Estimates for Public Services and Appropriation Bill.—Allocation of Time.
Contributions 1–169 of 345. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:—
That the proceedings on the Estimates for Public Services for the year ending 31st day of March, 1936, in Committee on Finance and on Report, on the Resolution, in Committee on Finance and on Report, for the issue out of the Central Fund of the sum necessary to make good the supply granted for the services of the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1936, and on the five Stages of the Appropriation Bill, 1935, if not previously brought to a conclusion shall be brought to a conclusion at 12 noon on Friday, July 12th, 1935, by putting from the Chair forthwith and successively the Questions necessary to bring the proceedings to a conclusion: Provided that after the said hour on the said day a Question shall not be put from the Chair on any amendment, nor upon any motion other than a motion necessary to bring the proceedings forthwith to a conclusion and then only when moved by the Government: Provided also that after the said hour on the said day only one Question shall be put from the Chair in Committee on Finance on the Estimates then outstanding and that Question shall be in the form, that the total sum outstanding in respect of the Estimates for Public Services for the year ending 31st day of March, 1936, be granted for the service of that year; and that on the report of the Resolutions of the Committee on Finance, in respect of the several Estimates, only one question shall be put from the Chair, namely: That the Dáil agrees with the Committee on Finance in the said Resolutions: Provided, further, that in Committee on the Appropriation Bill, 1935, only one question shall be put from the Chair, namely, That the several sections stand part of and that the Schedules and the Title be the Schedules and the Title to the Bill.
The necessity for this motion arises out of the fact that the Bill must be law by the 31st July. When we consider that already we have spent 78 hours and 40 minutes on Estimates, and that the total amount of time spent on financial business amounts to 168 hours, we must realise that adequate time has been given for the discussion of financial business. At a rough estimate, six weeks of the sitting days of Parliamentary time have been already devoted to financial business.
Comment on this
We are opposing this motion, which has been so briefly recommended to the House by the Parliamentary Secretary. Whatever mistake they may have made yesterday in reference to the Bill that was then before us, with regard to the date of introduction, we are, at any rate, presented with the proposition at the present moment that a Bill which has not yet been introduced, which we have not yet in our hands, is to be passed by this House to-morrow at 12 o'clock. There is no doubt whatever about that. The Parliamentary Secretary tells us that we have spent 168 hours on finance business. 90 of those had reference to the imposition of taxation, and 78 hours up to the moment—78 hours and 40 minutes—have been devoted to considering the items which fall to be accounted for in the taxation in the coming year. To add ten hours to that would mean about 88 hours, which is a limited length of time to leave for the consideration of the Estimates. It is all the more limited when we take into account the fact that a Minister of State spent a very considerable time last night and a time the night before in dealing with a single Vote for £60,000. I presume it might be agreed that he spent one hour and a half on that £60,000. An hour and a half is a fairly considerable amount of time for a single individual to spend in speaking on a Vote for £60,000, when £28,000,000 besides fall to be dealt with, and a complaint has been made that the House has wasted so much time. Certainly we cannot exculpate a Minister of State for addressing himself for an hour and a half to a subject concerning only £60,000, during which time I am told he was called to order seven times. If, therefore, there has been a waste of time, that Minister has certainly been extravagant in the use of it.
The sum of money which is involved in this Closure Motion amounts to approximately £11,000,000. Obviously, careful consideration and examination of those sums of money are not going to be afforded in the limited time which is at our disposal. Two Estimates of outstanding importance to the vast majority of the people of the country have still to be dealt with —Agriculture and Compensation Bounties. Occasionally we hear from the front bench opposite, and perhaps as often again from the benches behind, that whatever economies are to be effected in this State can only be effected at the expense of social services. They mention no other item as a matter upon which any economies can be effected. In one of the Estimates which is now down for our consideration, the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture, we find that the sum of money which is proposed to be raised this year is approximately £1,000,000—£998,995— and if we take into account the other expenses which are in the Estimate it amounts to £1,030,000. The sum which appears lower down in each Estimate, bringing in other charges, is the figure which was usually adopted by the gentlemen opposite when they were on those benches. It is to be found in the lower portion of page 200 of the Estimates for Public Services, 1935-6, that the total expenditure given is £1,766,608, and the receipts amount to £736,921. Comparing that with the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture, published in 1932-3, which amounted to £407,408, or, taking the second figure, £415,000, we find a difference in those two Estimates of £615,000. Even if we exclude from the figure the item of £300,000, which is down for the wheat subsidy, we still find a figure of £300,000 over and above what it was in 1932-3. Examining still further the number of persons who are employed in that Ministry, as compared with 1932-3. We find there is an addition of 476 persons in the Department of Agriculture.
When we examine the sum of money that came into this country for cattle in 1931, which was over £12,000,000, and compare it with the figure for 1934, £4,256,000, we find there is a fall in the receipts from cattle alone of about £8,000,000. One would require to almost multiply what are called the advantages derived from the new agricultural economy to anything like balance that loss. And the loss does not stop there; it goes into other items such as sheep, pigs, etc. Yet this Estimate has got to be forced through this House without consideration either in relation to the number of persons employed or the cost that is going to be entailed in that way, or as to the losses occasioned by reason of our present agricultural policy. It is a strange thing that, when moneys are required and economies are going to be made, it is in respect of old age pensions and unemployment insurance we are going to make those savings, and not in respect of the increases in cost which have been entailed in the administration of the various Departments of State.
I have already referred in this House to the increase that has taken place in three separate Estimates— the Army, the Army Pensions, and the Gárda. These three items are £800,000 up this year as compared with 1932-33. Going down through the list, I see we have got here before us Estimates that, according to Radio 2RN, "have to be passed." I find that the increases for administration or administrative costs are not confined to the Ministry of Agriculture, but there is a kind of catholic distribution of these large sums of public moneys which have nothing whatever to do with social services. On an examination of the Revenue Commissioners' charges on the same level as I have examined those of the Department of Agriculture, taking in all the charges. I find that the present year is responsible for £924,800 as compared with £817,000 for the year 1932-33. The charge there is up in this Estimate by over £100,000 a year. Examination of administrative costs has established one fact—that social services such as unemployment assistance, old age pensions, housing, etc., do not exhaust at all the big administrative costs of £11,000,000 out of the total £28,000,000.
I find that the Civil Service Commission is costing this year £19,000 as compared with £13,429 in 1932-33. In that Estimate the charges have gone up by almost 50 per cent. If we take other figures as to the Estimates that are usually handed out in January, we find that in one Estimate there is £14,624 as against £7,593 for the year 1932-33. That is the Industrial and Commercial Registration Office. What is the reason for the enormous increase in the cost of the Civil Service Commission? There is only one answer. We are having a swollen list of officials throughout the country. In a short time, if it is not so already, the biggest employer in the State will be the State itself. The State exists for finding employment for persons in these various stages in agriculture and its ramifications. As to the efforts to give £1 value for £100 spent, the whole thing could be summarised in one sentence—that the Government finds itself in a fix and it makes a noise. The noise resulting from these increases is overshadowed by the claim that there is a larger number of persons in employment. Let us take the Vote we had last night—Law Charges. I need not go into a comparison there beyond stating that the figure this year is £64,439 as against £58,067 in 1932-33. That Estimate is up by over £6,000. In the face of these figures, is it any wonder that we have a motion such as this before the House? Is it any wonder that it is not desired to let the people know to what a height the administrative costs of this State are rising, or that there should be a reluctance on the part of the Government that the House should be allowed to proceed to examine closely and with attention these figures? The country should have that examination if it were to take 13 weeks. The House is entitled to an examination of every item of expenditure that comes before it.
The estimates for public services this year as published amount to £28,737,710, as compared with the figure of £21,906,962 in the year 1932-33. What are those social services to which so much reference has been made by the Ministers? The first big item is the unemployment insurance, £1,300,000; old age pensions, £600,000, and relief works, £500,000, and we arrive at a figure of £2,400,000. Deputies want to know in what way we can evade cutting down social services if we are to cut down our expenses. I will tell them. The whole of that £2,400,000 was provided for last year. Even the widows' and orphans' pensions were provided for last year. This year there is no additional item in respect of social services that we have been told of. The Minister may add that he has to provide for housing charges. Those housing charges will have to be provided for in the future. They are liabilities in respect of money that has been borrowed and planned with the liability falling upon future years. Future years will have to provide for the advantages derived this year, last year and the year before. The £2,400,000 was provided for last year and there is no necessity for any interference with it this year.
If we want to find economies they can be found in one of the last items in the Estimates. I refer to Export Bounties and Subsidies for which there is a sum of £2,705,000 set out in the Order Paper. The Government can find economies in respect of the increased cost of the Army, in respect of the increased costs of the Gárda, and in respect of the increased cost involved in the Ministry of Agriculture's amending Acts of a sum far in excess of the cost of these social services that I have mentioned. But besides that, these social services had already been provided for and they were provided for last year. They did not enter into our calculations in respect of the increased taxes imposed this year at all. It is no wonder that we should have a case made on behalf of the Government to force these Estimates through at short notice. Was it in keeping with that particular line of argument or that particular line of considering the case that we had the Minister speaking for one and a half hours last night on an Estimate of £6,000? Where is the waste? Surely, in the case of a large business such as Agriculture, that at any rate ought to have been disposed of before he came along here to closure that motion.
