Estimates for Public Services and Appropriation Bill.—Allocation of Time.
Contributions 170–345 of 345. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I am dealing with pigs. The fact was that the bacon curers in this country, when faced with the task of replacing the foreign bacon in the home market, not merely succeeded in doing that but they succeeded in maintaining their exports to the foreign markets as well. The export of live pigs decreased undoubtedly, but the export of bacon and hams increased——
Comment on this
The exports of bacon and hams are greater despite the fact that the home market was supplied from Irish sources. The number of pigs bought by the Irish bacon curers commenced to increase in June, 1932, and it is a fact that they have increased ever since. If Deputy Brennan thinks I am wrong I invite him to quote the figures.
Comment on this
I want the Deputy to give the number of pigs purchased by the bacon curers, the number sold in the home market, the quantities of cured hams exported, and I want these related to the previous imports.
Comment on this
The Minister can relate the amount of imports of foreign bacon that were stopped. The Minister can get these figures and they absolutely conflict entirely with his own statement now.
Comment on this
The Deputy need not assert that. He has got all the sources of information that I have and if he can prove that what I am saying is wrong let him do so.
Comment on this
It was necessary in the last year to take steps to discourage the consumption of bacon and hams in order to keep up the exports. An excise duty was imposed in order to induce people to eat beef and other foods instead of bacon so that we could fill the quotas allotted to us in the various foreign markets. Deputy O'Higgins spoke of the restriction on our exports by quotas. What quota was the Deputy referring to? Is it to the cattle quota? Let him ask any of the farmer Deputies in his Party whether they think we are going to succeed in filling up our quotas for cattle this year.
Comment on this
To anywhere. Are we going to succeed in filling in other agricultural quotas, much less to meet cattle quotas?
Comment on this
The Minister should not forget that we have had two years' destruction of our young cattle.
Comment on this
Again the Deputy is misinformed. The Deputy can get precise figures from the Department of Industry and Commerce and from the Department of Agriculture. What is the position with regard to the production of cattle and the number of cattle exactly in the country? The Deputy can find that out.
Comment on this
But why? What are the forms of agricultural production that matter? The dairy end of agricultural production is the important end of it from the employment point of view, and not merely from the employment point of view but——
Comment on this
The Deputy might remember that the number of dairy cows in the country is 100,000 in excess of what it was a few years ago, and the area under tillage crops has increased for the first time in a century. New markets have been opened up for Irish farmers. I am prepared to agree that the general level of agricultural prices is too low. I said that yesterday, and I make this point over again on it. We brought forward again and again proposals in this House to raise the prices of agricultural produce, and on every occasion these proposals were opposed by the Party opposite.
Comment on this
Nonsense! The Minister does not know anything about farming. There are people on these benches making their living out of farming and they know all about it. He knows nothing about it.
Comment on this
There is only one way of making a living for the farmers, and that is by raising the prices of agricultural produce.
Comment on this
The only way to raise prices is by increasing the price to the consumer. Now, every time we did that we had the Party opposite standing up to protect the consumer against the raising of prices. We had Deputy Dillon, Deputy McGilligan, Deputy Bennett, Deputy O'Higgins, Deputy Belton and others wasting the time of the House and comparing the prices to the consumer here with the prices in Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
Everybody knows the facts and they were trying to make propaganda against the Government by showing that the price to the consumer here was higher, but they took very good care that they did not go down the country with that story.
Comment on this
It is all humbug on the part of the Opposition, and they are falling between the two stools of the consumers and the producers. Let us get the position concerning employment and unemployment and explain it once again for the information of the Deputies opposite. There were uneconomic farmers in this country before Fianna Fáil came into office. There have been uneconomic farmers in this country since the time of Cromwell. Even the British Government had to resort to various exceptional devices in order to relieve the position of these uneconomic farmers. In the census year 1926, when Cumann na nGaedheal was at its height, if the Unemployment Assistance Act had been in operation, the number of farmers and farmers' sons who would have been entitled to receive assistance and would, consequently, have been registered at the exchanges, was not less than 150,000, and that number is to be compared with 75,000 to-day.
Comment on this
In addition to those 150,000 people on the land who, in 1926, would have been entitled to unemployment assistance, if they could get it, there were, according to the census, 78,000 other people unemployed, a figure which we have to compare with a corresponding figure to-day of about 50,000. There has been a substantial decrease in the number of people unemployed, despite the fact that the population is to-day 56,000 greater than it was in 1931. The efforts which the Government have made in the reorganisation of agriculture and the development of industry have not merely provided employment for a sufficient number to absorb all that increased population but, more than that, there has been a decrease in unemployment. These are facts which can be proved by official statistics and information obtained from official sources. But Deputies opposite do not want facts. They prefer to be able to continue voicing their general ideas, vague theories, and the platitudes which we heard a short time ago from Deputy O'Higgins. This motion is necessary in order that the business of the State may go on. The conduct of the affairs of the people of this State requires that the annual Appropriation Bill should be law by 1st August. Deputies opposite are trying to prevent it becoming law by 1st August in the hope that they will stop all governmental services and by bringing about general chaos succeed in discrediting, to some extent, the Government Party and improving the position of their own. They will not do it. They are on the wrong track, and I say that from experience.
Comment on this
We tried those tactics, but we had the good sense to abandon them when we saw they were getting nowhere. Deputies opposite will learn by experience that they cannot get increased political support by such means.
Comment on this
I do not agree with that. I think they have learned a lot during the past few days. We learned from Deputy McGilligan that you do not put a racquet frame on a ping-pong bat. We learned from Deputy Cosgrave that the material used in a tennis bat is catgut. We learned from Deputy Bennett that if you could not get leather footballs you can make a good substitute out of a sheep's bladder. We learned from Deputy Belton that a leather football cover could be made at home by anybody with the necessary implements. We got a lot of useful information from the members opposite on various matters of that kind. During the last few days they succeeded in spending a lot of the time of the House in giving us their personal views upon these matters. They even discussed my golf, as if that were worth talking about.
Comment on this
There is no desire on the part of the Government to avoid discussion. It is necessary that the Estimates and the Appropriation Bill should be disposed of. If the Deputies want time to discuss any matters which would naturally arise upon those Estimates, time can be afforded. Their first criticism was that the passage of these Estimates in this way would prevent them discussing the administration of the Department of Agriculture. They were offered a whole day next week for that purpose if they wanted it, but they declined it. They would sooner have their grievance. They wanted to be able to pretend that in some way they were being prevented from exercising their functions as an Opposition and thus explain their failure as an Opposition. As I have often said before, they are the world's worst Opposition. There is nothing unfair or dishonest about the tactics which the Government have resorted to. We copied the motion we are now discussing, word for word, from that moved by Deputy Cosgrave, as President of the Executive Council, on 10th July, 1929. If it is unfair and dishonest for us to move that motion now, it was equally unfair and dishonest for him to move it on that occasion.
