We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Supplementary Estimates. - Vote 52—Agriculture.

Contributions 1–182 of 372. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

With regard to Vote 52—Agriculture, I understand it has been agreed that the Minister will be called upon to conclude at 9.45 p.m. I shall call on him accordingly.

Comment on this
James Ryan Minister for Agriculture (Dr. Ryan) Fianna Fáil

I move:—

Go ndeontar suim Bhreise ná raghaidh thar £10 chun íoctha an Mhuirir a thiocfaidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar críoch an 31adh lá de Mhárta, 1936, chun Tuarastail agus Costaisí Oifig an Aire Talmhaíochta agus seirbhísí áirithe atá fé riaradh na hOifige sin, maraon le hIldeontaisi-i-gCabhair.

That a Supplementary sum not exceeding £10 be granted to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending 31st March, 1936, for the Salaries and Expenses of the Office of the Minister for Agriculture, and of certain services administered by that Office, including sundry Grants-in-Aid.

As Deputies are aware, this Supplementary Estimate is being moved in order to give the House an opportunity of discussing the administration of the Department of Agriculture during the last 12 months. This was considered to be the most convenient way in which agriculture could be discussed. It is not altogether that we need £10. It is more to give an opportunity for discussion. This £10 added to the original estimate leaves us something like a net expenditure of £998,000. That figure has been commented upon by certain Deputies here as being extraordinarily high. It is, of course, much higher than the normal expenditure under the Department of Agriculture for many years, but there are two large items which account for the increase. These two are the expenditure under the Cereals Act and the expenditure under the Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Act. Under the Cereals Act there is an estimate of £300,000, and the net expenditure under the Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Act would be £200,000. If we deduct that £500,000, from the amount here, we would get down to something under £500,000, which is about the normal expenditure of the Department over a number of years.

I do not think there is very much use in going through the various sub-heads of the Estimate. If the Estimate had been taken in the normal time I would have been inclined to say something in regard to the sub-heads. I presume that now the debate is going to take a more general turn and agriculture in a wider sense will be discussed. I would like to give Deputies some little help. I would like to tell them what the true position is with regard to prices so that they may not fall into error, as they might be inclined to if I did not give some prices to start off with. I want to take, first of all, the dairying products. The dairying business was a very important branch of the agricultural industry and in 1926-27, when the output of agriculture was taken, it was valued at £13,000,000. The output in 1934 increased considerably in quantity, so that if prices had remained the same in 1934 as they were in 1926 it would be still more valuable in cash than it was in that year. The world price in 1934 was considerably less than half what it was in 1926 yet, through the various measures taken by the Government, the income to farmers on a cash value basis was almost two-thirds what it was in 1926. In that particular branch of agriculture the farmers were not left to the disastrous consequences of world prices.

In 1935 things have been a little better so far as we have gone. In the first quarter, I see in the Irish Trade Journal, farmers' butter was 128/5 per cwt. On an average, compared with 116/4 in the first quarter of 1934. That applies to the whole Free State. Creamery butter was 138/6, as compared with 134/6 in the first quarter of 1934. The price of milk to creameries was 5.3, as compared with 5.2. I am quoting these prices to show that in 1935 the returns from dairy products are somewhat better than they were in 1934, and we managed to return to the farmers two-thirds of the income they had in 1926 although world prices were less than half. This, of course, has been due to many causes, the Stabilisation Act, the various subsidies and also, in some measure, to the development of the manufacture of certain dairy products not manufactured here three or four years ago. The principal one would be cheese. The output this year of cheese will amount to 30,000 cwts. A few years ago the output was only a few thousand cwts.

One of the results of this policy of guaranteeing a certain return for dairy products has been that we have increased the number of cows. A few years ago we had 1,222,000 cows and, in 1934, we had 1,309,000 cows. That was due to the difficulty of getting rid of old cows. We hope, in the course of a week or ten days, to have a factory commencing operations and taking old uneconomic cows for conversion into meat meal. That may have the effect of bringing the number of cows down again to the normal number that we had for some years. As I explained yesterday, the purchase of old cows for the Roscrea factory will be followed by a vigorous campaign for the elimination of tuberculosis.

So far as milk products are concerned, there does not appear any possibility of an improvement in the dairying industry as long as world prices remain as they are and as long as we have a surplus which we must export. If we had more consumption at home or less production, if all our own dairy products would be consumed by our own people, there would be no difficulty whatsoever in getting back to the 1926-29 prices. The largest item in the output of agriculture in 1926 was cattle. That was also worth £13,000,000. Everybody will admit that the price of cattle is very low. The economic war has been blamed, to a great extent, for the reduction in the price of cattle, but it cannot be blamed entirely for that great reduction, because the very most that the economic war can be held responsible for, as regards the reduction in prices, would be a tariff less bounty, and no beast should be reduced, even the best beast in the country, more than £5 a head owing to the economic war, and the majority of the cattle should be reduced only by £2 10s. a head or £4 a head.

Comment on this

What about the quota?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I am saying that the economic war is only responsible for that much but the quota was responsible for very much worse consequences in the cattle trade than the economic war itself. Let us take the economic war first—I will come to the quota in a minute or two. If it is admitted and agreed that the price of cattle is lowered by the amount of the tariff, less the bounty which varies from £2 10/- to £5 a head, that loss in itself is more than counterbalanced by the £2,000,000 a year that the farmers get in the remission of land annuities. With regard to the quota, the quota was undoubtedly responsible for a further decrease in the price of cattle. But under the new regulations which have recently been issued, the quota has been in fact dropped as far as the farmer is concerned, or I should say as far as the store cattle are concerned. The prices in the case of store cattle ought to approximate to the 1931 prices plus the bounty less the tariff. And we get back to the 1933 position. And if we get back to the 1933 position we should, taking into consideration the prices of cattle in Great Britain at the present time, have a rise in the price of store cattle here of 30/- a head as a result of these new regulations.

Comment on this

The price of the licence.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes, that is more than the licence was worth. We are getting rid of the quota disabilities as a result of the working of the export of store cattle, as these regulations are being worked now. As regards fat cattle, there is no change except in the distribution of the licences. Those vocal Deputies here appear to be generally agreed that the licences were not satisfactorily given out when given out by the Department of Agriculture. We can only hope that there will be a big improvement now when the County Committees of Agriculture have got the distribution of licences.

Comment on this

After the Department of Agriculture failed.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes—that will be a proof now of the Committees doing it better.

Comment on this

If we are given enough licences, but if we get only one in 12 we cannot do much with them.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We had only one in 12. The Deputy cannot fall back on that argument; that was our trouble too. I am sure the Deputy will put up a better argument than that.

Comment on this

It is a long time until 10 o'clock to-night.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I hope the Deputy will not take the whole of that time. With regard to the Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Act, I have a few words to say. There is an amending Bill circulated which will be discussed here within a few days. It appears to be generally assumed by some people that that Act did not do any great good. The Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Act was absolutely necessary for a good many reasons, and it has been very successful in many of the provisions which it contains. For instance, under the Act we succeeded in getting rid of 1,000 cattle had not been absorbed in that way they would have made a very big surplus of fat cattle on the market and, in that way, made matters worse. In the second place, we were able to do a great deal of good by the establishment at Roscrea of a factory for the disposal of old cows. That factory will be in operation before the end of this month. In the third place, we are endeavouring to get, and I think we have succeeded in getting, a canned meat factory established. The establishment of that factory is almost certain now and it will be in operation before the end of the year. That will absorb at least 10,000 cattle a year, for the manufacture of tinned meats and extracts and that will to that extent relieve the market of even that small surplus. Again, the Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Act was necessary in order to give the Minister power to trade in cattle with other countries. Under that provision of the Act we have succeeded in getting rid to Continental countries of between 20,000 and 25,000 cattle. One provision of the Act which did not work satisfactorily was the minimum price. That was as a matter of fact due, I must admit, to wrong judgment on my part. I did believe when bringing in the Bill that the farmers of the country would see that the victuallers paid them a minimum price. But I found that the farmers were not prepared to stand up for themselves, and the minimum price was not paid in many cases. We are bringing in an amending Bill which is compelling the butchers to pay the minimum price whether the farmers help us or not. I expect we will be able to enforce the provisions of the Act much more effectively when this amending Bill is passed.

The next item in our output which was most important was pigs and bacon. In 1926 the output of pigs and bacon was £9,000,000; cattle £13,000,000 and dairy produce £13,000,000. There was a very bad slump in the prices of pigs at the end of 1931 and again at the end of 1932. But since February, 1933, the prices were maintained at a good level until a few weeks ago. Now we have run into a slump again. It is rather difficult to explain to what this present slump is due. There are somewhat low prices on the British market for bacon, but if we take the fall in bacon in Great Britain for the last three or four weeks it does not at all justify the fall in the prices here. What the fall here is due to is that the curers for the first time in their history have got a perfect organisation. Up to this there were always one or two curers who stood out, but now it appears they have got almost unanimity.

Comment on this

And a perfect monopoly.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

A perfect organisation at any rate and one can see the result of that organisation. Unfortunately we cannot do anything until we get the Pigs and Bacon Act operating. That will be done with the least possible delay. I explained here some time ago that it will take a little time to get the factories constructed and registered. Then we have to build up a panel of electors for the Bacon Board. The Bacon Board elects part of the Pig Board, and they have to make the necessary orders when the Bill becomes operative. While that is taking place I am afraid we cannot do anything with the factories or check them in paying these abnormally low prices. The bacon factories were expected to lose money in the Spring. They always expected to do so, but they made it a practice to get that money back in addition to some profit in the Autumn. There is a slump in the price in the Autumn because there are more pigs then than the market can absorb at a good price. This year the bacon curers are afraid that when the boards begin to operate they may not take into account that the curers had a loss last Spring, and they may begin to operate the boards and give only a fair profit from the time they begin to operate without taking into account what was lost in the Spring. They are making sure to get those losses back before the boards commence to operate.

Comment on this

They will control the boards.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

They do not.

Comment on this

They will.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy was beaten in that both in the Select Committee and in the Dáil. The Deputy should recognise when he is beaten, and know when he is wrong. Other people recognise when he is wrong, and the Deputy should try and recognise it himself. There would be 152 to one with me on that point. I am quite sure there would be one in the minority.

Comment on this

That will be the Minister by the time the thing is done.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Boards of course when they do come to operate will take all this into account, and that is all we can do for the present. The next items I think in order of importance in the agricultural line are eggs and poultry, which I think were worth between £6,000,000 and £7,000,000 in 1926. The principal thing that I want to report on there is the securing of markets for eggs in both Germany and Spain during the year. This had a very good effect in two ways. In the first place it prevented a surplus of eggs here after filling the British quota. We would undoubtedly have had a surplus after filling our own market and the British quota if we had not secured those other foreign markets. The results of course would be that the price of eggs would fall very steeply, because we know what the position is when you have more of any particular commodity than is necessary to fill the quota. We were able therefore to stave off the very bad effects of the British quota by securing those two markets. Also we were able to get a somewhat better price in those markets than we would have got in the British market. It had the effect all the time of stiffening the price to a small extent, with the result that the average price of eggs here for the first quarter of this year, according to the Irish Trade Journal, was 7/10 compared with 7/5 last year. Also if anybody will look up the trade statistics of the imports and exports it will be found that, for the five months January to May, we exported a slightly smaller quantity of eggs than we did in 1934, but we got more money; we realised more for the lesser number than we did in 1934, so that the egg trade was slightly improved over last year. Also during that quarter if anybody cares to look up the Irish Trade Journal it will be found that we got a considerably better price for some classes of poultry and a slightly better price for all.

The next item is sheep and lambs. With regard to sheep and lambs the prices have been satisfactory for a couple of years up to a few weeks ago, but the last return that I have got from the Department of Industry and Commerce goes back to the 12th June, where it shows that the price for sheep was about the same as last year and the price for lambs a little less, but since 12th June, that is during the last four weeks, the prices have fallen still further. At the moment, therefore, the price of sheep and lambs is lower than it was this time last year. I do not know whether or not that is a temporary condition. It is held by some of those who profess to know a good deal about marketing that it is due only to the very warm weather, and that prices will again improve as soon as the hot spell is over. I only hope that that is true.

Those are the principal live stock and live-stock products. We now turn to another side of agriculture and come to the output on the two items, beet and wheat, where the output was very small in 1926-7. In that year the total value of the output of wheat and beet together was £324,000. This year the output will be valued at almost £3,000,000—about £2,950,000.

Comment on this

Is the Minister dealing with them on a common basis?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Of course I am not. Why should I?

Comment on this

Is the Minister taking the world price in the one case and the artificial price in the other?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I am taking what the farmer is getting. That is not artificial as far as the farmer is concerned.

Comment on this

It is, because he has to pay for it himself first.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy ought to reserve those arguments, because he will have to support them a little bit before anybody agrees with them. The farmer as a farmer does not mind very much whether it is the world price or the Irish price as long as he gets it. I am talking about what the effect is. For instance, if I say he is getting more than the world price in wheat, and if he is getting less than the world price in cattle, he ought to be satisfied, according to Deputy Belton, because it is artificial. I am not taking that line; I am going on what the farmer is getting, and not what is artificial. As a matter of fact, I am not taking the year 1931 for beet, because it would be unfair owing to the strike. The output was only 5,000 acres. I am taking 1932; 13,000 acres of beet and 21,000 acres of wheat were grown in that year. The output was valued in 1931 at £324,000. This year the output of those two crops will be valued at £3,000,000, and as soon as we grow our full requirements of wheat and beet, at present prices, the output will be worth £6,700,000. That will make up for a good deal of the losses in some of the others.

