We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Business. - Finance Bill, 1935—Committee (Resumed).

Contributions 1–166 of 334. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 15 of 1935 ›

I understand that the Minister for Industry and Commerce runs away from the attitude taken up by the Minister for Finance. Whereas the Minister for Finance, because he requires additional income, increases the tax on footballs, the Minister for Industry and Commerce considers that this tax is for the purpose of further developing an Irish industry, namely, the manufacture of footballs. Yet, he considers that Irish footballs cannot be manufactured except under an increased tariff of 40 per cent. When it was pointed out yesterday that the effective tariff on footballs at the present time is 25 per cent., the Minister seemed to indicate that footballs were being produced satisfactorily under the 25 per cent. tariff, but now he takes up the attitude that a 40 per cent. tariff is necessary in order to develop the industry. From the manner in which the debate on these taxes is being carried on, nothing is clearer than that the intention of this tax and of the other taxes that we discussed yesterday is to squeeze additional money out of the people's recreation: that having squeezed as much money as they can out of the people they will have nothing left either to provide homes for themselves, or if they have homes, to carry them on.

Comment on this

This tax which is being imposed is obviously a revenue tax. The Minister for Industry and Commerce may succeed in satisfying individuals such as the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance and others who have not got, perhaps, intelligence of a very high order, with his appeal to their limited intelligences that this 40 per cent. tariff is necessary. But I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce cannot expect the man-in-the-street, the man of ordinary intelligence, to accept his view that it is necessary to have a tariff of 40 per cent. in order that the manufacture of a very simple article like a football can be carried out here. If the Minister for Industry and Commerce expects the man-in-the-street to believe that I think he is going a little too far.

I always admire the courage of the Minister for Industry and Commerce when he gets up to speak in this House. In some respects he is one of the most courageous men in the House. He will get up and say anything. He does not seem to be restrained by any sense of what the public think of him and of his estimates. I think that on this occasion the Minister for Industry and Commerce should take us a little into his confidence, and tell us how this estimate was arrived at and what authority he has for it. It appears very unfair for the talking Minister to give way to the dumb Minister. At any rate, the talking Minister can explain his own point of view, but the poor dumb Minister cannot get up and explain that it is a revenue tax. I do not think that is playing the game. There may be a very round-head member of the Fianna Fáil Party, but it is not quite fair to mistake his head for a football and to kick it around when the poor dumb head is prevented from talking. I would ask the Minister to explain how he arrived at the opinion that this 40 per cent. tax is necessary.

Comment on this
Seán F. Lemass Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

There is no tax on footballs: only on football covers. The wind is still free of duty.

Comment on this

I would like to see a football without a cover.

Comment on this

I do not know what made the Minister for Finance pick on footballs for this tax. There was a time, perhaps, when some Fianna Fáil Deputies played football with part of the intestines of a pig. Perhaps the Minister intends to drive people back to that crude method of enjoyment, by taxing leather covers.

Comment on this

To bladders.

Comment on this

What I am surprised at is that the Irish air is not being taxed in order to make it a little more expensive. I suggest that one way of improving this industry here would be to buy a few footballs and to get some of the Deputies on the back benches opposite to take part in a match. They might be profitably engaged playing football on the lawn when they are not taking part in the debates. At any rate, it would be physical exercise for them.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Will you select a team to meet us?

Comment on this

A team can be selected from amongst Deputies opposite. I daresay some of them have played the game. This tax, like all other taxes in the Budget, was put on in haste and without any thought. There is no suggestion that it will put a number of people into employment. If the Minister thought it would he would get up and boldly face the Labour Benches, and tell the number of people he was going to put into the occupation of making footballs.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Are Deputies to be allowed to discuss this matter without interference from the benches opposite?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There should be no interference with debate.

Comment on this

I cannot prevent Fianna Fáil Deputies having their laugh. I believe the day is coming when there will be an end to the laughing, if I am any judge of the political barometer.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Barometers have nothing to do with this question.

Comment on this

No. The time is not far distant when the Fianna Fáil smiles will be ended. If I wanted to encourage this leather industry I would buy a dozen footballs and select a team. I would make Deputy Kelly full-back on one side and Deputy Donnelly on the other side. I would then get half-backs and would pick on Deputy Flinn.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

To select those teams would not be in order now.

Comment on this

If I was to leave out the question of leather covers for footballs, and if football was to be played with the intestines of the animal I mentioned, I am afraid the physical capacity of some Fianna Fáil Deputies would break up. We are compelled to talk about leather, so that I must get away perforce from the football played with the intestines of the animal mentioned. We discussed sections of the Budget as well as we could, and put some of the difficulties before the country. We could not do so sufficiently, because we had no help from the Government Benches. It would be impossible, without having documents that are at the disposal of the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce, to produce material to bring the full effects of these taxes before the people. If Ministers and Deputies opposite are going to treat this House with contempt, especially on measures that concern the finances and the economic condition of the country, then it is useless to be sitting here. One would think that on measures like this Deputies connected with the farming community would not allow the House to be treated with the insolence with which Ministers have made up their minds to treat it. Deputies opposite should remember that they have a duty to the House and to the country. They were elected to do their duty, to see that money was spent in the right way, and that the people were not mulcted in taxes. The tax on footballs is a small matter, but sometimes a straw shows the way the wind blows. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance especially should concern himself to see that the financial burdens on the people are reduced. I hope there will be a further discussion, even about footballs, because taxes of the kind should not be put on without some consideration.

Comment on this

I should like to congratulate whoever is responsible for putting in the particulars dealing with the subject matter of the tax. Legislation by reference is very confusing and one is unable, without tediously looking up the references, to find out what articles are referred to. Can the Minister say if this change in the rate of duty on leather footballs covers anything else?

Comment on this

No; only football covers.

Comment on this

The air is free.

Comment on this

Does a water polo ball come under this proposal?

Comment on this

Leather football covers.

Comment on this

A water polo ball is not a football, as the Minister would know if he ever got a blow of one in the face. There is a considerable difference between a football and a water polo ball. Am I to understand that football covers are subject to a duty of 45 per cent., and that water polo balls are subject to 25 per cent.? I will be glad to hear that water polo balls are not included, because they are not made in this country. There is a trial water polo match at Blackrock baths to-day, and a team is coming from Belfast. I suppose if the cost of water polo balls is dearer here, Belfast teams will bring down balls for the trial. That shows how necessary it is not to put an undue burden on the community, especially on articles that are not manufactured here.

