Finance Bill, 1935—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 571–768 of 768. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
No. 15 of 1935 ›
It was most appropriate that the Minister should be dealing with putty and paint because if there is one bogey which a man who is getting a job done, and has to pay for it, has to watch, it is the putty and the paint. That is what covers up bad work. The Minister is more illogical in this proposition than in any he has put before us. We are told that there is 20 per cent. of an effective tariff. I take it that is right—a 20 per cent. effective tariff. The Minister said, in reference to that tariff, that we have developed our putty and paint industry rapidly. If "rapidly" means anything, it means that we are getting quickly to that point at which we can produce our own requirements. I do not see what more rapidly the Minister wants to travel than that. I do not see what case he can make for more rapid travelling when it is going to cost more and to put up the price more.
The Minister said that last year £90,000 worth of putty and paint was imported. Then he asks: "Why should we not produce that putty and paint here, and why should we not have the employment that the production of that will give?" With that I agree, if we were stagnant, but we are not stagnant. We are reaching the point of self-sufficiency, in the Minister's own words, rapidly. In response to an interjection or a statement by Deputy Dockrell he said that the competition among the many firms would keep down prices. I wonder has the Minister taken leave of his senses. Where is the competition? We have a market of 100 per cent. but £90,000 worth, 40 per cent. of our requirements, is imported. We have a market of 100 per cent. and we are only supplying 60 per cent. We have a margin of 40 per cent. that we are not filling. We are rapidly increasing our production and the Minister says, soberly and deliberately, that even though we are 40 per cent. behind the production of our requirements, there is sufficient competition between the firms which are producing that 60 per cent. Was there anything ever more ridiculous than that? If these firms said: "Well, now we are getting a 20 per cent. effective tariff; we will fix a price 19 per cent. above the price of the imported article," that would leave a margin of one per cent. which would be effective to keep the market for home producers. But we are still only filling 60 per cent of the market we have. Where is the competition? The thing is absurd. I should like to be producing for such a market. I would not mind how many were competing with me, for no matter how many were competing with me and cutting prices, even if they cut prices down to the level at which paint could be imported here I could say: "Let them do it. I can charge 19 per cent. above the import price, less the tariff."
Comment on this
I said that the firms were quite capable of supplying all the requirements of the country.
Comment on this
At whose expense? If the firms are capable of supplying all our requirements, why do they not do it? Are they working short time, or what is the reason they cannot do it? Where is the competition? That whole fabric of the Minister's argument falls to the ground. A child would not put it up. Deputy Dockrell asked whether there was any difference in the volume of our products as between the dearer and the cheaper paints. Are we producing the best paints here?
Comment on this
I should like to say the best in the world, but I know the Deputy would not believe me.
Comment on this
If I heard that in my young days, when I thought everything Irish was the best in the world, I might believe it, but when I went out into the world my eyes were opened. If the Minister had any experience of the world his eyes would be opened too. The sooner we equate ourselves to other peoples in the world, the sooner we shall know ourselves. If this paint is the best in the world and that we are capable of producing all our requirements, why is it that we are still importing £90,000 worth? The thing does not wash. The Minister throws in the usual stuff by stating that it will give so many more people employment. I agree it would, if we could go on the level that we have been going up to the present, but the Minister proposes to double the effective tariff and have a double increase in the price. Has the Minister taken into account how much that increase in the price of these materials will affect employment among painters and painters' helpers? The Minister is going the right road to diminish employment in another line. A little boy or a little girl can stir the paint in mixing it, but it takes a tradesman to put on the paint, and the tradesman's employment will be curtailed because of the increase in the price of the commodity. People are not going to decorate their houses in future because of the increase in the cost of the materials and the decrease in economic standards, until they are driven to do it. Consequently the Minister's policy will lead to more unemployment in that way.
I should like to hear the Minister again explain to the House where the effective competition comes in when only 60 per cent. of the home market is now being produced at home. How can he explain that there is effective competition amongst the firms producing that 60 per cent. or that there is a sufficient assurance to the public that prices will not soar, if an increase of 20 per cent. is added? I think he actually said that prices would go down. In the name of heaven, what is the use of putting up the tariff if prices will come down? Why do they not come down?
Comment on this
The Minister, in reply to Deputy Dockrell, made a certain statement in reference to whiting, and I gathered from him that at the present moment 50 per cent. of it is untaxed.
Comment on this
There is quite a number of things about which the Minister was not sure. He mentioned that there were 100 people employed last year.