Comment on this
I do not think there is anything else I need mention. Deputies opposite adopted the usual tactics by saying that it is not permissible on this motion to refer to different things and then proceeded to refer to them, as long as they were allowed to do so by the Chair. Other opportunities will arise of correcting their wrong ideas upon these matters and removing any misunderstanding that might have been created in unprejudiced minds by their biassed remarks. The time afforded for Estimates this year was mainly occupied in discussing the economic war. Nothing has been lost to the Opposition by the taking of these Estimates before 12 o'clock to-morrow, because they will get plenty of opportunities of discussing the economic war again. They are trying to lead people to believe that they have discussed on the Estimates already before the House different matters according to the nature of the Estimates. They did not do that. They discussed one matter upon all the Estimates, whether for the Land Commission, the Department of Industry and Commerce, the Revenue Commissioners, or any other Estimate disposed of. The same debate went on interminably since March last. We have already given up hope of being able to convince some members of the Opposition that their ideas are entirely wrong, that their plans have no basis in commonsense and that their allegations against the Government have no foundation in fact. However, if they do want to discuss this matter again, adequate opportunity will be afforded them on various other measures coming before the Dáil. I do not think they could very well discuss the economic war on the Conditions of Employment Bill or some of the other measures down for discussion next week, but before the Dáil adjourns for the summer recess they will have full time and ample opportunity to say over again all the things they have said on various occasions since March, and so will I. The only point is that I have some hope that by saying what I have to say sufficiently often I will succeed in getting it into the heads of some of the Deputies opposite in due course. The whole art of propaganda is a repetition.
Comment on this
The firm which makes a well-known brand of meat extract does not put anything else on its posters except this: "Bovril is all beef," so that you see every day in the week and every week in the year the one sentence which, in due course, becomes embedded in your consciousness. We are resorting to the same tactics. By repeating facts, by putting facts before Deputies and showing them how to understand facts, by supplying them with reliable information and teaching them how to understand that information, and how to apply it to the facts of the situation, we hope, in due course, to make them a useful Opposition. I hear some members of my own Party say that is not possible, but I am one of those who think it can be done.
Comment on this
The oftener I hear the Minister for Industry and Commerce speaking the more I am reminded of the meetings in Hyde Park or at the Custom House steps in Belfast on a Sunday morning. The Minister has missed his vocation. He would have made a wonderful propagandist for any of the new religions or new doctrines preached in the places I have mentioned. It is most amusing to listen to him, just as amusing and just as enlightening as to listen to the Minister for Finance. They are the Siamese twins of this rather unfortunate Administration. There may be something to be said for the activities of the Minister for Industry and Commerce with all his faults. But anybody who has had the humiliating experience of listening here to-day to the Minister for Finance, and yesterday to his understudy Deputy Flinn, and their economic adviser Deputy Corry, any decent Irishman having listened to the gentlemen I have just mentioned, must have felt ashamed that he was Irish, absolutely ashamed.
This motion, I feel, is designed to deprive members of this House of an opportunity of examining in any kind of detail the spending of very large sums of money. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has told us that we would get another occasion for discussing agriculture, but there are other items covered by this resolution which we shall not get an opportunity of examining or discussing. I would ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce, what was his view when he was in opposition or what would be his view if the Cosgrave Government had introduced a motion of this character?
Comment on this
I am coming to that. The Minister has told us frequently that he has got away from these malpractices. He has told us that his Government would not indulge in this kind of practice, that they were more democratic, but the Minister a moment ago gave himself away. He has told us that his political faith is pinned to the slogan, "Get up and repeat something and people will begin to believe you." The Minister for Industry and Commerce is coming to believe himself that by continuing to shout "Up the Republic" he will get there. I believe that, in practice, it might be found very useful in this House if some arrangement were come to between the Parties to concentrate on one, two, three, four, five or six Estimates. It might be useful for the sake of curtailing discussion, and giving an opportunity for the allocation of private members' time, if they could agree on eight or nine items perhaps for discussion. That is the suggestion I put to the Minister now, that some arrangement might be found by which the Parties would agree to arrive at some solution of that kind. The Minister and his Government have set themselves out to stifle all kinds of discussion for the very obvious reason that they do not want discussion. They do not want the light to shine into the dark corners of Government administration. "Ha, ha," says Deputy Tom Kelly, the man who thinks that personation is a highly moral and good thing; honest Alderman Tom Kelly, who believes that personation—in my view the filthiest and most immoral thing——
Comment on this
All right. I welcome again the attitude of the Labour Party in relation to this motion. I welcome it as a come-back to commonsense, a come-back to the old tradition which used to obtain before the corrupt influences of Fianna Fáil began to operate. The old attitude in relation to a closure motion in so far as it concerned the Labour Party, was always to oppose the closure. That tradition has been departed from for a considerable time back, but to-day we find a change of front. Is it because they have discovered something immoral in this attitude or in this motion? Not at all, but because there are some Civil Service Estimates and some civil servants who must be considered. Then the closure motion will not be worked! It is all window dressing and nothing else. To day we had the Minister for Finance charging members of the official Opposition with encouraging or inciting arson and outrage. I took a note of his words. Who are better judges of arson and outrage than the Minister for Industry and Commerce who sits there and the Minister for Finance who is out of the House at the moment? Who are better judges of arson and outrage? By their arson and outrage they have taxed the citizens of this country to the extent of £50,000,000 or £60,000,000. Arson and outrage coming from the Minister——
Comment on this
We had the Minister for Finance here comparing two periods. I put it to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who I believe is a little bit honest, is there any comparison whatever between these two periods—the Cosgrave period of 10 or 12 years, when the Minister and his associates were outside this House breaking down the institutions of this State that had only just been erected, when they were indulging in arson and outrage——
Comment on this
Clearly that does not arise. We cannot traverse all the incidents that happened during that period of 10 or 12 years.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance spoke about arson and outrage. He also stated that the official Opposition were getting away with it. Am I not entitled to refer in the same orderly manner as the Minister for Finance was allowed to get away with it——
Comment on this
I am not preventing any Deputy referring to what the Minister for Finance got away with at all, but clearly anything that took place eleven, ten, eight or nine years ago is not relevant to this motion.
Comment on this
It was relevant when the Minister for Finance was speaking. It was relevant, apparently, when the Ceann Comhairle was in the Chair, for the Minister for Finance to refer to matters of this kind, but for a private member it is not relevant apparently.
Comment on this
I will bet you anything you like. His family have been in Dublin for over 200 years.
Comment on this
To-day the Minister for Finance said that the official Opposition were getting away with it. By "it" he meant propaganda which encouraged arson and outrage. We have that coming from the Minister of a Government which, when outside this House, was composed mainly of persons who were encouraging not alone arson and outrage, but arson and murder, and not a tooth on it. Of course I am entitled to reply to the Minister for Finance. He asked the Opposition to call off the dogs. I have taken a note of his exact words. I have condemned all outrages—arson, the felling of trees, and the cutting of wires—in public and in private. Therefore, I think I am entitled, as one who condemns all this kind of thing, to say that I find myself in agreement with the Minister for Finance in condemning these things; but it would come a lot better from me, or a person like me, who never indulged in these practices, to condemn this class of outrage.
There are some matters covered by this motion which I should like to examine and have discussed. There is a Vote here relating to Secret Service. I know it is not usual to disclose the payments under such a Vote, but I would like to have some information from the Minister for Finance in relation to how, and the circumstances under which, that money is being distributed. I am aware that in many remote areas of the country there is a very grave suspicion that hangers-on or partisans of the Minister's own Party are in receipt of this money and it is the general belief that the administration of this fund, or the expenditure of money under this head, is breeding a good deal of suspicion in the country. It has been represented to me that in some areas there are persons to-day who are amongst the newly-rich and it is thought at any rate that these people are in receipt of this Secret Service money. I am not asking the Minister for Finance to disclose the names of those persons, but he certainly could give us some idea of the activities of those people who are in receipt of this money.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Deputy is making certain reflections on individuals in this country, men who through their own industry and honesty have become rich. He is making allegations that that class of person is getting money from the Secret Service. He should not be allowed to make such reflections.