Comment on this

I would like the Minister to assure us that there is no possibility that the Revenue Commissioners will confuse footballs with water polo balls, and that the rubber portions will not be taxed. I take it that the leather portion only will be taxed.

Comment on this

There is no tax on bladders.

Comment on this

I refrained from using that word in the House. I did not think that we should name such intestines.

Comment on this

We have "blathers" for export.

Comment on this

As the Minister has descended to vulgarity, I want an assurance that these particular articles will not be taxed, because, if he does, then even the poor children down the country will not be able to fall back on the old time method of enjoying themselves.

Comment on this

I should like to know if the Minister has satisfied himself, before this tax was put on, that there will be no increase in the cost of the production of football covers, because they have been made here for a long time and have been made very well and can hold their own in competition with imported covers. This particularly applies to football covers used in Gaelic football, although it may not be so pronounced with regard to the football covers used in Rugby and Soccer. I think the Minister should bear in mind that a big proportion of the footballs used here are small-sized footballs used by boys, colleges and children. I do not think that any of these have been made in this country up to the present. I think that the manufacture has been altogether confined to the large-sized football cover, and unless there can be some assurance that the price will not be raised by this tax, I think it would be a serious thing that the children's and boys' amusement is going to be seriously affected by this tax. That would only mean that it is going to be another tax on the health of our young people. I would ask the Minister if he has had any assurance that the effect of this tax will not be to raise the price, and seriously raise it, over the price of the home-made commodity.

Comment on this

It is quite obvious, surely, to Deputy O'Neill and to all of us in this House that the object of the tax is to raise the price. What is it put on for except to raise the price? If Deputy O'Neill and I were engaged in the manufacture of footballs, we would be revising our price list this morning with a view to raising the price.

Comment on this
James Ryan Minister for Agriculture (Dr. Ryan) Fianna Fáil

Why would the Deputy do that?

Comment on this

What does the Minister think? Of course we would raise it. The Minister gives his time for natural love and affection everywhere.

Comment on this

I take it that the Minister will give us the effect of what he has said about water-polo balls.

Comment on this

I said nothing about water-polo balls. The duty applies to the same classes of football covers to which it applied always. It is not a new duty.

Comment on this

I asked the Minister was this item intended to cover water polo balls and I was told that it did not. Now I am told that it does.

Comment on this

The duty covers exactly the same items as always.

Comment on this

What did it cover before? Does the Minister know?

Comment on this

Subject to your ruling, Sir, I understood the Minister to say that water-polo balls were not covered under this. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is not responsible for statements of Ministers or Deputies.

Comment on this

Am I incorrect in that?

Comment on this

I am afraid I cannot answer the Deputy. As I said, the duty applies to the same items as hitherto.

Comment on this

I suggest, Sir, that an opportunity should be given to the Minister for Industry and Commerce to learn the meaning of the Bill.

Comment on this

I can tell the Minister that water-polo balls were covered by the duty before. Does the Minister mean that they will still be covered by this?

Comment on this

The position is precisely the same.

Comment on this

Although they are not manufactured in this country?

Comment on this

All that class of work is manufactured in this country in adequate quantities and by a number of firms.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give me the name of a person who manufactures a water-polo ball cover in this country? The Minister need not be afraid to give a well-deserved advertisement to anybody who does manufacture them.

Comment on this

There is a list of the firms in the Industrial Directory.

Comment on this

I say that there is not one of these firms that makes a water-polo ball cover.

Comment on this

Surely, it should be possible to provide that such a well-defined article as a water-polo ball would be exempt from duty and to arrange that such articles, not already covered by a previous assessment, should be free of duty. Furthermore, the Minister said, and made a kind of a joke about it, that it is only the covers or cases that are taxed, whereas he will see from his Order Paper that it refers to footballs, and not to covers or cases. Accordingly, we will have to have a change made, if the Minister is correct, in order to show that the duty refers to leather covers or cases, and not to footballs. The Minister should assure the House with regard to that matter and let us know definitely what is affected by the duty.

Comment on this

There is nothing affected except what is mentioned here in the Schedule.

Comment on this

But that is just the point. It is not mentioned here.

Comment on this

Well, we should tie the Minister down to it.

Comment on this

Oh, tie him down be damned! You might as well try to tie any of the members of the majority Party down to anything they have said. Obviously the Minister does not know what is embraced in this particular tax. Instead of the Minister telling Deputy Dockrell, Deputy Dockrell had to tell him, and the only excuse he has is that this is not a new duty. The Minister himself does not know what the duty covers. It does not matter whether the people have to pay or not: so long as the fault was committed before, it can be committed again.

Comment on this

And increased.

Comment on this

Yes, and increased. Again, no excuse or explanation of the increase is offered. We have tried to din it into the Minister— one of the few who attend and who try to deal with the situation, I must confess—that he is doing no service whatever to any Irish industry by the policy he has stood for in this House during the last two days.

Comment on this

This is another revenue tax.

Comment on this

Yes, it is a revenue tax, but the Minister pretends, and his Party, whenever they have opened their mouths, have pretended, that these are protective tariffs. They are nothing of the kind. They are much more calculated to do damage to industry than to help it. I hope I will not be accused of gross impertinence if I say that I refuse to accept the mere fiat of the majority Party in this House on a matter of that kind. The House should be allowed to make up its mind for itself and the House should not allow itself to be used merely as a conduit pipe for putting into effect the temporary will—the hastily conceived will, as I conceive these taxes to be—of the majority Party in this House. This House has certain rights and ought to assert them on every occasion like this—the few occasions, such as this, when it gets a chance. The House ought to reject this tax unless there is attempted at least some defence of the policy behind it. The Minister has not done so. He has refused to do so. He has not refused information. I must say that he does give information when he has it, but he has not the information, and he has been unable to justify this tax in a satisfactory way. It may satisfy some, but, after all, the minority are not bound always to accept the mere fiat of the majority Party in this House, and therefore we ought to get some explanation of this tax.

Comment on this
Division

Question—"That reference No. 10 proposed to be deleted, stand"—put.

Tá 52
·
Níl 24
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 52:—

In Part V, to delete reference No. 12, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 and 4.

