Public Business. - Agricultural Produce (Cereals) Bill, 1935—Final Stages.
Contributions 1–137 of 277. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 10 of 1935 ›
If Deputies will examine this Bill they will find that there are a good many of the provisions which would need to come into operation on the 31st July or the 1st August. Therefore, it would be necessary for the Bill to become law by the 31st July. I think if any Deputy will consider the time table he will find that this only gives three weeks to the Seanad for the ordinary examination that they are entitled to give to the Bill. They would probably take the Second Stage next week, the Committee Stage the following week, and the Final Stages the week after. If the Seanad proposes to insert any amendments there will be very little time at the end of that period for the Bill to come back to the Dáil, either for agreement or disagreement with the Seanad amendments, as the case may be. On that account I am anxious that the Dáil should take the Fifth Stage now.
Comment on this
It was at the Minister's request last night to the Chair that the view of the majority in the matter of urgency was accepted here. The Minister was the man who was put up to move that. He probably had in the back of his mind this Bill. Now we find that the particular urgency is that there is a measure going to the Seanad which happens to have in it the date 1st August. Is that date inflexible? Can it be changed by an amendment?
Comment on this
What is the difficulty about having the cereal year put back a bit, say by a fortnight?
Comment on this
There is great difficulty. If the Deputy will examine the Bill——
Comment on this
It would be extremely difficult to outline in detail the various amendments that would be necessary.
Comment on this
Supposing I thought it necessary in this House to put back the date of the coming into operation of some section until 14th August, would the Minister require an amendment?
Comment on this
Supposing I moved them all? Supposing I made the Appointed Day the 14th August, what is the difference?
Comment on this
To shift the date from the 1st to the 14th August requires a big number of amendments. If the Minister is too tired to do it I will get them put down in the Seanad for him, if he will give me the chance.
Comment on this
Possibly not. I ask the Minister to explain to me some difficulty arising from the circumstances and not from the drafting. I have not referred to any difficulties in drafting. The Minister said that there would be a number of amendments required, but I have not yet had explained to me any reason why the Bill will not work as well running from the 14th August as 1st August.
Comment on this
And for the purposes of the Cereals Bill the harvest is to coincide with the 1st August. It would not do on the 3rd August. Supposing some of the harvesters in the West want to go to Galway races, and they postpone operations until the 2nd August?
Comment on this
My spiritual home is elsewhere. That is one point. The second point is, what was the date of the introduction of this measure? What was the date when the Second Reading was taken and when the Committee Stage came along? Was there any delay which the Minister could have forestalled, or could he have cut out something in the running of this measure? Did he take the Second Reading as quickly as possible after the First Stage was put through, or was the Second Reading taken on the day for which it was first arranged? There is a lot to inquire into when we begin to talk of urgency. If the Minister has landed himself into something of a mess he should have come to the House with a plea based on the lines of compassion. Instead, last night he came in in the most irregular fashion and submitted a proposal, an unprecedented thing in the whole history of the Dáil, at about 20 minutes to midnight, on the grounds of urgency. Now we find this is one measure in regard to which there is urgency. I am quite prepared to ask Deputies on this side of the House to agree to the Minister getting even the last stage now if a case will be made for it, but there is no case made for it yet. The Minister's phraseology shows that last night's business was merely a stunt.
Comment on this
The Deputy's point about altering the date in the Bill could apply to any measure. Even the financial year could be changed.
Comment on this
It may be done by amendment, but it may lead to very great inconvenience. As Deputy Donnelly says, we cannot change the harvest.
Comment on this
The harvest commences in the first week of August.
Comment on this
Will he give me the text of one section, the operation of which will be badly inconvenienced by changing to the 14th August?
Comment on this
We have had another of the Bills in regard to which we were told last night there was urgency and we see the value of it. I have a constitutional objection to-day to speak to less than 20 Deputies.
Comment on this
Will you take a motion for the Adjournment? This is the second or third time that this has happened.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and 20 Deputies being present—
Comment on this
This is the other Bill about which there is urgency. The Minister is making his case, and watch how busy he is at it. He moved the question of urgency last night and we thought it referred to the Finance Bill. Now we find the urgent matter is the Cereals Bill and not the Finance Bill at all. For some occult reason, unexplained to anybody—possibly the Ministers may want to attend races or something— we are not taking the Finance Bill on Tuesday. That was the Bill about which there was so much urgency and pother. The urgent Bill now is the Cereals Bill. The Minister wants to get it passed to-day and the Finance Bill can wait until Wednesday. The Cereals Bill cannot wait until Tuesday. Does it get to the Seanad a moment sooner than if it passed here on Tuesday?
Comment on this
It could not be taken in the Seanad next week if it is not passed here until Tuesday.
Comment on this
But that is the rule in the Seanad. They do not take a Bill on Wednesday that has been passed here on the previous Tuesday.
Comment on this
Deputies opposite may have more influence with the Seanad than we have.
