We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Business. - Finance Bill, 1935—Committee (Resumed).

Contributions 167–334 of 334. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1935
Enacted

No. 15 of 1935 ›

In that case we may take it that the commercial manufacturer of clubs in this country is just dealing with what is merely shaped, and that it is only when the process has proceeded beyond shaping that the tax begins?

Comment on this

This, of course, is another imposition on somebody. I am not a golfer, and so I cannot be accused of defending my own case. I know very little about the game. In fact, I am completely ignorant of it.

Comment on this

Many golfers are.

Comment on this

I am told that it is a highly technical and difficult game to play, and that it requires a lot of care and attention. I expect there are a number of notable players on the Government benches, and they ought to know all about it, but the Ministry were driven from post to pillar, as on the last amendment, to find something to tax, and they have now settled on golf clubs. It seems to me that there are some people making golf clubs in this country who appear to be professionals, although what that means I do not know. I expect that there are professionals in the different clubs, and that they have been making these golf clubs and attempting to compete with the finished article that comes from somewhere else. The Minister is now taxing the parts that they use, and will make it more difficult for them to compete with the foreigner. A certain measure of protection will be given to the foreigner to enable him to send in the finished article, and that will make it hard for the professional to produce the finished club himself.

The Minister interjected—he did not get up to say anything definite, and one tries to gather by his interjections what his views are—that the component parts which are here named will not be taxed. I cannot agree with that because it seems to me to be plain enough. I would like the House to consider this. Some of you are golfers, but I know nothing about it and so it may be said that I am completely unbiassed. Probably, therefore, my reading of the section would be that of an ordinary member of the community. I might be in a bunker, for all I know, although I do not exactly know what that means, but I am certainly in a bit of a hole about this. At any rate, I am in a difficulty. However, I am reading this as an ordinary member of the community without any knowledge of golf, and the section says: "Articles which in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners are heads or shafts suitable for use as component parts of clubs or sticks mentioned in the preceding paragraph." My reading of that is that it means the completed head or shaft, and not, as the Minister says, entirely in the raw state. It might be half finished, but to make it quite clear it says: "in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners are wholly or substantially manufactured." I cannot see in what way the Revenue Commissioners are not left free to decide it in any way they like, and my experience of the Revenue Commissioners is that, where they can get anything on the strict interpretation, they always do. They are certainly highly efficient in the matter of extracting the limit from a tax. I know of a certain article that I was importing myself, that was badly needed. I thought that it was completely beyond taxation, and that it could not possibly be taxed by the Revenue Commissioners, but they informed me that they would have to subject it to certain tests and experiments in order to find out the content of sugar. They found out finally that the content of sugar was practically nil, which was no particular use to me. In the same way, they might find some difficulty with regard to these shafts and heads of golf clubs and they might manage eventually to convince themselves that it is possible to tax the partly-made heads of the Fianna Fáil Party. They may tax the heads and shafts, and even the ragged tails, for all I know, of the golf clubs, and altogether it will be made extremely difficult for the unfortunate man who is trying to compete against a highly-organised industry in another country and trying to make these clubs here and sell them at an equivalent price.

There is another item to which I should like to refer. As I said, I know nothing about golf, but I am informed with regard to golf and tennis, of which I know very little either, that the implements used in these games are of a character that require great skill and long technical experience to produce; that there is something in the balance, if you like, of a club that is very difficult to produce. The only club I am familiar with at all is the ordinary club. I had a stroke of a club one time from a Fianna Fáil supporter, and the only balance in that club was that the head was heavier than the handle so as to give it an extra impetus. That may not be true of the golf club, but I understand that it requires great technical skill to produce a cleanly-balanced club to hit a golf ball. It is possible that we have not arrived at the position in this country yet where we can produce the very best club. Barring one or two men in Ireland, I understand that the foreign golfer is able to beat all our men. They are longer at the game than we are, and it is natural to think that they would be more efficient in the production of the instruments. It might be, however, that the Minister, or some of the Deputies behind him who are graduating in this game, will be compelled themselves some day, when they get to that high state of efficiency, to tackle Bobby Jones—or is he the champion?—and one of them might be in a position to say: "Jones would be no better than I if I could get clubs as good as he has." I think that we should not lose sight of that point of view. Speaking of clubs, however, I think that, in the matter of anything pertaining to a club, the Fianna Fáil Deputies here should be the last people to attack a club, whether it is a golf club or any other kind of club. They are much more familiar with clubs than I am, either golf clubs or any other kind. I do not use golf clubs and I do not use any other kind of club. I think that there ought to be some defence put up by the opposite side for this tax. I see Deputy Tom Kelly smiling. I do not know whether Deputy Kelly is a golfer, but his genial countenance always offers me consolation. Whether he is a golfer or not, I do not know, but I suppose that he knows something about clubs, even as I do, and that is only by repute. I am quite certain, however, that, like myself, he is not a wielder of clubs at all, but he knows men who do wield them, and I am sure he is anxious to help out those people, and not make those articles dearer on anybody. I certainly think that in the case of the manufacturer, the parts which he has to use should not be made dearer to him so that the finished article from another country can be imported cheaper than he can manufacture it.

Comment on this

I should like to express my regret that the Minister thought it necessary to put in this additional paragraph. The clause of the section in the original Act seemed to be a mistake. There are few luxuries left now, and I suppose golf is counted as a luxury. To some of us, however in these days of stress it is really a necessity. It is prescribed by our doctors—possibly the Minister was led on to the links in that way—and it seems rather hard that we cannot have an innocent and simple pastime without paying very considerably for it. The cost is becoming so high that a person with a sense of responsibility has to cut down his golf, the same as everything else. I was pleased to hear that the Minister and one of the leading members of the Opposition belong to the same club, but I fear that if the game is made more expensive the possibility that they might come to an understanding even on the links is going to be removed. There is another objection which I see to this tax on pastimes. I think the original clause covers tennis, badminton, ping-pong, and a whole series of games. We have a number of visitors coming over, and I think it is good for the country that they should visit our links. They bring money into the country, and they bring the element of cheerfulness that we want. It is a pity that their luggage should be subjected to too close scrutiny. We will now have our customs officers, who have got to do their duty, prying into their golf bags and asking: "Did you buy that club across the frontier?" or across the water, as the case may be, and they will have to explain that they are visitors. The Minister may think that this is a mere fictitious case, but I have actually seen it; I saw a customs official reducing a little girl of 13 or 14 almost to tears over a tennis racquet. She thought she would be carried off at once to jail. It is a pity we have found it necessary to tax games. I wish we could have found the money otherwise. This is obviously—well, subject to the Minister's denial—a revenue tax.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and 20 Deputies being present—

Comment on this

Did I understand the Minister to say that iron heads are introduced here in the rough? I want to be quite clear on that, because it directly affects the paragraph as it stands—how much work is actually done and how much has to be done. I can understand that when an iron club comes in it has to be filed, smoothed and polished. Is that all that has to be done?