The Minister spoke about the Seanad holding up Bills. Is there any case made by anybody that the Seanad held up Finance Bills during the 12 years during which it was in operation, whether or not there was a majority there one way or another? When Deputies speak of our having a majority in the Seanad I want to say that we had no majority in the Seanad except what we were able to persuade in respect of the case we made. The Seanad is entitled so long as it is part of this Oireachtas to give consideration to this or any measure; but it has never held up a Finance Bill, so that excuse falls to the ground. Finance Bills have been brought to the Seanad with less than 21 days given them. The Minister who has moved this motion has made no case about the urgency; he gave no reason why those moneys should be passed in nine hours. Years ago, when a terrible catastrophe affected the State, and when by reason of that men's minds were turned in other directions, we recollect the denunciations that came from members on the benches opposite who were then outside this House when this course was proposed. But here we have these same Ministers and Deputies to-day when no excuse at all exists for forcing through this motion, except that they do not want to be kept here to answer questions, deal with the items and make a case for the increased estimates that the people are called upon to pay. That is the real reason for this motion before us, and it reflects neither respect for the House nor is it any credit to the Government as showing consideration for what is due to the country in respect of financial measures.
Comment on this
The Deputy who has just sat down has one universal tactic in the discussion of any measure which he knows to be justifiable, but which he wishes to oppose upon whatever specious ground he can present for that attitude, and that is to make a number of misstatements, or else to allege that what it is proposed to do is without precedent. He stated that a Minister spoke for an hour and a half either last night or the night preceding on a vote for £6,000.
Comment on this
If the Minister will look up the Estimate for law charges he will find it is for £60,000.
Comment on this
There was no Minister, no Parliamentary Secretary, and no Deputy on this side of the House who spoke for one and a half hours on that Estimate. I will refer to the records of the House to prove that statement and to disprove Deputy Cosgrave's allegation.
Comment on this
I am not going to overprove my case. The second point the Deputy made was that this proposal was without precedent, that we were asked to take to-day a Bill which was not yet in the hands of the House, and the First Reading of which had not been moved. The resolution which appears on the Order Paper is in the same form as the resolution which Deputy Cosgrave, the then President of the Executive Council, moved on the 10th July, 1929, this day six years ago almost exactly. Therefore he did not then think it was any abuse of the procedure of the House, any violation of the rights of Deputies, or that there was any disregard of the public weal in asking the House, after what he considered adequate consideration of the Estimates, to adopt a proposal such as we are asking the House to adopt now in order that the public business may not be held up.
It is quite clear then that, as I have said, the Deputy in debate has only one purpose ever, and that is to obscure the issue so that the public will not appreciate what is at stake. It has been said that we are anxious to get the Estimates through because we wish to burk discussion on them. When the first of these motions was under discussion on Tuesday and the plea was made that the Opposition would be at a disadvantage because they could not propose amendments on the Committee Stage of the Confirmation of Emergency Duties Bill, we offered to withdraw the motion, and to allow them, with the permission of the Chair, to put in any amendments they cared to that Bill. We offered to give them, not merely three hours, which they had previously declared would be ample time to discuss the measure—a statement which they repeated in the debate—but to give them an additional three hours if necessary; and if they did not wish to avail themselves of the additional time, then to allow that time to be devoted to the discussion of the Estimates which we are now compelled, by the obstructive attitude of the Opposition, to ask the House to pass under a motion allocating time. The Opposition rejected that proposal. They preferred instead to proceed under the motion allocating time. They rejected a similar proposal yesterday. The reason for that is clear, that the Opposition who, as well as the Government, have a duty to see that Parliamentary time will not be wasted, have been unable to control their own followers in debate.
The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs instanced the case which, I think, proves up to the hilt the statement which I am making. It is the custom, in order to ensure that business will be dealt with in an orderly and businesslike way, to have arrangements made by the Whips, as representing the principal Parties in the House, the Parties which are likely to take the foremost part in the discussion of the business of the House, in the form of an informal time-table to allow these matters to be disposed of. In one particular instance the Opposition Whips and the Government Whips made an arrangement in the presence and with the apparent acquiescence of Deputy McGilligan, who is one of the leaders of the Opposition, in order that, as I have said, Parliamentary time might be used to the best advantage. That arrangement had scarcely been concluded when Deputy McGilligan walked in here and in a speech extending, I think, over two hours broke the arrangement to which he, as a person who accepted the Opposition Party Whip, was bound in honour. If we are compelled to put a motion of this sort on the Order Paper, we are compelled to do it because either the people who, like ourselves, have a duty to see that Parliamentary time will not be wasted and will not be squandered, have been unable to discharge that duty, or have been unwilling to accept the responsibilities which their functions here as public representatives impose upon them.
I was saying that it had been alleged by Deputy Cosgrave that one of the reasons why we have this motion on the Order Paper to-day was that we were anxious to burk discussion of the Estimates. There are, I think, approximately 18 Estimates on the Order Paper and they have been on the Order Paper for a considerable period. There are only two of these Estimates which the Opposition Party have selected for serious discussion, because, as you are aware, Sir, when the Opposition wish to discuss an Estimate in detail and at great length, it is the custom to put down a motion to refer the Estimate back. To these 18 Estimates only two motions have been put down.
Comment on this
Twenty-three Estimates then. I am glad I gave the Deputy an opportunity of looking up the list, possibly for the first time, and counting them. To these 23 Estimates only two motions have been put down. One is an amendment proposing to refer back Vote No. 26, the Estimate for Law Charges. The other is an amendment to refer back the Vote for Agriculture. What is the Estimate that Deputy Cosgrave has accused us of wasting time in discussing? It is the first Estimate, which his chief Whip and his representative selected, for detailed and close discussion and consideration. The House has occupied three hours on the Vote for Law Charges, and in the course of these three hours there has been speech for speech. To every charge that was made, to every speech criticising the Estimate, which was made from the Opposition Benches, there was a rebutting speech from Government members. Is it the attitude of the Opposition that we are to sit here, keep silent and not reply to the criticisms that are hurled against us? When, Sir, last week I assumed that that was what the Opposition desired——
Comment on this
When I assumed last week that that was what the Opposition desired, that they liked to have it all their own way, when they were wasting the time of the House rising three and four times to say the same thing over and over again, in the hope that the dreary drip of their iteration would wear away the stony silence of the Minister, I was charged with being discourteous to the House.
Comment on this
It was alleged that I was treating the proceedings of the House with contempt but now, Sir, this week when we do rise to reply to the criticisms they make——
Comment on this
And because we did rise last night to reply to the criticisms of the Opposition, we are told to-day that we are wating time. When we rise, particularly, to take the part we are entitled to take in debating the Estimate which the Opposition themselves have chosen for close and detailed examination, we are told that we wish to burke discussion on the Estimates. Again, Sir, with regard to the second of these Estimates, the Vote for Agriculture, which the Opposition have asked to refer back, on Tuesday in the course of the debate on the motion to allocate time, the Parliamentary Secretary to the President, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, the Minister for Agriculture, and myself offered, that if the Opposition assisted in getting these motions out of the way earlier, they would have not merely the balance of each day's time, but also the greater part of to-morrow to discuss the Vote on agriculture, and, if that were not sufficient, we could give them a whole day next week. The Opposition refused to accept the offer, rejected it, and said, in a moment of pique possibly, "We do not want a day; we do not want this extra time to discuss the Vote on Agriculture." Yet in the speech to which we have just listened from Deputy Cosgrave opposing the motion, we are told that here are these two important items which they will not be permitted to discuss.
We have met the Opposition in every way. We have engaged in a serious debate on the Vote for Law Charges. We have offered them ample time to discuss the Vote for Agriculture and yet they are not satisfied. Deputy Cosgrave says that one of the reasons why we are anxious to get these things through is that we wish to deny the people an opportunity of knowing how the cost of administration is mounting in this State. In the Appropriation Bill the total amount which has to be passed for the Supply Services is set out in plain figures, a total amount of £27,000,000 odd. Is there any doubt but that to-morrow all the morning papers will have those figures emblazoned in large type across the principal news page? Of all the objections the Deputy has urged to this motion that is the flimsiest—that the people will not know what the cost of the public services is—when every newspaper, particularly every Opposition newspaper, will carry that knowledge to the people in large type to-morrow.
Deputy Cosgrave also said—I do not know exactly how relevant it was to this motion—that if we wanted to find economies we could find economies in the Gárda. We tried, when we first took office, to put ourselves in a position in which it would be possible to reduce unnecessary expenses on the police forces. We stopped recruitment for the Guards until what appeared to us a very serious and dangerous position had arisen in the State. Then we had to resume recruitment and to bring the Gárda up to its normal strength. Why has it been necessary to do that? Let Deputy Cosgrave, who has a personal knowledge of this matter, because he sits for one of the southern constituencies and he made a public pronouncement in regard to it some time ago, answer.