Comment on this
The Seanad never tried to hold up any Bill which they were willing to let pass. They never tried to hold up such a Bill on a technical point like the Minister suggests. I never knew them to hold up a Bill unduly which they were willing to let pass. If they objected to a measure and objected to it altogether it would be different, but in the case of a measure which they were determined to accept they never unduly delayed it either in the time of this Government or the other Government. The whole plea last night of urgency and the whole business of telling the Chair that this measure was urgent is mere moonshine. It is only for the purpose of showing their contempt for the House.
Comment on this
We object to taking the Fifth Stage of this Bill for another reason, and that is, that apparently the Government side of the House, anyway, are not in a position mentally to take part in the discussion on this Bill. Judging from the tired expression on the faces of the Government Deputies and our experience of them during the Committee Stage on the Finance Bill they are not in a condition to do so. To my mind it would be lamentable if the whole onus were to rest on the Deputies on this side of the House. We have largely assumed that duty in the debate on the Finance Bill. It is asking rather too much of Deputies on this side of the House that they should take the onus of presenting this Bill to the Seanad in the way in which it should be presented and as it would be presented if the whole intelligence of the House were concentrated on it. Perhaps, in one sense, the whole of the intelligence of the House has been concentrated on it but, at all events, whatever intelligence is on the other side of the House should be added. If the Committee Stage of the Finance Bill had gone through last night we would not have heard a bit about the urgency of the Agricultural Produce (Cereals) Bill. I am sure the Government would in that case be quite satisfied that the Agricultural Produce (Cereals) Bill could wait until Tuesday next. It can wait until Tuesday next week. I submit there is no need for this hurry and rush now.
Comment on this
I understand there must be the unanimous consent of the House before the Fifth Stage of this Bill can be proceeded with. As far as I can see the Minister has brought forward no reasons which satisfy my mind as to the urgency of the measure. I understand the House must be unanimous before the Fifth Stage can be taken.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the Fifth Stage of the Agricultural Produce (Cereals) Bill be taken to-day."
Do you agree with this result?
Whatever the majority Party may think about the power to tax the people without giving any explanation for that taxation, I can say that, though the Minister has not been silent like his colleague, he has put up no defence for this particular tax. On every stage of the Bill it has been put up to the Minister that what he is doing is financing wheat-growing by means of a bread tax. He has offered no defence to that. As far as I know, he has evaded the issue right through, until now on the last stage there will be no possibility of examining any reply he may deign to give to the charge. That there should be obvious hesitation on the part of the Minister for Finance to defend these taxes is understandable enough; that there should be equal hesitation on the part of his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, to defend this bread tax is equally understandable. My objection to the Bill on that ground is twofold, because it is a tax on the most necessary article and the most universal article of food. I hold that any Government or Party, whatever majority they have, in trying to impose such a tax on the people are behaving in practically a criminal fashion. Further, they are making an effort—and from some reactions occasionally observable on their benches it can be seen that the effort has met with a certain amount of success—to conceal from the people that this is nothing more than a bread tax. I do not know that it has been denied at any stage by the Minister that that is what it amounts to. A levy on bread or a tax on bread amounts to the same thing. I can well understand their anxiety to conceal that from the people as well as they can.
I do not think that even the Minister for Finance, with all his willingness to grind the last penny out of the people, would have dared, on account of Party consideration, to have come down to the House and in his Budget propose a tax this year of £350,000 or £400,000 on bread. This is a tax which it has been made clear on various stages of the Bill is bound to mount up until ultimately, even according to the conservative figures of the Minister for Agriculture, it is going to amount to at least £1,500,000. I do not believe that the Minister for Finance would have dared to make such a proposition openly and brazenly to this House. I believe that Party considerations would have kept him from doing it. I believe that the Minister, who did not shrink from taxing tea and every other article of food, except, as I said the other day, potatoes, would have shrunk on account of Party considerations from imposing this bread tax on the people. I am amazed that people who have protested through the country against the tax on sugar, the tax on tobacco, and the taxes on other things, have failed to protest more loudly against this most iniquitous of all taxes—a tax on bread.
Comment on this
You proved it. You have used your majority, as we saw, in a very questionable manner, and to give wrong information to this House on the question of urgency. You used your majority for that purpose, and I hope you are satisfied. The fact that there has not been that outcry against this cynical imposition of a tax on bread shows how well the concealment has taken place—that the people are not yet alive to the fact that they are being so taxed.
Comment on this
No wonder you laugh. At whom are you laughing now? At the speaker or at the Chair? It might keep you quiet for a while. What is this being used for? The ordinary taxes are raised to carry on the business of the Government, to finance various projects of the Government. What the Government are doing is really to take one particular portion of their policy, namely wheat growing, and to try and get acceptance of the bread tax because they pretend it is going to the subsidising of wheat. They could do that with every other tax—try to get it accepted by binding it up with the particular thing it is meant to finance. There would be no trouble about that. There would be no difficulty, as we saw, in the various stages of this Bill in getting a modification of the subsidy system. If it was necessary to provide a subsidy it could have been taken as subsidies are taken for other things out of ordinary taxation. Here the Government has chosen the most essential of all necessaries of life upon which to put a tax which shows that there is no limit to the lengths they will go to grind down the people of this country. That is what this Bill stands for.
