Public Business. - Agricultural Produce (Cereals) Bill, 1935—Final Stages.
Contributions 138–277 of 277. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 10 of 1935 ›
I do not know about that. I believe it was so, but I believe that in these ancient times it was the case of Malachi wearing the collar of gold and not a case of someone going to collar the gold, as it is now. I am against a tax on bread. That is the main thing in this. I agree with Deputy Belton that agriculture generally ought to get an economic price which it is not getting. But what you are trying to do now has already failed in Russia, and that is, you are trying to produce in this country an urbanised industrial population and you are trying to rear that urban population on the back of an impoverished farming community. Nowhere has that policy succeeded. It did not succeed in Russia. The ordinary farmer, on whose surplus the industrial community had to be reared, soon ended that problem by going out of surplus and back into subsistence. That is what happened in Russia, and if our farmers do that and go back into subsistence, we will have no surplus, and what the urban population is going to be reared on, whether money or goods, I do not know.
Leaving that aside, however, this is the problem at the root of the whole economic change that is being attempted here at the moment, and anybody who reads modern history—even the history of the last seven years— will realise that it can never work. It can only work under the conditions which obtain in Russia at the moment. You can make it work, as in Russia, by a system resembling Black and Tan squads and sending people to prison and to exile, and so on, because they will not produce a surplus and because they will not give up that surplus when the urban community want it. You have not got to that stage here yet, but you will have to get to that stage if you are going to try to make the farmer produce without an economic price. I think that there is a great deal to be said for letting the consumer bear his full whack of the burden. If you want to test the reaction to the policy being adopted now, put it directly on the bread. That is the way to bring it home to them. Let us look at the impact of this. Every person who is living on money that he earns is going to feel the impact of this as a tax. You are definitely down now to the necessity point. You are breaking in on every man's standard of living. You are breaking in on every man's wages. You are hitting at this urbanised community when you tax bread. You are hitting at the miserably poor wages of the people in the country.
Comment on this
Yes, everybody eats bread. This compulsory levy hits at everybody. Suppose you said to every man, woman and child—because it must be remembered that the child is affected, too—in the country, "We will take so much from you in the year," there would be an outcry. If you were to propose that people who are earning £1 or 30/- a week would have to pay 1/- or 1/6 there would be an outcry. You are certainly doing that in the bread tax. The calculation has been made here, and not denied, that you are helping about one farmer in eight by your wheat subsidy. We hear comments on all sides that the subsidy is not enough. It has a good reaction on one farmer in eight, and it has no possible reaction on the town population. But the town population and the eight farmers are to go on paying for it while the subsidy goes to one in eight. If it were possible to get this help in some other way, if it were possible to put the tax on a luxury, it should have been done. It is clearly not possible. The price of bread will go up. The price of bread, of course, has gone up. There are three things affecting the price of bread; there is the revenue tax on wheat this year, there is the tariff on flour, and now we have this question of wheat. Those three things are all putting up the price of bread. Why should bread have been picked out? You have only to let your imagination run a little bit to see that bread is the thing people should keep most away from when there is a question of tax.
Comment on this
It is eventually on bread that the tax is paid. The object of this Bill is to make bread bear the tax.
Comment on this
Let us get to the question of paying an economic price when we are tackling the whole matter of economic prices for the agricultural community. What is happening at this moment is that an economic price for a product that is going to be grown by one farmer in eight is being charged against the whole community, town and country dwellers as well.
Comment on this
You are not giving it to the rural people; you are giving it to one in eight, and the other seven out of the eight as well as the whole urban community are paying.
Comment on this
Let us take the figures. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney talked of the comparison between 1933 and 1934. It is much more educative if you take a comparison between 1930 and 1934. The figures for wheat and oats in those years are 670,000 acres and 677,000 acres—a difference of 7,000 acres between the two years.