Comment on this
Because of the campaign of destruction and outrage that has been carried on by those who are avowed members of the Deputies' organisation, and not merely members of it but responsible officers in it, because of the campaign of arson and destruction which those who are members of the League of Youth——
Comment on this
This activist organisation which operates under the guise of a peaceful constitutional movement——
Comment on this
——with Deputy Mulcahy, Deputy Cosgrave and other apparently law-abiding citizens, as masks and camouflage for it. Then he asks us to reduce expenditure upon the Guards. Let Deputy Cosgrave call off his dogs. Let him stop the slaughter of milch cows. Let him stop——
Comment on this
The Leader of the Opposition mentioned three respects in which he thought the expenses of Government might be reduced. That might not have been strictly in order but was in reply to a question put last night. The Minister has stated his reasons for increasing the expenditure on one of those heads but a discussion should not now be originated on contentious matters that have been repeatedly discussed. That would cut across the discussion of the Estimates. Furthermore, it would not be relevant to this motion.
Comment on this
I shall not occupy the time of the House any longer except to say this, that apparently the Opposition leader is under the illusion that the longer we talk about something, the more closely we discuss it and the more carefully we consider it. I would ask them, in conclusion, in coming to a decision on the terms of the Resolution, to remember the concluding words of the then President of the Executive Council, Deputy Cosgrave as he is now, in a similar debate on the 10th July, 1929. "I think," he said, "it will be admitted that the consideration of the Estimates does not depend on the amount of time devoted to their discussion. We could have done as much business in a shorter time by a more pithy discussion. I am not drawing any distinction between the Opposition to-day and the Opposition in times when it was smaller in numbers, but I would say for my own part that I had to pay more attention to the Estimates when the discussion depended upon a smaller number of Deputies in Opposition than I have now." I think, Sir, that that accurately reflects the position at the present day. We had a much closer discussion of the Estimates when we had a smaller number of Deputies in Opposition.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance delivered himself almost of an epigram, that the House seems to be under a delusion that the more we debate this matter the closer we get to facts. It more or less amounted to that. So far as he and his Parliamentary Secretary are concerned, both to-day and yesterday we had ample proof that is not so. I think the Minister can refresh his memory on that point. He need not go back too far, only to yesterday, when the House unanimously decided that he was completely irrelevant and Deputies did not want to hear him any more. It was a new precedent, a perfectly new precedent in this House. All sides admitted that the Minister was merely wasting time. The Minister who did not interfere in the various phases of the Committee Stage of the Finance Bill, did interfere when there was a chance of curtailing some of the Opposition time and the House unanimously decided that he was obstructing, that he was purely irrelevant.
His Parliamentary Secretary spoke last night for well over an hour. I think it was about 9.20 p.m., when his attention was first called to the fact that he was not on the subject. He was still speaking at 10.30 p.m. Perhaps the Minister disputes these times. The Parliamentary Secretary might not have been speaking one and a half hours, but he certainly was not speaking one and a half hours on the subject, judging from the fact that six or seven times, I will not say he was called to order, but his attention was vainly directed to the fact that he was not on the subject. The Minister pointed out that they did exercise their rights—the Government — and even the Parliamentary Secretary and Deputy Corry were let loose, these well-known time wasters. Until the Government had already determined to curtail the time, there was no contribution from the Government benches except from the Minister's colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The contribution came in when there was an opportunity just as the Minister had to-day. When there was no curtailment of time the Minister would not speak. He spoke yesterday and to-day, but he was silent when it was his business to speak. That is the interesting fact. He only speaks when he can still further cat into the time that is given to the House to discuss these matters. He referred to the amount of time given in 1929. Why not give all the relevant facts? If he will look up his own speech on that occasion he will find that when the guillotine motion was then proposed, 109 hours had already been given to the Estimates. To-day the Parliamentary Secretary was able to make out that almost 79 hours were given to Estimates this year. That, for a man who wants all the facts revealed, was a relevant fact that the Minister might have drawn attention to. Furthermore, at that time there were only eight Estimates that were to be discussed; there are now 23. What were the eight Estimates at that time? After that there was a full discussion on Fisheries; there was a discussion on the Ministry of Finance. Those that stood over were not the Agricultural Vote, but the Agricultural Grant, Universities and Colleges, Law Charges, Beet, Quit Rent, Civil Service Commission, Management of Government Stocks and Advances to the Compensation Fund.
The Minister, who now proposes the closure on £11,000,000 of expenditure, has the effrontery to make a comparison between the course that he is adopting to-day and the course that was adopted then. It was remarkable that until these motions were put down we had hardly any intervention from the Government Benches. The Minister's Parliamentary Secretary spoke on every other subject apparently under the sun except Law Charges, and his attention was called to the fact seven times that he was not yet on the point after at least one hour and ten minutes' discussion, if not more. That is what they consider making a contribution to the debate.
Comment on this
The Minister summed up the situation in this way, that so far as the Department of Finance is represented on those benches by himself and his Parliamentary Secretary, the more we discuss the less we get into touch with the matters under discussion. He speaks about our being unable to control our followers. His Party controlled its followers well during the Committee Stage of the Finance Bill. Not one of them was let loose. Once or twice I saw Deputy Corry bursting to speak, but there were frowns and angry admonitions passed back to him that he was to keep his mouth shut, and the strange thing is that he did keep it shut. Further, there was the question of agreement that the Minister referred to. Is the Minister not aware that it was made quite clear that such is his conduct when in charge of the business of the House that Deputies will be drawn into speech either by his attitude towards the House or towards the Chair? It was pointed out to the Minister for Industry and Commerce that if he wanted his three hours he could get it by amending his guillotine resolution without any agreement. That was suggested to him. There could be then no charge of broken agreements. He had only to amend his guillotine resolution to allow a discussion on the Committee Stage. It would have been accepted, but he did not do it. Why? Because, apparently, he preferred an agreement which his colleague says there was no guarantee would be kept. It is quite obvious he did not stand over anything of the kind. The Minister said certain things that I took note of, but you, Sir, ruled it out of order. I cannot, therefore, discuss the highly provocative action of the Government. It is hard to believe that it is meant for any other purpose except to promote disorder. You ruled that out of order, Sir, and I cannot now go into it.
There are a number of matters that we were anxious to discuss on the Estimates and they are now closured. We had nothing better put forward to-day than that there could be no serious discussion unless there was a motion to refer back. A motion to refer back an estimate would make no difference, and the followers of the Minister who so frequently hang upon his words would still be here to vote if not to listen. I would like the simple-minded Minister to tell us what is the difference. We can have a full discussion without a motion to refer back.
There were a number of matters which I should like to have an opportunity of presenting in order to get information. I do not say that I would have got it, but as a member of this House I regard it as my duty to at least try to elicit the information. There is, for instance, here an item No. 71—Repayment of Dáil Eireann External Loans. The House will remember the shock that was occasioned when that particular Bill was going through. It was described as scandalous and cynical. We want to know something about the administration of that Act. I would like to know whether the confidence trick upon which it was based—that was the phrase used at the time—has worked out successfully. I would like to get from the Minister information as to where these moneys that were paid back, are now. Have they got to the final quarter which the promoters of the Bill expected they would reach? I would be rather keen on that because the discussion of the Bill was cut very short when it came before the House.
Comment on this
That query does not relate to any item of the particular Vote or Estimate which is limited to administration for repayment of the Dáil Eireann Loan.
Comment on this
There is no Estimate before the House now. The matter before the House is item No. 7. If the Deputy wants to discuss the Estimate he can do so in its proper place.
Comment on this
The Chair has some difficulty in distinguishing between a discussion of the Estimate and an effort to obtain particulars of repayments under the Act.
Comment on this
Perhaps I have not made myself clear. The endeavour on my part to find out what is in the Estimate and the fact that I am precluded from that endeavour is now one of my reasons for objecting to this particular motion. I may say that my reason for opposing this motion is that I am precluded by such a motion from procuring that information. If that is not relevant, I cannot see what would be relevant. I think it is most relevant and most germane. I cannot think of any stronger reason at the moment for opposing the motion. It may be my fault that I cannot see how it could be otherwise, but I certainly say I cannot see any stronger reason for opposing the motion than that it precludes me from discussing certain things upon which I am trying to get information and have not been able to get it.
One of the things mentioned here is old age pensions. I am not going to discuss old age pensions, but I would like further information from the Minister in charge in reference to old age pensions. We remember that in his Budget statement the Minister for Finance estimated that he expected by administration to save £100,000. There are a number of things that I would like to have discussed in relation to that particular reference but I am precluded from discussing them by this particular motion. I think it is scandalous that members of the House should be precluded by a motion put down by the Government, from discussing these things. Does anyone believe that the Minister will stop short of this £100,000. What kind of administration is it upon which such a sum of money can be saved so easily. These are matters that I would like to have raised. I am only giving an illustration of the kind of things that I would like to have raised on this old age pension item.