Comment on this

£12,000,000——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy very wisely remarked that it is a long time until 10.30; he will have an opportunity of putting his remarks together in a speech.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Do not be surprised, a Chinn Comhairle, if he is wise sometimes. As I have shown under the other various headings, sheep, pigs, dairy products and so on, the farmer is not suffering any great loss as a result of the economic war. What he will gain in wheat and beet will cover this small loss, and indeed, perhaps, a good lot more. I know the case will be made here by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney and others, who quote statistics, touching them in spots where it suits them, that we have not increased our tillage at all as a result of this wheat policy. A few days ago here Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney compared wheat and oats, but, strange to say, he left out barley. Any unprejudiced person would think that if you are going to talk about wheat and oats you should also have a look at barley, but that would not suit Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney's argument. For fear he might mislead somebody again, I want to give him figures before he commences, so that he can take a note of them. In 1931 the total tillage, taking cereals, roots and all, was 1,425,000 acres, and in 1934 it was 1,497,000, that is an increase of 72,000 acres. Our wheat crop has been increased by 73,000 acres, so that it does appear that if we have increased our acreage in wheat, as we did in 1934 by 73,000 there is extra tillage to a great extent. It is true that the acreage in oats went down, but the acreage in barley went up. If you take oats and barley together, leaving out wheat, the acreage in 1931 was 739,000, and in 1934, 726,000 acres; that is we went down 13,000 acres in oats and barley together, while we went up 73,000 acres in wheat. That meant that of that 73,000 acres in wheat, 60,000 acres was extra tillage.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say what was the average production?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

We have not got those figures for 1934 yet. That is the yield?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not think we have yet got those figures for 1934, but I will try and get them for the Deputy if possible. I think these are the only points to which I want to draw attention before Deputies speak on this Estimate. I remember last year, when introducing the Estimate, I asked Deputies for some good suggestions, because the usual speeches they make here on agriculture are not going to do the country any good. If any Deputy would make a good suggestion for the improvement of agriculture, it would do a whole lot more good.

Comment on this

It would be badly wanted.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Very badly wanted. If any Deputy can make a good suggestion, I will be the first to say it is a good suggestion, and I will have it examined or adopted. But I am three years here, and I have never heard any suggestion from the Opposition that anyone would adopt, even themselves.

Comment on this

The Minister, as one would expect, has very naturally endeavoured to put the very best face he can upon the administration of his Department. But I do think that it would be better for the country, and especially it would be better for agriculture, and more in the interests of those who live upon the land, if the Minister would take a much broader and deeper view of Irish agriculture than he took in his opening statement; if the Minister would consider where the policy which he has been adopting is leading the country. In a very famous passage Edward Gibbon declared that solitude was the school of genius. I really wish that the Minister for Agriculture would go somewhere into complete and entire solitude for something like a week, bringing no book or anything with him, and having nothing except his own thoughts to rely upon. I wish he would go to some lonely lighthouse, or some place of that nature, and I also wish that he would make the same suggestion to the Minister for Industry and Commerce. When these two gentlemen have spent some little time in a lonely lighthouse meditating upon the condition of this country at present, looking to what the future of this country is, having regard to their policy, I venture to think that the Minister would cease from his present method of living from hand to mouth, of making experiment after experiment, in a desperate endeavour to produce some palliative for the evils which he is bringing upon agriculture by his policy. I am afraid, however, that we have very small hopes of the Minister going back to bedrock. We have very small hopes of the Minister taking a broad view of Irish agriculture, taking a broad and intelligent view of what the future of Irish agriculture must be if his policy is carried out, as it is being carried out, not amended and fundamentally altered.

When one comes to consider the policy of the Government in regard to agriculture, it is perfectly obvious that the Government, detached from Irish affairs and conditions, have worked on a theoretical scheme which they have been determined to put into force. They have been acting entirely as theorists. They have produced certain schemes which would be precisely and identically the same if they were the Executive Council of Kamscathcha or Korea or any other country. They have been working at a theory, and nothing else but a theory.

Take agriculture as it stands at present, and take the Minister's opening statement. How is agriculture situated, how is it living? As far as the butter industry is concerned that industry was most undoubtedly badly hit, and certain measures had to be taken to preserve the industry which was of great importance to this State. As to whether the Minister's methods were the wisest and best, I will not stop to consider. I do not think it necessarily follows that the method adopted by private firms and exporters who control the Australian market was the very best policy which the Minister could imitate. I will grant that to carry the Irish dairying industry over a crisis in its history it most unquestionably was necessary that certain steps should be taken, but I will not stay to examine as to whether those steps and the subsidising of Irish butter could be entirely justified.

When one comes to consider subsidies one must regard a subsidy as a thing which is either to keep a business going over a bad period, or else to keep a business going which is wanted, not for its own self, not for its economic interest, but because of some social interest that it has got. Now, on the ground of carrying a great important industry over what was a temporary crisis, certainly the Government subsidy, direct or indirect—in this case it is indirect—to the butter industry was justified. But when you have a great industry, an important industry, the cattle and sheep industry, what is the Minister's case to the House? That not now, not for any present crisis, but for all time, that industry is to live on a subsidised basis. It is being subsidised at present, and while it is being subsidised with export bounties on the one hand, it is being deliberately killed by the Minister, because when he is slaughtering calves in the senseless fashion in which they were slaughtered, the Minister is killing the live stock trade, because he is killing the things which are necessary to the live stock trade. You have got this main industry, the main source of wealth to the agricultural community, and especially to the smaller farmer, put, as the Minister himself must admit, upon a permanently unsound subsidised basis.

When dealing with the wheat scheme, the Minister did not tell the House that the price that is being paid for wheat is being paid out of a Government subsidy, direct or indirect. He did not tell the House, when talking about the increased area of beet, that the price which is being paid for beet is a subsidised price. He has never held out any hope, and he never could hold out any hope, to this House that wheat will be able to stand upon its own legs as a wealth-producing source in this country. It is impossible for him to contend, that beet can ever stand upon its own legs as a source of wealth in this country.

What is the condition into which you have got agriculture, in all its main features, in everything that goes to constitute its principal source of production? You have got agriculture on an unsound, because subsidised, basis. Where are the subsidies to come from? In other countries, no doubt in very highly industrialised countries, they can afford to subsidise agriculture. They can afford to subsidise various forms of agriculture, but remember that is being done, not because they wish to have agriculture by itself as a real source of wealth to the State, but because for social purposes they wish to have a balance in the State with the agricultural end kept up. That, for instance, is the reason why the British people are subsidising beet, not because they hope that beet in England can stand on its own legs, but because they wish for social purposes to have a certain number of their people engaged on the land. But, turning to this country, our position is quite different. We are not a highly industrialised country. I do not believe we can ever hope to be a highly industrialised country. I do not believe we can ever hope that the product of our industries will ever exceed the product of our land in value. But the Minister is so working agriculture at the present moment that agriculture has to look outside itself in order that it can be kept going at all. It has to look outside itself for a subsidy from some source or another.

Where is that subsidy to come from? It can come from two sources only. After all a nation when it spends has only got two sources to which it can look for the amount which it is going to spend. There is first the annual production of the country, and the main annual production in this country was agriculture. Agriculture has ceased in its main features to be self-supporting. It has become a national loss rather than a source of national gain under the Minister's policy. Where else can it look? The products of industry? Are the products of industry sufficiently large to be able to subsidiwse agriculture at the present moment? It is pretty plain and obvious, I think, that they are not. Certainly anybody who knows this country, could not contend for a moment that they could. Then there remains only the other source of wealth, namely, the accumulated riches of the State, the product of the work of past generations in this country. It is as clear as daylight— at least it seems to me to be as clear as daylight—that in order to keep this policy of subsidies going it is necessary for the Minister to draw upon the capital of the country, upon the accumulated resources of the country, and that can only be done for a short time, a very short time.

That, Sir, brings me to a point to which I have been leading up, a point which I want to emphasise. That point is that there may be a subsidy for beet and a subsidy for wheat to-day, but it is as clear as daylight that it is only as long as the capital of the country remains unexhausted, it is only as long as the Minister can draw upon the capital of the country, that the Minister will be able to keep subsidies for agriculture going. Anybody who comes to the conclusion that for all time this country will be able to maintain subsidies for beet or subsidies for wheat, at the present scale, or will be able to pay bounties on the export of cattle—anybody who thinks that that can be kept up indefinitely must be a person who thinks that the capital of this country is inexhaustible. And it is not inexhaustible. The Executive Council are draining it out in a hundred and one different directions. The whole principle is absolutely and fundamentally unsound, when you consider that what was the great source of wealth, the overwhelmingly great source of wealth, is no longer to be that great source of wealth and is put in a struggling position, helped by other resources and other industries.

Let me take this very simple illustration. Does anybody think that a country can get along permanently, if it has got to keep a huge number of its people on the dole? Does anybody think, on the Government side of the House, that this country could get on if an overwhelmingly large number of its people were put on relief work? But what is the difference? Remember that every penny you pay in subsidy to beet or to wheat, every penny that you pay by way of bounty on the export of cattle, as far as it reaches the farmer at all—I do not accept that it does—is of the nature of money spent on relief works. Your principle now is that the main industry of the country can be kept going by means of relief. It is obvious to my mind that it cannot, as it must be obvious to the mind of anybody who considers the situation. These are not temporary things; this is a permanent policy. The main source of the farmers' income, according to the Minister for Agriculture, is to be derived from wheat and from beet, and these products are going to be a permanent drain upon the resources of the country. That is for all time, not to pass over some temporary crisis, not called for by some world condition. Whether world prices be high or low, for all time Irish farming has to look, not to itself to be self-supporting, but Irish farming has to look elsewhere for help, to other sections of the community. That is obviously in its nature completely and entirely absurd.

While I am talking upon this question of wheat, I want to reply to a remark which the Minister made in reference to a speech which I delivered here the other day. I pointed out that the wheat area did not make up for the fall in the oats area and I stated that the conclusion that ought to be drawn and must be drawn from the figures, as between oats and wheat, was that oats had been knocked out and that wheat was taking its place. But the Minister comes along and says: "Let us take into consideration barley." If barley is driving oats out of the market will the Minister tell us why? If barley is driving oats from the tillage fields of the country will the Minister tell us why? Barley-growing is not substantially in competition with oats growing. Surely the bulk of the barley grown in this country depends upon the state of the brewing industry, so at least I would think. Surely the amount of barley used in home food is small in connection with the amount used in the brewing industry. If the malting industry is absorbing more barley than it did, then the conclusion I would draw from the increased area under barley is that it had nothing whatever to do with oats. I would like to know from the Minister why, in his opinion, unsubsidised barley is driving from the tillage fields unsubsidised oats? What is the reason for that? It seems to me to be perfectly clear that it is subsidised wheat that is driving out unsubsidised oats. The Minister makes a great boast. He says that there has been an increase of 72,000 acres out of his estimated 1½ million acres. Is that an enormous increase? Is that an increase that the country could not have had, and which the country ought to have had. if there never had been a beet or a wheat scheme?

The Minister asks for suggestions. He wants to know what is a sound policy; and he wants to know how he is to carry on his Department. I shall tell the Minister the policy which his Department ought to follow. It is a policy which has been preached from these benches again and again. It is a policy which has been derived, not out of books, thinking in the air, or out of any theoretical scheme, but it is a policy which has been arrived at by careful consideration backed up by practical experience of the conditions, the history of the soil, the climate and everything else which is separate and individual to this State. The main source of wealth in agriculture in this country must always be live stock and live stock products and the way for the Minister to carry on the Department of Agriculture in this country is to take that as his main, principal and general proposition. Let him consider how live stock and live stock products can be made now, as they have been for generations past, the main source of livelihood to Irish agriculturists.

It is due not to his policy in his capacity as Minister for Agriculture, but it is due to the other members of the Executive Council that what already has been alluded to and styled the economic war is in existence. It is due to the Executive Council, who, I think, fired the first shot in this economic war. In firing that first shot in the economic war they aimed and inflicted as deadly a blow as they could at Irish agriculture. You cannot take agriculture by itself. You cannot take the main features of Irish life and isolate it from its surroundings, because if you take agriculture by itself you get a false picture. Taking it in its general surroundings you see your future depends upon having a foreign market in which to dispose of your surplus goods, instead of stifling the foreign market. If the Minister wants to know how to administer his Department successfully, let him devote every effort in his power to see that that market is improved and rapidly advanced and again opened to our agricultural products. It can be done. I go further and tell the Minister that he should recognise that the policy which was preached from these benches has always been the sound policy for Irish agriculture. Trade as largely as you can and as much as you can, and sell the products of your policy not in unmanufactured but in manufactured form. Increase the output of your tillage as much as possible and feed that to your live stock, and sell your produce in the form of live stock and in poultry and poultry products. That is the sound policy upon which this country should be run.

I know that policy has been travestied. I know the Party opposite declare through very unscrupulous propaganda that we, on this side of the House, prefer grass lands to tillage. That was never the policy of our Party and never was the policy of Deputy Hogan, former Minister for Agriculture. That is the policy I shortly re-stated to-day, and it is a sound policy, and, despite the theatrical masquerading of the Minister, he must approve of that policy and I hope he will approve of it again. That is the position at the present moment. It is the sound policy of practical experience, and it is the policy that was worked for generations in this country with reasonably good results. Sometimes it has been found not to be so good; at other times it has been found to be very good, but on the whole it is the natural, sound policy for this country. Let me say to the Minister and his Party that although they seem to despise the natural sources of wealth in this country, they ought to know that this country contains some of the very best land in the world. I do not think I exaggerate when I say that there is to be found in the Irish Free State better and richer grazing land than in any other place in the world. I know in saying that I cannot be very far wrong. You can get better grazing land in the Golden Vale of Tipperary and certain areas of Meath than would be found in the great grass lands of Kentucky. When you have these great sources of wealth, where you can fatten your cattle to the greatest advantage at the smallest expense, are we to be told— and this seems to be the view of the Ministry—that these natural advantages should not be used? Are we to be told that the great grazing wealth in this country is not a source of wealth but of poverty, and that it is wrong to use it in order to raise cattle, and that it is almost a criminal offence to so use it, and that we would be very much better off if, instead of having the magnificent grazing lands that we have, we transformed these grazing lands into tillage land? That is the false theoretical basis on which the Government are rearing their agricultural policy. They will not consider that an agricultural policy here is an agricultural policy for the Irish Free State, and that it does not matter one button what other countries have done. Let them give up their slavish imitation of other countries. One country slaughters its cows, possibly wisely or possibly foolishly, but at any rate that was what they thought ought to be done, and immediately, without any reason, without any sense and without any cause or excuse, the Minister says: "They are slaughtering cows because they have too many in Denmark; we will slaughter calves so that we may be of the slaughtering line. The rest of the world is destroying its coffee and wheat, and we will get into line by slaughtering calves."

