Finance Bill, 1935—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 376–570 of 768. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
No. 15 of 1935 ›
Would the Minister tell us in connection with reference No. 5:
Boots made wholly or mainly of rubber, rubber-proofed material, rubber-coated material, or a combination of two or more of those materials.
whether any of these boots are being manufactured here at the present moment?
Comment on this
Is the purpose of this simply to keep out supplies and to prevent forestalling or is the Minister satisfied that the new factory will be able to compete on the basis of this tax of 2/- per boot or 4/- per pair?
Comment on this
The duty upon rubber boots and plimsolls was imposed in order to discourage their importation. They were coming in in huge quantities in 1932-33, to the detriment of our existing boot industry, and the duty was imposed to discourage that importation. They are also subject to quota restriction, and the quota restriction is in operation at the present time.
Comment on this
Could the Minister give us any information as to what is likely to be the difference in price between boots manufactured here, when they are manufactured here, and the imported article? This tax amounts, if I mistake not, to 2/- per boot on a boot the overall length of which is nine inches. As a rule, I think taxation imposed on boots and shoes is imposed on the pair and that represents 4/- in this case. Surely it is not likely that that——
Comment on this
May I interrupt the Deputy? A corresponding duty of exactly the same amount was imposed in Great Britain in 1933 in order to keep out the Japanese footwear which was coming in to Great Britain in large quantities at that time. It was feared, and rightly feared, that a large consignment of boots and shoes, which had been printed in England, with English lettering and descriptions on the boxes and intended for the British market, would be diverted into this country and, in fact, a considerable quantity was so diverted, before we imposed a duty corresponding to the British duty.
Comment on this
The Japanese are exceptional in that respect. Their prices are lower. There is no preferential duty in this case for British manufactured goods?
Comment on this
I presume that some English manufacturer of rubber boots will come in here, and it is in respect of those that I should like the Minister to tell us what is the figure necessary in order to compete with the boots which he expects to have manufactured here.
Comment on this
We anticipate that rubber boots and plimsolls, that is, canvas and rubber shoes, will be manufactured here at prices which will be slightly higher than the corresponding British prices, but not substantially higher.
Comment on this
The main reason for the increase is the larger output in the British factories as compared with the smaller output here?
Comment on this
Is he satisfied that, so far as the rubber boots to be manufactured here are concerned, the quality will be as good as the quality of the British shoes, allowing for the small increase in price?
Comment on this
This putting of a tax of 4/- a pair on rubber boots is not a protection for rubber boots, but primarily intended as protection for boots?
Comment on this
This tax of 2/- per boot or 4/- per pair will probably operate similarly to the 6d. tax we had last night on the other alleged Japanese products coming in here. In that case the Minister had a choice of 50 per cent., or 3d. or 6d., as the case might be. Here it is a mere lump sum. Has he any indication of what that comes to on an average rubber boot coming, not from Japan, but from England? Last night we got a figure of 2/- per dozen in the case of knives, and 50 per cent. on that, from the Minister's point of view, would be no use. Therefore, he adopted, in that particular case, the full tax of 1/- to get over that particular very low product. At the same time he had the 50 per cent. What does this 4/- a pair amount to?
Comment on this
It has stopped imports of rubber boots entirely. The rubber boot which was being imported was one which competed particularly with the type of boot being made in the early stages here—the heavy farmer's boot intended for heavy wear. The imported boot was somewhat similar in character and was in competition with that particular type of boot. The 2/- per boot tax has stopped the importation of them.
Comment on this
This is an interesting sidelight on the tariff business, that when you tax an article you have to watch that you also tax anything which an unfortunate man might be driven to as a substitute for the tariffed article. You have to go down the long chain of possible substitutes.
Comment on this
I am sure, and if we pressed the Minister hard enough he would tell us that arrangements were being made to export some of them from here.
Comment on this
The Minister's speeches on tariffs are like an ordinary Greek chorus in a play—everyone will fit any tariff——
Comment on this
When they are made here in October, we will find them being given away with a calf-skin or something like that. At any rate, the situation is that you tax something and you raise its price. The individual who is taxed in that way, and who cannot pay the tax flies to a substitute, and then you tax the substitute, and the one person who does not count in it all is the consumer. If we had tariffs debated here in any sort of decent economic philosophy, we would be told what is the amount of employment given; what is the increased purchasing power that is going to be scattered through the community, through the employment of workers in the manufacture of these goods, so that we could see what is the lift of the burden from the shoulders of the community, in return for the burden that is being put upon them by making them buy things at a higher price than they used to pay.
Comment on this
The Deputy surely appreciates that the only change that is being effected by the duty that is now being ratified is to include children's boots.
Comment on this
The Minister has a happy knack of saying that because he thinks something which he has done previously is all right, therefore, something which makes no change in it is equally all right. The Minister has heard the growlings and the wailings of the absent Labour Deputies at the increased cost put upon them by certain things when they adverted rather critically to the fact that a wage fund which was increased by £25,000 in a £4,000,000 tot, is not a very big return for the burden the community is bearing.
Comment on this
The discussion has been entered on, and I thought I was going to get as much rope as anybody else.