Then there is the item for Secret Service; there is no chance of discussing that. We were challenged by the Government and by the Minister for Finance and his colleagues to say how we would propose that money should be saved. But we would like to have the opportunity of discussing the expenditure of the couple of millions spent on bounties and subsidies and as to the cause of the continuance of these particular measures which follow from the Government's lamentable policy. The country has been reduced to the condition in which it is as a result of the Government's policy. It is nothing short of cynical to pretend that parliamentary institutions should be debarred from discussing one of the largest items of the expenditure of the whole year, and debarred from discussing the nation-killing policy that has given rise to these particular Estimates and has made these votes necessary. Surely it is the negation of anything in the nature of parliamentary control of finance when this sort of thing can go on. As on the best opportunity we have of discussing this mad policy of the Government, we are deliberately shut out from discussing it by the motion now before the House, we can see the condition to which parliamentary government has been brought.
There are quite a number of other things that we could raise on these items. There is, for example, the Appropriation Bill. We are debarred from discussing that also. These are all matters of wide general interest. Unfortunately we have had too much evidence within the last couple of weeks of the serious inroads that have been made on the parliamentary institutions by the Government and by their conduct of public business in this House. I suggest that a very appropriate matter for discussion would be the Appropriation Bill. Then again there is the question of wide national interest, namely, the attitude of the Government towards the Press. I would like to have an opportunity of eliciting information on that particular point, because I have heard many complaints of the utilisation of the Press Bureau set up for the alleged purpose of giving information to the public and the utilisation of that bureau for the purpose of terrorising the Press.
Comment on this
Provision for the Press Bureau is contained in the Vote for the office of the President.
Comment on this
I am trying to answer the point raised by the Minister I said that I was anxious to raise matters of wide general interest on the Appropriation Bill, but he is anxious to have discussion curtailed. I can well understand from everything I have heard, Sir, why the Minister is exceedingly sensitive on this particular matter. I have heard extraordinary stories of the way in which that Press Bureau has been used to muzzle the Press. I would have liked to have heard some justification—if the Minister had such a justification—for the open attempt they made to nobble or to muzzle one particular organ. I will admit that they quickly got away from that, Sir, but I should like to know how far, in secret, they have used it, because my information would certainly justify all these questions being put, and would justify the most searching examination into the conduct of the Government in this particular matter. It might have been possible, I admit, to raise this matter on the President's Vote, but that is so big a Vote that we kept to general matters, and the practice has grown up in the House that, once the main matter is disposed of, it is extremely difficult to discuss matters of detail such as that.
Comment on this
The invariable practice is that once an Estimate has been passed by this House, discussion on it may not be reopened.
Comment on this
I am not discussing anything on an Estimate, Sir, but I am raising the matter in reference to the Appropriation Bill. I suggest that it was a matter of wide general interest and that it was perfectly appropriate to raise it on that particular Bill. I was very careful, Sir, as you will remember, to point out that it was in reference to the Appropriation Bill I was discussing it, and not in reference to any Estimate. However, I give these merely as illustrations as to why the Government should be anxious to closure this discussion, and as to why any Opposition, with a sense of duty to the country, should be extremely determined not to allow it to be closured. It refers to the attempt to closure discussion on the expenditure of some £11,000,000. It prevents discussion on vital matters such as those I have mentioned. It is a pity, as I say, that, when our Parliamentary institutions are practically tottering as a result of the Government's action, we have no opportunity of discussing their attitude towards the other great bulwark of democratic institutions, namely, the Press.
Comment on this
Sir, the Parliamentary Secretary has moved a motion which seeks to impose a closure on the discussion in respect of the Estimates which, so far, have not been dealt with. I think that he has sought, in the course of his remarks in justification of the Motion, to show that these Estimates are in somewhat the same category as the items discussed on certain stages of the Finance Bill. I should like to call the attention of the Minister, however, to the fact that he is now seeking to prevent discussion on matters which have not been dealt with so far by this House, whereas, in the case of the Finance Bill, I think it could truthfully be said that a considerable amount of time was wasted in repetition of arguments which had been made times out of number during the passage of that Bill through this House. I voted for the closure of the discussion on the Finance Bill because I believed that the speeches which had been made had not an iota of new thought or of new arguments in them: that they had already been made, and that, if Deputies believed in the validity and strength of their first arguments, it was quite unnecessary to repeat the same speech time after time. I think it can be said, with every truth, that many of the speeches made on the Finance Bill were just unnecessary repetition—talk merely for talk's sake. That was certainly clear from the discussions we had last week.
Comment on this
Last week, we had a discussion on matters of such profound national importance as football covers and golf sticks. The time of the House was clearly wasted in the discussion of that matter. This motion, however, is altogether different. This motion seeks to say that at 12 o'clock to-morrow all these Estimates, not then dealt with, will be automaticaly passed by the House and, consequently, the House is going to surrender the opportunity of discussing in detail the Estimates which are set out on the Order Paper.
Comment on this
There are many important Estimates contained in this list. If this were only a matter dealing with certain formal grants to institutions, or grants to maintain that important body known as the Administrators of the Quit Rent Office, I think that the House would give the Minister these Estimates; but, in addition, we are asked to curtail the time for discussion on Agriculture. We are asked to curtail the time for discussion on Fisheries. We are to have no opportunity of discussing the Estimate for the Minister's own Department and we are to have no opportunity of discussing the manner in which the £100,000 will be saved on old age pensions this year. In the latter respect, I should like to ascertain what precise machinery the Minister has constituted to make sure that, when the £100,000 is saved, the economy ramp will not be carried further in order to save £150,000, or £200,000. Can we be sure that the Minister is going to stop at the saving of that £100,000?
Comment on this
Or are we going to be presented with the spectacle, at the end of the year, of the Minister indicating that the work of the section of his Department dealing with old age pensions was so efficient that the economies actually yielded £150,000 instead of the £100,000 foreshadowed in his Budget speech? The Minister's own Department is a very important matter. The Minister says that these Estimates have been on the Order Paper for a long time, but his own Estimate has only reappeared on the Order Paper quite recently after having been off the Order Paper for a considerable time, and the House was asked to discuss a number of minor Estimates while we were not given an opportunity of discussing the Estimate for the Minister's own Department. The Minister's Estimate is concerned with the control of the Civil Service. His Estimate is responsible for the conditions of employment in the Civil Service, for the wages in the Civil Service, for the wages paid on minor relief schemes, for the wages of the Wages Advisory Committee which advises the Government and which recently advised the Government to reduce the wages of forestry workers in Offaly from 28/- a week to 22/- a week—and that just before we had this Budget, with its imposition of new taxation, introduced. Are we to be denied the opportunity of discussing that, or are we to be denied the opportunity of discussing on what basis wages were reduced from 28/- a week to 22/- a week for the forestry workers in Offaly? Are we to be denied the opportunity of pointing out to the Minister and to the community generally the low rates of wages paid under the jurisdiction of those in charge of the public services, or the starvation wages that are paid in many Departments of the public service? Are we to be denied the opportunity of bringing home to the Minister and to the House the fact that cleaners, paid at coolie rates of wages, have been seeking to secure from the Minister an increase of wages which even the most rapacious employer in the City of Dublin or elsewhere would have given them, having regard to their present low rates of wages?
The House is asked to gag itself on these matters. The House is not to ask any questions on these matters. Of course, there is another matter of transcending importance, not merely to the Civil Service, but to the whole community, and that is the question of the implementation of the Government's promise to set up an arbitration board for the Civil Service. It is over three years ago since the President embodied in the famous Fianna Fáil manifesto of February, 1932, a promise to establish an arbitration board. The Minister can clearly recollect the precise terms in which the President indicated that the Civil Service was going to have that arbitration board. It was indicated in the speech delivered by the President at the Rathmines Town Hall. That is three and a half years ago. The Civil Service was then promised arbitration, and up to the present they have not got the arbitration which was then promised. Recently there was circulated what was described by the Minister's Department as the draft heads of a scheme of arbitration, and that was done on the direction of the Minister. I do not know whether the Minister is the author of that scheme. If he is, he ought to claim patent rights for it as a scheme of arbitration, because certainly anybody who could get away with the contention that the scheme as issued by the Department of Finance is an arbitration scheme ought to keep that secret and exploit it for his own benefit.
We are to be denied the opportunity of discussing that spurious scheme which has recently been issued by the Department. We are to be denied the opportunity of discussing this counterfeit form of arbitration for the Civil Service, after the promise by which their votes were obtained in the 1932 election. Are we not entitled to an opportunity of discussing that, and telling the community that the kind of arbitration which the Minister has in mind is one under which he himself can decide what matters are to go to arbitration; under which he can decide the way in which the reference to arbitration is to be framed; under which he is not only to be free to choose his own advocates, as defendant, but he is also to be allowed to prescribe the kind of persons that the plaintiffs must select for their advocates? Mr. Thomas would be delighted with the scheme of arbitration which the Minister for Finance has now issued. The President was quite indignant when it was sought to put any restriction on his choice of representatives before an international tribunal. Now it is sought by the Minister for Finance in the same Government to do the very same thing that the President objected to Britain doing in respect of arbitration on the disputed financial payments. Those are all matters of considerable importance. Those are all matters which not only affect the well-being of the State and its servants but affect large numbers of the Minister's own constituents, and yet we have been asked to vote for a closure motion to stifle discussion on those matters. If I thought there was merely a desire to drag out an unnecessary discussion on those Estimates my viewpoint would be different, but we are now asked to vote for a motion to guillotine discussion on those Estimates although so far the House has not had an opportunity of wasting one minute on them.