Comment on this
A very high proportion. I think girls are employed only for the packing and decorating of tins. In the manufacture of paint men are employed very largely but for packing and decoration of tins girls are employed.
Comment on this
I wonder whether there is any good in trying to convince the Minister that he is doing these industries no service by the particular line he has taken on this matter and on many of the other industries with which we have dealt to-day for which a high tariff has been asked and imposed by this Bill. The case made by the Minister in defence of the tariff was, strange to say, the extraordinary strides made already in this industry. There you have an industry with the existing tariff showing, according to the Minister, every signs of health, and producing an excellent article. I think he said the best in the world. At any rate the article is good and the advance in the industry is rapid. What, therefore, is the excuse for this increase? According to the Minister, the industry is in a healthy condition. In putting this increase on is he not running the risk of bringing it into an unhealthy condition? He may make more profits for the particular industry. The increase in it may become more rapid, but what I fear is that in order to get that this healthy industry may be largely damaged. On his own showing there is no reason why he should have been dissatisfied with the present rate of increase. On the contrary, he should have been well satisfied, but by his present action he is running the risk of damaging an industry that is in a healthy condition by his unreasonable desire to go altogether too quickly.
I think the whole idea is unsound, and that there is no justification for the line that he is taking up. Deputy Belton's argument struck me as being perfectly sound. With 40 per cent. of the market still to be collared, I do not see where the necessity arises for this. There is a 20 per cent. tariff on already and with it the industry is in a healthy condition. Those in it, even on the existing tariff, can charge at least another 15 per cent., so that according to the Minister's argument prices will operate as far as competition is concerned. With 50 per cent. of the market still to be captured by these firms it is possible that competition will be done away with. Is not that the inevitable result? It is now proposed to increase the tariff by 40 per cent. without any justification, and this in the case of an industry that is rapidly increasing. I suppose it is not necessary to mention the fact that this is interfering with other industries. There are other articles tariffed in this Schedule. Grapes is one. In Schedule II, duties have been put on fruits of various kinds and vegetables, all of which require greenhouses. This tariff will make greenhouses more costly. The Minister will say it will make them cheaper.
Comment on this
Cheaper and better, of course. I have no doubt that with the Minister's putty tomatoes will be grown more cheaply and better. That is as good as any argument that the Minister used to-day. I do not see any justification whatever for this particular increase.
Comment on this
The Minister stated that something like 40 per cent. of the paint used here is imported. Can he give the House any information regarding the exports of paints from this country? They are considerable, I suggest. We all know what happens when tariffs are put on by one country against another. So far as this industry is concerned, it was gradually making progress here. It was well able to hold its own. It was doing that so well that a firm in another country came over here and joined a successful and well-managed firm here with a trade not only in Great Britain but on the Continent, where chemistry had been elevated almost to one of the fine arts. Is this tariff likely to interfere with that export trade? Even if we were to get the whole of the home trade and were to lose the foreign trade, we might lose on balance. There has been a gradual encroachment on the paints imported here. If, on the other hand, there are people with a disposition to buy paint, and that it simply means increased cost to them, that will have its effect on employment in other directions. The Minister has had experience of getting painting done in his own house. Speaking from experience, I should say that with the good quality paints produced in this country the results are very satisfactory for anybody who gets his house painted with Irish materials. The Irish paints last longer and retain their sheen much better. Even after a couple of years a house painted with Irish paint looks as if it had been painted only last year. With that position, and with the export trade increasing and the possibility of ultimately getting, let us say, 90 per cent. of the home trade, is it a wise proceeding on the Minister's part to interrupt that? Where there is an export trade there is always the possibility of expansion. The people in the trade here are highly specialised. They have been in it for generations and have made a success of it. They have made such a success of their business that, as I have said, a firm in another country was induced to come over here and join them. It surely is a dangerous thing to interfere with an industry such as that. It would be useful, I think, for the Minister to give us some information as to the volume of the export trade. When something of this kind was attempted in other directions we lost practically all our export trade.
Comment on this
But expansion may result there. There may be a disposition on the part of people outside to purchase more and more of these special classes of paints. I venture to suggest that there is still a great chance for an expansion in that direction. If, by reason of increasing this tariff, people are induced to impose tariffs against our goods, then the loss will be ours.