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Did you not join in the slaughter of cows in Kanturk?

Comment on this

I do not follow the Minister.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The slaughter of cows in Kanturk.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Minister means by the slaughter of cows in Kanturk.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy is innocent.

Comment on this

I am. I wish the Minister would be a little more explicit.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Who slaughtered the cows in Kanturk?

Comment on this

I never heard of any cows being slaughtered in Kanturk.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

You are too innocent.

Comment on this

Would the Minister make it a little plainer for me? Deputy Cosgrave tells me now that that is where cows were shot. If cows were shot, it was a damnable thing for anybody to do, but what on earth have I got to do with that?

Comment on this

The Minister thinks you have.

Comment on this

Does the Minister suggest—what is the meaning of his interruption—that I in any way countenanced or advised the shooting of cows?

Comment on this

He says that you engaged in it.

Comment on this

Let the Minister answer, please.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I think it was the Deputy's Party who did it.

Comment on this

Let the Minister speak up, please.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy's followers or Party did it.

Comment on this

My followers or Party did it? I deny that absolutely. In the first place, the Minister charges me. Then, that being so absolutely absurd, he says that it was our followers did it. I say that that is absolutely wrong and I say that the shooting of unfortunate animals carried out by anybody—the Minister's Party or anybody else—is wrong, criminal and disgraceful. The Minister may say what he likes on political platforms; he may break away and diverge from the truth as much as he likes on political platforms—we have no control over the Minister's unscrupulous propaganda or the ununscrupulous propaganda of the Party—but I am glad that the Minister has made that ridiculously false charge here where it can be met and answered and where it can be made apparent to the whole country what is the regard for the truth which animates the Minister for Agriculture.

Now, let me return to what I was saying. The Minister for Agriculture, in order that he might be in the swim with other countries, senselessly ordered the destruction of hundreds of thousands of calves. I do not know whether his anxiety for slaughtering calves is still as great but what is the result to be? It is that two years from now, and further on, when these cattle in the ordinary way should come upon the market, when they should be grazing and fattening on Irish fields and in Irish stalls, there are to be no successors and our lands are to lie ungrazed and our tillage is to go down because there are not cattle to feed on the produce of our tillage. The Minister's idea of saneness and sanity is to have understocking of Irish land and, by letting grass go to waste and by leaving turnips uneaten, the farmers of this country are to grow rich.

I do not intend to detain the House any longer, but I do submit to this House that if a fair and a long view is taken by any Deputy he must see that the Minister is leading this country to destruction. He is leading this country to destruction because he is destroying the main industry of this country. We have had other persons before who have destroyed Irish trade and Irish industry. Men have denounced Lord Strafford again and again because he destroyed the woollen trade. The country rang, and rightly rang, with denunciations of the then English Government when it destroyed the beef trade of this country in the 18th century, but precisely the work which was done by Strafford and by the English statesmen who destroyed our beef trade in the 18th century is being done by the Minister for Agriculture now and I sincerely hope that this House will give him no help in so doing.

Comment on this

This is the most important Estimate that comes before this House, and the Minister has realised that by giving the House the opportunity of fully discussing it on a token Vote. If there is any proof needed that on agriculture the general prosperity of this country depends, whether in industry, commerce, or the amount of employment given, it is to be found in one particular way. If one puts to oneself the question which I have often put to constituents of my own: "What was in recent history the most prosperous era in this country?" the answer will immediately jump to one's mind that it was the period of the World War. Why were we particularly prosperous during the World War? Was it that any new industry sprang up; that we exported a tremendous amount of manufactured goods to various parts of the world which we did not hitherto export; or that in some other way we brought wealth into this country? No; it was because, for once, in a number of years, the farmer came into his own.

Comment on this

Because he got enough credit.

Comment on this

Because, just for once, the farmer exported his goods at a big profit, exported an increased quantity of goods at a profit, and because of the increased profits of the farmers every other section in the community prospered. The people in the villages, towns and cities prospered equally with the farmers. The retailers, the shopkeepers and the manufacturers prospered, and, above and beyond all, the labouring men prospered. There was work for every man who needed work at higher wages than were paid for years before or since, and all because there was prosperity in agriculture. We have fallen on leaner days, particularly within the last two or three years, because the policy of the Government in relation to agriculture appears to be unsuitable to this country.

In discussing the Government's policy in relation to agriculture, it will be necessary to discuss it from two aspects; first, their general policy in regard to agriculture with a view to the future, and, secondly, their policy in relation to the circumstances in which we have found ourselves owing to the economic war. Proceeding on the first line of their general policy, I would like to argue on the relative merits of the old policy adopted in regard to agriculture of leaving the farmer more or less free to produce those things that suited him best and for which we had an export market. If any encouragement was needed for the agricultural industry it should be given in a monetary way in respect of an item that was likely to prove profitable in succeeding years. The Ministry, apparently with a wild desire for self-sufficiency in this country, adopted cereals as against the existing policy of live stock and dairying. I am not suggesting the Ministry wilfully desired to extinguish the live stock and dairying industry, but even before the economic war started they did advocate an intensive policy of cereals in substitution for the type of live stock farming hitherto pursued.

I will deal with what appears to be the foremost item in the agricultural world which has taken the Minister's attention, and that is the growing of wheat. To be successful in the growing of wheat in this State there must be a continuous subsidy. As Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney pointed out, one can envisage no period in the future when wheat could be produced here without the aid of a subsidy. There will be no world market, indeed no export market, for wheat so far as one can look ahead. The Minister had a particular advantage during the last two or three years because they were notably favourable years for the growing of wheat. In the next 50 years we may not meet three such favourable years in succession again. The Minister was lucky in that particular way in extending the area of wheat-growing here. He was lucky also in that the economic war gave the grower of wheat an advantage that he would not have in normal circumstances, if an economic war was not on. Wheat, even with the subsidy, is not an economic product. Wheat at 23/6 a barrel, the price proposed under recent legislation, would not be a very economic proposition. The margin of profit would in deed be very small. The only reason the acreage under wheat has been extended in the last two or three years is because every other branch of the agricultural industry has been so reduced that it is impossible to make even the production price. For the last three years it was impossible to engage in any other form of agriculture without losing.

Wheat even with the subsidy is barely able to maintain itself. The farmer is just able to get the growing costs and possibly a little profit. To suggest that at 23/6 a barrel wheat could be produced successfully if other agricultural items were not interfered with, is not a reasonable thing. Supposing the Minister, with the aid of the subsidy, was able eventually to induce people to grow the number of acres of wheat necessary to feed our own people, what would be the position? It has been estimated that to meet the needs of our own people we would require the produce of 650,000 to 800,000 acres of wheat. If the subsidy is large enough the Minister will eventually get the farmers to grow that amount of wheat and to substitute wheat for some other item of agriculture in which heretofore they were engaged. But one has to look further than the present when one is beginning a new policy. I would like Deputies to cast their minds eight or ten years ahead when we have reached the Minister's ambition by growing 700,000 to 800,000 acres of wheat with a subsidy. What is going to happen? If wheat is going to be the prosperous crop that the Minister visualises, then when we are producing 600,000 to 800,000 acres of wheat the Government will have to step in and reduce the subsidy or use some other method to restrain people from growing extra wheat: otherwise you will have a surplus, and when you have a surplus, whether you have a subsidy or not, you will have falling prices.

It seems clear that wheat growing, if it is continued even with the aid of a subsidy, will be insecure from the farmers' point of view. If it is successfully grown we will rapidly approach the day when we will be self-sufficient and then there will be a decline. The Minister said that this year we will have 200,000 acres of wheat. That is an enormous advance. At the same rate of progress, in three years from now we will be producing over 600,000 acres of wheat, and if you can get the millers to use Irish wheat only—which, again, is problematical, and I make that statement advisedly—for the manufacture of flour, wheat prices are sure to drop back. If we reach the stage when all our bread will be manufactured from Irish wheat and if we continue the present rate of progress, everything else remaining as it is, we will reach the stage when we will have all our requirements in wheat and prices are sure to decline irrespective of what action the present Minister or any Minister may take.

The Minister, on another Bill in this House, propounded the doctrine that to regulate prices satisfactorily, to keep the prices up, it might be necessary at times to create an uneconomic price. That was debated in the House not many weeks ago. That certainly will happen in relation to the Minister's wheat crops not very many years ahead and it will be necessary for the Minister, temporarily at least, to create uneconomic prices in order to limit the amount of wheat grown. I hope Deputies will take a note of this particular argument in connection with wheat—that a subsidy will make anybody grow it if the subsidy is big enough. If other items of agriculture remain as they are, unprofitable, wheat will be grown to an extent it was never grown before and then we will arrive at a state when wheat will become an uneconomic crop.

Comment on this

That will happen any crop.

Comment on this

It will happen any crop except crops the surplus of which you can export. If you have a surplus of wheat here you cannot give it away. In relation to live stock, on the other hand, we have a market. Circumstances have limited the profit on that particular market. We had a market for all the live stock that we could produce for many, many years in this country. Prices fluctuated as they did and as they will in the future, but on the whole farmers had a profit and they were able to survive, while a good many of them were able to provide for their children through following a system of live stock and dairying with a little tillage. I am not advocating, and I hope I never will advocate, that we should have no tillage, but I am advocating the merits of live stock, dairying and tillage—as against tillage extensively. For live stock we have a certain market outside. We are more favourably situated in regard to that market than any other country and we are in a better position to take advantage of that market than any other country. Our transport costs are less, and if we make a favourable agreement with that country—as we did some months ago— we should be able not alone to maintain our present export to that market but to increase it.

In that regard, as a testimony to our live stock producing capacity, I would like to quote an extract from a paper that I do not often read. But a few days ago I was caught by a heading on that paper. The heading was in connection with the Premier of another State, who was predicting a bright future for this country. In that paper, which happens to be the Irish Press, where I expected to see the Government lauded for its cereal policy, its acreage of wheat and other things that were rapidly to advance the country to a state of prosperity, I read something quite different. When I commenced to read the paper I found that, first of all, this Premier of South Australia who visited the President, and who incidentally was greatly taken with the President, I am glad to say, then went on to give an interview to this particular paper. On being invited by the representative of the Irish Press to give his views, he said: “I was immensely struck by the sincerity of your President.” Giving his impressions of the country, he said: “From a stock-raising point of view Ireland was perhaps unrivalled by any country in the world, thanks to the fertility of its soil and its proximity to the world's markets. For that reason,” he proceeded, “there should be a bright future before the country; I am satisfied that Ireland's statesmen are able to solve the difficulties that face them.” His reason for predicting a bright future for the country was that we were the greatest stock raising country in the world, and that we are nearest to a particular market. It was for these reasons that that statesman predicted a bright future for this country. He did not predict a bright future because we were growing acres of wheat and had a great deal of tillage crops. It was not for that reason that he saw prosperity ahead. It was because here in Ireland with her fertile soil he saw a possibility of producing stock the like of which could not be produced in any other country in the world. It was for that reason that he saw that prosperity loomed ahead for us, if we only reached out our hands to grasp it.

The Minister, as I have said, was obsessed with the idea of cereals as against live stock. He was also obsessed with the idea that the British market for our live stock had declined and could not be renewed. He was so sure of that that he embarked on a policy of deliberately restricting our output of live stock. We had in the last two years a policy of the destruction of our young animals—our calves. When the Minister embarked upon that policy some of us warned him of the possible consequences of his action. When discussing the coal-cattle pact some months ago, I pointed out to the Minister that there was the possibility that we, on our side, would not be able to keep our end of the bargain, and export the number of cattle to which we are entitled under that agreement. It now seems that I was right, and that the members of this Party who then warned the Government were giving them good advice. If my information is correct, we are at the present moment unable to ship all the stores we are entitled to ship. The evidence of that is borne out by the withdrawal of the quota on store cattle and the withdrawal of the Orders that made it necessary to issue licences for the shipment of these particular store cattle.

We are now at a stage when we can export all the store cattle we have. But the Minister has this year slaughtered 200,000 calves; last year he did not slaughter quite so many. As a result of the slaughter in the two years, we are going to have a shortage of store cattle this year. Certainly that shortage will be felt more next year and the year after than now, because the 200,000 calves that are slaughtered this year would not be exported next year, but in two or three years from now. Consequently, there will be a shortage of stores in the years to come. The Minister for Agriculture was undoubtedly obsessed with the idea that the British market was gone, and with that idea in his head he set himself out to reduce the number of young cattle in the country. I may tell the Minister that in the next three or four years the farmers of this country will have painful experiences of his slaughter policy.

The Minister, to-day, when opening the debate, gave us some headlines on which to conduct this debate. He himself divided the headlines as between cattle and cereals, I would say, very fairly. The figures will be helpful to Deputies generally when discussing this particular Vote. The Minister said that we exported £13,000,000 worth of cattle in 1926. He said that to-day we were exporting much the same number of cattle at a lesser price. He said the price was not due to the economic war, but to other causes. In our view the price certainly is mainly due to the economic war. The Minister spoke of a tariff of £6, £4 10s. and £2 10s. These figures will perhaps help to clear up matters more than anything else, particularly the statistical figures he gave. I have here the latest statistical returns from 1927 to 1933. Perhaps if I had later returns they would emphasise my arguments more strongly.