Comment on this
Of course this discussion has rambled a great deal beyond what it should be allowed to cover. Deputies Bennett, O'Higgins and the Minister for Industry and Commerce were allowed to range over a very wide number of subjects. That is not as it should be. Deputies will realise that if they dispose of this motion the Estimates would arise in the ordinary way and discussion could proceed in the ordinary fashion; not in this way, which is entirely irregular.
Comment on this
Both yesterday evening and again in the afternoon we had a number of items referred to. Amongst other things the Public Safety Act was mentioned. I submit that if any of the Government Party are allowed to discuss items of that character, such as the Public Safety Act, and the reason why it was introduced, some members on this side should at least be allowed to advert on the matter.
Comment on this
To-day you had even the League of Youth mentioned by the Minister for Finance. It is one of the organisations which he condemned, which aroused his displeasure. I am not a member of the League of Youth; I am, like the Minister for Industry and Commerce, possibly slightly over the age of what would be called a youth. However, it might be no harm to relate the circumstances under which that League was formed.
Comment on this
The Minister must know the circumstances that caused the birth of that organisation. I do not want to cut across the ruling of the Chair. I quite agree it would be inadvisable to bring up matters of this character, which might cause a good deal of acrimonious discussion.
Comment on this
The Minister himself always invites discussion. He suggested we might even discuss agriculture and he was prepared to give us another day to discuss it. I want to know how many more items in the Estimates will he allow us to discuss. I am anxious to find out something about the Secret Service money and how it is distributed. I want to know how many members of the Fianna Fáil clubs have been appointed Secret Service agents. I want to know what is the amount of money and to how many people it is paid. I am also anxious to know, but it can be elicited by way of ordinary Parliamentary Question, the difference between the Army Vote now and the Army Vote in 1927, 1929 and 1930. Of course, that can easily be got through ordinary channels. There are other matters which I am sure the Minister will agree should be discussed before we pass this motion and I am, therefore, opposed to it.
Comment on this
I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce is one of the ablest exponents of the new form of government by noise. In his whole discourse he has been altogether irrelevant. We have been accused of wasting time. The fact of the matter is that we have to deal with a very unique circumstance and that is that we are dealing with the worst Budget ever introduced in this country since the Free State was established. By plenty of noise and bellowing they have been trying to conceal from the country the fact that this Budget shows an increase of £10,000,000 as compared with the period before the Fianna Fáil people came into power. In 1932 the total Supply Services, the essential services, amounted to £26,000,000. Now the total cost is over £36,000,000. I need not point out how this increase of £10,000,000 compares with the great promises made by Fianna Fáil before they became the Government. The people are very anxious that these matters should be inquired into.
The Minister says he has learned a lot from the Opposition Benches. At any rate, he has learned that he has taxed a lot of things that are causing great suffering amongst the people. Through the searching and the intelligent examination exercised by Deputies on these benches in relation to the Budget taxes, the people have begun to realise the extent of their suffering and how they are being ground down by a terrible weight of taxation. We should owe no apology if we utilise the rights we have to discuss these financial proposals. This is the most important element in the administration of affairs in this country. If we have examined the Government's proposals in respect of taxation we have done so in a way that has been appreciated by the people outside who are called upon to meet taxation. Anyone who contributes to the taxation of this country will, I am sure, be grateful for the way in which the iniquities of the Fianna Fáil fiscal system have been shown up here. It was said last week that the House was kept in prolonged session, not because we wanted facilities for discussing these exactions, but because some Fianna Fáil Deputies were afraid to go home on Sunday, afraid to go to Mass in their home churches because they put a tax on the priests' breviaries and on Mass books.
Comment on this
We are not discussing taxation now. The Budget and the Finance Bill have been passed. We are now discussing the procedure to be adopted in the case of the Estimates for Public Services.
Comment on this
The Estimates give an idea of the way in which the taxation is going to be spent. We protest in the most emphatic manner against these 23 Estimates being bulked and run through the House without a proper examination or discussion being allowed. It has been said that a sum amounting to over £11,000,000 is being run through the House. The exact figure is £11,235,866—nearly one-third of the whole of the Supply Services and the Central Fund Services. I do not think that that redounds in any way to the credit of the Dáil or that such a thing should be permitted to happen. It is very necessary that these matters should be examined and very closely examined. Some of the matters that are to be run through are of very great importance to the country. There has been an increase of over £1,000,000 for new services expenditure and the greater part of that increase is included in these estimates. I protest against the passing of this motion, because it is going to stifle discussion on matters of very great importance to the House and to the national well being of the country as to how the Budget money is going to be spent. All this great increase in expenditure is being carried out at a time when the traders of the country were never worse off, and we are putting higher taxation on the people at a time when their trade is dwindling.
Comment on this
It is almost unthinkable to me that a motion such as that which is now being considered by the House should be presented to any popularly elected assembly. I join in the protest against this frantic, hectic and break-neck speed, in voting away over £11,000,000 of the people's money without giving their elected representatives any opportunity of criticising the different items that go to make up this tremendous expenditure, imposing a burden on the people beyond their capacity, and one that is bound, sooner or later to lead to absolute destitution in the Free State. This motion precludes adequate, if any, discussion upon these vital matters, including such important Votes as the Estimate for agriculture, which is, and has been, and long will be, the main key industry in this country. It precludes any discussion on fisheries which I suggest have been sadly neglected not only by this, but by previous Governments. Again, there is the Vote for old age pensions, which concerns a very large number of the poorer classes in this country; and we are asked to rush all these through in a couple of hours.
Last night, on a relatively small Vote, but a very important one, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance deliberately and designedly, as I suggest, and allege, wasted an hour and 15 minutes of the time of this House in what, in my humble judgement, were irrelevancies that had no bearing at all upon the issue before the House. For that reason I join with the Opposition, with the Independents and with the Labour Party, and with every lover of free institutions and democratic government in this country, against this appalling attempt to gag and stifle discussion upon matters that vitally affect the very life of the nation.
Comment on this
When Eastern tribes want to work themselves up into a war fury they beat their tom-toms; and when the Fianna Fáil Party wants to get up some kind of enthusiasm they bring in the Minister for Industry and Commerce——
Comment on this
That is so. The Minister for Industry and Commerce gets up and makes a loud noise. He endeavoured to give some figures a while ago, and the persistency with which he insisted that his figures were correct was amazing, in view of the publications of his own Department. The amazing thing is that he advised the Opposition to study the figures of his own publications. The question at issue was certain figures read out by Deputy O'Higgins as to the exports of pigs and bacon in the years 1930, 1931 and 1933.
Comment on this
They are not in the book. There is no use in the Minister trying to convince the House that Deputy O'Higgins was holding back something from it that had been published. He read all the figures that had been published, and that was the point. On page 38 we got the record of the imports of bacon into this country in 1930. It was said from the Government Benches last night that one of the first things the Government did was to prevent the import of Chinese bacon to the extent of £1,760,000. The figures given on page 23—Trade and Shipping Statistics, 1933—bacon imports, 1930, are £454,000. That is what they were and no more. The Minister a while ago gave us instead the figures he wanted us to take—home as well as export—and suggested that that was the amount of bacon consumed in this country plus the Irish killing, and that that was the only portion that had to be followed. Let us come to the exports. On page 148 of the same publication we get the exports for the year 1930 of bacon and hams.
Comment on this
I would have to go to the trouble of adding up these figures if I did that. I took the first column for bacon, hams, pork, sausages, and other pig meats for the year 1931.
Comment on this
Pork is not the product of bacon factories. I specifically mentioned bacon and hams.