Comment on this
The real position with regard to the imposition of this tariff is still obscure. The enormous burden that is being put on the general building trade is also obscure. The Minister told us that about 40 per cent. of the paint used here is imported. Taking that figure, it means that something more than £200,000 worth of paint is used here every year. At present, the Minister is getting about £20,000 in revenue from imported paint. If he is getting that on the import of paint, there is the equivalent cost of something nearly approaching 20 per cent. falling on the people buying Irish paint. I propose to increase it to 50 per cent. If the present import of paint continues as it is and if it takes the Irish houses a little while to expand their production, the Minister is going to raise £50,000 in 12 months instead of £20,000 and there is going to be a corresponding rise in the price of Irish paint here. I submit that the Minister's proposal will have the effect of imposing an additional cost on the users of paint of anything up to £80,000 or £90,000 per year. I should like the Minister to address himself to that aspect of the question and to say if the housebuilding industry can bear that impost.
Comment on this
By increasing the price to something close on the 50 per cent. margin? I submit that the housebuilding industry is not capable of bearing that impost. There is sufficient falling-off, due to the financial condition of the people, in work of that kind without adding to it in this way.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the Dáil do now adjourn until 10.30 a.m. to-morrow, July 6th, 1935, and that the Order for the Adjournment on that date be taken not later than 12 o'clock midnight."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 49:—
In Part II, to delete reference No. 5, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 and 4.
Reference No. 5 proposes to clear away a tax of 15/- and a preference of 10 per cent. on presses for racquets used in any of the games of tennis, lawn tennis, badminton, racquets or any similar game. The Minister proposes to clear the ground in order, subsequently, to put on a tariff of 50 per cent. on these articles. He proposes to extract a revenue tax from persons who take part in sport and who wish to keep their sporting instruments in a sound and proper condition. This is an attack on real economy, or, you might say, an attack on the character of the people. Persons who keep their sporting implements in a sound condition are the type of people who build up the country in the right way and who do its work in the right way. The Minister proposes to single that class of persons out and to take a revenue tax from them by imposing a tax on the care and solicitude that they have for their equipment. If that is not so, I should like to hear what the intention of the Minister is.
Comment on this
The Deputy can be assured that the people who play tennis and badminton will be able to keep their racquets in much better condition by using Irish-made presses.
Comment on this
Will the Minister tell the House if Irish racquet presses are being made and, if so, the class of material from which they are made. If presses of this kind are available, will the Minister tell us why there should be an extra charge, and why the effective tariff of 10 per cent. is to be raised to 50 per cent.?
Comment on this
How can the Minister assure the House that these presses will be superior to, or just as good as, those made elsewhere?
Comment on this
These racquets are expensive and this represents money going out of the country. I never bought a racquet, but I am told that the price of a good one is about £3, and that it lasts, perhaps, a season. I am sure that £2 10s. or 3 guineas leaves the country for a racquet and, that being so, it is advisable to ensure that more than that amount will not leave. I understand these presses are essential to keep the racquets in good condition. Can the Minister give any information as to the quantity of racquets imported? I understand that specialised knowledge is required in order to keep them up to the standard for people who are proficient in the game. I have no idea what presses cost. I presume about 5/- each.
Comment on this
Will racquets of a specified quality be made here? If we save 2/6 and lose £2 10s., it is bad business.
Comment on this
They will be made here by a firm with an established reputation in woodwork for many years and that has maintained a satisfactory export trade on the quality of their work.
Comment on this
If that is so, why is the tariff being increased? Are these things imported with the presses?
Comment on this
They are usually sold with the racquets, and it is necessary to impose a large tariff to discourage that.
Comment on this
The racquets come in without these presses. I am told the racquet is sensitive to climatic conditions. I understand there is catgut in it. I am sure the Minister understands something about that and that he played the violin or the banjo.
Comment on this
That is what is wrong with the Minister and why there is an absence of harmony. I am sure that, if he wanted to annoy his neighbours. he practised on the melodeon. The Minister knows that these things are liable to suffer from climatic conditions. If racquets come in, is he aware that they will be liable to injury unless they are protected by presses? Is it fair to the people to have articles coming in unless arrangements are made that they can be detached from presses at the port of entry?
Comment on this
Will some arrangements be made so that the racquets will not be injured in transit? I take it that the Minister has not consulted any tennis players about this. Tennis players would not like to have the racquets sent here from another country unless they were in presses. Will arrangements be made that they will come in containers that will not be subject to duty, so that the cost will not be increased or that the racquets will be put into presses immediately on importation?
Comment on this
I understand that racquets are being strung here now and that only handles and the framework come in.
Comment on this
If the Minister does not agree, will he look into the matter to see if something can be done to ensure that if people play this game the racquets will not be injured?
Comment on this
The Minister says that racquets are now being imported with the protection of the presses and that racquets are not being made here. People who buy tennis racquets have to pay a duty of 50 per cent. on the cost of these articles. The Minister says they come in with the racquet presses.
