh taxes. We have an example here again in fruit. All the time we have to leave out the special item of oranges because of our glorious arrangement with Spain. The Spanish Treaty is, apparently, going to rank with the Belgian and German Treaties, and even the Coal-Cattle Pact is going hard to be on the top line—and mind you, it is a hot class when you think of the Coal-Cattle Pact, for rottenness.

Comment on this

I would like to ask if there is any discrimination in connection with these duties on the raw fruit as to what countries they are brought from. In regard to some fruits that we are not permitted to mention, I understand, in view of the ruling of the Chair, it occurs to me that the same situation might arise as has arisen in relation to other fruits, namely, that we might allot certain portions of the year to certain fruits and, having split up the year amongst certain countries, we might then find that a war had broken out in the fruit trade and we would be compelled to buy from each of the combatants in turn fruit at the highest prices, and we might not be able to take advantage of what I might call the world war which might be going on in the fruit trade. I would like to urge upon the Minister not to tie his hands in any way in connection with the fruits that are scheduled here, and to take warning from what has occurred in other sections of the fruit trade, namely, that we may be delivered over to each of the combatants in turn to be charged the highest market prices instead of the world price.

Comment on this
Division

Question—"That Reference No. 8 stands"—put.

Tá 39
·
Níl 21
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

On the Fifth Schedule I would like to ask the Minister what is the amount of increased duty which the tobacco tax is going to bring him in this year?

Comment on this

That is a question that ought to have been asked on the section, Sir.

Comment on this

The Minister gave no explanation of the matter when we were dealing with the section. In view of the enormous duties that have been disclosed since on the poor, particularly on the workingman and on the less well-off section of the community, will the Minister say whether he contemplates modifying this section in any way?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not the Minister who could modify it. The House has already decided on a certain section of the Bill and that cannot be altered at this stage.

Comment on this

It is only just now that the Minister has advised us that in connection with other sections he proposes to introduce amendments on Report Stage. I would now like to ask the Minister if he proposes to introduce amendments which would reduce taxation on tobacco when he comes to the Fifth Schedule.

Comment on this

Wait and see.

Comment on this

We want before it is too late to get some explanation of this particular matter. I understand that there is nobody precluded from bringing in an amendment, on the Report Stage, to reduce taxation. I am aware that it is only the Minister could bring in an amendment on the Report Stage to increase it, but any Deputy can bring in an amendment to reduce it. There is nothing to preclude him from doing so.

Comment on this

No amendment will be brought in to reduce the amount.

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy's question was asked with a view to getting a statement from the Minister as to whether he would bring in an amendment to reduce this taxation. I understood you, Sir, to say that since the House had taken a decision on the question that it could not now be altered. I would like to submit that on the Report Stage——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I did not say what the Deputy says he understood me to say. I did not say that an amendment could not be brought in and have the thing altered on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Well, therefore, the question as to whether an amendment could be proposed on Report Stage was in order.

Comment on this

I have given the House due notice of any amendments I propose to introduce.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot discuss whether an amendment can be introduced now or on the Report Stage. I am only on the matter of order in connection with what is being discussed at present.

Comment on this

It is clear from what you said that, as we are at this moment, an amendment can be introduced on the Report Stage for increasing or decreasing. The Minister tells us now, as a sort of third removed answer to what Deputy Mulcahy asked, that he has already given full indication to the House. That bright moment in which he gave full indication of anything to the House should be remembered. The Minister also makes the excuse when asked about the amount of extra money to be derived from the people through this, that that should have been asked on the section. I suggest that that should have been mentioned by the Minister as an appropriate matter on the section. Again, we have this peculiar viewpoint, that what the Minister has to do is to come in here slapping on tariffs, duties and taxes, and not even saying what the aim is, in the sense of protection or benefit to the community, or what the effect is. The Minister apparently thinks that all these matters should have been got out of him by the laborious process of parliamentary question or that he is entitled to sing dumb until he is asked.

Comment on this

All the information that has been asked for from me on this stage of the Bill was given in my Budget statement and is available to any Deputy.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Minister has begun to recognise a point of order when he sees one. But I suggest that that type of thing never was a point of order. It is not either cute or anything else to deal with this matter in this way. There is this very vital matter of the tax upon tobacco, which has come to be regarded by economists as a sort of necessity in certain walks of life, and the Minister simply sits here and will not indicate what he means by it. The Minister I know did tell us generally in his Budget speech that he was driven to desperation and simply had to get money. This is Deputy Donnelly's advice again. Here was something the people were going to use and to continue using and he would get a bit extra. As he is not putting it on bread, we ought, I suppose, to feel some way relieved. The Minister, at any rate, did interfere with the tobacco business early, with disastrous results. He is now interfering later, with still more disastrous results, and the intelligent Deputies in the background are asked to vote on this without knowing what the impact of it means.

Comment on this

Is this in order?

Comment on this

It is finished anyway.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 39
·
Níl 20
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

What does it mean?

Comment on this

The only alteration it effects in the duty on boots and shoes is to include children's boots and shoes. It was done by Emergency Order some time ago, and this Bill confirms the Emergency Order, extending the duty on boots and shoes to children's boots and shoes.

Comment on this

And I suppose the reasons given then operate now?

Comment on this

Oh, yes.

Comment on this

What were they?

Comment on this