This is another of the many duties which involve an increased cost on persons in the building industry. It proposes to extend to pillars and posts made of cement a tariff of the same nature as is already imposed upon blocks and bricks made of cement. It puts it on in such a way that licences can be issued to certain people to import these things free of duty. I should like the Minister to tell us what is the necessity for imposing this heavy tariff on such pillars and posts, and who are the people who are going to be allowed to import them free of duty while other people have to pay a tariff of 50 per cent.?

Comment on this

The extension of the existing duty upon cement bricks, blocks and slabs to posts is, I think, logical. The construction of these posts is a very simple matter and there is no reason why they should be imported. It may be necessary temporarily to permit importation in Border areas until local production is organised, but after a little it is hoped the duty will effectively prevent importation.

Comment on this

In those areas where the shock of the rise in price is likely to be too great——

Comment on this

No rise in price is anticipated.

Comment on this

In such areas these articles are going to be allowed in under licence free of duty, but where people are a little away from the circumstances that would indicate the effect of the trend of the Minister's policy, these people are going to bear the whole burden of this particular tax right away.

Comment on this

While the Minister is on that point, I would like him to inform the House if these are ornamental blocks or are they very plain?

Comment on this

The plainest of the plain.

Comment on this

I think there is great force in Deputy Mulcahy's point why they should be allowed in under licence at one point more than another.

Comment on this

I do not think we have yet joined issue with the Minister. I think we all could support the Minister's contention that concrete posts if imported should be subject to a duty, but it only goes to show how difficult it is in smaller centres to be in touch with what can be imported or manufactured in larger centres. For instance, the manufacture of articles from cement in the last few years has undergone an enormous increase. I imagine there are articles made the other side in different ways from what they are made here and in a way that probably a large number of people here are quite unaware of. The Minister says that this is to catch concrete posts. Having been caught on the last reference myself, I went back to the original duty and I found there "manufactured articles which in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners are bricks, blocks or slabs made wholly or partly of Roman cement, Portland cement, or any other hydraulic cement and have not been subjected to any process of glazing or polishing." I would have thought that if the Minister wanted to catch pillars or posts he might have said merely: "made of Portland cement."

When one examines the extension of this duty, one sees that here it applies to a slab which has not been subjected to any process of glazing or polishing. If you go back to the First Schedule, reference No. 6, you will see "surrounds, hearths, and curbs which in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners are of a kind normally used for fireplaces and are made and consist partly of tiles, bricks or slabs." You have a slab in one place which is subject to 33? per cent. and, in another place, it will be subject to 50 per cent. It is quite possible that a surround may not have been subjected to any process of glazing or polishing. I would like to point out to the Minister in reference to the duty on these surrounds that there is a two-fold object. I would have thought that 33? per cent. duty was enough protection of that article if the Minister does not continue to steepen up, as he has done under another section of this Bill, the duty on the raw tiles, the raw materials for surrounds. The Minister might say that he wished to keep out all surrounds.

Speaking for the people who would manufacture those things over here, or make them up, as it would be more correct to say—speaking in their interests I do not think when they have a high protective duty that they want to see a prohibitive duty put on. I will tell you why they do not want to see a high prohibitive duty put on them. There are a number of tile manufacturers scattered all over the earth. Some came over here and they employed very expert designers to make up these tile surrounds. Having shown illustrations of these, they are quite prepared to sell the raw materials to make them up and the position is really analogous to something like a person in the drapery line who would buy a Parisian model and afterwards make up a number of dresses in the same way.

Comment on this

And sell them all as Parisian?

Comment on this

Of course, I never heard of anything like that. I would like to suggest to the Minister that his policy ought to be to allow a high protective duty to the people who make them up, but not sufficiently high to prevent samples coming in which the people in this country can copy. I would like to urge that aspect of the case on the Minister. I would like to suggest to him that if it is only pillars or posts of concrete which he wishes to catch that there is a whole series of bricks, briquettes and other articles which will be the subject of an acrimonious dispute under this Schedule and that he ought to consider whether he could not see his way to revise this duty or do away with the anomaly of slabs in two parts of the Bill at one time and also to see whether he could not catch what he wants to catch by allowing in certain things which I do not think are any disadvantage to the home manufacturer if they are allowed to come in here as samples of what can be done in these surrounds.

Comment on this

The Minister, in reply to a question asked by Deputy Belton, said this tax was not to protect ornamental work but dealt with the very plainest of the plain, with pillars and posts. I would like the Minister to tell us to what extent the 5/- a ton tax on cement is responsible for this extension. He has not informed us as to whether it is responsible or to what extent it is responsible. Would the Minister give us some reason for this tax. Surely to goodness if we are not able to make the plainest of the plain in pillars and posts we are not able to make anything at all?

Comment on this

It is because we are able to make them that this tariff is put on.

Comment on this

If we are able to make them and produce them of a good quality, surely we ought to be able to compete with cement pillars and posts coming from any country. I suggest that by increasing the price of cement by a tax of 5/- per ton the Minister is operating to the disadvantage of the people who make them in this country.

Comment on this

Cement is cheaper here than in Great Britain or in the majority of European countries.

Comment on this

That is not the point. I am speaking of the 5/- tax on cement. The people who make these things in this country are now 5/- worse off than previously. They are worse off to the extent of 5/- per ton. They have that much of a disadvantage when competing against outside firms in the making of these pillars and posts. Does the Minister deny that?

Comment on this

Cement is substantially cheaper here than in England. There is no need to import these things at all. To me it is completely inexplicable why they do it.

Comment on this

The Minister denies that notwithstanding the fact that he has imposed a tariff of 5/- a ton on cement in the last few months, these people are as well able to compete against the import of slabs and posts as previously.

Comment on this

I say again that the price of cement here is much below the price in Great Britain.

Comment on this

That is not the point I am making, and the Minister knows it. I say it is going to cost them 5/- a ton more for cement now on account of the tax. Surely to goodness if we can make anything at all in this State we can make pillars and posts. They can be made by any ordinary tradesman in the country. Concrete pillars and posts are made in the main by the county councils and other public bodies. Is it to protect public bodies such as these against the danger of importing pillars and posts that the Minister wants this duty? Or is it another case of trying to scrape in a few shillings here and there? The Minister tells us that 5/- a ton tax on cement makes no difference whatever in the cost of producing cement posts and slabs. Now, that statement by the Minister gives one a good idea of the mentality behind this whole Finance Bill.