I find that the value of our cattle, in 1933, as compared with 1931, had depreciated by something like £18,000,000, and I am taking those figures from the statistical records furnished to Deputies in this House. I have computed the losses as well as I could from the figures given in the book itself and in the appendix thereto. In 1931 we had 4,029,000— cattle, and in 1933 we had 4,136,000— about 100,000 more. Taking the values as well as I could, and segregating the cattle as between young and old, I found that 3,000,000 of the ages mentioned would have lost an average of £5 8s. 0d. per head; 3,000,000 cattle would have dropped £16,000,000, and the other 1,000,000 would have dropped to the extent of £2,000,000. Between 1931 and 1933 the value of cattle alone would have dropped to the extent of £18,000,000.

There were 3,500,000 sheep in 1931, and the number dropped to 100,000 less in 1933. The average loss on all sheep was somewhere about 14/- a head. To make the calculation easier I put it at 13/4. The loss on the number of sheep at that rate is £2,250,000. Those two items are taken from the statistical record. In regard to horses and ponies I was in a difficulty. I found that in 1931 there were somewhere less than 500,000 horses and ponies in the State, and in 1933 the figure was something about the same. To estimate the loss on those would have been difficult, because this particular book did not give figures of prices for the different classes of horses, but as one who is fairly intimate with the horse-breeding trade from ponies to thoroughbreds, I do not think that anybody will contradict me if I put the loss so low as £5 per head. Mind you, that would not be sufficient, taking all classes from the pony to the thoroughbred. Putting it at the low figure of £5 per head, the loss would be £2,500,000 odd on our horses and ponies. The sum total of the loss on live stock reaches the colossal figure of £23,000,000 in the farmers' stock-in-trade in two years, and the value has probably been reduced much more since 1933. That, in itself, is an indication of the pass to which agriculture has been brought owing to the policy of the Ministry, and, to a small extent, owing to the world fall in the prices of the different classes of stock. In the main, the loss is brought about by the circumstances of the economic war, for which the Ministry opposite are responsible.

If the farmers' stock-in-trade has, in a few years, been reduced by £23,000,000, and if his property has been reduced by a number of million pounds which I dare not estimate, and which any other Deputy in this House would not dare to estimate, then the condition of the farmer is beyond words. I do not think any Deputy could paint in words the real position of the farmers in this country. Their stock-in-trade has, as I said, been reduced by £23,000,000, and the loss in their property is incalculable. The 15,000,000 acres of land in this country must certainly have been reduced in value, and the figure I suggested in this House, and at which some of the Deputies opposite shook their heads and raised their eyes in horror, was the colossal sum of £100,000,000. That represents an average fall of £6 per acre in the price of land in a few years, and taking the hills and valleys, the mountain and fertile lands, I do not think there is any Deputy who will not agree with me that land has fallen in value by at least £6 per acre all over this State. The fact that there is £100,000,000 of an estimated capital loss, and £23,000,000 of a stock-in-trade loss, taken from the Minister's own figures, shows the pass to which agriculture has been reduced by a few years of Fianna Fáil policy.

I referred a minute ago to the relative merits of wheat and cattle as a paying proposition for the farmers, but at the moment I forgot to point out what the merits of either were in their relation to the employment of labour. Again, I am indebted to the statistical volume which the Minister produced for aiding me in this particular matter. I find that instead of advancing the employment of labour, an intensive tillage policy—as a substitute for the policy of dairying and live stock generally, which some of us have pursued—would have a very damaging effect on the amount of labour employed. I went to some pains to take figures from the statistical volume as between the largest tillage counties in this country and the ones that had least tillage. I took two different counties, represented appropriately enough by the Minister and myself. The Minister represents one of the most intensive tillage counties in this State, and I, fortunately or unfortunately, represent one of the counties in which I think there is the least amount of tillage. In Limerick, a slightly larger area than Wexford, we have some 36,000 acres under tillage, and in Wexford they have 171,000 acres, or, so that the figures will be more readily understood, I may put it that in Limerick we have 5.45 per cent. of our land tilled, and in Wexford they have very nearly 30 per cent. of their land tilled. Yet I find that in Limerick we employ more labour than they do in Wexford, whatever way you compute it. Whether in numbers generally, or in numbers in relation to a certain acreage, or in numbers in regard to the population, we employ more labour than in Wexford. I find that there is one man employed for every 27 acres in Limerick, and one for every 28 acres in Wexford, notwithstanding the fact that we have very little tillage in Limerick and there is such a tremendous lot in Wexford.

I also found a curious thing in the course of my incursions into this volume of statistics; one would have thought that, if all that the Ministry had been telling us during the last three or four years is true, everything disastrous will fall on a county like Limerick where there was a large proportion of grass land and very little tillage. One would have thought that all the dire consequences that could have fallen on any county would have fallen on Limerick, but yet we find that the population of Limerick is proportionately greater than it is in Wexford, and above all we find that the wages paid to labourers in Limerick greatly exceed the wages paid in Wexford. If anybody wants an argument as to why tillage should certainly not be advanced as an agricultural policy in lieu of a dairying and live stock policy generally, I would recommend him to take up the volume of statistics which the Minister has issued, and study it carefully, particularly in relation to the counties that are intensive tillage counties and the counties that are largely engaged in the grass policy of live stock and live stock products, and horse rearing, if you like. Having said so much on the policy of cereals as against live stock, I hope I have proved to the House in some way that there are no particular merits in the policy of cereals in lieu of live stock. If we pursue the policy of subsidising wheat as we are subsidising it, when we reach the stage of 600,000 acres, the price will drop, no matter what the Minister does.

Comment on this

How would Limerick fare if butter was not subsidised?

Comment on this

I am coming to butter. Sufficient for the day is the evil thereof.

Comment on this

And you are getting it now.

Comment on this

I am not getting it at all. I am coming to it, and perhaps you will get it when I come to it. I am speaking of the relative merits of wheat-growing and live stock and I want to have that once and for all threshed out here so as to see the possibilities of them. One thing is clear, that if a subsidy is big enough we are going to get all the wheat we want. When we have got all we want, whatever the Minister does there will be a collapse and a drop in prices. That is the one thing that is facing every wheat grower. On the other hand, we have the live-stock trade on which the people existed. The people were even able to put by and save money on it. It is still there, despite the action the Ministry took to destroy it.

I might as well get straight ahead to the bone of contention, the danying industry. The Minister to-day gave us some figures in regard to dairying. He said that dairying was a very important branch of agriculture and that the industry in 1926 was valued at £13,000,000, and that in 1934, when the output was higher prices were lower, and the value of it was £8,000,000. The consolation no doubt was not that it was worth £8,000,000 instead of £13,000,000, but that the output was increased owing to the Minister's activities. Then he went on to point the moral about butter prices —that the price of butter was higher than it was in 1933, I think he said. At any rate, that was the general line of argument. Anyhow, if he did not say that to-day, he said it 100 times, that the price of butter would be much less now than in 1931 only for the Minister's attitude. That is the one thing I am going to admit.

Comment on this

And agree to.

Comment on this

And agree to: that if no action was taken the price of butter would have been something less now than in 1931.

Comment on this

Subsidise creamery land but do not subsidise wheat land.

Comment on this

I am admitting that the price of butter would be something less in 1934 or 1935 than it was in 1931 if no action were taken. Then there is the other end of the dairying industry. Remember that butter is not all that we produce. I have noticed that the Minister kept as far away from that to-day as he could. Whenever he engages in a discussion on the dairying industry he keeps just as far away as possible from the fact that butter is not the only thing we produce, and that possibly, almost certainly, the most profitable end of the dairying industry was the production and rearing of calves. That was the farmers' main source of profit in the dairying industry and the Minister destroyed it. If he has kept up the other end by a little fraction, it is a small recompense for the loss to the farmers in the most profitable end of the industry, the rearing of calves.

Even on the question of the increase in butter prices, nobody in this House has suggested yet that, with the world fall in butter prices if there had been any other Government there instead of the Fianna Fáil Government, they would not have done something of their own accord or been compelled to do something by the farmers to keep butter prices up. It is inevitable that they would.

At the general election in 1931, when one would have thought that one would have kept as far away from dairying as was possible, particularly in County Limerick, I referred to the matter in my election speeches, which are there in the Limerick papers for anyone to read. What I said then I have said many times since and I will say again now, that the price of milk was then just on the verge of fourpence and there was a prospect of its falling much lower than fourpence. The then Minister for Agriculture had the courage to come down to Limerick and tell the farmers, not that there were visions of prosperity in three or four months' time, but that most certainly the price of milk was going to fall. He had the courage to tell the people the truth as given to him by his advisers. I followed that and told the people of Limerick, which is the chief dairying county, that nobody could envisage the price of milk going below fourpence per gallon, and that if it went below fourpence, I did not care whether we were re-elected or not, whether a Fianna Fáil Government came in or whether the Cumann na nGaedheal Government came in again, that either of them would be compelled by the force of public opinion to maintain the price of milk at least at fourpence per gallon. I want to give Fianna Fáil the credit for it, just as I would give Cumann na nGaedheal credit for it if they were there, but no Government would have allowed the price of milk to fall below fourpence per gallon. The dairying industry would have collapsed if any Government permitted the price of milk to fall below fourpence per gallon.

Comment on this

Of course it would collapse.

Comment on this

They did the right thing in the wrong way.

Comment on this

Then there would be no employment in Limerick.

Comment on this

I say that a subsidy or financial aid of some kind was necessary to tide the butter end of the dairying industry over a temporary drop in prices. Speaking of subsidies generally, I would never agree to the use of subsidies which were going to be continuous. Where, as far as you can look ahead, it seems that you will have to continue subsidies indefinitely, then I say subsidies should be carefully considered before they are given. But to tide any item of the agricultural industry, or any industry, over a temporary disadvantage, the use of subsidies is advisable, and the use of a subsidy in the case of butter was certainly advisable and would have been taken by any Government, whether Fianna Fáil or not.

Comment on this

Up Limerick.

Comment on this

But the advantages that the Minister claims for his particular policy of dairying are not real. The Minister and many Deputies behind him claim that if it was not for their policy milk would be selling at 2d. per gallon. That is not true, and every Deputy on the opposite benches knows it is not true. At the present moment, if there were no subsidy or other arrangement to bolster up the price of dairying produce, and, incidentally, increase the cost to the consumer, the price of milk would be somewhere about 3d. per gallon.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The price of butter is 20/- higher than this time last year.

Comment on this

The price of milk would be 3d. per gallon last year.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

2d. per gallon last year. The price of butter was 60/-.

Comment on this

60/- for a very short period. The Minister himself in one speech here said that the average price would be about 80/-. It was as low as 60/-.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The average was about 70/- last year.

Comment on this

The price of milk would be somewhere about 3d. per gallon without any subsidy or any assistance, and it would be something more now.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

The Deputy knows that that is wrong.

Comment on this

If there was no interference, if we had no economic war, or none of the other rows we have kicked up unnecessarily, the price of milk could have been maintained easily by any Government at 4d. by an average temporary subsidy of 20/- or 21/- per cwt. of butter. That would have kept the price of milk at 4d. per gallon and that is what the Minister set out to do, and what all of us would have set out to do. Contrast that with what it has cost the present Government and the difference is a huge one. The Minister paid a subsidy on some occasions of very nearly 40/- and certainly on the average of 31/- or 32/- and the average price of butter to the consumer has increased by from 4d. to 6d. per lb. I maintain that a price of 100/- per cwt. for butter is the equivalent of 4d. per gallon for milk. Suppose a Government came into power and said they would not give a penny to the dairying industry. Even if we had a Government vile enough to deny temporary help to the dairying industry, dairying would be better off than it is now; even with that Government which we cannot envisage, because if the price of milk dropped a penny or so owing to world conditions, the higher price which the farmer would get for his calves, as compared to what he is getting now, would have doubly compensated him for his loss on the milk end and the farmer would be much better off without any Governmental interference than he is at the moment notwithstanding all the subsidies and bounties.

I have been challenged with voting to help the dairying industry, but I make no excuse for that whatever. I shall vote in the same way again. It is the principal item in the agricultural industry in this State, an item upon which every other agricultural activity, even to the extent of tillage, depends. If the dairying industry collapsed in this country, not alone would the butter industry collapse but the live stock industry would collapse, too, with all the consequences which that would entail. No Government could sit here and see that happen. I do not care whether you are a Government of fully fledged tillage cultivators or what else you are, nobody amongst you would dare say that you should altogether wipe out the cattle industry, and if the dairying industry had been allowed to get into a condition in which it would be perpetually insolvent, that is what would have happened. Luckily it is not going to be perpetually insolvent. Prices have fluctuated before for butter and they will fluctuate again. They will probably reach a stage when the farmer will be assured of something approaching the cost of production.

If the farmer gets the cost of production he asks nothing more, except that he should be allowed a free market for the other end of the industry, namely, the live stock end. He will then be fairly well satisfied. But he does not want to live either in the dairying industry, or in any other part of the agricultural industry, on perpetual charity. That is what is being forced upon us by the Government, perpetual subsidies and perpetual bounties, so that we are being driven always to live on the charity of the rest of the community. As I have said, I personally am not tremendously in favour of artificial aid for the agricultural industry or any other industry, but if there is an item in the agricultural industry which in a time of deep depression needs relief and if there is a prospect that, with some temporary financial aid, that particular item will be kept in production until it can eventually bring a profit and stand on its own legs, then by all means subsidise it, and keep it going during the period of depression until a time of prosperity comes. That, however, is not the policy that the Government is pursuing. They want to give subsidies and bounties to articles which cannot stand on their own legs; in other words, perpetual subsidies. That is a policy which I could not support in this House or outside of it.

I should like to say something in relation to the price of pigs. I think the Minister himself admitted that he has been favoured by the rise in pigs in the last couple of years. The pig market has not been too bad, on the whole, but, like everything else, it has got its turn and now there has been a collapse in the price of pigs as well as everything else. The Minister made the remarkable admission here to-day which he refused to make when we were discussing the Pigs and Bacon Bill, that the curers are going to be too strong for us.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I did not.