Comment on this
You endeavoured to relate the whole discussion to the prosperity or otherwise of the bacon industry.
Comment on this
Possibly the Minister, not being engaged in farming, does not know that pork is pig. Does he know that?
Comment on this
That is so, and it has to be reared and fed as if it was being fed for bacon. That is information for the Minister. In 1931 our exports of all those pig products, of any and every kind, were £3,140,833.
Comment on this
The quantity of bacon and hams exported, in 1931, was considerably in excess of what it was in 1933, and the amount of money realised was treble what it was in 1933. The only advantage the Minister could claim with regard to the whole situation was that, when a prohibitive tariff was put on, which kept out foreign bacon, a market was opened here which otherwise was not taken advantage of by Irish producers, to the extent of £400,000 odd, but we lost in production, whether in bacon, pork or hams, over £1,300,000. I am not saying that that was all due to Fianna Fáil policy, but there is no use in the Minister pretending here that the pig industry has gone ahead since Fianna Fáil came into power.
Comment on this
The statement I made was that we reduced the import of bacon and hams, and, at the same time, maintained our export.
Comment on this
It is not in these statistics. The Minister ought to read his own publications before he advises others to read them. This is the thing the Minister tried to put across the House a while ago. With regard to the motion before the House, I contend that it is quite reasonable for the Government to endeavour to closure discussion on these matters, in view of the position into which they have landed this country. Agriculture has been mentioned so often that it needs nothing further from me. We have the supplementary agricultural grants reduced, and I do not blame the Government for endeavouring to hide that reduction, considering what has occurred to the country and considering the position of local authorities in the country to-day. We have a reduction of £100,000 in the supplementary agricultural grants this year, and this is the year in which the Government withheld grants, to the extent of £750,000, from local authorities, and the year in which local authorities have not brought their accounts up to date or estimated for their full expenditure.
The position, so far as local authorities are concerned and so far as the agricultural community are concerned, and they are both concerned in these Estimates, is a position in which nobody can look to the future with any hope, so that it is not any wonder that we find the Government endeavouring to closure discussion of these matters. Take the Secret Service, which, a few years before Fianna Fáil came into power, did not cost £1,000. It cost £25,000 last year, and the Estimate this year is £20,000. What is the Secret Service? It is a political party fund. That is what it is.
Comment on this
Even if it were, when it cost £900 odd, it could not do very much. Now it is costing £20,000 odd.
Comment on this
If Deputy Cosgrave had demanded £25,000 from the nation for the Secret Service, it would have been open to very grave suspicion, and a jump from £900 odd to £25,000 is a very suspicious jump.
Comment on this
I know enough about it, and I know enough about people getting money in the country, and it is not for the detection of crime.
Comment on this
Deputy Cooney had better keep quiet about that. It might come too near home. In any case, we have this method of closure, which is merely a cloak for getting these things through, and it certainly does not reflect any credit on the Government. As we cannot go into the detailed items which we want to go into, I do not see any use in pursuing the discussion any further. I am simply disgusted with the whole situation.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce stated that there would be ample opportunity for discussing all these matters in which we are interested on another occasion. He said that these Estimates had to be through by the end of August.
Comment on this
That is three weeks away. Why rush them through to-morrow?
Comment on this
The Minister gave an undertaking that if we let them through we could discuss all these matters again. If there is time to discuss these matters, is it not the most suitable and proper way to discuss them on the Estimate? He cannot have it both ways. You cannot make the case that you will apply the closure and rush these Estimates through, saying that you are doing it because you are short of time and, at the same time, put up the case that we will get plenty of time to discuss these matters. That is what the Minister has done. It is said that this was done in 1929. I do not remember the circumstances of the closure motion of 1929, but I do know the circumstances of the present time. One thing I know is that if such a motion came forward in 1929, the attitude of the Labour Party would not be equivocal on it. I do not know what their attitude is going to be now.
Comment on this
I have no intention in the world of going off the deep end. I do not know whether the Labour Party have learned or unlearned anything——
Comment on this
If you want me to abuse you, I will do it very quickly. I do know that if such a motion came forward in 1929, their attitude would not be equivocal on it. As Deputy Brennan said, it is absolutely preposterous to compare the conditions of 1929 with the conditions of to-day, in spite of what has been very properly called the noise of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, because it is nothing else but noise. The country is in a hopeless condition at the present moment. There is hardly a producer in the country at present, who is not in receipt of a subsidy of one kind or another, who is making a profit. I do not think that could be challenged. There is not a single producer in this country at present, who is not in receipt of some kind of dole or another, who is making a profit. If that is the state of affairs, are we not going into bankruptcy? I should like to hear from the Labour Party of one industry, which is not bolstered either by an exorbitant tariff or by a subsidy or dole, that is able to make a decent profit and pay a decent wage. The joke of it is that the main industry of the country which, in the main, is paying all the doles and all the subsidies, is in receipt itself of a tremendous amount of doles and subsidies from itself and was never in a worse condition.
When coming into the House, I heard the Minister for Industry and Commerce talking about the immense prosperity of agriculture, because that is what it amounted to, under the new system. I challenge the Minister to name a single penny that they are spending on agriculture that will produce a dividend in five years. All this expenditure that we are asked to vote for is simply appalling. There is not one penny of it productive. It is all in order to stop holes here and there. It reminds one of a broken down motor car with four very bad tyres. A hole comes in a tyre and you stick a patch on it. That only increases the pressure somewhere else. You put on another patch and you keep doing that, but you know that the whole thing will explode before very long and break down. All these Estimates are simply a series of patches on the economic system. They are evidence of the position to which the country has been reduced by the present Government.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce said that he would give another opportunity for discussing the economic war. He was rather jocular in suggesting that. Does the Minister realise that the economic war has brought ruin to the very best, to the most hard-working classes in this country? That is the literal truth. Of course, there are people making money out of the economic war. There are people who want to keep the economic war going for ever. Any war that lasts any length of time gives certain classes of people an opportunity of getting vested interest in it, and you have people all over the country who have a vested interest in the economic war, but they hide the fact by the protestations of patriotism, etc. It is a fact that the best and the most hard-working men in the country, the best citizens and the best Irishmen, the people who have produced the most wealth in the past, the people who always paid their way and whose pride it was to pay their way, are being steadily ruined by the economic war. So that you could not talk about the economic war often enough. If there was a spark of real patriotism amongst those on the benches opposite they would think and talk a lot more about the economic war, and if they did there would be no economic war before long.
We have been told that we can discuss agriculture on another day. Of course, we can have a general discussion. We can make a series of speeches, but is that a satisfactory way to discuss the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture? The items relating to the Department of Agriculture cover 25 pages in the book of Estimates. There are a lot of questions that anyone who knows anything about the Department of Agriculture and about its administration would like to ask in connection with the present Estimates, even if he only gave them the most cursory glance. Deputy Cosgrave referred to the immense increase in the staff in the Department of Agriculture. There is an immense increase and there will be a bigger increase. The position at the moment is that any enterprising farmer, the sort of farmer who in the past made money for himself and for the State, is prevented by Government action from doing his business—the people who think that they ought to be able to do their business in such a way that they will be able to produce a profit and to pay taxation. There are a hundred and one things in connection with the Department of Agriculture that one would like to discuss on the Estimate that cannot be discussed if you have simply a discussion on agriculture generally. The same thing applies to all the other Estimates that are to be rushed through.