Comment on this
We are asked to accept these duties because there is no change and because they were put on before. We are told that Plimsol is going to be manufactured here in October by the Dunlop people, and we were told, just as we were told previously about Dunlops, that they will be under the control of the Prices Commission. I presume that is the only check we have—what the Prices Commission does. I do not know what the number of complaints received by the Prices Commission has been, but the Prices Commission have operated only once— in relation to profiteering by coal hawkers.
Comment on this
Do I understand the Minister to say that this means an increased tax on boots? I think I did.
Comment on this
It strikes me at any rate that we have a new tax here on rubber boots and to a certain extent on other boots. While we are making these boots here, I am not sure that we are making the finer quality boots to any extent and these will be dearer for many people. At the moment we are paying duty on uppers made of leather or skin to the extent of 30 per cent. of the value of the article. At the same time we are sending skins out of the country for nothing and paying a bounty to get them out. Possibly the fact is that we are paying a duty on these skins when we get them back in the shape of uppers for boots. That is a policy, of which those of us engaged in the agricultural industry are rather suspicious because the raw material for some of these boots is being exported——
Comment on this
This Schedule adds an additional duty to imported boots. We want to be sure that that duty is not being put on the raw material that originated in this country. Even though the Minister said that the additional cost of these rubber boots will be small, no matter what amount it is, those who are engaged in agriculture will certainly object to it and vote against it. I do not care if it is only a penny per boot. Our capacity to buy any kind of boots has been limited tremendously and this is not the time to add to the cost of boots or shoes. I hope the Deputies will vote against this Schedule. I am not prepared to stand for an increase of even a penny or twopence on boots, not to mention 6d. per boot.
Comment on this
That means that the Deputy will be glad to know that the price has gone down since 1931.
Comment on this
This is not going to make them cheaper. This is going to mean an increased duty of 30 per cent.
Comment on this
With all respect Section 22 does not decide it. Section 22 is merely declaratory. The Schedule might be rejected or amended.
Comment on this
I am not opposing an amendment of this Schedule; in fact I am determined to vote against it. The Minister can amend it as far as I am concerned.
Comment on this
Is it not possible to discuss an amendment of the Schedule, even though we have not certain amendments down to it? Can we not suggest certain amendments which the Minister might make between this and the Report Stage? We could not have done it on Section 22. The only place at which we could make a suggestion of that kind is on this Schedule. We surely are at liberty to make suggestions to the Minister to change the schedule between now and the Report Stage. I have heard again and again, on the Committee Stage of various Bills, suggestions made to make certain changes in the Schedule. I suggest that is in order now.
Comment on this
The Minister has made what is to my mind a bit of a startling admission in perhaps one of his unguarded moments. What I gathered from the Minister was this: there has been a fall in world prices. The producer in this country, especially the agricultural producer, feels the effect of the fall in world prices as far as it affects the products which he himself is selling, but when it comes to a question of buying manufactured articles the Minister says: "Oh you have no right to complain; it is true that the price of what you are selling is falling but I shall take right good care that you do not get any advantage that comes from a falling market in the things you are going to buy." That seems to me to be a most unjust way of looking at the matter. The Minister takes one particular year, any year he likes, and he is going to keep the price that prevailed in that year in his mind for all his period of office. The result will be that he will maintain by tariffs a price which has become artificial, and he will say: "In the year 1932 you were paying just as much for it. It is true that if you went out of this country you could buy it 50 per cent. less, but you are not going to buy boots or any other article in this country cheaper than they were in 1932." I am glad that the Minister has made that perfectly plain to us. I am glad that the people may know that while they may suffer from falling markets, in anything they may have to sell, the unfortunate producers will not be able to get any advantage from that falling market in the commodities that they have to purchase.
Another remark which the Minister made also struck me as rather strange. So far as I understood the Minister, speaking previously on the production of boots generally, I understood him to say that there was one part of the trade in which the boot producers of this country were able to meet their rivals on equal terms and that was the manufacture of heavy boots, especially farm boots. Unless I have misunderstood many speeches made by the Minister that was his point of view, but to-day he tells us that the home market for strong boots has become too high priced for the agricultural community to continue to buy leather-soled boots.
Comment on this
If so, what does the Minister mean by telling us that the rubber soled boots have driven the leather boots out of the market. That is what I understood the Minister to say. I cannot understand the Minister's present position. If heavy boots are being driven out of the market, why are more of them being sold than ever before? It is very difficult to reconcile two completely opposite points of view, and it seems to me that is what the Minister is asking the House to do. Without coming to our assistance, he is setting us an extraordinary task, namely, to make two absolutely irreconcilable things reconcilable. If his earlier statement, as distinguished from his later statement, is to be taken as correct, and if heavy boots are being driven out of the market by rubber soled boots, then that must be due, if I am to accept anything that he has said as being accurate, to the fact that the purchasing power of the farming community has fallen to such an extent that they are unable to buy the better class article. Everyone knows that for the farming community the leather soled boot is ever so much a better article than the rubber soled boot. Anyone who has ever walked through a grass field, or who has played golf, knows well the advantage of the leather soled boot compared to the other. We all know how difficult it is to walk in the streets of Dublin on a muddy day in a crepe soled shoe. Of what use would a rubber soled boot be to a ploughman or a man digging with a spade? Of course, he would not wear such a boot if it was possible for him at all to get a leather soled boot. I would like very much if the Minister would enlighten my ignorance. I am always anxious to hear the words of wisdom and of illumination that fall from him. Will he tell the House why the very best article that the Irish boot manufacturer can produce is being driven out of the market by a second rate article?