Comment on this
No, because the suggestion is that what happened is just the same as what happened in the sugar beet area around Carlow—that there was no new tillage. What happened was that the people went into sugar and out of something else. The suggestion here is that the people have gone out of oats into wheat.
Comment on this
As between the three, it has gone up from 786,000 acres to 819,000 acres, a difference of 33,000 acres.
Comment on this
Not at all. Bread is to be taxed. I think bread comes into every phrase you can think of that deals with poverty, or a low level of life. The people who queue up for food in America are called the people who go into the bread line. The first thing they have got to get to sustain themselves is a bit of crust. When Germany was at war, and when there was the impact of the blockade, what was supposed to be the way in which that most injuriously showed itself on the population? They had to turn from the ordinary wheaten bread or even ordinary rye flour bread to potato bread, which was regarded as a substitute. When people were boasting of the effect of the blockade they boasted that the Germans had been driven to this potato bread. Later, when the Germans themselves wanted to show the terrific hardship and inhumanity of the blockade, they always pointed out that they had to go off bread. The phrase has been used here that bread is the staff of life. In the case of a tax on incomes, there is always a certain amount of the income exempt from taxation. There is the subsistence point; you have your £150 or £170, or whatever the figure is, and that is the amount which a man is supposed to spend on food for himself and his wife and children. It is spent mainly on bread, and the lower the level of life is at the more of a particular income is spent on foodstuffs. You have only to go to the cost-of-living figure to see how the index is arranged here; you will find that great weight is given to foodstuffs. From calculations made on a variety of small incomes, it was found that the lower was the amount of money coming into the household the greater was the percentage of that money which went on bread. We are deciding that that is what is to be taxed.
Comment on this
Like the Deputy's conversation—terribly dry and ugly to the taste. I should like to hear any person who represents an urban community—a community in which there are tenement dwellers——
Comment on this
——justifying a tax on their bread in order to provide a subsidy, of whatever type it may be, to one in eight of the rural community.
Comment on this
Will you get the trade unionists to advocate the use of goods produced under sweated conditions?
Comment on this
This matter of dumping is one which we have heard spoken of theoretically here. We have never got the concrete issue faced up to.
Comment on this
As far as I am concerned, if we could get the wheat with which Canada and other parts of the world are now glutted, in here without any imposition of duty, I believe that by selling the bread at the figure which it would reach, and by paying a pension to the farmers who were attempting to grow wheat in this country, we would be better off. We would be better off by paying them something for doing nothing.
Comment on this
I do not believe in taxing the people of this community for ten years in order to meet the theoretical danger that Canada might raise wheat at a particular point. Wheat must go up some time, but that it is going to go to a point which would make it economic for us to grow wheat in this country I do not believe.
Comment on this
No; he was right in his day. Arthur Griffith himself, towards the end of his life, and he was quoted in this House, said he did not think his propaganda writings, dated to a certain period, should be used in an attempt to solve modern problems.
Comment on this
Economics distinctly, and he was talking particularly of protection. Supposing we were back in the good old days of the sending out of marauders, aggressor parties, that we could conquer a certain part of Canada, enslave a certain number of the Canadian citizens and put them at work on their land to grow wheat for us at a miserable pittance for themselves. Suppose we did that through the strong arm of conquest, would anybody object to our getting the benefit of it in the shape of almost free bread at home? Why do you object now to what previously the strong arm of might would have brought into play? Just envisage that. Why should we prevent ourselves getting the benefits of very cheap food if it can be got willingly from the people who grow that food?
Comment on this
I cannot see any objection in that procedure; that is, the problem of taking the commodity that can be produced in such circumstances that it can be sold cheaply here.
Comment on this
The Deputy seems to fear that this country might not have enough food if there was a war on. What would be happening in this country if there was a war on? We would be simply glutted with food.