There may be a case for a closure motion; I am not a doctrinaire of opposition to closure motions. If we are going to maintain democratic Government in the country I think we must take the view that democracy does not consist merely in talking, and that any democratic State must ensure that its business is done in a reasonable and expeditious way, after reasonable discussion has been allowed and a fair opportunity has been given to Deputies of all Parties to express their views. But we are now asked by the Minister for Finance to pass Estimates without discussion. As I said, we could probably pass the Vote for the Quit Rent Office without discussion, and perhaps grants to certain Universities and Colleges could be passed without discussion, but we are now asked to pass over such important items as the Estimate for the Minister's own office and for old age pensions without any discussion and without it having been shown by the Minister that a second of time has been wasted in discussing the matter. Whatever case there might have been —and I personally think there was a strong case—for a closure motion on other matters, where it was believed that time was being wasted in unnecessary repetition, there is no case whatever for moving a closure motion to prevent discussion of Estimates which have not so far been discussed. Whatever case the Minister can make for the closure motion in respect of the Finance Bill there is no case for moving a closure motion to throttle discussion on Estimates which have not yet been reached, and in respect of which not one word has yet been said. I would ask the Minister at all events in the circumstances not to apply the closure motion in respect of those important Estimates. In respect of unimportant Estimates the House will, I think, be guided by its own desires and its own conveniences. I hardly think at this time of the year that there will be much waste of time or much unnecessary discussion on those Estimates. It is obviously unfair to the House—and I personally protest against it—to make any effort to fix an unreasonable time table for discussion of important Estimates, and that is what the Minister is seeking to do by moving this motion.
Comment on this
Might I ask your advice as to whether, if there is no motion down to refer an Estimate back, that Estimate is assumed to be agreed to? The Minister mentioned that there are only two Estimates here about which there were motions to refer back. Are we to assume that the others are agreed to?
Comment on this
It is not necessary, in order to discuss an Estimate, to have a motion to refer back. A motion to refer back or reduce the Vote is an indication of a desire to discuss the whole policy involved in that Vote. The absence of a motion to refer back does not preclude discussion of the Vote.
Comment on this
But the Minister has mentioned that, for instance, when you wish a Vote to be abolished, a motion to refer back would be inadequate. At any rate, I think that the motion which we are discussing to-day is the most objectionable of the three. The motion yesterday was more reasonable, but I think there is no excuse whatever for this guillotine motion. The Minister has adopted the guillotine in this House, but we are all well aware that the people are setting up a far bigger guillotine outside in preparation for the Minister. I have listened to the discussion during the last few days, and I have noticed two schools of thought amongst the speakers. Some felt that this situation which we have arrived at is due to incompetence on the part of the Government, and others have urged very strongly that it is the result of deliberate conspiracy on the part of the Government to curtail if not to supersede parliamentary government by a form of Party dictatorship. I, myself, was rather inclined to the more lenient view until I listened to the speeches of Deputy Corry and his spiritual disciple, the Minister for Industry and Commerce. They rather convinced me that there was a deliberate conspiracy, but, on the other hand, I think one's better judgment would be that the conspiracy, if it exists, is the result of previous incompetence on the part of the Government, and particularly their incompetence in the conducting of public business during last winter. They could easily have prevented the congestion which is taking place to-day if the Ministry had taken the trouble to give the Dáil work to do during the winter months.
There were many Bills of a social nature such as the Widows and Orphans Bill which could have been taken last winter, and there were a great many other social Bills which could well have been introduced last winter with the result that the summer session could have been devoted exclusively to financial matters. The time of the House is now being taken up with Bills of one kind or another; Bills that could have been brought in last winter. Instead of that Deputies were summoned up here for one day in the week and returned home the next day. With them it was like the song of the "Old Bog Road"— Deputies can "go their way and draw their pay and smoke their pipe alone." There is, however, one bright spot in the whole situation, and that is that it is clear that the Government is getting old and feeble. Like old despots, the tendency is to become more and more tyrannical. When his grasp on things is slipping from the hand of the tyrant he gets more and more tyrannical. This Government claims to be democratic. They climbed into power by means of abusing the Parliamentary system. Now when they have got into power they wish to sweep away the ladder on which they climbed. I think I can safely say that this Party can no longer climb up on the shoulders of democracy. In the case of any future inroads they may make upon the democratic system we are forewarned and will be forearmed. I must say that the Labour Party has ably assisted them in this matter. They usually do.
The Votes which we would have to consider ordinarily include such important Estimates as the fisheries, about which there should be very lengthy discussion. There is very great dissatisfaction in the matter of fisheries all round at present. I presume we will have an opportunity some time later this year of discussing the Fishery Vote. There is another Estimate—that is the Estimate for the Oireachtas, which will now I presume go through without discussion. That is an Estimate on which I had something to say. Then there is another Estimate for a very considerable sum —that is the Estimate for Secret Services. On that Estimate all discussion will be suppressed. So far as I remember on a previous occasion here when these Estimates were passed en bloc because of the imminence of a General Election they were brought up later for a discussion in the autumn session. I wonder would it be possible in this case to do the same and to allow in the autumn a discussion on Estimates not adequately discussed in the summer session. That, I think, was the case in 1927.
Comment on this
It was not the case in 1929. However, in view of the importance of some of these Estimates, that is a suggestion that I think the Minister should consider.
Comment on this
On that point, might I explain to the House that there is a very big legislative programme for the Autumn Session?
Comment on this
There are a good many reasons why we should oppose this motion. In the case made to-day by the Minister the argument was advanced that the time of the House had been wasted by Deputies on this side. We had the curious spectacle of the Minister, a Parliamentary Secretary, and a few Deputies who treated this House with the utmost contempt when we were discussing the Financial Resolution coming here themselves and deliberately wasting time, even in the course of the last 18 hours, and even on the motion which they themselves are proposing in order to save time. The Minister rated Deputy Cosgrave for having suggested that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance spoke for an hour and a half yesterday. He rated Deputy Cosgrave because the Deputy was not precise to the minute. The fact was that the Parliamentary Secretary spoke for about one and a quarter hours. That was on a Vote for £60,000. If every Deputy in the House had spoken a proportionate length on the Estimates as the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance had spoken, I calculated that the time taken in discussing the whole of the Estimates would have been 40 hours. The Minister tells us that we on this side of the House are responsible for the waste of time.
But this motion arose out of the difficulty the Ministry themselves created on last Friday and Saturday when they succeeded in keeping country Deputies here from Friday evening until Saturday evening, knowing full well that if the country Deputies did not get away early on Friday that the week-end was of no good to them. The Ministers themselves could get to their homes no matter what hour they left, and they could take up any work of their own outside their Parliamentary duties. But the country Deputies were compelled to stay here until midnight on Friday. Having been kept here, having been compelled to stay, they took part in the debates. Had they been liberated earlier all they could have done would be to have gone to a picture house on Friday night. The Minister spoke about wasting time. I know myself that Deputy after Deputy had to get up on this side of the House in order to drag information out of the Minister. That was information which the Minister refused to give. Now he accuses us of wasting time. Our efforts to get the information would not have been necessary if the Minister had given reasonable opportunities to Deputies in the course of the debate. I myself made speeches that I would not have made in the course of an ordinary debate if the Minister had been courteous and helped us to elicit the information that we sought. At all events, our speeches had the merit of being relevant. We were not ruled out by the Ceann Comhairle. The speech of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance last evening was not relevant.
In our speeches there was no attempt to treat the House with contempt. The main reason why my colleagues and I object to this Closure Motion is that we are interested in the chief industry of the country. The Vote for Agriculture is one of the Votes that have been closured. The Old Age Pensions Vote has also been closured. I will not repeat what Deputy Norton has said on that Vote. But there are other Estimates, particularly the Estimate for Agriculture. There was never a time since the institution of this State when the policy of the Government in relation to agriculture needed to be more closely examined than it does to-day, and debate is to be curtailed on that.
The Minister says that he made us an offer to give us a day next week for its discussion. The Minister brought in a motion here to save time. He himself took half an hour of that time, and his Parliamentary Secretary took one and a quarter hours yesterday. What guarantee have we, if they did give us a day next week, that they themselves would not take seven-eighths of that day and again put up the Parliamentary Secretary or Deputy Corry to waste the time they gave us? There are important questions that we should like to put to the Minister on the Vote for Agriculture and which we possibly will not get an opportunity of putting. I should have liked to ask the Minister if he would explain why the value of the stock-in-trade of farmers has diminished by £23,000,000 since 1931. I am not speaking from hearsay, but am taking the figures from the book which the Minister himself recently published giving agricultural statistics. Taking those figures, I find that if we were to take an inventory of farmers' goods to-day they are £23,000,000 short of the value of the goods in 1931. I should like to give the Minister an opportunity of explaining that, and the Minister might find it difficult. The Minister would have to keep the same silence as he deliberately enforced on the members on his own benches last week.