Comment on this

I apologise to the Minister. He did not use these words exactly, but he substantiated the claim we made on the Pigs and Bacon Bill, that the curers would become too strong for us.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I did not. I said that we could not deal with the matter now, but that when the Bill would be operative we could deal with it.

Comment on this

The Minister did admit that they were now more highly organised than ever.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Yes.

Comment on this

That is what I am coming at. He made the admission that the curers are more highly organised than ever they were before. Why are they? Because we passed that Bill.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Because we passed the Bill?

Comment on this

The curers have organised themselves more closely and more highly than ever they have been organised before. They are prepared for the fight with the producers, and I venture to say, before the fight comes to a conclusion, I would nearly put my money on the curers.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

You would be delighted to see them beaten.

Comment on this

To see the curers beaten.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I do not believe you would.

Comment on this

The Minister is imputing motives to me that I would not impute to him. We are both interested in the success of agriculture. To suggest that anybody who has an interest in agriculture would like to see the farmers beaten in that fight is to suggest something that is viler than anything I would like to have to reply to. I should not like to cast an aspersion on any Deputy on the Fianna Fáil Benches in that way, or to suggest that he would like to see the farmers whom he represents beaten in this fight. At any rate, the price of pigs has fallen within the last few weeks. Might I suggest to the Minister that the 10/- levy has something to do with this? I understand that there has been a levy of 10/- collected off the pigs, that the farmer has been more or less mulcted to the extent of 10/- a cwt. That has been a financial asset to the Minister. The farmers generally do not see why they should have to suffer by this levy of 10/-, and they think that there should be some means of relief afforded to them. I hope the Minister will put his new Bill into operation as soon as possible. I hope that it will not be deferred for many months, because if pig prices collapse and the collapse continues for many weeks the Bill will not be able to set them on their feet very rapidly.

I have, I think, fairly well covered the main items of the agricultural programme. If we never had an economic war, as I have said previously, I think the policy which the Government has pursued would be harmful to the agricultural industry generally, that is, the policy of artificially stimulating the production of cereals as against the policy hitherto pursued by the farmers, thus upsetting the whole economy of the country. That policy would have been sufficiently injurious if it had not been aggravated by the losses which farmers have suffered owing to the economic war and the manner in which the Government has handled the economic war. As I say, the butter question could have been handled in a better manner than it was. I think portion of the subsidies might have been more advantageously expended in maintaining the profitable end of the dairy industry, namely the calf, than in spending it in other directions where it is not likely to have the same beneficial effect. We had proof that the market for store cattle is not exhausted, that it can be extended, and the policy of the Minister should be to extend it so as to develop that end of the industry for which we are certain to have an export market that is profitable, to carry out for the State during the temporary process of the economic war which we all hope some day will be ended. We all hope that, if not before this Government goes out, then, very soon after the next comes in, that war will be ended. We should concentrate in my opinion on a policy for the future which can be successfully carried out. It seems to me that the only branch of our agricultural industry for which we have a fair prospect of success is live stock, and any monetary aid we are able to advance to agriculture should be in that direction.

There is no outlook for the export of cereals from this country and there is no hope they would ever be able to stand upon their own legs. In God's name, let us give up visionary policies and have the sense to concentrate upon the British market for our live stock. We should be able to get it. It is a market the world is facing. Let us produce the goods. The British market wants our live stock. If there is financial aid necessary the House will not grudge it. This is a suggestion which I make to the Minister. Let us concentrate on the development of live stock instead of the slaughtering of calves. Hundreds of thousands of calves have been slaughtered. Let us instead of pursuing that policy induce the farmers to raise them and produce honest to God stores. We have a market for them and will continue to have a market for them. In the course of a few years the British market which is ready to take them all now will be crying out for more. We are the country that ought to be able to supply them, and we should be in a position to do so as we always were.

Comment on this

I listened with a good deal of attention to the last two speeches which have been delivered. I expected to hear something new, or at least some indication as to what the future policy of the Opposition would be as far as our agriculture is concerned. But I think I am not wrong in coming to the conclusion that so far as they are concerned there is to be no change whatsoever, and that the policy they pursued during the late Government time is to be their policy for the future. Deputy Bennett disagreed almost entirely with subsidies of any description. The only subsidy he would agree to, and that only to a small extent, I understood, was a subsidy for butter and dairying. He emphasised the great importance of dairying, which emphasis to a large extent perhaps was superfluous. At the same time he led us to believe that if we only gave a subsidy to butter and dairying, the policy that his Party had hitherto adopted, all would be well.

I think such a day as this ought to be welcomed by everybody. We have the whole day long to discuss in a friendly atmosphere this important industry of agriculture. I think the Opposition will agree with me that the conditions which obtain in agriculture at the moment — world agriculture and international agriculture — are by no means normal. Things have gradually developed to such a point that world conditions in agriculture are quite abnormal. This state of things has been brought about by various causes. That being the case, I think it would be well, at this moment, if we did not try to show that it was the economic war that destroyed agriculture not only in this country, but all over the world. We are supposed to believe that the economic war with the Twenty-Six Counties, upset the conditions prevailing in Canada. We are to believe that in the Argentine the meat industry has gone all wrong because the President of the Executive Council in this country interfered in some way or another; and we are asked to believe that this country never did anything else but to produce cattle and that at the moment it went off producing cattle for something else, a terrible catastrophe took place.

It was not until 1850 that cattle were really of any value at all. It was only after the Crimean War that cattle went up to about £5 a head. After that they increased in value. At the same time the United States of America and Canada were going definitely into wheat production. They believed that wheat production suited them. Machines were invented to help industry, and in the United States of America new districts and provinces were conquered, brought under the plough and put into wheat production. Huge quantities of flour began to reach the English market. It was peculiarly white. White flour was unknown up to that time. Not only did that flour get into the British market but it got into this market as well. We heard of a practical monopoly of the British market. Up to a certain period the Argentine and Canada had not entered into competition, and the moment this country came into competition with them we hear the first sign of difficulty. Inmediately after that the wheat production in the United States of America got into difficulties and they turned to cattle, and the result was that up to 10 or 15 years ago owing to the low price for wheat all these countries went into cattle. As a consequence there is a surplus of cattle, and so long as the surplus is there, subsidies will have to be brought into action to assist the producer.

The question is, will the subsidies go to the producer? It is questionable whether in some cases subsidies should be employed at all. It may be another menace, in this line of production which may not be possible to revive or keep going. The next change may be to the production of other classes of meat and not the production of beef at all. It may even happen that the 5/- per cwt. subsidy which the English are giving, may not be able to keep up the price of beef in the British market. I do not think that anybody will argue that these two or three latter years have been the most prosperous for British farmers engaged in beef production. If they continue to give a subsidy to the production of beef we would get an advantage in the sale of our store cattle. There is hardly a question about that and I am prepared to admit it. The idea at present is that we are short of store cattle. I hope we have not too many, but the next fortnight or three weeks we will find out how that matter stands. It is quite possible, if we had too many cattle here, that the free export of cattle will do us an injury again and still further reduce the price. We have no definite knowledge of that. There are, I suppose, statistics in the Department of Agriculture. They may be properly collected or they may not, but it is the opinion of many that we have a lot more cattle in this country than is generally known, and movements I have noticed in the last week or so indicate quite clearly that there will be a slump in store cattle in this coming week. There will be too many cattle there and prices will fall. If prices fall, it is not at all likely that the Englishman will allow them up again.

Other things have happened to agriculture besides this. There has been a great change in agriculture in England since the advent of free trade there. As everybody knows, once free trade was introduced and these factories set up all over England, the people fled from the land. They were herded into these rotten towns and villages and jammed into all classes of rooms and they lived and worked in those sweated industries even up to the present day. Since the war, some little effort has been made to relieve them, but, up to the period of the war, they were herded in Manchester, Liverpool and almost all the big manufacturing cities. They lived their whole day opposite a machine, pushing one button in and pulling out another, uneducated, and they became complete slaves of the niggers and foreigners for whom they made these things. The owner of the land, the baron and the duke, fled with their capital from the land and put their money into these industries, and the result is that, up to a few years ago, there was no respect whatever for land in Great Britain. All they wanted they imported and imported far more cheaply than they could produce in England. There is not a single item we need here but we could import it far more cheaply than we could produce it. We can import the very best of beef and the very best of lamb at half what it costs us.

Comment on this

It would be a bit tough, I think.

Comment on this

It may be, but it is eaten, and largely eaten, and it is quite good stuff. Butter is the same, and eggs the same. There is nothing we could dream of producing here but could be produced more cheaply abroad. For instance, in regard to vegetables alone, before our advent to power, at least two ship-loads of vegetables reached the port of Dublin every day and you had far cheaper vegetables than you have to-day. Whether they were better or not is another question. They were certainly clean and well packed. Each evening, the different vegetable stores in Dublin telephoned their orders to Covent Garden and they were landed next morning by the boat. We then became the villains of the piece. We changed all that and said we would start industries. The late Government said the same thing, but they took every possible step to ensure that they would not do it, or, at least, that no result would be forthcoming.

We started them because we believed it was the right thing to do, and one of our main considerations in starting them was that we found that we were dealing with human beings here. We found that, while the port was open, boats were carrying 30,000 of our young people away. "Let them make mischief in other countries," it was said; "let them work for other countries and let them get their living from other countries"— and what was worse: "Let them keep the annuities and rates paid here by sending home their earnings." For good or ill, that was stopped. What were we faced with here? We were faced with lands in many counties wilder than the plains of South America or Australia, without people and with no indications whatever of civilisation. We were faced with those young people helpless here and we had to find employment for them. It was essential. We found hundreds here who had not a house to live in. There were no houses built here for years; there was not a single labourer's cottage built for years. The City of Dublin was rotten with slums. What did we find the position of the farmer in those glorious years of prosperity, the result of what Deputy Bennett calls the great war period — the acme of success? We found that practically 80 per cent. of the farmers were bankrupt; that for the three years before the late Government left office the rates were paid out of overdrafts; and that, in few cases, were farmers solvent. Do you think that was a system which we were going to continue? Not at all. We decided: Cost what it may, we will put the country right. That is the position, and we did succeed in putting the country right and the country knew it well. We were elected in 1932, and in 1933 we went back again to see if there was any doubt about it, and there was not the slightest doubt about it.

Comment on this

Try it again and see if the third time will be lucky.

Comment on this

There is no necessity to go every year. We were there only last year.

Comment on this

You were not.

Comment on this

We had a local election, and the worst of the local election was that it was only the sober people, the aged people, who had a vote.

Comment on this

They were gone soft.

Comment on this

The Party opposite very definitely opposed, not alone here but in the Seanad, giving a vote to the youth. What did they say? They told us it was a good job that the youth had not a vote or we would be thrown out; that the life of the old people was short and they did not care a jot. Ask any person who comes into this country to-day what is the position so far as agriculture is concerned. What do foreigners see when they come in here? They see a marked change; they see the effort of the country to become normal; and they see a country in which the people are living on the land and making every effort to produce something to eat.

Comment on this

And they see the people's cattle being seized.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

And bought back again.

Comment on this

That is not a new phase. That had been happening before you came in.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

Oh, yes. It happened in Westmeath and Meath at least. I remember in the year 1927, coming on to Christmas and shortly after we entered the Dáil, Deputy Kennedy had a motion down requesting the then Parliamentary Secretary to have mercy on the tenant farmers during the following Christmas.

Comment on this

Would he put it down again?

Comment on this

The Deputy can put it down if he likes.

Comment on this

No necessity.

Comment on this

There is no use asking for mercy now.

Comment on this

There is no necessity for mercy. Any person who showed that there was necessity was treated properly. Can you give me any case where that did not happen? So far as Meath is concerned, there is no case in which consideration was not extended where a worthy case was presented. I am quite sure that in Westmeath the same applies. In 1927 that went on and I supported the motion. I definitely stated that at that Christmas period there were 4,000 writs in the hands of the sheriff in Country Meath.

Comment on this

That was the year you got out of your farm.

Comment on this

No. I have as much of it yet, and perhaps twice as much as you have.

Comment on this

You ran away from it at the right time.

Comment on this

No. I have it yet, and I intend to stick to it; there is nothing wrong with it at all.

Comment on this

You were never a farmer; you were a rancher.

Comment on this

It is satisfactory that you got that off your mind. The statements made here since this debate opened were definitely intended to mislead. Apart from the economic war, there was a necessity for changing the policy. If the economic war never took place, I believe that the agricultural policy of this country would have to be changed. Long before the economic war arose we indicated quite clearly as a Party that such a change was definitely intended. It is not because the economic war took place that we introduced wheat-growing or cereal-growing. We introduced it because it was our policy, and it is the policy that has been preached in this country for generations. We advocated it because we saw the day would come when we could no longer send our young people abroad, when they would have to get employment here. Everything that could be done to give them employment is being done. Now that subsidies are being used to do it, some people say it is a misfortune, but what remedy are you going to adopt if you do not select bounties and other things? What would the Opposition do with the thousands of young people growing up here?

Comment on this

What are you doing with them?

Comment on this

The whole question resolves itself into this: what methods are we going to adopt in order to see, first of all, that people get employment both on the land and in industry? The late Government tried to develop industry here by putting on a very mild tariff on foreign goods. The result was that the tariff was merely a medium of collecting taxes and no industries were established. The very industries that might help agriculture, the milling industries, were rapidly disappearing. We had to take very determined steps here, by means of tariffs and subsidies, to see that not alone was the agricultural industry made more suitable for the people, but that other industries were established with the object of employing as many people as we could possibly employ. The economic war intervened. That was to a large extent only a side issue. It had nothing to do with our policy; it did not change it one iota. Tariffs were imposed on our cattle to recover moneys that were supposed to be due and that were in dispute. Those tariffs were paid by being collected at the port of landing in Great Britain. A little later there was a quota put on our cattle, and perhaps the quota was the most difficult part of the whole fight. I suppose it created the greatest amount of hardship and dislocation.