Comment on this

Yes. It has to be polished, filed and fitted to the shaft.

Comment on this

It is forged before it comes in?

Comment on this

And yet the paragraph stands "and are, in the opinion aforesaid, wholly or substantially manufactured." Surely they are substantially manufactured if they are forged when they come in, and if all that has to be done is a little filing and polishing?

Comment on this

They are not filed. You never saw a filed iron head yet.

Comment on this

It is quite obvious, anyway, that they are substantially manufactured before they come in. Is not that obvious to the Minister?

Comment on this

They are forged. The bulk of the employment is given here.

Comment on this

In the making of the iron head?

Comment on this

Who gives it?

Comment on this

The firm——

Comment on this

What is the firm? They do not advertise it.

Comment on this

They do not sell direct to the public.

Comment on this

Are they listed in any directory?

Comment on this

I cannot say.

Comment on this

Can you give us the name of the firm?

Comment on this

There is a firm in Abbey Street. I forget the name.

Comment on this

They got lost in the slums of Dublin.

Comment on this

Ask the professional.

Comment on this

He would not be able to tell me any more than you.

Comment on this

Here you are deliberately putting into the hands of the Revenue Commissioners a paragraph which you do not intend them to interpret, apparently. The paragraph says "wholly or substantially manufactured." If they are forged they are substantially manufactured. I do not care what the quantity of work is; they are substantially manufactured even according to the Minister's own statement. Does he tell us at the same time that they are not taxed? Again, there is no consideration of the tax before it is put on.

Comment on this

I think this has to be inquired into a bit more. I do not know whether the Minister has ever been in a professional's shop when the work is going on. I know from observation over a long period of years that there is quite a lot of difference between the amount of work that has to be done on the iron head club as compared with the wooden head. The wooden head comes in here in a very rough state indeed. There is a well-known contour about it, and the work that has to be done is considerable. It has got to be filed to the proper point, and the whole thing has to be smoothed and varnished. The shaft has to be fitted into the socket, if it is a socket head, and the binding put on. The shaft has to be planed, grooved and varnished, and the two grips put on and bound. As regards the iron head, in all the time I have been knocking around golf clubs over a long period of years, I never saw a professional doing anything to an iron head except fitting the shaft into it.

Comment on this

That is what I said.

Comment on this

But the work on the shaft——

Comment on this

So the only difference is that he buys the head from a firm in Dublin, instead of from a foreign firm.

Comment on this

I am talking about how the head comes in. It comes in here in a complete state. Only one thing has to be done by the professional. At the very top of the socket part of the iron head, the steel of the iron is split and the professional fits the shaft into that. He gives it a turn in a vice, and puts in the serrated end more securely. There is a hole just near the top, and there has to be something in the nature of a rivet put through that and through the shaft, which is then filled with glue, and the whole thing is given a turn in a vice. I do not even believe there is a hammer put to it. There is certainly no filing.

Comment on this

In any professional's shop?

Comment on this

Not in any part of this country.

Comment on this

I am saying there is.

Comment on this

And I am asking where.

Comment on this

There are two or three firms.

Comment on this

Now there are two or three; there will be five before you are finished.

Comment on this

The forging down of those heads is, in the main, done by two or three big firms who confine themselves entirely to that type of work. Forgan's used to be a great firm at one time. There was a works at Carnoustie, but I forget the name of the firm. I know there were at least three firms. I do not believe that even the burnishing is done in this country. This is the way these things used to arrive at two or three professional establishments. The heads came wrapped in a piece of sacking, and when they were rolled out on the floor they were found to be tied together with pieces of wire run through the holes in the top. There was not even polishing to be done. They generally came in with vaseline rubbed on them. The burnishing had been done already and the makers wanted to preserve them against rust. To tell me that nobody could pass that, that it was not substantially manufactured——

Comment on this

It is, but it is liable to duty.

Comment on this

It is, when it is coming in. We have been arguing on the basis that that was not intended.

Comment on this

The unfinished head is not liable to duty, the one that comes in rough.

Comment on this

If a head such as I have described comes in, it is substantially manufactured and is therefore liable to duty?

Comment on this

I will put it further, that 90 per cent. of the heads come in in that fashion and therefore they are liable to duty.

Comment on this

They are not.

Comment on this

At least the Minister should be able to tell us whether they are finished and burnished here, and where?

Comment on this

There are two or three places in Dublin, one in Abbey St. It is a well-known firm.

Comment on this

Is it the rubber company?

Comment on this

I think it is.

Comment on this

I would like the Minister to get his first introduction to a rough iron head some of these days and then he can let us know the difference between the rough iron head and the type I have described. The Minister said that the bulk of the employment in connection with these iron heads is given in this country.

Comment on this

Other than the casting.

Comment on this

That was never said. That is the sort of thing that may get the Minister out of a hole with the Tralee Urban Council, but it ought not to be said here. The Minister's statement now discloses a falsehood. He said the bulk of the employment on these heads——

Comment on this

——is done here. I say all the employment is carried on here other than the casting.

Comment on this

My suggestion is that these things come in in the way I have described and there is no finishing or burnishing to be done. Some one lifts them off the cart, throws them on the floor, cuts the wire connecting the heads and unloosens them. I do not understand this business of a shaft, because steel shafts are now being used more and more I gather that the steel shaft is not substantially manufactured if it has not a grip on it. The difference between substantial and non-substantial manufacture is whether the grip is on or not. Is this what you might call a grip tax? Is this a tariff to enable the grips to be put on here? Is that what it comes to?