Comment on this
That was not meant for this country. This country was never as well off as in the days when Britain was blockaded, because they got their stuff from us; and the compulsory tillage order was not for the purpose of getting more foodstuffs for this country but to get more foodstuffs grown here for England. That was the advantage of our insular position. I am speaking of commodities that can be grown elsewhere and that can come in here at a rate less than they could be produced at here. So far as the bounty is concerned, one always fears the bounty, because eventually the bounty will be withdrawn and then we will have to face the blast. As long as the sun gives heat in the proportion it does to Canada and to this country, this country will not be able to produce the wheat at anything like the cheap cost that applies to Canada.
I am prepared to depend, so far as wheat and bread are concerned, on the Canadians and if ever any danger arises I know we will have plenty of food in this country; we will not have any deprivation; and if Canada raises her prices we have our own resort after that. I certainly am not going to go in for that foolish policy of insurance of having wheat grown for 20 years at a nonsensical figure here, because the contingency may arise that Canada may find it necessary to curtail her supplies or raise her price. We can meet that devil when the time comes. We are not going to do any better or any worse in regard to wheat than what the world experiments have shown. Most of the countries that went in for wheat are now trying to get out of it. France, which was the leader, passed a law preventing any development of wheat; definitely there is a law preventing it.
Comment on this
And, on the 98 per cent., the calculation has been made by French economists, and it was never denied in their Parliament, that it would pay them better to vote the money and give it to the French farmers for doing nothing than to put it into wheat growing. The only thing that prevents them doing that is that they have their unfortunate peasants used to this, and there might be a revolution if they tried to stop it. But it really would pay them better to give that money to those peasants and tell them not to grow wheat. That has been stated in the French House.
Comment on this
It is not a strange theory. It is all worked out, and it is as clear as the daylight. The same thing has happened with regard to industrial alcohol factories. The best expert opinion based on those things after the war was that if they blew them up they would be better off. That expert opinion was passed as sound. Of course, England did not go in for that sort of nonsense.
Comment on this
The wheat-growing in England represents three per cent. of their agricultural economy.
Comment on this
It might have been a good policy in certain areas, but it represents three per cent. of their total agricultural economy. At any rate this Bill is definitely putting a tax upon bread, and I object to that. If I was going to be cynical about it I would welcome it. When you are trying out a tax of this type, referred to as a subsidy, possibly the best way of having the reactions of it understood would be to say to the people who consume the article: "We will teach you what it is to grow wheat. You will pay for it in your bread and we will make you pay." If one were to adopt that attitude, one could welcome this Bill.
Comment on this
Is it not a good thing to let the people decide whether they will have that policy or not?
Comment on this
Perhaps it is a good thing to bring it home to them in that way, but it is a harsh thing to bring it home to them by means of a tax on their bread. Here is the way I would like to envisage this as happening. Let us introduce a new system. You have unemployment insurance and national health insurance, in connection with which cards are stamped. What about a wheat-subsidy stamped card making everybody, just according to whatever their income is, put stamps on the card, labelling these wheat-subsidy stamps? You would make it a little bit clearer to the people then. Every man would know what it means. Very few now realise what they are getting from it. By such a method we might get it to the people's heads after a bit what they are paying for. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said that the price of bread is not up by so much. That is not the question. Has it gone down as much as the ordinary economic law would permit it to go? That is how you would get at the difference in what you are paying for your wheat; and that is what the stamps on the wheat card would show you. If you could get it that way there would be nobody then I think who would be willing to vote for this subsidy. But if you take the other point and say: "Let us pay the least, particularly when it is to be dragged from everybody and let us use the less payment for letting these men idle and let us get our wheat in from beyond——"
Comment on this
The same would not apply to boots and ready-made clothing. That is the argument that is thrown out so often—that there is nothing that comes into this country that could not be produced cheaper elsewhere. That matter has been dealt with by economists. I think the great American statesman, Alexander Hamilton, was the man who had the best social theories? He had the view that you cannot allow your own people to be a mere pastoral people. He held that even with a cost to your own people you have got to get a certain range of activity and there is no doubt that in this country we have a consuming community for clothes and boots and certainly for a number of other things which ought to make it possible for them to be produced here. Even if they are not being produced as cheaply at home as abroad it may be for an otherwise very desirable reason. I do not object to things being dearer here if the community benefits by their being produced here.