Comment on this
The Minister tells us that these racquet presses come in with the racquets and he wants to stop that.
Comment on this
I did not say that. I said that the tendency when selling a racquet made by a particular firm was to sell a press of the same brand.
Comment on this
It is in order to discourage that, and to secure the use of Irish presses, that the tariff is being put on.
Comment on this
The fact is that tennis racquets coming in now will pay 50 per cent. They are usually bought with a racquet press in order to preserve the property and so that the racquet will last longer. Now the pressure of the present financial situation is such that they decide to make these things subject to a tax of 50 per cent.
Comment on this
Well, the Minister ought to look at his Customs and Excise list. He will see, on page 46 of his Customs and Excise List, under reference No. 188, that on racquets, golf clubs and parts, which are, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, designed, constructed and intended for use in games of tennis, lawn tennis, badminton, racquets or similar games, and so on, there is a 50 per cent. tax ad valorem, and that the preferential rate is 50 per cent. also.
Comment on this
I have explained that the racquet frames are not liable to duty, and that the frames are strung here.
Comment on this
I am talking of racquets. I doubt if we have come to the position that all the racquets sold here are now Irish-strung.
Comment on this
The Minister is very glib with what he thinks, but when he asks for an increase of a tax from 10 per cent. to 50 per cent., he ought to be clearer in his explanations as to what exactly the situation is. We see no reason for such a jump in connection with this particular class of goods. In the absence of more explanation from the Minister, I have nothing more to say.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the reference proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 50:—
In Part III, to delete reference No. 8, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 and 4.
It is proposed here to impose a duty of 50 per cent. on presses for tennis racquets, etc. The Minister says those things are going to be made here. I should like to hear any argument that the Minister can bring forward as to why a tariff of 50 per cent. is necessary in order to get presses for tennis racquets and badminton racquets made here.
Comment on this
The Minister gave no explanation as to why a duty as high as 50 per cent. was necessary in order to get those made here.
Comment on this
I should like to hear the explanation, because if it satisfied anybody it must have been very cogent. This reference number says "presses for racquets used in any of the games of tennis, lawn-tennis, badminton, racquets, or any similar game." To start off with, there is no tennis played here. There is no such thing as tennis played here. There is not a tennis court in all Ireland. The game does not exist here.
Comment on this
Does the Minister know that the game does not exist here? Where did he copy this from? There is nobody in this country who plays tennis, and I do not suppose the game has ever been played in this country; well, I do believe there was one private court in a house which still exists. I think the outline of the court is still there, but it has been turned into either a veranda or a flower show. I do not suppose there is anybody in the country who has a racquet for that game. As far as lawn tennis is concerned, it is played; badminton slightly; racquets progressively. Then we got "or any similar game." I wonder what that is supposed to catch. You do not put a ping-pong racquet in a press.
Comment on this
Not recommended? I would nearly give the Minister 10/- if he could get a press in which you could put a ping-pong racquet. What else is there to be caught? What is "other similar game?" I do not suppose he wants a press for fishing nets? What is the requirement for 50 per cent.? There used to be a rather ugly and—being ugly and having more board—a somewhat dearer type of press for a lawn tennis racquet. It was much heavier and more expensive than what is now used. With regard to the old type of frame I suppose the ordinary carpenter could turn it out with great ease, once he got the boards for it. It was a 3-ply board. Of course, the only thing that is required in the press is to keep the racquet from warping. It has a natural tendency to warp, particularly with the strength of the gut tending to make it curl up at the side. The board had to be fortified and strengthened. It was more than 3-ply; the wood was fortified in different ways. Given the bits of board, an ordinary carpenter could do the dove-tailing of one into another. The ordinary rectangular type of frame which used to be made was a simple thing. After the boards were cut all that was required was the addition of four holes bored in a particular way, and the adjustment of the screws. The cost of sending the presses across to this country, particularly the old type of press, must have been fairly expensive. They are heavy articles and, secondly, they make an awkward parcel when sent in big lots. The person who was getting in the boards and making the presses here must certainly have the advantage of a fairly heavy freight. You can get the boards in decent lengths, and have them cut. Of course, the type that is coming in now is much lighter. The price has gone down. The wood is much more strengthened and fortified than it used to be. The type of frame is now a criss-cross diagonal thing, with one screw only. Instead of four screws there is only one. I think for the badminton racquet there is a very light press indeed. We are told there is a requirement of 50 per cent. instead of whatever it is that we are removing.