Comment on this
I invite the Deputies opposite to vote against the Schedule, and I will be very disappointed if they do not. I notice that they forget it very quickly whenever they take action of that kind, because, whenever there is an official opening of a boot factory, they are all there on the band wagon leading the procession, indicating their joy at the new development. When the two new boot factories are opened in Kerry, I am certain that Deputy O'Sullivan will be there just as Deputy Cosgrave will be at the opening of the new factory in Cork. They will be all there on the band wagon beating the drum.
Comment on this
The Minister, I think, did indicate that the real alteration in this tax relates entirely to children's boots and shoes. On that basis I ask the House to reject the Schedule. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney talked about heavy farmer's boots, heavy Government Front Benchers' boots, shoes for playing golf and all the rest. The point that I want to emphasise is that this tax will punish most those who have to dress their children in canvas shoes and rubber boots which can be cheaply got at present. These are the people who are being taxed, and not the man behind the plough or the spade, or the gentleman playing golf. At present, as I have said, these canvas shoes and rubber boots can be got cheaply. The Minister tells us that they will not be produced in this country until October and even then, he says, he cannot guarantee that they will be available at a price equal to that at which they can be obtained at present. It is the poor who are being hit by this tax, and particularly the poor who live in the towns and cities. Even country children will not suffer so much as these city children, because the country children develop hard skins—like Ministers—on their feet.
Comment on this
This effects no change in the present position in respect to boots. There has been no change in the past two years.
Comment on this
It affects the price of these articles. The Minister said that it would not change the price beyond what it was in 1932.
Comment on this
I did not say that it did, but why should a duty be on them? Five years ago I raised this question of a duty on canvas shoes.
Comment on this
The Deputy could not have done that, because there was no duty on them five years ago.
Comment on this
I raised the matter of sizes. There was such a duty, and it was then extended to include boots and shoes for children. First of all there was a duty on sizes—sizes 5 and 6—and later that duty was extended down to the smaller sizes.
Comment on this
What this means is that the children who want boots and shoes most are being taxed. It is really an extension of what Deputy Mulcahy said this evening.
Comment on this
I am pointing out to the Deputy that the matter he is dealing with should have been raised on the section.
Comment on this
I submit that I am advancing reasons as to why the House should not accept the Schedule.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows that the section gives power to impose certain tariffs on certain classes of boots and shoes as mentioned in the Schedule. The House is now discussing the Schedule, but what the Deputy is discussing has already been decided on the section.
Comment on this
If that is so, then, may I say it with respect, the putting of the Schedule is either an insult to the House or an insult to the Chair.
Comment on this
It is not an insult either to the House or to the Chair. Section 22 gave certain power with reference to the imposition of a tariff on boots, shoes, etc., and that was passed by the House. To re-open that matter on the Schedule is not regular or in order. I have allowed several Deputies to go a good distance, but to go into the merits of what has already been decided is not in order.
Comment on this
The Deputy is raising what has already been decided on the section. Deputy McGilligan knows that as well as I do, and so does Deputy O'Sullivan.
Comment on this
May I put to the House a single argument as to why that Schedule should not be passed? If I may, why is that allowed? Why should I be able to do that when the Leas-Cheann Comhairle tells me that the whole thing is ruled by the section to which the Schedule has reference?
Comment on this
I submit that the Dáil has clearly decided that the Sixth Schedule to this Bill shall operate.
Comment on this
My point is that, according to the procedure we have adopted up to now, the House votes whether this Schedule is to be a part of the Bill or not. Is not that so?
Comment on this
The section sets out certain things which may be done in respect of certain items mentioned in the Schedule. Obviously, we cannot reopen what we decided on the section.
Comment on this
It is not for the Chair to say what can be discussed. It is for the Chair to intervene when the rules of order are being contravened.
Comment on this
I am sorry if I broke any rule of order. I feel that I have not done so. I am simply putting to the House a reason why it should not accept the Schedule.
Comment on this
That is to say that a matter decided by Section 22 should be reopened and the decision of this House reviewed.
Comment on this
If the Schedule has already been passed, as I understood the Minister to contend, what is the sense of having a vote upon it?
Comment on this
My point is that we cannot possibly be asked to vote upon anything in the Bill which we are precluded from discussing. If the rules of order preclude us from discussing the Schedule, the same rules of order are bound to preclude us from voting on the Schedule.
Comment on this
Deputy Gearóid O'Sullivan was traversing what has already been decided—the principle as to whether there should be a tariff on a certain type of boot or shoe or not. A decision had already been taken on that matter by the House.
Comment on this
I was not going to discuss the question whether there should be a tax on a certain type of shoe or not. But surely if I object to a tax of 6d. per shoe, for example, I am entitled to show cause why this House should not accept the Schedule even in the absence of an amendment?