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy means by a social tax but I do not see that there is any proof that the community is getting any benefit by this tax on bread. There is reason to believe, however, that a certain number of people, employers and their families are getting a benefit. But look at the £4,000,000 wages bill. It has been increased by only £25,000. That surely ought to make strong tariff reformers sit up and take notice. I am in favour of taxation on these things that can be produced at home if it is shown that that is going to give additional employment but the position under these tariffs is that that is not so as we see from that £25,000 increase on a wage of £4,000,000.
Comment on this
See how quickly I will get back to it. I do not believe in any tax to get the people of this country rooted in agriculture. That is because of the fact that they are already rooted in agriculture.
Comment on this
We had a good deal here to-day about majority rule in this House. But we must have majority rule governing this country in other ways too. I would like to have the majority, or somebody representing the majority, tell me that they are satisfied to pay this subsidy. I would like them to tell me why it is better to pay a subsidy in relation to wheat and in relation to the people's bread. How is it fair or right to ask people in the back streets of Dublin or in the slums of Cork to pay a tax on their bread for the benefit of one farmer out of eight farmers in the country? There are certain parts of this country that never can get any benefit from this tax on wheat.
Comment on this
If so many acres are taken in the Midlands for the growing of wheat, it means that there will be less grasslands left in the Midlands and less competition with the grasslands in the West of Ireland.
Comment on this
The cattle graziers in the West are to get more benefit because they will be able to raise more cattle in the West. Is that the argument?
Comment on this
I will let the agriculturists ponder on that argument and leave it for the moment. Why tax the man in the back streets of Dublin and in the slum areas of Cork and the other cities, and why tax the bread of their women and children—why tax the thing that they must get to sustain their lives in order to give this benefit to one man in eight amongst the farming community?
Comment on this
Why tax the farm labourers throughout the country in order to give a bigger price for boots and ready made clothing to the people who produce these in Dublin?
Comment on this
If the agricultural labourer is going to give a big price to the boot and shoe manufacturer at home, and to the maker of ready made clothing, I am against it. But if the making of boots and ready made clothing is to give a big benefit to the urban population, I am for it. When you make it possible for the urban population by a tariff on these things to get more wages, of which the community as a whole will get the benefit, that is a different matter. Boots and shoes are a bad thing to take, because everybody must wear them.
Comment on this
Boots and shoes are not on the same level as bread. At a pinch people can go without boots, and even when they are nearly worn out you can mend them, but the people have to get their meed of bread every day if they are to sustain their lives. I do not know to what point we have been reduced. We have to choose most the taxes that do not press on us. The reason why we have this Agricultural Produce (Cereals) Bill dealing with this matter is easy enough to understand. I can understand quite seriously the orders given by the Minister for Finance at the beginning of the present financial year. I can understand his saying to his colleagues: "You must lighten the boat." The poor old ship was waterlogged and the tax had to be put on bread and butter and something else, and something had to be got out of the Unemployment Assistance Fund and out of the old age pension. I can understand the Minister for Finance saying: "Do not let me go into the Dáil to face them with all these taxes. You will have to get the money out of bread and butter and unemployment and all the other things." That is why this Bill has come up here as a special Bill and why the Government is making a change over from subsidising wheat-growing out of the Exchequer. The Minister had got to rid his Budget of these subsidies. The water was pouring in and all hands were needed at the pumps and he had to lighten the cargo. There used to be an old poem about "...a loaf of bread beneath the bough, A flask of wine, a book of verse... And thou. And Wilderness is Paradise enow." Look at the change we have made—Spanish oranges without juice and a bread tax in the Finance Bill for 1935. Deputy Donnelly may think that that is as near paradise as he can get.