Comment on this

Surely the Minister does not suggest that the putting on of the grip means substantial manufacture?

Comment on this

I suggest that a substantial number of unemployed golf professionals are now employed for the first time because of this duty. I suggest that the duty has been welcomed by the golf professionals, and it was imposed at their request, and I suggest that better and cheaper clubs are now being made here.

Comment on this

Why not finish it off by saying that probably one of these days we will be exporting them to the whole world?

Comment on this

We are sending out golf champions at the present time, men who are doing well in other countries.

Comment on this

One could wish that the Minister would become a golf champion, and in that way we might be able to get rid of him.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That reference No. 16 stand."

Tá 47
·
Níl 21
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I beg to move amendment No. 54:—

In Part VI, to delete reference No. 17, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 and 4.

The Finance Act of 1934 in reference 16, which is referred to in the Schedule here, imposes a tariff of 20 per cent. on "any of the following articles which is, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, made wholly or mainly of leather or of skin or of an imitation of leather or skin or of a combination of any two or more of those substances or of which the outer covering is, in the opinion aforesaid, made wholly or mainly of any such substance or combination of substances as aforesaid, that is to say (1) purses, pouches, wallets, pocket books, and card cases which are, in the opinion aforesaid, designed, constructed and intended to be carried about the person, and (2) ladies' reticules or handbags which are in the opinion aforesaid, designed, constructed and intended to be carried and worn about the person to serve the purposes of a pocket and to hold articles for current personal use, (b) cash bags made wholly or mainly of leather or skin or a combination of leather and skin, and, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, designed, constructed and intended to be worn on the person."

Apparently the agent of the Minister for Finance who went into the home of the average working man to see what could be taxed there, had a look at the purse when he was taking a note of the last halfpenny in that purse. He thought it was a terrible pity not to get a bit off the purse itself, too, before he left. A tariff of 20 per cent. imposed on these articles in 1934 is increased now to a tariff of 40 per cent. I would like to put to the Minister for Finance one question—what is the reason for increasing this tariff other than the financial stringency to which the Government and the country has been reduced? I would like to ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce what has happened in the realms of Irish manufacture since this time last year which necessitates the reason for this tariff of 20 per cent. put on these articles at that time being increased now to 40 per cent.? Is there a licensing provision by which the people along the border can be relieved of the blow imposed by this tariff?

Comment on this

Last year this industry did not exist, and the tariff of 20 per cent. was imposed for the purpose of encouraging people to engage in it. That tariff has more than achieved its purpose. Those who visited the Spring Show spoke as much about the excellence of the leather products they saw there as they did about any other production at the Show. Arrangements have been made for a large scale expansion of the industry and it is in order to facilitate that and to encourage this industry that it has been decided to increase the duty. An important new industry has been brought into existence. This industry is intended to increase employment and to be a benefit to the country. I am quite sure that by this time twelve months Deputies opposite will have arrived at the stage that they will vehemently deny they ever opposed this tariff.

Comment on this

As usual the Minister has given us no figures in support of this tax. In support of what he said there is a complete lack of figures and a complete lack of any explanation as to the causes for the increase in the tariff imposed. The Minister forgets to say a word about the real matter that is before the House. He seems to forget that he is now imposing an additional tariff. The Minister has not been asked to defend the 20 per cent. tariff imposed last year. What he is asked to defend is the change from 20 per cent. to 40 per cent. That is what he has been asked to defend, and I invite the House now to look at the reason he gives. That reason is characteristic of the Minister. He says he is imposing it because the tariff of 20 per cent. imposed last year is quite enough and more than enough. Mark, that is why he is now increasing it to 40 per cent. He says the purposes for which that 20 per cent. were imposed have been achieved and that they have been more than achieved. But that did not satisfy the Minister. He goes further, and without giving any title of excuse and no reason for the increased tax that he was supposed to be defending here, he changes the tariff from 20 per cent. to 40 per cent. He does not defend that change. It is quite obvious from the speech delivered by the Minister on this occasion that he will not grasp and cannot grasp the seriousness of what he is doing. The Minister a year ago put in operation a 20 per cent. tariff on these things. He found that tariff successful and successful beyond his hopes and more than he expected. He found that tariff capable of establishing an industry which, he tells us, has been extremely successful. There are hopes of its doing more than he expected. Then when it is successful with immense possibilities, likelihoods and actualities of development he goes further. He is not satisfied with leaving it developed beyond his expectations but he jumps there from 20 per cent. to 40 per cent. When asked to defend that in the House, the Minister in reference to the precise thing which he is supposed to defend makes a speech, which is largely irrelevant, in defence of last year's tax and not in defence of the present one. We know now from the Fianna Fáil Party that in their minds there is no real distinction between a revenue tax and a protective tax.

Nobody can tell for what reason it is imposed. The Minister is not satisfied with what has already been done with the assistance of the 20 per cent., and jumps it to 40 per cent. Here is a large scale industry, established in the space of 12 months, with the assistance of a 20 per cent. tax, and the Minister, without any rhyme or reason, jumps that to 40 per cent. The inevitable result will be a bad effect on that industry. I do not see how the ordinary commercial men in the long run, no matter how excellent they may be, can resist the temptation to increase the price altogether unnecessarily and to deteriorate the quality of the article. What you get is a combination of these two movements—a movement upward of prices and a movement downward of quality as a result of what the Minister is doing. All the defence he has is a gibe about the future—how glad we will be in future to hail the success of the 20 per cent. tariff; but no justification for raising it to 40 per cent.

Comment on this

As Deputy O'Sullivan said, this is another tax for which there is no justification. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, in the few words he said on this, pursued the common argument used by the Fianna Fáil Party, that this is not meant to be a protective tariff: that the industry is getting on very well without it. The Minister said that last year we had none of these articles made here, and that in 12 months remarkable strides had been made with the 20 per cent. protection. A very big industry had been set up. If they are getting on so rapidly with 20 per cent., why do they need any more? We are opening the way here for profiteering and nothing else, because if 20 per cent. is sufficient to set the manufacturers going in making these articles, they certainly do not need 40 per cent. to do it. The experience of these things is that if you increase the protection advantage will be taken of it. It is almost inevitable that manufacturers, being human, will take advantage of the added protection given, and increase the price of the article. It appears to us to be the inevitable consequence of the ever-increasing tariffs.