This is an amending Bill, and I am speaking only of the amending Bill. We are not talking of the policy of subsidising wheat. To do so, I am told by the Chair, would be out of order. Therefore, we are not discussing the original Bill. We are discussing this amending Bill and we are only entitled to discuss it so far as it changes from the original Bill. The change it brings about is in the method of helping wheat-growing and, therefore, the question of policy does not arise. The change brought about is the change in the method of collecting money for helping the flour milling industry. This is a change from the ordinary practice where income tax and every other form of tax have to bear their share. It is a change where the particular tax is put on to bread. The majority of this House are determined to put that tax on to bread. When it came to the Schedules I expected more discussion, because even the Government benches were vocal upon this matter. It was pointed out that the actual subsidy given in this Bill for wheat-growing was too low and was uneconomic. We heard a great deal about 23/6. We were informed that that was the general figure that would be paid. But I am informed, by people who know all about farming, that a 60 lb. bushel is not the normal all over the country. Therefore, when you speak of 23/6 you are not speaking of the normal price to be paid. I have been told by farmers with a thorough knowledge of farming that on making inquiry elsewhere they were informed that a 58 lb. bushel is the average for ordinary good wheat and not 60. Therefore, when you speak glibly that the normal price is 23/6 you are misleading people; that is according to the information I got from people who know all about these things.
For these reasons I am opposed to this Bill. As I said it has nothing to do with helping wheat-growing and that question does not arise, and there is no use pretending it does. The principal change effected by the Bill is a change in the incidence of the taxation to help wheat-growing, by separating the tax from ordinary taxation such as income tax and various other taxes and putting it on to bread, because the subsidy offered in the Schedule is inadequate.
Comment on this
This, as Deputy O'Sullivan has pointed out, is an amending Bill. We are opposing it because from our point of view, whatever section of the community you take, it offers no advantage beyond the original Bill. There is no provision whatever which shows that the position of the producer, when the original Bill was brought in to help wheat-growing, can be in any way improved by this amending Bill. I am not quite sure that his position will not be worsened. I think it will work out in practice that the average price paid for wheat under the amending scheme will be something in the neighbourhood of 23/6 per bushel. I think the average farmer got at least that, and something more, last year. Whatever way you take it, the farmer's position is not going to be improved, and it may be worsened by the main sections of this Bill. The chief reason that we are opposed to the Bill is, that while it does not improve the position of the producer of wheat, it puts a certain burden on people who are least able to bear it. The result of this Bill will be to put an additional cost on bread consumers.
Comment on this
The position is that the Government are now going to make the millers tax gatherers for whatever burden is put upon the consumers in respect of bread. In the previous Bill we had farmers paid a subsidy, and they were guaranteed a certain price for certain quality. That is not much changed in this Bill, but, to my mind, they will get a little less than they got under the original Bill. The Government are relieved of the subsidy, and they are passing it on to the millers and to the consumers. But there is something else in the shape of charges to be collected, and these did not fall upon the consumer last year.
Under this Bill we have several sections amending the original Bill. The millers will have to undertake a large expenditure if they are to fulfil the conditions of this Bill. They are to provide storage for the wheat, and drying-rooms and other things which the Bill compels them to do. We know the millers will not bear that additional cost and that they will pass it on to the consumer. The Bill also provides for other incidental expenses which the millers must undertake.
We had a discussion yesterday on another impost on the bread consumer. And it works out in a tax on foreign wheat of 6d. per cwt. That is going to mean 2/- per sack additional on the cost of flour. And this Bill on top of all that will add many another two shillings per sack to the cost of flour. The result is that flour here at the moment is, in price, beyond all comparison with what it is in another part of Ireland. Already we have the price of bread creeping up even before this Bill can come into operation. Bread rose by a halfpenny, I am told, in Dublin, and in County Limerick it rose by a penny. In different parts of the country it rose one halfpenny to one penny and, perhaps more in some distant places. We are going to have it dearer still. Everything points to bread being a luxurious necessity in the future, and what puzzles me is how any farmer-Deputy could have defended this Bill. If, in my sympathy with the farmers of any grade, wheat producers or otherwise, I could see anything good for the farmers as a result of any legislation in this House, I would support it, but if anybody tries to prove to me that wheat at 23/- or 23/6 is going to help the farmer in any way, everything else in the farming world must be at a very low ebb.