I should like to ask the Minister why he pursued the policy of cutting down the store cattle stock in this country when he was forewarned last spring that it was probable that we would not be able to keep the arrangement made with Great Britain to send a certain number of cattle to that country; why he deliberately pursued a policy of slaughtering animals, and why it is necessary to-day to withdraw the licences and allow the free entry of store cattle into the British market. The Minister has killed the store cattle trade in this country, and he knows it. This is, perhaps, not the time to go into that fully, and I am just mentioning some things which I would like to ask the Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture, unfortunately, is not here. The Minister for Agriculture is as responsible as the Minister for Finance for this closure motion. He ought to have known that when we came to discuss this motion some reference would have to be made to the Estimates that are being closured. Some other Ministers might have been here, even if only a passing reference to their Departments had to be made when discussing the closure of 23 Estimates. We know that it is going to be impossible to discuss most of these Estimates and, therefore, Deputies were bound to make some reference to the Estimates that were being closured and on which an opportunity for discussion was not to be given. But we have only the Minister for Finance here.
One should have liked to have asked the Minister for Agriculture also why, when issuing licences, because there are still a number of licences being issued, as only the store cattle ones are withdrawn, he adopted the principle of allowing licences to be issued by purely political bodies; why a discrimination of that kind should be made, as was the case recently in some counties. The Minister for Agriculture challenged us on various occasions last week to engage in a discussion on the relevant merits of wheat and live stock, and we should have liked to have that discussion. In regard to that, one could again quote from these statistics to show that there were possibilities in live stock rearing for farmers which there are not in wheat growing. One could have put to the Minister, as a definite refutation of his statement that a purely wheat-growing or tillage policy is the best for this country, inasmuch as it employs most labour——
Comment on this
I am loath to interrupt the Deputy in the circumstances of the case, but I put it to him that if the motion before the House were disposed of, the Vote on Agriculture might be reached. Without projecting myself into the debate, I suggest that the discussion which the Deputy is now entering upon would be more relevant on the Estimate for Agriculture.
Comment on this
Have we any guarantee that if this motion were disposed of the Estimate for Agriculture would be come to? Would the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance continue his speech upon the Estimate for Law Charges for another one and a half hours, like he did last night?
Comment on this
There is one portion of this motion which states "That the total sum outstanding in respect of the Estimates for Public Services for the year ending 31st day of March, 1936, be granted for the service of that year." It would appear that in this motion, racing against the face of the clock, we are asked to vote money for certain public services, and that therefore the discussion of these public services should directly arise on this motion.
Comment on this
My point is that if some of us, on the discussion of this motion, did not take the chance of giving the House some reason for opposing it and make some reference to agriculture, the opportunity might never arise again. If the House were discussing the Estimate for Agriculture ordinarily, I think it would be necessary for me to speak at great length. I do not think I could cover all the ground in less than an hour, or an hour and a half. I do not propose to take that much time now. There are other Deputies who would have just as much to say on that Estimate and there are Government Deputies who, in defence of their own policy, or if they had any argument to put forward against what was said, would have to reply at length and the Estimate in these circumstances would have taken possibly longer than it ever took in this House before. That was the reason why the Minister wilfully postponed this Estimate from day to day. Other Estimates have been taken out of their order, but the Estimate for Agriculture has been deliberately left over so that it could, at the end of the session, he burked and put into a list of closured Estimates.
To my mind, the Government had never any intention that agriculture should be fully discussed in the present session. I do not intend to go into the question of agriculture further than that. As I said, if I were to make the speech that I intended to make on agriculture, and perhaps that I shall make if the Government change their minds and give us sufficient time to discuss it here, it would take more time than I should like to waste on this motion.
There are other Estimates besides agriculture that we should like to have discussed. I mentioned agriculture because I am chiefly concerned with agriculture. There are other Members, however, interested in one or other of the closured Estimates. The fact that the Ministry have found it possible to spare a day next week is, in itself, proof that their time for the coming week was not already fully occupied and that all the fuss about a Friday night sitting and a sitting until late on Saturday evening was altogether unnecessary. Their argument, that because these Estimates must be passed by the 31st July it was necessary to bring in the closure, is as futile as any of the other arguments the Ministry have used. They know full well that the Seanad would not have refused to pass any measures necessary to get the Appropriation Bill through in time, that there is no precedent for the Seanad refusing to do so, and that if they were a day or two late in sending these matters to the Seanad it would not matter. They know also that silence on the Government Benches when we are discussing an important Estimate or an important measure does not lead to a shortening of debate. If Ministers prefer to remain sullenly silent or refuse to explain certain points which are raised, there are bound to be strong speeches to try to force out of the Ministry an explanation about certain things which they are deliberately trying to conceal and which they are unable to defend.
Comment on this
Like the previous speaker, I would not have intervened in this debate—I would like to see the motion discussed and, I presume, passed as quickly as possible, so that we could get down to the business proper—if we were sure that we would not be obstructed in discussing the Estimates in their proper sequence. Those of us who take a special interest in certain Estimates feel disgusted and pained when we find complete ignor-amuses getting up on the Government Benches and occuping the time of the House for an hour or two, telling us something that every child on a farm in the country knows to be untrue. Like the previous speaker, I felt last week that a few words spoken by the Minister for Finance, by way of explanation on many points, would have shortened the discussion considerably because critics of the Bill then before the House in Committee would not have any room, even if they wanted to, for making certain assumptions, as the Minister could, with one word have put us right on these matters. Even if they wanted to prolong the discussion, he could have shortened it by a word or two. The day before yesterday, after a similar motion to this had been carried and when we were tied down to a definite time, he occupied 40 minutes out of one effective hour which we had for debate, and he made statements that were laughable and which he dare not make if there was an open discussion, because he knew they could be refuted by any Deputy in the House.
We were told a while ago, I think by the Minister for Finance, that ample time would be given for the discussion on the Vote for Agriculture. There are two Estimates here which I am particularly anxious to discuss. I hope I shall get time to discuss them and that I shall not be obstructed by the misrepresentations of the Minister for Finance. I hope that the queries that I put to him yesterday will be answered. If they are not answered, I shall continue to repeat them. I shall stop his mouthings about a Republic when he is not even operating a Dominion in this country. The Minister for Agriculture said a day or two ago: "If you want time to debate agriculture, we shall give it to you." I do not know if that offer was rejected. Personally, I shall be glad to accept it. If a day or two were allowed to discuss the Estimate for Agriculture I think it would be well worth while. The time of the House could be very usefully employed in debating it. We farmers over here are not afraid of an all-night sitting if necessary.
Comment on this
If they want a trial of strength we will give it to them, but I hope it will not come to that. As a farmer I do not want to trip up the Minister for Agriculture. I am prepared to support the Minister on many things. I have done so and will continue to do so. I hope that when we enter on that discussion the Minister will not take up the attitude that he frequently adopts. I do not think it is the intention of the Minister to conceal any information from the House, but by slightly changing the tone he sometimes adopts, he could be very useful in rounding off points on occasions when Deputies are looking for information. I should be glad to hear repeated the offer to give a whole day or a couple of days if necessary to the vote for Agriculture. I would be glad to take up a reasonable share of these two days——
Comment on this
——and I shall take it up intelligently. The Minister for Agriculture went further and said that if that were not sufficient he would be prepared to accept a motion on Agriculture and give time for its discussion. I should like to hear that repeated.
Comment on this
I remember asking if such a thing could be done six months ago, and I was told that it could not be done. The Minister for Finance said that that offer was turned down, but I do not know anything about that. To come back to the motion itself, I wonder whether under the ruling given yesterday it would be in order to discuss the matters covered by this motion? I, however, do not propose doing that. I look upon the motion simply as a motion to fix a limit for the discussion of these items, and I do not want to go into the items themselves. Within those limits, I should like to see the motion before us disposed of as quickly as possible so that we can get down to the business proper. Then we shall be entirely in the hands of the Chair. I have no doubt that the Chair will give a fair and square deal to all sides of the House, so long as Deputies are not killing time or introducing any arguments which they are not entitled to introduce. I hope the Chair will watch carefully any attempt at obstruction.
Comment on this
Personally, I am quite prepared to leave it to the Chair, and I am sure that all sides of the House will get a square deal from the Chair within the manacles that this motion will put on.
Comment on this
I really consider that it is nothing short of a grave public scandal that this Parliament should be asked to rush through a Motion affecting millions of public money in a year such as this without ample time for discussion as to why those moneys are required, how they are going to be spent, and without any opportunity of getting the Minister responsible for the various heads of expenditure to give some explanation to the House and to the people outside as to why the money is required, how it is proposed to be spent and, above all, how he proposes to collect it. The meaning of the motion is this, that if it were not to be discussed even for 30 seconds, nine hours of Parliamentary time are to be given for voting millions of pounds for 23 different Government services.