Comment on this

There was a very interesting point raised by Deputy Dockrell as to why this amendment of the Schedule is one that the Minister should bear in mind. Deputy Dockrell can speak on this matter on a plane of his own. That is because he deals with these things and in his own workshops they are assembled and assembled with care. He does a large business in these things and knows exactly what he is talking about. I have a little knowledge of these matters but nothing comparable with what Deputy Dockrell has. I say it would be a calamity when the country is just only starting to grow in this trade and where designs and plans mean such a lot, if the work-people engaged in the assembling of these things did not get a chance of seeing and examining the best designs that are in the trade. Deputy Dockrell and men like him can take a tour through the warehouses and factories in Great Britain and bring home ideas that will be of some national use and business use to him and to men like him. But it will take a long time to disseminate that knowledge amongst the people who, in the ultimate resource, would do the job. An intelligent workman seeing those designs would gather a lot not only as to the designs but as to the doing of the job. He would see how it could be made a strong job. I suggest that the Minister ought to bear in mind that suggestion of Deputy Dockrell's. It is the suggestion of a very practical man. The Minister ought to examine that and see if it can be of some practical service to him. When I first saw this Schedule 8 and reference No. 12 I thought it related to some polished cement slabs or things like that. I began to think that perhaps the idea was that we were getting out of the rough state here in the matter of these posts and pillars and that we were beginning to polish up cement construction. I was amazed to hear from the Minister that it was purely the roughest cement blocks and slabs and posts and that kind of thing that were to be covered. I thought that under no circumstances the Minister would consider it necessary at this hour of the day to put on such a tariff on these things.

Comment on this

It only shows one the size of the shock.

Comment on this

I cannot understand how the imports could compete here. For the ordinary job of pillars and posts the principal item is gravel. We all know that the price of gravel will not bear freightage where the very extreme limit with the best of transport is 15 or 20 miles. Otherwise, you are putting the cost up to a prohibitive point. I can see no reason for this tariff and I see no reason why if a tariff was required it should be increased. Surely we are getting more expert with these things. I am deadly opposed as a protectionist to increasing tariffs in cases where we are doing a job at these things already. If we are any good at all we should be doing the job well. This sort of thing is going to destroy industry and enterprise amongst our people. There should be a scaling ground and as soon as we get a foothold we should be getting level with the scale of prices. I do not say that our prices should be equal to the prices abroad. Taking into account our limited output we are working under disadvantages as compared with Great Britain. But after taking those things into account and allowing a margin for them we should be on a border line with the prices abroad.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton voted against every proposal put up here to protect Irish Industry.

Comment on this

That is a deliberate lie on the part of the Minister.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That statement must be withdrawn.

Comment on this

I withdraw it.

Comment on this

But the Minister has repeated that charge again and again.

Comment on this

I have great regard for the efforts the Minister is making, and except with the pace at which he is going, I agree with his entire policy. It is with the pace that I disagree. The Minister has an unfortunate kink of trying to misrepresent people——

Comment on this

There is no necessity for using the word "trying."

Comment on this

That is a fact——

Comment on this

Yes, it is a fact.

Comment on this

I am sorry I made use of that statement, but I challenge the Minister to point to a single division in which I voted against the development of Irish industry.

Comment on this

I said against the protection of Irish industry.

Comment on this

I am going to vote against this. In doing that, am I going to vote against the protection of Irish industry? I like an Irishman to be a man. I do not want him to be a sapling. I do not want him to be afraid to go into a cold wind. The Minister is only growing saplings here, and the first breeze they get, down they go. My whole attitude in this matter of protection is that I have supported it. I am supporting protection in this case by voting against what I consider unnecessary protection. Luxury and ease destroyed empires. When you are starting to climb, the one thing that will make you succeed is adversity, having to fight your way. The Minister is not putting it up to Irish industries to fight their way. I would make them fight their way from the start. The survival of the fittest always operates in the world. He is not going to make the people who are building up industry fight their way. He gives them too much protection. He said that there was no harness, no rough cement blocks, and other things coming in. It would be ridiculous to think that they could come in at all. Yet the Minister affords more protection to them.

I should like to hear on this or some of the other proposals to increase protection on articles in which we have control of the home market already the Minister's philosophy as to why, in such circumstances, an increased tariff to protect these industries is required. If the Minister does not keep those engaged in industry on the border-line of competition with outsiders then he is rearing up a plant here that some day will wither and die when it has to face competition. He told us yesterday that our own firms would compete in a market that we were only able to supply to the extent of 60 per cent., and that that was effective competition. I thought the Minister was a better business man than that—that he would not make such a fatal admission. Starting from that point, I am not surprised at the proposal here. I think it is only as a little bit of by-play to protect his own flank that he made that accusation against me.

Comment on this

What tariff did you vote for?

Comment on this

I voted for 20 per cent. yesterday, and you proposed 50.

Comment on this

You voted against them.

Comment on this

I am sorry Deputy Belton has seen fit to fall into the bad example of the Tralee Urban Council as regards the Minister. I am glad he withdrew, but they did not withdraw. I think they ought to. However, as they are not in Parliament, I suppose they have some rights left.

Comment on this

They tell the truth sometimes.

Comment on this

The Minister, I think, said that this was the logical thing to do.

Comment on this

Everything we do is logical.

Comment on this

I hope the cement blocks will be a little bit more consistent than the logic we have heard from the Minister. We have had a typical example in the course of the debate of the tactics of the Minister. He has put up no case for this increase, but because a Deputy—I admit a Deputy of the smallest Party in this House, but still a Deputy—gets up and, as a protectionist, objects in the interests of protection, he is accused by the representative of the majority Party as if he had no rights whatever in the House. Arguments have been put in this connection and in other connections, and the Minister has not met a single one of them.

Comment on this

I have not seen or heard or met one.

Comment on this

Or even attempted to meet one. Here is a very outstanding case. According to the Minister, cement is cheaper here than in other countries. The gravel and the other materials which are mixed with cement to make blocks are here, and it will not pay to import them. We have every natural advantage to enable these things to be produced here better and cheaper than elsewhere. The Minister did not even attempt to traverse that. Yet we have this duty of 50 per cent. proposed and no justification given for it. If there was ever a case in which the natural advantages played into the hands of the manufacturers in this country, this is one. The Minister has no excuse. But the Government have now got into such an extraordinary condition of mind that they cannot prevent themselves interfering in everything. I think it is really due to that. It is not merely that they desire to scrape out the last penny, although, of course, that is operative; it is due to the habit, of which we have had so many examples in the last couple of months, of being unable to let anything alone.