Wheat is being produced at that price because there is nothing else they can produce without losing much more than they would lose by growing wheat. I should like to have had the advantage of hearing, before I got up to speak, some Government Deputy make a case for this Bill and show me in some way what it does to help the farmer, or even what it does to help the miller, but in any event to show how the Government can make the case that it does not throw an enormous burden on the already overburdened consumer. I do not think that any sensible Deputy in this House, who had any care for the people whom he represents, whether in town or country, could, with a clear conscience, vote for this measure.
Comment on this
This Bill is one which is very hard for the ordinary person to understand, because it is difficult to see how a Government which knows, or is presumed to know, the conditions of affairs in this country at the present moment, could introduce such a measure. The object of this measure, we are told, is to keep wheat growing advancing. I cannot deal with that matter, I am aware, on this particular Bill but I can point out to the House that the present measure will not have any greater success than its predecessor had. I should also like to point out that if you take the area under wheat and the area under oats, there was, in 1934, actually a lesser area under wheat and oats combined than there was in 1933. In 1933, there were 50,491 acres of wheat and, in 1934, 93,817 acres—an increase of, roughly, 43,000 acres. On the other hand, oats, of which there were 634,675 acres in 1933, shrank to 583,430 acres in 1934, so that, taking wheat and oats combined, we find that the shrinkage in the area under oats is greater than the increase in the area under wheat.
It is, in order to subsidise wheat growing, as against oats growing, that this particular measure is brought before the House. I am aware that under the rules of the House I cannot follow that line any further, because we are not discussing the policy of subsidising wheat, but I can and will point out that this new method of subsidising is a wrong, cruel and unjust method. Last year the subsidy on wheat was a subsidy paid by the ordinary taxpayer which came out of revenue and, accordingly, the proportion which each taxpayer paid towards the subsidy on wheat was roughly in accordance with the financial position of that taxpayer. The richer the man was, the larger the share he paid. This year, it is the opposite. This year, the tax is to come out of bread. It is to be taken off the shoulders that were bearing it last year and transferred to other shoulders; it is being taken off the shoulders of persons who could bear it, if any persons in the State could, and it is being taken off strong shoulders and transferred to the shoulders of the very weakest in the community.
Take the case of the man with a large income—the man with £5,000 a year or £10,000 or any other income you like. That man ought to pay a larger share of any single tax imposed in this country than the poor, wretched, struggling little agricultural labourer or small holder, but under this new scheme of finance, this scheme of finance which makes an appeal to the Minister for Agriculture, this scheme of finance for which he asks this House to vote, this scheme of finance which, I have not the slightest doubt, every Fianna Fáil Deputy here will vote for, he is taking a completely different line, because it is not the person who is richest, but very often the person who is poorest who consumes most bread. Therefore, he is the person who will pay the larger proportion of this tax. I ask every single member of this House to ask himself in his own heart and mind: "Is that fair; is that just; is that equitable?" After all, if there is one tax which you should not lightly impose, it is a special tax upon the main article of food of the poorer classes. You should not so arrange your taxation that the poorer the man is, the larger the share of any particular burden he will bear, and that is what this new taxation is doing.
That is what this new change in the wheat subsidy is doing. The ordinary, poor man will probably and, in fact, does eat more bread than the richer man. The richer man has substitutes for bread in the form of meat, fish and other things. But the poor man's range is very limited, and the main item of food upon which he must rely is bread. Therefore, you are putting on a tax which is weighing more heavily upon the poor than upon the rich. But your tax has a worse result. There is real and desperate poverty in a great number of remote districts in this country now. I know that the condition of part of my own constituency is far worse than it was two or three years ago. Anybody who goes down to the mountainy and poorer districts of Mayo—and it must be the same in Donegal and in Kerry—and examines these poor districts and how the poor people are living there at present, knows that they are in far and away more straitened circumstances than they were a couple of years ago.
It is almost impossible for many households to get the money to buy the actual food which will keep body and soul together. Is it fair in these circumstances, which cannot be denied, to increase the price of a vital article of food? Is it fair or just, or is it a thing that the House should do, to increase the price of bread? It appears to me that not only is it hitting the sound foundations of taxation but it is likewise hitting the ordinary rules of modern justice. I do not think this House should vote for a tax which is going to bring want into many households and absolute destitution and hunger into others. The areas in which I am particularly interested, the areas on behalf of which it is my bounden duty to raise my voice in protest against this tax, are areas that receive no benefit from the wheat subsidy. The subsidy on wheat has helped the rich and fertile areas but it has been of no assistance to the unfortunate persons in the poverty-stricken areas who are endeavouring to eke out a livelihood on the less fertile, non-wheat growing, areas of the State. You are subsidising the better-off people at the expense of the poor. That is the policy which is being adopted by this measure.