The Government seems to have no other policy when making any change in the tariff system than to add a figure. They make it 5 per cent. one year, 10 the next, 20 the next, 25 the next and 30 the next, without any consideration whatever of the consequences to the population. This word "bag" seems to be dinned into my brain since we commenced this Finance Bill. We had bags of flour, bags of sugar, bags of tea, and all of them taxed. Now we have leather bags. There seems to be only one thing left to the community: to pack up their troubles in some sort of a bag and smile, if they can—if there is a smile left in them— because nothing seems to be left untaxed.

The people are getting sick, tired and sorry over the whole tariff system of the Government. There is neither thought nor consideration behind it. The Government are not satisfied to stop at what is necessary but they increase the chance of putting extra profits in some manufacturer's pocket, if he wants to avail of it, and most of them will. The consuming population and the agricultural community know well that if the chance is given to a manufacturer to make an extra profit he will take it. He would be a fool if he did not. We have to bear the consequences. Half of the opposition in this country to tariffs is caused by the policy of the Minister in increasing tariffs beyond the point that is necessary. We have had so many cases of this that one gets tired of repetition, but if repetition is any good in wakening up the Government to the seriousness of the situation then we shall repeat it as often as is necessary. We can only say that we are going to oppose this, as we have opposed many similar taxes.

Comment on this

Would the Minister tell us how many extra people will get employment as a result of this increase from 20 to 40 per cent.?

Comment on this

We have been told that 20 per cent. had more than served its purpose. It is well that we should get back to what its purpose was. I am sure the purpose was to give employment to people. If it has more than achieved its purpose, I suppose we have got to the position that we have a huge export and are probably exporting bags, pouches, card cases, etc., all around the world. The Revenue Commissioners do not seem to have had the same difficulty with regard to these articles as in regard to others, because they are given the job of deciding here whether these things are "wholly or mainly of leather or of skin or of an imitation of leather or skin or of a combination of any two or more of those substances, or of which the outer covering is, in the opinion aforesaid, made wholly or mainly of any such substance or combination of substances as aforesaid." Then we get a general description of "purses, pouches, wallets, pocket-books and card cases which are designed, constructed and intended to be carried about the person," and of "ladies' reticules or handbags which are designed, constructed and intended to be carried or worn about the person to serve the purposes of a pocket and to hold articles for current personal use." Will the Minister tell us "what is current personal use"? Has he anything on him that he wears about his person serving the purpose of, say, a taxpayer's pocket? What is the meaning of this phrase? Then the next section (b) reads: "cash-bags made wholly or mainly of leather or skin or a combination of leather and skin and, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, designed, constructed, and intended to be worn on the person." Purses are designed to be carried about; reticules are designed to be worn, and the cash bags are to be worn on the person. I would like to be shown the cash bag which the Minister says is to be worn on somebody's person.

Then we get an explanatory memorandum about these taxes, and the cynicism in them never really slipped out better than in a phrase used here. Somebody was told to write up all the descriptions. He had got to reference No. 17 in the explanatory document in the reference back to the old Schedule. He, at any rate, got to within three of the end, and we may take it that he was very tired and weary of writing descriptions. This is quite a good description of what is happening: "This is a provision merely to increase from 20 per cent. ad valorem to 40 per cent. ad valorem the rate of duty chargeable on such articles as purses, pouches, ladies' handbags and cash-bags made of leather or imitation leather.”“Merely”—that is the Fianna Fáil attitude towards raising any duty from 20 to 40 per cent.; it is a mere increase. We are not told whether there is any reason for the increase or not. The Minister, in fact, told us something which would lead us to vote against this. He said that the 20 per cent. tariff had already achieved its purpose, and its purpose was to get employment. It has more than achieved its purpose, and so he wants another 20 per cent. What does it mean? If any manufacturer or retailer is paying any attention to the proceedings of this House he must make up his mind that Deputies do not care a “thraneen” as to the difference between 20 and 40 per cent. when putting on taxes. Why should they care about it when thinking of price? Nobody is going to bother about an increase to 40 from 20 per cent. If the Prices Commission were thought to be good for anything at all they might say: “No one is going to make a complaint about this. The price is being raised from 20 to 40 per cent. in the Dáil. No one is bothering about that, and nothing is heard about it except a casual statement that it is a ‘mere increase’.” There is no explanation except that the 20 per cent. has more than achieved its purpose and therefore we will double it. This means a direct incitement to profiteering or to increase charges either by manufacturers or retailers. I withdraw the word “profiteering” when we are faced with the official statement issued saying that it is “a mere increase of from 20 to 40 per cent.”

Comment on this

I think the phrase "mere increase" shows that the whole purpose is to make the article dearer. No case was attempted to be made by the Minister except that. The whole purpose is to increase the price to the consumer. We waited in vain for the Minister to justify this increase; he did not even try. All he did, in the parting remarks he flung to the House, was to justify, or to try to justify, the 20 per cent. He made no attempt whatsoever to justify the "mere increase" of the tax. That, of course, was the last thing that was in the mind of the Minister—I do not know which Minister; we can never decide now which Minister is responsible, whether it is the Minister for Finance who raises the taxes, or the Minister for Industry and Commerce who puts on the increased duties. A more satisfactory explanation is that contained in the memorandum which was read by Deputy McGilligan that it is merely doubling the tax.

Comment on this

There is a great tendency on the other side of the House, and accepted by Ministers, to misrepresent our attitude to these duties. We are to be regarded as enemies of the development of Irish industry and as setting our faces against such a policy on the part of the Government. I think the opposite would be the true representation of our fears.