Comment on this
What are the agricultural community getting as a result of the increased price that the people have to pay for their bread? What are they to get; are they to get employment, or are they getting an increase in their wages? In so far as we can get an interpretation put upon the statistical information that the Minister for Agriculture gives us for the three years during which this policy has been pursued, we find that the agricultural community are getting a rate of wages and that in so far as the type of agricultural labourer that you expect to see getting an increased wage by measures of this kind we find, in fact, that they are getting less and, further, we find that permanent employment amongst the agricultural labourers is becoming less. I would like to ask the Minister or any member of the Fianna Fáil Party, or even Deputy Belton, who is watching this wheat experiment with plenty of interest, to tell us that the agricultural labourers throughout, say, the Province of Leinster, where so much of this subsidised wheat crop is grown on top of the subsidised beet crop, that the agricultural labourers are now as well off as they were when this policy was started?
Comment on this
I would like to hear that argument pursued and hear of the things that would make their position worse; and whether all the Minister's figures for last year have shown that the farm labourers' position is to be better next year. If we take the provinces, we find from official statistics that the wages of agricultural labourers in Leinster were down by 3/- per week in 1934, as compared with 1931, the year before this experiment was started; that in Munster they were down 4/-; in Connaught, 2/6; and in the three counties of Ulster, 3/-.
Comment on this
This Bill is changing it in such a way as to hide the enormous and growing cost to the people. Up to the present we were able to say that this experiment was costing, say, £192,000 one year, and £300,000 the next year. No one knows what it will cost in the year to come.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan says this will make plainer what it will cost.
Comment on this
According to the way it works out. I do not see how it is going to be plainer to us how much this is going to cost when every halfpenny to be paid will be paid across the counter on the loaf. We may know when we make a careful calculation. But we were told in a simple way up to this every year by the Estimates what it was going to cost. So that while the cost is going up in such a way that the Minister has to hide it by taking it off his Estimate, less wages are being paid than before the experiment began. County Wexford, if we take the increase in the beet area and the wheat area since 1931, is growing one-sixth of the total increase in the 12 counties of Leinster. Leinster itself, as well as growing two-thirds of the increased beet crop, is growing over 50 per cent. of the increased wheat crop. So that if the results of this particular policy are to be seen any place in the province of Leinster, they ought to be seen in Wexford. But the Minister knows that the County Committee of Agriculture in Wexford three months running in the beginning of this year appealed to the Government to apply the free beef scheme to agricultural labourers in Wexford. For what reason?
Comment on this
Because, as was stated at the County Committee meetings, the average wage for agricultural labourers in Wexford was 8/- per week and their food.
Comment on this
The Minister has had many months to point that out to the County Committee in Wexford.
Comment on this
The County Committee of Agriculture three months running appealed to the Government to put the free beef scheme into operation in respect of agricultural labourers in Wexford, on the ground that their wage was 8/- per week and their food.
Comment on this
On the ground that there was too much beef in the country.
Comment on this
The Minister will have an opportunity of getting details with regard to that, and we will have another opportunity of giving them to him. That is the case that was made before the County Committee for the giving of free beef. So much for wages in Wexford where, as I say, one-sixth of the increase in the beet crop and one-sixth of the increase in the wheat crop of the whole province of Leinster was grown, and Leinster grew 50 per cent., of the new wheat since 1931, and two-thirds, or about 64 per cent., of the new beet. What is the position with regard to employment? In County Wexford, there were in 1934——
Comment on this
This is an amending Bill, which does not deal with the wheat scheme, but with an alteration in the wheat scheme. The main provisions of it are, fixing a new cereal year, fixing the percentage of Irish-home-grown wheat to be milled, and the minimum price of home-grown millable wheat. I find it very difficult to see how the percentage of wheat and beet and the agricultural wages paid in Wexford are related to these three matters.