Comment on this
If we cannot discuss the Schedule as a whole, we cannot discuss an amendment to it. If the Schedule has been already passed, we cannot amend it. We cannot amend a thing which has been passed, and I understood you to say that we could.
Comment on this
The Chair must not be misrepresented in that fashion. The Chair did not say that the Schedule had been passed.
Comment on this
I submit that the passing of Section 22 has no reference whatever to the Schedule. Quite a number of these taxes in the Schedules come under one of two, or both of two, headings. A tariff is either intended to help in the manufacture of goods here or as a means of getting in revenue. It was stated here to-day—I was not here at the time—that in one case it was partly one and partly the other. That is reminiscent of a question put in the police courts on one occasion by the magistrate: "Was the man drunk?" The answer was: "Partly, your worship.""What part of him?" asked the magistrate. In this case, we have elicited from the Minister that these goods are to be manufactured in this country. I am prepared to accept that. I am prepared further to say that, from my experience of the firm mentioned, the goods will be well made. They are in a position to compete with any firm in England. What I am not satisfied about is that, during the period that will elapse between now and the time of manufacture in this country, the people should be saddled with a price beyond the needs of the moment. A tax of 2/- per boot is not required in this case. The Minister's own statement is that what would be required would be the difference of cost in manufacturing for 45,000,000 people and manufacturing for 3,000,000 people. That is not 2/- per boot. This is an unreasonable tax because it falls more heavily on the section of the community less able to bear it than on the other section of the community.
The Minister was rather unfortunate in his remarks about attending the opening of factories. I do not know if anybody has attended these functions as often as the Minister. During our period of office, the expansion of industrial employment was probably 20 times what it has been in the Minister's period and he has probably attended 20 times as many functions as I attended. If he wants figures as to that matter, he will find them in the statistical return. That continuous employment, which was particularly noticeable from 1927 to 1931 or 1932, was possible by reason of the care taken in the imposition of tariffs. This particular imposition is unreasonable. It is more than a tariff; it is a tax. While the Dáil may have committed itself to accepting some proposals in respect of this matter, the Dáil has not committed itself yet to this imposition of 2/- per boot. It is a sum beyond the need and beyond what is necessary to give the factory its opportunity. I know more about the factory and its history than the Minister does. I was using their products before the Minister was born and I found them satisfactory. There has been an improvement in quality during the past few years far beyond anything the users ever contemplated. Their tyres run two or three times the length of time they used to run a few years ago. That is not a character they require from me. Their goods provide it in their quality. If that factory undertakes the work this tariff is unnecessary. If it is imposed before they undertake manufacture here, it will place an undue burden on the people and, therefore, I oppose it.
Comment on this
We cannot escape one fact, that we are asking the House to put on a tax that was not there already. I do not want to go back to Section 22, which deals with the principle of the amendment concerning the duty on boots and shoes. I would like the Minister to state if he is satisfied his Party will support him in taxing the boots and shoes of the children of the poorest people, when they know that it will increase the cost. I do not know whether the Minister says yes or no to that.
Comment on this
I take it that the Minister says this is an extension of the tariff on boots and shoes.
Comment on this
Those who want most shoes. We are told by the Minister that prices will not be increased.
Comment on this
I could not say that. There are various qualities. Quality for quality, the price here is not higher than in Great Britain.
Comment on this
On the question whether the House ought to accept this Schedule or not, the Minister has given one sufficient reason against it. I want the Minister the next time he goes on the band wagon to one of these factories and makes a speech, to say. "I will not congratulate you on the magnificent work you have done." Here is the test. There was a time when the people wore an agricultural boot for which they were charged certain prices. The people are drifting away from the heavy soled leather boot to the unsuitable article with a rubber sole.
Comment on this
That is much more unsuitable for digging with a spade, and is very unhealthy. The Minister ought to state, the next time he is on the band wagon—and it is the greatest criterion of the work of these factories —that there was a period in which the people went away from the agricultural boot to which they were accustomed, which the factories here produced and in which there ought to be a good trade, because it was the heavy end of the trade. There was then no question of wearing boots with finer uppers. The Minister could say: "That is the criterion on which I award the palm but, in some way, you drove the people away from using an agricultural boot to the unhealthy rubber boot."
Comment on this
Possibly not. That is the situation here, with protection, machinery, equipment, and with the tradition of the boot factories that developed mainly with the agricultural boot. All the Minister can say is that they broke away from that. I suggest that the question of very much cheaper rubber boots would not be weighed in the balance if the people got the old type of leather agricultural boot at the old price.