In a case of this kind it is evident that the industry has been very cleverly and successfully established on the basis of a 20 per cent. tariff. There is no case for increasing that tariff except to do some injury to that industry. This we are told is but a mere increase. It is an increase of a 100 per cent; and shows the mental attitude of the Government towards the people of this country in regard to the imposition of taxation. If this industry is going to get a further shelter of a 100 per cent. there can be only two results. The industry has established itself successfully on a 20 per cent. tariff. If that tariff is increased by a 100 per cent. it can only lead to carelessness and indifference on the part of its promoters. The element of competition is ruled out and an industry worked on that basis may lead to the notion that anything produced is good enough for the public. Secondly, we have here an utter disregard for the consuming public, and the cost of living in no way enters into the mentality of the Government in imposing this extra tax. This industry should be left alone. It is not a very big industry absorbing a great amount of capital but it absorbs a fair amount of trained labour. Its products have been very successful, and have been able to compete with similar goods imported. The raising of the tax from 20 to 40 per cent. is going to have a bad effect upon the industry itself. It is going to lead to carelessness and disregard for competition and it is going to lead to cramping of design. In a lot of these matters design, artistic output and change in fashion prove great incentives to good and successful work. That incentive will disappear and this increase of the tariff will only lead to the cramping of the industry and to the putting of additional cost upon the public.

Comment on this

It seems to me the general trend of this discussion might be summed up by proposing a vote of confidence in Japanese competition. What are we to do if the Japanese are not allowed to send their goods in here? How are we to protect ourselves against high prices if we prohibit that wonderful thing, competition, with our own manufactures? I do not think that is a good basis on which to found industry here. I think if the policy of competition, and low tariffs, and the keeping of prices right here by reference to foreign countries is admitted, it will not do much for prices here and will do precious little for Irish industry.

Comment on this

More than you have done.

Comment on this

That is not the opinion of the country.

Comment on this

I think it is.

Comment on this

The opinion of the country is that the industrial development that went on during those ten years——

Comment on this

It will be allowable, of course, to discuss this on the same lines?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am going to stop it now definitely. We are not discussing the industrial policy of any Government but the proposed tariff on bags.

Comment on this

It is a great pity.

Comment on this

And the only reference I was making to any outside subject——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is to this reference the Deputy must speak; we cannot discuss the policy adopted here during the previous ten years. That would lead us into several byways in which every Deputy would have the right to travel.

Comment on this

The alternative to a high tariff is a low tariff, and to argue in favour of a high tariff without reference to the trial of low tariffs would be rather difficult.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We cannot discuss the policy of the previous Administration on reference No. 17. That deals with a specific thing and we can deal only with that.

Comment on this

We can, at any rate, discuss the difference between 40 per cent. and 20 per cent. on this reference, and that is all we are asked to discuss here. It is merely an increase from 20 to 40 per cent., and an increase to 40 per cent. when the Minister said, with regard to the 20 per cent., that it had more than achieved its purpose. I should like the Deputy to found any debate he can on an attempt to justify a mere increase of the 20 per cent. —a doubling up of the original—after the statement made than the 20 per cent. had more than achieved its purpose. I hope he will enter into the discussion.

Comment on this

I hope he will not.

Comment on this

I am afraid that he has got tailed off, too. It is a great pity, because that was the first sign of intelligence over here for two days.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words stand."

Tá 50
·
Níl 22
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 55:—

In Part VI, to delete reference No. 19, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 and 4.

The Finance Act of 1934 imposed a duty of 25 per cent. on any article "which is, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, bias binding designed, constructed and intended for use in the manufacture or repair of articles made of textile material." It is now proposed to raise the rate of duty to 50 per cent. I should like to ask the Minister what are the circumstances which dictate that this rate of 25 per cent. should now be raised to 50 per cent.?

Comment on this

What is bias binding? Does the Minister know?

Comment on this

No, but the Revenue Commissioners do.

Comment on this

Can the Minister not tell us what this is?

Comment on this

Has the Minister got a definition of it in the book with the yellow cover, which he has been studying for the last couple of days?

Comment on this

Only one page of which, I understand, he has been able to read in two days.

Comment on this

It is more interesting than the speeches to which I have had to listen.

Comment on this

More interesting than the Minister's own Budget.

Comment on this

I have no bias in this matter, but I should like to know what a bias binding is. Surely we have some Deputy on the opposite side of the House who can tell us what a bias binding is.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

You have all the intelligence on your side.

Comment on this

Accepting the compliment, we should still like to know what a bias binding is.

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

You should know.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy know?

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance came to the House 12 months ago and asked the House to put a tariff of 25 per cent. on this article. I do not know whether he explained to the House at that time whether the tax was for revenue or industrial purposes, but I should like to know now if this material is made here, and if so, to what extent, and what employment is given in the manufacture of it. Why is it necessary to raise this tariff to 50 per cent? Is it simply the case of another industry from which the Minister, because of the financial stringency in which he finds himself as a result of this policy, wants to collect a few more halfpence?

Comment on this

The Minister refuses to give us any explanation of what bias binding is. For all the Minister knows, it might be anything. If a woman takes a piece of cloth and cuts it on the bias, is that article to be taxed? I know numerous cases of that kind. I want the Minister to explain it to me and to take his head out of the book for a couple of minutes. When a woman takes her needle and thread in her hands and cuts some article on the bias, and proceeds to bind the garment, is that a bias binding; or am I just biased in suggesting it?

Comment on this

It is something that Deputy Kelly knows—even Deputy Kelly.

Comment on this

I want to know what this tax means. It should be clarified for the House. We have great difficulty in discussing legislation if some Minister will not get up and explain what it means.

Comment on this
A Deputy

He does not know.

Comment on this

If somebody on the opposite side knows what a bias binding is, will he inform us so that we can discuss it further?

Comment on this
Mr. Kelly

That is one of the reasons we will not tell you.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact there is an explanation possibly of all this, irrespective of Deputy Kelly's ignorance. A bias binding is used to bind cloths that are cut on the bias. Deputy Kelly himself has clothes that are bound with a bias binding. I mean his clothes like his politics are cut on the bias—they have a bit of a twist or a curl in them. The Deputy may not know that bias bindings are used for clothes cut straight as well as those cut on the bias. I understand that a bias binding is the main binding whether for clothes cut on the bias or cut straight. We are given in the explanatory memorandum the very lucid explanation that "the provision merely increases the rate of duty from 25 to 50 per cent." You could not have anything simpler than that. It "merely increases" the rate of duty by 100 per cent. Why should anybody bother his head about the future when this House considers that an increase of 100 per cent. is something that need not be considered, something to be done en passant. If we are to regard an increase of 100 per cent. as a “mere increase” why should we be alarmed about the activities of profiteers? There should be no fear of anybody being hauled before that glorious body known as the Prices Commission to have their intricate prices system examined if we are to regard this increase of 100 per cent. as a “mere increase”.