It seems to me that the whole position is unreal. Here you find in the year 1935 a country in extreme poverty. There are very few able to pay taxes, to buy tariffed articles, to pay their rates or their annuities, and yet, when you come into the Dáil, you find the estimates dealing with an expenditure of £11,000,000 are being rushed through without any real discussion. With that situation it is coolly suggested by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and by the Minister for Finance that the Opposition are adopting wrecking tactics when they object. The Government will see at the end of another year. They are rushing through this expenditure this year. If they continue to carry on in that way they will have to rush through most extraordinary expenditure next year.
The Minister for Finance will have to get out of his head the idea that there is unlimited wealth in this country. It is no wonder that he should have that idea. This country must have been one of the richest countries in the world, comparatively speaking, in 1932 when the present Government took over. The highest tribute that could be paid to the wealth and the stability of this country is that there could have been such a rake's progress during the last three years and that it did not begin to show itself seriously until now. It must have been an immensely wealthy country to stand that. I think that a dispassionate judgement of the situation would be this, that the biggest work that was done by the last Government, not even excepting the establishment of majority rule in this country, was the husbanding of the country's resources in the way that they were husbanded up to the end of 1931. If these resources were not there the Minister for Finance would not have been able to carry on with the outrageously extravagant expenditure that he has indulged in over the last three years. But I warn him that it is coming to an end. All your tariffs will be no good before long because the purchasing power of the people is going. The hard-working productive farmer is nearly finished, and your tariffs, subsidies and doles will all break down.
The Government should not take up the attitude that when we seriously protest against the procedure that is being adopted in connection with the rushing through of these Estimates that we are simply adopting wrecking tactics or that we wish to upset the administration of the State. I think the best service that we could do would be to prevent the Government getting their supply before the 1st August, because if it was made clear to the Government that they could not get their Supply and if their back benchers could be made show some little spirit of patriotism or any real respect for their constituents—before long they will have to do that because their constituents will see to it— then the Government might come to their senses. The best day's work that we could do for the country would be prevent the Government getting their Supply, and instead agree to a Supply that the country can afford at the present moment.
But, as the Minister for Industry and Commerce has said, propaganda is a wonderful thing. If you keep on repeating a thing you will eventually come to believe it. The members of the Government Party repeated certain slogans and for a long time the people were prepared to believe them, but I can tell the Government now "Your noise will not get across any longer; the time is coming when you have got to deliver the goods and the first step you must take is to reduce taxation to a level which the country can afford and to a figure which the taxpayer can afford to pay." The Government have got to do that first. I put it to the members of the Labour Party, to the Independents, and to any man on the opposite benches who has the real interests of the country at heart that this year's Budget is an outrage from top to bottom, from beginning to end. It is an outrage and a sin against democracy and against the old principle of no taxation without representation that we should have a procedure such as this: to closure estimates which represents one-third of the total cost of the Supply Services of the country. I put it to the Labour Party, to the Independents and to all others to stop that, to bring the Government to their senses and if they do, they will be doing a good day's work for the country.
Comment on this
I protest against a closure motion to prevent the House discussing 23 Votes. When any Deputy ventured to deal with some of the items connected with these Votes he was told that there would be an opportunity to do so. Where is the opportunity now? There is to be no discussion. We were told that there would be other opportunities to do so. There was plenty of time to discuss all these Votes if the opportunity had been given. The House was given holidays six or seven times last year when all these Bills could have been dealt with. Deputies were at home during periods of the year that they could have attended here. There is no excuse for this closure motion. I believe there was a deliberate design to closure discussion. The Vote for agriculture is a most important one, as is also the Vote dealing with old age pensions. The cut being made in old age pensions might be worth discussion at a time when national taxation has been increased by £6,000,000 compared with last year's figures. If taxation were cut there would be some excuse for bringing down expenditure. We are extending expenditure, and old age pensions are to be cut. Another important Vote is that dealing with bounties and subsidies. About £1,000,000 is being thrown on consumers that normally would be dealt with in the Budget. That amount of taxation is being imposed on the consumers of bread, and affects every person in the community. It falls hardest on the poorest class. Owing to the closure that question is not to be discussed.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce talked about the prosperity of agriculture, and about increased prosperity in the pig business. If our exports have increased, why is our trade balance not coming right? Why is the adverse trade balance gone from £13,000,000 to £20,000,000 in three years? The Minister contradicted his own figures. Apparently he is not prepared to recognise the facts that these figures disclose. While his Department furnished the figures of the adverse trade balance it seems he is not prepared to accept them. The Minister maintains that the country is more prosperous, that we are producing more, and that whatever we have lost in exports, we have pulled up in another way. The figures prove the contrary. I would be glad to have an opportunity of going into the details of the Vote for Agriculture as well as the other Votes. I protest at this attempt to closure important discussion that it is the right of the House to have. This procedure is bringing the House into contempt, is depriving the country of representation, and is directed against the fundamentals of democracy. I protest against it.
Comment on this
I desire to protest against this motion. Deputy Norton made a very reasonable proposition when he asked the Government to give more time for consideration of the Votes for agriculture, fisheries, finance and old age pensions. The Government should at least set aside one week for consideration of these Estimates. It is admitted that agriculture is the main industry. I think it is a crime to pass the Vote for agriculture under a closure motion. The Minister responsible for this Vote stated in this House on one occasion, and the President made the statement on another occasion, that the farmers produce 80 per cent. of the wealth of the country. Therefore, they are paying 80 per cent. of the taxation. I say that it is a monstrous thing for the President of the State to stand over a proposal of this kind. It is a shame to have an attempt made to curb discussion of these Estimates. On one occasion we were told by Deputy Donnelly that the President drove a donkey to a creamery. Recently, when the President stated that he saved hay when he was young, he was interrupted by his uncle, who remarked: "And a damned bad hand he was." I have my doubts about the President ever driving a donkey to a creamery, because, if he did, he would not indulge in the policy he is indulging in to-day, and that is driving unfortunate farmers to desperation.
We see what is happening all over the country—farmers being compelled to pay a debt which admittedly they have paid over and over. If the Government disagrees with that statement, let them accept the challenge that was issued from these benches on several occasions, to set up a commission to inquire into the question. I guarantee that they will get information that will startle the country. We were told by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that more people are now employed on the land than previously. I admit that there are more people on the land. Why are they there? The sons of small farmers are at home, and they have to be fed by their people, because they cannot get the employment that they were in the habit of getting before this Government came into office. I am not going to accept the Minister for Finance or the Minister for Industry and Commerce as authorities on agriculture. When the Minister for Industry and Commerce came back from Ottawa he told us we were not so badly off, as he could have bought a sheep for 1/- in Ottawa. All I can say is, may the Lord deliver us from the Minister. The sooner the people realise the position they are being driven into the better. Deputy Hogan put it very clearly when he stated that while this country could carry on for a time, every intelligent person should realise that while we must have had great resources to stand the strain imposed for the past three years by this cursed Government, that could not continue.
Comment on this
I did not hear the whole of Deputy Hogan's speech, but what I did hear of it struck me as curiously inconsistent for one who is generally so clear. Speaking of the achievements of the last Government, he said that their biggest achievement was the establishment of majority rule. At the same time he invited Deputies at this side of the House to vote against what is obviously the opinion of the majority of the people in the present situation. The strange thing about it was that that came from a Deputy who has just arrived from Galway. He was through the recent election there, and he knows how emphatically the feeling of the electors in Galway was declared.
Comment on this
I am replying to statements made by Deputy Hogan inviting back-benchers from this side to state their views with regard to the existing position in the country. Surely, if one is to have the respect for majority rule that obviously Deputy Hogan has, one cannot always put aside what is apparently the decisive wish of the people in the present circumstances. No message was given at the recent Galway election that the people want any change.