People for years were accustomed to sell all the cattle they had, every class of cattle, at any price, but there was hardly a doubt about it that prices were falling rapidly, whether they were falling because there was no organised method of selling or because there were too many cattle all over the world, is immaterial. The real reason, to my mind, was because there were too many cattle produced all over the world. The indications of the collapse in that trade were intercepted by the opening of the economic war. The butter trade showed signs of distress and then the co-operative system was introduced. What was the cause of the co-operative system being introduced in the creameries? Was it not definitely introduced to increase prices? Huge sums of money were spent to do that, and that did not do it because world conditions had so changed and world production was at such a low rate that no matter what was done it was not possible to compete against it. The only method of competing against foreign butter production was by total exclusion. No other system would have done any good. Every country in the world is satisfied that there is extreme difficulty in marketing produce, whether industrial or agricultural. There is nobody on the opposite benches going to deny that cattle and beef producing countries have a great difficulty in marketing their produce, that they are subject to tariffs and quotas and other restrictions. They are, and that is the case all over the world. I would like to have from the Opposition some policy that will indicate that the people who are left here, who cannot get out of the country, who must find employment here will get that employment, that we can continue on a free trade basis and export our cattle to England as we like, and not put tariffs on British goods coming here. If they can tell us how that difficulty could be got over the day would be well spent here. As I see it, looking at it apart from the question of the economic war, the moment we impose those tariffs on British goods to establish industries here the British Government is entitled to impose a tariff on our agricultural products. That really happened and that was partly the cause of the imposition of tariffs. The other reason they imposed tariffs was because they thought this country would collapse the moment they put a tariff on our cattle. They got a little surprise there. That did not happen and there is no indication that this country will collapse. Bank dividends are as good as when the late Government were in power, or even better. The price of land is going up, definitely going up.

Comment on this

Will the Land Commission pay more?

Comment on this

They are giving more. The price of meadows in Country Meath went as much as £4 10s. an acre.

Comment on this

The ranchers are doing well down there. They are buying the land from the poor people for practically nothing.

Comment on this

I do not know what the wail is about. On every side there are indications of the difficulties being surmounted. The sales of insurance stamps and other things indicate that we are making headway. On the Opposition Benches they really try to make the people believe that if by to-morrow morning we did something, such as to hand in our guns, to collapse, go on our knees and say we have sinned — the usual thing — that there would be a paradise here.

I want anybody on the other side to prove here to-day that there was a paradise in this country, as far as agriculture was concerned, while they were in office, and that the agricultural community had no difficulties. As long as I remember — and I remember as long as anybody in this House — there were difficulties in agriculture and those difficulties were growing year by year. These difficulties are not going to become easier in the near future; world conditions do not indicate that it is going to be easier. What would make the position easier in a country like this, in which there is so much to be done, would be more co-operation from Deputies on the opposite benches.

Comment on this

I am sorry I cannot congratulate the Minister on his agricultural policy or on his judgment on agricultural matters, though I must say that there never has been a Minister who worked harder or who spent more money on agriculture. The Vote is increased by 100 per cent.; expenditure has been doubled and the profits have been wiped out. The value of our exports has been reduced by 50 per cent. since 1931. The principal part of our exports are agricultural products, and as no other industry has been as much affected in its exports I would venture to say that the value of our agricultural exports has been reduced by more than half in the three years. Looking over this Estimate I see that there is a very large increase in the direction where less might be expected, having regard to the promises of the Government before they were elected, that their policy was to cut down expenditure, to reduce the number of officials and all that sort of thing. Salaries, wages and allowances have been increased by £23,000 even since last year; travelling expenses of £12,700 for last year have been increased by £600, and there has been an increase in telegrams and telephones of £550 and increases under other heads.

It would be interesting to know why we have these increases in travelling expenses; if we are moving towards self-sufficiency there should be less travelling, seeing that we are living on ourselves. I wonder has this travelling expenditure been caused in the search for the alternative markets? I would say that the officials of the Department are an excellent body of men and if the policy of the Government were right they would be worth their money. As a matter of fact, I myself have a motion down to give them a chance. I need not go into that now; I hope we will get a day for it soon, but if the officials did get a chance of running some farms on their own either of two results would follow: either they would teach the farmer how to make farming a success — how to make a profit out of his land — or otherwise they would teach the Minister or somebody else what the position on the farm is. I would be satisfied if the officials could show the farmer at the present time how to make his land pay. Even if they failed in doing that they would show the Minister the error of his ways. In any case this would be a good move, but the Minister does not want to learn or he does not want the farmer to learn. That is why he will not act on my suggestion.

I see that there is an increase also in the sub-head for the improvement of live stock. Why should live stock be improved? What is the improvement for, seeing that when the calves are dropped what is done with them is to hand away 10/- with their skin. Is it not absurd to be spending money improving live stock when that is the use that is made of the calves. I remember once standing for a while looking at a man selling watches in the street, wrapping up 2/- with the watch and handing it over for 6d. When I saw that I never thought I would see a Minister for Agriculture taking a calf skin, wrapping up 10/- with it, and then giving it away for 1/-. Unless the Minister changes his policy I think it is ridiculous for him to aim at improving our live stock. The Minister's policy should be directed towards improving the markets so as to enable the people of this State to make something of their live stock. The Minister is spending a great deal of money on bounties and subsidies.

There is a difference of opinion between the members of this House as to what particular commodity should be subsidised. I am not opposed to subsidies. I was one of the first to advocate the payment of bounties and subsidies on agricultural exports. I believe if these bounties and subsidies were used properly they would serve a very useful purpose. Apart from the economic war altogether, my view about bounties and subsidies is that the money that is raised by protective tariffs to protect home manufactures should go towards subsidising the export of our agricultural produce. That would merely compensate the agricultural community for the increased price which they pay for the manufactured article. The Minister would there have a remedy against the tariffs that are now imposed by Great Britain because of the dispute between the two countries. It is ridiculous and quite absurd to say that the bounties and subsidies now paid compensate the farmer for the tariffs he has to pay on his exports to Great Britain. It is simply the same as if the Minister had a mill worked by water and if somebody turned off half the stream that fed the mill-dam. If he continued to keep the mill grinding, the water in the mill-dam would become too low. Would it not be very absurd if the Minister were to employ men to pump the water from the side back into the mill-dam? If somebody were to call attention to the water escaping here and there in the mill-dam and he were then to say: "Get a man here to pump up that water," would it not be regarded as absurd? Half the national income of the State is being cut off and it is impossible to make up the loss by bounties and subsidies. It is just as absurd as if one were to try to make up the loss of the water turned off from the mill-dam by pumping water from one part of the dam to the other.

I am afraid the Minister has been in the wrong school. He has been listening to Senator Connolly speaking about self-sufficiency, and he has gone out of his way in that direction, but I am afraid he is not reaching his goal. He reminds me of the medical man who believed that he had discovered the panacea for all ills of the human flesh. He believed that he had found the preventive of all disease. He was convinced that all disease was due to the consumption of food, and that in reality food was not necessary. He believed that the stomach was merely an unnecessary appendage, and all the difficulty he had was to get somebody to submit to his treatment, so that he could prove his theory to the world. He did get one woman foolish enough to submit herself for the experiment. She was captivated by the promise he held out. She was thinking of the fine time she would have, the fine dresses she could wear, and the holidays she could afford, if she could save what was being spent on food, so she put herself under the treatment of this doctor. He put her on half rations for the first week. She felt better, and he was delighted. The next week he cut the rations down to a quarter, and she began to complain that she was a little bit weary. "Well," he said, "I told you so. You must understand that you do not achieve a great object without making some sacrifice. You are in a transition stage, but you are on the road to self-sufficiency anyhow." In the third week he put her off all food, and she complained of a lot of troubles. She had a pain in her head, and her arms were getting feeble. He said he had a plan. He told her: "You have varicose veins. I am going to make a levy on them, and transfuse the blood into your arms." He did that, and she felt a little improved for the moment. The next thing that happened was she began to complain of her feet. He said: "That is a great dilemma; you have to walk about on your feet. But you have a red nose, and I will make a levy there." So there was another transfusion. To make the story short, the next operation was carried out by the undertaker. That was the finish of the case so far as that woman was concerned. He next turned his attention to the husband, and sent him a bill for 50 guineas for curing his wife.

In this case, I might congratulate the Minister in that he did not wait to collect the fee until the patient died. One thing he has proved anyhow, and that is that it costs more to keep a person who is ill than to keep a person who is in good health, because there is twice as much spent on the Department of Agriculture now as when agriculture was in a good position. I think this policy should be discontinued, and that the Minister should direct his efforts in future towards finding a market for agricultural produce. The value of our exports in 1931 was £36,276,118. In 1934, it had been reduced to £18,604,531 — a decrease of almost 50 per cent. Let us look then at the other side of the account, and see the value of the imports. We find that our adverse trade balance was £14,184,762 in 1931, and that it was increased in 1934 to £20,461,318. We are told from the other side that this is a general thing all over the world; that this was due to the depreciation in agriculture all over the world, and that before 1931 this tendency existed. I admit that up to 1931 there was a decrease in the value of our exports. For instance, in 1927, the value of our exports was £44,168,118, and it was reduced in 1931 to £36,276,118 — a reduction of about 10 per cent. In the four years from 1927 to 1931, the value of our exports was decreased by 10 per cent. It will be remembered that 1931 was the most depressed time for agriculture in every part of the world, and that there has been a recovery since. There certainly has been a recovery in Great Britain, and we should have benefited by that recovery. We should at least have got back to the same position which we occupied in 1931 with regard to the value of our exports. Instead of being back to that position we find that the decrease has continued to an alarming extent. Whereas, for the four years from 1927 to 1931, there was a reduction of 10 per cent in the value of our exports, there has been a reduction of practically 50 per cent. within the last three years. Again, between 1927 and 1931, our adverse trade balance was reduced by 16 per cent.; so that, although the value of our exports was decreased by 10 per cent., our adverse trade balance was decreased by 16 per cent. Since 1931, our adverse trade balance has been increased by 44 per cent. If the decrease in our adverse trade balance had continued at the same rate as between 1927 and 1931, it would have been reduced by 80 per cent. since 1931. That would practically have wiped it out.

I refer the Minister to the statistics, which will prove that this is correct. The Department of Industry and Commerce have published the statistics from which I take these figures. It will be impossible for any section in this country to continue if the national income is to be reduced at such an alarming rate, while the adverse trade balance increases. In four years, there has been a decrease of 50 per cent. in the value of our exports— that is a decrease in national income —and an increase of 44 per cent. in the adverse trade balance. That is certainly a state of things which cannot go on indefinitely. I would appeal to the Minister to make an effort, even now, to find a way out of the impasse in which he finds himself. We know that the Minister and the Government have got themselves into difficulties. The Opposition are quite anxious to help them out if we were only allowed to do so, but when the Opposition point out the only way in which those difficulties can be overcome, they are jeered from that side. I hope that the farmer Deputies on that side of the House will try to induce the Minister to save agriculture, because, after all, it is the principal industry of this State. If agriculture goes down, the State goes down. All the other industries are being fostered on agriculture. If the agricultural community are not able to buy the products of the other industries, what is to keep them going? It is out of the question that they could contine to exist.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce—I am sorry he is not in the House—when speaking on his own Vote defended his own position all right. He admitted that there was an increase in unemployment, but said that it was in agriculture the increase existed. He said there were 75,000 farmers unemployed. The Minister for Agriculture was not present, and I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce did not play the game fairly in throwing all the responsibility for unemployment upon the Minister for Agriculture.

There is no doubt that the Minister for Industry and Commerce is right. There are 75,000 farmers unemployed and there are 400,000 farmers as good as unemployed, because they are working for nothing. They might as well sit idle as work. The Minister for Industry and Commerce may boast of starting some few hundred factories, but here we have 400,000 factories, because every farm is a little factory giving employment. They are on their last legs and, unless the policy of the Government is changed, down they will go. There is no question that they would be closed now if they were in the same position as other factories; every farmer would close down and turn his attention to something else. But the position is that they cannot close down; they have to keep going and try to exist. They cannot run away from the land; therefore they have to live there. They are in a position of white slavery. They certainly cannot balance their accounts and have anything like a decent living. I think the Minister knows that. He must be aware that the farmers are not complaining without very good reason.

I heard Deputy O'Reilly say that they were very prosperous. I do not know what made them prosperous. He told us that if there was a little depression here other countries were in the same position. He mentioned Canada and Northern Ireland. He did not tell us that Canada and other Commonwealth countries, like Australia and New Zealand, have increased the value of their exports to the British market since 1931 at a time when our exports decreased by 50 per cent. The figures show that the average increase for these countries is over 30 per cent. for the three years for exports to the British market. Does that show that there is world depression? It shows instead that they have taken our place in the British market. At the present time, Canada has not any cattle to export, because it has a good market in America and prices there have improved.

Up to two years ago we were in exactly the same position as Northern Ireland. There was no difference North or South until the economic war started. But since then the position has very much altered. The Minister takes great pride out of what he is doing for the dairying industry. I shall give some simple facts about the dairying industry. The position is that they are getting 5d. per gallon for milk in Northern Ireland. The parish in which I live is partly in Northern Ireland and partly in the Free State. In the Free State portion we are getting 3.6d. per gallon for milk or 1.4d. less than in the other part of the parish in Northern Ireland. Yet we are told that the dairying industry is prosperous and that farmers are prosperous because of the dairying industry. We are getting 1.4d. per gallon less than they are getting in the other end of the parish. That is a very big difference.

With regard to pigs, the Minister admits that there is a little bit of difficulty about pigs; that the curers are organising and giving the farmers a bad deal. I do not know exactly what is the price of bacon pigs at present, but I do know that about ten days ago the price in the Free State was 50/- per cwt. for lean and 46/- for fat. These figures are taken from the Farmers' Gazette.” On the same date the standard price in the Six Counties was 60/6. It was 63/6 for Grade A and something less for Grade B, but the average price was 60/6. That price still stands in Northern Ireland. The price is still 63/6 for the same class of pigs as are being sold in the Free State at about 40/- or something over at present. I do not now know exactly what the price is at present, but we are losing on pigs at least 30 per cent. We are also losing on our milk. As to calves, there is no use talking about them.