Comment on this
This Bill also shifts the cost of this scheme from the Estimate of the Minister for Agriculture on to the people, and hides it in the loaf and the price of flour. When dealing with a measure that takes the cost to the people from a place where we can examine it, and throws it directly on to the public in a way in which we can only imagine what the size of it is, are we not entitled, when taking up the attitude we do, that the cost of this scheme is increasing, that it is increasing so much that it has to be hidden from the people as far as possible, to ask whether the results of this scheme are worth the increased cost at all and, particularly, worth putting the cost of it in such a way that the people cannot readily understand what the cost of it is——
Comment on this
It was also in your programme at the last general election.
Comment on this
I am asking the House to take into consideration that, while the price of flour and bread is being increased to the community, and machinery is being set up under this Bill to hide the cost of it and change the incidence of it, we get no results either in increased wages or increased employment for the agricultural community. If I refer specifically to County Wexford, it is only to point out that Wexford is a county where this scheme, if it is bringing benefit to the farmers, should be bringing it to the farmers and agricultural labourers in the clearest possible way. I want to point out that wages are down so that the agricultural labourers in Wexford are reduced to the position that I have pointed out. As far as employment is concerned, there were less permanent agricultural labourers over 18 employed in Wexford last year than there were before the scheme was brought into operation. If we look a little bit further we find that there were 1,630 more agricultural labourers over 18 years of age permanently employed in 1934 as against 1931. There were 54 less in Wexford. But when we look at Westmeath we find there were 192 more employed there. There was an increase in the permanent agricultural labourers over 18 years employed in Westmeath in 1934 and a decrease in Wexford. Westmeath is a place where the Fianna Fáil writ does not seem to run at all economically, whatever about politically. It is neither touched by the beet scheme nor by the wheat scheme, yet we find we have an increase of permanently employed agricultural labour there.
Comment on this
Compared with Wexford there is little. There is an increase of 1,500 acres in Westmeath; in Wexford there is an increase of nearly 7,000.
Comment on this
What were the figures in the three previous years?
Comment on this
In 1934 there was an increase in Westmeath of 1,469 acres—from 71 acres to 1,540—but when you come to Wexford the increase was nearly 7,000 acres—11,544, as against 4,628 in 1931.
Comment on this
Only an increase of 100 per cent., whereas in Westmeath the increase was nearly 1,600 per cent.
Comment on this
In Westmeath in 1931 eight acres were under beet, and in 1934 31 acres—an increase of 23 acres. In Wexford in 1931 there were 2,047 acres under beet, and in 1934 6,125 acres, or an increase of 4,078 acres.
Comment on this
Beet has nothing whatever to do with this Bill; neither has the number of labourers employed or unemployed in the different counties. That argument would be equally applicable to beet or any other agricultural produce, and might be reviewed on the Estimate for the Department. The Bill does not deal with the wheat scheme, but with a change in it, and the Deputy is not entitled to go into the employment or unemployment figures for beet and wheat all over the country.
Comment on this
I only mentioned beet because it was a matter that might give rise to increased employment. Over the whole country there is only an increase of 1,700 labourers employed. But in Wexford, where the whole incidence of the wheat crop falls, there is a decrease in agricultural employment. We have nothing to show that there is an increase in agricultural employment given or any hope of anything, but a falling off in agricultural wages. In this Bill the Minister is asking us to shut our eyes and put our hands into our pockets to give more for this scheme.
Comment on this
I think it should be quite obvious to Deputy Mulcahy, or any other Deputy, that they do not want to quote the statistics that are available here. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney compared the acreage of wheat and beet and left barley out. Deputy Mulcahy quoted Westmeath, where there has been an increase of something like 2,000 per cent. in the area under wheat, and then he refers to Wexford, which is a big county and where a man could put ten or 12 extra acres under wheat without having to employ additional labour. In Westmeath, if a farmer goes into wheat at all he must employ extra men. It is obvious that if we were to get our 800,000 acres of wheat a big increase would have to be made in the employment of agricultural labour in counties where there is no tillage whatever. If Deputy Mulcahy knew a little about the intricacies of agriculture he would know that if a farmer has three or four men employed for a number of years he may till ten or 20 acres, while in other years he may till 40 acres without having to give increased employment. Ten acres make little difference. If a Wexford farmer increases his tillage by ten or 12 acres it does not necessarily mean any extra employment.