Comment on this
On a point of order. There is a motion of closure before the House. Is the Deputy for it or against it, or is he going to speak on general politics?
Comment on this
Deputy Hogan addressed himself to the Independent Benches as well. I do not think that Deputy Belton was present at the time. But Deputy Hogan asked Deputies on the Independent and Labour Benches and on the back benches of Fianna Fáil to join with him in refusing supply to the Government because of the dangerous position of the country. The people must be very bad judges. They were given the opportunity of saying whether they considered the position dangerous. Surely, the people are not dumb beasts. When they get the chance of voting, their votes, in Deputy Hogan's eyes at all events, must have a very big significance. The people recorded their view with emphasis during the past few weeks in the biggest constituency in the country. I could not, in these circumstances, take the responsibility of joining with Deputy Hogan in saying that the Government should be refused supply because of the dangerous financial position of the country. Further, I have to remember that, on the occasion of the first Fianna Fáil Budget, I listened to Deputy Hogan in exactly the same position as he occupied to-day warning us that, in six months' time, the country would be bankrupt. He proved a very false prophet. There is nothing to indicate bankruptcy at the moment. If he were so very wrong then, there is no reason why he should not be equally wrong on the present occasion.
Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted and 20 Deputies being present,
Comment on this
On the general question of whether or not this motion should pass, I regret very much that such a motion is necessary. I think that, with proper relations between the two big parties, it should be possible to come to an arrangement by which motions of this kind would not be brought forward at the end of every session, as they almost invariably are. They were brought forward under the last Government, and now the present Government has had to resort to them. Surely that is more the fault of the fact that there are only 24 hours in the day and 12 months in the year than the fault of the Government. If the rather desultory method of debate that prevailed here during the last few weeks were to continue, I could see no probability of the House rising until the end of August, at earliest. It is obvious that government is not entirely conducted in this House, that Ministers have other duties to attend to and that they must be given time to attend to these duties. If, merely from a desire to go on debating, we limit the time at the disposal of Ministers for their departmental duties, we may be doing a very bad day's work and, even from Deputy Hogan's point of view, I think we would be doing a very bad day's work. I remember that nobody was so scornful in debates of this kind in previous years as was Deputy Hogan. He was very scornful of any plea that government consisted of debate in the Dáil. The real business of the Government was done apart from the Dáil, he always asserted, and he claimed that Ministers should have full time to attend to that work. With that I entirely agree. I believe that no Minister can properly discharge the duties of his Department if he has to attend in the Dáil continuously during the greater part of the year. He must have periods during which he can review the work of his Department and look ahead. It is essential, for our own sakes, that we should give the Ministers the time necessary for that type of work. I think that it is not altogether good taste to comment upon the speeches of other Deputies, but it is obvious that there has been a great deal of repetition in the debates, particularly since financial business came to occupy so much of our time. If Deputies opposite were so eager to have every estimate debated, their leaders would have taken steps to see that there was something in the way of reasonable curtailment of debate, so that each estimate would get its proper time. It is a great pity that certain estimates are not going to get the time they would be entitled to under a proper allocation governing the whole body of estimates.
Comment on this
Certainly. Since I know that the Government are not to blame for the existing position, I think they are entitled to claim that there should be a curtailment of debate in view of the lateness of the season and in view of the necessity for getting on with more urgent work. For those reasons, I am supporting the motion.
Comment on this
Deputy Moore has given the most ingenuous reason for the passing of this motion that the House has, so far, heard. As I understand, his main reason for voting for this motion is to allow Ministers to have more time in their Departments. That is a very innocent reason. I am sure that the Deputy, in all honesty, believed in what he said, but the Deputy, whose reputation for innocence and honesty is unsurpassed in this House, will not get many to support them in that reason. One of the outstanding features of the conduct of Parliamentary affairs by the present Ministry is their continuous absence from the House. It is very rarely there is more than one Minister on the Government Benches. We presume that the others are in their Departments doing the work that Deputy Moore wants them to do. But, since they do ignore the House to that extent in the interests of their Departmental work, the reason put forward so ingenuously by Deputy Moore has no substance at all. When the Minister for Finance is present during the debates on these financial matters, he is really doing his Departmental work in the House. During the three or four months occupied with Estimates and financial matters, the Minister for Finance is doing his Departmental business here, and other Ministers have nothing to do but attend to their Departments. Deputy Moore's reason for the passing of this motion is too ingenuous. The real reason, I suggest, is to endeavour to conceal the imposition of these taxes. This motion is really a continuation, if not the culmination, of the policy of concealment which has been adopted by the Government during the past few months.
The whole basis of the taxes which they propose to impose by the Bill that has just passed the House—the Finance Bill—is concealment. Most of the taxation proposed to be imposed by that Bill is concealed taxation. It was the business of the Opposition— and they endeavoured to carry out that duty—to expose to the public the effect of the taxation which was proposed and, in particular, to point out to the public the various concealed taxes which were implicit in the Finance Bill. Many people have, in fact, expressed their surprise to members on this side of the House at the information they had obtained through the discussion that took place on the Committee Stage of the Bill, and through the revelations made by Deputy Mulcahy and other members of the Opposition Party in the course of the so-called and wearisome discussions in the last fortnight. They have been amazed to find out the number of taxes generally, and the number of concealed taxes proposed to be imposed by that Bill. This proposition that is now before the House is merely a continuation of that policy of concealment. They wish to prevent the Opposition from continuing the policy of exposing to the people the effect of the taxation that is being imposed by the Government openly and secretly, and to prevent us from discussing in detail the various items which would normally fall for discussion if a proper opportunity were given to the Opposition to discuss these various Estimates which are proposed to be closured. They are afraid that if we were allowed to discuss these items in detail, we would be able to expose still further the policy of the Government and to show the effects of their policy of endeavouring to impose taxation by concealed and indirect methods.
The Minister for Finance referred to-day to the closure motion on the Estimates which took place in the year 1929. As Deputy Hogan pointed out, the circumstances were entirely different then. Look at the facts and compare the circumstances prevailing then with the circumstances obtaining now. At that time the total amount of the Estimates which were closured in 1929, on a closure motion introduced by Deputy Cosgrave, who was then President of the Executive Council, was the sum of £613,889. £613,000 odd! The amount that is proposed to be closured by the present motion is £11,000,000—in other words, 20 times the amount that was closured in 1929 by Deputy Cosgrave is proposed to be closured by this motion. At that time, also, the then Opposition had taken 109 hours in discussing the Estimate, whereas, up to the present, we have taken only 79 hours. That is the contrast—£613,000 odd as against £11,000,000 odd, and 109 hours as against 79 hours. From that, the people can judge as to whether or not this motion is brought forward for the purpose of stifling discussion, as we suggest, or, as Deputy Moore ingenuously suggests, in order to enable the Ministers to get back to their Departments.