Comment on this

I think the House should realise by this time that when the explanatory memorandum says that a thing is "merely an increase" it is one of those things which the Minister for Finance, when he is really stirred into explosion by long silence, thinks is a revenue tax.

Comment on this

And which somebody else will say is partly revenue and partly protective.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister whether this is partly revenue or partly protective, or whether the interpretation which we are driven to attach to the word "merely" is that it is a revenue tax.

Comment on this

It has been rather interesting in this discussion to have the pathetic appeal Deputy Kelly made to have the duty on this particular article explained. He has had to make this pathetic appeal to Deputy McGilligan and not to the bear with the sore head who ornaments the front bench of the Government at the present moment. I would suggest to Deputy Kelly that it would be rather better for him in future, for the sake of public opinion, to make his application to the Minister with the sore head in private. He then possibly would be allowed to approach him. I do not know whether Deputies on his own side are allowed to approach him in that way. I do not know whether Deputy Kelly would be allowed into the august presence or whether he would be duly kicked out if he approached him.

Comment on this

We would always have the excuse of the Deputy's kicking cow.

Comment on this

A Minister who cannot speak when he is wanted to speak had better keep quiet when it is disorderly to speak, because it seems to me that the only thing the sore-headed Minister can possibly do is to make disorderly interruptions. No matter whether this is or is not a matter of very great importance, no matter whether it will or will not bring in any large increase of revenue, the principle which lies behind it and behind the attitude of the Minister for Finance is one against which we must protest. That is to say, that when revenue taxes are being raised upon certain articles, not one suggestion comes from the Minister for Finance either as to whether the article is capable of bearing the taxation or whether it is necessary for the balancing of the Budget that the small sum imposed by the tax must be raised. That is the principle which lies behind this amendment, a principle against which this House should protest.

When we tax anything, be it great or small, it increases the burden upon the taxpayer and the reason for doing so should be placed before the House and, through the House, before the people of the country. Instead of that, we have this silent taxation, this coming along to the House and flinging down a proposal for a certain tax, saying: "We will give you no reason for it; we will give you no idea of the amount of revenue to be raised by it; take it or we will drive it through the House." This tax is to be driven through the House by an unthinking and, as Deputy O'Kelly has conclusively shown us, an absolutely ignorant majority.

Comment on this

The tax relates to women's garments and we do not know much about them.

Comment on this

I presume the Deputy will vote for what he does not know much about. I will be called upon to vote also and I do not know anything about this article. I want to obtain some information about it and then I shall make up my mind. If I am refused that information, I will vote against the tax as a protest against a novel-reading Minister coming in without a single official adviser—and we all know that he wants an adviser. He has treated the House with the utmost contempt. "Bias-binding" is not even a name to me. I never heard of it before. The Minister wants to increase the tariff on this thing— whatever it is—to 50 per cent. I understand it has been 25 per cent. Are we able to meet our requirements in it? Has the 25 per cent. been ineffective or are we progressing favourably towards the desired goal? If we are—and no case has been made to the contrary—there is no justification for increasing the tax except the justification that it will increase the profits of people who are capable—if the assumption I make is correct—of expanding their trade under present conditions.

If they are capable of doing that, they should not get any further facilities. Putting people in a favoured position like that is not conducive to industrial development. The whole theory of industrial tariffs is that those of a temporary nature should keep out dumping, and that others should assist in the development of industry by giving the home producer a sufficient margin to enable him to overcome the disadvantage he is at in competing with another country, and to start practically on a level with it. Any Minister who wants to impose tariffs for industrial development should satisfy himself that the tariff he imposes is sufficient, and no more than sufficient, to overcome the disadvantages under which the home producers have to work. We are given no information as to whether the 25 per cent. tariff represented a sufficient levelling up as against those disadvantages. The Minister merely said: "We will put on another 25 per cent." We are given no reason why that tariff should be doubled. There is an old proverb current in the part of the country from which I come—"Children and fools should not handle edged tools." I am afraid that the tariff weapon is in the hands of somebody who does not know how to handle it.

Comment on this

Apparently, the Minister intends to persist in his efforts to reduce the procedure of this House to the level of a farce and to bring the Parliamentary institutions of this country into contempt. There are certain regulations laid down for dealing with a position like that. We have been discussing here for the last three or four days what I described before as the most important Bill that comes before this House in a year—a Bill which imposes, particularly this year, an enormous burden on the people. On this section, as on other sections, the Minister has refused absolutely to assist the representatives of the people to understand why these taxes are being imposed on a number of articles and why taxes are being increased in other cases by 25 per cent. and, in this case, by 100 per cent.

I submit that the Minister has not only failed in his duty to the House and to the country but that he is guilty of gross contempt for which he should be made amenable. There is machinery to make him amenable. The Minister for Industry and Commerce sat in the House yesterday and for the greater part of to-day. He gave certain information when requested to do so. Whether members of the House thought that information satisfactory or not does not arise at the moment. But he did not treat the House with the gross contempt with which it has been treated by the Minister for Finance. The Minister whose primary duty it is to put through the Finance Bill and to explain to the House its provisions, and the reasons for the different impositions, the Minister who is paid for doing this work has thought fit to spend his time for the last three days reading some book.

Comment on this

Looking at it.

Comment on this

Which book, we must assume, has no relation to the business of the House—the business which he is paid to perform. As you, a Chinn Comhairle, are responsible for upholding the dignity and the prestige of this House and of our parliamentary institutions, I suggest that this conduct by the Minister for Finance should not be tolerated and that we should hear from the President of the Executive Council an explanation as to why his Minister refuses to give information he is bound to give. We should be told whether that is merely the attitude of the Minister himself or whether he is acting under the instruction of the President of the Executive Council in withholding from the House information which it is entitled to receive.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is aware that the Chair has no power or jurisdiction in that matter.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, we have got the standard the majority of the House set up.