Comment on this
Has anybody indicated to the Minister that they cannot make those presses under the protection of 15 per cent. plus freight, and that they are going to make them under the protection of 50 per cent? Has anybody indicated that 15 per cent. was not sufficient? I should be surprised to find it was not. That is the argument I want to hear. There is nothing very subtle or expert about the construction of those presses, and it should be possible to make them here once the boards are fitted together in a particular way. I should like to hear the argument which the Minister says satisfied the House that 15 per cent. is not enough, and that 50 per cent. is required. As I have not heard the argument I have to go on some of the possible reasons that might have been alleged. The main one would be that 15 per cent. is not enough, and that 50 per cent. is the proper figure to induce the manufacture here, whereas the lower figure would have failed. I should like to hear why that 35 per cent. additional has got to be made. Can the Minister even tell us what is the average cost of the roughest type of board press for, say, a lawn tennis racquet? We will then know what this 50 per cent. additional means. Would the Minister tell us where those are likely to be manufactured? Is it at the ordinary sports outfitters' establishments or is it going to be an addition to some timber place?
Comment on this
Unless they are definitely connected with the sports outfitting places, remember there can be a danger, because if the press is not made in a sufficiently expert way it will have the same tendency to curl up in damp weather that the racquet has. If that is slipped on to the frame of a good racquet it will give it an additional tendency to curl. I would have thought that some of the good sports shops in the city might have taken it on and engaged some of their employees in their spare moments in the winter time making these things. I wonder if the Minister could give us an indication of the number required, so that we may get an idea of the extent of employment.
Comment on this
It would certainly be ludicrous if there was any estimate based on that assumption; it would be sheer folly.
Comment on this
A press will certainly outlast many racquets; it ought to be good for at least five or six years. In these days, perhaps, a press might be let drop or might be pitched around the court, but if it is kept in the ordinary way there is no reason why a press should not outlive several racquets. A person who buys a racquet in a particular season does not require to buy a press at the same time, if he has one already in his possession. Some people are inclined to assume that each racquet brings with it its own press, but I do not suppose there would be any necessity to get a press each time one purchases a racquet. There are, in fact, quite a number of people who never put a press around a lawn tennis racquet at all. You will find people who think that the best way to keep a lawn tennis racquet through the winter is to prop up a window with it, to use it in order to let in the air. Of course that is bad for the racquet.
Comment on this
It might slip and, in view of the Government's attack on window glass, you would want to be more careful of the window glass in future.
Comment on this
I merely meant that when the clothes brush is not handy they put in a tennis racquet or a shoe. That is not good for the window or for the racquet. It is only the experienced club player who gets down to the point of using a press at any time, and not even that type of person gets a press every time that he purchases a racquet. As I indicated before, a press will outlive any racquet and, in the circumstances, I see no reason for this 50 per cent.
Comment on this
I think it is a very bad principle to tax anything in connection with sport in any form. The Government have gone as far as they could in the way of taxing the necessaries of life and now we find them taxing the type of amusement which is beneficial to the health of the young people. With regard to racquet presses, the number of them coming into the country annually must be very small. There seems to be an idea that every racquet comes in with a press, but that is not so at all. I have used a press for the last 15 or 16 years, and it is still in quite a good condition. Only a couple of shillings would be involved in the purchase of a very efficient press. The amount of protection that will be required in connection with this matter is really not worth all the trouble. I think the tariff of 50 per cent. proposed by the Government is an extraordinary amount to put on. I am perfectly sure that whatever presses are made here they will be well able to compete with the foreign article without any protection whatsoever. I have seen some Irish-manufactured presses and they are very good, and they can make them very cheaply.
I really do not see the object of putting on this tax. It is not going to bring in any appreciable revenue. There would not be more than a couple of hundred of these presses imported in the year; they certainly would not reach the thousand mark. The cost will be only a couple of shillings, possibly 5/- each, and the whole amount will not be much more than £50 or £60. I do not think any industry could benefit very much with a tax like this. It is wrong, at any rate, to tax any form of sport, because it means an indirect tax on the health of our people. There was a time when tennis was not so popular as it is to-day. It is now very popular amongst our young people, amongst the younger generation working in offices and other places. I do not think the Minister should put anything in the way of the advancement of tennis, which has now become a thoroughly democratic game in this country, a game within the reach of all our boys and girls and a game that induces very healthy exercise.