Comment on this
A million an hour and no discussion. The moneys are required for such absolutely dissimilar services as are enumerated here: local loans, law charges, miscellaneous expenses, quit rent office, agriculture, fisheries, Oireachtas, office of the Minister for Finance, office of the Revenue Commissioners, old age pensions, Civil Service Commission, property losses compensation, personal injuries compensation, superannuation and retired allowances, secret service, Tariff Commission, supplementary agricultural grants, universities and colleges, electrical battery development, remuneration for management of Government stocks, export bounties and subsidies, repayment of Dáil Eireann external loans and compensation bounties. I want to know from any impartial Deputy in the House whether it is really decent or reasonably fair to the public to come along and, under a guillotine gag motion, to demand and abstract from the people millions of pounds for these services without any discussion. We are asked to rush through, in a period of five or six hours, the moneys for all those 23 services at a time when the general taxation required for Government services has gone up by many millions. Included in this group of Estimates is a proposal to curtail the expenditure on old age pensions by £100,000 and to increase the expenditure on secret service from £900, as it was three years ago, to £20,000 as it is proposed to-day, and to wedge in between that cut in the old age pensions and that extravagance on secret service money a Vote such as the Department of Agriculture. I wish to protest against this new practice. Closure motions have been received here before on Bills where the debate was over-prolonged, where the situation was such that there was a genuine case of urgency; but I think this is about the first time that Estimates in bulk——
Comment on this
If I am to be interrupted, I will be interrupted in a specific manner. I am stating my opinion and my opinion I adhere to, and I repeat that it is the first time to my knowledge that Estimates in bulk were put through in this fashion.
Comment on this
The Minister is the most inaccurate Deputy or Minister in this House. Every second statement he has made here is proved to be incorrect, and the statement he is making now is on a par with the average statement he makes. We are here asked to put 23 Estimates through in bulk without discussion, without explanation, without the various Ministers responsible for the expenditure giving any report to the Dáil or the people why the money is required and how it is to be expended. That comes hot-foot on top of a period when we were asked to put through the Finance Bill by guillotine and when various motions taxing the people and interfering with trade were put through the Dáil also by guillotine motion. Under the guise of the guillotine motion, not satisfied with curtailing the time the Dáil has to discuss matters, we have one member of the Government Party after another put up to indulge in deliberate clowning in order to occupy the time of the House and take up even the limited time allowed for discussion. That reached such a degree that for the first time in this House, and I think even the Minister for Industry and Commerce will agree with me in this, there was absolute unanimity in gagging the Minister and agreeing that he was totally irrelevant. Fianna Fáil, Labour, the Independents and Fine Gael all supported the motion by Deputy Mulcahy that the Minister for Finance was foolishly and frivolously occupying the time of the House in order further to curtail discussion on matters of public importance.
I venture to express the opinion that the real reason why this closure motion is put down to curtail discussion on those 23 Estimates is in order to burke and dodge discussion on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture. The real reason why all these Estimates are bulked together is in order to shirk and avoid discussion or any criticism about the industry that is being slaughtered by the Fianna Fáil Government and the Minister for Agriculture. Even in face of this closure motion we find that the order of Estimates that existed here some days ago has been altered and Agriculture has been put further down on the list, so that if this motion was got through before 12 o'clock to-morrow there would be enough of that clowning spirit on the opposite benches to occupy the time of the House up to noon when, the motion tells us, every one of these Votes for many millions of pounds would be put one by one successively from the Chair and without any discussion. I want to know if the Minister or Deputies sitting near him, forgetting all about who is in the majority and who is in the minority and remembering only those we represent, the people who are asked to pay the piper, considers this procedure fair. It may be a cheap joke at the expense of the Opposition. It may be a smart Parliamentary trick; it may be the subject of humour for the like of Deputy Smith, but I want to know if it is fair to the people whose taxes are increasing. Is it fair that whatever point of view they want expressed, whether it is a point of view that is agreed to or disagreed with, should not get an opportunity of expression? But above all, is it fair that 23 dissimilar Votes should be rolled through the machine by a common Vote without any ample opportunity for discussing each and every one of them?
We have petty tyrants, and we are getting used to them, and we are beginning to see that they are producing reactions. A big tyrant may succeed, while a little tyrant brings about his own downfall very quickly. We have a group of little tyrants in this country who, by dishonest public words and lying promises, have got on to the benches over there, and think they are going to stay there by their choppings and changings. I believe there is nothing as nauseating to the public mind as the cowardly failure of a Government to stand up to their own expenditure. People, although they do not stand for such expenditure, will respect those who demand money, and are brave enough to stand up and defend its expenditure; but people have nothing but contempt for a crowd of little squanderers who pinch every penny out of the public pocket and shirk their responsibility when called to account for doing so. They shirk giving any explanation as to why this money is required, and as to how it is going to be spent. They give no explanation as to why there is economy at the expense of the poorest of the people and an increase of expenditure on the civil servants.
There are a number of questions which should be answered on these 23 Votes. By this motion the Government are trying to ensure how they can dodge their responsibility and avoid even being asked to answer questions put to them. They can dodge their responsibilities by quick, unfair, dishonest and bullying tactics. They may shed themselves of their responsibility here, but the people who are paying are watching all the time. When any man pays out money, from a penny to a pound, any time, and in any place, he is entitled to know, at least, what it is for. He is entitled to know what return he is going to get, and why he has to pay that much. Why is there a sort of divine exemption from income tax for those who occupy the front Government Bench? Is there any reason why they alone, in this State, should be entitled to take money and give no account as to why it is taken, what it is for, or how it is proposed it is expended? Is that the new substitute for the Republic? Are we to have that little tyranny in place of a Republic? Is that the latest smoke screen thrown out to stifle public discussion and to take the public mind off the pledges and false promises that were given by the Party opposite to the people? If that is the latest red herring, it will certainly defeat its purpose.
We have grouped in amongst these 23 or two dozen items, covered by this motion, the Estimates for the Department of Agriculture. I take it we are entitled to presume that that particular Vote will not be reached by 12 noon to-morrow. There are enough people on the other side of the House prepared to engage in inanities that will take an hour or two to-morrow out of the public time allowed in order to prevent that particular Vote being discussed. This particular motion includes an invitation to the House to Vote all the money required for the Services enumerated. We are asked to Vote money for particular purposes, quite apart from the motion outlined here, but we are entitled to discuss no specific Estimate, or heading under which money is asked for, and under which it is proposed to be spent. We are asked, in fact, without discussion and no opportunity of discussion, to approve the expenditure of the moneys here without any explanation from the Minister concerned. We are asked to vote money for Department of Agriculture and thereby to express approval of the agricultural policy which exists in this country at the moment. We are asked to do that without any explanation as to why the trade has shrunk, as to why the industry is crippled, or as to what has become of the promised foreign market.
When the Minister for Agriculture took over responsibility for the agricultural industry of this country, just three short years ago, the exports of the agricultural industry of the country were something like £44,000,000 per year. According to the statistics produced by the Department of Industry and Commerce £44,000,000 was coming into this country, to develop it, to provide for its people, to enable the farmers to pay wages, to enable them to pay their overhead charges and to enable them to provide for their families. In 1933, according to the latest returns I have seen, that £44,000,000 worth of exports had dropped to £17,000,000. The headings given of those exports by the Department of the Minister for Industry and Commerce are as follows:—In 1930 the value of the cattle exports was £14,600,000; in 1933 the value of the exports had dropped to £6,054,000. In 1930 the value of the sheep exported was £1,350,000; in 1933 it had dropped to £319,000. In 1930 the value of pigs exported was £2,500,000; in 1933 it had dropped to £310,000. In 1930 the value of the horses exported was £2,123,342; in 1933 the value had dropped to £784,515. The point I am making I notice has caused the Minister to smile, incredulously. He is, of course, capable of disowning responsibility for these figures and for words that have come out of his own mouth. The particular publication that I am quoting is the Trade and Shipping Statistics, 1933, compiled by the Department of Industry and Commerce. Whether it is correct or incorrect, the responsibility certainly is not mine; but it will be merely another minor scandal piled on top of several others if we are to be told that the figures are misleading or unreliable.
Comment on this
The production of a warped mind is capable of being understood only by a warped mind. We have a situation where the imports of this country have dropped from £56,000,000 to £35,000,000 and where we have a drop of £25,000,000 in the money coming into the country from outside. Now, I do not mind whether you argue that, if exports are down, imports are down also, and that we are becoming more self-reliant and buying less from abroad. The difference between the exports and imports three years ago was £11,000,000, and to-day that difference is £16,719,000. There is a drop of £25,000,000 in exports. Let us get at who is affected by that drop. Out of that drop of £25,000,000 in exports, livestock accounts for £14,000,000, food-stuffs of animal origin account for £8,000,000, and other food-stuffs for £2,000,000. In other words out of the £25,000,000 of a drop in our export trade, £24,000,000 is at the expense of the agricultural community. I do not say —deliberately, I do not say—that that drop was at the expense of the farmers. I say that it was at the expense of those living out of agricultural industry, by which I mean farmers and labourers alike. Accordingly, we have a state of affairs where we find, in spite of umpteen thousand tin-pot factories, and 12,000 or 13,000 extra people put into employment in secondary industries, according to the Minister, that we have the huge return of 130,000 unemployed human beings in the country. It is quite possible that, for once, the Minister is correct, and that some 12,000 or 14,000 extra people did find employment in secondary industries and that, along with that, his own official returns of 130,000 unemployed is, nevertheless, correct. During the first couple of months that the present Government was in office, the Minister's leader, the President of the Executive Council, told us that the real number of unemployed in this State, was in the neighbourhood of 60,000. The Minister for Industry and Commerce—the side drummer, never to be outdone by the big drum when it came to a question of exaggeration—said, in the course of the same debate, that the actual number of unemployed was nearer 70,000. Taking the Minister's own figure of 70,000 as being the number unemployed at that time, the number of registered unemployed at the present time, or last month, was 130,000.