Comment on this
The wages should be better, and I agree that that question of wages must come up for review in a very comprehensive way before long. Deputy McGilligan made a statement, by way of reply to an interjection from this side of the House, that if there was a blockade, or a war, we in this country would not have any trouble in getting food in. Our real trouble, he said, would be in getting food out. I contend we would have trouble in getting food in. We all remember the Great War. Everybody will admit that it was a most unpleasant experience going into a hotel in Dublin and being only able to get a spoonful of rice, while, of course, being able to get plenty of potatoes and other vegetables. That is the position we would be in again in the case of a blockade or a great war. Before the Fianna Fáil Party came into power 11,000,000 cwts. of maize were imported. We have not enough carbohydrates in this country, while we have too much meat and too much beer. But a man must have some carbohydrates, and it is not true to say that we would suffer no inconvenience if there was a blockade.
To deal with the points raised by Deputy McGilligan, I must take his arguments backward. He says we cannot grow wheat in competition with Canada. I say we have a much better yield than Canada. They have all kinds of trouble with their crop in Canada. They have the trouble of disease, the trouble of frost and the trouble of drought. We never have the trouble of drought and frost with our wheat. Our wheat grows through the heaviest frosts and is never injured. In Canada they have to put down their seed before the frost, or otherwise their whole crop is gone. Very often in Canada they have only ten days' margin to sow their wheat. Our position is that we can start to sow in September and we can continue until April. We have seven months for our crop more than they have in Canada. Yet one would think, hearing Deputy McGilligan, that they had most admirable conditions in Canada compared with ours here. I think the crop we grow here is up to the world's standard. Statistics will show that we get the very best yield for good quality wheat. Our farmers are not working under any conditions of slavery. They have plenty of time to put in their wheat, and plenty of time to reap it too. Whether they are getting a sufficient price I do not know.
I said at another stage of this Bill that nobody knows what the price of wheat should be. We are in a position to hire our men at the street corner, put them at the plough and, again, we have them ready to sow and reap the wheat. The farmer must use the men he has for various things. He cannot possibly give costings for each individual crop. It is only after years that the farmer can give an impression whether the crop is paying or not, and it is only then that we will be able to find out whether the farmer can go on growing wheat at this price. These are the only tests.
Some of the figures quoted by Deputies on the other side were absolutely outrageous. They selected certain special figures to try to prove their case. That is an old trick. Perhaps dishonest is too strong a word to use but it certainly is not fair. Anyone could select figures, some here and some there, and use them to try to prove his particular case. But they are not prepared to hand them over to the other side to have them examined and their true meaning discovered. Deputy O'Leary said that flour was 15/- a sack dearer here than in Great Britain. These are the kind of figures we hear quoted to bolster up shady cases. If it is necessary to bolster up cases in that way, or to indulge in exaggerations of that kind the cases they are intended to support must be very poor indeed.
One would imagine that the Opposition were against wheat growing from the way they spoke, but, at the last general election, whether they were against it or not, they told the farmers that if they returned them to power they would continue the wheat policy. If they are against it, it was very dishonest to say that at the last general election, because a political Party— even the Fine Gael political Party— should have a little more morality than to say to the farmers that if they were returned they would continue the wheat policy, although they disapproved of it. Either that or they are dishonest now, because they are trying to make out that they are against it, even though they were in favour of it in 1933. It may be that the result of their promise in 1933 has made them a little sour about the whole thing but, at any rate, the fact is that in 1933, at the general election, they were in favour of the wheat policy and now they are against it. We do not know why that change was made.