I shall assume on his own behalf that the Minister for Agriculture hates this change in the incidence of taxation as much as any decent-minded man can hate it. I dare say, and I shall assume on behalf of the Minister for Agriculture, that before this change was made, he exhausted every persuasive effort with the Minister for Finance. I shall assume all that, and I shall assume that the Minister for Finance, unable to make ends meet, unable to balance his Budget, turned round to the Minister for Agriculture and said to him: "You cannot get a single halfpenny out of the general finances; you will have to follow the policy which we are told is the Fianna Fáil policy. You will have to go wherever you see a single halfpenny to take, and wherever you see an article that can produce taxation, tax it. Wherever you can see an article that cannot evade taxation, because it is a necessity of life, that is the right and proper article to select for taxation." That is the doctrine we heard enunciated from the back benches of Fianna Fáil. That is the doctrine to which the Minister for Finance, at any rate tacitly, has given his approbation. It is obviously in pursuance of that doctrine that the Minister for Agriculture has been forced to change the incidence of the taxation which is producing this subsidy.
I put it to the House: are you going to have subsidised wheat on the one side, and want on the other? Are you going to have subsidised wheat and to have starving women and children in this country? Are you going to have subsidised wheat and to have children reared without proper food, without proper nourishment, driven off the bread standard on to a potato diet? Is it better to let wheat grow unsubsidised and to have a sound, growing population or is it better to subsidise wheat and to have a stunted, underfed population? I do not think this House recognises the real gravity of this Bill. I do not think this House and I do not believe that the Executive Council themselves recognise the real cruelty, because it is nothing less than cruelty, of imposing a very heavy bread tax at the present moment. As has already been pointed out by Deputy Professor O'Sullivan, by direct taxation this year the price of bread is being increased. There is also the fact that the price of bread has been greatly increased already for those who bake their own bread because of the increase in the price of flour. It is a cumulative increase. This is adding to it further. Certainly, anybody looking at the social side of it must consider that the Government are doing a grave and serious wrong. I would ask the House in all sincerity to regard this tax in its true light. For once do not be led away entirely by Party discipline. For once do not let the Party whip absolutely drive you into what you yourself know is wrong-doing. Do not impose this cruel and heartless tax upon the members of this community who are least able to bear it, who are not only least able to bear it but who cannot bear it at all, who will be driven to go altogether without the staff of life, without wheaten bread.
Comment on this
I desire again to offer my opposition to this measure. I am not a bit surprised that the Minister for Agriculture last night moved the closure and compelled the Dáil to sit this morning, because by doing so he has cut down a good deal of the discussion on this Bill. A great many Deputies who were opposed to this measure, and who went home yesterday evening, were under the impression that the Dáil would not sit later than 12 o'clock last night. I do not think it necessary for me to take up much time of the House in speaking on this measure. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney has put the matter very clearly. He represents a constituency which is very similar to mine. I, too, protest against putting a tax on the poor people of my constituency in order to maintain the people on the better lands in other parts of the country. Discussing this question here within the last month, and its effect on the country generally, I asked the Minister for Agriculture, who boasted that next year we will grow 200,000 acres of wheat, what it is going to cost. I asked him what it cost per barrel last year, and he said 6/6 per barrel. I then asked him how many barrels he allowed to the acre. He said seven. I pointed out to him that his own published figures were eight barrels per acre, and that, taking the yield at eight barrels per acre and the subsidy at 6/6 per barrel, it would mean that there would be a subsidy of 52/- on every acre. I asked him who was going to pay this. Dr. Ryan said that the taxpayer paid it last year, but now they were going to put it on the consumer. That appears to bear out the statement of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. As Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney put it, the man with £5,000 a year will pay less under this tax than the poor unfortunate labouring man with seven or eight shillings a week.
That is the policy sponsored by the Government and the Party behind it. I would follow no Party when it comes to a question of standing for the people I represent, and I put it to the Deputies on the back benches of Fianna Fáil whether they are representing their constituents in voting for this measure. Flour, as everybody knows, is already about 15/- per sack dearer in the Free State than it is in Northern Ireland or in England. That is a terrible burden on poor people. I know that there are unfortunate poor people who, formerly, were able to buy a sack of flour, and who now have to buy it in halves. I am prepared to give evidence of that if the Minister is willing to set up an inquiry into it. When my Party was in power certain steps were proposed in regard to a matter of this kind, and I stood up and said: "If you do this, I am going to vote against you. I am going to stand for the people I represent, and I am not going to tolerate the placing of any extra burden upon them." I stood against that then, and for that reason I am going to vote against this Bill, which will bring a lot of hardship to unfortunate poor people all over the country.
Comment on this
I am going to vote for this Bill. I am sorry I have to part company at the end of the week with some Deputies here. Though I have been in their company throughout the week, I have been in their company through conviction, and not because of Party ties. Like Deputy O'Leary, when it is a question of national economic policy, no Party fetters would bind me, even if I were in a Party.