Here is a case in which the operation of the ordinary economic law would play completely into the hands of the people of this country. The Minister is not satisfied with that. He wants to give it a kick along; he wants to help it. But he is not helping it; he is interfering with it. Again, there will be the inevitable result of bad work if he continues this particular policy. If there are peculiar people in this country who prefer, despite all the natural conditions at the disposal of the makers of these articles, to import them, I suggest that that is not a sufficient reason for this unnecessary interference on the part of the Government. Time, experience, and costs will bring these people to their senses. They are much better mentors, much better advisers, much better teachers than the Government. I must say, however, for the Government, that so far as their economics are concerned, they are teaching the people of the country remarkably quickly. I think it would be much better to leave these things to the play of economic forces. You will have a much more healthy condition in the end. But the Minister cannot wait— things are too slow. In his haste he does not mind what damage he does.

Apparently, there are to be certain exceptions along the Border. He tried to give some explanation of that at a previous stage, as well as I remember. Is he afraid of smuggling along the Border; that people will slip over the Border in the dark nights with these pillars on their backs? The whole thing is so illogical, the thing refuses to stick together to such an extent, that the Minister really ought to try to put up a case to the House. At least he is not bound by the vow of silence and contempt for the House of his fellow-Minister. He is available here, and when he talks he gives information. I should like if he would attempt some justification beyond the mere parrot-like repetition that blocks are imported and that they can be made here.

Comment on this

Why are they imported then?

Comment on this

In my view you are doing more damage by your interference than anything else.

Comment on this

The Deputy is supporting an amendment to let these things into this country free of duty.

Comment on this

I am approaching the thing as it stands as well. We had great difficulty in discussing the operations of the Schedule yesterday unless amendments were put down. The Minister must be aware of that. It is extremely difficult, within the rules of the House, to discuss the Schedule unless amendments are put down. We hoped to get some justification from the Minister for his action. He has given none. This shows an extraordinary tendency to interfere with the people in place of letting the play of economic facts teach them. If there is anything at all to be said for the Minister's statement it is this: that the policy of the Government is bringing the people to their economic senses.

We have waited for an explanation and a justification of these two duties. No quantities were even given to us. The people are mad, according to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, but he does not understand that the Government's interference with the free play of economics has damaged industry, but, of course, if people do not agree with everything the Government does they are immediately shouted down.

Comment on this

This is a tax on posts and pillars, but it is doubtful if it can be restricted to posts and pillars. Deputy Dockrell looked up the principal Act and discovered that there were other articles besides posts and pillars included; and, therefore, they are included in the Schedule here. Another development of Deputy Dockrell's incursions on this Bill was that he found in various sections of the Bill there were differential duties. Certain articles were made the subject of duty in one section and not in another, so that it is clear that neither skill nor care was exercised by the Ministry in bringing these matters forward. Not only is there differentiation in duties, but there is also the danger of differentiation in the prices to be charged.

The Minister said that perhaps he would give licences for the introduction of some of these slabs. That only points to the danger of this tariff policy if it is not very carefully used. It allows an opportunity for differentiation and perhaps for graft, if anybody was unjust enough to operate the graft. We have the admission of the Minister that in border counties he may give licences.

Comment on this

Did he say on the Border?

Comment on this

I understood him to say that; and that is the very place where people would use the differentiation in price. People cannot be hoodwinked. The Minister said that this duty only relates to posts and pillars but so far as we can read plain English other things may be included as well. Obviously the Minister is only concerned with posts and pillars. Why he selected posts and pillars I do not know. The Ministry seem to change their minds altogether with regard to their programme. They have here changed from hitting people on top and now they use cement to hit people at the bottom. The agricultural people of the country are users of cement posts and pillars. Even though there is no tax the price will inevitably be increased on those people.

The Minister tried to get round the 5/- tax on cement and it is for that purpose that he is bringing in this in connection with posts and pillars. The manufacturers were subjected to an increase in the price of their raw material by a tax of 5/- and to recoup them for that the Minister is bringing in this amendment to the Finance Bill. That gives a chance to the manufacturers to pay the price if they wish to do so. With the increase of 5/- on cement it will certainly be dearer and the Minister is not going to hoodwink people into believing that posts and pillars are not going to be dearer than they were six months ago. Again I appeal to Deputies opposite to shake themselves up and to give us some indication that they have not turned into cement blocks. Let them show that they have not swallowed cement and that their tongues and insides are not congealed into cement.

Comment on this

They swallowed cement tombstones.

Comment on this

The speech that Deputy Dockrell made is the best proof that in discussing these matters a good deal of research is required. We have no help from the people responsible to this House. The occupants of the Front Bench opposite might have cement tongues for all the use they are in discussing this measure. Debates in this House have been reduced by the Government to a sorry pass. I did not think in this House or in any other Parliament in any other country in the world when a Bill of this importance was going through that no assistance would be rendered by those responsible for the measure.

Comment on this

This cement is a queer thing entirely. We get cement here cheaper than in any other country in Europe, and yet we are told that the people who make these pillars and posts require a protection of 50 per cent. It is a peculiar thing when one considers the details of it. Deputy Belton says that the main constituent of these pillars and posts is gravel. There is no inducement from the monetary side to bring in these pillars and posts if the Minister's statement is true. Yet a tax of 50 per cent. is to be imposed as a protective measure. That is queer enough. But it takes another turn. Imagine any commodity about which a statement can be made such as the Minister made when putting a tax of 5/- per ton on that commodity. Deputy Morrissey asked him whether the fact that there is 5/- per ton on cement has anything to do with this protective tax, and the Minister said it had nothing to do with it.

Comment on this

What has?

Comment on this

This is a most amazing business, because it is still cheap and, being still so cheap, 5/- a ton makes no difference. I wish we could get the range of these articles about which we could make the same statement, that 5/- a ton just makes no difference, with the same truth. Add these two peculiarities together and you find yourself in a bit of a mess when you come to decide, on a purely protective basis, as to the necessity for this. The Minister then said in answer to queries put from this side that cement is cheaper and that 5/- a ton makes no difference, so that we are still in the position in which the cement is cheaper and the posts are being manufactured here. We all know that and, remember, the constituents do not bear the cost of freight from the other side. So that there is cement cheaper, and certain constituents found here are protected by, at any rate, the cost of the freight of the made-up article or of the raw material here, and 5/- a ton makes no difference.