Taking yearlings and other cattle, I should like to give a few examples. The Minister told us to-day that the only loss is £5 per head. £5 per head would be a big loss on an animal that would be worth, say, £6. On inferior classes of cattle you lost not merely £5 out of £15, but £5 out of £6 in some cases, so that there are some classes of cattle practically worthless. I shall read a few quotations from the Farmers' Gazette as to prices in Antrim, Carlow, and Drogheda. It is generally known that Antrim cattle are not to be compared with cattle from Carlow or Drogheda. In Antrim the price for yearlings was: first class, £8 10/- to £9 10/-; liveweight average, 31/- per cwt.; second class, £7 10/- to £8; liveweight average, 30/- per cwt.; six-quarter old, first class, £10 10/- to £11 10/-; liveweight average, 30/-. The prices in Carlow were: store cattle, 12 to 15 months, first class, £3 10/- to £4 10/-; liveweight average, 19/-; that is a loss of 11/- per cwt.; 15 months to two years, first class, £4 10/- to £7; liveweight average, 19/-; second class, £3 2/6 to £4 10/-; liveweight average, 16/-. Then we come to springers and milch cows. If the dairying industry was so prosperous, and if the country was as prosperous as Deputy O'Reilly told us, would not one imagine that milch cows would be worth as much as in Northern Ireland? Yet what do we find? We find that the prices of springing cows in Antrim are returned as: first class, £24 to £26; second class, £18 to £20; third class, £13 to £16; while in Carlow the prices were: springing cows and heifers, first class, £8 10/- to £11; second class, £6 to £8 5/-. In Drogheda the prices were: springing cows and heifers, second class, £6 10/- to £9 5/-.

It is the same with every other class of stock you take—calves, pigs, sheep and lambs. If the people of Dublin have to pay 6d. more per lb. for their butter, what advantage is it if the farmers do not get any more for their milk? They have a loss of 1.4d. on every gallon they sell. The fact that other people have to pay so much extra for their butter is of no advantage to the farmers. That is how it works; the people are paying this levy out of one pocket and they are getting it in nominally in the other in the price paid for milk. The net benefit of the whole scheme is summed up in the price of milk at the creamery. That is the fairest way to calculate the net benefit to be derived from the Minister's policy, although I admit that, were it not for the bounty, butter would be worth nothing at all and milk would be of very little value. Where there is no economic war you can get a much higher price for your milk even without the bounty. In addition, there is a bounty paid by the Government in Northern Ireland. The general price paid in the month of March by the creameries in Northern Ireland was 4.12d., and the Ministry of Agriculture, by means of the equalisation process, brought the average price up to 6d. That price has been reduced for the summer months to 5d., which is the fixed price.

There is also a fixed price for pigs, which, like the price of milk, is based upon the cost of production. A commission inquired into these matters in the North, and they based the price of these commodities on the cost of production. If they are getting only the cost of production, and we are selling at 30 or 40 per cent. lower than the price they are receiving, is it not apparent that farmers in the Free State are producing at a price much less than the cost of production?

We are told about wheat and beet. Beet may be a paying crop, but the production of beet is confined to certain areas only. I believe that farmers growing beet do not consider that they are getting such a great price at all, and that the other commodities which farmers had been previously producing paid them much better. The production of live stock, the growing of food-stuffs for pigs and cattle, and the rearing of calves and things like that always paid them in the past, because they suited our climate and we had an excellent market for selling these products. We have no market for selling beet and wheat except the home market, and then we are limited in the amount which we can grow. I think the Minister has stated that 700,000 acres of wheat would supply all our needs. To pay a high bounty on that would impose a very heavy burden on the taxpayers. I am sure the Minister could tell us, if he wished, how many millions it would cost. When that area is occupied with wheat, what will be done with the remainder of the land? We have 16,000,000 acres of arable land. If we utilise 2,000,000 for producing all the cereals and all the food we need for home consumption, what is to be done with the balance unless we go in for the production of live stock? We want not merely to get all the land utilised, but we want to get it utilised to the best advantage and to produce more of these things than we have been producing at the same time as we have an increased production of wheat and beet. If we want to find employment for our increasing population, it is necessary that we should grow more of everything and to export more as well as grow more for our own needs.

The policy pursued by the Government at the moment in agriculture is leading to more and more unemployment, and everybody who can get away from the land is getting away from it. I know men each of whom used to employ three or four men when times were prosperous and they are now out looking for jobs themselves while their land is going wild. That is the condition to which they have been reduced. I heard Deputy Dr. O'Higgins here one day challenge the Minister to name one industry in the State that was on a paying basis and that was able to pay its way. I think I could name one myself—Guinness's. I do not know of any others. It is significant that that industry is about to establish itself elsewhere so that it will not be altogether dependent on this country. Apart from that industry, I do not think there is any other industry worth while that is on a paying basis at the present time. They are in the position in which one is leaning on another. Previously they were leaning on agriculture, but now agriculture has to lean on other industries. What has it to lean on? It is difficult to know. While all industries are leaning one on the other, how long can that continue?

The position reminds me of the story of a number of foolish boys who were anxious to cross a frozen lake. The ice was thin in the centre, and several times they made an attempt to go across but they got afraid. They were afraid that they would go through the ice. Then one of them got a brain wave and he said: "I will solve the difficulty; come along and we shall lean on one another. I will lean on the two boys next to me and they can lean on the boys next to them." A certain number of them, a majority, agreed to do that. There was a minority who did not like the arrangement and they warned the others about the danger of it. The majority said they would be all right, as the majority must be always all right. They started to cross the lake. The others warned them as long as they could, and when they could not convince them of their folly they turned their backs on them and would not look at what happened. When they looked again, those crossing the lake had disappeared into the middle of the lake. I hope the Minister will take warning from that and will not rely too much on his majority to keep him right always. I hope that not only will he take warning but that he will seek the assistance and co-operation of the Opposition here. There are some things I should like to see even more than seeing the Government knocked out of office. I should be very glad to see them knocked out of office, but there is one thing I would rather have, and that is to see them prepared to co-operate with the Opposition and with all Parties in the House so that we might work together to get the country out of its present difficulties. Unless there is a little more co-operation, unless the Government listen to the Opposition in trying to solve their difficulties, it is going to be a bad thing for this State. It may be very good to gain a Party advantage but, in my opinion, it would be better to pull the country through, and I would rather see the country come through than see the Opposition to-morrow in the place of the present Government.

Comment on this

I listened to the Minister with great interest to-day. He used a phrase to the effect that the farmer is not suffering any material loss, and he wanted to make out that the Government beet and wheat policy supplied a profitable alternative. Now I do not want to take up too much time in this debate. I know there are many others very anxious to speak and so I shall proceed to take one of the Minister's alternatives, namely, wheat. That is the one pet subject at the present time of Government supporters. They try to persuade the farmer that if he will only grow wheat he will become a millionaire. I do not know whether the Minister compiled the cost of production figures of one acre of wheat which I am going to quote. I shall read these cost of production figures, and I ask the Minister to point to any particular item that he considers too high. The figures are: "Ploughing, two horses, 5/-, and man, 4/-; ¾ acre per day—time 1¼ days per acre, 12/-; first harrowing, 4/6; drilling seed, including wear of drill, 2/6; wear of plough, 2/-; harrowing after drilling seed, 2/-; rolling, 2/-; reaping 1 acre, including twine, 5/-; stooking and stacking, 10/-; carting to stack yard, 5/-; making rick, 2/-; manures, £1 12s. 0d.; seed, 14 stone at 1/6 per stone, £1 1s. 0d.; threshing 1 acre of wheat, £1 4s. 0d.; hire 8 sacks at 1½d. per sack, 1/-; carting produce to market, 10/-; rent and rates, 10/-; repairs to fences, 2/6; and buildings, 2/6; total, £7 10s. 0d." I would like to know any particular item that any Deputy on the other side considers too high on the list.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

What was the figure for stacking?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I would do it in half a day. I would stack an acre of land in half a day.

Comment on this

Would you consider 5/- too high?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I would for half-a-day. Is Deputy Curran paying it?

Comment on this

Yes; but I note that the Minister considers 5/- for stacking is too much for a day.

Comment on this

One man could not do it.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I often did it.

Comment on this

I am quoting from the Annual Report of the County Cork Committee of Agriculture——

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

If I did not stack three acres a day, I would not consider myself any good.

Comment on this

I have shown that the cost of production of one acre of wheat is £7 10s. plus 7/- interest on capital at 5 per cent., making in all £7 17s. as the cost per statute acre. Now for the return. The average return of 7 barrels of wheat at £1 3s. 6d. makes £8 4s. 6d, and 25 cwt. of straw at 1/-, £1 5s., give the total return as £9 9s. 6d., which, less cost of production £7 17s., leaves a net return of £1 12s. 6d. I make the Minister a present of these figures. But even if the growing of wheat was more profitable than it is, it is not going to solve the problem of the country at all.

I turn now to beet. I understand that there are 45,000 acres of land under beet, and that there are 30,000 registered growers. That makes an average of 1½ acres per registered grower. If this Government, or any Government, can only succeed in getting a cultivation of 1½ acres for every registered grower of beet, even if they can make it profitable, it is clear that such results are not going to be of any material benefit to the farmers. Deputy McGovern said that there were 16,000,000 acres of arable land in this country. I thought there were 12,000,000 but, even so, supposing that out of that there were 500,000 acres producing wheat and 45,000 acres producing beet, what is to be done with the rest? I listened many times to advocates of the beet industry, and they said that there was no great advantage in it, beyond the fact that it was a cash crop. I know, as far as beet is concerned, that while we are growing a little it is not going to revolutionise the agricultural industry as the present time.

It may be of interest now to turn to the other side of the picture. It certainly should be the duty of the Minister for Agriculture to do the best he can for the agricultural industry. The cattle population of this country is over 4,000,000. Let Deputies just consider what that 4,000,000 cattle population means to the Free State, and let them ask themselves honestly what the loss has been to the farming community as a result of the Government policy in connection with that 4,000,000 cattle population. Would not a very ordinary calculation show that it represents £4 per head? Does anyone in his senses say that there is not a big loss in connection with the cattle population owing to the Government policy and to the economic war? Would not anyone in his senses, if he wanted to do something for agriculture, and make it prosperous, do everything in his power to save that great loss? That is the case of cattle.

Let us now take the case of sheep. I remember not so long ago listening to a man, who happened to be a T.D., talking about the sheep industry. He was speaking at a fair in a certain country town, and he said it was 40 years before that he was in that particular town. On that occasion, he said, he was doing much the same business as to-day: "I was buying lambs." Then he went on to say that 40 years ago he bought lambs for 16/- apiece. The cost of marketing them and sending them to Birkenhead and Bristol was 3/6. That made the total cost 19/6. He was there on that occasion paying the same price for lambs, but he had to make 33/- before he could get out. There was 10/- tariff and 7/- expenses. That was the difference. What other industry in this country is asking to go back to 40 years and take the same price? Is there anybody doing it? But that is the situation we have to face at the present time. It is idle for Deputies opposite to try and gloss over all this. It is a very serious position. Is there not a tariff of £6 per head on Irish cattle entering the British market? Again, is there not a levy on home consumed beef of £1, and 5/- on sheep, and is there not a tariff of 10/- on sheep going into England? If the Minister thinks he can minimise all this by growing wheat, he is wrong.

We hear very little talk to day about the growing of tobacco. In the early days of Fianna Fáil tobacco-growing was to do a lot. Now, all that appears to have gone by the board. There is very little talk about tobacco-growing and the benefits that were to result from it. I will turn now to the dairy industry. Deputy McGovern said the price was 3d. per gallon for milk. I got a little more than that. The Minister for Agriculture tells me that I am associated with a bad creamery, but the Government last year collected from that creamery, and from the district which supplied it, £7,600 in levy, and yet Fianna Fáil Deputies will speak of what they are doing for the dairying industry. What are they doing? I agree that world prices are bad and that something should be done, but it is no compliment to anybody to charge 29/- a cwt. of a levy. That is the position and, so far as I can see, dairying in itself was never a profitable proposition without the rearing of young stock.

I previously gave the case of a farmer with 15 cows. He would be a fairly good-sized farmer, and I took an average of 4d. per gallon for milk. It might be a little over, but I think a fair average for 15 cows would be 480 gallons. I know that in Deputy Hogan's time he aimed at the 800 gallon cow and I suppose the Minister for Agriculture is doing the same now, but it is easier to talk about it than to get it realised. I think that anything from 480 to 500 gallons would be fair average. Tot it up if you like. £8 a cow for 15 cows is £120 and I know men working with a horse and cart for a local council who have a better income than the farmer with 15 cows. Is it not idle to think that you can make agriculture prosperous unless live-stock are a profitable proposition? It is all very fine for the Minister to boast about guaranteeing 15/- a barrel for barley. What is going to become of it at the finish? Is it not fed to live-stock for the production of beef, bacon, mutton and so on?

Those are a few points I should like to put to the Minister. I would like him to take cognisance of them because I think we are going along a road which may have very serious consequences for the farmers. There is a good deal of talk about Cork and the lawlessness that is taking place in Cork at present. The cattle population in Cork is over 500,000—526,000 to be accurate—and would not a fair estimate be that they are losing on these cattle round about £4 or £5 a head? This Government will send men down, not alone to Cork but to practically every county in the Free State, to collect annuities from the farmers. They have destroyed the only means by which they could pay them and then they take them from them afterwards. I think it is about time the Government took a serious view of the situation so far as the annuities are concerned. As has been said many a time, and probably will be said many more times before this debate finishes, the British Government have succeeded in collecting them from the farmers. Undoubtedly, they have and much more. It is not a thing I boast about or like. I do not, but the fact is that it is so. I will not delay the House further as other Deputies wish to say a few words in connection with this Vote.