Comment on this
I have as much objection to this Bill as the Deputies who spoke against it but not from their angle. My objection is that it does not go far enough or in the right way in dealing with the extension of wheat growing. But it does go in that direction and it is for the Bill or an alternative which would be an opposite I have to vote. Hence, I am voting for the Bill. I failed to follow Deputy Professor O'Sullivan's contention, that this is a bread tax. It is nothing of the kind. Deputy O'Leary often sold milk below the cost of production. If a Bill were introduced to give him the cost of production, would he call it a milk tax?
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, I was not discussing the cost of production. I was discussing the hardship on the people. If the Minister wants to subsidise wheat, let him subsidise it from the Central Fund.
Comment on this
If the Deputy had to sell his milk below the cost of production and a Bill were introduced to give him the cost of production, would he say that that was a milk tax? Would he say that it should not be paid by the consumer but should be paid out of the Central Fund, as a subsidy, to bridge the gap between what he could get for his milk and what was an economic price?
Comment on this
So long as he got it, we would not hear anything about it.
Comment on this
The people never had to look for subsidies from any Government until this Government came in. If they restored to-morrow the markets we had, we could tell them to keep their subsidies. That is the policy I stand for and that Deputy Belton, in his heart, stands for.
Comment on this
That is precisely the policy I stand for but I am dealing with circumstances as they are. I am not dealing with the view I would have under other circumstances. To fix upon an economic view for to-day, we must consider and weigh the economic circumstances of the day.
Comment on this
I am sorry the Deputy did not follow up that point. I was dealing with the point which Deputy O'Sullivan endeavoured to make—that this was a bread tax. It is a bread tax if Deputies accept the doctrine that they should not pay an economic price for any commodity when they can get that commodity dumped from foreign countries at far below the cost of production. Which should be the basic price—the economic price or the dumped price of a surplus?
Comment on this
If you, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, are prepared to allow me to discuss that question, I shall do so.
Comment on this
I shall not allow Deputy Belton to go very far on that line. He is raising a question as to the Government's policy in subsidising wheat, which question does not arise on this Bill.
Comment on this
I should not like the stigma to be on me, if it is to have a place at all in the public mind, that I voted for a bread tax.
Comment on this
It is a bread tax and nothing else. Did not the Minister say that it would be passed on?
Comment on this
If you go in and buy a new suit you have to pay the trades union rate of wages. That charge is passed on to the consumer. I am not concerned with Fianna Fáil policy. In 1928, before there was any sign of Fianna Fáil becoming the Government of this country—and, if it were in my power, I would not allow them to become the Government—I used these words at an agricultural congress:
The Department of Agriculture should be requested to instruct committees of agriculture to endeavour to treble the wheat crop. There will be no difficulty in obtaining this increase if the Government at once pass legislation providing that from and after the 1st November, following, all flour sold in this country must contain at least 15 per cent. of home-grown wheat.
Comment on this
My friend Deputy McGilligan also refers to a tax on bread. The tax on bread seems to be the outstanding point made here. It was the whole point of Deputy O'Sullivan's argument. As one who proposes to vote for this Bill and who has done so all along, except on one occasion when I made a mistake, I want to clear up that point. Incidentally, reference has been made to the 6d. on imported wheat. That is a bread tax so far as it goes. I hold that the farmers are entitled to an economic price for their wheat.
Comment on this
Why, then, do you vote for the Government? They will not give an economic price for anything owing to their policy.
Comment on this
These questions are too big for discussion now. We can deal with all these points on the Agricultural Estimate. We are circumscribed now and the Leas-Cheann Comhairle is watching. I shall not go outside the bounds, though I may go to the border-line. Deputy O'Leary said that his constituents were opposed to this Bill. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney said the same. It would be very hard to govern if every Deputy looked merely for such legislation as would suit his own little bit of the world. I put this to Deputy O'Leary that we have an export trade in cattle and in milk products, etc. The part of the country for which Deputy O'Leary and Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney spoke is more suited to the raising of these products than to the growing of wheat, but do they realise all the wheat land that is competing with them in producing live stock?
Comment on this
On a point of explanation. Is Deputy Belton aware that the people in the wheat-growing part of the country are better off than the people in the poorer parts, and that the people in the poorer parts are producing store cattle for which they can get practically nothing to-day?
Comment on this
Deputies should realise that the matters that Deputy Belton is endeavouring to discuss do not arise on this Bill.
Comment on this
I was simply dealing with some points raised by previous speakers. Is it not obvious to Deputies that when you narrow down the production of an article you help the fellow who is allowed to go on with its production? Therefore, when you take away from cattle raising the land that is now engaged in that form of production, you automatically increase the productive value, for cattle raising purposes, of all the land not suited for wheat growing.
Comment on this
We discussed that before, and there is no use in getting into it now. I want to discuss the question of wheat growing that is before the House. It was, perhaps, wise enough, though I never believed in it, to subsidise wheat growing for a year or two, but it is now getting a bit out of hand. When you expect to have 30,000 or 40,000 acres of wheat grown in a year, you can fix a price for it, leave an open market to the producer for millable wheat, and have the difference by way of subsidy to be made up by the Central Exchequer. That is all right for a year or two until you see how the experiment will work. I understand that this year we are going to have at least 25 per cent of our requirements grown in this country. Therefore, it is quite obvious that the time has come to make a change.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy not now dealing with the Government's general policy of a wheat subsidy? Surely he knows that has already been decided.