In all these circumstances, the Minister says that anybody who does not immediately swallow this 50 per cent. is against protection and against Irish industry. Finally, we are driven to ask: "Why let these in free?" For some inexplicable reason, some people are importing posts. Maybe, it is a matter of design. It may be that there is somebody who has something in the way of a design which certain people here using these pillars and posts for particular purposes desires. It may be that posts have been brought in here in order to get them commonly used so that whatever new design there is will be available here. But to the Minister it is inexplicable. His answer is: "Why let them in free?" But that answer would rule everything. Why let anything in free? You cannot argue on the basis of its being required to protect somebody because, taking it according to the standard here, the thing is so cheap, the raw material from which these posts are going to be made is so cheap, that 5/- a ton makes no difference and why they are brought in is inexplicable and how much is brought in has not been told to us. If the overwhelming argument is to be: "Why let things in free?" we should tax everything. It is not a question of having a Schedule like this; there should be a Schedule of the whole import list and against that should be put 50 per cent., because if it is not protection, it will bring in to a hard-pressed Government a bit of money. We can stand on the protection leg at one time and on the revenue-producing leg at another time.

On the argument used by the Minister, there ought to be nothing let in free and certainly the inhabitants of this country ought not to be allowed to buy anything cheap. We have also one argument put up in regard to the Border counties. We are going to have the possibility of licensing along the Border areas. This is a new device. We know, in the items taxed in the Budget, the anti-house construction items, but we did not arrive at this deep-laid plan about the Border. Apparently, the idea is that in order to entice the Six Counties to join up with us, we must make two or three counties near the Border as nearly cheap as possible as Six-County standards. That might have another repercussion. We might be enticing certain people in the Border counties to begin to think of the cheap lives they might have if they joined up with that area. Apparently, this is the new idea and the phrase which the Minister threw out probably explains quite an amount of what was hitherto rather inexplicable.

Why give licences for a whole lot of things? We have been querying that for a long time and it is quite likely that this Border argument rules more comprehensively than we imagine, because there is no doubt that people around this area can only know by report, and amongst the conflicting stories the Minister produces from time to time, they cannot always get a clear report, as to what is the difference in the cost of living here as compared with the cost of living in the Six-County area, but the people near the Six-County area will know. There is a certain amount of inter-communication between the two areas. The people along the Border areas get newspapers which cross the frontier and you have, therefore, notionally to drop that Border some two or three counties and have a midway zone in which people, by licence, are going to get the sort of cheapness that is apparent on the other side.

That is the new thought, and, as I say, it probably does explain the licensing system and its development, the whole idea being to prevent the impact of the increased prices being brought about to the people who would have the demonstration under their eyes of just what is the difference in the cost of living and the standards of living. The only explanation given was this matter of the Border. We are left to analyse that for ourselves, and, apparently, as I say, it means that people on our side of the Border must be handed off from the knowledge of what is the situation down here. That satisfies for a little bit, but then it fails, because if you do think of a sort of belt along the Border area, in which there will be a licensing system, and in which you will get the same sort of living conditions that they have in the Six-County area, by degrees, you will have to extend that border, because that belt has another border edging on it, and when they, in the operation of licences, get their pillars and posts and everything else that is going to be given under licences at the cheap rates they have in the Six-County area, the Border is going to move down and, by degrees, we are going to get a reconquest of this part of the country by Six-County economics, or, at any rate, by Six-County economic methods. That, in itself, is as great a condemnation of the so-called protection or economic policy of the Government as anything that has as yet been said.

Comment on this

I should like to tell the Minister that I am going to oppose this Schedule, because I see clearly that, by opposing this Schedule, I am opposing his imposition of a tax of 5/- a ton on cement. This Schedule only covers up this tax of 5/- a ton on cement imposed by Order a short time ago. Deputy McGilligan's philosophy of the conquest of the South fails, I should say, on about a 15 or 20 miles line from the present Border, because that is about the distance it would be economical to run these rough blocks made in the Six Counties south or into Donegal, and then the fellows in the South would be able to compete. The Minister said that in making these rough blocks the recent increase in cement prices has nothing to do with it. He said that cement is cheaper here than in any European country. I think he will accept the position that it is not cheaper here than in Great Britain or the Six Counties. They were, I think, about level, and, for revenue purposes, he put on a tax of 5/- a ton.

He says that does not affect the making of these blocks. Let us examine these blocks. About the poorest block you can make would range from a mixture of 5 to 1 to 8 to 1. Let us say 6 or 7 to 1. You put in six or seven tons of gravel, which will not cost you 30/-, to a ton of cement, which will cost you 30/-, without this tax of 5/- a ton, so that you have over 50 per cent. of the cost of the aggregate tariffed to the extent of 5/- a ton, which is about one-sixth or anywhere from 15 to 20 per cent. of an increase on half the cost of the material.

The Minister, yet, says that it does not matter. When you come to pillars and posts, the cost is more effective, because nobody would think of making a pillar or post with an aggregate of six, seven or eight to one. They will probably make it of three or four to one, and therefore two-thirds of the cost of the raw material is being subjected to a tariff of 16 to 20 per cent. Yet the Minister says that does not affect it. As far as I am aware, and I have made some inquiries, as I am interested in this matter, those blocks, pillars and posts are not made by machinery. They are made in frames or moulds. It is a question of one man taking off his coat and working hard and another man not working so well. The tariff on the raw materials is equal, the skill is about the same, and no machinery is required. It is a question of the man who will work against the man who will not. A tariff in a case like that is a tariff against efficiency, a tariff to protect inefficiency and laziness. There may be some pillars, posts or slabs of special design coming in here, but these are things that we should allow in here in order to learn new designs, just as in the case of the surrounds. The Minister is standing in the way of industrial development in concrete work by putting a tariff on these articles and leaving us here in, I might say, our ignorance, to try to develop. Some block-making machines are able to turn out more than others. You may have a man making blocks across the Border and another man making blocks on the south side of the Border. If the man across the Border works more intelligently and more efficiently than the man on the south side, the Minister says that we must impose a tariff to protect the lazy man on the south side.