Comment on this
That is what the Minister says, that in fact agriculturists have been offered these boots cheaper than ever. They were accustomed to those boots and valued them, yet they went to rubber boots and we have to put 2/- a boot on them to keep them out. I would not like to be the manufacturer who would have that said to me in an after lunch oration by the Minister. I would not like to have to listen to that type of phrase. At any rate, the Minister has shown the standard price in certain years. Arising out of boots and shoes, can the Minister take this as a test? The next time there are industrial exhibits in the Industrial Hall he might ask people who make a display there to put above their boots the tariffs they are now enjoying, the number of workers employed before the tariffs went on, and the number now employed, with the increased purchasing power. Say that wages came to £25,000 or £3,000,000 or £4,000,000, that would give the populace something by which they could judge whether the tariff is good or not. They could look on the prices they are being charged and they could see the wages paid now, with the tariff, to let them get a grip of the industry. Until you get that you do not know any proper standard. The increased wages would be a criterion. This ought to be voted against, from the angle of the introduction of the duty, especially as it is no answer to critics to say that the tax has been on already. Most of these taxes were rushed as emergency imposition duties.
Comment on this
They were put through the way this is being put through. Can anyone say that this Finance Act has been discussed properly?
Comment on this
I think it has been rushed. You can associate a different rate of speed with a light, fast-starting car to the heavy, lumbering sort of vehicle. No one can say that this and the attached clauses have been discussed, or that information was given about the taxes that are being put on, that is required, for their proper discussion.
Comment on this
Question—"That progress be reported on the Committee Stage of the Finance Bill"—put.
Do you agree with this result?
Because we had already put them on at a higher rate—except one. We are taking the duty off certain studs and cuff-links.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 47, standing in Deputy Mulcahy's name:—
In Part I, to delete reference No. 1, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 and 4.
As far as I understand this, from the explanatory statement, the effect of it is that a duty had previously been imposed at the rate of 20 per cent. ad valorem, which, in October, 1932. was raised to 37½ per cent., with a preferential rate of 25 per cent., and that the present provision is to increase the rate of duty on harness leather to 40 per cent.—a flat rate. The situation, apparently, is that the preference rating was the rating that ruled, which was 25 per cent., and that that has been increased to 40 per cent. Of course, anything before that was at 37½ per cent., and we have not been given any reason why this duty on harness should be increased. I do not know whether any explanation is going to be given, but I move the amendment in the hope of a reason being given.
Comment on this
The main reason of the duty is for administrative convenience. All the leather duties are being arranged on the basis of a flat rate of 40 per cent., for the purpose of convenience in the administration of these duties. There is, in fact, practically no importation of harness at the present time, and there are sufficient firms in this country to meet all our requirements. They are, in fact, meeting all our requirements at the moment. Since there was a question of a varying duty on straps and so on, it was thought better, for the sake of administrative convenience, to have a flat rate.
Comment on this
I do not follow the Minister's argument. He seems to be striving after symmetry in this matter, chiefly. No doubt, symmetry is a good thing to have, but I do not think it is the one thing to look to. I think that the Minister should aim rather at efficiency than at symmetry. The Minister now tells us that the reason for this is not because there is any need of it, but merely that it looks more symmetrical and more in keeping with all the other taxes on leather. His argument seems to be that, since there is a tax of 40 per cent. on a leather strap used in harness, therefore there ought to be a tax of 40 per cent. on a collar. Now I must frankly confess that that is an argument I did not follow at all.
Comment on this
It was what I understood. I am afraid that the gift of lucidity of expression which used to be characteristic of the Minister for Industry and Commerce is suddenly beginning to desert him, because it appeared to me that he was speaking very lucidly and very clearly when I understood him to say that as there was a duty of 40 per cent. on straps it would be very improper if there was not a nice levelling up of that; because there is a duty of 40 per cent. on straps, there is to be a duty of 40 per cent on everything else.
Comment on this
There is a duty of 40 per cent. on straps other than straps forming part of a harness, and it is desirable, in order to prevent evasion, to have 40 per cent. on the rest.
Comment on this
The Minister did not say that before. What is the use of quibbling and being nonsensical?
Comment on this
As a matter of fact the Minister is not doing himself justice. He can really make himself quite intelligent when he wants to, but I still do not quite understand his argument. A strap that goes round a portmanteau bears 40 per cent.; a strap on harness bears 40 per cent., and, therefore, because a strap on harness bears 40 per cent., a straddle or collar must bear 40 per cent. That is a thing I do not understand. Of course, the harness trade is naturally a decaying trade. As far as I know, the number of harness makers in this country is very reduced. There used to be harness shops in every town, and now there is possibly one harness maker in some old back lane, just to make the few odd collars that are required. That is the position in regard to harness-making, certainly as far as the West of Ireland is concerned.
Comment on this
Of course, the two things do not necessarily go together, because you can get imported harness quite cheaply for use in connection with your increased tillage.