Comment on this
But does not this Bill make a change? Instead of a subsidy it is proposed to pay on the loaf. I submit that I am dealing with that change over.
Comment on this
Personally I would prefer if what is proposed in this Bill had been in operation from the beginning. Therefore, I am in thorough agreement with the change over. Deputy McGilligan, whose intelligence I certainly do not question, seems to say that that change over is from what you may call free bread to a tax on bread. At any rate, that point was made by Deputy O'Sullivan. The point that I want to emphasise is that the Minister in this Bill is fixing a price for wheat that he considers economic. I do not. I plead guilty to a certain degree of negligence that during the passage of the Bill I did not take steps to express what, in my opinion, would be an economic price. But certain things happened in my private life that called me away, and it was then too late for me to do anything. I did press on the Minister, on an earlier stage, that he might do something on the matter, but I am afraid he was not as warm on it then as he seemed to be on a previous occasion.
The Minister in this Bill is providing 27/- a barrel for wheat. I suggest to him that he might as well have put in £27. Whether the Minister intended it or not, that figure is the merest eyewash. The Minister must know from his personal experience and from his experience as Minister since he became definitely interested in agricultural politics, that wheat bushelling 64 lbs. is not the rule. There are exceptions, of course, but you very seldom get that. Would the Minister tell us how many samples of wheat bushelling 64 lbs. he had last year? Therefore, that can be cut out. If the wheat does not bushel that amount, the 27/- will not be paid, so that what we come down to is about 23/6 a barrel. We can take that as the average price. I do not consider it an economic price, though I admit it was 9/- or 10/- a barrel more than the average price of wheat on the world market last year. But that world price last year, and for some years past, has been fixed by the surplus wheat on offer.
At the end of the year 1926-27 there was a carry-over of 184,000,000 bushels; in the year 1928-29 it was 454,000,000 bushels; in 1932-33, 625,000,000 bushels; in 1933-34, 589,000,000 bushels, and in 1934-35—the year 1934 was a very dry year—the carry over was 310,000,000. The reason why wheat was so cheap on the world market was because that surplus had to be dumped. The real explanation is that the world's greatest authorities say that they cannot fix on any stabilised price for wheat. Owing to last year being a dry year, and the measure taken to push wheat for live-stock feeding, in order to reduce the carry-over, and also the subsidies to people in wheat-growing countries not to grow wheat——
Comment on this
This has nothing to do with the killing of calves. It was the violent change in the economic system had to do with that. The change was too violent.
Comment on this
Until there are no surplus stocks left, there will not be an economic price for wheat. It has been advocated by Deputies O'Sullivan, Bennett and O'Leary that world prices should rule our market. They said that we should take the basic price as that at which the world ranchers are prepared to dump wheat into this or any other market. The difference between these Deputies and myself is that I will not take that basic price. I will not even take the line of the Minister for Agriculture but, in preference to what they want, I will vote for this Bill.
Comment on this
The Deputy said that the price of bread last year was so much, and that there would be an increase in the price this year because there would be a bread tax. Then ipso facto the Deputy is basing the basic price upon the price that obtained last year, and that price was dictated by the world's surplus stocks, which they wanted to dump.
Comment on this
There is the big principle, whether the consumer of the article should pay an economic price, or whether we are to collect it in general taxation, letting the Central Fund pay a subsidy to make up the difference between what the consumer would pay and the economic price. The Deputies who preceded me take one view and I take the other view. I endeavoured to give my reasons to Deputy Bennett, but he does not agree with them. That is the position.
Comment on this
The price of wheat has gone down gradually since 1926-27, as surplus stocks increased. These surplus stocks increased because the wheat consuming peoples are consuming less per head than they did ten or 12 years ago. The open spaces of the world produced more wheat as national economics on such lines developed. These agencies combined to bring about the glut. That glut had to be unloaded and as a result we had the bread price here and in England last year at the unloading price. The question the House has to decide is, are we to vote for a scrap price for wheat as the basic price because wheat ranchers want to unload stocks, or are we to fix the basic price, and consequently the price of the loaf, on the economic price of wheat grown here? We are only going a quarter of the way towards an economic price. The most sanguine expectations are that we are unlikely to get beyond 25 per cent. of our requirements this year. Assuming that the Minister's figure is an economic standard—I do not hold that it is—the average selling price will be about 23/6 a barrel. We could buy all the wheat we want at 14/- or 15/- a barrel. We get only 25 per cent. at 23/6 and we pay 14/- or 15/- a barrel for the other 75 per cent. That will bring us a quarter of the way towards an economic price. The more wheat we produce the higher must go the price of bread. From the little knowledge that I have of the world's wheat position, I am satisfied that within five years no wheat will be grown under 25/- or 26/- a barrel. Other people want to get a fair price for wheat just as we do. Deputy Bennett has experience of wheat-growing in Canada and he knows that 14/- or 15/- a barrel will not pay for wheat grown there. He knows that wheat cannot be got there for human consumption at 14/- or 15/- a barrel. Wheat cannot be got at that price in Australia or in any wheat-growing country. The peoples of the world are taxing bread consumers in order to fix an economic price for wheat. The only fault I have with the Minister for Agriculture is to the nature of the wheats grown here, the price given, and the bushel weight required. I wonder if I am right in saying that substantially the top yield last year was about 60 lbs. to the bushel.