We have here an Estimate for agriculture, one of the most important Estimates in the whole book of Estimates that are presented annually to the Dáil. We have 25 pages of the book of Estimates devoted to agriculture, and yet we are not to be allowed to discuss one single item of that. There will not be time, we are told! Of course, we were offered a day for that; but Deputy Hogan has stated that it would be impossible for him to discuss, even in the time allowed by a day's discussion in the Dáil, all the various items contained in that Estimate. Then there is the office of the Minister for Finance. A variety of topics is comprised in the Estimate for that office, all of which should be discussed in the public interest. We are anxious to know what is the reason for the extraordinary increase in the staff of the Civil Service, and we should also like to know whether or not the statement made by the Minister for Finance, in answer to Deputy McGuire the other day, is correct, and, if so, what system of arbitration is proposed in view of the President's promise to give a system of arbitration to the Civil Service. I was anxious to discuss the question of arbitration in the Civil Service. I was all the more anxious to discuss that particular item because I felt that I could do so without being taunted with the fact that we, on this side of the House, were in favour of arbitration merely for the purpose of vote-catching. I felt that we could not be taunted in that way because we have the authority of some of the spokesmen for methods of arbitration in the Civil Service, that, whether or not we were in favour of arbitration, these civil servants will not vote for us. Let us accept that. Let us take it that they will not vote for us. Nevertheless, we are still in favour of arbitration, and therefore I felt that we could discuss this matter impartially and that it would be known that we were not out for vote-catching.
Comment on this
Why did not the Minister carry out the promise that the President gave to the civil servants in Rathmines Town Hall? We never gave a promise to give arbitration, but the President did, and we want to discuss whatever queer sort of arbitration has been offered to the Civil Service. We did not promise it, but the President specifically promised it before the election, and that promise has not been carried out. Nevertheless, we are not going to be allowed an opportunity of discussing that particularly interesting topic. Neither are we going to be allowed sufficient time to discuss the Law Charges Vote. The Minister for Finance, when he moved the Law Charges Vote yesterday, moved it in a few words and airily said: "Let the Opposition go to it; they are anxious for it." Then his Parliamentary Secretary wasted the time of the House for an hour and a quarter.
Comment on this
That is a very sound point! We are overwhelmed with the potency of the Minister's argument.
Comment on this
All right. It was not moved last night. I concede that point to the Minister. It was moved, let us say, the other night by the Minister, who spoke a couple of words. Then Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney got up and spoke, and then, last night— in order to be strictly accurate and in order now—the Parliamentary Secretary wasted the time of the House for over an hour and a quarter and had to be called to order at least six or seven times by the Chair, but we are not to be allowed to discuss it because, forsooth, we will not have time to discuss the very vital question we were anxious to discuss on this Vote: as to whether or not sheriffs, who are being paid on this Vote, are carrying out their duties in accordance with the law. I was anxious——
Comment on this
If the Deputy is so anxious to discuss this matter, I make him the offer that we will put the motion now, and so allow him to start immediately discussing law charges.
Comment on this
Will the Minister increase the time from 12 o'clock tomorrow so as to enable us to discuss law charges, agriculture, export bounties and subsidies, and all the other important matters?
Comment on this
One single day would not be sufficient for agriculture. Even I, who am not an agriculturist or a Deputy who represents much of an agricultural constituency, know enough about agriculture to realise that the present policy of the Government in reference to agriculture could not possibly be discussed in one day. The Minister is very much pressed for arguments if he has to rely on the sort of stuff he has been interjecting in the last few moments. We are not to be allowed to discuss, in connection with law charges, the very vital matters we want to bring forward. I, personally, wanted to speak on the Estimate for law charges. I did not want to speak in a critical or even a Party spirit, but I find it somewhat difficult, listening to the irrelevancies of the Parliamentary Secretary last night, to restrain the remarks which I would make if I had spoken last night on law charges.
We are not to be allowed to discuss the item for sheriffs' salaries which appears in this Law Charges Vote. I wanted to point out and to prove conclusively that not a single one of the sheriffs' sales, which are being carried on at the moment by the sheriffs whose salaries are being provided on the Law Charges Vote, is conducted in accordance with the law. We are not to be allowed to draw attention to that. It would not suit the Government that I should stand up here, I hope, impartially and without political bias, draw the attention of the Attorney-General to the fact that the law is being flouted at those sheriffs' sales, and ask him in the interests of the country, in the interests of the public, and in the interests of the agricultural community, to see that when those sales are being carried out the law is enforced and is strictly adhered to.
We are not to be allowed to draw attention to those matters. We were prevented by the speech of the Parliamentary Secretary, who spoke about the Constitution (Amendment) Act— which he so unctuously referred to as the Public Danger Act—and spoke about it in such tones that I asked myself several times: "Is the Act in force at the moment or is it not? Is it being operated by that Government whose Parliamentary Secretary speaks about it as the Public Danger Act?" I wondered was the Attorney-General prosecuting before the Military Tribunal at the moment, or was I dreaming it, or were the newspapers dreaming when they reported prosecutions by the Attorney-General against the I.R.A. The Public Danger Act was the general topic of the Parliamentary Secretary's so-called discourse last night. We are not to be allowed to reply to that. We will not have time to reply to it. We will not have time to reply to a number of things which I had wished to discuss, in, I hope, a perfectly friendly fashion, with the Attorney-General. We are not to be allowed to draw attention to certain matters which we have in common. The Minister's Parliamentary Secretary did everything that he could to prevent it, and probably, if this motion is passed to-night in sufficient time to allow the Law Charges Vote to be continued, the Parliamentary Secretary, who is in possession, will continue for another hour and a quarter to prevent us from discussing this Vote. That is the type of thing we are faced with at the present time. As I have said before, it is only the culmination of the policy of concealment which has been adopted by the present Government. It is only the continuation—I do not think it is the culmination yet —of the policy towards dictatorship and towards the stifling of Parliamentary Government and Parliamentary institutions which has been carried on by the present Government.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance addressed himself to some remarks of Deputy Cosgrave, but his mode of address was to keep away entirely from the remarks made by Deputy Cosgrave as to what had actually been done here. Deputy Cosgrave pointed out that the Minister for Finance is presenting this House and presenting the people to-day with a bill of expenditure which is £6,768,000 more than the bill that was presented in the year 1931-32. One of my objections to this particular class of guillotine, and to preventing the Estimates which still remain to be discussed from getting any kind of reasonable discussion, is that if the House were allowed to discuss those Estimates which remain there would appear from those Estimates that a very considerable burden, outside of that £6,768,000, was being put on the people, and that the people's eyes would be opened to the huge additional amount of money which is being taken out of their pockets.
We are prevented from having any reasonable discussion on the Vote for the Department of Agriculture. One of the reasons why we are prevented from examining the Department of Agriculture Vote in the systematic and detailed way in which it would be examined, if the House had a reasonable time for doing so, is that if we turned to some of the items on that Vote under the head of appropriations-in-aid this House would wake up to the fact that, outside of the money which was being provided on that Estimate, the people were being taxed to the extent of £285,000 by means of a levy on cattle; that it was more than likely that they would be taxed to the extent of an additional £240,000 in respect of bacon fees; that in regard to the expenditure on wheat, if it were systematically examined here, it would be seen that the increased cost in bread and flour to the people of this country, outside of the taxation that is being put on them, would be about £900,000. By examination of these estimates the bill which is being presented to the country through the Finance Bill would be thrown into further relief with regard to the people's capacity to pay. When we were examining the Vote for the Department of Industry and Commerce—from the criticism of which the Minister for Industry and Commerce ran away; the Minister for Finance will not say that an excessively long time was spent in examination of the Vote for the Department of Industry and Commerce; the Minister ran away from it—we had our attention drawn to the fact that, outside of the moneys provided through the Finance Bill for the carrying on, with all its increased expenditure, of the Department of Industry and Commerce, the people were being additionally taxed in a way which did not appear as taxation, in that they were paying £195,000 in rates from certain towns in this country for the upkeep of the Unemployment Assistance measure; that, in addition to the amount of money which was being extracted from the people under the Finance Bill, £195,000 was being extracted from urban ratepayers, and that in addition £250,000 was being lifted out of the Unemployment Insurance Fund for the purpose of spending on that particular scheme.