Is this a bread tax? I do not know whether you would call it a bread tax or not, but call it a bread tax if you like, if it is going to increase the price of bread. I agree absolutely with Deputy Belton, and I think it is scarcely necessary to restate the case as he stated it, that if you want to give an economic price to our own producers, whatever it may mean in the price of the finished article, the consumers have to put up with it and it is really scarcely fair to refer to it as a bread tax. There is no doubt that everything we consume here, whatever Deputy McGilligan may say, is dearer than it would be if we were to throw our ports open to imports from other countries. Our consumers are paying a tax on bacon. We could get much cheaper bacon than our own from other countries. If we threw our ports open and allowed bacon to come in from outside, our consumers would get cheaper bacon. Because we are making them pay more through a tariff, they are paying a bacon tax.
The same applies to mutton. We have a 6d. a lb. tariff on mutton, and, in spite of that, last spring, lamb was imported into this country, paying the 6d. tariff, so that the consumers of mutton and lamb in this country are paying a mutton tax. They are also paying an eggs tax. Take the Shannon scheme as an example. Some people hold that the electricity from that undertaking is dearer than it could have been got by other means— by steam or as it was being provided in Dublin City. The people in Dublin are paying more for their electricity. Are they paying an electricity tax? Why was that not paid out of general taxation, and why were the people not allowed to have electricity at ordinary economic rates? All these things are taxes, if you like, but there is no reason why we should talk about a bread tax any more than anything else. With regard to the fixing of this price, from the figures returned in the Department last year—and we had to get returns from every individual farmer as to what his wheat bushelled —we found that 60 lbs. a bushel was the average and, therefore, we put in 23/6 as the price of 60 lbs. of wheat. There was a good amount of wheat up to 62 lbs., but very little, I believe, over 64 lbs.
Comment on this
There was at least a little —I do not know how many samples, but at least a few. Whatever we may make the price of wheat bushelling 60 lbs., we should at least give a graded price until we come to 64 lbs., because if Deputy Belton, for instance, succeeded in growing wheat bushelling 64 lbs., I am sure he would be disappointed if he did not get a little more than the person whose wheat bushelled 62 lbs.
Comment on this
Deputy Belton said he was anxious to insert an amendment to increase those prices. Those prices are in the Bill in order to implement the Orders made by the Executive Council already with regard to guaranteed prices for the harvests of 1935 and 1936. They are the minimum prices already settled by the Executive Council. It is not necessary to insert any amendment in this Bill to enable the Minister or the Executive Council to increase that price. We cannot go below it.
Comment on this
The Executive Council can at any time make an order increasing them. If Deputy Belton could convince me that a higher price would be advisable and if I, in turn, could convince the Executive Council, there would be no necessity to amend the Bill at all, because an Order would be sufficient.
Comment on this
Use your influence in that direction. Deputy O'Sullivan said that farmers had told him that the average bushel weight of wheat was about 58 lbs. That is not right. Deputy O'Sullivan must be in touch with a rather poor class of farmers. He should consult some of those hardworking farmers who mind their own business but vote Fianna Fáil, and he will find that they have much better wheat.
Comment on this
Is the Minister sure he is consistent in that—"who mind their own business and vote Fianna Fáil"?
Comment on this
I think it is quite all right. After all, we do not take up very much of their time.
Comment on this
In conclusion, I want to say that I find it very difficult to understand the opposition to this Bill which has been worked up during the later stages. On the Second Reading, we had a very friendly discussion here and everybody appeared to be satisfied and the Bill went through without a division. On the Committee Stage, a little opposition arose and, I think, there were a few divisions against the Bill. The Fourth Stage appeared to go fairly smoothly again but, on the Fifth Stage, I think we had the greatest opposition, in length of time at least, whatever way the vote will go.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?