It is not a case of mass production by huge machinery or anything like that. There are scores of people in and around the City of Dublin who will deliver 20,000 blocks in a few hours if you only give them an order on the phone. They may want protection, but the Minister is going to protect laziness, and he thinks that by doing that he is going to develop Irish industry. If there was mass production, big machinery or skill involved in this question, I would admit the necessity for a tariff, but there is nothing involved in the making of pillars or posts except to construct frames and fill them up with concrete. It is the fellow who throws off his coat who will produce the cheapest article; the fellow who talks about work, but who never does work seriously, will produce the dearest article. This is all pandering to laziness, this so-called effort to develop Irish industry. I say that industry can only be developed by hard work. The Minister asks any sane man to believe that increasing the cost of the raw material by 50 per cent. and the cost of the aggregate by 20 per cent. will not affect the cost of the article. There is no use in arguing against that, but we can vote against it.

Comment on this

I wonder which of two possible alternatives gives us an explanation of the Minister's attitude—whether the poor Minister for Industry and Commerce is suffering from mental atrophy, or whether he is deliberately keeping back something from the House. It seems to me that this proposed impost upon cement pillars, blocks, slabs and posts shows that one or other of these two things must be the explanation of the Minister's attitude. Either the Minister is suffering from mental atrophy, so that he does not understand or does not know what is happening in the Budget, or he is unable to explain the meaning of the Budget to the House. There may be some power behind the scenes which is pulling the strings and the Minister is merely dancing to them. Indeed, from the general tenor of the Minister's reply, in the course of these tariff debates, it would seem to me, from the want of knowledge of detail which the Minister has consistently and steadily displayed, there must be some other power behind the Executive Council. There must be some other persons who are dictating the policy of the Government. There must be some individuals from whom the Minister for Industry and Commerce is learning lessons and learning them extremely badly, so that he is unable to repeat them to the House. It may be that the Minister's mind has gone, that he is unable to understand things, or it may be that the Minister is keeping back something from the House.

I look at this reference and see that it puts a duty upon cement slabs, cement pillars and cement posts. Anybody who knows anything about the erection of pillars made of cement must immediately, I think, come to the conclusion that the putting of cement pillars into this reference is pure and entire imbecility. I do not believe that a cement pillar has been ever imported into this country or that it will be ever imported into this country. There could be no intelligent reason as to why a pillar, as distinct from a post, should be imported into this country. I do not know whether the Minister has ever seen cement pillar work but I am informed that the way in which pillars are made is that first you put up a framework, then you pour your liquid cement into the framework, you wait until it is set, you remove your framework and there you have the pillar. I hope I have now added to the Minister's stock of general information. To say that anybody is going to import a weighty article like a cement pillar into this country seems to be absolute imbecility. Yet the Minister puts forward a motion before this House with this imbecile suggestion in it. Therefore, I think we must lament the overthrow of the noble mind that used at one time to inhabit the framework of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Let us now come to the other two items, slabs and posts. What is the meaning of the duty on slabs and posts? If there is any sense in it at all——

Comment on this

There is no duty on slabs imposed under this reference.

Comment on this

"The words ‘or slabs' shall be deleted and the words ‘slabs, pillars or posts' shall be inserted." I am dealing with the words slabs, pillars and posts. I am dealing with slabs at the moment.

Comment on this

Slabs were always subject to duty.

Comment on this

I do not mind whether they were or not. I have dealt with pillars and now I propose to deal with slabs and posts. Slabs and posts are, to a certain extent, articles which can be transferred from place to place. What is the reason for putting a tax upon them? The only reason is that they can be and are, in fact, being imported either better or cheaper than the slabs and posts which are manufactured in this country. They are very heavy, rough articles and must bear the cost of carriage? Why should they be cheaper than the home article? I can see only one explanation. I shall accept the Minister's statement, for the purpose of argument, that cement is as cheap here as it is in whatever country these posts and slabs are imported from. What is the other constituent? Water. I do not think that one has to pay any price for water in this country and I may, for the purpose of my argument, leave out water. I come to the next constituent of cement —gravel or sand. Cement is equally cheap and water is equally free. The only reason I can see why home-made posts should be dearer than posts from outside is that there has been some sort of ring formed by owners of large and important gravel pits producing gravel suitable for the manufacture of cement. I can see no other reason why it should be possible to import these slabs and posts more cheaply than the price at which the home-manufactured slabs and posts can be obtained. That the owners of important gravel pits have got behind the Executive Council in order that, in certain areas, they may be able to form a ring and, by charging extravagant prices for gravel, put up the price of the completed cement articles to the consumer—that is the only explanation of the difference in price that I can think of. If there is any other explanation, I should be glad to hear it from the Minister. I do not agree with Deputy Belton that workers are not as good here or as willing as they are in the Six Counties. I would guarantee that the workers of my county—Mayo—would hold their own with the workers of any part of the world both in efficiency and industry.

If we have equally good workers—I think we have better workers than the others—and if cement is the same price, there must be a ring of some kind at work. The only ring I can see is a ring of the owners of the important gravel pits. If there is any other explanation, I shall hear it with the greatest pleasure from the Minister, because the Minister for Industry and Commerce does treat the House with courtesy. If an argument is put forward which he can meet, he does meet it. If requested to place facts before the House, he does place such facts as are at his disposal before the House. I regret that on occasions—the occasions are not the exception but the rule—the Minister's knowledge of his facts is lamentably small but, out of his poverty, he gives us what he can— the widow's mite.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That reference No. 10 stand."

Tá 52
·
Níl 23
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 53:—

In Part VI, to delete reference No. 16, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 and 4.

This reference purports to put a tariff of 50 per cent. on articles which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are heads or shafts suitable for use as component parts of the clubs or sticks mentioned in the preceding paragraph—that is, golf clubs, etc. The making of golf clubs gives a considerable amount of employment in various parts of the country in a small way, but nevertheless in an important way. The effect of the Minister's proposal is to put a 50 per cent. duty on the shafts coming in, and a 50 per cent. duty on the partly manufactured head. Again, this seems to be dictated by financial stringency of such a nature that we had to get a cement tax put on without any reference to or disclosure of the fact to the House. It is that sort of financial stringency to get additional revenue which is forcing the Minister to put on this duty on the shafts and heads of golf clubs that come in here for assembly. It is an inexcusable tax.