Comment on this
The Minister took a big bite when he said 64lbs. The last yard is the hardest in a race of 100 yards. A man who minds his crop, and does everything humanly possible to get 62lbs., finds that it is much easier to get the first 60lbs. than to get the last 2lbs., and that it might be beyond him to get these 21lbs. I suggest that the Minister should seriously consider raising the price for wheat-growing. Many people who are against this whole principle of wheat-growing consider that if we are going to grow wheat there should be a fair price paid for the crop. There is a good deal to be said for that point of view. I am sure the three Deputies who spoke against wheat-growing will agree that if we must grow wheat there should be a better price than is being given. I do not think the price offered is a fair one. I intended to deal with that on this stage. I was asked by Deputies who had to go to the country not to overlook it. I mentioned on a previous stage that the Minister should, even in this Bill, offer an enhanced price next year for hard wheats. Curiously, I had a letter from a man, who I did not know was farming and who is farming in Western Canada. I received that letter since the debates on this matter started here, and he criticises very adversely the danger of our going in for the growing of very soft wheats in this country and the danger of filling the land with disease if we are not careful as to the kind of wheat we grow. I think that the Minister should consider that aspect of it at once. That, I think, covers all the ground that I meant to touch on.
Comment on this
Deputy Belton's speech was marred by two glaring fallacies and by a whole heap of lesser mistakes. The first fallacy is that, as a matter of theory, Deputy Belton apparently makes no distinction in his mind between a price brought about by the artificial mishandling of politicians and a price brought about by a natural economic law. Apparently, he sees no difference. I see a big difference, but I see a bigger difference than that in this matter, and the whole Bill turns on this point. I refer to the iniquity of off-loading the sacrifice that you must get in any of your legislation on to a commodity that is used to sustain life at its most primitive point.
Comment on this
I am told that last year we had free bread; at least, if I say that and if it is wrong to refer to it in that way, I can say that we will have taxed bread in this coming year.
Comment on this
All right. Let us say that we had sweated bread. Considering modern development, I do not believe that this country is ever going to be able to produce wheat at the same rate at which the mineralised earth and the hot sun of Canada can produce it.
Comment on this
I have read Griffith, but that has to do with other times and other conditions. If Canada were to go back to the primitive stage of our wheat growing, then we might be able to stand competition, but with recent development and the breaking up of huge tracts of land, I do not believe it will be possible for us to compete. It was the breaking up of one area in Northern Canada, about three miles wide, and bringing it into cultivation somewhere about the years 1919 or 1920 that brought about the glut to which Deputy Belton referred.
Comment on this
If the Deputy would consult the agricultural instructors, they would tell him the facts. We could stand comparison with Canada at a time when everybody grew wheat in the same way. As one of these instructors put it on one occasion, the growing of wheat was back-breaking work; it was done with the hand and the foot.
Comment on this
It was back-breaking work, and it was back-breaking work again when it came to gathering in the harvest. You are still in that position in this country, whereas, against that, in Canada you have huge farms where they have tractors dragging 15 or 20 machines.
Comment on this
I do not quite know what the Deputy means by that, but I agree that there is a heap of water in this country—even in the land of it— and that there is very little sun here, and a heap of it in Canada. You have only to scratch the Canadian earth, and you will be able to raise a wheat crop. Canada has its difficulties at times also, such as when there is a sudden rush of disease in the wheat, but that occurs only very rarely. I do not believe that the time will ever come when this country will be able to produce wheat at the same rate as we can import it at. If and when that time comes, we will grow wheat.
Comment on this
Yes, I would believe it if I saw it in print and if I had the print analysed and explained, but it is ludicrous to believe in the possibility of wheat growing simply because, at one stage of our history, before other countries had developed, we had grown wheat here. It is ludicrous to found a policy on that assumption. You might as well say that, because there was a time in the world's history when this country grew the best rushes for strewing on the floors, we should do away with carpets and grow rushes to be used instead of them. It is just the same as to ask "What do we want carpets for?" That is the hair-shirt policy which certain people in this country would like to have as the fashion, but modern conditions do not tend towards that. Modern conditions tend towards getting the best the world can give us, and economic nationalism is against that trend.