Comment on this
This is another of the little incidentals; I might say it is one of the mosquitoes that are going to make the swarm. The Minister says he is only levelling-up matters—that straps other than straps on harness are taxed already. If the Minister is so anxious to level things, I will help him to do it. Why not bring them all down to the same level instead of levelling them up? Instead of levelling up the 35 per cent., or whatever the figure is, I would suggest that we bring them all down to 35 per cent., and change this Schedule a bit. As I say, this is another of the little mosquito tricks, and they all add to the burden. The whole matter of this Finance Bill has been most illuminating to some of us. In fact I myself did not completely realise the iniquity of it until we came to discuss it in Committee. The discussion has been somewhat limited inasmuch as the Government side did not partake in it. It has been left to us to try to drag out whatever elucidation could be dragged out of the Bill without the assistance of the Minister. In that way, perhaps, the discussion has not been as useful as it might have been with the proper intervention of the Government Front Bench to explain matters. I dare say that the discussion might even have been shorter if the Government had been more helpful in explaining matters to us. We would not have had to get up one after another, and try to drag out some information on the particular points that affected us all. This particular tariff in the Schedule here is raising the duty on harness, and for much the same reason as I objected to very many of the duties here I am objecting to this one. This is not the time to put up the price of harness. Perhaps the people in the towns and cities will not be so much affected as the people in the country will be by the increase in the cost of a set of harness, or a set of tackling as it is commonly called in the country. Even a very small addition to the price is going to affect us. I do not care whether it is going to mean 6d. or 1/- or 5/-, I certainly object to it. For my own part I object to this Eighth Schedule on that particular point.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present—
Comment on this
I gather that the particular recommendation which the Minister put forward for this tax is that it is no use—that it does not do anything.
Comment on this
But really so far as we are concerned, it does nothing, because there is no harness being imported. I gather that is the contention.
Comment on this
Either this is an effective tax or it is not. I gathered from the Minister that it is not. I think it is objectionable—I will not use a stronger word than that— to put on those tariffs which are of no use whatsoever. The principal advantage that it has in the Minister's mind is not anything affecting industry, not anything affecting the country, and not anything affecting farming; he says it will do them no damage because no harness is being imported at present. It will not increase the amount of harness made in this country because no harness is being imported at present. The only reason he has, therefore, for putting up the price to a higher level, with all that may come afterwards—which, of course, the Minister leaves out of account in all those taxes—is that it will facilitate the Customs, and enable them to make up their minds as to whether a strap belongs to a set of harness or tackling or whether it belongs to a portmanteau. Again we are approaching the same question which we had last night—the inability of the Customs people to make up their minds. Last night they could not distinguish between thread and yarn. I have never known the Customs officials—and I think the Minister bore me out on this last night—to err on the side of the consumer or of the person who was to pay the tax. I could give plenty of amazing examples of the way in which they have interpreted those things; they have never erred on the side of the person concerned, so the Minister need have no fear in that regard. Merely for the convenience of administration, as the Minister calls it, and to save the Customs officials from making up their minds as to whether a thing is harness or not, this tariff on harness has been levelled up. There was one aspect of the matter which the Minister left out of account—though at the present moment that will not affect the price of harness, or it should not if there is any substance in the Minister's argument—and that is that when you fix a tariff of that kind I cannot see how the inevitable result will not be a gradual approach to the level which you set.
Comment on this
I wonder when the Minister will approach his job in a business-like way and when will he give intelligent protection of our industries a chance? With the Minister's desire to bring all leather goods of this kind under a common tariff for administrative purposes, I agree. I think it is a sound and proper principle that the Minister should do that. But I part company with him when he start levelling up. I would not part company with him if he said that harnes and leather goods are still being imported. I understood him to say that there is practically no harness being imported now. In such circumstances why does he want to level-up this tariff? Is it not time he started levelling it down until he would come to that point, if he would come to it at all, when he would reach zero and harness started to come in? If the Minister is trying to develop that other arm of the nation he must not amputate the arm that is there.
What is harness used for here? Mainly for agricultural horses. The Minister is giving a margin of profit of 40 per cent. above the British profit to harnessmakers here. But what commodity do these agricultural horses produce that is equal to the British price of an agricultural product? Who is to buy the harness made by the harness makers? In the main, it is the agricultural population. In other words, the Minister is fixing 40 per cent more outlay for agriculture and 40 per cent less for the produce of agriculture. That is a simple economic exercise and if the Minister ponders on it he will realise there can be only one ending. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney said that harness-making is a dying industry. Of course, it is, because the produce of the purchasers of harness is a dying industry and, therefore, harness-making must inevitably fall into that grade.
I would prefer if the amendment were worded to fix a much smaller percentage than 40 and I would feel more comfortable in voting for it then. In face of the Minister's statement that no harness is coming in here, and in face of a 40 per cent. imposition on agricultural produce, I am prepared to vote for the amendment. I must say as a protectionist the Minister has made an exceptionally bad case for the 40 per cent. It is only 40 per cent. to encourage profiteering, to sell in a market that is getting poorer every day.
I would like to hear the Minister justifying this levelling-up. I remember when all the top straps and all the accessories of harness were imported here a few years ago. Now they have been kept out through a tariff barrier. Only a tariff barrier sufficient to keep them out is justifiable, and no more. The Minister, having kept them out on a low barrier, wants to increase it. For what purpose? Profiteering. That is quite unjustifiable. That is the policy that is going to kill protection in this country. Every producer here should be made produce on the bare margin, on the border line. He should be protected to that border line and he should be made justify any increase in the tariff.
The policy of the Government, once a certain productive capacity has been attained, should be a policy more or less in line with that of the Revenue Commissioners—impose taxation until the taxpayer jibs. The policy of the Government should also be to lower the barrier when we have destroyed imports of certain commodities that we can make here until the manufacturer jibs and then he should be made sit the other side of a table before an expert who knows his job and be made justify to that expert that it is necessary to have that tariff barrier kept at its existing height or, if he wants it, increased. The Minister should not be throwing away the people's money encouraging profiteering. That is what he is doing under this proposal. For that reason I will vote against it.