Comment on this
I would very much like to know where the Minister gets his facts from. He tells us very glibly certain things and he gives us certain estimates. Who makes the estimates for him? If I understood the Minister correctly he said 60 gross of presses come into the country in the year. Sixty gross would mean 8,600 presses, and the Minister mentions that that number comes into the country in the year. To be accurate, 8,640 presses are brought into this country, according to the Minister.
Comment on this
I wonder how many tennis racquets are sold in the country each year? If we allow three or four years' life to a press, that would be a fair estimate. I should certainly say there is about one press for every four or five racquets in the country. According to the Minister's estimate that would mean a sale of something like 40,000 tennis racquets in the year.
I wonder if the Minister instead of simply telling us straight away: "I will make an estimate" would tell us how his estimate is arrived at and who made it; because it seems to me to be a grotesquely impossible estimate. On the general question, apart from the accuracy of the Minister's figures, I think it is a great mistake in taxation all around to put on little taxes which really do no good to the revenue and do no good as far as giving employment is concerned. Nothing substantial of any kind in the way of employment is gained and yet it is very annoying to the ordinary person in the street. These little pin-prick taxes are annoying to the taxpayer and they do not tend or conduce to making the taxpayer pay up those other taxes which ordinarily he is quite ready to pay.
Comment on this
I think 60 gross is the figure, that is 8,640 racquet presses sold. I think the Minister would find on a calculation that there is not one in four used in the country as a press. Perhaps it might be put at one in five or one in six. People buy racquets for their children and they would not buy very expensive racquets. They go in for something cheap, just as people do in the case of cheap motor cars, something that would last during the season. They are used after that for holding up a window or something like that, and it is only about one in six would be kept in a press. Let us say there were 43,000 tennis racquets sold in a year. It is only the people who take a keen interest in the game and people who play in club competitions who would probably buy a new racquet each year. The ordinary club player will certainly make a racquet do, on an average, for three years. That would mean that there are about 120,000 lawn tennis players or about 120,000 between lawn tennis players and badminton players in the country. This figure is certainly the most fantastic figure we got to-night, a shocking figure.
Comment on this
Question put—"That the figures in reference 10 stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 51:—
In Part IV, to delete reference No. 10, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 and 4.
Reference 5 of Schedule 1 of the Finance Act, 1933, imposed a duty of 37½ per cent., with a preference duty of 25 per cent. on footballs, the covers of which are made wholly or mainly of leather, and also on football covers made wholly or mainly of leather imported separately. We have seen in the discussion of this measure how the agent of the Minister for Finance searched every hole and corner of a workman's house to see what he could take there; searched every bit of material that goes into the making of a workman's house, to see what he could take; and put the tax-gatherer outside the house of entertainment that the workmen could go to. We have seen various other taxes put on sports materials. We have had an effective tariff of 25 per cent. on footballs, which is now raised to 40 per cent. So that, following carefully the report of the various ways in which workers can be taxed, the Minister follows the workman to the football field. He will not allow him into the field until he has paid a substantial increase on his football. I should like to hear from the Minister for Industry and Commerce whether there is a side to that proposal other than the side the Minister for Finance has been giving us here in his interjections—that he is looking for revenue.
Comment on this
The Minister believes the 25 per cent. will not do it. How did he come to that conclusion without knowing the number imported?
Comment on this
The Minister evaded that in the other answers supplied to me with regard to harness. He chose the other explanation for harness. It did not go quite well, so we have this explanation this time. I should like to know if a big business is being done in the manufacture of footballs here.
Comment on this
Does that apply to the rounded cover of the football used in Gaelic and Association football, and would it apply also to the Rugby football?
Comment on this
They have been made here, and the 25 per cent. is not sufficient—we have to make it 40 per cent. Will the Minister tell us whether he has any certain information of the same assured type with reference to prices?
Comment on this
There is a sufficient number of firms in the business to ensure that there will be effective competition.
Comment on this
There is no possibility of firms having an arrangement with each other to get the extra 15 per cent. rake off?
Comment on this
That is the way tariffs should be discussed. We have now information in a certain way. The Minister knows exactly and can tell us how many footballs are booted round to extinction; how many have to be brought in for replacement and renewal purposes in a year. He can tell us accurately how many are made at home and how many imported; the number of workers employed and the wages these workers get. He can tell us the resulting price to people who indulge in this pastime and what he is going to get under the increased percentage. As a matter of fact, there is an extremely able case being made for this tariff on all the information the Minister has given.