Comment on this

I submit that the Ceann Comhairle must take some action if any member of the House— and particularly a Minister—by his conduct attempts to reduce the proceedings to a farce or to bring our parliamentary institutions into contempt.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy considering the amendment at all?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not so far.

Comment on this

My whole case is that the Minister is, on this section, refusing to give us the information we are entitled to receive. I submit I am perfectly in order.

Comment on this

The Deputy's voice will go out of order if he goes any higher.

Comment on this

The Minister is not in very good order. Whether he is suffering from mental or physical disorder, I do not know—perhaps both. It is quite clear to any person that the Minister is deliberate in the attitude that he has taken up. As I say, the position that he has taken up does not run to the remainder of his colleagues. I do not know whether the Minister has been instructed by that great apostle of democratic republicanism, the President, to adopt his present attitude, but at any rate it does not add to the prestige of this House either here or in the country.

Comment on this

There was a ruling given by you, Sir, a moment ago that I would like to refer to. You said, in connection with the matter which Deputy Morrissey raised, that you had no jurisdiction. I would respectfully submit that the Chair has an inherent jurisdiction to see that the ordinary decencies and courtesies of discussion are carried on in this House. If somebody walks into the House and, let me say, ostentatiously reads a newspaper —there may be nothing in the Standing Orders which deals with it—but there is power in the Chair—in the Ceann Comhairle—not merely a power but a duty to see that such general treatment of the House with contempt shall not be carried on. I submit that the same standard of courtesy is required from all members, whether they are Ministers, or back-benchers. The Minister has no more right to act in an offensive fashion, in an ungentlemanly fashion, than has an ordinary back bencher. If the Minister deliberately reads a newspaper in order that he may ostentatiously show that he is paying no attention to the debate, he is thereby insulting the whole House, including the Chair. The Chair has an inherent power, I submit, and also an inherent duty to stop that course of conduct.

Comment on this

It is clear, from the course that the debate has taken on the Committee Stage of this Bill, that it was the purpose of the Opposition to obstruct the measure. The proposals in the Bill were fully discussed on the Financial Resolutions and on the Second Stage of the Bill.

Comment on this

What was said about bias binding?

Comment on this

These discussions occupied 14 hours: more than twice as long as the discussions on the corresponding stage of any preceding Finance Bill. I have given to Deputies on several occasions all the information that they have asked for. It is obvious, as I have said, that when the Opposition embarked on a policy of obstruction it was my duty as the Minister charged with the responsibility of getting this Bill through in time in order to comply with the legal requirements, and to give the other House the time which is reserved to it under the Constitution to consider this measure, not to facilitate the Opposition in any way by participating unnecessarily in this debate.

On the other hand, as well as having duties here, I have also Departmental duties to perform, and any document which I have read in the House during the course of the debate related to those duties and those duties only. I have not read a newspaper, I have not read a book on card-playing, I have not read a novel, I have not read anything that has not been connected, directly or indirectly, with my Departmental functions and, therefore, I have not been guilty of any discourtesy to the House. I am not bound to get up and answer an argument of the type which was used by Deputy John Marcus O'Sullivan yesterday: an argument of this type in relation to the tax on slates. I am quoting now something which is printed in quotation marks in yesterday's issue of the Evening Mail:“When a man awoke in the morning,” said Deputy John Marcus O'Sullivan, “the first thing he saw, provided he had a ceiling, was a roof that paid taxes.” If the House is treated to foolish, nonsensical and incomprehensible remarks of that kind, surely I am not expected to occupy its time in replying.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

With regard to the points submitted to the Chair, there are many rulings to the effect that the Chair has no power to compel a Minister or a Deputy to reply. The attention of the Chair was not called to the fact that the Minister was supposed to be reading a book. I first learned of it from the newspapers.

Comment on this

A yellow-backed one at that.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister has dealt with that matter. If the Chair saw a Minister or a Deputy reading a book or a newspaper the Chair would certainly take notice.

Comment on this

The Minister has stated to the House that he has been reading papers having no connection with the matter under discussion—ostentatiously reading them. He has stated that to the House himself.

Comment on this

On the Minister's so-called explanation——

Comment on this

No explanation to you.

Comment on this

For a Minister with a reputation through this country of the man who has just gone out to pass any critical comment on a man with the reputation through the country of Deputy John Marcus O'Sullivan is as big a farce as was ever witnessed here. Deputy O'Sullivan's reputation is as high as the Minister's is low, and for Deputy MacEntee, Minister for Finance, to attempt to criticise a man of the calibre of John Marcus O'Sullivan is ludicrous.

Comment on this

And unnecessary.

Comment on this

And unnecessary. The Minister for Industry and Commerce was called names by a little group in Kerry that we would not be allowed under the rules of the House to attach to him here.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That matter does not arise now.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce attempted to come to the aid of his sorely harassed colleague, and we then have to pay attention to him that possibly he is not worth. One can, at any rate, say of the Minister that a particular group of his own, intimately associated with him, found him out and passed a comment on him which the rules of order and of gentlemanly conduct do not allow us to pass on him. He is standardised by that. The Minister for Finance has carried on a course of conduct here definitely tending to bring parliamentary institutions into disrepute. Parliamentary institutions only can live where a Government is supposed to live by persuasiveness, by being able to argue its point. You cannot say that you are governing by persuasion if the method adopted here is followed when a Bill is being dissected, when its various reactions are being examined, when the whole scope of it is being laid bare: you cannot say that you are ruling by parliamentary institutions of the deliberative assembly type if silence is the only answer.

I think silence on the part of the Minister is bad enough, but when the silence extends to what we see in this House, the silencing of Deputy Kelly and the definite ordering, which was heard at this side, of a man like Deputy Corry to "shut up," when he tried to intervene, the boycott is so rigidly enforced that people elected with the right to represent their constituents have been reduced to the same silence as that on the part of the Ministry, it is surely bringing this House into disrepute. The attitude adopted by the Government, apparently, is "Here are the Bills. We do not need to discuss them. They are self-explanatory." Anyone who speaks against them or who tries to argue a clause or to dissect the meaning of a clause is told that that is obstruction. That is the attitude. But that is not an attitude consistent with Parliamentary Government. If we want to get away from parliamentary government let that be said. The attitude of men who sit silent, while the most amazing Budget ever produced is under discussion, does not help parliamentary institutions. Look at the comment we had this morning about spending 14 hours on this Budget. Was there ever any Budget introduced which contained so many taxes?