Comment on this
Administrative convenience is the only argument put up to justify this change. Administrative ease. There are two arguments swaying different ways in that respect. If they want very many articles tariffed in this country, one could say there is not very much necessity to ease the duties of the Revenue Commissioners or those employed under them. Of course, we know that they are overburdened. On the other hand, if we felt that the Revenue Commissioners were going to be perturbed in a decision as to what was harness and as to leather of particular types in harness, there might be a little difficulty there. But we know very well the Revenue Commissioners and their staffs decided distinctly in one way. We have this particular measure littered with phrases such as "things which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are suitable for use as wall-paper,""things which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are suitable for household ornaments," or "things which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are primarily suitable for laboratory use." We have the judgment of the Revenue Commissioners often put in as a standard and it could easily be done here if there were any necessity. But I do not consider that a desirable way out of this at all. Look at the further mess we are getting into. Harness and harness leather had a 20 per cent. ad valorem duty which was increased to 37½, with a preferential rate of 25. We now want to increase the rate on harness to 40 per cent. and we are leaving the duty on harness leather as it was.
Comment on this
This seems to indicate that the harness leather duty still remains at 37½ with a 25 per cent. preferential rate. I suggest that is only going to make confusion worse. Supposing we say we are disposed to leave this to the judgment of the Revenue Commissioners and supposing we agree that administrative ease is a thing to be regarded, then that can be discussed. What is the minimum duty of a protective type that is required for leather straps? If it is 35 per cent. I suggest the better scheme would be to reduce all to the 35 per cent. If we are going to have the rate raised in order to make it equal to something else we should be able to discuss what is the proper protection for these other articles and what is the proper rate at which these duties should be fixed. It is a matter of some importance to regard this question of price. There is not the slightest doubt in the world that when you put a tariff at a certain point the price increase approximates as closely as possible to that particular aid, that particular protection. The community sacrifice is really measured by something a little bit lower than the particular amount at which the tariff is put. Now, if 35 per cent. will do, there is no reason under the sun why we should give harness makers in the country an extra 5 per cent.
If 35 per cent. is sufficient, there is no reason at all for giving them 40 per cent., and it is as inevitable as day follows night that the prices will creep up when this is raised; they will creep up just that little bit extra that is put on, particularly when these people read and understand the arguments; when they find that the House regards it as of no consequence whether the real rate was 25 per cent. or 40 per cent. Surely, the natural deduction they will draw from that is that the House does not care whether their price has a relation to the 40 per cent. instead of to the 25 per cent. That is one view that can be taken of tariffs— that the price follows on the wide stride of the tariff. The Minister said that prices can look after themselves, that we will put on the tariffs and the consumers pay. That is practically what it amounts to. He told the House there is no protective addition necessary. If the House is to consider the thing on any basis at all they should consider what is the protection required. I suggest that this item should be held over for equation to enable the whole thing to be reconsidered and put at 25 per cent.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the question be now put."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 48:—
In Part II, to delete reference No. 4, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 and 4.
I understand this is the twenty-first tax on house-production and is about the seventh of these taxes uncovered by a budgetary joke of the Minister for Finance. Reference No. 4 proposes to increase what was an effective tax of 20 per cent. on putty, paints and distemper to 50 per cent. So that if a person, going into one of the new houses built by a local authority, finds a notice on the wall that he must pay a tax before he puts wall-paper on the walls, and turns aside to see whether he will not, in the circumstances, colour the walls with some distemper, he finds himself faced with another notice on the new white walls that he must pay a tax before he can put any distemper on them. The rent has already been raised somewhat by the increased tax on paint and putty, and he must now put his hand in his pocket and pay a tax before he can colour the walls. The tax on putty in respect of the house-builder or the person renting the house is also in the same class as the tax on rice-pudding for the occupier.
Comment on this
I should like to ask what is the position with regard to the putty manufacturer at present. Does he import his whiting free of duty? I should also like to know what is the position with regard to linseed oil.
Comment on this
I am afraid I cannot give Deputy Dockrell the information he requires. The arrangement some time ago was that 50 per cent. of the whiting was imported.
Comment on this
Yes, and 50 per cent. of the whiting came from Ennis. But the intention was gradually to increase the percentage of Ennis whiting in the putty. I could not say what exactly is the position at present. So far as the increase in duty is concerned, the position is that paints, putty and distempers, to the value of £93,000 were imported last year, or about 40 per cent. of the requirements of the country. There was no reason why that paint should have been imported. There are a number of very excellent firms engaged in the production of these goods here which are quite capable of supplying all the requirements of the country. They are, in fact, supplying 60 per cent. of the requirements at present. They have expanded their production very rapidly. In the course of last year alone the employment in the industry was increased by 100 people. The increase in duty is for the purpose of stopping that import. We are satisfied that there is very keen competition between the existing firms and that competition will be effective in keeping the price position right.