Another of the Estimates which we are prevented from examining is the Estimate for the Supplementary Agricultural Grant. We would understand from examination and discussion of that Estimate that, in addition to the moneys which were being taken out of the people's pockets through the Finance Bill, £100,000 was this year being raised in rates on agricultural land, for spending by the Executive Council. Our minds would then travel to the other hidden taxes that were being raised from the people — £600,000 from butter £1,088,000 from sugar—and we would end up our discussion of the Estimates by a realisation that although the Estimates themselves present an increase of £6,768,000 on a bill to be paid by the people out of taxes imposed on them by the Government, all those other items I have mentioned were raising out of the people's pockets an additional £3,708,000, so that in fact the people were being taxed by more than £10,000,000 over the taxation level of 1931-32.
We are prevented here discussing in detail the Estimates that only serious and detailed discussion of them would bring out these facts. The Minister for Industry and Commerce addressed himself to the position in which the agricultural industry was, and he explained that there was considerably more employment in that industry in 1934 than in 1931. There are 1,600 more permanent agricultural labourers employed according to the statistics. Deputies who do not know the country on this side of the House asked Deputies on the other side of the House whether they think there are more permanent agricultural labourers in the country in 1934 than in 1931. I am prepared to take the Minister for Industry and Commerce with his figures in that respect, for the Minister bases his claim not on 1,600 additional labourers, but on figures which he has already given us, of 16,836. A more detailed examination of the Estimate for the Supplementary Agricultural Grant would throw some light on that. Last year out of the Supplementary Agricultural Grant there was £385,000 odd given as employment allowances to farmers whose valuation was from £20 upwards in respect of the number of persons employed permanently in agricultural employment on their holdings. An examination of the situation would show that what has happened really as a result of the giving of this £385,000 as employment allowances on these farms is that every male member of the farmer's family on a farm of more than £20 valuation has been put on the agricultural Schedule as employed in agriculture. When the Minister for Industry and Commerce is claiming that there are more persons employed in 1934 than in 1931 he is not talking of the 1,600 permanent agricultural labourers. He is talking of the total 16,836 additional persons, more than 15,000 of which are members of the farmers' families who have been induced by the grant of £385,000 to come on the statistical records as "employed."
The House has some idea of the amount of money that is being used to subsidise wheat, to subsidise beet and to subsidise tobacco in a certain number of counties of this country. They have been told that these would increase the farmer's income and would increase the wages payable to all the workers on the land. In the earlier stages of the Fianna Fáil régime the present Minister for Defence told the people in Louth that the prices guarantee would ensure farmers a decent wage, and would enable them to pay their work people a decent wage. Deputies have drawn attention to the fact that there has been a considerable fall in wages in the agricultural industry. We have repeated again and again that the Minister's own figures show that there is not a province in the country in which the agricultural wages have not gone down, in which the wage has not decreased; even amongst the cream of the agricultural labourers—if the word "cream" can be mentioned in connection with agricultural labourers in this respect—the wages have gone down. The figures which the Minister for Industry and Commerce can quote as wages are miserable figures. Miserable as were the wages of the agricultural labourers they have, during the Fianna Fáil régime been reduced by 3/- per week in Leinster, 4/- per week in Munster, 2/6 in Connaught and 3/- in Ulster.
Again I have to repeat that in the most subsidised county in this country for three months in the earliest part of this year the committee of agriculture pleaded with the Government that as the average wage in Wexford was only 8/- a week and food, the free beef scheme ought to be extended to the labourers there. Only a week ago we had a report from the responsible commissioner in South Tipperary. The Minister for Local Government and Public Health had issued instructions to dismiss certain cottage rent collectors if they failed to collect the outstanding arrears. What was the reply? The first collector said the reason was that the agricultural labourers in South Tipperary were getting no more than 8/- a week; the second collector said that some farmers in his part of the county were unable to pay the wages and that in some cases they were as much as six months in arrear——
Comment on this
I do not know whether it is the desire of Deputies to go into Estimates, as is being done, because it simply throws the Estimates open for discussion on this motion. At least two Deputies have devoted most of their time to the actual discussion of the Estimates instead of speaking to the motion. That is the position.
Comment on this
I only want to refer briefly to that aspect of the agricultural situation and to reply to the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The Minister laid stress on the additional employment that was given in agriculture and I simply want to draw attention to the fact that we are prevented from discussing here such additional employment as his figures show has been induced by the additional supplementary grant. I advert to this motion because there are a number of Estimates that would require discussion. I will take the old age pensions. The Minister for Finance told us that certain abuses had arisen in connection with the administration and the grant of old age pensions and that he expected to reduce the amount of the pensions this year by £100,000. This House should have a reasonable opportunity of discussing the Old Age Pensions Estimate. A parliamentary answer was given here the other day and it disclosed facts that I think are worthy of discussing. There should be some means of discussing them in this House on the Estimate and they should not, therefore, be shut down by this guillotine motion. The Minister and his colleagues claim that there has been a considerable increase in the payments for pensions in various counties. The incidence of this increase is, in my opinion, a matter that ought to be discussed. I would like to have an opportunity of discussing why it is that there has been an increase in old age pensions in Galway, a county of approximately the same population as Donegal. The increase in Galway has amounted to 7/- per head of the population, whereas the increase in Donegal is only 2/- per head of the population. I would like to have an opportunity of discussing why in Monaghan the increase between 1931 and 1934 is equivalent to 6/- per head of the population, whereas in the City and County of Dublin it is only 2/3 per head of the population.
Comment on this
I heard of the means test but I should like to discuss why there has been such a great increase in Galway as compared with Donegal.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister for Finance is serious when he suggests that we should shut up now and that we were going to have an opportunity of discussing the Old Age Pensions Estimate. He knows very well we are not going to have that discussion. I would like, too, to have a discussion on the Secret Service Estimate, which has gone up from £1,500 in 1931 to £20,000 now, in spite of the fact, as Deputy Cosgrave pointed out, that the Gárda Síochána Estimate has gone up enormously.
We are not going to be allowed to discuss these things. We are not going to be allowed to discuss particularly the things that would come out here if these Estimates were considered. Not only is there increased hidden taxation of a kind that could be portrayed as a result of an examination of these Estimates, but there is even taxation which would require very minute scrutiny of the Estimate to understand. A trader in Tipperary had consigned to him at the end of June a 12-lb. box of tomatoes and it cost him 4/-. A quota order was issued by the Minister for Agriculture and the next 12-lb. box cost him 9/6. These are matters that can only be brought out and understood if the Estimates still down for consideration could be discussed. A full appreciation of the burden of taxation that is being put upon the people can only be got when, after a discussion of the budgetary proposals, we can in a reasonable and detailed way complete the discussion of these Estimates, and that is what we are not being allowed to do. I object to that. The burden of taxation remains. The various taxes and the maladministration remain and we will not be allowed to discuss them here. The Minister and his colleagues, by the choking down of discussion here, cannot stop in the end a full appreciation of these things by the people. We belong to a race that has been throttled for generations. Yet an Irish Parliament sitting here——
Comment on this
I am going to go on saying and reminding the Ministers that this is an Irish Parliament set up by the Irish people against all the throttling and the beating down that could possibly be brought to bear upon it. If some of the throttling and the beating down is attempted inside the walls of this Parliament, the people who met that throttling and beating down outside when they had no Parliament are not going to be subdued by it even when it operates from the Government Front Bench of an Irish Parliament. It will see its end, as well as other attempts at throttling and beating down saw its end.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?