Comment on this
The cat is out of the bag now. When discussing harness leather, the Minister told us that the increased tariff was necessary—it was only for levelling up matters. As Deputy McGilligan suggests he thought of another answer since. But whether he thought of it since, or whether it is the correct answer, the fact remains that the present tariff of 25 per cent. is not sufficient; 40 per cent. is necessary and the possibility is that the price will go up. The Minister says that is most unlikely, but he did not say it was not possible. I suggest that it is extremely possible and that when it is possible the manufacturers will take care that it will be probable, and in fact almost certain. The price of footballs is going to go up as well as other articles of necessity, of sport, and of luxury. In fact, one does not know in what way we can escape from tariffs in any direction. As we are discussing sporting matters I suggest that the Minister should blow the whistle now and cry halt to this game of increasing tariffs. Let the country rest on its laurels for a while with what we have achieved, and give the industries started a chance to prove their worth in competition with other countries. Do not surround them with artificial boundaries or, as Deputy Belton put it, put them in a nursery altogether. There ought to be some limitation to this almost continuous increase in tariffs. I do not see any necessity for the increase in this tariff and we will have to oppose it, as we have opposed most of the extra charges in this Schedule, and I hope Deputy Mulcahy will insist on pressing it to a division.
Comment on this
Like Deputy McGilligan, I am very uneasy about the statement of the Minister in the matter of footballs. It is a levelling up apparently. The making of a football certainly does not require more technical skill than the making of harness. We were told that there was no harness imported. Now the Minister says that there was a considerable number of footballs imported and that led him to the conclusion that the 25 per cent. was not adequate. We are not fit for anything if we cannot make footballs with a 25 per cent. margin and the sooner we recognise it the better and stop this "codology" about the industrialisation of the country. I was only a nipper when I made a football.
Comment on this
If I had a skin like the Minister's I would cut it off annually and sell it for making footballs. They could not compete with such a hide.
Comment on this
It is ready for use the moment you take it off. There is no technique required here. The Minister said that some are machined and some are hand-sewn. What is the hand-sewing of a football? An awl and a piece of wax-end. That is the whole technique of a football. We have a 25 per cent. tariff and we are not able to compete with the foreigner, according to the Minister, in the making of these footballs. Is it not time we shut up shop? The man who would vote for an advantage for the making of footballs in this country would be the greatest enemy of Irish industry. It is time we learned to work; it is time we started to do a day's work and stopped talking about it.
The Minister talks about employment in this matter. Frankly, I do not believe the Minister when he said that 25 per cent. was not sufficient, and I do not believe he has any information on it. He cannot be correct in both statements—that we have cut them out in the harness competition but that they have beaten us in the football competition. I suppose the Minister is aware that they are both leather goods. The discussion like this up to midnight is really a waste of time. You would not find lads in toss-pits at the cross-roads wasting their time talking stuff of this kind, and not one will believe the Minister when he says that we are not able to make a football with a 25 per cent. advantage against the people of any other country. That is not the dope the Minister puts out when he goes down to the cross-roads, but it is gradually getting to the cross-roads, and the Minister will be known better and better every time he goes there in future.
Comment on this
The Chair has also received another motion:
That the Dáil do now adjourn until 10.30 a.m. on Saturday, July 6th, 1935, and that the Order for the adjournment on that date be taken not later than 12 o'clock midnight.
Comment on this
I submit, with all respect, that that is out of order. The Dáil has already decided to adjourn until Tuesday and we were so informed by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, I think, on the announcement made here this morning. That decision was taken and that decision remains and stands.
Comment on this
The order on the adjournment is made before the adjournment. A statement was, as usual, made in the morning but no order. That is the position. The statement was that the motion for the adjournment would be until such a date.
Comment on this
I submit that the House was left under the impression that that was the order that was come to and that this is out of order. It is without precedent to accept a motion now that the House do adjourn until any particular time. The Standing Orders of the House provide certain dates for meeting. Those Standing Orders govern the proceedings of the House and they arrange for meetings on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday. I submit that unless a motion were made at the hour of sitting, on any of those days, which would cover the proceedings here, it is irregular to adjourn to any other date. I submit that, having regard to the Standing Orders, it is irregular to permit of a motion being made now, without notice, without any information and when Deputies are scattered throughout various parts of the country and unable to be made aware of this meeting.