Comment on this

Very excellent golf clubs are now being made in the country. In fact, since Irish-made golf clubs came into general use it has been noticed that the standard of golf in the country has considerably improved. The Irish players are doing very much better in the international competitions than they did previously, and from what I have seen myself on various golf links recently, even the standard of golf amongst the members of the Opposition has considerably improved.

Comment on this

The standard of the Minister's golf in Portmarnock has not noticeably improved.

Comment on this

I am doing my best.

Comment on this

The Minister says that since the tax was put on the golf amongst members of the Opposition has improved. The point that I want to make is that this tariff, so far as I can see it, is going to affect professionals very much in the work they do in their workshops. It may be that this tariff is going to help some of the bigger firms that engage in the assembly of golf clubs, or even in their manufacture. I do not know that any firm is at the moment engaged in the manufacture of a complete golf club, but I do know that as a result of this tax the professional and his assistants attached to the various clubs throughout the country are going to be very badly hit. There is, as we all know, a professional attached to almost every golf club in the country. In some of the bigger clubs, the professional has two, and sometimes three, assistants. A very considerable amount of employment is given throughout the country in the workshops of these professionals.

Comment on this

The tax was first imposed as a result of representations made by the Irish Professional Golf Club Makers' Association.

Comment on this

Precisely, and this tax is going to hit them very severely, as I see. If, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, the blocks which come in for the golf professionals are a substantial part of a golf club, they will be taxed. In fact, everything coming in for the professional will be taxed. The result will be that the professionals will not be able to carry on their business in their workshops. In the golf club which the Minister frequents there is displayed on the walls an appeal to the members to assist the professional and to deal with him. Instead of taking that advice from the club that he belongs to, and that I belong to, the Minister apparently is taking advice from some manufacturer or other who is going to put the professional golf club maker out of business. As I see it, the professionals and their assistants are going to be put out of business by this additional tariff.

Comment on this

I wish to direct attention to the extraordinary change in the views of the Minister as to the ability of the Revenue Commissioners. One day they cannot distinguish between yarn and thread, to the great loss to the Revenue, and the next day they have to make up their minds—and we ought to know the extraordinary way they do it on some occasions—whether or not an article is substantially manufactured. That means that every individual is at the whim of the Customs authorities. Yet the Minister refuses to ask the House, when it could not trust the Revenue Commissioners, to distinguish between thread and yarn.

Comment on this

What is the difference?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It does not arise on this.

Comment on this

I submit that it is rather difficult to make a speech without giving an illustration.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The difference between thread and yarn does not arise now.

Comment on this

This is a good example of the incapacity of the Minister to deal with the matter, and the Revenue Commissioners are asked to define——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister asked the Deputy to say what was the difference between thread and yarn, and I pointed out that that does not arise.

Comment on this

The point made by Deputy Costello is a sound one. Whether the Minister does or does not pay any attention to the notice in the club in which he wastes his time I cannot say. There is not the slightest doubt that if there is any interference with a professional in being able to get material readily, and at a reasonable cost, the Minister is doing what he often did before—he is sacrificing the ordinary worker for one of his alleged factories. That is the point made against this proposal, but the Minister misunderstood the situation. His interruption shows that the object here is not to put a tariff on fully-made golf clubs, but to put a tariff on the raw material of the professional makers of clubs. Why is it not made clear that heads of clubs are being taxed? That is an extension that we object to.

Comment on this

In an interjection the Minister said that this would be of assistance to professionals in golf clubs. Obviously the Minister is wrong in saying that.

Comment on this

They said it would be.

Comment on this

The Minister's club is Portmarnock, of which Deputy Costello and Deputy O'Sullivan are also members. I say to him: "For goodness' sake do not let the Minister for Finance join it." As the Minister knows, the professional in that club, as in other clubs, gets in the heads partly manufactured. In the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners any head wholly or partly manufactured, meaning wooden heads that come in shaped——

Comment on this

They are not liable.

Comment on this

Well, iron clubs are not manufactured in this country. It is the wooden heads we are speaking of. I do not mean the heads of the Opposition but of the Government Party. Heads of golf clubs that come in shaped are taxed.

Comment on this

They are not.

Comment on this

Under this they will be taxed.

Comment on this

The duty has been in operation for a long time.

Comment on this

They are caught by this duty because they have only to be finished. They come in substantially manufactured and only the finishing touches are put on by the professionals. Even if it is the intention that they should not be touched——

Comment on this

They are not.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Minister is suffering from mental aberration or has not read this paragraph.

Comment on this

This duty is in operation.

Comment on this

A shaped head is substantially manufactured?

Comment on this

The Minister may say that a duty is in operation. I do not see how that affects the position. Here we have a submission, and we are legislating that a shaped wooden head for a golf club is substantially manufactured and will be liable to duty.

Comment on this

The duty is not being charged upon it.

Comment on this

We do not know if the Executive Council have taken it upon themselves to break the law. If this proposal passes these clubs will be liable to duty. There may be licences granted by the Revenue Commissioners. All we have to do now is to legislate and we must do so correctly.

Comment on this

The Revenue Commissioners have expressed their opinion on this matter.

Comment on this

Then the Revenue Commissioners have expressed their opinion that what is the law is not the law. To say that a club is not substantially manufactured, when it comes in shaped, and only requires finishing and a certain amount of labour, is simply absurd. From his experience of golf the Minister should know that people buy clubs from the big shops or from professionals. The shops have large supplies, and because they get them wholesale they can sell at cheaper rates than professionals. The Minister must know the advantage of getting wooden clubs made by professionals is that they are built to suit the individual. It is like the difference between buying a ready-made suit of clothes and one made by a good tailor. If the margin between the shop price in Dublin and the price charged by professionals is increased, as I think it must be increased, the professionals will lose substantially in the sale of clubs.

Comment on this

There seems to be some doubt on these benches as to the freedom from tax of golf club heads. Can the Minister say how far the manufacture of shaped heads goes before they are taxed?

Comment on this

The shaped block from which the head is made is not liable.

Comment on this

Does that apply to the steel shaft?

Comment on this

Steel heads are imported in the rough and are finished, polished and adjusted here.

Comment on this

Are steel heads imported in the rough?

Comment on this

One or two firms are manufacturing them here.

Comment on this

I should like to see one.

Comment on this

There is a factory in Abbey Street owned by a well-known firm.

Comment on this

And they import the heads rough?

Comment on this

Are steel shafts taxed?

Comment on this

The steel shaft is free if it has no grip attached to it.

Comment on this