Comment on this
The Deputy might be excused if he ceased reading the Minister's figures, but that is one figure that he did read. I will not say that the figure is absolutely accurate, but I will say that it is in the neighbourhood of 130,000. That was the figure in May last.
Comment on this
The Deputy is referring to the number on the register, which is a different thing altogether. He is referring to the people registered at the employment exchanges, which includes 75,000 farmers.
Comment on this
The Minister is contradicting a figure without replacing it with another figure. Will he give us the correct figure?
Comment on this
Will the Minister give us the number of unemployed people in the last week of May according to the official returns?
Comment on this
The number of persons who have registered themselves as being available for work is, roughly, what the Deputy stated.
Comment on this
Now we know. According to the Minister, 130,000 people are looking for work and 75,000 of them are farmers, and we are asked to put through the Vote on Agriculture without discussion when agriculture is in such a position that 75,000 farmers are looking for work in order to get work on the land or in any other way. Now the cat is out of the bag. Do not trim your sails again. We have 130,000 registered as looking for work, over 70,000 of whom are farmers, finding their agricultural work so unprofitable that any class of work is preferred to carrying on on the land; and we have had that increase in the course of three years of an industrial revival. We have that increase at a time when the Minister tells us that some 12,000 or 14,000 extra hands have found employment in secondary industries.
Comment on this
97,000? The Minister is quite capable of saying 97,000,000. He is quite capable of it. As I say, we have that happening at such a time, and we must, and we should, get an opportunity of analysing and discussing why we have that appalling figure of 130,000 people looking for work when everybody is paying through the nose for the establishment and continuance of these factories, when every article bought by the people is costing more, and when very much public money is being invested in the starting of new industries. The reason is obvious. The reason is that, thanks to the slump, thanks to the political foolishness of Fianna Fáil, thanks to their so-called economic war, thanks to their lack of courage in grappling with the situation when it did arise, we have an outside market rapidly disappearing, shrinking away, tariff walls going up between us and that market, and quotas further restricting the amount of our goods admissible to that market. As a result of all that, we have agriculture in such a position that it is unable to pay wages and overhead charges, and we have very many of the agriculturists of this country in such a position that they are unable to pay one or the other, and so we have all the equipment of a small war being directed towards trying to get the annuities from the farmers a second time, leaving them nothing with which to pay wages. If we take it that there are in or about 500,000 farmers in the Irish Free State, and that at least one-tenth of those paid wages in the past, when they had the money to pay wages, we have 50,000 farmers who were wage-givers economising to the tune of at least one man.
Comment on this
Agricultural employment includes your reafforestation work. Does the Minister say "No"?
Comment on this
I am saying that the number of persons employed by farmers for wages is higher now than it was in 1931.
Comment on this
And I am asking the Minister did he say "No" when I stated that agricultural employment included employment under reafforestation schemes?
Comment on this
The statement I am making is that the number of persons employed by farmers for wages is higher now than it was in 1931, or in 1929 for that matter.
Comment on this
The Minister shook his head and said "No" when I stated that it included those employed in reafforestation work. Well, it is not only from the Minister's neck up that he is shaking. I would leave it to the Labour Deputies to say whether any Deputy representing a rural constituency believes there are more or less agricultural labourers at work to-day than heretofore. Every one of us knows that there are considerably fewer agricultural labourers employed to-day than three years ago.
Comment on this
And the Minister knows it better than any of us, no matter what twisting may be done with figures. I will take the Minister's own figures if he will point them out to me.
Comment on this
When figures are read out from those returns they are disowned—your own figures. The Minister has not the right to own and disown his own figures just according as they suit or do not suit. Time and again we have heard the Labour Deputies, who can claim to be more conversant with the situation in rural Ireland than I am, deploring the increased unemployment in rural areas.
Comment on this
In the last official return of this kind which we had we saw a big increase in the number of agricultural labourers out of work, or in the number of people deriving employment from and on the land. I invite the Minister to go down to any rural area in Ireland—he can select the area—and in that townland or that parish, demonstrate that there are more agricultural labourers in employment on the land now than there were three years ago. However, I would suggest to the Minister that if he wants to get away with his inaccuracies and his contradictions, if he wants to cover up the figures already issued, if he wants to sidestep the official publications of Government Departments, even that cannot be done even by him without time. We might have a clearer mind with regard to the alleged profitable state of the agricultural industry, and the alleged absence of unemployment in rural Ireland, if we were given more time to discuss the various Votes which we are asked to put through without discussion. Every one of us— Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and Independent—might at least arrive at something like true, clear-cut figures, if each of those Estimates were examined, discussed and criticised by itself, rather than adopting the cowardly policy of rolling together the whole 23 so that there would be no true or detailed information given with regard to any one of the 23.
Comment on this
Whatever differences of opinion may exist concerning the necessity for this motion, I think we would all be unanimous in the enactment of a Bill to prevent any members of the Front Bench Opposition getting within a hundred miles of a book of statistics. Once they get statistics into their hands each one of them becomes a public menace. They are obviously incapable, not merely of understanding the figures that are given, but of profiting by the various lessons which have been given to them here as to how statistics should be read, as to the significance of statistics and as to the impossibility of refusing to accept them just because they do not happen to fit in with their own particular theories. If the Deputies opposite want to discuss agriculture, we have offered them a whole day next week for that purpose. They have not accepted it. They do not want to discuss agriculture.
Comment on this
The Appropriation Bill must be law by the 1st August. Perhaps Deputies opposite will understand that if I repeat it again—the Appropriation Bill must be law by the 1st August. If it is not, every Government service stops. Deputies opposite, I know, want to see them stopped. They have embarked on this policy of obstruction, of delaying business, of talking unnecessarily on Estimates, of adopting all the usual devices to delay the passage of measures, in order to prevent the Appropriation Bill from being law by the 1st August, and therefore ensuring that there will be a complete breakdown of Government services on that date. They want to do that because they think it will be some advantage to their Party. I do not know how they can imagine it is going to be of any advantage to them, but they do not care a snap of their fingers what damage it is going to do to the country, what reactions it is going to have on the finances of the State, on the credit of the State, or upon the fortunes of individual businesses conducted within the State. They are prepared to wreck everything provided they can inconvenience the Government a little. That has been the whole purpose behind their obstructionist programme, and behind the tactics they have been resorting to during the past fortnight, which are being nullified by this particular Resolution. The Government is not anxious to avoid discussion upon any part of its policy. It has given more opportunity for the discussion of its programme than its predecessors ever did. Dr. O'Higgins said that this was the first time a motion of this kind was introduced in the Dáil. It is not; he is completely wrong. A motion in precisely similar terms was moved by Deputy Cosgrave, then President of the Executive Council, on the 10th July, 1929, and moved for precisely the same reason for which this motion is being moved—because the Appropriation Bill had to be law before the 1st August of that year, just as it has to be law before the 1st August of this year.
Comment on this
I am merely giving it as a precedent, but even if there were no precedent this motion would be here. This Government rather likes establishing precedents. Most of the precedents it has established are very good ones, and will no doubt be followed by our successors. I want to deal with the extraordinary display given by Deputy O'Higgins. Deputy O'Higgins takes himself too seriously, in the first place. He purported to tell us here what the country thinks of the Government, what the country is thinking of the Government's present tactics, and what it thinks of the various measures which the Government has introduced. But he forgot to produce his credentials. The people did not authorise Deputy O'Higgins to tell us what they think of the Government. The people themselves have expressed their opinion upon that matter on a number of occasions. They spoke in a different voice to Deputy O'Higgins; they spoke in no uncertain manner, and I am quite sure they will do so again if it is necessary to consult them.
Comment on this
They seem to be fairly satisfied, if not with the conditions which exist, at least with the efforts that the Government is making to improve those conditions, and it is particularly noticeable that the most effective and consistent support for the Government is coming from members of the farming community——
Comment on this
——whom Deputies opposite pretend to represent, and certainly succeed in misrepresenting. I do not know what Deputy Anthony said but I presume it was a very illuminating remark.
Comment on this
I apologise to Deputy Anthony. What is the position of agriculture? Deputy O'Higgins made his first mistake when he burst into statistics and assumed that the figures of our export trade had any real significance——
Comment on this
I am trying to educate the Deputy. This is a process of education. I am doing my best to make Deputies opposite understand the situation.
Comment on this
Deputy Curran said very little while Deputy O'Higgins was speaking about agriculture.
Comment on this
Deputies opposite were allowed a great deal of latitude in speaking on this motion; they spoke on agriculture and other matters. The Minister is surely entitled to deal with the points they made.
Comment on this
I am not going to take up much time. I will either succeed in convincing the Deputies opposite of their error in a short time or else I will be convinced myself that it is impossible to convince them. The exports are no indication of the agricultural production in the country. Deputy O'Higgins took our exports in 1931 and 1933 and compared them; he showed there were lesser exports in 1933 than in 1931.
Comment on this
It does not matter. In 1932 the importation of foreign bacon and hams was stopped. That was a very considerable importation, a huge importation.