Comment on this
I suggest to the Minister—I do not know whether he will agree with me or not—that there are certain lines of paint which are not covered by the existing paint manufacturers here, and that is the reason for their coming in. After all, there must be some reason why they are coming in. The Minister has not answered my question about linseed oil.
Comment on this
I said I could not tell the Deputy. I do not know what precisely is the position, but I can inquire for the Deputy if he so desires.
Comment on this
It seems to me that again the Minister is busy destroying his own case. The Minister seems badly off form to-day. In the other two or three debates in which I listened very attentively to the Minister he was very careful to point out that he had no case. But I do not think that in any one of them he pointed it out quite so plainly as in the very short speech which he has just delivered. He told us that the Irish paint industry is going on in splendid style, that it is driving its rivals out of the market, and that it gave employment to 100 more men last year. If it is driving its rivals out of the market, what is the necessity for putting on an extra tariff? I could understand a tariff being put on to aid a struggling industry. That is the justification for a tariff. It is the only justification that a tariff has got. In a great number of instances it is a complete and entire justification for the imposition of a tariff, because you have in other countries a well-established industry which has got its connections, and a new industry starting in another country is badly handicapped and is not starting on equal terms. In order that it may be on equal terms, it is bound to get some of the assistance which a tariff gives to it. But when you have a manufacturer or a number of manufacturers who are going ahead, without any further increase in the existing tariff, and when, according to the Minister's statement, the existing tariff is ample and adequate and the industry is increasing and employing 100 more men and is going on increasing and driving its rivals out of the market, surely the only result of a tariff will be that that industry is able to rise indefinitely up to the very limit of the tariff the price of its paint and putty. It does not want a tariff otherwise. Again and again, in the course of this debate, the extraordinary ingenuity with which the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance have found articles of domestic necessity for the purpose of taxing has been referred to.
Comment on this
It does not matter, even assuming that the tariff reduces the revenue. The Minister is absolutely impregnated with this idea that there is a State and that the State is everything. The Minister has completely and entirely forgotten that there are individuals who compose the State and that there are people who have got their rights. The Minister must consider that whether his revenue goes up or down is not a matter of primary importance to the persons who are bound to pay the extra and higher prices which the imposition of these tariffs brings about. Indeed, any particular individual who has to buy paints at an enhanced price, owing to the existence of this tariff, would, in all human probability, say: "Let that go into the Exchequer" rather than say: "Let it swell the profits of firms that are already making adequate profits and making profits so adequate that they are able to extend their business." They would very much prefer as a whole that the extra cost they are put to should be a gain to the State than that it should be a gain to manufacturers who are already adequately recompensed for the labour and capital they have put into their work. I do not, therefore, understand the meaning of the Minister's interjection. As I say, the Minister is terribly off form to-day.
To get back to the point on which I was when the Minister interrupted me, these taxes are taxes which are being put upon persons who are unable to bear them. They are increasing the cost of living and increasing the cost of repairing a house to persons who are not in a position to bear that, and this tax has to be taken in conjunction with all the Minister's other taxes.
Comment on this
That may be so, but the Deputy must take this particular item by itself. It is simply an increase of duty on certain specific articles, and those alone may be dealt with.
Comment on this
I do not propose to go into any of the other things. I say simply, and I say nothing further —and I submit the sentence is in order, as I do not propose to develop it any further—that you ought to have present to your mind when discussing this all the circumstances in which this tax has been imposed——
Comment on this
The Deputy will see that that would apply to every tax in this Budget and that it might be said about every one of them.
Comment on this
I am not discussing it. I am asking that, when you come to discuss this, you should keep in your mind, silent to yourself, the surrounding circumstances. Do not draw vocally the attention of other people to it. That, I agree, would be against the rules, if I may respectfully say so. But surely I am in order in asking members considering this tax to consider the surrounding circumstances —not to discuss them but to consider and bear in mind the circumstances surrounding its imposition.
Comment on this
The Minister can think in a certain atmosphere. He can talk, and at the same time he can remember that he is sitting in the Dáil, and even the Minister will not require two minutes' silence to remember that he is in the Dáil. In the same way, we need not have two minutes' silence to remember the other taxes which are imposed, when talking of this. Again, I am afraid the Minister is off his shot to-day. He is foozling badly.
Comment on this
If I might come back to the point which the Minister has been strenuously endeavouring to prevent me from making—and I do not mind it; I like his interruptions—the Minister and the Minister for Finance have been going around in the most careful way to see if there is anything which is of real use to the community upon which they can slap down a tax which would increase the price to the consumer. They have found out: "There is putty, and you cannot put in a window without putty; you must have windows in your houses, so we will see to it that the putting in of your windows is a little more expensive than it used to be, and we will slap a tariff on putty." I think it was Alexander Pope who drew a distinction between man and a fly, because, he said, the fly had a microscopic eye and man had not, but, if Alexander Pope had been listening to this discussion, he would have classified the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance as a very fine brace of flies, with the most magnificent microscopic eyes, because the number of things which they have been able to discover which they can put up in price to the unfortunate individual who they consider has no rights, the ordinary citizen of this State, is wonderful. There has been no justification at all for the tax proposed here, and I certainly will oppose it.