Comment on this

I know that there are very many Opposition Deputies who want to speak in this debate and it may be necessary to say that I am intervening with regard to one particular point only and I will not long delay the House. I think that in view of all the anxiety there was for this debate and in view of the very big grievance that was expressed the other day when the Opposition thought they would not have an opportunity of debating agriculture, it will be agreed that the debate so far has proved decidedly disappointing. There has been singular absence of new ideas.

Comment on this

Perhaps we will hear some from the Deputy when he is at it.

Comment on this

That responsibility is on Deputy Curran and his friends, because they it was who expressed the grievance that they were not getting a chance of debating the position of agriculture. One would infer from that anxiety that the place would be exuding ideas, that there was some marvellous idea which had been discovered and which it was desired to bring out in this debate. Yet, one Deputy to-day, a Deputy who is always prominent on agricultural questions, spent about 10 minutes emphasising and moralising on the terrible position we would be in when the full requirements of this country had been met in wheat and the awful problem the Government and the people would have to face when we have an exportable surplus in the matter of wheat. That was his contribution to the debate. I doubt if anybody in the House remembers anything else he said. He called our attention to it again and again, and he asked us to note that that problem was coming. His leader in this debate, I rather think, was hardly more fruitful in ideas than he was, but I think that Deputy Curran's picture a while ago fairly took the bun, when he referred to a lot of industries in this country, none of them being on a paying basis except one. Guinness is the only paying industry in this country.

Comment on this

I said nothing about Guinness.

Comment on this

I am sorry; it was Deputy McGovern. He referred to industries in this country leaning against one another and depending on one another for support. The rotten boot factory is leaning against the rotten clothing factory and they are mutually supporting each other. What exactly Deputy McGovern meant does not seem clear. There is another curious side to it in that last week we had a terrible lot of talk about the big profits that industrialists were making here out of tariffs. Evidently Deputy McGovern does not believe at all in those statements of his leaders because his statement to-day, repeated more than once, was that he believed there was only one industry in the country paying, and that was Guinness. It is in curious discord with the statement that big profits are being made by big tariffs. It is very hard to get anything intelligible out of a debate containing contradictory statements of that kind.

Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney surveyed the field in what seemed to me to be a very thin way. He told us that subsidies could never be justified except as a temporary thing; that agriculture has become a source of national loss rather than national gain; that both subsidies and bounties were to be condemned; and that they could not last, as there was no means of paying them. These statements, too, I think, could hardly be accepted as dogma from any source. The subsidy and bounty, it is obvious, is the State's way of doing a thing which the farmers are unable to do for themselves. I think that in Deputy Hogan's time he was very fond of appealing to the farmers to do things for themselves rather than to leave it to the Government to do them. Now, one thing that the farmers would obviously do if they were as united as Deputy Hogan desired, would be to insist on a reasonable price for any crop they have to sell. Surely a fixed price for wheat that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney found so much fault with to-day and which he associated with subsidies and bounties in some peculiar way is merely an action by the State that the farmers would take for themselves if they had any sense. If the farmers decided to grow wheat and decided that they would withhold it unless they got 23/6 per barrel, I think there is no Government that would say: "You are altogether wrong, and we will give you no support whatever in getting anything like that price for it." I could quote from Deputy Hogan's statements to show that he was in favour of such a line for farmers and that he actually appealed to them to take that line.

It looks as if the wheat dispute were to go on for ever. On one occasion you have a Deputy of the Opposition like Deputy Minch praising the Government's efforts to develop the growing of wheat and saying it was the hope of the country. On another occasion you have Deputies like Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney saying it is on an artificial basis and it is altogether opposed to the country's best interests and that it was merely playacting on the part of the Government to try to substitute a crop like that for the natural products of the country which he describes as live stock and live-stock products. I do not think this Government is at all opposed to the production of live stock and live-stock products. I think they are rather anxious that so far as they can be sold at a reasonable price all the live stock and live-stock products that the country is capable of producing should be produced.

Comment on this

Had we not to kill the calves?

Comment on this

I have made the statement that so far as they can be sold at a reasonable price the Government is anxious to encourage the sale of these things. The Government is not so unwise or ignorant as to think that exports will not always be a useful thing, and that the thing you can most rely upon in that sense is agricultural exports. When Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney talks about live-stock products he surely has to bear butter in mind, and if he reverts to butter as a desirable product, and at the same time condemns the whole system of bounties and subsidies, I wonder where he is?

Comment on this

We have asked you to open our markets and keep the bounties and subsidies.

Comment on this

Practically the biggest item in animal products is dairy produce. The House is generally agreed that dairy produce could not be exported at present without the aid of subsidies, and it is somewhat unreal to see a Deputy condemning the system of subsidies and bounties and at the same time advocating the production of dairy produce in the country. There is a terrible vagueness amongst Deputies opposite with regard to their policy. I would like to understand their policy. I think agriculture is not in such a very good position that it does not need to have new policies advocated for its good.

Comment on this

I thought you wanted something new when you stood up to talk. Now you seem to think there could be nothing new.

Comment on this

I think that is not a very useful interruption.

Comment on this

Are we to take you as an authority?

Comment on this

In my opinion, agriculture is not so prosperous that there is no reason to debate its future and no reason to discuss different lines of policy in connection with it. So far as I can see, it is very hard to generalise in regard to the economic position of farmers. The farmers who were always in good circumstances seem to be in pretty good circumstances still. Lots of them do not even complain. Those who were always in debt, and particularly those who were unfortunate enough to get land within the 1922 period, are in a very bad way indeed. The question of liquidating their debts, if it could be solved, would be well worth considering because they are a considerable number and the acreage of land they account for is quite big. Then you have farmers who have a sentimental attachment to wheat and who, in my opinion, actually go to the extent of praising it more than it deserves. I agree with the Deputy who said to-day that there is probably rather a small margin in wheat. So far as my own immediate relations are concerned, they say that by the time it is threshed there is only a small margin.

Comment on this

Get the Minister to stack it for you and you will make a profit on it.

Comment on this

I think the real problem for the Government is to meet the losses on cattle by stimulating prices for other produce that the farmer has to sell. One would think from the debate to-day that the only thing the farmer has to sell is cattle. Those who had grain to sell for the last couple of years were rather satisfied that they got a remunerative price for it. A good many people who go in for pig production are well satisfied with the prices they have been getting. Those who had sheep up to recently were well satisfied. There are complaints that the 5/- levy on sheep is a factor in price and that it is rather too much for those who have small means. Surveying the whole position of the agriculturists, I am not prepared to say that the farmers are prosperous. They are certainly not in a position to save money considered as a class. But I would say this, that in their relations with the Government the Government can claim that all a Government could do for any section this Government are doing for agriculture. They have run away from no problem that farming presents. They have tackled things that it is doubtful if any other Government would have the courage to tackle. The Slaughter of Cattle and Sheep Act was a credit to the Department. They have, as the Minister explained, been successfully opening up new markets and these markets have been an undoubted help up to the present. We all hope they will be even more helpful in future. How much they mean with regard to products like eggs and poultry, particularly eggs, is not, perhaps, sufficiently realised. We have all seen the boast of the Minister of Agriculture in England that England is now almost self-contained in the matter of egg-production. If it were not for our Government's success in opening up markets, particularly the market in Spain, you would have the position that you might be faced with such prices for eggs as would cause people to give up egg production altogether.

Comment on this

What are you getting for the eggs?

Comment on this

The prices I am told are about the same and perhaps better than last year and generally what they have always been at this time of the year.

Comment on this

Measured by the price of oranges that cannot be sold here?

Comment on this

That is quite another thing.

Comment on this

Ask the fruit merchants and then you will know what you are talking about.

Comment on this

There should be an attempt to give both sides of this question. If Deputies opposite are going to be realistic in this debate they might at least take into account to some extent the changed position in England. It is ridiculous and it is very unfair to the farming community to have responsible Deputies telling them that if only the present Government were out of power they would get a wonderful price for their cattle in England and have a market for an unlimited trade. When you have the English Minister of Agriculture apparently determined to encourage beef production and determined to make farming there a paying proposition as far as he can go, surely Deputies here should consider that in connection with our problem and they might take cognisance of the fact that England has definitely gone protectionist. There are in England people like Lloyd George who differ substantially from the present Government there and yet are prepared to accept protection and actually propose to increase the population on the land by 500,000 people. There is also the fact that in the period between 1926 and 1933 they increased the cattle population in England by 500,000, sheep population by 2,000,000 and pig population by 1,000,000. In view of that tendency surely it is not fair to be asserting that all the grievances of the farmers of this country arise from the failure of the Government to appreciate that there is an unlimited market in England and that there always will be a market there for our goods, and that it is only the stupidity and incompetence of the Government in power that is standing between them and that advantageous position.

There is one matter that I want to put to the Minister before I finish. He is probably aware that there is a very bad position in Wicklow and the other counties that supply milk to Dublin and that the slump in milk prices in the present year is disastrous. The Minister is probably aware that those in the milk producing industry are facing a state of things which obviously will mean ruin to them unless there is a remedy. At present they are selling milk at 4d per gallon. Obviously that price would not be sufficient to enable them to pay their way.

Comment on this

Deputy McGovern is selling it at less.

Comment on this

When one realises that that milk is retailed in Dublin at 2/- a gallon, there is surely room for some interference there so that the two prices would be brought more closely in relation to each other. I do not like to suggest that the State should take on more duties than it has but that looks like a duty that I think the Government will have to face. I would be glad if the Minister, when replying, would say whether his Department has considered the question and whether they have any proposals to make in conection with it. Generally, Sir, I think the Minister need not be frightened at the result of this debate. So far as it has gone at all events it has merely brought into prominence the fact that the Government has a policy for agriculture and that its critics are altogether lacking in a policy for agriculture.

Comment on this

If this debate has done nothing else than publishing to the world the prowess of the Minister for Agriculture in the wheat field, it was well worth having. This debate will be read with interest down the country. The people will read with interest that the Minister for Agriculture is able to stack single-handed and alone three acres of wheat in the day. That is something to boast about. The Minister is quite prepared to stack an acre of wheat in less than half a day alone by himself. If the debate did nothing else but bring out that fact it is worth much.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

Any Wexford man would do it.

Comment on this

I am sure any Wexford man would do it. If Wexford men are able to work as efficiently as the Minister for Agriculture, it is a pity they are not paid better wages, because the agricultural wages in Wexford were so poor that recently the County Committee of Agriculture in Wexford asked the Minister for Local Government and Public Health to give free beef to the workers down there because the workers are so badly paid. I am afraid that the Minister's prowess will fade out when you come to examine this side of it. Deputy Moore told us he could not understand how some speakers on this side said that the fixed price for wheat was in the nature of a subsidy. It does not matter whether it is a State subsidy or whether the subsidy is paid otherwise. The State was paying the subsidy or bounty, but that has now been transferred to the consumer. That is what happened as far as we are concerned. The peculiar thing about it is that while the farmers are supposed to be wealthy and well-off and able to leave money by, Deputy Moore has been quite honest about it, and he says no farmer is able to lay money by.

Comment on this

There are some.

Comment on this

Yes, some people who deal in sheep and cattle; it is not the people who rear the sheep and cattle.

Comment on this

Some of the Kerry sharks.

Comment on this

The peculiar thing about it is that Deputy Moore thinks they are not able to lay money by; at the same time he says they are prosperous and well-off.

Comment on this

No, I did not say that.

Comment on this

Very well; we are all agreed on that. They are not well-off, so that as far as the Fianna Fáil people are concerned their policy will not stand the test—the people are not well-off. It is immaterial whether the Minister for Agriculture is able to convince the people of this country that he has induced the growing of wheat to any extent. The one thing that matters is this: Are these people better able to meet their commitments than they were before the start of this policy? That is a thing that I would like to ask the Minister— that is a thing I would even ask the Minister to ask himself. Let him go down to the farmers of the country and ask them are they better off and let Deputy Moore or any other Deputy on the Fianna Fáil Benches tell me why no farmer in the country can answer the question affirmatively: "Are you able to lay enough money by for your daughter's dowry?" or "are you able to lay enough money by to save enough to buy a new place for one of your sons? Are you better off?"

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell us whether there is any country in the world that has escaped the economic depression?

Comment on this

Would Deputy Moore tell us why this country has not escaped it?

Comment on this

The peculiar thing about it is that Deputy Moore and other Deputies in this country who are supporting the economic war must admit that every farmer in the country is selling his cattle by £6, £4 or £2 10s. cheaper than he would be selling them if there had been no economic war; they will have to admit that. That is the way to cure the depression.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I did not say that.

Comment on this

Of course you did not say that, but you gave those figures. Those are the figures given by the Minister—that they ought not to be more than, say, £5 for one class to £2 10s. 0d. for another class cheaper than they are in England.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

I did not say that at all.

Comment on this

I know the Minister did not say that. It would not suit the Minister to say that, but that is exactly where we are. Now we are asked what is the Opposition policy. It is a rather peculiar thing that that is the same question to which the Minister for Industry and Commerce wants an answer.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

What is it?

Comment on this

Exactly. Mind you, the Minister for Agriculture, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and the people on the Government Benches would apparently be quite satisfied if we came in and said: "We are going to reduce the Civic Guards; we are going to reduce taxation by £3,000,000; we are going to reduce the Army," and then get into power and say: "Come on, boys; we will get jobs for our friends in the Civic Guards and the Army, and instead of reducing taxation by £3,000,000 we will put up the Estimates by £8,000,000." Is that what you want us to say?

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

No. We want to know what is your policy.

Comment on this

Of course you do. As Deputy O'Higgins said, you have a plan to rely on. Give them the plan— that wonderful plan of which we had three or four copies here, and the last one was so valuable that it was lifted. This Fianna Fáil plan was going to solve all our difficulties.

Comment on this
Dr. Ryan

What is your policy?

Comment on this