Comment on this

Surely we are dealing with an amendment now about bias binding?

Comment on this

I am dealing with an explanation.

Comment on this

But not a word about bias binding.

Comment on this

Unfortunately the Minister was out when the discussion was on. I have often commented on the Minister mixing glibness for argument.

Comment on this

Neither silence nor argument has been characteristic of the discussion.

Comment on this

Unfortunately it took place in the Minister's absence. There has been comment about 14 hours being spent on the most amazing Budget ever introduced. There were more passing references to taxes on food, taxes on house building——

Comment on this

And bias binding.

Comment on this
Division

The Committee divided: Tá,

Tá 47
·
Níl 21
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Division

Question—"That the Eighth Schedule as set out be the Eighth Schedule of the Bill"—put.

Tá 48
·
Níl 21
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

When will the Report Stage be reached?

Comment on this

On Wednesday next.

Comment on this

Is there a proposition to that effect?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

This is a most illuminating proposition—that we meet on Wednesday. I would ask the House to consider what occurred last night, and now we are asked to meet on Wednesday.

Comment on this

We are taking the Bill on Wednesday.

Comment on this

We are asked to discuss this urgent Finance Bill on Wednesday. Last night we broke every precedent so far as this House is concerned, and now we are asked to discuss this on Wednesday. Last night we could not wait until next Tuesday to finish off the Finance Bill. We had, as I say, to give rise to that very regrettable breach of precedent into which the House was led on the alleged plea of urgency—a plea of urgency which I understood from the Ceann Comhairle was put before him by the majority Party in this House. They could not wait until Tuesday. The Ceann Comhairle, acting on the information which he received from the majority Party in this Dáil, decided that it was a matter of urgency.

It is now obvious that it was not a matter of urgency, and that we could have conducted the business in the normal way last evening. There was no necessity for this breach of precedent; there was no necessity for meeting here to-day. With reference to the proposition that we meet on Wednesday, I do suggest that we require an explanation of the urgency from the Government. This is a very weighty Bill. Amendments will have to be tabled on Report Stage. Owing to the fact that there has been such a lot of discussion on the Committee Stage they will have to be very carefully considered. I would draw attention to the fact that if there has been delay in this Bill, and if there is any necessity why we should take it up on Wednesday, the delay is entirely due to three things; first, the incapacity of the Government to make up its mind as to what it is taxing——

Comment on this

That has nothing to do with it.

Comment on this

It lost a week to start with. I would ask you, Sir, to keep the Minister in order. I think I am entitled to that. On more than one occasion I appealed to the Chair to keep that particular Member of the House in order, and I ask you to do so now. The Minister may laugh at the Chair. He has done it all the week. There was a week lost in that way—because the Government could not make up their minds as to what tax they would inflict on the people. The Bill went through the Second Stage. It was put down for a certain day, and Deputies were given the concession that up to a certain time they could get amendments. The Committee Stage was not taken for several days after the date for which it was tabled. What was the cause of the delay there? Next, Sir, the way in which this Budget has been managed by those who had charge of it in this House is a reason why we are requiring a further explanation as to why we are asked to take this on Wednesday. There are two people who gave no assistance whatever in the discussion on this monstrous Budget, this appalling Budget in many ways, putting such heavy taxes on the very poorest classes of the population. One was the Minister for Finance, who is supposed to be intimately responsible for this particular Budget, and the other was the Chairman of the majority Party in this Dáil.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I should like to know whether the Deputy is making an oblique reference to the Chair, as that interpretation would be possible from insinuations made in the course of to-day's debates. Criticism of the Chair should be by way of express motion, and I understand that such a motion is to be tabled.

Comment on this

I intend to propose such a motion, but I certainly would not hold myself precluded from protesting in the interim if the Chair did anything which, to my mind, merited protest.

Comment on this

I refer to the complete absence of the President from this Dáil.

Comment on this

On a point of order, the rule here is to refer to a Member of the House by his official title. Is the Deputy entitled to refer to the President of the Executive Council as the Chairman of the majority Party?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The President of the Executive Council should be referred to as the President of the Executive Council.

Comment on this

I hope, before I am interrupted, I will be allowed to get on to what I wish to say. I am referring to the Chairman of the majority Party—the President of the Executive Council. I refer to him as the Chairman of the majority Party for one particular reason, namely, that it is because they have the majority that they force their wills upon this House.

Comment on this

And that standard was accepted by the Chair.

Comment on this

I think it was a shocking thing, when the majority Party were steam-rolling the principles of this institution, that the President should be entirely absent—that the man who was responsible both for the Party, I take it, and for the business of this House, should be absent.

Comment on this

You used to do that yourself.

Comment on this

We never had the majority view accepted by the Chairman. We usually had the Chairman's judgment on it.

Comment on this

I strongly protest against the way in which the Minister for Finance, when he was in the House, tried to conduct the business of the House as the temporary leader of the House. He showed contempt for its institutions, and it seemed to me, Sir, as I have pointed out, that long before last night he did show contempt, and open contempt, for the Chair. That was what struck the Deputies in this House. It may not have struck the Chair, but certainly it struck every Deputy in this House. On more than one occasion, when the Chair refused to accept closure motions from him to put a stop to the discussions in this House, he showed a fit of ill-temper, and informed the Chair— and through the Chair informed the House—that if it continued he would leave the House; that is, if there was discussion of those enormous taxes the Minister for Finance was going to leave this House without anybody responsible for the Budget in it. I hold that that is quite in keeping with his conduct all through this Budget, and I strongly object to it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Deputy relate that to the matter before the House?

Comment on this

On that account, any urgency which necessitates asking us to take this next week is due both to the loss of time, for which the Government is altogether responsible, and the amount of discussion, for which the conduct of the Minister for Finance is mainly responsible. Those are the reasons why I do not, without further explanation, feel inclined to accept this motion.

Comment on this