Comment on this
On the motion that progress be now reported, I desire to speak. To-day, we were told that it would be necessary to get this Finance Bill through, with the Conditions of Employment Bill, the Cereals Bill and the Widows' and Orphans' Pension Bill, and whatever reasons were given for that seemed sufficient to certain people who were then present, including the Labour Party, who are now entirely absent, to ask them to sit until 12 o'clock to-night to finish this business. During the course of the debate that followed, nobody took any exception to the debate that took place on the Conditions of Employment Bill. If anything is to be said about that, it is that the discussion was, to a great extent, shortened and, to some extent, burked by the fact that the Minister decided to indicate that he would bring in amendments on another Stage in order to allow other points to be debated. It was presented as an urgent Bill. It was certainly a Bill which had lain long enough. It was incubating for a long time, and there had been what some of us regarded as insufficient time given for the setting down of amendments between the time at which the Second Reading was taken and the date the Committee Stage was fixed for.
The Committee Stage was not taken on the day arranged, but that was not the fault of the House. Any amendments that had been put in were in in good time. I do not think that the green paper which came out contained any more amendments than there were in the white paper that came out in time. There cannot be any suggestion that the Bill was held up. That debate lasted until 2 o'clock to-day, and we then took up the Finance Bill— probably the most cumbrous and unwieldy Finance Bill with which this Dáil has ever had to deal—and the tactics adopted by the Ministry in regard to that were that, first of all, they were too afraid of criticism to make any comment themselves, and they effectively boycotted into silence any of their own members who had the temerity to make any comment on that Bill. The only occasion on which Deputies on that side arose in the debate was when the Minister for Finance said, with regard to one tax that was being imposed, that it was a revenue tax and he was interrupted by three people——
Comment on this
Might I propose that the question on this motion be now put?
Comment on this
Question put—"That reference No. 13 stand."
Do you agree with this result?
Question put: "That reference No. 14 stand."
Do you agree with this result?
As regards the motion that the Dáil do now adjourn till 10.30 a.m. to-morrow, July 6th, that motion was handed to the Chair as a matter of urgency, as certain Bills have to get through this House within a week. I consider that it would be rather an impertinence for the Chair to decide that the majority in this House in a matter of urgency cannot come to a decision as to whether or not it would sit to-morrow.
Comment on this
I propose to take that method. It is the only way in which proper comment on your conduct can be made.
Comment on this
Am I to understand that you are taking this motion without notice to the House? This is a motion different from any motion of which any notice has been given and to which objection is taken by a certain number of Deputies in this House. The reason, I understand, is urgency, but the Bill can be still got through in the course of next week without any necessity for sitting to-morrow. I will ask your reconsideration of your decision on the grounds that any such urgency is due to incompetence and delay on the part of the Government and the majority Party in this House in the way in which they have conducted their business. There is plenty of time for the Finance Bill in the course of the next week—Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday—to get through this House. Therefore, I suggest to you, Sir, for your consideration that there is no such matter of urgency in this particular matter. We have been treated with the grossest impertinence by the Minister for Finance. He has taken up the attitude, so to speak, of not recognising the court. The Opposition has discussed this measure. His attitude is one of contempt for the House, and I suggest that the majority Party on the motion it is taking at present is treating the House with the same contempt.
Comment on this
So far as this motion is concerned and the reason for it, there is no doubt whatever but that the Finance Bill can pass through this House by Wednesday and that there will then be 21 days in which it can go to the Seanad, and be passed before the first of August. In these circumstances and having regard to the precedent that has been established and observed here since this House started, I submit that the taking of this motion now is certainly unfair to the Parliament. It must be remembered that if there is a majority here there is also a minority and that the minority has a right to express its view. They have been elected as well as the majority and it is their bounden duty to take part in the parliamentary proceedings. They have done that with all the ability at their command, as was their duty.
The House this morning was informed that the intention was to adjourn until Tuesday at 3 o'clock. Outside of the majority everybody in this House believed that that was the programme. They believed in all good faith that once that announcement was made no attempt could be made or would be allowed to be made to interrupt the business by moving that the House would meet to-morrow. I put it on another ground. We have been sitting here since Tuesday at 3 o'clock. We have been sitting from 10.30 a.m. to-day and it is now near midnight. I put it in all reason that members of this House are not likely to bring to the consideration of business that application which is demanded of us in the Parliament of the nation. If you are accepting the motion that the House adjourn until to-morrow morning at half past ten o'clock I submit that it is an outrage on the proceedings and precedents that have been established in this House. If you are going to accept that motion I will have to move an amendment.
Comment on this
Will you accept an amendment from me: That the House adjourns until 3 o'clock on Tuesday?
Comment on this
I have accepted the motion that the question be now put. The Deputy understands this matter must be decided before 12 o'clock.
Comment on this
Question put.—"That reference No. 15 stand."
Do you agree with this result?
Question put—"That the words stand."
Do you agree with this result?